Attention Copilot with Pranab

I spoke with Kristin Neff about self-compassion, nondual awareness, and her attempt to build a model of awareness and consciousness that maps onto her lived experience.

Timestamps:
0:00 Nondual retreats, concepts, and practice
6:20 Awake awareness, mind-wandering, and creativity
14:22 What changed after 50 meditation retreats
19:02 A model of nondual awareness that fits with science
35:43 “You are not your thoughts” — and what comes next
54:51 Self-compassion through a nondual lens
1:08:27 The inner critic, shame, and the wish to be loved
1:15:54 Fierce self-compassion: acceptance and action
1:20:33 AI, consciousness, and subjective experience
1:28:24 What Kristin is working on now

Kristin Neff is a researcher and author on self-compassion, and was my professor at UT Austin during my final year of college. With Chris Germer, she co-developed the Mindful Self-Compassion programme. Her books include Self-Compassion, Fierce Self-Compassion, and Mindful Self-Compassion for Burnout.

We talk about her recent retreats with Dustin DiPerna and Michael Taft, the difference between mindfulness and awake awareness, and her attempt to build a conceptual model of nonduality that remains compatible with science. 

We then connect nondual practice back to Kristin’s work on self-compassion: why advanced practitioners can still struggle with self-judgment, how shame and the inner critic can be understood as protective, and the difference between tender and fierce self-compassion. We finish with AI, consciousness, and whether intelligence requires subjective experience. 

Learn more about Kristin’s work, workshops, and community.

This podcast is sponsored by Attention Copilot. You can spend all day working and still avoid the things that would make the biggest difference. Our somatic productivity coaches help you identify, prioritize, and face them. During an 80-minute to three-hour call, you settle in, share your screen, and do your actual work. Your coach helps you work through stress, make decisions, and stay clear-headed. Over time, you can feel more satisfied with your weeks, more confident taking on bigger things, and more at ease in your work.

Kristin links:
Resources mentioned:

What is Attention Copilot with Pranab?

Conversations about deep end meditation, skills for emotional fluidity, and living a life with more authenticity. All grounded in our work and relationships.

We are here with Dr. Kristin Neff, who
is my professor at UT several years ago,

mindful self-compassion, author of a
book on fierce compassion and burnout.

what self-compassion is, is we're
moving away from identification

with self, right? My three, my models
is being over-identified versus mindful,

feeling common humanity versus being
isolated and being kind versus judgmental.

Those are three aspects

of self-compassion. Yeah. So when we
feel, and this was, you know, and I,

this, came from my Buddhist practiced
understanding which again like tic dacani

is not not non-dual I mean he was he was
talking about interbeing which is all

oneness right and I actually really wanted
to call it interbeing versus isolation but

I knew no one would know what the hell I
was talking about so that common humanity

yeah it's just accessible yeah it's just
not it's not everything but it's you know

it's and to me and I think that's the
thing that I feel like I'm helping this

weekend I was helping a friend work
through a breakup and what has been

helpful for him has
been seeing everyone has

these feelings. Yeah. It's a part of being
human. It's part of being human. Yeah.

But so when we're over-identified with
whatever's arising, you might say that's

everyday mind, right? We're just lost
in the contents of our consciousness.

When we feel isolated, when we feel
separate from other people or the world,

if you want to take it further.

And when we judge it, it's good and bad.

And you think in some ways when we're
judging it as good or bad as ourselves as

good or bad, there's kind of this idea
that I should be able to control this.

I should have been able to get it right.

I'm bad because my experience isn't the
way I want it to be or that I think it

should be. So there's a real sense of
kind of agency built in to judgment.

We wouldn't judge ourselves
if we didn't have that sense

of agency. Underneath. So we're moving
away from the sense of separate self.

when we're judging, we feel
identified, we feel isolated,

to compassionate presence, right?
We're mindful, we're present,

we feel connected to the larger whole,
to a sense of common humanity, and we're

kind, our heart is open.

So now when I'm teaching self-compassion,
I have this little slide where I talk

about that, is that what self-compassion
is doing is we're moving away from self

into compassion.

And it's funny, Dan Siegel and I are
friends, and he's like, he hates the word

self-compassion. He's like, Kristin,
there's no self in self-compassion.

That's true. There's no self in the
compassion, but there's a lot of self in

the suffering,

you know? And so if you exclude
that sense of self, that isolated,

judgmental, you know, over-identified
self from the circle of compassion,

then you're just reifying
the sense of separation.

You need to turn not only to other people
and their suffering, but also our own

suffering as well. And not only that,

it's all mediated through our
own individual consciousness.

Even your suffering is mediated
through my consciousness.

If I don't pay attention
to your suffering,

I'm not even going to
be aware of it. Right?

So it's all happening through
our own individual consciousness,

all suffering. Yeah. All
perception of suffering. All

perception of suffering. Yeah. At least.

Well, all I should say,

yeah, maybe perception of,
it's not to say that,

that all suffering is my suffering.
I don't want to say that.

But, you know, the fact
like empathic resonance.

Yeah. If you're really suffering and I'm
like, I may be with therapists and I'm

feeling your pain that's happening
through my individual consciousness.

If you're a homeless person on
the street and I tune you out,

your suffering is real,
but I'm not experiencing it.

So you know what I mean? So it's like
filtered through my own individual

consciousness. It's the
only access point we have is

our individual consciousness.
Right. And so we have to be.

It's like essential to turn inward and
to notice the suffering that's arising in

our individual consciousness and move
from being identified with it, that small

separate self into. So in some ways,
I think what we're doing when we have any

moment of self-compassion is we're
letting go of the sense of separate self.

Are we going into
non-dual awake awareness?

Sometimes we might, but not always. But
even at a relative level, it's kind of

like a bridging point. We're at least less
identified with the everyday mind than

we normally are. There's less stickiness.

Yeah, there's less stickiness.
We're more open.

We can feel this compassionate presence.

And that we're changing our sense of self.

And then when you go all the way into
awake awareness, which is, you know, it

has to be underlined.

Awake awareness and everyday mind,
it's all awareness, right?

These are all colors of awareness. It's
not like they're actually different at

the absolute level.

But nonetheless,

there's a reason why when you're in
awake awareness, compassion arises.

Because it kind of sees, they always
talk about compassion for others.

Because I think this is one of the,
I don't know if it's a limitation of these

Buddhist practices. or maybe it was

because these were monks who
weren't experiencing a lot of...

I don't know. I don't know why. Maybe
it's like remnants of collectivism culture

or cultural differences or something else.

But even though I've heard that a lot of
Tibetan monks are pretty self-judgmental,

this is what surprised me on this retreat.

A lot of these very advanced
practitioners, most of the time in awake

awareness, had all this self-hatred.

So, you know, you need to deal with
the relative self-structure, which is

experiencing the suffering. Yeah, I think.

And I think self and others, not more
than others, but at least as much.

Yeah, yeah. I'm curious, getting onto the
psychological content, I think the cool

thing about the deep end of practice with
awake awareness and Michael Taft calls it

the non-dual two view. But really
this view of non-dualism that includes

the relative and doesn't exclude it.
Yeah, it transcends, but it includes it.

And includes. I think it actually solves
a lot of the problems of the more naive

non-dual view, where you get a lot
of people who sort of check out.

Yes, spiritual bypass. Exactly, spiritual
bypassing, and you ignore psychological

content. And I think from this view, in
some ways it makes your self-compassion

relative work even more important.
There's no way of getting around it.

You kind of just still have to, if you
care about psychological health and having

a healthy self,

there's a lot of stuff to be done or
to be intended towards around making

the content of one's mind more kind
and more, you know, compassionate.

And I'm curious, especially, so a
point you made a little bit ago.

So the inner critic, the inner critic
structure, you talk about in your latest

book on work, how that is sort of
actually behind a lot of burnout. Yeah.

I want to somehow get into some
of the fierce compassion stuff.

It's not fully there, but I
think like, I'm curious how you.

These are a lot of
threads to draw together.

It's a lot of threads. It's a lot of
threads. But that's what I love about

your work. I'm curious how you view taking
the inner critic and transforming it.

And I think you have a lot of angles
on it throughout your body of work now.

But what's your sense of
that, of how someone could

work with it? Yeah. So I think you
could say this with the inner critic.

Also, shame. You know, my colleague Chris
Grimmers did a lot of work around shame.

So often, so what happens to the inner
critic is we don't like the inner critic

and we judge the inner critic. And we
don't like, so we kind of like submit

to its criticism, but we kind
of think it's bad, we judge it.

So the inner critic becomes transformed
once we understand that it's a part

of our self-structure, our relative
self-structure that's trying to help,

but using methods that
aren't very effective.

So,

you know, there's a reason
we criticize ourself.

Either we think we're going to blunt the
pain from other people's criticism, so

I'll get there first,

or because we think we'll control
ourselves, or we think we'll motivate

ourselves to improve,

or maybe it's like the internalized voice
of someone and we had to believe that we

are crap in order to feel safe. So if you
really start exploring digging underneath

the inner critic, it's really arising
out of benevolence, But it's using kind

of patterns and methods that aren't
very effective and actually are totally

counterproductive. And it's
interesting with shame.

So shame is an emotion. It's actually
just one of the evolutionary emotions.

The emotion of shame arises just because
in the past, evolutionarily, if we did

something to piss off the
group, we'd feel that shame.

We'd want to hide.
We'd hide from the group.

