Protrusive Dental Podcast

🦷 Plaque Friday™ is here!

Get 20% off Protrusive Guidance Ultimate for as long as you stay, plus 7 days free to try it. That’s every masterclass, AskJaz, verifiable CPD on hundreds of podcast episodes, and our new live series Caries, Cracks and Contact Points with Dr Ronit Patel. Use code PF26 at checkout. Ends Monday 30 November, 11:59pm UK.
👉 https://protrusive.co.uk/plaquefriday

How good is your consent for orthodontics — really?
More adults are having ortho, and more GDPs are providing it. So which risks should you be discussing with every single patient — and which ones depend on the person in the chair?
When a case is heading for a big overjet or a tricky rotation, is that a conversation you have at the start, or one you scramble to explain halfway through?
And what actually makes a consent form legally valid — the signature, or everything around it?
This episode brings together two perspectives you don’t often hear in the same room. Dr Zaid Esmailis a specialist orthodontist and founder of the Online Orthodontic Academy, who mentors GDPs through fixed and aligner cases. Dr Neel Jaiswal returns for the dento-legal view — he’s a dentist and the founder of Professional Dental Indemnity (PDI). Together with Jaz, they get very specific about what individualised consent looks like in practice, and how to build a process your patients remember and a court respects.
 https://youtu.be/YvsiIiX1Q1w 
Watch PDP273 on YouTube
Protrusive Dental Pearl: Make Your Patient Feel Unique
It might be your 100th, 500th or 1,000th case — but for the patient in the chair, this is a significant event. Never forget that. A routine extraction is routine for you; for them it’s a big deal, and remembering that makes you a better communicator.
To make a specific risk stick, make the patient feel unique. Point to their OPG: “Your sinus here is actually really interesting,” or “Did you know your roots are unusually long?” Patients remember a risk framed as if they’re a special case far better than a generic warning. Make it personal, and the consent becomes memorable.
What You’ll Take From This Episode
The whole episode turns on one idea: generic, templated consent is no longer defensible — the skill is individualising the form to the patient in front of you. Premium members get the full breakdown; here’s the shape:
  • The layers of valid consent — consent is like an onion; a signed form and a documented conversation each cover a gap the other leaves open.
  • Individualising risk from the records — how the OPG and photos turn a generic warning (resorption, devitalisation, recession, relapse) into a patient-specific one.
  • The two-appointment consent flow — records, individualised risks, thinking time, and why you sign or initial every line.
  • The Class II Div 2 overjet trap — the case that looks like simple crowding and ends in a big overjet, and how to consent for it before you start.
  • When to treat, add an option, or refer — the GDC line on offering all options, and building alternatives into the form.
Highlights of This Episode:
  • 00:00  Teaser
  • 01:01  Consent in Orthodontics: Why It Has to Be Individualised
  • 02:59  Protrusive Dental Pearl: Make Your Patient Feel Unique
  • 07:58  What Makes Orthodontic Consent Different
  • 10:08  How Much Ortho Litigation Comes From Consent?
  • 11:53  What Makes Consent Valid and Patient-Specific
  • 12:26  Individualising Ortho Risk from the OPG
  • 13:11  Using the ClinCheck as a Consent Tool
  • 14:40  How to Structure the Consent Appointment
  • 15:30  Root Resorption, Devitalisation, Recession and Relapse
  • 19:37  Should You Initial Every Line of a Consent Form?
  • 21:50  Midroll
  • 27:11  Building a Multi-Layered Consent Process
  • 29:31  Consenting for Fees, Relapse and Retainers
  • 34:41  The Class II Div 2 Overjet Trap
  • 37:51  When Should a GDP Refer an Ortho Case?
  • 40:31  How to Learn Orthodontics with Mentorship
  • 47:01  Outro
Dr Zaid Esmail is a specialist orthodontist. He founded the Online Orthodontic Academy to teach GDPs orthodontics — assessment, diagnosis and treatment planning across fixed appliances and aligners — with one-to-one case mentorship. He’s extended a 10% discount to the community with the code PROTRUSIVE.
👉  Online Orthodontic Academy — online ortho mentorship, fixed & aligners, Level 7 Diploma
Dr Neel Jaiswal returned for the dento-legal perspective. He’s a dentist and the founder of Professional Dental Indemnity (PDI), which introduces dentists to insurance-based indemnity cover.
Request a Quote for Insurance and Get £100 off
👉  Professional Dental Indemnity (PDI) — insurance-based dental indemnity
Want more?
If you enjoyed this episode, check out: Consent Is Like An Onion – Are You Consenting Your Patients Correctly? – PDP113
Tags
#PDPMainEpisodes #OrthoRestorative #Communication 
Listen, Subscribe, Earn CPD
Listen: Subscribe to the Protrusive Dental Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube.
This episode is eligible for 0.5 CE credit via the quiz on Protrusive Guidance.
This episode meets GDC Outcomes A
AGD Subject Code: 565 Documentation & Risk Management 
Aim & Learning Outcomes
Aim: To help dental practitioners obtain valid, individualised consent for orthodontic treatment — identifying the risks that apply to every patient, tailoring them to the individual, and structuring a consent process that is both comprehensible to the patient and defensible in law.
Learning Outcomes — by the end of this episode, dentists will be able to:
  • Describe the elements that make orthodontic consent valid and patient-specific, including the material-risk standard and the role of reasonable alternative treatments.
  • Apply a structured, multi-layered consent process — individualising risk from the clinical records and documenting the discussion — to an individual orthodontic patient.
  • Identify the case types and clinical situations that warrant additional consent, an alternative option, or onward referral to a specialist.

What is Protrusive Dental Podcast?

The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast

SEO METADATA

SEO TITLE:
Consent in Orthodontics Should Be Individualised | PDP273

META DESCRIPTION:
Orthodontist Dr Zaid Esmail and Dr Neel Jaiswal on individualised ortho consent: key risks, aligner pitfalls, layered consent and avoiding complaints.

URL SLUG:
consent-in-orthodontics-individualised

PRIMARY TOPIC:
Individualised consent for orthodontic treatment

SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Orthodontic risks to consent for
- Aligner complaints and removable appliances
- Root resorption and devitalisation in orthodontics
- Using ClinCheck as a consent tool
- Retention, relapse and future costs
- Class II division 2 overjet after alignment
- Alternative options in GDP orthodontics
- Medico-legal record-keeping for consent

CONSENT IN ORTHODONTICS SHOULD BE INDIVIDUALISED
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP273
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUESTS: DR ZAID ESMAIL AND DR NEEL JAISWAL

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Dr Zaid Esmail, a UK specialist orthodontist, and Dr Neel Jaiswal, who gives the medico-legal perspective, about how to consent patients for orthodontic treatment. Jaz shares how he lost vitality in his lower incisors after ortho as a teenager, and doesn't remember being warned.

