The DeFi Report

A $6.3 billion Binance hack should have crushed Bitcoin. Instead, BTC barely fell, and Mike is more bullish than before. Mike and Ryan break down why Bitcoin held its critical 50-week moving average, what the selloff revealed about its holder base, and whether the final market reset is now complete. They also cover ETF outflows, post-election macro risks, the key levels to watch next, and why Mike still expects months of chop before the next major move.

----
🎯Join TDR Pro & get 1-month free
https://thedefireport.io/friends

🎯20% off our annual plan ($16.67/month)
https://thedefireport.cc/tdr-rss

🎯Follow & subscribe to The DeFi Report 
https://thedefireport.transistor.fm/
https://x.com/the_defi_report
https://x.com/JustDeauIt
https://x.com/RyanSAdams

----
RESOURCES

The Watch List: Pump Fun (PUMP) & the Social Trading Market
https://thedefireport.io/research/the-watch-list-pump-fun-pump-the-social-trading-market

The Commanding Heights
https://commanding-heights.com/

----
TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro
0:22 Bitcoin’s Biggest Test Yet
1:47 Why People Make Bitcoin Volatile
3:15 The $6 Billion Hack Test
8:59 Diamond-Handed Bitcoin Holders
11:20 The Slow Leak of Selling
16:13 Altcoins After the Sell-Off
20:19 ETFs, Stablecoins, and Market Signals
22:44 Midterms and Crypto Markets
26:34 Reading the Credit Spreads
29:59 Bitcoin’s Early-Bull Outlook
34:22 The Case for Pump and Social Trading
40:04 Closing Thoughts and Disclaimers

----
Not financial or tax advice. For educational purposes only.

What is The DeFi Report?

Our weekly show is hosted by Michael Nadeau (The DeFi Report) and Ryan Sean Adams (Bankless). Each week, we discuss how we approach managing our own portfolio and the data, research, and analytical frameworks that inform those decisions — for educational and informational purposes.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[0:10] Welcome to The Report. Well, well, we just had the largest crypto hack in history last week, and we are still here. $6 billion gone from Binance, the world's largest crypto exchange.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[0:22] Is the early bull market still intact? We're going to take a look at the numbers and see what Mike thinks here. But last week, there was a key question. How diamond handed is this new foundation of Bitcoin holders, this cohort that Mike has been tracking for the past couple of years. This week, the market gave us a special test. There was a $6 billion hack and we got to see how diamond handed this cohort is and what that says about the early bull market and the market structure that we see right now. So we're going to look at that. We're also going to take a look at time-based capitulation, that leak that Mike has indicated is still going on, why that leak could be ending soon. And also, crypto is up today, midterms in, election results in. Wondering if that has a role to play? I'm going to ask Mike that question as well. And stick around to the end. We'll get some key prices to watch. Also, I want to ask Mike why he is overweight still on social trading, what he thinks about it, why he is still a contrarian on Pump, the asset, why it composes a large portion of his portfolio.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[1:36] But before we get in, there was a key quote that I loved from today's report. You said this, Mike, Bitcoin is not volatile, but people are. What do you mean by that?

Michael Nadeau:
[1:47] Yeah, you know, we do all this work to try to understand the market structure for Bitcoin. And part of how I think about this is you have different points in the cycle where Bitcoin's market structure is what I would say is more volatile. Bitcoin is not volatile. Bitcoin just does what it does. It just prints blocks, processes transactions, fix supply. There's nothing that changes about Bitcoin. But obviously, it's a very volatile asset. I think it's more volatile at various points in the cycle based on market structure, who the investor who has come into the market. That is going to dictate, I think, price action in many ways. We've talked about why we tend to not see really nasty drawdowns in the early bull period of cycles. And I think the reason for this is because we sort of have this less volatile investor, as maybe how I'll frame this. You've brought in sort of the smart money. The more volatile investor came in at the top of the last cycle. We've talked about how they've been passing their coins on to new investors throughout the bear market. And I think that process is like mostly complete. We still have a little bit of time-based capitulation going on out there, but because you have this sort of more diamond-handed holder base right now,

Michael Nadeau:
[3:11] I think the Bitcoin is going to be less volatile during this period.