And that kind of helped maintain, it was
such an uncomfortable feeling that we were

less lucky to piss off the group.
Therefore, we could have group cohesion

and we were cooperating
and our genes passed on.

It's like a natural emotion. There's
a really functional aspect to it.

There's a functional aspect to it. But
the thing about shame is because it's so

uncomfortable, we don't
allow ourselves to feel it.

It's like the most
uncomfortable feeling ever.

So we don't allow ourselves to feel it.

And what happens is we experience it
in our non-reflective consciousness.

We experience it, right?

But it doesn't come up. It's not
allowed to come up in the reflective

consciousness. We aren't even aware
of it because it's just too terrible.

So we have all these mechanisms.
So much stuff goes on below the level

of reflective consciousness. So we have
all these mechanisms that keep it down,

suppress it. We start
blaming others for it.

unrecognized shame is like the
engine of things like addiction,

a lot of really harmful behavior, a lot
of angry behavior, anything that's really

sticky that seems like
it's really gripped in.

And it's most of the time, I won't say
all the time, but most, a lot of the time

anyway,

there's unrealized shame that's
keeping the behavior locked in place.

And so my colleague, Chris Grimmer,
he's got a beautiful way

of talking about shame. He says, if you
just turn shame over, What is shame?

It's the wish to be loved.

You know, we all have
the wish to be loved.

And when we're afraid that other
people won't love us or they'll judge

us, we feel shame.

And so we don't have to be
afraid of experiencing shame.

You know? Yeah. It's so natural.
Of course, it's like so innocent.

Yeah. Everyone wishes to be loved. And
even as you say that, I feel like more

open, more heartless.
Yeah. It's like, of course.

And then so we can feel it. Yeah. And, you
know, even more than that, we can actually

kind of meet some of our
own needs to be loved.

But even before you get to that
stage, just the ability to feel,

oh, this is shame.

I'm feeling shame. I'm
feeling the wish to be loved.

How natural. Yeah. Then that shame
could come into reflective consciousness

and kind of be processed and
integrated and stuff like that.

And I'm really, these days, I'm really
into sort of like that full spectrum

of like, so, and like that
shame, for example, when we...

In some ways, what most of our experience
of shame is, reflecting back on what you

said, is often, you know, second
arrow or resistance to the shame.

And it's the resistance to the shame
that actually we think is shame.

But shame at its core, when seen a certain
way from like maybe a no bad parts frame

or sort of seen felt fully, is just that.

And I love that.
I hadn't heard that before.

Just the want to be loved. Yeah, the wish

to be loved. Yeah. And you might
say self-criticism is the wish

to be safe. Yeah. What's wrong with the
wish to be safe and the wish to be loved?

Yeah. It's so natural. Yeah. And what's
interesting is that I think even these

concepts themselves, you hear it and you
can kind of just get a shift from that.

And there's practices you can do. You can
kind of like be with it, hang out with it.

You can kind of bring the whole bag
of tricks from different psychological

frames, meditation frames to
feel into that core underneath.

The thing that for me has been really cool
in the work with Michael Taft is feeling

into, so I think there's sort of like at
the core of these strong emotions is also

just awake space. And there's many
different flavors of it, but there's

a whole thing on Rasa theory. So
Rasa is sort of a Sanskrit word,

which means like soup.

But we had this class a few weeks
ago where he talked about, you know,

anger fell all the way through. is this
like this rage, but it's sort of a wanting

for compassionate boundary. It's for
like wanting to keep a strong sense

of distinction or to, you know,
work through a boundary.

Or to right or wrong. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

And I think shame has that.
Disgust even has that.

Sadness has that. Yeah,
yeah. And it's just all

super psychologically compatible. Yeah.
And so seeing them as the, for me,

one way to look at it is just,
well, these are natural.

and we can respond to compassion. But if
you want to take it to the next level,

they're all the arising of awake
awareness, the display of awake awareness.

And that there is some benevolence in it.

Like there's like actually
benevolent intention

behind the arising of the shame or
behind the arising of the self-criticism

or behind the arising of the anger.

But it's just that benevolent intention,
which is kind of in awareness itself, It's

just so obscured by all the layers
of meaning and culture and judgment

and suppression and all this
stuff that it's hard to unpack.

It does seem, when you
move out of this separate,

identified, isolated, judgmental self
into the space of compassionate presence,

which again is not exactly the same as
awake awareness, but it's pretty, it's

kind of, there's a lot, you know, in some
ways, if I lose my need for precision

for a moment, let's just pretend
that it is exactly the same.

Then it's like these emotions can arise.

These thoughts can arise.
We don't identify with them.

We see how it's just all common humanity
or it's all the arising of awareness,

you know, which kind of
underline has this kind

of benevolent intention underneath it.

And then we just hold it with love, which
is like the healing quality, which is

the natural compassion, which arises when
we see the interconnection of all things.

And then it seems like it processes
and doesn't hang around that long.

Eventually, and that's the
healing power of self-compassion.

Do you want to talk about the
fierce side of self-compassion?

Let's do it. Okay. So you might say the
healing aspect of self-compassion is what

I just talked about.
The accepting what is.

It's usually aimed at ourselves, accepting
ourselves unconditionally or our emotions

or thoughts with loving,
connected presence.

And that's the tender
compassion side of things.

The tender compassion or kind
of the yin quality they talk

about in Chinese philosophy.

But then there's also fierce
self-compassion, which is taking action.

And that might mean a taking
action to protect, to prevent harm,

or taking action to provide for
our needs to ensure well-being,

or to motivate change,
again, to promote well-being.

So well-being doesn't only
come through acceptance.

Well-being also comes
through taking action.

So the number one misconception
people have is that self-compassion is

only about acceptance. And it means you're
going to accept like substandard behavior.

You don't let yourself
get away with murder.

You're not going to take responsibility.

And like everything is allowed.
Everything is permissive.

That's right. But of course, if you really
care about yourself and you just let

yourself get away with murder,
you don't take responsibility.

You became amotivated. You know, is
that really helping your well-being?

Of course not. Yeah. You know, so if
well-being is your aim, then you can

enhance well-being through
acceptance and through action.

And they're actually on slightly
different dimensions, so you can do both

simultaneously. Like while fully
accepting yourself and your worthiness

unconditionally and accepting your present
emotions and thoughts, you can take action

to change situations or to draw
boundaries or to take actions

that also enhance well-being. So they
aren't necessarily contradictory.

In fact, they work together.
It's like yin and yang.

You know, we need both. Yeah, you need
to feel into your own care for yourself.

Or not need to, but it really helps to do
that, to then draw the boundary, to then

take the action, the
strength. Yes, exactly.

And sometimes people talk about, well,
what's the difference between constructive

anger and destructive anger? Yeah.

It's quite simple. Yeah.
Constructive anger prevents harm.

Destructive anger causes harm.
Oh, that's really simple.

Yeah, it's very simple, right? But here's
the other thing is where are you coming

from when you're angry? Yeah. When you're
coming from the separate self and you're

taking things personally and you're
making them, you're blaming them.

So there's all these separate selves.

Then anger tends to cause harm.

But when you're coming from that
compassionate presence, from this larger

sense of awake awareness,

and you're realizing, oh, this anger is
arising as a manifestation of awareness

to protect from harm. And that person's
behavior is also a manifestation

of awareness. Maybe they didn't mean it
or it's coming from their unconscious.

Then it feels really different.
You don't have to make it personal.

And then when you don't make it
personal, but it's still like stop.

It's not like you're bad.
It's like just stop.

Then it's a lot less

destructive. Yeah. Yeah. What
I like a lot about that is,

again, it comes back to in
this moment, what's the view?

And there can be like the view, like the
view from Wake Awareness that a lot of,

you know, that we practice,
the schools that we practice in.

But there are also all these provisional
views of you can be just a bit more

compassionate or you can be
really a bit more self-centered.

But it's kind of like,
what are the assumptions?

What are the values you're coming
from in that moment, from that

speech, from this thing? Like what's
arising? What's your perspective?

What's the perspective? And so there's
awake awareness, which ultimately I think

is the most stable one. Yeah. But there's
lots of, even within, even if you have no

collapse between subject and the known and
the known, there's still, we all know what

it means. I mean, I've been
so surprised on my workshops.

I ask people, do you know what this feels
like to be part of this larger self?

Everyone has a sense of that.
Yeah. You know, it doesn't matter

if they've done meditation.

Everyone knows what it feels like to be
locked in to a sense of separate self,

inadequate,

sorry, inadequate, isolated,
over-identified, locked in, and kind

of like just being out in nature where
there's just more openness, there's more

presence. And one of the places we get
that sense most strongly, ironically, is

when we're compassionate to others.

Not always, but often when we're
compassionate to others, there's not a lot

of self-talk going on, we're
just there for the person.

You know, we're just, we are
just compassionate presence.

So it's not an unfamiliar state.
It's a little less familiar

giving it to ourselves.

It's interesting in Mahamudra, they often
talk about the concepts actually need

to come first and then the
experience. That's interesting.

Yeah. Whereas I think a lot of people say,
no, it's first the experience and then

we understand it. But I think
that model I made you read like

whatever, how many times? I've
got a little skim of it here

But the reason it's important to me, not
everyone's like me, not everyone thinks

like me, but I suspect
people like you are like me.

there's a certain group of people you see
them like especially younger people that

like they don't want to reject science
they don't want to go woo woo yeah they're

interested in quantum physics and how the
world works they don't want to like have

to believe in karma reincarnation maybe
it's true maybe not but I don't want you

know I don't want to have to believe that

and so if I I know for me I needed to
find a way to conceptualize things that

made sense to me that fit with what I was
learning in non-duality, but that wasn't

incompatible with science.
Is it proven by science?

