Zen Community of Oregon Dharma Talks

Jomon explores the Diamond Sutra and its invitation to loosen our grip on fixed ideas about ourselves and the world. Through the simple example of a cup of tea, stories of Zen teachers, and reflections on habitual thought, Jomon invites us to meet life with curiosity, humility, and a willingness to let go of what we think we know.
★ Support this podcast ★

What is Zen Community of Oregon Dharma Talks?

New podcasts every Tues, Thurs and Sat. Here you can find talks from various teachers involved with the Zen Community of Oregon. We share talks from our retreats, as well as our different weekly offerings between Great Vow Zen Monastery and Heart of Wisdom Zen Temple.

Zen Community of Oregon's purpose is to express and make accessible the wisdom and compassion of the Buddha’s teachings, as transmitted through an authentic, historical lineage. To support and maintain Zen Buddhist practice in order to realize and actualize our Buddha nature in everyday life.

For more information, please visit zendust.org.

Jomon:

Hello, and welcome. This is the Zen Community of Oregon, making the teachings of the Buddhadharma accessible to support your practice. New episodes air every week. Good morning and welcome to a beautiful rainy day in Oregon and from wherever people are in the Zoom world. This rainy season here is something that gets in your bones, think, when you live in Oregon and the Pacific Northwest.

Jomon:

And I've seen a few transplants bounce off of it a little bit, you know, maybe a couple years of it and woah, uh-uh, can't do it. But maybe those of us who have a little bit of moss in our blood sort of thrive on all of this moisture. And so here we are in a rainy season, just like in the time of the Buddha, we utilize this time to deepen our practice. And so we are in this season we call Ongo in the Japanese Zen tradition that is translated to mean peaceful dwelling, peaceful dwelling. Here at the monastery the schedule is intensified and all of the practice places in the Zen Community of Oregon are participating together in this deepening of practice and this theme of Ongo at the monastery, at Heart of Wisdom, at Plum Blossoms Endo in Vancouver, and at Trillium House.

Jomon:

Everyone is in their own way practicing and if you haven't had a chance to join in this effort, there is a central repository for a lot of the information on the website under the blog title so you can look that up and find catch up with everyone and maybe even make a commitment. How might you intensify your practice? How might you prioritize your practice? That can look all kinds of ways. So I encourage you.

Jomon:

Theme, one of the themes, or I guess a guiding aspect of our practice is this look at the Diamond Sutra. And so we are working with this particular translation by Ken MacLeod who very generously donated a slew of these books to our community. The book is called This Unexpected Jewel, Reading the Diamond Sutra. And it is meant to be read aloud as a practice. It apparently takes about forty minutes.

Jomon:

I haven't had a chance to do it all the way through just yet, but it is a lovely translation of the Diamond Sutra. And so I'll talk a little bit about that today. The Diamond Sutra is primarily a conversation between the Buddha and the monk Subhuti. And it's wonderful how it begins with Subhuti asking a very important question. Basically, how should we practice?

Jomon:

How should we hold our minds? And if you got to meet the Buddha and sit in front of the Buddha, I mean, I hope I would have been as wise to ask a question like that. Just how should we practice? How should we hold our minds? So from the MacLeod translation, Most honored, how should those who have entered the way of the bodhisattva live?

Jomon:

How should they practice and how should they hold their minds? A slightly different translation from Thich Nhat Hanh of this line, the question from Subhuti. World Honored One, if sons and daughters of good families want to give rise to the highest, most fulfilled, awakened mind, what should they rely on? And what should they do to master their thinking? I liked that.

Jomon:

What should they rely on? What should they rely on? How should they practice? How should they hold their minds? The Diamond Sutra is all about seeing the ineffability and the way that everything, everything is constantly changing and is therefore not the way it seems.

Jomon:

Things are not things with permanence or solidity as we tend to treat them and respond to them. The monk Subhuti is asking the Buddha to teach about how to hold our minds. And this sutra, the whole thing, is the Buddha's response in dozens of examples. In particular, there are several examples of this manner of teaching, this particular formula of an example. With regard to A, what is called A is not A.

