My Kabbalah course at OccultCourses.com is where Meister Eckhart keeps coming up, and in this Ask Baal episode I finally explain why. I go through his ideas on God and the Godhead, the ground of the soul, and living without why, and I compare them with the Ein Sof, the Sefirot, and what Crowley and Austin Spare taught about letting go of the result. I also say plainly where Eckhart and the Kabbalists part ways.
My Kabbalah course at OccultCourses.com is where Meister Eckhart keeps coming up, and in this Ask Baal episode I finally explain why. I go through his ideas on God and the Godhead, the ground of the soul, and living without why, and I compare them with the Ein Sof, the Sefirot, and what Crowley and Austin Spare taught about letting go of the result. I also say plainly where Eckhart and the Kabbalists part ways.
A listener who is taking my Kabbalah course asked why I mention Meister Eckhart so often, and I realized I had never stopped to explain it. In this Ask Baal episode I take a medieval Dominican friar born around 1260 and show why I think he belongs in a conversation about magick. These are hard ideas, so I try to put them as plainly as I can.
What this episode covers:
Who Eckhart was, his two terms as a master of theology at the University of Paris, and why his German sermons matter more here than his Latin writings
The heresy proceedings in Cologne, his appeal to the Pope, and the 1329 bull of John XXII that condemned 28 statements
God and the Godhead, and what he meant by praying to God to be made free of God
The ground of the soul and the line about the eye with which I see God
Detachment, the poor in spirit, and living without why
The birth of God in the soul and the breakthrough into the Godhead
Why he gives no technique and distrusts visions and raptures
The Ein Sof and the Sefirot beside the Godhead and God
Isaac of Acre, hishtavut (equanimity) and bitul
Why there is no evidence Eckhart read Kabbalah, and what Maimonides and Neoplatonism have to do with it
Where the two part ways, with tikkun as the clearest example
What Crowley in the Book of the Law and Austin Spare's sigil method share with Eckhart, and how the abyss in Hermetic Kabbalah compares with his breakthrough
Courses I mention in this episode are my Kabbalah course and The Truth Is Not Flat, both at OccultCourses.com.
If you want to go deeper into Kabbalah, Neoplatonism, grimoires and the rest of the Western esoteric traditions, you will find all my courses at OccultCourses.com. Thank you for listening.
Chapters:
00:00 Welcome and the question about Meister Eckhart
01:44 Who Meister Eckhart was
04:25 The heresy proceedings and the papal bull
07:01 God and the Godhead
10:01 The ground of the soul
11:58 Detachment and living without why
13:54 The birth of God in the soul and the breakthrough
17:36 The Ein Sof and the Sefirot
19:19 Isaac of Acre and equanimity
20:47 Did Eckhart read Kabbalah?
23:03 Where Eckhart and the Kabbalists part ways
24:08 What Eckhart means for magick practice
Watch the video version on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cL9H91xWJCA
I have been practicing magick and studying the Western esoteric traditions since 1985, and in this podcast I talk about all of it plainly, with no hype. Kabbalah, the Greek Magical Papyri, the Goetia and demonology, the saints and Saint Expedite, grimoires like the Key of Solomon and Sefer Raziel, Neoplatonism, and the strange figures history forgot. Real history, real sources, and rituals you can actually use. If you want to go deeper, my courses are at OccultCourses.com.
Welcome and the question about Meister Eckhart
First of all, I want to say thank you to everyone who has been supporting the Ask Baal episodes. This is the second episode, the first one. I got a lot of excellent feedback. It is a very interesting topic and I love it and one day, like I said, I'll create a course about Melek Taus and the Yezidi beliefs and all of that. In this episode, I am going to answer a question which I was really, I love this question.
It was about Meister Eckhart. Now Meister Eckhart is someone that I mentioned a lot in my work and so the question was, any chance of making some content related to Meister Eckhart? You mentioned him on several occasions in the Kabbalah course and first of all, thank you for the question and yes, there is and this video is going to be about that. And I'm glad, you know, I'm really glad someone noticed that because I do keep bringing him up in my programs and I've never really stopped to explain why, you know, some of you and if any of you have my course, The Truth Is Not Flat, many people don't know that it exists, but it's there. I discuss him there too.
