Scalability School

Question: How should DTC brands plan their Black Friday ad spend and offers?
Direct answer: Plan Black Friday around contribution margin, not a ROAS number. Run the exact offer weeks early so cart, checkout and discount-code problems surface before the big weekend, and set acquisition targets that account for the higher return rate after the promo ends. During the sale, use time-boxed incentives such as a one-hour free gift with purchase instead of a deeper percentage discount, track orders by channel by the hour against target, and put creative effort into founder-led storytelling ads rather than new landing pages. Zach Stuck's best customer cohort ever came from spending $100K before 9 AM on the Saturday after Black Friday, because the 12-month contribution margin on those customers still came out ahead.

Last Black Friday weekend's ad strategy started with a mistake that paid off: Zach Stuck
spent $100K before 9 AM on the Saturday after Black Friday, his team panicked,
and those customers became his best cohort ever on 12-month contribution margin.
Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch and Zach walk through how to plan BFCM spend and
offers: test the offer in October, set ROAS targets that account for returns,
run a one-hour free gift with purchase, pace orders by the hour, and film
founder ads instead of building new landing pages.

We discuss:

- Why your Black Friday ad won't save a weak business-as-usual setup
- Testing your Black Friday offer in October to find what breaks
- Setting ROAS targets that account for post-holiday returns
- Whether discount customers are really worse (and how to measure them)
- The one-hour gift with purchase that tripled hourly sales
- Building an hourly pacing sheet by channel, with Claude
- Why bonuses and gift cards beat a bigger percentage off
- Why a lower AOV can scale better on Meta
- Founder ads, yapper ads and the "source of the week" creative process
- AI character ads and turning blackhat tactics white hat

Get the Scalability School newsletter (free, short, no spam):
https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter

Watch last year's BFCM recap with Zach: https://youtu.be/3POPSecWu_M
Get the newsletter: https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter
Learn more: https://www.scalabilityschool.com

To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com
To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch
To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck

This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It’s a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they’re offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you

This episode of Scalability School is sponsored by Alia, the AI-powered pop-up platform. Head to aliapopups.com, book a demo, and mention AI DTC WTF for an extended 45-day free trial.

Scalability School is a weekly show from Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch, and Zach
Stuck about what is actually working right now in DTC growth. No theory, no
recycled LinkedIn takes, just the numbers and decisions behind real brands and
real ad accounts.

Chapters

00:00 Black Friday ad strategy: the $100K morning and why the basics win
02:10 Test your Black Friday offer in October
03:58 Set Black Friday ROAS targets that account for returns
05:49 Sale cohorts, BOGO and keeping evergreen ads cranking
08:04 Are discount customers worse? The $100K Saturday cohort
11:13 The one-hour gift with purchase that tripled hourly sales
13:05 How to pace Black Friday by channel and by the hour
20:59 Why a lower AOV can scale better on Meta
23:40 Black Friday creative: founder ads beat new landing pages
34:45 AI character ads and turning blackhat tactics white hat

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

funny story.

Like the team

got upset at me

because we overspent on Saturday

after Black Friday

and kind of was a little

was freaking out a little bit

because we spent like 100

K in the first, like at night.

It was 9 a.m. central.

We already spent 200

so the team is losing their minds.

But the CCaC to contribution margin on

those customers is still our best cohort

that we've ever had.

ran a gift with purchase.

That was basically an SMS, an email

that would go out

that basically say, hey,

for the next hour,

get this product for free

if you order, our hourly sales,

even during the Black Friday,

like normal trend,

which is like up way

above baseline, we're triple

during that hour.

in the world of AI slop

that we're in, real

people want to buy from real people

where my brain goes

most days is like, what are the crazy

like, blackhat people doing?

And how do I actually make that

white hat?

so here's the deal.

We're talking about

Black Friday, Cyber Monday.

All right.

And you know,

there's a lot of different ways

that you can go about this.

I think there's a lot of different

takes people have

I think a lot of people want to hear

what Zach Stuck has to say about this.

Brad and I have recorded

our own episodes.

But Zack, like,

what's your general

feeling about Black Friday, Cyber Monday,

and this time frame as it relates

to what branch to do?

Let's just pretend

this is a mentor pass call,

and we're paying you $12,000 an hour

for your time.

Okay.

So first and foremost, I think that

having

good business as

usual, like

strategy is still

the most important part of is your back.

I'm going to go well

or not, it's not like this one

ad you're going to make

that talks about the product

being a great gift, or

adding a Santa hat to your logo,

or any of that shit

is really going to make

or break your VCM.

I think it comes down to doing the basics

really well.

I tweeted this the other day like good ad

good offer, make the ads entertaining.

Make them educational.

Make the offer as clear

as you possibly can.

If you're doing those things,

like you're

probably going to see success during BFS

and hopefully you've done the math

to figure out how hard you can push.

So I'll try to break some of that down.

The when it comes to like,

creative when it comes to landing

pages, when it comes to website for BFS

and like tying it to an offer.

I think the number one thing I see brands

mess up

is like

they overcomplicate the UI of the offer.

