Medieval Archives

Medieval Mythbusting: Mud, Misery and Other Medieval Myths

Executive Producers:
  •  Michelle Oleander
Associate Executive Producers:
  • Mari Hopegood
Medieval Archives is listener-supported and ad-free.

Become a Producer and support the show at MedievalArchives.com/support.

If medieval movies are to be believed, everyone in the Middle Ages was covered in mud, five-foot-two, drunk, and dead by 30.
But was medieval life really one long, dirty, miserable Dark Age?

In this episode of the Medieval Archives Podcast, we’re doing a little mythbusting, medieval style.

Did medieval people believe the Earth was flat? Did the Church suppress science? Did everyone die at 30? Did medieval people avoid bathing, eat terrible food, and live powerless lives under the thumb of kings and lords?

Some of these myths are easy to bust. Others contain just enough truth to survive.

We’ll look at some of the most persistent myths about medieval life, then finish with a lightning round covering bad water, Viking helmets, witch burnings, and a few more.

It’s time to separate medieval reality from the Middle Ages Hollywood gave us.

Full show notes, sources, and bibliography: MedievalArchives.com/98

Listen to A Distant Mirror by Barbara Tuchman with a free Audible trial.

Mentioned in this episode:
Episode 12: Black Agnes

  • (00:00) - Welcome to Medieval Archives
  • (01:26) - Myth 1: Medieval Women Had No Rights
  • (07:19) - Myth 2: Medieval People Thought the Earth Was Flat
  • (10:38) - Myth 3: The Church Was Against Science
  • (14:38) - Myth 4: The Middle Ages Were a Dark Age
  • (20:13) - Myth 5: Everyone Died at 30
  • (26:20) - Myth 6: Medieval People Never Bathed
  • (30:17) - Myth 7: Medieval Food Was Terrible
  • (33:14) - Myth 8: Peasants Were Basically Slaves
  • (37:10) - Lightning Round: More Medieval Myths
  • (41:04) - Conclusions
  • (41:38) - Thank you for Listening!
 <----------->
Stay Connected
Have a question, comment, or idea for a future episode?
Email: podcast@medievalarchives.com

Follow Medieval Archives on X.com | Mastodon | Bluesky

📜 Sign up for The Weekly Herald for medieval history, news, discoveries, and new episodes delivered to your inbox.

Support Medieval Archives
Medieval Archives is independent, ad-free, and supported by listeners like you.

If you enjoy the podcast and want to help keep Medieval Archives going, consider becoming a Producer.  Your support helps fund the podcast, website, research, and hosting so Medieval Archives can continue preserving and sharing medieval history. 

Become a Producer: MedievalArchives.com/support

★ Support this podcast ★

Thanks for listening, subscribing, and supporting Medieval Archives.

Chronica pergunt.

The Archivist

Creators and Guests

Host
The Archivist
Illuminating the Dark Ages for the Digital World. Podcast and website dedicated to the medieval era.

What is Medieval Archives?

The Medieval Archives Podcast explores the history, people, stories, and mysteries of the Middle Ages.

Join historian and host Gary, the Archivist, as we dig into the real medieval world, from kings, knights, popes, battles, and political intrigue to ordinary life, strange beliefs, and forgotten stories.

Each episode takes a closer look at the people and events that shaped the medieval world, separating history from legend without taking all the fun out of it.

Whether you’re a longtime medieval history enthusiast or just curious about the Middle Ages, there’s always something waiting in the Archives.

Track 1: Welcome

back to the Medieval Archives
Podcast, the podcast for

medieval news, history, and
entertainment. I'm your host

Gary aka the Archivist. Now in
today's lessons we're going to

do a little mythbusting,
medieval style. Now if you watch

a medieval movie, you'd think
everyone living in the middle

ages was covered in mud,
five-foot-two, drunk, and dead

by 30. Was that the reality
though? Was living in the

medieval era dark and miserable
time? Did medieval people think

the Earth was flat and everyone
died at 30? Was the entire

medieval world just one long,
dirty, miserable dark age? We'll

be looking at myths about the
medieval era and see if they are

true or if they are truly myths.
Now before we begin I'd like to

thank the new producers on the
show, Michelle Olyander, and

Mary Hopegood for their generous
support. And if you'd like to

become a producer and get your
name on the show, head over to

medievalarchives.com/support for
all the details. Now if you have

any questions or comments or
want to suggest a topic, send an

email over to
podcast@medievalarchives.com or

leave us a message on the
voicemail line 720-722-1066. The

show notes for this lessons,
along with any reading

suggestions, are gonna be at
medievalarchives.com/98, the #9,

the #8. All right with that,
let's start into this world of

medieval mythbustin.

Myth. Medieval women were
subservient and oppressed. Now I

grew up in a household of five
women, my mom and four older

sisters, my dad and I were
seriously outnumbered. And if I

ever told one of my sisters that
they were less than me or

couldn't do something I could
because they were a girl, I

would have been whipped by one,
and probably all of my sisters.

So let's look at this myth and
see if they would be oppressed

in the Middle Ages. Now few
ideas about the Middle Ages

feels ingrained in modern
culture as a belief that

medieval women live bleak,
oppressed lives, silent, and

powerless, confined to kitchens
and convents. It's a tidy

stereotype and great for
storytelling, but as soon as we

look deeper into the medieval
evidence like court records,

guild registers, wills, and
writings, the picture becomes

much more complex. Medieval
society was male dominated,

there's no doubt about that, but
that didn't automatically make

women less powerful. Medieval
women's experience varied and

were more dynamic than pop
culture would have you believe.