Michael Nadeau:
[3:15] We had a perfect test of this with the Binance hack last week. I think, you know, if I had told you when we were recording last week, hey, Binance is going to get hacked for $6 billion, largest financial heist in history.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[3:29] Not even close either. I mean, it's like even, you know, four or five X greater than the last biggest financial heist, which was also crypto.

Michael Nadeau:
[3:37] Right, right. So if we had talked about this last week, we probably both would have agreed, or maybe I wouldn't have, but we would have thought that probably would have caused 20% correction. But because I think of this market structure, we actually only went down about 5%. We held the 50-week. We've so far have held that 50-week moving average. It's been tested twice now. And we kind of have, I think, what is a pretty good setup here for the bulls now that we've sort of gone through this reset. We've been tested. And this week we're going to kind of go through the data and kind of see how the market responded to all that volatility last week.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[4:13] That's an incredible test, really. I mean, $6 billion. How big was FTX? Do you recall? I recall it being in the same ballpark. It was like $6 to $10 billion or something like this.

Michael Nadeau:
[4:22] Yeah, they were short $8 billion when they initially realized that there were all these withdrawals coming and they couldn't fund those. So I think it was a lot more uncertainty as well because we didn't really know if they were solvent. Sure. There were multiple days that were going by where people, you know, they had basically halted withdrawals from the exchange. A lot of uncertainty, I think, for this one as... As large of a hack as it was. And I'm sure everybody, you know, I saw that when I was out to dinner, you know, I had to come home and try to figure out what was going on. They told you to sell, you know, it's a hard thing when you're in crypto and you see stuff like this.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[5:01] But that, you know.

Michael Nadeau:
[5:02] By the end of the night, I sort of felt like it was probably contained. And I think that was kind of the takeaway there was that, you know, a lot of those, about half of the funds that were stolen were immediately frozen. And then Binance was pretty quick to come out and say, you know, we have the balance sheet to reimburse our customers if we have lost this money. Everybody knows Binance is the largest exchange. They probably are good for that. And so I think, you know, the market kind of processed that pretty quickly and somewhat has, you know, moved on from that already, I would say.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[5:37] It's actually incredible. And I think bullish. So the biggest test of the early bull market, and it looks like on the week we have passed Bitcoin at the time of recording about 80K, which is surprising. It traded down towards 76K just after the hack earlier this week. We'll talk about whether it maintained above the 50-week moving average, which I think is a key indicator for you. But maybe I want to start with the hack itself. I think everyone listening is probably aware of what happened. This made national, international news. An attacker on October 29th gained access to Binance's internal wallet. They stole what, totaled to be about $6.3 billion. I think it was like $2.5 to $3 billion of that has been frozen. It was in stablecoins. It was in frozen. Another $3 billion, of course, is gone. The FBI says North Korea was responsible for this hack, one subgroup in North Korea. Kim Jong-un's sister denies it for what that's worth. I saw that headline this morning.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[6:44] It was a fake job interview, got control of somebody's laptop, a DevOps type flaw. And Binance put together a whole kind of postmortem retrospective on how it happened. So there's been some transparency there. Binance has absorbed almost 100% of the loss by this time as well. So the $3 billion or so that was lost, actually the $6 billion because the $2.8 billion is still sort of frozen. Has not been returned to Binance. All $6 billion that was hacked, Binance proved that they have the capacity to absorb that loss and publish proof of reserves, that the funds are still there. They did that, I think, by early this week, even by Sunday, and they had reopened their exchange. So a quick, I guess, restoration of services and proof of reserves from Binance. I think they should get some credit in the aftermath of this, even though this hack was so large. When you saw this news, Mike, you said you were at dinner. What was your first reaction?

