Speaking of Insurance

A grease fire, a slip in the walk-in, an over-served customer and a dead cooler on a holiday weekend: Aaron Bollinger walks through which policy answers each call for California restaurant owners, from the BOP and business income to spoilage, equipment breakdown, liquor liability, workers' comp, EPLI and hired and non-owned auto.

Show Notes

A grease fire on a Saturday. A server slips in the walk-in. A customer drinks too much at your bar and crashes on the way home. The walk-in cooler dies on a holiday weekend. Those are the four calls restaurant owners make to their insurance broker, and each one lands on a different policy.

Aaron Bollinger of Bollinsure Insurance Services walks through the core of a restaurant insurance program in California: what a business owner's policy (BOP) does and does not do, why spoilage and equipment breakdown are two different coverages, where liquor liability fits, and the employee and delivery exposures owners overlook.

Key takeaways:

  • Property and general liability are the foundation, and many restaurants buy them together in a BOP. A BOP does not mean every restaurant loss is covered.
  • Business income coverage can help with lost income and continuing expenses after a covered shutdown, subject to waiting periods and limits.
  • Spoilage pays for the food; equipment breakdown pays to fix the cooler. A power outage can be treated differently from an internal breakdown, so read the wording.
  • General liability policies commonly exclude liquor liability for businesses that sell or serve alcohol. You usually need a separate liquor liability policy.
  • California requires workers' comp even with one employee. EPLI is a different policy, and wage and hour claims are often excluded or limited.
  • If employees deliver in their own cars, hired and non-owned auto liability can help protect the business.

Resources:

Clarifications

  • The wording of any policy controls. Whether a loss is covered depends on your forms, limits, deductibles and the facts of the claim.
  • California liquor liability law is summarized for general education only. It is not legal advice; talk to an attorney about your situation.
  • Around 2:00, "BOP" is a business owner's policy.
  • Around 5:15, "sublimate" means sublimit.
  • Hired and non-owned auto is sometimes shortened to HNOA.
  • The email address is quotes@bollinsure.com and the website is bollinsure.com.

More at bollinsure.com. Get quoted: Review your restaurant coverage with Bollinsure Insurance Services at www.bollinsure.com/quote, or call 562-268-9355.

CA License 6013787

This episode is for general education only and is not legal, tax, or coverage advice. Coverage, eligibility, and pricing depend on the carrier, underwriting, and your policy terms.

Chapters

  • 00:00 Cold open: the four calls restaurant owners make
  • 00:25 Welcome and what this episode covers
  • 00:59 Property insurance and general liability
  • 01:52 The business owner's policy (BOP)
  • 02:41 Business income when you have to close
  • 03:26 Walk-in cooler: spoilage vs. equipment breakdown
  • 05:49 Liquor liability and California law
  • 08:49 Employees and workers' comp
  • 10:02 EPLI: employment practices liability
  • 11:42 Deliveries and hired and non-owned auto
  • 14:01 Waiting periods and how to review your coverage
  • 14:52 Recap: four coverages to ask about

What is Speaking of Insurance?

Insurance, explained clearly by a family with three generations of expertise. Speaking of Insurance from Bollinsure Insurance Services features California insurance conversations with Brian Bollinger and Aaron Bollinger, covering home, auto, business and personal umbrella topics. Find episode transcripts and related resources at https://www.bollinsure.com/podcast.

Aaron Bollinger (00:00)
A grease fire on Saturday, a server slips in the walk-in, a customer drinks too much at your bar and gets in an accident on the way home, and the walk-in cooler dies on a holiday weekend. What a bummer. Those are the four calls restaurant owners make to their insurance broker. That's what we get to hear as insurance brokers. Today we're going to go through each one and which insurance policy is going to cover you for what.

Aaron Bollinger (00:25)
This is the Speaking of Insurance podcast brought to you by Bollinsure Insurance Services. My name is Aaron Bollinger, and I think it's always important for us to start with the foundations of an insurance program. Today, of course, we'll be talking about the restaurant risk mitigation strategies, the claim management strategies, and the general insurance company tips to save money, to optimize your coverage, of course, which is so much more important than saving money.

