Confessions of a Shop Owner is hosted by Mike Allen, a third-generation shop owner, perpetual pot-stirrer, and brutally honest opinion sharer. In this weekly podcast, Mike shares his missteps so you don’t have to repeat them. Along the way, he chats with other industry personalities who’ve messed up, too, pulling back the curtain on the realities of running an independent auto repair shop.
But this podcast isn’t just about Mike’s journey. It’s about confronting the divisive and questionable tactics many shop owners and managers use. Mike is here to stir the pot and address the painful truths while offering a way forward. Together, we’ll tackle the frustrations, shake things up, and help create a better future for the auto repair industry.
[Bryan Pollock] (0:00 - 0:17)
Can somebody be an A-Tech on a certain subject? A, B, C-Tech's been thrown around so much, everything's become so diverse, so complex, that maybe A, B, and C-Tech aren't... It doesn't exist.
...across the board, doesn't exist. It doesn't exist. Can you have a guy who's just an absolute rock star on your car and exhaust work?
[Bill Laurie] (0:17 - 0:18)
Yes, got one.
[Bryan Pollock] (0:19 - 0:21)
Yes. Got one. And that's just what you feed him.
You don't give him any answers.
[Bill Laurie] (0:21 - 0:34)
As a leader, right? Exactly. But as a leader, no matter where it is, as a leader, a real leader, you are in charge of a team.
Your best path is to identify all weaknesses within that team, starting with yourself, and higher to those weaknesses.
[Intro] (0:37 - 1:08)
The following program features a bunch of doofuses talking about the automotive aftermarket. The stuff we, or our guests may say, do not necessarily reflect the beliefs of our peers, our sponsors, or any other associations we may have. There may be some spicy language in this show, so if you get your feelings hurt easily, you should probably just move along.
So without further ado, here's your host, Mike Allen, with Confessions of a Shop Owner, presented by TechMetric, the best software in the history of ever.
[Bryan Pollock] (1:09 - 1:43)
My friend Dan, he's another shop owner, and him and his girlfriend bought a house recently over the summer, and he had an HVAC company. It didn't have air conditioning, right? It doesn't get hot, hot up where we are, but like, you know, it gets hot enough for long enough to where you got to have air conditioning for the couple weeks top.
And he's like, in there, he's like, he's like, I'm 30 grand deep into this thing, and I'm like explaining to these dudes how to do their job. I know. He's like, and I'm just a stupid grease monkey.
I know. I'm like, Dan, it's not just, I go, it's every field, man. Either people have, I know, the mechanical super mindset.
[Bill Laurie] (1:43 - 1:57)
I had an AC system problem in the house in Raleigh, and I had the third person come out who was their diagnostician, and I had to tell the third person in the room, this is a startup capacitor problem. See how I take this screwdriver and start this fan, and the system runs fine?
[Bryan Pollock] (1:57 - 1:57)
Yeah.
[Bill Laurie] (1:57 - 2:00)
The capacitor isn't holding enough power to make it initiate.
[Bryan Pollock] (2:00 - 2:01)
This is universal.
[Bill Laurie] (2:01 - 2:03)
Because the blades are too heavy. Why am I explaining this to you?
[Bryan Pollock] (2:03 - 2:14)
It doesn't matter if it's your air conditioning unit. It doesn't matter if it's your air compressor at the shop. It doesn't matter if it's the garage door motor at the shop.
The capacitor is the capacitor. It's all the same thing. Doesn't matter.
I believe you.
[Bill Laurie] (2:14 - 2:27)
And if you went through, and if you learned electronics for automotive well, all those principles that govern what electrons are doing and how they do it are everywhere. Electrons do the same things no matter what you do with them.
[Bryan Pollock] (2:27 - 2:32)
Yeah, electricity is physics. That's why guys that understand electricity also understand hydraulics.
[Bill Laurie] (2:32 - 2:33)
Yes.
[Bryan Pollock] (2:33 - 2:34)
Because electricity is just physics.
[Bill Laurie] (2:35 - 2:42)
Well, you can change in your head what the differences are between the materials, and then the governing properties. Everything's the same concept. Yeah.
[Bryan Pollock] (2:44 - 3:25)
What's up guys? So anyways, there's Mike, and then there's me, and I'm like, pay someone to do that. This is our first recording of Apex 2026.
So everybody's here. It is 923 local day one. I'm 7181 steps in for the day.
7,000 steps in for the day at 9 30 a.m. I did 28,000 steps Saturday. So, considering you weren't at an automotive show, that was pretty impressive. Well, I took a cab up to the Strat, which is evidently it's a really stabby place now.
It's a very good place if you want to get stabbed, and it's a Strat, but I was there at night. I was there at 9 a.m., so.
[Bill Laurie] (3:25 - 3:36)
I think as you've aged, you've gotten more and more of the look of someone who's inconvenient to mess with, right? And that's what it is. Like, I'm going to go stab the other guy that looks like maybe he's not faster than me.
[Bryan Pollock] (3:36 - 3:45)
Do you know that's my new line I was given? Oh yeah. Oh yeah.
I wrestle around. I'm in this one. The jujitsu guy says, be careful.
That guy looks nice, but he's really inconvenient to mess with.
[Bill Laurie] (3:45 - 4:07)
So I started to realize the value of this, because I was about twice this size for most of my life. And now I'm sitting at a desk, and I'm an instructor, and I'm at that age where, you know, your hormone numbers change, and this is the tinier version of me. And I'm okay with it, because I still look awfully inconvenient to mess with.
Like, I'll walk all around at night. I don't care if it's two o'clock in the morning.
[Bryan Pollock] (4:07 - 4:12)
Oh, you shouldn't walk there. I feel like you guys look inconvenient to mess with. I look like a target of opportunity.
Yeah.
[Mike Allen] (4:13 - 4:14)
No, you're not quite there.
[Bryan Pollock] (4:15 - 4:31)
Do you know what we used to call? We used to call the guys that wrestled the late. We used to call them victim weight.
You either wrestled 189, 215 heavyweight. Everybody else was victim weight. Anybody wrestling under 189 is victim weight.
My brother wrestled 112. Victim weight. Yeah, tiny.
