Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
We, we think about agentic commerce.
Agentic commerce is really when a system
is smart enough to go across multiple
different systems, perform complex tasks,
come back, and the job is done, uh, to
oversimplify what agentic commerce is.
And so Shopware is building a bunch
of agents ourselves using our own
AP- uh, you know, our own open
source product to demonstrate how,
how agentic commerce can work.
But at the same time, we're encouraging
people to build out agents as well.
So today you might have an app store
with a bunch of third-party apps.
In the future, there
could be a agent store.
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast,
where we explore the intersection
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call retailgentic.
Our mission is simple: we are shining
a bright light on the new agentic AI
shopping megatrend, which will disrupt
the trillion-dollar digital retail market.
The stakes are high.
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.
What happens to checkouts?
How should payments work?
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not
from humans, but from AI agents?
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends, and best practices.
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating
our AI shopping agent future.
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.
Welcome back to the Retailgentic Podcast.
Today, I'm excited for
you to meet Jason Nies.
He is the General Manager of
North America at Shopware.
I guarantee you this is the only
podcast you'll hear this year, and
maybe ever, where in one conversation
we talk about the BlackBerry
App Store and agentic commerce.
Shopware is an e-commerce
platform headquartered in Germany
that's about 20 to 30 years old.
Like Magento, Red Hat, MySQL, those
types of companies, they're an
open source company with a premium
non-open source enterprise offering.
It's kind of a freemium model
where the open source is the free
and the enterprise is the premium.
Uh, it may be a brand you haven't heard
of because it is European, but they
are in-- they're either number seven
or six, depending on what you look
at, uh, in the ranking of e-commerce
platforms by processing volume.
So definitely a top 10, uh, company there.
Jason was previously at Digital River, uh,
for 20 years, and in 2022 was recruited
to run and open the United States for
Shopware, where he is today The reason
we wanted to have Shopware on the pod
is in July, they announced something
called the Agentic Commerce Alliance.
Uh, in this podcast, we learn all
about the Agentic Commerce Alliance,
what that means, what their vision
is for this alliance, the types of
companies they're gonna have in there.
Then we also get some insights from Jason
where Shopware is taking the alliance,
as well as some of the areas they're
investing in around agentic commerce.
And finally, uh, we get, uh, we get
Jason, uh, his opinion, because he's been
in e-commerce, uh, for quite a while.
We get his opinion on where he
sees agentic commerce going in
the next two to three years.
Enjoy the conversation.
Jason Najus, GM at Shopware,
welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast.
Thank you for having me.
Let's start with your background.
I, uh…
you and I were talking in the
green room that it's shocking
we haven't met each other, but
this happens a lot in e-commerce.
There's a Kevin Bacons- We're
Kevin Baconed in e-commerce.
So let's, let's talk
about your background.
Yeah, let's do it.
Well, first of all, it's
wonderful to be with you.
Um, this will be my own personal
version of the Jason and Scot Show.
Um-
Jason's just overhead with a
big title, so it's all right.
Middle management.
We're kicking him out.
I love, I love him.
He's one of my e-commerce idols.
I, I've had the pleasure of spending
a decent amount of time with him.
Um, and he's, he's amazing.
I don't think we're probably gonna
talk about Amazon as much as you do
on the other pod, but that's okay.
Um, I'm, uh, Jason Najus.
I've been in e-commerce
for about 25 years.
Uh, the lion's share of it was
spent at a company called Digital
River, uh, which was a pioneer in
taking brands direct to consumer.
And the, the vision of that business
was really to disintermediate retail and
let the, the cons- the brands own that
direct relationships with consumers.
Um, I was there 20-plus years and
started as a customer success guy.
Worked all the way up to owning marketing,
eventually owning partnerships, uh, and,
and net new revenue for the business.
So I, I kinda saw it all, uh,
through the evolution of commerce
through many different phases.
Yeah.
So, uh, Digital River is fascinating
because everyone I've ever met that
worked or has worked there or works
there, uh, was always there for 20 years.
Like, what, what's that all about?
Is it just, like, that great
of a place to work or…?
No.
It was a tough, it was, it
was a tough place to work.
In fact, it's, it's no longer
in business actually, but,
um, that's a different story.
The, um…
what was really, really fascinating
about it is it, you got a front row seat
to the different eras in e-commerce.
And, and at the early days, it was
all around brands going direct.
Yeah.
Lar- Microsoft was the
first big customer, right?
You guys helped Microsoft open
a, basically an app store.
Um, and we didn't call it that, but
it was, like, a buy software online,
or maybe it was, like, even…
Maybe it was, like, the
keyboard or something.
There was, like, something that Microsoft
wanted to sell online, and you guys
built it for it, and then that's, like,
seems to be what catapulted the company.
That's my outside observer
of, of what Digital River did.
Pretty, pretty good, pretty good memory.
Uh, it goes back a
little earlier than that.
It was actually most of the
software companies that were
trying to sell software online
and digital downloads, which was
really the origin of the business.
Um, the first app store that Digital
River ran was actually for BlackBerry.
Believe it or not…
I'm sorry, no, I'm wrong.
Nokia.
Nokia had the first ever app
store, um, for developers to
build apps for the Nokia devices.
So you got Snake for free, but
Snake Plus you had to go to the
Digital River shopping cart.
That's exactly right.
Yep.
But that was a funny business 'cause
no one did anything, and then ringtones
came along, and, like, people were doing,
like, $100 million a day in ringtones.
It was just, like, bonkers.
I, I, I remember you guys, like,
rode that wave in there, too.
Yep, we rode the wave.
