Scalability School

This episode is a practical walk-through of forecasting for e-commerce growth, specifically how media buyers and operators should think about revenue targets, paid spend, CAC/ROAS degradation, contribution margin, fixed costs, and cash flow without building a fantasy plan that assumes everything stays perfectly flat.

Abir (outsourced CMO/operator for multiple e-comm brands) and owner of UpCounting.com breaks down a simple-but-real framework: start with the story in the historical data to build a forecast that's honest about constraints (marketing efficiency, supply/inventory, staffing, cash conversion cycle). Then, turn the forecast into an ongoing operating rhythm where you review monthly performance vs plan, diagnose why you landed where you did, and update assumptions instead of "hoping next month works."

A big theme: most brands hit a "terminal velocity" with their current offer/creative/channel mix. From there you either (1) increase the value you get from customers (LTV/retention, bundles, new products, adjacent audiences) or (2) improve business efficiency so you can reinvest profit to raise your ad spend ceiling—aka the "two machines" model: ads machine + ops/profit machine. Key Takeaways:

  • Using more than just "vibes" to justify perfomance when CAC stays flat while spend goes up.

  • How to forecast using your actual "terminal velocity" instead of your dream scenario.

  • The difference of forecasting from a revenue goal → spend/CAC → contribution margin, Vs. just backfilling numbers to match a target.

  • Knowing where your business actually breaks first (marketing efficiency, inventory, cash conversion cycle, headcount, or fixed costs)?

  • The fastest way to spot whether growth is coming from new customers vs returning customers and why this changes the whole model.

  • How to properly plan for CAC degradation when you begin to SCALE.

  • Why tracking this one metric can confirm if extra spend is actively hurting your brand.

  • Moving away from just looking at ROAS and moving on to a monthly system for forecast vs actual + "why did this happen?"

  • How to know you're investing cash in the right lever and helping raise your ceiling faster.

  • How to run the numbers to insure you're holding your internal team to an ROI standard and not just giving the team a free pass.

  • OpEx bloat (tools, subscriptions, extra layers of people) and how it is quietly eating your ability to reinvest in growth.

To connect with Abir, you can follow her on x at https://x.com/Abir_CFOofEcom or at https://go.upcounting.com/ To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

But brands that have very high fixed

expenses, especially ones that like do

their own manufacturing

and stuff like that, like those are the

ones where it's like

you need to make sure that

your worst case can cover

all of your fixed expenses.

So that's not going to

destroy your business.

The second big chunk is the relationship

between new customer

revenue and advertising spend.

So being able to kind of see, okay, what

was spent on different channels?

How much was that kind

of increasing over time?

What sort of caks were you able to see?

What sort of volatility

did you see in your cak?

How much of a degradation did

you see in your cak over time?

Whether or not the projections you have

for increased spend and

a certain amount of cak

degradation, like are you making the

investments on the creative side?

Most business owners do not spend enough

time scrutinizing the

ROI on full-time hires.

I think when it comes to personnel, for

some reason, they

just fly under the radar.

And so far as like what sort of value

they're driving and what they're

contributing to the business,

where if I were to go to them and be

like, okay, what did

this person do last month?

Like, well, they did

XYZ. I'm like, okay, cool.

That cost you in

salary, let's say $8,000.

If somebody came to you with an RFP and

said, I will do these things for $8,000,

would you assign that contract?

Absolutely not.

And now let's take a listen to the

Scalability School podcast.

Welcome to another episode of the

Scalability School podcast.

Your best friend for running your

e-commerce business the

best way that you possibly can.

Glad to have you today. Special guest,

Abir, who is one of the

financial gurus really that

we have in the Fox Hill Founders

membership, somebody that we

all look to, to think about

planning and forecasting and all of that

as it relates to running a business.

So Abir, welcome. Glad to have you.

Thanks so much. I

appreciate you guys inviting me.

Are you guaranteeing everybody's going to

have a 50% increase in ROAS and

contribution margin this year

by your presence on the podcast?

If they don't, I'm

willing to give up my CPA title.

Perfect. Perfect.

Yeah. So Abir, I don't, if you don't

know a beer, I'll just give like a quick

bit of background on my own.

Abir's organization is like an

outsourced CMO for a bunch of different

e-commerce businesses.

It's also done presentations in the Fox

Hill community about running your agency

better and thinking about

just how to think about, you know, how

you're making money and you're thinking

about expenses and everything else.

Brad was trying to figure out how to do

forecasting and was digging around

YouTube and found a beer's old

YouTube's about running things. And so

Brad, do you want to give

your background on a beer

in case people don't know who he is?

Yeah, I know we've chatted a few times

just like through the Fox Hill group and

that's where we met.

And it's one of my favorite things about

the group, not to make

this a pitch for the group,

but you get to meet people who have

similar and differing opinions.

But we've interacted over shared and

differing spreadsheets primarily.

So yeah, now I've just kind of seen the

work that you do and the resources you

put together for the folks in the group

and just always admire and take

inspiration from those. So yeah.

I appreciate it. I know you do some great

work on the margin side

in the models as well.

So a big kind of your work too.

Appreciate that. Appreciate that.

The goal of today's episode is to walk

through, you know, look,

you're looking at 2025,

you're looking at what happened in the

previous year, and then

you're looking into a new year.

Just right out of the gates, a beer like,

what do you, do you start reviewing the

prior year before planning the next one?

A hundred percent. The historical is

always the best place

to start because it's,

forecasting is a very challenging

exercise because it

obviously requires a lot of

dreaming and assumptions and

imagination and what have you.

And as much as possible, you want to be

able to ground it in

some amount of reality.

And the arguably most honest data that

you could work with is

what has happened in the past.

Not to say that that's necessarily a

perfect reflection of how

the future is going to go,

but nevertheless, it is something that

can be a very strong starting point.

So usually the whole forecasting game is

kind of broken into, to

simplify it like the three pieces.

So one is that you kind of pull up the

historical data, make sure that you're

able to analyze it in a

way that allows you to,

as much as possible, understand a story

of how the business has been doing.

And it gives you a lot of indications,

not only as to what sort

of trends you're seeing,

but also kind of like fundamentally what

the company is capable of,

like what their market looks like, how

their product stacks up against things,

like what they've

actually been able to accomplish.

The second piece of it is then having

that conversation with the brand in,

to one extent, to be able to kind of

understand a little bit more

depth beyond just what you're

going to see from the financial side.

So like, what are the

things that you tried?