Michael Nadeau:
[7:47] Here we go again. Here we go again. That's kind of one of the biggest fears is like the largest exchange. My initial sort of thought was the sort of the black swan. We've talked about these new AI systems. We know there's quantum threats out there. So that's kind of the worst case scenario. I think once I was able to kind of figure out what had happened, it seems like it was some sort of social engineering attack in which a smart contract was exploited. That's kind of what opened the door. It wasn't that the private keys were actually stolen or the blockchain was hacked or a quantum system or an AI system broke through. It was kind of like similar to a lot of these other hacks that we've seen. Obviously, much, much larger. But I think once I saw that, once I saw the communications coming out, my attention really just kind of shifted more to like, OK, this is actually going to be a good test of the early bull. And we're going to get to see here, you know, how volatile the market's going to be for the next few days. And I think we got that answer and we can kind of like do a little postmortem, you know, through the on-chain data here.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[8:59] Well, let's do that. Start with market structure. So you think the reason we passed this test and we're down only 5% rather than 20% plus was because of diamond hand holders, the market structure held up. In particular, there's the 78K to 92K cohort that we've been talking about. This now has 18% of the supply. So correct me if I'm wrong, but this looks like the largest cohort of Bitcoin supply right now. How did they prove themselves? Did they prove themselves as diamond handed as maybe you'd hoped?

Michael Nadeau:
[9:34] I think so. You know, when I kind of looked through this and we were kind of just looking at week to week, like what cohorts changed the most, really the because we dipped underneath 78k there. And I think. Upper 75s at one point. So actually kind of intraday, I think we actually did dip below the 50-week moving average. It wasn't there for very long. And it seemed like there were a lot of bids that had already been placed in the order books to purchase up Bitcoin if it got close to that 50-week moving average. So to the extent that there was selling, which we'll get to the ETFs here in a minute, it was mopped up. There was demand that was sitting there waiting for that supply to come online. So that happened sort of initially right on the Thursday when the hack happened. There was a little bit more selling through the weekend and then into Monday. But Bitcoin hasn't been able to break down below that 50-week moving average. And that's kind of like the key support zone that I'm watching. Not to say it can't break below there. Like I could still see it dropping below there. We just wouldn't want to see it drop below and then stay there and then not be able to get above and reclaim that level, you know, on a weekly or multi-weekly time frame.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[10:52] And what's the 50-week right now? Is that 76K still?

Michael Nadeau:
[10:55] It's just below. I think it's 75.9K, so it's still coming down. We haven't fully bottomed. At some point, that's going to bottom and kind of flatten out. And I'm expecting that to happen in the next month or so. But 75.9K is that line right now.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[11:11] So this market structure allowed us to absorb this bad news without a panicked sell-off that we might have seen at other phases in the market.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[11:20] And that's an indicator of the strength of early bull. You also mentioned in your notes something about the time-based capitulation. I know we've been watching those higher cohorts, the 108K and above buyers, even the 92K and above buyers. And you called this before time-based capitulation or almost a slow leak in the market. That sort of capped our upside ability a little bit. I think in today's report, you indicated that that slow leak, that time-based capitulation might be almost over. Did some of the wind come out of the sales and did it accelerate? Did the Binance News kind of accelerate the time-based capitulation? Now, most of that air has leaked from the tire?

Michael Nadeau:
[12:03] I think so. So we did see more selling from those kind of top buyer cohorts. And from, you know, even before the hack, you know, I kind of have come to the conclusion like most of that selling activity has come out. There's still somewhat of a leaky bucket there, as you're calling it. But I think this was a good test because I think if people that were holding and were nervous about what they were holding When you see that hack, maybe that's the thing that tips you over and you say, all right, I've had enough. I'm out of this. And I think we had some of that last week. So at some point here, we're going to get to a place where those top buyers are fully exhausted. I think they're 90% of the way there already, but that gets fully exhausted. We've talked about sort of momentum traders who are always in the markets. We think they've taken profits after we had that initial move off the lows in August. And and then you have just sort of like these people that are just coming in and mopping up supply longer term holders. And that's just like creating this structure for when there is new demand or there is a catalyst, there is positive price action that you just have this like very healthy setup where we can start to move up, you know, from these levels.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[13:17] So if your first question was like, or your first thought was like, okay, here we go again. My first thought was like, oh, I wonder if the 50-week moving average is going to hold for Mike or not. Actually, that's what I was thinking at the time. And this is the chart with the 50-week moving average in purple and Bitcoin price in blue. And there we are. We just touched the line just barely, but still above the 50 week moving average, which has preserved our early bull market structure. So it almost feels like a miracle on the week. And I have to ask the question not to jinx it, but you still think that line is going to hold? We're still going to hold about 76K Bitcoin.

