Prose + Comms: Engagement, Unplugged

Brand collaborations are everywhere, but are they delivering real results? As unexpected partnerships become the norm, marketers face growing pressure to turn creative ideas into meaningful business outcomes.

In this episode of Prose + Comms, Laura Smith and Brian Rowley explore what separates a strategic brand collaboration from a fleeting marketing stunt. They discuss how partnerships can introduce brands to new audiences, tap into cultural trends, and drive business results. From authenticity and audience alignment to timing and long-term impact, they examine what marketers should consider before jumping on the collaboration trend.

What is Prose + Comms: Engagement, Unplugged?

This is your go-to podcast for all things marketing, branding, and customer experience. We’re bringing you honest and fun conversations with bite-sized insights. Hosted by BrightSign’s CMO Brian Rowley and Head of Integrated Marketing Laura Smith, you’ll hear from industry pros, creatives, and innovators about what’s actually working in today’s evolving, digital-first world. No fluff — just real insights on how brands are connecting with audiences and driving growth. Tune in for fresh ideas, big thinking, and all the tips you need to take your marketing game to the next level.

Laura Smith:

So a coffee chain is selling sweaters. Gelatin is in lip gloss aisle. Butterbeer is in the spice rack. Brian, this year has been quite a year for creative brand collapse.

Laura Smith:

Collaborations used to be super rare, newsworthy, but now they feel like something every brand is doing or wants to do. So today, we're diving into whether those brand collabs can still be creative power moves, or are they just an easy way to grab short lived attention? So to kick us off, I wanna ask you, Brian, do you remember any great brand collaborations off the top of your head in one that you may be engaged with and bought something because of it?

Brian Rowley:

So I mean, collabs per se, like, this is kind of an interesting one. Because when we started this whole conversation, I was like, let me think about this a little bit. And and honestly, you're gonna laugh at me, but like a collab that I actually was a part of was like Bark Box, which is a dog toy company and Dunkin Donuts. Like I know this sounds like completely off the end, but I was in Dunkin' getting Dunkin'. And they were like selling like they had done this big collab with like, could get a donut or you could get a cup of coffee or whatever.

Brian Rowley:

And I actually surprised myself and I was like, oh, my dog will like that. And I bought it for him. I don't see myself like on a regular basis. I mean, stand out, but I don't know. I don't see myself a lot like really focusing on the collab.

Brian Rowley:

I mean, am I alone here or what about you?

Laura Smith:

No. Yeah. I don't feel like... I mean, I think... I feel like they're noticed or we notice them because it's brand marketing creative stuff that we would be familiar with, but I haven't actually ever purchased anything based on a collaboration.

Laura Smith:

You know, I think as we get into some of the Never? Brands... No. Like, I cannot think of one that seems... I mean, again, this is like all kind of a newer thing.

Laura Smith:

So I I definitely think I'd remember. And I'm I'm curious about the BarkBox one though too because what... Like that probably was somewhat of like a... Obviously, it's a partnership of some sort, but like was it a trend or was it just happened to be that Duncan was selling dog toys?

Brian Rowley:

No. It was actually a charity. It was a charity for children like that they were doing and they had done a collab for it. So like immediately, like I was like, alright, I'm interested. Like I like charity stuff.

Brian Rowley:

You know, again, I like, you know, my dog loves that type of stuff. Bark is actually a brand that's actually pretty good. Do all sorts of things where you can do monthly subscriptions where dog toys arrive every blah blah blah. I mean, I won't get into it too much.

Laura Smith:

We've already gone into it too much. I

Brian Rowley:

know, fair enough. I'm already weighed on this rabbit hole. Hole. I don't know. I mean, you know, I guess the question that I have though is what actually makes like a collab actually work?

Brian Rowley:

Like from, I mean, your perspective, like what, what would work for you if you were in that position? Because I have to tell you, for me, I don't think of it at all.

Laura Smith:

Yeah. I think that it would have to be something that's just not that one moment in time blitz. I think that's gonna give a brand attention. It's gonna probably make some sales maybe. But when it just lasts like that really quick moment, I feel like was that really a success?