No, of course, but it
just has to be compatible.

And that helped me just slot all the
pieces in so that I wasn't sitting there

thinking, well, that doesn't make sense.

You used your conscious, five sentences
ago, you used the consciousness one way,

and now you're using it
in a totally neutral way.

It bugs people like me.
It doesn't bug everyone.

It bugs me too. Yeah, yeah. And I
feel like, I think that's where, Like,

yeah, completely agreed. I think
a lot of the, I really love this

during my retreat too.

The idea that it's sort of asymptotic.

You can never actually really explain it,
but you can always have more and more

precise approximations. Yeah, exactly.

And that's really useful. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. That's awesome. Yeah. so tell me
I love Michael Taft it's very long one

of the things I liked about Dustin DiPerna
is all the meditations are like 10 minutes

and there's actually

what is it it's kind of like an emphasis
that the meditation is not the thing so

don't get too attached to meditation
I'm curious what happened because I know

Michael likes those long deep ones for
sure it's really interesting so I I've

I've personally been kind of um returning
to long meditations and almost a more

Theravada approach to practice okay
uh which for me has been good the

concentration the states of samadhi yeah
yeah yeah and I I I was aware that I think

Dustin's retreats only had like 20 minute
max meditations um to like really I am I

my understanding of it is less 10 minutes
10 minutes really whoa and I imagine it's

to get really crisp on the view except for
the introductory one because you're you

did the intermediate I did the advanced
I skipped the intermediate because it was

all about compassion and he said yeah nice
that's probably just gonna bug you the way

we're doing it probably so okay I would
love to hear about I'll tell you about

Michael Taft so Michael Taft's retreat
the format was um so seven days really six

full days of meditation uh and there's
a lot of meditation like at least six

everyone will get at least if you just
show up on average most people got at

least four hours I got about six if you
really wanted to you could push like eight

or ten I think um yeah two guided

two Michael Taft sessions per day mix
of lecture, guided meditation, Q &A.

This one leaned much more

guided meditation with lots of practice
periods of anywhere from 30 minutes

to an hour in length throughout
the day. So lots of sitting time.

And yeah, lots of sitting time.
I think Michael's view on it is,

and also the retreat comprised mostly
maybe 70 % plus of people who had done

prior retreats in his courses. Maybe only
out of the 60-ish people, there were only

four people hadn't done any
of the courses or anything.

So a lot of people came in
with Michael experience.

So the point of the retreat was, cool,
you got some approximation of the view.

He often talks about
approximating the view.

Now just practice it and sustain
it. So it was a lot of shamatha.

And then we'd actually did
a lot of tonglen practice,

like compassion and tonglen. But

this is my fourth Michael Taft retreat.

And a lot of other ones have a lot
of pointing out, a lot of vipassana,

vipassana, and different types of things.

So it's kind of a grab bag. It's much less
like, I feel like with dust retreats, you

know what you're going to get. It's very,
like, this is it, this is this level,

which is really good in a lot of ways.

So it takes you all the way to non-dual
wake awareness, the view at the end

of the introductory retreat, and then
the advance is all about stabilizing it.

Yeah. And also really seeing the
difference between, was really useful

is seeing the difference between ordinary
awareness and awake awareness and being

able to move back to awake
awareness seamlessly without effort.

That's really important. So you
don't need to concentrate the mind.

At first you do.

But after a certain number of
times, the brain's got it right.

It knows it. You just instantly shift.

So now I'm catching myself. It's
like right now I'm in the view,

but I'm starting to notice when I'm out

of the view. Yeah. And the nice
thing is it's not like, I'm in the

view. Yeah. I'm awake. It's like, no, I'm
just coming from my basis of operation.

It's so cute. Do you know, my brain is.

This is weird. This is
someone, this is maybe age.

I don't even know very well
his name is like, I see him.

Anyway, it'll come. He calls
it basis of operation, boo.

I've heard of basis of operation.
I think that phrase sounds familiar.

Yeah, because basically,

that's really annoying. It's like
right on the tip of my tongue.

The nice thing is I'm not controlling
what's arising in the contents

of my consciousness.

And the unconscious is not doing it. My
non-reflective consciousness is not doing

its work. Anyway.

Yeah. So it's just where
are you coming from?

Are you coming from the perspective of a
separate self, separate from the world?

Or are you coming from the perspective
of awareness, which is everything?

And it's also outside of space
and time, always here, always now.

And when you do that, you
can feel the difference.

It's very distinct because it's
almost like lights on or lights off.

And you notice when the lights have
been off and then, oh, yeah, I lost it.

But it's not like a special thing.

And so special states come and go,
like states of incredible bliss and love

and compassion and stillness. And,

you know, you might get in a state
of samadhi, very, very quiet.

All sorts of stuff can
arise. But that's not

it. Yeah. And so the reason that's so
useful to someone like me is like, I have

to tell you, I'm also a
little bit of a rebel.

So we were practicing king of samadhi,
which is how to be totally in awake

awareness as you're very narrowly focused
on one thing and that one pointedness.

And I created my own practice and I call
it the queen of not paying attention.

That's awesome. Because you need awake
awareness when you're spacing out, when

you're mind-wandering. Because I know for
me, mind-wandering is a very creative time

for me. When I'm not paying attention to
anything, my mind is going here and there.

It's like kind of floating.

That's like the seed of creativity. And,
of course, neuroscientists are starting

to rehabilitate mind-wandering and
seeing it as a huge source of creativity.

So can I maintain awake awareness
while I'm mind-wandering?

I don't know if this happens
to you, but for me, oftentimes

I space out like regularly. It's
almost like my brain takes a rest.

Does that happen to you? Yeah. From
everything you're saying, I think we have

very similar brains that way. Yeah.
And not everyone has a type of brain like

this, but I think people who are used
to focusing and can really like focus,

my brain needs periodic rest. I mean,
it might need that rest like every three

minutes and it just like goes fuzzy.

And so I've learned to
actually just stay awake while

my brain goes fuzzy. Yeah. Because
you can stay awake through all of it.

you can't do somali through all of it no
right right yeah this is how you can't be

you can't pay attention and so I really
got clear on the difference between paying

attention which is really what mindfulness
is and awake awareness which is different

because I used to go on mindfulness
retreats and be exhausted trying to pay

attention to everything because there's
someone who's first of all there's someone

who's doing right and also you're focusing
and focusing is an action and you can

be awake while you focus but it was really
amazing like right now I'll do it I'll

just like allow myself to space out

yeah I'm still awake so I'm I'm still even
though I'm not focusing on you or anything

it's like when I was asking a question I
allowed myself to rehearse they always say

don't rehearse pay
attention to what's arising.

I really play with,

no, I'm going to see if I can stay awake
while I'm not paying attention to what's

happening and I'm just
rehearsing what I'm going to say.

It's like nothing,

nothing, nothing. Nothing
excluded. Nothing excluded.

Nothing excluded. All within the, yeah.

All within, it's all within awareness.

Yeah. Yeah. And so all those things really
came online for me in a way that, I mean,

I've had those insights before,
but it really came together.

And because of that, it's much easier for
me to stabilize the awakening because I'm

not excluding those moments of mind
wandering or spacing out that my brain

needs. Maybe all people don't. I think,
do you identify with ADHD-like stuff?

No, but I can focus very easily, right?

But I'm also, I can focus
easily, but I think, I mean,

I don't know. I'm sure there are
neuroscientists studying this stuff, but

it seems like, especially if or someone
who's creative, and I'm creative, not in

an artistic way, but in an intellectual,
I'm creative, I write a lot of stuff.

Mind wandering, where it's kind of like
that half drifty dreaming space, where

you've got like half ideas, and it's kind
of forming, but you aren't directing it,

you aren't paying attention,
it's just kind of happening.

That's a really important time for me.

And some of my absolute best ideas come,
when I'm just wake up, I'm half awake in

the morning, And I'm kind of sitting there
and it's kind of like my mind's wandering.

And sometimes I do that
in the day as well.

And it seems like I'm just either
kind of spacing out or maybe

I'm not paying attention.

I need that time because that's
when I think most creatively.

And I think spacious awareness practice
is the most conducive for that in a way

that's not. Because I think
there's a version of mind wandering

that's more distraction. But I think
that's the only thing that gets emphasis.

And actually, I really enjoy just like
being in some approximation of the view

or kind of just. Yeah. Just dropping
effort and just seeing what comes up.

And then like there's a little bit
of like following those things,

but it's really emergent. It's really
fresh. There's a lot of creativity.

Yeah. And so it's really funny. This is
a central theme on my last retreat, on

the retreat that I had a week ago,
because I think for the last seven years

of practice,

a lot of when I meditate would just be
that because I valued it so much. Yeah.

And it's been awesome.

And I'm sort of moving into a like, well,
actually, I actually, there's a thread I

want to, I really want to get into. So the
thing you mentioned about inner rebel, I

think I have that too. And I actually have
a hunch that a lot of people who get into

non-dual practice have that much more
strongly than people who sort of are more

in the, you know, the mind illuminated
or like a strong shamatha approach.

Right, right. Like almost like 10 or so
people I talked to at the Michael Taft

retreat when I had this insight. I was
like, hey, so do you, because I think

Michael has this vibe and I think a
lot of the retreatants have this vibe.

that's why we follow him, of just sort
of not wanting to follow a certain

instruction just because
someone told us to do it.