Jomon:

That's why it's called A. Or another way to say it, there's not really A. We only call it A. That's why it's called A. So one example of this is in the...

Jomon:

He uses an example of generosity. At this point the depth of these teachings, this is another really interesting part by the way that it's through this example that Subhuti starts to weep. He is moved to tears at the point he begins to understand what the Buddha is saying. So this is this is the moment at which the depths of these teachings moved Subhuti to weep. After he had wiped away his tears, Subhuti said to the Most Honored, how these teachings are expressed in the way that thusness teaches is awe inspiring.

Jomon:

And in this translation, Ken MacLeod uses the word thusness as another way to refer to Buddha, that thusness is a translation of the Tathagata, or the one who has gone thus, thus come one. And so it can kind of refer to the Buddha specifically or to thusness itself, that the teachings arise from thusness. How these teachings are expressed in the way that thusness teaches is awe inspiring. Most honored is awe inspiring, most joyous, most honored since timeless awareness took birth in me. I have never heard these teachings expressed in this way.

Jomon:

Most honored with this explanation of the sutra, those sentient beings who give rise to a correct understanding will be truly remarkable. What is the point here? The point most honored is that that which is correct understanding is without understanding. Therefore, thusness calls it a correct understanding. That it can't be grasped.

Jomon:

And that's what's being offered, that it can't be grasped, thus recalling that correct understanding even though it can't be understood, grasped. So maybe a different example. There's not really a thing as a cup of tea. It's made of parts that are anything but tea. It's made of ceramic.

Jomon:

It's made of empty space. It's made of water. It's made of dried herbs, heat, electricity maybe, or gas, or power generated from the Columbia River, money, history, grocery stores, the Silk Road. It's all in there. How many people's livelihoods are in a cup of tea?

Jomon:

Where does it end? It's really boundless. A cup of tea doesn't exist without all these things. And yet we hold frozen in our mind a concept of a cup of tea. So go ahead right now and imagine a cup of tea.

Jomon:

What is your experience of that? And the sense of even knowing what that is. What is the cup? What is the tea? What is happening there?

Jomon:

Would anybody be willing to describe cup of tea?

Jomon:

I think the cup of tea I had this morning. Mhmm. So it's a little mug that's in my room and it's got some little, I think a goose or something on it.

Jomon:

A mug with a goose on it? Mhmm. Mhmm. That's important. Mhmm.

Jomon:

It's an Assam tea bag.

Jomon:

Assam tea.

Jomon:

Brewed first thing in the morning.

Jomon:

Mhmm. I

Jomon:

got some half and half from the tea fridge.

Jomon:

Okay. So it's Assam tea in a mug with a goose on it that is brewed in the morning and has a little bit of cream in it, half and half in it. Alright, that is a cup of tea. What else is a cup of tea? It's comfort.

Jomon:

It's comfort. The vision that you have when I say cup of tea, what is the actual vision in your mind? There is a feeling of comfort too with it. Yes. Is warm.

Jomon:

Warm. And you have to slow down and sip it. And so Embedded in the drinking of tea is the time that it takes to, and the temperature, and so slugging back a cup of tea is not your idea of a cup of tea. Alright, thank you. Other ideas, concepts of tea?

Jomon:

Sip it hot, water. Sip it hot diluted water. Mhmm. Not a fan. Not a fan, apparently.

Jomon:

Steam and aroma. Steam and aroma. What is the aroma? Probably a mint. A mint.

Jomon:

Mint. Yeah. Mint tea is mint tea. Yeah. Yeah.

Jomon:

The demo. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. So many ideas of tea.

Jomon:

And so if we we forget that this isn't real, we have this idea of what it is or what it should be or what we think it is, and then an actual cup of tea is presented in front of you that could take any endless number of shapes or smells or flavors. But if it doesn't match my idea, then I might be disappointed or I might be delighted. But there's perhaps a gap in between my idea and then the actual reality, for sure. What if reality doesn't align with our concepts? How do we usually work with that?

Jomon:

So this is one example of, there's really not a cup of tea that any two people could ever agree about, is there? Especially if you have opinions and views. I have a friend who's British, who had a very, very clear idea of what a cup of tea is, that it's P and G tips steeped for a certain amount of time such that when you put the milk in it still has a slightly ruddy color. And certainly iced tea was a total abomination to this person. So there's not really a cup of tea.