Sometimes it might be like the first time

they run this offer,

maybe like they're used to

running by more,

say more,

and now they're going to run

Bogo like you have to chua the shit

out of your your UI with this offer.

And I would try to do that

pre season

like even if the offer

isn't quite as perfect.

Like even if you want to run it

for like a four day

or a weekend or something like,

I think it's worth it to do it

because you're going to find

kinks in your car

or your checkout or a discount code.

Not being like, being as like,

stable as you thought it was going to,

I don't know, whatever, whatever it is.

Like you're going to find these little

you're going

to find these little pockets, of errors

that hopefully you can find

before it actually happens to be.

We have an awesome tool.

That's a little bit of a secret,

and I'd like to tell you about it.

It's called the Foxwell MCP.

The Fox MCP

connects into Claude, connects

into your ChatGPT Pro,

and it gives you direct access

to every single thing

we've ever said in the Foxwell

founders community.

Check it out at Foxwell digital.com

forward slash.

It gives you access to

every podcast

transcript we've ever put out,

every workshop,

every course we've put forth.

It's honestly

very inexpensive for the value

that you get.

You could get it plugged in and say,

put together a report on this account

of what I could do better.

I mean, it's endless.

What this MCP can do,

and I encourage you

to check it out today.

Foxwell digital forward slash MCP.

We'd love to have you.

So that's one thing

that we've done with

hollow in the past

is we'll run the same offer

like in October,

call it a warehouse

sale, call it whatever.

And just try to figure out what's broken,

what's not,

and then pull back to evergreen.

And then when we launch the SM,

we already know, kind of

like what mistakes we

hopefully already had cleaned up.

When it comes to like, pushing,

I think like

this is a term that I've always,

like told

our team is like,

I want to really know the threshold

of how

I create more profit

during this peak period.

Is it by keeping Roas higher

during during the sale period,

or is it by actually

keeping Raw is lower,

but being able to punch up

way more volume?

So I think

like having the financial understanding

of how your business works

to offset

opex to offset cost of delivery

during this period is like

super important.

Also making sure you're doing the math

on like things like return return rate

might go up.

So like

if your normal return rate

is 1% of orders,

it might go up to 3% of orders.

And that may have a huge

impact on your January.

So you should really bake that in

and know that.

And that may have an impact

on how you set your targets for your cash

or your row as targets on acquisition.

Those are like big mistakes

that I've made in the past

where like we're like,

oh, our target is a 2.05.

Or really

it needed to be like a 2.15

because the returns like went up

after the promo period fell off

after the holidays.

So like understanding the math of

how to set an equation for

how can I

scale into this

if I have the opportunity

to scale into this,

I think is like

one of the biggest things.

So I'll stop there.

I just ranted for a little bit,

but like I think

thinking about the financials

and how you can actually push into it

to take advantage of the fact that,

like CPMs and CPAs

are going to look really good

in knowing,

like all the moving pieces of that,

and then ideally having the ability

to run it like a pretest,

even for like a day,

and just make sure nothing is broken,

I think is important.

Before you run a promo for 30 days

during the most important

time of the year.

So I'll stop there. Yeah.

Makes sense of sense. Are you.

So do you know loosely

what you guys are doing for offer

this year?

I know we're yeah,

it's technically beginning of October,

so I don't know if you've run.

You're running a pretest promo. Yeah.

So we've already.

Yeah. From Mars.

You've already run the promo.

Like we already know

what rough CPAs need to be.

What take rates

on post-purchase upsell are.

We already ran

the sale

that we're going to run for Black Friday,

and then we're going to run for our New

year sales.

So we already know

kind of what that looks like.

The other thing

that's really important for us is like,

we're a subscription business at Mars.

And so we run a cactus TV and a payback

kind of model.

And I need to know how a sale

customer interacts versus a business

as usual price point customer interact.

So we already have cohorts

now that are starting to back out.

So we kind of know the threshold

of how good and how

like what

the likelihood of the LTV

is of those customers,

which is inherently

going to be a bit worse.

And customers are

inherently going to be a bit worse.

They were worse last year,

but because the catch and payback period,

like, looked so good,

it was worth it

to even have like worse cohorts.

So for Mars, it's fully baked for hollow.

It's pretty much rinse and repeat.

I think we're going to take the promo

and just make it slightly stronger.

We run kind of Bogo promos at hollow.

That's it's

important for us to run it there

so that we can keep our prices

high on our on.com

so that retail can

be at a certain map pricing.

So that's why we have to run

kind of the promo and pricing strategy

we have at hollows.

Now that we have retail employee,

to not go

below the map pricing with the discount.

So that's that's pretty much fully baked.

But yeah,

I mean,

I think the thing

that I really have the hollow team

just kind of obsessing about is like,

evergreen has to be cranking before

holiday, like, we can

we can slap B at Black Friday sale on

an evergreen

ad, and it's just going to perform

a little bit better.

But I need that initial like winning

ad winning funnel to already be working,

and not just like bank on a new

lander or a new template

or anything like that.

We're trying to keep things

like business as usual,

and then just like

add in the promo

overlays on on kind of everything.

Yeah. Go ahead.