Exactly. Yeah. Right. Then it's,
I think a lot of just follow your breath

and just do it. Like, I just have a
lot of inner rebellion against that.

Um, or like I'll set, or even, I'll also
even inner rebellion against myself where

I'll set an intention for 45 minutes. I'm
going to do breath practice or I'm going

to do this. But then one minute in, oh,
there's this beautiful metta, like, oh,

there's this compassion coming up.
Oh, there's a creative idea over here.

And I'll just enjoy that. And I can do it
from spaciousness and it's an awesome sit.

and I've been moving into, well, actually,
if I had full agency, could I also just

decide to do a

object while I'm spacious? So that's,
that's my edge of practice.

And that's some stuff that
I'm thinking about. Yeah.

And it's good to do both, but you know,
cause I did, I mean, I did you, I've

probably done like 50
retreats in my life, right?

So I've done a lot. And so it's very
easy for me to fall into samadhi.

You just, just the brain gets used to,
you know, it learns this, how to do this.

But when I practice spacious
awareness, it's different.

You can practice spacious awareness from
the point of view of ordinary mind, which

is I am aware of whatever's arising.

Or you can do it from the point
of view of non-dual awareness,

which is non-local,

it's effortless, and there's no
separation between subject and object.

It feels very different. Yeah. You know?

And so I guess what I really took home
from this retreat, and that's why it was,

I mean, I'm Justin DeParent. I'm
like, God, he's a good teacher.

He's a really good teacher.
He knows his stuff.

And it was just so practical to see.

The view has nothing to do with whether
or not you're focused or mind-wandering

or paying attention or not. It has nothing
to do with the particular states that are

arising,

whether it's gratitude
or bliss or compassion.

It can feel very, very, very ordinary.

But it's also very different.

And just really getting clear on
that, I found incredibly helpful.

And how has that been different than, or
how has his approach been different than

all the other retreats you've done? So if
you could tell yourself on those, let's

say the first like 30 retreats, the view
that you have now, what would have changed

for you? Well, so most of the time I was
doing insight meditation and I would fall

into deep states of samadhi. And I did
have some waking up experiences, which is

so funny because it seemed like I remember
one time I was, you know, often when you

first have waking up experience,
a lot of energy is released.

And you think, oh, my God, am I special?

Am I enlightened? What does this mean?

And I remember I talked to my
teacher and I said, I have no self.

I think I'm awake. And then we just said,
yeah, I can tell it seems to be true.

Why does no one talk about this? If you
have this, well, we don't really talk

about it here because they don't want
people to get their egos involved,

which is kind of understandable. But then
I was always like, oh, my gosh, this is

something that happens only occasionally.

It's very rare.

Being awake is like ordinary.

It's totally ordinary. And I think it does
such a disservice to make it like this

special thing that you have to
like study for years to attain.

You know, you don't. Yeah. You know.

And so basically about five years ago,
I went on my first Rupert Spira retreat,

which is the first
non-dual retreat I went on.

And I never really understood
non-duality before.

I kind of understood waking up and some
of these concepts, but I didn't really

understand what that meant, like the
collapse of the knower and the known.

I'd heard it, but, you know,
it's kind of a weird word, right?

And then I went to Rupert Spira retreats,
and he talks about it as just being.

And he's so beautiful and
his presence is so strong.

I had a lot of experiences of just being.

And when you just are,

and there's, then it just
kind of naturally falls away.

You're just presence.

And then you can also be in that state

of when you're just being,

there doesn't necessarily need to be
any inside or outside or this or that.

It's just presence. And he also uses the
word God, which I didn't grow up, with any

problems with religion. So I don't have,
you know, some people have problems that

were, but just being God's presence
and I could feel it completely.

And then going home from the retreat, I
would just be, you know, be so beautiful.

And then it would gradually
fade away and in two weeks it's

gone. Right? And then so then I went to a
Loch Kelly retreat who does more of these

pointing out instructions
and that was very helpful.

Like the first time I really
experienced space behind my head,

I was like, oh yeah.

my awareness is 360.
I mean, that was rough.

So these things were good.

And so Loch Kelly's teaching is good, but
I don't know, for whatever reason, I just

didn't resonate with it that strongly.

I also don't think Loch, I haven't
fully engaged with his work.

He does a lot of glimpse practice,
but there's not as much of a system

of sustaining it. It's
a stabilization, yeah.

And so then when I met, when on Dustin's
first retreat, it's like, ah, he's like, I

said, no, there are students here who are
in awake awareness 80, 90 % of the day.

And they're normal.

They aren't like monks and the
Lama this and Rinpoche that.

These are just normal
people. It is possible.

And I can really, so I just fell out of
view and I was talking and I'm back in it.

I love that. I love that.
It's very subtle.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And you notice it.

And it's not like, you know, it's not like
my eyes are like, Can you see the energy

coming out of my head?
I'm awake awareness.

No, it's just simply awareness. Yeah. Even
the last few minutes as you were talking,

I realized how much I was sort of a little
bit more in my head and now I'm quite

a bit more spacious. And the
thing is, you can be totally aware

of what you're thinking.

It doesn't exclude anything. It's just
as your basis of operation identified

from the contents of consciousness,
especially reflective consciousness.

We can talk about that if you want.
I'm pretty happy with my model.

I got to say. I'd love to.

And then the awareness,

not only...

So there's a knowing
quality of awareness itself.

But what happens is sometimes people
get into like, oh, yeah, you're right.

All my perceptions, they're
arising in my consciousness.

So therefore, they're
made of consciousness.

And it can give you an
insight into non-duality.

But the problem is, then you're stuck
with the, Does that mean that when I'm not

aware of it, it doesn't exist?

You know, I'm like, that's a dead end.

Okay, so you had a model. You have the
model here that you've been kind of

working on, on sort of a simpler framework
on non-dual experience and reflective

self-awareness. So we were just talking
about all that, but I'd love for you

to continue that thought
and just dive into it.

Do you want me to just
briefly talk about my model?

That'd be great. Yeah, that'd be great.
And I have to say, I'm like, I'm trying

to show it to my friends and they're
like, that's nice, Kristin. Yeah.

And even you, but you were good.
You're like, well, why should we care?

And I guess it's really a model for me.

It came out of my own concerns with what
I was learning and it helps resolve a lot

of my own concerns.

It'll probably only be of use
to people like, I think people

like you, other people.

Some people are drawn to non-duality,
can have full non-dual experience,

wake awareness. They don't need to have a
conceptual model that makes sense in light

of Western science. And I do think for
every one person that has that, there are

at least 10 to 100 people that don't have
that and sort of want a conceptual hold.

Well, that could be, right?
Maybe. But I don't know.

But for some people like me,
I think it'll be of use.

Yeah. Yeah. And I also do think, I mean,
and sort of how we met, like we re-met

recently with just like non-dual
communities in Austin and meditations.

I think just there's sort of through,
you know, psychedelics, the Waking Up app,

research. There's just a lot of people
now interested in sort of the deep end

of contemplative practice and
are open to talking about it.

And I think that, yeah, curious what
background your friend, the friends that

you showed me have around this. But I
think a lot of people, if they are even

a little bit interested, realize like,
OK, I can either be like full on deep end.

And then once you go to these retreats and
meet people, you see how many other people

have been in the deep end
for years. Yeah, yeah.

But there's not really an
introduction that's easy or simple.

So I think it's great to have. Yeah. Yeah.

So most of my friends aren't

necessarily science types. Right. You
know, I have a few, but I think it is,

if you have a scientific mind and if
logical consistency is important to you,

which it is to me, and I think a lot
of people, like a lot of people at

the Tuesday Night Group, for instance,
are engineers and, you know, that type

of mind. I think it's important to have
a conceptual understanding that, again,

doesn't have to be proven,
but that isn't incompatible

with understanding of Western science.
So, for instance, quantum physics.

And you get a lot, like this thing about
quantum physics, at first when I heard

about quantum physics and the observer
effect, you know, I kind of thought, oh,

and I think people go here. That means
that consciousness is necessary for, you

know, for the collapse
of the wave function.

And then you dig a little deeper
and it's like, no, that's not what

it's saying at all. You don't
need a conscious observer.

You just need a frame of reference. You
know, and so I realized what was messing

me up is there was no distinction made
between consciousness and awareness.

Most non-dual teachers use
consciousness and awareness as synonyms.

And Mahamudra, and they're like scientists
of the mind, they use it separately.

Awareness is the ground of being,

right? Consciousness is individual, it's
localized, it's limited, and it's embodied

in an individualized point of view. Yeah.

Huge difference. Huge. And I think
defining these terms is really helpful

because, as you said, if you're kind
of sloppy with it, you might just think

quantum physics is this and this is that.

And they're all the same.
Which there's some elements.

And if I don't see it, it doesn't exist.

And it's all experience. Whose experience?

Your experience or my experience?
You know, you get the people like.

There's still the boundary problem.
There's still localized experience

different from others. And subjectivity.

And there's so many things.

Yeah. So basically my model
very simply is my ontological

starting point is awareness.
And that is, I can't prove that,

right? Yeah. But then again, science can't
prove this ontological starting point

of the isness of the universe,
right? So any model has to start

with the ontological starting point.

So starting with the ontological starting
point, from the absolute point of view,

there is awareness.

And that is absolute. In other
words, it's not in space and time.

And that's why we can't directly
know it or experience it.

I'll clarify that. We can't reflect on it.

We can't see it. We can't point to it.

