Awaken

Wrath doesn’t just help fuel social movements—it’s a prerequisite for transformation. Anger is the spark that wakes people out of complacency and inspires them to take action to safeguard the vulnerable and push for change. A painting of the fierce guardian deity Mahakala reflects the relational, interdependent nature of our world and our capacity to shape it.

This episode features author and emergent strategist adrienne marie brown and is hosted by singer, writer, and frontwoman of the bands Bikini Kill and Le Tigre Kathleen Hanna.

Read the transcript and learn more about the artwork in this episode

Creators and Guests

Host
Kathleen Hanna
Kathleen Hanna is an American singer, musician and pioneer of the feminist punk riot grrrl movement, and punk zine writer.

What is Awaken?

AWAKEN is a Webby Honoree podcast about the dynamic path to enlightenment and what it means to “wake up.” Throughout the series we dive into the personal stories of guests who share how they’ve experienced a shift in their awareness, and as a result, their perspective on life.

Annabella Pitkin:
It's such a wonderful question to think about the role of wrath understood as enlightened fierce compassion in the context of societal responsibility.

Myisha Cherry:
Just take a brief tour of history and social movements, and that will convince you that anger and compassion can be utilized to bring about change.

Kathleen Hanna:
Welcome to season 6 of AWAKEN, a podcast from the Rubin Museum of Himalayan Art about the dynamic path to enlightenment and what it means to “wake up.”
I am Kathleen Hanna, punk singer, writer, and frontwoman of the bands Bikini Kill and Le Tigre, and your host for this season of AWAKEN.

At a time when anger seems more present—and potent—than ever, how can a better understanding of wrath help us transform this challenging emotion into an effective catalyst for change?

In this season, we explore the concept of wrath as a powerful force for awakening and transformation. Experts in the realms of art, philosophy, Buddhism and more share how wrath can be used for protection and meaningful action when applied with intention, skill, and compassion.

Buddhist and Hindu art have long been a pathway to insights and awakening, illuminating perspectives on how to navigate the world. Over the course of eight episodes we look at artworks of wrathful deities from the Rubin Museum’s collection to learn what these terrifying figures can teach us about harnessing wrath for the benefit of all.
In this episode, we look at how wrath not only helps fuel social movements and change but is, in fact, necessary. Wrath gives us the awareness and the motivation to gather our strength and fight for what we love, even for people and places we may not even know directly. It gets us to act.

Annabella Pitkin:
I think one of the first things that our minds might leap to is the idea that if we are not feeling some sense of urgency when harm is happening in our society or being done in our name or happening to vulnerable people and beings that we become aware of, if we don't feel some kind of push, some urgency, some discomfort with that, some impetus, then we are complacent.

Kathleen Hanna:
Professor Annabella Pitkin teaches Buddhism and East Asian Religions at Lehigh University.

Annabella Pitkin:
We are complicit in it. We are passive. And so I think there can be a real sense that wrathful compassion can be a kind of flame, a kind of heated energy that gets things going, gets things in motion, causes people to snap out of their shyness or their fear or their social anxiety or their concern for themselves and gets them moving in the service of others and also in the defense of others.

Myisha Cherry:
Without people feeling anger and using that anger and collaboration with a whole bunch of other emotions, such as compassion, love, and empathy, a lot of things would not have gotten done.

Kathleen Hanna:
Myisha Cherry is an associate professor of philosophy at the University of California, Riverside, the director of the Emotion and Society Lab and the author of numerous books including The Case for Rage: Why Anger is Essential to Anti-racist Struggle and the forthcoming How to Love.

Myisha Cherry:
A lot of change would not have occurred. I mean, let's be clear. That's how the world's changed. I mean, King says, people are not just going to bring language power. That's not how it works. The power really belongs to the people.

adrienne maree brown:
We love something, we love a land, we love a people, we love a person, we love a creature, but there's some kind of love. And for some reason what's coming to mind, it's less often for ourselves.