Michael Nadeau:
[14:01] I think so. Like I've been saying, I need Bitcoin to prove to me that it's not going to hold. And looking for a catalyst to spark some volatility and to see it get tested like we did last week makes me more bullish. It makes me feel more strongly that it is going to hold. That was actually the, it's really kind of touched twice now. So we've kind of tapped off it twice. You can see going back to 23, like this was always going to be tested, right? This early bull call of mine was always going to be tested. Really, every call we make is always going to be tested at the market.

Michael Nadeau:
[14:40] And, you know, you can kind of see a similar pattern there early 23, where you kind of struggle to break it initially. You get up there, maybe get rejected. Finally, you break through and then you always are going to revisit that line again. And we did in the past. We held it back in 2023 so far you know we're holding it here and I think if you're bearish like that's that's kind of the thing I've been thinking about if you are on the bearish side of this and you've been looking at the macro uncertainty you know we've had you know the clarity act failing we've now pushed our way through midterms we've seen you know rates rising real rates rising. We've seen a lot of things get thrown at Bitcoin over the last six to nine months. And I think if you're in that bear camp, I think you have to start to think, well, wait a minute. You know, what's the, these are the things I thought would cause Bitcoin to go down. It's been able to hold these kind of important levels. You know, does that thesis need to be updated or is there some other catalyst? Is there some other thing that you think is coming next to force us, you know, below that line? I'm struggling with it. I'm kind of still, I think the bulls are in a much, you know, kind of sturdier footing at this stage right now.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[15:57] It does. It really looks like a different Bitcoin than Bitcoin did six months ago or so. And I guess in your words, that wouldn't be Bitcoin. That would be not Bitcoin's volatility, but people's volatility, right? I guess we're trading people here on the week, Mike.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[16:14] Let's talk about altcoins. This was an interesting point. So altcoins actually outperformed Bitcoin on the recovery at least a little bit. What does that tell you? Have we hit kind of the lows in terms of the altcoin sell-off? And are we due for a bit of recovery here? Yeah.

Michael Nadeau:
[16:32] I think so. I think, you know, it'd be interesting to see how this plays out now that it looks like Bitcoin may be starting to recover itself. We talked about how altcoins, you know, outperformed in a big way in September. That has come off. And over the last 30 days, there's only about 8% of the coins in the top 50 have outperformed Bitcoin over a 30-day period.

Michael Nadeau:
[16:55] What's interesting is, like, we've seen, you know, significant correction in almost all altcoins out there. And prior to the Binance hack, things got even worse after Binance. So you're kind of like really oversold, I would say, on a lot of these names that are like kind of on the longer tail, higher risk assets. Really oversold. And so when we kind of bottomed out of that, we did get a sort of a larger move from alts on the recovery. That caused Bitcoin dominance to roll over a little bit. But so moving forward here is going to be interesting to see if Bitcoin leads us into the next move. We still have resistance at like 87K or so. And then we know we've got the 50-week moving average. So we're kind of in this channel. And we'll see if Bitcoin leads us out of this up to 87. Maybe it breaks that. I know what I am looking for here in the coming weeks and months.

Michael Nadeau:
[17:52] And then is there another kind of wave of speculation, sort of the on-chain space comes back, social trading, all those things that were popping off in September? We'll see if there's another wave at some point behind this. But I think, you know, historically, Bitcoin kind of leads you, you know, into the early bull. When we go back to that chart showing the 50-week moving average, just want to remind people, you know, that... And we're in a zone here where we may just be chopping for six to nine months, right? Like we may go back to 87 and just not be able to break it. And we kind of come down and build some more energy. So we'll see. We may need a sort of macro catalyst or something else if we're going to kind of like aggressively move out of this and sort of challenge 90K or so.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[18:40] That's what we did in the previous cycle in 23. A lot of the 23, the early bull was just chop for Bitcoin, wasn't it? Bouncing around the 50-week and above, but it couldn't kind of break that channel. And it took, how long did it take before we did break upwards?

