The Honest Money Show is your guide to understanding what money really is, and where Bitcoin fits in. Hosted by Anja Dragovic, Australia's female-led, Bitcoin-only podcast, it cuts through the noise to explore how money shapes our lives, why the current system leaves so many people behind, and what a clearer, fairer future could look like.
Expect honest, accessible conversations with some of the most interesting thinkers in the space, the kind that take you from "I don't really get this" to genuinely curious. No hype, no pressure, just money, made clear.
Whether you're brand new to these questions or already deep in them, you're welcome here.
What is the sentiment in Australia at the moment?
Like what does the public sector think of Bitcoin?
The problem is that it doesn't!
But you've got banks already saying within
the terms of conditions that they'll look through
your social media and that's really them deciding who
who they want to be able to, uh, service.
For a, a institution that has no opinion on Bitcoin
it sure talks about it a lot.
You don't get to decide for me what I use as a currency.
I decide, and I choose to use Bitcoin.
Joining me today for a very special
episode of The Honest Money Show is Bayani
Mills. Bayani is the CEO of Australian
Bitcoin Industry Body, also known as ABIB
in short. Bayani, welcome to the show and
thanks for joining us. Thanks very much,
Anja. To kick things off, I really want to
know, so you obviously engage a lot with
the government and I want to know, what is
the sentiment in Australia at the moment?
Like what does the public sector think of
Bitcoin? The problem is that it doesn't.
That's probably the problem, the long and
short of it. It's a spectrum of interest
across a range of different access, but in
short, it doesn't. And why would it? It's
only experience or exposure to Bitcoin is
really around crypto and what's in the
mainstream media. So it doesn't have many
people engaging government overall,
specifically on Bitcoin. Yeah,
interesting. So with the people that you
have had a touch point with, have you
managed to change the hearts and the minds
of some of those people? Again, mixed
result. There's been, it's been promising.
It's been promising. That being said, the
people that we're typically engaging with
are typically people that are already
curious. It's often difficult to try and
change the hearts and minds around with
people who don't have an interest in
changing their mind on things. So if
you've already come to a position where
you're engaging with ABIB, it's possibly
that you're willing to hear us out and
have us help them understand what Bitcoin
is and what it isn't. Yeah. Okay. That's
interesting because they do, I'm not going
to mention their name, but I do recall a
few years ago, someone reached out wanting
to know more. And it was like the first
instance where we had a politician who was
curious and I guess wanted to speak to the
people in the industry behind it. But has
there been any other instances like that
since? Yes. Yes. A number of independents.
And I think that's probably more
interesting than otherwise
would have been considered because an
independent is not having to tow a party
line. And so it can go to these types of
engagements. It can go to and speak to us
far more freely than somebody that's
within a party. I think what we need to
try and do is be able to find on an
individual basis why these policymakers
might be interested in understanding more
about Bitcoin. And then from there, start
there, I think, is really get a baseline
feel for what their sentiment is and help
them through that. And that is a long-term
project. That's not a, hey, let's go for a
coffee and I'll tell you everything about
Bitcoin and you'll get it and you'll buy
some or you'll do some Bitcoin mining.
Like we know that's how that happens.
Okay. But tell me about the recent event
that you organized at the Parliament House
in Melbourne. Yeah. So, Australian Bitcoin
industry body with its people down in
Victoria. We were hosted by David
Lindbrick, MP, from the Libertarians. And
so we were in Parliament House speaking
specifically, not about Bitcoin as money,
but rather Bitcoin as part of facilitating
better energy infrastructure, better
methane abatement, better data centers
built out. And the downstream effects of
that, cheaper cost of energy for the
consumer. So the interest is there, but
it's one of those things where the event
itself isn't the pinnacle of the
engagement. It's just part of that
campaign of engagement policymakers on a
larger timeframe. So reaching out to
federal along with it, they had a sitting
week in Canberra, so no one really was
able to come from there. And this is what
at the time was the last sitting week in
Parliament before the elections up in
November. So the fact that we got the
right kind of people in the room, it bodes
well for what we intend to do in the
future. And this would just be one of many
that we do across each state. Yeah, I love
that. So what do you think is going to
take to marry the problem with the
solution? Because I feel like the energy
angle is like the most obvious way to, I
guess, showcase the benefit of Bitcoin to
someone who might be a little bit hesitant
to think of it as a monetary solution. But
it is an energy solution. So what do we
need to do to kind of help bridge that gap
and marry the solution and problem? What
you've got is that knowledge gap. That's
what we're going to close is that
knowledge gap. And that starts with an
awareness that there is a knowledge gap to
close. We find that a lot of the time the
gap is what's Bitcoin got to do with
energy infrastructure? And of course, why
would they know? So we can bring awareness
in its first instance. Sometimes that's a
matter of letting that sit, let them
digest that initially. And then over time,
present some ideas about, hey, look, it's
not about some type of theory. This is
what's happening outside. And to a degree,
also domestically in Australia. What we
have, however, is a range of entities that
are doing Bitcoin mining that just don't
talk about it. For obvious reasons. But
maybe let's touch on that. Like, why do
you think that is the case? Why aren't
they talking about it? Because, again,
just recently there was a case of a
brewery. I had no idea they were mining
Bitcoin. And, like, they kept that under
wraps for a long time. So I do imagine
there's probably a lot more that we don't
know of. Even, you know, being in the
industry body ourselves, we'll probably be
surprised knowing that it's not something
you advertise openly. But why is that?
There's a number of different reasons.
It's typically down to the sites involved
and also the people involved. So that is
why I say there is probably a lot more
Bitcoin mining happening than
policymakers, regulators would otherwise
think. Or let alone we would think.
