The show that explores what makes Sri Lanka Sri Lankan.
Sri Lanka's Polonnaruwa Kings Part VI. Dodging Destiny
How did the Polonnaruwa kingdom manage to dodge its destiny, at least for a bit - and build an even more brilliant kingdom?
Many a self-help manual solemnly tells its riveted readers, “You didn't lose them—you dodged a bullet".
It seems that you can always count on that advice to float benevolently to the top of nearly every opening self-help chapter on relationships, unabashed by its apparent disinterested altruism.
From the bestseller “You Dodged the Bullet,” to the blockbuster “He's Just Not That Into You,” some of America’s finest relationship gurus line up to tell you to give yourself a pat on the back for having had a lucky escape, one in which you lost nothing.
But were they to see the world with the more unforgiving eyes of politicos and power brokers, they might realise that they were saying something quite different - you may have escaped for now; but they are still after you.
And for the fractious, poisonous, multifaceted cliques of the Vijayabahu dynasty, this would be the wisest reading of all. Forewarned is, after all, forearmed.
At the time that Vijayabahu II ascended the throne in 1186, the dynasty was little more than 130 years old, but for 70% of the time the throne had been enjoyed by just two of the five kings that had reigned to that point – its founding paterfamilias, Vijayabahu I and the great king, Parakramabahu. The reigns of the other three kings had been crippled by family politics, their tenures either brutally short or embarrassing elongated feats of raw survival.
Ever since the first Vijayabahu died, cousin had fought cousin, nephew aunt, husband sister-in-law, and on and on through all the possible permutations of family relationships.
Falling out with your family was ever a feature of royal life in Sri Lanka – since its very foundation in 543 BCE; and more of its kings met their death at the hands of their successor than they ever did in the more comforting arms of natural old age. Even by these standards, the Vijayabahu had set itself up early on to break all previous records. But what gave the bloodshed its most terrible edge is that they were doing so on the edge of a metaphorical cliff, one of history’s spectacular hinge moments when the future could have been so very very altered had people at the time behaved just a little differently.
The backdrop to all this was, of course, the Anuradhapura kingdom itself – the kingdom that had safeguarded, nurtured, and created all that was unique to Sinhala culture; and which had been almost wholly destroyed by the invasion of the Tamil Chola in 993 and their subsequent decades-long occupation and impoverishment of the island.
After much effort by many others, not least Vijayabahu I, the Cholas were finally pushed back to India. The country once again belonged to its original inhabitants.
But it was a broken inheritance. Almost every aspect of life, from water technology to religion, functioning ports and roads to language, law, and architecture and the effective governance and administration of the land, needed to be reinvented.
The energy, focus, money, resources, and human capital needed to repair, restore and reinstate all of this was colossal. It was certainly not the sort of endeavour that could be done again and again, let alone when anyone bothered to make time.
For this sort of enterprise a nation would be lucky enough to get more than a single go to put things right. But just when sustained governance was most needed, the ruling dynasty played truant.
Parakramabahu may have overdone things with his massive overspending, foreign adventures, and later debilitating coercive economic policies, but he reunited the land and restored a dominant Sinhalese state. Yet the state he bequeathed to his heir was almost bankrupt, certainly exhausted, and most definitely both overtaxed and over-strained. It needed nurturing.
Whereas Parakramabahu’s claim to rule had come from his descent from Princess Mitta, the sister of Vijayabahu I – the Arya or Pandyan Branch of the family, his lack of sons led him to appoint a nephew from the Kalinga Branch of the family, so-called as it claimed descent from King Vijayabahu I and his Kalinga first wife - Vijayabahu II.
Nurturing his overstressed new state was precisely what the new king had in mind. And nurturing is what it appeared to get – at least to begin with. The Culavamsa Chronicle calls him a “wise poet sovereign,” whose very first act as king was to “release from their misery those dwellers in Lanka who his uncle had thrown in prison or tortured with stripes or with fire.”
He ended the fractious Burmese war his uncle had begun shortly before his death. He was, the chronicle says, “practised in the exercise of justice,” was respected by both the “lay people and the Order,” and “interested himself in all beings,” with “kindness, purity and other virtues”.
Had Sri Lanka really got lucky with this prudent new king? Possibly. But not, sadly lucky enough. For what Vijayabahu II had in goodness and wisdom, he lacked in cunning and guile. He was just not Machiavellian enough to survive
At first all seemed fine. Broad pardons were issued, political prisoners freed, and land forcibly confiscated by Parakramabahu was returned to its rightful owners. Bounty rained down on the monks. He even wisely reappointed Nissanka Malla, his Kalinda cousin and/or brother-in-law, as his heir apparent – the Uparaja.
Even so, he was murdered.
Quite what lay behind the assassination of the king, apart from raw political greed on the part of his assassin, Mahinda, is unclear. The chronicles teasingly allude to the two sharing the affection of a cowherd's daughter, “Dipani, by name.” But quite what part she played in the coup is unrecorded.