I just didn't say there was a,

I think a

Daniel O'Connell friend,

a friend of the pod here.

He was he says, I'm on Twitter.

That reminded me of

like the

the cohort thing that you just mentioned.

I think there's like this

common trope

that discount customers are worse,

but the context that matters a ton

because like,

yes, what you're saying is

the retention rate is worse on them.

And so that means that gross margin

or lifetime gross margin on them

is potentially worse.

But that's gross margin.

It doesn't consider

what you acquired them for

and the volume

that that you acquired them.

So if you can acquire

ten X as many customers

and you take $1 less,

you know, it's

probably more than a dollar or less,

but you take less like it matters,

but it doesn't matter. So it's new.

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

You need

you need to understand

that contribution

margin over 12 months,

especially 36 months,

which no branch in really

look at in

my opinion on 12 months

is probably going to be a bit worse.

But yeah, the to contribution margin like

that's where

we write in volume is

kind of the important piece.

So yeah, I mean like

I know that Mars last year

funny story.

Like the team,

the team got pretty upset at me

because we overspent on on the,

the Saturday after Black Friday

and I kind of was a little

I was freaking out a little bit

because we spent like 100

K in the first, like at night.

It was 9 a.m. central.

We already spent 200 K,

and so the team is losing their minds.

But the CCaC to contribution

margin on those customers

is still our best cohort

that we've ever had.

So, on on like a 12 month contribution

margin basis.

So because of that, we added

such a large threshold of new customers

that morning

that it actually helped us out

through the rest of the year

as that

like compounded over time,

even though that the churn

even a month one was like 15% worse,

which is insane or

like not more than that,

like 30% worse

than our business as usual.

But just because the volume was so high

and was so low, it just backed out.

And that's, that's for people problems.

When you can,

you can look

at a one day cohort

and know that it was better.

No, no. Right. It's unbelievable.

I mean,

I was thinking somebody said to me

something interesting

at the founders meetup, which was that,

you know,

I think we have to start also considering

the fact

that on the Black Friday, Cyber

Monday cohorts and on the weekend,

each of these are

these are actually separate people

to a degree, they're kind of different.

Right?

There's the people that are

the that are the grabbers of deals

right away that are in there.

Then there's the more considerate buyers,

which actually tend to

buy through the weekend

and sometimes

wait until the cyber until Monday,

which is why it's big.

But like sometimes

actually somebody else

was saying something

similar, Zach,

which is that

they actually saw

really good results on Saturday to this,

you know,

segment of kind of considered customers

that had been around

but hadn't made the purchase,

and they had the time

they sat down and purchased on it,

and their comment

was actually something

like 40% of the purchases.

Had taken place on a desktop versus

it was it's normally like in the 20s

for them.

So, you know, one thing

I think people are always

curious about SAC

is the systems around all of this.

And how do you kind of

get these together?

I think there's obviously we've

talked about,

a little bit,

you know, the offer

and the things that you're,

you know, adjusting their.

So let's talk about the offer

a little bit deeper

when you go through and consider

and you're let's say

you're talking

to another brand

that's asking for your advice about,

okay, here's how we're doing the offer

for Black Friday, Cyber Monday.

What are the things that you're

looking at in considering

and when you're starting

to build that offer?

the reason

I ask this is,

you know,

you mentioned

last year that you're doing things by our

so, you know,

you did hourly promotions

and they were different

and you tested a lot of different things,

which I think is actually quite

an innovative idea.

And I don't know

many people that do that.

So, do you think about

how do you kind of build that up

in terms of framing an offer

that's really going to be attractive,

or a segment of offers

that are going to drive people through?

Yeah. So that was that was for hollow.

We ran a gift with purchase.

That was basically an SMS,

an email that

would go out that basically say, hey,

for the next hour,

you'll get this product for free

if you order, in our hourly sales,

even during the Black Friday,

like normal trend,

which is like up way above baseline,

we're triple during that hour.

And because of that velocity got so high,

we were able to

then spend into

just like adding more new customers

kind of throughout the day.

So I would say, like

if you have

a compelling gift to purchase.

So we were giving me like a $50 alpaca,

100% opaca beanie

made in the US, like a quality,

good free gift of purchase.

So if you have something like that

that you actually think your customers

maybe wouldn't buy

as the first product from you,

but would consider buying

if they've already been a customer

or they like your product?

I would try something like that.

Something that can drive

true, like fear of missing out true,

like high bias

to take action

from the customer standpoint.

Like,

that's something that will we'll

do again

very likely for hollow this year.

Kind of keep that in your back pocket,

depending on

how performance is balancing.

But I mean, the systems

that we think about is mostly

not now, kind of like

at the scale that we're at is

mostly about like pacing

throughout the day.

So we kind of set targets

and profitability targets

and then we kind of know, okay,

I need pacing to be at a certain degree

on a daily basis

by our otherwise like we fall behind

on our profit targets.

And for hollow specifically,

it's such a seasonal business that like

we don't really make any money

most of the year.

Q4 is where we make like our hay.

And so for us, like the systems

that we have in place are

basically hourly tracking.

So we can kind of compare,

target versus goal.

