Deeply researched audio documentaries that tell the definitive stories behind golf's greatest clubs + weekly conversations with the characters and communities shaping golf today.
00:00:00 Opening toast
Matt Considine: So, as we know, the Scots enjoy their scotch, their scotch whiskey. And it's, for all of our listeners, it's 10 a.m. We're just getting started. But, Professor, we got to do a toast. Extensive research went into this podcast. Even more research went into this bottle of whiskey.
Kevin “The Professor” Moore: was 21 years ago. So, that's 2005. This is when we would have been landing in the, not the country of Scotland. with the country of Ireland, which changed both of our golf trajectories. Yeah.
Matt: And just being curious as hell, I think has led to this very long discussion we're about to have on the oldest, the very first Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golf is to
Professor: The game of
Matt: Golf, to friendship, to
Professor: Today. You took all that from the back of the bus and everything. All I remember is the amount of fish and chips that we ate from the back of the bus. Leith, Forbes, Rattray.
00:01:03 Introducing the Honourable Company
Matt: The Howes. If those names don't sound familiar, how about Musselburgh, Blythe, Morris, Colt, Simpson, Maxwell, Bladley, Archerfield? Maybe we're getting somewhere?
Professor: Well, what if I said Vardon, Braid, Hagen, Player, Nicklaus, Trevino, Watson, Faldo, Els, Mickelson, and finally, Buhai. Now are we tracking? Welcome to
Matt: The bag drop. Untold stories in golf. If those names did not ring a bell, they will soon.
00:01:30 Meet the hosts and the Great Clubs series
Matt: This is the first of our long-form deep-dive series, the most complete telling of the great clubs in
Professor: The game of golf. I'm Kevin Moore.
Matt: And I'm Matt Considine.
Professor: Golf is roughly a $100 billion global industry. There are something like 38,000 golf courses on this planet. It is played in nearly every country on Earth. It's back at the Olympics. And at the very top of the sport sits a short list of holy places and hallowed clubs. The St. Andrews, the Augusta Nationals, the Pebble Beaches, Pinehurst. Pine Valley, and the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers Home, Muirfield. 22 opens in total hosted by the Honourable Company, with 16 of those occurring at Muirfield. Wiley called the finest championship links in the world, and fitting because it crowns some of the greatest champion golfers of all time. And
Matt: That is not what we're talking
Professor: About today. No, no it is not. We'll get there.
Matt: We'll spend hours there, actually. But listeners, if you came for a golf course tutorial or a rewatch of old Opens, you're going to be genuinely surprised. Because today, we're telling the story of the club. The story of what is now, but not always, known as the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers. And part of that story is the club didn't own a golf course for the first... 150 years of
Professor: Its life. Not a single blade of grass.
Matt: So what do you do without a course as a golf club? Well, the once small society of 18th century Scottish gentlemen turned golf from a recreational pastime into an institution. They survived political upheaval, financial ruin across multiple moves. They ultimately...
00:03:10 From the first rules to Muirfield
Matt: Built one of the world's most influential clubs and courses. And professor, I want to lay out for people just how wild this story really is, because I don't think I understood it fully until about hour 40 of our research on this. Well, let's lay it out then. 1744, 22 gentlemen in Edinburgh asked their town council to be recognized as an organization of, and I quote, gentlemen of honor, skillful in the ancient and healthy exercise of golf. The council said, yes, on one condition, you compete for a silver club and you have to write down the rules. So they did. 13 articles to be exact, the first written rules of golf in human history. And here's the thing that got me most. Roughly nine of those 13 are still, in spirit, the rules you and I played last weekend. That's
Professor: Right, listeners. You, me, your weekend game. What we play by was laid out 280 years. prior to UTing it up.
Matt: That's older than the steam engine, the United States of America, and the modern Olympics. So these men codified the game. And yet, they are not golf's governing body. That's the RNA up the road in St. Andrews, a club founded 10 years after them that borrowed their articles pretty much in full.
Professor: And it gets even better. These skillful gentlemen helped create the Open Championship. They helped run it. They helped pay for the [unclear] Jug. They helped care for the grounds it was competed on. And then when they moved towns, well... They just took it. But was it theirs to take? That
Matt: Is another part that could be debatable, and we will get there. But that's also the second move, by the way. This club packs up its things and moves from its chosen grounds not once, but twice. Leith, then Musselburgh, then finally Muirfield. Three homes in 150 years. One of the most
Professor: Storied clubs to ever do it. Complete financial ruin. Multiple mortgages. Creditors at the door. A secretary fleeing the country due to debts. They even had to sell their own clubhouse. The building, the portraits, everything they had for pennies on the dollar. Or I guess being technical, we should say shillings on the pound. That's
Matt: Right. The oldest club in the world broke with no clubhouse to enjoy their claret and celebrate their dinner matches.
Professor: Whoa, whoa, whoa. You said oldest or possibly the oldest. I'm going to need some proof on that
Matt: Claim. What can we prove, Professor? When they finally get the thing they'd gone a century and a half without, when they finally present the Muirfield Golfing Greens, the critics take one look at Muirfield and call it, quote, nothing but an old water
Professor: Meadow. Now, that doesn't make much sense. What I personally might call the most perfect golf course in the world. was just
00:05:53 How a private club shaped the game
Professor: An old watery meadow.
Matt: They got there, but here's the paradox, I think, of the whole episode, Professor. This club never set out to shape the game. Every major decision they made, the rules, the open, the moves, that fantastic course at Muirfield, they made for themselves, for their own members, their own dinner matches, at times, almost aggressively uninterested in what the outside world thought of them. And yet? And yet, you cannot point to a private golf club anywhere on earth today, not one, that, isn't in some way running their playbook. The rules, the captain, the secretary, the competition, the bet book, the dinners, the waiting list, the idea that a club is a society first and a piece of property second, third, or maybe even fourth. That's all in here. That's all them. Some of it by accident.
Professor: So really, I guess the question we're going to be chasing for the next several hours is what happens when a group of friends who just want to play golf and have dinner together and maybe drink some Claret accidentally invent the institution of the golf club? And then what happens today? They finally own the ground under
Matt: Their feet. And listeners, I want to be upfront with you about this. This is not a highlight reel. We are going to go slowly. We start more than a century before the club even exists with one of the earliest mentions of this new upstart game called. We're
Professor: Going to talk about the townspeople who cut turf out of the links for their roofs. We're
Matt: Going to talk about King Charles I playing at Leaf, being handed the letter that told him of the Irish Rebellion. And
Professor: Of course, we're going to be talking about John Rattray, a surgeon, the man who signed those first 13 rules, the first captain of the Gulf, who was then sentenced to die for treason and was saved because of Gulf. That
Matt: Is not hyperbole. That is the
Professor: Story. We'll do the gutty ball, an innovation that made the game affordable. We'll do Old Tom Morris. Harry Cole, and how Muirfield Golfing Greens was actually built, and then entirely rebuilt. We'll do the impressive list of champions, including Faldo's 18 pars and Nicklaus, who loved the place so well, but far before he even won the Grand Slam there. And
Matt: We'll do 2016, when the club that wrote the rules of golf had a vote about whether women could be members, didn't pass it, lost the Open Championship over it, and had to decide who they were going to be for the next 300 years.
Professor: All of it. The full arc.
00:08:06 How to listen, sources and founding partners
Professor: Roughly three centuries, three homes, and one very stubborn idea about what a club is. Professor, how
Matt: Long have we been working on this one?
Professor: Years in our minds and months since the resources found their way to our libraries. Books, club histories, letters, more books, more archives. And of course, that one 12-hour conversation that we had in a room together. Which
Matt: You, listener, are now going to hear the best five-plus hours of. So settle in. Take us with you on the drive, on the walk, on the range, or while doing your dishes. This is meant to be lived and listened to bit by
Professor: Bit. And listeners, if you want the show notes, our full source list, and a heads up on where we might go after the Honourable Company, get on the list at thebagdrop.fm or come talk about the episode with any of us on our socials, at thebagdrop on Instagram and at thebagdropgolf everywhere else. Every one of these episodes will get better because of the arguments. And yes. of course, the corrections you send us.
Matt: And none of this happens without the founding partners of this first story in our new series on The Bag Drop, The Great Clubs. Thanks to Titleist, Inglewood, Erin Hills, Western Golf Association, and Evans Scholars Foundation, Holderness, and Born. Thank you to each founding partner for betting on a five-hour story about golf's great clubs.
Professor: Surely a wager the Honourable Company would have wanted recorded in that bet book. For
Matt: Sure. And with that, Professor, you and I are not members or involved in the clubs that we will discuss. Everything you hear on this episode was based on our own independent research using the materials and resources readily available to us that you can now find in our show notes. This should not be considered an official record of any one club. The professor and I are not qualified to fix your slice, and we are almost certainly going to mispronounce at least one Scottish name.
Professor: At least one. This is
Matt: For
00:10:00 The 1632 Kelso account and the origins of golf
Matt: Your education, your enjoyment, and for the game of golf. Professor, shall we?
Professor: Let's do it. All right. Where are you going to start us with this one, Matt?
Matt: Most would think, Professor, that a date 1744, perhaps, would be the place to start this discussion.
Professor: That's where my timeline starts.
Matt: I'm going to go back a little bit further. I want to go with 1632.
Professor: Okay. All right. So we're rewinding over a hundred years.
Matt: Where a death had taken place in the small inland town named Kelso on the border of Scotland and England. As many things in this story we're going to be telling today, there is a legal record of this death. A group of young men had gathered for a bond spiel, which... Don't know if your research showed it. It's a social gathering of a lot of curlers will know very well what a bonch bill is.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Curling might come up a few times.
Matt: Also another game. Yes, it will. Born out of Scotland. But it was a regular social, recreational, different games that they'd play. A lot of times after church, which this occasion was on a Sunday, they would meet in the churchyard. There was a ball in one of these games that hit a participant, struck near the lug. which is apparently an ear, and there was a great effusion of blood. The victim died from the fatal blow, which the report, and I quote, was strucken out of [unclear] Golf Club. So, Professor, this is one of my favorite early accounts where the word golf, G-O-L-F, had been found in any public record.
Professor: I don't know what it says, that this is one of your favorite accounts that we're starting with a death a murder if you will with the game of golf but okay where did the actual start of golf happen and there's competing theories on that there's competing games you know and much like most sports they evolved from just some hooligans or whoever doing some random stuff somewhere and call it the
Matt: Mysterious years because yeah it's so true that like there are no concrete answers to some of these questions but I think it is a really important precursor to understand what people were doing at the time leading up to the creation of this early golf club.
Professor: And I think that's where Scotland does get to claim the formalism of the game and the formalism of clubs.
Matt: Did you realize,
00:12:43 Stick and ball games and unwritten traditions
Matt: Professor, that whether you're looking at the history of civilizations in Egypt or Greece or Rome, Asia, Africa, Europe and Britannia, as we're doing today, It is nearly impossible, impossible to show a human race that was without a stick and ball game.
Professor: Yeah. Any culture you look and as a kid, why are we so attracted to like taking something little and like doing something with a ball with it?
Matt: Using tools is really what separates us from monkeys, is it not? And you can take that a step further and say that the stick and ball game. is really to be human, to play a stick and ball game, to use a tool, to projectile something. It is really to be human. These rules of these games, they were never really written down, but they were passed down through rituals and customs. It's almost like your grandma's recipe. So I think the early civilizations were with these stick and ball games and they all knew, but they didn't. formalize it. They didn't write it down. And so put simply, I think this pre-industrial society that we're moving into, the medieval times, people were born, they lived, they died in these small communities, usually just family. And those were those handed down codes and traditions until things like clubs started to emerge.
Professor: And you think without, you didn't have ways to keep early record other than by... voice right yeah you could write on stone or anything like that but for centuries it was just passing down within a community where you just pass down rules by engaging in whatever you were doing And then passing it on by word of mouth. And you think it's much like a skit. Think of the times you're playing games and you create roles on the fly. And then you establish them over time and they just stick within your local neighborhood. Then you go play that same game against another local neighborhood. Yes. And all of a sudden it's like you're negotiating. What roles are we playing? You play by those roles? No, no, no. Still play that game.
Matt: That was probably the early days of any of these stick and ball games. Do you want to go through
00:14:53 Related games and the continental connection
Matt: A short list of them?
Professor: Give us, yeah. I got some, okay.
Matt: Kambuka was played in England. Kira Kitty in Samoa.
Professor: Now are these games that look like golf, like look like golf as we know, or this just sticking balls and they're doing whatever.
Matt: Some would hit at objects. So you have the target ones. And then there's the ones that were more like field hockey and defensive type thing.
Professor: So you're actually going to get some opponent, trying to score goals or whatever.
Matt: Yeah. Cole in Belgium. Joie de [unclear] in France. Poletta in Spain. And there's even this game in Germany called Hirschsteiner. That was the shepherds. So we talk about golfing and the shepherds out in the field and pebbles. Camachid, which, Camachid, sorry to my Irish friends, I'm butchering
Professor: The Gaelic
Matt: Pronunciation. Exceptionally violent sport. Exceptionally violent.
Professor: So it's like you're playing against an opponent and this isn't like. Golf is like you're playing physically against an opponent.
Matt: So this evolves. It involved drinking.
Professor: Okay. This might be a theme through our story.
Matt: There was a version of it that was a whole game. So that's important. That's why a lot of historians will make the argument that golf could have been born in Ireland is the versions of these stick and ball games that actually had holes to it. The other sport was more Scottish Highlands focused.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Okay.
Matt: Shinty? Shinty.
Professor: I've heard of Shinty. Why have I heard of Shinty?
Matt: Most that follow the PGA Tour will know Shinty now because of the Scotsman from Oban, Robert McIntyre. Yes. Big Bob. There it is. He made it famous because he was skipping tournaments to go play with his amateur Shinty crew. That's right. Like you said, neighborhood buddies.
Professor: That's right.
Matt: But that was a really popular game. that has records dating 15th century up in the highlands. But as late as 1671, it was played in North Berwick. So it wasn't really viewed as a lowland game, but neither of those were as important as golf.
Professor: No, I've heard that one. That rings a bell. This is the one I've definitely see return to in all the debates of where golf got its start. This is one of the ones that emerges every time.
Matt: Any thoughts on where golf came from?
Professor: It was one of the northern countries in europe yeah the countries they
Matt: Call it so we're talking belgium belgium netherlands and luxembourg
Professor: You got the famous image or drawn sketches of it yes
Matt: The reason most historians tie it the most direct linkage to eventual game of golf is the port city that we're going to talk a lot about edinburgh and leith and all these areas that had Goods coming in and out. Guess where predominantly they were coming from? The Netherlands. Luxembourg. Today's in Luxembourg again in Belgium. Also, paintings. So there's a lot of paintings depicting Honourable Company-like folks playing this game of golf on ice most of the time in the winter if they had the freeze. but also it was a street game. Predominantly, it was a children's game that they would play it with, like you said, pick up golf, grab a stick, grab a ball, and go bang it down the street or frozen ice in the wintertime. There are also some similarities with the head. So they actually used iron heads.
Matt: Or one's made of lead.
Professor: And that's in the paintings that you see and all that. It looks a lot like golf if you've seen paintings. It looks very similar to some of the portraits if you happen to walk through the place that we're going to talk about. Totally.
Matt: And molding a head to a wooden shaft is so different than those other sports. And that was one thing. It also had loft. So a lot of the others were just flat. [unclear] sticks, right?
Professor: Hit the ball, hit along the ground, let the ball roll and take care of itself. Yeah. Now we're going projectile.
Matt: And it was primitives. But yeah, these guys were trying to get it up. And so there was a consistent five iron-like loft to all the modern stuff. And the first golf club was a clique. And that was also that same loft. So all those connections is really why they say colf, also the word they used, was the predecessor. the descendant was golf.
Professor: So our friend that had that untimely and unfortunate finish to their life can thank them for the lofted irons and creating projectile balls. You know, I wonder,
Matt: It because I think it's the hinge of this story that takes us to organize golf. Every stick and ball game we've talked about, golf, shinty, hurling, you hit it along the ground and let it roll. Then somebody molds a head onto a wooden shaft and gives it loft. And now we're
Professor: Going projectile.
Matt: And now we're going projectile. The moment the ball leaves the ground, the equipment stops being a stick you found in a hedge, it becomes an instrument. Which makes this
00:20:01 Presenting partner: Titleist
Professor: The perfect moment to welcome the presenting partner of the Great Clubs series,
Matt: Titleist. When we planned a series about the Great Clubs and the history of this game, it felt right that the company presenting it... is the one that spent 90 years obsessing over the tools and instruments we use to play
Professor: It. And obsessing is certainly the right word. Tyler's golf ball R &D team is chemists, physicists, computer scientists, engineers, and of course my favorite, mathematicians, sitting right next to PGA professionals and turf specialists. They hold more than 1,600 patents on the golf ball. That's the largest portfolio of golf ball intellectual property in the game. For a ball. For
Matt: The one thing that in the scene we're in right now all started with a kid in the low countries banging down the street across frozen ice. And
Professor: It's innovation across the whole bag. The number one ball in golf with the Pro V1 and Pro V1X, T-Series irons, Vokey wedges, GTS medals. Look in the bags at any professional event, at your club championship, or even the yearly member guests, and you'll see that familiar 1935 handwritten script that
Matt: Says Titleist. And here's what I love for our listeners, no matter your level of play. Titleist leaves nothing about your game to a guest. Titleist has been on the cutting edge of club fittings for decades. Irons, wedges, driver, and the ball. There's a free golf ball selector tool on Titleist.com, and their fitting network can connect you with someone certified to match your tendencies with the right tools.
Professor: Which, if you think about where we are in the story, it's the whole arc. 500 years ago, the equipment was whatever was lying around. Today, Titleist flips the script and answers, what fits your
Matt: Game? Titleist, the number one ball in golf and the presenting partner of the great clubs. Head to Titleist.com and thank you to Titleist. All
Professor: Right, back to the story. maybe
Matt: Before we move on to the actual founding of the first golf club, it's pretty famous and well-known that
00:21:55 Parliamentary restrictions and military duties
Matt: The actual first mention, not the guy getting struck and killed in Kelso, but the acts of parliament. in 1457 that actually one they show that golf was really popular with ordinary towns people because two they uh were it was big enough where it was causing issues and you know authorities were paying attention to what all these golfers were doing because This was churchyard golf, so much more like golf, going down streets, town squares, maybe, but a lot of churchyards and courtyards, it was a nuisance. And that's why it was mentioned in the parliament, those acts of parliament then trying to set some rules.
Professor: Well, I think that's what some of the earlier accounts of whatever golf was. stem from situations like this, including what days you can play it. Oh, they're playing it on Sundays. Maybe you shouldn't be doing that, right?
Matt: The piece that was really under the authority's skin, it was definitely the ordinary people that were playing. Because if laws were coming out to say, you can't do this, why would they care about the ordinary people doing that? It's because they're expected to be foot soldiers.
Professor: In the militias of the king. They need to be serving their country.
Matt: So King James, he required that everybody had a certain amount of military service every week or practice. Archery was the main one.
Professor: And we'll have a lot of archery connections with golf, I think.
Matt: And so he wanted people to practice that. They also had their marches and just general military fitness. Well, people weren't showing up. Why?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Because they're playing the schoolyard game of golf.
Matt: And I don't blame them. That sounds a hell of a lot more fun than, you know, marching for some king you never met.
Professor: I feel like there's a lot of things we skip in our life to go play golf. Probably some things that we shouldn't skip. Yeah.
Matt: Yeah. Yes, for sure. For sure. I was definitely didn't like those 6 a.m. workouts, maybe for the same reason. There finally comes ahead 1595. The town started to act on this. Probably out of pressure from. the king from the military but 1595 glasgow was the first town council to ban both shinty and golf and uh banned permanently
Professor: Not just like
Matt: Started on sundays okay but then eventually it was wow overall uh many many many other towns followed suit so that that was uh the the call at the end of what I would refer to as short golf yeah
Professor: You always wonder what it actually looked like I would love to see like time travel and be like How pervasive was this that they thought we have to create laws against it? Were there so many people on the streets doing this? Or was this truly just the noble flex of we're the rulers of this land? There's this thing you enjoy. We're mad at you for other reasons. So we're going to take something away from you that you enjoy. I really wonder.
Matt: Man, and that is a theme we're going to hear a lot in this story, right? Like what really is the problem? If you're not a golfer. watching people hit a ball and chase it around a field and these hard objects that could probably hurt somebody. I bet you that would feel kind of weird. And you would probably push back on it. But as we know, as golfers, once you get hooked, you're hooked.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: It's the bug.
Matt: So the churchyard game played by ordinary people starts to fade. Around the same time that it was getting banned, another
00:25:23 Links land and early noble golfers
Matt: Form of the game was played by Call it a more elite class. They were using this area between the sea and the town. Any idea what you...
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: What might that be called?
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Connects them?
Professor: Connects the two, maybe? Yeah.
Matt: That is where we get the term links. It's that narrow strip of land that isn't beach. It's not city streets. It was the Dooney kind of... wasteland that couldn't be used for our agriculture. But it's a proximity to those seaside towns really is what made it so useful for this noble class really was the first to take this game of courtyard golf and take it to a little bit longer form in those lynx lands next to the sea. The early noble golfers, I didn't write down a ton of them, but King James V, he was certainly an early noble golfer. Mary Queen of Scots, I hope a lot of our listeners will know the stories of Mary Queen of Scots. We won't get into too many of them, but she has quite a few. And she was one of the most famous noble golfers.
Matt: And I, frankly, Kevin, think she was obsessed with playing this new game.
Professor: Her name shows up enough that... I have to imagine it was one of her favorite leisurely pastimes.
Matt: I don't think she traveled anywhere she couldn't get a game of golf in. Yeah. That seems pretty clear. And then this other gentleman, Robert Maul, was one of those famous early noble golfers. These are people that you knew throughout the towns. And when they came through, you certainly saw them golfing, which is probably played a hand in the future popularity of golf is just the awareness of golf. One group of noble aristocratic golfers were actually attacked by horsemen on that one links land between Edinburgh and the sea, a place called Leith.
Professor: Oh, we're finally getting there. And the Leith, the links of Leith.
Matt: I had to get a connection to our actual subject matter somehow.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: So I found this one story.
Matt: I found this one story of these guys playing there in 1575.
Professor: And then a horseman attacked them.
Matt: And horsemen came and they were murdered. A lot of murder happened prior to the Honourable Company. Maybe the gentleman cleaned up this game. But golf was, and I love this part of the historical record, being played that afternoon. So they didn't let it deter them from their tee times, even though someone got slaughtered out on the course.
Professor: Hey, you got to stick to that tee time. Golf is always more important than other things going on in life.
Matt: Professor...
00:28:07 Leith Links and its early landscape
Matt: Now that I've finally mentioned this first focus of our discussion today, which is the first location for the Honourable Company, what do we know about Leith Links? Can you get us started?
Professor: I didn't know anything about Leith Links going into this other than the name. So it's a fascinating place. Well, first, it's in Edinburgh. Its location doesn't look a lot like the links that you might. pop up in your head, like right against the water, right? So it's a little bit inland, but it is on lynx land in the sense of very dunes-y, very, I mean, huge blowout bunkers all over it. Nothing glorious about the grounds themselves in terms of the turf. You might be thinking of St. Andrews, these little rolling, you know, subtle, just knobs and little pot bunkers that form. Like, no, this is pretty aggressive. aggressive turf and not the best grass in the world. It's not low fescue or anything like that. Imagine just sort of a rough hill with lots of aggressive contours on it and blow up bunkers right in the city.
Professor: Yeah, the
Matt: Current pictures was interesting because I obviously went on Google Maps and took a look at Leaf Links and it really just looks like a town square today, like flat as can be. Was it always the case? No, not at all.
Professor: If you can find any pictures or just sketches of what it was, you see some really, really cool contouring. And by contouring, I mean not smooth, but just like aggressive dude. with little pockets of grass that move through these crazy dunes and blowout bunkers that we'd all be salivating overnight.
Matt: I also loved the tidbit on Leith that trees were maybe even less popular than they are today in the golf
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 00:30:00 ==========
Matt: Architecture world or the trend of today to remove trees. There were multiple accounts of the early days of Leith. even before the clubs, with people chopping down a perfectly good tree that was kind of on the perimeter,
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Maybe coming into play on one of the few
Matt: Holes they had. Hey, responsible tree management.
Professor: So, you know,
00:30:19 Common ground and competing uses of Leith
Professor: Leith has been called by different people the metropolitan links of Scotland and of the world. This was truly a metropolitan links in that it existed within the city. And over time, that caused issues because the buildings were encroaching on it. everybody using it the public could use it cattle were out on it fairways were kept by sheep grazing there was no maintenance to this golf course at all all not and we'll get into the problems that caused with drainage and just being wet um and a lot of dunes were removed for cricket and football at one point golf in these early years was just a game played by people on a piece of property that was literally common ground. No different than if you think of kids at a park, they show up with a ball and set up cones for a soccer match and they're playing at amongst everybody using that park.
Professor: And so these areas of grounds that are being used for competing interests and golf is played amongst that. during this time. It is just something that's co-occurring on property rather than something that like, no, this is the golf course. It's like, no, this is a piece of open grounds that happens to be played by golf or whatever we're calling it at the time. And there's nothing glorious about it. There's nothing where the ground's being kept in intentional ways. There's no, oh, this is the fairway. This is the green. Nope. There's somewhere we're going. We're going to start here and we're just going to hit this ball along the way and try to avoid all the obstacles, including everybody else that's using this land
Matt: Bit nicer. What's another fun fact you found on Leith?
Professor: Might be the place of the first international match. This is probably the first international match, which we all love. President's Cup, Ryder Cup, Walker Cup, so on. So I'll tell the story as the fun version of it was Duke of York chose John. Patterson as his partner in the made-for-movie event. Patterson, local poor shoemaker. The means just aren't there, but is crafty at the game. One of the best players of his time, so certainly someone no one would know about. Well, two English noblemen come up, and the Duke of York and Patterson take them down, right? The noblemen probably walk in there like, oh, this is easy, this poor shoemaker, and they just... They dust them. I don't actually have the final tally, but the way it's told makes it sound like they probably dusted them.
Matt: I'm guessing Patterson had a reputation of being skilled at the game.
Professor: Definitely the Duke of York chose him based on his skills, for sure. For Shoemaker, nobody knows about him other than the locals. And Duke of York played out there regularly, so he would have known Patterson was there. Well, the winnings that Patterson then was given by the Duke of York enabled him to build a house. So you don't know the story at all, why this house is important. You can still go to one Cannon Gate in Edinburgh, Scotland. 77 Cannon Gate was the house, but go to one Cannon Gate and you can find the display on the wall. The family arms is emblazoned on this wall to this day. Far and sure is the slogan for the family arms at the top of it. You can walk up there.
Matt: Now it's coming back to me. That is the original far and sure.
Professor: Okay, removing the romantic version of it. So a golf club maker in addition to being a shoemaker. So that might be how the Duke of York knew him. The Patterson family also might have had some wealth and already owned this house at the time. Patterson's land is alluded to and then was renamed golfer's land in the 19th century. So, you know, we love to romanticize the story. I much more enjoy the other version of it, where it's just a shoemaker off the street that the Duke Yorks knew was skilled and said, hey, come help me beat this nobleman. We'll do that.
Matt: Maybe they hit golf balls. Maybe they tossed arches. We don't know. A couple quick hits. Divots. Did you find where the word divot came from?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: I did not. No.
Matt: So this I found really interesting. It's going to tie together some of the history, both at Leith and our next location. But divots were actually not from golfers. Again, this was public land. People were using it for everything. The term divot was actually townspeople coming over, chopping off a piece of turf, cutting it.
Professor: Just cutting turf out.
Matt: Just cutting turf like a sod farm, taking it home. They would use it for roofing.
Professor: Oh, that's right.
Matt: They would use it for fuel in some cases. If it's a long grass in the summer times, they'd use it for feeding their livestock and cattle and sheep. I thought that was funny that the term divot was people doing that. I'm sure the golfers would be like, damn, there's so many divots out here today. Like what's going on? Is everybody doing roofing projects? But that term. they adopted on we've been dealing with divots ever since
Professor: Divot rolls man you wonder how much in their local pub um post rounds were they actually complaining about that and asking for relief
Matt: Now, what about this course?
00:35:37 The five holes of Leith Links and match play
Matt: I know I didn't think there was going to be anything to talk about golf architecture wise here, but is there things that relate to the holes and the names and the numbers?
Professor: It was a hard golf course. It was five holes. That's it. Perfect. All around 400 yards. And at the time, 400 yards was a lot.
Matt: Yeah. How far are people hitting these feathery balls at this time?
Professor: A skilled golfer, 150 to 200. Right. At best. But this way, like at 400 yards, six was counted as a good score. They call it par 35 or whatever is what the language was used there. So like par was bogey in the terminology at this time. So score around 35. was good. Just to give you context and like, okay, five holes around 400 yards.
Matt: If I go to Reswick,
Professor: Let's say in 1851, their original 12 holes, we're at a total yards of 30, about 3,800 yards. That's 316 yards per hole. I can give you St. Andrews, 1836 at 16, at 6,300 yards, pretty similar yardage, um, to Reswick a little bit longer. So this thing was a beast.
Matt: Golf being difficult has always brought people to it because of that challenge. And people like these gentlemen golfers, they like challenges. And I think that's interesting that it laid out this way.
Professor: All of our judgments of difficulty are from our perspective as knowing golf. At its core, when you're learning golf, there's two aspects. You just get it to there. You have no pre-conceived, oh, it should take seven. It should take 10. It's just, okay, I'm here. I got to get there. Then the other core aspect is typically at this, especially this time, you're playing a match. And I need to do that better than this person. So the idea of difficulty made no sense. It was like, I got to get there. And did I beat? my fellow person, the end. And that's still true today. Anybody entering golf has no idea of easy versus hard. It's just, I got to get there. And certainly it's hard in the sense of you don't do it in one, you don't do it in two.
Professor: It takes you a while to get there. So probably in that world, 400 yards felt kind of right because it took a while to get there. It took a while to get from here to there. There was a challenge to be had. And I'm going to share that challenge in my match with someone else. So it is interesting that it was by today's standards, it'd be like building what? Probably, I don't know, a course of five, 650 yard holes. That was what we would be like, oh, we're going to build that. And that's what you're going to, that's what we're going to learn golf on. The holes did have names. Yeah, what were they? You had the Brayhead hole, you had North Mid hole, the East hole, the South Mid hole. In the thorn tree hole, I think were the
00:38:30 The original landscape at Leith
Professor: Five names that I came across.
Matt: What strikes me about Leith, Professor, is that nobody designed it. The dunes, the blowouts, 400-yard holes with a feathery. The ground was the architect.
Professor: With a little help from some grazing wildlife in the dunes, of
Matt: Course. Exactly, which makes this the perfect moment
00:38:47 Founding partner: Erin Hills
Matt: To welcome a new partner of the bag drop, Erin Hills, because their story started in the exact same. place. Ah,
Professor: The cattle.
Matt: The cattle. Before it was Erin Hills, it was Charolais Ranch, home to big white French beef cattle. The rancher, Earl Milliken, dreamed of putting a golf course on that land, but that dream never came to fruition. But what does every great man across the years have in common, professor? What's that? A great partner. Years later, his wife Bernice went looking for and found a buyer who would put that dream in the ground.
Professor: That's right. And about that ground, it's older than any of it. Roughly 15,000 years ago, the two lobes of ice that dug out Green Bay, Lake Michigan start pulling apart, and Erin Hills sits right in the seam. Huge chunks of ice get buried under sand and gravel and slowly melt out. Thin ice left the ridges, thick ice left the valleys. And
Matt: Here's the number that floored me. Their assistant superintendent ran half a million survey points to work out what it would take to build Erin Hills from a flat site. at least 9.6 million cubic yards of fill. That's enough soil to pack the Brewer's American Family Field floor to roof and nearly fill it a second time. The architects moved almost none
Professor: Of it. And those architects were Michael Herdzen, Dana Fry, and Ron Witten, Golf Digest's longtime architecture editor and the man who literally co-wrote the history of golf course design. Well, in 2000, Witten walks the land confidently, naming Eskers and Moraines. 19 years later, a Wisconsin glaciologist named Luke Zoot walks it with him and politely tells him, these are great hills, but they aren't those. These are something more rare. Giant chunks of ice buried by sand and ballooning them up.
Matt: A man corrected on his own golf course? Now that is pure relief.
Professor: Exactly. And of course, he took it like a gentleman. And from that correction came the poetic embodiment of Erin Hills. From Buried Ice. came paradise.
Matt: And just like Leith, Erin Hills opened in 2006 with a stern test. It was a par 73 with half a dozen blind shots, including a par three modeled on that Dell hole at La Hinge. Golfers found it so baffling that they had to take it out, and the spare bye hole became today's ninth, which is one of the best par threes in championship golf.
Professor: At 140-some yards, it played as the sixth hardest hole at the 2017 U.S. Open. And the caddies called it the shortest par 5 in Wisconsin.
Matt: And just as we prefer to enjoy our round, you walk it. It's walking only. With an in-house caddy program and unlike many of the great games tests, this one is open to visitors. So when
Professor: You go, stand on the 12th tee. It's the one hole that made every single one of the dozen routings they drew. Dana Fry says it feels like Ireland. I'd say it feels a little like the original Lynx at
Matt: Leith. Minus the cattle. Go to AaronHills.com and start planning your trip. Erin Hills, an exhilarating Wisconsin golf experience. All
Professor: Right, back to Leaf. like?
Matt: Did skip over this from the early days of golf. Golf was a winter sport. I don't know if that surprises anybody out there. It surprises me. It is so clearly for hundreds of years a winter sport. I mean, think about it. They didn't have any modern equipment. And even sheep and cattle aren't going to be able to keep that stuff tight.
Professor: At the growth of fescue
Matt: Grass in the summer months.
Professor: And more people are using the grounds in the summer months for things.
Matt: Exactly. Okay. And then on top of that, think about these people. What was the primary work every single day for most every human at the time? Agriculture. Whether it was at home or more industrially where you're doing things to sell your goods. you were busy. You were working in the peak of summers towards harvest. Then harvest would happen. Winter was the leisure time. And so as I talk about Edinburgh, I think that's really key in this whole story, that it was a winter sport.
Professor: I mean, people forget we live in such a luxurious world right now where we don't have to use the summer to stay alive in the winter. You had to use growing season.
Matt: You still get strawberries even in February.
Professor: Yeah, if you didn't do what you needed to do in the summer, you weren't going to make it through the winter.
Matt: So when you put that on top of, okay, Edinburgh. Edinburgh was, in the winter, this increasing popularity of a leisure time.
00:43:19 Edinburgh as a winter centre of leisure and law
Matt: So people would come from inland. A lot of landowners would come to Edinburgh. They would complete their harvest in autumn. And then a lot of them would drop their children off at the boarding schools in the colleges. So St. Andrews being one of the oldest and most acclaimed. They would venture up there by carriage or horse or whatever. And then on their way back, the parents, the landowners, would stop in Edinburgh for a good time. And it was a leisure town. It was also, and I love this, the legal practices of Edinburgh. It was really a town run by lawyers, which makes so much sense when we talk about this group. Here's the quote from Chambers. Traditions of Edinburgh said, it had no royal court, no factories, no commerce, but there was a nest of lawyers in it. Attending on the court.
Matt: Of a session and a considerable number of gentry gave it the benefit of their presence in the winter. So a lot of guys would do their legal stuff that they'd have to do related to whatever their business or land required. They would do it in Edinburgh. And so they were looking for downtime. And I bet you a lot of those lawyers said, hey, join me. Let's go play some golf. And the game grew from there.
Professor: Well, I could imagine some short days where, you know, you're on the links and then at other aspects of the day where you don't have much daylight there, especially in the winter, you know, you're using your candlelight or whatever to do your law work, right? Pen, whatever you need to do. And that makes, that makes a lot of sense. Well, that's opens my eyes. I never, never thought of that. And now we're kind of the opposite of that where golf is the, you know, good weather sport. Exactly.
Matt: And we're going to talk, I mean, it's going to be a few hundred years here before they actually do branch into those shoulder seasons of spring and autumn. And it goes from there. But yeah, this was most definitely a winter sport. The other thing related to that for the leisure or these lawyers that called Edinburgh home, Leith in particular, and the Honourable Company certainly would be individuals that classifies this. It really was known as a land of confidence of people that were assure of themselves. And it was wealthy. It was cosmopolitan-esque in that area because a lot of trade was coming in and out of that port. Right next to it was the port that connected it to the rest of Europe. So it was really this place of confidence and success and independence. That people wanted to be around.
Matt: And so if you get a bunch of those people together, Professor, my guess is they probably want to set some guidelines around some things.
Professor: Eventually. But I think you're jumping a little bit too forward to where you might be trying to take us. Before we get to guidelines, they had been playing channel links for a long time. And they're going to come together. So
00:46:30 Tavern gatherings and the beginnings of a club
Professor: You felt the need to socialize after rounds. I'm sure, or I wonder how much of a byproduct of that is you didn't socialize during the rounds because it wasn't like you had the golf course to yourself. It was public lands. You're busy navigating that land with everybody else using it. So there probably wasn't a lot of time to socialize other than moving to your next shot and moving on. You didn't have beer carts running things and all that. So you would socialize after the round. Well, they had a favorite place.
Matt: At this time excuse
Professor: My pronunciation throughout this entire episode but lucky clefon's tavern is what I have their favorite place to partake in their pints after the round that was owned and ran by lucky clefon as with the best taverns this was actually an inn at the time and lucky was the inn keeper and every inn at a tavern where they served food and their best pours and pints and claret and other um alcoholic beverages a lot of
Matt: What I read and stumbled upon I would argue the dinners and socializing after golf had way more to do with these clubs establishing than the game of golf they did it around the game of golf but I think they just wanted to have a drink and hang out.
