Silence | The Men Who Saw It Coming and Said Nothing

AB Hernandez wins two California girls' state track titles — and the real story is the silence of men who had every chance to speak and chose comfort instead. Based on 1 Peter 3:15, today's charge is to name where your silence has been cowardice and prepare to speak.

Show Notes

Sunday, May 31, 2026 • Today's Principle: Silence

The AB Hernandez situation in California isn't just a sports story — it's a symptom of men who confused disciplined silence with cowardly abdication. This episode breaks down the difference between governing your tongue and burying your responsibility, grounded in Proverbs and 1 Peter. The charge: find the room, the conversation, or the moment where you've gone quiet out of fear — and prepare this week to speak like a man who actually believes what he says he believes.

Scripture: 1 Peter 3:15

Today's Charge: Identify the specific place where your silence has been cowardice — a conversation at home, a school board room, a hard truth you've been swallowing — and this week, prepare to speak with clarity, gentleness, and preparation.

—

📖 Men of the Republic — the book behind the briefing.
Get the book on Amazon • carlosreyesiii.com

🎧 Subscribe: Apple Podcasts • Spotify • RSS

💌 Daily newsletter: menoftherepublic.org

Today's Silence chapter reference: Ch 1 — The Silence of Good Men

What is The Republic Briefing?

The Republic Briefing is a daily news podcast for men who take their faith, their families, and their responsibilities seriously. Host Carlos Reyes covers the same headlines everyone else is covering politics, culture, economics, world events but reframes them through Scripture and challenges men to respond with conviction, not reaction. Every episode ends with The Republic Charge: a direct call to lead your household, govern yourself, and steward the republic entrusted to you. The news. The standard. The charge.

This is The Republic Briefing. I'm Carlos Reyes. For men who govern themselves, their households, and their public square — this is your daily charge.

Today's principle is Silence — and what the AB Hernandez situation in California reveals about the men who saw it coming and said nothing.

Here's what happened. AB Hernandez, a biological male, just closed out a high school career in California by winning two girls' state track championships at the CIF state meet. Two titles. Girls' division. And the debate — as every outlet calls it — rages on.

But I don't want to talk about the debate. I want to talk about the silence that got us here.

Because this didn't happen overnight. This didn't fall from the sky. There were school board meetings where fathers sat in the back row and said nothing. There were athletic association votes where men who knew better kept their mouths shut because the room felt hostile. There were coaches who saw this coming — who talked about it in parking lots and group chats — and then walked into the room and said nothing.

The girls who lost those races? They trained. They got up early. They did the hard work. And the men in their lives — fathers, coaches, board members, pastors — had chances to speak. And they made a choice. They chose quiet. Not the disciplined quiet of a man who listens before he speaks. The cowardly quiet of a man who doesn't want the trouble.

That's a different thing entirely.

One is restraint. The other is abdication. And right now, we've got a generation of men who've confused the two. They call it staying in their lane. They call it not being political. They call it picking their battles. But what it actually is — what it looks like from the outside — is men failing the women and girls in their households.

So what does a man do with this?

He starts by understanding what silence actually is — and what it isn't.

Today's principle is Silence. And I want to be precise about what that means, because it's the most misunderstood principle in this entire book.

Chapter one of Men of the Republic — "The Silence of Good Men" — opens with this exact distinction. Silence is not the absence of speech. Silence is the discipline of speech. It's the man who controls his tongue, who listens before he opens his mouth, who doesn't react from his gut and call it conviction. That man speaks with weight because he doesn't speak with noise.

But there is a counterfeit version of this. And it's everywhere. It's the man who calls his silence wisdom when it's really fear. It's the man who says he's waiting for the right moment — and the right moment never comes. It's the man who has a word that needs to be said, and he swallows it, and he calls it peace-keeping. That's not silence. That's surrender with better PR.

The principle demands that you govern your tongue. It does not ask you to bury your responsibility.

Now here's what Scripture says about this.

Proverbs twelve, verse seventeen. "An honest witness tells the truth, but a false witness breathes out lies." That's from Proverbs twelve, verse seventeen, English Standard Version. Notice what's happening there. The honest witness tells the truth. Not when it's convenient. Not when the room agrees with him. He tells it because he saw it and he owes it. The false witness — he breathes out lies. But there's a third man the Proverbs keep circling back to, and it's the man who saw the truth and said nothing. He didn't lie. He just didn't witness. And the outcome in that courtroom — in that school board room, in that athletic association meeting — looks the same.

Proverbs seventeen, verse twenty-eight says "Even a fool who keeps silent is considered wise; when he closes his lips, he is deemed intelligent." That verse gets weaponized constantly by men who want to justify inaction. But read it in context. Solomon isn't praising silence as a lifestyle. He's saying that a fool who finally shuts up long enough to stop embarrassing himself is making progress. The point isn't that silence is always wisdom. The point is that controlled speech is the mark of a man who has something worth saying.

And that's the Republic framework. It starts with you. Do you actually know what you believe about this? Or have you been so allergic to the conversation that you haven't done the work of forming a position from Scripture and reason? A man who hasn't thought it through can't speak clearly. So the silence that's required first is internal — shut down the noise long enough to know what you actually think.

Then it moves to your household. Your daughter is watching. Your son is watching. They are learning right now whether the men in their world will say hard things or go quiet when the room gets uncomfortable. What they learn at home is what they'll expect everywhere else.

Then it moves to the church. Is your pastor addressing what's happening in the culture around his congregation, or is he avoiding it because it's messy? You have a voice there too. Use it rightly — with respect, with preparation, not with rage — but use it.

Then it moves to the public square. School boards. Athletic associations. City councils. These rooms are not filled with giants. They're filled with people who showed up. The question is whether you will.

Which brings me to your charge for today.

Here's your command: Find the place where your silence has been cowardice — and this week, prepare to speak.

I'm not telling you to go pick a fight. I'm not telling you to walk into a room and perform outrage. That's not what this is. What this is — is a man identifying the specific conversation, the specific room, the specific moment he has been avoiding because it costs something. And deciding in advance what he will say, and how, and when.

Here's what that looks like in practice. Maybe it's that you haven't told your son clearly what you believe about what's happening in girls' sports right now — because you didn't want to have to explain it. Do it this week. Not with anger. With clarity. He needs to hear you say what's true before the world tells him what to think. Maybe it's that your school board has a meeting coming up and you've never been in that room. Go find out when it is. Put it on your calendar. You don't have to have a speech ready for the first meeting. You just have to be there.

Maybe it's that there's a conversation in your marriage that you've been swallowing for months — and you call it keeping the peace, but she knows it's avoidance, and you know it too.

Here's what disobedience costs. Your children grow up watching men go silent under pressure and they learn that's what men do. The girls in your community lose another round not because the opposition was stronger, but because the men who should have shown up didn't. And you — you carry the weight of knowing you saw it, you knew what was right, and you said nothing. That weight compounds. It doesn't disappear.

The Anchor. First Peter three, verse fifteen, English Standard Version. "But in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect."

Prepared. Gentle. Respectful. But always — always — ready to speak.

If today's charge moved you, Men of the Republic is where this goes deeper. The book is at carlosreyesiii.com. I'm Carlos Reyes. Govern yourself. Lead your household. Take your square. This is The Republic Briefing.