We did BlackBerry's App Store.
At one point, I remember the conversation,
um, we, we had BlackBerry, and if you
remember, I mean, we're old, so back
in the day, BlackBerry was it, right?
Everybody had one.
And Google, we were in a conversation
with Google around running their
App Store, and we declined because
we were worried we'd have too much
concentration in low-margin App Store
business, and we already had BlackBerry.
So we made good decisions.
Yeah, there's a lot of, a lot
of stories from that era where
people chose the wrong horse.
Um, so then 2022, you took a, you, after
20-plus years, you joined Shopware.
Tell us what was the impetus there?
What is, uh, GM is one of those
things that can mean a lot.
Um, it can be geographical.
It can be a division.
So tell us what your, what is, who is
Shopware, why you decided to, to join,
uh, and what the GM role is all about.
Yeah, you bet.
Well, so I think w- the last episode
at Digital River, the last chapter of
the book for me was at Digital River.
I'll, I'll kinda rewind a little bit.
Um, so Digital River had finally
made it to the leader q- quadrant in
the MQ, the Gartner Magic Quadrant,
and that put us up against five or
six of the greatest other e-commerce
platforms at the time that there were.
And that list was Demandware,
Magento, ATG, WebSphere, and
Hybris, and Digital River, okay?
That's who was in the, in
the upper right of the MQ.
Well, it was around that time that all
five of those companies got acquired by
IBM, Oracle, SAP, Salesforce, and Adobe.
And so we were kinda
the last man standing.
Uh, we were a public company at
the time, and we were the last man
standing, uh, with regards to kinda
being an independent company not owned
by big some big software conglomerate.
And it was, we ran independent for
a while, and then realized that we
couldn't outspend or out-innovate
those big software companies, and
so we facilitated a pivot, which was
a really smart decision, frankly.
So instead of being the commerce platform,
we had this utility called Merchant
of Record, and that Merchant of Record
capability was really valuable if we could
put it inside of Salesforce, inside of
Adobe, inside of BigCommerce, et cetera.
And so that's what we pivoted to do,
and I was responsible for that pivot.
Well, we did that for a number of years,
won a bunch of meaningful customers,
and my teams got to sell next to
all of their reps from Salesforce,
Adobe, and, and, and the like.
And what I realized in that
tenure is almost everybody had
the same- Kind of capability.
They priced it a little different, they
packaged it a little different, they
described it a little different, but it
was really a lot of the same utility.
And in my mind, I thought we were at the
point where we had mass commoditization of
e-commerce, and that, you know, there was
no real new feature innovation happening.
And then I got a call from a recruiter
about Shopware, uh, and they were
recruiting for the GM of North America,
which is a geographic responsibility
role, uh, to take this business that
is dominant in Germany, it's like 20%
market share and the third largest
economy in the world, but it was
very isolated to Germany, Austria,
Switzerland, Benelux, and that's about it.
Um, and so when they approached me,
my response was, "Who the hell is
Shopware, and why does the world
need another commerce platform?"
And I started to dig into the
product, realizing that it was modern.
It was launched in December of 2019,
which made it, gave us a huge operational
advantage in performance and, you
know, it was a lighter weight in
terms of the amount of code required,
better architecture, et cetera.
The way it was priced doesn't have to be
a revenue share, which everyone else does.
Uh, and we had 50,000 clients in almost
every vertical, and it was, and it was
designed around the context of the day.
So mobility was built in, social commerce
was built in, marketplaces, uh, uh, APIs,
all of the things that today's e-commerce
context, it was built with those in mind.
It didn't have to retrofit into them.
And so when I looked at this and
said, "Okay, it feels different.
I think I can actually…
I think the United States
market actually needs this."
And so that's why I jumped in
and why I was really excited
to be a part of Shopware, and
it's gone really, really well.
Got it.
Uh, you said my favorite
word, marketplaces.
So this comes with the ability
to, to add its own marketplace,
or it's just integrated with,
like, one of the platforms, like
a Miracle or something like that?
Yeah, exactly.
It, it, it works with a
Miracle, or it works with other-
Okay … market-leading products.
Yeah.
But it, but it's built to,
uh, support it naturally.
You know, it doesn't have
to be some custom feed- It's
not a Frankenstein jammed
on the side kind of…
Okay.
Exactly.
Exactly.
Now, 2019 predates MACH Alliance.
Are, are you guys, um, uh, you know,
part of that, or, or kind of, you
know, you, you, you, you adhere to it
basically because you're composable
and you're a more modern platform?
Where, where do you fall in
that MACH Alliance world?
Yeah, that's a really interesting one.
I'm a big fan of, of, of Kelly and what
those guys did with the MACH Alliance.
It's really innovative and smart.
Um, but the fact is, some of the
requirements around a certain percent
of your customer installs have to be
utilizing, uh, I don't remember exactly
what, but essentially, we doesn't
qualify or don't qualify, uh, to
become a member of the MACH Alliance.
Now, the principles of what MACH
stands for, being microservices
led, having an API-first solution,
being composable, being headless if
needed, all of those things we are,
we are, and we're really good at.
It's designed with that intention.
Uh, but no, we are not a member of
the MACH Alliance, and, and frankly, I
don't, I don't ne- think we need to be.
Yeah.
Yeah, there's kind of, like, two parts.
There's a There's a philosophy and then
a do you meet the criteria and, um, yeah.
If your customers choose something else,
it's not worth saying, "Well, we're
gonna have to fire these customers,"
because to get to your percentage
they're, we're not meeting, you know,
"How dare you use our front end.
