The American Record

On Armistice Day, 1921, President Warren G. Harding buried a soldier whose name no one could say — and gave a grieving nation one grave to stand before.

What is The American Record?

A daily history podcast from Patriot Compass. Each episode explores the events that shaped America on this day in history, told through expert narration and grounded in primary sources.

Narrator:

A sergeant stands in a city hall in France facing four identical caskets. He doesn't know what's inside any of them. He's been told to choose one. He reaches out and sets down a spray of white roses on the second casket from the right. This is the American Record from Patriot Compass, one story from this day in American history.

Narrator:

It's 11/11/1921, Armistice Day, three years to the day since the guns of World War I went silent. In Washington, President Warren G. Harding is about to bury a soldier at Arlington National Cemetery. The soldier has no name. That's not a mystery to be solved.

Narrator:

That was the entire design, a way for the country to finally bury the thousands of family's sons who had vanished into France without a marker of their own. It started months earlier. On Memorial Day, four unidentified American servicemen were dug up from four separate cemeteries in France, deliberately mixed so no one could later claim this body came from this battle from this unit. Four caskets, identical, unmarked. In October, at a city hall in Chalons En Champagne, army sergeant Edward f Younger was led into a room with all four.

Narrator:

He'd served in the war himself. Nobody told him how to choose. He picked one. The other three stayed in France, buried together, their part in the story over. The chosen soldier crossed the Atlantic aboard the warship Olympia, arriving in The United States on November 9.

Narrator:

From there, he went to the capital where he lay in the rotunda for two days. More than 90,000 people walked past that casket. Not one of them knew his name, his hometown, his rank, and that absence was the point. Any mother who'd gotten a telegram from France could stand there and let herself wonder. On the morning of the eleventh, the casket left the capital in procession, through Washington, across the Potomac, through Fort Myer, and up to Arlington.

Narrator:

The state funeral began around 11:40 that morning at the Memorial Amphitheater, timed so that the nation's two minutes of silence, observed in cities and towns everywhere, fell right in the middle of the service. Harding spoke, and then came the strangest part of the ceremony. He awarded the Medal of Honor, the nation's highest military decoration, to a man whose specific act of courage nobody could name. Then, one after another, representatives of other nations stepped forward, Great Britain, France, Italy, Romania, Czechoslovakia, Poland, each laying down their own country's highest honor on the same casket. No citation could be read for any of it.

Narrator:

There was nothing to cite except the fact that he had died in the war. Eight of the highest military honors in the world given to one man, and not one of them could say his name. What began that morning as a single burial became a permanent institution. The tomb stayed at Arlington as the nation's site for its unidentified dead, and its meaning kept widening. Unknowns from World War II and Korea joined him there in 1958.

Narrator:

A Vietnam unknown was later added too, and in 1998, identified and removed, the only reversal in the tomb's history. But the soldier Sergeant Younger chose in 1921 has never been named. He remains exactly what the country needed him to be that day, everyone's son and no one's in particular. That one unmarked grave at Arlington wasn't the only thing taking shape on a November 11 in American life. In 1839, a cadet named John Strange relieved the guard at a Virginia arsenal and in doing so helped launch the Virginia Military Institute as its own school.

Narrator:

In 1889, President Benjamin Harrison signed the proclamation making Washington the forty second state at 05:27 in the afternoon. And in 1926, state highway officials approved the national system of numbered U. S. Routes that still guides drivers today. This has been the American Record from Patriot Compass.

Narrator:

Come back tomorrow for another story from America's Past. Before you go, if you wanted to know more about that soldier at Arlington, what's carved on the tomb today, or how that marble changed over the decades, that's the kind of deeper story we build out in the app. Patriot Compass is free with a new piece of American history every day, plus longer dives on the moments worth more of your time. Find it at patriotcompass.us.