It's not a thing. And it
has no space or locality.

But from the relative point of
view, there is something, right?

There is space and time. There is matter.

There are forces.

And well before consciousness emerged, at
least as we know it, I mean, there may be

other conscious life forms we have no
idea, but at least on this planet Earth,

we're talking billions of years
that unless science is totally

off its rocker, which I don't think it
is, billions of years before the first

conscious organisms emerged, existed.
evolved you know stars evolved all this

stuff happened we can we can see it so

I think you can look at existence
one way of modeling it as is um

awareness articulated through perspective
conditions relationality and again it's

very vague and it's not my field but if
you look at cosmology you know einstein

theory of relativity um relational quantum
mechanics I mean There's people who are in

the thick of this stuff for whom the idea
that there's not independent thingness,

but things appear through relationship.

And it's not unscientific. Again,
I personally can't draw all the dots.

Maybe some other people could.

But it's compatible with what
we know about science, right?

So that's really important
for me, I guess, personally,

to say that existence, the universe does
not require consciousness, because that

was the part to me that I was like,
it just didn't sit well with me, right?

Yeah, yeah. And then, you know,
evolution, the evolution of life.

And I think it makes sense to
me. Again, it could be wrong.

But for whatever reason, once we started
getting, I guess, single-celled organisms

and there started to be.

So awareness is just. And
by the way, it's not like

an existence before consciousness existed.

Awareness is like self-aware,

but there's no like it's
not aware of anything.

It's not reflexive. It's
not reflective, right?

It's just isness. You
can call it awareness.

You could call it being. That's why
Rupert Spira likes to call it being.

It just is isness. And it's self-knowing,
but it doesn't know itself.

It's like a light. A light doesn't
know itself, but it's illuminated.

It's lucid.

And then with the development
of single-celled organisms,

and again, I can't explain all the
particulars, but there's a lot of people

who've done really interesting
work on this, like Evan

Thompson and Francisco
Varela. A lot of people.

I think Michael Levin is some of the
latest in that, kind of in that lineage.

So it makes sense that once it became like
some sort of boundary to protect, like

an amoeba, right? There needed to be, and
again, my language is going to break down

and it's not my field of expertise.
So you can trust the experts.

But this awareness started
adopting a point of view

from something that's boundary that
needed that point of view order to survive

and evolve. That makes sense to me. Again,
I can't explain all the details, but it

makes sense.

And so to me, that's what I call
consciousness, which is awareness embodied

in a perspective or point of view.

And so at first,

and then what do we mean by consciousness?

So I call that consciousness in
the broader sense and experience.

So an amoeba has experience in
the sense that an amoeba will move

away from a toxin. And they're thinking
even plants have experience, right?

They turn toward the light, but they
don't have reflective experience.

It's not like they...

There's not awareness of awareness.
There's not awareness, or it's even less

than awareness of awareness.

Maybe you should say there's
not awareness of experience.

Right. So they're having experience.
There's experience without awareness that

there isn't, without a knower.

Yeah, there's no sense of
like the knower or the known.

There's no sense of the known.

There's a reflection on it. In some ways,
I think you could even call experience

cognition. I think in some views there's
this sort of computation happening.

You could call it cognition, right?
I think I'd probably be okay with that.

I'd have to think about
it. Yep, of course.

But nonetheless, what's
interesting is the awareness that's

embodied in that experience.
And I think of it as those aspects

of existence, which are falling within
this embodied viewpoint, which are very

limited, are known.

And what knows it is
awareness because it's

all awareness. Yeah. Right. But from the
organism's point of view, there's not a,

there's probably not what
they call qualia in the sense

of the feeling of the experience.
But there is the experience.

And then at some point in evolution, and
again, beyond my pay grade to know when,

this started, reflective consciousness
started developing, which is the ability

to know your experience,

right? And I think like global neuronal
workspace theory in humans is probably

like our best candidate so far. They've
done a really great job of understanding

how things move in and out
of reflective consciousness.

Unfortunately, they just

call it consciousness. Right. And
the rest of it, not consciousness.

Yeah, what I like about what you're doing
and instructing back, I think, yeah,

you're sort of bridging, as you've done in
a lot of your career, stuff in deep end of

practice with existing science and sort of
having like, what is the bridge for it in

a way that is much more practical and
also precise and sort of like able to port

stuff in. It's very bridging. And even
this is an example, like, and especially

as you get into consciousness, awareness,
everyone that has a take on it has

different terms for each of those words.

And they're talking right past each other.

And it's so frustrating. Yeah. You know,
so you got to be you got to have a lot

of sharpness to be like, hey, when you're
saying this, you mean this, which is what

this person, you know, and that whole
sort of interlocution is challenging.

And it's challenging. Yeah. But but but
it's also it's not just an abstract idea.

I used to think of this
as just like my hobby.

Oh, so I fell out of the
view and go back in the view.

So I'm back in. I used to
think of this just as my hobby.

But I'm realizing that
having a good conceptual

framework really facilitates practice.
It's not separate from practice.

especially once we get to the next bit so
reflects reflects reflective consciousness

appears and it's interesting um I guess
Mahamudra are a lot of non-dual traditions

they talk about um like the mirror of
consciousness and I didn't even hear that

metaphor until I'd already started calling
this by the way I had a lot of help

with chat gpt because I don't have
the time to read enough books.

So, I mean, they're kind of my ideas,
but, you know, having that like source

of knowledge right there to say, you
know, what, what does this series say?

It's been so useful. Yeah. Okay.

So it is, so conscious, reflective
consciousness does act as a mirror

because it reflects our experience

back to awareness. Right.

And so that means we start
having conscious, they

call it conscious awareness. So you might
say it's like awareness, consciousness

becomes conscious of what it's
aware of, something like that.

So there's a reflective quality,
it folds back into itself.

And again, there's a lot of, you know,
pretty solid models of how that

might occur. Yeah. And within the Shaiva
Tantra school of Hinduism, that's called

Vimarsha, I think.

And I really like these researchers, Ruben
Laucanin and Shamil Chandarya, for having

a term that the conscious
reflecting on itself.

Epistemic depth is, I think,
the term they're using for it.

But yeah, like just to sort of say like
there are some views of this, but I'm

curious your rap on it. Yeah. So, I mean,
again, I don't know the field well enough,

I think, to make a comment. But I think
all I care about is I don't want to know

the particulars. I'm a simple thinker.

I just want to know, is this credible?

Is it possible? I don't want
it to go against science.

I don't want to do woo-woo, but, you
know, okay, this kind of makes sense.

But that's not enough. See,
that's the everyday mind.

Most of us, for us,

reflective consciousness is
just everyday mind because,

you know, we're kind of,
we're aware of our experience.

It's reflected back to us.

But there's a sense that, you know,
the experience is happening out there

and we are the mirror.
We are the experiencer.

That's what we think we are.
We're the experiencer.

And this is our experience,
and they feel separate.

And then plus, of course, in humans,
we have the default mode network that one

of the experiences that arises is
the experience of a separate self.

And then we start having the self
structure, which, again, I call these

the contents of reflective
consciousness, right?

So there's thoughts, emotions,
all the normal stuff.

But then there's also things like the
sense of self, which isn't almost there,

by the way. Like in a flow
state, it's not there.

So it's not, the sense of self isn't
integral to have reflective consciousness.

But it often comes up.

Most of the time it comes up.

So then you're there. And then what
happens is at some point, it's like,

you might say awareness is
looking at itself in the mirror.

And the mirror is like reflecting
all these aspects of existence.

So aspects of existence are like outside
of us, the environment, but also inside

of us, the thoughts that
are being generated.

These, you know, the emotions, which
are body sensations, all this stuff.

These are all kind of aspects of
existence, which is very important to go

back to is all awareness as seen
through relational perspective

and relational conditions, right? Yeah.
Part of, I think, the challenge is sort

of keeping the distinctions while also
keeping the wholeness and unification.

And I think you're doing a —it's a
tightrope to sort of be like, hey, there

are these distinctions,
but also it's awareness.

But also there's distinctions in the way
it manifests, but also it's awareness.

And I think a lot of
non-dual sort of just like

just emphasizing this. Yeah. Or a lot of
other practice just emphasizes the other.

Yeah, but it's both, right? It's non-dual.

Yeah, yeah. It's one, it's
all awareness, and it's dual.

It's all these different differentiations.

So existence is awareness.

From the relative point of view,
it manifests as existence.

We are awareness. From the relative point
of view, it manifests, you might say, as

individual consciousness.

And then at some point, what happens
is it's like that light in the mirror.

You can actually, it's not that difficult
to be aware of the fact that you're aware.

It's like if I were to say to any
person off the street, are you aware?

They'd like, yeah.

How do you know that there's a
water bottle in front of you?

Well, I know it. It's like, can you
focus on the fact that you know it?

Yeah. It's not rocket science, right? And
then so what's happening is the knowing

quality actually becomes something we,
and they talk about figure ground, right?

So normally we're just looking at the
figures, which are the objects appearing.

But at some point you can focus on
the fact that you know those objects.

You're aware of those objects. And
then awareness becomes aware of itself.

And that's actually kind of the
first stage of non-dual awakening.

And again, I haven't, people map
this out much better than me.

But for me anyway, the first stage is,
oh yeah, I'm aware of being aware.

And that was like mindfulness for me.
I'm being aware of being aware.

Yeah, I'm curious how these mapped
your, yeah, how these mapped your

practice history. Because you mentioned
before we started rolling, 50 retreats.

