World Cement Podcast

On this episode of the World Cement Podcast, Senior Editor David Bizley is joined by Dr Ed Cavanagh of Breedon Group. Picking up on themes raised in the previous episode of the World Cement Podcast (featuring Martin Casey of the MPA), David & Ed explore the challenges facing British cement producers and consider what success will look like for Breedon Group’s Back British Cement campaign.

Topics covered in this episode include:
  • Energy Prices
  • The UK’s imminently arriving CBAM
  • The Back British Cement campaign
  • And more!
[Note: This episode was recorded in October, so some statements regarding policy, etc., may no longer be 100% accurate.]
 
If you enjoyed this episode of the World Cement Podcast then please make sure to leave a like, review the episode and subscribe if you haven’t already done so! 

Creators and Guests

Host
David Bizley
As well as the day-to-day editing of content and working with article authors and advertisers, he is actively involved in the commissioning of material for both the magazine and its expanding online presence.
DC
Guest
Dr Ed Cavanagh
Works Manager at Breedon's Hope site - Breedon Group

What is World Cement Podcast?

The World Cement podcast: a podcast series for professionals in the cement industry.

David Bizley:

Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the World Cement Podcast with me, your host, David Bizley, senior editor of World Cement. Regular listeners will recall that we recently spoke with the NPA's Martin Casey to explore the various challenges and opportunities facing the British cement industry. Following on that theme, today's guest is doctor Ed Cavanagh of the British Cement producer, Breeden Group. And in this episode, we'll be exploring energy prices, imports, CBAM, the Back British Cement campaign, and more, all from a producer's perspective. I just wanted to take a moment to remind you to register for World Cement.

David Bizley:

It's free of charge and gives you access to the latest issues of World Cement, both in print and online. Every issue comes packed full of regional analysis, technical articles, project case studies, and the latest industry news. Simply head over to worldcement.com, click the Magazine tab, and register today. It's as simple as that. Happy reading!

David Bizley:

Ed, welcome to the World Cement Podcast. Delighted to have you with us. Good morning, and welcome. Thank you. So from the perspective of a British cement producer, how are things in the British cement industry these days?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Yeah, challenging is the word I think I'd use if I was being really polite. There's a real sense of jeopardy in our sector. I think we all know, certainly in The UK, know that cement demand has been declining year on year for some years now, and we're actually at the lowest production rate since 1950 now. It goes beyond my lifetime, that I only have a reference point if you like it, but that's twenty years in the sector, and I can certainly refer to that period and say it feels dark. On the slightly more positive side, I think it's created a greater sense of togetherness in terms of the dwindling heavy industry.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

We're very conscious that we sit in that sector, and I think across all of the operational sites, regardless of your organization, I think people do feel like there's an element of being in this together, if you like. At the same time, we're an island nation, as we know, and that's in a world that's just getting smaller in terms of communications and technology, so I think it feels even more apparent and we feel even more exposed than we probably have done historically. And then of course we've got a backdrop of increased complexity with embodied carbon, need to reduce that, importation, which no doubt we'll discuss at some stage, the increased costs, more complex operations, greater legislative requirement. So more and more demands placed on a constrained sector, I would say, and, yeah, so there's some other challenges.

David Bizley:

Yeah. And so spurred on by those challenges facing British Cement producers, you guys at Breeden launched the Back British Cement campaign. First of all, tell us in a bit more detail about those challenges and what made you decide that now was the right time to become more vocal about the future of domestic cement production.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Yeah, I think starting at that endpoint really, I think we could just really feel that growing sense of urgency to communicate, it was becoming palpable. I think we'd seen what was happening with the steel sector and not just the relative collapse of steel in The UK, but the way they were more effectively communicating. I think in our sector we've got a bit of a history of just getting on with things, rolling our sleeves up, keeping our heads down, and just cracking on and trying to get through. But I think it was feeling far more challenging than that. The burning platform we had was just getting hotter all the time and dwindling as a consequence, so we had that.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