Why do these things work or not work?

What sort of challenges do you have that

may not necessarily be

reflected purely in the

financial data?

And then also then kind of speaking

towards what the plans are,

like what do they want

to be able to accomplish?

You know, what the goals are to some

degree, but also like,

what are the things that they think

they'll be able to do or

what sort of tactical plans

that they have in place that will be able

to kind of allow them to see improvements

over the historical data?

Then that's obviously tempered by some

amount of conservatism

and judgment on my part,

because some people are especially

ambitious with the plans that they have.

And then it's a question of being able

to, okay, now say, let's take

that story and then build it

out as to an extent extrapolation of the

historical data so that there

is at least a little bit of a

consistent story between kind of the last

12 months and the next 12

months to be able to kind

of show how that can, you know,

realistically be the same company, you

know, run by the same people

and with the same product in the same

market, and then see how what

would have to actually happen

fundamentally to be able to kind of

achieve those goals to be

able to say if it's realistic.

So if you say you want to be able to, I

don't know, increase

revenue by 150%, then at the very

least, we can say, okay, well,

historically, this is what the profile of

revenues look like in terms

of new customers, returning customers,

the ad spend that you had

in the CAC that you had.

So mathematically, what would those

numbers have to look like? And what

configuration of numbers

would actually let you hit that 150%

revenue growth? And, you

know, if your CAC would have to

go down by 50%, but you'd have to double

an ad spend for that to

be hittable, then we say,

okay, it's probably not a realistic goal.

So let's go back to the drawing board.

Yeah, can I can I lay out like a very

specific example of how

somebody could do this? And you

tell me like, that makes sense. But I

would change it and do

it differently this way,

just to give people an idea. Sweet. So

the way that I the way that

is a very like light version

of looking at last year could be, let's

start at the top, like let's look at

revenue and ad spend

trend by month. And let's just export

those for like the last

three years and put them side by

side. The way that we do it is like a

simple version is like you

can just wait the last three

years and say, cool, if if the last three

years are similar to what

we can expect this year,

now you can understand where revenue

occurs throughout the

course of the year on a monthly

basis. So before you think about 2026,

and whatever, it's like,

okay, I can see how revenue

flowed throughout the course of the year

seasonally. And I can see how

spend kind of went along with

that. And then you start to look at those

those peaks and valleys.

And to your point, what you're

saying is you start to plot, well, okay,

what are we doing this month? What are

you doing this month?

Where could you know, maybe we have some

ideas as we're doing this is

like start to plot this out

and literally see, okay, this is the this

is the quantitative power to the

marketing calendar that

becomes the qualitative stuff that goes

along with it. So we just

kind of export look at the last

and call it you know, you can do two,

three years, see when those

revenue peaks and valleys occur,

and then start to like map it out side by

side. Is that was that

similar to what how you do that?

Yeah, I like that approach. Because

essentially, you're

incorporating not only the month over

month aspect of it, but the year over

year aspect. So you have the seasonality

component. And so far

as like how does revenue peaks and

valleys occur during the year, but then

also making sure that

the trend from a year to year to year

basis makes sense. So if you're one to

two to three, you only

grew by 15% each year, and now you're

predicting 80%. It's like, cool, maybe,

but you've got to give

me some sort of convincing story as to

why that might be possible.

So you're incorporating both

sides. The only other thing that I would

probably add to that, which

is, to some degree already

factored in what you're describing is

that for high retention

brands, I think the breakdown

between the returning customer and the

new customer revenue

is extremely important,

because the way that those cohorts kind

of affect what sort of

growth you can get from a

compounding basis, like that can be one

of those things where it's a very

different profile of how

that analysis is done for like a higher

retention brand versus

kind of a mostly first order

profitable brand. Right? Because you

might see the concept

applies. Because the new customers

might flow with seasonality. But if your

retention has been crazy,

like that might smooth it out.

And it's kind of misleading and

confusing. Right? Yeah. And

there's a compounding effect,

because you could grow from like, say 15%

to 25% to 35% to 50% 60%.

That can happen if you have,

you know, really good retention, and

you're able to kind of

make that that play work,

especially for subscription brands, like

it's a much more

different approach. So that aspect

does it's almost like having two

different versions of how

you approach forecasting. It's

like if you're below a certain amount of

returning customer

revenue, and if you're above, and

especially if you're on a subscription

heavy brand. Yeah. And

would you say that doing that

kind of like top level, like starting

with revenue, maybe

splitting it by new and returning

customer looking at ad spend? Is that

enough depth for like

most brands, if they've never

done this before, is like a starting

point, just like, hey, like

zooming out and looking at this

is going to get you a long way. Or when

do you start to layer in

like, okay, I want now I want

to pull up meta and see how that

fluctuated throughout the

year, I want to pull up Google

and see how that fluctuated throughout

the year, I want to look at

my creative trends and see how

that fluctuated throughout throughout the

year. What is what is like,

how do you how do you take it

and add depth to it? I mean, I think if a

brand isn't doing

anything, then certainly kind of

starting with the revenue side of it is

the easiest place to go.

I think if they have a lot

of ambitious growth plans and kind of

maybe going to a little bit

more of the creative or the

channel level side of things can help a

lot. But then you'll also

you get into a little bit of

the whole issue around kind of

attribution, incrementality

and all that stuff. And it comes

down to the sophistication of the person

analyzing the data. I think

doing this split on a channel

by channel basis and kind of attributing

things to different things

like if you're mostly meta

Google, like I think maybe that breakdown

is maybe somewhat worth

it because Google again,

depending on the product and whether

you're going heavily branded or non

branded, whatever the case

might be, then like that can often be a

little bit more stable to

some degree. So I think where the

analysis will probably get you the most

bang for your buck for people

who have ambitious growth is

when they're looking at their meta spend

and kind of whatever they

can make any assumptions they

want about their CAC and how much that

degradation they're going to

see as they increase spend.

I think the key part that a lot of people

neglect is their

investment on the creative side

because fundamentally for you to be able

to double your spend and

only see maybe say a 20%

increase in CAC, you probably are

investing a lot more in creative. That

doesn't happen unless you're

giving a very substantial investment to

that side. And I think that's

a part that people oftentimes

just gloss over. Yeah, I think it's

easier with people that are

marketers that became brand

owners versus people that are brand

owners that are trying to

figure out how to do marketing.

Right. So let's say that you're starting

to build a forecast for the

next year. You're thinking

about, so what are you taking from there

to inform, to make a great

forecast? Yeah, it's a good

question. So I'm probably tackling them

maybe like three pieces.