Professor: I'm pretty sure there's a famous quote somewhere that talks about Muirfield being a dinner club with a golfing problem. We'll maybe get to that one a little bit later. But so this is where they partook in their pints. Now, Lucky also was a club maker at the time. It certainly seemed. A lot of people had a lot of different professions. If you're an innkeeper, you're also maybe making golf clubs. You're also doing this and doing that. And Lucky happened to be a club maker. Do you know what happened in 1742?
Matt: I know a few things that happened in 1742.
Professor: Do you know what happened with Lucky at 1742?
Matt: I do not. Lucky passed.
Professor: Yeah. So Lucky passed. This is two years before the year that we should have got to about 45 minutes ago. But fear not. His widow's house became the company's HQ. I have no idea what this looked like.
Matt: You're kidding me. Yeah, the widow's house became
Professor: Where the fellas, after their round, like to gather and have their pints.
Matt: I can't believe I missed that, but also, I understand why it didn't make a lot of historical records. They took his wife's...
Professor: House? Yep, that's what the history books have. This house is unfortunately now destroyed, so you can't go visit it. But they had visited her house, so 1742, this is where they grabbed their pints. I wonder what she thought of this, how that came about. But eventually, 1744, we need to be formalized. They want to be recognized. Now, technically, that's not true. They'd actually been penning the Edinburgh Town Council. numerous
00:49:38 Duncan Forbes and the effort to formalize the group
Professor: Times before this, saying, hey, we want to be recognized. Now, before we get to that,
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: You have to have a ringleader. It helps.
Professor: Duncan Forbes. I'm sure you know that name. Mr.
Matt: Duncan Forbes. Tell us a little bit about Duncan.
Professor: Born near Invenus, one of our favorite places in the world. Then attended Edinburgh in Leiden University. Leiden University is in the Netherlands. If you're up there and you're doing the touristy thing outside the golf course, outside Inverness, you might hear of a Kilravoc
Matt: Castle.
Professor: That is family that he married into on that castle. And that's near and near his official title, Lord President of the Court
Matt: Of Sessions. Yeah, he was really the most famous judge in Scotland.
Professor: Yeah, like top as could be, right?
Matt: Yeah, Edinburgh. He was known as a golfer maybe first.
Professor: He's one of the more recognizable people at Leaf Links early on. And this confirms your telling of golf being played in the winter. The most notable thing about him was no matter the weather, he was on the links. So he was the one, as cold as it could be, it could be sleeting sideways, he was always the one out there playing. Hence, he was the ringleader of... this group of golfers that we're going to tell the story of today. He was the one that pulled them all together, formalized the matches, said, hey, let's meet up. Hey, let's hang out at the pub afterwards because you always need that one person that's pulling everyone together. All right.
Matt: So they got Duncan Forbes. That's a big step towards being the first. Golf was happening. There were these clicks that were all playing together, but it really was going to take
00:51:33 Archery as a model for organized competition
Matt: Somebody to push it. And there had to be kind of a model to do it. Now, any ideas, Professor, where they got some of their early?
Professor: Oh, where they might have got inspiration to? No, I don't. If I had to guess. I bet archers might have beat them to the punch here. Just a pure guess based on everything I was reading. Maybe something with horses. I don't know. I'm sure other clubs and other groups of leisurely activities might have been going on. Well, you would be right.
Matt: What do you got? You'd be right. I'm lucky guess. It was definitely archery. People were already doing this for a while, getting together in, not called archery clubs, but the archers of Edinburgh. We're getting together. And so in 1709, the Royal Company of Archers approached Edinburgh, the authorities, the town council. They wanted to compete and they wanted a silver arrow. A silver arrow. Are you foreshadowing? Maybe. They received a yes. And this beautiful arrow is... I think larger than the other trophy we'll be talking about with the Honourable Company. But it was impressive. And the winner became named captain of the Royal Archers for the year ahead. And then they all drank a bunch of claret out of this silver bowl. So I think that was really important setting to golf because silver archers, they were doing it.
Professor: Yeah,
00:53:17 The 1744 recognition and the Silver Club
Professor: So there's the inspiration. So we fast forward to March 1744. [unclear] Town Council has been badgered by the quote-unquote gentlemen of honor skillful in the ancient and healthful exercise of golf. With G, H, and G all capitalized. So technically, gentlemen of honor, skillful in the ancient and healthful exercise of golf is, quote unquote, what they call themselves badgering the Edinburgh Town Council to be recognized in exactly the same way. So how does the town council respond? They present a silver club to the company and they require them to draw up, quote unquote, proper regulations by which a gentleman will compete for it annually. Obviously, inspiration has been taken from the archers. The town council is familiar with this exercise and said, sure, we will recognize you as a group that are skillful in the ancient and healthful exercise of golf, but you'll have to compete for the silver club.
Professor: And to do that, you will have to draw up proper regulations. And the name will be the company of gentlemen golfers. So this is our start there. Soon to be recognized, they have to come up with the proper regulations to compete for the silver club. And they will be named a company of gentlemen golfers here in Edinburgh.
Matt: You got your Duncan Forbes. You needed a hitter. You got him. You need a formal thing to rally around. The silver club becomes that. What else do they need?
Professor: Well, they need rules and regulations. But what I find interesting, pausing for a second, reflecting on this, is that relationship with the city being recognized by the city is one that brought a club into existence and it created a... permanent relationship with the city we'll get into this silver club and what it was in the competition and how that stayed related to the city but it's interesting that there was a lock and step between the city and the golf club uh in this case the company of gentlemen golfers
Matt: It's so true because we're you know at the early side of this 150 year history where
00:55:26 Invitations and the first open competition
Matt: The gentlemen golfers, the Honourable Company, don't own a golf course. Therefore, they are always going to be held into other groups and outside people. In fact, this early Silver Club competition, I don't know if you found this, Professor, but I double-clicked on this little tidbit. Who did they invite to play in it? The first Silver Club? Yes.
Professor: My notes had... anyone could play in it it was the it was the original open competition it
Matt: Was and they invited so all could play there was a sign up fee that was actually pretty expensive
Professor: Yeah at the time and we'll do some numbers as we get through this episode but yeah there was you had the and that was also to pay for different things and upkeep to the course there was actually some maintenance to the grounds nothing like we would see it today but the grounds needed to be prepared for the competition someone had to go out there and fill divots or shoe off the laundry or whatever needed to be done so they could actually play a competition that wasn't violated too much by the public.
Matt: That's right. And there are many things that the Honourable Company probably shouldn't get much credit for based on a lot of the things I learned through this process. But that is definitely one that they do, is the early age of greenskeeping, which they had a long history of innovation around taking care for the course. not just doing it for themselves, but for other groups that would use it. But back to the Silver Club and this competition, I really did love the nature of them setting out to do this as somebody who has tried to run golf competitions and with a small membership, inviting people outside. The phrasing they used, the invitation did go out and they sent it to all the known golfing families of Great Britain, as well as some distinct links, towns, seaside towns where golf was being played.
Matt: They posted it to their papers. They wanted this to be a big. stinking deal and what it would read was noblemen gentlemen or other golfers of great britain and ireland that's what they were looking for right that's how that they consider themselves and that's who they were looking for noblemen gentlemen and golfers of the land they wanted to mimic the success of the royal They wanted to mimic the success of these horse races. The horse races would get people from all over the place to come and compete on these [unclear] slams for racing. So they thought, for sure, this is slam dunk. We're going to do the same thing for golf. Well, in any event, no entries outside of the gentlemen golfers themselves were received for this first competition. So it was really just them. that were doing that. And you know who else didn't compete?
Professor: Who's that?
Matt: The best golfers. This was not the best golfers in the land. They wanted it to be kind of teed up that way. You know, Duncan Forbes and his buddies were going to go duke it out. It was not the thing that they had envisioned.
Professor: Let's run back to that first Silver Club. competition
00:58:51 Captain of golf and the winners obligations
Professor: And what it meant, what regulated. So much like the archers, the winner, captain of golf, right? That was one of the first. Captain of golf. What a term. Captain of the golf at the time. And they were expected to fix a gold or silver coin or ball to the silver club. And also they did have to return the club to the city of Edinburgh within a month.
Matt: Of the next competition [unclear]
Professor: And if
Matt: There was some ceremony around
Professor: That too and if they didn't I forget what the cost was it was significant it was like 50 pounds or it was 50 pounds or shillings which I think shillings were pounds at this time um
Matt: Shilling and pence yeah like it was
Professor: A lot of money at the time and so I think some of the okay we'll give you the the winnings and because if you don't return that club it's going to cost you so
Matt: They did my notes actually had they were responsible for the cost of affixing the silver ball, no matter what.
Professor: The winner. Yeah. Yeah, the winner was. The winner had to pay for that. They had to pay that out of the [unclear]
Matt: So there is a good
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 01:00:00 ==========
Matt: History of the honorable government of like, hey, you won, congrats, pay for things. Pay for things. Which I can't, there's more stories we'll get to later, but that's so funny. You're asking all these people to come from all
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Over to your
Matt: Club to compete if you do win. well, we're going to ask you to pay for the ball. But that probably came out of the considerable winnings of this event.
Professor: Yeah, and would be considerable winnings if they actually had a big entry. But obviously that first one, not so much. We'll get to that in a second. Now, you just alluded to why did they need to return the club to the city within a month of the next competition? There was a marshal ceremony that occurred in the city the day upon which it was played. The city made it very clear [unclear] your responsibility to organize everything. So these are the expectations. And one of them was a martial ceremony. So it wasn't just some informal gathering and winning a trinket. They had the foresight of they wanted to see something bigger. The club was always property of the quote unquote good town as a stated rule. So technically the company of gentlemen golfers didn't. owned the Silver Club, that it was property of the town at this time.
Professor: And that remains for a long time.
Matt: Outside of those 11 golfers, did
01:01:17 John Rattray and the first Silver Club winners
Matt: You find anything on many of them other than Duncan Forbes? It seemed to me that Duncan Forbes was clearly the main prominent individual. I searched most 11 and got varying degrees of brief information on... being surgeons and physicians and lawyers, of course, probably majority lawyers. But yeah, Duncan Forrest was really the character of the bunch.
Professor: Yeah, another big one was John Rattray, which do we want to go there now or do we want to put a pin in him?
Matt: No, I think we should.
Professor: Let's go to him right now.
Matt: He definitely was, right? And of those 11, I think he was pretty clearly the best golfer too.
Professor: I think that's...
Matt: I don't think he was the best in the land, but it wasn't much of a competition. for the first two years because we'll talk about him winning it back to back um the uh he's a local physician and and a surgeon um he was as I said the winner of this event that took place the silver club did take place in april of uh the first monday in april the gentleman golfers preferred mondays that was viewed as a day of leisure for most of the uh legal I guess it still is today. Shout out to our lawyers. But in April 2nd of 1744, he became, as you said, the first trophy holder of the Silver Club and the first captain of golf.
Professor: Do you know what else he had won other than the Silver Club?
Matt: It escapes me.
Professor: He won the Edinburgh Arrow on two different occasions. That's right. So our man was a gamer.
Matt: He liked to compete.
Professor: He liked to compete. By all accounts, whatever he put his mind to, he would show exceptional talent to. So it is no surprise that he did win the
01:03:08 The original rules and thirteen articles
Professor: First silver club.
Matt: Back to this competition, the one thing I wanted to ask you about was the rules.
Professor: Yes. I mean, how much time do we have?
Matt: The rules are really a huge part of the DNA of the Honourable Company. And this early group of gentlemen golfers, they wanted it to matter. The rules seem to be more important to them than anybody else. The Edinburgh town council also did just because they were commissioning this deal to occur. They let them march with drums down the street. They let them take over the leaf. There was actually a notice sent out to the horsemen and the launderers and everybody else on the leagues, like not this day. So for them to all do that, it felt like, oh, we need to. put a framework around this game now. And so what did you think about these early rules for the Silver Club?
Professor: Yeah, you can see the tone is being set for what, if anybody's played in a competition in Scotland, especially something like the town match in St. Andrews, you're seeing the tone is set like, hey, this is going to be formalized and this is something that's going to, the city is going to be involved. The city is going to understand, even if they are playing, they're going to understand this is meaningful and something that we should turn our eyes to and respect and try to at least understand. You see that here with this early competition. Now, what's interesting about the rules, and I'm going to kind of go quote unquote here. First, they weren't complex. They reflected the game as they saw proper, right? They got to draw up the original rules. How do we want this game played? No penalties were listed in these original rules.
Professor: I'm going to read them all, but no penalties were listed.
Matt: Wait, are we going through the Silver Club rules or are we going through the 13 articles?
Professor: The 13, which were the Silver Club rules by which the game would be played over, right?
Matt: Wasn't there a formalization process after the Silver Club around the 13 articles? Well, yeah, so the
Professor: Silver Club was played.
01:05:03 Match play stroke play and the first competition format
Professor: Under the 13 articles, it was successful. And so then in the minutes after the Silver Club was played, that's when they're signed into formal being.
Matt: Prior to that, the notice that went out for how the Silver Club would be contested, I did want to just zone in on that for a second because it
Professor: Was
Matt: Confusing as hell. Yes. Right? So I guess you would call this the format. So rules, You're right. The rules that got signed into, codified into the game of golf, which is remarkable foresight that those guys had. We'll get into each of them one by one. We don't need to do the overall format for
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: The
Matt: Silver Club one by one, but maybe I will read just this.
Professor: Yeah, good to go in.
Matt: Old Scottish, old English. The set or match beginning with number one and progressing shall go out first. With a clerk. To mark down every stroke of each of them shall take to every hole. And when the match is ended, a scrutiny of the whole clerk's books or jottings is to be made. And the player who shall appear to have won the greatest number of holes shall be declared to be the winner of the match. And if there shall be two, three or more that are equal, then these two or three or more must play around themselves. So what the hell is the format? Is it a match? Is it stroke play? I mean, there's 11 people playing at the same time. That was what I think historians still don't know today. The interesting part about this is when I read the golf, it referenced heats.
Matt: And so if you think about track and field having heats, I think that's what this first competition was. I think they went out in pairs, maybe three or four. If you beat the guys then in the group, then you came back and played the others at one. But it also talks about totals. And so I think it was really this weird hybrid of match play and stroke play, which there is some other precedence across golf that I think early, early. golf clubs were trying to figure this out, but it was just a bit bizarre. And so I wanted to reference it because, man, the style of play might have been fairly clear, but I'll tell you the format.
Professor: Yeah, it was very convoluted and not clear. Looking at where medal play went overall, by that the medals as in the formal events they do, my best guess is this was a stroke play.
Matt: You know, what's funny is this being the first formal golf competition, for hundreds of years and even to today the predominant game is match play yeah and so this early attempt my guess is there and there were adjustments as time went on but I think they were trying to find this balance of match play was played you know in the clicks and everything and match play was exciting and and match play was definitely you think of the um mono a mono style of all the other sports at the time which just made so much sense But then they had these visions of this larger tournament that was going to welcome the best golfers from all around the land. And then they asked the question, oh, how will we deal with this? But then they end up with 11 players and they're like,
Professor: Oh, we should have probably just played match play to begin with.
Matt: So I think this was just like such a beautiful, sometimes when you think about these institutions and the origins of things, like it gets romanticized. But I think this was just like, wow, we didn't know what the hell we were doing.
Professor: We got to figure it out as we go.
Matt: Tell us about these rules.
Professor: Yeah, so
01:08:50 The captains role in enforcing the rules
Professor: Again, no penalties were listed. They weren't complex. And that's partially because one, the competitors were few in number. They all knew each other. So they all knew what offenses each other might have done. So you didn't really need to lay that down, right? Like they could detect them. They would know them. They were best friends with each other. And quote unquote, the members of the Honourable Company could be left to deal with offenders accordingly. The rules were there and any violations would be. handled by the club. And that was then the role of the captain. So obviously we don't have a captain going into this event. Whoever became captain for that next year, any disagreement that occurred, it was taken to the captain. Whatever they decided, everybody had to live with, that would be their role. So the rule book that said how you played, but that any discrepancy, debate, violation would be handled by the captain.
Professor: But what were the rules?
Matt: Let's break them down. Let's go through them a little bit.
Professor: I think nowadays we have... 25
01:09:47 The thirteen articles examined rule by rule
Professor: Main rules but we have dash dash dash dash dash hey we got 25 rules no they did not have dash like 3.1 so all right first one you must tee your ball within one club's length of the hole it
Matt: Was one so it started I was wrong I thought it was two two it
Professor: Got actually extended to four club lengths at one time um But that's because, yeah, you want to get them away. We don't want to keep marking up the ground around it, right? Get a little bit further away from the hall sort of thing. Even back then, like, don't mess with my green.
Matt: That was a good adaptation.
Professor: Your tea must be upon the ground. That one's interesting because what were they trying to do? That, like, someone in 1739 had decided to tea in some way. Like, no, you got to put your tea. Must be upon the ground. You can't put it on anything else. You can't prop it up further. Because again, tees were just little piles of sand at the time. Yeah.
Matt: I wonder though, what were the devices that they were picking up and trying to put out there?
Professor: Yeah. I mean, because golfers just like today, we just try to find ways around the rules.
Matt: You're just looking for an edge, you know?
Professor: You are not to change the ball, you strike off the tee. So there is certainly a rule.
Matt: There's one that stayed intact. Yeah.
Professor: You are not to remove stones.
Matt: Now you can change between holes though. Between holes. And that lasted for a very long time, which will come up once we get to mirror field.
Professor: You are not to remove stones, bones, or any break club for the sake of playing your ball, except upon the fair green and that only within a club's length of your ball. So yeah, if a stone is against your ball, leave it. This is sort of the play it as it lies rule. But if you are on the green, hey, if there's something within a club's length of your ball, you can move it over the years that would move to further and we got formal greens to define and you can remove things anywhere on
Matt: The green yeah I think in that one too one thing that I found of the 13 rules is there's no unplayable lie and when you think about what they were playing through oh they definitely had unplayable lies like there were times I'm sure you're just screwed but Because they played match play.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Bingo.
Matt: Because they invented a rut iron, which was the club that nobody wanted to play. And it almost was like humiliating to pull it out of your bag. But it was to get you out of the ditch. So yeah, I thought that was interesting.
Professor: And some of the famous stories in the stroke play metal events are when someone found themselves in a place in a stroke play event they couldn't get out of, infamously take an 11 and be just ejected from a tournament. But you just foreshadowed the next rule. If your ball come among water or any watery filth, you are at liberty to take out your ball and bringing it behind the hazard and teeing it. You may play it with any club and allow your adversary a stroke for so getting your ball out. So there's your sort of unplayable lie. It was water.
Matt: Filth. Watery filth. What do you think watery filth is?
Professor: I don't want to know because this is public grounds.
Matt: I still have an infant. I know what watery filth is. Think about this too. The feathery golf ball. It was pretty good. would hold up in most conditions, but what happens to feathers and leather when you put it in water? Those things were expensive. People didn't want to waste them in water. And actually caddies, that was an early part of caddies' responsibility was to fork caddy to if a feathery landed in some watery filth, you get it out right away.
Professor: And this also paints a picture of the leaf links that these weren't the links like we think of St. Andrews and other links courses you might play. You had gathering water. probably sometimes not just rainwater, across these grounds that needed to be accounted for when you play. I also, in this one, the match play language comes out that you allow your adversary a stroke, right? So it's not like, oh, you're penalized a stroke, which makes sense as stroke play because you need to be penalized against the whole field. Where in match play, no, you get an extra shot, go ahead and take it, and now we stand even again. All right, next up. If your balls be found anywhere touching one another, you are to lift the first ball till you play the last. Then this got changed eventually to six inches, the stymie roll.
Matt: Stymie roll. So that one didn't make it or last.
Professor: At holing, you are to play your ball honestly for the hole and not play upon your adversary's ball on lying in your way to the hole.
Matt: So trying to block.
Professor: Yeah, no stymies again. And don't like, hey, your ball's right beside mine. I'm going to hit my ball really hard at yours and it's going to knock your ball down in a rut over there. So this speaks to the spirit of the company here of playing the game honestly in the sense of you versus course versus your opponent rather than, oh, I'm going to play little tricks on my opponent directly by playing against their ball or getting in their way. It's you versus the course and it's them versus the course. And then whatever comes out, you have a match relative to that. If you should lose your ball by its being taken up or any other way, you are to go back to the spot where you struck last, drop another ball and allow your adversary a stroke for the misfortune.
Matt: This one was also indicative of leaf lengths. And, you know, there was a lot of times where balls were just taken up. Kids and dogs and... uh stolen frankly like they were
Professor: Expensive so that's
Matt: Why why they they were desirable some a lot of kids would would come out and steal golf
Professor: Balls I guess and at least you had the significant mounding and everything so your ball would disappear over a mound and someone could easily take it and you wouldn't even have eyes on it yeah right so this is a lost ball by we by we know but also a lost ball as a stolen ball now this is something that change over time over the years lost ball became lost hole eventually then you had stroke and distance you had distance only then back to the original provision and often course and public use dependent in this case does this speak to your winter rules here maybe a little snows on the ground maybe you can't you know just put a little track in there or he thinks was often wet And muddy, so you can't put a little trough, pat it down, and make yourself a little path to the hole.
Matt: Interesting. Yeah, it was Duncan Forbes playing when he said, all right, let's do a little funnel, if you will,
Professor: To the cup. Next up, we're on number 10 now. If a ball be stopped by any person, horse, dog, or anything else, the ball so stopped must be played where it lies. So, hey, there's stuff out there.
Matt: Again, it comes up a lot that they just play it as lies.
Professor: 11. If you draw your club in order to strike and proceed so far in a stroke as to be bringing down your club, if then your club shall break in any way, it is to be accounted a stroke.
Matt: Interesting. For me, I was like, huh.
Professor: Did you dive a little deeper on this one?
Matt: Well, I did do a good amount of research on early clubs, and I think it just speaks to me on the fragility of it. Early club makers probably didn't reinforce things the way that they did later on. The weight wasn't probably correct the way they molded it to these wooden shafts. Clubs broke a lot, so they had to have a rule to account for it.
Professor: Break also has a different interpretation here.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Oh, that's right.
Professor: We've got the original yips, or as they call them, the staggers. So yes, accounting for a club breaking, but also, hey, your stroke broke.
Matt: The staggers. I did read. This is great.
Professor: And you go through some of those early stories and some of the stances they allude to, the swings. Even then you're like, that swing's only like that because they're fighting the yips, right? Like they are.
Matt: This game has been 95 % mental for all time.
Professor: All time. 12, he whose ball lies farther from the hole is obliged to play first.
Matt: There you go. This always made sense in the game.
Professor: Last but not least, neither trench, ditch, or dike made for the presentation of the links, nor the scholar's holes or the soldier's lines shall be accounted a hazard. But the ball is to be taken out and teed and played with an iron club. So it speaks to the public use of the land. There was something in there that was not an integral part of the course that was there because of other public uses, especially soldiers' use. Okay. Remove it from that. Can't play with
01:18:43 The lasting influence of the original rules
Professor: A wood, play with an iron.
Matt: So those are our 13 rules. Do you know how many of the 13 articles, how many of those 13 original rules are largely still in effect? So like the spirit of it is still clearly in effect today.
Professor: I would guess,
Matt: I don't know, 9, 10. You nailed it. It's 9. Okay. The original rules of cricket, which had like 22 or three or four, two. Two of the rules are still in place. So there was something that these guys understood about the nature of this and what it was going to be from a competition standpoint. And so I think that's pretty remarkable in itself. I definitely took away the play it as it lies ethos. There's no unplayable lies attached to any, you know, they didn't say that anything was unplayable either. The watery filth being the only exception to that. And then here's the big one. And I think the Honourable Company, this company of gentlemen golfers, fully, in my opinion, gets credit for being the first to care about the greens, to care for the greens, the green keeping. You know, the greens meaning the entirety of the links.
Matt: I found that to be so obvious in these. I mean, they're referencing the trenches, the ditches, the dikes, the soldier lines. And it fixed a lot of the issues on the course. I think they fixed a lot of the drainage. I think they said, hey, we got these rules for these things. What if we just fixed it? That's right. And they did some things to make that possible.
Professor: I think, yeah, you have less soldier use as you move along. And the game's becoming more formalized and understood by the community, I'm sure, right over time as things formalize. People are respecting the grounds a little bit more.
Matt: So at this Professor, before we settle who was first, I have to take us back to the watery
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Filth. Of course
Matt: You do. Because tucked inside that rule is a job. The four caddy. Somebody out ahead of the match wading into a ditch on leaf links to fish out of feathery before the water
Professor: Ruins it. That's right. The caddies are a fabric of the story of golf before the rules are. I mean, the golf, your favorite poem from 1743, even has caddies in it. Bingo.
Matt: Caddies run through it all. You can't read the club's early history without them. And the other thread we keep pulling on is its championships. That first silver club in 1744 was, as you put it, the original open competition. Open to noblemen, gentlemen, and other golfers from all of Great Britain and Ireland. And yet,
Professor: Nobody else shows up.
Matt: That's right. Nobody except their loyal and trusted caddies.
Professor: Caddies in a championship competition. A natural fit.
01:21:27 Founding partners: Western Golf Association and Evans Scholars Foundation
Professor: Which makes this the perfect moment to welcome our final founding partner, the Western Golf Association and the Evans Scholars Foundation. Caddies and championships are what they do best.
Matt: In 1899, 11 golf clubs around Chicago formed the WGA. In that September, they held the very first Western Open and Western Amateur at Glenview Club, four years after the first
Professor: U.S. Open. And who was the critical figure in those early years of the WGA? A caddy. Chick Evans. He started carrying bags at Edgewater Golf Club in Chicago when he was just eight years old. In 1910, he became the first to win the Western Open as an amateur. Then in 1916, he wins the U.S. Open and the U.S. Amateur in the same year. Nobody had ever done it. Only Bobby Jones has done it since.
Matt: And with a resume like that, professor, you turn pro, right?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Of course.
Matt: Well, not if you're Chick Evans. He never did. So the money that comes his way, including royalties from a set of instructional records he made, real vinyl records, goes into an escrow account. And it's his mother, Lena, who tells him that the money came from golf. So it should go back into golf. Why don't you send caddies to college?
Professor: Amazing. He takes his earnings that he's worked so hard to gain to the WGA. And in 1930, the first two Evans scholars, Harold Fink and Jim McGinnis, enroll at Northwestern. the same school Chick
Matt: Attended. And that was the same year Bobby Jones matches his open amateur double victory. I love it
Professor: When two stories come together. And here's the part of the story I think the gentleman golfers would appreciate most. When Chick's original fund ran out, the WGA's own directors reached into their pockets to keep those scholarships going. The returns of the scholarships were obvious in those that benefited. And a group of golfers decided that mattered enough to pay for it themselves.
Matt: That might be this whole story in a single sentence, Professor. Go read the rest of it at wgaesf.org. And if you're interested in supporting the Western Golf Association and the Evans Scholars Foundation, join the park club and let them know that Matt and the professor sent you. All
Professor: Right, back to 1744. So
Matt: At this time, Professor, we got rules. We got a
01:23:39 The oldest club claim and the Royal Burgess
Matt: Incorporated entity, this institution of gentlemen golfers. Are we a club? Are they the first club?
Professor: I mean, they're a club. They would like to call themselves the first club, I think.
Matt: 1744 is pretty old. And there's not a lot of clubs that can informally make that claim around Scotland or anywhere else. But there's definitely dispute over the gentleman golfers and the Honourable Company being this first golf club. And the one that is most notable would be right down the street, the Burgess Golfing Society. Did you deal any with? The Royal Burgess Golf and Society.
Professor: They came up a couple of times. I did not dive into them. What do we got on them? What's their stake in this game?
Matt: Well, I think their stake is that they were getting together to play golf much earlier. So again, back to poems. I dug through some of these poems and there was one written by a man named Ramsey, which had some references to the Burgess golfers. You know, if you go to... historians that really like to camp out and suggest that these guys were the first formalized golf club you would not have expected this poem to be as vague as it was the connection here is maggie johnston she had a establishment a tavern you know as we said earlier these clubs were every bit as much about the dinners and the drinking as they were the golf well in that poem it references 17. 11 was Burgess Golf Golfing Society was congregating there. So it's pretty vague. It's in there. Their actual organization date or their incorporated date was 1773.
Matt: Okay.
Professor: So that's their actual incorporation date.
Matt: Yes. Yeah. So their formal club, good 30 years after the Honourable Company had minutes and recorded, you know, this silver club competition. I think it became pretty clear to me, even though it's a fun. clip to put on social media that, you know, Muirfield isn't the oldest club in the world, the other company aren't. I'm pretty confident at this point after all this, they most definitely are. When it comes to the formalization of a club, these rules, their competitions, keeping record, they did at first.
Professor: The technicality there is they were recognized by the city, right? And they formalized rules and these rules were picked up. by
01:26:17 Restricting the Silver Club to the company
Professor: The other clubs at the time, including the Royal Burgess Golf Society.
Matt: But the other piece about that and kind of that, hey, we are a club. We've established ourselves. Do what you want, but these are our rules. I want to come back to the Silver Club competition because I found this very interesting about them is that, you know, that event remained open to noblemen and gentlemen, other golfers, for quite a while, but it didn't last. First off, the turnout stunk. Yeah. But in 1764, so we're talking 20 years later, the Honourable Company went back to the town council and basically said, hey, listen, we are the only group really playing in this thing right now. Why don't we just keep this to us? So the gentleman golfers claimed, and I think I wrote down their actual claim, the rules. Or too broad for by it any person whatever from any part of Great Britain or Ireland is entitled to play for the silver club whereby person or bad fame of bad fame or such are not fit company or gentleman may play for and win the silver club.
Matt: So that was their actual claim.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Why might that be important?
Matt: Don't let these scallywags come in and take.
Professor: Might that have something to do with what happens if you win the silver club? Exactly.
Matt: If someone from, call it Northern Ireland, comes down by boat and train and hops, not train, sorry, carriage, and hops into the Silver Cup competition and actually wins. Yeah, he's got to go buy a silver ball. He gets to set the rules for the club for a year.
Professor: He is the leader. Unquestionably leader. There was no appeals court. There was no committees. You are the captain. Every dispute comes to you. There's no voting procedures. You get to decide. I can't believe it took them that long. They got lucky. They got lucky. They got lucky.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Because they weren't that great of golfers, too.
Professor: 1763, or I guess it had been 1764. Someone in that competition almost won. We're on captains here. The very first captain. You got to tell us a little bit about John Rattray, don't you?
Matt: I want...
01:28:35 John Rattray political divisions and the 1745 rising
Matt: Just start with maybe my, it's my favorite story about John Rattray. Even though the Silver Club itself didn't grow acclaim amongst the golfing populace and the other loosely affiliated golfing families and whatnot, it definitely did in Edinburgh. And I think John Rattray's name, he was a hitter, as we said. Uh, he, he was a surgeon and a physician, but very smart, very intelligent and very opinionated professor. You would think this group was all politically aligned that they would advocate for the same things. They're all kind of on the periphery of noble and they were the merchant class and not tradesmen.
Professor: And that would fit the narrative of golf being a elitist sport. Oh, they have the same alignment and the same general interests.
Matt: These guys had. serious disagreements. We're talking rebellion. My favorite John Rattray story involves Bonnie Prince Charlie. So Bonnie Prince Charlie was laying claim to the throne. This is 1745. And rebellion was at the gates, right? There was this constituency that believed that he had that rightful claim. You know who wasn't claiming that?
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 01:30:00 ==========
Matt: Duncan Forbes. He strongly disagreed with it. He was the judge and the lawmaker, as we've said.
Professor: Who was one of the more powerful people in the city.
Matt: Yeah, and he played all the time on the links. So his position on this whole rebellion was very clear. Well, John Ratchery's was not. And John Ratchery was actually the Surgeon General for. prince charles okay and and so he was on the battlefield attending to the wounded and uh and so all this is playing out um um they're having these battles and on one particular one he travels to derby where they were badly defeated like and by the way these are the jacobites they were defeated they got their asses kicked at derby and so he was taken prisoner john ratchery um you know not not fighting with [unclear] weapon in hand but he was attending to those folks and and guess what when you go to prison for working for their other side at this time what do you think the offense of treason what do you think the punishment for treason is
Professor: Professor I mean either you're being sent to a prison on island or death I would assume
Matt: Death by beheading oh or hanging both kind of sound like a terrible way to go out
Professor: Yeah I'm not sure which one I would choose on that one if I had to uh
Matt: So he um um Duncan
01:31:22 Duncan Forbes intervenes for Rattray
Matt: Forbes, chief lawmaker. He certainly didn't care for the Jacobites. But his good friend, John Ratchery, was one of them. And these guys play a lot of golf together. So you see where this story is going. There was another gentleman that they played golf with as well who stepped in and said, hey, John's our old pal, Duncan. What can we do here? Yes, he's on the wrong side of this. History will tell. But I want to beat him in the silver club. You know, he's our guy that's won it. We're talking 1745, Kevin. He just defended his title. So this is the summer after he just won it for the second year in a row. Well, it worked. Duncan came to the rescue. I don't know how exactly. But long story short, he got his sentence. He didn't win the Silver Club in 1747.
Matt: So I assume, I can't remember if it didn't happen or he didn't play, but he was back playing with Duncan Forbes for the Silver Club in 1748. So I love that story. You're on death's door. And because of the game of golf, it saves your ass. I mean, not to be too hyperbole or philosophical, In the discussion, it helps you see the common nature of others. And certainly it appealed in this situation for him to make that work. By the way, just a small nugget, we Bonnie Prince Charlie. Okay. You know what happened to him? Uh-uh. So he actually escaped. Okay. He was able to get out of Dodge and he went to Italy. And there's multiple accounts of him bringing the game of golf with him. to the villages that he was hiding out. So the Italian, if you've ever played golf in Italy, there's a claim maybe there that Prince Charles had something to do with that.
Matt: Wow.
Professor: What a fascinating story.
Matt: Yeah, there's others on Rattray even later in his life, but that's just made for TV movie there. this time, Professor, I have a ton on this word that I... When
01:33:40 Clubbiness camaraderie and a growing network
Matt: We were talking about what is the story we're telling here, like what is actually happening? There's this word I just think just there's not, I don't know if it's in a dictionary, but it's clubbiness. There's just this clubbiness that then started to happen. It was things like the ceremonies around a silver club or other competitions, things like the camaraderie and heck, golf saving John Rattray's life. after treason is a good example of clubbiness or network now of people that you trust and spend more time with outside of even golf. I have a ton of all these periods of what I wrote down of just like, man, that is so clubby. Like that is just such a clubby.
Professor: Little stories, little rules put in place, things they did, decisions they made. Yeah, I'm with you on that. So many, oh, this happened right here. It's a little thing, but it also. is a big thing and that it tells us something there
Matt: Some serious some fun do you want serious or fun where should we start let's Let's
01:34:42 Taverns dinners and the beginnings of clubbiness
Matt: Start with fun.
Professor: We've had deaths already. We've had saving from deaths and treason. We've had people being financially ruined. Let's start with a fun one.
Matt: Houses being stolen from widows. As we've said a couple of times, the dinners were a big deal. So you play your golf, you need a place to go. So the clubbiness of hanging out, having a drink afterwards, that was huge. And they did like to have a good time. You see all these serious portraits that hang in Muirfield today. Not a lot of them looked like they'd have a good time. But the pubs, the taverns, these were these focal points in neighborhoods and towns. And it wasn't just the clubs and many of them at the beginning. They welcomed local residents and they would eat and drink, drink whiskey and claret and all the other things. They also had accommodations for guests. They had entertainment at night. They were just places to hang. They loved their sport. They had boxing. They had...
Matt: Cockfighting was actually really big. Cards were being played, early card games. So at these places, there's a lot going on. And the guy that probably had the most going on in this
01:35:54 Singing James Balfour and the responsibilities of the captain
Matt: Time frame of clubs becoming clubs, clubs being clubby, it's singing James Balfour. Did you stumble on this gentleman?
Professor: I came across this name. I don't have a whole lot, so I'm going to let you take this one.
Matt: Apparently, he liked to have a good time. And he became captain. And one of the rules for the captain was during the dinners, they would prepay for the food and everything and have a bill for that. But then they would just drink. They would just drink and be merry. And it was a good time to be alive and a part of these groups. So sometimes they'd get out of hand. And so the rule they came up with was the captain, just like with the rules of golf, the captain would have to monitor how much they were imbibed by. and making sure the bill didn't get out of hand [unclear] if it did tough
Professor: Tough job and
Matt: If it did it is a very tough job uh the captain then became responsible for that bill
Professor: Oh so it switched from the club to the captain
Matt: Yes yes oh so
Professor: You gotta be yeah yeah you
Matt: Gotta be on your game and well and maybe that was the reason that singing james balfour for should not have been in the seat because He never stopped. He never stopped at the bartends. He was the one keeping telling them to go, go, go, go, go. In fact, and this takes me back to my college years when we'd walk from pub to pub down on Main Street. Oh, yeah. He liked to race citizens walking by to the next pub. He would pull a stranger aside and say, hey, I'll race you to Cleffin's pub. And if you beat me, order the Claret and it's on me. So he must have been a man of some means, I'm sure, but he was just a character. And I guess he was always just singing wherever he went. And he did a good job other than not protecting the barbell.
Matt: But this was the early signs of clubbiness and the joy of congregating with others.
Professor: A note I had [unclear] was he brought the energy.
Matt: He brought the energy.
Professor: He did. And then what he served as, I think, secretary and treasurer for the club. And despite his jovial nature and just bringing the energy, when it came to down to doing work, he was all about accuracy and precision.
Matt: Yeah. Yeah. I think he was one of those work hard, play hard kind of guys. Get it done. Let's do it the right way.
Professor: I got a little bit annoyed with his fellow comrades that weren't so serious when it came to actually the books and making things we're being accounted for.
Matt: What else with the clubbiness?
Professor: Do you know what happened in 1758?
Matt: 1758. I don't.
01:38:26 The first levies drainage work and member duties
Professor: So this sets the stage for everything we associate with clubs now is it's the first sign of dues.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Yes. Oh, of course.