Now, some people are wondering, you know, what a medieval Catholic friar is doing on an occult channel, but by the end of this video, hopefully, you'll see that he does belong here and that some of what you already practice as a magician, as an occultist, was said by him in some way, like 700 years ago, even though he would, if he were alive today, he would probably petition me to be executed for saying that.
Who Meister Eckhart was
So hopefully, you'll enjoy this, this video. So his name was Eckart von Hochheim. He was born around 1260 in Thuringia in central Germany and as a young man, he joined the Dominican Order of Erfurt and Meister, you know, is not his name and Meister just means master in German and that was sort of that was his academic title. And so he was a master of theology at the University of Paris, which was at that time the most important university in Europe and he held the Dominican chair there twice and before him, the only man that held it twice was actually Thomas Aquinas. So he was not, he was no slouch, right?
You know, he had many accomplishments and he left two kinds of writings. There are his Latin writings, which are essentially commentaries on scripture, basically written for scholars, and then there are his German sermons, which is where he gets his reputation from and that's the ones that I refer to. I don't speak German myself, so obviously I use English translations. Now he, one of the things he was known for was that he preached in the language of ordinary people, right, how ordinary people spoke and a large part of his audience actually were lay women, many women, both Dominican nuns and a few other orders and including the women who had lived religious lives, but they didn't necessarily take vows, you know, to become a nun. And he said his most daring things in German, right, in public and much to the chagrin of a lot of people.
But he said a lot of interesting and I would say even daring things for his time to people that had no training in theology and he had to, you know, invent German words to do it because the language did not yet have the vocabulary for what he wanted to say. And he said a lot and like I said, some of it was quite ahead of his time. So as you can imagine, anyone who's sort of a deeper thinker, who thinks outside the box, even today, you know, you can get into some trouble, you know, and that's what got him in trouble was the fact that he, you know, he had all of this interesting knowledge and we'll get into that in a moment.
The heresy proceedings and the papal bull
And in 1326, the Archbishop of Cologne, Henry of Wernenburg, opened up heresy proceedings against him. That was, you know, in his mid-60s at this point and on February 13th, 1327, he stood up in the Dominican Church in Cologne and had a statement read out in which he said that he might be capable of error, but he was no heretic because error, you know, if you're wrong in your theology or wrong in your ideas, it's a matter of mind, right? It's like, all right, you know, I messed up a little bit. But heresy is something else. Heresy is a willful act of going against the church.
And so when he made that distinction, he appealed, you know, to people even over the Archbishop's head to the Pope, and he even traveled to the Papal Court in Avignon to defend himself in person. Now he himself died before the verdict sometime around 1328, and we do not know exactly where though. And then on March 27, 1329, Pope John XXII issued a bull called In the Field of the Lord, and it condemned 28 statements taken from his work. And around a dozen or so, probably about 17 of them, he deemed them as heretical and 11 as being, you know, sort of borderline heretical. And it's, you know, that was that was a big thing.
But lucky for him, he was actually dead by then. So he didn't suffer the consequences of this. Now there is a detail in this that those of us in the occult will appreciate. Now, you know, Pope John XXII is the same pope in those same years, issued the decree against ritual magicians, by the way, and basically the people who made images and rings and call on spirit of that time. So you have a pope who condemned Eckhart's sermons, but he was also a pope who went after the magicians too.
And that's not why I like Eckhart. I actually like Eckhart for what he taught, and we're going to get into that now.
God and the Godhead
So I'm going to give you four ideas. And once you sort of grasp them, then you're going to have a really good idea of who Meister Eckhart really was, like what did he really believe. So we're going to start and this is, you know, going to it's going to get a little deep here because these are these are, you know, pretty intense ideas, so I'm going to try to make them as accessible as possible. So we start with the difference between God and the Godhead, right? God is the one who creates, right, who creates the world, the one that people pray to.
He's, you know, the father, the son, and the Holy Spirit, you know, God. He's in the world, he's acting in the world. Now the Godhead is what lies behind that, right? It doesn't have a name. It's a very Eastern concept, right?
He has no name, there's no person, and it does not act at all. And so Eckhart describes it as a desert and as a nothing. Now he doesn't mean that in a derogatory sense. He says that God acts and the Godhead does not act. And in his most famous sermon, he says that he prays to God to make him free of God.