Jomon:

We only call it a cup of tea. That's why we call it tea. So that when I go into a restaurant and I say, I'd like a cup of tea, I might actually get something that vaguely resembles this idea. But just like that cup of tea, there's not really a Jomon. Who was the Jomon that arrived here today?

Jomon:

The Jomon of ten years ago was not the same, will not be the same as this moment is continually changing. How do I keep thinking I am the same person? Who do I keep thinking I am? Am I my habits? Am I my story?

Jomon:

How much of identity can change until it's no longer me? What what are all the things that could fall away and yet there could still be a Jomon? Is it really so unchangeable? Is it really so solid? So there's some utility in having these conventions of tea or Jomon so that I don't have to introduce myself anew every single time I see someone like, hi, I'm the brand new Jomon of this moment, that would be annoying.

Jomon:

As true as it is. That's why we call it a cup of tea.

Jomon:

Can I have a cup

Jomon:

of tea? Sure. That's why we call it that. But we just call it that. But we can begin to see that it's so much more.

Jomon:

That it's everything. So we can begin to see our thoughts in this way too, how we create these concepts, these frozen ideas, how we believe our own stories, and we forget that that's all they are. They're just representations. We begin to see that many of these things cause suffering in our life because we have gripped onto our concepts of how it should be. So when we loosen our grip, can we loosen our grip on what we think is definitive, certain, or immovably problematic?

Jomon:

Can we loosen our grip on these ideas about ourselves or about others? Even just seeing these concepts or these ideas that we have that we treat as reality can be kind of hard. I've done this exercise a few times and I'd like to invite you to do it again if you've done it before or maybe it's new for you. But if you're comfortable go ahead and close your eyes. And now if you're here in the Zen Do, bring to mind every detail of this Zen Do, of this meditation hall and what's in it and what it looks like, all of the objects, and see if you can recreate it in your mind exactly as closely as possible or whatever room you're in.

Jomon:

Go ahead and close your eyes and try to recreate exactly in your mind this room. And when you've got it all clear, lots of details, very specific, go ahead and open your eyes and see what you've missed. See how the concept of the Zen Do is really one dimensional compared to this living, breathing room full of worlds. Each person is a world that we can't possibly truly imagine in our concept of Zendo with some people in it. So after many rounds of this A is not A, that's why we call it A, and other aspects of the teaching, that he's moved to tears.

Jomon:

So the Buddha then says, the only thing bodhisattvas need to do is to free themselves from all concepts and nurture the aspiration for freedom. They shouldn't allow the mind to dwell on concepts that arise from anything they can perceive, from sight, sound, smell, taste, touch, or any other qualities. The mind should be kept independent of any thoughts that arise within it. If the mind depends upon anything, it has no sure refuge. That's the Stephen Mitchell translation.

Jomon:

The only thing bodhisattvas need to do is free themselves from all concepts and nurture the aspiration for freedom. The mind should be kept independent of any thoughts that arise within it. If the mind depends upon anything, it has no sure refuge. In the MacLeod translation he says, In the same way, Subhuti, bodhisattva, mahasattvas cease to engage concepts and set their intention on ultimate, full, and complete awakening. They also set their intention without dwelling on form.

Jomon:

They set their intention without dwelling on sound, smell, taste, touch, or thought. They set their intention without dwelling on the absence of thought. They set their intention without dwelling on anything. What does it mean that the mind should be kept independent of any thoughts that arise within it. Kept independent.

Jomon:

I don't think this is swatting away thoughts or suppressing thoughts or fighting with thoughts certainly, but just being independent of thoughts, watching them come and go without getting too entangled in them. Seeing thoughts as just thoughts, not dwelling on them, not not dwelling on them. I mean, I can have any kind of thought. I am from the planet Jupiter. That's a thought.

Jomon:

But how come that feels so different from or somehow less believable than I will never be good enough? Why are they so different? They're just thoughts. I will never be good enough. Is that true?