So what I've,

what I've had the team

build is

we have this for marzban as well,

but it's a daily report that's built

on last click and it's orders per channel

per day. So

on a daily basis I can see

did email, did SMS did organic

did Facebook did

Google, did each channel drive

the amount of orders

that I need in aggregate

to kind of hit our target for the day?

Because it's a balancing act, right?

Like I think a lot of people are like,

Facebook is not working today,

but your email might crushing

it might balance you right back out.

So I think that's something

that I would have

people consider building.

It's something that you can easily have,

like Claud build for you.

It's just have it

like pull all your last click data

and aggregate it all into Claude

and basically say,

build me a sheet of like,

what a daily outlook

could look like to hit my targets,

which is X amount of orders per day

with X amount of spend.

So we've built that for Mars.

We've now built that for hollow.

And so the biggest difference

there is the system that we'll

build for Black Friday

is basically the same thing,

but it's on an hourly basis.

So we basically trend out the day

on orders by volume.

And then we'll punch in and we'll say,

okay, an SMS is going to go out at 9 a.m.

central.

What should that do

to, to to SMS orders for that

that our

like it should pop from 100

an hour to 300 an hour.

Whatever.

I'm just throwing numbers out there.

But the biggest thing for us

now is, is truly actually

keeping an eye

on pacing to hit targets

so that our team knows

if we need to go push in another area.

If we need to go spend more on YouTube

that day,

if we need to go

move dollars over to Apple

oven or whatever.

If we're not hitting target

or if something weird happens in meta.

So,

that's kind of like our current stage

and more of the processes

that we're at at our current scale.

I would say, like

if we make it and go back to historical,

the biggest lessons are truly like

knowing how to drive that action rate up.

And I think a lot of that

comes down to like these

like unique offers that you can run these

like hourly

sales or like this day,

only you get this, which there's apps

like after sell that make a lot of that

like really easy

to just like add and integrate in.

that's kind of like the biggest takeaway

for smaller brands is

I would say like think through

what free gifts with purchases

you can do.

Some of that can even be like gift cards.

Like if you're like,

I don't know if he gives the purchase.

Can you give him a gift card?

Let's give him a $25 gift

card, that you can add in to the order

for a three hour period

or even a half day period.

Just as an extra raising

for someone,

an incentive for them to buy,

versus maybe waiting,

as Andrew said,

like through the weekend

or maybe and finding a different deal on

something like that.

The interesting thing to me,

you talking about this,

the interesting thing to me is,

is I hear you talking

about a lot of bonuses

and people are getting product

bonus, gift card

bonus, whatever

gift purchase type stuff,

and it's not as much or and

or it's like a Bogo offer.

It's not as much around raising

the higher percentage discount.

I think to me,

I feel like consumers

have been so flooded

with percentage discount

and it just feels

not fresh and uninteresting.

And a lot of them are like

a lot of brands are like,

I'm pushing to 35% off or whatever.

And it's just like, okay,

like that's cool,

but it's not necessarily

a huge incentive.

So it's I think rethinking.

That's an interesting one

in terms of what that offer

can be to really drive that through.

And the pacing thing

is really interesting.

I mean, I guess

it's it's tough

because you have to look at it

year over year by our

so much of it happens in the evening,

you know what I mean?

So I guess it's really an adjustment

for the following day

to that you might be making

are just interesting.

Don't know. Brad, what do you think.

Yeah.

I mean I'm going to

I, I've said this

and by the time that

this actually comes out

it will be recorded.

But I'm going to put together

like a video of like

last year were to do the pacing.

And part of

that is for the week of Black

Friday, it's, it's

how to do the hourly pacing sheet.

You can definitely have Cod

just help you with it, but I'll,

I'll give you a template.

You can go into Shopify,

export your numbers,

paste it into the sheet

and it'll show you exactly what to do.

But I think

something interesting in there

which kind of relates to this,

which is you're going to put together

your hourly pacing

and you're going to notice,

like there's these random pops.

And what that reminder is is,

okay, well,

what did I do during this hour

last, last year?

And then you might even find

some values in your data.

It's like, okay, well,

what could we do to fill

fill in these things?

And, you know,

maybe that's these, these moments

where you add in those,

some of those extra offers,

one little follow up on the the offer.

Do you guys edit like,

do you do anything

with the site experience

for that free gift for that hour,

or is it was it like just SMS exclusive?

Like I just wonder if

like you can

you wonder

you could add like a little bit

of like a dynamic thing

to the, to the SMS, like,

okay, the UTM passes through

and it actually shows

that you're going to get the free gift.

Like what was the

what was the site experience

when you do that?

All right, friends, quick break.

This episode is brought to you

by North Beam,

the marketing attribution platform

that we love over here

at Scalability School.

If you're a marketer,

I mean, you probably agree, right?

Incremental testing is broken.

They were.

These tests

require tons of labor

spreadsheets to reference,

and the designing of the test

is slow and error prone.

How are you supposed to know

what to test in the first place?

Right.

There's a million factors

that can make incremental

testing difficult.

But the good news is North

Beam has completely changed the game

and they fix this.