And medieval women is in a
single category, a peasant woman

in a 13th century French village
or a merchant's widow in London

or an abyss overseeing an estate,
or a queen navigating court

politics all lived under
different legal and cultural

conditions. Some women had
little power others wielded

extraordinary authority most
women lived in the middle spaces

where their rights and
limitations were constantly

worked out in everyday life.
Popular imagination says

medieval women couldn't own
property. The truth is, many

could and did, and many regions
women inherited land and managed

businesses, urban widows
frequently took their late

husband's workshops or market
stalls, continued the business

long after their husband had
died. Mediterranean cities

archived show women lending
money, suing debtors and

negotiating contracts. Even in
rural areas peasant women

weren't passive bystanders, they
managed farms when their

husband's traveler were at war,
they tenored the livestock, they

brewed ale, which was a major
medieval industry, and they

participated in local markets.
Their economic contributions

were essential in many areas
they were legally protected. And

another surprise women appear in
guild records. They worked as

brewers, silk workers, money
changers, parchment makers, even

metal workers. Some guilds
admitted women formally and

others collaborated with them
informally through family

workshops. In Paris, the
professional embroiderers

produced luxury textiles for
elite clientele in England, the

brewing trade was dominated by
women. The word brooster, which

means female brewer was
synonymous with the craft of

brewing. As early as the 14th
century, blacksmith guilds and

other male dominated guilds let
the widowed wise of craftsmen

continuing running the family
business in their husband's

place. They could register their
own marks and join the guild

roles. The whole "combival" in
the 1300s includes several

images of women blacksmiths. So,
yeah, the movie and night's tale

had it right. There were female
blacksmiths. The medieval house

was the basic economic unit of
the medieval world, and married

women often served as the
co-managers of this family. Many

contracts explicitly required
the consent of both spouses and

some courts accepted a married
woman's independent testimony on

financial matters. Now marriage
could be restrictive, but the

idea that the husband held
absolute unchecked authority

doesn't match the historic
records. Churches handled

marital disputes and sometimes
protected women from the abusive

spouse and co-urst unions. And
on the religious side, consents

weren't prisons where peasants
sent away unruly daughters, they

were some of the few
institutions where women could

receive an education, learn to
manage finances and lead

communities, avocés controlled
land, and they oversaw the

tenants. Hill-de-Garde Abinion
corresponded with emperors and

popes. She wrote theological
essays composed music and

conducted scientific studies.
Other nuns, Rand Scriptoria

produced illuminated manuscripts
and acted as advisors. For many

women, the convent offered
autonomy, unavailable in

marriage, that have control over
their daily life, meaningful

work, and they were literate.
Noble and royal women wielded

power in unmistakable ways as
well. Queens like Eleanor of

Aquatain, shaped political
alliances, commanded military

resources throughout the
crusades. Noble women acted as

regents when their husbands
traveled or died by negotiating

treaties and defending castles.
I did an episode on Black Agnes

who defended Dunbar Castle from
an English siege while her

husband was away. Agnes
commanded a small contingent of

guards and servants and kept the
English out. The siege lasted

five months until this English
finally gave up and left. And

you can find that episode at
MedievalArchives.com/12. In the

1370s during the Abinion Papacy,
Catherine of Siena wrote the

Pope urging him to move the
papacy back to its rightful home

and room. In her letter to Pope
Gregor the eleventh she wrote,

"Up father, put into effect the
resolution you have made

concerning your return. Up to
give your life to Christ. That

is what he did, and you, his
Vicar, ought to be carrying on

his work. It is expected that as
long as you are his Vicar, you

will follow your lord's ways and
examples. So come, come, delay

no longer." She was scolding the
Pope, telling him to man up and

do his duty and get his butt
back to Rome. Only her respected

woman could scold the Pope, the
highest religious office in the

land. Christine Depezon, who's
called Europe's first

professional female writer,
defended women's intelligence,

leadership, and their moral
authority. Courtly poetry and

medical writings show
participated in intellectual

life more deeply than the
stereotype suggests. Now, none

of this changes the structure's
medieval women lived in. Their

opportunities were constrained
by law, custom and religion, but

women were not the downtrodden,
subsurrient characters pop

culture would like us to believe.
They contributed and helped

shape the medieval world.