Jomon:

But there are perhaps we could, maybe everyone, I don't know, you tell me. For many of us there are sticky, repetitive, ruminative thoughts. Some thoughts seem to have formed a groove in our brains. And what about that when we might catch ourselves dwelling on these thoughts or catch ourselves trying to depend on or believe certain thoughts. It may be that those would benefit from some inquiry.

Jomon:

Can we do this in a friendly way? Can we do this with curiosity? Why is this coming up repeatedly in my meditation? Or for example, a recent argument I had with a friend. I don't have to swat that away.

Jomon:

I don't have to fight with it. But I can notice that I happen to be stewing on this conversation. I notice that that's happening. I said that thing and then they said that thing and then I said that thing and they ought to know that they were not right about it. I was right about it and...

Jomon:

Next time I see them I'm gonna that is entanglement. That is dwelling on it. I am caught. I am in it. Completely hooked.

Jomon:

The big difference, the game changer is to be stewing and know that we are stewing. To be ruminating, worrying, planning, future tripping, judging, daydreaming, fantasizing, rehearsing, replaying, whatever your thing is, and to know that that is the habit of mind, probably quite familiar, and that's bringing awareness to it. Oh, Jomon, how long are you going to stew about this? Oh yeah, I have choice in that matter. What's going on here?

Jomon:

Do I need to do something else? If I notice I'm caught, that is what gives me more room. If I have an argument on repeat and I know it and I'm aware of it and I notice that it keeps happening, well then I can inquire about, well, what is perpetuating this? What is going on here? And just shed some light on it.

Jomon:

Drop down into the feeling tone. Is it all unpleasant? Oh, maybe there's some energy in there. Maybe there's some righteousness in there. Righteousness.

Jomon:

That's interesting. No wonder. What's under that though? What else is there? Oh, sadness.

Jomon:

Oh, hurt. And under that maybe a fear, fear of loss. No wonder it's sticky. There's fear. Well, am I safe right now?

Jomon:

Am I safe in this room? Is everything okay, really? Is this just something that's happening in this conceptual realm of thought and sensations of the body? Can I work with this material? What's also here without getting entangled it, can I just acknowledge it?

Jomon:

Can I just bow to it? Right there. That's where you bow. Go on. Yes.

Jomon:

This guy doesn't have too many concepts. Everything is new. Yeah, that's what we're going for. What a great example. So when we bow to what is, when we acknowledge what is, it doesn't actually have to take a super long time.

Jomon:

It doesn't have to take a whole retreat. It doesn't have to take a whole sitting period. Just be clearer and see if I can settle back into my practice. It's just noticing what is happening. Oftentimes these things do self liberate.

Jomon:

They go on about their own way when we're not holding on to them, arguing with them. My first silent retreat, I was so, I felt the silence was so precious. I hadn't had that experience before, and it felt so valuable, so rare and precious. And one of the first afternoons we're sitting outside having lunch and I was just so enjoying the not having to talk or do small talk. But then I started noticing this lady in front of me sitting across from me, she was chewing super loudly, and I became completely enraged.

Jomon:

Like, woah. And there's nothing to distract me from it, nothing for me to do about it, so all I could do was just look at it and realize, like, this is outsized. This is not commensurate with this innocent person just, you know, happily enjoying their lunch. What is happening here? Why so angry?

Jomon:

And so I just kind of looked at it for a minute like, I was like, oh, yeah. This is only how my dad ate my whole entire childhood. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

Jomon:

This is karma. And it just dissolved after that. It just completely dissolved. Yeah, in this being some story here. Shining the light of awareness on is already changing it.

Jomon:

It's already changing it. It may not dissolve immediately, or it might. But if we meet it with this gentle, kind attention, this inquisitive mind, patience, curiosity, determination to know our own mind, Doing this, it can't help but change. That is not dwelling on it. That is independence from it.

Jomon:

But it does require patience, especially the places where we get caught over and over again. Caught up believing our thoughts or drinking our own Kool Aid. I am right. I have been wronged. They should not be like that.

Jomon:

Things should be different than they are. And then maybe we catch ourselves on this treadmill of judgment, and we maybe pour on another layer of judgment. I should not be so judgmental. I should know better by now. Shouldn't I be more enlightened than this?