Because Bitcoin, being a disparate bunch
as we are, being a privacy conscious bunch
that we are, are just building. They're
not necessarily asking permission if this
is okay. And that being said, it's not as
if Bitcoin mining in and of itself is not
allowed. Rather, the reputational or
social license or political will to
support it is not really there where they
want to be able to deal with those kind of
conversations. It's like, you know what,
I'd rather just build and just do the
thing, not sit there and try to justify,
defend what I'm doing when we know that
the outcomes are beneficial. Yeah, okay,
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So I guess that raises
the bigger question and that is why are we
so behind in Australia? Yeah. I think Dan
Roberts, I think it was, from iron,
probably said best in one of the AFR
articles about the brown cardigans over at
the ASX example. We have a situation where
innovation is and was happening in
Australia, but the regulators for whatever
reason, just started probably out of fear
and ignorance rather than trying to lean
into that innovation, put the barriers up
and for all intents and purposes, the
talent and the investment just went
overseas. And so a lot of the building
that could have been happening here in
Australia over the last 10 years never
did. We're now at a stage where we're
trying to ram through regulations around
data centers that never needed to be the
case. If we had a regulatory framework 10
years ago that was supportive of, or at
least curious enough to look at how the
characteristics of Bitcoin mining was
different to that of general demand loads
and how that could have been utilized to
flywheel the build out of greater amount
of energy infrastructure. Be it energy
generation assets or the poles and wires.
So that being said, it's only within the
last nine months that we've started to see
regulations around that change. There's
now far more discussions around flexible
load, but Bitcoin isn't specifically part
of the conversation. And that might be by
design in the sense that it's trying to be
technologically agnostic, but they are
talking about flexible loads requiring
that centers power downs during certain
thresholds. But if Bitcoin mining becomes
part of that equation and they sit above
what they would require as part of their
baseline demand for their AI HPC, then it
might very well just be part of what we're
doing. And for some places it already is.
As I said, there's a range of different
assets out there that are already doing
Bitcoin mining, but they just don't talk about it.
Yeah, that's an interesting take Bayani because
I've noticed in Australia, there is a
cognitive dissonance between what the
politicians say and what it is that they
do because they talk about innovation
being very important, but then they don't
actually do anything to support it. So the
other thing I was thinking about last
night is just how much talent we have in
Australia, specifically in the Bitcoin
industry. We're punching well above our
weight globally. So we have lightning
wallets, we have lending platforms, we
have collaborative custody arrangements,
companies that do that. We also have like
custodial, I believe, platforms as well.
Like there's, there's a lot that we do in
Australia that I feel like needs to be
seen and supported. I think on a per
capita basis, like we're having five
Bitcoin only exchanges. That's, that's
well above our weight for, for, for those
types of services, including hardware
wallet manufacturer like Frostnap. Yeah,
we, we do have a, a large number of people
that are building in Australia. And I
don't think it's necessarily an issue of
policymakers making rules that, that
require Bitcoin innovation, et cetera, but
rather sometimes it's just getting out of
the way. And acknowledging that some of
the regulations that are out there are
for, for frameworks that were, you know, a
couple of decades old and they do need to
be updated. But the, the machinery of
bureaucracy is a lot slower than the
ability for someone to build, especially
for nimble startups. And so if you're not
going to have a framework that is going to
be forward looking that says, okay, look,
you know, we, this is what we could be
doing in the next five to 10 years, but
rather sits there and says, no, this is
the way things are. And we've always done
it this way. Well, that's, that's exactly
the kind of circumstance that leads to
capital flight. And in fact, that's why a
lot of people are leaving Australia,
right? Like there's so much discussion
around looking for people's plan B, where
they're moving to, where they're taking
the capital with them. So as much as the
regulations to try being changed to try
and increase the amount of revenue going
to the government, the very people that
likely would have been paying a large
portion of that are just going, I'm out.
So I suppose that goes to a large question
of where's the hope? Where can we, where,
why would we stay in Australia if we're
not feeling like our capital was being
treated well? And I don't think a lot of
us, a lot of Bitcoiners see that being the
case. They want to stay here because they,
they, they love the people. They love the
places that they live in, but you know,
that comes with trade-offs as well. Yeah.
I'm noticing a lot more in independent
media, not necessarily anything to do with
Bitcoin, but that is that very common
theme running through. And a lot of
podcasters are interviewing guests who
have either already left or are leaving.
And it's, it's heartbreaking that this is
the, that what it's come to in Australia,
that young people no longer see hope in
this country, that they feel like the only
way to make it and get ahead in life to, I
guess, start a family, start a business is
to do it overseas. So, yeah. And to, to
avoid the doomerism, you know, if we might
be in a situation where we might not want
to be politically involved and you don't
have to be political about it, but if you,
if you want things to change, those
changes don't happen in a vacuum. You have
to be turning up. You have to be in the
room with, with the policymakers, with the
regulators, with the bureaucracy, pushing
back against whatever idea they've got
that you don't agree with, because you
need to be able to be represented in some
way. And if you're not being represented,
don't expect the regulations to change in
your favour. They just won't. Why would
they? That's a really good point. And on
that note, let's talk about how people can
get involved in ABIB. Yep. So the, the,
the two key ways is either financially,
and that's simple enough, become a member,
a sponsor, and that's an annual fee. The
other side of things is contributing your
time and effort. You know, if there's a, a
particular type of niche area you want to
develop maybe your skills in, um, or maybe
your understanding, then, you know, get,
get in touch and become part of the
working groups that are working in, in
that particular field. There's a range of
different things from Bitcoin mining to
AML KYC to AUSTRAC, ASIC, Treasury, and
then there's state-based issues as well.
So there's a range of different angles
that we're looking at this, uh, about how
we can be politically engaged. Um, and it
might even be as, as simple as, um,
creating a bit of a state-based group, um,
amongst, uh, people that are looking to be
more engaged politically in their state,
uh, which is exactly what has resulted in,
uh, what's happened in Victoria is we've
got a number of Victorian Bitcoiners that
said, okay, let's do something that is
going to address the issues in this state.
And that's part of a larger multi-year
campaign of engagement. Um, so it
definitely is a bit of a, a long-term
thing, but ultimately, Viris in numeris,
like, strength in numbers. We, we need, we
need people, um, that are willing to, to
build, to do the things. To do the things.
Do the things. Do all the things. Do it,
yes. Love a good meme reference. Um, I'm
going to ask you to pick a favorite. Is
there a state in Australia that has the
strongest Bitcoiners? Hmm. Okay. Yeah. So
that's a couple of different angles there.
So funnily enough, Byron Bay has the
highest per capita penetration of Bitcoin
accepting businesses. Nice. Well, thank
you. By far. Uh, everyone out there has
been doing a great job of communicating
the concept, um, and helping people
through that process. And that's the same
kind of thing. You have to be engaged with
people if you want things to change.