We need to be 50% headless," or something.
We, we, we actually, we actually
talk about it in the context
of practical composability.
And what do I mean by that?
I, I mean we walk into the…
We try to serve the mid-market, and the
mid-market has future design needs to
be able to use their own search or their
own merchandising or their own whatever.
Uh, but today's needs are, "I
need to do it economically.
I need to, I need pr- I need really
good, not perfect, um, utility."
And so our strategy is to sell them the
castle that is built of Lego pieces,
that at any point they can interoperably
change them out to a market leader.
And so that, that's kind of been our
approach, and it's working really well.
Got it.
This is more Rick Watson's world,
but, like, help me understand.
You, you said mid-market.
Like, let's define that.
And then another way these platform
companies seem to be going is kind
of a B2B orientation and a B2C.
So, so help me, help me navigate if
there was a mental map of where you
guys are, the Shopifys of the world
and Salesforce Commerce Cloud, like
where, where do you guys see yourself?
Where's kind of like your
spot on that, that diagram?
Well, first and foremost, um, we
think Shopify is the greatest box
ever invented for commerce, and
if your brand fits in that box,
you should probably buy from them.
Um, and anybody who's probably competing
for the simple commerce use cases,
which are, you know, classically B2C,
um, apparel, health and beauty, you
know, footwear, um, largely domestic,
I think if you're competing with
Shopify, you're, you're gonna lose.
And it almost doesn't matter if you're
small or large or anything in between.
Where's…
And it, and, and so Shopware's goal is
to really help in search of the merchant
who has, uh, more complex use cases.
And what do I mean by that?
I mean, uh, regulated industries,
things like government, healthcare,
fintech, outdoor retail, et cetera.
Those, those businesses, the rules of,
of doing business change frequently.
Um, we also love the, the, the category
of, of businesses with huge catalogs
that don't lend themselves to being
on a multi-tenant shared environment
because of the, the ch- the, the,
the c- amount of data inflow and
outflow and just burden on a system.
And then the third is really
B2B, but more specifically, uh,
businesses who are distributors.
And predominantly we do really well there
because there's enormous complexity, but
also the, they, they do not wanna pay
a revenue share to a commerce platform.
These businesses are normally
making between 5 and 7%.
Uh, you know, they're a middleman
by definition, and to share a half a
point with the commerce platform plus
two and a half points for payments,
that's three of the six they might
make, and that's just a non-starter.
And so Shopware's ability to charge
a license fee, uh, to support
any payment engine they want is
really a big differentiation.
So we crush when it's mid-market
or above, and we re- do really
well in the complex use cases.
And, and do you find, do you find
mid-market by 100 million and
up or, like, uh, more company
size versus e-commerce size?
Like, how do you, how do
you think about mid-market?
Yeah, that's, that's a
little more art than science.
You know, we can do the classic
definitions of online revenue, uh,
but it more comes down to, um, some
of the use cases they wanna support.
Um, so, you know, we would-
The complexity kinda, like, tips 'em over.
The complexity of their use case
is more important than the size.
And, and I was reading up on it, and
a lot of the descriptions I, I see
describe it as open source, whi- which
kind of reminds me of Magento and all.
So is this kind of the model…
And we have Red Hat born here in
the, in the Triangle area, so I, I
know that model really well, where
they have this open source version
you can download and use freely like
Magento had, but then if you want the
supported enterprise version, you pay.
I- is that kind of y'all's model, or
is there something different in there?
Yeah, that's it.
I mean, we, we, we have an open source
product that is completely free to
use and, and frankly it's quite good.
Um, and it's purpose-built for developers.
Um, and then we have enterprise
class features that you can
unlock based on your needs.
Um, we have three different plans.
We'll call it good, better, best,
but it's more aligned to, uh,
the complexity of your business
and how much you actually need.
So, um, plans are, can start off
at really inexpensive a- and kinda
go up to enterprise class plans.
Yeah.
Um, couple more questions on Shopware
before we jump into agentic commerce.
The, um, can you say…
So it's a private company, right?
Can, can you give us an idea of, like,
how big, um, people or revenue range or
something, just so we kind of know, is
this, like, a, is this, like, a smaller,
like, $20 million platform, or is this,
like, up where, like, commercetools
is, or is this, like, bigger?
Like, help me, help me place
it on some, some scale there,
somewhere in the- Yeah, I'd love to.
Thank
you for asking.
So-
I actually don't know how big
commercetools is, so I should've been a
little more … I know they're big, but
I don't know, like, how big they are.
Well, they're, they're, yeah,
they're not that much bigger.
But, um, so Shopware is private.
We're actually 30% owned by,
uh, the Carlyle Group, which
is, like, the second-largest
PE in the world, and PayPal.
And so 30% private equity owned,
70% employee owned, which is a
really important distinction.
Uh, being private is a big advantage.
Number two, I think this year we'll exit
somewhere between 60 and 70 million,
uh, in revenue Um, but what makes it
really interesting, Scott, is we're
probably the sixth or seventh largest
commerce platform by processing volume.
So, uh, somewhere in the $23 billion, $24
billion range this year we'll exit, which
again, puts us in the top six globally.
Now, in terms of our revenue, like
I said, 60 and 70 million, that
doesn't even put us in the top 10.
And so what that tells you is we're
not, uh, we're monetizing only
the commerce platform, not the
professional services business.
We're not competing with our technology
partners, and we're not taking a
huge chunk of the payments business.
That's what that tells you.
So we're really, really focused
on being a software company.
We'll come back to that in a minute.
Um, that'll be…
Everyone remember that.