Laura Smith:

Because I think it's like if there can be long term impacts from collaboration, whether that be by growing new audiences, increasing sales, doing other collabs, like down the road, it's not just that one and done, where two brands really have some kind of shared interests or audiences or whatever that may be that can work effectively. And I think as we dive into some today, there are some that definitely didn't work, or I I would view it as, like, so random. But when you look into them and you do research on them, you're like, wow. That actually did have some sales impact, which is fascinating. So...

Laura Smith:

But I think it has to be that one and done feels like if you... Something going quote unquote viral, and then what does that mean? And think the brand has to just be set up for like, are you trying to sell more, or are you trying to get in front of new audiences, or are you trying to get a lot of headlines? Yeah. Because I think there's different reasons to collaborate based on what your goal is.

Brian Rowley:

I would agree because I think it goes back to... Mean, we talk about authenticity all the time. Like, it's very difficult, I think, to find two brands that are very authentic working together. And authentic in the sense of they each add value or they each tell a similar story, where they could pair up together where it would be effective enough where someone like myself or you would actually be interested in, doing something with them. You know, I don't know.

Brian Rowley:

It's it's an interesting one. But alright. So we have talked about what makes a brand collaboration work, but it's a lot more fun actually to look at some actual examples. And twenty twenty six actually has given us some interesting ones, from partnerships that make perfect sense to actually ones that make you wonder how did that idea come to life. You and I talk about that all the time.

Brian Rowley:

So let's actually run through a few recent collabs and see which ones we think actually got it right. So do you remember the... I think this was like, not actually not too long ago, like maybe about a month or two ago, but the Duncan and L. L. Bean?

Laura Smith:

Yes. Yes. New England. So yes.

Brian Rowley:

Exactly. So I mean, for of you that are listening, two really iconic, right? New England brands partnered on national coffee day, which was actually September 29, I think if I remember correctly. Why I have that stat here is an important thing to wonder, like what's going on inside my head. But anyways, so basically what ended up happening is, they offered a bird's eye sweater cup sleeve, one of those things that you put around your coffee, right?

Brian Rowley:

And it was Dunkin' pink bird's eye sweater and an orange and pink boat and tote. So like, I think like they were both under $100, but both brands actually have strong New England roots and the partnership played into sort of a shared identity. But is regional pride in this case enough to make a collaboration compelling or does there need to be sort of a stronger connection between the brands? So you're familiar with it. You're obviously a New Englander.

Brian Rowley:

I'm a New Englander. Did it work?

Laura Smith:

Yeah. I think I think it did work. I mean, don't... I'm not a customer of either of those two brands. So for me, I'm like, I didn't go buy anything or anything from this, so it didn't influence, like, a new customer in my perspective.

Laura Smith:

But they're very... Also very loyal audiences who buy from them already. So... And they're both New England. So it's very, very relevant.

Laura Smith:

Obviously, timely coming into fall, the sweaters. I mean, they made... I mean, I saw them on the Today show, like, all of this. So it got a lot of probably earned and paid and all kinds of other coverage. But from a from a success and business standpoint, it's like, yes, they ran out of these products, like things they could not get any more of.

Laura Smith:

So people were running in to get them. And I get... I'm gonna tie it back to the fact that I think it's because those two brands just have very, very loyal audiences and probably a lot of overlap of those audiences. So, like, it's it's makes relevant sense that people who buy coffee there may also want an L. L.

Laura Smith:

Bean paraphernalia or vice versa. Right? So so I think that... I think it's... Did they make, you know, a ton of ongoing money, or was it one of those moments that they just made a...

Laura Smith:

Like, they sold out of those things, and then did they see that can continue to to increase? I don't think so. But I would say it feels relevant to me and very on brand for both.

Brian Rowley:

Well, I think for for me, when I when I saw this one, I think the reason it worked is obviously because of the New England connection. Because just taking two logos, putting them on something doesn't necessarily work. But I do think because we're both from New England, right? Two very prominent brands in New England. I mean, I think L.

Brian Rowley:

L. Bean is like one of the longest standing clothing brands in the New England market. Right? I mean, they've notorious for their, you know, outdoor apparel and all the other things that have grown over the course of the years. And obviously, Dunkin's Dunkin'.

Brian Rowley:

Right? Like, I mean, you hear Dunkin' everywhere. So I think it's the geographic connection that actually was really the part that actually made it potentially work.

