MacStories Unwind

This week on MacStories Unwind, we look at silly review conspiracy theories, the negative reviews of OpenAI's latest models, and pick a couple of Apple TV shows.
Also available on YouTube here.

---

Links and Show Notes

Reviews, Embargoes, and Hot Takes
OpenAI
Anthropic and Claude
Picks
  • (00:00) - Review Conspiracies
  • (04:26) - A Mini GPT 6.2 Sol Review
  • (14:41) - Season 2 of Stick
  • (17:25) - 12 12 12

Leave Feedback for John and Federico
Follow us on Social Media
  • Federico is @viticci everywhere
  • John is @johnvoorhees`everywhere
Affiliate Linking Policy

What is MacStories Unwind?

MacStories Unwind is a fun exploration of media and more.

John: Hello and welcome back to MacStories Unwind.

John: I'm John Voorhees, and I have Federico Viticci with me. Hey, Federico.

Federico: Hello, John. How are you?

John: I'm doing great. I'm having a good day.

John: What do you want to talk about today as we lead into our picks?

John: I wanted to ask you, I guess, one thing, or at least make an observation.

Federico: Okay.

John: As we record this, yesterday, OpenAI released some new models,

John: which I think it is fair to characterize them as universally panned by the people

John: who had early access.

John: And I always get a kick out of the fact when you look on social media,

John: people are saying this must be a conspiracy because - Oh

Federico: my God.

John: Because one, everybody's negative, and two, they all came out at the same time.

John: How could that I'm amazed to this day that people

John: don't understand the concept of a review embargo?

Federico: And also the simplest concept,

Federico: the simple concept of if it's a bad product,

Federico: people are going to say that it's a bad product. But

John: no,
Federico: these people are like, ooh,

Federico: look at all these influencers conspiring at the same time to tell people that

Federico: it's a bad model. Clearly, something must be going on.

John: They must have been paid by Anthropic or something like that, right?

John: And I think it's funny because,

John: see it a little bit in our more Apple-centric world, but not as much.

John: And I mean, to give you, I mean,

John: just to like paint a picture of what it would be like if you transplanted what

John: we're seeing with OpenAI into the Apple world,

John: it would be like saying that Jason Snell and I conspired to both do good

John: review of the iPad mini and both decide at the same time that

John: the fact that it's not a ProMotion display is okay.

John: And we both said that in our reviews, right?

John: I never talked to Jason about his review.

John: I mean, the thing about this is, in part, is that people don't understand that one,

John: I think people talk a lot less amongst themselves than people think they do.

John: Because like, for instance, like with my reviews, I mean,

John: I don't really care what someone else thinks.

John: It's the question of the review is, what do I think?

John: And I think it's the same is true with all these influencers and and websites that

John: are writing about OpenAI.

John: It just, it's like, well, these people are like,

John: they're writing their own reviews and everybody who writes their own reviews,

John: there's a certain amount of ego involved that they don't really care,

John: I don't think, about what other people think if they have the confidence to write

John: their own opinion. And so it's, it's silly, I think,

John: is really what it comes down to.

Federico: Yeah. Yeah, I think this is especially a problem on x.com.

Federico: There's a lot of people just posting absurd content,

Federico: just for the exposure, and just to get the likes and the reposts.

John: I think sometimes people can't distinguish between what's a legitimate review and

John: what's a hot take.

Federico: No, and also people,

Federico: people seem to think that every reviewer is,

Federico: is on somebody's payroll.

John: Yeah.

Federico: And like, I saw one of these posts, and I sent a response,

Federico: like there was this guy saying, ah, what do we think is going on?

Federico: And I sent just a URL to the Wikipedia entry for Occam's razor.

Federico: So, Occam's razor is a philosophical principle where, and I'm simplifying here,

Federico: basically when you have a question, when you have a problem,

Federico: and a set of competing explanations to that problem and solutions to that

Federico: problem, usually the one that prevails and the one that is objectively true is the

Federico: simplest one that requires the fewer jumping points in an

Federico: argument or,

Federico: or theoretical things that need to exist for that condition to be true.