Put a pin in the checkout piece.
That's gonna come up later.
Yes, it will.
Does that number include, like,
do you think of your impact,
the open source piece as well?
'Cause you may not even
be able to track that.
I remember Magento basically
said, "We know if we, we kind
of host it what's happening.
We guess there's this bigger
number, but, but it's just a swag."
Do you guys have an element like that
where you, you know, you know on the
enterprise version what's going on, but
there's this whole other impact you're
having that, that's really hard to track?
Is that, is that something that's a thing?
Yeah.
Well, it, it, you're exactly right.
It's complicated.
So, so one of the things that when you
decide you wanna give away your product
for free to the community, you're
also giving up the ability to know
everything that's happening all the time.
And so, yes, there is thousands
and thousands of people who've used
our product, modified it to the
point where you can't even see it's
Shopware, and they're using it.
Um, and so we do rely on tools like
BuiltWith and others to actually see
who's using our product in a lot of ways.
So, so 2022 you decided, "I'm
gonna do this," and I imagine that
you'd picked up some US customers
just kind of by happy accident.
That kind of happens, but not, you know.
As you said, like, the
bulk was probably not here.
Um, how's it going?
You're kind of in year four.
Uh, have you, you started to find
some beachheads and getting some
wins and, and starting to carve out a
space for the product here in the US?
Yeah, actually a lot.
Um, we've had a, uh…
The first year was kinda a, a tough year.
It was, it was, uh, a bit of a transition.
Um, inflation was hard.
A lot of people were kinda
clenching their, their wallets.
Uh, but years two…
This is year three, by the way.
Uh, it's gone really, really well.
Um, some customers that are notable,
uh, you know, Dunham Sports and,
and, um, UPPAbaby, and, and Turning
Point Brands, all examples of
live customers, tons of B2B ones.
Uh, at this point, if you were to
go on BuiltWith and look up Shopware
United States, you'd see over,
uh, I think 2,100 sites running
on Shopware in North America.
Combination of deals we sold in
North America, combination of brands
in Europe who've expanded here, uh,
once we planted a flag, and open
source customers using our product,
uh, and having success with it.
So, um, we believe we are the
fastest growing e-commerce
platform in North America.
Um, but again, we're open source, so in
a lot of ways that can be hard to prove
I'm always jealous of op- as a
proprietary software guy, I'm always
jealous as open source because it's
this lead gen engine that's huge, right?
Because your first, the first thing
I'm sure you did was you're like, "Who
are the people using this free thing?
And let me call all them and
see if they wanna upgrade."
And, uh, you know, so that,
so I, I'm very envious of that
freemium-type business model that,
that, that, that you have there.
That, that's pretty amazing.
Is that, was that kinda like where
some of your first early wins came,
just kinda harvesting that, that
group that was out there in that
community that kinda self-formed?
Absolutely.
But in addition to that point, there's
a whole bunch of people in the community
of open source, and that was the big
eye-opening moment for me of how much
there's a community of like-minded
people really pushing open source.
And so, you know, when Magento
was acquired by Adobe, um, I
think we can probably agree Adobe
is world-class at serving the
biggest companies in the world.
And what they ultimately did is they
continued to move the line of deals that
they wanna work on with their sales team,
which ef- essentially alienated a lot of
the mid-market and all of the agencies
who used to make all their money there.
And so, ultimately, a lot of these
agencies were looking for alternative
ways to continue to make money, and some
of them went Shopify, in fact, a lot.
Um, a lot of them went BigCommerce, and
frankly, it's a big reason BigCommerce
was able to get public on the backs of
a lot of those Magento, uh, merchants.
And in Europe, you know, we took
over 3,000 merchants off Magento,
and all of the agencies and devs who
supported it, um, benefited from it.
And so we're, in a lot of ways, um,
in North America as well, benefiting
from the fact that Magento Adobe
really doesn't target the mid-market
as their primary go-to-market.
So we, we've benefited
there as well, Scott.
Let's see.
There's the WordPress-based one.
Are there any other big open source
guys now that Magento's … I, I'm sure
it's still out there in open source,
but I'm gonna … I, I don't know much.
Uh, actually had Roy Rubin on,
but I didn't ask this question.
Uh, I'm sure that they've kinda let,
let the open source community atrophy
and, and I'm sure they're out there
doing their own thing and forking the
code and, and, like, keeping it alive.
But it's not like they're
nurturing it, I'm, I'm sure.
Um, uh, are there any other open
source, uh, communities out there,
or you, you guys kinda have filled
that, that hole pretty dramatically?
Uh, I think there's plenty of…
Yes, there are.
Um, so, so WooCommerce is, uh, an open
source product that does pretty well.
I mean, there's still more Woo installs
than Shopify, which blows me away
In my mind, it's like if you're
mid-market, it's like super, super,
super SMB solopreneur almost.
Yeah.
Yeah.
E- exactly.
So yeah, the, in the mid-market,
there's not a lot of open source
companies we compete with.
I hear Spree Commerce from time to time.
Uh, Sailor is a, is a, it's a
developer-centric tool that gets adopted
from time to time, but no real…
OroCommerce in B2B, which
is, you know, the old Magento
dev team kind of started Oro.
But for the most part, there's
not a lot in that market.
And then if we just look at mid-market and
take the open source angle out, is it…
I, I feel like BigCommerce has kinda like
had to go kinda where DUR because Shopify
has just kinda walloped them on the,
the parts you talked about, that the…
Anything in that box, they've kind
of pushed everyone out of that box.
Is that kinda who you're up against
a lot, is the BigCommerce guys, or?