So the first one would be

kind of what we discussed with Brad, the

breakdown of kind of what

your overall revenue performance

looks like. So especially if you want to

be able to forecast

effectively and you do have good

retention, then like being able to pull

all the cohort data to be able to

understand like how does

how do newly acquired customers perform?

Like that's one very big aspect of it.

The second big chunk is the relationship

between new customer revenue and

advertising spend. So

being able to kind of see, okay, what was

spent on different

channels? How much was that kind of

increasing over time? What sort of CACs

were you able to see? What sort of

volatility did you see

in your CAC? How much of a degradation

did you see in your CAC

over time? And whether or not

the projections you have for increased

spending, a certain amount of CAC

degradation, like are you making the

investments on the creative side? And

then the third piece is

everything essentially operational. So

that covers a lot, but I just kind of

lump it all together

because philosophically you're kind of

approaching it the same

way, but it's a question of,

okay, for a given level of activity, what

are you seeing in terms of

kind of agency expenses for

personnel? What do you need to invest in

development cost or

product expansion or product

research or launches or whatever? And

then also that has to tie

into everything from a cashflow

and inventory perspective too. That's the

very big chunk on the

balance sheet because

you can kind of predict whatever sort of

growth that you want, but

that has to be fundable.

So depending on the cash resources that

you have available, can you

actually fund that sort of

growth? Can you purchase the inventory at

the rate that you need to be able to

scale up into it? So

that part is the... That's difficult from

a mathematical

perspective, but it is very

logical. If you can get the first two

things right, then

everything else technically just

flows mathematically from that, but

people still struggle with

it because it's hard math.

But the first two or the second one in

particular is the especially

difficult one because that's

the one where you're kind of just

guessing and it's essentially

impossible to know for sure.

Yeah. So let's say there's two scenarios.

It's either what...

Particularly in your case,

it's like you're saying, "Okay, we've

looked at last year client.

What would you want to do in

2026?" And you either get, "Okay, that's

realistic," or "It's probably not

realistic." And I've been

telling our team lately, it's like we're

not really in the camp of

it's not possible. We're

just like, "Likely to happen, unlikely to

happen. What needs to

happen in order to make it more

likely to happen?" But those are the two

scenarios. Let's assume that

they've been growing 20% year

over the year, the last couple of years,

and they want to push for

40%. When they give you the 40%

number, are you asking for, "Hey, what's

your profit goal?" Or are

you breaking it down into

revenue and spend? What is the specific

metric that you're starting

with? Are you going bottoms

up, top down? How do you usually do that?

It usually starts with a

little bit of a conversation

as to what the brand has insofar as their

aspirations for the company and what they

have available in terms of funding. For

example, if their aspiration is like,

"Oh, I want to be able

to build a cash flowing business or a

lifestyle brand," whatever

it is, that's going to be one

approach versus like, "No, I'm

specifically trying to target

an exit in X amount of years."

That inevitably, to some degree, just

lays out what the sorts of

goals are and whether or not

what they're saying for this particular

year is in line with what would be

necessary several years from now to be

able to accomplish that overarching goal.

The second piece of it is like, "Okay,

with the resources

that you have available,

is that possible?" If you're

bootstrapped, then that's a very

different game versus like if you

plan on raising funds or if you're going

to be taking on a lot of

debt or whatever the case might

be. Beyond that, I agree with what you

laid out where it's not

about saying that anything they

bring to the table is not possible. It's

about saying, "This is

what would need to happen for

that to work." Anything is kind of

possible. Something is just very

difficult, but you'd have

to be realistic about it. If somebody

says, "Well, I want to be able to triple

my ad spend, but also

like I'm not going to invest in creative

or improve my agencies

and I've never been able to

do that in the past," it's like, "Yeah,

sure, fine." Maybe if you find like a

spectacular marketer that

is able to completely change the

messaging and branding and

everything than possible, but

realistically, there's going to be

certain amounts of

investments necessary in the marketing

machine to be able to help it increase

because it's not just about ad spend,

that's just the fuel.

The machine itself has to be capable of

processing a certain amount of spend

effectively. If not,

you have to upgrade the machine. So

that's the thing that people... It can

often be a little bit

of a hard pill to swallow for some

brands. Yeah,

definitely. So let's use Andrew's

hat shop scenario here. We've got...

Andrew's been slinging hats.

He did $2 million in profit

last year and he wants to do $3 million

in profit this next

year. How are you building...

What's a simple version of... And I know

it might be hard to fully

visualize this if we don't have

a spreadsheet in front of us of actually

going through this, but I

want people to be able to

walk away saying, "Okay, I know I need

this, this, and this, and I can work my

way back to a goal."

What kind of steps did you take from

there? I usually go top

down. So it starts from the

revenue perspective. So these are the

sorts of revenue growths

that I would have to hit.

Obviously, the models are dynamic. So you

start with a rough guess

and you're like, "Well,

that only got me to $2.4 million. So let

me tweak my assumptions." But

essentially, that's the idea.

You come at it from the revenue

perspective and say, "Okay, well, this is

the sort of revenue that

I need to be able to hit. For that, I

need to be able to... This amount of

spend at this sort of

CAC that will give me this sort of

contribution margin." And then from a

fixed expense perspective,

you kind of hope that you're able to keep

it stable, but

realistically, you're going to have

to increase it to some degree. So you

say, "Okay, well, I need to

add a little bit more personnel

on this side. I need to be able to do X,

Y, Z." And then again, you

also come back to the cashflow

side to say, "Okay, this is the P&L that

I want to be able to have

inevitably for this amount of

revenue growth. This is the amount of

inventory I'm going to have

to buy based on kind of like my

lead times and what have you. And do I

have enough cash in the bank to be able

to sustain that whole

cash conversion cycle?" So it's really

just kind of working top down

from the revenue perspective

in most cases. So looking at... You're

making this forecast,

you're looking at the revenue,

going through that with them and

forecasting. When people are building...

How are you changing

forecasts quarterly, monthly, weekly? How

often do you recommend a

brand owner changes that and

revisits the forecast? Because I think

sometimes people... I've

seen brand owners hold on to a

forecast longer than they should based on

things that aren't

happening, right? And that could be a

combination of a lot of different things,

but how often do you

recommend people are revisiting it

and looking at it based on what they're

seeing? Because there's

obviously going to always be

changes that are taking place in the

case. Generally speaking,

I'd say a month, like every

month. I think you get your updated

through that. Yeah, you do your forecast

to actual analysis. You

see the process, you get your books

closed, you do your forecast to actual

analysis. And then you

ask the question, it's like, "Okay, cool.