Michael Nadeau:
[18:54] It took, it was really Q4 of 23 when Bitcoin started to move off of that. And that's also, you know, some of the best performing assets of last cycle. Sol, for example, really didn't start making its big move until around that time. So there was a lot of chop, a lot of like, there could be assets out there that haven't been discovered yet that are going to see that their moment come, you know, later in the early bull cycle here.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[19:18] So if that same thing plays out, I mean, are we talking the first half of 2027 could just be chop in this channel? In fact, is that kind of your base case?

Michael Nadeau:
[19:29] It is kind of the base case, you know, it's the base case is kind of we hold 50 week moving average, we kind of chop around. We know there's resistance at 87. If we break that, we're probably in a channel between 87 and 94 K or so. I'm not really seeing, you know, maybe we push up to 100 K. I'm not really seeing all time highs, you know, this year or probably Q1 next year. So, yes, I think, you know, we still have, you know, a lot going on in the geopolitical world and with AI and all that, that needs to get sorted out. So I don't know if we're in like a sort of fully kind of risk on market broadly, but I feel good about like crypto's market structure, Bitcoin's market structure for like this stage of the cycle. And it's behaving really kind of the way I would expect to so far.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[20:20] Any other indicators as you look at ETFs, as you look at even stablecoin supply, which is pretty flat, spot markets still kind of anemic, which is a little bit different than last time. Anything here that really raises an eyebrow for you?

Michael Nadeau:
[20:35] Yeah. I thought the ETFs held up fairly well. We saw some outflows last Thursday, which put it in the 86th percentile of the number of outflows on that day. We had more outflows that was more in the 95th percentile on Monday. So two pretty significant outflow days, but we're basically flat over the last six weeks in terms of the capital flows in and out of the ETFs. Because what's kind of interesting on ETFs is ETH has been getting hammered on ETFs, had like 25 straight outflow days, almost like the capitulation we saw from the Bitcoin ETFs in June, July is now playing out on ETH. And that's kind of interesting to me because ETH's price action has been fairly strong.

Michael Nadeau:
[21:26] I would think that ETH would be down more than, I think it came down 15% or so off its local high. So that's kind of interesting that even ETH is handling a lot of sell pressure from the ETFs. And the worst of that is probably over, I would say, given that it's been in 25 days there. So the ETFs look fairly good. The stablecoin supply dropped last week. So that's kind of interesting. It's now at its lowest point over the last year. That's a big indicator for me when like liquidity conditions and demand for credit and DeFi, all of those things should start to inflect later once we see more stablecoin supply coming online. So I think a lot of these indicators just look to me like similar to what we'd expect in the early bull. We're not in a full-on risk-on market just yet, but we sort of have the ingredients based on sort of the new holder base, the lack of leverage in the system. We've kind of got the right recipe for that to come later, but we're still kind of early in this process,

Ryan Sean Adams:
[22:28] I'd say. I got to tell you, if you want to get bullish on stablecoins, you got to read that Commanding Heights essay that was published all over crypto Twitter last week from investors. The whole thing was about stablecoins, basically. Anyway, we'll include a link in the show notes if folks are interested.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[22:45] Okay, let's talk about macro for a minute. So maybe we should actually start on midterms. So midterms are now over. Crypto is up this morning, which is sort of surprising because I think there are some senators that have gained power that have been crypto unfavorable in the past. And yet this uncertainty at the same time is behind us. We know what's going to happen with Democrat-controlled Senate. And house. What do you think of the crypto price response on midterms? Did that surprise you?

Michael Nadeau:
[23:21] Um... Not really. So we did actually kind of dip a little bit yesterday and it looked like NASDAQ, I think overnight NASDAQ was down 2% or so and crypto came back down to 76K, BTC did. And we've kind of rebounded out of that. I think that's kind of consistent. You tend to have like some volatility right around the election. NASDAQ's up today, now Bitcoin's up, gold's up.