Professor: The course was needing some drainage work. And so the club treasurer picked up five shillings sterling from 29 members. That would be approximately 60 pounds or 80 American dollars in today's dollars per member. So picked up about 1700 pounds or 2300 us dollars in total to work on club drainage. So we see our first signs of dues, you know, and responsibility of the membership to the course at this time that like, Hey, we need to invest something back in the, into this course to get it playable to where we want. And obviously this is probably self-serving and that we want the course to be under certain conditions and a way of which we're going to do that is by having members contribute.
Matt: Small amount of money. Yeah, and it was a more, just like it is today, a predictable revenue stream, right? Now, did subscription fees come first?
Professor: This was just a one-time. This was a one-time. A one-time due at the time.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: I believe they called them levies.
Professor: Yeah, levies was a traditional term. And you see, at the same time, you see other things. These are all captured in their minutes, which again, go into your point of the history being kept here, where you see them. Again, the argument of them being the first formal club. You see in the minutes, other signs of duty and responsibility comes up. You had a clerk of agents of the golfers removed for a poor job at this time. That's being documented in the minutes. Hey, you did a bad job. You're no longer doing this. We're going to discipline you. You also have one of my favorite stories of this time.
01:40:04 David Lyon and discipline within the company
Professor: This is directly from the minutes. The captain and his counsel consider that Mr. David Lyon, an eminent golfer, after subscribing and engaging himself to play for the silver club this day, has not only not started for the club, but contrary to the duty of his allegiance, has withdrawn himself from the captain and his company and has dined in another house. So he was cited for this, for not only not playing after pledging to play, and then not dining with the company that evening and got caught dining somewhere else. I was at home sick. Dining somewhere else. He was cited and had to answer to the company. the following Saturday. So you brought in front of your own members. Now, he was punished. Specifics are not kept in the minutes, typically, on what the punishment was. But he no longer ever entered a silver club competition.
Professor: And he was an eminent golfer. Remember, that was quote-unquote. So there's a good chance he might have been asked to leave the club relative to...
Matt: Our first non-gratus. I have one example of one dinner from their minutes if you would like me to run through it real quick.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Please do.
Matt: So
01:41:12 The cost of club dinners and a new financial model
Matt: Dinner, two pounds. Bread, two shillings. Porter, ale, and spruce. Whatever spruce is, I don't know. Eight shillings. Gin, brandy, six shillings and eight pence. Port and sherry, seven bottles. It was specific. One pound and 13 shillings, six pence. Claret, 16 bottles. By the way, this was, I think I have the number of people that attended this. That is more than a bottle of guy of Claret. That was a fairly high alcohol content, I believe. It was 14 people, I believe. Yeah, 14 attended this dinner. So 16 bottles of Claret was five pounds and 12 shillings, more than anything else on the menu. And then lights and service for the night, 11 shillings and two pence. So that adds up to 10 pounds, 13 shillings and four pence. That is roughly. 3,500 pounds today. By today's standard, that would be what?
Matt: Call it $5,000. That's one heck of a party for 14 people.
Professor: That is quite the event.
Matt: Right? So you could see why these dinners were becoming kind of this like, eh, we probably should figure out a different economic model. So they started with initiation fees and then I believe soon after ended up with subscriptions.
Professor: And what a 3,500 pound dinner might cause for a club when... Yeah,
01:42:34 Membership vetting and the 1764 regulations
Professor: One that might occur on an irregular basis. One more for you. 1764, new rules put down for a vetting process. That's the same year of the Silver Club Open rules being changed. It's no longer the Silver Club Open. It is now the Silver Club competition.
Matt: There's more than maybe just him competing that they're like, eh.
Professor: And so that same year, the company of gentlemen golfers... Put up the following rules. Every person inclining to be admitted a member of the club must be proposed by a member the Saturday before the election. Every member admitted must be balloted for. At admission, every member must pay half a guinea to your initiation fee. Every member must attend the meeting when the club is played for, if he is in Edinburgh or Leith, or must give a proper excuse for his absence, otherwise he forfeits his place in the society. A penalty that I allude to. We're going to formalize that. If the silver club's going on and you're in town, you better be there.
Matt: There's another leap that they make a few years after, and that's to a clubhouse. So they go from Stratton's pub, where
01:43:38 The first clubhouse and the pub tenancy
Matt: They were hanging out, sharing that space with all the other citizens and town people, maybe a couple other clubs, to 1768, they built their own clubhouse.
Professor: They're the first.
Matt: Yeah. To do it. So that's another first. We can add it to the list. They're the first to build it. But interestingly, they decided to lease the space to a pub owner. And there was part of the agreement that they could just use it for their purposes whenever they wanted. But they had a tenant. So a pretty good deal they worked out, I think.
Professor: That's a really, really smart move on their part.
Matt: The formalities continue. And if you're a conspiracy theorist, I recommend trying to connect the tie between the Honourable Company of Admiral Goffers and the Freemasons.
Professor: Where are you going with this?
Matt: Nick Cage, national treasure type stuff professor. In these years towards their maturity, let's call it at Leith, the Jacobite influence was a portion of the club. And then I was kind of stomped out once that rebellion was exhausted. But the Masonic Lodge, you know, when you look at a lot of the ceremonies that they do within this club at this time, the formalities that they're bringing to it. Really, there was another blueprint, and it was this Freemason, Freemasonry, which was a group that they connected around politics. They were quite secret. There was a lot of secrecy. Also very well documented, actually, even though many of them maybe don't exist. Nick Cage needs to find them. But there was overlap within these two groups. The whole conspiracy stuff around, you know, Deep State and the Honorable [unclear] I don't know. I think there was enough that I read that was like, these guys cared about the golf.
Matt: They cared about who was a part of it. They cared about their better, but they're not really cooking up master plans.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Or maybe that's what they want us to think. Or maybe that's what they want us to think.
Matt: I really got sidetracked here for literally two, three days. And I stopped myself and I said, I might need a tinfoil hat if I go any further.
Professor: We'll save that for an addition. But on that note.
01:45:49 Alexander Duncan and connections between clubs
Professor: I mean, the foundation stone laid at Leith, and who was there during the building of that? Do you want to take us down that road?
Matt: At least down that road? In Edinburgh.
Professor: A name that was there at the time? Go ahead, if you want to go there. One Alexander Duncan.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Alexander Duncan.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Do you have much on him?
Matt: Member of the Honourable Company, member of the Freemasons.
Professor: Captain of the R&A from 1756, 61, and 81 there, and also of the gentleman in 81. I think he was maybe the first to serve as captain of the both. 82, 1982, he establishes the port and punch as the ordinary drink of the society unless the silver club or cups are up for grabs. And in that case, any liquor was permitted. Port and punch in 1782 gets established as the ordinary drink of society.
Matt: How about that? Oh, that's a cool connection. Yeah, I think the reality of this time is
01:46:47 The Scottish Enlightenment and an age of leisure
Matt: Clubs were forming across all elements of society. And that had to do with coming into a golden age where the Enlightenment, the Scottish Enlightenment, why are all these people so happy? They really were. This is a joyous time. They're coming out of epidemics and plagues and rebellions. They're spirited and they have sports and they have a lot of the bands were being lifted. The Sunday sport came back. The 1600s band was taken off. I think Leith itself, again, we talked about that being a place of confidence, of success, of reassured people. Well, the economy was booming. All those illnesses were gone. They liked to drink. Food was plentiful. There was new logistics systems that were building and coming in. It really was this hub, Leith in particular, but Edinburgh overall was a hub of European influence. And, you know, the Scots weren't just learning things from elsewhere.
Matt: They were exporters. You know, all these written, all these books that we were able to dive into, they were exporters of knowledge. They were poets, they were writers, they were architects. You know, a lot of medicine came out of Edinburgh at this time. And so I thought that really had a lot to do with why did they want to congregate? and be a part of clubs. They had a lot to talk about. There was a lot that was happening. And I was trying to put myself in that place and time and thinking, what would Edinburgh have been like? What would Leith have been like at this mature stage of the Lynx? I'm guessing it's, you know, I don't know. What do you think, Professor? Like, where's a place that is the center of innovation, of enlightenment and globalization in our lifetime?
Matt: I guess Silicon Valley comes to mind, San Francisco, perhaps. I don't think it's hyperbole to say that. Athens, Greece was that back in Aristotle and in Plato's time. There was more than just golf cooking here is what the point I'm trying to make.
Professor: Yeah, and I think anybody that visits Edinburgh would probably recognize that in terms of the timepieces that are there. So much of that is from the late 1700s, the history that you would see and navigate as a tourist.
Matt: Yeah, and let's not forget. It was filled with a nest of lawyers.
Professor: So they
Matt: Also liked formalities around those things. We wouldn't have been
01:49:11 Changes to medal play and scoring at Leith
Matt: Able to do such a deep discussion on something like this without these people who shared so much of that time, which I think is really cool part of it all they played. Just thinking about the end of this era. Let me
01:49:26 Weather featheries and the pace of play
Matt: Ask you just a simple question. Do you think they played in the rain?
Professor: I would guess yes. I don't have... Well, you brought the feathery point earlier, so I might backtrack that. I think with the point you made about the feathery, I would have to say no. Mist, sure. But actual rain precipitation, I would guess no because of how expensive those balls would be and how quickly they would be ruined on a day like that.
Matt: Played in all kinds of wind and other conditions. But because of that feathery golf ball, they didn't. They did not like to play in the rain. And there's a lot of accounts that speak to it. So these were not mudders. If it was a squall, they weren't playing. They were probably inside drinking more claret. They also had caddies, both caddies and four caddies. If it was wet conditions, they protected those feathery balls. Some would even rotate them out, you know, whole. by hole after the rules were established. But they were so paranoid about those really expensive featheries, which makes sense when you look at the cost of what that was. Pace of play. These guys played matches and they played fast. An hour and 30 minutes for a game. That's 15 holes of 400-yard length.
Professor: Yeah. You're not playing 400-yard length in three to four. You're playing it in five, six, or seven.
Matt: The pace, I think, had a lot to do with the focus on being social and having... appropriate time to drink and be merry and do whatever in the club and go back out and play again. So they were even doing that at Leith, which I know became part of the story later on. But yeah, just the overall clubbiness, the routines, the cadences, they were all starting to emerge.
Professor: Speaking of clubbiness, do we want to dive into the dinner matches and club dinners at this time?
01:51:10 The bett book and unusual wagers
Matt: We talked about how darn expensive they were. What else?
Professor: The emergence of the bet book. Ah, yes. And what that meant and then how these club dinners actually unfolded relative to the bet book. Tell us about the bet book. I think this was my favorite part of all the research I've done is just this idea of a bet book spelled B-E-T-T. And it documents all bets, the Honourable Company over the years. Traditionally, the dinner matches they're called, which are. by definition, made during the club dinners, but also some other random bets too. But these are documented in the bet book across the entire history of the Honourable Company. And I'll start with a few of the fun ones. You've got stuff. I mean, let me go on. You got boat races, some Calcutta matches. Again, these are rare. They're not often in there. It's typically just a dinner matches that are in there.
Professor: But Mr. R. Allen bets one guinea that he will drive a ball from Castle Hill without the gate of the palisade into the half-moon battery over the... parapet wall where one guy got beat only by irons and there was such
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Offense to that
Professor: That the captain put in a rule that no one would play with irons only at least right like no like we don't like irons in general petition that's what it came from that bet and that gets to dinner
Matt: Matches.
Professor: You brought the club dinners, you know, once a month, I think they were. The formal club dinners once a month.
Matt: That you were required to be at.
Professor: And you had. dinner matches proposed during this so how did this proceed I'll go through that how this was formally um decided okay so you're meeting at this dinner the captain
01:52:53 How club dinners and dinner matches were organized
Professor: In his red coat, which we'll get to saying a little bit more about, in the silver club sitting in front of him at the top of the table, is organizing this. Again, the captain is responsible for everything. As all this I'm playing, he's the one basically an auctioneer, sitting up in front of everyone making sure this goes in.
Matt: By the way, pause. Could you imagine the quote-unquote best golfer at every club being the guy that has to call the shots for these? other things. Usually the best golfer is not the person you want in charge of all this stuff. Go on.
Professor: So first, the winning scores from the last medal are read. Captain reads those out. The winners receive their insignia and a toast is had. We have to toast the winners of the medal. They also typically give replies to this as the winners. Then the book from the last dinner match is read with the results. All the previous dinner matches that were proposed, they go through reading all the results. So you go down in the books. If you're playing in a match that's going to be in the book, it will be noted there for history that you played in that match and its results. And the captain has to go through and read all of those and why that's important is going to come up because that sounds pretty boring, right? Do you really want to sit there and like, you know, it is somewhere typically between like 25 to 40 matches were typically in there for a time period and you have to read, listen to that.
Professor: Why that's important is going to come around here in a second.
Matt: Recognition and shame have always been a motivator in the game. Yeah.
01:54:19 Fair matches wagers and the role of the recorder
Matt: Okay,
Professor: Now matches are proposed. And the captain again resides over this, has to prove everything. And the captain's main goal is to ensure fair matches are played. And there's a recorder also documenting all this. Now a fair match doesn't mean, let's bring up the word handicap here. They're all the same handicap. It could mean it's a scratch player with an 18 playing a nine and a nine. It's just the captain's job, whatever that match is, to think like this is a... fair match. And typically handicaps were not a thing. Everybody played as it was. You take no shots. So the captain, that's his main duty, whatever gets proposed. So now members are proposing matches. So a member gets up, I want to do this match. Me and Matt Considine versus player by player X on this day. Captain says, that's a fair match.
Professor: So the recorder's going to knock that match. Now the captain opens it up for wagers for everyone else in the room [unclear] this is where the recorder truly has their job where all the other members in the room get to make wagers on that match if they wish and the recorder has to be listening and documenting all those wagers and who it's between and so they document all of that as the room quiets down the captain then asks for the next match to be proposed and a member can get up and propose a match sit down, and then the rest of the room will erupt over who wants to take who and who's making bets with who. And the bet book records all that done by the recorder, which within the club is now one of the most important positions there.
Matt: There's money changing hands.
Professor: Money changing hands in their first 190 years
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: As a club
Professor: With the bet book being a thing and dinner matches, only 27
Matt: Recorders. Wow. Wait, 190 years, 27 individual recorders.
Professor: And that's it. Yeah. [unclear] like a tough job. These guys stick around. That's a little bit shorter than a 10-year tenure. So the recorder is a critical job. Obviously, a very trusted individual that actually has a skill set to be able to handle that. So much so that when this is all done, all the matches are proposed, we're good, we're going to close the bet book. They toast the recorder's health.
Matt: I
01:56:42 Pride camaraderie and the appeal of foursomes
Matt: Think about pride when I hear about these matches, that there was a lot of pride in both the recognition of it, of winning and playing the game the way that they wanted to play it, but they were proud people.
Professor: And that's very clear in the history, and this is spoken directly to by historians, that the matches were not about money. And this is why the captain's job was so critical, because he needed the matches to be fair. So when you're making a wager on a match... It really was a toss-up, and there are a lot of stories about just 50 % win rates. You had foursomes play matches regularly over their whole career, and it'd come out to basically 51 % to 49 % for these four that always played against each other. Or people making wagers that it was intended everything to be a wash at the end of the year. Nobody won a lot of money, and nobody lost a lot of money. The fact was, this was a way to have camaraderie, to play against each other.
Professor: Have a competition that we can then bond together over afterwards and have this joyous retelling of the match without anybody being angry because they've lost a lot of money upset you know
Matt: Storming off throwing your clubs in parking lot do The
Professor: Bet book has been kept across the history of the club.
Matt: It is a really cool tradition. The nature of it and the fact that it still happens today. But they don't do that at Leith anymore, Professor. It wasn't all in the high times. They're obviously formalized. They're playing competitions. They're having these matches. Wait, so are you telling me...
Professor: You know, in 1800, they get established officially as the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers. They're a body corporate now. The city says [unclear] body corporate means you take care of yourself. You're self-contained, self-sufficient, self-governing. They're rolling.
Matt: The game is booming. We're enlightened. We're coming into this world. It's a busy place. They only got five holes out there. And on top of that, it's actually being viewed, golf that is, as a fairly dangerous sport
Professor: Because
Matt: Have you ever held a feathery?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: I actually haven't. It doesn't. What's it?
Matt: We're talking about a mini baseball. It doesn't feel like the soft feather. It is so tightly compact that you get hit with those things. You're going to feel it. And there are multiple accounts of that occurring out on the links. There is the creation at this time of the customary four. That was kind of an unspoken rule. before the Honourable Company, that you needed a way to tell the people that are up there with their horses or with their laundry or with whatever that you're coming. And so they would yell for prior to the golf shot.
Professor: Oh, so, okay.
Matt: It later became with balls flying that they would yell it again. They obviously aren't going to try to hurt people on purpose, but they're going to let everybody share this common land that does require communication. But the other places where the game was expanding at this time, they were outlawing. golf in these public places because of that chaos, because of people crisscrossing and balls flying through the air.
Professor: Well, you had what streets literally against the golf course or houses being built at the economic boom. So nicer Victorian style houses possibly being built around. Yeah, exactly.
Matt: And they were encroaching. The world was encroaching
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 02:00:00 ==========
Matt: On those public spaces as well. The buildings, the factories, there was a rope factory right next to a Leith links. It was becoming a little bit. cumbersome [unclear] little bit more snug and frankly when you really think about it it could have easily been banned golf on the links because it was so many other activities going on there was now other competing forces and I think what served the sport well is the Honourable Company was there to defend it uh the game of golf like they made sure that golfers had their say when it comes to some of the decisions around that and I think a lot of that was around the time that they were on their own, but also they carried weight around town. They were gentlemen of some positions trying to do things for themselves as a club, but they were so reliant on these other parties in the town and essentially a municipal golf course that that started to frustrate them, which will bleed into some of these upcoming decisions.
Matt: Do you know the uniforms for
Professor: The Honourable Company I know what they are now the red I I don't know the full history of that so
Matt: 1787 right on the lead up to that time the scarlet coat with blue colors in it, I think blue buttons, these were a sign of their solidarity with each other as a club. So it would be fun to look over and see the other dinner match going on in the other club. That was part of it. But really the main reason was safety. That not only were they yelling for, but they also wanted just people to see.
Professor: Because the
Matt: Good part of this, I think, was there was a tolerance of golfers in Leith and maybe not some other places because... This awareness, the silver club marching through town once a year, the guys in red scarlet jackets playing the game. So there was a knowledge of even non-golfers that were out there to say, oh, yep, they're going to be coming through. Let's let them do their shots and be back at it.
Professor: Love that. You've alluded to issues. You brought the course being really, really busy. The game is getting more popular. You only have five holes to spread out people. Yeah, they're 400 yards, but that's not a lot of room for a lot of golf. I'm sure
02:02:18 Leases drainage and stewardship of the grounds
Professor: The club is growing at the time. Other course use is going on. What were their solutions?
Matt: It was kind of made for them. They did lease the land when they officially became the Honourable Company. They would lease the land. And one of the big reasons, they were already taking care of it.
Professor: That's right.
Matt: And I think all the stuff I read was there were many firsts that could be disputed. But one that I certainly couldn't find is these guys were the first to tend to the land, tend to the grounds. There was the first entry related to Greens as like an almost committee. It was already 1758. In the 1762 minutes, they referenced major drainage issues. And so they started to fix that. Later in 1764, there was this additional fee for keeping the Links in good order, as you mentioned. So I think they had a leg to stand on, finally, because they were already taking care of the Links. And they were their own people. This ultimately, I'm guessing, contributed to, hey, we're not only are we're stewarding the land, we're investing in it, and we're not getting as much out of it as we would like.
Matt: That led to, well, first, them building their own clubhouse. I think you could say the same thing being true of the pub, Stratton's Pub, and needing to go to their own clubhouse. You could see the signs of wanting their own course towards this time. But the reason I said the decision was really made for them is,
02:03:46 Declining interest in golf and wider economic pressures
Matt: I think the good times might be over, Professor. Towards the 1780s, 1790s, there was this lessening of interest in the game of golf. And it was all throughout Scotland. So the membership of the Honourable Company, they rose to 140 members somewhere in there, 135, something like that. That was a lot of a group of people playing on a five-hole golf course. Yeah.
Professor: Right? That was a lot. I mean, thinking now, I mean, some clubs, you know, 200 to 300. Can be a healthy number for an 18 hole complex.
Matt: And when you see 150 people together, it actually shows you like, oh, that's a lot of people. And most of them were actually playing golf at the same times too. And that might've been their adapted lease arrangement of that time. So this was really the first documented sign though, that interest in Great Britain and Ireland was just starting to, you know, change. Things were more serious. They had less leisure time. I don't know if our friends listening would remember what happened in 1776. But there was an independence elsewhere, breaking away from Great Britain. Colonies, they won. And that threatened the European economy. You talked about the older rebellions almost bankrupt at Duncan Forbes. Well, now we're talking about huge impact. on the economies. And so things were getting more serious. People were tightening their belts a little bit. People just couldn't relax and have as much play.
Matt: I say that decision was made for them. It was really just the end of this era, this changing of the times. You have this decline in golf, this decline at Leith. And the Honourable Company who was investing in golf was investing
02:05:40 The financial crisis at Leith
Matt: In Leith, they were put into kind of a tough spot. What the heck happened? The crisis, as it came to be known or referred to, was from a very risky financial position the Honourable Company was in. They attempt to balance their books, use that annual fee to do so, but the money didn't arrive because people weren't joining. And they started to postpone the payments that they've already actually signed up for. The pre-order dinners, the stuff on the links, the drainage. They just stopped paying people in the recession. I guess that's what would happen. But they did freely continue to pay for expensive portraits. I think it had something to do with a gentleman named Rayburn, who is one of the most famous portrait artists ever. And many of his works are worth millions and millions of dollars today, many of which are stored on behalf of the Honourable Company, I think at the National Scottish Archives.
Matt: But anyways, he got his bills paid by the sounds of it. Maybe they were more modest because he was doing a favor for the club. I don't know. Other people were not getting paid. And in 1803, the minutes note that there was a demonstration of the cavalry upon the course. It did a ton of damage. So they already just put a bunch into the drainage and some other solutions that they were trying to do for the links. And I guess Calvary just destroyed it. They wanted to play still. So they, I think, kept finding the dollars to do it. But it was just contributing to this financial position, this really risky state that they were in. And they didn't pay their rent. Their club professional, Simon, went broke. They had to back him. He was bankrupt. So they took over his debts.
Matt: And the Honourable Company. was just in a sad state. And so with a bunch of lawyers, he actually successfully started to lay claim against some of the parties that are demanding payment. There was just a weird, ugly, dark time towards all of it, both golf and the club itself. And so really it leads to this final decision of, hey, think we might want to move someplace else. And Leith might not be the place for the Honourable Company anymore. And I think that's probably a perfect place to go next. So Before we do, Professor, I want to sit with where we are for a second. If you've ever run a business or sat on a board, the last 10 minutes probably made your stomach churn.
Professor: Increased liabilities and decreased assets. What could possibly go wrong?
Matt: For starters, they've stopped paying people. They put real money into drainage on the links. And then the cavalry rides a demonstration across the course and tears it up. Their own... Club professional goes bankrupt, and they end up taking on his debts. People are demanding payment, and it's turning into claims and counterclaims. And
Professor: We haven't even gotten to the mortgages yet.
Matt: And we haven't even gotten to the mortgages
02:09:00 Founding partner: Inglewood
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Yet. Exactly
Professor: Why this is the right moment to welcome a new partner of the great clubs, Inglewood. Inglewood is a senior-led advisory firm that's been in the room for critical business turns since 1983. turnarounds, transactions, leadership gaps, and the hard decisions in between. They work with owners, boards, and lenders, mostly in the middle market.
Matt: We've gotten to know their team well now, and aside from a few golf games that are in need of a turnaround, the thing that has stuck with me the most is how committed they are to the firm's promise. The senior people, the ones you meet in the first conversation, are the ones who do the work. No junior teams, no handoffs.
Professor: Their line is that they're business people first, not lifetime consultants. Their partners have made payroll, negotiated with lenders, and run companies. Across the team, you'll find former CEOs, CFOs, CEOs, board chairs, and court-appointed receivers, each averaging more than 35 years of experience with the war stories and battle scars to
Matt: Prove it. And their turnaround playbook reads like a letter they could have mailed to Edinburgh in 1830. Stabilize first. Get control of the cash, build a 13-week forecast, give the lender a credible story. Then, figure out what's actually fixable. They negotiate with lenders, landlords, and vendors from a real plan. Then the part I love the most, they stay involved until it all holds.
Professor: Not until the report is written, until it holds. And as anyone who has run a business knows, the critical turn usually shows up quietly through conversation, which is why I love that Inglewood has a page on their site called, Do I Need Help? You pick the situation that sounds like yours, and if it's not them, they'll tell you directly.
Matt: Inglewood, senior experts for critical business transitions. Start the conversation at ingw.com.
Professor: And if you can't remember that, Inglewood has a trick for it. ingwineedgoodwhiskey.com.
Matt: Appropriate for the point we just left off in the story, visit ingw.com and tell them that Matt and the professor sent you. All right.
Professor: Let's
02:11:03 The club opens its books
Professor: Get back to the story and open the books.
Matt: So the financial picture for the company of gentlemen golfers, now the Honourable Company has changed. How has it specifically changed, Professor? What are they going to do
Professor: About this? So we still don't have the idea of an annual subscription going on. But one of my favorite stories as they're going through this sort of call to financial ruin, if you will. Remember Henry M. Lowe, the course record holder for the... When they play at 10 holes, he becomes a pretty key character right now. So he is the captain from 1826 to 1828. Again, the course record holder, hence captain. He was a pretty good player in his own right. And he also served as secretary in 1829. Well, during this time period, they had a mortgage on the golf house. They took out in 1824. They took out a second mortgage in 1828. So two mortgages on a golf house in a four-year run. Something's going on.
Matt: Overextended. Well, Henry M.
Professor: Lowe fleeds the country in 1830. Do you know why this is?
Matt: Because they're after him for the money.
Professor: Client and personal debts. So our man. Does not a good manager of his own personal finances and has been at charge of the club has taken out a second mortgage during his time there. Who knows what he used that second mortgage for.
Matt: Did they confirm impropriety? Like, was he embezzling from the club?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: So specific
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Records have
Professor: Not been created or kept regarding Mr. Lowe. So I feel like those were. probably either disappeared
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: He was such a dark spot on all that east
Professor: Lothian golf and social scene right this extends well beyond the Honourable Company these are personal debts
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Um
Professor: These are client debts this is a
02:13:04 Selling assets while preserving club trophies
Professor: Across the board throughout East Lothian, he disappears, leaves the club high and dry. They are in rough shape.
Matt: So as you mentioned- Was he a mason?
Professor: Maybe he was. So they're in a position where, hey, we got to do some stuff. One of the first things they do is they're like, okay, we're going to relinquish removal assets. So internal items from the golf house. This goes for about 106 pounds. We're in 1833 right now. That's about 11,000 pounds, and today's are $15,000. You know what they didn't sell?
Matt: What's that?
Professor: Club trophies.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Oh, you got to hold on to history, baby.
Professor: Club trophies. Shout out to them. Everything else internal, we're going to be getting rid of stuff. Even portraits are flying out the window. Those things are now worth millions. There's a good history. Someone out there should do a whole history on just their portraits that they've had, they've lost, they've got back, that are forever lost. But they didn't get rid of their trophies. They kept those. They also kept, of course, the least of the links
Matt: Going. Do you know what they sold it for? The clubhouse?
Professor: Did you get that total
Matt: In there?
Professor: I do.
Matt: Do you want to share it? I think mine's correct. 103 pounds?
Professor: Oh, I had 1,130.
Matt: Is that adjusted for inflation?
Professor: My adjustment would go to 120,000 pounds or $160,000. Okay. The 106 I had pounds was for the internal items.
Matt: Yeah, I had it woefully short of those mortgages.
Professor: Regardless, even whatever they fetch.
Matt: Top number, I think they're still underwater.
Professor: That's right. That secretary that skipped out of town, the mortgage he put in place, we're now moving. This is post-sell of the golf house. Suits, counter suits, Royal Bank of Scotland is involved in this. They are in a bad place right now. Very bad
Matt: All right. Where
02:15:07 Recovery renewed dinners and the move east
Matt: Are we going to now, Professor?
Professor: They've sold off the clubhouse. I think it was in 1835 that they did pay off the deposit they owed to the Royal Bank of Scotland and got a little bit of credit back. During all this time, the club dinners are not going on. They're not self-supporting. Obviously, that's not happy times for them. They finally decide to resume the club dinners in 1836. They don't have a clubhouse anymore. So where do those club dinners start back up?
Matt: The pub.
Professor: And where at?
Matt: Well, it's not going to be in Leith. Everybody's asking them for money in Leith. They got to get out of there. How about another town that's a little bit more accessible thanks to some updates to transportation? Musselburgh.
Professor: And what are those updates to transportation at this time?
Matt: It seems like it's a hybrid between a carriage and a rail, a train. What were those called?
Professor: Oh, I don't know their name. I just know, you know, something we take for granted these days is our ability to jump on a plane, fly to Scotland, jump on a train and get ourselves out to North Berwick or Golan or wherever we want to go. We could be there in, I don't know, 12 hours if we wanted to be.
02:16:25 The omnibus and access to Musselburgh
Matt: The name, it was called the Omnibus.
Professor: The Omnibus. That sounds like a name that could be right now.
Matt: Yes. I think it was just horses that pulled along rails. And the Omnibus made it much more efficient. They had these cars that were bigger than your typical carriage. And you can more cheaply get out. Because remember, the things aren't great in the economy at this point. People are concerned about cost. It didn't cost you anything to play unless you took a caddy. So the links are still free. Getting there was the problem. So Leaf was busy. A lot of the common golfer was out there. Clubs still resided. But the first to make that decision are our friends at the Honourable Company. They're packing up. And where are they going to go? Well, it's got to be somewhere that's accessible. Their business is still in Edinburgh. Their families and friends are still in Edinburgh. They're not going to up and go to the Highlands or Glasgow.
Matt: But they needed something that was accessible. Transportation now made it possible. They're headed to Musselburgh.
Professor: That's right. Now, it's a little bit misleading. A lot of the picture painted makes it look like, oh, we got to search for a place. Where are we going to go? As if they're out on the streets trying to figure this out. There's notes as early as 1828, they'd actually been dining at the Anchor and Mussel out there and having kind of unofficial club dinners. that they were doing just east because transportation was there. There was a nice little golf course out there to be played. Remember, Leith Links wasn't glorious as a golf course. The city was enclosing on it. The public use, lots of people laundry off. The ground itself was wet. It didn't drain great. So you can imagine, especially if you've been out to East Lothian, there's a lot of nice little firm land out there east of that city that good golf can be played on.
Professor: So they've been out there dabbing a little bit. Obviously, nostalgia is a hell of a drug. So moving from Leith was never going to be an easy decision. But when all of a sudden your hand's forced, you're in financial ruin, you're coming out of that finally, but you no longer have a golf house. A little bit easier to say, well, maybe we should get away from where all of our previous problems were.
Matt: So transportation made it possible. The Lynx land existed. They're not going to, as you said, go anywhere but Lynx. That's where golf is played.
02:18:46 The Musselburgh landscape holes and pace of play
Matt: Did you find to be especially attractive about Musselburgh at the time for the company?
Professor: I think you touch on it, easy to get to or easier to get to now. And that's where golf was going on. It was originally seven holes. on good property like a firm firm turf much more probably what is is coming to people's mind when they think of lynx land much more just subtle rolling ground more akin to a saint andrews for those that have been there so originally seven holes moves eight holes in 1838 nine by 1870 just doing a quick fast forward there we're now at something where the holes are 80 to 400 yards so you're actually moving into what Maybe I would be more kind here and a little bit less kind to lead more proper golf course or different tests where it's not just, okay, I'll hit you in the mouth with five straight 400 yard holes, but we have holes ranging in their flavor.
Professor: You've got more smooth table greens. You have a winding direction course off the fairway. It's difficult, but playable. And again, that just is a fast playing golf course. So you think of the technology at the time, what they're playing with. They like to play quick. Now you're having a grounds of the game that embodies that, that enables that quick, swift play with the ball moving along the way. What's another key aspect? Pub right there. Hey, we need somewhere to congregate afterwards. It's right there.
Matt: And as you said, one of their favorite pubs, some of the oldest members of the Honourable Company were already going over there for dinner. and likely playing here and there, but not as a group. So when the decision came up...
02:20:38 Other clubs and shared use of Musselburgh Links
Matt: There was a familiarity to the owners of the pubs and the taverns and probably a lot of already playing members. Who was Professor playing at Musselburgh before the Honourable Company?
Professor: In terms of the different clubs that were playing there, you had Royal Musselburgh. You had Royal Burgess were out playing there. You also had Brunsfield Lynx. that were playing out at Musselburgh at the time. And so, again, why did they move out there? It wasn't like, oh, the Honourable Company found Musselburgh. No, golf was going on there. It was a worthy golf course and a popular golf course. So it made a natural place for them to move at the time. All right, so what about the links itself? As I mentioned, it was seven holes, then eight holes, then nine holes by 1870. It was somewhat city locked.
02:21:39 An evolving golf course within a racecourse
Professor: Like Leith had surrounds all the way around it. Interesting enough, you wouldn't see the sea from it. Just the way it had a little bit of wilderness around it. It had military aspects on one side. So it wasn't like we would traditionally think of a Lynx land, even though it played like that. there was a huge constraint to this golf course, which again was why you didn't get to see the C. surrounding it. Well, there was actually another thing surrounding it, a racetrack. So this is the famous connection with horse races that a majority of the golf course actually exists within a racetrack. And that obstructed the view from around it. And on the non-racetrack side, the main city street butted up right against the golf course. So tons of famous stories of golfers slicing their balls into the main city street.
Professor: Much like Gleith, we are amidst other aspects they're not out on their own in their own piece of property playing golf not being surrounded by the public
Matt: Yeah and we've already talked about the horses on these links they were around but this is one of the few that had the formalized race course even the Honourable Company needed a place to to hang and I believe one of the places they went was actually the facility of the race
Professor: Course yeah the grandstand of the horse track played a
02:23:01 The pub hole and the clubs meeting places
Professor: A prominent role for them to meet up. You also had Miss Foreman's Inn. So the fourth green was called the pub hole. Longer hole, 430 yards. After a long hole like that, what might you want? Nice little pint. We'll clear it. So this was unofficially the first halfway house in golf history. Whereas you finished the fourth hole. Okay. There was a little cut into the garden wall so golfers could be. given their you know pint of ale without having to leave the course it's an interesting little tidbit now this foreman's inn um eventually became foreman's bar and kitchen then foreman's lodge now it is actually a cottage for rent so you can stay within the former or the first halfway house in the uh unofficial history of golf okay so you can dine in a nice little italian restaurant that also was one of their original watering holes uh mckendrick's inn Initially, this then became the Musselburgh Arms Hotel, and now is, I believe, an Italian restaurant.
Professor: There are flats above it. So a couple little pieces of the Honourable Company's history that you can still check out, stay at, and dine in relative to their stay at Musselburgh.
Matt: Got to get to Musselburgh
Professor: Have you heard of local golfer Robert Gray? Yeah. And what he did in 1829, a little
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Drain
Professor: Pipe cutter.
Matt: Ah.
Professor: So the original 4.25 inch drain pipe to create a consistent hole.
Matt: The first golf cup.
Professor: So this became later the global standard. Robert Gray at Musselburgh is responsible for that. Some other little
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Tidbits
Professor: About the golf course. It has one of the best closings in Open Championship history. I know we're going to get to the Open Championship history in a little bit more detail, but relative to Musselburgh, one of the more important was in 1883, Bob Ferguson, who was a local professional, needing nine to tie with three to play. The last three holes there, 220 yards, 270 yards, and 150 yards. At the time, very, very difficult task [unclear] to what they were playing with. But he did it, but then lost in a playoff and did not complete his 4P.
Matt: Competitive golf ramps up in the 1800s. One early account I liked in these matches that would take place, one of our first famous golfers, that we've mentioned on the this episode willie park senior so the parks the great golfing families Musselburgh was where they're at in this time um they were also tradesmen that knew how to build the equipment and whatnot but my favorite willie park senior occasionally he would just grab a single shinty stick a shinty stick and He would go beat the pants off of anybody with just a simple shinty stick
02:25:59 Subscriptions and changes to the captaincy
Matt: At Musselburgh. So I loved that little anecdote.
Professor: How about we move back to the Honourable Company in their time at Musselburgh? Perfect. They've moved to Musselburgh in 1836. This doesn't mean their financial situation was solved. So I mentioned still no annual subscription.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: That wasn't abnormal.
Professor: At the same time, the R&A proposed annual subscription. Members of both R &A and the Honourable Company wrote a letter protesting this, to which they claimed, it has been invariably found that an annual subscription to a club for sheer amusement has prevented that club from thriving. You would think, in light of the financial difficulties that they're not even truly out of and everything going on, that they would maybe have rethought that. These are all just like clubs today. pretty well-to-do professionals run good businesses that they might be a little bit more introspective than that and think well an annual subscription we could use in strategic ways and can be used as a buffer relative to some of the financial difficulties that we've come across
Matt: Correct you would
Professor: Think at the same time they were moving grounds our whole purpose is to play golf and to play matches we have a silver club rule change Ah,
Matt: The first of Musselburgh.
Professor: No, I don't know this one. So they moved there in 1836. Good time to change the rules. This one is not relative to how it's going to be played, but the winner will no longer be captain. So the competition moves to the winner of it will receive a gold medal and the silver club will be restricted to the captain. This was something I did not know going into this. I thought going into silver club was always dedicated to the winner of the event and they'd fix their balls no the captain is not chosen based on a competition anymore the captain just gets the silver club the club champion gets a gold medal now and is not does not move into position the captain they get the fixed silver ball to the silver club so I think it's established that it will be a silver ball to represent their captaincy um
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: And
Professor: I always wondered how much I had to do with just Henry Lowe and his run from the law. So you come off the backs of a guy who wins the captaincy, then basically almost ruins the club and has to skip the country. And did they rethink this? Well, maybe the best golfer isn't who we should be putting into the captaincy position.