Bitcoin is not going to gain adoption by
everyone being quiet about it. You know,
as much as it's, uh, there's that deep
sigh of, of, of frustration of being able
to orange pill people. I think that, um,
for the most part, um, yeah, we just need
to be more involved. There's not telling
people, you know, necessarily what Bitcoin
is, but helping them understand what the
problems are initially. And then letting
that sit with them, come back to them a
little while later. But in terms of, uh,
what's happening in states, uh, each
state, um, look, there's, there's, other
than Victoria, there's not a great deal of
activity happening in each state. I'd love
to see more involvement from people
within, uh, the ACT and the Northern
Territory. But again, it's very disparate
lot. It's like a bit like herding cats.
Uh, um, yeah, it would be good to get a
number of different people across each
state. The next goal for us, uh, or at
least the next event planned is going to
be, um, New South Wales at this stage. Um,
yeah. Nice. Yeah. I can imagine trying to
herd and centralize the most decentralized
lot of people would be a unique challenge.
Um, which is why, which is why the
contribution angle for ABIB is contribute
what you can, when you can not sit there
and try and micromanage everything. Just
bring what you can, it will be an effort
and time. Love, love that. Um, let's talk
about KYC, also known as know your
customer, also known in the internet
forums as kill your customer. Yep. So
let's talk about that because how is that
unfolding in Australia? Um, so
interestingly enough, there was a lot of
people that got very vocal about
legislation that got brought in that were
not vocal during its development.
And that's, I think, half the problem. If
we want things to change to any degree,
whether it is holding the fire door open
or kicking it back open altogether, then
we have to turn up. Um, what we've seen is
that a lot of this legislation that's
coming through, um, is from the FATF.
We're not necessarily, um, we're not front
running anything else that other countries
haven't already done. We're relatively
behind, which could be good from a range
of different angles. Um, but we find that
the engagement with AUSTRAC is, is pretty
good. Um, they're willing to listen and,
and, you know, engage with us when we're
saying, hey, we've got these concerns
about this type of privacy issue, et
cetera. Um, and they, they've gone off and
continue looking at, uh, or continue to
investigate what we've, we've raised with
them. Um, but if it's going to be any type
of more substantial, um, addressing of, of
those issues, then it really does require
some effort of people to go through what's
coming down the pipeline, looking at
consultation opportunities, um, and, um,
creating the content specifically to
address those concerns, both for, not just
for Oztrac and, um, and policymakers, but
also for media. Um, the policymakers are
still going to be, um, the social license
that policymakers have is going to be
driven by media. And if it's not going to
be political, it's not going to be
politically, uh, savory to do so, then
they, they possibly won't. But that, that
public perception is shaped by how media
portrays things. If we are putting out in
front of, or putting out towards media,
the information that they require to
accurately report on the downstream
effects that, um, this data collection,
um, this widespread data collection is
having, uh, that we need to be able to, to
communicate that to them. Yeah. Do you
think AUSTRAC gets it, like gets our
concerns? Because you and I know Bitcoin
is like, I just regular Australians that
are trying to save in a better form of
money. They're trying to, I guess, beat
inflation. They are trying to save maybe
for a deposit for a house. So obviously
they're not necessarily against KYC as
such. Um, it's just to the extent and the
level that it's being done and creating
those kind of honeypots of data is a real
concern, especially now with the Medicare
hack that happened recently. Um, do, do
people in AUSTRAC understand that there's a
safety concern in Bitcoin that doesn't
exist in fiat and that it is a legitimate
concern of law abiding Australians? I
think they hear us when we say it, but I
don't think it really follows through
given the very, um, given the type of
regulation that ends up going through. And
I think that it is a, a matter of a
privileged position in that, um, what I
sort of find is that these government
departments get quite siloed. And so they
have this, these blinkers on about what
they address and they don't, because it's
not within their scope, they go, okay,
well, that's not for us to consider. It's
like, well, what you're doing results in
these types of downstream effects. So we
can address these types of effects by what
you're doing. So it's sort of the emergent
property of the system. It's not as if
they were scoped that way that it results
in this. It's, this is the result of it
being scoped in this way. And I think that
given some of the conversations that I've,
I've seen happen over the years, um, yeah,
it's not that it's necessarily just lip
service. I think it's maybe the, the
implications, um, is not deeply thought
about. It's quite, um, it's quite surface
level consideration. Um, not long-term
considerations about how to manage data,
um, or what needs to be collected. Um, you
know, ultimately it really is, AML KYC is
really about that, that system of control,
about who gets to engage in what type of
activity. And the banks are in effect,
these deputized, um, gatekeepers to who
can, to, who can engage financially with
other people. Um, and yeah, you know,
police would typically require some type
of, um, you know, police can confiscate
things, judges can, can issue warrants, et
cetera, but banks can just do so. And
they, they get away with not being held to
account because there's no system to hold
them to account. It's just the RBSA RBA
saying, oh, you can, you can't do this. Or
I was trying to say, look, we don't think
we should, you should be doing that. Or we
don't recommend it. It's like, well, we
don't really have much of a choice if the
incentive model for the banking sector is
the same. And it's only been in recent
years that the, the banking sector is
opening up to its first aspects of digital
assets. And it's only within the confines
of being able to issue assets that they
can control. Yeah. Like I'm really
concerned. I'm not going to lie. Like I
know Australia is a very safe country, but
I almost feel like it's only a matter of
time until there is a case where let's say
maybe a boomer couple went overseas and
went to a developing country. And somehow
on the dark web, people found out they had
some Bitcoin and like a $5 wrench attack
happened. And I guess these policymakers
will put their hands back and say they had
nothing to do with it, but the writing was
on the wall. And we've been saying that
this is only a matter of time until
something like this happens. And so I just
don't think this data needs to be
centralized to the extent that they're
trying to centralize this data. Like why?
Yeah. The, what I've seen from Austrac is
that they,
again, to whatever degree it's this level
of lip service or cursory or service level
acknowledgement, they acknowledge the
concerns and but take none of the
responsibility. It's like, well, you've
created the legislation that requires it
and you're going to beat us with a stick
if you don't, if we don't follow these
legislation. But then you also say, well,
if something happens as a result of that,
of the data collection that we enforce,
that's not our fault. That's not our
fault. Well, yeah. Yeah, it will be, I
mean, I would like to see in Australia, a
politician start to agitate and ask these
questions on behalf of the Australian
Bitcoin community. Because we are, I mean,
there is silver lining. I am seeing some
positive stuff out there. People are
starting to ask some of the more deeper
questions that I guess Bitcoiners have
cared about for a very long time. Not
necessarily to do with Bitcoin, but, you
know, agitating the RBA a little bit and
asking them questions about, like, you
would have seen the recent clip being
asked, like, have they ever modelled?