All right, here's another one.
Medieval people thought the

Earth was flat. Everyone in the
Middle Ages believed the Earth

was flat until Columbus proved
otherwise. Now, this is perhaps

the most famous myth about the
Middle Ages, and maybe the

easiest one to debunk, educated
medieval Europeans knew the

Earth was round, not flat. The
idea of a round or spherical

earth goes back long before
medieval times. In 6th century

BC, Pythagoras, the man whose
name is attached that ubiquitous

theorem we all used in algebra
class, he's credited as one of

the first Greeks to teach the
Earth was round. By the time of

his death, it was accepted by
the Greeks, the Earth was indeed

round. Two hundred years later,
Aristotle agreed the Earth was

round and used observations like
lunar eclipse to support his

theory. He noted that during a
lunar eclipse, the Earth cast a

curved shadow on the moon. Now,
travelers moving north and south

could see different stars, both
make much more sense if the

Earth is a sphere. Around 240 BC,
Aero-Thonigus, a Greek polymath,

calculated the circumference of
the Earth by comparing the Sun's

angle at noon and Alexandria,
with observations from

modern-day Aswan, where the Sun
appeared directly overhead

during the summer solstice. He
calculated the Earth's

circumference as 40,338 km,
about 25,000 miles. The current

estimate for the Earth's
circumference is 40,000-75 km,

just under 25,000 miles. And
that's at the equator. He was

off by less than 300 km, without
the aid of satellites, computers

or calculators. Let me think
about that. People can't make

change today without a
calculator and he measured the

size of a planet using shadows
cast by the Sun. All this

knowledge was passed down and in
the Middle Ages universities

were teaching Earth was a sphere.
The 8th century scholar, the

venerable bead, described the
Earth as a globe. Theologian and

scholar, Thomas Aquinas,
discussed around Earth as a

matter of accepted natural
philosophy. Dante put it in the

divine comedy when Dante and
Virgil passed the center of the

Earth, their direction reverses.
His view of Earth is definitely

around sphere. In the 13th
century, Johann to Skateraboska

wrote on the sphere of the world.
It became a standard astronomy

text in European universities
for centuries. Skaterabosko

explained how people in
different places see different

stars, and that someone high on
a ship's mass can see land

longer than someone standing on
the deck. It wasn't a shocking

new theory, it was based on
centuries of accepted science.

The myth we were all sold that
Columbus sailed the ocean blue

to prove the Earth was round is
just that, a myth. In 1492, it

was widely accepted that Earth
was round. Nobody thought

Columbus was going to fall off
the edge of the world. The real

uncertainty was the size of the
Earth. While Ayrathienius

calculated an incredibly
accurate circumference, no one

knew for sure. Columbus widely
underestimated the distance and

thought he could sail to Asia by
traveling west. A Columbus

didn't prove the world was round,
educated people knew that for

centuries. He used a smaller
calculation for the size of the

Earth and underestimated just
how far Asia extended to the

east. And he died believing he
had reached the edges of Asia.

But he never thought that he was
going to fall off the edge of

the Earth. Myth busted!

The church crushed science. The
medieval church opposed science

and kept European ignorant until
the Renaissance rescued humanity.

That was myth Conjure's images
of medieval clergy sitting

around telling everyone what to
think. In the bright, glorious

Renaissance arrives and everyone
is enlightened. Now I think this

myth persists because of Galileo
and his arguments with the

church. But Galileo wasn't in
the medieval era. His famous

conflict was with the Roman
Inquisition, not the infamous

Spanish Inquisition, and it
happened in the 17th century

long after the Middle Ages. It's
an important story in the

history of science and religion,
but it doesn't prove the

medieval church oppressed
science. After the fall of the

Roman Empire, at least in the
west, monasteries and churches

became the centers of learning.
Monks copied religious texts,

but they also copied philosophy,
medicine, history, and

literature. Now while they
couldn't preserve every ancient

book, they weren't restricted to
only copy and religious texts.

In the 11th century, many of the
Greek and Arabic works were

translated into Latin. Christian
and Muslim scholars took their

knowledge across Europe.
Aristotle was taught alongside

advances in medicine, math, and
astronomy. Knowledge wasn't

stagnant. Even in a time without
the Internet, when everything

traveled by a word or mouth,
knowledge made its way across

Europe through travelers and
trade routes. And clergy

attended and taught at the
universities, and not just

theology. They taught law,
medicine, math, and natural

philosophy, which we call
natural science today. This

church wasn't shutting down
knowledge, it was encouraging it.

Scholars like Albertus Magnus
were writing about planets and

animals. Robert Greathead, the
Bishop of Lincoln, studied the

nature of light and argued
mathematics helped explain the

natural world. Roger Bacon,
considered one of the greatest

scholars of the Middle Ages,
combined his Catholic faith with

scientific thinking. Medieval
scholars studied astronomy and

anatomy medicine, mathematics.
They developed ideas, they would

improve the astral lab, they
calculated planetary movements,

they built mechanical clocks,
and they argued over whether a

vacuum could exist. All that's
not to say that the church never

interfered with intellectual
pursuit, because it most

certainly did. Church
authorities condemned ideas they

believed threatened theology.
The condemnations of Paris in

1210 and 1277 prohibited the
teachings of more than 200

propositions associated with
philosophy. In 1210, the

condemnation read neither the
books of Aristotle on natural

philosophy or their commentaries
are to be read at Paris in

public or secret, and this we
forbid under penalty of

excommunication. But that was
only at the University of Paris.

The University of Toulouse
issued a statement saying,

"Those who wish to scrutinize
the bosom of nature to the

innmost can hear the books of
Aristotle, which were forbidden

at Paris." I like that even back
in the Middle Ages, universities

were advertising how they are
better than the other

universities, and it wasn't just
their football teams. The church

went further in 1277 and
condemned over 200 of

Aristotle's books, calling his
propositions false and heretical.

They even condemned the
teachings of Thomas Aquinas.