[Bill Laurie] (4:31 - 4:44)
I think we have three very good representations of levels of not convenient to mess with. Yes, yeah. Entry level.
Yeah, like journeyman master. You're probably, all right, there's really no one else you're saying I'm the GS of being messed with. You might be.
[Bryan Pollock] (4:44 - 4:45)
I'm the luby.
[Bill Laurie] (4:45 - 4:49)
There's nobody else this guy might get me, but I need money.
[Bryan Pollock] (4:49 - 4:51)
If you scare me bad enough, I might lubricate myself.
[Bill Laurie] (4:52 - 5:04)
And then there's me where it's like, it's really unlikely, but I have another person with me and this is an emergency and there's been no one around for an hour. Maybe they'll mess with him. Well, forget about it.
[Bryan Pollock] (5:04 - 5:16)
Because I have no self-confidence and I'm fearful for my fragile, fragile ego. I do have relatively accurate wireless hole punch usage.
[Bill Laurie] (5:16 - 5:17)
Yes, sir.
[Bryan Pollock] (5:18 - 5:19)
That's the great equalizer.
[Bill Laurie] (5:20 - 5:28)
I get made fun of still for not carrying. Like a lot of people are like, why don't you carry it at work? Like I can't carry it at work.
[Bryan Pollock] (5:28 - 5:28)
Okay.
[Bill Laurie] (5:28 - 5:37)
Why don't I? I don't know. Because it's like, I'm trying to manage my outfit that day.
I have big hands and most of the comfortable things to carry.
[Bryan Pollock] (5:38 - 5:53)
Full size, large pistol. You want a desert Eagle? It's a really good tool for when the guy's hiding behind the fridge at your neighbor's house.
My favorite feeling. Five layers of drywall, a garage door, and the neighbor's fridge.
[Bill Laurie] (5:54 - 6:18)
Remember Johnny Dangerously? Remember Johnny Dangerously, the movie from the 80s? It's an 88 Magnum.
He had it made special. It shoots through screws. No, like I have this Beretta 92F, right?
Very proven firearm. It's a great feel. It's too heavy to carry.
And it's like, I don't know. I don't want to shoot somebody. I don't want to have to.
[Bryan Pollock] (6:18 - 6:26)
I think if you're one of those dudes who like fantasizes about getting into trouble where you get to shoot somebody, you probably don't need to have a gun in the first place.
[Bill Laurie] (6:27 - 6:29)
Yeah, correct. That should be the defining factor.
[Bryan Pollock] (6:30 - 6:43)
I fantasize about avoiding that type of conflict with strangers. I think that's the best tool in your arsenal is to avoid the conflict. I would tell you that there's no amount of range training that will outrun being able to avoid the conflict from the get-go.
[Bill Laurie] (6:43 - 7:12)
And it's so much, when you get some time in your life and you start realizing it's so much easier, no matter what your approach is. If your approach is like, man, you know what? I'm sorry.
And you're out. Let me buy you a beer. Let me this or that.
You're probably getting out of it. Or if your approach is, are you sure about this? I know you don't know me and I don't know you.
But I know me. And for me, that's enough. Are you really sure?
Do we need to do this? Because we can both have a really good night or one of us can have a really good night. I know that I don't need to do it.
[Mike Allen] (7:13 - 7:14)
I know that I don't need to do it.
[Bill Laurie] (7:14 - 7:23)
And it's in everything. Anytime you choose peace or a conflict resolution. That person stole my party spot.
Smile and wave. Yeah.
[Bryan Pollock] (7:24 - 7:48)
I get it right about 2% of the time now. So de-escalation is the word of the day is what you're saying. Because you're the master of motherfucking people on the internet or rage baiting them.
Well, after usually the second comment is, if I go farther than like two comments back and forth, I'm in it for the game at that point. It's just, it's the game for me.
[Bill Laurie] (7:48 - 8:18)
So my favorite with that is I like to make you come beat me up. I like to sit there and I do all that in my head. Right.
And all the dumb things I want to say back, that's just going to amp this person up. And then I choose something that's going to unleash the hounds that are already in the chat. And I just sit back.
Right. Like I look at who else is in the chat, whatever it is. And I'm like, Oh, I bet you, if I were to say this, these three people are going to do all my dirty work.
And that's your version, right? I have hired goons many times in a chat by appropriately.
[Bryan Pollock] (8:19 - 8:33)
They don't know they've been hired. Because they're in it for the game also. I master my response.
All right. Bill, introduce yourself. Who are you?
What do you do? What's your story?
[Bill Laurie] (8:34 - 8:42)
My name is Bill Lurie. I am the automotive director at Wake Tech Community College. The rest of my story.
[Bryan Pollock] (8:42 - 8:43)
If we edit that part out.
[Bill Laurie] (8:43 - 8:43)
Yeah.
[Bryan Pollock] (8:43 - 8:46)
Will you tell more unfiltered versions of.
[Bill Laurie] (8:47 - 8:50)
If we edit that part out. Yeah. I mean, you know.
[Bryan Pollock] (8:51 - 8:51)
All right. Yeah.
[Bill Laurie] (8:52 - 8:55)
I can't see it going horribly sideways.
[Bryan Pollock] (8:55 - 9:01)
Because I'm going to ask some questions about. Yeah. Wake Tech.
Early.
[Bill Laurie] (9:01 - 9:05)
And we can talk about like, hey, you know, when I did that and then I moved into education.
[Bryan Pollock] (9:05 - 9:06)
Perfect.
[Bill Laurie] (9:06 - 9:15)
And now all the horrible leadership mistakes I've made in my shops and in the automotive industry and led me to be the leader in an automotive program.
[Bryan Pollock] (9:15 - 9:16)
Okay. So just start over. I'm Bill Lurie.
[Bill Laurie] (9:17 - 9:18)
Around the board.
[Bryan Pollock] (9:19 - 9:21)
Around the board. What is that?
[Bill Laurie] (9:21 - 9:21)
Is that what you said?
[Bryan Pollock] (9:22 - 9:24)
So you start over with. I'm Bill Lurie.