Yeah.
You know, for sure.
Uh, you know, what's so funny is
Shopify is such an amazing marketer
and, and storyteller with such a huge
network, that whether they should or
shouldn't be, Shopify is in every deal.
BigCommerce is in probably half of them.
And then we're usually up against, you
know, when I talked about those segments
in which we have success, uh, we're
usually up against, um, someone who has
an ERP integration to their commerce
platform as their core differentiator.
And so it's, it's names that aren't
as mainstream as you would expect.
So because they're a manufacturer,
they're using some ERP thing, and it's
just easier for them to slap on a…
Yeah.
But that's like a, I'm sure a lot of
those boomerang, 'cause that's never
gonna be Putting the, the pieces, y-
you know, it, it's very hard to be
an ERP company and do this part well
E- exactly right.
A- and even the ones who are commerce
platforms who have that connection
to the ERP are kinda old school tech,
they're kinda sleepy, and so there's
real opportunity to disrupt that market,
which is what we're experiencing now.
Okay.
So one of the reasons I wanted to have
you on the pod is you guys recently
announced an agentic alliance.
Uh, and that was the magic word,
so, uh, w- we want to understand
what is that, what was the impetus.
Um, your, your CEO there, uh, Sebastian,
he s- he seems to have some religion.
Um, I've seen some of his talks about
this, um, on YouTube and whatnot.
Um, so, so tell us about that.
Is that a thing that's in
Germany now and coming to the US?
So I wanna know all the things,
so, so hit us with everything
about the Agentic Alliance.
Let's do it.
So it's called the
Agentic Commerce Alliance.
And let me take a little
bit of a step back.
Most companies that have been in
e-commerce, and their founders
started the business, and,
and for us it's 25 years ago.
Sebastian and Stefan, these two
guys in Germany, teenagers, started
Shopware with a family project, turned
it into a company, and now is, you
know, the sixth or seventh largest
processing company in the world.
And, um, why does that matter in this
use case is because these two brothers
are still deeply, deeply involved.
In fact, they're co-CEOs.
And one of the brothers,
Stefan, is, uh, is, uh…
he'll, he'll describe himself as the
nerd of the family, and Sebastian's
a little more of the artist.
Stefan, this is his brainchild,
this Agentic Commerce Association.
Alliance, excuse me.
And the reason it matters is because
he sees this as a massive moment
at which, uh, the rules of how,
how a- agentic commerce is gonna
get applied are being written.
And the reason that this, uh,
exists is because we don't…
We want the future to be open.
We don't want a few large companies
who own your checkout experience, own
your cart, can d- dictate how AI and
agentic commerce is gonna be done.
It's a little bit like a proxy of
having AOL try and own the internet, as
opposed to it being an open internet.
And so that's this big moment,
and the fact that Shopware is
open, we've got modern technology,
and we have an open ecosystem.
And again, our goal is not to
monetize everything, it's to
be a great software company.
And so we're inviting in any company
who shares similar beliefs to, to
participate and help write the standards
for how open agentic commerce can happen.
Uh, say a little bit more about that.
So, so kind of hidden in there or like,
uh, I'm reading between the lines,
let me just make sure I get this.
You, you don't wanna have a world where,
uh, and there's a Financial Times, um,
you know, this is in the rumor category.
So in July they had an article that,
that, um, and, and one of my early
predictions in this, I thought it
would take three years and it took
four months, but that's AI for you.
Uh, I, I kind of felt like If I'm
OpenAI, and then consequently all
the other frontier model builders,
the, the dominoes for me are they're
spending hundreds of billion dollars
on data centers and GPUs, uh, and
building these models and training them.
Um, they can't monetize with ads
because to beat Google you can't
do ads, you have to differentiate.
So therefore, they're gonna have
to figure out how to monetize.
Um, a consumer subscription is one way.
Um, um, open source to
enterprise is another model.
They're not choosing to do that.
Maybe, maybe Llama will, but I think
they're just more the destroyer of
value, um, as is DeepSeek and some of
the other open models in this world.
They're, they're less monetizing
it all versus throwing a
grenade at the whole thing.
Um, or you're gonna have to pick off
some verticals and figure out how
to make money and, and in a weird
way, Shopify has shown us how to
do this, back to the pin we placed
earlier, by monetizing the checkout.
So, uh, it seems like, and, and you're
starting to see them start to build
out the user experience by pro- popping
up product cards, showing a, a winner
of the product card, and then today
you agentically check out or you get a
redirect to a checkout or cart injection.
Down the road, you'll just
go right into a ChatGPT cart.
So, so are you saying part of this
is to kinda say, "We also want a
world where there's a vibrant…"
Sure, that's one option, but there's
a vibrant world of agents that, um,
you know, maybe they're verticalized,
maybe there's a fashion agent and a
grocery agent and a, uh, you know, I
don't know, a piano agent or whatever.
Or, uh, in the B2B world, I think that's
naturally gonna be verticalized, right?
'Cause the way you buy an electronic
testing machine is different than the
way you do a, you know, a electron
microscope is different than a dental
X-ray machine is different than, um…
So, so I think…
So am I na- Am I getting that ethos right?
That you're, you're trying to have
at least an alternative to that, that
world where you have these big platform
companies that soak up everything.
That's exactly right.
And, and, and I think we can all agree
that we're still in very early innings
on AI, and the future is unwritten.
And so we believe in a world where
you wouldn't hardwire any decision.
And what do I mean by that?
We don't wanna hardwire which, which
platform, OpenAI, Perplexity, you
pick, is gonna be h- who we work with.