Saint Thomas Aquinas, the father
of the church. A man who would

become a saint and called father
of the church in the future was

somehow condemned at the time by
the church for what he was

teaching. The kind of nation's
focused mainly on ideas viewed

as heretical. While that's
pretty subjective, it didn't

shut down learning completely.
It just said these certain works

couldn't be taught. We're red.
Historians will still debate

whether some of these
restrictions push scholars to

alternatives, or if they got in
the way. But the church didn't

spend the Middle Ages
suppressing all science. In many

places, church institutions
created the schools, paid the

scholars and provided the
classrooms where the study of

nature continued. Now it's not
all black and white as they did

or did not crush science. They
did in certain aspects, but not

across the board. Myth busted,
mostly.

Is good. The Middle Ages were a
single, dark age. After Rome

fell, Europe entered a thousand
years of darkness called the

Dark Ages. This one goes back to
my tagline, illuminating the

Dark Ages. The Middle Ages
weren't dark. Science and art

and culture didn't take a
thousand year break.

Civilization didn't shut down in
476 and restart when somebody in

Florence found an old Roman
statue. In fact, the term 'Dark

Ages' didn't even come about
until the Renaissance, when

writers used it to describe the
period between classical Rome

and their era, the Renaissance.
It was used to heighten the

greatness of the Renaissance,
they framed it as the

Renaissance, was restoring a
lost greatness. I'm using the

term 'Renosaurs' loosely because
it wasn't a term until the 19th

century. Thinkers and the
Renaissance were more humanists

and wanted to revive the old
Greek and Roman philosophies.

But calling the Middle Ages the
Dark Ages was great marketing,

but the reality is much
different. The Middle Ages were

anything but depressed stagnant
society. Some of the greatest

innovations and works came out
of the Middle Ages. Some

historians use the term 'Dark'
to describe periods where

written sources are limited and
scarce, but even that doesn't

apply to the Middle Ages. When
the Western Roman Empire

collapsed, it caused major
change. Once thriving city's

shrank, politics and trade
changed, and some things

disappeared. But the Middle Ages
were anything but dark. Today,

most medieval historians shun
the term 'Dark Ages'? I still

use it. It helps identify a time
period, and it's useful term to

help debunk the myths that
surround the Middle Ages.

Instead of chideing someone for
using the term, it's a good

moment to teach them how
enlightening the Middle Ages

actually were.

In architecture, Gothic
architecture was mastered

throughout the Middle Ages, and
the term Gothic was also coined

during the Renaissance by
painter Georgesieaux Vissari. He

used it as a slur against the
style, calling it barbarous

German style. Gothic
architecture gave us some

incredible buildings like Notre
Dame, Wells Cathedral, Cannabury

Cathedral, Yorkminster, St.
Barberess Church, Flying

butchers' Pointed Arches, Rib
vaults, all allowed builders to

create enormous stone buildings
filled with light and stained

glass. Now, they weren't piling
up rocks and hoping the roof

didn't collapse. They understood
geometry, materials, weight and

the construction at an amazing
level that seems lost even today.

Now, I'd take Yorkminster or
Wells Cathedral over a lot of

the Renaissance architecture any
day. The Middle Ages also saw

the rise of the university.
Universities emerge in the 12th

century in places like Bologna,
Paris and Oxford. The University

of Bologna in Italy
traditionally dates its founding

to 1088, and it's recognized as
the oldest university in

continuous operation in Europe.
Modern baking systems got their

start in the Middle Ages.
Italian merchants develop credit

systems and bills of exchange.
Maybe one of the best

innovations in the medieval era
was the technology that evolved.

In agriculture there was the
heavy plow and improved horse

collar and three-field crop
rotation, which all helped

increase production throughout
Europe. The heavy plow helped

farmers turn the hard, compacted
clay soil to expose a lighter

nutrient-filled undersoil so
crops could thrive. The horse

collar adjusted where the burden
and weight load of the horse was,

so it transferred the load from
the throat and breast of the

horse to the stronger shoulders.
It didn't choke the horse and

allowed for heavier loads and
more endurance. And it's been

recorded the horse collar
improved the work output of a

horse by over 50%.

The three-field innovation is
still one that's used in farming

today. Farmers would use three
fields to plant crops. One field

was wheat, the fall, cold
weather crop, a second field

would be beans, spring and
summer crop, and then a third

field was left fallowed and used
for grazing animals. The next

season the fields would rotate,
and after three years each field

would hold a different crop or
was fallow. Now, the reasoning

behind this was each crop
affected the soil differently.

Using one or two field system
left the soil depleted of

nutrients and decreased the crop
production. Wheat depletes

nitrogen, beans and peas restore
nitrogen, so planting beans in a

wheat field restored the soil
for the next season. And leaving

a field fallow and allowing
animals to craze on it replenish

the soil naturally as the
animals waste would fertilize

the soil. Watermills, which had
been around for centuries, were

used extensively and adapted for
more industrial purposes

grinding grain, power in saw
mills, crushing oars, processing

cloth, and 1086 roughly 6000
mills in England alone, 6000.

Minival England was covered with
machines turning water power

into work, and hollown the Danes
used windmills for the same

purpose, grinding, crushing,
anything that would make it

easier and faster to get work
done. Eyeglasses weren't vented

in the middle ages, and if
you're like me, you're very

thankful they were. Mechanical
clocks, the magnetic compass,

paper making, all invented are
improved in the middle ages.