And then I think also the CBAM timing, the carbon border adjustment mechanism, with that coming in the EU and then obviously The UK being slightly behind again timing wise, together with that decline, just felt like we needed to speak out, and I think as we were speaking out, we were getting more of a sense of awareness that people didn't understand and weren't educated to our plight, if you like. So whether that be government, whether that be local communities, whether that be even some of our customers, because a lot of people look inwardly, don't they, including ourselves, and you don't necessarily realize the greater impact. So we thought it was really important for us to communicate outwardly and help educate, I mean, in the nicest possible way, people that just didn't understand the plight and didn't want to get to a stage where everything collapses, but nobody knew that was apparent. And I think it really is that stark at this moment in time. So that was what really spurred us on,

David Bizley:

and that's why the timing was so important to us, I would say. Diving into some of those challenges in a bit more detail, let's start with the old favorite, energy prices. When you're sitting in a boardroom making decisions about production, investment, future projects, how significant a factor have those high energy costs become? Barry is the one word answer to that, Barry. Yeah.

David Bizley:

A slightly longer answer, of course.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Yeah. We obviously are really have an immediate impact because we're large heat and electrical power consumers, as everybody will know and understand, and also of course we're shipping large volumes of materials constantly, whether that be in or out of locations. So we're exposed to that immediate impact. And then of course there's the broader market impact. We've got the fertilizer industry supplying ammonia for consumption for SMTR systems for production.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

We've got commodity chemicals through additive supply markets for grinding aids and quality improvers, even equipment supply for casting steelwork, electrical components and the complexities of that market, even the refractory materials. The energy costs are basically affecting virtually every part of our operations. Aside from the really obvious fact that we consume lots of fuel and we turn around lots of big equipment, so we've got that direct impact, there are also these less direct impacts that clearly anybody that operates in our sector understands and is familiar with, but often people outside our sector again don't fully understand and appreciate that. So these are the topics that are constantly in discussion in the boardroom, as you say. They're front and center for us is how we look to further control those costs without crippling our operations, because it's really important that we also maintain high levels of performance, that we have good reliability, that we're able to serve our customer base.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

So doing all of that without disrupting is really important to us, and of course we also want to source responsibly. I spoke about materials for instance, responsible supply chain management is dear to our heart and really important, so we have to ensure that we don't compromise there at the same time as trying to reduce our cost base.

David Bizley:

And sticking with energy prices for the time being, what would you like to see government do about these? I know the NPA have been calling for Cement to be included again in the energy intensive industries compensation scheme, for example. Assuming you're in favor of that, is there anything else you'd like to be...

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

No. No. You're absolutely right. We are in favor, and again, we've... For the energy intensive compensation scheme we've been actively involved as the NPA have in any of the consultation processes.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

It was unfortunate we were omitted from the last round, we continue to lobby hard, press hard for that, we feel like that is important to us. So yes, really clear we're on that pathway and we want that. We are at the same time grateful for any established schemes that we do get benefit from historically, so we understand that government do listen. But of course it's slightly wider than that. I think UK government also could do is support in the wider sector when it comes to energy supply, so it's not the electrical power and reducing cost on supply of electrical power.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

In the same period that we've been speaking about, referring to in recent years, we've also lost the only UK coal mine that supplied fossil fuel to our sector, and I just don't think people are fully aware, the immediate impact feels as if that's a good thing because we're no longer mining coal in The UK, to delay Bansham, but of course to anybody that operates a site like Hope or any of the other biggest amount producers that are reliant to some degree on fossil fuel, we immediately have to sell elsewhere globally, and of course there are additional transport CO2 costs associated with that. So I'd like governments to be fully appreciative of that much bigger picture. So yes, we feel like they are listening with electrical power, and we're making some inroads with some of the compensation schemes, and we'd like to see a bit more there, of course, but it's slightly wider than that, and I just don't think all of the picture is fully appreciated when some of the decisions are made across our nation, and that's part of that education process, I would say.

