Scalability School

Brad and Zach go deep on the single biggest scaling lever most media buyers are ignoring: the landing page. The spine of the episode is a mindset shift, meaning you can scale spend without new creative, new offers, or more discounting. You scale with pages.

They open with creative-to-lander congruency: the ad makes a promise and the page has to keep it. Zach shares how MarsMen now runs 33 active landing pages organized by roughly 10 messaging pillars (aging, cortisol, energy, weight loss, GLP-1, TRT vs. natural), and the company has a hard rule that no ad launches without a congruent page behind it. The reason goes beyond conversion rate: Meta's Andromeda algorithm is reading the landing page itself. Page copy is a targeting signal, not just a destination.

Brad backs this with a case study: a client sending all traffic to a PDP ($41K in spend) duplicated the exact same creative to a "5 Reasons Why" page. Same spend level, substantially better ROAS, lower CPMR, and the age breakdown showed 45+ ripping harder than ever. Same ad, new audience, unlocked entirely by the page.

From there they cover the format progression (listicle → advertorial → dynamic hybrid page → quiz), the specific page elements that matter (comparison charts, clear single CTA, social proof, FAQ, shoppable PDP sections injected below listicles), how to structure tests inside the ad account, kill criteria (48 hours at MarsMen's spend level, plus a "graveyard campaign" with cost controls to separate creative problems from page problems), what "winning" actually means (net new spend volume added to the account, not just beating the PDP head-to-head), and reporting (spend velocity as the success metric, heat maps, and session recordings, including one recording session that led to a single button change worth +20% revenue per session).

The episode closes with the getting-started playbook: don't reinvent the template. Go pull the landers from the biggest spenders in Motion or any ad-tracking tool and copy the structure, because they all run nearly the same one. The real bottleneck is copywriting, which is much harder than people think (raw AI output without heavy pre-prompting gets you "shit copy with a bunch of em dashes"), and perfectionism: your landing pages can be uglier than your website, and your ads can be uglier than your landing pages. Use your brand font and colors, but if it's not perfect, get started.

Key Takeaways
  • Did you know Meta's Andromeda algorithm is reading your landing page copy, not just your ad, and using it to decide who sees your ads?
  • How one brand took the exact same ad, swaped the PDP for a "5 Reasons Why" page, and matched $41K in spend at a substantially better ROAS while unlocking an entirely new age demo.
  • What if you could scale spend without a single new creative, new offer, or deeper discount, using only landing pages?
  • Why "my lander beat the PDP" is the wrong definition of a winning landing page test.
  • What watching just 20 session recordings revealed that a single button change fixed.
  • Why MarsMen refuses to launch any ad that doesn't have a congruent landing page behind it, and how they actively enforce it with 33 live landing pages.
  • Why nearly ALL nine-figure brands run the same landing page template, and why this one thing (and not design) is the real reason your pages take forever to ship.

This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you!

Chapters

  • 00:00 – Intro
  • 02:42 – Creative and lander congruency: the ad makes a promise, the page has to keep it
  • 04:20 – Mars's 33 landing pages and the "no ad without a congruent page" rule
  • 06:48 – Organizing pages by pillar and how wide to go
  • 09:04 – Case study: same creative, $41K PDP vs. 5 Reasons Why page (and the 45+ audience unlock)
  • 11:27 – "Andromeda is reading the page, not just the ad"
  • 12:52 – What CPMR is and why it's debatable as a metric
  • 13:54 – The landing page format progression: listicle → advertorial → dynamic page → quiz
  • 16:51 – The elements that actually move the needle on a listicle
  • 20:48 – Testing individual page elements and the spend velocity you need to validate
  • 23:46 – How pages get launched into the ad account (3 net new funnels a week)
  • 26:44 – What a "win" actually is: adding net new spend volume
  • 29:01 – Kill criteria: 48 hours and the graveyard campaign
  • 30:08 – Persona-specific PDPs and injecting the PDP below the lander
  • 32:32 – The Dr. Gundry VSL rabbit hole and why VSLs demand insane AOVs
  • 34:29 – Using one open-ended quiz question to generate new creative pillars
  • 37:23 – Landing page reporting: spend velocity, heat maps, and the recording that added 20% revenue per session
  • 41:09 – How to get started: copy the top spenders' templates, copywriting is the real bottleneck, and "your landing pages can be uglier than your website"

To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com

To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch

To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck

Learn more about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com

Learn more about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com

Made With AI

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

Can you hear my kids?

Yeah, a little bit, but it's fine.

It's not too bad.

Well, that's until they start.

Hold on.

Let me do one more thing.

It sounds like you live next to a park.

It's distant, but...

Is that any better?

No, your voice is...

No, just put it back.

All right.

I'm just going to try

to throw it on mute.

Hold on.

Give me one second.

It just starts screaming instantly.

All right.

Welcome back to another episode of the

Scalability School podcast.

Andrew is not with us.

That sounds really dark.

He's with us somewhere.

He's busy right now.

And so he left us to do intros.

And this is what happens

when you leave me to do intros.

But we're excited to jump

into some landing page stuff.

I know I've been spending a lot of time

talking about landing

pages on this podcast.

And basically, if you've talked to me

about marketing in the

last 60 days, it's something

that I am talking about way too much.

And today, we're going to dig into a

bunch of specific

insights and just kind of have

a back and forth YAP session about things

that we're seeing

working, progression, how

to test, what we'd like to see more of,

how to do reporting,

and a bunch of things in

between.

And so, yeah, it's going to be a little

bit of a YAP session.

I did, I will say, I'm about 30 minutes

into your operators podcast.

So, you know, you're big timing us.

But no, it's cool, dude.

Well, it gets worse.

Don't listen.

Don't listen much longer.

I am for those, you know, the our 10, you

know, 10s of singles of listeners that we

have on skill building school.

They were asking like this, like

whatever, ask the same 10

questions at the end of every

podcast.

Like, what's one metric that's what's one

metric that's like, overrated?

And I said profit.

And I immediately was, I was gassed.