If I miss my forecast

above or below, what were the

assumptions that I had made incorrectly,

even if it's a favorable

outcomes? What are the assumptions

that I made incorrectly? And how does

that affect my future assumptions?" I

think if people are doing

that monthly, that gives them the

opportunity to make the corrections. I'm

a brand owner could look

at that and say like, "Oh yeah, I thought

I was going to 58% increase

spend and I didn't do that,

but that's because, you know, zuck." But

next month it'll work. And

like, "Okay, cool. They can

be delusional, that's their own

prerogative, I suppose." But

nevertheless, I think the

habit is to do that monthly forecast to

actual analysis because

realistically, the forecasting

is always going to be guessing to some

extent. It's just a

question of you getting better at

guessing over time and improving your

judgment and hopefully improving the

conservatism as well,

if you happen to be somebody who's a

little bit overly optimistic. So that

analysis on a monthly

basis is good. And then usually you

should, it's usually easy enough to be

able to just kind of

tweak the forecast as necessary to make

it a little more

realistic. Is it a lot that they're

missing forecasts because they're not

properly understanding like

what their OPEX is and it's

changing and they're not able to get as

many sales in the door? Or is

it tied to, is it, you know,

you mentioned creative previously, is it

that they haven't invested

in the other arms of it? Like,

what are the reasons that people are

missing a forecast?

Almost always it is that they

overestimate how much they'll be able to

increase ad spend while

maintaining the same row as our

CAC. It's almost always, like the most

default assumption is

people just showing up like,

"Yeah, we'll increase ad spend 10% month

over month every month for

the rest of the year." Like,

that's like the default that everybody

just assumes is going to

happen. And it almost always

is the biggest problem because to be

honest, almost everything

else flows from that. So yes,

a person can, like you'll have other

instances. Like for example,

one brand comes to mind, they

hired a very expensive like VP of sales

because they wanted to be

able to kind of like have all

this retail growth and the person didn't

work out. So they would

have projected that, "Okay,

we're going to get this sort of kind of

traction and retail and

whatnot." And that didn't really

end up happening. So then they end up

firing the person. So there's

adjustments to the forecast as

a result of that where, okay, your

personnel, your revenue didn't

kind of go up the way that you

hoped and your personnel costs went down.

But realistically, if

you're being at least somewhat

thoughtful about how you optimize and run

your business, everything

should flow downwards from

the way that revenue is performing. So in

a sense, it's like, if

you're thinking in terms of cause

and effect, it's sort of like almost all

of your OpEx is an effect

of, or sorry, yeah, an effect

of the cause, which is kind of like the

revenue and the ad spend.

And the only thing that's

upstream of that, if you will, is

creative investment for the

most part. Just either your

investment in kind of like the marketing

talent, the agency and the

creative, because that is

probably step one, which affects how much

you can spend at whatever

sort of CAC. And then for a

given CAC and for a given amount of

spending, a given obviously,

consequentially amount of revenue,

that's what affects everything else. That

affects your cashflow, your inventory

balances, your OpEx,

the personnel that you hire, how much you

spend on software. Pretty

much everything is downstream of

that. So like that's the biggest place

that people miss. It's just the

assumptions around ad spend.

I mean, I feel like that's something that

as a marketer, I've had to

tell people for a long time

on meta, the more you spend, you're going

to reach less relevant

audiences. And thus you're

creating creative immediately as you

expand to reach out to new

personas and stuff. One more

question, and then Brad can ask a

question. But like, if

people are doing this, they're

reaching less relevant audiences, the

cost is going up. It tends to be, to me,

a brand owner will say, well, now we're

going to fire the agency and

bring it in house. It's going

to be cheaper. Or whatever that seems to

be an answer. It seems the

new answer is we're going

to try to find something that can be

subscription, which I think is

actually a good answer. And I

think a lot of it too comes to like

product innovation and

coming out with that, along with

sometimes bundling would maybe be another

answer. What other things

have you seen businesses do

that help them fight the rise of CAC as

they increase ad spend?

I think one of the stronger ones is to be

able to rely on increasing

the LTV and the retention side

of things. So essentially how do I sell

more things to the people

that I'm already acquiring,

and then also having a little bit more

expansion in so far as like what my

acquisition mechanisms

are. So simplifying a little bit, let's

say I have one core product that I

acquire, like put all my

ad spend into. And over time, I do make

the investments in

creative and I'm able to optimize

that. That is going to, to some degree,

hit a bit of a natural plateau or an

asymptote, which just

can't really scale that much more beyond

that. So then the

question is, okay, cool. This is

essentially my terminal velocity for this

particular configuration

of the business. So I either

increase how much value I can get from

each one of the people that

I acquire without changing my

front end offer, but it's all on the

retention of the lifetime

value side. So making sure that I

have more products that I can sell to

them. And that can also show

up on the front end in terms

of like bundles and what have you. But

for simplicity, let's

just say I'm selling more

things to those same people or I expand a

little bit. So I have a slightly

different avatar or an

audience that it can kind of pull into.

And ideally it's adjacent

enough that I can also still

leverage the same sorts of things that

I'm selling. But once you kind of hit

your terminal velocity

from a revenue perspective, then it's a

question of just optimizing

everything else to be able to

say like, okay, now how do I maximize my

profit from that

perspective? Because a frame that I use,

that I started using a little bit more

recently, so I'm curious if you guys

think it makes sense,

but I think it's a bit of a simple but

elegant way to think of e-commerce is

that it's essentially

just two machines. One machine is just

saying, how do I spend as much money on

ads as possible to be

able to get like at the best possible

cacto? How do I just keep increasing the

amount of money that

I can spend without too much cacti

gradation? And the second one

is how do I run a business as

efficiently as possible for a given level

of revenue and ad spend?

And the goal is to maximize

your profit as much as possible so that

you can just reinvest it

in increasing that ceiling.

So that's why a lot of brand, the two

mistakes that often happen

is number one, they're not

running operationally very efficiently,

which means that there's less profit

available for them to

reinvest in. Again, not to say the

creative is the only thing to say, but

just for simplicity,

like oftentimes that is the thing that

will move the needle the

most. So there's less profit

available to invest from that

perspective. And the second mistake they

make is that they often

try to spend beyond the point of like

their peak contribution margin. So

they're going to spend

closer to a break even because they think

that's like the fastest

that they can grow. But the

problem is that that's actually hindering

themselves because

they're shooting themselves

on the foot because if you're less

profitable from a contribution margin

perspective, then you have

less money to reinvest in the actual

improvement of your ability

to spend at a higher ceiling.

