Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
The agents are your number one customer.
If you can, if you can roll out
the red carpet to an agent and make
your, your site super crawlable,
like, you know, provide these really
great endpoints and MCP or whatever
technology the agents really want,
you know, find the most accessible,
then you will get not ju- you're gonna
get thousands of customers, right?
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast,
where we explore the intersection
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call Retailgentic.
Our mission is simple.
We are shining a bright light
on new agentic AI shopping
megatrend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.
The stakes are high.
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.
What happens to checkout?
How should payments work?
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not
from humans, but from AI agents?
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating
our AI shopping agent future.
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast.
Today on the pod, we're gonna explore
the intersection of retail-focused ad
networks that everyone calls retail media
networks, or RMN, and agentic commerce.
To help with the discussion, I
called in a lifeline to a longtime
friend of mine, Kerrie Masters.
Kerrie founded the agency Bobsled
Marketing, which she then sold
about 10 years later to Acadia.
Those two experiences give Kerrie
over a decade of experience in retail
media networks and selling on Amazon.
Today, she is focused on her
awesome podcast, which I highly
recommend, and newsletter called
Retail Media Breakfast Club.
She's also a frequent contributor to
Forbes on these topics of the intersection
of retail and ads and many more.
Finally, she is an
advisor to us at RefiBuy.
On the pod, we go over Kerrie's background
and her entrepreneurial journey.
We then discuss some of the potential
impacts that agentic commerce could
have on the entire retail media network
ecosystem, and I get to hop on my
Amazon has way too many ads soapbox,
which is always a fun place to be.
Thanks, Kerrie, for coming on and helping
lead this dis- discussion as we explore
some of the impact agentic commerce
will have on retail media networks.
I hope
you learn as much about retail
media networks as I did.
I am here live with Kerrie Masters.
Kerrie, welcome to the Retailgentic
Podcast and welcome back to
the United States of America.
Thank you so much.
It's great to be here.
Yeah.
So, uh, you and I have known each
other for a very long time, but, uh,
listeners and viewers may not know you,
so let's start back at the beginning.
Where, uh, where are you from, and
give us a little bit of background that
how did you, how did your background
lead you into this exciting world
of e-commerce and retail media?
Yeah.
So I'll, I'll rewind just to 2015, which
was the first year of Prime Day, when
Amazon really started to kind of…
I, I think there was a bit of an
inflection point of a, of a year, really.
Um, I had no background in
retail or e-commerce or agency
world, and I decided to start an
Amazon marketing agency in 2015.
And the reason, reason for that was,
um, I was working a corporate job.
I was working in banking.
I was in New York working for Chase Bank,
and I had this e-commerce business on
the side that was, like, my nights and
weekend kind of hobby business selling
craft supplies, and eventually started
selling those products on Amazon.
And then I would, you know, I'd
speak with my clients at the bank
and I'm, I was like, "I know more
about Amazon than these guys.
Maybe I could go and just
be a, be a consultant."
So that's what I did in, in 2015, and
like I said, it was kind of, it was, I
was kind of unwittingly at the beginning
of a pretty big wave with e-commerce and
re- eventually retail media at that time.
And the agency I started was called
Bobsled Marketing, and, um, propelled by
that and, and doing a lot of free content
along the way, 'cause I didn't have any
Rolodex and I didn't have any money, but
I did have time to blog and write videos
and start podcasts and stuff like that.
So, um, we became a, a pretty well-known
agency in the space, and in 2022
Bobsled was acquired by another agency
out here in Atlanta called Acadia.
Um, so I was there for a couple of
years and then I left, um, last year and
started a publication called Retail Media
Breakfast Club, which is a almost daily
podcast and newsletter talking about
trends, um, in the retail media space.
Let's go back to Bobsled.
Why Bobsled?
It…
Was it, was it an Olympic year?
Are you an avid bobsledder?
Or what?
Tell me about the origin of the name.
Yeah.
I don't know if you, you have like a, a,
a really smart, uh, way of thinking about
naming your companies, Scott, but I don't.
Um-
That's fine.
I always like to hear the s- there's
always a story inside these things.
It was kinda like we'd, um, needed a
name, needed to like register my LLC.
I'm like, "Oh, I gotta
come up with a name."
And we ha- my husband and I ha- uh, we got
from this very eccentric friend a wedding
gift that was a, it was a toboggan, and I
turned it into a light fixture and I put
it on the wall of our Brooklyn apartment.
I was like, "Oh, what name am I gonna
come up with for, for this agency?
Oh, Bobsled."
It's like, you know, it's a performance
sport, it's like a team sport,
it's about speed and execution.
I was like, "I'll come up
with a tagline later, but I'll
just call it Bobsled for now."
I never really came up with a
really good tagline, but that's
why it was called Bobsled.
Oh.
Inspired by a toboggan lamp.
Yeah.
And then, uh, explain, you know, so as
an agency, what, what was the profile…
That, that has like a wide spectrum
of things when you have that word.
What was the profile of your customer?
Were they all selling on Amazon?
Were they brands?
Were they retailers?
Were they like kinda small
entrepreneurial third-party sellers?
What, what did that look like?
Yeah.
So initially it was, you know,
whoever would pay me, and in many
cases didn't end up paying me.