Zaid explains what makes orthodontic consent different, including compliance and lifelong retention, and how he individualises risks such as root resorption, devitalisation and recession using the patient's radiographs and photos. He describes his two-appointment consent process and why he uses ClinCheck as a consent tool. Neel explains why removable appliances generate more complaints than fixed, and why a signed form needs to be backed up by notes of the conversation. They also discuss Jaz's three-layer aligner consent, putting future costs in writing, the Class II cases that catch GDPs out, and two sections to add to any ortho consent form. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to make your patient feel unique when explaining risk.

IN SHORT

This episode explains how to make orthodontic consent specific to each patient, rather than relying on a generic form. The key points are to identify each patient's individual risks from their records, discuss consent over more than one appointment, record the conversation as well as the signature, set out future costs, and always include alternative options and likely compromises.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

- Jaz's pearl: make patients feel unique, for example by pointing out their long roots, so they remember the risks.
- Neel says removable appliances account for around 15 to 16% of complaints to the Dental Complaints Service, compared with about 3% for fixed.
- Zaid individualises risks like root resorption and devitalisation using the patient's OPG, photos and trauma history.
- Zaid treats the ClinCheck as a force-movement table, not an outcome simulator, and shows patients what he thinks he can achieve.
- Zaid consents over two appointments, spending 20 to 30 minutes on the discussion, and repeats retention advice near the end.
- Neel recommends initialling each line or page of the form, and noting the patient's own questions in the records.
- Setting out future costs, such as replacement retainers and relapse, avoids disputes and makes goodwill gestures more valued.
- Add "alternative options" and "considerations and compromises" sections to ortho consent forms, including referral to a specialist.

QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE

1. What makes consent for orthodontics different from other dental consent?
2. Why do aligners generate more complaints than fixed appliances?
3. How do you individualise orthodontic consent?
4. Should you use the ClinCheck to consent patients?
5. Is it enough for a patient to sign a consent form in the waiting room?
6. Should you tell patients about future costs such as relapse and retainers?
7. Which orthodontic cases catch general dentists out?
8. What should an orthodontic consent form include?

IN THIS EPISODE

1. Introduction: why orthodontic consent needs to be individualised
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: make your patient feel unique
3. Meet Dr Zaid Esmail and Dr Neel Jaiswal
4. What makes orthodontic consent different?
5. Why removable appliances drive complaints, and keeping consent valid over time
6. Individualising the risks: root resorption, ClinCheck and devitalisation
7. Zaid's consent process: two appointments and the risks he covers
8. Annotating, initialling and note-taking: why you need both the form and the conversation
9. Jaz's three-layer aligner consent
10. Putting future costs in writing: retainers, relapse and goodwill
11. Where GDPs get caught out: ClinCheck traps, the hidden Class II and alternative options
12. Building the ultimate orthodontic consent form
13. Learning orthodontics with mentorship, and where to find Zaid and Neel

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: WHY ORTHODONTIC CONSENT NEEDS TO BE INDIVIDUALISED

JAZ:
Isn't orthodontics just wonderful? I find that ortho, whether I do it or refer for it, helps my patients so much in my tooth wear cases. I think 70 to 80% of my tooth wear cases would benefit from some pre-restorative orthodontics.

It's been great over the last two decades to see the boom in adult orthodontics and GDP orthodontics. But because more adults are having ortho, and more GDPs are providing it, we really need to talk about consent. How good is your consent for ortho?

I used to think there were so many different camps, dogmas and opinions in restorative dentistry and occlusion. Then I was exposed to the world of orthodontics, and oh my goodness, it's a whole new level of different beliefs, opinions and camps. We're not going to go into all of that, but we are going to go very deep into the consent conversation you need to have with your patients.

What's an appropriate level of consent? What are some common things GDPs may be missing? I'm joined today by Dr Zaid Esmail, a UK-based specialist orthodontist, and our good friend Dr Neel Jaiswal returns to the podcast to give the medico-legal perspective we need.

Look, a lot can go wrong in ortho, the biggest point being managing your patients' aesthetic expectations. There are different risks for different movements, and some movements are less predictable. Aligners versus fixed appliances has its own conversation.

Then there's loss of vitality. Guys, I lost vitality in all four of my lower incisors from ortho. I don't think I was warned. I don't remember it, and I was about 13 or 14 at the time.

It's a very rare risk, but it happened to me, and I've seen it a few other times in my career. So there are lots of rare things, and lots of common things, that we need to discuss with our patients. But the crux of this episode is individualised consent, and it guides you on how to do that with your own patients, ultimately so your patients are better informed, you sleep better at night, and you avoid litigation.

CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: MAKE YOUR PATIENT FEEL UNIQUE

JAZ:
Now, every PDP episode we give you a Protrusive Dental Pearl. Today's pearl is a reminder that whether you're doing a wisdom tooth extraction or an orthodontic case, it may be your 100th, 500th or 1,000th case, but for your patient, this is a significant event. Never forget that. Even a routine extraction is only routine for you.

For the patient, it's a big deal. The more we remember this, the better we'll become at empathising with our patients, and I think our communication will benefit. And tying this in with the topic of this episode, talking about risk, consent and things that can go wrong, one way I really like to communicate specific risks is by making my patients feel special.

Now you're thinking, "What does that mean? Make them feel special? Do you sing them a song or something?" Well, if it's their birthday, I might. But jokes aside, let me give you an example. If I'm removing an upper first molar, we know a routine risk is an oro-antral communication.

For some people it's more of a risk than others, depending on the radiograph. When I see someone at slightly more risk, medium or high risk, I make them feel special. I point out where their sinus is on the OPG and say, "Hey, your sinus is actually very interesting. Did you know your roots are really long?"

You see, that kind of language, "your sinus is interesting", "your roots are interesting", is something patients remember. I've observed over my career that patients really do remember and recall information when they've been made to feel like a special case, a little bit different. Not unusual, but unique.

That's a good word. Make your patient feel unique. It makes whatever you're telling them as part of consent really memorable. So remember, guys: it might be routine for you, but it's special for your patient. And if you want your patient to really recall that risk, make them feel unique.

Let's now join the main episode. I'll catch you in the outro.

CHAPTER 3: MEET DR ZAID ESMAIL AND DR NEEL JAISWAL

JAZ:
Welcome back, Dr Neel Jaiswal, our resident medico-legal dude, and dentist of course. And Dr Zaid Esmail, orthodontist?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yep.

JAZ:
It's great to talk about consent in orthodontics. Neel, we'll come back to you second, 'cause we know a lot about you. You're a veteran. Zaid, tell us about yourself and your background in orthodontics. What got you into moving teeth around?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah. I've been a specialist for 10 years now. I remember doing work experience in dentistry, doing a bit of orthodontics, and actually quite enjoying it.