Aaron Bollinger (00:54)
restaurant owners probably know better than anybody else. Most restaurant owners need two basic types of insurance protection. That is property insurance and GL, general liability insurance. Property insurance protects the physical things your business depends on. That includes the kitchen equipment, furniture, inventory, potentially the building itself also, if you own it. The general liability is different, designed to protect your business when a third party claims you caused them bodily injury or property damage. For example, a customer slips on a wet floor in your dining room and breaks their wrist. That is what typically we would see the general liability insurance policy cover, assuming that the claim and the event is explicitly stated on the insurance policy as covered or not excluded, depending. But let's say that a grease fire starts in the kitchen and it damages your equipment and forces you to shut down for repairs.

Aaron Bollinger (01:50)
That's commercial property insurance. And many restaurants purchase these coverages together in what's called a business owner's policy. We call it a BOP. I mean, I know there's a lot of different meanings for BOP, like a hit song or whatever, but this BOP is more important for restaurant owners than playing BOPS. And that is the fact that it combines property and general liability insurance into one package. And it commonly also includes some business income protection. We talked about that in the prior business income protection podcast and the ability to operate your business while it is shut down from a different location and or get compensated for lost revenue due to a covered loss. Very nuanced. Definitely go back and listen to that if you are interested in that type of insurance as well. This type of coverage though is particularly important for restaurants because even a temporary closure can create serious financial problems.

Aaron Bollinger (02:49)
If you think about it, and maybe your rent doesn't stop just because of your restaurant being closed, you may still have the payroll obligations, loan payments, and other ongoing expenses that you as a restaurant owner are responsible for. So if a covered fire forces your restaurant to close, business income coverage can help reduce the lost income and pay certain continuing expenses while you recover. Of course, this is subject to your policies, limits, and coverages. But here is what restaurant owners need to understand. Just because you have a BOP doesn't mean every restaurant-related loss is automatically covered. There are several additional coverages that deserve a closer look. Let's go back to the walk-in cooler. It's Friday afternoon before a holiday weekend. Your restaurant is fully stocked. You've got thousands, maybe tens of thousands of fresh ingredients, and suddenly your refrigeration system stops working. By the time someone discovers a problem, the food has spoiled. Now you've got two separate financial losses. You've lost food, And second, you've got a refrigerator system that needs to be repaired or replaced.

Aaron Bollinger (03:49)
This is where two coverages come into play, spoilage and equipment breakdown coverage. Spoilage coverage can help pay for perishable inventory that becomes unusable because of a covered refrigeration or temperature control failure. Equipment breakdown coverage, on the other hand, can help pay for damage to covered equipment caused by separate mechanical or electrical breakdowns. So again, two different coverages for two different things. One of them actually fixes the refrigerator. One of them compensates you for what was in the refrigerator that got spoiled. They're related, but they're not the same thing. So depending on the policy, you should definitely need both if you are a restaurant owner. Let's say the compressor in your walk-in cooler fails. Equipment breakdown coverage may respond to the compressor damage, while the spoilage coverage could help cover the food that is lost.

Aaron Bollinger (04:42)
But you have to look at the actual policy wording, guys, because there are some nuances with what particular events cause that triggered coverage. And so this is why we recommend looking at the policy forms in addition to the prices and the coverages, the face values. Because again, if you're in a specific industry where you have more refrigeration of foods and more things that could be susceptible to spoiling and maybe some more refrigerators, then just because one coverage has the exact same amount of sublimit for X, Y, and Z doesn't mean that your business is going to be in the correct place after an event happens. So like a power outage, for example, can be completely differently treated from an internal equipment breakdown.