Matt: Aren't always going to line up.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: That's right.
Matt: Yeah. And just making that change at that time really made a lot of sense too. They're getting this momentum again. Are we at
02:28:49 The grandstand partnerships and a new clubhouse
Matt: 1865 yet with the new clubhouse?
Professor: So that was actually in 1836 that they made their role. So in that move, they change and this sets up, you know, we need to rebuild as a club and now we're going to put a captaincy in place where their role isn't being the best golfer. Their role is the best stewardship for the club.
Matt: Obviously with all that background, they've made some good decisions now and they didn't rush into their own golf club. There was another agreement. with the gentleman that operated the grants. stand where he welcomed the Honourable Company and they actually brought with them Douglas. Douglas was the best feathery ball maker probably at the time. Alan Robertson up in St. Andrews obviously took that title, but Douglas was doing it for the Honourable Company in Leith and he actually came over with. So in that window of time from the 30s to the 60s, 1800s, they were hanging out at that place [unclear] part of the reason was that's where he was too and so there was a good number of people and we'll talk about the innovations of equipment here in a second but a
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 02:30:00 ==========
Matt: Good reason to go there and they had an arrangement where the featheries were a good center of profit for for many of the tradesmen not many people could do it and so I think there was some good arrangement there with the grandstand where we're going to take care of the Honourable Company because they buy a good amount of golf balls uh And so there was these little partnerships that were a little bit savvier, let's say, probably a reflection of the times too, but they made it a bit more sustainable. And then in 1865, it became time for them to have a building for their own because I don't have any of the quotes or anything, but I'm pretty sure the food at the grandstand was pretty terrible by the majority of accounts.
Professor: I'm sure it was. You make a good point there relative to commerce at this time. If you're a club maker and a ball maker, there was no reason to be city center or away from the golf courses. You benefited from being at the course, at the inn. We allude to inn makers being the club makers. I conjecture in a lot of these cases, it was more an opportunistic venture, where if you're an inn maker and you see the golfers in there having their pints, well, it would behoove you to... be selling golf balls, be making golf balls, be making clubs and selling clubs. And so if you're a grandstand operator, they're using our thing, we'll be benefit if we're selling golf balls out here. So let's go find a feathery maker and have them be a part of this venture.
Professor: Very opportunistic in that way.
Matt: Yeah, figuring out a way to make it all work. Well, you didn't want to be in the feathery business after that transition
02:31:38 The gutty ball and a transformation in equipment
Matt: Monumental leap in the equipment had arrived. Before we get to that Leith professor, I want to stay on Douglas for a second.
Professor: Ah, yes. The
Matt: Ballmaker. The ballmaker. The Honourable Company packs up and leaves Leith. And their feathery maker comes with them, moving towns to stay with the club. And at Musselburgh, they get looked after because, well, they buy a lot of golf
Professor: Balls. And that makes them the first equipment partnership we found in this whole story. A club, a tradesman. and the one thing no one could play without. Which
Matt: Makes it a pretty good moment to
02:32:14 Titleist and the story of the first ball
Matt: Talk about the ball and equipment maker we trust in our bags today, Titleist, the presenting partner of the bag drop and our new series on the great clubs. You know what?
Professor: Titleist's origin story is more like Douglas than you'd think. It's 1932, and amateur Phil Young is in a Sunday match. He strokes a putt he knows is good. And as he gets ready to chase it into the cup, it misses. Can
Matt: Relate.
Professor: Yeah, we've all been there. Well, here's the catch in that story. Phil Young owned a precision rubber company and his opponent? Well, he ran the x-ray department at the local hospital. So they go to the hospital and x
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: -ray the golf ball on a Sunday. And
Professor: Sure enough, the core is off center. Phil had hit the right putt, but he was playing the wrong ball. So what does Phil Young do? He brings in an MIT rubber specialist and they spend three painstaking years trying to make one thing, a uniform ball that won't miss. They create ball after ball after ball. And in 1935, They create the first Titleist.
Matt: I heard that story many times, but it wasn't until we were invited to the Titleist R &D and player testing facilities that I realized because of that one missed putt, every Titleist golf ball is x-rayed to this day. Every single one.
Professor: That's right. Even 90 years later, every ball in your bag went through that x-ray. That's why Pro V1 and Pro V1X are the number one ball in golf. All because of a
Matt: Process. And just like the gentlemen golfers had Douglas to tell them which feathery to play, you have Titleist team ready to find which ball fits your game best. Go to Titleist.com, run the free golf ball selector, and stop guessing about the one piece of equipment we use on every single shot. Titleist and the
Professor: Number one ball in golf. Thank you to our presenting partner. All
Matt: Right, let's get to that monumental leap in equipment. Do you know what that is, Professor?
Professor: No, but I think you're going to tell us.
Matt: The gutty ball. The gunny ball shows up. Roll it back, baby. There's a few different debates around when this took place. I don't know what you found for the first gutty ball.
Professor: I don't have a good year on it.
Matt: But 1848, I was the majority of accounts. It was really... Pretty interesting. The gutta percha is the material that was used for this new ball. It came from the Malaysian Peninsula. And so again, back to the port towns of East Lothian, they were getting the stuff in significant supply. It was commonly used. They'd use it around their homes for fixing up patchwork type stuff. And it could be easily heated up but hardened really well. And the stuff was collected, I guess, in the rainy season on the Malaysian Peninsula. It was brought in, but it lasted and could be molded into a variety of things, including a ball. And so these big blocks of gutta percha are being pulled off and people are looking for things to do with it. Well, one of the claims to being used for the first gutta percha is...
Matt: The gentleman golfer, Leslie Balfour. He was a sportsman, played all kinds of games, rugby, cricket. He played for the national team in golf. But he was apparently one of the first to experiment with this gutty ball. There were others as well. A guy named William Smith. He was a watchmaker and an inventor in Musselburgh. And he also lays claim to playing the first gutty ball. His claim was two years prior in 1846. So whatever it was, it without a doubt changed the game. The ball costs 10 shillings per dozen. To put that in perspective, it was two pounds per dozen and six shillings per feathery. So this is a significant reduction in the cost of what it is to play the game of golf. to this date is going to do what the gut approach it did for the game of golf.
Professor: And it lasted longer, right?
Matt: This thing, Kevin, well, not only that, it had a sound to it
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Too, which I think if
Matt: We all know, sound has a big part of your satisfaction in hitting a shot, right? Oh yeah, 100%. This was so much more satisfying than hitting than a feathery, apparently. You felt it more and you heard it. And so that was a big part of it. But yes, its durability was huge. Maybe mattered most. beyond anything else, that these things, these gutties, they were economical, not just because they cost less to produce and there was plenty of gut approach and supply. It also was extremely desirable because unless you lost one of these things, you could play it forever. And in fact, they started to realize going into the 20th century that, wait, you know, these things that when they do get... cut up and little dense and stuff. I think they fly better. These are actually like kind of working.
Matt: And my, my older balls are the ones that have more value to me than the new ones. I'm going to just keep playing those. And so by default, they just realized, man, it's a better golf ball flies better. You know, aerodynamics of the spin of the gutty ball really contributed to this proliferation of the game and this huge boom that's about to rise and all that. is coming out of Musselburgh. Honourable Company probably had a big deal to do with it, although they also probably had a lot of the purists who said, no thanks, I'm a feathery man. Many guys continued playing for decades when the gutty came that they would prefer their feathery balls. Guys like Douglas and Allen Robinson, they weren't put out of business, but they certainly weren't going to be making the money that they used to off of feathery balls because these gutties were just...
Matt: The
02:38:10 A growing game and the company at Musselburgh
Matt: Bee's knees.
Professor: Yeah, you mentioned the proliferation of the game at this time. And I don't know what you found in your research, but honestly, from that 1836 to 1890 run... I didn't see a lot relative to the Honourable Company. And they spent so much at their time at Leith and all these formations and everything. Here, it sort of seemed like, hey, they're just operating as a golf club and we're just playing golf and we're just playing more golf and golf's getting popular. So much so, they discovered in 1879, for the last 12 years, no captain had put their silver ball on the silver clubs for 12 years straight. It was almost as if they were asleep behind. the wheel and I say that in the best way that things are just clipping along and we're just playing we're just playing our matches having our club dinners or build a clubhouse in 1865 which aligns about perfectly with those 12 years they're just enjoying their game um to themselves and just playing their matches and they did receive a new silver club at this time they kept their relationship with
Matt: Edinburgh this is their second I think
Professor: This is the yeah I think this is their second um The town council still gifted them the club, despite no longer being at least. They had maintained that relationship with them and said, okay, yeah, here you go. We need a new one. We've fixed all the balls. It's being taken up. Can we have a second one in the town of Edinburgh? Gifted them that second club.
Matt: There's many things you can say about this collection or this group of Honourable Company. They definitely... have friends in high places. But yeah, you're right. I did find this window of time now thinking about it to be just a little bit quieter because they weren't innovating. Like they were obviously innovating the club concept and that idea of clubbiness. But a lot of the progress that say, or the innovation around golf, it is coming outside of them, not outside of Musselburgh, but the Honourable Company was happy to be more. insular with themselves, I think at this time, you add in the gutty now and the gutty responded well to an iron shot and the ball actually flew further. So people started to use irons more. People started to use the gutty ball more. But as it pertains to the proliferation of golf and more people coming, the more people coming needed to look to something to organize.
Matt: This is the beginning of the golf club boom. And who did they look to? The most noticeable and earliest golf club, the Honourable Company. So a lot of the templates, let's call them, of clubs that followed, they follow the Honourable Company. So it's quiet, but it's definitely their impact. And maybe they were kind of sitting back, but everybody else wasn't. Everybody else was like, okay, we're organizing this club and this club and this club. And at the heyday, wasn't there a double-digit number of clubs that resided on the golf place right outside Musselburgh? That's right. They all looked to the first club, the first clubhouse, and the first greenkeepers. That was the Honourable Company.
Professor: Underlying, emphasizing, bolding that point, you had Prestwick emerging, you had the R&A in St. Andrews emerging as more. outwardly forces in the game of golf. So you've got all these clubs within East Lothian, Honourable Company setting the image, the template of what a club looks like. And on the broader external intentional impact, you've got clubs like Prestwick and the R&A that are making moves outside their own walls. So it makes sense that from a historic perspective, even doing the research and reading authors that were either within Honourable Company or not, Yeah, the [unclear] company is just kind of keeping themselves and just, they're just doing their thing and they're just having a blast. They're focused on, okay, what do we need to do better? Probably also influenced by that financial ruin that almost got put in place. Okay, in the 1820s and 30s, we were in a bad place.
Professor: Let's just not let that happen again.
Matt: Tighten the belt.
Professor: And build a competency that keeps us from doing that. We're here for the game. We're here to play matches with each other.
02:42:27 New trophies club staff and preserving records
Professor: That's why this is here. Let's make sure we enable that to happen.
Matt: I have some good clubbiness for this chapter of the Honourable Company. Yeah, what you got? They diversified trophies a bit. Okay. I liked the silver pocket watch personally.
Professor: Oh, I did not come across that one.
Matt: Which was awarded to a long drive champion. So any friends of yours who are saying, hey, this long drive stuff, that's not golf. They're swinging so out of their shoes, hitting the ball 500 yards. Hey, the Honourable Company says it was because they gave away a silver pocket watch for that. They also started to give, I guess, responsibilities within the club to what I would call staff. So that starts with head pros, right? And they would actually have some on staff. who was a ballmaker. He was a caddie. His name was David Lindsey. They actually collected funds for him. I think he fell on poor health and the club actually had a weekly stipend to support him. He also helped out with the club records. Clubbiness, again, new ways to preserve their history, which obviously they care very much about.
Matt: There was the anti-irons. I was fascinated by this jump into... more
02:43:45 Irons equipment debates and fast play
Matt: Sophisticated equipment or better players were really driving a lot of this. And Musselburgh had all the great players. The Honourable Company kind of took a stance against it. Really? Yeah. I mean, there was the early stand that we already talked about where they preferred it because it was against the turf and taking these divots and they preferred the wooden clubs. But there was multiple. minutes that talked about the club even at Musselburgh being against it. But I feel like that ship had sailed.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: The gun is here. The irons are here.
Matt: So the rollback was alive and well in Musselburgh, even with the Honourable Company. Also pace of play. Golf was still played exceptionally quickly. And now we're talking mid-1800s where two rounds plus lunch. followed by golf. So how many holes are we talking about professor at Musselburgh in the mid 1800s? Is that still seven or did they expand?
Professor: The mid 1800s, we should be, let me pull up my notes here. We've got a nine by 1870.
Matt: Okay. Well, perfect. Because nine holes was still played in under an hour and 15 minutes. They break for lunch, get back out in total four to five hours. Here
02:45:06 The introduction of tee times
Matt: Was the kicker. And the piece that I found was in Musselburgh, the starting times, we have the introduction of tee times.
Professor: So you asked about it earlier. Okay.
Matt: So this is it. Yeah. No specific club gets credit. The Honourable Company was the most organized, you know, so I would imagine they had a lot to do with this, but four minute intervals, four minutes, four minutes. So that's how you are, you're
Professor: Hitting your ball and you're racing.
Matt: So four minute intervals and to get done within an hour and 15. For nine holes. That was remarkable to me. So the intention was always to play golf fast and also match play. So match play, the whole I'm beat here, pick it up, move on. That was very prevalent at Musselburgh.
Professor: Some other asides from this time period.
Matt: Hit me.
Professor: 1857, the principal item of expenditure was the mount on wines and usually champagne.
02:46:00 North Berwick relations and protecting the links
Professor: So they started turning into a champagne club at this time.
Matt: Okay, we jumped up from claret to champagne.
Professor: A wonderful relationship with North Berwick fell apart. So this is later in their tenure at Musselburgh. North Berwick Golf Club, I believe 1832 was their start date. The Honourable Company paid them an annual fee for the upkeep of the course. Increases occurred in the late 1800s, two right in a row. The latter led to the Honourable Company requesting a new green committee in which they had representation on. And they asked that actually all clubs subscribing to North Berwick have representation on that. North Berwick never acknowledged receipt and canceled their annual subscription.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Really?
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Yeah. They didn't have that.
Matt: No thanks?
Professor: No thanks. Thanks for no thanks. Also during the time, they did have encroachment issues relative to the city. The town tried to fence the links and also build a road through the links to which the Honourable Company played a major role in ensuring that would not happen. So much like Leith, they really saw a major part of their duty as protecting the links and making sure to preserve the grounds that were there and that were played upon.
02:47:17 Leaving the uniforms behind and the rise of summer golf
Matt: Obviously, there's a theme emerging here, right? Where by looking out for themselves, they were doing what they thought was good for others and protecting the game of golf. So that stewardship, I think, is a three point, even through Musselburgh. A lot of it is conservative. I have one that was a bit of a liberal step for them. They lost the uniforms. So I had a quote in here. I didn't cite it correctly, but it's a funny one. The old Scottish dress. first donned by the Honourable Company is about the most uncomfortable garment that any golfer could endure. The staring red alone is enough to give anyone a fever on a hot summer day. So this quote, I wrote it down for a couple of reasons. One, these uniforms look brutal to play in and the equipment's a little bit better.
Matt: And so now you're getting a little bit more athletic move. So you want to shred this thing as soon as possible.
Professor: You want speed. And you want speed.
Matt: And Kevin, what's happening? Summer heat.
Professor: Oh, okay.
Matt: The game is coming into these other months. The industrial revolution is happening around this time. Manufacturing, machinery, people aren't as tied to the agricultural schedule. So summer golf was becoming a new thing. And that ties directly into what you said about those committees, the agricultural practices, the greenskeepers are now doing their thing. They could play and manage the grass that was growing a bit quicker.
Professor: Oh, wow. I never thought of that, what the role the Industrial Revolution would have played in switching golf from primarily a winter game to, oh, now we can actually play through the summer months. Within that part of the world, the amount of hours and daylight that you had to play, that mess at the stage for the longer lunches.
Matt: Professor, I have to go back to that quote, the most uncomfortable garment that any golfer could endure. It was one of my best chuckles in all this research. Well,
Professor: I much preferred the staring red alone is enough to give anyone a fever on a hot
Matt: Summer day. Those are the ones. But look, they finally let go of the coat because of better equipment, a more athletic move. Golf now in the summertime. They didn't throw out the tradition. They kept the class. and they
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Lost the coat. And added a signature fit.
Matt: Which makes this the perfect moment to welcome a
02:49:36 Founding partner: Holderness & Bourne
Matt: Founding partner of the great club series here on The Bag Drop, Holderness and Bourne. When we first talked to their team about this debut, I said, it's a five-hour episode about the club that started it all. Little did I realize what students of history the H &B team are themselves.
Professor: And their own story has way more golf history in it than you expect. Alex Holderness and John Bourne met during their MBAs at Yale, but their friendship formed on the McDonald and Rainer. Yale Golf Course. That's right. Two friends with a shared reverence for classic golf courses. But when they entered the pro shop, they noticed the classic part of the classic grounds was left at the door. In its place were logo plastered polos and attention-grabbing branding.
Matt: So, one night over Bourbon in Manhattan, they agreed to stop the complaints and make a better polo. They say they'll meet in the garment district at 8 the next morning. And neither one honestly thinks the other one's actually going to
Professor: Show up. But to both surprise, both of them did. They
Matt: Absolutely did. And a year and a half of nights and weekends later, they have one shirt in three colors. They make a thousand of them. The company's codename? Project Tillinghast. Of
Professor: Course it was.
Matt: That first sales call was to Wingfoot, a Tillinghast course. The shop took them on, and within a couple of weeks, the shirts were gone. The club, ready for more.
Professor: And here's the part that fits this great club episode best. They put their own names on the label on purpose. Like the old shirt makers on Jermyn Street in London. Why do you do that? Well, if your name is on it, you have to stand behind it.
Matt: That could sum up the Honourable Company's operating philosophy right there. Write it down, sign your name, own it. And this
Professor: Philosophy is seen throughout every detail. An English red collar with hidden stays sewn in on the diagonal. Your collar stands up all day instead of curling during your afternoon meetings or during that afternoon tea time. And let's not forget about their signature fit, which relaxes as the sizes go up. So it works for everyone. It honors one of their founding tenets. Dressing well is a form of good manners.
Matt: The gentleman golfers would approve. Their best-selling white polo is even called the McDonald. They're very open about the reverence for C.B. McDonald, the father of American golf, who learned the game in St. Andrews at the same exact time as our story is currently unfolding in Musselburgh, just across the Firth of Forth. Today,
Professor: You'll find Holiness and Bourne in around 2,000 golf shops, including the great clubs around the country. Always put in
Matt: Golfers. Holderness and Bourne, premium apparel with a signature fit. Find them in your pro shop or at hbgolf.com. All right, let's
Professor: Get back to Musselburgh.
Matt: When we say clubs at this time they were creating
02:52:09 Artisan clubs course care and broader participation
Matt: Clubs within the clubs.
Professor: Yeah, yeah.
Matt: So my favorite, personally, the Honourable Company was the first to have an artisans club.
Professor: That's right.
Matt: So within the Honourable Company was another club.
Professor: And their responsibility was?
Matt: To take care of the course while playing. So they would typically play at off-peak times, and they'd be handed maybe some basic tools and some things to fill divots or tend to the edging of certain features. And so... It wasn't intense stuff, but they would do that while playing, which I don't know how that would work. I'd love to see that. But they were paying less subscriptions, playing at off-peak times. But it was formal and it was organized and it was through the Honourable Company. I love it. I love it. And there was a bunch of others just like that, the Mechanics Club. So you're talking tradesmen who weren't in the noble class, who weren't in the merchant class. They had people to play with too. And so this is one of my favorite elements of this whole story was the proliferation of not golf, but clubs.
Matt: And people playing together is really cool.
Professor: I always thought the artisan clubs, and to give a shout out to the Golf Book of East Lothian by John Kerr, that gives a history of a lot of the early clubs throughout East Lothian. The artisan's club has been one of those situations to me that if we're going to get into lessons to be learned from this story. Every club
02:53:31 Sir Walter Simpson and the appeal of foursomes
Professor: Could have an artisans club inside of it. Hey, let's go out at 5 p.m., play a couple holes and fill divots, right? The artisan club is one of those that just makes, it makes a lot of sense, right? To form that within your own club. Respect your supers, give them a little extra help through that. Does a Sir Walter Simpson ring a bell to you? Not the other Simpsons. I was going to say. Not that one.
Matt: Are we at the architecture?
Professor: No, this is Sir Walter Simpson, who wrote, he was a captain and wrote the art of golf. All right, so beautiful book. took up golf on doctor's orders. I just wanted to read a quick quote from him on golf in foursomes. Some particularly tender-hearted golfers play better in foursomes than in singles because in the latter, they are apt to have their bowels of compassion moved in their game made loose by the grumblings and the lamation of an adversary whom they have got well in hand. Playing a foursome will not lessen his dread of the other side when down, but it will prevent the merciful man from being moved by pity. The wailing, the disconnect about the odds, the depreciation of stymies, the harping on the flukiness of long putt's hold, his good luck, their bad luck, will not melt his heart and soften his muscle.
Professor: Between him and them is one near and dear, his partner. It is not selfish to crush the enemy. It is duty, duty to the partner what are the tears of two enemies to the joy of one friend And I just thought that was so poignant. That was this takeaway of what foursomes brought forward, right? These different emotions you have.
Matt: That's such a good quote. And with all these clubs, you're doing it for that sense of belonging as well. And so I think that the foursomes match has only gained steam through Musselburgh in this phase. I think that's why. Because they want to play for a side. They want to represent something. And there was great rivalries because of that. With all these clubs in the... call it
02:55:24 Interclub matches and the beginnings of the Amateur
Matt: Mid-1800s, they marked another milestone where the clubs started to play each other. There's this nice little symphony across a number of different links, but the first that garnered a lot of attention was in 1857, Prestwick, the other coast. Prestwick invited the R &A, the Honourable Company, Burgess Golf Society, North Berwick, and... I'm missing a few. Montrose, Royal Albert, Dalton Castle, and Royal Blackheath.
Professor: This actually starts a trend in competitive golf that is my favorite thing in the world now.
Matt: Connect the dots for me.
Professor: All right, so you mentioned 1857. Prestwick requests several clubs at first to send four members. That would be doubles or foursomes, drawing of opponents, and the winning pair would be champions. So they send that out. The initial one actually takes place, 1857, and the initial competition is not at Prestwick. They end up holding at St. Andrews. The Honourable Company, North Panmere Club of Carnoustie, had a team. Royal Blackheath wins by seven holes over the R&A in the finals. Interesting enough, the winning pair. then had to play for each other. So let's say me and you are Royal Blackheath, right? We got to go teed up against each other. And the winner of me and you would be the possessor of the medal or the plate that's paid for by all the losing clubs. So that went on for a while, right?
Professor: No, after one year, they're like, that's weird. We're not going to do that anymore. So the next year, they turned this into just an individual competition of 28 people. So clubs are still sending four people, but you will not be pairing up. They're all going to play individually. To do that, 28 people show up the first time. So that's, I think, seven clubs represented. All in all, this was the foundation for the amateur championship. Ta-da. This whole letter that went out by Prestwick that was supposed to be, again, basically club versus clubs, quickly turned into an individual match play situation that then set the foundation for the amateur championship.
Matt: And it makes sense.
02:57:40 Prestwick and the first Open Championship
Matt: That the amateur was born out of those club, those inner clubs, because obviously those are who we're talking about here, the gentlemen golfers, not the pros. And there's another event that around the same time started to take shape.
Professor: If we rewind back to 1957, I said Prestwick sent the letter, but where was it first held?
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: St. Andrews.
Professor: St. Andrews. So the R&A held it.
Matt: Right.
Professor: Well, Prestwick. isn't going to just sit back. You know, they want to get something going. This one kind of, in some ways, failed. They learned from their mistakes. And in 1860, what do they do? They hold the first open change. Of course. We saw the experiment.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Yeah, yeah.
Professor: That's cute. That was cute. That worked out. It wasn't what we wanted. We made some changes. How can we actually do something from day one that gets off the ground exactly what we want it to be?
Matt: Yeah, so what's interesting about that and where it stems from is the best golfers were very clearly in this mid-1800s, not amateurs. You got a lot of these tradesmen. You got people like Allen Robinson. You got people like Douglas in Musselburgh. You got Dunn, Willie Dunn.
Professor: It's not the lawyers anymore.
Matt: Yeah, it's not the lawyers playing in their scarlet coats. These were very talented players. And none were more talented than a gentleman named Tom Morris. But Prestwick, Kevin, nor St. Andrews had the best players. It was without a doubt Musselburgh. The Honourable Company, I think, always had admiration for great golf. The pride they had in Musselburgh and the people coming out of there.
Professor: So anyways, actually Tom Kidd was the first one to actually be presented
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: The
Professor: Claret Jug when he won it at St. Andrews in 1873. So again, I mentioned the Claret Jug was jointly done by Prestwick. We're an ancient and Honourable Company. So it was played at Prestwick in 72. It was played at...
02:59:54 Musselburgh joins the early Open rota
Professor: St. Andrews in 73, that takes us to, well, if the Honourable Company was the other group
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 03:00:00 ==========
Professor: To pay for the Claret Jug, where are we going in 74?
Matt: Well, you got to bring it, you got to bring it home.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Got to go back to Musselburgh.
Matt: To the backyard, to back to Musselburgh. So the 1874 open at Musselburgh had 16 of the 42 entrants. that were local players. You think about Willie Park Sr., Willie Park Jr., the Dunns, the Mungo, even in the Park family, obviously the Morrises, but there was just a lot of really good players. And even after that, the 1886 Open that came back to Musselburgh. So the Rota, I don't know if you've said this already, the Rota is established.
Professor: This time the Rota is what?
Matt: It is. St. Andrews, Prestwick, and Musselburgh.
Professor: That's right. Those three right now.
Matt: And those are the power players in the game of golf. 1886, half of that field were Musselburgh men. I almost imagine Musselburgh at this time, professor, as a place that if you were competitive golf, you just, you like almost geared up. You knew you were going into where the players play. That's
03:01:17 The Parks the Morrises and professional match rivalries
Matt: Why the rivalries were so strong. There are accounts, and a few of them, I don't know if you stumbled on the matches between the Morrises and the Parks?
Professor: No, I did not.
Matt: They were the best golfers, and they were playing these foursome matches, and it would get ugly out on these lengths. People could literally stumble out of a bar on to where the match was being played. And there was fights that would break out, and there was a lot of gambling. Gambling was a huge part of this era. And so these matches would get fierce, and people... townspeople, club members would have a lot running on Mungo and Willie Park versus these gentlemen from St. Andrews and the Morrisons. And so, yeah, those are some interesting accounts that would break up.
Professor: This does start the sort of hustle era of professionals where they are traveling around playing matches either at their home course or going elsewhere, and they're playing for wages. And they're making a lot of their livelihood through. setting up matches and playing matches for actually money again within the clubs themselves money is pretty inconsequential we're not playing back but the professionals themselves are now setting up matches and traveling around one thing
Matt: I learned about muscleborough is there the concentration of good players there also had a lot to do with um it being this commercial destination for
03:02:39 Equipment businesses and early sponsorships
Matt: Club makers and ball makers. And so them lending their name to certain equipment was also a way. So we're talking early sponsorships as well as owning some of this themselves. A lot of them would make the clubs still. They would make the balls.
Professor: So if you can stamp a Morris name on the bottom of your
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Club, you're going to
Professor: Be able to push those clubs a little bit more.
Matt: You got it. So really Musselburgh had a lot to do with the commercial. expansion. And I know we're not there yet, but we're getting close. I wonder if that's something the Honourable Company didn't love. I wonder if there was a little bit of decorum that started to slip. We obviously know they pride themselves on being noblemen and gentlemen. I think about these accounts and I didn't get any direct linkage, but I got to imagine it added to the tensions.
Professor: Anything a little too much attention coming in, a little too much just noise going on?
Matt: Maybe, but I think...
03:03:36 A thriving company on increasingly crowded links
Matt: Well, I know majority of it had to do with, it was just a busy place again. We went from Leith that was just slammed and crowded in horse fairs and soldiers to Musselburgh where there wasn't as much of that. Although the race course still was a prominent focus of the community. Some of the biggest horse races were always taking place in Musselburgh. I think it was this new rail line made it super easy to get there. The professional game was growing out of there. People knew that they would run into those talented golfers there. People started to come there. I think all that added up. And the Honourable Company themselves were thriving at Musselburgh. So my count had it by 1865. Their membership had well. more than doubled, and they were in the 300s at this point.
Professor: Yeah, so you've got a nine-hole course. You've got our four clubs we mentioned playing it, publics playing on it. Golf is booming at the time. Arthur James Balfour, who eventually becomes prime minister, huge public figure, is playing golf. Now, he was an Honourable Company member, but a Westlinks, North Berwick Westlinks guy through and through. So East Lothian itself is booming at this time. So I can't imagine that, like you said, Musselburgh, which is Edinburgh adjacent, right? If you look on the map, pull up Google Maps, take a look. It's not too far away. I think you're right. It is a bustling place. And they're back in the situation they were at least better financially.
Matt: They're definitely better financially.
Professor: But a similar situation, you know, moving in the late 1800s, the Open is a popular championship. Yeah, golf's booming.
Matt: So over this window of time, they host six Open championships. 1874, 1877, 1880, 83, 86, and 89. Three Musselburgh natives I mentioned, Willie Park Jr., Sr., and Bob Ferguson won three of those. But, Professor, there's a new decision that likely needs to be made. As we've said, the course is busy.
03:05:47 Land negotiations and the need for another move
Matt: There's a lot of attention on Musselburgh. Can they expand this course maybe perhaps? Is there a way to get
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Some
Matt: More land for it maybe?
Professor: I don't think at Musselburgh you're doing that.
Matt: Why not?
Professor: I mean, what, it's surrounded by a horse track. I know north you got water. You're surrounded by a town. Do you got other information? I'm not familiar. Did they have an option?
Matt: There were negotiations with the town that would have protected land just North of the racetrack and [unclear]
Professor: There's our turf up there.
Matt: That land is no longer there. Okay. So what took place was industry. Musselburgh was not benefited off of the holiday crew as much as these other places. There was some, it was factories and tradesman class, the working class. And so. Probably not as much influence the golf course would have had, perhaps, unless the group, the Honourable Company and others would have bought more. But they had a path, is what I understand. And when you look at those old, old, old paintings, which are just sketches and drawings of what it was, it looks like Incredible Dunesland. Just like the nine that they had, but they didn't own it. Obviously, they didn't own it. The town had other plans. They were expanding. They needed places for people to live in factories to be. So that's what ended up winning out. And now it's not even really land.
Matt: I believe it's water. It's been reduced into the port.
Professor: Yeah, if you look north of the golf course now, it's just like you can tell that land was probably flattened at some point. It might flood every once in a while. It does not look like very usable land.
Matt: Yeah, well, it was at one point. I know that you're certain. And what a shame because, you know, not to say they would have outlasted. St.
03:07:42 Braid Hills nostalgia and the investment in the clubhouse
Matt: Andrews. Who knows? They could have, but it would have been cool to have another true Lynx course.
Professor: Maybe this is another reason they didn't take advantage of that. The city of Edinburgh actually tried to entice them back to the city during this time. Yes. Do you know where they tried to get them to move? I did. Braid Hills. An alternative reality, the Honourable Company moves back into the city and is playing at Braid Hills. One of the reasons they stuck at Musselburgh as long as they did. And the finances was the sunk cost into the clubhouse. So as you mentioned, the growing popularity, they'd been rumblings of maybe we should look elsewhere and figure out something that's not quite as busy. Obviously, nostalgia held a huge hold on them with the open being there, the first opens, being involved in that. You've got this awesome golf course to play. And also, well, we built this expensive clubhouse. We're enjoying it.
Professor: And it's tough to move from that when you've got a sunk cost into an infrastructure like that. At least we had lost that. We had sold the clubhouse. We're not beholden to anything. Got a lease on the course. That's it. Here, they still have the infrastructure in place that a move would have financial repercussions on what do we do with our clubhouse if we move somewhere else.
03:08:57 Rising wages falling land values and new possibilities
Matt: Between 1870 and 1890, wages in Scotland rose 60%. Wow. So this was accompanied by also a fall in land values because everyone was, one, getting cheap imports of corn from places like Russia, North America, and two, all that agriculture that land was potentially used for. agriculture wasn't a focus of society anymore. And therefore, there was this ability to go look at land elsewhere because it was cheap. So wages are up. People are making more money. Land is going down. And there was this huge increase in people owning land.
Professor: So they've been dragging their feet during this time period about not wanting to move. There's documented examples of them using excuses. Well, it's busy, but that's camaraderie. We're all getting along. We'd see everybody. And eventually,
03:09:57 Internal matches and the desire for a course of their own
Professor: [unclear] the club they all ruminated over this and they're like man you know what all of our like most vivid memories and just our vivid stories are actually within the club the Honourable Company wasn't as involved as other clubs were in doing the inner club scene and they realized we get so much joy just playing internal matches and not for prizes in fact um The dinner matches were so front and center to the club's activity that John Kerr, one of the first historians of East Lothian golf, explained, quote unquote, the Honourable Company, it may have been stated, is almost, if not absolutely, the only club which never plays for pots and pans. Then this is also, this is expanded upon by Pottinger. He brought up, there's two meetings a year, spring and autumn. are that that's the only time prizes are scratch medals the rest of the year match play is the thing and however insular they may seem to the outside world the members are content with the rewards to be derived from the rigors of the game and from overcoming the adversary so they ultimately settled we're in this for enjoyment with each other for matches with each
Professor: Other
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Musselburgh
Professor: Is no longer the place of which we can do that at the regularity that we would like. There's so much else going on here. So much noise, so much busyness to the course, so much competing interests with the committee of the course and the management of it. Man, it'd be great if we had
Matt: Our own thing so So
03:11:27 Looking beyond Musselburgh and notable members
Matt: It's all lining up for getting out of Dodge. They're looking for more control, more land, more golf. They're moving. But before we take off and head to their new location, their second relocation, I want to pause on Musselburgh and a couple members that we haven't mentioned yet. Dr. Andrew Duncan was a physician, like many Honourable Company members, a civic leader. He was responsible for pioneering the first psychiatric hospital. Whoa. Yeah. His best friend was Sir Henry Rayburn. We've mentioned a couple of times because he's the portrait guy. So you always see his name because he's the one that did these remarkable portraits of all these captains and members of the honorable companies. He was early on at Leith. But he was really kind of a staple into Musselburgh. I know we were dogging the players at the Honourable Company, like a bunch of lawyers who can't keep up with the scratch guys.
03:12:33 J E Laidlay and innovations in golf technique
Matt: But there's a guy that we can't move past Musselburgh without mentioning. If he wasn't in your notes, I'd be shocked. J.E. Laidlay?
Professor: Laidlay, Laidlay. Laidlay? A stick. A stick. Arguably the best of the era.
Matt: Proper scratch player. Proper golfer. I've always called it the Vardon grip. but he was probably one of the first to popularize the overlapping grip well in advance of Harry Vardon.
Professor: Certainly predated Vardon. Certainly.
Matt: He also choked down on the club. So the idea of choking down wasn't really a thing, but he would do it for more control. I guess he had longer arms.
Professor: Okay. I didn't come across that. Yeah.
Matt: He was the original stack and tilter.
Professor: No kidding.
Matt: Called it, it was specifically called something, the left. Playing off the left leg. He pioneered playing off the left leg.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Starboy was a flighter of the ball.
Matt: Yeah, yeah. He must have known where to find that bottom
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Swing from
Matt: Any footing. He won two amateurs, but five finals. So he got there a bunch.
Professor: In a six-year span, those five finals were within a six-year span. It's a tough event to do that.
Matt: He was runner-up. to a name anyone that has been to St. Andrews would recognize, which is Willie, I'll butcher this one, as I always do, Octoloni. That's not how you pronounce it. But he was the winner in 1893 Open, that Open at Musselburgh, and J.E. was Honourable Company Member for second. Okay. Because I know we kind of
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Painted with a broad brush
Matt: There, and I just wanted to set the record straight.
Professor: He was a member of various clubs that I had in my notes, won well over 130 medals. including 10 at Musselburgh. And then this is part of the Honourable Company. And then 10 more at the site that we'll be talking about soon.
Matt: He was the only one who could brag of hitting a gutty over the grandstand of Musselburgh race course. I think he did it while I was in school. So it was one of those, let me show you what I can do. here
03:14:41 Photography and early golf instruction
Matt: Type of guys but um but yeah humble individual our
Professor: Dude was a clubber
Matt: He was a player so so he I'm
Professor: Shocked in a happy way that if you don't have this this is more this is more down your lane than mine let's hear it he he was one of the earlier influencers in the game so you don't have this huh well I knew
Matt: He was like a pretty good cricketer I don't have anything was it what is he on
Professor: Tiktok he was an avid amateur photographer Our man would lug around heavy equipment to the lengths and took some of the earliest action photographs of golf. Swings, people out on the courses, including at the site we're going to be talking about soon. Those photographs were used in classic golf instructional books, including those by Horace Hutchinson. So he was into the photography as well. We give people a hard time, set up their cameras on the golf course nowadays, behind their shots and whatever. He was one of the OGs being out there with the camera equipment on the golf course.
Matt: A child of the enlightenment. So they had players, they had artists. That's cool.
Professor: What's interesting about this era... is how many of these power players span both the time at Monroe and then the time at Muirfield, which was probably critical to what happened in their transition beyond just moving and acquiring the land and building a golf course. But is this like when the Browns moved to Baltimore, do you keep the traditions? Do you keep the history or do you leave it behind? A lot of these power players played a key role in what's to come in this story.
Matt: Well, I thought of one who...
03:16:18 A cross country match between North Berwick and Gullane
Matt: Just precedes the move to Muirfield, and that was Hall Blyth.
Professor: Hall Blyth. We're going to talk about him a good bit.