Then at undergrad it was very poorly taught where I was, and that kind of put me off again. When I qualified, I did VT, and my trainer did a bit of orthodontics, so I got into it again, quite enjoyed it, and just went down that route. I knew I wanted to specialise. I needed that focus of the next stage, and I liked the idea of working in practice as a specialist.

I like being busy in practice, and I've never been a huge fan of the hospital system, and orthodontics lends itself to that very, very well. So yeah, I've been a specialist for 10 years now, based in the South East.

JAZ:
If you'd asked me at 18, when I was applying to dental school, where I wanted to be, I didn't want to be a dentist. I wanted to be an orthodontist. And I wish I'd done that, 'cause I'd be driving a nicer car. So, talking of nice cars, Neel, remind us about yourself for those who haven't listened to the podcast before. What do you do, who are you, and who do you represent?

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Sure. My name's Neel Jaiswal. I've been in practice for about 30 years, in private practice. Before that, NHS. Before that, maxillofacial. Before that, Australia. So I've been around a bit.

I started an indemnity company that introduces dentists to brokers and insurers, which is going really well. I know, Jaz, you're part of it, and Zaid, you're part of it too, so thank you for your support. What we really want to do is this: you see distress and difficult times on D4D and so on, on Facebook, every day, and we want to reach out to those people, help them and put an arm around them. And for our existing members, we want to foster really good, ethical dentists who do the right thing, protect themselves and have a wonderful career.

CHAPTER 4: WHAT MAKES ORTHODONTIC CONSENT DIFFERENT?

JAZ:
Well, Neel, thanks so much for connecting me with guests like Zaid, who really help with the medico-legal side. Some of those episodes have been brilliant discussions, about when aesthetics go wrong, or consent in different areas of dentistry. And today, orthodontics is a huge one, 'cause, Zaid, I'll tell you something, mate.

When I had ortho, no one warned me that my lower incisors could lose vitality.

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Oh, okay.

JAZ:
And they did. So I'm just saying, it's rare, but it does happen. I'm sure it's not the first time you've heard of this, right?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah, yeah.

JAZ:
So do you see what I mean? It happens. No one warned me. But it's one of those things. Maybe it was written somewhere, I don't know. So I really want to get into this. Obviously I have no hard feelings. As a dentist, I understand that things happen. It wasn't the orthodontist's fault, I hope. It's one of those things.

But we need to stay safe. So the purpose of this episode is: how can we make sure GDPs out there are consenting appropriately? Not only so that patients understand more and get more from it, and the right type of patient goes ahead with treatment, but, more importantly, so we stay out of trouble.

So the first question is: what elements of consent in orthodontics may be different from general consent?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yes. I think the key thing with orthodontics is that there are a few things. One is that compliance is a heavy factor. If you're doing aligners, or even fixed appliances with elastics, and retainers afterwards, the patient has to be on board.

If you're doing a filling, there's no compliance involved, 'cause the patient sits there and you get on with it. But with orthodontics, there's compliance with cleaning and compliance with coming to appointments. That's a big factor. And we also know the risks associated with orthodontics.

Orthodontics is quite non-invasive compared with other parts of dentistry, but there are risks associated with it. The common mistake is to think, "Oh, it's just braces. We're just moving teeth. What can happen?" So it's knowing what the actual risks of the treatment are.

There are some well-documented risks. Thankfully, some are preventable, and the more severe ones are much rarer. But it's important to discuss them with the patient, and like everything else, it comes down to risk versus benefit. You mentioned your lower incisors.

I suppose my question to you is: if you'd known you would lose vitality in your lower incisors, would you still have gone ahead with the treatment?

JAZ:
Yeah, absolutely. My problem was a huge one, so I would definitely have had it. But my own personal scenario is an example of consent in orthodontics: "Hmm, no one ever warned me about that."

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah. And that's the difficult thing. We see it all the time. We've had that conversation with patients and explained it to them, and they come back at the next visit and say, "What was that again? What do I do about the retainers?" or, "What do I do about this?"

Patients don't retain all that information, and I think that's a key factor. The other thing with orthodontics is that we're seeing our patients quite regularly, so there's a chance to reinforce that consent. When I talk about retainers with patients, I talk to them right at the start of the-

CHAPTER 5: WHY REMOVABLE APPLIANCES DRIVE COMPLAINTS, AND KEEPING CONSENT VALID OVER TIME

JAZ:
Look, Neel, Zaid's already mentioned that there are unique aspects of consent, which we're going to get into. I'll ask Zaid what we should be consenting every single patient for, and how we know which patients to talk to about losing vitality in their teeth, or whether it should be every patient. I'll get into those nuances.

But Neel, from your medico-legal perspective, what percentage of the pie in terms of litigation does orthodontics represent, and what percentage of that is perhaps related to consent?

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
That's a very good place to start, so your listeners will pick this up: removable appliances are actually a really big risk factor in complaints. Anything removable. Fixed is very low, something like 3%.

It's really low. But removables are about 15 or 16% of complaints to the Dental Complaints Service. And I think there was maybe 100-

JAZ:
Why do you think that is?

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
There's an aesthetic need, they're adult patients, and maybe there's less focus on function. I always stress function.

JAZ:
Compliance, as Zaid said. Compliance.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Well, my patients are functional patients. "And by the way, it'll look better at the end." But your teeth are in the wrong place, so I always go for function, and my patients value functional health. But if your practice has a younger audience, it's cosmetic, and that's really subject to variability. And it's more than crowns, and more than implants.

The nice thing is, if you're doing a lot of aligners, it's quite easy to get your consent down pat. It should be the same thing every time: these are the risks. And the other difficulty, which I'm sure Zaid will touch on, is that the patient might have signed that consent form two years ago.

I was just thinking yesterday: is this something we should be sending to patients every year, or every nine months? "By the way, we started a long while ago. Here's the consent form you signed. We just wanted to make sure nothing has changed from your point of view, or whether you have any further questions as we progress." Just to keep that consent valid over time, which is very difficult.

The other thing is that valid consent has to be pertinent to the patient. So you need a bit of social history initially. Why do you want it done? What are you expecting? Can we meet your needs? Are you a professional singer? Are you on TV? We now have to consider all those little things, the material risk to that patient, not just to a general patient.

CHAPTER 6: INDIVIDUALISING THE RISKS: ROOT RESORPTION, CLINCHECK AND DEVITALISATION

JAZ:
Well, you mentioned valid consent. So, Zaid, for your patients, what makes your consent valid? There are some general things we might warn any orthodontic patient about: the risk of resorption, the risk that some rotations will be difficult or incomplete, the risk of temporary joint changes and the bite feeling unsettled during treatment.