Michael Nadeau:
[23:48] I think just kind of the wall of worry, like it's just this uncertainty is really not good for markets. And once you have the uncertainty, once you have certainty, you know, sort of how Congress is going to be structured. People can now start to build

Michael Nadeau:
[24:01] Sort of a view on what's coming and what could change or what's not going to change. And I think, you know, when we look at the past since 1946, there's been, I think, seven Congresses that were Democrat controlled with a Republican White House. The S&P 500 was up 11% after three months on average and up, I think, 16% over 12 months. So it doesn't mean that's what's going to play out here, but maybe somewhat comforting to know that maybe the worst in the markets is over. Usually the midterm year is the worst year for the traditional markets. And the year after midterms tends to be the best performing year in like a four-year cycle. So, you know, I haven't had a chance to really process everything in terms of like, what does this mean for crypto markets specifically and things that the SEC has done? We did have one law, the Genius Act was passed, so we're good there. But basically anything that wasn't made into law, kind of thinking about that, What does this mean for perps? What does this mean for things that we were expecting? Some regulation or rules, tokenization. We've had the SEC come out and give us some guidance there, but it's not a law. So that potentially gets ripped up. So I will be going through this over the next week and just kind of thinking about this a little bit.

Michael Nadeau:
[25:20] Data centers and the AI build out is potentially something that could be impacted here. I think broadly like,

Michael Nadeau:
[25:29] I think if you have a Democrat-controlled Congress and you have a Republican White House, I think we talked about this a few weeks ago, you mentioned everything is just going to be vetoed by Trump, I would think. So I don't expect a ton of lawmaking to occur over the next couple of years. It's going to be interesting to see what it is. Is Trump going to try to work with Democrats or is it going to be more contentious where he's getting impeached and everyone in the cabinet is just being brought forth and investigated? You know, if we get that type of structure, which is kind of what I expect, I think markets kind of like that. It's just divided. It's almost like you don't have to worry. Neither side is imposing its will on what can happen in the economy. And it's just you're kind of at a standstill. And I think that's kind of what it's going to be for the next few years. And then we'll start to see, you know, what direction is the country going into, you know, leading into 2028, which hopefully Bitcoin's in a bull market. We're in the wealth creation phase, hopefully at that time.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[26:35] I know the one macro indicator you keep putting in these reports and you did again this week is credit spreads. So talk about credit spreads. Why is your focus on credit spreads and what is it showing you on the week?

Michael Nadeau:
[26:48] So credit spreads have been the focus. You know, we've talked about, you know, we talk about macro. We always have a section on macro in here. And we're trying to just figure out what is the most important thing to be looking at. Because I think you can really get yourself twisted up spending too much time on all the risks that are out there. The reason we've been looking at credit spreads is if there are... Risks that are playing out, whether it's in the rates market, whether it's in bank lending, whether it's in oil inflation, like you'll start to see it get expressed through rising credit spreads. And it's just telling you that like riskier companies are having trouble getting access to credit. This recent spike we've talked about, this is mostly related to AI financing, AI build out concerns. What I've been looking at to sort of figure out is this actually starting to bleed into the economy is looking at the percentage of banks that are tightening their credit standards, you know, commercial loan activity, those types of things. And I haven't seen any changes to that stuff just yet. So, like, banks are lending, there's demand for loans, and we haven't seen usually,

Michael Nadeau:
[28:00] And when banks really start to get nervous, they'll tighten their credit standards. That could then impact the number of loans that they're putting out, potentially impact liquidity conditions and, you know, the business environment. Not seeing that just yet. So the economy still looks healthy and this is kind of like a scare for now in terms of just Investors questioning the AI build-out, the amount of demand behind all this capital spending, and whether or not the market's going to be able to finance these build-outs and these refinancings at similar rates. And maybe those rates go up. Maybe that impacts margins and it causes kind of a shakeout in sort of the neocloud space. But for now, keeping an eye on this, if we see credit spreads spiking further, I do think that will cause more volatility in NASDAQ, possibly Bitcoin. And like I said, we're looking at bank lending activity to see if this is starting to transmit its way into the amount of loans that are getting issued.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[29:06] But so far, it seems like nothing alarming in macro that you see. And so I guess you're maintaining the base case of things just continue to chug along. Thank you.

Michael Nadeau:
[29:16] Yeah, you know, rates have come down. So real rates have come down quite a bit. The 10-year has come off quite a bit. Oil has come down quite a bit. I think it was in the trading in the 80s last time I looked. Kind of interesting considering we still have a result, that situation, and strategic oil reserves are still being depleted. But oil has come off. So, you know, I can't predict. I just have a hard time trying to predict how Iran's going to shake out, what's going to happen with rates and stuff. So I'm kind of just looking at these indicators, see how the market is kind of thinking about these things and then saying, OK, is this feeding through somewhere else where it's kind of becoming clear that it's going to transmit its way into markets?