Matt: Well, here's one of my favorite things, though, before you get into the actual impact. He was the one victorious in this famous cross-country match, 1880, that was played against Willie Campbell. They went from Point Gary, North Berwick, to the high hole at Gullen. So if you've ever been to East Lothian, like that's, what is that?
Professor: I should have looked up how long that actually is. It's long. Yeah.
Matt: And so, I mean, this was probably just one of those obscure dinner matches or some sort that they said, oh, I wonder if you could play from here to there. And they just went out and did it. So I love that.
Professor: We were walking from North Berwick to Golan. Right now, just walking by road, it would take us about an hour and 42 minutes to do the five-mile trek just by straight walking. Just a straight walk. Just straight walking down. I think it's A198 if you've driven it, taking you from Golan City Center down to North Berwick. You're about [unclear] from four and a half to five miles.
Matt: That sounds right. I do know. that he was victorious by taking the inland route and so his competitor willie campbell went up the coast and just got destroyed by the rocks uh
Professor: You wonder what Willie Campbell was thinking at the time. They're going like, why would you, it's not, it's not shorter.
Matt: You think closer to the shore, maybe, but not, no, no, he must not had Atlas at home.
Professor: I don't know. He did not, he never looked at an overhead map and actually thought about his plan. That, that bet in execution of it might've been fueled by a little early morning lunch with some pints.
Matt: So now we have this 1891.
03:18:16 The move and the transfer of the Open Championship
Matt: 1892 [unclear] a turning point this is such a significant moment for the Honourable Company but it's also really important for the game of golf I would
Professor: Argue golf history changes in some ways period
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: From this moment
Professor: Yeah
Matt: A lot of it does have to do with the clubbiness that we're gonna get into and how Things started to evolve in that regard and that template. I used that word earlier for the game as a social endeavor, as a collective endeavor that started to evolve, but also competitive golf. And so one of my favorite discoveries that I knew nothing about in this was the Honourable Company decided to move, but the open went with them. And so I don't know if you came across a lot of this in your, stuff. But we're talking shortly after their move, they established the new course. And in 1892, they're hosting the Open. Do you know who wasn't hosting the Open in 1892?
Professor: I mean, so what Musselburgh hosts in 89. Musselburgh. Yeah. And so 90, 91 would be Pressbook St. Andrews. I don't remember which order. So 92 would have been set up to be Musselburgh. So they take it. So there's
Matt: Multiple accounts on this. And this one, And this is why doing this stuff is so fun, Professor, because as you've said multiple times, the victor writes the history. We have many books out on these tables that we were digging into over the...
Professor: Yeah, mine, it was natural. We got to get this ready and host. Yeah, there's nothing to be said about the open at all, other than we got to get ready to host it.
Matt: I'll tell the other side. From the Musselburgh perspective, they took it hard. And rightfully so on their account. The Honourable Company... really kind of matter-of-factly just announced confidently that they would be proudly taking the Open Championship with them the following year. It was just shocking to the people of Musselburgh, you know, folks like the Parks and Dunn's and Burgess Society.
Professor: The entire residency that's there.
Matt: Yeah, there was issues at Musselburgh for sure. But it wasn't like they had this really sharp decline. they were still a powerhouse. And so for them to just lose the open.
Professor: And you expect the town council to be invested in and it not moving to where it's going to move because Musselburgh is at least Edinburgh adjacent.
Matt: Yeah. Now I will mention as the books we've read appropriately state. They do have a solid claim to do this, the Honourable Company, to move the Open with them because- And why is that? Well, they're one of three clubs that has been involved from the beginning. They wrote the rules.
Professor: And who's running the Open at this point?
Matt: The R&A. Oh, I'm sorry. No, the clubs collectively. Yeah, you're right.
Professor: The clubs collectively, meaning the three clubs.
Matt: So the R&A. The R&A, Honourable Company, and- Prestwick.
Professor: Prestwick. And Honourable Company are running the tournament when it comes to- Musselburgh, the old course in Prestwick. So the clubs themselves are running it at this time.
Matt: There is an argument that a lot of the responsibilities were being shared. And the Honourable Company certainly was in the room with those others. But when it came down to the actual setup and breakdown and clubs had to open their clubhouses and do a bunch of stuff for these opens, they were popular. tournaments
03:21:57 Willie Park Junior and a competing Musselburgh tournament
Matt: At this point.
Professor: Yeah, everybody's thrown in their sweat and labor, I'm sure, from a club perspective to make sure this thing runs.
Matt: But, I mean, they did invest the substantial early resources to purchase the Claret Jug. So, I think that in itself probably lays claim to why they can do it, but not everyone saw it that way, particularly Willie Park Jr. So, Willie Park Jr., who loves some stories on Willie Park Jr., probably another aside, he wasn't an Honourable Company. but he was a heck of a player and opinionated beyond his father. He felt strongly about keeping the competition in town in Musselburgh. So his stance was to him a perfect sense when you, and when you think about it, how the event had transformed into major occasion that offered really huge benefits to club makers and innkeepers and the wider community. It had nestled itself into the fabric of Musselburgh. So having it on the calendar was vital for the local culture.
Matt: So he actually made a social argument. You can't let somebody just rip out thousands of pounds of economy just like that because they just announced it that way. To tackle the situation, Willie Park took on some impressive steps and got the right people. He raised prize money. I do not know the story. Yeah, so he raised money for a competing tournament. No. He got additional money to get a gold medal for the winner. So they got the silver claret jug. He has gold medal. He not only elevated the stakes, but he also nudged the Honourable Company to elevate their prize at Muirfield. it's a little live golf PGA tour situation.
Professor: I was going to say, this sounds a lot like,
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: This sounds a lot like,
Professor: I didn't get into Augusta, I'm going to build this, like this whole.
Matt: Yeah. And I think, I think this, this whole debate is out of the success of what the Honourable Company had hoped the original silver club was potentially going to be. Um, the open was, and so now they're in this, this battle and the, the true story, I can definitely say with certainty is that Willie was. planning to hold this Musselburgh open on the same exact day. That's how spiteful he was. We're going to do this on the exact same day. The players now having to decide between these two. I mean, it's a considerable purse over at Musselburgh. So the whole situation was really in the public domain, which the Honourable Company probably want. If their history tells us anything, it's they want to do what they do for themselves. And if it benefits the game of golf, great. They are
03:24:44 Readiness of the new course and reactions from other clubs
Matt: Making this decision for other reasons. So this whole scenario created a ton of noise and they were already relocating. So that decision was separate. We'll come back to it. But the Open Championship was being stolen.
Professor: Do we know where the R&A and Prestwick stand on this? Because obviously they're the other two clubs
Matt: That are...
Professor: Running this tournament in lock and step with the Honourable Company are they speaking out on this at all or are they just sitting that's
Matt: A really good question so yes I did find a a comment from the R&A that didn't dispute that they had the right to to move it to mirror field what the comments were mostly around was the course and that they're not going to be ready so there was a public opinion of the other clubs particularly the R&A, that said, I don't think they're going to be ready. This is a new golf course. And some were even saying, is it really links in land? And it was known to be soft at that time. No, it's not at all today. But that was actually more the R&A's position was like, I just am concerned because these guys might not be ready and it's a bit wet.
Professor: So there's an original skepticism. to the potential of the coerce hosts in the open. I want to circle that. Totally. Hold that in the back of our minds, because that's plenty of the seed that I think is going to grow for a long, long, long, long, long, long time.
Matt: It was only 100 days from the time that they announced it to the competition. That's all it was? Yeah.
Professor: Wow. So Musselburgh, the clubs at Musselburgh had no clue the open. They knew the Honourable Company was moving for a while. but they didn't know the Open was getting moved with them until 100 days before the competition.
Matt: Wow.
Professor: So you wonder what was, because the clubs knew they were talking about, so what were the other clubs told about the Open leading up to the Open in those years?
Matt: A precedent that was already set of, they did this once before from Leith to Musselburgh, and a lot of other clubs did as well. Same thing is happening at Musselburgh. Clubs are now moving and going to other places. The Honourable Company.
03:26:49 Searching for land and the importance of railway access
Matt: They like to be first. I focused in on this as like, wow, this is a fascinating little tidbit of golf history that I never knew. Yeah, so talk about the actual move.
Professor: Let's get to it.
Matt: I feel like I'm the TMZ of dropping rumors of stealing opens and such. Give us the facts.
Professor: I mentioned a couple other favorite tidbits, the bet book. This is right up there. They're finding the next facility. Summer of 89 or so. Like, all right, we got to find a new place. And this isn't today's world where we can go Google Maps, we can look for places, go find what's for sale, go travel, whatever. That's not the case. The one, they're very constrained in where they're going to have to go. We alluded to the horse and carriage, the omnibus, I believe it was. We've had another proliferation at this point. As a transportation buff yourself, what do we...
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: It's got to be the train line.
Professor: Got to be the train line, right? So step into the North British Railway Company. They have established a train line running from Edinburgh to Barrick-upon-Tweed. For those not familiar with Barrick-upon-Tweed, that is not North Berwick. That is over in the Dunbar region. And there's a train line running along there. This was completed in 1846. By 1850, they get a line to North Berwick. Why? You talked about this earlier. Holidays. Yeah.
03:28:14 Alternative sites and the proposal at Beltonford
Professor: Good services as well, right? Holidays and good services. All right, we're going to get something out to North Berwick. North Berwick is a good popular Holloway destination. This was originally a three-hour plus trip between Edinburgh and North Berwick, and now this is no longer that. So, okay, we've got train stations and train tracks moving all over. Emerging from this are several different properties that they're going to consider. One's near Hatterwick, near Dunbar. This is called Beltonford. this is owned by the earl of haddington very supportive of this venture wanted it to happen offered a lease it was 150 pounds a year it's about 17 000 pounds in today's dollars by the converter I was using um 23 000 a year the lease would have been for this land
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Still travel
Professor: Distance was an issue this wasn't right on the stop again this was over near dunbar there was a station there but they're gonna have to build a new station from that station to get to. So that was going to be complexity, a little bit of money having to be invested there. But hey, still have their own private golfing green. In fact, in June of 1890, it leaks to the press. And in the Haddington Shire Courier, they did claim a golf course was going to be built. They even quoted costs. So this is in the summer of 1890, going to the point we brought up earlier. You mentioned 100 days before the open got moved. So everybody knows vulnerable companies trying to move.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: It's out there.
Professor: Of course, the paper had to backtrack this in a week later. Difficulties and obstacles were reported. They continued to walk back their claims. At the end of the day, the plot of land wasn't overly interesting. And also building that station,
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 03:30:00 ==========
Professor: That was a little bit of a hang up there. There was going to be a financial investment that had to occur that made that potentially problematic. Okay.
03:30:09 Craigielaw Saltcoats and the Archerfield option
Professor: So other course areas and included, um, I always forget how to pronounce this. Craigie law, Craigie law, Craig law, Craig law. Sounds good. Um, point, um, stall coats in the house or a hundred acres park on Archer field.
Matt: All right.
Professor: Craigie law point. Um, Earl, we miss is the owner of that. Turns down the interests, just not interested at all in selling and putting a golf course there. Saltcoats, that's owned by Henry, Mr. H.W. Hope or Henry Walter Hope of Loughness. He is an Honourable Company member and committee member for this move. Very enthusiastic about the site and several members, yeah, as well. So why don't they end up moving there? Enter one Benjamin Hall
Matt: Blyth.
Professor: Blyth comes in.
Matt: The old cross-country champ.
Professor: And Mr. Blyth has interest in this house or 100-acre park on Archerfield owned by Mr. and Mrs. Hamilton Ogilvie. So let's dive into the situation that occurs now. Who was Mr.
03:31:27 Benjamin Hall Blyth and the case for Archerfield
Professor: Benjamin Hall Blyth, because I think who he is, describes why it happened, how it does.
Matt: Yeah, so he was Mr. East Lothian, and he was a member at multiple clubs there already. My understanding is he's just a, he was a tall man, a big dude, and he got his way.
Professor: He was a force.
Matt: He was a force. He had this absurdly strong mustache.
Professor: Yes, he did. Handlebars all the
Matt: Way. just lip sweater that would keep you warm in the winter months. Quite famous too, I think. People knew who he was. He was a referee for matches with the Honourable Company at R &A.
Professor: I mean, reading between the lines was a... pretty smart, intentional, intelligent individual. So in terms of his background, his father was a railway engineer. He got his MA from Edinburgh University and went to Apprentice under his father immediately. Within four years, he was a partner, and the company eventually gained Blyth & Blyth with other partners retiring, still operating today. You can go look this up. It's Blyth & Blyth Consulting Engineers. They still operate today. So he became a consulting engineer of most of the major railway companies in the area. So he is fully embedded into the major transportation situation at the time. In fact, he became president of the Institution of Civil Engineers in 1914. So this is down the road. Acted as lieutenant colonel of the engineer and railroad staff corps.
Matt: He,
Professor: Smart, was a winner. He was a force as a golfer. Cut his game at North Berwick. The family house overlooked the Redan hole there.
Matt: A member of R&A. Those are such cool properties. Rewinding back, he
Professor: Wasn't a captain of the Honourable Company in 1880 to 1881, so he's already established as a leader within the club a decade earlier. He was a captain of Royal Liverpool, a captain of... Tantalon. He helped create the Amateur Championship. He was a chairman of the New Rules of Golf Committee in 1897. He acted as a consultant to a number of East Lothian clubs. And he was the recorder from 1888 to 1896 with an Honourable Company, which is one of the most key positions there. We brought up the recorder earlier. Do you know what course he also helped with in his lifetime?
Matt: I imagine it's in East Lothian.
Professor: It is not an East Lothian.
Matt: Is it Ely?
Professor: No, that would be great.
Matt: There's some connection there.
Professor: The new course at St. Andrews. So there's a quote about him. Probably he was the first real golf course designer. meaning that he considered that fine holes might be made without waiting for the slow evolution from nature. And he set himself about the design and construction of such holes as St. Andrews itself, North Berwick, Muirfield, and Golan. He was a consultant for major clubs, and he brought his civil engineering eyes to golf course holes and thinking about how they were designed.
Matt: I found the references to him in the designs for the clubhouse, which he was obviously capable of.
03:34:40 Competing plans and the eventual land decision
Matt: I didn't find the parallels to golf course architecture, but he was likely pals with old Tom.
Professor: Let's circle back to Muirfield now. You've got Mr. Henry Walter Hope putting up the salt coats against Blyth that sees Archerfield as the right place to go. Who's going to present the more compelling case if we're thinking of that? Now, that's not undersell Walter Hope, Mr. Henry Walter Hope of Loveness. He owned the salt coats land. as well. He's a committee member there. This wasn't just a heavyweight versus a lightweight. Mr. Walter Hope was a huge player within the Loughness-Golan area. In fact, he's responsible for a lot of the golf development in the Loughness area. He owned the estates throughout there, including the land of which Loughness ended up being played upon. So there was
Matt: A fight.
Professor: But at the end of the day, Blyth was confident, boisterous, smart, an engineer, and the plan he laid down ultimately won out. We're going to Archerfield. Now, what did become of these other places before we get to the building of Muirfield as we, well, not quite know it today, but the initial building of Muirfield? The Hederick property? That one over in Dunbar became a nine-hole course until 1937. Like I said, it was pretty uninspired land. No real train station near it that disappeared. Nothing notable in today's world. But with respect to the other ones, now sitting on Craigie Law, Kilspindi, and Craigie Law Golf Course are part of that property. So you're on there. That's where Muirfield could have ended up. Salt Coats, Loughness New Golf Club, which is what you see when you're playing Golan. Also great. And Loughness itself is a really cool story.
Professor: If you go to Loughness, there was Loughness Old that was there. If you have Park playing a role, moves it over, that's how Kill Spindy becomes a thing. Then Loughness New happens. But hey, we're going to Muirfield in July of 1890. We're there. The vote was unanimous. We're going to the Lowe's Archerfield. And
03:37:10 The Muirfield name and a toast to the new chapter
Professor: We have to build a golf course.
Matt: Well, it's our third name of this collection of golfers, right? From Gentleman Golfers to the Honourable Company to Muirfield.
Professor: Do you know what Muirfield refers to at this time? So it's the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers, and they're going to call their golf course, Muirfield Golfing Green, or the Muirfield Private
Matt: Green, depending on- The reason I ask is we started with a clubby toast. With the 21-year-old Glen Livid, I can still taste a little bit on my tongue. Now that we've arrived, at least at the land, I'd like to make one more toast.
Professor: You're full of surprises.
Matt: So the very Scottish drink of Kummel
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Is
Matt: Darn near impossible to get in the States.
Professor: We should have asked our friend Kenny Pallas to ship us somewhere over from
Matt: - There's multiple friends I thought about, but you know me. I was pretty late in doing this. So I tried to find something similar. Kummel is, if you don't know, it is the drink of the Honourable Company that they have after their traditional lunch. I want to get us started with this last chapter of this saga with a little toast. It's not Kummel. It's Drambui, which comes from the Isle of Skye. It's a liqueur. One more toast, Professor. As they say in Scotland, It's
03:38:38 Old Tom Morris and the rapid creation of the course
Matt: A good health. All right.
Professor: So we're moving to Muirfield. We've settled on the land. Blyth draws up the original clubhouse. Estimated cost at 2,500 pounds. About 280,000 pounds is what that converts to. Or $380,000. And the 19th of November, they approve to approach. the one and only old tom morris to design and build the
Matt: Golf course you got to I mean old tom at this point is peak of his uh design career he was laying out courses all across the united kingdom and ireland and um it seemed like the logical choice for a group like the Honourable Company was there anybody else involved In the running, let's say?
Professor: I didn't come across them looking at anybody else. Did you happen in your research to see who they also might chose? I'd be shocked if anybody had actually a serious chance other than old Tom.
Matt: I didn't find anything. I know who it wasn't, if there was anybody else they were considered, and that's Willie Park Jr. Yeah. He was also getting started and building some sweet golf courses. He probably wasn't.
Professor: I was going to say, that is not going to happen. So old Tom's going to design the golf course. December of 1890, he marks out individual holes and estimates that the golf course will be ready to play by, what would you guess? This is December of 1890. He marks the holes and said, we're going to be ready to play golf by.
Matt: I mean, yeah, under modern standards, you're talking 1892, so two years. January. The way that you took a sip of your liqueur, your fake cummel, and then answered
Professor: That 45 days, we're playing golf. Yeah, put a steak over there, put a green over there.
Matt: It is fascinating, though, because, you know, is that a byproduct of just the land isn't, it's so there in front of you? I don't think so. I just think they probably had a... A sense of what works, what doesn't. And you just get on with it, as they say in Scotland. Yeah.
Professor: Old Tom says, this is what we're doing. This is what the course is going to be. And he leaves it to the one and only David Plender Leith, or Leith, who's the original superintendent. And at that time, superintendent was not a greenkeeper, as we would envision. It was his job to create that golf course on the land. Old Tom says, here's the course. Here's what it's going to be.
03:41:27 Building a natural course and the first sixteen holes
Professor: David, go to work, and he had four workers under his control called the Capital Quartet, and they are the ones that executed Old Tom's vision. They focused on, you may get this right in terms of the wording, achieving a naturalness with the work. Give the club its own lie was a mantra throughout the entire project, and their goal was to provide greens that look naturally undulating rather than flatten. the product what was self-described as the finest turf that has ever been seen so in actuality by the end of may of 1891 16 holes were ready to play so the speed of it of the construction this was a natural site for golf there was blown out sandy areas all over it that they just left there old tom had navigated the course through those the ground itself didn't need movement created in it that's just let it sit how it is you know I love that quote give the club its own lie as in the turf is here just get it to where it's playable because the ground is already going to give the club its lie
Matt: Did did you find anywhere why old tom built 16 holes I mean he built 18 everywhere else there's a couple 12s I think 16 seems so odd to me they did
Professor: Believe that old tom intended 18 holes but they're not sure when he laid it down like it might have just been well I got 16 right now and I'm not sure what to do with the rest yet like as if this was a thing to be finished and again remember like he had a little too
Matt: Much cummel and put the my the plan in front of the quartet and they all said hey boss we're
Professor: Missing a couple into that point with David being the one that executed, might have been, I've got 16, you figure out the other two with the land that's there. Because at this time, to give some broader context, it wasn't until 1882 that Crestwick expanded to 18 holes. And they were only the 18th course to do so. So when they were building this, it wasn't exactly that you had to have 18 holes immediately. Certainly, we're going to get to the open conversation. You wanted it for that because of where the open was being held. That was tradition. it wouldn't be like today if you open 16 holes people are like oh something's going on there did they run out of financing like then it probably was truly okay we got 16 of them done maybe we're trying to figure out what the other two holes are
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: But
Professor: Hey we at least have this because with that
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Said when they
Professor: Added the other two holes they actually did have to adjust the routing so it wasn't we've got our 16 here's two more no the first 16 hole routing was not then 16 plus two additional they actually had to reroute some of the course so the next when they got to 18 holes some of those original holes were now gone to account for the additional holes made so it probably was one of those okay I see 16 holes here
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Hey
Professor: David you figured out it's your problem to solve now here's 16 great holes maybe keep 12 of them, whatever it is, create 18, but this is the best I can do in my time here.
Matt: I would love to hear a recording of that conversation. It doesn't feel to me that the people laying out the golf courses of the time, back to that quote on Musselburgh being a malleable plot of land, it almost felt like there was an acceptance to that, that, hey, this is the best version of the course right now, but time's going to tell. And, you know, what's the next gut of a football that comes? That's a really interesting philosophical question to ask as, you know, what did old Tom think about that when his courses were being changed, which this one in particular, what did that feel like to old Tom and the people that did it? Yeah. A little bit more
Professor: About the course, the original 16 holes. So
03:45:27 The original routing yardages and surviving holes
Professor: You had eight holes that were three of the 400 yards. One hole was over 500. Six were between 200 and 300 yards and one short of 200. Playing at 179, its total yardage was about 5,000 yards. We had Leith at five holes each over 400. They played 15 holes that were longer than that. So Muirfield comparatively was far shorter than Leith. When they actually stretched it out to 18 holes. that only added
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: 300 yards.
Professor: So I'd call it 5,300 yards or so once it got to 18 holes. remain in terms of today, if you were to travel and spend a day with the Honourable Company on the Muirfield Golfing Green, third hole is almost the same as today's second hole. So their third back then, almost same as second. The fourth fairway is currently the 15th fairway, but played in reverse. So back then, they'd be playing backwards down 15. And the 15th green site is the same as the 9th back then, as our current 9th. And the 18th green sites are the same. An 18th green site is something that will actually persist throughout the entirety of the rest of our story. But there was something about the 18th green site that just, it stuck, and it stuck, and it stuck.
Matt: The way it frames. a clubhouse and finishes as well is the template for country clubs everywhere but unlike country club everywhere it's a phenomenal golf hole that 18th hole is just such a great or is it
Professor: Some people might disagree as we move forward in this story. Let's jump back to the open real quick. We're in 1891 when this course is completed. And
03:47:08 The 1892 Open and the first seventy two hole format
Professor: Circling back to what you brought up, they got to host the Open.
Matt: They got to host the Open, yeah.
Professor: I believe it was September of 1892 was when the Open was hosted. That's right. Was it a success? I don't think so. Did you read much on it?
Matt: I was too deep in the whole move from Musselburgh Open, but I don't think- I could tell.
Professor: That thefting story was brilliant.
Matt: Yeah, but it was loose ends that I couldn't close. I bet you there's more concrete evidence of the 1893 Open.
Professor: Yeah, so what's crazy is we now start a trend where the Honourable Company's major external stories are the Open, are the amateur, the Walker Cup. the curtis cup they move into their true competition era and it's impossible to separate anything that occurs to especially the Muirfield golfing green from the open championship they're intertwined from this point forward and to speak of one without speaking to the other is doing disservice to their decisions made and I suspect a lot of that it's going to be because some of the feedback that we get even going back to the skepticism that was introduced by the R&A I'm sure they wanted support from the R&A to say like no the open's going with with Honourable Company they pay for a clear jug they run the tournament and so they were probably put off a little bit by the well I don't know if they'll have the course ready or not
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: They
Professor: Do execute the 18 um I need to open with Pretty good success. Do you know what this was the first time for the Open?
Matt: Was this the first time they played four rounds of 18?
Professor: First time for four rounds of 18. That's right. 72 holes. Now over two days. So we're playing over two days at this time. First round is led by Horace Hutchison. We're moving into the professional era of golf, right? A lot of names are going to come up in the next 100 years that we'll be familiar with. He shoots 74-78. Harold Hilton from Hoylake, seven back. Harold Hilton goes on the final day, shoots 72-74, and wins by three at 3.05. Hutchison fired an 86 in the third round
Matt: There was another first for that 1892 Open. And do you know what it was? I do not. It was for the patrons. It was the first open to charge admission. Oh, no. Yeah.
Professor: And that's... Okay. Yeah. All right.
Matt: First 72 hole. First one to charge admission.
03:49:50 Harold Hilton and the first Muirfield Open winner
Matt: What about Harold Hilton?
Professor: I looked up a little bit on him. I didn't go too deep on Harold Hilton.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: I got some Darwin.
Professor: [unclear] let's dive into Harold Hilton.
Matt: Imagine a short man.
Professor: Because he won the first one, so he deserves some.
Matt: Yeah, the first open. Because you're right, it's eternally linked. He's the first winner. Bernard Darwin. Bernardo, by the way.
Professor: Bernardo? Is that his actual name? It is his actual name.
Matt: I did not know that. Imagine a short man, this is on Harold Hilton, imagine a short man five foot six inches in height with a long club placing his feet with meticulous care with regard to the line and then rather sitting down to the ball. The waggle is careful and restrained. Then suddenly all of this changes. He seems almost to jump onto his toes in the upswing and fairly bling himself at the ball. There is no doubt at all that he is on his toes at the moment of hitting. In the old days, when caps were smaller, his cap almost always fell off the club when he came through. So he was Justin Thomas, right? He was a wild swinger. On the toes of his swing. But yeah, he let it rip by the sounds of it. He also went on to be the only Brit to ever win the U.S.
Professor: Amateur at that time. Yeah, and he won both the British and the U.S. Ams in the same year.
Matt: Same summer.
Professor: Which is amazing. The only other amateurs that have won the Open Championship are John Ball and Bobby Jones. And he also won at World Liverpool, which was his home club. I believe at the one in Muirfield, he almost didn't get to go because his...
03:51:27 Clubhouse construction and the buildings beside the course
Professor: Father wanted him to do family business and he had to travel by train late up to the tournament another just put a footnote on the first open championship clubhouse got a lot of criticism
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Oh yeah
Professor: There's a lot of reasons for that it was a fine design clubhouse but they accepted the lowest bid blithe I'd convinced them to accept the lowest bit of [unclear] So you had dry rot within three years. Oh my gosh. In a clubhouse. But they just, they were merely changing places, you know, because golfers preferred the clubs. There wasn't a lot of forethought in it. You know, there was some cool things in terms of the, the grand hall in the clubhouse that stuck around. But there was an iconic building built during this time period. High walls was built, which is now better known as gray walls. So that was built at the same, same time period.
Matt: Very
03:52:16 Early criticism and the changes ahead of the next Open
Matt: Nice hotel that someday I'd love to stay at. Yeah.
Professor: That would be nice. I've never even been.
Matt: You walk right out the courtyard onto the first tee.
Professor: It's perfect. One will dream. Okay, so again, we're intertwined with the open now. St. George's is involved. So they have four years until they ask the host. Well, they definitely did not rest. Now they've got their own property. It's time to go to work. I think this also leads some evidence to, you know, old Tom laid out those initially priced 16 holes, said, hey, maybe figure out, you know, what else to do with this to get to 18. And that meant, hey, this really was a work in progress that was laid out. So we're going to do more. Also, we had the issue of that first one. I mentioned the score of 305.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: The winning
Professor: Scores of the three leading up to the next one were 322, 326, and 322. We're not going to like that. That stands out, right? The score might not have been that big of an issue, but you're at 305 and everybody else is at 320.
Matt: The weather over there is so unpredictable. Who knows what could have been?
Professor: And at this time, they were already getting criticism of inaccessibility. Because the other places that are involved are public access places, lots of clubs involved. So Muirfield's... kind of taken on the chin a little bit and nothing significant nothing you know nobody's writing to the press or anything that but it's like we're getting criticism we got low scores the course was somewhat okay received we're getting accessibility things they then just dive in we're going to focus on the course and we're going to our job is to make this course as good as it can be to host the tournament and host the championship and so They appoint a new superintendence of changes. So one of the things they do is they can take a remeasurement of the entire golf course. So they order a remeasure in the golf course and it shows it to be under three miles.
Professor: Oh, yeah.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: I mean.
Professor: Which they're not happy with at all. And three miles would be about 5,300 yards.
Matt: It's a scholar's hole. It's a scholar's hole.
Professor: It's a kid's course. [unclear] it's a kid's course. It's a scholar's hole. Okay, so what do they do? Well, it's different than sort of what we might do now. We're going to add difficulty through hazards. We're going to combine a few new holes with old holes. We're going to change the routing a little bit. And we're going to get up to... 5,900 yards at the end of this. So we're lengthening it out. We're changing some holes. We're adding hazards. We're in H95. This is just months ahead of the next open. They move forward with this. So we lengthened this course out almost to 6,000 yards under the guidance of a new superintendence. So we're going to play the course today. The 11th hole is now similar to the 9th hole. So you remember the 9th hole. Oh, yeah.
Matt: The ninth hole is one of the greatest par fives on the planet.
Professor: And this will now remain. So we can etch that. We can cement that. That hole, which is now, again, the 11th hole, is there. So that remains. The fourth continues to play backwards down the new 15th. Third hole is still the same day as today's second. 18th green site remains the same. So anything we've added in terms of today's course, the ninth hole as we know it now.
03:55:43 The two loops and the shape of the land
Professor: Was added to this routing it's very distinguishable from the current routing uh there is a foreshadowing that occurs here this routing does include clockwise and counterclockwise components so whereas the new routing is famous for that the one the outward nine going clockwise inward wine going counterclockwise
Matt: It's credit for that um we'll get there okay well I'm just making sure because I think that it is a I guess you'd say innovation in golf course architecture at the time, the courses just didn't do that. Golf was played out and back. And when you think about where golf started all the way back a few hundred years ago now in our story, it was the links land. You're leaving town, you go that way towards the sea and you haul it back. That's right. And that was just how everybody, even old Tom, what, five years earlier, or maybe a few more. That was how he approached it as well. And so I just want to know who's getting the proper credit for it because it is the thing every time the open or any event goes back to Muirfield. It's what we always talk about.
Matt: It's the links course that does that.
Professor: And I think it might be a mistake even as we move forward and move to the next era where the permanent routing is put down or the routing as we know it. It might be a mistake to say that's super intentional versus just the constraint of the land. The type of plot we're doing versus like... the links land is long and skinny kind of makes sense just to run out and back we're now we're on more rectangular even some places square plots or constrained plots and this was a problem already at this time as they were doing this renovation they approached archerfield to purchase more land the state was not interested at all um real quick the superintendents that executed this was a famous rugby player played for the scottish team numerous years don wash up is the is the name um
03:57:36 Harry Vardon and the 1896 Open
Professor: Mr patrick hamilton don washop him and his brother were famous rugby players uh his brother one of the best halfbacks of that era
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: So
Professor: They finish that up and they move into the second open championship hosted at Muirfield do you know much about the 1896 open
Matt: This one obviously needed uh to stand out it's harry Vardon's open yeah there was a great quote where he gets to the last and the last was playing hard and it's into the wind. And he's like, when I arrived to the last tee, I was set with an extremely difficult problem. I required a four to gain a victory outright and a five to tie, which would give me the right to play off with him, which I think was Taylor.
Professor: That's right. Mr. John Henry Taylor.
Matt: Give me the right to play off with him for the championship. The last hole at Muirfield at this period was a testing one, requiring, as it did, a good drive and a real good brassy to reach the green. There was, however, a very bad bunker guarding the green, and while there was very little difficulty in securing the necessary five, which would enable me to tie, I might very easily take a six in my attempt to reach the green with my second shot. Thoughts flashed through the brain with a lightning rapidity. at such a moment, and to me, this was an occasion of the utmost importance. The final decision, however, was to a large extent the result of allowing my eyes to wander among the spectators in front of me [unclear] caught sight of my friend james k of seton carew making frantic efforts to attract my attention he was pointing with his hand to the ground this side of the bunker.
Matt: So this was... He was trying to give him a different route because the fans had matted down the grass, and he was trying to give him a better play to do it. Well, Vardon took the advice, which he had not solicited. He played short and knocked it on two putts for his five to get into a playoff with Taylor. Just such a great account of that. Now, he was gassed because there was a tournament at North Berwick
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 04:00:00 ==========
Matt: That Friday. And the playoff got delayed till Saturday. Imagine that. Imagine you hop over to the course down the street, play a different tournament, and then come back and try to finish it all.
Professor: And the playoff is how many holes?
Matt: 36.
Professor: So you played 36. I would suspect the North Berwick tournament was 36 as well. Yeah. And then you're playing 36 in the playoff.
Matt: And I'm sure you got this as well. But to add to this lore, he started putting terribly.
Professor: Oh, I do not have this.
Matt: Vardin started the next day. You're probably nervous, right? I got this big playoff. I'm trying to win my sixth open. I'm sorry, his first open. Yeah, it was his first, right? Yeah, it was his first. And so he's over there at North Berwick. Ben Sayers is the head pro at North Berwick. He asked him, you know, what do you got? I need to look at something different. I mean, what golfer hasn't done this? He gives him a new putter. He goes out, putts pretty well with it, keeps it in the bag, goes and wins the 36-hole aggregate of 157 to Taylor's 161. What a weird story.
Professor: To picks up a new putter on the quote-unquote off they had a different tournament to go back to a different course and then win it with that playoff
Matt: And we got to mention the interlapping grip or the
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Interlock the overlap the overlapping I play overlap which
Matt: Is a good tribute he wins his first open at mirrorfield uh and he popularized that grip from another Honourable Company member [unclear] lay
Professor: Amazing and then a quote from varden um that I'll read in its fullest I think it captures this positive feedback that does occur with the golf course this time. For some reasons, I like Muirfield. But it does not enjoy so many advantages as other championship courses. There are not many sand hills. It is on the flat side. And at the first glance, you might take it to be an inland course. But after a single round, you're greatly impressed by the good golf that is to be obtained upon it. The turf is capital. Some of the hazards are very fine. And on the whole, I think it might be regarded as a very good championship test of golf. The 4th, 12th, and 18th holes all call for first class seconds if the greens are to be reached. Of course, probably helped that he won.
04:02:12 The reputation of the Muirfield champions
Professor: But giving positive accolades to the golf course.
Matt: You know, that quote really does support the claim, great champions win at Muirfield. Yeah. And I know that was in the modern championships, what we'll get to, but even this stretch under this revised course, you got Harold Hilton, top player, Harry Vardon, best at the time, James Braid.
Professor: We'll come up in 19, yep.
Matt: 01 and 06. you And then you got Ted Ray, the lumbering figure of a man, as Darwin said. He was a big dude who knew how to hit the golf ball. Big by those standards. I don't know. I don't think people were as large as they are today.
Professor: Maybe, maybe not.
Matt: Ted Ray could send it. And yeah, so you just have under... You know, what is
04:03:06 The 1897 Amateur Championship
Matt: That? That's all the 1910s, 19-0s and 1910s. You have the best of the best winning the Open there. It really built this reputation of Muirfield as being a great course for champions.
Professor: Yeah, and at this time, you see them really growing into their own. So we turn after the 1896 run by Barden. They move right into the 1897 Amateur Championship. Did you come across what is notable about the 1897 Amateur Championship?
Matt: In general, just the... support of all championship golf was evident to me. It's, you know, knowing what these open champions were, I didn't really give credence to how many Walker cups they had hosted, how many amateur championships they had hosted, how many, you know, modern day we'll get into the women's open and others. But it was clear that this was just such a new guiding, not new, it was just competition of the best versus competition of the club that they really rally around as a club and were good from outside looking in. They looked like good operators. They knew how to set up courses. They knew how to, from a spectator standpoint, put all those pieces together well. So yeah, there was just like an efficiency of competitive golf that they created.
Professor: Circling back to the line here that encompasses this era, a great course for champions. Varden, Braid, Hilton, Ted Ray. The best of the best keep winning here.
Matt: And what surprised me the most was the breadth. Walker Cups, Amateur Championships, eventually the Women's Open. They knew how to set a course up. and consistently put on a show, testing the best in the world, while also maintaining that standard for their members and visitors the other 51 weeks of
Professor: The year. Which brings us right back to our partner, Erin Hills, because I can't
04:04:52 Erin Hills as a championship venue
Professor: Think of a modern public American venue whose story rhymes more closely with that level of commitment to championship golf.
Matt: That's right. In 2017, Erin Hills hosted the U.S. Open, the first ever played in Wisconsin with more than 200,000 people attended. And I don't know if you know this, Professor. I was one of them. I took my dad, my brother, and my Chicago roommate. We were maybe 20 feet away from Justin Thomas in his bright pink pants when he hit his three-wood to eight feet on 18, rolling in that putt for a 63, the lowest score to par in U.S. Open history. When you go, you got to check out the plaque that sits there today. Truly mind-boggling how he hit that shot. Then, of course, Brooks Koepka closes with a 67. for his first of five major championships on Sunday.
Professor: The story I didn't know is the operator story. The superintendent, Zachariah King, was 27 when he took over the course. Within a year, the USGA hands the US Open to a young public course in rural Wisconsin. This leaves [unclear] asking if it's good and ready enough. This leaves Zach asking, can I do this as the youngest superintendent in US Open history? So what does he do? He gets to work and spends seven years preparing for four days. Much like the Honourable Company, he's going to do it. Everything he can to ensure their course presents a great championship. No excuses.