So I think those two mistakes are the

things that really

hinder the brands from making

the progress that they need to. But yeah,

I'm curious if that sort

of frame is something that

again, I started using this recently when

I talked to brands, but

I don't know if you guys

see it makes sense too. I don't know if I

was having a

conversation with somebody or I was

talking to myself via AI and just keeping

notes and brainstorming

things as I've tended to do so

far this year. But I had a very similar

kind of like thought process

to that. So that definitely

resonates with me. But it's like brands

today, it's like you have to

be good at a lot of things,

but like you have to be good at

marketing. Like it is just for better

words, like it is one of the

fundamental things you have to be good

at. And it might sound dumb.

Like you've always had to let

people know about your stuff and how you

sell it, but like more than ever, like

ads just continue to

eat the world. AI eats the world, AI ads

eat the world. Like it's

just this, these are the two

things that are happening. And so I think

that speaks to machine

number one that you're talking

about. And then yeah, machine number two

is like, well, if you want

to have any dollars left over

for you or for growth or for inevitably

both over long-term, then yeah, it's key.

We should probably come back to the OpEx

point of like OpEx and

efficiency and like where the

biggest mistakes you see are with that.

But we can put that to the

side for the moment. So like,

okay, we've talked about or looking at

the last couple of years,

setting an understanding,

then building your forecast for this

year. And then you kind of

went through what you guys were

just talking about was, okay, I'm now

reviewing on a monthly basis.

And so a takeaway, maybe for

people to do is like, you should go set a

task in your project management tool

right now or wherever

to say like, review the forecast. It's

like, if you don't have

one, you should do it. And you

should have a monthly cadence for

reviewing the forecast and to your point,

so you can go and see,

okay, I said revenue is going to be this,

it landed here. Why was that?

Okay, well, maybe my spend was

less efficient than I expected. Okay, why

was it less efficient than

I expected? Well, I thought

Facebook is going to be here and it

landed here. Okay, well, what's wrong?

You know, it's like,

it's the chain of the use kind of follow

that logical chain to find those issues.

Let's say you come in and you're 20%

behind on forecasts for January. Does

that mean you're just

kind of doing this like quick like, okay,

well, I know we're

simplifying it to not be new versus

returning. But does that mean, okay, for

the rest of the year, we're

going to say we project to be

down 20% off forecast the rest of the

year. Then what do we need to

do to not let that happen? So

at least how rude did someone in reality?

It's like, what, what,

what step do you take from,

you've, you've updated it. How are you

updating it? Like, maybe

specifically on the number side,

and then like, how do you build a plan

from there? It comes down to the answer

to what you describe,

which is under the analysis that cause

and effect relationship

analysis. So like when you kind of

keep working down towards a root cause of

what happened, once you

have that answer, that'll

determine what sort of an impact you make

to the rest of the forecast

and what is necessary to be

able to kind of change it. So really, if

it's something we're

like, yeah, we were below on

revenue because this one particular ship

container from China didn't arrive

because of XYZ war that

happened or whatever, then yeah, fine.

That probably shouldn't

happen again. We should be

good going forward. So that could be

reasonable. Where if it's just like a

ROAS assumption thing,

where you just got a little bit trigger

happy with like setting

really high targets and

yeah, probably worth making the

adjustment to the, to the forecast.

Do you set multiple, like you set a range

of forecasts? Like are you doing a,

here's kind of like the base case. Here's

the best case. Like, are

you setting multiple or

you just kind of go in like, this is the,

this is the, this is the

one that we're going off of.

We're going to stick

with this one for the year.

Where possible. Yeah. I mean, it's always

ideal to be able to set, you

know, your base worst best.

Um, obviously it's also a question of

like the brand that we're working with

and whether it makes

sense to kind of, cause that's obviously

a lot more work. Um, so

it depends on that. I'd say

the value of doing the based, uh, like

the, the three sort of

scenarios, if you will,

are important in brands that have a lot

of high, a lot of fixed costs.

The, the reason being that take the

logical extreme of a brand

that's like all variable,

say a dropshipper, right? It's just like,

they don't have inventory.

They don't have any fixed

costs. I don't mean employees. There's

some like 18 year old kid

that lives at home has got like,

no, no expense. It's just like, he just

rides the wave of ad

spend. So like things go up,

revenue goes up, profit goes up,

everything goes up and

things go down. They just go down,

but he doesn't have any issues with that

to a certain extent.

Like there isn't necessarily

that much of a need to be able to

forecast what's my best case. What's my

worst case? Because then

you're just going to ride the wave either

way. So yes, if you have

like maybe a contractor for

like say 1500 bucks a month or something,

but you're actually doing a

hundred K a month in sales,

then like whatever ride your wave up and

down, your, your worst

case, you're still not going to

fire the contractor. You're good. But

brands that have very high fixed

expenses, especially ones

that like do their own manufacturing and

stuff like that, like those

are the ones where it's like,

you need to make sure that your worst

case can cover all of your fixed

expenses. So that's not

going to destroy your business. So that's

where the scenario analysis

becomes a lot more important

because you want to make sure, okay, at a

worst case, am I good?

Cool. Now, what do I need to be

able to achieve the more likely base case

so that you can make the

investments for that place without

necessarily putting yourself in a

situation where you screw

yourself over? Yeah. Well, you,

so we're talking about like the

potential, the negative side, but there's

even, there's even a

cap on upside growth from a cash

perspective, which I think

we've been talking a lot about

like P and L ish metrics, right? It's

like get revenue spend for

efficiency, but we're not,

well, I think it's hard. I think it's

hard conceptually to

understand cashflow. I mean,

I struggle with it for sure. It's like

one of the things I'm

really trying to spend my head,

wrap my head around this year is like,

okay, what is the cashflow implication of

these things? Because

if you're barely above break even, it's

like you can't even place

it your next PO until you

sell through most of your inventory. So

like, and then you're stuck for two

months waiting for it

to come in on a boat. And then you could

finally ramp back up. So

there's this like huge delay.

But let's assume things are going well.

Have you seen people like

actually be constrained because

their growth is either too fast and not

efficient enough or like some kind of

combination of that?