Only North Beam

incrementally automates

your incremental test

design and monitoring,

while protecting you

from the major mistakes

that plague incremental testing.

North beam builds tests

using your own MTA data,

launches them directly

in ad platforms,

and automatically

monitors them throughout.

If something threatens validity,

you're alerted before

it ruins the result.

With North Beam,

you can launch tests in platform

with a single click,

saving you tons of time

and reducing any chance for errors.

And when the

test concludes, your results

flow straight into your MTA,

meaning you can easily

see results

alongside the rest of your data.

Incrementally. Was broken.

North beam fixed

Yeah,

I think we've started to do

more of that now.

We didn't

I don't believe last Black Friday

of have any actual side experience

or push them to a URL that showed it

this year for these things like,

we very likely will have like a banner

that shows, for the hour,

we'll just like, take it up,

pull it back down.

That'll be like on the collection page

or bestseller page that we push it to.

But last year we didn't.

I know that we have since

because we've run this

same kind of strategy

like a few times

since Black Friday,

because it works so well.

But yeah, the. Yeah.

So no, we did it last year,

but we will for sure this year is

have like

the site experience

feel a bit more in your face of like

oh it's very clear

despite what you just yourself

just reading the text or the email

that got you to click through. Yeah.

I wonder if

like because the,

the scratch and sniff pop up

thing is super popular.

You know, it's like,

can you just make something like that

where it's like

instead of scratching off your gift,

it's like it pops up

and it's like revealing your free gift

and all you gotta do is click like,

oh yeah, I do want this within this hour.

I wonder if that would be

like disruptive

or actually, like,

add to the fact that,

hey, I'm getting this free gift.

It's a good idea.

I'll tell the team to like, look into it

and see if

after sell can build something like that

and they after sells does like to

to share things that brands are doing

that are working well.

So maybe,

maybe, maybe they've already,

maybe they've already done it

and they'll give it away.

The, the thing that you said, Andrew,

I just want to like,

comment back on

is the like pushing up aof comment.

I've like gone back and forth on this

a bunch.

I think that for like I,

I don't know who it was that tweeted it.

Someone tweeted recently about health

and wellness brands and like

whatever your offer is on the front end,

basically like estimated new customer

over on the front end,

if you're a subscription based business,

you can basically anticipate meta

being willing to double or triple

that as your whatever your front end.

So for example,

if you're if you're front end

new customer,

a Ovi is like $50,

you can anticipate meta to basically run

a cash at a 100 to 150 on that.

Now, based on

how many brands are in the ecosystem,

what's going on, whatever.

So I think

what's been really interesting for us

at like, Mars is

actually taking the approach

of saying, hey,

I actually don't want to push up

my front end AOV.

I want to keep it in a healthy lower spot

that has a allows

for more impulse purchases

and a lower entry point,

and that should drive

more estimated action rate with meta,

which should hopefully

then lower CPMs drive more,

better users into like our auction.

And so that's something

that's kind of changed in the last like,

I don't know,

maybe a year from my perspective.

And I'm thinking

kind of similarly

to hollow,

where historically we were like,

hey, we need to get a Ovi.

Like it was so impressive

that we had a stock company that had 128

and it's like,

yeah, we did it

because we needed the to work.

But I'm I'm now almost thinking like,

if we could have our AOF at like 75 to 99

in our CPA,

as long as conversion rates stay strong,

if we can bring our if,

if we can bring our CPA

from 50

down to 30, the amount of volume

and contribution margin we would create

would actually be

a better thing for the business.

So I do think like

this is where

testing these offers early

to see like what happens.

Is super important

because this

this completely dictated

now how we're running our offer

for Black Friday for for Mars

then was actually us

having like a lower AOV

than actually a higher AOV.

Yeah.

I mean, somebody you're

just pricing people out, right?

Like these people just

they don't want to buy three pairs

because it's actually literally

just too expensive for them.

Like it's

just yeah,

that's that's the real

this of people's everyday

spending habits.

Totally. Yeah.

It's a, it's

a, I mean, it's a,

it's an interesting conversation,

particularly during the holidays,

I think that so many people

just slap a slap a percentage off

and then, you know, that's it.

That's

when we're going to start our sale.

And I think that that works to a degree,

but it doesn't work

from a volume standpoint.

I don't know.

There's a lot more levers

to pull, around

kind of all the things

that you've ever mentioned.

So I guess another question,

I have another segment of this

is talking about creative,

which is sort of where everybody goes,

you know, what do we need?

Brad and I have talked about in

previous episodes about,

you know,

so much of it is,

as you said in the early part,

making sure the business as usual

and evergreen stuff

is running and cranking

before you start to adjust from there.

As it relates to,

you know,

looking at it from a Black Friday server

Monday standpoint,

you can certainly put banners

on preexisting stuff and run that.

And I think you want to

because Meta's going to,

you know,

respond, people are going to respond.

And meta wants you to do

put out a variety

because people are going to respond

to different pieces of this.

How do you think about the planning

of creative, of what

people are going to want based

on what has actually converted for you

in years

previous, and based on knowing

that the more variety is out

that's out there,

the more Andromeda is going to be,

you know,

helping you hopefully with more variety.