[Bill Laurie] (9:24 - 10:16)
Okay. I'm Bill Lurie. Spent a couple of decades in the automotive industry.
Started off with electronics in high school. Thought I was going to fix computers and electronic devices. Realized that the level of neurodivergence that is common in most technicians was never going to let me sit still for that long.
So I took that. Brought it into cars and very quickly had a lot of these older techs that were very dissatisfied that we decided to run things with computers. Trusting me to help them figure out electrical problems because I had that real strong foundation.
And then I got to learn about a lot of things that are obsolete in this industry. I've always had this thing where in my career as soon as I'm bored with this thing. Like I've accomplished this.
I understand that. I'm good at that. I jump into something that I'm completely inept at.
[Bryan Pollock] (10:16 - 10:16)
Yeah.
[Bill Laurie] (10:17 - 10:18)
So it brought me to.
[Bryan Pollock] (10:18 - 10:19)
You like feeling uncomfortable.
[Bill Laurie] (10:19 - 10:20)
I like being uncomfortable.
[Bryan Pollock] (10:20 - 10:21)
Yeah.
[Bill Laurie] (10:21 - 10:38)
I like looking over the fence and going that looks really easy but I have no idea. And if I'm going to give that service advisor a hard time I guess I should go do that job and see how easy it is or isn't. Then I totally have the authority to talk as much crap as I want to every service advisor.
[Bryan Pollock] (10:38 - 10:41)
So you know that the service advisor's job is the hardest job in the shop right?
[Bill Laurie] (10:42 - 11:49)
No. It is not the hardest job in the shop. So like you know I was a service advisor.
I spent a couple years working for Jaguar's corporate headquarters fixing buybacks so Ford could sell at auction. And that happened because I was a Chrysler tech and my zone rep would randomly start sending stuff to my dealership because he didn't want to buy it back. Hey I'm sending this to Bill.
I don't want to buy it back and he'll probably fix the car before it's through complaints. And all that came from saying yes to everything whether I know how to do it or not. Yep.
Right. Hey do you want to do you want to learn how to rebuild automatic transmissions? Yeah.
Hey do you want to deal with this drivability warranty problem? Yeah. Hey do you want to go to this training that they're requiring that's like horrible?
Yes. I want to do all those things. I decided to be a shop owner at one point.
It was okay. And then I had a business partner and it was great for a really short period of time. And my business partner had very different ideas about customer service and where the money which pocket the money should go in right and how it should go.
Which was awesome. Like at the time if you talked to me I don't know how many years ago it is now maybe five years Mike?
[Bryan Pollock] (11:50 - 11:51)
Five years ago since what?
[Bill Laurie] (11:51 - 11:56)
Because we've known each partner and then we split up. Five years?
[Bryan Pollock] (11:56 - 12:09)
Oh no I bet it's been more than that. I bet it's been seven or eight. Everything was like remember in your head a ten-year-old Chevy pickup truck is like a 1996 in your head remember that?
That's true. That's like this.
[Bill Laurie] (12:10 - 12:11)
Yeah 1993 is like a couple of years ago.
[Bryan Pollock] (12:12 - 12:12)
Yeah yeah right.
[Bill Laurie] (12:12 - 13:51)
But anyway at the time it was oh this was terrible this was all this problems I'll never this again blah blah. It was one of the greatest experiences in my life because it moved me in a direction of I don't care. Not that I don't care about doing the right thing for customers or being a good person or making the kind of choices that let me sleep at night.
I don't care what the results are to anything that I do to a point where it's ever going to defeat me. Yep. Right?
So it's like oh the things that have been many things that have been listed to me as the worst possible things could happen in your career happened to me and I'm alive. So what I instead of exploring a new shop this happened this was COVID. This was 2018-19 so yeah seven years ago eight years ago.
I was gonna jump right into opening another shop and it's like oh COVID's happening. I have no idea what this industry is gonna look like tomorrow never mind in a year. I'm gonna chill.
I'm gonna go work at this restoration shop around the corner because I like old cars. I know a decent amount about them but I'm not really a restoration technician. I'm gonna learn more about that.
I'm gonna learn how to paint and I spent a couple years just kind of hanging out in other people's shops upskilling and then I opened the shop again for a while because that was a great idea but the shop was just me and I said no to things that weren't a match for that business model right and a lot of shops forget that if it doesn't work for you it's no. That took me a long time. I came into this industry when every technician was taught that you have to learn everything that there is about every system on a car and you have to be great at all of it.
[Bryan Pollock] (13:51 - 13:56)
The quote the master yeah right the most misused term on earth.
[Bill Laurie] (13:56 - 13:56)
And it's fine.
[Bryan Pollock] (13:57 - 13:58)
What does it even mean?
[Bill Laurie] (13:58 - 14:18)
But it's insane because a lot of our guys that are opening shops now and open their own shops they were that guy and then they open a shop and what's going to make your shop great we're going to do everything. Maybe take a business class first because that is probably the dumbest thing you could possibly say out loud to another human being. We're going to do everything that there is in this area.
That's a horrible idea.
[Bryan Pollock] (14:20 - 14:28)
You don't really want to say no. Should you have direct mail postcards with cheap wall changes that say we fix everything? No you shouldn't.
I know that your car shop did and my shop does.