It was like after like,

I had all day of calls.

And I was like, yeah,

it's because of cash flow.

I was, it was the worst fucking answer I

could have ever given.

But you know what?

Here, here we are.

So I like reached out to Aaron.

Can we take this out?

He's like, it's already edited.

I'm like, he's like, we could.

And I'm like, I'm not an asshole.

Just put it through.

It's fine.

Everyone will think I sound like decent.

Then they're like, he

doesn't want profit.

What the fuck is that?

So anyways, yeah, go listen to it.

There's a big crossover of people who

listen to this and that.

Maybe, you know, so there's a, for sure.

Like we, we probably have

all the problem from that.

Probably already listened to that by the

time they listen to this.

So for sure.

Anyways, again, let's, let's get into it.

So I think first, first topic, we've

talked about this a bit.

I think I mentioned it actually on that,

on that episode, but

creative, creative land of

congruency.

Do you want to like kick this off and

then I'll, I'll add my, my perspective.

Yeah.

One of the, one of the biggest like

frustrations that I see still,

I spend a lot of time looking

at ad accounts and libraries and I like

watch an ad and it'll be

like, help your dog sleep

better at night.

And then you click through to the page

and it's like, okay, I

landed on the PDP, which

like might be fine, but there's literally

nothing about sleep on the page.

Like maybe a comparable for, for like

hollow, like cause I know

he always used hollow as

an example.

It's like, if you were talking about, um,

hiking, uh, to somebody

and then you send them

to like a page that like was using images

of the, like the

compression socks has nothing

to talk about with hunting.

One more example.

We were looking at a, uh, is like a

bedding, bedding company.

Uh, and they like their, one of the top

performing ads was talking

about like how it makes bedtime

easier for me.

Like kids making their

bed was so much easier.

And they're like, there's all the only

pictures on the website are

a bunch of old people making

their bed.

It's like, dude, where

are the kids at brother?

Um, so anyways, point on landing page

congruency is like you're, you're

telling, you're starting

to tell a story in the ad.

Um, and then if you're not continuing

that story on the

landing page, I think there's

just a pretty big missed opportunity.

And I think the recurring word of the

year for us has been, and

you said this a lot is like

just intentionality and like being more

thoughtful at every

single step of the way.

Um, and so creative and lander congruency

is like the way that we're seeing this.

Um, so now you guys are spending a lot of

time thinking about that.

And it's like, I think one of these last

episodes, you said you

didn't want to talk too much about

it because it's, it's one of the things

that's been, uh,

unlocking stuff, but I think cats

out of the bag.

Um, so I don't know if you want to expand

on things that you're

seeing working and how

you guys have been thinking about it.

Yeah.

So we built a report just recently.

Um, and it's just, it's just landing page

reporting, which I know

we're going to talk about

that year in a minute.

But the, one of the things that I wanted

to do is look at, so

I'll, I'll talk about Mars,

for example, on this one, Mars actively

is running 33 landing

pages, which is quite a

few.

And I think probably more than the

average brand, but I think

what we're starting to do

well is we're, we're, we're matching.

We are not going to launch an ad if it's

going to talk about

cortisol or if it's going to talk

about, you know, uh, strength or

willpower or whatever.

If we do not have a landing page that

also talks about that.

So that's like a new thesis in the

company that we won't do

it, which like won't launch

it.

And then the creative strategist

basically say, Hey, I don't

feel like I have a landing page

that's, that's congruent enough.

Go, go make me one this week.

So what's crazy about that is now I get

to go look at all

these ads that are running

to these 33 different landing pages and

actually see in my report that I built.

Um, it's just like a quad generated

report with a dropdown.

What are the top spending

ads to that landing page?

And I can go figure out, is there

concurrency happening or not?

Cause there's something that's happening

that this ad is getting

more spend, which usually

means, okay.

So I mean, meta likes it or yes,

performance is probably there.

But like to your point about the sheets

example, like if we're

talking about cortisol in the

ad and then we jump on a page and it's

literally has nothing says

it doesn't even say cortisol

on it.

Why are we running that,

that ad to that, to that page?

So that's been like

really, really helpful.

Um, I think that not a lot of people,

like people look at

landing page performance and

then look at ad creative performance.

They don't usually look

at them like combined.

And I think the cool thing about looking

at it from a landing

page, you are out first and

then the ad creative

that actually goes to it.

You're able to actually reverse kind of

into, is this, is it

doing what it's supposed to

do versus just looking at top ads and

then just like seeing,

it's just like, it's hard

to kind of resonate.

Is that matching the page or not?

Um, I think it's easier

to go the other way around.

Yeah.

And so you said 33 pages live and I'm

sure we'll talk about

maybe if we have enough time,

we'll talk about like how we actually

test, um, and how you

think about testing.

But those are like individually, you're

not, it doesn't sound

like you're using backend

split testing tool to split them.

Like they're all active

URLs listed inside of meta.

That's not really my question.

My question is really more like, what is

the limit to the

quantity of pages and like how

specific, you know, like, cause you can

continue to go deeper and deeper and more

narrow.

Yeah.

And so I guess like, how are you thinking

about the width of the pages?

So we break this down by pillar, just

like we would with an ad creative.

So we start with pillars.

So we've got like, you know, aging,

cortisol, energy, you know, weight loss.

GLP one is like a huge category, you

know, uh, TRT versus natural.

Like these are all pillars.

So you're going to start with the pillar.

So like maybe we only have, we have 30

pages, but maybe at like

10, 10 ish pillars, right.

To choose from.

And then obviously

dependent on the pillar.

Like if we see traction,

we'll have different pages.

So like we might start with a listicle.

This goes to the

easiest one to start with.

We might start with 10 reasons why.

If we see a 10 reasons why it's working

really well for an aging

pillar and performance is

there and spend is there.

We're like finding some congruency of ads

and like traction is there.

And then we might go take it 10 reasons

and punch it over to an advertorial.

And then we'll maybe make a

variant of the 10 reasons.