And pain for the first few days of wearing fixed appliances, for example. How do you make sure all these general things become valid and unique for that individual?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah. I think that comes down to assessment and diagnosis. For example, one of the risks is root resorption, and we know patients with shorter roots, blunt roots, or long, spindly roots are more likely to have root resorption.

So for every patient, we take an OPG before we start treatment and look at those risk factors. "You've got really long roots, so even if you get a little root resorption, chances are it won't be an issue for you." Or, "This tooth in particular has quite long, spindly roots, so the risk of root resorption will be higher on that tooth."

So then we're individualising our consent for that patient. With aligners, we know certain movements aren't as predictable. It's picking that up from the start: "That lower canine is quite rotated. I don't know if we can fully line it up."

As a specialist, I can put a fixed brace on to get that bit right. And I wonder, about what Neel was saying earlier about removable appliances, whether it's because the ClinCheck can look very, very good. As a dentist, if you don't know that, you can be lulled into a false sense of security, 'cause a ClinCheck is essentially a force-movement table, not an outcome simulator.

I've seen plenty of ClinChecks where it looks like you've got the perfect result, but any computer simulation can show that. It's about knowing what you can actually translate to the patient and saying, "This is what we can get to." I use the ClinCheck as a consent tool. If patients have different options, I run two different ClinChecks, but I don't set them up the same way.

The ClinCheck I set up for the aligners is actually different from the one I show the patient, because the aligner ClinCheck is about the forces on the teeth needed to get that end result. The end result is what I show the patient: what I think I can get to. So it's having that knowledge, being able to impart it to patients, and using it as a consent tool. I think that's really useful.

Similarly, we know devitalisation is a risk of orthodontics, but we know the risk is higher if they've had previous trauma. So if the patient has a history of trauma, we can warn them that-

JAZ:
Is devitalisation on your form, Zaid? Obviously I'm personally interested in this one.

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah, yeah.

CHAPTER 7: ZAID'S CONSENT PROCESS: TWO APPOINTMENTS AND THE RISKS HE COVERS

JAZ:
Tell us where it fits into your appointments. You have your consultation, then you send them a letter or whatever. Tell us your flow. At what point does consent happen? Do they come back, and you present to them and go through the form? How does consent work as a system in your practice?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Sure. When they come in, we take records, give them an idea of what the plan will be, and talk about the risks, more the individualised risks for that patient. So if they have periodontal disease, maybe we talk about black triangles, or, if it's active periodontal disease, we have to get that sorted.

Once they're dentally fit and ready to go, we bring them back and talk through the treatment plan and the consent. Doing it over two appointments, where you're almost repeating yourself the second time round, gives them a chance to think about it in between.

Then we go through the full consent process. It's all written down, and we go through it verbally as well. And it's the same risks discussed for a lot of our orthodontic patients: root resorption, with a higher risk if they've got spindly roots; and decalcification, if they have poor hygiene.

If they had poor hygiene, we probably wouldn't get that far in the process, but we'd still have to warn them. And again, that's a preventable risk if their oral hygiene and sugar intake are under control. Devitalisation: we mention that if you've had trauma in the past, you're at higher risk of devitalisation.

Relapse is a big one, so we talk about retainers from the beginning, and about the different retainers available, fixed and removable, advising that it's really lifelong. Relapse happens in different ways. There's periodontal ligament bounce-back, but we also know teeth naturally move throughout life.

They become more crooked as we get older, and everyone's very different in that sense. So if you've done treatment, and two or three years down the line the patient suddenly stops wearing the retainers and a tooth moves, that may not be true orthodontic relapse.

It could be physiological tooth movement. But from the patient's point of view, relapse is relapse. The tooth has moved. So it's advising them that they're in it for the long haul with retainers. Then there are things like recession. If the patient already has some recession and we're treating them non-surgically, we've got to advise them that the recession could get worse.

So again, it's tailoring it to the patient. And on treatment failure: if we don't get the result we want for whatever reason, or if compliance wanes halfway through, we've got to know when to say, "Now is the time to stop." If a patient develops decalcification during treatment, do we carry on, stop at that point, or change the endpoint?

With root resorption, if they're at higher risk, the guidelines say we take an OPG nine to 12 months into treatment. If we see more root resorption on that OPG a year into treatment, it's having the next conversation: do we carry on and risk further root resorption, or change our end goals to reduce the amount of root resorption going forward?

So it's really tailoring it to the patient, having it all written down, and making sure they're fully happy before we begin. From my point of view, I think orthodontics is quite low risk compared with anything else. It's less invasive. And a big factor is that we get to know the patients.

We see the patients every six to eight weeks, so we almost become friends with them during that time. When you build up that relationship and rapport, you're less likely to get complaints at the end, if you've done things properly and treated them like a family member or a friend.

And obviously we explain the stuff about that first week, the brace rubbing on the cheeks and so on. So it's a full appointment just discussing it. But I'd also discuss it at the first appointment, because you don't want to go that far and have the patient say, "Oh, absolutely no way, I'm not having it for that reason." Like I said, the big risks are root resorption and devitalisation. Thankfully, they're very low risks, but they are higher in a certain percentage of patients.

JAZ:
So is this essentially all on your consent form? You sit in front of the patient, go through each point, and make it bespoke: "In your case, that's less of a concern. This one's more of a concern for you. This one's lower risk."

But you're covering all of it. Have I got that right? Is that what a typical appointment looks like, and how many minutes are dedicated to this consent discussion, with the form in front of you both?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
It's usually about 20 minutes to half an hour, so at least 20 minutes, and it goes over if needed, because I think it's important the patient is fully aware before they proceed with treatment. I also have a treatment coordinator who goes through it as well, and the correspondence usually comes from her, so if they have any follow-up questions they can say, "Oh, can I just ask a quick question?"

We always tell them that if there are any issues, they should let us know before we start. It's a very important process, and it's about having everything at the start. And patients will still forget it. Near the end of treatment, I'll talk about retainers and they'll say, "What are retainers?"

And I'll say, "We've discussed it all." So two or three appointments before we finish treatment, I'll reiterate what we do about retainers in the long term. Several points have to be repeated for patients to retain the information.

CHAPTER 8: ANNOTATING, INITIALLING AND NOTE-TAKING: WHY YOU NEED BOTH THE FORM AND THE CONVERSATION

JAZ:
I was once given a very good tip about consent. It was specifically for wisdom teeth, but it can be applied to anything, and I certainly do it. When I go through a consent form, I squiggle on it, draw on it, highlight, star things, and cross out things that aren't applicable. I like that, because it's proof that you made the consent more valid. It stops you skipping something, and it allows you to make it more bespoke. Is that something you do as well, Zaid? Do you annotate or draw? How do you get your patients engaged in the process?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah. I've got the consent form in front of me, but I'm not reading it out word for word. It's a conversation with the patient. The consent form is just a guide to make sure I don't forget anything.