Mahinda was not even slightly related to any part of the various royal lines that dominated matters in Polonnaruwa, though it is quite possible that he played on the rivalry that existed between the king (he of the Kalinga branch) and the Arya or Pandyan Branch, now out in the cold since Parakramabahu’s death.
Despite the liability of his birthright and his apparent lack of military experience, Mahinda was ruthless enough to simply kill the king and seize the throne.
In retrospect, it was rather a silly thing to do, despite its great boldness, for he did not last long. Yet there is a tantalising stone inscription – the Madigiriya inscription, found in a monastery an hour’s drive north of Polonnaruwa, that adds a tiny bit of flesh to this shadowy killer.
Amid various attendant ordinances, immunities bestowed and protections granted against overbearing royal officials, the inscription takes special care to honour a local nobleman for helping drive the Chola forces out of Sri Lanka. Perhaps this unexpectedly patriotic gesture suggests some nationalist impulse behind Mahinda’s actions. Or perhaps not. As with so much ancient Sri Lankan history, this is a coy and playful cul-de-sac, to be noticed, smiled at and filed under “Miscellaneous”.
Curiously, the Culavamsa Chronicle, whilst eager to brand the upstart as a “traitor,” who “treacherously slayed the monarch,” especially castigates him for having done so “without gaining the consent of the generals,” almost as if his greatest fault had been to fail to prepare the ground better for his coup.
Mahinda’s 5-day reign lasted about as long as a mosquito takes to develop from an egg to a biting adult; and he was, of course, killed and succeeded by Nissanka Malla, the Uparaja.
An observer on the sidelines at the time might easily have concluded that the almost 10-year reign of this new 30-year-old king, Nissanka Malla, was all it took to nip ruin in the bud. A good, legitimate king had died, but his assassin had been quickly eliminated, and the natural order of things was restored.
All was good. Destiny – at least the destiny that led to total disaster – had been defied. Or had it?
If any king ever deserved to leave behind a prosperous, stable legacy simply by dint of governing well, Nissanka Malla merited it. He is certainly one of the most overlooked, productive, and dynamic kings the island ever had the good fortune to enjoy.
The historical sources for Nissanka Malla’s reign are almost excessive, certainly compared to most other monarchs. The usual four great written chronicles of the time give many details and help corroborate dates and people. The trusty, if not wholly trustworthy, Culavamsa tells us all about Nissanka Malla’s Kalinga origin, his religious patronage, and the political chaos that followed his death. The 13th-century Puja Valiya confirms dates and lists his religious endowments. The Raja Valiya chronicle does much the same, chucking in a few more construction projects for good measure. The Nikaya Sangrahaya restricts itself to detailing just how keen Nissanka Malla was on purifying the Buddhist sangha.
At least 20 inscriptions, including one or two found in Tamil Nadu, detail many other aspects of his rule, from his family tree to his views on Buddhism, kingship, tax policies, and tours. Some of his stunning buildings still exist, and the coins he issued during his reign are still plentiful enough to be unearthed today.
The Chronicles quickly note how the new king governed “in the most excellent fashion,” earning much merit, and that from the outset he was evident everywhere.
It is perhaps no coincidence that the many inscriptions he left behind, along with the remarkable architecture he commissioned, were part of a deliberate self-promotion campaign to legitimise his reign and compensate for his Indian origins. He even went so far as to carve his own inscriptions onto monuments and irrigation tanks originally built by earlier kings.
Related through his lineage to Vijayabahu I, Nissanka Malla was all the same an Indian prince ruling over a Sinhala nation, with one branch of the family, the Arya Pandyan side, left grumbling on the side, and at least one, if not several, of Parakramabahu’s three remarkable queens always on hand to remind everyone of the good old days.
One of his first acts was to underline and validate his right to rule, passing a royal decree that only a devout Theravada Buddhist of the Kalinga dynasty could rule the island. “People,” he proclaimed, “should not establish in the Island of Lanka, which belongs to the Kalinga dynasty, non-Buddhist kings of Cola countries who are inimical to the religion of the Buddha. Since the time of Prince Vijaya, it is to the princes of the Kalinga dynasty that the Island of Lanka has belonged.”
History, of course, gives the lie to this bold statement, but propaganda wars are never won by telling little lies.
A massive 26-foot stone slab inscription in Galpota not only connects his ancestry back to Prince Vijaya in 543 BCE but adds some more immediate validation:
“He grew up in the midst of royal splendour and being invited by the great king of the Island of Lanka, his senior kinsman, to rule over the Island of Lanka which is his by right of lineal succession of kings, he landed in Lanka in great state. Enjoying (thereafter) the regal dignities of the governor and sub-king, and being proficient in the science of arms, in religion, and in all arts and sciences, he is due order of regal succession received the sacred unction and wearing the crown assumed supreme sovereignty.”
And if this was not enough, the inscription adds, “ the appearance of an impartial king should be welcomed as the appearance of the Buddha,“ making clear the old, sometimes-discreet claim of most island kings that, though they appear in human form, they are human divinities (nara-devata) and must, therefore, be regarded as gods.