Kathleen Hanna:
adrienne maree brown is an emergent strategist and author of many books including Emergent Strategy and Pleasure Activism.

adrienne maree brown:
For me, wrath is something when I'm like, I feel on behalf of the collective or on behalf of another more than I access it for myself, which might just be my own self-work to do. But yeah, there's something about these strong emotions that feel really tied to each other. In order to feel something so strong as wrath there, it has to be rooted in something as deep as love.

Annabella Pitkin:
When I look at Buddhist art and when I hear Buddhist teachers and experts explain what wrathful compassion is or what compassionate wrath is, one of the things I hear them say over and over again is that it is not the same thing as self-cherishing anger. It's not the same thing as self-righteousness. And this distinction I think is extremely important to make, particularly in our times, it is so easy to find examples of really wonderful movements and people where the goal was so admirable, and yet something got distorted around self-righteousness around us versus them around we are the good guys and those bad guys are not like us, and therefore we can do whatever we want to them. And that is a real danger with the wrathful compassion imagery.

Sharon Salzberg:
A lot of what we do doesn't have an immediate result.

Kathleen Hanna:
Sharon Salzberg is a meditation pioneer, world-renowned teacher, and New York Times bestselling author of books including Loving Your Enemies, Real Change and Finding Your Way.

Sharon Salzberg:
We're planting a seed, we're standing up for what's right or it seems right to us, but we're not finding the great, not evolution, but revolution in a moment. What Buddhism is urging us toward is landing our sense of integrity and knowing our intention, what was it? And how skillfully did we act?

adrienne maree brown:
It's an interdependent emotion.

Kathleen Hanna:
Again, adrienne maree brown.

adrienne maree brown:
When someone comes into a room and they're feeling wrath, when someone's in a meeting and they're feeling wrath, when someone's in the public square and they're feeling wrath, it impacts everyone around you.

Sharon Salzberg:
The intention to seek change for the common good, can have a lot of different forms. And when I wrote this book some years ago called Real Change, it started with my work with caregivers and people who were really on the front lines of suffering who were often more concerned about the wellbeing of others than their own. And I woke up one morning and I thought, who does that remind me of? And I thought, oh, activists.
I was having a conversation with bell hooks…

Kathleen Hanna:
A philosopher, professor and author of many books including All About Love.

Sharon Salzberg:
…and she said to me, "I don't really like the term social action because for some people it might only imply protesting or marching." And she said to me, "What about art?" And it was such a great reminder of the many, many forms that our own wish to work for the good or even to be expressive of that kind of wrath, it can take many, many forms.

Myisha Cherry:
If you are a lawyer, then you need to figure out how to do these briefs so we can fight this stuff in the courts. If you're an educator thinking about all the fascism and how universities and educational institutions and libraries are being attacked, then you need to use your anger and your compassion and make sure that they don't take certain kind of books off the shelves, that you stand firm in the classes that you teach. There's something for all of us to do, and we need to use our anger and our compassion to do those things that we can do.

adrienne maree brown:
If we cannot get extremely angry about the things that are actually wrong, I don't think we stand a chance of stopping them because it's so much easier in some ways. Before you access your rage in a healthy way, it's so much easier to suppress it. That's what we're trained to do.

Myisha Cherry:
Society can inform how we feel about our emotions, can make us feel shame about the emotions that we do indeed have.

adrienne maree brown:
It's so much easier to get along, to keep it polite, to try to normalize.

Myisha Cherry:
And it used to be the case that if a woman was angry, she did not have a right to be angry. She was hysterical. Her anger was irrational because there's no way that she could respond to her disrespect because she was not an entity that was deserving of such.

adrienne maree brown:
Even I remember this young experiences of patriarchy, young experiences of racism and feeling like, oh, that person couldn't possibly mean that, or I've got to make a way to stay connected to their humanity.
And there's a place we have to get to where we're like, no, you don't get to take anything from my body. No, you don't get to take my children. No, you don't get to make me work in a field. No, you don't get to take this land.