John: Yeah.

Federico: And the simplest explanation is, there was an embargo, it's a bad model,

Federico: people didn't like it.

Federico: Like, or you can conspire, and you can come up with this, you know,

Federico: movie plot behind the scenes of Dario Amodei, you know, just slipping, you know,

Federico: I don't know, a thousand bucks into everybody's pockets.

John: part of their IPO and all

Federico: this stuff. Like, look, yeah. But I'll give you this, John. All right.

Federico: So, the review is mostly focused on Astra.

John: Yeah.
Federico: 6.2 Astra.

Federico: I actually think a 6.2 Soul is not bad.

Federico: Like, I actually think 6.2 Soul for everyday work,

Federico: like knowledge work, research.

Federico: Like, I plugged it into my assistant for the app that I'm working on,

Federico: where I just ask questions. Like, what are my tasks due today?

Federico: Can you find me this MagSafe charger on Amazon?

Federico: Can you check the weather for tomorrow? Like, regular assistant stuff?

John: Yeah.
Federico: It's pretty good.

John: And... Yeah. Even before 6.2, I was using 6.1 Soul. I

Federico: 6.1 Soul a lot.

John: Same.

Federico: So, here's what I do.

Federico: For months, no, for a month,

Federico: I've been using 6.1 Soul in fast mode as a fast

Federico: secondary reviewer in T3 Code for the apps that I'm

Federico: working on. So, Opus or Fable are driving the session.

Federico: I'm using a modified version of PStack,

Federico: which is a plugin for building and verifying software.

Federico: And for every unit that I'm working on, so a unit may

Federico: be a feature, may be a bug fix, may be a redesign.

John: Right.

Federico: There have to be multiple rounds of review.

Federico: And usually, there's a first review by Opus or Fable,

Federico: and there's a second review.

Federico: And the second review, I've been running through 6.1 Soul fast mode.

Federico: And because 6.1 Soul was so efficient,

Federico: burning through the 2.5x usage of fast mode

Federico: and it allowed me to go, you know,

Federico: an entire week with these agents running 24 -7 and running these fast reviews

Federico: through Soul. And it was pretty great.

Federico: Now, this morning,

Federico: one of the other things that OpenAI announced yesterday was that ultra-fast

Federico: mode, which if you recall,

Federico: they launched with the $500 plan.

John: Right.
Federico: With DevDay.

Federico: And now, ultra-fast is also available on the $200 plan, which is what I have.

Federico: And so, I have been driving my main assistant with 6.2

Federico: Soul ultra-fast. I don't hate it.

John: Yeah. But

Federico: the problem is, OpenAI, I think, you know, to sort of sum up the current scenario,

Federico: OpenAI has a bunch of pretty good, smaller,

Federico: and efficient models that can be used with fast mode.

Federico: They don't have a true flagship big model competing

Federico: with Fable, right?
John: Right.

Federico: And even these smaller models, their main issue is that they're pretty good,

Federico: but they're not Opus 5.5 good.

John: No, they're not.

John: And to me, like, the things that, I mean,

John: one thing that I think Soul is known for is being able to do the kind of reviews

John: that you're doing. And I think that's a really good use of them.

John: I also think it's very good for just general knowledge work,

John: whether you're monitoring your email or creating tasks, you know, tool calling of,

John: you know, just productivity.

Federico: Notion, like that sort of

John: stuff. Yeah, exactly. Building an Notion page with the CLI or the API,

John: whatever you're doing, that works really well.

John: And that's why I'm still subscribed to Codex, to, you know, OpenAI's plan,

John: because I use it for that kind of stuff. And it works really well for that.

John: It's just not great for code because Astra has to be babysit a lot closer, I think.

Federico: God. Yeah. Astra is, in my experience...

John: It'll really mess up your code.