Simon Kennedy? Yeah. Yeah. If they've
modelled a scenario where government
spending is reduced and it just seems like
such an obvious thing to model,
but they've never done it.
So [yeah] I would like to
raise awareness of these issues so that
people can, you know, in power within
Australia can actually start addressing
the concerns and looking after the
interests of Australian people. Because
there is really a growing number of people
who own crypto or Bitcoin in Australia. I
don't think it's a niche thing anymore.
It's still niche to talk about it. But
let's be honest, a very large percentage
of Australians own some. Yeah. Yeah. There
was, I can't remember who it was, but
someone from the SEC recently outlined, I
would believe over the last week, where
they were questioning the AML KYC
requirements, data collection
requirements, given it's the lack of
ability to efficiently and or rather
efficaciously stop bad actors from being
bad actors. By deputising, by basically
being data collection officers for the
government, there is a cost involved to
everything downstream of that.
From the LLM KYC offices
they require to be, to be
engaged to do so through
um, the cost to have services
provide those services.
All those costs get passed down to the
customer at the end of the day. So there
is a portion of what we're paying that is
purely a cost to collect data on behalf of
the government for what is in effect a
very ineffective method of preventing
money laundering, especially when most of
it is through the banking sector anyway.
Yeah. And I think that's the core issue
here is that, like, I haven't been able to
find any clear reporting in terms of how
much money Australia spends annually on
just AML KYC reporting requirements to
implement all of these regulatory things.
You can't really find how much it's
costing Australia. There is some data out
there that some people have done. I forgot
the name of the guy who's done an
investigation into how ineffective the
program is and that it, like, prevents
something like less than 0.1% of crime. So
it's just like, why is there not a lot of
information? Why is the media not doing
anything to investigate this? Like, it's
like, no, it's almost nobody cares. It's
in the background and there's only, like,
a very handful of people in Australia who
actually care about this. It is very easy
to frame someone pushing back against
these systems of control as being against
national security. So under the guise of
national security, they just push
everything through. So, you know, it's for
the safety of the community. It's the
safety of this, the safety of that. But
saying one thing and actually
demonstrating it to be true is two very
different things. And the rhetoric that we
often hear is, well, you know, we're doing
this for this. So I get the good
intentions there. But the reality is, is
that you're not effective at what you're
saying that this is supposed to be
resolving. But the fact that you can stop
a level of transfer of value is a very
different premise than saying what you're
doing is cost effective. What is the cost?
Like, why do you not just then have your
actual law enforcement running down these
kinds of issues rather than us having to,
you know, basically be raising red flags
to, with a whole heap of personal
information to a government agency that
just stores it. And they'll just say, oh,
well, you know, if we get breached, if we
pass it off to a third party like
Palantir, you know, that's not our
problem.
But it is. It is. Because the reality is
that they're the ones responsible, that
were supposed to be responsible for the
security of that data. And I think it's,
it is largely Bitcoin only companies that
are sitting there going, we don't agree
with, with having to maintain the level of
data collection that, that a lot of other
companies are doing. Like there's a lot of
companies out there that collect so much
more data and hold it for far longer than
they need to. But the maximum amount of
data collection is the minimum that's
legislatively required. That that's, that
really is the, you shouldn't really be
carrying any more risk than that for your
customers. And arguably, obviously a lot
of Bitcoiners would agree that that's more
than it needs to be as well.
Yeah, absolutely
Okay, well, let's talk about
what else is ABIB working on? What have
you guys been doing over the past year?
Um, okay, so let's see, earlier this year,
we went and saw, um, uh, we went to the
ACT, uh, respect to the ACT treasurer, um,
and the deputy treasurer around Bitcoin
mining about the downstream, um, economic
benefits of, of Bitcoin mining. Again, the
conversations that I have with these
policymakers are not around, um, Bitcoin
as an asset. It comes up throughout the
conversation, um, but that's not the
intent. Like in the sense that we have a,
a mining sector that, that mines uranium,
but we don't utilize uranium in nuclear
power here in Australia, but we're willing
to sell it. Um, the same is true for, for
Bitcoin. You as a policymaker may not
agree with what Bitcoin is. You might not
find value in it, but you can see value.
And the economic benefits of having
Bitcoin mining result in greater amount of
energy infrastructure being built as a
result, uh, resulting in a, uh, a
subsidization of the cost to consumer, um,
which then keeps businesses afloat in us,
in that state, uh, which means you become
more domestically competitive for
manufacturing and industry. Um, so
there's, as I said, a lot of those
conversations are quite positive. They,
they see the downstream effects. And I
think what we're, um, what we're trying to
do through those conversations is outline
the economic goods that can come about,
including the, the environmental good from
say methane abatement for landfills. Um,
but the gap that needs to be closed is
the, the social license for them to be
able to, to support Bitcoin mining quite
publicly. And it's not that we're upfront
trying to find these orange flag waving
policymakers, but rather to say, look,
here's, here's a technology, uh, that can
be utilized to get the benefits that
you're looking at, you know, that are
aligned with your policy outcomes. How
about it? You can, you can use it. We
don't need the, we don't need the, uh, um,
the praise. Just, just go and let it
happen and all will and good.
Um, one of the other things we were involved
in was, uh, going with the Bitcoin, going
with Bitcoin policy Australia to Canberra,
uh, during a digital wallets and payments
hearing. Um, we were on a blockchain, uh,
uh, panel, which was quite frustrating
because all they wanted to do was talk
about stablecoins. As much as Bitcoin
came up, I don't think that, um, or
rather, I think it's quite evident from
the discussions that were had that they
saw Bitcoin as a, again, a surface level
issue. Um, rather than looking at how
Bitcoin could have been used to address
the very problems that they're talking
about. One of the questions came up was,
you know, who pays basically for what was
infrastructure? And for us, we're like,
you don't, you don't need to pay. You
don't need to, to continue to be value
extractive. You don't need the banks to be
taken X amount for every, from every
transaction. The network is already there.