We're not gonna hardwire that you have
to use PayPal or Stripe or Adyen or
whatever payment engine we want, or
whatever wallet or checkout we want.
We're not gonna make hardwired decisions.
We also believe that, that, um, merch or
brands- This could be in a world where,
um, uh, it could be the death of brands,
and that would be a terrible outcome.
Um, so we wanna give merchants the
independence to differentiate, to
make, to romance their products,
to let people pay the way that they
want, to use whatever models on the
back end and form a great experience.
So we see this as a moment where open
is gonna be the winner, not closed,
not hardwired decisions, but basically
allow for a framework, um, that allows
for the, for AI to really flourish.
Alliances can mean a lot of things, like
we talked about the MACH Alliance, right?
Where it's an ethos and then all
these, like, requirements to get
into the club kind of a deal.
Um, talk a little bit more about,
like, what's the structure of this?
What are some of the types of
companies, any companies that are
in there that you wanna announce?
Have you guys built some features
and functionality around this?
Uh, and, and just…
So, so give me kind of like a…
It, it was update, It was announced, like,
three months ago, so pretty recently.
I have to go look that up.
But, um, so it may be too early, but,
but would love an update on where
it is and then we can talk about,
like, where do you see it going?
Yeah.
So absolutely.
So the Agentic Commerce Association,
or Alliance, hell, I say it wrong
every time, is, is relatively new.
I think it's three and a half months
since we announced it, and we've
been overwhelmed with people who have
applied, um, from people who absolutely
belong to people who are just trying
to run in front of the marketing story.
And, you know, one of the things
about, you know, our German owners
is it's, it's all about substance,
and style will come later.
And so we're really in the formation
stage of having, um, a small number of
companies who we really feel have a strong
voice as to where agentic commerce needs
to go, how we create frameworks and,
and publish out these things publicly.
Uh, there are some big announcements
happening in Germany, September
16th at our community day.
Um, I think this will probably publish
after, but I can't pre-announce them.
Um, but there's some strategic
partnerships, there's the commitment
to openness, and we're gonna announce
some big meaningful members as well.
So on our podcast, we've had a…
There, there's some interesting
payment companies, right?
So you have the big guys, so MasterCard,
Visa have all announced things.
PayPal's announced a bunch of stuff.
Stripe has.
Um, but then there's
like several startups.
We've had a company called Nakuda on.
Um, we're having another
one called Fusets.
There's, um, once you get, once you
cross the chasm into the crypto world,
there's tons of, um, you know, all kinds
of different crypto solutions from stable
coins and all kinds of stuff like that.
Um, is that like a category of
companies that, that you would
see joining an alliance like this?
Is, is kind of, so payments is a thing.
Um, and then there's lots of
companies thinking about, you know,
different elements of agent building.
Uh, you know, so obviously, you know, the
checkout is, and payment is part of it.
Also, there's a how do these,
uh, you know, how do we trust…
There's trust layers, there's
fraud detection, there's, uh,
frameworks for building agents.
There's MCP servers, A
to A servers, MCP UI.
There's a, you know,
there's, there's like six…
There's a new standard kind of
being born every day and, and so
it's, we're still early on how these
things will talk to each other.
Um- Uh, are those some of
the, the types of companies?
And then obviously the platform
companies that, that, you know,
I think your vision is you could
build an agent on your, your…
Or, or your platform will be very friendly
to agents, and maybe you could build one.
Like, is that kinda how
Shopware factors in this?
A- absolutely.
So j- just to take a step back, we,
we think about agentic commerce.
Agentic commerce is really when a system
is smart enough to go across multiple
different systems, perform complex tasks,
come back, and the job is done, uh, to
oversimplify what agentic commerce is.
And so Shopware is building a bunch
of agents ourselves using our own
AP- uh, you know, our own open
source product to demonstrate how,
how agentic commerce can work.
But at the same time, we're encouraging
people to build out agents as well.
So today you might have an app store
with a bunch of third-party apps.
In the future, there could be
a agent store- Agent store.
Mm-hmm
…
that performs these agents.
And so, yes, third parties
are a big part of it.
In fact, just had a conversation, uh,
with a company called Vouched, which
does a bunch of the basically, um,
validate who you are, who you are,
and allow you to do things online,
and they envision a world where…
Or they're ta- they have a new
product called Know Your Agent.
So instead of KYC that brands have to
go and do business with, and when they
file their payments paperwork, they
have to do this KYC that they know who
they are and what it's being used for.
In a world where agents are gonna
be performing a lot of these complex
tasks, Vouched has a Know Your Agent
protocol that allows you to do business
with an agent and trust that it's
a good, a good, you know, behaving
agent that's, uh, that has the rights
of the business to go perform it.
So we're entering a whole bunch of new,
uh, use cases that we've never thought of.
Let me make one more point.
The entire last 25 years of
e-commerce has been all about removing
friction from doing commerce, okay?
I think we can all agree on that.
It's all around multivariate
testing and removing friction to
optimize for a shopping experience.
The removal of all that friction
actually then inserts some risk
from bad guys and bad behaviors
and bad agents taking advantage
of some of that reduced frictions.
And so the, uh, this is a really
interesting kinda can of worms that
we're getting into, which is why you
need an Agentic Commerce Alliance to
bring some of the smartest companies
together and talk about designing a
system to support the future state.
It can't be done by a single commerce
platform 'cause we simply don't know
enough or have enough broad of a view.
We need the ecosystem.
Okay.
So, uh, announced it three
months ago, September 16th.
Um, we're gonna see some more stuff.
This is a great reason to
have you back on the pod.