Um, so it was small startups
and, you know, small companies.
Over ti- over time- It got larger
mid, mid-market and towards the end,
um, a smattering of, of enterprise
brands and, and things like that.
But, um, at, at, at the time
back in 2015, there was really…
Um, it's a very, it's a very dense
space now in terms of competition.
There are so many agencies that, that
cover the space and have different value
props for different types of audiences.
Um, but back then it was, you
know, the holding company agencies
just didn't take it seriously.
I, and I remember in the, in the
early days listening to some interview
with, I don't remember which holding
company CEO it was, but they were being
asked about Amazon, and they c- it,
the CEO just completely blew it off.
Like, "Oh, we don't see
any opportunity there.
That's kind of ridiculous.
This is all gonna blow over."
But that was really the, uh, the approach.
And I, I do remember, like, i- in, in
2015, still having these conversations
with brands who just r- just had
no idea that their shoppers were
buying their category on Amazon.
We'd speak with a luxury skincare
brand, and they'd say, "Well, our
shopper doesn't shop on Amazon."
Like, putting, putting, um, luxury
skincare in the same shopping cart
as toilet paper, I mean, come on.
Um, so there was still a lot of resistance
back then from, uh, from certain brands
and, and even a lot of the established
agencies to recognize that consumer,
uh, behaviors were changing, which
is why you and I are talking today.
Like, I, I think that we're at a similar
inflection point in that consumer
behavior is, is about to change really,
really quickly, and we'll look back
at 2025 and say, "Well, that's sort
of really where it all started."
As a founder f- a fellow founder, I always
love to ask these types of questions.
Like, so you grew from, you know,
seven years is a really good run.
First of all, congrats on that.
Most, you know, every year you survive
as a business, there's only, like, maybe
10% of companies make it that year.
So, so once you get to seven years
old, you're into that, like, .001
kind of, kind of r- range.
Um, so what was it like
selling after seven years?
Some, some people when they sell
their first company, it's kind of like
giving up a child, and other people
are very, like, "All right, I w- I was
kind of burned out, and I am now…"
It's like the ha- the happiest day.
Like, what, how did it land for you?
It was all of the above.
It was- … it was great.
I, I, I sold to a really great
company, um, and they, they were…
That doesn't happen all the time.
Um- Uh, so they, they were awesome
and, and, and did everything that
they promised, which is great.
And my whole, like, management
team, they're all still there.
They're all still at Acadia- Great
… like three years later, which is awesome.
Um, but it was also kind of
devastating in a way as well.
I was burnt out, I was ready to sell.
But, um, I think a lot of people, a
lot of people who sell their companies,
it's a huge percentage that have kind
of a bit of a breakdown afterwards,
and they suffer some, maybe for the
first time in their lives, like some-
a real change in identity because
it's not all about you anymore.
You're not carrying the load of the
company anymore, for better or worse.
And, um, that changes your p- whole
perspective and reason for being.
So certainly came with challenges
that I wasn't expecting.
And you've, but you made it through.
I made it through.
So that brings us to
what are you up to now?
So you're, you're obviously a
thought leader and you, you have
the Retail Media Breakfast Club,
and you write, um, do a lot of
writing and stuff, which is awesome.
And is there any desire to take
another run at, at doing something
or are you doing a little bit
of consulting on the side?
Like, what else is going
on in the world of Kiri?
Yeah.
It's, it's, it, it may evolve over time,
but for now, I'm, I'm very curiously
following the, the space and doing this
publication and, you know, I'm, I'm…
The, the way I'm monetizing that is
through sponsorships and speaking
at events and things like that.
I saw a gap in the space for commentary.
There's a lot of news out there, and
there's some fantastic journalists
that cover the space from a news
perspective, but, um, when you're
a j- when you're a real journalist,
you can't share your opinions.
It's not about you.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Journalists are an inch
deep and a mile wide.
They- they'll cover, you know,
this, that, and then they have to
cover some other, you know, some
other fintech thing or something.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, the, I mean, there is, there's,
there are some journalists out
there, um, at, at publications who,
who really do focus on the space
and they're, they're brilliant.
But I think what I, what I wanted to
do is a bit more commentary and, like,
maybe say some of the things that
people think but don't say out loud.
And in this space, there's, um,
there's different stakeholders that
have quite different perspectives,
and they don't always understand
those other perspectives.
So the retailers are the one, you know, in
the retail media space, they're the ones
standing up these retail media networks.
They've had these management
consultants come in to the, to
the retailer and say, "You…
Retail media profit margins are 80%
and you sh- you should be able to
build a, you know, a, an eight-figure
media business in the next 12 months."
And they get so excited.
They go stand up these media networks.
It's not, doesn't grow as quickly
or is as profitable as they were
promised by the consultants.
So then they're trying to cut costs and
grow the network, maybe cut some corners
in terms of their actual ad product.
So the brands actually spending money
on these networks are a bit disappointed
because they don't get the data back,
they're not getting what they…
They're not getting from retailer XYZ what
they get from Amazon, but they're kind
of being forced into spending this money.
So they're not happy about that.
Um- And then there's the tech ecosystem
and the agency ecosystem as well.