David Bizley:

Okay. Excellent. Now another central concern behind the the campaign you've been running is that the growing share of imported cement, which I think now accounts for just over 30% of The UK market, some of which obviously comes from areas with less stringent carbon controls. From Breeden's perspective, again, as a UK producer, how does that impact the economics of keeping your plants competitive, to find investment in continuing to decarbonize domestic production in that kind

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

of environment? Yeah. So what we're really champion is to look for as level a playing field as we can achieve. So inevitably that means searching for any measures where we can reduce our cost base. So we've already spoken about electricity for instance.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

We still continue to work really hard though on addressing any operational efficiency improvements. Inevitably, our operations over the years have already focused on taking the low hanging fruit and established operations such as our sites at Hope. Operating for some time has taken much of the quick wins, if you like, so we're always looking for those smaller opportunities or even advances in new technology that allow us to make some step changes that just weren't evident historically. So they're the kind of things we're always looking for, and of course everyone's speaking about AI nowadays, artificial intelligence, so anything that's even in that broader sphere could now be applicable that clearly even twelve months ago wasn't necessarily a viable option for science such as ours. Now that technology advances at such a pace, it can become applicable, whereas historically it wasn't.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

So they're the kind of spaces we look for, of course at a site like Hope in Peak District National Park, we have to be cognizant of its position and minimizing impact, whether that be visual or wider environmental, so often what we're looking for is advances that aren't detrimental to that environment at the same time, which puts us in a slightly difficult space if you

David Bizley:

like compared to

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

lots of other sites and decarbonization, the big step change there for us will clearly be carbon capture and storage if we're able to advance at the rate we would like to, the pace we'd like to with the Peak Cluster project where we're collaborating with some of our competitors, which again is not a usual step to collaborate with the competitors, especially when you're majors, and working closely on this project with Tarmac and Holzim in particular in the cement sector and then of course with lime, we've got Sigma Art, Bookstent and lime, all working together on this single project which can decarbonize up to 40% of The UK cement and lime, it's a radical step, quite a different step, capturing around 3,000,000 tonnes a year of CO2 is our target. So we'd like to see that we then have a similar revenue support model from government that was offered to, and has been taken by the Heidelberg Materials Plant at Paidwood. That looks like a good model from what we can see. We'd also like some development expenditure support from government, which is again something we're in constant dialogue over. There are things we'd like to see, and it would also be ideal if I could have one more ask if you like.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

B, there was a nice scheme with the Industrial Energy Transformation Fund, the IETF, that offered an opportunity for us to explore technologies that were maybe earlier in their development phase. And if we're truly to advance in our sector at the pace we need to, we need support mechanisms such as that that allow us to advance with first of a kind or embryonic technologies and see them through a development stage and then see them applied to our whole sector. It's important that we do this together, it can't just be individual organizations. I think technologies have to be applied sector wide. So that's some of the things we'd like to see.

David Bizley:

Now you touched on this a little bit earlier, but The UK is due to begin enforcing its own carbon border adjustment mechanism or C band from early next year. Now you've called for it to be strengthened ahead of its introduction. What exactly are you looking for?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

And what are the risks if that mechanism isn't robust enough from day one? What we tend to say is we'd like it to be watertight. By that, what we really mean is no loopholes and strict enforcement. So that's what that distills down to. The difficulty for us at the moment is a lack of visibility over default values and the detailed calculation methodology, and I think that puts us in that difficult place mentally where we can see the clock ticking, we know the implementation date is January 1 and that keeps being repeated, but without being able to see that detail, it's very hard for us to gauge the true impact and set our business up accordingly.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

And there is of course a growing fear that as a consequence it might not be as robust as we need it to be. So it's this growing level of anxiety if you like around not knowing the full detail that is largely calling for us to, is asking us to move in that direction of wanting the watertight C band. We can't almost go drill down much deeper than that without knowing the true detail. We're trying to give space to civil servants to come up with the model and have an opportunity to have listened to us and implemented some of our ass, so we are trying to give that space, but we're really conscious now, we're less than one hundred days away from implementation and don't have the full detail.