Yeah, I think it's

at the end of the day,

it comes down

to, from my perspective,

it comes down to trying to find these ads

that can

that can really break out

in your ad account

and to do that effectively,

especially if you're a smaller brand,

I think you have a higher likelihood of

trying to do that with like owners,

operators, people within the

business telling stories.

So even if it's a Black Friday ad,

like some of the best ads

that hollow has ever had

is literally me in the warehouse

talking about value props,

talking about USPS,

talking about the things,

and then also bringing in the fact

that this is like a

the biggest sale of the year

and showing the list of, of like,

Shopify orders.

Those are the ads that I think

a lot of people resonate with,

especially if you're a smaller business

and a smaller brand

that isn't as recognizable.

And you're trying to get people

to impulse buy during that period.

So, you know, if I,

if I'm a brand

that's a seven figure or low

eight figure brand,

like I am trying to shoot

as much founder

team content as possible,

trying to tell stories

that people will resonate with,

and then trying to tie in

how our offer is something unique

that is time limited.

And, you know,

they have to buy it through your website.

And you can,

you know,

if you're not on Amazon,

you can always make the claims of, like,

we're a small business

we only saw on our website.

Like,

you can do all the things to kind of try

to keep them gated in that ecosystem,

but those are the creatives

that still will absolutely smash.

So like

I haven't filmed funny enough,

I haven't filmed any ads for marksman

up until now.

I finally just filmed

like our first ad for our new product.

And I think the likelihood of

that doing well,

I, I think is actually quite high

because it's such

a genuine piece of content

and like talking about

how I'm an entrepreneur

and I'm a new dad and,

you know,

I own a few businesses

and there's just like

so much happening today

and that normal

energy drinks just, like,

aren't able to help and help me

keep up and stay sharp.

And so our new product,

which is a natural energy

and focused supplement

like, is actually accomplishing

what I wanted to do.

It's why we created it.

And so

I'm just like filming that ad like here.

Like it

literally looks like

I'm filming this podcast right now.

It just feels very organic and natural.

I don't have like a mic either.

I'm just like talking to my phone.

I think people really resonate

with that shit.

And I think if there's someone

that we want to, like,

really give shout out to,

it's like Harry over at really.

Pulley digital

has proven to me

time and time again

now made absolute bangers from ours, man.

Made absolute bangers for hollow.

Is that very simple,

like storytelling

and having a story that like is

easy to follow

but then still gets to the point

of like the final point

being this product solves that problem.

This product fills

that void, this product

does what you're looking for

are the ads that just absolutely smash.

Because I think still,

you know,

in the world of AI slop

that we're in, real

people want to buy from real people

despite being entertained

in those AI ads,

like still doing really well

for some brands.

So I think smallest brands

all the way up to the biggest,

like focus on, focus on that.

That is where I'd put my eggs is like

instead of trying to like spend

a bunch of time

coming up with a bunch of new

landing pages

or a whole new website, like, like,

skin for the for the,

for the sale period.

Like go

spend some time filming some ads,

go study ads, basically three minute

long videos

of people just talking to the camera

and telling their story.

Like, those are going to be the ads.

I think that make your holiday

and ad account just like rip.

So that's what I would double down on it.

Yeah.

I mean, you would create

I create 5000 stacks a day now,

you put them all into the account

and separate CBOs.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Are you a

you throw it on like a Santa costume.

Any and any of these coming up here,

you just you just going all Santa on top.

No pants on bottom.

That's that's the bad move.

I can't steal your your creative genius.

It didn't work.

But, you know, you could always try.

I mean,

I mean, you know,

Harry talked about this in depth

at the foxhole event

that we had in Lisbon, and he.

I interviewed him,

which is the only way

I could get him to go on stage. And we.

And we went through this,

and he's gone through this episodes

we've had, you know, with him

on scalability school

and on T to see

if we talked about it as well,

because he's kind of a

to a degree in terms of these long form.

Yeah.

And it was so interesting about it is

I think that yes, it follows a narrative.

And I think

really what these things go through

is it's so

organic, half these things

that he showed us examples

of these people sitting in their car,

and they actually hired a person

whose job they're actually trying to,

you know, emulate

the thing he showed us for a toothbrush.

And it was a dental hygienist

who does UGC

and she's like,

she's like,

does your mouth ever wake up feeling

super gross like mine did this morning?

Like I, you know, I see it all day long.

Like it was this whole,

you know, and I'm

and it's like these interesting hooks

that felt really natural.

And I watched the whole thing.

And, you know, because it just,

it captures you

because you're like, yeah, what is that?

It's interesting.

And then you get convinced over time.

And I know you guys are are aware of this

and masters of it, but I think

it's hard to it's hard

when there's

all these different options

getting thrown at you

of like statics work or high,

high production stuff works.

And I think, you know, to a degree like,

you know,

sort of the ugly eyed concept,

that's what this is in today's world.

Like,

I think ugly type stuff

sort of still can work

and depending on what it is, of course.

But I think

that this is like that version of it

for today

is what a Yapa is is

it's like doesn't have to be fancy,

it's just talking about it.