[Bill Laurie] (14:29 - 15:16)
But think about it right where are you in your evolution as a shop right so i was trying to find this place i mentioned to you that i'm directionally awesome some words i got in one of the teslas and a guy was coming to get his pass and he talked about how he's restoring the 69 gto and he does a youtube channel on it and now i make fan shroud covers for all gms that's where his money comes from he makes one part for five different models extremely specialized and he's that's his job now and he gets to come to shows like this do you think he's stressing out about a customer that's mad because this priest doesn't look like the 67 it looks like the 68 maybe but is he stressed about it his answer is probably like hey i'm sorry you know other guys
[Bryan Pollock] (15:16 - 15:25)
make these you could order one of those they probably aren't other guys who make those which is why that can be his job maybe so i am familiar with geographical monopolies when you're starting
[Bill Laurie] (15:25 - 16:13)
when you're starting a shop and you're starting out yeah it's just everything right here's a great example most shops don't take apart transmissions anymore because you can't warranty it as well as your manufacturer you know another good reason there's almost no good transmission guys almost every independent shop unanimously says no to transmission rebuild work and they forget that a factor is i don't have the talent to do that in my building it's the same thing with your shop if you're not looking at your highest and lowest profitable job every year and throwing away the ones that never make you any money and just trying to avoid doing that you don't tell customers no you just take it off the yes list it's the yes list and then mark it to the things that are the most profitable what are you doing how's your how are you growing i think
[Bryan Pollock] (16:13 - 16:58)
another thing is too i think that a lot of people take in everything when they first open and when you don't have the staffing that's not taking in everything is what you do when you've got 18 technicians and you got one guy that does this oil cooler job well and you got this guy that's a heavy line guy that's going to knock out any heavy line job super fast and you got this guy guy i got a guy i you know i grew up you know i was i was running a stick welder when i was 11 years old i have a guy that welds better than i do he does the exhaust work yeah whatever i don't care and he's a lot younger than me this kid could weld a fart to a rainbow in the middle of a hurricane and i'm just like you know what the fuck did you just say i said he could weld a fart to a rainbow in the middle of a hurricane it sounds like that would probably be a challenging welding job it would be very challenging does that imply that he's good at what he does cole could do it
[Bill Laurie] (16:59 - 17:07)
cole can do that so i'm going through that now like i'm in education and identifying specialties
[Bryan Pollock] (17:07 - 17:35)
yeah like like it's not just identifying somebody be an a tech on a certain subject right because the word the abc tech's been thrown around so much everything's become so diverse so complex that maybe a b and c tech aren't it doesn't exist across the board doesn't exist it doesn't exist can you have a guy who's just an absolute rock star on your car and exhaust work yes got one yes got one and that's just what you feed him you don't give me as a leader right but as a leader
[Bill Laurie] (17:35 - 20:05)
no matter where it is as a leader a real leader right you are in charge of a team your best path is to identify all weaknesses within that team starting with yourself and hire to those weaknesses anything that you can't do better than anybody else that's your next hire that's the next person that you get on your bus and it's like any other team you don't have the quarterback play left tackle yeah i got an email this morning i got an email this morning for one of my guys we have a thing we do at the school that's a pain in the butt i have one of my instructors that's awesome at it superstar at it been doing it for 10 years oh so i delegated it out to him right so he sent an email to everybody yesterday because he had a meeting that was a follow-up to my meeting about it which nobody knows about and about this is what's going on these are the changes we have to do and one of my guys that's always miserable emails back thank you for helping with leadership while we have none or something to that effect and it's like the old me instantly took over oh really well he and i are gonna have a talk when i get back no i thanked them also hey thank you for doing that did you find out anything about the hours number of hours we're supposed to run i need to know that answer by the time i get back so we can fix it i said no to that intentionally because i've become a much better leader than i ever was i don't think i'm the greatest leader ever i don't even know if i rank in the top 100 million um but every day i look at something that looks like true leadership in my head and in practice and i adopt whatever i'm weak in and the idea of being able to hand off something i know i'm not the best at especially when the best at it is standing right next to me is a key to success within your team success within your shop right success within your educational organization success at your bakery whatever it is you have to constantly self-identify where you're strong and where you're weak and and shut that ego off and get the people that can do all the things that you're not good at get the best ones you can find and tell them i hired you because i am horrible at this i intend to never do this again that's why you're here and it comes the same thing with the profitability in the shop right if every single time this thing doesn't work out until you hire the superhero of that or buy the shop that does it the best and let that shop specialize
[Bryan Pollock] (20:06 - 20:37)
it's kind of a waste of energy so back up before we get into your uh current career in automotive education yeah you had you had the shop with your partner and that didn't work out um and greatest thing that ever happened and i feel like that didn't work out for a lot of reasons and a lot of them weren't you believe it right but a lot of them were me yeah um but you started your own shop what made you what took you to the decision to close that shop and do something different the
[Bill Laurie] (20:37 - 21:11)
opportunity to teach so i had you know a friend of mine had this really cool oversized garage at his house i was doing a different endeavor for a construction management company by the way right we talk about how technicians get into everything i did a short stint for this construction management company because a friend of mine who left the automotive industry who worked for me and my ex-partner as a manager for a while by the way um was doing this and he's like hey man i need you for six months i need someone that can go to a job site and say that is not going to pass an inspection i know the plan says it this way do this so it matches there's a pretty profitable
[Bryan Pollock] (21:11 - 21:28)
uh diesel shop owner in alabama um that did that for like a friend in california for a while yeah like just he's like dude i need somebody to like keep an eye on this thing and like keep it under control and that's what he did for a while right so i'm doing that job yeah and on the side man
[Bill Laurie] (21:28 - 22:49)
me and a buddy of mine he's buying these old jeeps right and i'm working on them with them and he's selling them and there's some profit right and then we have the finally after six months of that we have this uh billatorial about it and i sit down and go all right the most profitable stages in classic work is you take this thing and get it running and driving and stopping enough for someone to get it on their trailer and finish it their way highest profit margin percentage wise yeah because you're not doing all 100 restoration yeah anything in between while it might be more dollars in it's not as profitable return so we transitioned into buying a bunch of things and the ones he liked got further and the ones that supported that project got someone can drive it and stop it get it on their trailer and then finish it their way um and then i started doing some of my side stuff there and left doing the property management thing and i was doing some restorations and it was cool i didn't have really customers to deal with that expected to be driving it tomorrow right yeah i didn't have any expectation of it you need to tell me it's going to be thirteen hundred seventy nine dollars and seventy two cents with tax i need to know exactly no this will be somewhere between two thousand and three thousand dollars if i find an oh my situation when i get in there that doesn't match that we'll talk i'll let you know when i'm at some