No, you're absolutely right. And don't

feel bad. Like even most

accountants have a lot of difficulty

with cashflow because it's a conceptually

very, it's a very

counterintuitive thing, honestly.

I wish I could say that I see it more

often because that means

like some brands are just

crushing it, but realistically, everybody

always ends up like setting

themselves up in a way where

it's like things have to work out

perfectly for them to be able to hit

their plans. And like a

lot of times it's a little bit tough, but

yes, it does sometimes happen

in theory. You're absolutely

right that like if you are able to

absolutely smash out of the

park from the ads or let's go

with a simpler example. You should go

viral, right? Like that's

not a question of like things,

you got lucky, things just shoot up, you

have a lot of sales and yes, it can

happen where you just

from a cashflow perspective aren't able

to necessarily sustain

what's necessary to be able

to hit that. I think it's interesting

because in e-commerce it's a

little bit less of a risk in a

lot of cases because of the fact that

your cash conversion cycle

is pretty low. So for the most

part, depending on again your supply

chain and lead times and all

that stuff, if you're getting

like such say really, really good ROAS

all of a sudden and things

are just going really well,

you are for the most part in a pretty

healthy place because

Shopify is going to pay you out

in a couple of days. You pay your ad

spend, you know, whatever 30, 50 days

depending on like your

financing structure there. And as long as

your supply chain is not

like 120 days, like you can

just place the inventory order. So

generally you should be able to kind of

move relatively well,

but where it becomes a little bit

problematic is for the

brands that are being a little bit

aggressive and kind of running closer to

break even, then they have

to be able to say, "Okay,

cool." Even unless they have a negative

cash inversion cycle, they

have to be conscientious of

like, "Okay, how much of a credit line do

I need? How much funding do

I need to be able to take?

Where do I spend that money?" So it's

less of an issue of you, if you have

incredibly good return

on ad spend, then you're usually pretty

good, but it's more of an

issue of like, "Okay, we're in our

best case where our revenue number is

very high, but we are still operating on

kind of a razor thin

contribution margin." Then you still just

need to be very

conscientious of the funding as well.

Yeah, that's fair. When does adding

complexity with a forecast actually

improve decision making?

That's a great question. I'll give you

three things. So firstly, it

depends on the sophistication

of the actual person. There's no point in

having a forecast if you're

the type of person who like

doesn't really pay attention to it,

doesn't really look at it,

doesn't try to operate against it,

doesn't really make any changes to your

assumptions. So some

people are a bit more

like methodical, sophisticated, and

thoughtful about those

things. So some of it is really,

"How are you going to use it?" Because a

forecast is not inherently

valuable. It doesn't make you

money by existing. It only works if you

use it to inform your

decisions and are thoughtful about

that. The second one is with respect to,

it's a kind of like a risk

element to it. So if you are

running in a situation where you are

taking some very big risks, so kind of

maybe going back to the

example where you have a very significant

amount of fixed expenses,

then yeah, that's a situation

where the additional complexity of the

forecast can kind of cover

and show you the different areas

where you can have failure and where you

can have that risk. So adding that

additional complexity

can be quite valuable. But at the end of

the day, if you're in a

situation where, I guess coming to

the third point, you have very few

constraints, like the actual

bottlenecks on your business is

this one thing, adding the additional

complexity is not

necessarily going to add that value. So

the other piece is really, "What are your

constraints right now

to be able to grow?" So

to kind of clarify that with an example,

if really the problem that

I'm having right now is that I

cannot increase ad spend beyond 100K

without, you know, CAC imploding, then I

don't necessarily need

to spend too much time forecasting all of

my software expenses or

exactly when I'm going to

hire each person, how much are going to

pay them, how much are their bonuses

going to be? That's not

the thing that's needle moving. For me,

it has a lot more to how

much I'm going to spend on the

agencies, how much I'm going to spend on

creative and how much I'm

going to spend and what's the

CAC going to look like. So like, I need

to focus the entirety of my

attention from a forecasting

perspective on that aspect. It's not

really the rest of it that's

going to be a big needle mover.

Or on the other hand, if you're a

business that does a lot of

manufacturing, like another brand

I'm thinking of that we work with, for

them, like they do their own

manufacturing. So for them,

their constraint is they're actually

doing quite well from an ad perspective.

They can kind of push

the revenue up. Their constraint is that

they can't keep up with

supply unless they make

investments in machinery and the size of

their warehouse and the

staff that they hire. So for

them, they would spend a lot more their

time on that aspect. So

it comes down to where the

constraint is. But if you have low fixed

expenses, your constraint is

really just on the marketing

side and you're a marketer minded person,

then you can put 90% of

your forecasting attention on

just that aspect. And most of the OpEx do

it at a high level, but you

feel like get 20% of revenue.

That's probably an 80 20 you're good

enough. Maybe I'm

misunderstanding. But I think what

you're saying is like, once you identify

the constraint, then

you can make a decision on

whether you should be investing OpEx into

solving that

constraint. And to what degree?

I was talking about it from the context

of like specifically the how

much value there is to kind

of going super detailed on that part

forecast. But it's exactly

the same as what you're saying

from the perspective of like, that also

mirrors how important

that section actually is.

So if my constraint is over there, then

like, I don't need to spend

that much time on that other

place over there from a forecasting

perspective, because it doesn't really

affect the business that

much anyway. Yeah. Well, I think it's I

think this is an

appropriate time for beef, Andrew,

given that we're talking about our

frustrations with OpEx

decision making. And I mean, look,

we're marketer minded people. So like we

want every dollar

that we can to pour into

into into into marketing rather than

random fixed expenses. So I'll start but

beefs, if you're not,

if you're not familiar, it's just like

something that's something I

frustrate to. And since we're

on the top of your gears, you have really

grinds your gears. I'd say

in the context of beefs as

relates to OpEx, I just think like my one

of my biggest

frustrations is like, when when when

brands make decisions around OpEx without

like an actual expectation of

what that is going to return.

Now you can have a you can have a theory

about like, I think hiring

this agency is going to do

is going to help me increase my

efficiency. It's like, okay, well, how

much does efficiency and

need to increase and at what spend level

or like what in order

for it to pay for itself,

like what actually needs to be true. And

so I just think it's not

like taking that next step and

just doing the math. You can just yap

into chat GPT with how much

it costs and like your metrics,

and it can return to you like what needs

to be true. And so I think

it's just not actually taking

like making it making an OpEx decision

that you don't take to the math to

understand like, well,

okay, what needs to be true of this, the

same could be true for

like, you're opening a retail

location is like, okay, I know most

people opening a retail location, like

generally think that through

because it's a pretty big thing to do.