Aaron Bollinger (05:31)
This is why we recommend restaurant owners review both coverages, both the equipment breakdown, and the spoiled food coverage with their insurance broker. You do not want to discover that your refrigeration loss isn't covered after you've already thrown away thousands of dollars in inventory thinking that you would be compensated. That's the worst case scenario. But let's talk about alcohol. Very tricky insurance coverage if you filed for your liquor license or anything like that and you've got all of these things going for your business and you understand. But if your restaurant does serve beer, wine, or liquor, this is something that you need to put a highlighter on and ask ChatGPT about or listen to this podcast about. Imagine a customer spends several hours at your bar, drinks too much, leaves a restaurant, and gets into a serious car accident. This happens.

Aaron Bollinger (06:19)
The injured party files a lawsuit against the restaurant alleging that the business served alcohol improperly. Also happens. A lot of owners assume their GL, general liability, will automatically protect them and their business. Not necessarily true. CGL, commercial general liability, commonly contain liquor liability exclusions for businesses that sell or serve alcohol. You usually need separate liquor liability coverage. Now, California has some specific laws regarding when a business can actually be held responsible for injuries caused by someone who consumed alcohol at their place of business. Generally, California provides significant protections to alcohol providers against civil liability for injuries that are caused by an adult customer's intoxication, keyword adult. So there are, again, important exclusions. Certain situations involving service to an obviously intoxicated minor could be one of these situations where you don't think about it right now, you don't think about it when you're serving the drinks to a 20-year-old who's got whatever, and they get into an accident and they're more susceptible to

Aaron Bollinger (07:25)
getting into those more damaging accidents because of their age, because of their tipsiness and whatever happened. It's a difficult conversation because I've had friends and acquaintances who have passed away due to this sort of alcohol problem. So again, on a personal level, please go get liquor liability coverage exclusively for your business. Make sure it's covered for you and your business so people and their families can get adequately covered if they do have to come after you. Again, I'm not guilt tripping you and just going and getting. I'm just saying like everybody would be better off if you had it. So even when a restaurant has a strong legal defense, the fact that they can be named in a lawsuit can still be expensive. This liability coverage of liquor insurance is intended to address covered alcohol related liability claims, including the legal defense coverages where the policy provides it. Also something that something possibly landlords, lenders, and other business partners will require as well as a part of agreement. So you probably already have it if you are serving it. But don't assume that it's

Aaron Bollinger (08:30)
included under your current insurance policy. Go get a look. Go send it out to a broker or send it out to me or our agency. Maybe you listen to my dad's prior podcast. You think he's a very educated individual. I would 100% agree. And I would say, please go talk to him about liquor liability. He's far more experienced in that realm, right? So we talked about the customers. Let's move to your employees. Restaurants are physically demanding workplaces. Employees are constantly moving between hot kitchens, wet floors, sharp equipment, and crowded workspaces.

Aaron Bollinger (09:00)
Now, we can't name names and of course we can't talk about specific client circumstances, but we have seen lots of individuals, lots of business owners send us loss runs that are horrific. not in like the, oh, how dare you do that? Because sometimes it is uncontrollable, but in the sense that it's hundreds to millions, so hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars of claims that these insurance companies are paying out on behalf of these workers' compensation and employment related claims. A cook can suffer a serious burn, a server can slip while carrying dishes, a dishwasher can cut their hand, different kinds of workspace injuries that workers' compensation insurance is designed to address. Employers, of course, must carry workers' comp insurance even if they have only one employee. It can provide medical benefits and wage replacement for covered work-related injuries and illnesses. So if your server slips in the walk-in cooler while working and injures their back, workers' comp would generally be the first coverage that

Aaron Bollinger (10:01)
you would look at. There's another type of employee-related risk that restaurant owners sometimes overlook. But EPLI is different from workers' compensation. EPLI, employment practices, liability insurance, addresses certain employment-related allegations, like wrongful termination. That's a big one. You don't want to get involved in that. Discrimination, don't want to get involved in that. Harassment, retaliation, depending on the policy, these things can be covered up to billions of dollars, which is definitely an amazing coverage for restaurant owners to have and to highly consider because restaurants often have large teams, multiple supervisors, schedules are changing, and there is employee turnover, whether you like it or not.