David Bizley:

Yes, it's approaching rapidly, isn't it, Neil?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Yes, exactly. And then we're aware that, for instance, in the EU, Cement Europe have been doing some good work around specific KPIs for monitoring. Again, we're looking at something similar, we can measure relative success in terms of carbon leakage, investment leakage, whether that comparative investment is occurring within or outside the relevant boundaries and a comparison of carbon intensity. They're the type of things we'll need to look at as we move into the implementation phase, really to gauge whether it's been successful or otherwise.

David Bizley:

Okay. And speaking of the the EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism, you've also highlighted the importance of making sure that The UK's version is aligned with the EU's version. And how important is that relationship for a company like Breeden, and what problems could arise if the two systems start pulling in different directions?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

I think it is important. I think slightly wider than just Breeden. I think firstly, there could be an advantage, of course, to the EU moving twelve months ahead of The UK with CBOM, and that does offer a learning period. It's a shame in a way that they weren't implemented at the same time but if they have to be implemented as they have it with the gap in between, then we make use of that that time. It'd be great if there have been some learnings that have been taken by by government.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

If the two schemes drift apart, which is something you referred to, I think it does lead us to a greater risk of non compliance, possibly due to legitimate confusion. If other bodies are working under different schemes with different rules and different approaches, that can lead to a level of confusion that could cause non compliance, so that's definitely a risk. Over time, of course, there could be a divergence in terms of inclusion of indirect emissions as well. At the moment there could be different time scales for that inclusion of indirect emissions, that's what we could anticipate and we need to anticipate that with, again, with government to be able to understand what the potential risks and I suppose opportunities, but largely risk could be from that level of divergence. Okay.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Thank you. Now the Back British Cement campaign has also highlighted the issue of procurement. Do you

David Bizley:

think customers currently place enough value on where and how their cement is manufactured? And following on from that, is there enough understanding in government of the importance of cement as a foundational industry?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

Yeah, think all customers are different. Some definitely do appear to place greater value on the origin of material and other aspects of the material performance, whereas others are more focused on price alone, in this difficult space, we respect that there will be customers that are very price driven. So there is that element, and then of course not all customers are exposed to the wider sector and they don't necessarily have that full appreciation of the vulnerability and ultimately the lack of national resilience if we continue to go down this pathway if sites were closed for instance. So I think we do encourage that by British approach to again, and that's not just our own business, to be able to ensure that we have this resilient supply network within The UK. We've interacted with a lot of MPs so far during the Back British Cement campaign, that's directly through site visits and then also some polling that we carried out.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

I think what's obvious is the majority of MPs don't have a full understanding of what we do, how we do it, how we're impacted, how important we are as a foundation industry. So again a big part of those conversations has been bringing people up to speed, getting people to the same baseline of understanding has been very important. I would say there's been a great level of reception to that, it's been very positive in terms interaction and people openly admitting that they don't know but would like to know more, which is Okay, that sounds a good like start a Exactly, exactly. But that national resilience is absolutely critical, I've referred to it already. Think we're all aware the the geopolitical instability that we see in the news every single day, and some people globally will be far closer to the action there as it were.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

But again, we're highlighting that real risk. Okay. So we've spoken a lot about the challenges facing British cement production. So let's turn towards something a

David Bizley:

bit more optimistic. Where do you see the greatest potential for Breeden and the wider UK cement sector over the next decade, for example? Does it lie in new greener products, carbon capture, greater circularity, or something else entirely?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