That is like, you know, maybe the images

go from in the 10

reasons goes from images to

then gifts, or like maybe

we go from 10 down to five.

And then we add in a whole different

comparison section grid to the page.

That's kind of how we think about it is

like, we start always with the listicle.

We start before the listicle, even

choosing that, that template.

Start with like the pillar of the page

that we're going to try

and match the pillar of

the ad creatives.

Yeah.

And then will you keep,

will you keep the advertorial?

Sorry.

Okay.

Will you keep the listicle, the quiz and

the advertorial all live

as long as they're still

performing?

So like same creative, just different

landing pages with the match messaging?

So the only way that we're doing the same

actual ad creative to

a different lander is

to quiz.

So if, if a page is working on the 10

reasons why we'll, we'll,

we'll kind of like graduated

up to the quiz.

But outside of that, it'll always be a

net new piece of ad

creative that we'll try.

Yeah.

So no, we don't have any

of like the duplicate stuff.

We used to do more of that.

We started to see like

performance take a hit.

So again, based on what Meta is telling

us, like they, they see

that as the same thing.

So we were trying to actually build it

out as something different,

even though if the landing

page is different, we're, we're, we're

treating it as if it could

be the only funnel that we're

okay with it being the same exact

creative is, is the quiz

because it's such a different

type of experience and funnel.

So that's what we think about it.

Yeah, that's cool.

I have a, there's an example that the

reason I asked that, um, is

because I have an example.

I, I tweeted this recently,

so I'm just pulling it up.

So I have the numbers in front of me, but

we took, um, we had a

client that was sending

all their traffic to a PDP, but it was

sending out all the

traffic to the, to the PDP.

So you can see that at the bottom there,

but it spent the PDP,

um, spent $41,000 and we

duplicated that same piece of creative

and sent it to a five reasons why page.

And they ended up over that time period,

at least spending the

same amount of money, five

reasons why, which has graduated to many

other things since then,

um, like spent the same

amount, but perform

substantially more efficiently.

And then everybody's obsessed with CPMR.

So I kind of made a meme out of that and

just saying like CPMR was

also lower, um, for this,

but like, those are the same ads.

And what was interesting about that, as I

found it, I was

looking at the delivery of

the different, what is the, what is the

delivery difference between

the two of these specifically

the age breakdown.

And if you look at the age breakdown for

the PDP, it was like 45

and up pretty clearly.

Um, and that was one of the

insights that landed on the page.

So like the headline says, X reasons why

women 45 and up are

blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

Um, I was looking at the breakdown again

for the five reasons

why and how that changed.

So really the only thing that changed is

that all of a sudden 45

and up started to rip even

more.

So 45 and up was spending more.

It was more efficient, but

the 55 and up was still good.

It just didn't get any

more spend proportionally.

Um, and 65 and up was

also still really good.

Just getting, and it didn't get any more

spend proportionally,

but it was the same ad.

So there's a couple of points in there,

um, that I'm just kind

of like yapping through.

The first is that we find that having

multiple pages live has been

interesting because it meets

people at different

points of where they're at.

Like to your point, quiz is maybe, Hey,

I'm a little less

aware of what's going on.

Um, I'm not sure if you'd agree with

that, but like, it's a

little more top of funnel

in the way that people

traditionally talk about it.

Listicles may be somewhere in the middle,

depending on the positioning.

And then PDP is like, obviously as, as

close as you can probably

get without sending people

directly to checkout, which I've seen

some ad accounts that try to do that.

And then the other point is like, okay,

well, there's an

interesting progression on that,

on that five reasons why page and those

insights, which is, okay,

we've got this messaging on this

page that says 45 and up.

What if we just duplicate the headline

and go 55 and up and

still leave the same ad live?

How would that change things?

A lot of philosophy around like how

fragmented the ad account starts to get.

Um, but the whole, I said something on a

call, um, recently that

like seemed to make it clear

to people, but like Andromeda is reading

the page, not just the ad.

And that was, that was, that was

interesting for me to see

because now, yes, Meta thinks

that the creative is the same, but it's

very clearly different delivery.

Um, so you're thinking about that whole

funnel as, as the ad really.

You said a couple of things there that I

think are super

interesting that I'm personally

gonna like take and break down, which is

like the age breakdown by

landing page performance.

That's something that I

haven't thought about in a while.

I look at it by creative, um, but I don't

look at it by Lander.

So that's, that'll be

fascinating to dig into.

And then I've never

looked at CPMR by Lander.

Yeah.

Like destination URL.

So that just another one to be like, I

wonder what that does.

And if some landing pages, which I think

would make sense

inherently have a better CPMR.

So two good call-outs there for sure.

Yeah.

And that, that was, that was the thing

that was so interesting

about that is, I mean,

I mean, CPMR to me, I'm still the cat,

uh, the, the, I don't, I

don't know if I've like

fully come around to that

as like a useful metric yet.

I think it's interesting.

Um, but like ROAS was substantially

better and then we

could spend more behind it.

So it's like, I didn't need the CPMR

signal to tell me that.

Um, and I'm sure we'll

get into how we test things.

Um, but like, it was very clear that that

just like consumed all the spend.

So, um, we still find success sending the

same creative to, to,

um, different landing pages

because you actually do unlock a

different audience as we saw

in, in that age, uh, breakdown.

Brad, I'm sure people that are listening

to this probably know

what CPMR is, but do you

want to explain what that is?

Cause we've said it like five times, but.

Yeah.

Yeah.

So, um, generally

people look at, um, CPM.

So cost per 1000 impressions.

CPMR is basically just

the reach version of that.

So pressure impressions are non-unique.

Reach is a unique impression.

So, um, it's just the amount that you

spend to reach 1000 unique people.

The one of the reasons I don't like it is

like inherently just goes down over time.

Like it, the second you spend $1 on meta,

your next piece of

reach, like it just inherently

goes down.

There's only so many people

you can reach in the world.

And if you narrow it down to the U S and

then you narrow it down

to your target market,

you just, you just run out of people.

And you, you kind of

alluded to this earlier.