And the, just the, the dyn- the
relationship dynamics between those
four stakeholders in, in the game is
quite interesting, and there's a lot
of tension and, uh, unspoken, uh,
un- unspoken issues bubbling- Love,
hate, hate, love kind of
thing going around the circle
a bit.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Mm-hmm.
Exactly.
Exactly.
So it's, it's a very rich, rich
and interesting space to cover.
And then so your gateway into retail media
network, I've always assumed, but just to
verify, is you were helping people do more
like traditional selling on Amazon, 3P.
Maybe then you kind of like got into
a little bit of 1P 'cause you kind of
like have to help people navigate that.
You pick up a little FBA, and then
Amazon's added more and more ad
capabilities, and then other retailers
have replicated that, and that's
kind of the form of retail media.
Is that kind of how you got into it?
Yeah, absolutely.
Yeah.
So back, back in 2015, Amazon, uh, at
least, unless if you were a huge brand,
you had a direct, um, you know, uh,
advertising way into to Amazon, I guess.
But the biddable media on Amazon was
like auto campaigns or manual campaigns,
phrase match or exact match, and that was,
that was kind of, that was kind of it.
So over time they've…
And they've done a fab- an incredible
job of building a really, really
amazing media network over time.
So, so the capabilities have expanded
on their side, um, really rapidly
over that period, and we have…
That they built a DSP, and they
built a data cloud and things
like that over, over time.
Um, so their capabilities grew and
then we had, uh, other retailers
coming into the mix with Walmart.
Best Buy has had a retail media
network for, for a very long time.
Um, eBay was a, you know, huge
early mover there as well.
But then, you know, Instacart
and, um- All, all of the, a lot of
other retailers came into the frame
more recently, so that's when the
retail media moniker came along.
But now there's, like, this huge
push, uh, in the industry to extend
beyond retail media to commerce media.
So I might have to change
the name of the podcast.
We'll see.
Is that because they wanna…
I, I keep hearing people wanna
do in-store, so they wanna have
screens, like, in your face on the
cart, like, you know, everyone wants
Minority Report where, like, constant
ads beaming at you every second.
Is that kind of the vision of
where- What's, what's the
problem with that, Scott?
Well, I'm, uh, as a
consumer, I'm not a huge fan.
This is where, yeah, we'll, we'll,
we'll talk about that, but yeah, I'm,
I'm not sure that's the, the retail
future I'll, I'm 100% signing up for.
In-store is a category of retail
media, but this is actually-- when
we're talking about commerce media,
it's the non-retail players that have
consumer data, um, that, that wanna,
like, resell that data in some cases.
In some cases, they have screens as well.
So United Airlines, Chase Bank,
PayPal, DoorDash, Marriott, they're
all rolling out their media networks.
And the thing is, those publishers have
had media networks for a long time.
Western Unit- Unions had
a network for a long time.
Expedia had a publishing
network for a long time.
They just didn't call it
retail media back then.
They just Had a nice little ad business
on the side, but now they wanna be part
of the, part of the, uh, the movement
Yeah.
And this is timely, Jason.
I just recorded our Amazon, uh, recap
for earnings, which came out yesterday,
and, uh, incidentally, Wall Street
did not like them because of AWS.
But the, the big surprise was the ad
platform accelerated even more, and now
it's growing about 23% year over year.
It's by far the fastest-growing part
of Amazon, with now AWS is, uh, growing
at, like, 17 and a half percent.
So, um, and it did 15.7
billion in the quarter, so that
gives it well north of a, uh, you
know, 65 billion run rate right now.
And then in fourth quarter-- I think
in third quarter it's gonna take a
huge step up because of Prime Day.
Um, did y- I heard that they were really
pushing ads very, very aggressively on
Prime Day, almost to the point of it's
become a gate where you can't participate
in the Prime Day activities without
buying a pretty big commitment on, on ads.
Um, how do, how do you feel about the
whole where Amazon is with all that?
None of it strikes me as anything
particularly new with, with, uh, you know,
ads being considered a, a, a, a toll, um,
to, to sell on Amazon or to participate.
It's pay to play at the end of the day.
And, and there's, there's some charts
out there from people, I've made a few of
them over the years as well, just showing
on an Amazon search results page just
how much real estate is taken up by ads.
And it is in many cases more
than half of the page is ads.
So there is a ga- and this is how a
lot of retailers are trying to think
about their media networks as well,
is there's a, there's a tipping point
where more ads, or let's say less
relevant ads, actually reduce GMV.
And, um, different tech vendors
in the space have looked at, you
know, that, that tipping point.
And for a retailer, at the very
co- the very core of their business
is this merchant organization
that's responsible for growing GMV.
And they, there's tension within
a retailer to drive that GMV, but
then also, like, build this pro-
much more profitable ads business,
even though it's much smaller.
So Amazon, I th- you know, they don't
seem to worry so much about that tension
as traditional retailers do because
it's so, it, it's like it was built into
their system right from the beginning,
um- And it is very interesting to see.
I mean, they're one of the only retailers
that's large enough to be required
to split out their ads business, so
Do, do you think they see
data that it's hurting?
It, it, I feel it's hurting
the customer experience.
Like, I can just feel it as a consumer.
Like, it's gotten to the
point where there's certain…
Especially as I get into CPG
stuff, it, it has made it a
game for me to find what I want.
Like, it's making it
al- almost impossible.