The infrastructure is already there. It's
already paid for. Um, but I, yeah, the,
the other actors throughout the entire
hearing, it's all quite commercially, um,
incentivized. So they're not talking
about, you know, these, uh, open protocols
that don't, these open protocols. They're
really just trying to sell their latest
token. Yeah. Okay. Interesting. Yeah. Um,
the other thing I wanted to ask you as
well is, um, do you have any updates on
the RBA's project Acacia? Uh, no updates
per se, other than it continues to
progress. It really is just a wholesale
CBDC. But I think what, well, what we are
seeing has been the privatization of
stable coins in the sense that it's the
same kind of thing for all stable coins or
rather blessed stable coins in the sense
that they're, they meet right around the
regulatory requirements. But because they
meet the regulatory requirements, they're
also those captured parties. And so it
would not surprise any of us if there was
a 6102 attack, uh, on these types of, of
companies where it becomes a de facto CBDC
or whole retail CBDC by nature
, but not by name.
So, uh, in the sense that it wouldn't
surprise, I don't think it would surprise
us if a company that is creating stable
coins backed by a range of different
assets to the value of, to the Australian
dollar value of that, that, that which
they have issued is subsequently, um,
sequestered, uh, and confiscated by the
government in some way, whether it is
through some type of private deal where
they purchased a company or they extend
the regulatory framework to include those,
uh, companies within, um, the same kind of
deputized, um, activity that the banking
sector already participates in. But the
very fact that so many of the banks are
looking to develop this internally
themselves, um, I think it's going to be a
matter of the banks themselves are just
going to issue more their, their own CBDC,
sorry, their own retail CBDC, CBDC. Um, so
it will have the same properties. It'll
have the same properties of, uh, despite
it not being a, um, a currency that is
issued by the RBA. Okay. Interesting.
interesting. Cause I did read
that, um, paper that was recently
released, uh, what they're basically
saying, uh, the TLDR is not right now.
They're not looking at a retail CBDC right
now. And they held a focus group, which I
just found it so hilarious. The design of
that study, um, it's like the government
marking its own homework. It was just,
there was a blue box that explains, first
of all, what a retail CBDC is, and it left
out a lot of the important information.
Um, so I would have just loved to be on
that focus group because it said that most
people are indifferent to it. Well, it's
like, well, they properly, um, educated on
what a retail CBDC is and what it has
potential to do. Like it's programmable
money. And even if you don't assume bad
intent and you don't think that that's,
um, going to be used nefariously, it's
being built, it's being designed in a way
that it can. So the question is why, you
know, and that's, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's,
uh, the, the explainer of cryptocurrencies
from the RBA's page is also incorrect.
Totally incorrect. But it still hasn't
been updated. It still hasn't been
updated. The RBA says that, or rather
Michelle Bullock says the RBA has no
position on Bitcoin. Then why do you
mention it so often? If you have no
position on it, why do you mention it so
often within papers? If, if, and you're
frequently, and they're frequently doing
it in a way that they're comparing their
CBDC and when Michelle Bullock responded
to Joran Laxor on a, uh, to the question
around Bitcoin, um, they pivoted from
talking about Bitcoin to, well, we've got
a CBDC. It's a wholesale thing. And we're
involved in that. It's like, well, if
they're not at all comparable, why are you
trying to compare your CBDC to Bitcoin? If
not to create the, the distinction, um,
and the tacit, um, connection. The, when
it comes to a, a CBDC, you're absolutely
right. The public doesn't know. The public
doesn't understand the concept that the,
the public doesn't even understand, or
Genpop doesn't understand the, the
characteristics of good money, let alone
the difference between money and currency.
How is it supposed to understand what a
CBDC is from a, from a little blue box
that doesn't outline what those
characteristics are, what the implications
of characteristics are other than the RBA,
I suspect has been going through a process
of trying to, from its outset, say, well,
look, you know, there's no interest, no
interest, no interest with the full
expectation to bring it on at some point
and not do so because, um, and frame it
as, well, we've got to a stage where the
public wants it. Yeah. There's a public
interest in having a CBDC. So we're going
to introduce it or they'll do so by
saying, well, look, you know, the public's
already using the stable coins and because
they're using all these stable coins,
there is an interest for retail CBDC. They
want the trust. They want the, the, the
safety net of a government institution
like the RBA to determine its monetary
policy rather than it being commercially,
you know, a commercial banknote or, or
liability as it were. Um, I expect that's
the play is that. Within five years, um,
that shift will change because we are
either towards the end of five years.
Wouldn't surprise me. Wouldn't surprise me
either because that's kind of when you,
when you're watching what's been unfolding
in the EU with their digital euro. What
started out a few years ago as being
socialized as like a maybe turned into a
definitely. And then the language around
it changed because initially they were
calling it nothing like cash. It's a
digital euro. And now they're basically
trying to market it as like cash like, and
it's like, it's absolutely nothing like
cash. And they're trying to, I guess,
groom the public into, uh, thinking of it
the way that they wish to think of it. Um,
which I think is manipulative and going to
manipulative. There's just a few things as
well that I've noticed reading the RBA
website. Um, when they explain money, they
talk about medium of exchange. They don't
focus on store of value a lot. They talk
about medium of exchange and they talk
about unit of account, not so much on the
store of value. They really downplay that.
And I was like, well, an uneducated eye
wouldn't pick up on that nuance, but I was
like, it's there. Um, and the other thing
as well, in that report that was recently
released, they were talking about public
money versus private money. It's almost
like Bitcoin is private money. Well, it's
like, not really. It's the most public
money the world has ever seen. Like it's
the most public ledger. There's nothing
that's hidden. There's nothing that's
behind the closed doors. And yeah, I guess
sometimes even this conversation feels a
little bit nutty because we're so early,
but it'll be interesting, um, timestamp to
have there forever. The, um, that very,
um, report reading it and knowing how
they've, they've framed things previously,
uh, around Bitcoin, because again, for,
for a, a institution that has no opinion
on Bitcoin, it sure talks about it a lot.
Uh, they, they have shifted their framing
around what Bitcoin is. And so it is,
these reports are in effect marketing
tools to, um, reframe what, um, what
Bitcoin is, reframe what their CBDC is
looking to do. So it's not as if they're,
they're responding to things. They are
manual, it is being a manufactured result,
um, that is, that's coming through. And
that's why I say within five years, I
fully expect that we'll have a, um, a
pitch towards a CBDC, uh, a retail CBDC.
Yeah. That's, that's a great... Yeah.