Then, in the fifteenth century,
Gutenberg revolutionized

printing with movable type
printing, changing the

production of books forever, and
speaking of books, this supposed

culture wasteland gave us Dante,
Chaucer, Thomas Coinus, and more.

Epic poems like Bae Wolf in the
Song of Roland, all classics

that are still red-loved and
studied today. Now, the term

"Dark Ages" put forth by the
Renaissance was purely meant to

enhance their culture and art,
while downplaying the time

before them, but in no way were
the middle ages a Dark Age.

Myth-Busted!

People died at 30. Life
expectancy was low, and everyone

died at 30. This is another one
of those persistent, sensational

facts repeated about the middle
ages. The idea that medieval

people rarely live beyond the
age of 30. It shows up in

textbooks, documentaries, trivia
books. A world where everyone

died young makes the past feel
harsh, gritty, a fantasy setting

rather than a real part of human
history. But the claim is

misleading. The medieval world
was dangerous, but so is the

world today. The idea that
people routinely dropped dead at

30 is crazy. It wasn't a form of
medieval Logan's run. It's a

myth born from a stat that
medieval life expectancy was

around 30 years old. Medieval
life expectancy was shaped by

one major factor. High infant
mortality. Not a 30-year-olds

entering the carousel for
renewal. Sorry, sorry. That's a

lot of Logan's run references.
You haven't seen the movie. Go

watch it after this. You'll
thank me later. But the

statistic most people cite. Life
expectancy was around 30. It's

technically true, but it's an
average that sounds fascinating

while hiding the real truth.
Infant mortality in the medieval

world was high. Extremely high.
It's estimated that in some

regions, 30 to 50% of infants
died before the age of 5. There

are various factors for that.
Infection, bad sanitation,

disease in general, giving birth
can be highly dangerous. But

when a large group of children
die young, the average life

expectancy drops drastically.
It's really the fault of using

an average for life expectancy.
If 50 babies are born in 25 diet

birth, so age zero, and the
other 25 lived at the age of 60,

then life expectancy is roughly
30. Even though no one died at

the age of 30, the law of
averages doesn't work in this

case. If a medieval person
survived childhood, usually past

the age of five, their odds of
reaching a mature adulthood were

good. Medieval records,
including legal documents and

monastic chronicles, repeatedly
cite adults living into what we

would comfortably consider old
age. There are numerous records

of people living in their 80s
and beyond. Archaeological

evidence shows that many people
in the medieval period lived

into later life. Skeletor
remains reveal that a

significant number reached old
age by studying features like

toothware and bone fusion, they
can estimate age at death. And

these markers consistently
demonstrate medieval burial

sites include a high population
of elderly individuals. Emperor

Justinian, the first died in 565
at the age of 83. Hope lucious

the third died at 85. Antipope,
colicis the third was 88. The

oldest pope was Gregory the
ninth and he died in 1241 at the

age of 96 years old. Charlemagne
died at 71. John, the first

support turtle at 75. Eleanor of
Aquataine was 80 when she died.

At William Amarsha, one of the
most famous knights died at the

age of 73. And he had a
dangerous job. He served five

kings. He was in numerous
battles, the Crusades,

rebellions and he won over 500
tournaments. If he can live to

be 73, anyone can. Not granted,
these were nobles and royals.

Maybe they had the means to live
longer, better food, better

medicine, better living
conditions. But the stats for

the commoners were pretty good
too. In medieval England, if a

person made it to the age of 25,
it was likely they would live to

be 50 or older. And if they made
it to 40, they could live into

their sixties and beyond. The
real key to a long life in the

Middle Ages was avoiding combat
and disease. Across the social

classes, life expectancy did
differ a bit. Pezans and

laborers had the highest infant
mortality rate due to poor diet,

hard physical labor and poor
living conditions. But those who

reached adulthood often lived in
their 50s and older. Craftsmen,

merchants, artisans, who with
stable, guild jobs frequently

lived long enough to train
apprentices, ran businesses, and

for some they could retire from
their work in the later years.

Many guild set up welfair funds
to support elderly members among

other things. Monks and nuns and
religious communities kept

careful records showing many
monks and nuns living in their

60s or 70s and beyond. Communal
living, regular meals and less

physical strain probably helped
contribute to their longer life

expectancy. We listed the
various nobles who lived in

their 70s and 80s, but better
access to food, better medical

care, which I suppose is the
better leeches for bloodletting,

and better living conditions all
contributed to longer life spans.

Now it's hard to pinpoint why
people died young in the middle

ages, but really it's not much
different than today. War,

malnutrition, accidents, disease
injuries, disease and injury are

the ones you could do little
about. Disease like typhus,

which is spread by lice,
smallpox, dysentery, all could

be deadly without modern
medications. They had no concept

of antibiotics, they couldn't
treat gangrene or tetanus or

other infections. It was the
lack of the medical advancements

that really took its toll. All
that shortened lives, but it

didn't limit the natural human
lifespan. They simply meant some

people died younger, not that
everyone was dead at 30. So what

is this myth keep going? Well
for one, it sounds dramatic,

sane, middle of what people died
at the age of 30 is shocking and

sticks in your mind. And another
reason it boasts our modern ego,

we're not much better than those
in the Renaissance believing

medieval people had miserable
short lives makes our world

appear more advanced by
comparison. And maybe the real

reason this mist still persists
is Hollywood pop culture loves a

dark gritty dirty medieval
setting movies, games, novels,

they all tend to present the
middle ages as filthy and brutal,

a shorter lifespan reinforces
that image. Living in the middle

ages wasn't all rainbows and
butterflies, people faced great

health risks with fewer medical
tools, people died young, but

those who survived into
adulthood could and often did

live long full lives. The middle
ages was full of elderly

grandparents, wise old scholars
and old monks. The idea that no

one lived past 30 says more
about our modern misconception

than medieval reality. myth
busted.