And, um-
Have you guys added any…
So another use of agentic is on, I kind
of think of it as external and internal.
Um, external is the things we've talked
about, checkouts and new ways of these
things interact with other systems.
But then there's like, a lot of
retailers are getting big wins off of
agents for customer service, thinking
about inventory allocation, pricing,
personalization, even, even, you
know, uh, a, you know, LL Gen AI-ing
and agentifying the loyalty program.
Uh, are these some of the things
you guys are thinking on, on,
uh, you know, the software side?
And then any, any features, or
is that like a September 16th,
there may be some news there?
Well, I'll give you an example
'cause I, I, I don't wanna be the
guy that says, "Wait and listen."
So one example of a use case we hear
all the time, and there is utility to
go do this, um, already in the market.
But a lot of our distributors,
uh, are deeply, deeply Paying
attention to competing on price.
And they know a small number regionally
of, of different distributors they
compete with, and their goal is to have
a very kinda sensitive pricing strategy.
So today they hire companies like
PriceSpider or other third-party tools.
They go and they research
their competitive prices.
They get that information
at some frequency, and they
manually decide what to go do.
Well, that is the perfect
use case for an agent.
And so, um, you can…
In- inside Shopware, we're, we're
launching a competitive intelligence.
Um, we call them Codys 'cause we're a
bunch of techies, and this Cody would
go off, look at the sites you tell,
look at the SKUs you tell, come back,
tell us the price, and automatically
adjust that price based on the rules
you've set for those prices to happen.
And so maybe you just wanna know, maybe
you wanna change it, maybe you don't.
But the system should be designed
to go perform all those complex
tasks across multiple systems and
automate the job on the back office
to do it for you, uh, included.
And so that's, that's part of an
example of how agentic can take
the blue-collar work done by e- by
ecommerce teams and, a- and automate it.
Yeah.
And those pre-2022 solutions, um,
not to pick on PriceSpider, but we
will, um, that, uh, you know, they're,
they're built off very fragile scraping
and, you know, 80% of the time they
break very easily and, and there's…
You know, the people that know
distributor A is looking at B
and C, they try to break them.
So, so they're…
That adds to the fragility.
And, um, LLM-based agents are way
less fragile, and they're, they're…
Because they have like a little
brain inside of them that if you
move the price around on the page,
they're like, "Oh, I see the price.
It moved from point A to point
B and now it's at point C."
So, um, you know, not only is
it automated, but it's gonna
be inherently more reliable and
more robust than, than kind of…
And more scalable than, than some of
these, m- you know, pre-2022 solutions.
That's what's so wild having been
in the industry for a while, is,
you know, if you think about like
the Digital River BlackBerry store
and like all the stuff that…
You know, I've, I've been behind a
lot of those operations in that era,
and there's like, you know, there's
a, a large percentage of transactions
that result in things being printed
out and people looking at them.
And I remember being in a Sears room one
time where they're actually pulling arms
on registers and stuff, and, uh, it's
just pretty wild to think about now we've
got the little computers doing, doing
everything and, and they're, uh, in many
ways they're, they're better than all
those things we've ever done before 'cause
they're way more scalable and reliable.
Yeah.
You know, the interesting thing that
nobody's talking about is, um- What, what
companies are positioned for the future?
I mean, obviously the companies with
huge R&D budgets are, 'cause they can,
hopefully they can invest in chips and
software and teams to go build the future.
But I, frankly speaking, some of
the upstarts, some of the people who
have more modern tech that have kinda
open thinking, those are gonna be
some of the recipes as who's gonna
be well-positioned for the future.
And that's, that's part of why we
created this alliance, to invite those
companies to come in, to give them an
opportunity to, to, to build agents, to
give them access to our 50,000 clients
and really kind of invent the future.
So that's why we did it.
Yeah.
Cool.
This is, uh, this is
one you can opt out of.
So, and I'll ask as Jason the
industry expert, not the GMO software.
But o- o- one thing I think that's
interesting is while Shopify's good
at, they seem to be able to inject
themselves into, like, whatever's
going on at ChatGPT and Perplexity.
At, at some point, do … I kind of, part
of my theory is those companies get greedy
or, or they wanna capture that checkout.
And there's not anything super
proprietary about the Shopify checkout.
It's basically Stripe with some,
with a one-page and some features.
Um, uh, do you think they get
cut out of that or opt out, out
not to talk about it or Yeah.
Boy.
I, I think, I think everyone's at risk.
Um, you know, uh, a- and all these
existing models, they can pretty
easily tip into an innovator's dilemma.
So, so for example, I
think Google's at risk.
I think there's some Amazon risk.
It's gonna be interesting
to see what happens to them.
And I, I think Shopify feels inoculated
for a while, but at some point, if
you look at the data, they make, like,
70% of their revenue off the checkout.
They're basically a fintech company.
They're, they're a small SaaS business
with, like, a huge, you know, you
know, checkout business where they,
they basically s- you know, make,
make, you know, small percentages
off a huge transaction volume.
So it, it'll be interesting to kinda see.
Or in, in, in, in your, uh, you know,
your, uh, agentic alliance uh, you
know, uh, what's the middle word?
Commerce?
Yeah.
Yeah.
The, uh, Agentic Commerce Alliance,
maybe there's this Cambrian explosion
of little agents and they all have
checkouts, and then in either of
those scenarios, Shopify is not really
running dollars to the checkout.
So, so I just, I kinda come
to this conclusion, and I
don't know which way it goes.
I'm just kind of pointing out there's,
there's, there's a cone of uncertainty
there that's kind of interesting.