Those conflations between money and
currency happen all the time because the
RBA works within its legislative, uh,
framework. You know, it's, it's
definitions are from it, from the, well,
it's definitions supposed to be from this
legislation, but that is not a, that's not
a, um, pragmatic or practical definition
for how people actually, um, consider what
is money. A government can issue and say,
what is a fiat currency, but it can't tell
people what to use as money. That's for an
individual and a, and a, and it's count
their counterparties to be able to
determine what they choose to use as money
and, and accept whatever, um, spectrum of,
of quality they get from each
characteristic. But the RBA to say that
Bitcoin is not a currency up on stage, uh,
in November, 2024. It's like, well, you
don't get to decide for me what I use as a
currency. I decide. And I choose to use
Bitcoin. Yeah. I watched recently, I love
watching Andreas up in Antonopoulos, the
old school videos that he's released. And
I guess this one's very relevant at the
moment where he talks about, um, what are
the four functions of money? And people
are saying store of value and medium of
exchange and unit of account. And they
couldn't guess the fourth. And he's like a
system of control. And, you know, and then
he explains what happened in 1971. And
when the Nixon actually 1970 signed the
bank secrecy act, we basically, yeah, our
money globally has changed forever. And
it's now, I guess, coming to fruition with
everything that's happening with a retail
CBDC. It's like, why does it have to be a
niche question to just ask, why do we need
this? And why does it have to be almost
like controversial question to, uh, to
pose that? Like, why is this necessary?
Bitcoiners want humanity to flourish. We
want people to have dignity. We want
people to have digital privacy. We want
law-abiding citizens to be treated like
law-abiding citizens and not criminals. So
why is this like considered such a, like,
do you know, like it's, it's so normal to
me. It is the most normal stance to take,
yet it's not the mainstream stance.
I had a conversation with
somebody the other day
and we were speaking for about an hour and
a half. And one of the neighbors were
working on his car nearby. And he came
over and he goes, hey, just listen to you
guys go. It's great. The fact that you
guys have your conversation, this is what
needs, this is what needs to happen more
of. Uh, this is what needs to happen, uh,
far more often than it previously does, and.
it's great to see these types of
conversations happening. You don't see
enough of it. Uh, and I think that really
speaks to the depth of interest people
have in wanting to talk about deeper
concerns. If you have someone that
actually wants to talk about it, take the
opportunity because you're going to be
able to exchange ideas. Um, that, you
know, you might learn some things that
might load some things, but it's really
got to be a matter of communicating with
people that are interested. If you're
surrounding yourself with people that just
aren't interested in asking those deeper
questions. That's, that's, that's their
loss really, because they have within
yourself and any other Bitcoin that wants
to know these things. The, uh, the, the
potential conversation that could have had
that would have helped them understand why
they're dealing with some of the, the,
the, the problems that they are. You know,
we, we have a country who do not know the
difference between inflation, debasement
and CPI. That those terms, like we don't
even hear the word debasement, uh, in, in
mainstream, um, other than some mimatic,
uh, reference to a debasement trade. But
media and policymakers frequently conflate
the two terms of CPI and inflation as if
they're the same. Um, and I think until we
start holding policymakers and, and, and
the media, in fact, anyone to account on
saying, well, hang on, you said inflation
there. Do you mean CPI? Because they're
two very different things or do you mean
actually debasement? Um, you know, with
the Australian dollar losing 96% of its
purchase power over the last six decades.
You see, you'd mentioned that to somebody
like, what do you mean? Because they
don't, they're in effect sleepwalking.
You're not because they're there by
choice, but because they're too distracted
by everything else. But the game
yesterday. Yeah. And that's, I guess, goes
back to my deeper concern is that, I mean,
there is a small segment of the Australian
population that is concerned about this.
It could be people in the Bitcoin
movement. Many could be people in the
freedom movement, um, that talk about
these things and just in general, like I
know Northern Rivers has a community, um,
that organizes, like they talk about
freedom related things like digital ID and
legislation that's coming. That's kind of
eroding, um, those personal freedoms,
whether it's to do with private property,
whether it's to do with, um, digital
privacy. It can be anything, but like,
again, those numbers are so small and the
rest of the Australian population, I'm
just really afraid, won't, um, appreciate
the importance of this until it's actually
been implemented. It's in place. And then
they see a bad example of that system
being used against them because it's
already happening now. I don't know if you
saw, um, a podcast, what's his name? The
Lambo guy. I really forget his name. He's
only come on my, up on my radar recently.
Carl Stefanovic, um, interviewed him. But
anyway, like it was, it was an interesting
interview, but, uh, basically he was
agitating the system a little bit and they
debanked him. They like, like it came down
on him. So they can use those levers now,
um, if they wish, if you say something
that's politically inconvenient. Um, if
you're a, yeah, if you, if you dissent in
some way or shape or form against whatever
is, I guess, like for example, during
COVID, um, a lot of people weren't happy
with the government. And then like, you
can have that played against you. And
that's the concern that I have. Um. Um,
but you've got banks already saying within
the terms of conditions that they'll look
through your social media and that's
really them deciding who, who they want to
be able to, uh, service. Um, but we don't
have a right to the banking system here in
Australia. And we have a, a financial
system that is so reliant on the banking
system that by precluding people from it,
you are possibly preventing people from
being politically engaged. In which case
you're in effect, uh, affecting their,
their constitutional right to be
politically engaged. Well, speaking of
constitutional rights, like we also don't
have very strong constitutional rights in
Australia compared to the U S. I think
it's just a matter of people that aren't
aware of them. And also they don't fight
for them. Like if you don't use it, if you
don't fight for it, why would you, again,
we, we need to be showing up if we want
things to, these things just didn't come
about. Right. They didn't just, someone
didn't come up to us and give it to
people. People had to, to fight for them,
to, to fight, to maintain them. Um, and
you know, as going back to earlier, like
if, if people are, um, not so much
doomers, but they don't feel like there's
any hope. In the country, then they'll,
they'll leave. But they, I think they,
that, that sense of, that, that cynicism
might very well be because they feel like
not by being politically engaged, I don't
think they're going to get anywhere. And I
think that's largely, uh, a lot of some of
the conversations I have with, with people
is like, well, you know, glad you're doing
it, Bayani. Cause they don't want to be,
because they don't feel like they're going
to, they're, they're going to be able to
make any, um, uh, progress with it. But
sometimes it's not the act of, of having
to do something, get a result right away.