But like, did you figure out how much

your lease is going to

be and what this needs to do in revenue

and what the implications

are for the staff that you need

to hire and there's a lot that goes with

that we had a client that

just did this and they did they

did the exact opposite, which is they

thought it through very

thoughtfully. And so that's why I

bring that one up. But what OpEx are you,

what are you beefing with, Amir?

So I don't want to copy you because I

would probably say the

same thing. So I'll give you

a couple, but they're very closely

related. So one of them is specifically,

this one annoys the crap

out of me because I think it's something

that we fall into like as a

business as well as a trap.

Businesses do not spend most business

owners do not spend enough time

scrutinizing the ROI on full

time hires. I think when it comes to

personnel, for some reason,

they just fly under the radar

insofar as like what sort of value

they're driving and what they're

contributing to the business.

And a person who works full time can

like, I'm not, not to

imply that they're like time

thieving or like actively trying not to

do stuff, but they'll do

stuff, but it'll just be like a lot

of busy work along the way too. And the

frame or the scrutiny that

people apply to agencies or

freelancers or contractors, like anybody

that's an external to the

business, they just do not do that

to somebody full time where if I were to

go to them and be like,

okay, what did this person do

last month? They're like, well, they did

XYZ. I'm like, okay,

cool. That cost you in salary,

let's say $8,000. If somebody came to you

with an RFP and said, I will

do these things for $8,000,

would you assign that contract?

Absolutely not. But people just don't go

into that frame at all.

And I think it often comes up as a

specific point of frustration in the

context of like people

comparing in-house marketers to agencies

because they'll hold like

this almost unreasonable level

of scrutiny to agencies that they'll just

never apply to somebody

in-house where it's just like

things just kind of happen with the

in-house persons, like how

much time they spend on things,

how much value they drive. It's just,

it's a completely

different way of analyzing things.

But at the end of the day, yeah, cool.

One's a full-time employee. Sure. The

other one's an agency.

Yes. But at the end of the day, it's cash

out and what are you getting

in his ROI? And people just

don't think about that. And I think that

I personally find

quite annoying, but just to

not completely copy you, I'll add in a

slightly tangential second

one, which is that there's also

oftentimes a lot of bloat that develops

when it comes to fixed

expenses. People will be thoughtful

about adding it, but then it's now there

forever. And so they don't

necessarily spend that. It's

almost like in the real world, people

have subscription

issues. They just kind of keep

subscribing to stuff. It's like, "Oh, I

had 10 bucks for Netflix and

10 bucks for Spotify and 10

bucks for Apple Music," or whatever. And

then it just kind of adds up

over time. So whether it be

softwares or also personnel too, or like

you just have an army of 17

VAs that all had different

things that they had to do, they kind of

made sense at the time.

There's a lot of bloat that

shows up in OpEx that people just don't

necessarily scrutinize

because it takes time

and effort to kind of... And it's

cognitive load to do that. And people are

so busy kind of trying

to focus on all the fun, dynamic,

exciting stuff like ad spend and CAC.

They just kind of assume

the fixed expenses are fixed and they

never really take the time to think like,

"Okay, cool. How much...

If I were to be able to shave off 10K of

fixed expenses, and then I

spent 10K on creative, how

much more of a needle mover would that be

for the business?" But people

just don't do it. And I find

that... Yeah. Well, you've given people

very tactical homework. It's

go look at the last couple of

years, then build a forecast, then make

sure you're updating the

forecast. If you didn't set the task

in your project management system, you

need to go do that. And now you've given

them another task to

add to that, which is like, "Okay,

probably on a monthly cadence,

go look at your OpEx." I think

at this point in time, there's this viral

thing on Twitter, which is

some guy made a thing that you

can upload your personal expenses into

chat and it reviews it and

yells at you if you're spending

money on dumb things. You can do that

with your business as well.

Andrew, I don't want to leave

you hanging on the beef. So you got

something teed up for us. I

mean, my big beef actually is in

relation, just because you mentioned

about people opening up retail locations.

Mine is, I feel like

I don't know why we keep seeing it, but

it's so common that you hear big

companies opening up

retail location before they need to. The

most recent example

I've been very privy to,

because I'm a cyclist, as a lot of people

know, is Rad Power Bikes.

So they're an e-bike company,

and they grew in the pandemic and

everybody was buying

e-bikes. And then they just assumed

everybody was going to buy a billion

e-bikes till the end of time. And they

opened up some crazy

number, like 12 retail locations. And I

know for real, in Santa Barbara,

California, where I live,

they're at least, somebody told me, is 50

grand a month. I was like,

how many e-bikes do you have to sling to

like, and then guess what? They just

filed for chapter 11,

because they're freaking bankrupt.

Because like, yeah, so I

think there's so much in business

from a forecasting standpoint, if I am

given the keys to a business,

I always ask myself, how much of this in

the forecast is based on

hubris? And how much is

based on reality? And I think that

there's a lot of ego and

hubris that's like, it tied into

running a business. And the more you can

be tied into like, is

this a real thing? Like,

is this, are we actually seeing this

happen? Is like a big thing that

separates operators.

So that's my beef. Because for some

reason, these MBAs get put in

these jobs at red powerbikes,

and they're sitting around a conference

table. And like, they make

this decision, you're like,

I know that things are going well, but

like, I'm just so conservative, I would

never make that call.

And then people get PE money, and then

they do really crazy

stuff. And they're just like,

okay, I guess you're just lighting money

on fire now. So that's my

beef on that. But anyway,

back to the regularly scheduled

programming. I think what

you said about looking at the

employees is a huge one. I think that is

something I've seen and I've talked to a

lot of people about,

because I do a lot of work with people

that are brands that are in

the Foxville community. Do I

to go in, do I train my person better? Do

I bring it in house or do

I use an agency? Obviously,

there's this is an endless debate we

could go on and on about. But

in terms of other things that

people can assess in forecasting and

continuing to forecast, what

are the top three things you

would make sure that a business owner is

doing that you don't

think 90% of them are?

I'd say deeply in analyzing their

inventory. A lot of times people just

kind of assume that it's on

the balance sheet, right? So people don't

even necessarily look at

it. So look at how many days

inventory on hand do you have and what

the distribution is for

the various amount of skews.