I think the timing's really interesting. Our conversation in the Labour Party conference was just Yes. Around this week in in The UK, and there was a lot of talk around the specific topics such as re industrialization, housing market growth, but actually attaining the levels that have been discussed for some years but never never reached, and the wider support for net zero. So I think those those three areas we've heard a lot about earlier on this week with some positivity, which is great because that sounds like we're moving in the similar direction, that it'd be good for our sector, and again maybe highlights that this government is listening for breeding in the wider sector. We'd also see that support, for instance, the carbon capture and storage project we referred to earlier, seeing that support model continued, seeing clarity around that, and that gives us confidence to continue and to invest.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

And also I think it'd be great to see over that period our current producers in GB shift into a greener product portfolio, bringing in new technology alternatives, a true alternative to Portland cement hasn't been realized at scale yet, I think that would bring a level of healthy competition. So seeing a really competitive market in terms of product portfolio and that shift to lower embodied carbon can only be a good thing, I would say.

David Bizley:

Again, it's interesting timing because you mentioned the idea of house building and construction. One of the major pledges of the current government is to kick start house building in The UK. I think all of us have been waiting with bated breath for that to actually start in a real way at some point. But if demand does begin to recover strongly, how well positioned is The UK's domestic cement industry to respond

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

to that? Today, we're really well positioned, really well positioned. However, the concern would be if that doesn't come quickly enough and then any sites, I'm talking just around The UK production facilities as opposed to breeding specifically, not all of the sites, operational sites could be sustained by the current requirements. So if that recovery doesn't come quickly enough then I think inevitably we'll see mothballing of sites and to resurrect a mothballed site is not a simple task and I think that's the concern again is people outside their sector don't necessarily understand how challenging it can be to, you can't just press pause, you can't just press and then you lose, you could lose your skilled workforce along the way for instance, it's not just about can the equipment restart, that loss of a skilled workforce in this heavy industry manufacturing sector that isn't well supported more widely would be a real risk. So yeah, positive answer in that if we see a response quickly to the housing market and to that pull through, we can respond, otherwise it could be a different story.

David Bizley:

Okay, And finally, if we're having this conversation again in five years time and Back British Cement has been successful, what would have changed? And what would a healthier and more competitive UK cement industry actually look like?

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

I think we'd see a real bounce back. We'd see that position where all manufacturing sites are running at full capacity, which is I'll tell you it's a happy place to be. People on manufacturing sites like that, they like that pull through, they like to be busy, they like to be challenged, so I think it feels like a happy place because everybody is gainfully employed. So we'd see a nation that was booming in terms of national infrastructure growth, we've heard a lot about defense, for instance, and defense spending, so that would be stronger. We'd see greater use of renewable energy and see road upgrades.

Dr Ed Cavanagh:

If it was slightly further in the future, we'd be storing CO2 not just for our nation but possibly other nations. I'm looking outside our immediate sector, but this is something we've clearly become exposed to is the opportunity for CO2 storage in UK waters through depleted gas fields for instance. So we'd see a booming nation in relation directly to our sector but also indirectly I would say and ultimately would feel like a happier place and then it'd be great icing on the cake if you like if part of that solution was a much wider range and much wider portfolio of products that were offering lower embodied c o two.

David Bizley:

Thank you, Ed. I think that's all we have time for this episode of the World Cement Podcast. Thank you for guiding us through the challenges and opportunities facing the British Cement sector. Thank you. It's a pleasure.

David Bizley:

I hope you enjoyed this episode of the World Cement Podcast. If you did, please rate the episode, leave a review, and subscribe if you haven't already done so. And while you're doing all of that, why not check out some of our other episodes from our ever growing back catalog as well. That's all from me. Goodbye for now.

David Bizley:

I just wanted to take a moment to remind you to register for World Cement. It's free of charge and gives you access to the latest issues of World Cement, both in print and online. Every issue comes packed full of regional analysis, technical articles, project case studies, and the latest industry news. Simply head over to worldcement.com, click the Magazine tab, and register today. It's as simple as that.

David Bizley:

Happy reading!