Nissanka Malla’s tireless self-promotion was both necessary and well executed – and reinforced by royal tours of the kingdom, many recorded in a scattering of stone inscriptions, including one that marks a recent visit by declaring the site a "joy-conferring pavilion" with the legal right to confer asylum to anyone who sought it.
Nissanka Malla’s rule was almost textbook perfect. He didn’t just enact rules and orders. He first checked out what was actually going on – and then gave instructions. More than most of his predecessors, he is recorded as being addicted to travelling around his land. His tours were always carefully planned, with 4 army regiments accompanying him as he inspected the quality of local administration, administered justice, and even standardised measurements by introducing a stone milestone system to measure distance along royal roads. The ever-insubordinate southern principality of Ruhana was especially singled out for repeated visits, with his retinue arriving in a flurry of additional troops to remind locals of the wisdom of obedience.
Nissanka Malla was that rarest of leaders – one who governed both very well and very energetically. He rolled back the taxes Parakramabahu I imposed for as many as five years, cancelled levies on poor farmers who earned a living through slash-and-burn farming and set up a programme to distribute livestock and land to desperate farmers. “He quenched the fire of poverty with showers of gifts,” runs one inscription in Polonnaruwa’s north Citadel and East Gate. At least a dozen smaller slab inscriptions dotted around the country record other more specific acts of charity.
He built an astonishing number of stunning structures within Polonnaruwa, including the beautifully decorated Hatadage to house the Buddha's Sacred Tooth Relic; the largest stupa in the city; a 7-story royal place with bathing pools; a Council Chamber whose pillars were annotated with the exact seating positions his ministers and nobles were required to follow – evidence, if it were ever needed of the very structured bureaucracy he had created.
He also built a unique Pavilion of Vines, whose lotus columns twist upward to enclose a suitably sequestered space for listening to Buddhist prayers. In the shortest of time, he gilded his capital with monumental new architecture and even set up a special stone seat in its centre to mark the very spot from which he would watch elephant fights and theatre.
He ensured that a close relationship existed between himself and the Buddhist Sangha – all the better to reinforce royal authority. One inscription records his pilgrimage to Anuradhapura in the 4th year of his rule and the vast sums he spent restoring its great stupas. Inscriptions found in the Dambulla caves record how he furnished the temples with 73 golden Buddha statues. He even undertook a lengthy pilgrimage to the summit of Sri Pada itself.
Like his famous uncle, he took pains to do whatever was possible to limit the power of the Chola empire in India, at one point personally leading an army to Rameswaram, a small Tamil island that lay close to the Sri Lankan coast as part of his efforts to place a more amenable anti-Chola king on the Pandyan throne. His many accounts of his Indian expedition, all within Sri Lanka, claim the victory was his, though contemporary Indian accounts claim the opposite.
Whatever the truth, the wonder is that he was ever strong enough to make such expeditions in the first place. Almost none of his predecessors - going all the way back to the earliest records of recorded Indian history – ever dared do this much. And certainly, by morphing into ferocious warrior mode, he would have cast his reputation wide as a king one would be best not to cross.
There are no standout accounts of rival claimants and internal rebellions during Nissanka Malla’s rule – most probably because he was so strong and ever-present a ruler that no one dared. But as with his uncle, all this fell apart the very moment he died. And he was to die very young, even for the times – aged just 38 or 39 in 1196. It may well have been a natural death; and certainly he was immediately succeeded by his 16-year-old son, Vira Bahu I - but given the sorrowful fate of his successor, it is just as likely that something much more nefarious and sudden happened to shorten his remarkable reign, even if there is no smoking gun, merely the faintest possible whiffs of what-ifs. It is another entertaining, impossible-to-escape historical cul-de-sac.
But his death did draw an indelible line for both the Polonnaruwa kingdom and the future of the unitary Sinhala state. Within the shortest possible time, both had fallen apart; and though the island-wide rule of Sri Lanka from a single point would flicker briefly for a moment here and there over the next 8 centuries, it would not be until the centralising powers of one last colonial occupier – the British – and the independence that followed their departure in 1948 before the island was ever again to enjoy such national freedom as it had during the reign of its last great real all-island king, Nissanka Malla.
Like this magnificent uncle, he is just one of a tiny handful of Sri Lankan kings you can actually meet - at least in effigy.
His face still exists, ready for you to gaze upon – a quite remarkable life-size painted statue located inside Cave Number 3 in Dambulla.
At first glance, the king seems wholly humble, his hands held together in homage to the Buddha. Yet the very positioning of his statue within a cave otherwise wholly dedicated to statues of the Lord Buddha tells you much about how he regarded himself. A golden gem-studded crown rises from his head. Jewels loop and hang from his chest to his belly and all around his hips. Even his clothes are golden. Pious he may have been, but he followed no one, a king whose very style made explicit an unquestionable dominance every bit as unmistakable as the remarkable achievements of his short, sure-footed, starry destiny-dodging reign.
"Après moi, le deluge," was said to be the last wise words ever spoken by France’s last all-powerful king, Louis XV. Nissanka Malla would be forgiven for wishing to say the same. If ever there was a deluge to come, it was the one that awaited Sri Lanka after his death.