And it's one of the things you talked

about in the, in the

operators episodes, which is like,

you think about starting a product that

just has so many

fricking angles that you can

unlock because that's

how you can open up.

I mean, TAM is one way to think about

this, but like specific

angles is how you can say

different things to different people.

But yeah, CPMR is, um, cost per 1000

unique reached people.

Sweet.

Yeah.

So you, you kind of, you were talking

about the progression of

landing pages and the types

of landing pages.

Um, I don't know if you want to speak to,

um, you said you start

with listicles and then

go into some of those other things.

Um, is there like a certain progression

that you go to a certain

reason why you start with

listicles?

Um, maybe just talk about

the formats or a second.

Yeah.

I mean, it's just ease, right?

So once you have a light, a 10 reasons

why template for the

most part, if you go look

at any big nine figure brands, like they

all run pretty much the same template.

So the nice thing about it is it requires

copy and it requires

like static, static image

design for, for, for the graphics.

So I think just for, you know, ease of

speed, it's, it's the best.

Um, and I think it's, again, it's such a

simple concept of like,

here's 10 reasons why here's

five reasons why it just, it's inherently

how people think about things.

Um, they just like lists.

So that that's usually

where we start from there.

Then obviously getting

advertorials to work.

I used to be like a

advertorials will never work.

I think I've said this on this podcast.

We've started to get them to work.

And I think it just has

to do with copywriting.

Like it has to have the right ad creative

that, you know, usually

is a bit more top of funnel

and it then can do, you know, if, if the

creative then kind of

answers the, the, it closes the

loop of what the

creative might, might produce.

You know, people talk about native ads,

which is like, you know,

it looks like a phone from

your, or a photo from like your parents

phone, like that, that

they just accidentally took

almost like, that's the piece of

creative, you know, like something

sitting on a counter.

It's like shitty lighting, interesting,

and just kind of, you

know, like, what is this?

That's the whole concept of like a proper

native ad or native creative.

And so when those images that just kind

of prompts, you know,

curiosity to then an advertorial

style page, or then it might be more of a

story that you're

telling, uh, I think can work

well, but it's just harder to do.

So start with 10 reasons, then go down

that kind of rabbit

hole of, of advertorial.

And then we might just do like kind of

its own unique blend, which

is like different sections.

You know, there might be, uh, kind of

like a mini 10 reasons

why built within the page.

Then there might be a us versus them.

And then there might be,

you know, uh, an FAQ section.

There might be all sorts of like these

kind of unique things, a longer story.

Maybe there's like a

founder story section in it.

That's kind of like the third one.

And then the fourth, which is quiz, which

I think, you know,

there's a couple of people

on Twitter that talk

about quizzes all the time.

I mean, they are underrated.

I think like, I think, you know, the

problem is people seem

like it's going to be like

super hard to build.

They're not really hard to build.

There's a, there's a tool called Hayflow,

which is what we used

for the beginning of

Marsmen.

We've now built the tool internally.

Our head of e-com built it and clawed and

then self-deployed it, which is sick.

Um, so we can do a lot more kind of

custom stuff with it,

but Hayflow is great.

Like if you're wanting to try to build a

quiz, like just go

study again, top brands.

Most of them build them very similarly.

So this is another great entry point.

So it's kind of like listicle,

advertorial, dynamic page,

and then quiz is kind of a whole

other one.

So that's how we think about it.

Yeah.

And within the, so like going back to

listicles for a second, um,

at some point, I'm sure you

started with a three reasons or a five

reasons and then a seven and then a 10.

Um, so there's like a progression that

you've gone through where

you started, Hey, we started

with a five and then we went to 10 and it

made a big difference.

And then we added, I mean, I've the

amount of times I go into

an ad library, I click the

landing page and it's like, Oh, this

looks like Marsman's

landing page is like astounding.

Um, but like there's comparison charts at

the top or somewhere on the bottom.

I know Primal Queen probably, I think

Primal Queen was one of

the original people to add

like the timeline to it.

Um, so it's like, what are those, what

are the elements to a

listicle that you've seen

really make a difference?

Yeah.

I mean, the comparison

chart is, is a no brainer.

That one.

And then just like a

super clear final CTA section.

Um, and then usually like some type of

social proof, usually above that.

So it goes like comparison chart, 10

reasons, either FAQ or social proof

section of just like

review style content, um, or

like a story from a customer.

And that is like super clear.

This is the only CTA on the

page to move you over to a PDP.

That's usually it.

And again, like, I think I might've

mentioned this in the

last, on the last episode, but

like now we're testing, like taking the

PDP and injecting it below.

So not even like that CTA section.

So I think we'll see more people

inherently copy that.

Uh, if it's, if it's, you know, I don't

know if that was us

really doing that for the

most part, but if you go look at our

pages, there's a lot of, a

lot of shoppable versions

of PDPs below listicles and stuff like

that now that we run.

So yeah, I mean, I think,

I think that's mostly it.

I, you know, candidly, these ideas

aren't, aren't always us or mine.

Like, you know, the OG goats of, of DTC

and direct response

were like Javi and Blissey.

You know, those are the two I got to meet

the founders and get

to become good friends

with them.

And, you know, inherently ended up

copying some of their

ideas or talk to them about

concepts.

But like the five reasons why originally

it was because Blissey was doing it.

And then they wrote that like six, seven,

eight, nine, 10, 12, 15 reasons why.

And like, they just kept adding more and

kept seeing better

performance and we didn't ratchet

up to 15 or anything like that yet.

But yeah, the Vahe and the team over at

Blissey, just absolute

goats with, with that.

And then I think the Javi team were the

ones that were figuring

out some of these unique

elements to add into these pages, just to

add a little more sauce to them.

And maybe it would answer like a little

more context, which is

usually what you're looking

to do.

It's just like, what is the missing

context of this page that

they would, it would be great

for the customer to know

before they see the price.

All right, friends, quick break.

This episode is brought to you by

Northbeam, the marketing

attribution platform that we

love over here at the pod.

And if you're a

marketer, you probably agree.