For example, I've got a big screen in my surgery, and I'll put the OPG up. Say they've got short roots: I'll point to the roots I'm concerned about. I'll point out that this tooth has a root filling, and we want them to know the risks of that, or that there's been trauma to this tooth.

And the patient's photos as well. I'll get the photos up if there's anything related, and say, "Actually, I don't know if we can get this tooth moved here, for whatever reason," or, "There might be more recession here." So it's visual, as well as spoken, as well as written. And that's a good question. I might start doing that.

JAZ:
Neel, I used to work in a clinic where, let's say a patient was booked in for a root canal with me, which I don't do much of anymore, thank the universe.

The patient would be handed a clipboard with a three- or four-page consent form all about root canals. They'd read it by themselves, sign it at the end, then come in, and I might gloss over it a little. But that was their consent.

Early in my career, I decided, "Okay, I don't think that's how consent is best done." I might be wrong. But what do you think about clinics that, instead of going through it with the patient like Zaid does, say, "Here's your consent form. Please sign"?

And then the patient sits in the waiting room with the clipboard, reading and signing it. Is one consent more valid than the other, or in a court of law are they equal? Doing it Zaid's way, going through it with the patient, takes longer and is more involved than sending them to the waiting room so you can see the next patient while they read and sign.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
It's a good question, Jaz. I think one follows the other. With oral surgery, say, you're talking about eights. We have a list of all the things that can go wrong: paraesthesia, OAF, whatever. I might cross out OAF if it's a lower, and paraesthesia if it's an upper.

So I'm annotating it, like you said, but we also get them to sign, or initial, each line. The reason is that we've seen cases where someone signed the back of a page but not the front, or page two or three, and then said, "Well, I never saw pages one and two. I just signed this page."

JAZ:
Wow.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
The smallest little thing can make or break your day. So I like them to sign at the bottom of each page, so they've seen the page. For us, with oral surgery, it's a one-page thing, and it's tick, tick, tick. For ortho, I'd prefer something like: retention has to be lifelong; compliance has to be there.

You might need edge bonding afterwards. There might be residual spaces. There's a risk of relapse. And they sign it all. You might annotate a little, like you do, but it's really followed up with notes saying, "We went through the consent form, and a discussion was had. No more information was requested. The patient asked these questions."

And I'd write down what they ask, 'cause it's really personal. "Will I still be able to have my coffees?" or, "Can I take it out when I'm on a call?" That really makes it unique to that patient, because you've really had a chat, rather than just having a signed form.

A signed form on its own can be pretty useless, but it's a really helpful adjunct, and it leads you into the next conversation. I also write down: why do I prefer this option? What are the risks of not doing it? What's the chance of success: low, moderate or high? Have the costs been given? Risks versus benefits.

So I'd get everything signed, then have the conversation about the consent form and add your personalisation to the record. Or your nurse can write it while you're talking, as Zaid's team would do. I think you need both. With one on its own, they might say you didn't get the consent form signed.

Without the other part, they might say the patient didn't understand the consent form. So it's better to be safe and have both.

CHAPTER 9: JAZ'S THREE-LAYER ALIGNER CONSENT

JAZ:
Okay, I like that. I'm going to make myself vulnerable here with both of you, 'cause this is how I do my Invisalign consent, and you can tell me if I'm not doing it well. Honestly, I'm that type of guy: I'll change it.

And don't say it's good just 'cause you're on this podcast and I might not publish it. I'm just kidding. Here's the thing. I go through the consent with the patient in the chair, covering the more pertinent points, like whether they've had a history of trauma, and the main points I think are applicable to them.

As you may know, and Neel knows for sure, I voice-record all my consultations. As Raj Rattan said, consent is like an onion. There are many layers to it. One layer is me having that verbal conversation. The second layer is that it's recorded, including the patient saying "uh-huh" and "yes".

Then I send them a YouTube video of me going through the 15 points I've come up with: "This could happen to you when you're wearing aligners." I email them that video and say, "Mrs Smith, for you, point two is a bespoke thing: you're actually low risk for this. And point nine is very pertinent for you, because of what we discussed. Please reply when you've seen this video."

Then I wait for that email. That's my third layer: an email saying, "Oh yes, I've seen it. That was a very good video. Thank you." Critique it.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Excellent. You're doing what we said, but in a better way, because it's not just written notes. You've got the audio, you've got something visual, and you've checked they've received it. 'Cause you might send them something and they say they never got it. So you're waiting for them to say, "Yes, I received the video. Thank you." I think that's excellent. You've got consent, a visual element, feedback on it, and they've had the opportunity to think about it. I think that's pretty gold standard, Jaz.

JAZ:
Zaid, anything to add?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
The only thing I'd say, and I'm sure you do it anyway, is that it should include something like, "If there's anything you don't understand from these points or the video, let me know, and I can explain it further." Sometimes patients feel under pressure just to say, "Yeah, that was good."

JAZ:
That's true, it's a good point. I think it's in my template, but it's a good point to make sure we give them time to think about it and ask questions.

It's a very good line to put in anything you do, even when voice recording: "Have you got any questions about this?" It's important to make them understand they're welcome to ask questions. That's a very good addition.

CHAPTER 10: PUTTING FUTURE COSTS IN WRITING: RETAINERS, RELAPSE AND GOODWILL

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Jaz, and Zaid as well, do you include anything like: "The fee for this is £4,000. If you don't wear your retainers and need new ones, there's a fee for extra printing. If there's relapse because of this, we'll redo the ortho at a 50% rate"? Are you pre-empting them saying, "Oh, this has happened. Are you going to do it for free?" Are you setting them up so that, if there is a failure, they know what it will cost them?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
I have a costing sheet as well as my consent. It lists the treatment options we've discussed and the cost of each one. With my costs, I try to cover everything, and I include retainers for my private patients, including Essix. I'm using dual retention for everyone.

We include a two-year guarantee on those, so any problems with the Essix or bonded retainers are covered. We normally replace broken Essix retainers within a year, and we'll sort out the bonded retainers within two years. That's what it covers. We don't say everything is covered, and there's a line saying any further treatment will be an extra cost.

But to be honest with you, if a patient comes back with relapse within three, four or five years, especially in an Invisalign case, where a lot of mine are Comprehensive, so you've got five years, I'll just do it free of charge, as a practice-builder, for the sake of a sectional fixed or a few extra aligners.

I've only had to do that a couple of times, where they'd broken a bonded retainer, a tooth had moved, and they hadn't come in. It's for the sake of less than half an hour's chair time to get that patient in. So I say there will be a cost, but a lot of the time I'd waive it. I'd still say-

JAZ:
I think that's a great point, Neel.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Sorry, Jaz.