Aaron Bollinger (10:48)
That creates opportunities for disagreements and employment disputes. So imagine a former employee claims they were fired in retaliation for reporting inappropriate conduct. That's a tricky one. Even if the restaurant believes it acted appropriately, defending an employment lawsuit can be very expensive. And so EPLI, again, in addition to covering you for if you are at fault, possibly it can help you cover defense costs and settlements as well. Subject to, of course, the policy terms. One important distinction that I would like to make is that wage and hour claims, including unpaid overtime and missed meal breaks, are often excluded or only covered on limited coverage basis. So workers' compensation protects against covered workplace injuries. EPLI addresses certain, but not all, employment-related legal claims. Two different exposures, and restaurant owners should understand both very comprehensively, should I say. Let's talk about deliveries.

Aaron Bollinger (11:44)
Restaurants, you guys are doing deliveries, right? I mean, it's the new wave, right? Offering delivery services. Maybe you don't even own a single delivery vehicle. Maybe employees use their personal cars to deliver orders. That's an insurance gap if you don't have the proper insurance coverage. If it's their driving of their own vehicle, the truth is that the employee's personal auto policy might provide some coverage, but this depends on if their own personal policy, which you don't have oversight on, has business delivery use as a permitted coverage. Personal auto insurance can exclude different delivery activities as well, not just the business operations, but business delivery activities on their own personal side and liability exposure.

Aaron Bollinger (12:29)
And there's another world where the limits that they have are insufficient to cover claims. And so your restaurant's GL policy isn't designed to cover automobile accidents. Get HNOA, go listen to that podcast. Hired and non-owned auto insurance coverage is your gift here. It is the solution to that. Non-owned auto liability is designed to protect a business against some claims involving vehicles that you don't own. And so that includes your employees' personal vehicles that are used for business purposes. Hired auto liability, the other part, addresses covered liability involving vehicles that the business rents. So you might rent vehicles for delivery. You might lease vehicles or hire vehicles as well for that. Go get the hired auto liability portion as well.

Aaron Bollinger (13:13)
important for you to understand this coverage and understand that your business needs to be protected against all different types of liability claims. If you want to have a comprehensive insurance package that you can sleep at night or sleep during the day, if you so choose and feel comfortable in your business's operations in the way that your exposures are covered, it's worth discussing the exposure with your insurance broker or with a insurance broker.

Aaron Bollinger (13:38)
Even if you have one employee that's occasionally making deliveries, obviously that's hypothetical. But again, we talked about the limitations of fire shutting down your restaurant, about business insurance coverage for your income. We talked about the combination of property and general liability. So hopefully you guys got enough insight into these coverages. But one last little note is that these policies have waiting periods.

Aaron Bollinger (14:05)
These policies that pay out for your business's lost income have waiting periods and their own coverage limits and specific rules for how long they're able to cover you and your business in the event that your business does have to shut down. More on that can be found in prior podcasts. But when you're reviewing your restaurant insurance, please do not just look at your property insurance limit or your workers' compensation limit. Ask how your business would survive financially if you couldn't open your doors for a month or longer, if a specific liability claim were to come out, if a certain spoiling of food or equipment breakdown were to happen, how you would be covered. Ask your broker for claim mitigation strategies.

Aaron Bollinger (14:45)
If you do have, again, hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars of losses, it gets really tricky. If you own a restaurant, it is important to reach out to a licensed insurance broker for four things. Spoilage coverage, equipment breakdown, liquor liability, and hired and non-owned Auto. Understand what you need to be covered for. Ask the questions, put the emphasis on the expert and get free advice from your insurance broker that you're paying. If you own a restaurant and you are unsure about any of the coverages that we had talked about today, it is all the more reason to reach out to our family office and to get a free comprehensive insurance review. You can shoot us an email to quotes@bollinsure.com or just visit our website and give us a call.

Aaron Bollinger (15:30)
We are available to talk, give zero cost consumer information and put you on the phone with an expert in your industry. Thank you so much for listening. With that, this has been the Speaking of Insurance podcast. My name is Aaron Bollinger. I hope you guys have a great rest of your week and stay safe and please stay claims free.