Like, there's so much ad load,
especially for some reason dog
treats is, like, just bonkers.
Um-
Mm-hmm
It has to be impacting some
element of their performance, but
I think, I think they don't care
or they look at the margin, right?
So you can lose a fair amount of GMV and
for an ad, 'cause the ad is pure margin,
and the margin from the GMV you're losing
is much smaller dollar, dollar for dollar.
So, so I think, I think they're making
a, an economic decision on margin,
but I think it'll erode LTV of the
customer base is what I worry about.
I, I don't disagree.
I don't love the experience m- myself, but
people have been saying that exact same
thing for the last three to four years.
And then it's like, they're
like, "It grew again."
Yeah, and they're like,
"Let's triple ad load."
Yeah.
And, and they keep growing,
and people keep shopping there.
So I think that there is a, you
know, there's a, there's a big…
A, a lot of people would say, "Oh,
there's too many ads on Amazon,"
but what are you gonna do next
time you need to, to add something?
I don't know, like the
behavior is just so strong.
Not to say that they can't be
disrupted and including by more, um,
uh, by new te- new technologies like
we're gonna talk about today that
have a better ex- ex- experience.
So yeah, Amazon, they, they need to keep
disrupting themselves, that's for sure.
Yeah.
That's, that's a good setup
for, we'll just jump into it.
The, um, you know, so you and I have
kind of gone back and forth on LinkedIn
and haven't had a chance to talk,
so this is like our first exposure.
And I don't know if you saw Roy
Rubin on, but that got a fair
amount of attention on the podcast.
He basically kinda said there'll
be a, there'll be a billion-dollar
brand without a website.
And, you know, he kind of views that
eventually if you're spending all this
time up at this gen AI agentic layer
and it's so convenient, why are you…
You're, you're gonna start to
atrophy and go to websites less.
Um, then if you take it to the logical
inclusion, it's kinda like, well, then
you can build a brand without ever having
to have like a traditional website.
Um, and there's a lot of those today.
You and I know TikTok
Shop is kinda like…
There, there's a lot of brands that
just exist on TikTok Shop, and I'm
sure they do have a website, but
if we were to look at a pie chart
of their sales, it's like 99.9%
of TikTok and, and other mechanisms
like that and like, you know, .001
direct from a website.
Um, but it is an interesting
thought experiment and then, so, so
that's a good thought experiment.
And then if, if that happens due to
this change in consumer behavior,
what happens to retail media networks?
Yeah.
Well, just to build on that point There
was a lot, ha- it's, it's less so now,
but there were a lot of businesses that
exclusively sold through Amazon FBA
Yeah, I've, I've met a lot of
the Channel Buying customer.
You would go visit them, and it
was like someone sitting in their
house, and they would, you know,
all the inventory, they would…
It's inventory arbitrage.
They would find something, usually
hair extensions or drones, um, off
of like an Alibaba, put it into a,
a fulfillment center and sell it on
Amazon and never, never touch it.
I remember the, the glory days well.
Yeah.
You probably had some as clients.
Um, yes.
They'd all get really big and then
they would just disappear one day.
Right.
Ex- ex- exactly.
So I don't, I don't know what
that says about the next wave
of, of website-less businesses.
Um-
So what do you think, uh, Gen AI
does to retail media networks?
There's an argument to be made that,
uh, retail media networks are a bit
of a trap that retailers have put
themselves into 'cause they've got an,
addicted to this high margin ad business-
Yeah
… and spending more, more mental
energy on that than selling stuff.
And we're about to enter a world
where selling stuff's gonna be really
important, and there's gonna be a
whole new mechanism, which is agentic
shopping, and they're not ready for it.
Looking forward to jumping into this
argument because, um, I, I wanna hear
what, what you have to say, but yes, I
think that there really is an existential
risk that AI, or at least a- agentic
shopping, um, poses to retail media.
So I'll, I'll break down some
core pieces of my argument.
I wanna hear what you think.
So one, the fundamentals of
economics in retail media, how
retailers make money, there's a few
different buckets of advertising.
One is the surface itself The on-site
ad surface that a retailer can sell.
So this would be your website, your app.
Um, that's an ad surface that
brands wanna be on because if we're
spending time on a bestbuy.com
or on an Amazon app, then the brands wanna
be there where people are making decisions
and, and considering their options.
And so the estimates vary on
this, but let's say that's a 70%
to 80% profit margin for running
these on-site ads for retailers.
So that's pretty attractive.
What's in the cost part of that?
Like, why isn't it 100% margin?
Like, what's the cost?
Just the cost of serving that?
Yeah.
So you have, um, t-technol-
different technology partners
that play a role in that.
So you've got an ad server, you've got
a supplier side platform, and then you
actually have to have a front door to
that ad inventory as well, which would
be a DSP, and everyone, like, everyone
takes a cut of that along the way.
Got
it.
Okay.
And then also, like, some, some
of these retailers and publishers,
they'll have, like, a direct sales
team as well that might handle the
VIP, um, sales orders coming in.
The other big piece of retail media
is off-site retail media, and what
happens here is a retailer will, um…
Sell is the wrong word.
They would never say sell, but they're
essentially selling the transaction and
audience data to third-party publishers.