JAZ:
I just want to say I'm definitely going to change this and add it in. 'Cause I do it for my veneers. When I do veneers, which I'm not prolific in, it's, "Hey, first we'll check you're happy with the shade before we bond them.

"Once they're bonded, they're in place. Should you change your mind afterwards, that's completely fine, but the replacement cost is £800 per veneer," blah, blah, blah. It's all in there, the ifs and buts. But I don't do it for aligners, and I think that's a great point, so I'll add it in. But you were saying, sorry.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
So again, the cost: if the bonding is chipped, how much is a new wire? 'Cause I've replaced a few wires, and I never know how much to charge. So I think you should do it, Zaid. But what I'd do in your case is say, "As per our terms, we'd normally charge £2,000 for this, but you've been such a great patient.

"You've come regularly, and you sent Mrs Jones from next door to me. I'm happy to do this for free." That's an even nicer thing for them, because they realise you're doing it out of goodwill, because of your relationship, rather than just, "Oh, it's free."

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yes, I do bring that up. It's usually reception who have that conversation.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
There's more value in it if they know. And I think it's safer for everyone, the patient included, because when they break something, or when an implant fails, for example, they often come in angry, because they're expecting a big cost: "I've just spent £4,000." Then you have to calm them down.

If you've already told them, "Your implant is covered for two years, don't worry, and after that, this is the cost," it sets the tone before they come in. People worry about the cost, or what it's going to take, or whether they'll have to have an argument with someone, because they may not be used to dealing with nice people like Jaz and Zaid.

They might be used to dealing with dodgy builders, where you have to have an argument every time. So set out the case: these are our fees, this is what the future may cost, and we generally have a lot of goodwill. That makes it clear for everybody, I think.

CHAPTER 11: WHERE GDPS GET CAUGHT OUT: CLINCHECK TRAPS, THE HIDDEN CLASS II AND ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS

JAZ:
I want to follow on from that. Zaid, in your education space, you teach dentists orthodontics. What worries dentists when they're doing their first few aligner or fixed appliance cases?

What complications do they run into that make them think, "Did we consent for this appropriately? How do I manage this now?" Those hairy moments, if you like.

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Yeah. Let's split it into fixed appliances and aligners. The big issue with aligners is that the ClinCheck looks so simple. It looks like you've got a great result, and people assume there's an orthodontist at the other end setting up that ClinCheck. But, like I said, you can make teeth move in any direction on it.

So you don't know what's going to happen during treatment. That's one aspect. The ClinCheck can lie, if you like, and you can be lulled into a false sense of security. There's always that worry: have I got the right attachments here and there?

And with aligners, when the patient comes back, it's a bit of an unknown. Did I plan the tooth movements correctly, or has the patient not been wearing them? That's why I tell dentists who are starting with aligners to do everything as Comprehensive.

If you do it as a Lite, you might get away with it, but then you run out of aligners. What do you do then? If you're starting out, the worst-case scenario is just doing another refinement, and another, and another. You're not out of pocket.

You're not trying to persuade the patient, "Well, you've got to pay for an extra refinement now," or, "Oh, the teeth look fine. Don't worry about them." You just keep going, and you'll learn from it. The big issue with fixed appliances, which came about from the whole Six Month Smiles thing quite a few years ago, is the focus on anterior alignment.

Anterior alignment is a perfectly reasonable treatment modality in some patients. The issue is the underlying Class II case, the underlying Class II division 2 case, where the patient looks like they have crowding. Suddenly you line them up and they've got a stonking overjet. And you haven't warned the patient about that overjet.

I'd do the same treatment. The difference is I'd have anticipated it and said, "Actually, when we line them up, you're going to have a big overjet. Do we take out upper fours? Do we accept the overjet? Or do we not do the treatment, or do surgery?" The classic adage is that if you say it at the start, it's consent.

If you say it halfway through, you're making excuses for yourself. So it's picking up from the start which cases you know will end up with an overjet. And I think the worst ones are the Class II division 2 cases with contact on the teeth. Suddenly you've retroclined the teeth.

Suddenly they lose contact, and those lower teeth are now biting back on the palate. So now you've created a traumatic bite for the patient, and you hadn't picked it up at the start. The only options then are jaw surgery, extraction of fours, or lots of IPR to bring them back.

If you haven't got the knowledge to do that, or you didn't know it from the start, what's the next conversation with the patient? It's going to be a referral to an orthodontist. Who pays for that? You've lost that trust. And, more worryingly, the dentist then loses confidence.

So again, it's picking it up from the start. On a lot of my courses, I provide mentorship. We pick up these cases from the start and know what they are, so the dentist can consent the patient appropriately. It's knowing where we're going to go, and managing the patient's expectations.

So, in this case, you're going to end up with a 7mm overjet. The problem is the patient doesn't know what a 7mm overjet is. So I'll do two ClinChecks: one showing what the teeth look like when they're forward, and one showing what it would look like if we took out upper fours.

With some of those patients, I'll say, "Okay, we'll start non-extraction. You're going to end up with a 7mm overjet. If you don't like it, we can take out upper fours and bring them back." Then the teeth are straight, they can see them and say, "Oh, actually, I don't mind it," or they choose to take out the upper fours.

The problem is, if you're a dentist doing just a few aligner cases or simple fixed cases, what do you do then? You can't offer that. So is it a referral halfway through treatment? Do you have an orthodontist you can refer to who'll take it on?

But if you've picked it up from the start, or you have the knowledge to treat extraction cases with proper mentorship, that's one way around it. I think that's the biggest thing. You always have one or two cases where dentists get their fingers burnt. It's the classic Dunning-Kruger effect: at the start, you think you know everything, and it's all going really well.

Then one case burns you, your confidence goes down, and you realise you don't know what you don't know. When you see a ClinCheck, it lulls you into a false sense of security. I think that's the issue with orthodontics. And that's why I come back to Neel's earlier point about there being more complaints about removables. I wonder whether that's the reason, because I talk to some dentists and say, "Oh, do you do any aligners?"

They say, "Yeah." I ask, "What about fixed appliances?" And they say, "Oh, no, I didn't think I could do fixed appliances as a general dentist." And I think, well, if you're doing aligners, what's the difference? Orthodontics is orthodontics. As far as the GDC is concerned, you're moving teeth, so you need a full assessment and diagnosis.

You need to be able to give the patient all the treatment options. If you don't know what all the treatment options are, should you be doing the treatment at all? If all you're offering is Invisalign, and another treatment option is extracting all four premolars to camouflage that Class II, but you're not offering that, and you're not offering fixed appliances...

Even something as simple as, "I could do aligners here, or I could refer you to a specialist for this." That's absolutely fine if you don't want to take on those cases yourself. But it has to be in the consent form as an alternative option. Does that make sense?