That's pretty intense, right? So what does that mean? To pray to God to make him free of God. And what he means is that God, the God he is able to think about, has to be let go before he can reach the Godhead that no thought can hold. So basically, he's saying, free me of what I understand conceptually to be God.
I want to go beyond it. I want to go into the being itself that is beyond words. Because when you think about words and you think about how they act, they act as definitions. God is good. God is this.
But God is this unfathomable thing. So by us putting words onto it, we lose it because then you're labeling something that cannot be labeled. And what cannot be labeled is the Godhead. And so that is what he's talking about. He's talking about the ground of being or the groundlessness of being.
And it's very hard to imagine because there's no label to apply to it. And even saying that there's no label to apply to it is a label. You see what I mean? So he's asking God, get me out of that conceptual trap.
The ground of the soul
That's what he's saying. And from that point, he then turns to the soul. And he says there's something in the soul, sort of a deep point in it that has the same nature as the Godhead. And he calls it the ground of the soul. And at other times, he calls it the spark or the little castle.
And he says that at that point, God's ground and the soul's ground are one and the same ground. So he's now taking this concept even into the soul, that the soul and the Godhead, there's the deepest part of the soul, is in union essentially with the Godhead. Now there's a line of his that gets quoted everywhere, which says, and this is a great line actually, that the eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me. Now think about that now. The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me.
I just get chills just thinking about that. Just think about what he's saying. And so as you can probably imagine, especially during that time, he was accused of teaching that this part of the soul is uncreated, which would make it part of God in the fullest sense. And he denied having said it in that way, but it went into the papal bowl anyway. And then, well, first of all, that's profound.
Just think about it. Let me say it again. The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which God sees me. That is total immersion in the Godhead.
Detachment and living without why
And then he comes to the practice of detachment. And there's another word that he brings with it. I'm not even going to try it in German. I'm sorry. I'm not going to try it.
German is one of those languages. I just don't know. I can't even pronounce. I'm lucky I can pronounce his name. So he has these two concepts.
He has detachment. And he has another word, which means letting go or letting be, right? So he ranked detachment higher than love and higher than humility. So to illustrate this, he had a sermon where he focused on the verse that's in the New Testament, blessed are the poor in spirit. As he taught, he says that a poor person is one who wants nothing, who knows nothing and has nothing.
And he takes that all the way, right? If you still want... So basically what he's saying that if you still want to do the will of God, he says, then you are still wanting something and you are not yet poor. So basically, he took the words blessed are the poor in spirit as making an analogy that a poor person is someone who wants nothing, who knows nothing, has nothing. He's saying the same thing.
He says, if you still want to do the will of God, then you still want something. So even the desire to want to do the will of God is wanting something. And so then he tells people to live without why, which means to act without asking what you will get out of it. And that includes what you will get from God. So basically complete detachment.
You are just sort of one with God.
The birth of God in the soul and the breakthrough
There's no wanting to be one with God. It's just this sort of natural state. Now another idea which sort of ports into this is he calls the birth. So when the soul is empty of wants, right, and is this pure, pure Godhead. So when the soul is empty in that way, he says, God gives birth to his son in it.
So basically, he means that the same birth that Christian theology places in eternity, he says is happening now in the ground of your own soul. And that by you emptying yourself out of wants and whys, then God can be God in you, can be born in you. So that's very powerful, right? So past the birth, there's one more step which he calls the breakthrough, where the soul goes through God and into the Godhead. And he says that in the breakthrough, he is neither God nor creation, right?
He is what was and what will always remain. It's the state of complete and utter oneness with the Godhead, but even saying oneness is a label. So it's sort of like the concept in Eastern philosophy, nirvana. What is nirvana? Can you, the minute you say, oh, I've achieved nirvana, you have not, because nirvana is a label-less state.
And even calling it label-less is a label. And so that is what he is thinking and discussing as the Godhead and the soul is that, you know, for lack of a better term, because we are very limited by what we can say, you know? So he talks about all of these ideas, but you know what? He doesn't give you a technique on how to do this because a technique, you know, a breathing method or a visualization, right, is striving for something, right? You're using it because you want something.
And he was actually suspicious of visions and raptures and all the spiritual experiences in general. He was suspicious of it because there was this sense of desire in it. And if you have any type of desire, then you have a want, and then you're not empty, like the Godhead, because even desire is action, right? And he even says, whoever looks for God in a special way gets the way and misses God. So basically, any method, devotion, whatever you do to attain this connection with God, all you got was the technique.