Many people never bathed,
everyone stank and no one ever

bathed. This is also another one
perpetuated by Hollywood. They

want to make sure you know a
movie is set in the middle ages

everyone is covered in mud, even
the king is dirty, the castle is

dirty somehow the candles look
dirty. It's like a washed face

and clean clothes would destroy
historical accuracy. Actually,

making more accurate. The
popular version shows medieval

people wearing the same old
shirt day in day out, never

taking a bath only getting clean
when it rains on them. Many

people did bave, they wash they
use soap, many towns and public

bath houses. One of the greatest,
I'll be it built by the Romans

is in the town of bath, or maybe
it's Bob as I was reminded

multiple times when I was there,
guess what? I'm an American,

it's bath. Sorry, a little bit
of tangent. Now did they take

hot showers every morning? No,
they didn't have the modern

plumbing, no hot water tanks or
12 kinds of body wash in the

shower getting a full bath took
work. Somebody had to draw the

water, carry it, heat it, fill
the tub. That limited how often

people took a full body bath. It
didn't mean they never were

clean. People commonly wash
their hands and faces even when

a full bath wasn't practical
hand washing before and after

meals mattered because people
often ate with their hands.

Monasteries built La Vatoria
communal washing areas placed

near the refectory so monks
could wash before eating.

Medieval household inventories
include basins, pictures, towels,

cones, people wash clothing and
linens, soap made from fats were

known and produced. Well, the
households had wooden tubs in

private rooms and filled them
with heated water. The tubs

could be lined with a cloth and
sometimes meals were even served

while someone bathed. Poor
people used basins, river

streams, simple tubs and
whatever water was available.

Now medieval towns across Europe
had public bath houses. Bath

houses offered warm water steam,
but they also had food, drink,

conversation and sometimes
entertainment. Some became

associated with prostitution,
but brought them under moral

suspicion and government
regulation. But here's the point,

town governments and church
authorities wouldn't spend time

regulating bath houses if no one
was bathing in them. Bathing

also paired in medical writings,
physicians recommend a bath at

different temperatures for
different conditions. Some of

the reasons came from the
humoral theories, but they

treated bathing as a normal part
of health and body care.

Medieval people cared about
appearance and smell, clean

clothing, washed hands, combed
hair, and pleasant breath

mattered socially. They didn't
understand bacteria, but they

all had noses and can smell.
While people were somewhat clean,

the cities weren't always clean.
A medieval person could value

personal cleanliness and still
live in a town with serious

waste problems. Animals moved
through the streets, butchers,

tanners, and diars produced
unpleasant waste. Chamberpots

had to be empty, and usually in
the streets until it was

regulated. Wells could become
contaminated, license fleas were

common. Now cities could be
gross, some were extremely gross.

Country living wasn't
automatically clean, though,

either, especially living around
livestock, manure, and standing

water. Medieval towns did their
best. They passed laws about

dumping waste, maintaining
drains, protected water sources,

and they even employed people to
remove trash. Now the laws

weren't always follow because
people are people, but it tells

us that they recognized the
problem. Public bath houses

declined in some places during
the late middle ages. Moral

concerns and a fear of disease
played a role, especially during

the Black Death. But later
bathing habits were then

projected backwards across the
entire Middle Ages. So was a

medieval town fragrant and fresh
like a modern hotel lobby?

Probably not. It probably
smelled like bad cheese and feet.

But did medieval people go to
their entire lives without

touching soap or water? Also no.
They washed as often as they

could. So the entire medieval
population wasn't covered in mud

and dirty clothing for a
thousand years.

Food was bland and spices hid
rotting meat. Now this myth has

always been a little confusing
because it makes two opposite

claims at the same time.
Medieval food was supposed to be

bland and tasteless but it was
also buried under so many spices

that nobody could taste the
rotten meat. So which one is it?

Is it no flavor or is it too
much flavor to hide the meat?

The truth is, medieval food
varied enormously by region, the

season, and by religion. A
peasant family and a royal court

weren't even the same meals. A
fishing village ate differently

from an inland manner. Lent
changed the menu completely and

the harvest changed what was
eaten or what could be eaten.

And money definitely changed
what you could eat. For many

people, the daily diet centered
on bread, potage, and ale. Now,

potage was a thick stew made
from grains, peas, beans,

cabbage, whatever else was
available. And people ate cheese,

eggs, fish, meat was less common
for poor households, but it

wasn't completely absent. Bacon
and salted pork would stretch

throughout the year. Local herbs,
garlic, mustard, onions, added

flavor, a diet built around
grain and vegetables could

become repetitive, especially in
the winter during a shortage.