Jomon:

This may be hopeless. Those are just more thoughts upon thoughts. And it's natural for doubt, aversion, craving, restlessness, sleepiness, those are all hindrances. It's natural for those to appear and we can work with them over time, learn how to respond skillfully when they arise over time or immediately just by even questioning them. Is it true?

Jomon:

Is it true? In our community, we often use Byron Katie's The Work, which is a very beautiful form of inquiry, asking of these thoughts. Is it true? Can you absolutely know it's true? And who are you when you believe that thought?

Jomon:

And who would you be without that thought? This is inquiry. This is pointing to this very interesting moment of belief, which I'm always curious about, especially when we're doing the work. What is belief anyway? It seems to be invisible belief.

Jomon:

Or it's visible in our behavior, it's visible in our reactivity. But what is it? What is it when we lean into a concept, when we put all our weight onto a concept that is like everything, constantly moving and changing and flowing and ungraspable? Some example of beliefs, and she has a whole page of universal beliefs or very common beliefs. Some of those, I know what's best.

Jomon:

I know what's best for you. I know what's best for me. How many times have I been wrong about that? People should not be like that. What are your fixed beliefs?

Jomon:

It's easy to reify these thoughts, especially when they're associated with emotions and body sensations, which are real in the body. They're happening. They are occurring, they are convincing, they are compelling, they may be part of our survival system as an organism, but they do not make these thoughts true. When we believe a thought, this is being dependent on a thought. This is dwelling on thought.

Jomon:

Or maybe we could say dwelling in thought. We try to make it our home and shut the door and stay in there. Trying to take refuge in conditional, conventional reality when there's no unchanging reality. Another example is just currency, money. We generally agree on this conditional reality, but there's not really money in that these pieces of paper aren't inherently valuable and heck now it's computer digits.

Jomon:

We only call it money. But it's quite conventionally useful, so that's why we call it money. It's just a concept. But we can see right through that convention, that's not so hard. So what is behind that veil of our thoughts and beliefs?

Jomon:

It's the same. Once again, Subhuti moved to tears. The only thing Bodhisattvas need to do is free themselves from all concepts and nurture the aspiration for freedom. They shouldn't allow the mind to dwell on concepts that arise from anything they can perceive, from sight, sound, smell, taste, touch, or any other qualities. The mind should be kept independent of any thoughts that arise within it.

Jomon:

If the mind depends upon anything, it has no sure refuge. We're trying to take refuge, trying to dwell in these concepts. Have you ever experienced a moment when your beliefs were challenged? Or when you got to let go, maybe, of a fixed belief. Sometimes our paradigms shift in a in a major way.

Jomon:

Sometimes maybe our deepest assumptions are something we learned as a child. We can see easily that these assumptions no longer apply to the reality in front of us. This can sometimes be painful or it can be liberating. Sometimes we resist letting go of our assumptions. I can quit anytime.

Jomon:

Can think that about our own thoughts. I can quit any time. Or this is for their own good. Or this is just how I am. Or this is just how they are.

Jomon:

This is how they will always be. I can remember growing up as a child of the seventies and eighties, people who were gay, lesbians, they, you know, was not okay. There's something wrong or something laughable or terrible or wrong or bad about that. But then, my freshman year of high school, I met my friend Jim. And it was like the most obvious thing that I would be friends with this person who I came to just absolutely love, and so did my family.

Jomon:

And all those ideas that I had been taught that I thought were true just dissolved. Just like, oh, well, if Jim is gay, then all that stuff I heard before, that's clearly not true. Because he's wonderful. It's just simple, sometimes as simple as that, there's just reality. Just like this idea of a Zendo, the real Zendo is so much more interesting, isn't it?

Jomon:

It's so much more alive, it's so much more beautiful than this idea I thought I had about somebody or something. And yet, we keep trying to rely on those thoughts as if they're real. It's way more interesting in here. Beliefs may be another way of staying dependent on thoughts. Beliefs are perhaps attempts at refuge, and you can see the appeal.