Incrementality testing is broken.

Tests require a ton of labor,

spreadsheets, statistical reference.

Designing tests is slow and error prone.

Once the tests are running, you have to

monitor them daily in

case anything happens.

If you don't, a test can flow through

thousands of dollars

while being totally useless.

And how are you supposed to know what the

test is in the first place?

And when there's a million factors that

make incrementality

testing really difficult.

But good news.

Our friends at Northbeam have

completely changed the game.

They fixed incrementality.

Only Northbeam incrementality automates

your incrementality

test design and monitoring

while protecting you from the major

mistakes that plague

incrementality testing.

Northbeam builds tests using your own MTA

data, launches them

directly in ad platforms,

them throughout.

If something threatens validity, you're

alerted before it ruins the result.

With Northbeam, you can launch tests in

platform with a single

click inside Northbeam,

saving you tons of time and

reducing any chance of errors.

And when the test concludes, results flow

straight into your MTA,

meaning you can easily see results

alongside the rest of your data.

This is automated and accurate testing.

So you and your team

can spend with confidence.

Incrementality was broken.

Northbeam fixed.

So the customer didn't know

before they see the price.

Yeah, there's that's like that's such an

interesting like place that

I think we've kind of talked

about this really briefly where like

that's where like you can probably

innovate quite a bit is

like, OK, I know what

I'm trying to answer.

Like I know what a

comparison chart answers.

It shows very quickly how you stack up

against other things

that people are considering.

Is there a different way you can

communicate that other than a comparison

chart or like people

want to know what the

product is going to do for them?

Like what does the transformation look

like before and after

as a way of showing that

transformation?

But that timeline that I mentioned Primal

Queen and I know a

lot of other people have

something like it, but like that timeline

also kind of paints the

picture of here's what

you can expect and here's the

transformation you can expect

along these kind of timelines.

I just it's such an interesting place

because like that's where

you can actually innovate.

But that's also where it's very difficult

because you have to figure

out like what is the actual

format and what is that section?

How does it get delivered?

I don't know if you've thought about like

unique ways to deliver

those those elements,

but that's something that that I've been

spending a lot of time thinking about.

So I have two more two more

follow up questions to that.

The first thing is you kind of mentioned

in the notes on

something you wish you had more

insight into, which was like what

elements that we just

talked about, like how they drive

impact.

How are you thinking about that?

Like I think heat map might be a tool

that kind of tries to map

sections more specifically

to revenue.

I'm not sure exactly how they do it, but

how are you thinking about that?

I think that's just that

you'd be testing pages.

It's like the page with the element, the

page without the element.

I think that's really all you can do.

And the issue is like you just need the

velocity to actually like do that.

I think people you're probably better off

most brands that are,

you know, are spending less

than seven figures a month on ads.

It's just like testing a whole new page

versus like, hey, I add one new section.

Is that going to get the lift?

Like if you don't have enough velocity,

like the test is going

to have to run for months

to technically validate.

So you can obviously take the first

couple of days or hours of

performance on IntelliGems,

however you want, and send

it, which I've done in the past.

And things have

generally worked out for us.

So sure.

But that's how we, that's how we do it.

It's just like design the whole new

section, usually test it

against the highest spend or

highest traffic volume lander, and then

run those side by side

where it's just like we

add one new section into the page.

Did it add any performance or not?

And then it's just a URL, URL change.

I do have, I don't know,

this is a tin hat theory.

I do have a weird, there's something in

my brain that says

that meta doesn't like AB

tests on the backend of URLs.

I don't know what, but I think it's, I

think it's the fact

that, you know, Intromete is

scraping the content on the page and it's

seen a load happen or

it's seen some JavaScript

happen where it's like, I

don't like this as much.

Who knows?

Maybe it just gives you like a, you know,

you have a hundred

points score and it takes

one away of those hundred.

Like maybe it's something, but I just

have a weird feeling

that it has an issue.

No proof of that, but it's

just something I think about.

Yeah.

Yeah. It's like, is it confusing?

Is it confusing signal for

the reasons you just mentioned?

Because the way that it loads, but also

like if a different type

of person is resonating

with that page, but it's technically the

same ad creative, like

it's different if they

were two different pieces of, of like

actually two different ads

in the ad account, but like

it's actually delivering based on how

that ad is responding.

So like, is it sending confusing signal

back because different

types of people are, you

know, responding to

them in different ways.

You know, my tinfoil hat is,

is, uh, is with you on that.

So I get it.

That, that leads into

something interesting.

Um, so I'm skipping, I'm skipping ahead a

little bit with this

one, which is how you

think about actually testing the pages.

Like how do they get into the ad account?

And like, you know, are you, when do you

decide to actually use an

IntelliGems on the backend

versus not?

Yeah.

Usually it's just content

swaps now for the most part.

Like we're just, we're, we're, we're

adding a new element or

we're adding potentially

like a whole different, like a 10 reasons

why listicle that

pushes you to the PDP versus

a 10 reasons why listicle that, that has

the buy box or the whole PDP below it.

That's when we're using IntelliGems where

we're taking kind of

swings like that or we're

launching things.

I mean, again, with the creative volume

you have with, with the

spend volume, you have

the ability to test more.

So I'm in a little bit of

a unique scenario there.

We're just because we just have to launch

so much shit every

week to keep up because

just so many things burn out.

So we're launching like realistically,

probably three net new

landing page funnels a week.

I'd say around that number feels right.

For Mars, I'd say we're a bit, a bit less

than that for hollow,

maybe one to two a week

for hollow net new landers.

And yeah, we just launch

them like we normally would.

So it's like, depending on the products,

it will go on a different campaign.

And then, or depending on the funnel,

it'll go on a different campaign.

If we have them broken out by pillar, not

sometimes we do that, sometimes we don't.

And then it'll just go into its own ad

set with its own

budget, just like it normally

would with like a creative test.

Yeah.

We've, we've played around a lot with

like with it when it's a net new page.

So like we like to build around, like

start with the ad as the insight.

It's like, okay, what can we,

what can we build off of this?

