Ten years ago, Family Engagement Lab set out to help schools and families become better partners in student learning. A decade later, co-founders Dr. Elisabeth O’Bryon and Vidya Sundaram reflect on what they’ve learned along the way—including what worked, what didn’t, and what surprised them.
They explore why simply giving families more information or better tools isn’t enough, what an unsuccessful AI learning coach taught them about implementation, and why family engagement still too often sits apart from teaching and learning.
Looking toward the next ten years, they consider what it would take for schools to stop treating family engagement as a separate initiative and instead make families true partners in instruction.
This series shines a spotlight on the innovative edtech companies working to make a difference for students and educators.
Through conversations with the founders and CEOs, partner organizations, and the educators who are using their products in schools today, listeners hear about solutions relevant to their chronic challenges and opportunity-expanding ideas to go into uncharted directions.
David Cicero: I'm David Cicero, and welcome to the Family Engagement Lab series on EdTech Startup Showcase. Family Engagement Lab is now 10 years into its work with schools and families. Today, I'm joined by Family Engagement Lab co-founders Dr. Elisabeth O'Bryon and Vidya Sundaram to look back at that decade. Not just what worked, but what didn't, what surprised them, and how their thinking about family engagement has changed along the way.
Elisabeth, Vidya, welcome to the show.
Vidya Sundaram: Thank you. It's great to be here. Thanks so much.
David Cicero: So I'm gonna start with you, Elisabeth. Ten years later. So when Family Engagement Lab started 10 years ago, what did you think schools were getting wrong about family engagement? What do you think now?
Elisabeth O'Bryon: Yeah, it's a great question, and thinking back, like pre-pandemic, pre, you know, the proliferation of so many tools.
So, you know, when, when we think back 10 years ago, we were hearing from families a lot around, like, this gap in information, especially in families' home language. So, you know, families wanted to be able to help their children with their learning but weren't quite sure what were their children learning, were they on track academically, and really, what could they do at home to help?
And so, you know, one of our first answers was like, "Okay, let's focus on really timely, specific, actionable, learning-focused activities in families' home language." Um, and then, you know, fast-forward to now, you know, we have a lot of different mechanisms for translation out there, um, but we're realizing that, you know, that sort of information transfer was only a piece of the puzzle.
Uh, and so really something that we've been focusing in on is just how critical the teacher side of everything is. Like, you know, do teachers really see families as partners in instruction? You know, do they know what to share with families to really engage them as partners? Um, and, you know, does the school have routines that support the ability for families and schools to really partner?
And so, you know, we see these implementation gaps are really big, and, you know, a big challenge of that is that family engagement is often, like, sitting to the side of that teaching and learning, something we've talked about in some of our, of our other podcasts together.
David Cicero: Mm-hmm. Vidya, what about you? What did you think schools were getting wrong 10 years ago, and how has your thinking evolved around that?
Vidya Sundaram: Oh, yeah. I, I mean, it, it is, um, you know, really interesting to think about, um, you know, the time we were in 10 years ago, and even relative to, um, you know, when I w- I was growing up. And, um, I think, you know, 10 years ago there were some really interesting, um, you know, things happening in, uh, uh, the intersection of early childhood education and K12 education, um, that started our work, which is the, um, which is the, um, introduction of transitional kindergarten in California.
And it was a moment where so many families were suddenly, um, you know, sending their kids to, um, pr- like K12 school, which is really different from preschool. You know, you're, uh ... It's very academically much more rigorous. Um, there's no nap time. You know, there's, there are a lot of things that are really different, um, about, uh, transitional kindergarten for families, and teachers were very eager to, uh, partner with families in that moment.
And it was, um ... You know, and you think about when are the, there are moments, um, that catalyze the, uh, focus and interest on parent-teacher partnership in learning. Um, that was one of those moments. Um, and it was I think, uh, for, for many in the transitional kindergarten space as they were starting up, starting to realize that like, oh, there's something in preschool where there's a really strong emphasis on family engagement and partnering with families to support students developmentally that just, um, doesn't really follow the kids into elementary school, when the research shows that parents are just as important, you know, in elementary and, and up.
Um, so uh, transitional kindergarten was a really interesting, you know, window of opportunity for us that, that happened 10 years ago. But, um, you know, it still, uh, remains, I think, you know, what, what Elisabeth was highlighting, that, um, you know, the culture and the, um, you know, the, the way that teachers as you go, you know, higher and higher up in K through 12, how do they see families as partners as, uh, in instruction is something that, um, you know, w- we, we saw then, and I think there, uh, still remains a big challenge in our system today
David Cicero: Hmm.