Jomon:

Wouldn't it be great if this one thing, this one belief actually would be something sure in the swirling, boundless unpredictability of the actual world. Wouldn't it be great if we really could just pin ourselves down to something that was gonna always be true? Some idea that we have. But as we notice our own experience, if we really allow ourselves to be attentive to experience, to perception, sight, sound, smell, taste, touch, we can see how impermanent they are too. Even the present moment can be a concept, can

Jomon:

be

Jomon:

a goal, a place I can be or I cannot be. One of my favorite cartoons is this person who's saying, I'm really in the now. And then they go, I can't wait to blog about it. And they think about themselves in the little thought bubble blogging, I was so in the now. It's all there.

Jomon:

But even this is ungraspable. How can even this moment be a concept? The diamond suture points to the ungraspable nature of past, future, and the present. Ungraspable. Ungraspable.

Jomon:

So here's one way that this comes forward in the sutra. Subhuti, what do you think? Does thusness have physical sight? Most honored? Yes, indeed.

Jomon:

Thusness has physical sight. Subhuti, what do you think? Does thusness have divine sight? Most honored? Yes, indeed.

Jomon:

Thusness has divine sight. It goes on and on. Wisdom sight, spiritual sight, awake sight. Yes. Subhuti, what do you think?

Jomon:

If all the grains of sand in the Ganges Valley were to become Ganges Valleys, and all the grains of sand in them were to become world systems, would there be many world systems? Yes. Yes, indeed. Most honored. There would be many world systems indeed.

Jomon:

So let's let's make our minds really big here. Subhuti, I am fully aware of the mind streams of as many sentient beings as there are in those world systems. Why do I say that? Because Subhuti, thusness teaches that what is called a mind stream is without stream. Therefore, is called a mind stream.

Jomon:

Why do I say that? Because, subhuti, the past mind is not found, the future mind is not found, and the present mind is not found. That's another translation and many of the translations do use the word ungraspable, pointing to the ungraspable nature of past, future, and present. So the wonderful story about that is about Teishan, who was a scholar in the Tang dynasty, a scholar of the Diamond Sutra. And he was so renowned and really enjoyed his own story, his own hype that he was called the Diamond Sutra King.

Jomon:

And so king of the Diamond Sutra heard that there were these barbarians in the South Of China that were teaching about this mind to mind outside of scripture transmission, and he needed to school them such that he packed up all of his commentaries in a cart. There were so many, so many of his observations and thoughts and opinions about the sutra that he packed them up in a cart and had to go on down there to teach them about it. And on his way, as he's approaching one of the monasteries at the foot of a mountain, there's a tea house, and in it is a tea lady. And so she asks him what's in his cart and he's like, oh well don't you know who I am? I'm the king of the Diamond Sutra.

Jomon:

And she says, Oh, well that's nice. Hey, so you know, since you're the king of the Diamond Sutra, I have a question for you about that Diamond Sutra. And if you can answer it for me, I'll give you these tea cakes for free. But if you can't answer it, then you don't get anything. He's like, Oh yeah, okay, no problem, I got this.

Jomon:

She asks him, With which mind will you eat those tea cakes? Past mind, future mind, or present mind? And he's just struck into silence. He can't answer all of his scholarship, all of his opinions, of his commentaries. None of them are able to meet this moment, able to meet this living person, this question, this inquiry, these simple tea cakes.

Jomon:

So then he says, is there a Zen master around here I could talk to? He sought out a teacher and he burned his commentaries in this realization that all of his concepts were just two dimensional, didn't, weren't up to the three-dimensional reality. So I love this story because in it are these assumptions of gender or ordination or station. Here's this, you know, scholar who's meeting a humble tea lady and yet her understanding was helpful to him. He surrendered.

Jomon:

He asked for help. He proceeded with humility and not knowing. Not knowing. These are the seeds of wisdom. And he wrote a poem, and I'll close with that.

Jomon:

I carried my commentaries over the mountains. I burned them in front of the master's gate. The fire warmed my hands. The teaching has not needed a footnote since. We already have everything we need.

Jomon:

Thank you. Thank you for listening to the Zen Community of Oregon podcast, and thank you for your practice. New episodes air every week. Please consider making a donation at zendesk.org. Your support supports us.