And how do we make a page based on this?

And usually it's like, can you actually

build it from one specific ad?

Now, you know, obviously if you can look

at the entirety of

your ad account and say to

the pillar point that you're making, if

there's a bunch of

different things that could benefit

from a more specific page, great.

We've, we've been

rolling out landing page tests.

We'll start with like an ad, right?

So the one I referenced earlier in the

tweet that I was talking

about, that was built off

of one founder ad that had some very

specific insights about

the delivery of that ad.

What that specific ad was saying, we just

duplicated it in

within the same campaign,

same ad set, and just let meta dictate

the spend between it.

And that landing page literally,

literally the next day was

spending more than the PDP

and continue to scale

well in excess of it.

But we've also had other wins where like

we've winning to me with

landing pages is not just

it spends more or performs better or is

more efficient than the other page.

It's like, can you add net new spend

volume to the ad account?

So an example of this recently is if we

had, we had, if I'm using

my hands to describe this,

it's like you have a, if your spend

volume is 100%, your

current funnel is set up to get

you 100% to spend or whatever you spent,

maybe I should use a dollar amount.

You're spending 5k a day on this funnel

and you launch a lander,

you have, you have your

PDP is spending 5k a day.

You launch a lander and it adds 1k a day.

As long as it goes up to 6k a day and

spend and adds that new

volume to me, that's a

win because you're, you're, again, you're

kind of meeting

different people where they're

at.

Like that, that's a win.

It's not about just like

getting, getting an excess.

And that's why I like duplicating the

existing ads and letting

them, letting meta dictate

the spend between them

because it shifts over time.

Like I was looking at an ad account the

other day where it's

like, we launched a quiz, it

took over, then it fell back.

Then I take it over again.

Like it just keeps going in and out

depending on the season.

Now, I don't know if there's like an

actual seasonal reason for

the change, but it's just

ads, the landing pages and how they

perform shifts over time.

So as much as possible, I try to like

leave things on, but I'm

also the, I'm also a little

bit of a CBO leave things on Maxie.

So yeah, that's probably part of it.

I think you're right for the most part.

I think we're just a little extra

critical of, because we

have so much volume of creative

going in.

It's like, okay, if we're, if we're, if

we have to launch this

to validate the creative,

we might as well try to match the page to

it versus just like

duping it again and trying

it to go to another one

that might not be as congruent.

So I think generally you're

right in thinking that way.

And the whole idea of adding incremental

spend is the goal at the end of the day.

I mean, like, yeah, you might get a

landing page of five

reasons that outperforms your

PDP.

If you have a set monthly budget that you

can spend into because

of inventory constraints

or whatever, sure.

Great.

Huge win to get

incremental, you know, raw as lift.

But the whole idea of

this is building new funnels.

So you get more scale.

Yeah.

Yeah.

That's how we do it.

If you, yeah, if you're, if you're going

to try to launch, you,

you make, um, you're,

you're looking at your, your pillar and

you're trying, it's like,

okay, we got one piece of

creative.

Now we need to launch it to the three

different variants of

landing pages that we have live.

Like all of a sudden you have, you know,

you have to analyze

performance on that, that

same piece of

creative, those landing pages.

And it's a, I mean, it's a lot, a lot of

work on top of the fact,

like, is there actually

marginal benefit in that?

You know, debatable.

Yeah.

I would agree.

Yeah.

How long are you letting things rip then?

Like how, what is, what is your actual

test and your patience for those?

What does this test look like?

Yeah.

It changes.

It changes all the time.

I feel like sometimes

we, we are more patient.

Sometimes we're not.

I think, I think at the spend threshold

that Mars is at

specifically now, things are just

burning out so quickly that we, we turn

them off fairly quick.

So like, I mean, if we're not seeing the

numbers that we want

in like 48 hours, like

we're usually killing that, that ad.

Um, and when it comes to landing pages,

it's like we, if this is

something that we've done,

if the ad does work or doesn't work,

we'll duplicate it over

to a different funnel for

us.

It might be quiz or PDP and then we'll

launch it in a, what we

like the graveyard concepts,

graveyard campaign, um, with a cost

control and see if then that works.

Cause it's like, was it actually the

creative problem or was

the landing page problem that

it was going to?

So we do that a lot if, if like the soft

metrics on the creative

looks good, but the performance

of shit.

So that is like the other

way that we think about it.

We're pretty hot to kill things, but it

doesn't mean we're not

going to do that and throw

it in the cost control campaign and see

if we can get some more steel out of it.

Um, going to a different page.

Yeah.

And then I'm, I think going this, this

rolls nicely into

reporting, but before we do that,

um, Jordan and I, George, my business

partner, uh, for those

that don't know, um, we've

been, we've been like flirting with this

idea of like the persona

specific PDP, um, because

PDPs can still work really well.

And I know, um, I've talked to a bunch of

people in the space

and like just expanding

your PDP and giving more information that

answers questions and

customizing your product

photos to, um, you know, I, I know you,

you gave that insight

and then all of a sudden,

like last year and now everybody's

product page, their

carousel has a bunch of images that

are dialed in a certain way.

Like, have you, have you flirted with the

idea of just like

making the product page a

little bit more persona specific?

Like, okay, we just changed

the product title to match.

It's like, I mean, you, you've, the

extreme version of this

with hollow is like compression

works.

So we made fucking impression socks.

Yeah.

Yeah.

It's like, right.

Right.

So you just do go the

product route, but right.

No, this is exactly, this is the next

level of where we're at now for more.

So it's like, we've taken the ad to

landing page congruency.

We've got that.

Now we move, now we move the

PDP to the bottom of the page.

Does that perform

better than pushing the PDP?

Let's say it does.

Now it's much easier to edit that quote

unquote PDP section if

it's all one long funnel.

And I think this is the one

that was really interesting.

I would, I used to look at, at brands

like, um, even grooms a

little bit, but, um, primal

queen.

I'm like, these pages are so long.

How do, how do that many customers get

through this whole page?