But really what it is,

is it's deeply researched, brand new

concepts that nobody else

is talking about really.

And that's really what

I think the innovation is.

It's not really the style.

It's just the fact

that it's, it's bringing something

brand new to the account.

Would you agree with that, Zach?

Like,

that's what it is,

is it's not not regurgitating things

that you're saying in other places.

These are

net new kind of ideas and ways

to talk about it

in terms of issues that it solves

that aren't being

that haven't been done before.

The best way that I can describe

kind of what's happening is

this is like the source of the week.

This is like boom,

source of the week is basically CSS

Creative strategist

taking time to do more deep research.

Meaning they're like going to go study

whatever you're selling.

Let's just even use this like

toothbrush example.

Your sign an electric toothbrush.

Going to go

figure out what dental hygiene is,

what doctors, what physicians

are talking about.

That actually is a problem

with with oral health.

And so what

what you might end up

finding is like there's

this like concept of, I don't know,

maybe it's like the

the floss isn't really where

like the magic happens.

It's where, like,

the toothbrush doesn't reach to.

I don't know that

that a dentist might say, well,

they're while they're in deep research

and they're like digging through Reddit

or they're watching YouTube

videos of doctors talking about oral,

that concept of just talking about like,

okay, it's

actually like

the reach to the back of your mouth

is where, where like the magic happens.

And then it's going to go

look and scroll through organic

to go find something really interesting

of a concept of

or of an organic video that popped off,

got a ton of use

and a ton of comments

and really resonated.

And then like

taking the two of those things

and mashing them together

and it's like, okay,

there's this organic video of a nurse

or a dental hygienist

where she's wearing,

like the crazy glasses or whatever,

and she's like talking to the camera.

And she's like,

I don't know, maybe

like there's

like something funny about it

or something unique

about this video that,

that an organic really,

really resonated with people.

It's like, cool,

go take that and then talk about that.

The issue is not the floss.

It's the fact that your toothbrush

doesn't reach all the way to the back.

Combine those two and make it a

like a real person is telling the story

about what they found out

and what they realized,

and that this toothbrush is like

the only one

that has been able to do that.

And that's like the real issue to

oral health care.

It's like, boom,

that combo

is now just going to like

absolutely break out and smash

because it's unique idea

plus unique

like filming concept combined into one.

And I think, like you can take it,

you can try to do,

you know

like a lot of

just got a brief from one of our CSI's

to like film content in my vehicle.

Because I think it's just like such

an organic, natural way.

But there's other ways to do that

that I think the organic content people,

when things just pop off on TikTok

or on, on, on reels,

they're not even trying to do it

intentionally.

It's just like something that's happening

that's interesting and unique,

and it's just like, okay,

how do I apply that to this,

like ad concept?

And then again,

merging them together

is where, where the magic happens.

That's literally what Harry's done

for us time and time again.

We still can't.

We still can't do it ourselves yet

like we're we're trying to learn

and figure it out.

But that man and that agency,

really, Polly is just incredible

at taking

those two things

and combining it together

to make make the magic happen.

So that ends that ends. Today's segment.

Source of the week.

There it is. Thank you. Sponsor. Sponsor

our sponsor.

Boom boom boom boom.

Yeah,

it's just good stuff.

I'm just gonna add one thing.

One thing that we've seen work

well off the back of

that is like taking that creator.

If they're like

a really great

representation of that demo.

And like the founder,

when you were saying

the founder thing that really,

that really resonated with me to like,

if you are,

if you are the customer or, well,

I guess, subset of your customers

as a founder

and you've got a bunch of

like really nice, like clips of you

showing the use case of it, like,

you know,

you're not a probably don't

wear compression socks from hollow,

but like, that's the example

that comes to mind.

Like, let's say you were

you were a nurse,

you were at you're on your feet all day

wearing compression socks.

Like actually you in the clip showing it

like your founder video,

then went to a landing page

that showed a bunch of clips of the USPS.

We've seen that print, like aligning

the creator video

with the page

that it's actually going to,

and just like clipping

from the actual video itself

and just like showing

it has been, really nice.

So just throwing that in there,

some random additional tip.

I was looking at your

your your latest tweets

act to see if there's anything

I want to ask you or your latest stuff,

and you're talking about

your AI character, which.

Yeah, I know what that is.

I gotta I gotta read this.

I don't even know.

This is the first

I've ever heard about this.

What is this? So

there

are so this is this

is basically what I've been trying to do

lately, is live

in the fucking zeitgeist

of the most cracked marketers.

And so you just said are running

insane blackhat shit.

And then what is happening in organic?

So what is happening there?

If you can stay up to date there,

and then you can take proper

like marketing mechanics

and just like general direct

response marketing, combine

the two together, you fucking win.

And so

there's super blockhead brands

that don't even have to be as blackhat

as they are.

That could build really big businesses

because they're so good at this thing.

So what I,

what I tweeted about

is there's these people

that are using Higgs Field

to make

what they're calling like characters.

And so they're just these

like wild looking individuals

that look real,

but they look fucking crazy,

like insane hair

with some crazy mustache

or whatever is going on.