Well, it's very, it's very
interesting, and I'm certainly…
I, I'll, I'll disassociate myself
with Shopware for a moment and
kinda talk about my perspective.
I'm a Shopify shareholder.
I'm a big fan of the company.
They're, they're, um, they're
amazing at what they've accomplished.
Um-
You and
Tobi have the same hairstyle?
Me and Tobi, yep.
He's, he, he's German, I'm American,
but we both have the German connection.
Um, but let me, let me say this.
There are 18 vendors on the Gartner
Magic Quadrant for Commerce.
If history is any guide, half of
them, in five years, will be gone.
They'll be acquired or
they'll be out of business.
Shopify has a lot of runway to do really
well for a long time, and they should.
They're a great company.
That said, McDonald's, as a
proxy, is not a burger company,
they're a real estate company.
Just like Shopify is not a commerce
platform, they're a fintech.
Okay?
So there's a lot of parallels.
The companies can be really
successful showing you one
thing, but making money another.
But there are, as you know, there are
two great ways to make money, uh, in,
in, in, in America, corporate America.
Bundling and unbundling.
And so Shopify bundles payments with
it today, and at the time it makes more
sense to unbundle it and take the payment
relationship direct, they probably will.
Um, and, and open, and the, the
Agentic Commerce Alliance, or Agentic
Commerce itself could be the potential
great unbundling of commerce.
Yeah.
Okay.
So I'm not barking up an
entirely wrong tree there?
Not at all.
You'll let us know when
you sell your Shopify.
That's, that'll be the
canary in the coal mine.
Yeah, there you go.
Uh, awesome.
Well, Jason, that's all
the questions I had.
Any, any topics you wanna hit on
while we're, while we're here?
Anything I, I didn't cover that,
that's top of mind with you?
No, I don't think so.
I'm just excited to have you on
the Commerce Famous podcast, uh,
here coming up soon, where we're
gonna flip the script and I get
to ask you all the hard questions.
Absolutely, I'm looking forward to it.
The, uh, a couple kind of like,
uh, wrap-up lightning round ones.
Um, so when I had Roy Rubin on, he
basically kinda gets this conclusion
where we're probably three years out…
He, he kinda comes to the conclusion, and
there's two ways he kinda has said this.
We're three years out from there
being websites that get used,
that they're m- mainly there
for, uh, an agent to read stuff.
Um, so that's one side of that coin.
And the other one is he thinks we'll have
a billion dollar brand built without a
website in, you know, the next two years.
Um, what's your reaction to that?
Well, Roy's smarter than
me, so he's probably right.
I'm just gonna defer
to he's probably right.
Um, but, but I'll say-
I You know, anytime you get these
predictions, you have a bunch of
people who are trying to prove
they're either right or wrong.
And I, I think what's gonna happen in
B2B is you're gonna take a lot of the
transactions that are happening today
through, uh, other offline means,
and they're gonna just attribute
them to an agentic commerce use
case, whether it fully is or not.
So I, I do think that headline will be
happening, that there's a billion-dollar
business that doesn't have a website,
but I think it's mostly because of share
shift and not because of value creation.
That's what I think.
Yep.
The other one I like to kinda ask
guests is the PayPal CEO said by 2030,
25% of e-commerce will be agentic.
Do you, do you take the over,
under, or agree with that?
I take the over.
Uh, definitely, and I
think Alex Chriss is…
got his finger on the pulse here.
Uh, big fan of, of him and his, his
positioning around agentic commerce.
Um, I will say I think that
the pie is getting bigger.
Um, I think agentic commerce has the
ability to serve significantly a larger
portion of digital as opposed to taking
what is classic e-commerce today and
shifting it to, to, to agentic commerce.
So to me, the pie gets bigger,
and yes, 25% is probably
reasonable in that period of time.
Okay.
And then the last one, um, Bernstein's
a Wall Street analyst, and, uh, right
now e-commerce is growing kind of 6.8%
year over year if you look at the
US Department of Commerce data.
This is a US number.
I'm sure Germany is,
like, a different set.
Um, but, but, but everyone's kinda seen
this, like, you know, tapering off of
growth where we were growing crazy, uh,
and now we've kinda slowed down to…
We're still better than retail, but, but
yeah, I would like to see us grow faster.
But anyway, they've said that they
believe agentic commerce in the next
two years will accelerate that one and a
half to two and a half points, which 2%,
2% doesn't seem like a lot, but on 6.8,
it's actually a, a, a
25 to 30% acceleration.
Do you take the over,
under, or agree on that one?
I'll take the over.
Um, but it's gonna be, it's gonna
be distributed very differently.
So first off, Shopware is growing at,
like, 38%, and so we are taking shares.
So I'm a bit biased on where I
think growth is coming from 'cause
we're seeing a lot of growth
through new customer acquisition,
not necessarily same source sales.
Now, that said, again, there's 18
vendors on the Gartner Magic Quadrant.
I think five to seven of those
are gonna be winners, and
the rest are gonna be losers.
And so, um, I think the industry
itself will grow, you know,
somewhere around double digits.
Maybe 10, maybe 9%.
But the people who win
on it is gonna be more
less distributed than it classically.
I think AI is gonna separate the
winners and losers in that regard.
So hopefully I answered your question.
All right.
That's a good place to, to wrap it up.
Um, good luck, uh, with your
conference coming up, and I look
forward to being on your podcast.
Amazing.
Thanks, Scott.
A big fan.
Proud.
Super excited to be on the call.
Awesome.
Thanks for joining us.
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with Retailgenic, your guide
to the future of AI shopping agents.