Matt: So we fast forward to 2017. They never opened for the season. And the Saturday before, it's 90 degrees with 25 mile an hour gusts. And players are walking off saying, we're going to shoot 100. Then Monday, it pours. Not what you're looking for if you're Reineking. But from the USGA account, it was one of the most prepared operations they'd ever seen. And
Professor: Then in 2025, they prove once again they are a true championship venue, this time with the U.S. Women's Open. Maja Stark wins her first major and celebrates on the 18th green, Finley with a spotted cow in one hand, and Annika on FaceTime in the other.
Matt: See, Professor, dreams do come true. But let's not skip over my favorite, the 2022 U.S. Mid-Am. 264 players from 14 countries. And the final is two Irish pals who traveled over together. An optometrist from Belfast. beats his buddy from Dublin in the town of Aaron, which if you didn't already know is Gaelic for
Professor: Ireland. That's certainly some club history book stuff right there. And
Matt: More stories like that are to come. Recognizing Erin Hills as a championship setting, the USGA has committed five more, starting with the US amateur four ball in 2027 and running out through 2039.
Professor: Wow. In all, that's 10 USGA championships at a site that just turned 20. As the USGA put it, you can't buy history. You can only earn it. And with Muirfield-like numbers, Erin Hills is surely earning its rightful place in golf history. But unlike Muirfield, you don't need a letter of introduction to get through their gates. But
Matt: You do need a reservation. Yeah,
Professor: You definitely need a reservation. And like my favorite towns in the UK and Ireland, Erin Hills is a village. It has it all. An Irish pub, cottage just named for Bally Bunyan, La Hinch, Port Rush, County Down, and even Waterville. And let's not forget about the Drumlin, a putting course lit up at night. It's their nod to the Himalayas.
Matt: Plus the caddy barn. Ping pong, pool, darts, golden tea. On a few occasions, I've watched the losing captain of our trip regain a shred of his pride and dignity in
Professor: That room. So if you're the trip captain in your group, and if you listen to the show, you probably are. Go play where champions play. Book your stay and play at AaronHills.com and go create your championship story. Now let's get back to our story.
Matt: That they created. But what happened in that open?
Professor: Yeah, so this one, this was, you got the heavyweights at the time. You got Hutchinson, you got John Ball, Freddie Tate, Balfour Melville, Lele. These are the players of the amateur world. They win everything. They're going to obviously win at Muirfield. No, the unknown of Alexander John Travers Allen of Edinburgh University would win. beating James Robb of St. Andrews. They were only 21 and 19, respectively. The heavyweights, all a little older. These young lads come along. He's a medical student at Edinburgh University. Oney has played golf for six years at Braid Hills at the time. Traveled by train. from Edinburgh to Drem, something we haven't mentioned. You actually had to get off at the station in Drem and that was two and a half miles from Drem to get to Muirfield.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Yeah, they didn't have a real station.
Professor: So obviously the members in that would have different ways that people would get them there by carriage or whatever. He biked to Muirfield. He kept and he traveled in his just normal shoes, didn't wear studs and spikes to play. There's a somber note to this one. He died within a year. of winning
04:09:27 Freddie Tait and his legacy
Professor: That thing he died from tuberculosis meningitis in march in 1898 just three months past his 22nd birthday in less than a year after listening lifting um that amateur championship trophy wow
Matt: Yeah a
Professor: We do have one more note that I have in the 1800s that they introduced at the club. They had some growing debt because they, one, built a dressing accommodation that cost as much as the original clubhouse. And so much so that they end up having to turn down the telephone for a while that they needed. And they levied their members also to help with these growing costs and growing debt. Do you know what else they introduced in 1898?
Matt: What's that?
Professor: Greens fees for visitors.
Matt: There you go. The new revenue stream. There it is.
Professor: I did not do research to see who else was charging visitor fees at this time, but they introduced that in 1898.
Matt: Did you get much? on other amateur competitions in your research?
Professor: I think we could do a whole episode just on amateur champion.
04:10:27 The Walker Cup and its origins
Professor: And walker cups I expected the open championship that obviously carry a lot of the narrative uh relative to the next turn in the century here in 1900 right the next hundred years of the open there was just as much history written on the amateurs that were held there and the walker cups and the curtis cup that was brought
Matt: In there yeah so I mean there was a lot of focus on you know these great championships um and allowing others to see this remarkably good golf course that they had conceived and cared for 1959 walker cup yeah anyone you remember from that one uh
Professor: When I have a strapping young lad maybe that might be an ohioan maybe ohio versus the world
Matt: Maybe uh that's jack Nicklaus do
Professor: You have any um Do you have any good quotes relative to who he was? This Walker Cup is famous in a couple different ways. I want to read a quote by Pottinger relative to the Walker Cup that sets the stage for what the Walker Cup was. So every two years, the new world sets about the old. with relish in what, though it is hard to admit it, has sometimes been almost a nominal match for the Walker Cup. The Walker Cup provides the occasion for statement-like utterances about the special relationship between the two countries and an opportunity for the Americans to look politely for Scottish ancestors.
Matt: Wow, wasn't it? It was one of the Muirfield amateurs that inspired the Walker Cup to begin with.
Professor: It was, I believe, yes, in 1920. So we've got 1920. We've skipped over the war at this point. World War I. It was time to host the Open again. Nope, we're not ready for it. So we're going to host the amateur instead. They got the chorus back in shape. Robert Maxwell participated. Tommy Armour makes an appearance in this one. [unclear] group later won the U.S. Open at Oakmont and the Open at Carnoustie. But the big one was George Herbert Walker. was there the president of the united states golf association walker was just
Matt: So ggw
Professor: Yeah it was so just deeply moved by the quality of play and the sportsmanship between the british and american teams that he's like we need a formal international amateur team competition and that's when he came up with a silver trophy and two years later the walker cup was officially born in 1922 how was
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: That yeah so there
Professor: Was inspiration we fast forward now back to that 19 what um
04:13:00 Jack Nicklaus and the 1959 Walker Cup
Professor: 59 walker cup right we've got jack Nicklaus and just a crazy that's the american went out and won you know we struggled with foursomes no we won the first we won the opening series four up british came back won 3-1 in the next series so it was 5-3 going the next day we waxed them yeah we ended up winning for a 9-3 win um you
Matt: The quote that I have was him writing this 10 years later. From the beginning. I liked Muirfield very much. I think we all did. While it has the intrinsic qualities of a British seaside links, fairways that tumble every which way, magnificent low crop turf, deep bunkers, and hard, unwatered greens, it is a frank and open course. He's quoted a bunch throughout the years. talking about Muirfield. And he obviously, very obviously, named his course in Columbus, Ohio, Muirfield Village, after his time there.
Professor: He also talked about Muirfield personified sport at its best people at their best the world at its best if anyone could handle it I could after all I was an old Muirfield man and he said that with respect to reflecting on the 59 matches winning my matches at Muirfield in 1959 was the moment I realized I could compete against the very best in the world on the truce championship stage that golf course has a special place in
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: My heart so
Professor: We just see how much he loved the place
04:14:30 Robert Maxwell and the 1903 Amateur Championship
Professor: So [unclear] rewind back to the early 1900s, actually understand how we get to the course as we know it, which is now a course I would say in today's world might be the most perfect course ever built. But it certainly wasn't that in 1900s. The golf course exists now, doesn't have much relationship with that in 1900s. In my research, one of the most pivotal moments I think set them down this road was actually 20 years before we're going to get to the emergence of the golf course that we know and love today. So in 1903, an amateur is held. And the name, Robert Maxwell, wearing putter, pretty actually important amateur, largest entry. And so they'd extend play over four days. The second amateur international between Scotland and England had taken place just before this. So you had this huge tension with Scotland and England going on because they had this international match.
Professor: So that's some background context. And in the amateur, four players from Scotland and four from England make. the round of eight. So there's this perfect drama. You end up in this final duel where Maxwell faces off against Horace Hutchison. So we got a Scott versus England. And Hutchison was just a huge figure in the sport. Had already won, I believe, two amateurs previously in his career. Maxwell's pretty young at the time relative to Hutchison. Maxwell waxes him. Seven and five. Hutchison comes out.
04:15:57 Horace Hutchinson and criticism of the course
Professor: Guns a-blazing after this. I'm just going to read his quote.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Let's hear it.
Professor: The poor course at Muirfield has had such hard things said of it as an arena for the amateur or any other championship by the critics, and a good many of them are no doubt deserved. Personally, if my opinion may be mentioned for the nothing that it is worthy, I do not think it is quite a championship course. I'm quite sure it is not a fitting amateur championship course while the present first hole is played as the 19th, for this is putting the whole decision between two players who have proved themselves equal over 18 holes to the chance of a hole that is perhaps the most unfair that could be cited. To be sure, The rough at the sides of the moan part is iniquiditas. You may lie teed up. You may lie desperate. That is all as it should not be.
Professor: And a nice selection of bunkers would be far better. He's just big mad. And this leaves a pretty sour taste in the Honourable Company's mouth. I bet. Because he is, again, a force. He's won several amateurs. Pretty loud voice. Writes this as an article. This goes out to everyone. this puts them down a road where they just keep tinkering with the course over the next 20 years.
Matt: What do they care? I guess, is it the reputation of the championship links that's at stake here? Because Robert Maxwell dusted them, right? Their guy who, when I think of all the Muirfield men that we read about through this, Robert Maxwell probably is the epitome of it for me. Gentleman, a player, but also, happier with a club match than likely is in a club championship horse hutchinson was you know much more um I'm guessing he enjoyed the spotlight much more but was it sheer ego here or was it just maybe an admission that there was truth in his comments.
Professor: I think somewhat there might've been an admission that there's truth in their comments. If we think about their move to Muirfield and the R&A questioning the readiness of the course, if we think about their roots, their main priority was playing a proper game. That's what they privilege. So we've moved in the era of hosting championship tournaments. They care that is a proper golf tournament being held. The rest of the year, every other day, leave us be. We'll play our foursomes. on
04:18:23 Course improvements in the early twentieth century
Professor: Our course the way we want to. But when we're showcasing a championship event, we wanted to show proper golf crown a true champion on championship links is a priority of theirs. And every championship that comes along, there's just this undertone of critique to the course. And so they begin tinkering. They're doing bunker improvements. They're trying to get additional land. And they just keep working on this as they move through these early 1900s. Every other year or so, they're hosting the amateur. Every other year or so, they're hosting the open. And every year, it's like, man, we need to keep tinkering with this course. And in 1910, Robert Maxwell posed numerous alterations. He posed a new seventh and new eighth hole. Keep that seventh hole in mind because they actually reject his alterations, but they do create a new ninth and they shorten the 14th.
Professor: They add tees to lengthen. This is all in 1910. And Blyth and Patterson all joined a Greens committee to just get involved. And they just continue throughout this entire period to tinker, to search, how can we make this golf course actually play as we want it to play?
Matt: And they're doing all of this in-house.
Professor: All this in-house. At this time, you're moving into that area where professionals are consulting, which Robert Maxwell poses 24 new bunkers. They peg them for member feedback. They eventually proceed. They monitor play, judge the impact of the changes. This does get them some more positive feedback. There's actually a Sports Illustrated article that quotes, the course has been made more of what Mr. Lowe would call a thinking one. So they are getting some positive feedback. But in the end, it's just not doing what they wanted to do.
Matt: So
04:20:03 Robert Maxwell as a golfer and club steward
Matt: Before we get to their more robust course of action, is it a good time to double click on in on Robert Maxwell?
Professor: Yeah, I think we should. I think when you think of actors with Muirfield, unquestionably, he's up on that Mount Rushmore probably.
Matt: And he's one of those incredible portraits, right? Not done by Rayburn, one of the few, but probably still, I think it was Stanley Curister who did this one of Maxwell. He looked like a... a humble man in the picture. And I knew that was part of his reputation. Darwin, so Bernardo Darwin wrote about all sports and all life. So we always read the golf element of Darwin, but Darwin remembered him mostly as a good oarsman. On my notes. And a large and formidable figure on the football field. So he was a really good footballer. And he went to Eaton, the affluent class, went to that school in Edinburgh. He was definitely a champion of golf as well. Oh, he boxed too. So he's a big figure. The two amateurs he won were both at Muirfield. That's right. That obviously connects him very deeply to the place.
Matt: And he would always tell people that, you know, yeah, those are fantastic, but I would much more prefer a dinner match or a medal. He won the last medal at the club before. that first world war and he won the first one after that
Professor: Yeah he'd won 84 medals total 20 from the Honourable Company nine from the R&A won the saint george's challenge cup at sandwich he was one of the ones that pushed for the R&A to take over the m and open coming out of the war he was one of the ones said we need someone to take this over and not be ran by the clubs and he was arguably the person that pushed that forward the most uh you brought up he preferred playing with friends even though He was a leading golfer in Scotland and left the competitive golf scene earlier because he primarily saw value in just playing the casual matches and also stewardship of the club was something he really firmly believed in. In fact, he gave the club all of his golf medals in a replica of the Challenge Cup for them to have rather than keeping them in his own stash.
Matt: And he too had one hell of a mustache. Yes. So these 1900 guys, these early 20th century, they knew how to grow a stash.
Professor: They also loved to play with a pipe and would tuck it into a pocket when he hit a shot.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Rocking the pipe.
Professor: He's the portrait of a golfer, the famous painting.
Matt: That's him, the portrait of a golfer. He just didn't like a big fuss about things. And I think we all need someone like that in our golf for some. So his game, man, nobody writes like Darwin. When he describes someone swinging, I can just be there talking about Maxwell. He stood decidedly open with a wide straddle, the right shoulder noticeably down, the left hand well over the club, the right hand under with the thumb down the shaft. His swing was what would then have been called a three-quarter swing, rather stiff than otherwise. I'm almost seeing visions of that description of a single plane type.
Professor: [unclear]
04:23:23 Ben Sayers and the Dreadnought driver
Professor: Mo norman with the same little mo uh you brought up ben sayers that name earlier do you know his connection with um with our mr maxwell here I don't so this goes back to the 1909 amateur which had according to most records one of the best matches ever that came down to the captain cecil hutcheson versus maxwell maxwell ends up just a long hard-fought match wins a one-up victory in the final hole on the final hole to claim his second national championship well leading up to that prior tournament club maker ben sayers over at north barrack had designed a new oversized driver they called the dreadnought inspired by the the battleship the hms dreadnought maxwell went on to win with that just an oversized driver just pounded the ball and this became one of the most demanded golf clubs in the world that Sayers couldn't keep up with production of it.
Professor: And interesting, Maxwell wins the 1909 Amateur, and this is when he soon leaves competitive golf. So soon after this, he decides he just wants to play with friends and turns his attention very much to the club and stewardship of Honourable Company and the private Muirfield Golfing Greens.
Matt: Right, and you talk about that step already of when he was captain, 1912, 1913, how he
04:24:48 The 1913 changes and World War I
Matt: Urged the club to consider acquiring more land where are we going next professor I think we got some changes
Professor: To make we got some changes the club in 1913 when made a bunch of changes the new seventh and eighth holes of today showed up and matched what they are now um well what happens around 1914 we're
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Off to war
Professor: We're off to war Everything shuts down. Club dinner's canceled. They ensure the clubhouse and contents. We almost lose the course in 1918. Did you uncover this little tidbit?
Matt: Yeah, like many, it was being used for military purposes, right?
Professor: And something else where the Board of Agriculture did no battle. They stepped in and said golf courses should be cultivated in national interest. Fortunately for the Honourable Company, the ground was unsuitable for growing crops. And the grazing of sheep was sufficient as judged by the Board of Agriculture. So at the time, you had the head and greenkeeper, two men, one boy and two girls were on staff. They kept after the course during World War I, making sure it was okay. So we come out of the war, 1919, we're back up and running. The autumn medals played. I think that Mr. Maxwell wins that. And we move into 1920. And we've been pestering Archerfield over and over.
04:26:13 Archerfield land and a new opportunity
Professor: And over but something's going to change did you come across in your research what happened at archer field because the Honourable Company had been after land for a while they've been bugging them and bugging them and turned down do you know what happened
Matt: Financial ruin
Professor: No no something way less interesting
Matt: Um I did did it I don't
Professor: Know we had new proprietors so people die within the family that owned archer field sir colonel nisbet hamilton grant colonel yes now owns archerfield as in he's the new proprietor of the estate and so the club comes back to him and says well what about [unclear] acres that's over here you're not doing anything with it he was prepared to sell he was descendant of mary nisbet the countess of elgin um He was notable for editing letters of his ancestors and managing significant East Lothian properties. The way lineage worked at all, all this East Lothian fell in his lap. So he sells that Archerfield 150 acres for 8,500 pounds in 1922. That's about 420,000 pounds today, 570,000 US dollars. Also at this time, Blyth passes, which is an important part of the story because Blyth had been steering the ship.
Professor: Making all the decisions, passing all decisions, even when he's not serving as captain. So Muirfield has their new property. Amateur in 19...
Matt: And it was what, 50 acres?
Professor: I had 150 acres in my notes, right? So they've got this new land, not doing anything with it because it doesn't get closed on until I believe 1922 is when they finally close on the land. Blyth has passed. We've been internal our entire history as a club.
04:27:58 Harry Colt and the redesign with Robert Maxwell
Professor: Everything we want to do to this course, as a club, every decision we've made, we've done internally with each other, that's about to change. Who enters the scene now?
Matt: There's Scotsmen that were architects who were quite well-known, particularly in our country, came here and built a lot of golf courses. Well, when you go overseas into the UK, it's not Donald Ross that was out there cooking and... creating really good golf courses and kind of the father of architecture, if you will. It was a gentleman by the name of Harry Colt.
Professor: Yes, sir.
Matt: But he was assisted by the gentleman we already spent a good amount of time on, Robert Maxwell.
Professor: That's right. Colt first is asked to visit. The Muirfield will lay out a course to take into account the added land. He meets with Robert Maxwell over three days in September, I believe, of 1922. They lay out. The plan it gets done is presented to Maxwell for feedback to ensure they're on the same page. Colt charges initial fee, just 52 pounds for that plan. They get it in place. Incredibly different than the previous layout. Very different than what exists now. The one through five, yes. But then just the ninth and tenth, the overlap was nearly non-existent. And that's because when they first lay it out, he sends it to the membership for review. And the membership actually gets to give review and here's a quote from a specific member which I think just tells the story of
04:29:33 Spectator crowds and the revised routing
Professor: The tension we're now with with Muirfield as a private club interested in their own game that also wants to host the best championships in the world Muirfield will always be a championship course and the very large crowds that now attend these meetings have to be taken into account I'm afraid that under your plan, with the 14th, 15th, 16th, 17th, and 18th holes all rather congested, you will find it next to impossible to manage one of these huge crowds. My intention in writing is
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 04:30:00 ==========
Professor: Not to be critical, but, if possible, helpful, and I hope you will take my letter in the spirit I write
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: It.
Professor: This leads to a meeting in March 1923. They meet with Mr. Colt again to discuss the routing, and he gives them an entire revised plan that doesn't match. anything of the previous plan that is now our current routing. So his first one down, him and Maxwell laid out together, imposed, got blown up. His routing would not be kind to large crowds.
Matt: You know, I know a little bit about Harry Colt, the man and the architect, just from our trips to the Heathlands in Southeast England, where he was born in London. That's where he...
04:30:45 Harry Colt and his approach to course architecture
Matt: [unclear] up and learned how to play the game. He wasn't a very talented golfer. I think he was like an 18 handicap.
Professor: Not a professional golfer, which was not who was working on golf courses at this time. Right.
Matt: And so he really was one of the first professionals to do this. And, you know, he also was a pretty good promoter, it seemed like, or he was good at winning over. The boardroom. He had so many influential courses under his belt. He quietly had significant influence here in the States. Yeah. And courses like Pine Valley, Old Elm in Chicago. The man did travel, but most of his work was how Donald Ross was here for America. Harry Colt was for golf in the UK. There was so many mid-tier clubs that were Harry Colts. And there's even more that they believe are Harry Colts because he was just so prolific at the time. I think there was a great story about, so Harry did Sunningdale. And so Sunningdale put him in the rooms with the most powerful people.
Professor: But he did Sunningdale?
Matt: I did not have that.
Professor: He was a secretary of Sunningdale. You're thinking of Swinley Forest.
Matt: Well, Swinley Forest was his least bad chorus. Sunnydale was the new, not the old, but the new. And so I just know that that was one of his first.
Professor: Yeah, the new.
Matt: Yeah, that's right. Yeah, it was one of his first gigs. And he only had one paid gig. I think that was his first paid gig, right? Yes. And meanwhile, Alistair McKenzie is at All Woodley. a surgeon in the military. You know, we know the McKenzie story for another time, but I think this is what I love. Harry Colt had one paid gig and Alistair McKenzie was trying to sell his club where he was a member on doing the work. They only allowed him to build one hole and they had to, you know, see how what they thought and then they do others, but they still didn't trust him after that one hole. They said, well, with your plan, we need you to bring in a professional, somebody that actually does this, Alistair, like great, nice stuff, but we didn't want a real architect.
Matt: They called Harry Cole. He only had one paid deal and they pulled him in. I just think that story is indicative of, man, this guy, right timing, right place. He was not your lay of the land architect. He was creating things in the dirt and was just deep on. on principles and strategy. And there's a quick read if anyone's interested in deeper on them called Some Essays on Golf Course Architecture. I read that going to England and it's really, really good and tells you how he looked at the world of golf course building.
Professor: Well, yeah, it was interesting because he was a believer that the course should look like it was discovered too. It was this combination of I got to create a strategic golf course, but I also wanted to look natural in what was there. He won a reward to scratch player, took on brave lines, but... bogey pass for the higher handicapper. So that really true strategic version of golf courses.
Matt: I think St. George's Hill was actually his first.
Professor: Yeah, St. George's Hill.
Matt: Swinley was the great quote of everyone thought Swinley Forest was just the most amazing place. And he said, it's my least bad course.
Professor: Yeah, that's right. That's right. So he was humbled. And yeah, because he was a secretary of Sunningdale. So the old course is obviously, you know, very influential on him, which he then did some work on. Unfortunately, a lot of his original designs were put under the knife. So a lot of them just don't exist as they do. It's crazy when you look at the names, right? Moorpark West, County Sligo, remodeling, including Muirfield, County Down, Lithium and St. Anne's, Hoy Lake, Port Rush, Port Crawl, Formby. You've got just so many different ones that he played a role in that just, I have not played enough Colts. I know you've done better than I have on that. And it's one of those things I'm kind of sad about that I haven't got to play many of them.
Matt: He did Rye Golf Club, which is incredible in Southeast England, Seaside Links. It was Sunningdale Old, but it was a revision.
Professor: Yeah, he did a revision to Old. This is after serving as secretary, right? He served as secretary, then later did a revision. There is one that has been very recently restored to Colt's version. But yeah, so we have the Harry Cole era. At Muirfield. [unclear] permanent assessment.
Matt: Just to put a time on this, I mean, hundreds and hundreds of choruses to Harry Colt's name. He is, yeah, he's in his prime, right? I mean, 1925, it's the heart of his career. Yes.
Professor: So the
04:35:28 The cost and completion of the new course
Professor: Course that we end up with, if we want to total up all the expenditures, including the little cottage for the greenkeeper, a horse stable, end up about 5,200 pounds. This occurred over a couple of years of construction using 1923 as our benchmark year, only about 280,000 pounds, $380,000. So if you look at the conversion, actually, like what they're getting relative to today's renovations, not that bad. And so 1924, the course is ready to play and they play the autumn metal. They're able to tee it up on a course of now about 6,700 yards, which is only an increase of 125 yards from the previous course. And many of the bunkers from the original course were still maintained and left. As I mentioned, it was kind of a sandy waste area. It was pretty common across the course.
Professor: So a lot of that sandy waste was still left where it was with the original routing, just new routing completely. We've now got Muirfield as we know it. And the next year.
04:36:25 Tom Dobson and the 1925 Scottish Amateur
Professor: They don't have to jump into the open or the amateur. They do get to host the Scottish amateur in 1925.
Matt: Do you know after his work how many bunkers they ended up with?
Professor: I don't. I don't have that number.
Matt: I saw this was another one of those discrepancies. Yeah. But again, I don't think the tweaking necessarily stopped.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: I'm sure it did.
Matt: It took a big jump, but I don't think they stopped. So maybe it was just a moving number, but it was 148 bunkers on the golf course after he was done.
Professor: And that might come back into the story. The 1925 Scottish Open goes off wonderfully. In fact, Tom Dobson of the Green Staff wins. At this time, this is the fourth Scottish Open, or the Scottish Am. It was being dominated by aristocrats, stockbrokers, and lawyers. And it was actually pretty contentious. this dobson entered it being on the green staff and not of that class people thought because he worked at a golf course for a living he should be a professional not in it lots of probably classism underneath this with what's going on but he goes on the win obviously the local hero the club is incredibly proud of that maxwell meets him as the first to congratulate him and dobson goes on to I believe turn into a professional in play at this time um moves on that east renforshire um club um to be a professional lord derby at the time explained quote unquote I cannot resist congratulating you on the tremendous success of the new holes they've made all the difference to the course and one no longer has the feeling one is playing round and round a field it is perfectly charming
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: So
Professor: Course is very much
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: A positive
Professor: Review, no critiques given
Matt: Of that. It clearly panned out the right way this time around. And now we're talking about the favorite of Nicklaus and all the others. That's right. That even though the tweaks did continue, the Muirfield we know and love today, this was it.
Professor: And moving forward, we're now playing on a golf course that grows into being known as one of the best. And that shows up in 1926.
04:38:41 The 1926 Amateur and spectator admission
Professor: Amateur comes in. This is the first amateur being held to host these renovations. The R&A runs this. The championship committee put a charge on spectators. They want the limited number of spectators, especially, this is quote-unquote, especially those ignorant of the game and therefore possible difficult to control. They were really worried about the Ryder Cup Americans already, right? The unruly, this speaks to you like these gentlemen Scottish. spectators now the R&A here in 1926 is like we got unruly people we're gonna put a charge in on spectators coming in because we do not want them coming in to watch our events again this is not a Honourable Company decision this was the R&A trying to limit the number of spectators to keep down uh the unruliness of
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Of them
Professor: Yeah now this amateur deserves just a few minutes Bobby
04:39:34 Bobby Jones and Jesse Sweetser
Professor: Jones. Mr. R.T. Jones comes in. He's certainly going to win it. He has to. Certainly. He's dominant this time. Third round, he wins four and three. The fifth, he wins eight and six. He's sure going to go on with this. Well, there's a their generation Stewart's sink in this story. One Andrew Jameson of Scotland comes out, plays level fours to that day, and Bobby just doesn't have his game. and actually loses they lose all the air of the of the event uh we do have an american come in and win it mr jesse sweetster or sweet sir comes in and wins it and he's the second to win since mr walter travis who won in 1904 um who else did sweet sir be along the way francis we met so we met shows up yeah beats him one up so we see right now yeah
04:40:30 Walter Hagen and the 1929 Open
Professor: The names at the amateur, names at the championship, especially when at Muirfield, just the names are there and start rising to the top. Not always winning, but just name after name on this wonderful golf course.
Matt: What's the first open after the renovation?
Professor: So they get the wait until 1929 is what I have in my notes. That's right. And you know who wins this one?
Matt: I do. I got that one. Walter Hagen. Again. The Hague. Uh-huh. What a character, obviously, in the game. Here was the Hague's description of the methods of the Honourable Company. They never artificially altered those greens, claimed Hagen. The idea is to play them as nearly to their natural state as possible. So these fellows just run a closed mower over what little grass has dared to show its head after the sheep got through and shaved it off. Why don't you just iron it on, he would ask. So they were known for faster greens there, even in the 20s after this Colt renovation. And I think the undulation of Colt's greens added to that perception of pace that I'm sure they weren't scalping greens, but there was just a bit more slope to a hairy Colt. green than there was to the lay of the land you know before him yeah
Professor: Reading between the lines it seemed like a lot of greens at this time were rather flat right that they were positioned in flat areas for uh for different reasons and murphy kind of stood out about that they're a little bit more interesting in terms of their undulations
04:42:07 Qualifying and the growth of championship crowds
Professor: This also represented a transition to open spectating. We mentioned earlier they started charging. Now the R&A also wanted some commercialism. We've got extensive catering. We've got marquees around the clubhouse. We've got supervised car parking, build-out car lots. So we're starting to move into, this is more than just a local tournament with people running around the grounds. This is a spectacle that people are going to come to and we want to put on a show.
Matt: Um with it this is another heyday of competitive golf at muirfield any others that we should touch on before kind of the quote-unquote modern championship golf yeah they
Professor: Continue to move forward we host another am in 1932
04:42:47 The eighth hole and slow play in the 1932 Amateur
Professor: Wrapping up that 1929 open this is when hagen went down number eight so it's changed the course does happen here to the right of number eight used to be pretty open by the last round it got trampled down completely by spectators yeah yeah um so hagen went down the right side of number eight I believe made a part skipped a long easy easy par might even been a birdie a birdie three and ran off to number nine where it used to be hey if you made a four skip to nine quickly and so that led to the planning of a buckthorn and other aspects down the right side of number eight that exists today where you ain't going down the right side of eight anymore unless you're on your way to a six or seven. They hold an AM 1932.
Professor: Quick just footnote on that one. They were very upset at how long it took. So slow play.
Matt: Still on the slow play. You gotta, if they're nothing but consistent.
Professor: So how upset
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Are they?
Professor: Very. How long was the 35 holes? If you had to take a guess, what really just set them over the edge? 35 holes? 35 holes.
Matt: Eight hours?
Professor: Six and a half hours. As comparison, that famous match between Maxwell and Hutchinson two decades prior went all the way to the 36 hole. That was a four-hour match.
Matt: Gosh. I mean, fair play. Fair play, Honourable Company. Let's make it brisk. They make it brisk.
Professor: Quote, unquote, unfortunately, the greatest drama is spoiled if it is played at too slow a pace. And so this match, which might have gone down in history among the great finishes, gave an impression of drabness and weariness. Sounds a lot about the, like the PGA Tour debates in today's.
Matt: Yeah, I would say. So that was the 30s?
Professor: That was in 1932. Again, we're, keep moving forward, man.
Matt: We're, we're, we're. So 35. Just a quick note on the Open Championship.
Professor: Ralph Perry.
04:44:42 Tom Simpson and the next course review
Matt: Yep. He was ambidextrous. Seriously? Yeah, he could hit a ball left-handed. Now, he mostly played from the right side of the ball, but he could beat pretty much anybody left-handed if he wanted to.
Professor: Well, what happened before 1935? A subtle big change to the golf course. Oh, Tom Simpson. Tom Simpson. The Honourable Company, they will not rap. They've got a golf course that is showing great to championships, and they're like, eh.
Matt: I don't have a ton on Tom Simpson. So I am curious to hear what you found. But the thing that I kept thinking about when I stumbled into him was I hit it in that bunker on nine, the centerline bunker. It's great. It's honestly the thing that made me think about that hole for so long ever since. It's just a great strategic part five with a boundary out of bounds on your left and fescue grass farther right, but a big corridor with strategy galore. I loved. that hole. And he put that, well, I don't know, and you're going to tell me what that bunker is, but they named it after him. So I have to assume he put it in. And here's what was going through my head. Honourable Company is not the type of club that would name things on a course.
Matt: If you think about even Leith and Musselburgh, they didn't really partake in the naming of these things. As we've talked, all these memorable competitions already, on this links. Nothing was named after it except for that bunker with Tom Simpson. Is that correct?
Professor: That is correct. So when they move to Riffle Golfing Green, they don't name the holes. This is intentional. They don't put yardages on the tee boxes. Very nondescript. Tom Simpson, he tells it as he sees it. He visits for two days and produces a report that the club still has to this day. Here's how he starts. There are a number of holes, such as 1, 4, 7, 10, 13, and 18, so that's six of the holes, which are featureless, by reason of their obvious and straightforward character. Now, in golf course design, the obvious thing is almost invariably the wrong thing. No course is really a great course unless it requires knowing. There should be at least as much need for mental agility as for physical skill. He goes on to say, basically, St. Andrews has a desirable quality and is a quality that Muirfield lacks.
Professor: I got to read some of these quotes just because how direct he is. For our part, we never look favorably on a two-shot or three-shot hole where the center of the fairway is the best place to be from the tee. And this was a majority of the Muirfield holes. The center of the fairway was the prime spot to be. The course will be more difficult for the good player. in the moderate player, will have a much less hazardous journey and a much more interesting time than he has at present. Okay, the moderate player should be able to get around here. Like if he hits a slightly off shot or a bad shot, shouldn't be penalized. Where the professional, if they hit a slightly bad shot, they should be penalized. So it's sort of like big miss to the moderate player, shouldn't be overly penalized.
Professor: And that's something he thought Muirfield wasn't doing well on. And so he went on a great deal about every hole. And
04:48:01 Simpson and his assessments of individual holes
Professor: I'm going to read some highlights. I suggest everybody, you know, put pause on right now. Go read these details because the highlights are awesome. This is hole one. It is a dull, monotonous, indeed a thoroughly bad hole. Six, a perfect hole, a classic. Okay, now remember Maxwell wanted to change hole seven. I mentioned Maxwell wanted to move that green and the club turned him down. For those that have been there, seven's this little par three. simpson writes on seven how anyone failed to notice this site made by nature for a green and greedily sees upon it passes our comprehension if it were necessary we could write page after page about this site but we hope and believe we have said enough in his praise so he saw maxwell's green site and just basically said what an offense yeah that the green wasn't like wasn't put here nine get into your your bunker
04:48:53 The bunker known as Simpson’s Folly
Matt: What's that yeah a s
Professor: A small semi central pot bunker to be made short the green which will be the best and most hated bunker on the whole course let it be called simpson's folly oh
Matt: So he called for he called his shot he said name it after me it yeah it's just a center line bunker that changes the strategy the whole yeah and I was going for it in two and it just like you know turns into a bogey
Professor: Quickly this bunker has been called machiavellian and siren like one of the better bunkers ever created and I'll say a little bit more about his bunkers um in a second so discreet
Matt: Too in terms of you know you're playing safe away from out of bounds but there you go
Professor: Real quick 10 this is really nice a dull monotonous hole which we would prefer to leave alone nothing could be done to improve it and that would be all worthwhile that
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Was Nicklaus's favorite
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Hole he's like like talking about two architects
Matt: Different views to each their own
Professor: 17 one of the best tee shots on the course but it could never be a great hole 18 a very very poor finishing hole and indeed a thoroughly bad one um simpson laid out all sorts of changes they put in some of them not on all of them obviously the bunker on nine went in changed the green on 13 that's the cool little par three
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: All that
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Bunkering on one is actually
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Master
Professor: Class in the gca world and that was his bunkering so if we look at the bunkering on number one which was you know dolman on this hole whatever uninteresting um that is used in the gca world of what strategic bunkering looks like off the tee because it forces your hand so those are three of the major ones that stuck around the work was spoke positively on
04:50:32 A lasting layout and the end of major redesigns
Professor: And a lot of his changes have stuck around with the changes to 113 and nine being significant. And we did move to now 169 bunkers, 67, 75 yards, an increase of 82 yards in his changes. And at this point, we've done our major modifications to the course. We can close the book on changes to the course. Captains make some changes. You know, they add bunkers. Those are almost always reversed by the subsequent captain. So the course, as we know, when Tom Simpson leaves with some minor changes here and there, that's where we're at today.
Matt: Is there other stuff on the golf course you want to mention?
Professor: Basically every open plate from here forward, we don't leave the open thinking, what are we going to do to the course? They truly move into, call it their best era of championship golf for the next, I mean, we could say to now a hundred years or 90 years where the Walker cups, the Curtis cups, the amateurs, the opens. nobody's leaving this property saying, man, they need to make some changes. Even with the technological changes, we move into a baked open in 2013 that we might talk on a little bit. You just don't have any sort of issues with, man, we got to blow this thing up. We need more land. We need to change the routing. The course we play today is rather similar to that 1920s and 1930s version. obviously adding some tees here and there and pushing back yardage to the combat, the growing distances that occurred.
Professor: But bunker wise, routing wise, design wise, we're stable.
Matt: And so they have this, yeah, more permanent golf course, right? And I think it's probably a good time to now talk about the experience that the club has there. So professional golf is clearly... not
04:52:17 The club first and the role of the secretary
Matt: Just professional golf, amateur championships, championship golf is a big part of their evolution where they see themselves residing, that they should be the stewards of this golf course that is going to be this great test moving forward. And we'll come back to a lot of those championships, but they're a club first, as we've been saying, like there is always about their play. So let's talk a little bit about the clubbiness at this time.
Professor: I would say the emergence of the importance of the secretary.
Matt: Yes.
Professor: For the next 90 years, I might contend is the most critical position at Muirfield in terms of its direction. Because I think the championships are held when they're held. They want their course to showcase great golf in a proper way during that week. And they want a great champion crown.
Matt: Weeks of the year [unclear]
Professor: Don't care about that they only care about their internal affairs the execution of the club certainly when guests come do guests have a good experience although that's not true through that entire period that's not always attention just the ongoing execution of the club for its members becomes a story of the next 90 years and those that served as secretary play a huge role in molding that into what we know as Muirfield today.
Matt: They really do. And the secretaries, they were members always.
Professor: Always, yeah.
Matt: That service to the club, that service to others, that idea that you're not bigger than the collective is true, right? That's why they don't name a bunch of things after a bunch of people. Yes, they have the...
04:54:10 A poem about serving the membership
Matt: Beautiful portraits that hang the clubhouse. But yeah, I like that you zoned in on the secretary. You know, in my spirit of poems for this one, there was Brian Evans' Loam.
Professor: Oh, you're taking this one.
Matt: Yeah, so.
Professor: Love this one. I'm so excited. You'll give it so much more justice than I will.
Matt: No, I'm going to let you do the details on him. Let me just read this poem as it relates to the secretaries of the Honourable Company. Club members to me, I think you'll agree. are as to a shepherd his sheep. I chase them off here and pen them in there, and I count them as I go to sleep. I have to listen as their eyes glisten, and they tell me of marvelous putts. All I've seen them sink is a great deal of drink. It's gradually driving me nuts. They tell me with force what to do with the course and how drinks are cheaper in pubs. ever was pressed, what they could do with their clubs. And when at last the ultimate blast of the dear old trumpet calls, they'll all expect me on the first fiery tea with a box of asbestos balls.