I come across a lot of businesses who are

sitting on hundreds of thousands of

dollars of inventory

and still ordering more every month

because it's in the wrong skews. It's not

in the stuff that they

sell. And so then figuring out like,

okay, fine. If you're not

going to sell it, like, can you

liquidate it? Can you do some sort of

bundling? Can you use it as

an offer to be able to kind of

improve your acquisition or something?

But at the end of the day,

if it's just sitting on the

balance sheet, it doesn't make you money.

And it's again, it's cash

that you could have been using

elsewhere. So I say the inventory is one

that a lot of people

miss. The second one, I mean,

we spoke about it at length, but just

essentially kind of spending

a lot of time to understand

what are the investments that you are

making in increasing the

ceiling for your ad spend. So not

just assuming I'm going to increase ad

spend 10% every month or

every quarter, whatever it is,

like it's easy to make the assumption.

It's like, why do you think

it will work? Like what are the

actual things you're doing that would

allow you to increase your

spend? Like, because last month,

you spent 100K. So why should I believe

that next month you're going to spend

110K and CAC's going

to stay the same? If it could do that,

why didn't you just

spend 110K last month? So

spending the time to be like, okay, I can

justify that there's a

reason this will go up because I

am making these sorts of investments. And

the third one I already

said, but personnel. I think

personnel, people need to spend a lot

more time on justifying why somebody

should be hired and what

the people are actually spending their

time on because, yeah, to

your point, I know the agency

versus in-house debate comes up a lot.

And I think that there are

arguments to be made for the

in-house, but I think a lot of times it

comes from an idealized

scenario of like the theoretical

benefits of having somebody in-house and

how much money you could

save. But the thing is that most

business owners don't necessarily have, I

think the, let's call it

discipline to be able to

scrutinize an in-house hires activity and

what they do in the same

way that for some reason they

naturally and easily do to agencies such

that the vast majority are probably

better off just going

with agencies until they're in a place

where like it's truly

justifiable to in-house.

Yeah, I've, so let's just talk about this

for one second because I

have lots of opinions about it.

I think it's totally true. You know, I

think that we've had a lot of

people that have brought, that

are brand owners that have brought their

head of growth into the Foxville

community to make sure

that the head of growth is like on it.

And they've given me a plan to say, make

sure that they, this

person is, you know, on it with this,

they're getting reviews and

whatever. There's so, there's

so many people that are just not, they're

not positioned to be able

to know whether that person's

doing a good job. So if you're going to

in-house, equip yourself

first and like almost learn it

eight out of 10, nine out of 10 yourself

before you hire someone

because hiring someone in-house

without the proper oversight is not going

to be helpful for you.

Someone's can come in and then

they're going to realize that you have no

idea what you're doing

and that they're, and it's,

they're unfortunately in most cases,

they're going to take advantage of you,

you know, and I've seen

that happen. And I mean, I'm not saying

there are certainly head of

growth type people. There are

marketers that are fantastic that are

self-starters that go out there like, and

could just crush it.

And the boss doesn't need to know, right?

Think about the previous

episode we did with someone

like Miranda from 365 holdings. She's

insane. She's so smart. And

she's going to keep doing that.

I could, you know, cause her, she's

probably, maybe she's

incentivized to do that. You know,

that's another thing. Make sure you're

incentivizing the employee

to do a good job. But like,

that kind of self-starting mentality and

attitude is rare. And

there's a, so just, anyway, that's

another thing I think is important to

talk about because what you're getting

with an agency is like

you, they are going to be on it mostly

like, you know, and that's

what you're paying them for

because they have to be. Beef's V2. I

didn't know we were getting, I could

look, you brought me

then pull something up. I can, I can

scroll through my Twitter for like four

seconds and I find it,

endless things to beef with. Super, super

fun to talk about forecasts for, I mean,

relatively speaking, obviously a lot more

fun to bitch about

agencies versus in-house, but no,

I totally. A beer, let people know where

they can find out, find

you and about your company.

Yeah, absolutely. So I'm on the internet.

My name's ABIR, so it's

not that hard to find me.

But yeah, beer, you can find me on

Twitter, LinkedIn, all that

kind of stuff. If you're a

brand that's listening, we offer a really

cool kind of like one hour

CFO deep dive that reviews

kind of like the last 12 months of data

and does a lot of the stuff

that we're talking about kind

of prior to the forecasting, just kind of

making sure that all your

numbers make sense. And you

have that strategic plan that is kind of

realistic. So that's also

something that we offer for free

to kind of Foxwell folks, but I'm sure we

can do it for free for

anybody listening to this episode

too. But yeah, otherwise, upcounting.com.

That's where I am. Awesome. Thank you,

Abir. I'm glad to have you. And thanks

for joining us. Of course.

Thanks so much for having me.

This episode is brought to you by Brad's

company, Work Marketing.

If you need a DTC marketing

agency, let me tell you Homestead is

great, but work marketing is also

fantastic. And let me

tell you, you aren't going to find

friendlier people out

there in the e-commerce space.

So we decided to do these little ads for

each other's companies.

So hopefully you find it

interesting, but seriously, great team at

work marketing, very

smart. Brad and Jordan are

incredibly dialed in. I just gave them a

lead. Artie made this

brand that I gave them. Like,

I don't even know, double, double revenue

that they had the

previous month or something. So,

it's very exciting to be connected with

Brad. And if you need a great agency,

there's really no one better. Zach,

anything to comment on work marketing?

Yeah. I mean, if you want an agency that

cares about your business

much more than they care about

their own website, I just tried to load

workmarketing.com and

it was broken. So they're

definitely going to give more of a shit

about your business than

their own. So I highly recommend

Brad and the team over at work. They've

been incredible. We've

referred a lot of business

over to them as well. Really, really

good. As far as like cracking

funnels and figuring out like,

rapid growth for brands.

So I recommend these guys.

The only way that we grow this podcast is

by you sharing it with

your friends. Honestly,

like reviews kind of don't really mean

anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful,

but they don't do a lot for the growth of

the podcast. And so

sharing YouTube links,

sharing Spotify links, sharing Apple,

whatever we call it

under the podcast app now,

anything you can share, the better we're

going to be guys. Anything

else you want to say on this?

Yeah. Please go check us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it. And then

subscribe. Make sure to subscribe on

YouTube as well. And I

relentlessly refresh the YouTube

comments because it dictates my mental

health for the day. So please say

something nice about all of

us. Thank you everyone. Thanks for

listening. Honestly.