Ryan Sean Adams:
[29:59] It sounds like with macro, it's just like there's not a lot of clarity or not a lot of signal that things could go in either direction. And so you're resting your case for crypto back to market structure. And this being the biggest test that we've seen of the early bull market, and we came out of this test relatively unscathed. That is continued faith in the early bull markets. I guess the question for this report, is the early bull still intact? Your answer on the week is a resounding yes. And this has been a massive test of it. And yes, we've pulled through. So let's talk about what that means for Bitcoin. You still think we're going to maintain the 50 week moving average. We just trade in this channel between 76k and what, like 90k? And we're going to just be hanging here for a while.

Michael Nadeau:
[30:54] Possibly. I would love to see us go back and test $87K where we got rejected back in September and early October. We break through that. I think the next level is probably $95K or so. We'll see. We've seen the full reset that I would be looking for. When you look at the momentum indicators on the RSI, Bitcoin went all the way down to $31K, which is overbought territory. We've seen the full reset across altcoins and kind of the on-chain space so you've kind of like, the tide has come out I think across the entire crypto ecosystem over the last couple of months um So I think it's going to be harder for us to actually continue testing that 50-week moving average because I think you're going to need some other catalyst to push us down there. And we'll see. I think we're kind of in this sort of channel where we're going to chop around. I think the market got very bearish after Binance. Like, you know, I think we talked a couple of weeks ago and it was almost like I was in consensus at that point with sort of early bull status and people were pretty bulled up at that point. I did sort of feel like I was becoming too much on the side of consensus, but I kind of always expected that that 50 week would get tested, which now it has. I think the market has flipped too bearish as this has played out. I've seen

Michael Nadeau:
[32:22] A lot of sentiment around people expecting Bitcoin, even though it only sold off 5% or so, that the same thing happened back in 10-10 liquidation last year and then it bled out over months to come. I haven't seen anybody make that statement and then also demonstrate that they're following the market structure because I think that's a totally different setup going back to 10.10 last year. That was like, you know, kind of a more clear thing that, yes, it probably is going to bleed out. Now that we've already reset the leverage, reset the holder base, I find it harder to sort of align with that view right now. And like I said, Bitcoin has to prove it. If it goes down and it breaks it, obviously we'll revisit and take a look at that. But I think Bitcoin has to prove that that's what's going to happen. I think the probabilities still support early bull, probably chop around a little bit. Hopefully, there's some catalyst that comes that sort of reignites, you know, just sentiment, you know, out in the market, which we've also seen sentiment. Fear and greed reset. So we went into fear during this last episode with Binance. That's also healthy. So I've kind of seen like almost every indicator I would look for to sort of reset has played out and we held the 50 week. That's making me feel pretty good about the setup.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[33:46] Well, as we're ending this, I'm almost wondering if there's a possibility then, Mike, you might be surprised to the upside. There could be an upside breakout that takes a lot of investors by surprise, especially if some of the narrative consensus is a little more on the bearish side, Bitcoin. Like what happens if suddenly in a week or two, we break that 87K? I mean, that could be a possibility. And that could certainly surprise and catch a lot of folks off guard who are waiting to buy Bitcoin at these still kind of depressed rates, like close to the 50 week moving average.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[34:22] As we close this out, I want to ask you about one other asset and maybe a key theme of the TDR portfolio. You put a report out on Friday about social trading. The asset, I think, that is kind of your blue chip for social trading is Pump. That falls in kind of the, I think, still narrative contrarian category, even though the revenues it's printing have been quite impressive. Maybe say a few words as we close about Pump because if altcoins come back, this is a place where you've put a lot of your chips in terms of the altcoin bet. Why? Why Pump? Why social trading this cycle? What are you really seeing that a lot of investors are missing?