Professor: Despite him saying this, he ends up being made an honorary life member, right? So at this time, the secretary is no longer a member, I believe. So let's rewind. Who is this guy?
Matt: He was...
04:55:37 Postwar leadership and the guest experience
Matt: As many of the secretaries before and after a military man.
Professor: Hence Colonel.
Matt: Yes, hence Colonel, correct. I think he was commissioned in the cavalry originally, the King's Royal Irish Hussars. He served just all different roles in the military. He had 17 years at Muirfield. He was also very stern but happy, just a cheerful person that people wanted to be around. He himself would always say, I live a wonderful life. Members were always cited saying that. I did like this recount of his time there. He said, we were a team, the members, the clubhouse staff, the greenskeepers, the caddies. As for Logan, the legendary head greenkeepers, here was an adversary worthy of his steel. He fought me, recalls Evan Lohm. with reminiscent relish. But I had the last word. And besides, in order the better to take him on, I had traveled to Yorkshire to take a fourth night course in greenskeeping. So he was getting these arguments with a greenskeeper who he clearly respected and cared for, but he wasn't going to lose the fight.
Matt: So he made sure he had all the knowledge to do it.
Professor: His role was critical because he also took over as a secretary when they're moving out of World War II. So I think 1947. was when he took over. It was a critical time. And he thought, my role is for the betterment and health of the club. That is entirely my role. I need to do anything that does that. So this was being very strict at times. So he had a known reputation for tracking you down on bike on the course. That is, if you were a trespasser or if you were someone as a member misbehaving in whatever way, he would get on a bike. He had a telescope. that he would keep tabs of the golf course. So attentive to the membership that one of the better stories was he saw a guest in the smoking room and he walked up and asked who the guest was.
Professor: It was a member of 20 years. The member told him that. His response was, quote unquote, in that event, you should come more often than I would recognize you.
Matt: This is an inspiration to general managers everywhere.
Professor: So very, very tough guy. But also, he was the one that paved the way for the guest experience as we now know it. He saw it as his duty with the membership. It was to make sure, again, they're having a good time at the club. They're getting a good member experience, but they're staying in line. It's that duty of the club you have as a member where you look at the best clubs you go to. The members do show a line. They're not just getting to act however they want. They have a decorum to them. And the guest experience, though, needs to be. 10 out of 10. The guest has to get a different experience of that, where the member's got to be watching over their shoulder a little bit for him. Well, he wanted to give tours to the guests to showcase the club's history and traditions, the rules, everything about the club, the pictures and the portraits, give them to understand the clubhouse, everything about the Honourable Company he wanted the guests to get.
Professor: He wanted to make you feel like a part of the club when you came. So when you left from the Honourable Company in the Muirfield Greens, You could take it with you. You could talk about it. And he was the one in his 17 years that kept pushing that forward. So you got that experience as a guest.
Matt: Well, Professor, not for every visitor and guest. I did find maybe one element.
04:59:01 Wartime experiences and the treatment of visitors
Matt: Of his character that would be surprising based on all these accounts from members and maybe not based on his military service. So he did serve in World War II. He fought in the Far East.
Professor: Landed during D-Day.
Matt: Landed during D-Day. And when you see a picture of this gentleman, Colonel Evans Loam was, again, back to the mustache. If you just want to be a tough dude, you got to grow a mustache. You and I have no chance.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: We have no chance.
Matt: But he was a sturdy, brick house of a man and uh and a tough guy and obviously with these comments of how he operated as secretary it tracks and it was good for the club and and but but a happy man except for when the visitors were coming at this time as you've established um and he was still in that secretary seat once they began to see japanese visitors oh and so there are a few accounts of uh he was not happy about that. You know, he
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 05:00:00 ==========
Matt: Fought the Japanese in World War II and his comment, if they ever called for those coveted tee times, he would say, while looking out over an empty golf course, sorry, we're full up. So it wasn't everybody that was welcome.
Professor: We are in the 1940s, right? But a
Matt: Lovely man, other than that. Other than, yeah. There's so many actually secretaries that I came across and it really does speak to this.
05:00:29 Club service finances and visitor access
Matt: Everything you said around the harmony of members and staff and leadership of the club with leadership of the members, that part of their DNA, I think it was passed down to most clubs, at least in the UK. And not so much subservience versus service. Everybody had to be of service or else, what are you doing? And I do appreciate that. There was Rob McGregor. Okay, Rob McGregor was the captain. Patty Hanmare. was the secretary.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: I do have that.
Matt: And there's just a little quip I love about his review of the club finances. He was surprised that there was very little planning going on when he stepped in for the club's finances. I guess the yearly figures were in the red. And as new secretary, his solution was going to get more visitors playing at the course. It's our best asset. We should be sharing it. That's how he predominantly felt. Only he was told, and this is where Robin McGregor comes in, if it could be done without upsetting members, then sure, go ahead. And his response, this is Petty Hanmer, who is a captain, by the way, another military man.
Professor: In the Navy, I believe, right?
Matt: His response to Robin McGregor was, damn it, we employ seven greenskeepers and they are lucky if they meet up with one member a week. So this was a window of time the American traveler especially was going to start coming.
Professor: And you saw a switch back in terms of the guest experience too, that Patty was pretty tough on the guests when they came in. There are stories of... insults slam telephones just staring dressing down americans you know in actually in front of their guests more of actually the members that he was hard on um he I should say he was a little bit nicer towards the guests but man he held a hard line with members and really all golfers the tea could be empty and there's stories of him may holding them for an hour for whatever reason um and during this time period
05:02:36 Watson Crenshaw and a hickory match
Professor: They started to develop that reputation of being a rude golf club because of his thing. Now, obviously, internally, they were okay with him and the way he was running things.
Matt: Did you get this story of Tom Watson and Ben Crenshaw?
Professor: Oh, is this after Tom had won the Open? Yeah. Oh, yeah. Tell this one.
Matt: Last night of the 1980 Open. Yeah, this one's great. Tom Watson and Ben Crenshaw, after Watson wins, they went out after dinner to play a quick Hickory's match. So they had Hickory's in the clubhouse and, you know, they just went down the 10th and 18th. It was just a two-hole match. Well, the old Sea Dog, as they referred to him, was still around. And, of course, he stormed out and said, what the hell are you doing out here?
Professor: And they just won the Open.
Matt: And so Watson told that story at some point. And he escorted them kindly back to the Gray Walls Hotel.
Professor: He has
05:03:32 The rhythm of a day at Muirfield
Professor: Some great quotes too. But one of the best was journalists actually asked him how long it took Muirfield. And his response was two and a half hours, two and a half hours, and two and a half hours. And they're like, two and a half hours for the first nine, second nine, whatever. He goes, no, it's two and a half hours for the morning round, two and a half hours for lunch, and two and a half hours for the afternoon round. His tenure as secretary was really focused on that sort of cadence being part of the experience, Going into today's world, if you travel there on a Tuesday or Thursday as a guest, that is essentially the experience you know. From the time you tee off one, the time you finish your 36th hole should be about that span of time.
Matt: Yeah, and this is probably the place to interject the club culture. I will say from my experience in 2022 of going to the Honourable Company, I was still... thinking of that Patty Handmere experience. And I was really expecting that. It couldn't have been anything different. You were with me. It was definitely the type of place that you did feel welcomed, but you also were made clear of your expectation. And I think they were overly patient in making sure you understood that expectation. And so... I could have used a little bit more instruction around lunch. I know we got yelled at for taking the wrong plate in the wrong line.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: We.
Matt: I was very scared.
Professor: Do not skip the stations.
Matt: I might have had my Kummel before I ate, but it was this remarkable lunch that... had this efficiency to it, particularly their staff. And the secretary was there, and I would venture to guess that they served in the military as well, because that's how they look at that two and a half, two and a half, two and a half. Obviously, it's been adjusted. It's a much longer day for their staff. But those expectations, as long as those can be set, it makes for just a fantastic day.
Professor: Reflecting You know what I keep coming back to in this section? It's not the slam telephones.
Matt: The old sea dog? The old
Professor: Sea dog. Well, it's the first thing Paddy Handmere did when he took the job. He opened the books.
Matt: And there was no plan. The yearly figures, all in
Professor: Red. Right. And instead of panicking, he asked a question no one was asking. What's the most valuable thing we own that we're barely using? The golf course. Share it with the visitors, he says. The captain draws a line. Fine. as long as it doesn't upset the members. And Handmere's answer cut through a sentiment that was inhibiting the club's ability to evolve. We employ seven greenskeepers, and they're lucky if they meet one member a
Matt: Week. One of my favorite quotes, but also, that's as clean as a description of the right person, a senior operator in this case, stepping into the right seat. Find the plan, find the asset, work inside the board's constraints, and run the playbook with discipline and attention to detail. Two and a half hours for four ball. Two and a half hours for lunch, two and a half hours
Professor: For foursomes. Which is why we wanted to come back to our partner Inglewood
05:06:40 Inglewood and planning for growth
Professor: Here. The first time we talked about them, the club was in crisis. That's the turnaround side of what they do. But the other half of their work is exactly this. A sound business that needs a seasoned hand in a key seat. Interim
Matt: Leadership, fractional CFOs, board advisory, EOS or other business operating system implementations, strategic planning, succession planning, and enterprise value work. In their words, making a sound company stronger and a strong company great.
Professor: One of their core values is be honest and transparent. Much like patty hammer to the captain, they tell clients what they need to hear, not what they
Matt: Want to hear. Probably the most patty hand mirror value imaginable. If you own a company that's plateaued or one that's growing faster than your systems can handle, or you're on a board that knows it needs a steadier hand and a key seat, Inglewood. has been having that conversation since 1983.
Professor: Inglewood, senior experts for critical business transitions. Start the conversation at ingw.com and tell them that Matt and the professor sent you.
Matt: All right, professor. The course is mostly settled. Let's get back to it. Much of the storytelling of
05:07:53 Club stories foursomes and the pace of play
Matt: Both their past histories and just the daily matches seems to be at the heart of its clubbiness. The energy that they could now direct towards not worrying about the course meeting a certain standard. And they became much more secure and confident as they were at Leith, as they were at Masabura. And because of that, they probably put a lot more energy into their own golf, plus hosting these big events, right? Those both took... A tremendous amount of coordination. But I always felt like there was caring consideration given to the story of the match. And we hopefully have established enough about the four ball. I'm sorry, foursomes. And that's the preferred play of the members of Muirfield is to not play your own ball, but to play as a pair alternating shots. And even to... The degree where when you look out at the tall grass, the fescue grass that is on Muirfield, you see these soldier lines.
Professor: And you're just like, what are
Matt: People doing? How is there a line through the fescue over there? And then you start to realize, oh, from the last green, that's where the alternating player is clearly going to walk. Why can they play in two and a half hours? That's because they're playing all shot.
Professor: Yeah, one of the famous quotes around that, and this notice hung on the wall for a long time. I think it might still be hanging. But notice said, four ball games are forbidden at weekends and on public holidays. Any member or visitor who attempted to break this rule would get short and shrift. If it be retorted that a player plays twice as many shots in a four-ball game as in a foursome, the Muirfield man would reply, play 36 holes in four and a half hours as we do, and you will get the same number of shots, twice exercise, far more fun, and you won't have to wait between shots. Furthermore, you will learn to play golf better.
Matt: In the club culture, I loved a couple things around greenskeeping. You know, that care for the course continued in their culture. Um, so a big part of the, the clubbiness and I love this. Did you realize in the 1970s over in the UK courses, even links courses like.
05:10:15 Greenkeeping trends and a return to links conditions
Matt: Lake Muirfield, they began just watering and fertilizing and they fell victim to just that access. So the 1970s was really marked by this time where there was so much change going on around the green keeping and the new technology of pesticide use and water and whatnot. That tender meadow grass started to come. And if you love links Golf, you know where this is going. You're probably thinking. oh hell no yeah like soft cushy fertilized grass growing on top of this round bouncy flat fescue like get out of here you can feel that with your foot joys that it's just a better place to play and so this was awful well there was a particular summer in the 70s where it died out with heat and drought and so thankfully that period of time was short-lived but they all returned back to the ancient way of taking care of the golf courses.
Matt: And Muirfield, you'd be surprised because Muirfield was the club that always seemed to be at the cutting edge of green keeping in the way that was natural, was the way the links golf was intended to play.
Professor: Yeah, I think we're all susceptible to changing trends and no one is excused from that or we circle back on?
05:11:43 The case for continuing to host championships
Professor: Some of the opens of this era
Matt: I think we should I I think let's pick some of our favorites because we got to get to a finale still as well
Professor: No I want to start us off with a quote from colonel broughton who I believe was a captain of Honourable Company um relative to their relationship with the opening because again we're now in an era where man they're holding up bangers of opens but also they're very just concerned with themselves kind of insular just sort of self-reliant and really focus on being prideful what they are as a club. He raised, the question now arises whether we still want to be considered for future opens. The committee are firmly of the opinion that any convenience caused to members and the hard work which it entails is more than compensated by the financial gains and the prestige it brings to the club. If Muirfield ceased to be a championship course, the number of visitors, especially from overseas, would drop. Golan would suffer financially as well.
Professor: Members will lose the opportunity of seeing the World Stars play on their own course at little cost and under reasonable conditions for spectating, and the Greening staff will lose a great deal of incentive in keeping the course in first class condition. Accordingly, I hope you will agree with the committee's view that if the Royal and Ancient consider our facilities adequate, we should like to be considered for future opens in any other major tournament. which they, the Scottish Golf Union, or other similar official governing bodies sponsor. We see their tie to championship golf. We see that it's truly inseparable relative to what the club sees as the best interest for them as a club and maintaining their clubbiness and how they want to enjoy the game.
Matt: That's great. I am remembering some more clubbiness before we get to those championships. You know, there's this medals themselves. [unclear] play
05:13:24 Medals handicaps and dinner matches
Matt: On sunday what is real
Professor: Quick what is a medal for those that might not be familiar with the scottish clubs what does a medal mean because I don't know if our entire audience is familiar with that it's
Matt: Their stroke play they are hitting cups as I like to say and and scoring their ball um they're used as handicapping um it's they're competitive and you want to win the medal right you get a medal every time you win the medal I do love And this is statistically a reality is overseas, handicaps are generally higher. The ability isn't. I mean, if you [unclear] people are people, right? They're going to have the same ability. One big reason is this. They don't count the hit and giggle. And a lot of that is cultural. That stems from these monthly medals that are on the calendar. And they put other medals on the books. And here, you know, the Honourable Company had them. But yeah, that's a huge.
Professor: Even an intentional four ball where you're. in a match, but you're giving putts, you do not put that score in as a handicap, right? For a handicap round in Scotland, 18 cups must be hold.
Matt: Yes. Yeah. And they're a big part of the club and they do put them on the calendar. Now I'm in the 90s, I should reference. So these numbers do jump here and there, but I do love the insights to the clubbiness. So Saturday are the monthly medals. The over-60s crowd plays on Sundays of that same deal with probably the dinner shared in between. The monthly medals in the 90s, they don't draw many more than half a dozen. Oh, interesting.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: I wouldn't have guessed that.
Matt: I know. Even the members... that play will probably be mainly interested in, you know, marking a card for handicap purposes, right? So that's the purpose a lot of times. The primary importance of the handicaps is the part they play in the dinner matches. So we're all the way in the 90s. And I think, I just wanted to bring this up because it reinforces how important these are to the club. The four ball, which are, you know, the heart of the club or the foursome matches. is [unclear] still what the Honourable Company is all about so I I think as we were talking about like what is clubbiness at mirrorfield at this time it's the same thing on steroids that was at muskboro which is the dinner match uh so the clubbiness continues and the thing that I think puts it on the biggest stage the biggest level of boy how do you get into mirrorfield is the attention it gets
05:16:00 Henry Cotton and the 1948 Open
Matt: As the game of professional golf starts to take off. I'll start with 1948. Let's do it.
Professor: Post-World War II. We're out of the war. Let's run through the opens because- Henry Cotter. Banger after banger.
Matt: Yeah, Henry Cotter. Love it. Let's do it. He qualified for his first open also at Muirfield, 1929, which was won by Walter Hagen. So he had a familiarity with it. He did enjoy the place, but like- another thriving links golfer peter thompson in the years that were coming he started thinking about uh the next open the moment the current one ended there was a time after the war where I mean europe was in bad place and uh standards of health and diet weren't there and he had a autoimmune disorder henry
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Connor oh I didn't know that
Matt: Yeah so he actually went to america to get healthy wow he gained a ton of weight he um was really kind of focused on these big events. He got in shape. He came out and he whooped butt. He kicked butt. The anecdote from this open was King George VI actually came out to watch him play when he shot 66. A lot of people in East Lothian always said he was with him for every shot. I guess he came out for like the final nine or something. He was your winner in 1948. Cotton was kind of this physical, muscular guy, which was rare for golf. His wife, Toots, was her name.
Professor: Toots. Toots.
Matt: His wife, Toots, she would always tell people to go, even if they're sitting on the other side of the room, go touch his legs, touch his legs, see how strong they are. She was very proud of her husband's legs. But there was another anecdote that occurred. In order to understand his wife's swing, he put two balloons under his shirt.
Professor: No, he didn't.
Matt: And started to swing on the range at Temple Golf Club with understanding the anatomy of the female and professing to her and some other players like, you know, here's what you got to do.
Professor: Good for Amber, actually, doing that to understand, you know, somewhat, at least partially, the anatomy. That was a course record 66 at the time. Oh, right. Yeah, with the king watching. Again, the king writing his letter wrote, quote unquote, a very good luncheon and thanking the club for the hospitality. Roberto de Vicenzo. Yeah. Siding before his open. That was the first open sighting made a double Eagle two on 17. Oh, I was there. And this was Henry Cotton's third open that he won and did establish himself as the best British golfer since the Vardon Taylor braid trio that had come before him. So really put them in that upper echelon of great British golfers. That third open title and be there 40 years until another British golfer would actually have three open titles.
Matt: You want to take the next one?
05:18:48 Gary Player and the 1959 Open
Professor: Do we go to 1959?
Matt: 1959, yep.
Professor: All right, this was supposed to be played in 1957. I thought you [unclear] the social context would have came across this one, so I'll steal this one from you. They moved to the St. Andrews in 57 because of the Suez Crisis and patrol rationing. Why St. Andrews versus Muirfield? in the Honourable Company I do not know but they did have to move um move that and this actually made them have to hold the amateur and open five weeks apart so this one gary player at 284 it was his third attempt and he was only 23 at the time and took this one home All players still had to qualify. Peter Thompson tied that 66 at Muirfield and is qualifying. And Joe Carr on the other side, on goal in number one, shot a 64 to set both the professional and amateur course records over there.
Matt: Player came with two weeks, maybe prior. He had to have this awkward negotiation with the secretary, Colonel Evans Loam, who was having no intention of creating this precedent where you can just show up whenever you're like. And so he turned him away without permission to play the links. I like it.
Professor: Yeah. Yeah, no preferential treatment. They show up like the other players.
Matt: He was heated player.
Professor: Not surprisingly.
Matt: And he would go on to win the title.
Professor: Yeah so he's going into the final day again playing 36 that final day um he's trailing by eight to start it I believe seven with 27 to play uh went in with the 33 to close it to four strokes out in 34 need to play the final two and one under the title course record he birdied the 17th so he's looking good and tying that course record finds a bunker on on 18 and makes a six this left him so upset that he thought he had blown it away. He says, I walked off that green feeling as if I'd committed a crime. I didn't think for a moment that 284 would be enough. And he actually went back to his hotel and put his head in his hands and cried. The Marine Hotel where he's staying over at North Berwick.
Professor: But the other guys coming down the stretch just all kind of folded up. And Mr. Player happened to get his first open title at 23 years old.
Matt: Yeah, young man. I mean, pretty impressive.
Professor: All
05:21:07 Jack Nicklaus and the 1966 Open
Professor: Right. Now you take the next one, which is 66. That's yeah. As a, as a, as an American, that's a, it's a big one.
Matt: I think the thing I remember most from reading about this one was it's seven years after the Walker cup, but it was fresh in his mind. And he even had said, I never stopped looking back to it. Not only because that match had changed me from a good junior golfer into it. a good golfer, but also because the whole week at Muirfield had a personified sport at its best, people at their best, the world at its best. It was Muirfield. And if anyone could handle it, I could. After all, I was an old Muirfield man. From the 59 experience, just kind of latched onto that club or they latched onto him or both.
05:21:56 Television spectators and the expanding Open
Matt: But yeah, he called himself a Muirfield man and that this was his coming home in a way. He just loved this golf course and he vibed with it quite a bit that week.
Professor: He did complete the Grand Slam by getting this victory. Interesting, during this time period, the tournaments were starting to compete with each other from a business perspective, so eyes actually started mattering. This meant attracting players through prize money, TV rights. Get spectators on the ground, grandstands, tented villages. They had a seating over top of the smoking room during this time period. CCTV, mobile banks, bars. It starts becoming the open at this time. And what better than having Jack Nicklaus against Palmer, Dave Thompson, Phil Roger, Doug Sanders. And Nicklaus outlasts all of them. Plays a one iron, three iron into the final green. two putts and takes home the title and this is where he broke down afterwards and asked if he could have a second and do you mind if I just enjoy this moment as he um celebrated in front of getting the Claret jug
Matt: You
Professor: Real quick side note on this, the R&A you know has taken over. This is one of the first times they decided to make significant course conditioning changes and they grew up the rough everywhere. So Nicklaus played a fundamentally different course in terms of playability. This time he only used driver 17 times around the golf course. This is also where even the longtime critics are coming to acknowledge that Muirfield and the Honourable Company might be the best championship hosts out there. There's a quote from a longtime critic of the Honourable Company and everything said, the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers, which for more than 200 years has been the name of the club which now plays at Muirfield, have always kept... themselves to themselves. After all, it is their club, and long may they be allowed to preserve their rules and customs.
Professor: But they have courted criticism in the past at championship time, and sometimes it has been justified. This time, the resounding success of this championship was due entirely to the members of the Honourable Company who, by their own contributions, set out to make the championship the best to date. And they did. They did. So we see it's truly entrenched.
Matt: Well, it keeps going with the winners. 1972.
Professor: 72.
05:24:15 Lee Trevino Tony Jacklin and the 1972 Open
Professor: We are with Lee
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Trevino.
Professor: Breaks a British heart.
Matt: He does. I think most of golf fans in the United States will remember it as Lee Trevino chipping in an absurd amount of times to win.
Professor: Five or six, I think, across the entire tournament.
Matt: And overseas, they will remember, without a doubt, the heartbreak. Of Britain's favorite golfer, Tony Jacklin. That's right. Which stuck with him for a long time.
Professor: He had a quote. I was playing the best golf of my life. When Lee chipped in, it was like a physical blow to the stomach. It didn't seem fair. I've always said that Lee didn't beat me that day. God did.
Matt: Yeah.
Professor: Do you know the story of the chip?
Matt: I have from Jacklin's perspective. So he said that. Trevino had played sideways out of the bunker, hit his third into the left rough, his fourth over the green, and he had given up. He simply took a club out of his bag. He looked frazzled. This is in Jacqueline's biography. He never lined it up. He took one look and hit the chip just like you would when you want to get the job over. And incredibly, it went into the hole. So obviously, Jacqueline's seeing him make a mess of the hole. He's seeing the championship come his way. He's got 16 feet pin high. And then that happens. What follows is, and you can see this documented, and I'm sure Tony, I wouldn't watch it if I was him, but he lags it up there to two feet short. He misses a short two-footer.
Professor: Trevino admits to it and says, I had given up. I was just trying to get it over with. I didn't even look at the line. I just walked up and hit it. And God put it in the hole. I'm a lucky dog. And that's how Trevino played at the time. He was wanting to do that, where if you had a frustrating hole, he would just walk up and hit the ball. And in this case, it paid off and went in.
Matt: I know we think a lot of Arnold Palmer, but Arnold Palmer met Jacqueline after he came off the 18th green. He said, whatever you do, try not to let it affect the way you think. Jacqueline tried, but he was quoted in that same biography, the most significant thing which happened to me in my golf by tenfold. It was the worst shock I've ever had on a golf course. It was such an important event. It was the one tournament that means more to me than any other in the world. And the only saving factor was that I'd already won an Open. If I'd never won one, then it would have been even worse. So yeah, he really was affected by this one.
Professor: So we've got Nicklaus. We come off Mr. Player. We move up to 1980. So
05:27:12 Tom Watson and the 1980 Open
Professor: Nicklaus Blair, Trevino.
Matt: Watson. I mean, the hitters keep coming.
Professor: The links master. Tom Watson.
Matt: Three Americans in a row. How do you think they felt about that at Muirfield?
Professor: Not good, appropriately so. But Muirfield being one of the more quote-unquote fair tests of open links golf, I think there's a reason for that, that Americans often do play well there.
Matt: Yeah, and obviously the links master, Tom Watson, was a welcome champ. Not only was Muirfield known as being a place that legends of the game were victorious, Tom Watson was known as the greatest links golfer of his generation.
Professor: He ran away with this one. 271 over 72 holes. Aoki shot a third round 63. That'd be the Open Championship lowest ever single round score. And obviously [unclear] to Muirfield. course record but despite that no one really touched them by all accounts this seemed like also a little bit of the passing of the guard so you've got jack's generation arnold's generation sort of trevino Gary Player, just all-time greats, especially from the American side. But this really signaled to Watson becoming one of the forefronts of American golf in terms of just how dominant this performance was at a course in which, if you are dominant on Muirfield, you truly are the best player that week. There is no faking it around there and fluking it for 72 holes. Well, you alluded to an American run here at Muirfield. That changes, though, as we moved to 1987.
Professor: Why
05:28:48 Nick Faldo and the 1987 Open
Professor: Don't you take us to that next Open Championship?
Matt: On the tee, Nick Faldo. So Nick Faldo in the late 80s and 90s was fascinating.
Professor: Do you remember much of him? Were you old enough? I was born in 82, so I do have some... memories of him, especially early 90s.
Matt: The 90s are far more the big, ugly, cotton, long polos. That's where my memories started to kick in. But I went back and actually watched these moving forward. And one, he's a unit. The man is a big dude. Two, Fanny's on the bag. She was just a rarity in herself. There wasn't...
Professor: In one of the best loops in the game.
Matt: And just phenomenal at what she did. Their chemistry was fascinating to watch. And you can just tell he was such a diligent machinist, almost precision. He almost would have been a secretary of the Honourable Company.
Professor: Oh, I never thought of that comparison. He would be a fantastic.
Matt: He would. And he had a long, fluid, tempoed golf swing. But he was a
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 05:30:00 ==========
Matt: Technician. You know, you just tell he was out there. digging it out every single time, never wasting a shot it felt like.
Professor: This is a famous final round by him. So it's a misty har. The har is coming in on Sunday. And if you've been to East Lothian during the har, you might see the ball 50 yards in front of you. Maybe it's a very difficult condition to plan because you might not get your head up in time to even see where your ball's going. Prior to this, he had been nicknamed Nick Foldo. for not finishing off tournaments. Faldo had reshaped his game by working with Ledbetter. He was reflective enough to say, yeah, I am struggling to finish. Work with Ledbetter to change up his game. Before
05:30:48 Eighteen pars in the mist
Professor: We get to what the round actually was, Ledbetter was quoted saying, it was the most disciplined round of golf I have ever seen. To go around Muirfield on a Sunday in the mist and not make a single mistake, that wasn't just golf. That was engineering to your point of him being a machinist. Well, he went around in 18 pars on that Sunday. Jack said, people look at 18 pars and think it's boring at Muirfield on a Sunday with the lead on the line. 18 pars is a miracle. So still known to this day as one of the... best rounds in major golf played because of that just steady pace of Muirfield of all places in a [unclear] trying to close out the Open Championship and Nick Faldo gets it done.
Matt: And was that his first?
Professor: That was his first. He said, I knew I'd do it and I knew I had to do it. So he said there was a lot of self-doubt going into this time period with him because again, he wasn't getting it done. So you feel like this is one of the situations that had gone the other direction.
05:31:43 Payne Stewart and his Open attire
Professor: It might have been a Tony Jacklin situation. We might never have heard from Caldo again.
Matt: Interesting all
Professor: Nick Faldo comes in at 272. to go back to back at
Matt: Muirfield that was where he played 200 in the last four holes not 18 straight pars like he did in 87 which looked even worse but uh but he looked spent for this one as
Professor: Well it was a back and forth event in that final round fouled out early on looked tough he had shot a 64 in the second round um setting record 130 strokes over the first 36 holes so that was an open record at the time um but then in the final round john cook made a run. He was four shots behind Faldo.
Matt: Where does John Cook reside from?
Professor: I think Ohio versus the world.
Matt: A little place called Akron, Ohio, born and raised.
Professor: Started four shots behind Faldo, but birdie 12 and 15 and Faldo started to falter again. So Nick Folda might've been back in play. And Cook went on to birdie the 16th to Faldo did find himself two back with four to play. Cook also had an eagle putt at the par five 17th. So, okay, that's, you know, Get this done and move on. Three putted. So this gave Faldo a chance. And like you said, Faldo knew he was faltering. And he actually had a little pep talk with himself. He disclosed us after the round that on 15, he said, you'd better play the best four holes of your life. And his reflection upon the end of the round was, and I managed to do that. One other closing on this with Faldo. So at the time, he had been struggling with his putting.
Professor: And the press had been. brutal on him. So one, he did break down on the 18th hole when he won. You could tell he was fighting some internal demons. When he finished the round and he had an acceptance speech, he said, and obviously without the press, what can I say about the press? Grinning, he added, I thank them from the bottom of my, the heart of my bottom. And then he broke into the famous chorus of Sinatra's My Way. For what is a man, what has he got? If not himself, then he has not. to say the things he truly feels and not the words of one who kneels. The record shows I took the blows and did it my way. He said [unclear] front of the president, he took some criticism afterwards at the same podium. He said he owed Scotland one big scotch and I'm about to send a bottle of Johnny Walker to every pub in Scotland.
Professor: And he was pretty jovial after, but the buildup of that championship, especially at Muirfield. And all that up and down that final round, that release of emotion just lends itself to that sort of candid moment of releasing everything. Shall we move forward to who would probably be a top
Matt: Five
Professor: To eight player of all time if it were not for another individual during his generation? For sure.
05:34:31 Ernie Els Tiger Woods and the 2002 Open
Matt: 2002. This is the heart of you and I in our competitive golf careers. So I was tuned in for this one live.
Professor: I remember this one pretty vividly.
Matt: The 131st Open Championship. It was Ernie Els and his big win. Ernie. I always look at this time, and I know it's the competitive window, especially Ernie, because he's wearing those big striped Adidas shoes. Oh, yeah. He's wearing the pleated baggy pants. He has a giant. you know ashworth type uh cotton golf shirt and uh and that old tailor-made script the 90s script across this beautiful he already won what two u.s opens he had one second place at an open which was st andrews in 2000 when tiger ran away with it no one's going to beat him so to your point of hall of famer tiger going into this one you probably have it tiger won the masters
Professor: It's winning everything
Matt: He won the u.s open So he's going for the third leg of the Grand Slam. He said, I love Muirfield. No hidden agendas. It's the kind of golf course that shows you exactly what you need to do. And you got to go out and get it. Tons of talk about the rough this week, which is now tradition of major championships.
Professor: We're in that era. Grow up the rough.
Matt: Early 2000s, absolutely. The secretary of the Honourable Company was quoted. He said, it's long, but I've certainly seen it longer. So I like that one. Els had a top five finishes nine times at the open.
Professor: Rewind 10 years prior, when we told the story of Faldo and Cook, both unraveling and Faldo got it done. We left Ernie out of that story. He shot a final round 74 to finish fifth. Muirfield always stuck on his mind as that one that got away because everybody else was unraveling. If he had just played a steady round, he'd have been right there and arguably won the 92 Open.
Matt: Yeah, it was at the year he opened with 66.
Professor: He was the low ball. That might have been right.
Matt: There were some characters. It wasn't just Tiger and Ernie in this. There's some characters in this one.
Professor: What's your favorite? Start with your favorite.
Matt: I got two. Maybe three.
Professor: This is a draft. Go with your first.
05:36:45 Duffy Waldorf and the arrival of severe weather
Matt: Duffy Waldorf.
Professor: Oh, I didn't have that one on my bigger list. What do you got with Duffy?
Matt: Duffy was wearing a Hawaiian shirt and he shot 67 to lead the tournament at minus four. The British press are asking him about his thoughts on links golf. I mean, he looks like he's on vacation with a family of six. And they're asking him what he likes about links golf. And he goes, all that sunshine? I don't think I've played links golf yet. That was American golf, my friend. So the weather was perfect to open. Now, was that a precursor?
Professor: That was a mistake. Was that a precursor? So he's the one that cursed the golf gods. Golf gods are fickle.
Matt: Who's your favorite character?
Professor: Oh, I'm going Monty then. We foreshadowed. I gotta go Monty. So the golf gods decide all this good weather you've had on Thursday, Friday, even somewhat Saturday morning, we're done with that. We're bringing in the weather.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Arguably,
Professor: In modern day history, especially with TV, the worst major championship weather today ever. If you haven't watched this on YouTube, pull this up. Umbrellas going everywhere. Spectators are running for shelter. Things are flying everywhere. People are struggling to walk. Sustained 25, 30 mile per hour wind, 40 mile per hour gusts, balls moving sideways rain. It's cold. No matter who you are, you're not playing golf this day.
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Even my biggest
Professor: Sicko friends were inside. staring out the window waiting for this weather to break. Circling back to Monty. Do you know how he handled the weather? I can see it, but how would you describe it? He went out on the course without any rain gear. No waterproof jacket, just a wool jumper. So he has this wool-soaked, just rain wool-soaked jumper, just squeezing to him of freezing rainwater, just sagging all around, restricting his swing, wearing a soaking wet leather glove. This weather's so bad, the rain gear doesn't even matter. I'm just going to tough it out wearing my normal stuff. And goes out and shoots an 84, to which Tiger, supposedly on the range on Sunday, yelled down, hey, Monte, I sure whipped your butt yesterday.
05:38:59 The bunker shot and the playoff for Els
Matt: Oh, man. There was a shot on Sunday where Ernie hit out of the par 3-12, the deepest of the pot bunkers. Kind of an awkward stance. His big frame, having to really drop his hands and his knees low to the ground. And he hits this unbelievable shot out of this bunker that he had to come straight up. carry 20 30 yards and so that he has said multiple times that's one of the greatest shots I've ever hit and anybody that knows the course the members of the Honourable Company were just blown away by by that one shot it doesn't look that but when you really start to size up the scale of it you start to realize oh he was dead and and he walked away with par yeah
Professor: Which is yeah So he ends up in a playoff. Ernie takes care of it, to which he said, at times I thought I would never get my hands on this. It is one of the hardest tournaments I have ever had to play, but it has been the most rewarding.
Matt: LeVay, who I think would be an ideal teammate by what I watched in the video. LeVay picked Ernie up on his shoulders, which frankly is more impressive than winning an Open Championship. Ernie is a big man. Thomas LeVay, not so much, but apparently they were good friends. traveling
05:40:23 Technology and the review of the course before 2013
Matt: Around on the dp world tour the european tour together and um that was that was a cool effort of sportsmanship all Professor, I just realized we've spent that entire segment doing an impromptu fashion review of the Open Championship.
Professor: Hey, I love my golf gear.
Matt: Faldo in those long, baggy cotton polos in 87, and by 92, they'd somehow gotten worse. Duffy, leading the Open in a Hawaiian shirt, and Monty in a wool jumper soaked through
Professor: To the bone. An unsurprising 84 strokes. If you aren't dressed
05:40:55 Holderness & Bourne and Open Championship apparel
Professor: Well, you aren't playing well. which
Matt: Is why we wanted to come back to the founding partner of our new series, Holderness and Bourne. Alex and John started that company because they were tired of that type of ill-fitted dress. And in a place with finicky forecasts like East Lothian, you and I both know, Professor, a classic style with a signature fit earns its keep. Let's talk layering.
Professor: Merino cashmere sweaters, quarter zips, quilted jackets, and vests. They look great in the clubhouse. And on the course, they still let you make a full turn once 50 degrees at nine and sideways rain by noon. At the 2022 U.S. Open at the Country Club, the weekend turned cold and windy. Layering was the name of the game. And Alex and John were right there on site, keeping the shelves refilled as they emptied.
Matt: Now that's the Holderness and Bourne I know. Professor, you know Andrew Bailey. Of course,
Professor: Everyone does.
Matt: Andrew is a national accounts rep at H &B and a good friend of ours. I met him about 10 years ago when we both qualified out of the same site for the U.S. Amateur 4-ball. The same year I started New Club Golf Society. A few weeks earlier, I had tried on my first H &B polo, and I knew then I'd be calling Mr. Bailey first. Andrew has helped stock our shop and style our membership ever
Professor: Since. And you know who else Andrew helped stock? At last year's U.S. Open at Shinnecock. He worked in a merchandise tent right there beside the rest of the H &B team.
Matt: And this fall, he won the U.S. Mid-Amateur at the Lido. That means next June, the guy who was selling shirts at the U.S. Open will be in the field at Pebble Beach. Wow.
Professor: I had not thought about that as a way to get out of work. Just go win a national championship. Hey,
Matt: Congrats to Andrew. He's a passionate steward of the amateur game and a tremendous representative for the holderness and Bourne brand and their values.
Professor: And now one more for the historians out there. One of their best-selling straight polos is called the Maxwell. As
Matt: Fans of golf course architecture, I'm pretty sure I know which Maxwell they had in mind with that one. But on this episode, there's only one Maxwell professor, and he's your favorite Muirfield man.
Professor: Guilty as charged. So whether you're heading to Muirfield, Scotland, Hutchinson, Kansas, or just your Saturday morning four ball, find Holderness and Bourne in your pro shop or at hbgolf.com.