Federico: It messes up your code. It's insufferable. And apparently, like, they didn't...

Federico: things that I didn't like about Astra is that, like,

Federico: it tends to overthink and block itself.

Federico: Like, that was already an issue for me with GPT -6 Astra.

Federico: And in 6.2 Astra, it sounds like they made it even worse.

Federico: And the model talks in a weird and obscure way that is reminiscent

Federico: of Opus 5. If you recall, Opus 5 was horrible.

Federico: The way that it talked was so inscrutable and weird.

Federico: And it sounds like 6.2 Astra is now that kind of model.

Federico: So, I have been a soul person for a while.

Federico: I really liked 5.6 Soul.

Federico: I didn't like 6 Soul, but

John: they... like 6.1.

Federico: I was going to say, they fix it quite quickly, if you remember,

Federico: with 6.1. It's

John: a really good balance of quality and cheapness.

John: Like, you can get a lot out of it.

John: A lot of productivity work out of it and not run out of tokens.

Federico: Yeah. And so, similarly, just quick vibe check this morning,

Federico: I think 6.2 Soul is pretty good.

John: That's good to hear. I haven't used it much since it came out.

Federico: Yeah. So, but that's obviously not a great

Federico: predicament that OpenAI is in right now.

John: Yeah. I kind of feel like they need to have a new leap forward.

John: Like, they need to get out of the 6th class

John: and move on to 7th, you know, as soon as they

Federico: can. Or, yeah. Yeah.

Federico: Or they need to have like a, I don't know, like a major 6.5 update.

Federico: I actually wouldn't be shocked if they somehow managed to release 6.5 Astra

Federico: before the end of the year.

John: Yeah.

Federico: clearly, so the rumors were saying that they had this huge pre-train going on for

Federico: a 10 trillion parameter model.
John: Wow.

Federico: So, for context, again, we don't have exact numbers.

Federico: Fable was rumored to be that kind of like massive model approaching 10 trillion

Federico: parameters. And until a week ago,

Federico: the rumors were saying that OpenAI was trying to have this model ready,

Federico: like to catch up to Anthropic finally by December.

Federico: Usually, if you recall, John, for the past two years,

Federico: OpenAI has been doing like the week of Christmas announcements.

John: right, right.

Federico: Remember like, it used to be like the 12 days of OpenAI or something.

John: Yeah, I remember that last year.

Federico: So, maybe they'll do that again this year and maybe we'll get a 6.5 Astra.

Federico: But clearly, for the past two months, month and a half,

Federico: it has been a complete and utter Anthropic dominance.

John: Very quiet. Other than some updates to Dots, really, there hasn't been a much.

John: And they still don't have Dots in Europe and other places. They

Federico: don't have Dots in Europe.

Federico: They said that they are going to completely tear down and redesign the

Federico: ChatGPT desktop app because that launch did not go well.

Federico: And they don't have flagship models to compete with Opus and Fable.

Federico: So, it's not great right now.

John: Let me ask you a question.

John: Are you using T3 Code for like productivity work or are you the desktop

John: apps for either Codex

Federico: or Claude?

Federico: I have found myself increasingly doing knowledge work

Federico: and productivity work in T3 Code

John: as well. I have not yet. I've thought about it, but I

Federico: haven't yet. I've kind of kept in separate.

Federico: So,

Federico: since we started smelling this Anthropic comeback a couple of

Federico: months ago, I started moving my entire setup,

Federico: which is pretty portable in and of itself. It's just a bunch of skills and plugins.

John: Sure.
Federico: But I started moving my setup to Claude.

Federico: I occasionally still dip in and out of the Claude app,

Federico: which has gotten much better than

John: it used to be. I mean, it's not as chaotic as going into ChatGPT. It's

Federico: not as chaotic as it used to be. It's not as chaotic as Codex right now.

John: Yeah.