You actually missed God on the way because you were so focused on the technique. You see, look at how deep that goes. I mean, and I'm saying this very quickly right now, but this goes very, very deep. Now, because the person who asked this question had enrolled in my program on the Kabbalah, I'm going to now tie that in here.
The Ein Sof and the Sefirot
So we're going to start in relation to the Kabbalah. We're going to start with the Godhead and God. And in Kabbalah, beginning with the Kabbalists of Gerona in the 1200s, there is that concept of the Ayn Sof, and you've probably heard that, right? The infinite, the never-ending, which has no attribute, no will, it cannot be described. Even calling it Ayn Sof is just, that's our way of conceptualizing it, but even that is a label.
And then after that, the Ayn Sof, we have the Svirot, right? The Ten Svirot, the tree of life, right? Which are God as he reveals himself. So the Kabbalists taught that Ayn Sof is not even properly an object of prayer, just like the Godhead, and that you pray to God as he is revealed through the Svirot. Basically, Meister Eckhart was saying the same thing.
But of course, he would have condemned the Kabbalah because all of the techniques and all of that stuff. So he's basically saying the same thing, that when we conceptualize God in the Kabbalistic sense, we have the same thing, we have the Ayn Sof, the Godhead, and then we have the Svirot, which is God, right? So that's very important in putting the connection between the two. Now, if we take the idea of detachment, right, there's also a match to that idea in Kabbalah.
Isaac of Acre and equanimity
So there was a Kabbalist named Isaac of Akre, who was alive in the same years as actually Meister Eckhart, and he taught something called Hishtavut, which means equanimity. And so he tells a story about a man who asked a master to teach him the secret of cleaving to God, you know, to attach. And so the master asks him one thing. He says, Is it the same when people praise him or when they insult him? Right, he's asking the man.
He's basically saying, Is it the same if people praise you or insult you? Now, the man admits that it is not the same, obviously, even in our own minds, right? Well, if someone praises me, I feel good. If someone insults me, I feel bad, right? I mean, it's not the same.
And the master essentially sends the guy away until it is, until it is the same. So what he's saying is that when you get to the point where you're detached, where praise and insult are, you're completely detached from both of them, then you've achieved a detachment. Because right now, the man is like, no, I don't. Praise and insult are two different things. The master's saying when they become nothing, come back to me, right?
Did Eckhart read Kabbalah?
I mean, even the Hasidics, they had a related idea called bitul, which is the nullifying of the self. So there's a lot of parallels, right? So the question is, did Eckhart actually read the Kabbalah? Now, there's no evidence that he did, right? The Zohar began circulating in Castile in the 1280s.
And when Eckhart was a young friar in Germany, none of his work showed that he had any connection to it. I just want to be clear about that, because you'll see people online calling him a secret Kabbalist. And there's just nothing that supports that. And remember, he's not the only one who has these ideas, you know, even before the Kabbalah. But what we do know about what he may have been exposed to is that he may have been reading the same books as some of these Kabbalists, right?
Because back then, Neoplatonism, the philosophy that comes from Plotinus, was all over the place. And Christianity really took it on, because Eckhart got Neoplatonism through Christian writers like Pseudo Dionysius. And the Kabbalists got it through Jewish and Arabic philosophers. And one interesting thing is that one of the biggest rabbinic commentators in Judaism, Maimonides, also known as the Rambam, was also a very popular source. Eckhart quotes Maimonides constantly in his Latin works, where he calls him Rabbi Moses.
And the scholar, Joseph Schwartz, has written an entire book on Eckhart's reading of the Guide of the Perplexed for Christ's sake. No pun intended. So because Maimonides teaches that you can only say what God is not, right, via negativa. And both Eckhart and the Kabbalists agreed on this, agreed on that concept. You can only say what God is not, because any positive saying about God is then a label.
But really, if you take it to its logical conclusion, even saying what God is not is a label. So although there are some ideas that are very similar, there are differences too.
Where Eckhart and the Kabbalists part ways
Because in the Kabbalah, what human beings do, as I mentioned in my Kabbalistic course, actually affects God. OK, I went quite deeply into that. When you do the commandments, when you do those things, you're repairing the universe, you're repairing the divine world, you're bringing masculine and feminine sides of God back together. That is the whole point. It's called tikkun.