But if we're just progressively having
more and more people saying no, like
that's, that's our collective power is
just to say no. And rather than just
walking away. Because if we're just, we're
just going to shift from one place to
another place and migrate until everywhere
else that we could have gone to is gone.
Because we didn't have stood up and said
no. Yeah. Like I am seeing some resistance
on social media and there's a few
political accounts of just like young
people, you know, I guess, Gen Zs,
millennials, whatever, um, talking about
part of politics that they're passionate
about. So whether they're on the left or
the right, someone's really like
championing their cause and is providing,
I guess, that independent media voice in
Australia that seems to really be lacking.
Because those issues that are important to
individuals are not necessarily always
represented by the mainstream media. So in
that sense, I'm very bullish on Australia.
But also, yeah, part of me just doesn't
know how things are going to unfold over
the next five years and whether, like,
what's going to win? Are the people going
to get the influence and the
responsibility from the government that we
want and need? Or is the government going
to win?
If the people that we want, if the policy
outcomes we want are determined by
government and influencing that, then if
there's more Bitcoin, it's becoming part
of the government. What is the outcome of
that? What is the outcome of people being
more engaged with government, with
policymakers that are voting for people
that are, that are, um, supportive of
policies, outcomes that they want, or them
themselves becoming more politically
engaged and becoming candidates in their
local areas, for instance? I think that
there's a, I would, I would, I have seen a
shift from, uh, from mainstream parties
through to independence, which, uh, I
think is good on a number of different
fronts. Um, because it's, it allows those
individuals to be able to reflect their
electorate more accurately rather than
having to toe a party line. I think if we
continue to see that, that, um, that
trend, we might very well see a, a slower
fall of government in the sense that it's
harder to get legislation through. And I
think for some degree, to some degree,
that's quite good because it means that
things have to go through a series of, uh,
they're going to be merit-based. It's not
just because, Hey, I've got to vote for it
because my party tells me to. It's true.
It's I, as the candidate for my
electorate, think that, or either the, um,
the MP for my electorate is, is supportive
of this because it has merit. Uh, and I
think that that's, that's, well, that
really is, should be how, how legislation
is written, but, uh, it's not necessarily
the case now, uh, or rather isn't the case
now. Um, but yeah, I think we'll still
start to see more, uh, more animated
discussions around the merit of different
legislation, if that's the case, which is
probably good. Yeah. Yeah. Are there,
you'd probably know better than me, but
are there many Bitcoiners in Australian
government? I probably know of one or two
or three. Do we have, do we have more?
Funny enough, there's, there's a number
of, um, there's a number of policymakers
and even people within institutions and
banks that have Bitcoin, just Bitcoin. Not
crypto, just Bitcoin. Just Bitcoin. Um,
but they won't say, right? And so this is
the, this is the social license thing that
we're talking about. So there is, uh, the
aspect of, for those in the private
sector, they don't really say much because
career risks. There's those in the public
sector, career risks. Um, to, to exactly
what you said earlier, there's a lot of
people, there's a lot more Bitcoiners out
there than we otherwise would believe. Um,
which is great. You know, I, I think the
doubt, the, the effect of that is that,
um, they're going to be looking out for
their, for their Bitcoin. Um, and so
they'll make decisions that reflect that.
Um, and so as more policymakers and more
people in the public sector, um, and those
in the private sector that are affected by
it, uh, start to, um, uh, start to acquire
more Bitcoin, start to save in Bitcoin.
Then, yeah, I think the, the machinations
of, or rather the machinery of the
government, um, end up becoming orange.
You know who I'm still bullish on? I know
he's obviously no longer a Senator, but
like Gerard Rennick, I've given him such a
hard time. I'm, I've mentioned him on the
podcast a number of times. I've messaged
him on Twitter a number of times trying to
like pose some, you know, curly thought
provoking questions to him. But I still
really believe he's, he's a good actor and
that he cares about a lot of the things
that Bitcoiners care about, even though
he's not a Bitcoiner and he's like, he
doesn't like it, but that's fair enough.
But what he does care about, he does care
about reforming the banking industry. So I
feel like he's someone who would care
about discussing things like a retail CBDC
and whether that is in the interest of
Australians. Um, so hopefully, yeah,
hopefully we can make up with him as a
community because he still has some
influence in the space and obviously he's
doing great work supporting others, um,
who are still active in politics. So,
yeah. Yeah. I understand that, um, he may
very well not be as apprehensive to, to it
as, as maybe we initially thought.
Interesting. I'll keep, I'll keep trying
to reach out to him on Twitter. Which is,
which is a good sign, right? Like, you
know, people should be able to change
their mind and, and not be, uh, chastised
for doing so. Um, you know, um, you know,
the information change, change your mind.
So if the information has changed for him,
fantastic. If he's understanding his
change, fantastic. Um, you know, there was
a time where many Bitcoiners didn't know
what Bitcoin was and they had to do the
work, learn what it was, learn the
distinction between money and currency
and, and the difference between Bitcoin
and crypto. Um, and so that is often a
time consuming and, um, lengthy period of
time. So, you know, it's been a couple of
years since, uh, that exchange on, on, uh,
on X. So, so yeah, look, it's, uh, my,
yeah, my understanding is that he's, um,
it's not as if he's apprehensive to it per
se. I think it's just, um, neutral,
relatively neutral comparatively to, to
say that some others. And that's a part of
what we try and do with, with ABIB is
we're trying to understand where do
individuals sit along a bit of a spectrum
of, um, of knowledge on Bitcoin. Are they,
are they neutral? Are they, um, not
supportive? Are they supportive? And then
if they are supportive, what are they
supportive of? Are they, are they
supportive of like blockchain and crypto
and, and that kind of thing? Or are they
looking at it from a tokenization aspect,
um, for let's say the ASX or, you know,
replacing the chess system or something
like that? Or do they understand Bitcoin
from a minership perspective? Because they
have very different concepts for, for
policy makers to get their head around.
Um, and so our mapping of that, um, does
take, take that into consideration because
we want to be able to bring to them, um,
the right type of information. Um, yeah.