And then they just make little storylines

and they talk about them.

So like,

there's a guy that's just like this,

like huge buff, like clearly

looks like

like a, like an action figure.

That's also like a goth.

And they like,

combine these two things into this guy

and they make a character and then like,

make him go into the real world

and just do, like, funny shit.

But like,

these videos are absolutely popping up.

So like, they've done it.

So, Sid from Toy Story,

is that his name?

Like the bad kid, the whatever.

The neighbor.

Like someone made one of Sid

like a real life Sid.

And then it's just like this,

like little shithead kid that's like,

going in, like,

causing havoc in his neighborhood.

But it looks real

because Higgs field

is absolutely cracked at, like,

making AI videos that look so realistic.

Staying ahead on

that trend is like what I'm trying to do.

So candidly,

what I'm trying to do here

is I'm trying to like,

get someone,

which I've got a couple DMs already,

and we'll see how this turns out

to make characters for our brands.

So, like, my brain this morning was like,

I really want

like a person that has like a llama

or a llama

alpaca head, but just like a person

that's just like telling stories about,

like their issues and whatever.

And like

their legs

have been swelling and whatever.

And then we'll talk about

compression talks

like work it in, Mars men.

There's a million ways

that we could go of just like

just crazy

huge Shaq dudes

to like skinny people or whatever,

but like, it's

basically taking the most forward

AI concepts and trying to, like,

loop them back in to like,

tell a story

that's actually interesting

and then ideally,

like have a product at the end of it.

So that's what's going on there.

There you go guys.

Thing is really interesting

because and Zach

you can tell Shane

if you want to cut this specific part out

but like the

the creatine bad you know like that

that like that stuff

like I've been watching

that guy's videos for three months

that I had never like

for some reason I was like,

hadn't thought like,

okay, this is the most obvious

ad angle of all time.

You just have to convert it.

And like,

that's that's like

sitting in the organic feed.

You see formats that you can adopt,

and then you just have to sprinkle

in your own,

your own product

and USP and storytelling.

Because yeah,

that, that yeah, it works.

It works. It does work.

It does work. Yeah.

It's interesting, it's interesting,

you know,

kind of the

the idea of staying ahead of it

and where the trend is

and what like how AI is.

It's just

that's like always

a constant thing that you're pushing

against in terms of trying to,

to stay relevant,

although also algorithmically

because like meta will know,

you know,

and well, what's crazy is like,

think we've made some of these

like song ads

and like some of them have worked

and it's like, okay,

why is this working so well?

Why is this convincing someone

to buy a product that, like,

you would never have thought that

this would have worked previously?

And a lot of it comes down to the story

and people resonating with the story,

despite it feeling like a,

like a Disney movie

or that, that they're watching. Right.

So and the piece that meta loves about

it is because the

watch rates are so good,

the hold rates are there.

Like people are engaging with these,

like the comments or whatever.

It's like insane.

And so despite it, even like I think

consumers seen it as potentially

even an ad right

away, like

the storylines are just so interesting

and they like,

I don't know,

like they're just very punchy.

So, I think there's something to

learn from that too.

There's I mean,

what's what's

really funny is like, where my brain goes

most days is like, what are the crazy

like, blackhat people doing?

And how do I actually make that

white hat?

Because they're the ones that just, like,

have to stay ahead.

Most of them were

like affiliate marketers

that like, needed CPAs and robes to be,

like, better than everyone else.

And so they've always

they're always like

thinking on the forefront,

but they're just not great people

not doing great business things.

But there's there's so much

to learn from that,

that I think a lot of us and me

candidly, historically

kind of just wrote off and was like,

dropshippers are just like

not good people.

And so they're probably

just their marketing probably sucks.

Actually.

It rips and they're really good at it.

They just

push the limits too far sometimes.

I mean, I can completely agree with you.

That's something that I was

I actually said

at like his dinner last week,

just somebody they were asking about.

And I, I agree

that you'll always

want to be looking for different areas

where people are innovating.

And one of the areas

is in this area of stuff.

And because,

yes, they have to push the boundaries

and that's

ultimately going to lead to innovation,

even if it's not totally like legal.

But it can be

it can be made into such, right.

So I think that is good

because there's like a hustling mentality

that those people have

that they have to stay ahead. right.

Well, gents, always good to be with you.

Always good to chat

for anybody that wants to.

Has any follow up questions

to always feel free to email

me Andrew Fox digital.com.

I can send it along to the gents

for any feedback that they might have,

but thanks for being here you guys

and hopefully you found this valuable.

And thanks for listening.

The only way

that we grow

this podcast is by

you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like reviews

kind of don't really mean

anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful,

but they don't do a lot

for the growth of the podcast.

And so sharing YouTube links,

sharing Spotify

links, sharing

Apple, whatever

we call it under the podcast app now,

anything you can share,

the better we're going to be.

Guys, anything else

you want to say on this?

Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it and then subscribe.

Make sure to subscribe on YouTube

as well.

And I relentlessly

refresh the YouTube comments

because it dictates

my mental health for the day.

So please say something

nice about all of us.

Thank you everyone.

Thanks for listening. Honestly.