So Disney, for example, Disney's
partnering with all of these retailers
so that an advertiser who wants, you
know, let's say you're a Kraft, y-
you're Heinz and you wanna be selling
more ketchup, then you're advertising
on Disney and using Albertson's audience
data to see, like, who, you know,
which families live in the suburbs
that are getting ready for a barbecue.
So that margin is lower.
Let's say that's 40%.
Again, it's gonna vary a little bit, but
making money off of that audience data.
And then finally, we talked a little
bit about in-store physical digital
signage and things like that.
Um, that is-- Oh, no, sorry.
What the physical environment,
this is more of the old school
type of trade marketing.
So the end caps and the, the, the,
the signs on the carts and things like
that, that's trade marketing and that's
where all the retailers are trying
to, like, move the budgets over from,
um, from trade marketing into retail
media, but that's super profitable.
That's pretty much 100% margin because
there's not really, um, there's less
technology involved with that and it's
really just, like, some humans on the,
on the retailer side managing that.
So then we get to this question of what
happens as consumer behavior starts to
shift from using a retailer website or app
to just now using ChatGPT or Perplexity
or whoever to research, find and buy.
You're not going to that retailer.com
or the app, you're not, uh, the--
I, I'm not sure who's gonna have the
transaction data on that if the, if
the retailer is gonna capture that or
if it's gonna be on the agent side.
That was one thing I
wanted to ask you about.
Yeah.
The, um, so there's no, there's no FBA.
It gets complicated with if you have
a third-party shipping piece in there.
But like let's say there's no FBA
option in there, and the, the way it
has to work is kinda like the way eBay
works, where you get a-- you receive
an order that's been paid for, and in
that order you're gonna get the bill to
information and the ship to, but you're
not gonna get the pay information.
So I'm gonna know I'm sending a,
a bottle of Heinz ketchup to Kerry
Masters in Atlanta, and I'm gonna
know her address, and I may know
her phone number, but that's it.
Right.
Yeah.
So, so I think, I think it
will most likely work that way.
There have been marketplaces proposed,
and this is one of the things Jet.com
did to be very differentiated,
is they basically said, "We're a
merchant-aligned marketplace, so
our customer is your customer.
We're, we're sharing that, all
that information with you."
So they would send downstream.
They still processed it.
It still showed up as merchant of record,
it was Jet, but then they would share
downstream a lot of the, the information.
Mm-hmm.
And what they were trying to do is get
the merchant aligned with, um, you know,
uh, it kinda had like a Shopify vibe, like
we're arming the rebels kind of thing.
We're arming you to sell
to these customers, and the
more we tell you, the better.
And then they, then they
were trying to incent the
merchants to offer lower prices.
Um, they would even share kinda
like how the merchant was doing in
the auction basically, um, kinda
like the buy box like auction.
And then they would also incent the
merchant to take, um, ACH payment, um,
and encourage customers to do that so
that then, uh, the payment processing fees
were lower and all these kinds of things.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So it was, it was interesting.
So we don't know until
they launch this thing.
I imagine It's gonna be,
it'll look more like…
They'll probably, the fast way
to build this is using Stripe
actually has a platform for this.
It's a marketplace platform, and
it's gonna probably be built on that.
And then they'll have Shopify sitting
next to it if you're a Shopify merchant.
So I imagine it's gonna
look like what I said.
You're gonna get a paid for order, and
it will, it will have all the shipping
information, and it'll be, you know, a
fulfillable order that's been paid for.
So that is gonna put this whole
offsite retail media business at
risk for retailers because they
don't have the transaction data
and the s- the signal data as well
is what's really important too.
So maybe-
They would have the transaction
data, so they would know that Kerry
bought the Heinz Ketchup for eight
bucks, a two pack or whatever it was.
Oh.
So they would know that.
Yeah.
Oh, okay.
All right.
They don't have traffic on their
site, so the, you know, the consumer,
they don't know the consumer journey.
They just get, like, an
order that came back.
I think e- it- even in that scenario
when the retailer has the transaction
data, the agent's gonna have the
transaction data as well, right?
'Cause they actually went
and did the transaction.
So now you've got two parties that know
that Kerry went and bought the ketchup,
and that degrades the, the, the, um, the
scarcity of that data from the retailer.
'Cause th- this is a
huge thing that they…
It's a huge advantage for
retailers is that they cover,
you know, different value props.
"Oh, we cover all of Texas," or
we, you know, "We're the number
one electronics retailer."
And so that, that, that first party
data that they can allow advertisers
to activate offsite Now, w- w- ChatGPT
can sell that data to advertisers as
well, so it degrades the value of that.
Yeah, they- they…
Sam Altman has said pretty
publicly he doesn't wanna do ads.
Mark Zuckerberg said the same thing.
And- … and Sam Altman just went
and hired Fidji Simo from Instacart,
who built a, a, a very successful ads
business over there to lead application.
So I'm, I'm sorry, I don't
buy it at, like- Yeah
first, second that there
won't be ads in ChatGPT.
Yeah.
I, I, I think you're probably right.
Yeah.
I think, I think they have a lot of, uh…
They're losing 5 billion a year, and
they'll have a lot of flexibility of
making revenue to cover that, sure.
This is…
It, it's such a no-brainer
for them to do it.