But that doesn't mean it was
bland. Medieval cookbooks call

for the use of pepper, cinnamon,
cloves, saffron, and sugar. Meat

might be served with fruit,
sugar, vinegar, sauces, mixed

sweet sour and savory flavors in
different combinations. Spices

carried prestige because they
traveled long distances and they

cost serious amounts of money.
Serving a heavily-spiced dish

showed your guests that you
could afford pepper or cinnamon

or saffron, and that it took an
enormous amount of labor to

produce. And that's why the
rotten meat claims fall apart.

If you were wealthy enough to
buy cinnamon or saffron, you

were wealthy enough to buy fresh
meat. You didn't spend a fortune

on imported spices to pick up a
roadkill on your way home.

Spices also can't make rotten
foods safe. They might cover up

part of the bad taste or the bad
smell but the meat is still

rotten. You would just have
expensive rotten meat that

tasted like cinnamon. Medieval
people knew how to preserve food.

They weren't refrigerators, but
they salted, smoked, dried, and

pickled meat and fish. Animals
were often slaughtered and

cooler whether to help preserve
the meat. Fish could be dried

and packed in salt, grains,
beans, and onions were stored

for later use. Food still
spoiled. There was no way around

that. Markets had dishonest
sellers butchered try to pass

off bad meat, but even today
they try to pass off bad meat.

When you see it on sale for 80%
off and it looks nasty and brown,

there's a reason for that low
price. Now there were laws

against selling disease or
putrid meat. The laws showed

that people recognized rotten
meat and didn't consider it

acceptable. Bad food could be
confiscated, destroyed, and the

seller find or publicly shamed.
Spices were used because people

like flavor. Because medical
theory assigned them useful and

because they displayed wealth
and status. Medieval food could

be plain especially for the poor.
But it could also be rich,

colorful, and aromatic. Now the
one thing it wasn't was a

thousand year conspiracy to hide
rotten meat under pepper.

Peasants were powerless surface
with no rights. When popular

culture needs a medieval peasant,
we usually get someone standing

ankle deep in mud while a noble
rides pass looking at them

disparagingly. Peasants had no
property, no rights, no voice.

Their only purpose is to hand
over everything he grows, get

kicked by someone armor, and
remind us how awful the middle

ages were. Peasant life was hard.
Lords had real power, surfed 'em,

placed serious restrictions on
millions of people, but not

every peasant was a surf, and
even unfree tenants usually had

customary rights. Peasant is a
broad description for rule

people, who made most of their
living farming from agriculture.

Inside category were surfs, free
tenants, farmers, and dozens of

other regional categories. A
surf might owe labor, rent, fees,

and obedience to a lord. He
might need permission to leave

or marry outside the manner or
transfer land. And those

obligations could be heavy and
true and sometimes humiliating.

But a surf usually had a
recognized place in the village

community, and had claims
protected by custom. Medieval

rural life ran on custom. A
family might hold the same strip

of land for generations. The
lord was owed rent and labor,

but he couldn't always rewrite
the agreement whenever he wanted.

Tenets claimed rights to pasture
animals, and used communal land

and inherited holdings and
access to local resources. These

weren't modern civil rights.
They were local, unequal and

dependent on status. The record
show land transfers, inheritance,

village regulations, peasants
who sued their neighbors who

defended boundaries and
complained about the officials.

Women even appeared in these
court records too, inheriting

land and pursuing debts. Local
tenants served on juries and

helped state the customs of the
manner. The court belonged to

the lord. It wasn't an
independent Supreme Court for

peasants. The lord still had the
advantage, but the court created

a record and it established the
obligations ran in more than one

direction. A lord who ignored
custom could face lawsuits,

organized resistance, or lose
the cooperation is a state needs

to function. Many of the daily
decisions were made at the

village level. Communities
decided when the common fields

would be planted in harvested,
where animals would graze, how

roads and ditches would be
maintained, and who had broken

any local rules. Peasants
negotiated labor, they exchanged

land, they borrowed money, they
brewed ale, they raised animals,

and they did all this alongside
their farming. In peasants

weren't equally poor, some
accumulated enough land to

employ their neighbors. Others
had barely enough to survive.

When negotiations failed, the
peasants resisted, they withheld

labor, they ignored regulations,
they moved away, and they used

common land without permission
and acted together to defend

customary rights. Then they had
rebellions, the jackery erupted

in France in 1358. The English
rising in 1381 brought rebels

into London. They attacked
officials, destroyed legal

records, and demanded an end to
surf to an oppressive lordship.

The English revolt failed in the
short term, its leaders were

killed and the king withdrew his
promises, but the revolt

terrified the ruling class and
it showed how much power

ordinary people could create
when they acted together. The

black death changed the balance
too, with labor in short supply

workers demanded higher wages
and better terms. Governments

tried to freeze wages in
restrict movement, but passing a

law doesn't magically create
workers who died in the plug.

Many surviving peasants found
new opportunities to bargain,

move, and acquire land. This
isn't a story of medieval

freedom. Peasants paid rent,
they paid taxes and ties, they

endured hard labor, poor harvest,
and demands from people above

them, unfree tenants faced
restrictions that would be

intolerable today, but powerless
people don't bring lawsuits,

they don't negotiate customs,
and they don't manage village

resources or bargain for wages.
And they certainly don't march

into a capital demanding the end
of surfdom. Peasants lived under

an unequal system, but they
weren't people with no rights or

voice. "Meth busted, mostly."