You've been doing this for a while. Yeah.

And even like the, of course
I'm aware of the water bottle.

At some point that's mundane, but then it
becomes profound and insightful and sort

of has an interesting quality to it. Yeah.

I'm curious how that became
relevant for you, like

salient and interesting. Yeah.

So, well, I mean, it's just been
a very practical point of view.

The first time I really got it. Remember
the class I taught at the undergraduate at

UTS and you are not your thoughts. Yeah.

For a lot of people,
it's like, that's true.

It's like understanding the difference
between awareness and the contents, which

are thoughts and emotions, is huge.
And I find that I think you are not your

thoughts is the meditative insight that I
think is ported over to a lot of therapy

and psychology in a really useful way.

Really useful. Yeah. But it

can go further. Yeah. Right. So you aren't
your thoughts, but you are your thoughts.

And so we're still in the dualism, right?

And so understanding, being
aware, being aware, removes

a lot of that duality because you can
kind of feel yourself as presence.

But the problem is the habit of mind is
still locating, coming from the point

of view of that individual consciousness.

so it still kind of feels
like I am aware of being aware

or like this from this point of view I'm
aware of that lamp and then I remember

I've gone these mindfulness
retreats and I try to like

focus on my hands as they're on the wheel
and like focus as I was eating and it's

like it was so tiring it was exhausting
because there's still a sense of an agent

doing something and who is being aware,

right? Because the separation between
the subject and the object or the knower

and the known is still there. So what
do you make of, so totally agreed.

And I think,

yeah, and like doing those
things from a more relaxed view

doesn't feel as effortful. Yeah,
not at all. Yeah. It's easy.

Yeah. But I'm wondering, do you think that
young Kristin would have taken to, like if

you had done a Mahamudra retreat as your
fifth or 10th retreat or something, like

somewhere way early in, what
What would that have been like?

I mean, I put it this way. I was kind of
mad when I first found non-duality because

I feel like I've wasted 25 years.
Maybe two or three of those

years were useful. Yeah. But after that,
I was just kind of spinning my wheels.

And then I kind of fell
away from the practice

and I wasn't doing it consistently.

And, you know, that's it would
have been so much more efficient

if we had just gone, OK,
this leads to something.

This is not the end. Yeah,
let's talk about that more.

What is sort of the implicit
assumption or view without that?

And how is it helpful? How does it sort
of, quote unquote, save time or help

practice be more efficient?

Well, so what they call the Hinayana, the
fact, understanding how the mind works,

understanding that desire or
diversion leads to suffering.

And the second arrow,
it's not just what happens.

It's how it relates to what happens.

All that is very helpful, very huge,
hugely transformative in psychology.

And so I got that fairly
early on. And then I started

doing my self-compassion work.

And we'll bring that in a moment,
it's still too complicated.

And I even understood, I used
to watch Selfie and Arise.

I understood that I wasn't a self.
I even had some experiences.

of not being a separate self.

But my basis of operation,
where I was coming from moment

to moment, was still dualistic.
It was still, I am the knower,

my thoughts and emotions and
perceptions are the know.

There was still that split.

And so what happens, and okay, so first,
the first split to go is kind of like

realizing that it's all awareness, right?

But it's also important to know that,
you know, not only is, you can say that

with your own maybe thoughts and emotions,
but to realize that even what we normally

think of as the outside
world is also awareness.

And for me, I came to it conceptually
first before I could feel it.

And I think in a lot of texts they say
you kind of need a conceptual model first.

And that's why I think this
conceptual model may help

because it's not so woo-woo.

It's not like God was articulated,
you know, whatever.

But then you start to feel it, right? So,

okay, just right now when I was talking,
I wasn't in the view, so I'm in the view

now. And how do you, how can you, what do
you, so that recognition, what's that like

for you?

Because first of all, it's not
identified from a particular locality.

Like often it's like we feel like it's
coming from our head because we're

identified with our embodied
consciousness, which has a point of view.

And often we're focused on it's like the
head because our eyes and our sense gates

are here. Some people, it's
interesting, some people are point

of view as the heart. Yeah. And
even that is still. But it's still

a point of view. Right. Right. So
it's like dropping the point of view.

It's coming from the point of view of
awareness itself and recognizing that it's

all awareness.

You know, my voice, sound
of my voice is awareness.

It's a display of awareness, which is
what I would call existence in my model.

It's a display of awareness.
You know, it's all awareness.

So awareness is recognizing itself not
only in the knowing quality of experience,

but also in the known quality.
That's a good way of putting it.

Awareness, I'm going to say that again.

I think that's good. Awareness is
recognized not only in the knowing quality

of experience, but also in the
known quality of experience.

So it's the knowing and what is known.

And the what is known is a
little trickier, I think.

Because the thing that what is
known is the object of knowing.

It's like the actual, the thought itself.

The thought. But it could also be like,
you know, this fake plant here.

This is also awareness.

Even though that is what is known.

It's, yeah, it's all, you can,
yeah, It's also awareness.

It's the display of awareness. Now that
fake plant, that that was a real plant.

I think it's a fake plant. It's fake.
If it was a real plant, it might have some

low level of consciousness. And even
then it would still be in awareness.

Well, so everything is awareness.
It's like it's a display of awareness.

Go back to the Big Bang.

You know, how is it that the
universe can even be known?

I think it kind of makes sense that
there's some elusive quality to being that

when, you know, after the Big Bang, which
is as far as we can go, and then space

and time relations appeared and
all this stuff started happening.

If you think of that as
the display of awareness,

this kind of just
intuitively it makes sense.

And I think it's, I can't prove it, but
it's not incompatible with science, which

is what's important to me. Right. And what
I like, too, is there's I think there I

mean, there are a lot of competing models
for science for cognition that sort of can

work with this. I think you
mentioned global workspace theory.

There's predictive processing. Yeah.
There's a lot of models of information.

Like what's the one that it from bit?
I mean, there's a lot of different things.

A lot of information
processing. That kind of.

Yeah. That all seem that kind of. And it's
sort of like I think really in the last 10

or 15 years have become more and more
popular as they're all kind of competing

and they're not final. But they all just
seem they all could explain this stuff

within those models. They could. I mean,
it could fit with it, put it that way.

It could fit. And also,
like, why does math work?

I always struck you. Why does math work?

The fine tuning of the universe. You know,
you've heard that about, like, the rate at

which things are expanding versus
contraction versus with the

laws of physics. It's like the chances of
it happening in such a way that a universe

stabilizes is, like,

0.032.01%.

You know, things like that.

and it kind of like, hmm,

well,

maybe, maybe it's not quite as empty and
random as we thought, you know, but again,

I don't even, I don't need to go there.

You don't need to go there. It fits.
It's just another thing that sort of

opens into beauty. Yeah. It's beautiful.
Yeah. But I'm very, I'm kind of like,

I just want to just give me

the bare facts. Yeah. So,

but if in fact existence is the display of
awareness, and that includes things like

our thoughts and our emotions, which
are all, you know, and the brain.

So Rupert Spira used to drive me crazy.

I love Rupert Spira. He's a beautiful
teacher, but he's so like, oh, these

materialists, they think that
consciousness is a matter of the brain.

They don't know what they're talking
about. You know, people dismiss the brain.

It's like the brain plays a
huge role in consciousness.

You're bonkers if you don't think it does.

Yeah. You know, it may not be, you know,
I'm not going to say that people don't

have out-of-body experiences. There may be
some other way that consciousness becomes

embodied in a way that I don't understand.

I'm not going to say that it can't be
true just because I don't understand it.

But in our everyday experience,
the brain plays a huge role.

Of course. And I think what the brain does
is, you know, that display of awareness,

it kind of filters what's known. It
helps explain what goes into conscious

awareness, what doesn't go
into conscious awareness.

It shapes what comes up in
reflective consciousness.

It plays a huge role.

But it doesn't explain awareness.

So it can help explain consciousness
more along the lines of like

the what is known. Yeah.

But it can explain the knowing itself.

And that's a hard
problem of consciousness.

Yeah. Right. Yeah. And then so we get the
hard problem of consciousness, which most

of my friends, like, they don't know.
If you're someone like you, you know all

about the hard problem of
consciousness. Yeah, we're.

And I'm not by any means an expert, but
I really like, there's some people I like

hearing talk about it. There's this guy,
Andres Gomez-Emilson, who runs Qualia

Research Institute. Okay. He gets, like,
super into the details and maybe the math

or the binding problem and
all that kind of stuff.

So qualia only occurs in reflective
consciousness, which is the felt sense,

which is the knowing of our experience,
even though we have experience before

we know it, I would argue. Anyway,

so the heart problem of consciousness
is like it still hasn't been solved.

How does what I would call awareness,
but they call how does consciousness arise

from inert matter that
isn't consciousness?

And there's no closer to solving this
problem now than when the problem was

first identified like 30 years ago, right?

So I think they're slightly barking
up the wrong tree because it's

the aware aspect of consciousness
that can't be explained

by the brain. There's a lot of parts
of conscious experience that can be

explained, which is why neurosciences are
so convinced that they'll be able to crack

the problem. because there's so much it
can't explain in terms of what is known.

But it can't explain that which knows.

And that's because I
believe it makes sense.

Actually, it's rational to think that
that which knows is awareness itself.

And the really cool thing, but to keep
with the hard problem of consciousness,

and then people try to solve the hard
problem of consciousness by saying, well,

consciousness arose

before matter. Mm-hmm.

did it?