Myisha Cherry:
When immigrants' rights are being disrespected and when government entities are coming into your house or you're deciding to protect yourself because your rights are being disrespected, people will say, "We don't have a right to be angry because they were disrespected." So even in our society, who we take have a right to be angry and not will also be informed by our isms, our racisms, our sexisms, beyond our individualism.

adrienne maree brown:
As soon as I become aware that I'm being oppressed, that something is unfair, I join into this massive river of people who have experienced apartheid and genocide and oppression and rape and harm. And all the time inside of ourselves, there's something that's like, "This isn't right. This isn't how I should be treated." And then there are times in histry when we can express that right and we can collectively rise up.

Annabella Pitkin:
This tradition of Buddhist art just uses over and over again this imagery of flames, there is a sense of strong energy, strong active, heated energy, the sense that laziness or spacing out or ignoring it or kind of staying in your chair, that whole inertia gets kind of burned away by the flames of this kind of fierce compassion.
There's this kind of warm, compassionate, but also wrathful forcefulness to that, that it burns through your own fear or anxiety, and that is protective, where you become this protective figure who defends the vulnerable, and you kind of place yourself between the vulnerable and danger.

Kathleen Hanna:
This season, we are exploring images of wrathful deities from the Rubin Museum’s collection. In Buddhist and Hindu art, wrathful deities are fierce embodiments of compassion and awakening in action.
In this episode, professor Annabella Pitkin looks at a 15th-century Tibetan painting of Mahakala—a fierce guardian deity shared across Buddhism and Hinduism. His name, meaning "Great Black One," refers not only to the color black, but also the concept of time—its inevitability, destructive force, and transformational potential. Within Tibetan Buddhism, Mahakala is among the most important protector deities, called upon to defend teachings, remove obstacles, and safeguard practitioners on the path to awakening.
To see this artwork, visit rubinmuseum.org/awaken

Annabella Pitkin:
We see a lot of the color red as well as this blue black color of darkness. These are very important colors associated with wrathful energy with blissfulness. At the very top register, we see a series of teachers, enlightened beings in monastic robes in the teaching lineage of this image. And also on the right hand side, bodhisattvas and buddhas. We see other enlightened beings in the corners.

We see the lotus seat as the base and the figure of the human corpse upon which Mahakala is dancing, subduing these negativities again. And then we see dancing figures at the bottom register of the image. And there's a real sense that this enlightened, compassionate wrathfulness in the world is an interactive, intersubjective energy that it manifests in the world of people and animals and beings of cities, of architecture, of politics and society, of men and women, of all the phenomena and sensory experiences that we're all familiar with, and they're all present connected to the things that we see in this painting.

And that I think is a really powerful, subtle, but significant layer of an image like this, that the wrathful compassionate energy, the protective guardian energy of a painting like this is very much intersubjective about our relationships. It's about our relationality, it's about the messy business of the world that we live in, the messy business of push and pull of what we want, of what we get, of what we're afraid of, what we negotiate of the world of economics and politics and competition and rivalry, all of the things where we actually get our buttons pushed, where we actually feel frightened or greedy or jealous or envious or competitive or shy or anxious. All of that stuff happens around other people. We are not in a beautiful meditation retreat in solitude in this painting. We're actually in the thick of it. And so in the thick of it is where wrathful compassion is perhaps the most helpful to us. How can we navigate when our buttons are actually being pushed? How can we actually stand up for what's right without getting angry in the selfish unenlightened way when the chips are down? How can we actually maintain the expansive view, the compassionate view, the altruistic view, the freedom from grasping and the freedom from fear in the real world? And an image like this suggests that that's where this powerful energy of wrathful compassion is always operating. In the thick of it.