That takes care of the big miss,
but we're not done yet. There

are plenty of more hanging
around and some of them are just

too good to leave alone, so
let's have a little lightning

round them miss. And one of them
is medieval people drink alcohol

because the water was polluted.
You've probably heard this one

before that they drank al and
wine all day because it was

safer than water. Well, that's
not entirely true. They did

drink a lot of al, both adults
and children. It supplied

calories and nutrients and it
had better taste than the well

water, but this wasn't the al we
drink today. In fact, today it

would almost be considered
non-alcoholic. The everyday al

that was given was around two
percent alcohol level. The small

al given to children was under
one percent, but medieval people

drink water too. They used wells
and springs and even collected

rainwater, town governments
protected water sources and find

people who polluted them. They
almost drink in part of everyday

life. It wasn't the only liquid
keeping Europe going, but it was

the preferred drink. Everyone
was short and malnourished.

Nutrition affected height,
famine and childhood disease

left real marks on medieval
bodies. Some populations were

shorter than modern averages,
but medieval people weren't a

separate race of tiny humans.
Average height changed by place,

class and century, and well-fed
medieval adults could stand eye

to eye with modern people, or
taller. So if you went back in

time, you wouldn't automatically
be the tallest person in the

village. It's not like going
over travel, or you just be a

giant among the population.
Vikings wore horn helmets. I

like this one, but no, Viking
warriors didn't normally wear

horn helmets in the battle.
There's no good evidence for it,

and horns would make a helmet
heavier, awkward and easier to

grab or strike. The imagery,
largely from 19th century art

and theater costumes, especially
productions of Wagner's operas.

So Vikings didn't wear horn
helmets, but opera and Haggar

the Horrible made sure that they
would wear them forever. Knights

were immobile tin cans. Now
we've seen the scene, and knight

falls over in his armor and
flails around like a turtle

while somebody runs to help him
up. A well-made suit of armor

was articulated and spread
roughly 50 pounds across the

body. Now that's heavy, but
modern soldiers carry as much or

more, and most of that weight
hangs from their shoulders in a

rucksack. Knights could walk,
run, climb ladders, mount horses

and fight in their armor,
surviving fighting animals show

armor men wrestling, rolling and
getting up from the ground.

Fighting an armor was exhausting,
and he could become dangerous,

but a knight wasn't a mobil tin
can. If he couldn't move, he

wouldn't survive very long in a
battle for people trying to kill

him. Witch burnings were a
medieval obsession. This one

seems like it should be true,
but the truth is that medieval

world didn't spend the entire
period burning witches at the

stake. Medieval accusations and
executions for harmful magic

happened, especially near the
end of the period, but the large

European witch hunts peaked in
the 16th and 17th centuries,

long after the Middle Ages. And
not every accused witch was

burned. Execution methods varied.
In England convicted witchens

were mostly hanged. So yes,
medieval people believed in

magic and feared harmful sorcery,
but the familiar mass witch

panic and burning them at the
stake belongs much more to the

early modern period than the
medieval period. Chastity belts

were common. The classic story
says a crusader locked his wife

into an iron chastity belt
before leaving for the Holy Land.

There's no reliable evidence
that this was normal or even

happened. The best known early
illustration appears in a 15th

century manuscript, and it's
believed it might be satire.

Many physical belts displayed as
medieval artifacts were made

much later, sometimes as a joke
or as a curiosity or a 19th

century fantasy. And if you
think about the practical side

for a minute, wearing an iron
device locked to your groin for

months would cause injury and
properly infection. It would be

less a guarantee of chastity and
more of an extremely complicated

way to kill somebody. The
medieval chastity belt tells us

more about the later fantasies
concerning the Middle Ages than

it does about the actual Middle
Ages. That's going to end our

look at the myths about the
Middle Ages and a few extras

that we threw in and the
lightning around. The medieval

world could be violent,
unhealthy, and unforgiving.

Women face legal restrictions,
search authorities, sometimes

restricted ideas, and children
died at heartbreaking rates. But

the myth takes these real
hardships and stretches them

until a thousand years of
history becomes one dark, dirty

joke. Medieval people ran
businesses, they studied the

stars, they built cathedrals, it
took baths and sometimes lived

long enough to become the old
man telling everyone how much

better things were when he was
young. Now you can find all the

sources and additional for this
lesson at the show notes at

medievalarchives.com/98. And if
you like one of those books you

can get a free audiobook through
Audible by going to

medievalarchives.com/freebook.
You have to sign up for a free

trial but you can cancel any
time and that free audiobook is

yours to keep. I use Audible all
the time, my kids use it, it's a

great service. If you're
enjoying the podcast the easiest

way to support is to tell your
friends. And if you're listening

on your smartphone you can send
them a link right now. And if

living in any value from the
show considering support

medieval archives with a
financial donation, it helps

keep the show and the website
add free and full of great

content. And there are some
great donation options you can

do 1066 which is big this year
for the William the Conqueror

fans or 1485 to commemorate the
Battle of Boswars. Or you can

pick any amount visit
Medievalarchives.com/support to

make your contribution. Thanks
for your time and thanks for

your continued support. That's
going to wrap it up for this

week. And thanks again for
subscribing and listening to the

Medieval Archives podcast
illuminating the Dark Ages for

the digital world.