Laura Smith:

Yeah. And I just think it's, you know, like it's entering into fall and people are looking into like the changes of the coffees and like all the hype around whatever, the pumpkin and all that. So I just think that's like that... Dunkin' is already top of mind for people coming into the fall and then obviously like fall sweaters and coming from LOB and all that. So, yeah, I think I think they got it right.

Laura Smith:

You know, again, I'm not, a customer of either, but I think from a mark... From a marketer standpoint, I think it worked.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah. I I would totally agree.

Laura Smith:

Okay. So there's two others that we're gonna talk about because they're closely tied in the sense that they're both like makeup, oriented.

Brian Rowley:

So you're gonna talk about them because neither of them have any relevance.

Laura Smith:

I mean, but you now understand about them.

Brian Rowley:

I do. I do.

Laura Smith:

So Jell O and Tower 28. Is it okay? So you're taking like... Letting the the Jell O flavors turn into a lip gloss basically. We're in Tower 28.

Laura Smith:

So... And that was at Sephora. The other one, we'll talk about top line, the other one is Sephora and Tabasco, and that's where they brought their limited edition limp plumping gloss to Sephora, which is obviously very Tabasco and spicy and all those things related. So the Jell O in Tower 28, I like because it's taking like a... Jell O's a legacy brand.

Laura Smith:

Right? So that audience potentially isn't of the younger generation who's buying Tower 28. However, I will admit, I buy Tower 28 because my 16 and 18 year old nieces tell me to buy Tower 28. So I... They're they're influencing the older generation.

Laura Smith:

But you're basically... Jell O's getting in front of new audiences. And Tower twenty eight, it's like everyone... Every young female whomever's wearing lip glosses wants, like, a cool new flavor, and Jell O offers really good flavors. So I feel as though there is a good connection there, bringing two kind of audiences together, but a ton of overlap as far as there's...

Laura Smith:

Like, it's hard to lose there, I guess, because, maybe some might not like the flavor, I guess, but it's trying something different and putting this in front of the new audience. So I feel like the Tower twenty eight one makes sense to me, but I never heard about it. So... And I am a purchaser of Tower 28, but I'm obviously probably not their target audience.

Brian Rowley:

K.

Laura Smith:

So you have nothing to offer there, Brian?

Brian Rowley:

Well, I I guess I think the... I don't actually.

Laura Smith:

Thanks for joining this podcast

Brian Rowley:

today, Brian. Well, I mean, you pick makeup. I mean, sorry. You kinda left me out there. But I would I mean, I think the attraction of new audiences obviously trying to generate a sort of awareness and likability in an older generation with a current product.

Brian Rowley:

To be honest, the one that I find that's interesting is actually Sephora. I think that their willingness and, their creative side of pulling something different into the store is actually something that I find to be kind of interesting. I think, keep me honest, but I think these were like limited time as well. So I wonder how much that has to do with the success of some of these collaborations, making it feel like it's, a limited time run and you must get a part of it today, otherwise you'll lose out. I think that probably has a lot to do with it as well.

Laura Smith:

The Sephora one actually went global. So that went far, and so I think Tabasco... I think it just probably felt like it was intrigued. Like what could this possibly be? But it gets Tabasco in front of, again, another...

Laura Smith:

Into the beauty industry, which why would it ever have gone into that space? So again, new audience is for them. I do know that it's still being cited as an unexpected brand licensing collaboration, so they definitely got recognition there and causing some people to turn their head. Like I said, it went international. From what I read, it did not go far from like a sales and product standpoint.

Laura Smith:

People were like, it's okay. I don't really love it. It doesn't work that well. Like it's not...

Brian Rowley:

I mean, not for nothing, but it sounds horrific. Like Tabasco,

Laura Smith:

like spicy things and I love lip gloss, but I'm not sure that I would put... It's supposed like, plump your lips. So when you do use stuff, I can educate you now. When you do use use these lip plumpers, it does kinda give you this tingly feeling. So it it...

Laura Smith:

Like, I get it. It's just gonna taste... I don't know it tastes like Tabasco or it just gives you that the the... How it's made gives you that same feeling. It's just Tabasco.

Brian Rowley:

Wish you had done a little more research on this one and gone out and purchased this, and you could have told us firsthand what you're thinking. I don't even

Laura Smith:

know if it's available. I don't know if it's available. But those two I think were like, you know, like where I think... I don't know. They they work for me.