I think if, if, if the content is right

and it's relevant, I

don't think the length of

the page is actually going

to hurt to a certain degree.

It's not going to hurt general conversion

rate if it's congruent.

If you're talking about weight loss and

then you go to a page and

it's 10 reasons why this

product is going to help with weight loss

this season, dah, dah,

dah, dah, 10 reasons.

Great.

And then you get into a product page

section and it's like the

weight, the best weight loss

products.

Here's your discount.

Da, da, da.

Right.

I think, and then all

the carousel images match.

Why would that not do better?

So that's where we're at now where we are

starting to, to, to

tinker with actual clinical

PDP because obviously we're signal SKU,

which helps us do that

much easier than if you're,

you know, 10,000 SKU apparel company.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, if you've got people that are

like, they want to solve

a problem so badly, you've

got them captivated.

Like they're going to continue to read

until you give them the solution.

I think, I think I

told you guys separately.

I saw this insane ad from Dr. Gundry,

which I think is golden hippo.

It's a golden hippo brand.

If I'm not mistaken.

Yeah.

I think so.

Dude, like I clicked

the ad on, on Twitter.

Cause I was like, this

is going to be insane.

And I clicked it.

And the only, like, it's a five minute

VSL and you have to watch it.

It's actually more than five minutes.

I'm pretty sure.

You have to watch the video.

You can't do anything else on the page,

but watch the video.

And at some point I

couldn't even wait that long.

I literally tried to leave my phone.

I was like, I can't wait anymore.

I was like, abandoned the page.

It was like, you have to watch the whole

thing and then get to the point.

Now, I'm not trying to get sued by

anybody by saying crazy

things, but like they're promising

some pretty insane things.

And so like the person who's watching

that is like desperate for a solution.

And so like, they're going

to watch the whole thing.

And like, you know, people talk about

like levels of interest.

Like there's people who sit down and

watch a three hour

podcast and like, it's cause

they're interested in it.

Like they'll sit through the whole thing

and they'll stop when

they don't want to read

it anymore.

That's the interesting thing about pages

is you can just like,

yeah, progressively build,

build more and more as long as it's not

like killing your page load speed and all

that good stuff.

So yeah.

Yeah.

We've tried VSL's failed.

I think we'll try it again.

I think we'll try it again, but we, we

didn't crack it the first go at it.

So it's something interesting that my

lessons from the VSL,

like going down the rabbit

hole is you just, you

basically just push up an insane AOV.

That's the whole entire.

So it's like, you can get someone to

watch 45 minutes of a

video before you finally

present the solution

as this magical capsule.

You need them because you've had so much

drop off throughout that.

You need that customer to buy this insane

AOV bundle, which is

usually just like a bunch

of crazy post-purchase upsells, like

stacked after another.

So, and unless you can do that, like the,

the full blown VSL

situation just doesn't make

a ton of sense, which is kind of why we

killed it to some degree.

Yeah.

Is there anything related to, I know I

still want to hit on reporting.

Is there anything related to like

merchandising offers, how it

shows up in the product page

post-purchase that like you think is

worth hammering through really quick?

I can't think of

anything off the top of my head.

We, we did some questions

post-purchase around here.

Here's one that's interesting.

In our quiz, we ask a really interesting

question as like one of them.

I won't say necessarily which one because

I don't want everyone

to steal and shit, but

we ask an interesting

question in the quiz.

And that question has given me so many

ideas for new pillars

because we leave it like we

kind of leave it open-ended.

There's, there's actual prompts, but like

it's open-ended

enough the way that we let

them fill it out that I think it's, it's

been really interesting.

So I would say like, if you feel like

you're getting stuck

with, Hey, I don't know what

pillars to go build for creative or even

for landers, build a

quiz and ask a question that

like prompts these people that don't know

much about your brand

or your product yet to

like give you some feedback and you might

come up with

something really interesting.

So that's one that's been, I'll just say

is like a teaser of something that's been

generating interesting ideas for me and

coming up with new, new

concepts for, for new pillars.

Yeah.

Does your quiz builder, I know you use

something else and you

guys recently switched.

Does it tell you like, are you guys

paying attention to who

ends up buying and how they

answer the questions and

then using that information?

Cause like you can get, like you have the

quiz answers in

aggregate, but like the most useful

ones are the people that ended up buying.

Right.

And obviously you can see where drop-off

looks like and things like that.

But if you, cause like post-purchases,

it's also a very different experience.

Like this person also bought, they

self-selected and they're

kind of, they may be answering

it different than pre-purchase.

So it was like, there's almost value in

understanding what the

people who didn't buy said.

And then also, okay, the people who did

buy, how did they

answer these, these questions

and just filtering it

by purchaser actually.

Don't have that data, but

we're going to figure that out.

Cause that's super interesting.

That's super interesting.

Yeah.

I mostly look at like.

It's a little bit from both.

Yeah.

I mean, right now I'm kind of going down

the rabbit hole of like

hacking the drop-off rate.

I'm looking at like drop-off by question

and I'm like, okay,

what can I change this,

this slide or question to be so I can

keep the progression,

progression happening.

That's mostly where my time is spent

right now in the quiz.

It's just like thinking about those

drop-off rates and figuring

out what about that question

or what about the answers that, that they

have as options to

select or slowing them down

or making them bored and

saying, this is too many questions.

But yeah, that would be pretty, that'd be

pretty important information to get.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, I've seen some

insanely long quizzes.

I'm always surprised by like, I don't

know, this idea of

friction, like people, people,

I feel like people are really coming

around to thinking that like

friction is not necessarily

a bad thing.

Especially with quizzes.

Cause like quizzes are

like starting to self-select.

Maybe it's the open loop concept.

I said that on a call today.

It was super cringy.

Um, it's like the open loop of like,

okay, I want the answer.

I got started this.

I want to know what

it's going to tell me.

I want to know what the answer is.

I want this like miracle thing that I

could take to solve all my problems.

Um, but yeah, uh, well, they'll have to

tell me how that goes.

Cause now I'm, now I'm invested.