CHAPTER 12: BUILDING THE ULTIMATE ORTHODONTIC CONSENT FORM

JAZ:
Makes perfect sense. And this episode has come at a good time for us, 'cause in the Protrusive community we're actually collecting everyone's consent forms.

Hundreds of dentists are sending in their consent forms. We're picking one topic at a time and creating essentially the ultimate consent forms. I go through them, and Xyra and Krissel go through them, and these are all dentists. Then we put them through AI, then Alex, our manager, who's a non-dentist, goes through them, and then we put them through AI again to ask, "What are the holes in this consent form?"

What I've gathered from what you just said, Zaid, is that everything we've said so far is good, but there are two extra sections we could add to the consent form we're building in our heads, and release from this episode. One is alternative options, so you squiggle on it, "This could be done, but by a specialist." That acts as an aide-memoire to remind GDPs to offer fixed appliances if they're not doing them, or an onward referral.

The other could be called "considerations and compromises". Like, "Look, this is a consideration: we can do this, but you might end up with a big overjet," and explain it that way. Or, "A consideration of this approach is that we might be able to get 80% correction of this rotation.

"It's probably unrealistic to expect perfection. If you're looking for more, you probably need fixed appliances. Is that okay with you or not? The best time to find out is now." So we'd have those two sections. Neel, any reflections on the ultimate consent form, or consenting in general?

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
As we said, the consent form is part one of a two-part conversation, or the video, so that should be clear to anyone using it. I also think there should be some sort of date stamp on the consent form, because in a year things will change. In two years, progress and technology will have changed.

Risks may change, and we might handle things a bit differently. The consent form isn't valid for 50 years, for example. So I'd just put a little medico-legal proviso: this is a guide, not the absolute, and it should be updated regularly.

CHAPTER 13: LEARNING ORTHODONTICS WITH MENTORSHIP, AND WHERE TO FIND ZAID AND NEEL

JAZ:
Okay, that's interesting. You've covered everything I wanted to cover on consent, and there are lots of takeaways for us to have the right kind of discussions. I want to give you a moment to tell us more about what you do and how we can reach out. Firstly, Zaid, you teach and mentor dentists. How can we find out more about your programmes? What do you teach? Fixed appliances or aligners?

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
I set it up earlier this year as a fully online, remote platform teaching orthodontics. Whether you do aligners or fixed appliances, we go through assessment and diagnosis, and treatment planning.

So even if you don't consider doing a case yourself, you know what to look out for and what the alternative options are. We cover fixed appliances and aligners, all aligner platforms. We're not tied to one aligner company over another.

But the key thing is the mentoring. I think that's what sets it apart. It's not just the course. The course is fully online, so you can watch the videos when you need to and go back to them as many times as you want. But the best way to learn is by doing.

On the online platform, you put photos up in a secure space, and there's a conversation back and forth: "Okay, this is a suitable case, and the plan will be fixed appliances, non-extraction." Then the dentist does it, takes photos at the end of the appointment and puts them up, so each case has its own thread.

Then I'll say, "Right, great," and give them feedback on bracket position or ligation, and on the next stage, from start to finish. Go back to our dental school days: how did we learn to do a filling? We had a supervisor on clinic who checked every visit.

For an orthodontist, the actual fitting of appliances and the adjustments are straightforward. We have orthodontic therapists who've done one year of training, going from being a nurse to treating patients, who've never been in a mouth before. Dentists are used to etching, bonding and sticking things to teeth. It's all in the planning, and in doing efficient mechanics.

With the aligner side, we go through the ClinCheck and assess it. It's not like a ClinCheck service, because first we're checking whether the patient is appropriate. We'd know from the start, "Okay, we know that lower three isn't going to rotate." And if they need a sectional fixed appliance at the end, that's already covered.

So there's no reason you can't put a sectional fixed appliance on at the end if the patient isn't happy. It's not a treatment failure. We know there are limitations with aligners. We know they're very good at certain movements and not others. But the key thing is picking it up from the start.

So you consent the patient: "Right, either we do it all with fixed appliances, or we do as much as we can with aligners, and anything that falls short, we may be able to mask with a bit of bonding, or we can put a fixed brace on for a few months at the end." And let them decide. If you're able to put the sectional fixed appliance on yourself at the end, it's much easier.

There's no worrying about how much the orthodontist will charge, and all that back and forth. So it covers that, and it covers retention. And with aligners, it's not a ClinCheck service. If the case is suitable, we go through the ClinCheck together.

And when they come back for refinements, and on the consent forms you were talking about, it's all covered from start to finish. It's onlineorthodonticacademy.co.uk, and I'm the person who mentors everyone, so I get to know what level each dentist is at.

Then I can personalise my teaching methods to each dentist. I get an idea of each dentist's level, and know what treatments they're capable of. I think with proper mentorship, there's no reason most dentists can't do most cases, really.

JAZ:
I think mentorship is part of the culture in implants and orthodontics especially, and it should be in all other parts of dentistry as well. We're trying to change that with a platform called Intaglio, where we welcome mentors to do more active mentorship. And orthodontics really lends itself well to that.

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
I'm happy to offer 10% off all our mentorship platforms and the course, with the code PROTRUSIVE. You can log in and request a code straight away. And because it's fully online, you can start at any point. There are no cohort intakes.

The mentorship starts from the beginning. You can even do a diploma in orthodontics, a Level 7 diploma, to give you that extra accreditation. Again, all done online and remotely.

JAZ:
Amazing. I'll put that in the show notes, and thank you for extending a discount to the community. I have no financial interest in it, but I always like to give my community a good deal.

Neel, before we wrap up, my friend, please tell us how people can get in touch, because you're so connected in this space. The only reason I'm with PDI is because I trust you. We've had this conversation before.

I'll be honest, thankfully I haven't had to use you much. Touch wood. But I know that when the time comes, there's trust, in you as a person, the organisation and the culture behind the scenes. And everyone gets an incredible rate.

It's not just me. Everyone basically gets the same rate, and it's great to be paying way less than we do with the big three, if you like.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
We've had really good feedback on the support we give. With any issues at all, people can text or WhatsApp me. Small bits of communication are what we're there for.

We're there to facilitate. You can find us at professionaldentalindemnity.co.uk, and you can WhatsApp me 24/7, even though I'm usually away with the little ones, or email any time. We really want a personal relationship, to put an arm around you and make sure we're looking after you.

And it tends to be for life. Our retention rate is around 97 or 98%. We want to look after you throughout your career so you can enjoy it. You can look at who's joined us and how long they've stayed, so we must be doing something right. And I think there's a Protrusive discount as well. It'll come up on the pro forma when you renew.