You mentioned transitional kindergarten. That's really interesting and, and first I wanna make sure I, I understood correctly. You were basically saying that when you were looking at that environment, that teachers were super eager to see families as really instructional partners and, and sort of an extension of school at home.
Did I g- did I get that right? And so you were kind of using that as a window saying, "Hmm, why do they feel that way here and maybe not in other places?" Is that right?
Vidya Sundaram: Yeah. I mean, actually we had really seen, um, uh, teachers f- experience a lot of pain points in the classroom. So, for example, um, uh, kids coming into TK will be, you know, at the earlier end of, um, you know, age five or, um, you know, they'll, they will just, you know, have turned five, which, um, developmentally is, um, you know, is an age where they...
You know, if you've seen five-year-olds, like, or four-year-olds to five-year-olds, they have a hard time sitting still, um, focusing, paying attention, um, uh, y- you know, holding pencils, um, cutting, tying their sh- you know, or, uh, knowing, you know, kind of what's appropriate behavior in different spaces, um, and, uh, you know, and for, and applying, you know, what they know about that.
And for teachers, um, they know, and especially, like, early childhood education teachers know how important it is for families to help reinforce those things at home, um, and to help st- you know, help their kids, um, you know, practice and develop those skills by, you know, playing games like Simon Says, so you learn how to take turns.
Um, you know, you learn how to share. Um, they, you learn, you learn how to, um, uh, uh, you know, uh, like basic, um, you know, uh, uh, early literacy skills of, you know, holding a book and turning a page. I mean, those are, um, things that I think are much more well understood in the early childhood space. And as, you know, as you think about that transition into kindergarten, there's a, I think a, a more common, um, understanding among teachers of the role of families in that s- in that age range, um, and how that impacts students' ability to learn in the classroom.
That same understanding does not really persist through, uh, for teachers in higher grades, and that's where we come in.
David Cicero: That's interesting. Do you suspect that Teachers are making sort of a judgment call saying, "Hey, this student is struggling in my classroom based on things really should already be taken care of at home."
Whereas, and so now I'm more eager saying, "Hey, these I, you know, these are family responsibilities, so I'm gonna partner to make them uphold those responsibilities." And as a child gets older, perhaps, this is just me, you know, hypothesis here, I'm wondering if you're seeing anything to support this or, or, or not.
And as a s- student gets older, maybe they have, you know, they're able to sit still, right? So like I'm seeing the s- the student is having problems when they're older that I don't immediately associate as something families should have, should be responsible for. Does that make sense?
Vidya Sundaram: It's, uh, it's interesting.
I'm, I'm sort of picking up on sort of two aspects of what you're saying. One is, um, kind of like these are kind of things that we should see kids be able to kind of do developmentally, you know, at, at different ages. And then there's the other thing I'm picking up on is this like, is the idea of who should be, who is responsible.
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Um, and I think, let me kind of talk about the second, which is that I think there is a more co- like a, uh, something more understood that it takes a team. Like, it takes a village for kids to develop those skills. Um, so it's not so much like, "Hey, that's your job or my job," but it's like we gotta work together And, and it's, it's, it's understood, and I think, you know, early childhood educators, um, you know, those, those who go through, like, training programs, like, there is much more of an emphasis on the role of families and how, you know, how, uh, they can, uh, work more with families in supporting child development.
Um, but that's virtually nonexistent, uh, in higher-- in K12.
David Cicero: Uh, Elisabeth, this one's for you. When we're thinking about digging into the relationship between family engagement, um, or I'm sorry, families and, and classrooms, families and districts, in many cases it's still treated as just simple communication, right?
I'm gonna send an email. This is what your child's supposed to do. Um, your child got this grade on this, on this test or this quiz or something like that. When, when a district or school sees family engagement as, as that maybe more transactional, what does that really miss, Elisabeth?
Elisabeth O'Bryon: Yeah, definitely. I mean, one thing that's, that's, that's sort of a hallmark of that type of, of communication is just how one-way it is.
So, you know, you have a lot of information flowing from schools to families, but you're not having that engagement piece, which means, like, families' insights are coming back to the school and getting used. So I think you really miss this great, you know, rich knowledge and understanding of, you know, the child and their needs and, you know, what's motivating for them, where do they struggle, that, that sometimes families have a very unique perspective on.
Um, so I think that's, that's really key. I think, you know, another piece is, you know, just thinking about sending out communications like, you know, "I got a text this morning that it's movie night tonight." Like, okay. And, you know, like I think, uh, oftentimes the instructional part gets missed, so, you know, there's less information going out around the, "Oh, you know, this is what your second grader is working on right now, and here's a simple way to, to support that at home."
And as, again, you know, that way to then tell the teacher what that family is seeing at home. So I think those are a couple of the pieces that if you just think about that one-way communication, you end up missing.