[Bryan Pollock] (22:49 - 23:11)
point right and i think that's a business model that works with restoration there's a absolutely there's a military truck outfit that does that you can buy them from hey we haul it out of here got the brakes freed up got the air leaks fixed and got the thing running you can buy it in the middle yeah or you can buy one fully done up do you want to spend eight grand twenty grand or sixty
[Bill Laurie] (23:11 - 23:46)
what do you want to do so i think that model might fit the classic car industry across the board you go find this ebay deal that hasn't parked when ran parked when ran of course they all did or uh ran when parked so right and it's been sitting for 18 years and who knows what it needs you go buy that and you bring it to me and i make it run move and stop not ready for the road or anything i'll assess it we get to this point where you can at least pull it in and out of your garage when you want to and then you come pick it up and then you do whatever it is you're going to do to it um i think we'd have to be somewhere like you know southern california where there's
[Bryan Pollock] (23:46 - 23:51)
a longer hot rodding season or maybe i think that arguably that would be the highest profit margin
[Bill Laurie] (23:51 - 24:14)
model no but i think there's more margin than the finished one it depends what it is yeah yeah depends on how well it's finished yeah well yeah and there's a ton of old cars that are cool and a restoration will cost you five times what it's ever going to be worth my truck i have a 47 dodge pickup love the truck perfect ones are like 13 to 15 thousand dollars
[Bryan Pollock] (24:14 - 24:19)
yeah right and i could spend 50 grand restoring one all day so like all right cool i put on an 87
[Bill Laurie] (24:19 - 25:39)
dodge dakota frame so i had disc brakes that were reliable and were designed by engineers that had to get it through a warranty and i put a much bigger motor in it um let the students paint it i was all hemmed up about having to have some perfect paint job on an old truck i'm going to drive that's still not going to be worth a million they didn't have a perfect paint job when they made them anyways and i let the students just paint it and like this is how the paint laid on it and it's like there's some defects and it's like oh you know you should fix that no every defect is going to let me know that 30 something students are going to go to a car show someday with their kid go see that truck that's the first type of thing i ever put paint on at school and it was one of the instructors truck and he just let us paint it and he didn't get mad that we messed this up or that you think they want to paint a miata i don't know it's gotten really hard to bring outside projects in um there's a lot of chairs here so take a picture so yeah i think that i think back to that business model about just that tinkering what's your business going to be are you somebody who's retiring and you a big garage at home and you just want to kind of pedal and not have any stress and not have employees yeah then getting something to the point where it just can be driven around the yard and then somebody finishes it might be a great business model for you um yeah i just want to work on cars
[Bryan Pollock] (25:39 - 25:58)
and not have anybody tell me what to do it's pretty easy it's pretty fun well you're very fortunate that you are in a position literally no one can tell you what to do in the business you have one person who can have a conversation with you and say i think we should do it this way instead of the way you're doing it but he doesn't but he trusts you implicitly so he doesn't yeah
[Bill Laurie] (25:58 - 26:10)
the um the ego and arrogance that came from good technicians that came up in the 90s no one can tell you what to do like yeah i remember being it's not just the 90s i was
[Bryan Pollock] (26:10 - 26:15)
there for a long time yeah i'm just relaxed you know i don't know whatever i think it was my
[Bill Laurie] (26:15 - 26:29)
personality type like i was that guy if i was having not a particularly good day and you were my service manager and you came out to give me a hard time about something it probably wasn't going well for you i remember i had i was in the shop sorry for interrupting yeah brexan just snuck by
[Bryan Pollock] (26:29 - 26:51)
behind me and then stood behind me and put both of his hands on my shoulders and it made me really uncomfortable did you put any down pressure on look all right where's hr do you have an hr department i understand that it's your birthday dude but i'm not gonna hey happy birthday doing that have you tried moving up there you go now quit it now we're on the front we're on the front so here's a don't you threaten me with a good time here's what's become a legend it was a legendary
[Bill Laurie] (26:51 - 28:26)
bill story i worked in this shop in new york and i had this corner bay and i had a garage store in the corner that wasn't the main door and from here to like maybe 100 feet was a deli and it's summer the week that it's hot in new york um and i would walk out and go to the deli if i wasn't working on a waiter i would go get something to drink i come back and my service manager dennis monroe who's about five seven great guy um my parents used to bring their cars to him when i was a kid and i'd be pastor and i'm in his shop what's that dude what's that for under the car with the whole time he's standing in my back and he's yelling what do you think you're doing you can't just go on a break whenever you want oh and i go hold on a minute i'm a flat rate technician well yeah do you know what that means it means you sublet work to me this right here is my shop you sublet work to me in fact get the f out of my shop and he looks at me looks around and shrugs and goes away and like you know adrenaline and temper later you know 20 minutes later i go and i'm like dennis i'm sorry for that he goes no man i'm sorry you're right in essence i sublet work to you and you're not working on a waiter and it's hot and you never let me down i don't know why i even came out to pick a fight with you but there was that kind of attitude right like i'm turning 80 hours a week i rarely have a comeback it's and if i do it's usually it's rarely me i think uh don't come and tell me anything other than thank you and do this one next i think leave me alone a lot of good
[Bryan Pollock] (28:26 - 28:51)
technicians are wired like that because in long story short to get through this stuff and to do it efficiently you can't be wishy-washy things yes the hardest thing that i have to work on and i still have to work on as trying to lead anybody i view everything very black and white yes either good or bad and there's no other middle but that's how you get in real life there is there's just not on a car there's not a ton in the middle when you're diagnosing what's
[Bill Laurie] (28:51 - 29:06)
what electronic well now imagine being that guy yeah and now you own a shop yeah and you have eight ten guys guys that all can handle their own thing yeah and you're ready to pick a fight with them because the way they grab that wrench isn't the way you get it because it's instant it pops
[Bryan Pollock] (29:06 - 29:26)
into your head all these a lot of good technicians view everything is black and white and that's why it's very hard to break that bowl and be like you know what that guy's gonna finish that job when it's finished and it's gonna take him 20 minutes longer than it would have taken me and you know what i don't have time to do everything i guess that's just what we're
[Bill Laurie] (29:26 - 30:50)