All right, Bayani, well, to wrap things up,
what are you most bullish and hopeful on
right now? Oh, geez. You know what? I
just, you know what, just having Bitcoin,
it's sort of, um, bullish for myself and
fellow Bitcoiners because we're going to
be in a position where we have some
optionality. And there's a lot of people
out there that won't have that optionality
because they never saw it coming. What's
happening with LLMs, um, as a tool and
that being paired with more physical
things like cars, et cetera. And we've
seen that, that development over time
with, with Ubers. Um, we don't see the
level of progress that is able to be
achieved here in Australia. And because
we're not exposed to it, but to have a
hollowing out of the middle class. That is
going to take time to retrain. And then
the question for them is retrain into
what? Um, I don't think they're going to
be able to get to retrain as quickly as
they might think. A lot of people are
going to be left out of what's coming. And
where does that leave their job choices?
It's going to be not going up. It's
probably going to be down, in which case
you become a large group of people that
are competing for the same small number
of, of jobs that aren't yet replaced by
LLMs. Um, and for some people that said,
oh, you know, go do some Uber driving.
It's like, well, that used to pay quite
well initially because there was a short
supply. There was a high demand during
COVID, for instance. And there was a small
amount of people that were available to do
it. You know, but now you've got a lot of
drivers and a lot less spending on, on
Uber Eats, for instance, or Uber in
general. So when that entire industry
starts to get cycled out for just
autonomous cars, there goes another job
that, uh, that now you could just, well,
not even just, just jobs. There's going to
be less cars on the road, I would expect.
Because now you don't necessarily need to own a car
because you can actually carpool with your family
unles they send a car back to you
and you can go where you need to go.
Um, yeah, so I suppose I'm hopeful
because, uh, I've got some optionality,
but, um, I would like to see more people
get that option, uh, that optionality,
that, that, that benefit, that ability to,
to choose. Um, yeah, it's, it's an
interesting time ahead. Interesting time
ahead. And from memory, the AB website
still holds the meetups all around
Australia, which people can find. Is that
correct? Yeah. Yes. So there's a lot of
projects. So, uh, the Australian Bitcoin
industry body, bitcoinindustrybody.org.au.
Uh, we have a, for Bitcoiners page. It,
um, uh, it does have, or it has an events
page that lists all the meetups that we're
currently aware of that have a page that
people can visit, um, where, uh, through
all the different states, um, even like
the, the Bitcoin walks, which would be
great to see more of. Like if you're
interested in trying to, um, start up a
meetup, uh, feel free to reach out. I want
to try and encourage that. Um, there's,
um, a range of different social activities
that people could be doing. I think that
would be a great place to start. Um, just
having a conversation with fellow
Bitcoiners and finding your tribe. Um,
yeah. And there's also a couple of
different things on the, on the website
that allows people to engage with policy
makers. It'll give them templates that
they can forward through to, um, their
local MPs, uh, or indeed send through
emails to, um, all of, um, state or
federal government. Um, what other tools
are there? Uh, there's also orange label
.io, uh, that outlines. Those events and
the, and where they are, as well as all
different places that people could be
spending Bitcoin either in person or
online, um, that we currently have listed.
Uh, that is a global project now. Um, but
yeah, it uses a lot of the, well, it uses
all the information that we can get from
btcmap.org, uh, and also, uh, pairs it
with websites that also accept Bitcoin. So
it's not just physical locations. It's,
um, it's non-physical locations to
plumbers, electricians, cabinet makers, et
cetera. Nice. So it's products and
services listed.
Uh, briefly, we
actually, um, we, in, you know what, I'll,
Add Text
I'll, I'll say this and I'll, in case you
want to slice this in, um, we had a
independent, um, MP come to our local
meetup and I'm reaching out to a couple
other independents, um, in the area, um,
around methane abatement for a local
landfill. Um, had them come down. We just
spoke to them about what's possible, not
to say this, this is what we should be
doing at this particular site, but here's
a consideration. The first step is really
a bit of a feasibility study. And I think
that's a good first step to try and work
out, is this site a good match for what
you're trying, what you're suggesting to
be the case? Uh, if it's not fantastic, at
least then there was an evidence-based
reason not to do it. But if the evidence
comes back and says, look, this site's
good, a good fit. Um, the, the
policymakers themselves, or at least, you
know, perhaps local councils, um, may find
it hard to argue against when there's,
when the feasibility study outlines the
fact that they could be getting an extra,
um, revenue stream as well as, um, capture
more methane. Yeah. Win-win. So what
prompted this person to reach out? I'm
curious. Oh, no, they didn't, they didn't
reach out. I reached out to them. Uh, I
said, look, you know, we're, we're, we've
got a meetup. We've got our local meetups
that we have each month. Um, and the idea
through that is not to try and again, sell
Bitcoin, but say, look, you know,
Bitcoin's more than just money, uh, or
rather the industry is more than just
money. Uh, here's a range of different
things that could be accomplished,
notwithstanding the fact that councils
want more money and nobody wants more
methane into the air. So fantastic.
There's a win-win. So if you're, if you're
saying that you want to address these
climate issues, uh, if you're saying that
you want to be able to, um, not increase
the rate of, uh, taxes or rates for your,
your locals, um, then Bitcoin money is a
way that could be a way that that can be
accomplished. And there's a range of
different sites around Australia, um,
that, that would be super, um, super
useful for. Yeah. Australia's made for it.
We need it. Exactly. You know, it really
is a matter of regulations that holds us
back because it's the operator that
chooses who can get connected to the grid.
Whereas if they were just, if Bitcoin
miners were allowed to operate with the
generators, with the man load guys like
data centers, we would be able to
accelerate the amount of, um, build out of
energy infrastructure, um, and also drive
down the consumer cost of it. Yeah. Which
I guess would be an election promise that
was never met, but, you know, imagine if
we did bring down electricity prices, I'm
pretty sure everyone in Australia would,
uh, appreciate that very much. Correct, correct.
All right. Well, thank you so much for your
time, Bayani. I love this chat. Thanks,
Anja. Hopefully it will reach some people
out there who are either curious and want
to join a meetup. Uh, there's really
friendly Bitcoiners all over Australia who
are dying to speak to you and, you know,
help you get started on your Bitcoin
journey safely. So you don't lose any
money. So you don't lose your Bitcoin that
you buy. But there's also obviously if any
policymakers are listening, um, there's,
yeah, you can find out how to get in touch
with Bayani through the website, which
I'll link in the show notes. Thanks
Bayani. No, thanks Anja.