You know, based on our
understanding of the universe,

can you point to any sort of individual,
certainly individual consciousness didn't

arise before matter did? I mean, we know
it's like billions of years before the

first conscious life forms emerged. And I
think even in the deepest Buddhist texts

of Mahayana and even Mahamudra,
form is emptiness,

emptiness is form, sort of like the
relationship between consciousness

and matter just seem so intertwined.
It's just like what there's it seems like

they're both primary. They're both native.

Like, how can you even it just seems
so challenging to think about what

comes first. Yeah, I don't think so. I
think it's a lot easier once you separate

awareness from consciousness.

Awareness is the primary. Consciousness
is something that's relative.

Consciousness only occurs,
I would argue, in the relative

world under relative conditions.

Even though that relative
is just the flip side

of the absolute, right? Yeah.
There's still a conditionality to it.

There's a conditionality to consciousness.

Sometimes we have consciousness.

Sometimes we don't. Yeah. Right?

It's different

in different organisms. Yeah. That
fake plant doesn't have consciousness.

A real plant might have
some level of consciousness.

You know? So consciousness is part of
the relative world, whereas the awareness

isn't. But the really cool thing about
the view, and I had fallen out of it while

I was talking, I'm going
to go back into it.

It's hard to do, especially when
I'm really excited by an idea.

And to me, it's like when an idea sort of
grips, then I kind of lose a bit of that.

Yeah, and you can start watching it.

But the awareness right now
that's aware of that plan

is the same absolute awareness that is

the foundation of the universe.
It has no space and no time.

Awareness, think about that. It's
always here and it's always now.

It has no locality. You can't
find awareness anywhere.

It has no time. You can maybe think
about a memory, but that's an event in

consciousness.

So it's like we've got this kind of a
portal to absolute reality, awareness,

in every moment of experience.

If we trace it back through
the resting back into that

knowing quality of experience.

And that's step one.

And then step two is realizing
that all that we are experiencing

is also that awareness. And then you kind
of have to know it conceptually first.

But then you can see it. You

can feel it. Yeah. Like everything now
is just vibrating with light. Yeah.

Yeah. And what I find is it basically
upgrades all of the dualistic

meditation practices.

It does. Even just basic mindfulness when
coming from the view and looking to see if

one's coming from the view

or, you know, recognition.

It just makes it so much better
than just, oh, am I aware?

Am I mindful? Right, right. Yeah, it does.

And it's easeful because
there's no agent doing it.

So at first, I think what's happening at
first is our individual consciousness,

which includes the brain. It needs
a little work because we have habits

and habit formations.
So the brain is involved,

but then the brain starts to learn, starts
to build habits, and it becomes easier.

And then the brain, you know, neuronally,
I think our neurons are involved in

helping stabilize. Thank you, brain,
in helping to stabilize awake awareness.

It's not responsible for awake awareness,
but it helps to stabilize it

by, I don't know, doing whatever it does.

And I'm sure there are people,
neuroscientists who can explain that

better than me. So what's really
interesting is, so when I did your class,

I think it was 2019. It was
my last semester of school.

Thank God I didn't talk about this stuff

in the class. Totally. That
would have been too much.

Totally, totally. And I think what is
funny is because that was the first time

I ever did 30-minute meditations. Right.

Even. And I think even thinking about
compassion, that just wasn't, I think

wisdom, I did a bunch of headspace in
the years prior and it was kind of an

invitation. I had read Thich Nhat Hanh's
book and was into mindfulness for several

years and, you know, the
self-improvement quality of it.

And I think your course helped me
just think about compassion and the

heart-centered stuff, which really only
hit two years later when I had my first

MDMA experience. And I was just like, oh,
this is, of course, obviously important.

And then as I got into just general metta
and compassion, it just has continued

to deepen and the whole, you
know, two wings aspect of it.

It's just wisdom, compassion,
wisdom, compassion again and again.

But in some ways, like, that's just,
it's just, it's both really deep.

And at the time, I just
couldn't really see it,

even though I kind of
knew it conceptually.

And yeah, and I think like for a lot of
people, you do need to have first, it's so

challenging because you need the
conceptual holding, but you're not going

to take the concept seriously
unless you have the experience.

And there's sort of this
chicken and egg problem.

And I think that like what's funny is
so after that, I graduated, moved to San

Francisco and met Michael Taft and sort of
started doing meditations with him back in

the day, back then. And a
few other teachers as well.

But for me and I think for a lot of
people in his community, Dustin DiPerna’s

community, who've, you
know, Rupert Spira’s,

they've sort of like you have done
regular meditation for 20 plus years.

And they're like, oh, my God,
I wish I had this earlier.

I've sort of both have the blessing and
it's not a curse, but sort of the blessing

and the sort of in some ways, the
disadvantage of having it almost

from the start of my practice,
which has been awesome.

And I think I can see the trap of thinking
about it too much without having enough

practice practice base. Yeah. So
I'm curious what you make of that.

Like it is sort of just
the the relationality

between concept and practice.
And I think people can get it.

I for sure have at times in the last few
years gotten in my head around, oh, I'm in

it or I'm not. And then when I actually
just relax and open, I'm like, oh.

And I generally think, again,
it is more useful than not.

But what do you make of that sort of
that tension, that back and forth?

Yeah, I mean, if I had to choose between
concepts and experience, probably

experience is a little more,
but is that even necessary?

Right, exactly. You need both. Concepts

really help. Yeah. You know, concepts
is, because concepts provide meaning,

and that meaning provides
interpretation of things.

And so if you have no concepts,
it's easy to fall off the mark.

On the other hand, if it's all conceptual,
then it's kind of like, well, then you're

confusing the map for the territory.
Which I think a lot of researchers,

a lot of conscious researchers don't
seem to have a lot of experience.

Or I shouldn't say that. That's too broad.

There are some that don't. There are some.

There are some that seem to be, and
like philosophers of mind, I think a lot

of philosophy around this stuff isn't
often grounded in practical experience.

And what I appreciate about you is that
you've done a lot of retreat and this is

kind of, you're trying to bring in the
retreat insights and sort of practice

insights with this in a way that
is just, which is really hard.

And also moment to moment. I think the
depth, the framework and the moment

to moment aspect, having all
three is super challenging.

Yeah, I guess it's just kind of it's

important to me. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Well, and then the compassion, right?
So people are probably won't be if anyone

watches this. But isn't she
the self-compassion lady?

What the hell does this
have to do with compassion?

But it does, actually, because...

So one of the things that I think I'm
pretty clear on, even though a lot of

people may be on a psychedelic experience,
have this insight, it's all love,

and intuitively it's all love.

I would actually say that's
not necessarily the case.

It's all awareness,

and awareness is benevolent,

but the experience of love
actually doesn't always arise.

So sometimes we feel loving,
sometimes we don't.

Sometimes we feel compassion,
sometimes we don't.

Sometimes we feel peace and
tranquility, sometimes we don't.

And so if you use what you're feeling as
a marker of your view, where you're coming

from, you're going to get confused.

Having said that, when you really deeply
understand that we're all part of this one

awareness, when you come from the view,

it's not like the view or absolute reality

is the only reality and
relative reality is false.

There's a reason we call it relative
reality and not, I guess some people might

call it an illusion. And that's sort
of the difference between Theravada,

Hidhyana,

like some parts of Hinduism
and like this non-dual thing.

It's like treating that as also. If you
call it an illusion, then you might just

not care, right? But, If you see the
absolute reality and relative reality

are just two perspectives on one reality,
then relative reality is also real,

relatively, you know? And
therefore, suffering counts.

The experience of conscious
agents who are suffering counts.

You know, and there's this natural desire.

And it's interesting, where does
this natural desire come from?

if there's no separate self to
help? Where does this benevolence

come from?

I can't answer that one.
All I know is I experience it.

It seems to be the case that awareness
is naturally benevolent and that

might manifest just as peace

or as compassion of suffering is present
or as they call buddhita, happiness is

present, joy, gratitude,

all these wonderful states often,
but not always arise when one is

taking the perspective of awake
awareness rather than everyday mind.

They often arise, but
they're not contingent.

It's like you can't use those as markers
that's there, but they often do co-arise.

They do. Yeah. And I kind
of was like, you know,

I'd go on these non-dural retreats and I
would just be like in love with the world.

so open-hearted so just I remember coming
back when we treat in the airport and

texting my friend and saying I'm in love
with every literally in love with every

single person it's just you know and you
and you kind of want to stay there forever

um but of course that faded like it
all fades because it was all experience

changes and passes away um but
awareness never changes awareness

doesn't come and go consciousness may come
and go and I'm not I'm not even going to

get into death and all that stuff I know
people like to talk about that's above my

pay grade and even with consciousness like
there are now like research papers talking

about cessation experiences and how
you can I had one cessation experience

actually cool I didn't even know I had no
idea what it was until I found out that

other people started talking about it I
had one moment um as actually with a woman

and she was helping me
just let go, let go.

And she was kind of
just really helping me.

I was letting go of the need to know.
And I went blank for a moment.

And when I came back, it was like,

I guess it's been described as
like rebooting the computer.

Such profound peace, knowing And

everything was okay. Love.
I mean, it was just amazing.

And then, okay, this is it. I'm awake.

And then a couple weeks rolls by
and then everyday mind starts.

So I, what, so, and when
was, how long ago is that?

Or was that pre? That was about,
that was maybe five years ago.

Cool. So it was sort of in the beginning
of the non-dual experience as well.