gonna do right and i learned a lot of that as an advisor like being an advisor changed my understanding of expectations like after being an advisor for a year i was like yeah this is way easier than these guys made it seem but it's because no one taught them how easy it is to under promise and over deliver right i come out to you when is this cars gonna be done i'm gonna have it done thursday morning all right hey mr so-and-so i'm pretty sure i'll have your car done friday midday i think it's gonna be twenty eight hundred dollars yeah somewhere right around there i'll call you when it's done when you call him right friday at five o'clock and it's five grand and it's not done yet he's mad you know what a customer is never mad about hey i know i said this would be done at lunch tomorrow but it's done now and it's about three hundred dollars under what we expected are you okay with that you want to have the easiest conversation in the world yeah you prepare for all the possibilities and all the things that can go wrong an advisor who's a technician knows joe told me he's gonna be done with this thursday but i know those bolts right there like to break i know that's a pain in the butt and i know he's never had that job before i'm gonna tell the customer i'm putting him in a loaner for the weekend or whatever it might be sure it made the job easier the other thing that made the job easier is i fired customers i worked in a dealership a mopar dealership i just want to pause you real quick there
[Bryan Pollock] (30:51 - 30:54)
i just want to make sure that we're all clear on this you're advocating that we should lie to
[Bill Laurie] (30:54 - 31:26)
our customers yeah and i would tell my advisors in my shop the only lies that i will tolerate to a customer that won't get you fired on the spot is if you tell them it will be more than we're actually going to charge them or it's going to take longer than we think it will really charge lie to them all day because that's what they need they need to know and they need to be confident that when they're gonna have their car back whatever day you say and the amount of money that's gonna leave their wallet is the worst you've told them the worst scenario even if it's
[Bryan Pollock] (31:26 - 32:06)
not true that's the two most important things in modern society i would argue that the timeline is more important than the money yes because if you tell right any family that's got kids mike do your kids do activities all the activities yeah right yeah so you're gonna tell a family that usually has two cars they're down to one car let's say or they're borrowing a car or whatever you know they gotta they have to organize their whole lives everybody and their brother's got a credit card yes if it goes a little over budget it goes a little over budget which i would i would definitely say your plan of telling them you know hey it's a little less than we thought the time when you tell somebody if you tell somebody their car is going to be done for
[Bill Laurie] (32:06 - 32:29)
the weekend it better freaking be done this is this is why every one of us can plan when we know what to plan for yeah before we started mike and i were talking about your technician that never shows up on time or has these random things if you know steve's never in before nine you never schedule a waiter for steve and if you just accept that you're never as angry at steve as you would
[Bryan Pollock] (32:29 - 33:25)
be if every time he shows up and understood and expected and it's been deemed acceptable okay but if steve's been told repeatedly that he needs to be at work at 8 30 and he comes in at nine then steve needs to go find another fucking job yes he does i still want to talk about the automotive education because i know that's the world that you operate in now and we will talk for three hours if we're not careful so i want to talk about the kids that are coming into your programs now i want to talk about i mean we got this severe technician shortage right which means we have automotive instructor shortages we do uh and so what are the caliber of the instructors that some of these programs are bringing in some or mine i'm going to say some okay uh because i mean i don't know the instructors of your program i know a couple of them yeah so it's a double-edged
[Bill Laurie] (33:25 - 33:40)
sword with that right there are programs in the state of north carolina right now and i'm sure all over the country that are grabbing anyone they can that has a little bit of mechanical knowledge and have them teach automotive and it's like that's great if it was 10th grade technology
[Bryan Pollock] (33:40 - 34:35)
class but what do you do well the schools won't pay enough they don't want to pay against the autom they get great benefits don't get me started they got benefits don't get me so the question every time if a quality if a quality technician who is knowledgeable enough to be able to explain uh the theory of operation of these systems in a way that a layperson can understand because that's true expertise is being able to explain a complex factor in a way that can be understood being able to teach it so effectively so somebody who's skilled enough to be a good teacher can make comfortable six figures in the private sector there are very few that are going up to go make in north carolina i would guess 50 maybe a little more north carolina is not bad okay it's never gonna be 100 yeah it's never gonna be 100 i know there's some there's some
[Bill Laurie] (34:35 - 35:56)
for me it's like 56 000 to 70 so um at the school i'm at automotive instructors are starting around 70. oh that's way better than i would have expected so this is what it gives you a lot well think about what it gives you right you're not just clamoring for the guys that absolutely can't do it anymore because of an injury or something like that or whatever right and you're not clamoring for someone who can't do it because there weren't any good yeah what you're getting now is the guy who's like oh i don't turn 80 hours a week anymore i'm kind of tired of working saturdays stuff hurts i've paid off my house i don't really need yeah that's a $25,000 difference and is that $25,000 or so different worth having a different paycheck every week depending on my customer's mood sure right if my advisor showed up if some new warranty thing comes up if you're a dealership right if all of a sudden this four hours that was too short was the warranty time and someone said that's too now so we have our our school has the best potential in our area to get those guys that can do all those things and they're not coming to us because they don't have a choice they're coming to us because they have choices and they're making that choice
[Bryan Pollock] (35:56 - 36:22)
but i've seen well if you're a technician who fits that mold or you have you know a technician who fits that mold in central north carolina and maybe they're interested in uh in pursuing the the possibility of being an instructor you should find bill lorry online and reach out to him privately and he'll connect you with the different automotive programs that are in central north carolina ideally i think yours first to see if it's a good fit for you
[Bill Laurie] (36:22 - 36:27)
because yeah i think we're the highest paying in the state okay i think it's not by a small
[Bryan Pollock] (36:27 - 36:31)
market well it's also one of the most expensive parts of the state to live in too right so you
[Bill Laurie] (36:31 - 37:29)
know so the other thing that happens is if you're the type of guy that really loved this industry and you realize that regardless of your worst days this industry gave you everything paid for your house paid for your tools paid for some toys whatever you do gave you everything you have yes you work for it but it was a vehicle it was a vehicle to all this stuff when something in your existence gave to you at some point you have to reciprocate right for a lot of technicians one of the greatest opportunities to reciprocate is going to be to teach make sure you help create the next group of people that can do what you've been doing for the last three or four decades and it doesn't mean with me go to a shop that's looking for a mentor that's going to focus on mentoring you know go someplace where you can teach the things you learn i mean that's what you're doing well you're grabbing these guys that are trying to open shops and you're getting together and go hey here's all the things let's start all things not to do because it's such a