Whereas Eckhart has nothing like that, right, in his teaching, nothing in the Godhead needs to be repaired. And your whole task is simply just to empty yourself so that God can act. So Eckhart is a Christian from beginning to end. So there's no thinking that he was any type of Kabbalist. So with all of those weird ideas, well, weird for those times, at least, you would think he was already condemned by the pope posthumously.
And usually that would end people's careers. But that's actually not what happened.
What Eckhart means for magick practice
In the end, his ideas kept moving through German religious life and was picked up by a lot of people. So how does this apply to those of us who practice the occult? And here's why I think he matters for your practice as well as for history in general. Because, look, every magician and practitioners taught that after a working, you have to let go of the result, right? Crowley has it in the Book of the Law where it says that pure will, unassuaged of purpose, delivered from the lust of result, is every way perfect.
Austin Spear based his sigil method on forgetting the desire once the sigil has been charged, right? And chaos magicians have repeated it ever since. And that is Eckhart's without why. And he said it 600 years before Crowley, Eckhart conceptualized that idea. I mean, Eckhart also explains why it works, right, to be without why, to be to sort of forget after you do something.
Because as long as you are grasping at the outcome, your own wanting is standing in the way. And so when you let it when you let go of it, something larger than your wanting is able to act, right? And I noticed this with my own work, you know, listen, I'm not immune to lusting for results, right? But sometimes I'll wake up in the morning and I'll just be. I'll just sort of, quote unquote, give it all up and just release it for myself, put it into the hands of my spirits, and then I forget it.
And let me tell you, shit happens, shit happens then. You know, it's very powerful. Another thing I want to mention that sort of a concept from the Hermetic Kabbalah is the concept of the abyss, right? In the Hermetic Kabbalah, there are three veils above Keter. Keter is the, you know, the first Svirah.
And the first of them is Ein, which means nothing. In Crowley's system, the adept who crosses the abyss has to give up everything that he is or she is, down to the very sense of being a separate self. Eckhart's breakthrough is what that is. Eckhart's breakthrough into the Godhead describes the same thing. And in my opinion, he describes it more clearly than Crowley ever did.
And another thing, which, you know, don't I don't mean to offend anyone, but from not only my experience, but what I see is that a lot of people in the occult want to collect experiences, right? They want the vision or they want, you know, they judge their practice by how dramatic it was. I see it all the time. You know, people are posting all of this stuff. Now, Eckhart had no interest in any of that.
And he will tell you that if you are chasing the experience, you have already lost the thing that you were after to begin with. And so I think every practitioner needs to hear that at some point. So and that's very powerful. You know, it's very powerful because, you know, when people contact me, they say, so when I do a ritual, I, you know, I want to feel this. No, you don't.
You know, no, you don't, because you're chasing the experience. You don't need to feel anything for a ritual to work. You see what I mean? So that that Eckhart's ideas are just baked in right there. So my personal belief where I stand on it is I think Meister Eckhart is one of the greatest mystics the West has ever known.
And I think a cultists skip him because he was a Catholic friar. And in my opinion, that's a mistake. And if you've read any of the texts from the late 90s and early 2000s, you know, they all wanted to claim Meister Eckhart. People have tried to make him a Buddhist. Right. And the Zen scholar DT Suzuki, who has great work, by the way, wrote about how close he comes to making, you know, or that how close Meister Eckhart comes to becoming a being a Buddhist.
Rudolph Otto wrote a whole book comparing Meister Eckhart with the Hindu philosopher Shankara. And as I said, people try to make him a Kabbalist, try to do all these things. And those comparisons, you know, there are some comparisons there. You know, I just spent a good part of this video, you know, doing some comparisons. But Eckhart was a Dominican who said Mass believed he was preaching what the gospel said.
And you'll get more out of him if you let him just be that way. So if you're going to pick up any work of his, go to the German's sermons before the Latin ones, because the German ones are the ones where he really gets, you know, gets to the meat of things. But, you know, what you could do is just look up Meister Eckhart quotes and some of them, you'll read them and be like, wow, that's astounding. You know, he has a lot to say and we can really apply a lot of his work to our own work.