So then what's left from those three
buckets of income that I mentioned
to you before, you've, you've
still got the physical environment.
You can still do end
caps, you can still do…
This is not my world, so I don't
know all the, all the, all the terms.
But all this, this trade budget that's
currently at risk from the hot new
thing, which is retail media, ironically,
I think that's actually very safe,
'cause people still will go to stores.
And peop- some people, uh, uh, if
they disagree with me, they're like,
"Oh, but you think you're gonna allow
an agent to buy everything for you?"
And it's like, well, no, there's…
It will still be one of several
modalities that we use to go buy things.
There's, there'll still be stores.
So that's sort of what, how I see things
shifting, and then what retailers do
with that and what brands do with that
evolution is, um, yeah, something el-
something else that we can talk about.
I have some ideas, but I'll,
I'll just, I'll just stop there
and see if you have any holes to
poke in my, in my outlook there.
No, I think it's right.
Let's say And it's easy-- It's a good
thought experiment to kind of paint
these things as black and white.
It's kind of like you, you see,
you feel the edge cases and p- you
can kind of see what's going on.
But, you know, we've been-- you've been
at this for 10 years, I've been at it
probably like 30, and, you know, I'm
always surprised e-commerce is only
like, depending on which number you
look at, 16% to 20% of overall sales.
So, so I, I do think, to your point,
I think this is just gonna be another
modality of how people are shopping,
and I think it probably gets to…
I saw a PayPal CEO said 25% of
e-commerce will be agentic by 2030.
That, that feels right.
But it's 25% of 20%, which is
4% of commerce, so, you know.
So it'll probably be a, a percentage, um,
and, you know, that, that itself isn't
material for commerce, but 25% is, right?
Material being defined
of anything over 10%.
But what, what happens if
25% of the traffic goes away?
Like, and you, you know
this world better than I do.
Certainly, you know, so
Amazon would feel it, right?
Because that's a $60 million line item
for them that's, I think, pure margin.
So that would go down
by 25% just naturally.
Or, um…
But then, like, who else do you think
that's cataclysmic for your world?
Or people would be like, "Oh, it
just makes inventory more valuable
and people will pay more for it."
Like, is there a counterbalance for that?
Yeah.
It's, it's a really great point about
it being a percentage of a percentage,
and ironically, I, I think you're right
that the, that the retailers that have
the biggest exposure to commerce, the
e-commerce, will have the biggest hit.
I mean, there's not many
There's, there's not so many…
I mean, I, I, I shop online a lot
regardless of the category, but for s-
for a, for a grocery retailer, like a
Albertsons or an H-E-B or someone like,
someone like that, people aren't doing
s- they're, they're not so much going
to the website and checking out or using
the app unless they're, um, they're a,
a, a, a chronically online, um, shopper.
So really the, the going, the, the
onsite environment for them is probably
less of a revenue stream than the,
um, the off, than the offsite in terms
of volume- Mm-hmm … that they're
bringing in with their network.
So yeah, I think you're,
I think you're right.
The ones that are more exposed
to e-commerce probably stand
to ga- to, to lose the most.
I think, and this just occurred to me, but
I think another big loser in this could
be Instacart because, um, yeah, that's
where having an agent is super helpful
because it's such a drag to press all
the buttons to get like the avocado added
to your cart in Instagram, in Instacart.
So, so I wonder, and then if it's
like an agent kind of pressing those
buttons, then the ad efficacy could go
way down because that's a huge part of
Instacart's revenue, right, is, is ads.
It's like last I looked it was, it was
almost all the margin if, and, and-
Mm … a pretty material part of revenue.
So that- Yeah … that's interesting.
And a lot of people have
been leaving Instacart.
I don't know if you've followed this or
not, but, uh, so you mentioned Fiji left.
The chief product officer
just got went to Walmart.
Uh, Perplexity hired previous
chief product officer.
And I think there's like three
or four people underneath
those folks that have left.
So I wonder if there's a little
bit of writing on the wall at, at
Instacart that maybe this agentic
thing is, is somewhat risky for them.
Interesting.
Yeah, and I, I think that there is still a
lot for retailers to, to do here as well.
I actually think, um, that
there's a very significant
opportunity for loyalty programs.
If you think about what kind of
preferences am I gonna feed to my AI
s- s- s- uh, sidekick, it's- Dietary
preferences, um, budget preferences,
uh, but it's also if there is a reta-
if a retailer has a really strong
loyalty program, that's potentially
gonna factor into my criteria as well.
So I might say like a grocery shopping
build a basket scenario, build a
basket, I'm making these five meals
this week, build a basket and like
tell me who's, whi- which retailer
is gonna be cheaper for all these
things that I need on my list.
It might come back with, you know,
retailer A is cheaper than retailer B,
but oh, I'm, I just remembered like I
have my loyalty tier with retailer B
and even though they're a little bit
more expensive, let's go with them
'cause I really wanna get this perk
that they offer when I get to the next
tier, or they always give me samples
in my order or what, you know, what-
whatever it is for retailers that-
Gas poi- for me it's gas points.
There you go.
Yeah, gotta get, get our
Harris Teeter gas discount.
Harris Teeter- … you listening?
They're part of Kr- they're
part of the Kroger group.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So that is, I, I think that
that's a, a, a really big
opportunity that could come back.