Federico: I still don't fully understand how remote control is supposed to work

John: in a lot. don't either. You look at it and it's

Federico: Like every single time I try, it's like, oh, there's a checkbox.

Federico: I think I checked the proper checkbox and it doesn't work.

John: I think it unchecks or something.

Federico: But I really... Let me give you a secret, John.

John: Okay. What's your secret?

Federico: Claude Projects, so the new projects with the main coordinator and the threads,

Federico: combined with my upcoming tool,

Federico: which is currently in beta for Club MacStories Plus and Premier members called

Federico: the Mac Remote, which is a...

Federico: It's a bridging tool that lets you use your local Mac tools like

Federico: command line utilities or MCP servers from your local Mac in a cloud agent,

Federico: such as Claude and Claude Projects, which run in a sandbox in the cloud.

John: And I think Duet works

Federico: with... Duet, same deal. That combo is lovely.

John: Yeah. I'm going to set that up this weekend.

Federico: You can have all the perks and the security of a cloud sandbox. Yeah.

Federico: And the nice design of Claude Duet or whatever

Federico: you want to use.

Federico: If you want to use Muse or if you want to use, I don't know, Codex Cloud.

John: Yeah.

Federico: You can have all those benefits, but on demand,

Federico: you can use my tool to reach down to your local Mac.

Federico: For example, if you have my Reminders CLI installed or my Apple Frames CLI installed

Federico: or any other MCP server, like you're using Paste, the Clipboard Manager,

Federico: that's on your Mac. That's not on the cloud.

Federico: You can use Mac Remote to reach down, use that specific tool.

Federico: And so Claude in the cloud can get your local Clipboard from your Mac.

John: Yeah. Which is
Federico: really combo is magic.

John: Yeah. No, that is really good.

John: I think that your timing on that app is really good.

John: And I think I told you last week that I didn't like Claude Duet and I've now

John: started to warm up to it a little

Federico: bit. I am very jealous because I don't have it.

John: Is it not available in Europe or is it...

Federico: Let me check again.

John: Because I got in, it took me a while to get in,

John: but I got in like a week or two ago.

Federico: Yeah. Look at this.

John: Oh yeah.

Federico: Look at this. Good afternoon, Ticci. No news yet.

John: Wow.

Federico: Yeah. So this was supposed to be, John, an episode of Unwind.

John: Yeah.

Federico: up... Well, sometimes we do unwind by talking about...

John: It's a little bit like an extension of what we talk about other places sometimes.

John: And I wanted to get your thoughts on this because I've been thinking about it and

John: you and I haven't talked in a while. But I think we should do some picks too.

Federico: I started season two of Stick on Apple TV+.

John: Yeah, yeah.

Federico: It's pretty good. A little bit unrealistic maybe at times. Like a little...

Federico: Some plot elements are a little bit forced.

Federico: So Stick is a TV show with Owen Wilson.
John: Right.

Federico: Who's a retired legendary golf player who had a

Federico: massive meltdown while on the golf course and completely abandoned his

Federico: very promising career.

Federico: Many years later,

Federico: he's like a shopping assistant at a tennis equipment store or

Federico: something. He finds this kid, young kid,

Federico: playing at a local tennis club and he basically insists and he becomes

Federico: his coach to coach him through the amateur junior championships.

Federico: And this kid is super talented.

Federico: Season two, without spoiling it because it was also in the trailer,

Federico: Owen Wilson, he goes back to playing golf.

Federico: And not only does he go back to playing golf,

Federico: he wants to play the entire PGA Tour and he wants to

Federico: win it. Wow. At 55 years old.
John: Wow.

Federico: And so it's a little bit forced because now the kid, Santiago,

Federico: Santi, is like he leaves him for an agency and so

Federico: he starts having this lavish lifestyle in LA. He has an agent.

Federico: And like there are... It's very enjoyable.

Federico: Like mind you, we're not hating this season.

John: Yeah,
Federico: yeah.

John: It's

Federico: just it's a little telegraphed in some parts.