David Cicero: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. So i- if we move on to, to, to kind of continue to reflect over the last 10 years, Vidya, this one will go to you.
Kind of wanna focus in on, you know, some, some of the things that may not have worked. I've got a couple questions for both of you, um, in, in, in this portion here. What's something the Family Engagement Lab maybe tried that didn't work as expected, and what did it teach you?
Vidya Sundaram: Yeah. Um, I mean, it, it, there, there are many things that we we have tried over the years.
Um, and I think you can always, um, you know, expect that things are, are never gonna go the way that you expect. And especially, um, uh, you know, when you consider how distinct, um, you know, each, um, classroom, you know, each school, um, each school system, um, you know, there's, there's so many, um, you know, different factors that make, um, you know, each of those, uh, you know, very, uh, uh, very interesting and different.
Um, and, and can make it- You know, a really significant learning experience, you know, for, um, you know, folks who are working on a more co- like a, uh, the problem of, um, uh, and the opportunity around teacher-family partnership to support learning is a, a challenge that is common across a lot of organizations, a lot of, uh, I mean, a lot of school systems, um, schools.
Um, but how they manifest and the conditions under which, uh, you know, they, they, uh, manifest are always gonna create a lot of, you know, room for, uh, you know, surprises. And I think for us one of the biggest, um, things that, uh, we've, we've learned recently, um, was something where we had seen so much enthusiasm for from families, um, for more personalized, um, support, like, and a, and a tool.
So many parents said, "I just want a tool to help me know how to help my child with homework," or just, "I wanna know what they're learning so that I can, um, you know, I can ask questions and I can get some advice." And they s- like, "Can I, can I get an app for that? Can I get a tool for that?" And there was s- so much interest.
Um, and then we, we did a lot of proto- prototyping. Uh, we, we, and we, we prototyped and then ultimately developed a tool, um, using an- and using AI. Um, and we developed an AI learning coach. And um, you know, so many families, uh, we gave very, very positive feedback, um, about the coach in, uh, when, you know, we, we conducted several, um, you know, one-on-one interviews and introduced, uh, the coach and tool and heard, um, very, very positive feedback.
Um, uh, "God, I wish I had this," you know? Like, "When, when can I get this? I want this now." And we put a lot of care into designing, um, both with teachers and with families, um, tools that would help families understand what their kids were learning d- you know, each week, you know, in the classroom. So, so this, this was a app that, and a coach that would help parents understand, like, okay, if their child was learning about fractions that week, it would explain to them exactly what the lesson they were learning and some tips on how to support their child without giving the answer, but that were appropriate for the parent to support their child's, um, development in key skills.
Um, and so we thought, "Okay, this is gonna be great." You know, so many families have been asking for this and want this. But, um, you know, can you g- can you guess what happened, David?
David Cicero: Well, well, well Vidya, hold on because I literally basically asked Elisabeth for that during my conversation with Carolin. Oh.
So tell, so t- so tell me what happened.
Vidya Sundaram: Uh, okay. Well then I won't, I, I, uh-
David Cicero: Well, maybe I don't want it.
Vidya Sundaram: You can sp- you can s- uh, it's, it's fine either way. Um, but yeah, so do we wanna talk about a different example? Uh,
David Cicero: y- No, no, no, no. It, was it not... I mean, it didn't survive testing, it wasn't a hit, or what, what ended up happening?
This is interesting. What...
Vidya Sundaram: Yeah, what ended up happening was that, um, it was so interesting because despite it being introduced multiple times by teachers to parents The parents didn't even know it existed. Like, it wasn't even, um ... The awareness of the tool was so low, um, and they didn't use it. And so it was a- Hmm
it was a, it was a strange kind of paradox, right? Because, um, y- you know, the, you know, even, even though, like the parents had ... And, and what was so interesting was that, um, uh, parents would remember, uh, a simple tip that they would receive from the teacher that we would also help the teacher send, um, about what their kids were learning in the classroom.
So, so parents would get an invitation side by side with a little learning tip, and the parents would remember the learning tip, but they w- had no idea, and they just kind of glossed over the reference to the AI coach, uh, that could help them- Yeah, so- ... you know, with personalized, uh, tips. And so, um, it, so it, it, it kind of went even beyond like, okay, you know, the, the
You know, so you can design all these, you know, a lot of tools. Um, but, you know, how the, the tool is introduced and, um, uh, you know, and shared with families, um, even with the invitation from the teacher, like it nee- like tools for families need a lot of context and information and, and a, and a h- like a, a very intentional invitation, um, from the child's teacher, uh, in order for them to be, um, you know, to become part of the fold and fabric of how parents are supporting their kids.