Um, and then other differentiators,
and th- these are not new concepts, but
you can differentiate on fulfillment
speed, you can differentiate on ease of
returns, you can differentiate like a,
a Sprouts farmer's market or something
like that on unique selection and
having like, you know, more homegrown
brands or what- whatever it is.
So this is…
There's, there's still many
things that retailers can do.
Um, and then we get into this
topic of like gating the agents,
and this is where I find it super
interesting, this philosophical
divide between Walmart, who is
By comparison to Amazon, like flinging the
doors open and saying "Welcome, welcome,
we welcome, uh, our robot overlords."
Like, at, at some point in the future
they actually want Sparky to integrate
with external agents, whereas Amazon's
building their, like, closed ecosystem.
Like Alexa, you, you know, you
use Alexa Plus for everything.
So, like, that'll be super
interesting to see how that plays out.
Yeah, if you're number one, you
wanna protect your position.
You're king of the hill,
so you build a wall.
And if you're number two and you've been
trying to catch number one for 30 years
and, and frustratingly you've never
gotten close, this is your opportunity
to lean in and finally catch up to them.
So, so it is interesting to…
It's gonna be very fascinating the
next three or four years to see
which of those decisions, right?
Yeah.
I had this, it-- when I posted a, an
article on this, I f- I, I'm sorry for
forgetting who commented this on LinkedIn,
but they said, um "Well, Walmart has just
been behind the eight ball for so long.
They missed the boat on marketplaces.
They missed the boat on ads.
You know, what, why, why is
this time any different?"
What, what do you th- what do you think?
Do you think that they, is, are they
always destined to be playing catch-up?
Could they, could they win, um, if
they approach things differently?
Depends on your definition of winning.
It, it would be, you know…
So, so if you-- so there's,
like, two parts to the business.
There's grocery, so Amazon's clearly,
um, losing to Walmart in grocery.
So, so Walmart, Walmart owns
the high ground in grocery.
Um, which is actually a good place
to be because it's such a frequent
purchase and a share of wallet.
So, so that, that's actually, you
know, so they, they've kinda won on
that, that part of the scorecard.
But where they're, you know,
where Amazon's really assaulting
them is everyday essentials,
so, so they're probably getting
to equal on some of that stuff.
Um, and then Amazon just has
totally trounced them on the other
segments like apparel, sporting
goods, the, the rest of the store.
So, so they need to use this as a way
to come back on, you know, both defense
and protect grocery, I would say.
Uh, and then I would say, and
then, then defense on, uh, everyday
essentials, and then I would lean in
on offense on those other categories,
uh, if I were Walmart, and, and
use this as a way to get out there.
Yeah.
So it is, you know, I've
had people say, "What if…"
So at some point this will go
from agents scraping websites
to agents talking to agents.
And what if you built your basket
up at the GenAI, and then the agent
on your behalf went and had, like, a
little auction for the basket, and it
said, "All right, Kiri's about to spend
$200 on back to school groceries."
And, um, you know, one agent says, "Well,
I, I would, I would, I, I can fulfill
that basket on this date for this price.
And, uh, but I wanna show Kiri three ads."
And you know, so, so I think
that could be a way that retail
media network gets back in here.
Like, the ad could be part
of the negotiation, right?
Because to make the margin of that
basket to be d- or maybe the agent
says, "I, I will only accept things
in the 170 range for this basket."
Maybe the, the retail responds almost
like an RFP and says, "I can do 170,
but I'm gonna need to see some ads.
And, and, you know, I, I wanna
verify she's in my loyalty
program, and I want her email."
You know, so I think there could
be some really interesting things.
And then you as a consumer, the agent
will come back to you and say, "Good
news, Kiri, I've gotten you 170 on
this, but you need to share your email
and see three ads to your agreement."
And you're like-
Yes
… "For, for 10 bucks?
Heck yeah, whatever."
bucks.
Yeah.
Or maybe you're in part of the world
where you're like, you know, "Uh,
no, I'd rather pay the 180 and get
it without all that hassle," and
all that kind of stuff, so yeah.
So, so it's gonna be…
I don't know if that's,
like, a bit out there.
Um, but I think, I think there could be
a world where that's what it looks like.
Mm.
The…
Yeah, so I think, I think
Walmart has a good shot here.
They thought for a long time they
were behind on infrastructure, right?
They, they had eight fulfillment
centers and when Amazon had 125.
That was not good.
Uh, they've caught up.
You know, so they can fulfill things.
The fulfillment, Walmart Plus is good.
I think, I think they've caught up
on the infrastructure with, and then
putting a better, getting in the
pole position on Amazon on that.
This could be a good
time to leapfrog them.
So I think they'll make up ground.
I don't know if they'll,
quote unquote, "win."
Right.
Just the fact that they're
being so aggressive about it.
And I've never met Doug McMillon, but
I've consumed a ton of his content, and
he kinda comes off as, like, a super nice
guy, but you can tell he's aggressive.
He wants to win.
And, you know, he has the full backing
of the Walmart family and, uh, the
Walton family, and I, I feel like he,
he, if-- he's probably been chomping
at the bit for a day like this.
It was kinda like when this came
out and Microsoft jumped all over
A- OpenAI, they were like, "Finally,
a chink in the Google armor.