[Bryan Pollock] (37:29 - 38:09)
list yeah no shit um there is a growing uh opportunity for uh kind of senior technicians who are in that place again also and in the private sector in that you have these groups like in my market you've got chop a little tire you've got heralds uh you get these groups they're they're in that mid section where they're 10 to 15 to 20 stores you got guys driving around well they're hiring directors of training yes oh yeah so and you know that's gonna give you probably private sector money well but it's changed the dynamic right yeah so now it gives
[Bill Laurie] (38:09 - 38:55)
the opportunity in an educational fashion for a young person right that's just out of high school where you're really focusing on getting them to the point where they know enough not to cause problems and can be taught because the industry is having these mentors that bring them from you know i don't know e to m right so you're our school's never going to produce an a-tech you're never going to get somebody that sits in all of our classes and and learns everything that every instructor has to teach and would still be at that point we want you to you need someone that understands the basics to me you know what the basics are don't break stuff don't hurt yourself all right the basics of how these things function be able to cut a rotor how to read and
[Bryan Pollock] (38:55 - 39:05)
understand service information service lit is big how to um properly write a report a concern cause
[Bill Laurie] (39:05 - 39:09)
correction you know that's our weakest area on educating in that because of the structure of
[Bryan Pollock] (39:09 - 39:37)
education so not to go too far off track every time i see somebody on one of these forums complaining about extended warranties i say that guy doesn't have a person in his shop that can write concern cause correct exactly i had extended concern cause correction with google gemini grok applaud yeah whatever it sells the job so it's easier to sell that if that company has an online portal i'd rather sell that extended warranty company than try to sell a customer it's literally easier
[Bill Laurie] (39:37 - 40:35)
i love as a service advisor for a chrysler dealer i love the extended warranty companies but that's because i would explain exactly what was going on with all the words and i knew the words they wanted and i know the words that the engineers wanted yeah um oh yeah i remember i had someone come to inspect the transmission vibration i was doing i was working on a truck and i did nbh and chrysler had this cool tool called the serometer it was this little metal wand and you would spin it out until it vibrated its maximum and then a window would show you the frequency the vibration was at and then you can say this can't vibrate at that frequency this can't this can't and i had found an internal bushing on the output of a transmission that was bad right so this guy comes they have me pull it all apart and i'm like you know i did this i did this and then i took out this serometer and realized that the frequency being at 47 hertz eliminated blah blah blah blah then i tried a new driveshaft i tried this and this is where the vibration is like dude you had me at serometer we're good fix it but like understanding the tests is what test
[Bryan Pollock] (40:35 - 40:45)
is that he understood what you were talking about or he suddenly realized that he didn't know what the fuck you were talking about but he believed you i'll take either one this guy's inconvenient
[Bill Laurie] (40:45 - 41:29)
to mess with but i mean think about that right that's exactly the point when you write a story with all the words that explain the things right what does that do for your customer yeah a customer is paying you 200 an hour right sure ish okay let's say 200 because i don't want anyone to see your podcast i've never come to your shop why would they choose not to come to my shop if they knew i can get into that um whatever it is i'm coming to your shop and it's this much money and then your advisor talks to me or i read your technician's report and it says i found the thing was broken replaced thing my literal comment the other day you don't like extended warranties
[Bryan Pollock] (41:29 - 41:35)
because it needs a transmission because i said so it's not a diagnosis and it's not a it's not an
[Bill Laurie] (41:35 - 41:40)
yeah but that's not an acceptable form of communication for customer confidence either
[Bryan Pollock] (41:40 - 42:15)
back to that point like when they have us like our local high school level trade school you know they go they go in like their junior and senior year they can go out to yeah right great group of guys over there and they bring us in a couple times a year and they see i take a ton of shadows from i think i take between the spring and the fall session i don't know probably 15 or 20 kids a year yeah and um anyhow when they ask i always say the same thing i mean you're going to teach them how to do lefty loosey righty tighty you're going to teach them how basic things work i need them to understand that they don't know anything and they have to go read service information
[Bill Laurie] (42:15 - 44:06)
so one of the things that there's there's kind of a couple of new components at wig tech right i'm one of them but a lot of the changes in the trades comes all the way from the president's philosophy of how to like kind of operate a lot more than departments now our president has this one college philosophy he's been working on it for a few years but it's to break down the silos between departments and everyone talks about varying effectiveness but like i sat down in a meeting with my english and math department and they talked about instead of an english 110 this english 143 which is the same kind of english class but it's more about writing technical reports with accuracy that's what that's going to be that's the one my automotive students are going to get like i'm going to make sure that that 143 is on my ppg my programming guide to tell students if you want to really do everything you do to match your trade this is the english class i brought this textbook from this company called gw it says automotive mathematics and it's all the formulas that relate to the physics of cars sure i gave that to the math department i say here have your instructors look at this because if they want technician engagement if they want engagement from students that are in trades explain to them how they're going to use this math every day the things that are going on at wick tech because of a lot of areas of change and realizing what the need is to really give our students the problem solving skills and that base so they can move on to the next steps and incorporates all the departments of education working together if i have a student that takes a math class and enjoys it because it was automotive math when you get them in the shop is your mentor going to be having to explain pascal's law 15 times or just this is how hydraulics work in a brake system they're gonna think of it in the math class that they liked because the teacher was talking about brakes or the instead of go find x
[Bryan Pollock] (44:06 - 44:33)
or the english class right but one reoccurring theme in the automotive industry is all being the guy being the diagnostic guy doesn't pay being the diagnostic guy doesn't pay is it the dike this pays yeah they can't it they don't think they need english until they can't document right what they did properly that's right and gain the confidence of the advisor and the customer to get more time the warranty company right whoever it might be yeah but it's
[Bill Laurie] (44:33 - 44:54)
like if you can't communicate in a way that shows a reasonable expectation of someone being confident you've thrown away at least half of your money whatever it is yeah customers that don't come through your door you lose your car counts you're not going to get all the time if it's a manufacturer or warranty time right you're not going to get that that outside warranty company
[Bryan Pollock] (44:54 - 45:50)