Yeah.

Okay.

Uh, that rolls really nicely into like

landing page reporting and

how you're thinking about,

um, reporting.

You kind of talked about the reports that

you just built out that you,

you found really interesting.

Um, I'll just really quickly say a couple

of things that I pay attention to from a,

landing page reporting perspective.

And then I know there's a lot more that I

would like to dig

further into, but, um, because

of the way that we launched tests in CBO,

spend velocity is like

aggregate spend for that

funnel, um, or that product or that

campaign is one thing.

Spend velocity is another thing.

And then once we start to see some

validation, that's where I'm

going and I'm looking at the

heat maps and I'm saying, okay, this is

how far people are making down the page.

Here's what people

are clicking most often.

And I'll give one specific

tactical thing that came out.

Like you should watch,

you should watch recordings.

It's really helpful to watch recordings.

We ran a quiz funnel on time and I

started watching recordings.

I watched fucking 20 in a row.

Nobody took the quiz.

It's like, it's working and it was

converting insanely well.

Nobody was taking the quiz.

Literally nobody.

We added a shop the product button.

It said, start the quiz or shop the

product right below it.

Uh, that literally revenue per session

went up, uh, 20% by just adding that.

Cause like, and if you don't want to take

the quiz, cool, you can

go to the product page

and check it out.

Um, and then the people that

want to take the quiz, great.

Like that was, so, um, I watched the

recordings and that's kind

of like, uh, the recordings

are tricky cause, um, small samples and

it's, you know, um, easy

to get distracted by that.

But, um, total spend, spend velocity are

kind of some core

things that I pay attention

to.

Um, what else are you looking at as

you're evaluating landing page reporting?

Yeah.

I mean, the biggest one is the creative

that's going to that landing page.

I kind of talked about it earlier.

It's like, start with the landing page

URL, see how performance is.

Is it, is it beating baseline versus the

rest of the account?

What does the spend volume versus the

rest of the account?

Which then gives you some indication of

like, okay, maybe there's

some ability for the raws

to be slightly lower on that.

If they're, if you're

getting more scale out of it.

And then what are the actual ads that are

performing for that later?

That is the main thing I'm paying

attention to right now.

Um, I think like the content on the page,

watching screen

recordings, watching heat maps

or like looking at

heat maps or click maps.

I think that's like the next level.

Um, but because we're launching so many

new ones and we're trying

to build this concurrency

thing, I'm mostly just trying to figure

out like, what are the

ads are actually working

within this later?

Which are the ones that are not, that are

getting a bunch of

spend that we, that are

kind of like failing at that

combination of concurrency.

So that's mostly it.

I don't really have anything else.

Super, super special.

We, we built like this thing that kind of

shows them on like a chart format.

So I can watch landers like, uh, scale

or, or fall off

throughout periods of time.

And then also this like scatterplot kind

of version, which then

breaks it out by like,

um, spend and then ROAS.

So it's like, you can kind of figure out

like, okay, the ROAS kind

of degrades, but then some

of these like landers have

a lot more scale to them.

So it's easier to kind

of identify those winners.

Again, nothing too crazy.

Um, mostly just like the, that combo of

what ad is actually not

working for this very specific

lander.

Um, yeah.

Well, it feels like getting into like

metrics, like bounce rate

and obviously like revenue

procession, profit procession, conversion

rate, those things are

like helpful, but it's like,

you need a, you need a success metric

first, which is maybe

total spend, spend velocity,

actual efficiency.

It's like, that's gonna be way more

insightful than looking at a bounce rate.

Well, it's like bounce rate might not

actually tell you anything

like, you know, the, when

the test that I talked about earlier, um,

going from a PDP to a

listicle bounce rate dropped

a lot, which was, that's a helpful

insight, but like it

also just performed better.

I didn't need bounce rate to tell me that

it's like, okay, people are

spending more time reading

the content on the page.

Great.

Um, you know, but it's bounce rate that

like, what is bounce

rate going to tell me that,

um, that spend velocity didn't, um, is,

uh, is something that

I've been thinking a

lot about.

Like if you, if you're doing nothing,

like you're, you're,

you're listening to this and

you're like, I bought it.

Like, yes, sign me up.

I would love to test landing pages.

How do I do it?

Um, I think it's kind of daunting.

Um, I know like AI is making it

progressively less daunting

to get pages rolled out, which

is great.

But is there any place that you would

suggest people go to start?

And a caveat to that is like, why, why do

you think it takes most brands forever to

build and test and deploy a landing page?

Like our CRO agency is

just like super slow.

Um, are they like, what, what's yeah.

Um, how would you start?

What's preventing people

from just like launching pages?

The answer is like, it's not that hard

anymore, but you do need

to do, you need to put all

the pieces together correctly, which is

the template has to be correct.

And it needs to be

like a winning template.

What would I do there?

Go look at in motion in any of your

favorite tools, go look at

the brands that are spending

the most, any trend track, any, any of

these tools that can

like scrape things, go find

the brands that are spending the most

that are pushing traffic.

Most of them have the same looking

templates for the most

part, especially for listicles.

Just copy that, like start

there, copy that template.

So many people have

copied ours already, right?

Hollow, Marsman, it's whatever.

It is what it is.

Template, I don't really care about.

Copy it away.

Then really what it comes down to is just

copywriting and copywriting

and then the images that go

with the pages.

I think the

copywriting is the hardest part.

I think writing good copy is much harder

than people make it out to be.

Throwing it into quad without a ton of

pre-prompting is going to

get you shit copy with a bunch

of M dashes.

And like, I think

people see into that now.

So I think doing copyright is hard.

And I think that's probably like the

biggest thing that slows things down.

And then if a brand is very brand

forward, they want

everything like designed to match

brand standard.

That's another thing

that can slow shit down.

So I think the one thing that I always

say is like your landing

pages can definitely be

uglier than your website and your ads can

be even uglier than your landing pages.

So like be okay with a little bit of

like, yeah, use your brand

font, use your brand colors,

use those things.

But like if it's not

perfect, get started.