We are gonna drive a wedge into that.
We're gonna drive the biggest
sword into that chink we can buy."
And, you know, that, that…
I think that same thing is probably
gonna play out with Walmart and
Amazon, and it's gonna be fun to watch.
Yeah.
He's been waiting his whole
career for this moment.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So I think, um, the…
And, and then just, like, putting a
bow on this, like, for the, for the
retailers, so yeah, don't gate the agents.
I think that, like, this reframe,
kinda like what Walmart's doing, the
agents are your number one customer.
If you can, if you can roll out
the red carpet to an agent and make
your, your site super crawlable,
like, you know, provide these really
great endpoints in MCP or whatever
technology the agents really want, you
know, find the most accessible, then
you will get not ju- y- you're gonna
get thousands of customers, right?
So I think reframing, uh, for these
retailers from agencies, like the big
scary unknown to like, no, this…
If we can in- this is the
ultimate influencer for, for us.
If we can actually get a pre- preferential
standing with these agents, we can
win a, a, a lot of the, you know,
the, the pointy end of consumers.
Yeah, I think that's right.
And it kinda goes back to, I remember
when, you know, stores were very
reluctant to come online, and they would
use GSI instead of doing it themselves,
and it was a hobby and all this.
And Nordstrom leaned in, and it
was one of the Nordstrom brothers.
They said, "We, we need to be where
the customer is, and if they're
online, we need to be there."
And I think it's the same thing.
If the customer is using this new way
of doing things, you need to be there.
You can't…
If you, if you feel like you're so--
you can hide in a fortress and the
customer's gonna jump over that wall
to get to you, history has shown that
does not work out very well for you.
So, so, so I, I think, I think it's
the, if you really are customer
centric and your customer's choosing
this, you need to roll out the red
carpet is the, the, where I roll.
I, I kinda land on the same, same…
I think the Walmart
strategy is the winning one.
But I totally understand the
Amazon one, where they've built
all this and don't wanna lose it.
I think they'll do it until…
It doesn't cost anything to try it for
a while, and then if it starts to be a
material problem, you can always take
it down, whereas it's harder to build a
wall after the horses have been out, so.
That's true.
That is true.
Yeah.
Yeah, that's that, uh,
Amazon concept, right?
The, the irreversible door or- The
one- … one-way door … the
one-way, two-way door.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So I think, you know, if on, on
the brand side it's brands are g-
brands are just gonna chase whatever
surface people are spending time on.
So once the, once there's ads available
in these LLMs, they'll, they'll migrate
some portion of their spend over there
as, as quick as, as quick as they can.
But, um, there's a lot of discussion
with brands about getting their product
content accurate and visible in LLMs
and, and that's a, that's a big, uh,
I don't know any brand that isn't
investing in that area right now.
Like, how can we be
discovered in these LLMs?
Yeah.
But this, uh, I think on the point of for
retailers, don't, don't gate the agents.
This is an area that brands should be
trying to push their retail partners
on as well, because what's good for,
what's good for the brand is good for
the retailer and vice versa in that way.
So to recap, uh, loyalty programs,
um, you know, focus on some
differentiators like fulfillment speed,
ease of returns, that type of thing.
Theologically, they're gonna
have to decide are you gating
or welcoming the agents?
That's an interesting philosophy.
Um, yeah.
And, uh, trade dollars are
surprisingly immune from this.
So it's just kind of a,
a funny conclusion, but I
guess it's, it's a good one.
Yeah.
I buy more end caps
What's old is new again.
Yeah.
Kerry, thanks.
I, I wanna stay…
You were very generous with
your time and I appreciate it.
I wanna stay within that.
Um, helping- thanks for helping us
understand kind of like retail media
network landscape and some of your
thoughts on how this is gonna impact.
And, uh, we'll have to ba- have you back
on as we, we have some big news items
that come up to help us navigate this.
If folks wanna learn more about the
retail media side, how do they find
the Retail Media Breakfast Club?
Yeah.
You can head to
retailmediabreakfastclub.com.
The m- main ways that people sort of
consume that content is as a podcast.
You can find Retail Media Breakfast
Club on your favorite podcast app.
There's an email newsletter you can
sign up for on the website, and then
also you can follow on LinkedIn.
I do a d- a, a newsletter over there
as well, if you pr- if you like to.
If you're a LinkedIn junkie,
you can find it over there too.
What's the, what's the most popular
way people consume your content?
LinkedIn, yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, absolutely.
And then, uh, what's fun about it
is you always keep it super tight.
Is there, is it like 15 minutes
or does it kind of wander kind
of the 20-something minutes?
Try…
No, try, try and stick to 10,
which is a bit of a challenge.
Yeah.
10, okay.
Yeah, yeah.
But that's, that's my USP as well.
Like, there's a, there's a lot of, um,
you know, not everyone has 20, 30 minutes
to, to listen or, or read, so yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, it's nice.
Uh, I have a very short drive into work,
so it's a perfect, perfect for my, my
t- my short commute, so, uh, part of my
daily routine, which is, which is nice.
Um, thanks for coming on and, uh,
thanks for sharing your insights.
Thank you for having me.
Appreciate it.
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with Retailgenic, your guide
to the future of AI shopping agents.