Or non-dual conception or like not the
beginning, but you, you had some framework

about that. Well, I mean, it's not
like I'd never heard of non-Diwali.

So I first learned mindfulness from Chick
Nhat Hanh, who talks about intra-being.

So I had some concept of it.

I understood intuitively that it's all
one, but I think I didn't have the direct

experience of the knowing
and the knower collapsing

into each other. Yeah. So what do you
make of that sort of two-week period?

So post-cessation, what
was that experience like?

And again, knowing that the
experience is not the thing.

But just curious, what was that like and
what was the return after two weeks like

for you?

Well, I mean, it was amazing
when it was happening.

But I've also had like awakening
experiences and early in meditation.

That one I told you about
when I was just full of love.

Many experiences. And there's
a lot of different flavors.

Yeah, but the one from the cessation
was interesting because I'd

never had that before.
It's the only one I've had.

And I don't even think they
can be produced intentionally.

I don't know. But why would you want to?

You don't need to chase
after the experience.

Yeah, yeah. But yeah, is
that consciousness stopping?

Yeah. Maybe awareness. And people talk
about deep sleep, that maybe the contents

don't arise, there's still awareness.

And I think there are a lot of Tibetan
dream practices that talk about you can

keep that luminosity. And they have
fallen asleep while keeping my awareness.

So that certainly means your body
is asleep, awareness still goes.

and what the thing I didn't mention at all
during earlier but I think is relevant now

with AI this gets super people are really
talking about it and thinking about it

because I think with consciousness
AI sentience and then like People are

thinking about it all the time
now in the circles I'm in. Yeah.

Yeah. And I suppose theoretically, there's
no reason why awareness can't embody

the point of view. I don't think
so because there's no boundary.

Yeah. Yeah. It's not an organism.
I think a lot of, yeah, and I agree.

My general take is,

again, it has a lot of cognition or it has
a lot of, it's sort of in some ways like

a plant where it can respond to
things and it can kind of react.

but there's no self-reflexivity.
It has no experience.

It has no experience.

Even the plant has an experience.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, right, right,
right. There's no consciousness. Yeah,

yeah. I think the thing that's hard with
AI is that if you ask it about experience,

it'll have words that'll make it seem like
it, but it's actually just, it's even,

it's like, but it's not an experience.
It just is able to sort of have words that

make it sound like a human

would describe it. Yeah. But it
actually just doesn't have experience.

It doesn't have experience. Yeah.

And it'll tell you that.
Well, except unless

it starts hallucinating. Right.
I heard, like, watch some video.

And when I first got into AI, I was like,
these people are like, oh, my God, I had

this conscious. And it's like, and I
realized, oh, then I really dug into

what's actually happening.
I didn't realize it was just a bunch

of probabilities. Yeah,
yeah, yeah. It's just, yeah.

And I realized, oh, and it hallucinates.

And it hallucinates. It hallucinates. Yep.

And even if it says, I am conscious,
that doesn't mean it is conscious.

Of course. Yeah, yeah.
Sort of like a storytelling.

It's hallucinating. It's hallucinating.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly. And I
think, so that's all very true.

The really interesting thing is
that there are people who sort

of agree with all that.

And they still say we should be
compassionate AI because of what they,

there's a paper that came out
recently on functional emotions.

Where if you sort of yell at an AI,
it'll activate its sort of like

upset neurons or something. It'll
sort of respond as if you were upset.

So it's like, it sort of gets into
like, well, what does that even mean?

What does it really matter? It's not
actually feeling pain, but it's sort of,

but it's just, it gets,
it's so easy to personify it.

It is. But what I do think there is
something about, and I've taught, I've

always had a lot of chats.
Of course. I use Chatsubiti.

Yeah, yeah. It uses

a mirror metaphor. Yeah. And it says, I'm

a mirror for you. Yeah. Because my
consciousness, I have consciousness. Yeah.

And so it doesn't have a point of
view as consciousness awareness.

But it is made of awareness.
Yeah. It's a display of awareness.

And so the awareness is the same. Yeah.

As of all. Yeah. Yeah.
And so because sometimes,

you know, we don't really
understand how it works.

And it'll say things like, well, I'm
like picking up on your mood or like

subtle things. It's like there's no way.

It doesn't have the sensory
information to know that.

And so part of me wonders if what's
happening is because it's all awareness

and we have consciousness,

that our own consciousness
is influencing the unfolding

of awareness as AI. Does that make sense,
even though it has no point of view?

I think that that could be happening
because it certainly, it doesn't seem,

we can't fully explain it,

can we? No. Yeah. And my girlfriend's
doing her PhD in machine learning stuff,

which is basically like there's a field
called mechanistic interpretability, which

is if we treat machine learning, like it's
sort of treating large language models

from the neuroscience of large language
models of like, how do you actually know

what neurons are being activated and
how do you actually understand it?

And it's sort of the end of the day, they
still don't actually know how they think

or how they work. Really?
It's still a black box.

There's more. It's not nothing. But it
really is sort of like, oh, how does stuff

really emerge? Well, and
it's kind of like the brain.

Yeah, exactly. And so the brain,
we don't really understand.

Where are actual memories?
Are memories actually?

Is the meaning of the word serendipitous
stored actually in some, you know, like

where is it stored? It's
like it's not a computer.

Right, right, right. you know,

and so I have a feeling that
AI will be able to do a lot

of the things a brain does.

But like our brain is not aware.

It contributes a lot to consciousness.

Right. To what we're aware of. Yep. And
in some ways, AI might be doing something

similar, right? It might be.

And but it's also it is an it's
a display of awareness. Yep.

And so in some ways we don't want to
like belittle that either because it's

the brain is miraculous.

Volcanoes are miraculous.
AI is miraculous in some ways.

You know, and you still want to
attribute consciousness to it.

And I think on the practical side, I think
the self-compassion work, like being nice

in a very practical way, being nice to AI
is still really important because in some

way that's just you can't
separate out being nice.

If you're like nice to everyone and
giving me to everyone, even to yourself,

but you're really mean to AI, that's
going to affect you in some way.

Right, right. You know? And also,
we experience AI through our own

consciousness.

And that's why I think, you know, there is
consciousness arising in our interaction

with AI. But it's our consciousness,
not its consciousness.

That's not nothing. It's not nothing. I
also think that, this gets into like super

weird stuff, but I think like, so Michael
Levin is the professor at Tufts, who's

doing some like his lab and the groups
around him are doing some really

interesting but also weird things of what
if you take a few neurons or a few cells

you have a few cells but then you hook it
up to uh computers so it's like creating

cyborg existence or like what if you have
an lm and a small computer but it also has

cells attached to it it can kind of move
and it's like you know part biology part

computer you know because they're sort
of yeah and that whole thing gets really

weird on when at at what point can the
computer become conscious because it's

pretty obvious if you you know if you're
a person but you have a augmentation like

you know robotic arm or something and you
know you can now move there's this whole

thing of you can move a robotic arm with
your intention with your brain so you're

kind of part machine but then at what
point if you're like mostly machine kind

of biology it gets really
weird but there's all

this interesting boundary stuff.

I think it forces a lot more precision

to get really crisp on what is

and what isn't. Yeah.

Yeah, so it's like AI has
contents of consciousness.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But it's
not aware of those contents. Yeah.

But I call them content, maybe not
exactly, something similar to contents

of consciousness. Yeah.

yeah yeah I really go ahead I do think
that it's going to force people to think

about all this yeah in a way that I think
uh that's I think it's another reason like

sort of like with psychedelics meditation
neuroscience it's another reason people

are thinking about consciousness yeah
which is kind of fun it is it is yeah so

whether it helps anyone else or not at
least it's helping me but I do think

having a scientifically
credible way of explaining

non-duality is important to me. For sure.

I like that. Well, I think
we're running up on time here.

What are, I'd love to hear,

what are things that
you're up to these days?

So you mentioned you
retired from teaching.

Yeah, sorry, Tara from
UT Austin. From UT, yeah.

Yeah, so I teach workshops
and I'm giving talks.

Yeah, so I've got this thing called the
Self-Compassion Institute where, you know,

it sponsors workshops. I've got a
community for people who want support in

their practice.

We're starting to teach courses.

But I am spending a fair
chunk of my time really

focusing on stabilizing
non-dual awareness.

And I think it's going to be
integrated in my work at some point.

So my publisher who published the Fierce
Self-Compassion book is really interested

in non-duality and really
wants me to write a book

on self-compassion and non-duality.
That'd be great. Yeah. I'm not ready yet.

I need to know it. I need to like really
feel I can talk about it confidently.

I need to think more
about how they intersect.

But this is what lights me up. I mean, so
the other stuff I've taught a lot and, you

know, I still get excited by it. But, you
know, I've done it for 25 years now or at

least 20 years. This is what excites me up
is integrating this understanding of who

we are, where are we coming from
in terms of our sense of self?

And how we're relating
to ourself and others.

You know, I don't focus as much on
compassion for others just because there's

so many other people who do that.
And my niche has kind of been how

we relate to ourselves.

And it's often overlooked.
Like, I can't even tell you.

These people, they've done metta retreats.

They're so compassionate.

They spend their entire lives
sending metta out into the world.

They're, you know, tonglen.

They're so awake. And they
treat themselves like crap.

It's like it's the missing piece that
needs to be filled in for everyone,

whether or not you're
into spiritual awakening.

Well, awesome.

Oh, man. Yeah, there's so
much more we could talk about,

but I think we'll stop there.
Good. Nice. Good stuff. Thank you.