Kathleen Hanna:
Lujan Rai Dongol is a visual artist based in Nepal who created the cover artwork for the wrath issue of the Rubin Museum’s Spiral magazine. It’s a vibrant, colorful image of Mahakala. See the cover at rubinmuseum.org/spiral

Lujan Rai Dongol:
The creation of this artwork and the representation of Mahkala as wrath for me is a comfort space because when I was growing up, everything was so turbulent. I was always fascinated with all these murals of these Tibetan deities around. And I never really gave it a thought what actually it was. If you look at a wrathful deity's face, if you just look at it plainly, it's obviously scary, but when you give it time and try to allow it to get to you, for me, I experienced this when I was in grade five, the wrathful deities always gave me a space to be human, to actually see me and know that I was going through something because I've always had trouble speaking about how I felt. Wrath has always been something that commands me. Wrath has always been something that has been very familiar as well as comforting. For me, to witness Mahakala was somewhat of a safe space. It's the place where I can confess and be sorry and always be accepted. Being accepted was the thing I really needed

adrienne maree brown:
Wrath is actually a very hopeful emotion.

Kathleen Hanna:
Again, adrienne maree brown.

adrienne maree brown:
I think it's a belief that something could be different, and that's why I'm so angry. If I didn't know that anything else could happen, if my imagination was not intact, I could probably passively go along with what's happening, but there's something in me that's, even if I can't put a word or a visual on it, there's something imagining a different possibility for me and feeling the distance I am from that reality. And that's the rage I'm always wanting us to activate and harness and use together. I think that's the rage that leads to general strikes. Wrath is strong. You're not feeling fragility and wrath at the same time. You're like, I'm going to lift this car if I have to. We are going to change this moment.

We're going to take to the street. We're going to confront power. We're going to go right up to the folks with their shields and their batons and their guns. And we're going to say, we're not scared of you. We're going to throw the tear gas canisters back. There's just a strength in it. And I'm really interested in that strength and fortitude for a humanity that wants to survive long-term. I'm really interested in the kind of people we could be and that some of us are or some of us are becoming right now because of this. I've never been this angry in my life and it's changing how I create. I'm like, if you're interested in learning, come be around me. We'll learn together.

Annabella Pitkin:
That is the kind of seed kernel of value in ordinary anger that compassionate wrathfulness harnesses and builds on. The crucial difference is the strong foundation that wrathful compassion has in the rest of the Buddhist path. And this is the absolute essential.

Myisha Cherry:
The people have to stand up, the people have to say things, the people have to demand things, the people have to do things. And we as people, we have this biological hack called emotions that can motivate us and guide us to do those particular things. So I will say, use it, don't be ashamed of it, get in a solidarity with other people and try to figure out what to do with it, because it's not enough just to have it, but you got to do something with it. And I think it's important to know that there's different things that we can do with it.

Kathleen Hanna:
You just heard the voices of adrienne maree brown, Myisha Cherry, Lujan Rai Dongol, Annabella Pitkin, and Sharon Salzberg.
I am Kathleen Hanna, your host.

To see the artwork discussed in this episode, go to rubinmuseum.org/awaken

If you're enjoying the podcast, leave us a review wherever you listen to podcasts, and tell your friends. Leaving a review is one of the best ways to support us. It really helps us reach listeners like you.

For more stories and news from the Rubin, follow @rubinmuseum on Instagram and sign up for the Museum’s monthly newsletter at rubinmuseum.org.

AWAKEN season 6 is an eight-part series from the Rubin, a global museum dedicated to presenting HImalayan art and its insights.

AWAKEN is produced by the Rubin Museum of Himalayan Art with Westin Harris, Kimon Keramidas, Christina Watson, Sovah Woydak, and Sarah Zabrodski in collaboration with SOUND MADE PUBLIC including Tania Ketenjian, Philip Wood, Kristin Mueller, Christine Driscoll, and Aaron Siegel.

Original music has been produced by Hannis Brown with additional music from Blue Dot Sessions.

AWAKEN season 6 is supported, in part, by the Charina Endowment Fund, The Prospect Hill Foundation, and Shelley and Donald Rubin, with generous contributions from the Rubin's Board of Trustees, individual donors, and Friends of the Rubin.

This program is supported, in part, by public funds from the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs, in partnership with the City Council.

This program is supported, in part, by the New York State Council on the Arts with the support of the Office of Governor Kathy Hochul and the New York State Legislature.
Thank you for listening.