Matt: Holderness and Bourne, premium apparel made with a signature fit. All right, professor, take us back to Muirfield.
Professor: All right, so now we get to fast forward to 2013. that's right now before we jump there yeah do you know what happened in 2007 they held the senior open we're not going to cover that
Matt: Well it was a big time winner that won the senior tom watson
Professor: There's just the golf course because we have our technology boom the solid core ball has come along The high caliber players, they're training better. We're starting to learn a little more about the swing. We're learning more about power. So they need to look at the golf course and figure out what are we going to do about that. Luckily, we don't have to change the layout. So R&A sends Martin Hawtree to the club. Here's what he walks away with. I think just encapsulates so much of what Muirfield has been since the 1920s now. Rare are those golf courses that have remained truly unaltered since their inception. Muirfield is such a case with its layout altered. since its actual inception but not since 1920 the colt routing is a masterpiece which complements Muirfield's biggest strengths that he developed very demanding bunkers challenging fast and firm greens and surrounds and rough line just off the fairways and of course not of colt's hand but taken into account by him the hidden hazard of the wind so they left with saying the course that is here is the course that should be here this stands the test of time at the same time because
Professor: Of technology we got to start moving things back. So they did go through and introduce some driving area bunkers and did a bunch of new teas, also recaptured some greens, enlarging them and getting them back to their standard from the 20s, 30s, and 40s. And this pushed the course all the way to 7,200 yards. So that is the one in these last 100 years from where we sit now, this would be the major changes that occurred primarily just in new tea boxes.
05:44:53 The dry conditions of the 2013 Open
Professor: And then that carries us towards 2013, certainly one of the more infamous open championships amongst the collection of infamous championships they have.
Matt: This is a good watch, you know. Oh, it's so good. Going, sitting down, I was slowly working through these, building up to our recording, and I waited, went in chronological order as we have today, but I was definitely looking forward to it. Ernie won the year prior. Oh, that's right. Ernie's game wasn't great, and he squeezed out this win at Royal Lithum, and he got to bring the Claret Jug back to the site that he had won at. I thought that was a really cool piece of it. Didn't play great. The woes continue, but it was dry. And I remember how dry it was. It was so brown, and it's a really fun watch. Five irons are going. 350 yards, but it didn't matter because now you got to hit in over that wrong angle to a slope that isn't going to be friendly.
Matt: I loved watching.
Professor: I think there's an argument for the course. actually not being intended to play under that firm of conditions. Even Carnousi, you can make the argument the course is meant to play that way. I think the way when Muirfield was built, who was built by, the strategic design, the intentionality, it was a design golf course versus a golf course that was found and evolved. It wasn't necessarily meant to play that way.
Matt: The R&A video production crew had a series of clips of... players describing the conditions and just some of the words I had to write down. Scorched earth, bone dry, rock hard, parched grass that needs a drink, brown and yellow with very little green and baked out. Those are all words I heard.
Professor: They wouldn't even try to chip. If
05:46:49 Phil Mickelson and adapting to links golf
Professor: They were anywhere inside 50 yards, because it was so firm, your chips wouldn't hold. You couldn't predict.
Matt: So with everything we know about the Honourable Company now, what do you think they thought of this?
Professor: So I think they got a proper championship and a proper winner. And this is Mickelson overcame his Open Demons. You know, it just won the Scottish Open. Did that rare? He might've been the first to win the Scottish and then the Open.
Matt: It is. Yeah. First one to win the week before with the Scottish Open at Castle Stewart. a modern links course, and then he wins here.
Professor: And so I think they got all of that. At the same time, in terms of their presentation of that course and how they want to play and how it's designed to play, I bet they're like, ah, we would prefer it not be that baked out and not be those conditions, would be my guess.
Matt: Well, it was a really unusual heat wave. So no links course was going to be... any more playable. Do you know who Phil played with the first two days?
Professor: I don't know who Phil played with.
Matt: It was Rory McIlroy.
Professor: Oh, this is fuzzy hair Rory. He looks like a driver head cover at this time. He's got his Jeremiah shirt or whatever on. Terrible outfits.
Matt: A little bit. He was all Nike at that.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Oh, so he'd gotten a Nike.
Matt: He'd gotten all Nike.
Professor: He'd got the baggy pants.
Matt: But he was paired with Phil. And it was such a contrast. Phil was very measured. Phil taught himself how to play links golf. McKay would say one of the most impressive and proud moments for both Phil and I was how we won the Open Championship. Because our style, the way that we played, was anything but fit for links golf. And we adapted to it. We prepared for it. And we got it done. You know, Phil has some fascinating stats, obviously. he's the
05:48:45 Club selection and the winning strategy
Matt: Only person to win a major with two drivers in the bag. Okay. And zero drivers in the bag. Okay. Which one do you think this was? This was, this
Professor: Was two drivers in the bag era, right?
Matt: This, he had zero drivers.
Professor: He had drivers. Oh, this is the Frankenstein three woods. Yeah. It's definitely a three wood. It makes sense with how fast it was.
Matt: It's not like a mini driver or anything like that.
Professor: Yeah, it was cranked down to like 12 degrees or 11 degrees or whatever it was.
Matt: Yeah, so yeah, he hit a lot of fairways for Phil. That's all you had to do with the fairways running as hard as they were. It wasn't a ton of wind, but that was a way that they approached it from strategy standpoint.
Professor: All right, so we're 2013. We're on about, what, every, I don't know, eight to 10-year clip that they're hosting or so. So fast forward to 2023, four, five, maybe account for a COVID year.
05:49:44 Membership policy and the future of hosting the Open
Professor: What's our next Open?
Matt: So we're still left wondering, when is Muirfield going to host again?
Professor: And the question is, why are we left wondering that?
Matt: Why do you think Muirfield hasn't hosted the men since?
Professor: Because they've been told you're not hosting the men. So let's rewind back to just before the 2013 Open Championship. Do we recall what happened in the golf world in 2012 with the United States? 2012. Social issues going on. A lot of attention given to...
Matt: Yeah, people were boycotting the masters and picketing outside of the gates. They didn't allow female members.
Professor: So a lot of eyesight on Augusta during this time, right? We're moving through the late 2000s up into the aughts. Social issues are coming. Augusta takes tons of pressure. Of course, in their due time, they admit women members and announced, I think, in 2012 was when they said, yes, we're going to take on women's members. Of course, 2013, the coincidence or irony that occurs there is an Honourable Company hosts the Open in 2013 coming off the shoulders of this decision by Augusta National, which is in typical Augusta National fashion, made very public. through
05:51:06 The 2016 membership vote and removal from the rota
Professor: A press conference by the chairman, and all the eyes of the world then turned to Muirfield, who's hosting the Open. I don't think it was a huge narrative going into 2013 Open, but it certainly was a narrative around, okay, Muirfield, you don't have female members. We now fast forward to 2016, and they do take a vote. They take a vote in May 2016. The policy has... to reach a two-thirds supermajority. Though the research I did showed they did do a majority decision to admit women members, but they did not reach the supermajority. So they struck it down. We're not going to admit women as members to the Honourable Company. The R&A very swiftly came in, almost immediately, and said, you are stricken from the ROTA. A quote by Martin Slumbers, who was chief executive at the time, said, The Open is one of the world's greatest sporting events, and going forward, we will not stage a championship at a venue that does not admit women as members.
Professor: Scotland's First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, called the decision indefensible. Supposedly, the club had 64 % vote in favor, but that wasn't enough, and they were then immediately removed from the ROTA. let off a little bit of firestorm from, we're talking about a May vote in 2016 to a March situation in 2017. If we would like to venture down that road a little bit.
Matt: I think we need to. This is a huge moment in their history.
Professor: In 2016, they got blistered. You had huge, huge adverse reaction to this. At the same time, you still had people like,
05:52:55 The public response and the role of a private club
Professor: Peter Alice, defending it. Saying the fact is...
Matt: Now, who is Peter Alice for our listeners?
Professor: Peter Alice, a former golfer, turned into a BBC commentator, had a relationship with Muirfield. He said, the fact is, if you talk to the wives of members of Muirfield, they would be horrified at the prospect of being allowed to join. The wives can use all the facilities of the club, but it doesn't cost them anything. If they had to pay to join, they would be horrified. So even people coming out of the defense weren't quite doing. Muirfield a favor obviously the defense is it's a private club they can do it they as they wish this [unclear] is traditions of the club they've been around for hundreds of years following these traditions there are lady clubs that have followed their traditions as a ladies club in scotland It's their decision as well. If the club makes a decision, the R&A as a club can also make a decision in turn, regardless if you do agree or disagree with.
Professor: Obviously, the attack is a much easier case to make here than the defense because the defense is simply their private club and can do as they wish.
Matt: Yeah, it was such an interesting time from, and just like you said with Augusta, I almost forgot about those two things going back to back 2012. So Augusta went through it in 2012. Probably didn't handle it as well as Muirfield. Yeah. I think there is this tradition, as we know from all the things we've read and talked about with the Honourable Company, the Ladies Golf Union, the Ladies Golf Clubs. There's three in St. Andrews, likely to be more in the future. There's still all-male clubs in Scotland today. I think that... there was a very core difference about where you played your golf and the allowance of someone to play upon the course. Yes, they've had women and hosted Curtis Cups and all those things, but because of the unique nature of Muirfield, do I think it became... More of a spectacle.
Matt: People weren't going and knocking on the new club's door. People weren't going to St. Regulus or Ruhl saying, you have to change too.
Professor: Muirfield owned their course. Muirfield has
Matt: The control of their destiny, as we know through this whole story. And I think that was the element of it that contributed to the outrage. But the Open, you know, they pulled it immediately.
Professor: Immediately. It was swift like that.
Matt: Yeah. Almost like maybe they were testing slumbers or something with the R&A.
Professor: I mean, you wonder about the closed door conversations. R&A and Honourable Company have always had a tight relationship. So who knows what those conversations look like and what the R&A might have been trying to pressure them to do. The R&A might have been like, hey, this is what we want. Here are the consequences. The vote occurs. And so the R&A comes out of me and says, all right, well, you know, they didn't pass that. So we're going to pull it right away because we feel it's appropriate as a leading championship in golf to be played at a place that everybody has access as a member, especially with Augusta National now having women members.
Matt: Yeah, it is about the single-sex course versus the single-sex club, right? But also the spotlight that are given to them every few years with these incredible... opportunities
05:56:06 The 2017 vote and reinstatement
Matt: To host these just so many eyeballs fall on the
Professor: Open and this speaks to yeah the complexity of them not just being a club they're a club with a course
Matt: Yeah complexity is a great word for it too no we
Professor: Gotta talk about the the other vote so 10 months go by we move into march 2017 we're going back to vote fresh ballot 80.2 percent of members say we're going to accept female members now and R&A quickly reinstates Muirfield on the road and not that they're hosting yet but yes you can be an open site um for the open championship yeah
Matt: And that obviously led to the 2022 women's open at Muirfield I I watched the clip of their announcement of the passing vote part of me says they learned a lot from the the past votes But it's in the same Honourable Company tone to come out in front of all those cameras. And this is during the 2017 affirmative vote to stand in front of all those cameras and press. And literally the captain reads the minutes. Reads the minutes. Verbitum. And there was no emotion to it. It was just, we're a club doing club things. We had a club vote. And for some reason, you people that are here today want to know about it. So I'll share that with you. When obviously there's a big reason they want to know about it because everyone made a stink the year prior about the failed vote.
Matt: But yeah, I just thought that
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Was so
Matt: Them. It was. To come out and do it that way and then talk about, you know, we'll be reviewing applicants for our membership. I did find one really good interview with Lindsey Garden on our friend John Huggins' podcast. This was only a couple of years ago. The Thing About Golf podcast, where they talk to people about what they love about golf. She's a fascinating individual. In her own right, she played professionally, but she caddied on the European tour. And she just loves the game of golf. As of 2019, there was like 15 female members. She was one of them. And some of her comments were, women members are just members. We go to dinners. We play in our dinner matches. We attend all the same events as the men. We play in these club festivities as... Honourable Company members always have, you should come see, see for yourself and go tell the world.
Matt: He said later, it really should not be about tokenism. If we're going to have women members, they've got to be members just the way anybody else is. And that's why we're not called women members. We're just members, the same as anybody else. She is clearly a person who represents that club now in a tremendous way. And that's where... you
05:58:56 The 2022 Women’s Open
Matt: Know, the lessons come from is that as we know from golf and the people defending the king and the people trying to overthrow the king in Leith, we're able to play that same game together and come together.
Professor: That's right. And respect the traditions of the game. And that's what brings us all together. Right.
Matt: 22, they host the women's AIG, Women's British Open.
Professor: And man, does the course shine. I remember. watching that event and I was glued to how beautiful the golf course played with the women and the style of their game
Matt: Yeah it was a good one and it was dramatic too wasn't it it came down the stretch
Professor: There's something about Muirfield and you know either people taking it by the reins down the stretch or faltering but yet correcting themselves and getting it done and this is of the latter category I'm sure it's really easy when you turn around on the 16th tee and start moving back and you see that clubhouse it's probably really easy to get ahead of yourself and think all right I got this and then all of a sudden Muirfield gets you and now you got to find a way to
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 06:00:00 ==========
Professor: Get back under yourself
06:00:01 The playoff and the celebration of the Women’s Open
Professor: Close it out
Matt: So
Professor: Ashley buhay buhay buhay ends up having a triple bogey on the 15th is what I remember of it I think this thing's over 15 hard par 4 but all right like now you might make a bogey you turn you can get it done and I just remember watching that triple bogey in the 15th hole thinking oh we're seeing someone throw it
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Away um
Professor: And I think it was g chung [unclear] was the other female involved leading to eventually a four hole over over an hour-long playoff between the
Matt: Two. That's right, yeah.
Professor: And you end up with a South African victor who gets to join Gary Player and Ernie Els as the three South Africans that have won an open on the Muirfield golfing leagues. Oh, yeah. I didn't even
Matt: Realize the South African connection for Ashley. But it was cool to see. membership of Muirfield's involvement in that week.
Professor: Catriona Matthew, just an absolute legend, female player, a Muirfield local, North Barrick crew local member. She got to hit the opening tee shot of the tournament and said, growing up just down the road, I never thought I'd see the day a women's open was played here. To see the crowds and the respect the course showed, the players was fantastic by all accounts. Everybody that walked off the grounds, the competitors, the spectators, the members, the locals, just had nothing but positive
06:01:31 Caddies and the history of championship golf
Professor: Things and a celebration relative to them hosting the Women's Open. Well, Matt, I can't let Lindsay Gardner go by that quickly. A Scottish international, a family lawyer, and before all that, a caddy on the European tour. She was on Wayne Riley's bag when he won the Australian Open at what many consider to also be a great club. Royal Melbourne.
Matt: And as a member of the Honourable Company, served on its championship committee, from carrying the bag to running championships on golf's greatest stage.
Professor: That's quite a long way from the four caddies who were fishing featheries out of the watery filth, at least. That's
Matt: Right. And don't forget about another caddy named Lindsey. David Lindsey, at Musselburgh, that is. A ballmaker, a caddy. When his health failed, the club took up a collection and paid him a weekly stipend. After that, help the club keep their
Professor: Records. Two Lindsays, more than a century apart, both distinguished loopers.
Matt: And another one of my favorites, Fanny Sunesson on Faldo's bag at Muirfield in 92. Just more evidence that you can't tell this club's story without the people carrying the bag. Which
Professor: Is why we wanted to come back to our founding partner, the Western Golf Association and the Evans Scholars Foundation. Earlier,
06:02:40 The Evans Scholars Foundation today
Professor: We told you how Chick Evans turned his escrow account into scholarships for caddies. Now it's time to talk about what that became.
Matt: This past year, the 2025-26 school year, a record 1,260 Evans Scholars were in college. And this fall, Arizona State became the program's 28th partner university. These Evans Scholars are on a full tuition and housing scholarship worth more than $125,000 over four years. Since Chick, They've had a total of 12,575 caddies graduate as Evans Scholars. Those scholars carried a 3.3 GPA with a 98 % graduation rate.
Professor: Impressive. And it's paid for the same way the Honourable Company paid to help their friend and caddy, David Lindsay, by the generosity of golfers. We have more than 43,500 Park Club members. Within Lundline, in total, they give back more than $15 million a year. Add to that proceeds from the WGA's championships, including the BMW Championship, the same event that started with the Western Open back in 1899.
Matt: And just as Muirfield didn't stop with their first Open, the WGA has been conducting championships ever since, adding the Western Amateur, the Western Junior, and the women's version of both. And I'll say this one from a personal perspective. I was introduced to the Evans Scholars at my club almost a decade ago, and I was blown away by these kids. how hard they work, how deserving they are, and the doors this scholarship opens for them. I ended up getting involved with WGA on their leadership council, and along the way, I've met so many Evans Scholars alumni who are years down the road. Every one of them will tell you how grateful they are and how much that scholarship and the WGA shaped
Professor: Their lives. I tell you what, I look forward to every time I step on an Evans Scholars club. So here's the ask. Next time you're at the club or playing somewhere with a youth caddy program, take one and ask about their plans. If they're a hardworking kid with good grades and a tough road to college, tell them about the Evans
Matt: Scholarship. And if you want to do what those members did for David Lindsay or add to the legacy of Chick Evans and what he started, join the Park Club at wgaesf.org. And if you're a club member interested in bringing a youth caddy program to your club, the Western Golf Association and the Evans Scholarship Foundation are here to help you out. All right, Professor, let's bring it home.
Professor: I guess we'll cap it off.
Matt: Let's just talk about the legacy. I feel like a lot of the discussion went back and forth between maybe they get too much credit and maybe they don't get enough. Where does it fall now that we have the full picture of the Honourable Company and their history? Where does that influence and that legacy sit with you today?
Professor: That was a tough one. Certainly going into this research project, Muirfield sticks out on the mind up there with, for me, Augusta National, the old course in R&A. Those are the three that's like, okay, they've been the ones that impact Galt, pulling the strings. Maybe I could throw the Shinnecocks in there and some of that world.
Matt: They all have in common, sorry to cut you off, but they all have in common the mystique of their club and the scarcity of the memberships, the elite nature of them, plus hosting very publicly. They almost have the dichotomy of... They're very private, yet
Professor: Really public. Yeah. And Muirfield specifically at that, even more so than probably Augusta National in that they're a little bit more public than Augusta National has ever been. But walking away from this, I really had the sense of the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers are reluctant influencers, are unintentional influencers of golf as we know it, especially clubs. They did not make the same intentional moves to influence the game outside of the way they played it. And what I mean by that is they created articles of rules of golf to play a competition within their club. Until they owned that course, they were very happy to just play the game as they saw fit. Other places certainly adopted their rules and do that and might have been influenced by them, but they were pretty insular and they made movements. To stay insular in that we want a place to play the game as we want to.
Professor: And when that starts getting chipped away, we're going to move away. As the open grew. R&A you take it on like you yeah you need to manage this run this now we'll go run over the Muirfield at the same time and we'll have our little thing here yeah you come we'll come host these tournaments but when the tournament's not being hosted just leave us alone oh you want us to build us you want us to build a putting green for the amateur no we don't want to do that like leave us alone let us like conduct our our game as we want to and certainly that is not to say with the open championship that they didn't want the world to look in at them and be like What a wonderfully hosted championship. Look at that golf course. Look how honorable the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers is.
Professor: They certainly were very prideful in what they had, but at the end of the day, they didn't care if that influenced the world or not. They didn't actually try to look out and go influence the world. And the way I thought I was going to uncover, I thought we were going to see a little bit more intentional impact on the world and meddling. Hey, let us be.
06:08:07 The rules of golf and the template for a club
Professor: Let us play the game as we want. And certainly you can learn from us if you want to, but this is how we do it. And this is how we're going to do it. And we're going to keep doing it this way.
Matt: I mean, just almost objectively, the fact that nine of the original 13 articles, the rules of golf that they put down on paper are still what we use. Like that's insane based on all other sports. You just have to tip your cap to those early attorneys. The guys that put pen to paper and quill to paper and gave us those rules. But then if I take that concept of that being their legacy, not just the rules, really they codified this club template, this way to make a club.
Professor: Oh, 100%.
Matt: And you're so on point. And I was also surprised to learn that it was really for them and their...
06:09:03 Internal priorities and the view of the outside world
Matt: Fellow members. But I do think through all of these eras, they were very self-assured and confident group of golfers. But there were times of clear insecurities. The women votes that we just touched on were certainly one where they're backed into a corner and they're probably very insecure. There were moments of losing the open or moments of our course isn't good enough. And many times our course isn't good enough. And how they reacted to those insecurities. I think you understand them when you understand their insecurities and that they do care about what the outside world does. They make the decisions not based on the outside world. They make their decisions based on what's happening within their club. But they want that out in the world. They want that to be seen. I think quietly, maybe they didn't want to do.
Matt: All the things that the R&A stepped up to do for the game. But I think they still wanted the eyeballs and admiration of the golfing world.
Professor: So do you think they care about what the outside world does or they care about what the outside world thinks of them?
Matt: Thinks of them. And I'm not saying that is a bad thing. That's probably any institution, membership company or otherwise, where you're going to try your best to not care. but inevitably you will. I'll compare their approach to the town council in Leith and commissioning that silver club with the silver balls attached to marching down the street and every year doing that procession and gaining all that attention. I'll equate that to them hosting these open championships.
Professor: I think you have a good comparison there. Expand on that. Why else do it? Yeah.
Matt: You want to be seen. You want it to matter. And we all want to feel like we matter. And I think the Honourable Company is just directing that energy in a certain way. Now, again, life is just a contradiction. On the flip side, where do they find their fulfillment? These conversations with members, these books that members have written, they find their fulfillment in plain. with their membership, playing a team game with their membership.
Professor: Playing a very particular style of game. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt: So legacy and influence, it's like being known for being them and doing what was needed to be known in that way. That's the legacy they left for, frankly, clubs and leaders of clubs that we've seen ever since. Isn't that what I just described? How's that different from any other golf club that we've ever been around?
Professor: Everybody wants to be, one, respected. And I think in this case, they're prideful. And it's around issues of tradition, history. being meticulous what they do, responsibility to the game. They saw all their courses as national assets and they had a duty to those. That meant showcasing them when other people were seeing them, if that's an open championship or just visiting as guests. And
Matt: Other legacies that I'm just now thinking about.
06:12:19 Architecture and championship golf as a combined legacy
Matt: And I'll just combine them into one, architecture and championship golf. And maybe the legacy is actually a fairly successful combination of the two. The constant pursuit of a great golf course architecturally while still staging these incredible championships, that's got to be in there for the legacy bucket.
Professor: Yeah. reading through all the tournament history, including the tournaments they held at Musselburgh, you can see that legacy being put down. Then when they moved to Muirfield, always striving to push it forward. And then once they had it dialed into the course that they thought was worthy of championship golf, that enabled them to just show championship golf through and through every time it came to their grounds. To win at Muirfield is to put yourself in the history books, arguably up there with, I think, the old course. uh and we're going to courses that doesn't don't see championship golf every year uh it's hard to go past the old course and Muirfield in terms of being the two of if you put your your name on the trophy there yeah that's something you can sleep well the rest of your life with
Matt: Yeah just speaking of open champions hilton Vardon braid hagen Nicklaus trevino faldo ells mickelson buhay what a hit like it's pretty good yeah pretty good
06:13:43 A playbook for building a golf club
Matt: Well, that's legacy and influence. If this was a playbook that you were going to put together for a club, I don't know if we want to say starting today, trying to find their identity, what would that playbook include? If you were trying to recreate this, what would be those plays?
Professor: You want me to start?
Matt: Sure.
Professor: A quote from Michael J. Walker, I believe, was a captain. We are very proud of our golf course and our
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Club.
Professor: So being prideful of what you are at all times. And when he said that, he was very much referring to the way they play the game. So if you're asking me for a playbook of how you build a club at this, you're starting with the way you actually conduct the game. on the grounds and you think of their start when they were formalized what was it formalized over a competition a competition and laying down rules for that competition how we play the game so if I'm starting with a playbook this is golf this isn't the clubhouse we're [unclear] build the amenities we're gonna have the experience you're gonna have when you come up to the club what it's about is when you go to the first tee what happens over the next In
06:15:09 Codifying and celebrating traditions
Professor: Their case, what happens in those two and a half hours? I think the playbook has to start there. And that's where your hyper-focus is to begin with.
Matt: Yeah. I already used the word, but I like it as we're talking about Muirfield. It's codify. Codify these traditions and celebrate them. Over this whole history, they really held to the early traditions despite no turnout for the silver club outside of theirs. They stuck with it. And over time, what does that do? It institutionalizes these rituals. And it makes you feel like you're a part of something larger than yourself. You hear the Muirfield members talk about the bet book and the dinner matches and the silver club and their medals. You are part of something that is this fabric over time. That you really connect to. So I think that's number one on my list. Codify and celebrate traditions. That is what they've been so committed to.
Professor: Give me another one.
Matt: Another C word. Control.
Professor [Speaker uncertain]: Okay.
Matt: You got to maintain control. Maybe not at all costs. At first, I was thinking this would be control at all costs. They never did that. You know, they never gave up everything in order for that to have that control.
06:16:36 Control ownership and staying true to the club
Matt: They collaborated where necessary with the outside world and the other groups, but they certainly had an eye on control above a lot of other things. I mean, even the arrangements they had at their clubhouses, the lease agreements and the bartering plays that came into works. And then when they get to Muirfield, the whole structure of selecting and building the golf courses. In order for those things to occur, we have to have a little bit more control than we've had in the past. And I think that's been a part of their progression. Extending that to the golf course too. Maybe more the golf course than anything is that when you own it, you can refine it and you can make it better. Give me one of yours if it was a playbook for making Muirfield Muirfield.
Professor: Don't play Keeping Up with the Joneses. I think you could take everything we've laid out in the playbook so far. And to accomplish those things is not to fall trap to what other people are doing and pay too much attention to that. If this club's doing that, if they're adding this or they're changing this, don't take that as a sign of, oh, we should change and do that too. We should go with that trend or whatever. Think about what you want to commit to and then stay on that path as much as possible without being caught up in the We have to be better than everybody else in all these ways. What is that thing that's going to be true to you? And then make sure you're always doing that the best. I think this is true across any, this is true across businesses, across life.
Professor: Do a few things really, really, really, really, really well rather than trying to do all things. And I think it's easy for clubs to fall in the trap of wanting to do all things and think of what other clubs do well and try to incorporate everything versus what are those few things that we want to be known for and making sure. As much as possible, you stick to that mission as you're moving forward with your club.
Matt: That's a good one. Their insulation at times allowed them to avoid some pitfalls. They had some of their own, but it was usually of their own doing. It wasn't trying to keep up the Joneses or do something that they're seeing elsewhere. Although they did rip off the Archers. Yes.
06:18:56 Learning from other fields
Professor: And learn from other fields. Learn from other fields. That's a good thing, right? Don't learn. If you're going to be a lead within your own field,
Matt [Speaker uncertain]: Why
Professor: Are you trying to learn from others in your field? You look to outside fields, especially in fields that might be out in front of you, that are similar in structure in different ways. And what are they doing? And try to bring that into your thing. And I think that would be, if we don't talk about their playbook, if you're a golf club right now.
06:19:22 Exclusivity welcome and clear expectations
Professor: Maybe you shouldn't be looking at other golf clubs, especially those that are hundreds of years ahead of you because you're trying to replicate the product they have now. You're trying to start where they ended versus what are the other places you can look for creative new things that aren't necessarily being done within your own environment?
Matt: This might be a more modern playbook item for them, but exclusivity combined with welcoming.
Professor: Oh, play on this. Pull that thread apart.
Matt: I think this is a thread that... they've embraced a little bit ahead of the trend. You know, you're at somewhere special that you're not going to get an invite to be a member of in your lifetime, but there is a welcoming nature to it. And there is a, it comes to my next playbook item. There's just a clarity of expectation that allows you to be there and be a part of it. And so that welcoming private club model. is definitely at the forefront of what [unclear] see with them and you know it's tuesdays and thursdays that's when you know you can play and if I were to take that retroactively to their playbook I'd probably flip the welcoming private club with you know stewardship versus exclusivities I think they found a balance of it as long as they could benefit from the improvements to the grounds to the improvements that they would make to the golf course to um you know, sharing tea times at Musselburgh, they would do the right thing.
Matt: But it was always a balance for them to maintain their elite position as the Honourable Company. If they were to lean too much into that stewardship and probably give too much to their artisans or what, I don't know what it would have been. They just wouldn't be Muirfield as they stand today. You know, there was always a... give,
06:21:22 Discipline and execution
Matt: But there were controlled limits. And I think that speaks to the next one I'll jump to. Militant level discipline.
Professor: Yeah, I think that's unquestionable.
Matt: Everything from the way their lunch line operates to how proficient they track the bet book to how their minutes are on point. There's just this level of execution overall that they're obsessed with. I think they're just obsessed with it.
Professor: They're so focused on this militant aspect of the betterment of the club as a whole and make it like thinking about these bigger decisions, the bigger aspects of the club rather than typical leadership, at least predominantly United States clubs. They're thinking about what's the identity of our club and let's make decisions with respect to that. It's like, what little things do we want? You know, what do members want? What do I want? Where they were so militant about bigger things than that.
06:22:16 Identity as the result of long term practices
Matt: Anything else for a playbook?
Professor: I brought up exclusivity and I'll give the generalized version of this. With exclusivity there, that was an outcome that happened with them. And exclusivity is created through demand of people wanting what you have. In today's world, clubs often think, oh, exclusivity. So I'm going to start there by having $125,000 initiation. I'm going to put in something that... [unclear] looks like exclusivity. But I'd argue that's not the version of exclusivity that Muirfield established. They established exclusivity that was a product of people looking at them and being like, I want to be a part of that. That is special. That created a sense of exclusivity. And certainly they can operationalize that with a huge initiation or they could keep a zero dollar initiation and just operationalize that in terms of we're going to let in people that we want to let in.
Professor: Maybe a lot of people, maybe not a lot, but we're going to vet you and depend on who you are. So in this sense, whatever the playbook is for whatever you want to establish as a club, what's your identity? What do you want it to be? And then think of everything you need to be in place so that identity is a product. of what's in place. So you don't want to achieve identity by doing this rule or this thing. You achieve that identity by years and years of practices and membership duty. And like you say, being disciplined and diligent in how you achieve that through leadership, through member behavior, how the members are directed. And so the playbook is... think of what you want to establish. And that's got to be a 50 year window. How are we going to be there in 50 years?
Professor: So when these people are telling stories about our club, that 50 year story ends with, and here's where they are now, all that created this thing. And that was your goal at year zero. I think that's honestly my biggest takeaway of this thing is you put mechanisms in place and you get the right people with the right discipline and everybody in alignment and you work. really dang hard for decades to actually achieve what you're trying to do.
Matt: Yeah, it's the byproduct. 20-year waitlist isn't fabricated because you just said there's a 20-year waitlist. The 20-year waitlist comes from everything you just said. All the playbook items actually result to that. Don't get blinded by the end. That's right. Well, we're end of the line here, professor.
06:24:41 Pride fellowship and the essence of the club
Matt: The question, one of our favorite podcasts came up with her own word for it, but essentially it's the word essence. Is there an overarching essence that you took from all this and our time with Muirfield and the Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers? Pride and fellowship.
Professor: That's something that they're always striving to achieve and maintain. pride for what they have, the way they play the game, the way they present it, but ensuring there's fellowship amongst the members that are there.
Matt: I'm conflicted on mine. There's a lot of smarter people that we researched, and there are people that we already mentioned much, but John Kerr, I know one of your favorite books that you dove into was The Golf Book of East Lothian. And his contention with Not just Muirfield, but really the exported product of golf was that outside of Scotland, golf was almost necessarily becoming this game based on a private club model that owned private courses. Rather than the way the whole thing started and existed for all... I mean, we're just talking about Muirfield, but...
06:26:09 Private courses accessibility and an alternative history
Matt: They were the only ones those last 150 years that really went that direction for private courses. Private club, yes, but private course. And I think he said it just really well talking about this was almost inevitable based on the progression of society, but he concluded that the new club system was potentially going to destroy the Scottish game. And so... I'm going to turn dark here for a second before I lighten things up. That hit me hard. I started here towards the end of our time talking about modern times where let's play the what if game. What if Muirfield decides to stay at Musselburgh? What if they decide to stay at Leith? What if they move like many did, but Muirfield is a municipal links like all the rest. I feel like you could say, depending on your, your worldview or your golf view I'm not saying right or wrong but you could say wow they created the system the template for private club exclusivity and success or you could say they ruined what was the symphony of accessibility and openness that all these clubs kind of had at that time we just needed to dig in a little bit further
Matt: And figure out how do we get another nine here at Musselburgh or figure out how do we expand to St. Andrew's links that now has seven golf courses versus going the other direction that we need control. We need our own land. Those key moments could have made a very different future for the game of golf.
Professor: You have an argument to make that in terms of their influence on the game, their turn to becoming a private club. And then everything they had to deal with along the way sets a precedent and certainly one that other people have taken forward to their own golf courses and clubs does call in the question where would we be had not Muirfield and a few other private clubs around this time, late 1800s, early 1900s, including those occurring in America, had that not started occurring, what would golf look like in today's society? And I think you can make a claim it would look very different relative to especially access across a lot of the different countries.
Matt: And I'll tell you what. Essence
06:28:48 The spirit of the club and the closing toast
Matt: Of a club, I think, falls down to those core decisions of all the playbook items and the decisions that they made and the principles that they stood on. And that's what makes them Muirfield. And that's the essence of Muirfield. Although, who am I to say, Robert Maxwell, one of the great men of Muirfield, he once put it, possibly the strongest feature of the Honourable Company is a spirit decor. Long may it continue.
Professor: And long may it continue. Matt, that's it. Leith to Musselburgh, Musselburgh to Muirfield, three homes, 280 years, and in the end, pride, fellowship, and clubbiness. And
Matt: It all started with a few gentlemen.
06:29:34 Acknowledgments and sources
Matt: Silver Club and 13 rules written down because the town council asked them to do it. Well, before
Professor: We let everyone go, I believe we owe plenty of people some thank yous, some real
Matt: Ones. Starting with everybody who came before us, for sure. We said at the top of this that this is not an official record. That means everything you just heard rests on other people's work. First and foremost. the members, secretaries, archivists of the Honorable
========== 30-MINUTE MARKER · 06:30:00 ==========
Matt: Company. For nearly three centuries, they kept the minute books, the bet books, the metal records, and the letters. By keeping those records, they kept the story. And that's what we all were able to enjoy and learn from today. Without
Professor: Them, there's no episode. There's no old watery
Matt: Meadow. Not even that. And then you have the historians and the authors who did all the digging long before we ever showed up. Our full source list is in the show notes, but I think the professor and I both agree there's a few that deserve an extra special shout
Professor: Out. I'm going to start with The Gulf Book of East Lothian by John Kerr, 1896. Definitely one of the favorite pieces on my shelf written while the Muirfield Golfing Greens were still brand new. I'll go
Matt: With Muirfield, home of the Honourable Company, 1744 to 1994 by Norman Mayer. That is 250 years of the
Professor: Club in one volume. Piggybacking on that one, Muirfield and the Honourable Company by George Pontinger, 1972. Deep dives into the clubs, the people, the stories, the bets. Maybe
Matt: One of my favorites that I've been recommending to many a golf nerd is golf. Scotland's Game by David Hamilton, 1998. If you want to know where this game really came from, this book was incredible. And
Professor: If you want to know ultimately how Muirfield Golfing Greens went from being an old watery meadow to the championship lengths we all know it as today, check out The Evolution of Muirfield by Richard Latham, written in 2013.
Matt: And the newest book that I added to the shelf was Musselburgh, The Cradle of Golf by Mungo Park. Mungo Park IV. By the way, 2025, this book came out right when we decided we were going to do this. That's a name that Musselburgh Golf knows very well. And it's a good reminder that the Honourable Company story is part of Musselburgh's
Professor: Story as well. So thank you to every one of those authors that handed us a piece of this story. Certainly, if we got something right, it's because of them.
Matt: And if we got something wrong, let us know. Send us a note. We want to hear from you. Our email is thebagdropatnewclub.golf.
Professor: And one more time.
06:32:00 Thanks to the founding partners
Professor: Thank you to the founding partners in our long-form series on The Bag Drop, The Great Clubs. They are Titleist, Inglewood, Erin Hills, the Western Golf Association and Evans Scholars Foundation, and Holderness and Bourne. You took a chance on two friends, five-plus hours, and a club that didn't own a blade of grass for 150 years. We are grateful.
Matt: Yes, we are. A sincere thanks to all our partners. You can learn more about each of them from the links available in our show notes.
Professor: And if you're like me and want the show notes, our full source list, and a heads up on which club we're going to do next, get on the list at thebackdrop.fm or come talk about the episode with us on any of our socials. Those are at thebackdrop on Instagram and at thebackdropgolf everywhere else.
Matt: And last but certainly not least, thank you, yes, you, for spending this time with us on the drive, on the range, at the office or at the airport. However you got here, we're glad you did. And we look forward to catching you again on the next one. Professor?
06:33:00 A dedication to Tim Miller
Matt: Thanks, man. That was fun.
Professor: Should we have one last toast to our first episode? And can I close this with a dedication of this episode that I've kept from you until now? We are closing the episode. Is it official now? Yeah, the official first deep dive of the backdrop. I would like to dedicate this episode to someone that I think he is a Muirfield man. Today, bear with me here. We have lost Tim Miller, one of my best friend's dad, who was one of the biggest influential people in my golf life. He helped teach me the game. He loved the game. He loved to play a proper game, a tournament game. He, other than my dad and my family, raised me on the golf course. So I'd like to toast. Tim Miller, Vicky, and Chris, we love you. We're thinking about you. I think Timmy.
Professor: We've been proud of this episode. He's certainly someone I'm proud of and truly a Muirfield man.
Matt: Yeah, a Muirfield man indeed.
Professor: To the Honourable Company and Tim Miller, today was fun.