JAZ:
Yeah, I'll put that in the show notes. And, to be very honest, that's one I do have a financial interest in, but I'm putting it in there so everyone knows. I use PDI myself, as do hundreds of Protruserati, and it's served us well.

So thanks again, Neel, but more than anything for helping us with the education side of things. And Zaid, thank you for such a comprehensive overview of consent. I'll send you our ultimate consent form once we've made it, 'cause ortho is what we're doing next, actually.

It'd be great if you could cast your eye over it and give us your opinion. Then we can say it's sealed and approved by Zaid, and of course by you as well, Neel. I think that collaborative approach would be good. Neel, you'll probably be burning holes in it: "Have you done this? Have you done that?"

But that's what we want. We want to make the ultimate consent forms, but we also want everyone to realise it's not just a consent form. There are multiple layers to it, as we said, and that's what ultimately keeps us safe. So guys, thank you so much, and I look forward to recording with you again one day.

DR ZAID ESMAIL:
Thank you, Jaz.

DR NEEL JAISWAL:
Thank you, Jaz. Appreciate it. Thanks so much.

JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening to this episode on consent in ortho all the way to the end. I hope you've gained some communication tips, or reconsidered how you consent for ortho, or found some points you'll now remember to emphasise a bit more.

In particular, how to make consent individualised to your patient. In healthcare, there's no more space for generic, templated consent. The forms themselves aren't the problem. It's how you individualise the form to the patient in front of you.

If you'd like to learn more from Dr Zaid, check out the link below. And if you're paying too much for your indemnity and you're looking into an insurance-based product, check out protrusive.co.uk/insurance. That's protrusive.co.uk/insurance. Get a quote and get a Protrusive discount of £100. It's with PDI or MedPro. That's who I have my insurance with, and have done for many years, 'cause I was sick of paying so much money to the mutuals for their discretionary cover.

If you don't know what any of this means, do check out an older episode, Indemnity versus Insurance. But if you already know and just want a quote to see how much money you'd save, once again it's protrusive.co.uk/insurance.

A reminder that this episode is eligible for CPD and CE credits. We are a PACE-approved education provider. Premium members, scroll down, answer the quiz, get 80%, and our CPD queen, Mari, will send you your certificate. If you're not on the app yet, what are you doing? Especially if you're a regular listener, you need to be on our membership so you can get CPD all year round.

You'll get 50 to even 100 hours a year, 'cause as well as a new episode every week, we have so many live and replay webinars, and we love doing clinical walkthrough videos. So it's well worth it just for that. It all starts with a seven-day free trial. Check out protrusive.co.uk/ultimate.

We also have our own AI, called AskJaz. You can ask it anything you want, and it uses the entire Protrusive database, every guest we've ever had and all our courses, to give you a well-considered answer. It's like chatting to all the podcasts at once. That's on the Protrusive Infinity plan. Check out protrusive.app to learn more about all these options.

Thank you so much, Protruserati. I'll catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

QUESTION:
What makes consent for orthodontics different from other dental consent?
ANSWER:
Zaid explains that orthodontics depends heavily on patient compliance, with cleaning, attending appointments, wearing aligners or elastics, and lifelong retainers. It's also easy to underestimate the risks because it seems non-invasive. Because patients are seen regularly over months or years, there are more chances to reinforce consent, and Neel suggests re-checking it during longer treatments.

QUESTION:
Why do aligners generate more complaints than fixed appliances?
ANSWER:
Neel says removable appliances make up around 15 to 16% of complaints to the Dental Complaints Service, compared with about 3% for fixed. He links this to aesthetic-driven adult patients and less focus on function. Zaid adds that ClinChecks can lull dentists into a false sense of security, because they show tooth movements, not guaranteed outcomes.

QUESTION:
How do you individualise orthodontic consent?
ANSWER:
Zaid assesses each patient's records for specific risk factors. Short, blunt or long, spindly roots on the OPG mean a higher risk of root resorption, previous trauma raises the risk of devitalisation, and existing recession may worsen. He points these out on screen using the patient's own radiographs and photos, and explains which general risks apply less to them.

QUESTION:
Should you use the ClinCheck to consent patients?
ANSWER:
Zaid uses the ClinCheck as a consent tool, but notes it's a force-movement table, not an outcome simulator. He sets up the aligner movements separately from what he shows the patient, which is the result he believes he can achieve. Where there are options, such as extraction versus non-extraction, he shows two ClinChecks so patients can compare.

QUESTION:
Is it enough for a patient to sign a consent form in the waiting room?
ANSWER:
Neel recommends having both a signed form and a recorded conversation. He gets patients to initial each line or sign each page, because patients have claimed they never saw earlier pages. He then writes notes of the discussion, including the patient's own questions, the preferred option, alternatives, chance of success and costs, to show the patient understood.

QUESTION:
Should you tell patients about future costs such as relapse and retainers?
ANSWER:
Neel suggests setting out future costs at the start, such as replacement retainers, new bonded wires and retreatment after relapse, so patients aren't surprised. Zaid includes dual retention and a two-year retainer guarantee in his fees, with further treatment charged extra, though he often waives small costs. Neel suggests stating the usual fee when you do.

QUESTION:
Which orthodontic cases catch general dentists out?
ANSWER:
Zaid highlights underlying Class II, particularly Class II division 2, cases that look like simple crowding. Aligning the teeth can create a large overjet or a traumatic bite, leaving only surgery, premolar extractions or lots of IPR as options. He says you should anticipate this and discuss it at the start, because explaining it halfway through sounds like an excuse.

QUESTION:
What should an orthodontic consent form include?
ANSWER:
As well as the standard risks, such as root resorption, decalcification, devitalisation, relapse and recession, the panel suggests adding alternative options, including fixed appliances or referral to a specialist, and a "considerations and compromises" section covering likely shortfalls. Neel adds that forms should be dated, reviewed regularly and backed up by notes or recordings of the conversation.

ABOUT THE GUESTS

Dr Zaid Esmail is a specialist orthodontist based in the South East of England, who has been a specialist for 10 years. He runs a fully online orthodontic course and mentorship platform for dentists, covering assessment, diagnosis, treatment planning, fixed appliances and all aligner systems, with case-by-case mentoring and an optional Level 7 diploma.

- Online Orthodontic Academy: onlineorthodonticacademy.co.uk (10% off with the code PROTRUSIVE)

Dr Neel Jaiswal has been in practice for about 30 years, with a background in NHS dentistry, maxillofacial surgery and dentistry in Australia, and now works in private practice. He founded Professional Dental Indemnity (PDI), which introduces dentists to brokers and insurers, and regularly gives the medico-legal perspective on the Protrusive Dental Podcast.

- Professional Dental Indemnity: professionaldentalindemnity.co.uk
- Protrusive insurance quotes, with a £100 Protrusive discount: protrusive.co.uk/insurance