The American Record

Four months into the War of 1812, two frigate captains who once shook hands over a wager meet again at sea — and this time it's cannon fire, not a beaver hat, on the line.

What is The American Record?

A daily history podcast from Patriot Compass. Each episode explores the events that shaped America on this day in history, told through expert narration and grounded in primary sources.

Narrator:

The smoke clears over open water 500 miles south of the Azores, and a British frigate is dying by the minute. Her mizen mast is gone. Her gun crews are falling silent one by one. And from the deck of the ship that just beat her, a voice calls out across the water. Has she struck?

Narrator:

This is the American Record from Patriot Compass, one story from this day in American history. It's 10/25/1812. The War of eighteen twelve is four months old and nobody yet knows if America's young navy can stand up to the Royal Navy on open water. Captain Stephen Decatur commands the USS United States, one of six frigates Congress built from scratch back in 1794. Waiting for him at dawn is HMS Macedonian, commanded by Captain John Carden, a man Decatur knew before the war and who'd once bet him a beaver hat his ship would win if they ever met in battle.

Narrator:

Macedonian wasn't even looking for a fight that morning. She'd just finished escorting a merchant convoy to Madeira and was cruising alone, hunting American merchant ships for prizes. Instead, at dawn, she found an American warship bearing down on her. Decatur opened fire around 09:20. His first broadside went wide, knocked down a small spar, nothing more.

Narrator:

Macedonian answered immediately. But Decatur's gunners adjusted and the second broadside tore away Macedonian's mizzen top mast and dropped her driver gaff. In an instant, the British ship lost the ability to maneuver. And that was the whole fight, decided right there. Decatur knew exactly what he had.

Narrator:

His ship, United States, carried thirty two twenty four pounder cannon, a broadside of 864 pounds of iron. Macedonian carried twenty eight eighteen pounders, only 528 pounds per volley. So Decatur held his distance. He let his heavier guns do the work his crippled opponent couldn't answer. Over the course of the morning, United States fired 70 broadsides.

Narrator:

Macedonian, her rigging in ruins, barely managed 30. Below decks on the British ship, a 13 year old sailor named Samuel Leach watched American shot tear through the hole around him. Young enough that decades later, his memoir would become one of the only firsthand sailors' accounts of what a War of eighteen twelve naval battle actually felt like from the inside rather than from a captain's log. By noon, Macedonian was a dismasted hulk. She'd lost 104 men killed and wounded.

Narrator:

United States had lost 12. When Decatur's ship finally hailed the wreck and asked if she'd struck, there was nothing left for Cardin to say but yes. The two ships floated together in open water for more than two weeks while American sailors patched the British frigate well enough to survive an ocean crossing. On December 4, they sailed into Newport, Rhode Island side by side, Macedonian flying American colors over her deck. The Navy bought her outright and kept her in commission under her own name.

Narrator:

As for the wager, no record says the hat ever changed hands. Macedonian was the first British warship ever brought into an American harbor as a prize of war. Congress and President Madison praised the crew publicly because this wasn't just a victory, it was proof. A navy built from nothing in 1794 had beaten the most powerful fleet in the world ship to ship in open water. A four month old war suddenly looked different.

Narrator:

Two frigates once floated side by side healing from battle before sailing home together. And plenty of other October twenty fifths have carried their own kind of reckoning out at sea and beyond it. In 1944, the submarine USS Tang was sunk off China by its own torpedo circling back on her in one of the strangest losses of the Pacific War. In 1962, Adlai Stevenson held up photographs of Soviet missiles in Cuba before the United Nations Security Council, daring the Soviet ambassador to deny what the pictures showed. And in 1983, American and Caribbean forces landed in Granada at dawn, launching a brief but consequential invasion.

Narrator:

This has been The American Record from Patriot Compass. Come back tomorrow for another story from America's past. Before you go, if you liked hearing a naval duel decided broadside by broadside, that's the kind of story we tell every single day. This show comes from Patriot Compass, a free app with a new piece of American history each morning, plus deeper dives on the moments worth more of your time. Find it at patriotcompass.us.