Laura Smith:

Again, not necessarily target audience, but they make sense, and I think they saw some success. They can cite some success from those.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah. I mean, I think it's creative. It's an interesting approach. I think from a brand perspective, kudos for them for trying something that might be a little different. To your point, I don't know how successful either would have been, but I will...

Brian Rowley:

I mean, we do know Sephora got a lot of coverage as a result of it. So success if they were trying to create and promote the brand for sure. Similar to that, do you remember, I think it was earlier this year, the McCormick and Harry Potter?

Laura Smith:

Potter? Oh

Brian Rowley:

my god, there goes there goes that there goes that New England accent. Wow. So Harry Potter. So note, you know, very much known as a spice brand, right? Sort of tapped into the nostalgia just as a new generation sort of is discovering their series.

Brian Rowley:

So they launched a butter beer. There's a lot of ours in there. Flavored. It's finishing sugar that people can use. Yeah, it's yeah, I it's in baking and drinks and desserts.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah, I probably got that more than you miss takeout. But the collaboration actually taps into, as I said, the nostalgia of Harry Potter. My God, I got to stop this. This is really bad. You wanted to do this one?

Brian Rowley:

No. So the collaboration actually taps into Harry Potter's nostalgia and gives fans sort of a way to bring a piece of the fictional world into sort of their everyday lives. I think it did pretty well in terms of its performance.

Laura Smith:

Well, was was was all... And this is all through this is all through research because I don't... Again, not a Harry Potter person. Yeah. And you don't cook,

Brian Rowley:

so we know that. Do.

Laura Smith:

I haven't I haven't cooked out of it. The hook here was from what I what I've read was that it's... It was Harry Potter's twentieth... Twenty fifth anniversary. So, like, there was a moment in time.

Laura Smith:

And so, obviously, like, having a collaboration to help with that kind of time, you know, celebration or whatever, it sounded like they launched with that one. And then they did expand the line, though. So that to me is successful because they're like, okay. This is actually working, and we have enough probably Harry Potter fans and people who are interested in trying different flavors of things. So I think that it...

Laura Smith:

You know, while I never heard of it as it came out last year, I think it last winter, it seems like it it did have like a lot of legs to kind of carry on into the future.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah. I mean, I think if you're sort of looking at what drives success, you know, was there sort of a strategic brand fit associated with it? I would say probably. Potential for new audiences? Maybe.

Brian Rowley:

Product differentiation? I'm not sure. Guess maybe. So I think it'd be interesting to see.

Laura Smith:

Well, those flavors would never be in anyone else's their competitors. Right. Know, there is that product differentiation for if there is a need for those specific flavors.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah. So I I don't think you're gonna see collaborations going away. In fact, I think we're probably gonna see more and more of them sort of enter the space because I think it's a unique way to try to get new audiences. And I think whether it's, that long term approach to it, or whether it's just a quick something that might be culturally relevant. I think it's worth a shot, I guess.

Brian Rowley:

I don't think brands have anything to necessarily lose.

Laura Smith:

I would agree. I think that they're not going away. They seem to be on trend right now. There are a lot of brands out more open to it, I think. In the past, I don't think that would have been...

Laura Smith:

It's probably easier as a sell in. Obviously, you have to be creative with how they kind of think about not only just... I mean, some of these things are making products. Right? Or they're doing things bigger than just having shared, like, here's a thing for our coffee and a sweater.

Laura Smith:

They're having to make things unique. So I I feel like it it involves much more than just the marketing team. Right? That's got you going into product or whatever other departments that are creating these these things. And I do think it is very much tied to cultural relevance.

Laura Smith:

I think that's where it's at right now, is that where people are trying to be culturally relevant and figure out ways to do that and maybe to show up in a... Front of an audience that they just haven't had a lot of luck showing up in front of. So, yeah, I think it's... It'll keep coming. I think some of them are weird, some of them make sense.

Laura Smith:

I think we'll continue to see that. And and I think a lot people have perspective on it. So I think a good topic for us to bring to our audience.

Brian Rowley:

Yeah. I I would agree. And and I do I do applaud the brands that actually are some of the older brands that are trying to approach these new audiences in different ways. So for those of you listening, we appreciate it. And most importantly, if you like what you heard today, be sure and follow us.