Federico: And it feels a little bit unrealistic.

Federico: He as a limp and hasn't trained in years.

Federico: And now he's like, oh yeah, I'm going to win the PGA Tour.

John: Yeah.
Federico: Sure. Okay.

Federico: So I guess, I mean, if I were to guess, like obviously they're going to be rivals,

Federico: right? That's going to happen.

Federico: I mean, if the events that have happened thus far are of any indication,

Federico: it doesn't seem like the storyline is breaking any particular ground.

Federico: It's like it's the student that now becomes

Federico: the rival of the master type of plot.

John: Yeah. It's one of those shows that kind of played out its

John: theme in the first season. And now they have to come up

Federico: with a new plot line. I'm trying to say. I'm afraid. This is what Silvia said.

Federico: I'm afraid you're right.

John: Yeah.
Federico: But we'll see. It is enjoyable.

John: That's what it sounds like, at least from what you're saying.

Federico: It is enjoyable, but it's totally that.

John: All right. Well, I've got an Apple TV show for you too,

John: that I think both you and Silvia would like a lot, which is 12 -12 -12.

Federico: Oh, I've seen the banner on Apple TV.

John: Yes.
Federico: It's a heist thing.

John: Yes. Believe me, it's hard to miss.

John: It's a heist show, which is interesting to me,

John: because I think most of the heist things I've seen in the past are heist movies.

John: And this is a heist show.

John: And the whole idea about the numbers is that it takes 12

John: months to plan a heist,

John: like 12 hours to execute it.

John: And if the thieves aren't caught within 12 days, they get away with it.

John: That's like the rule of thumb that the FBI has.

John: And there's this FBI agent who's been living for months in Europe

John: trying to track down these robbers.

John: And one of them is an American guy, kind of the head bad guy, the head burglar,

John: is living in the south of France.

John: And he's got like a French girlfriend who he just found out is going to have a baby.

John: And he's living there with her father too.

John: And he's trying to get out of the world of heists,

John: which is kind of a very familiar plot line to these things.

John: But he gets dragged back in, you know, one last time.

John: Because there's going to be like almost a billion dollars worth

John: of Swiss franc notes delivered to this bank in

John: Zurich, Switzerland.

John: And so the whole thing revolves, and it jumps back and forth in time,

John: both forward and back as the heist is happening.

John: And then the FBI is trying to catch the criminals.

John: And then flipping back to like before this and earlier times.

John: And it's just really well done.

John: I mean, it's a lot of nice sets in, you know, various European cities.

John: And a lot of action feels very, I don't know,

John: feels very realistic.

John: And some unique ways that they,

John: the unique way that they break into this Swiss bank is pretty cool too.

John: So, and yeah, I mean, I, there've been a few episodes out now,

John: two or three, and we're enjoying it so far. So I, I recommend

Federico: it. Nice. Okay. Yeah. I thought about it. I saw that it was about a heist.

Federico: And I was like, hmm, I like, we, we both like heist related things.

John: I thought you did. I thought you

Federico: did. It's not creepy or anything, right?

John: No, not at all. This is much more like, if you like Ocean's 11, you'll love this.

Federico: Oh yeah. Because she was like, what is this about?

Federico: And I said like from the trailer and description, I like,

Federico: I think it's like Ocean's 11.

John: It is. It's like a group of, of robbers who are like, there's like two brothers.

John: The support characters who are, have different specialties to, you know,

John: try to break into this bank and get away with the money.

John: So it's, yeah, it's really well done.

Federico: All right.

John: All right, Federico. Well, that's it for this week's episode of MacStories Unwind.

John: You can find more about what's going on at MacStories right over at macstories.net.

John: And of course, we're on social media where Federico is @viticci.

John: That's V-I-T-I-C-C-I. And I'm @johnvoorhees.

John: J-O-H-N-V-O-O-R-H-E-E-S. Talk to you next week, Federico.

Federico: Ciao, John.