Michael Nadeau:
[35:08] Yeah, so we covered Pump in the bear market. We built an extensive dashboard on PumpFun. I think it's probably the most comprehensive one in the market. And I think what I was really trying to develop some conviction around was just like the usage of PumpFun in a bear market. Even with tokens trading down where we were in a nine-month-long bear market, PumpFun was still doing like a million dollars in revenue a day. So try to understand that. Try to understand those users. Why are they there? Why are they trading? I just think it has this game-like feature to it that is very sticky. There's all kinds of narratives in the market around this. I've been unable to confirm any of the negative stuff about Pump Fund. We put out a report around this. Um and so we ended up you know putting a lot of research out there nobody agreed with our research it ended up leading to building a pretty substantial position in the portfolio i think it's over 12 of the portfolio right now um and then we did see pump sort of uh the narrative shifted towards fundamentals i think a lot of people started to jump on the train and some other large popular X accounts started to talk about PumpFun a lot.

Michael Nadeau:
[36:25] This was really in the September period. And it's kind of come off a little bit again. We saw Robinhood Chain and a lot of social trading activity when Robinhood Chain was doing really well back in September. And now the air has kind of come out of the space again. So we put out a report last week. Kind of revisiting pump from a fundamentals perspective, but also, you know, kind of the social trading market as a whole. I think it's kind of an interesting space right now in terms of the tech stack for social trading with the launch pads, bonding curves, decentralized exchanges where these coins are trading. You've got new interfaces, things like FOMO that have these kind of social features and transparent P&Ls and things like this. So I just, this sector is very interesting to me just because it's clear people love these apps and they're using them a lot. There's way more usage of these apps than hyperliquid, perps training, for example. So anyways, we've been building our views around this. We put this report out because I thought it was a good time to revisit this. Maybe just a little something if people want to check out the report. One of the interesting findings in that report is just the way the tech stack is being built out and PumpFun as serving as essentially an infrastructure player, where a lot of these social trading apps like FOMO, like Axiom or GMGN,

Michael Nadeau:
[37:50] These are actually growing the market. They're sort of competitors to Pump, but because those are just interfaces, they're actually tapping into PumpFun for the actual launch of the tokens, the initial trading of the tokens, which happens on PumpFun's bonding curve. And then if a token that a user on FOMO is trading... If that was issued via Pump, it's trading on PumpFund's decentralized exchange. And actually more of the fees from a FOMO user are actually making its way to PumpFund and the PumpFund token creator, which is pretty interesting. I don't think this is very understood in the market right now. So PumpFund is kind of like a, it's an interface and it has like sort of sticky organic usage itself. But it's actually kind of like capturing some of the economics from these other social apps that are being spawned around it now, which is which is pretty interesting. So maybe we could put a link in the show notes and people can check that report out if they're interested.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[38:50] My last question here on Pump is, so what's the price to sales ratio right now? And how does that compare to something like hype? I mean, you may not know the specific number, but I recall it being so much lower than hype, which indicates possible undervaluation for every unit of revenue, right?

Michael Nadeau:
[39:08] Yes. I don't want to misquote my own report, but I want to say it's around five price of sale, which is pretty low considering the revenues it does. I think when we invested, it was trading around 1.5 or so. So it's repriced a little bit, but that's well below consumer, fintech, and almost any other product or company with the growth rates.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[39:32] What's higher, something like 70 or something like that?

Michael Nadeau:
[39:35] Much higher, yeah. Yeah, I think it's over 100 on fully diluted and somewhere around 70 on circulating supply. So yeah, that's kind of interesting in itself, just considering how much usage these apps get, which they still just haven't really, you know, because of the speculative nature of these apps and how they have these kind of like big... Spikes in user activity and things like this. They still haven't garnered the respect of the market just yet, but we'll see. We'll see if that eventually changes.

Ryan Sean Adams:
[40:05] Well, Mike thinks there's an opportunity there. And if you want to see where the other opportunities he thinks exist, you could check out the TDR portfolio. Unlock his full portfolio with the TDR Pro membership. We'll include a link in the show notes. And of course, if you enjoyed this, Make sure you subscribe across YouTube, Spotify, Apple. Give us a review if you are benefiting from this analysis. I think the counsel on the week is patience. Hey, we're hanging in there above the 50-week moving average. And we will be with you next Wednesday, of course, with a new report. Got to end with this. None of this has been financial advice. This is an Investor Journal, and we're on the journey right alongside you. So until next time, stay curious.