And so, um, you know, this, uh, insight of, you know, that we learned from, um, you know, developing and rolling out this AI coach is that, you know, you, you know, uh, now it's ... There's the kind of g- generic Field of Dreams kind of analogy. If you, you build it, they will come. Well, that doesn't really work. Um, but, um, we also learned that what happens, um, around whatever you build, it actually, it might matter more than the tool itself.
Um, you know, the s- designing of, um, the introduction and that whole experience, um, is extremely important, uh, to, uh, thinking about how, um, uh, you know, we, we, we integrate ... It, whe- whether it's technology or not, it's like it's just some tool for a parent, uh, it's gotta be thoughtfully rolled out.
David Cicero: Yeah. So it sound, it sounds like, and, and Elisabeth I'll, um, I'd love for you to, to share your thoughts on this.
It sounds like there's two separate sort of paths, um, away from this experience. It's like one is rollout marketing, right? How do we present it now? But I feel like there's also something about, I don't know, maybe just the, the way families, parents understand learning at home. Like, we want this, we want this, we want this, we need this, and now I have it, I don't pay attention to it, and I actually remember the thing that I thought wasn't enough, right?
Um, what do you think, Elisabeth? What, what has that taught you about how families see learning at home?
Elisabeth O'Bryon: Yeah. I mean, I think it, it sort of gets back to this idea we were saying at the begin- beginning of this conversation around like what is a family's role versus a teacher's role, and sort of having to break down these, these preconceived notions that, you know, there, there is, uh, not a lot of overlap there.
And so I think, you know, what we, what we really have to be focusing in on is how can we, how can we help teachers see like this tremendous value that families can, can provide, and how, you know, eager families are for that information to be invited in. They have so much to, to give. They're already supporting their children in very many, many different ways.
Um, and, and just, uh, recognizing that like that partnership can be really powerful for teachers and families and for the kids, of course.
David Cicero: Mm-hmm. I'm gonna, I'm gonna close, um, with a question for, for, for both of you. Um, if we-- So I'll go, um, Elisabeth first. If we talked again at Family Engagement Lab's 20th anniversary, 20 years in, how do you hope family engagement has become a part of how schools think about teaching and learning?
Elisabeth O'Bryon: Yes. Okay. I can, I'll start it off at one level, Vidya, and then you can take the, the next sort of level. But I think if you think, if you think about, you know, a s- a, a school building, you know, and those classrooms, you know, what we'd love to see is, like, teachers see families as partners in instruction from day one.
You know, you're thinking about, you know, what, what key information do families have? How can I invite them in to be supportive of this child together? Um, and that teachers really have simple, practical routines to make it real that, you know, th- they are planning for what's gonna happen in their classroom related to the curriculum instruction.
At the same time, they're thinking, "How am I going to engage families around these concepts as well so that they can be supporting and reinforcing the same thing?" Um, and also that, you know, asking families, families what they're noticing becomes a really normal part of teaching. Uh, and that information then comes back to how teachers are teaching their students in the classroom.
And then also thinking about schools and districts, um, I think a really key piece is that, you know, family engagement needs to become part of how schools plan instruction and measure progress. Uh, and so, you know, when you're thinking about, uh, you know, like, what really matters, well, you have measurement around that.
You're tracking that. You're trying to see what's working and what isn't. Um, and so I think that's another really key piece. And that, you know, you see family engagement in the budget and the district priorities. It's not tied to just one champion or school or classroom that is really committed. Um, and that's a way for it to survive, you know, leadership changes or new platforms, funding shifts.
So I think those are a couple pieces that I think would be, would be really different and would be just great evidence that the field has really progressed.
David Cicero: Hm. Vidya, how about from your perspective?
Vidya Sundaram: Yeah, I mean, I, I- I think if, if the field s- recognizes that, um, you know, the practices that we talked about are really just, they're part of good teaching.
Um, that it's not, uh, you know, just family engagement, uh, as a sort of separate discipline, but a really core aspect of what it means to, uh, provide a great education for, um, you know, for our, our, our young learners. Um, and I think, you know, when we look aga- you know, if we were to talk again, um, you know, in, in, in 10 years, right, like I think what would need to be different, um, and what I would love to see is more, um, systems being like, one, cognizant of, um, how much of a, of a, a, a shift, um, that would require, uh, to do the things that Elisabeth, you know, just outlined.
Um, and to recognize that, um, you know, the power and the importance of investing in, in that, um, you know, those critical shifts across the systems that make it possible for our families to place that, you know, that really vital role in supporting students.
David Cicero: Thank you both so much for coming on, and congratulations on your 10-year anniversary.
Thanks for sharing today.
Vidya Sundaram: Thank you.