i mean a newer theme that was you know in years past you know for many years advisors tended to be technicians that just weren't working on cars anymore that kind of thing has all shifted there's a lot of there's you know there's advisors that haven't serviced vehicles before it's quite common so now yeah right it's it's really common so now you have to build confidence you have to build the advice the advisor not only do they need their confidence built against that they need something to tell the customer because they don't know how the car works it's not their job to know how the car works right they don't need to know they don't know how it works so do you think an advisor when you give them three well-written paragraphs feels a lot better about going back to the well saying hey this is what my technician tested this is what he found this is what he expected to see this is what he expects is going on but we're going to have to do a b and c to get there and that's going to take us another three hours possibly or do you think explain it more time
[Bill Laurie] (45:50 - 46:26)
right you know what i mean and now this is what's insane to me like i see your tech metric hat right all this all this stuff we have we all of our students my hardest thing is to get them to put their phone down but you're a technician in the shop you can log into tech metric and talk to message and tell the story to your phone in all those five dollar words that you don't remember how to spell because you just took english to get your associate's degree and now you're out there doing things in the world you're not worried about being better at spelling or you say the things to your phone and it makes it into a legible and intelligent document for extended warranty
[Bryan Pollock] (46:26 - 46:45)
right extended warranty stuff you don't even say it into tech metric you say it into your ai of choice you say i'm working on this this testing i've done probably give it all your test results give me a concern cause correction that would be accepted by an aftermarket extended warranty you copy and paste that in you go back to your computer you tune it up a little bit you're five
[Bill Laurie] (46:45 - 47:52)
minutes into writing a six i gotta tell you i'm not a fan of ai there's a couple reasons here's the thing here's the first reason so when i went to work at wake tech fuel injection is also a fan i do my resume right i do my resume on the computer and i have ai write me a cover letter right and it writes me a cover letter with things that were true about me that i don't remember telling it never mind the fact that i had like the last 20 years of resumes in my computer and it was searching what i told it search it bugged me out the other one i don't like is and i have my students do this as an exercise by the way we'll go over something and they all understand i'm like all right now hop on your phone and google it and tell me what ai's first answer is and it's rubbish it's garbage well and i say to them we did it we wanted ai to be as just like real people we wanted ai to be like a real personality yeah real people when they don't know they lie and so does ai we have succeeded it makes up whatever story if it doesn't know it fills in the blanks i think that's one of my those are my two biggest things right a lot of what i
[Bryan Pollock] (47:52 - 48:19)
happen is with people's prompts they're not specific enough on where they want the information pulled from so that's why i always say i ai for diagnosing a car is not great when you've done the testing you can listen you can talk in your phone the testing i've done these are the results i got this is what i expect to see write me a concern what you're describing is a technical writing agent right you're just having it do the technical writing for you yeah
[Bill Laurie] (48:19 - 48:38)
close using it to say because you should be if you have shopkeep pro in your shop right you should be able to tell your ai what is blank blank blank go in the shopkeep pro pull information from there and i only want manufacturer certified information i don't want well nappa's got oem text nap and you
[Bryan Pollock] (48:38 - 49:03)
it should pull from there only we're close nappa's got uh smart glasses now that you can wear and link to your phone uh obviously and you can be like the ones they had at asta yeah you can say hey nappa i'm working i don't have a sense of humor no he did so they came to the school i told them they did a thing on abc123 what's the torque spec on this and it will it just goes all that and pulls it or goes to whatever their database there was one word that was wrong
[Bill Laurie] (49:03 - 50:36)
and it was nm for newton meters the thing talked about it as not newton meters they said nm was some other thing that it's not and my add was off to the races man my whole time it's like how are you doing a presentation when your technical information isn't wrong isn't right everyone you show this to that knows better to be like i don't want my technicians to have this who knows what will happen and i'm off down the rabbit trail of like all the horrible case scenarios that can go wrong and by the time i got done i went to the guy i said hey man i just want you to know before you present again do some research here i noticed one error in your presentation i think this is great i think your presentation is beautiful i would fix this i spent 15 minutes 20 minutes the whole time i didn't tell them that hardly be able to pay attention to you because of that and you are going to be presenting to people on some spectrum because that's most of us are on the spectrum in this industry or there's no way we would handle it how'd you get that done so fast the tism yeah like a bunch of it yeah a bunch of it like you have no idea how do you lock in like that tism yeah like how is it that i haven't completely lost my mind by never like how many cars do you not finish you get to a point and you have to wait for the part to come in or something else and you're going to finish 10 more cars and you pull it back in and it for a second it's like i don't remember everything i remember everything about this car like i just worked on it yesterday go back to work yeah um so uh the kids that are coming through the program now
[Bryan Pollock] (50:36 - 50:43)
uh have you noticed an evolution in the in how they're motivated and the types of kids that are
[Bill Laurie] (50:43 - 52:58)
coming in i mean so there's some challenges um people are different there's less motivation here's one of the things i've noticed and i think it comes from everything becoming more and more very few of the students that walk in now did a brake job in the driveway with their dad ever or mom or anybody right um because there are so many people that would be uncomfortable doing a brake job on a modern car because of how much more there is to it than there used to be sure so there is a lot there's a lot less of the type of experience you just got from being around the house where things get worked on there's an interesting level of expectations and entitlement with everybody um younger people more and it's you want to respect their need to be heard and that they have feelings but you got to dip that in the mud like it's it's a challenge for me because i can be you got you know i can go right to gruff right there i mean i can make a sailor cry with the way i respond to things um but what does that do for my student like i have to figure out i have to reach them exactly where they are and figure out who they are and come up with an approach that moves them forward like i have to hit it exactly right i remembered an engines class a couple students answered a thing wrong i'm like no that's not right and they get this look on their face and i stopped cold i said let's let's go on a little mission here why is being told you're incorrect about something have an emotional response i didn't say you're a horrible person i didn't say you'll never get this you thought it that's all that doesn't matter we're not at the point yet where what pops into this matters as long as what comes out of my mouth is appropriate and the next one i'm working on is that the facial expression also matches something positive but we had a 10 minute discussion on like this is the first time you're doing this someone in a shop when you get out there that comes up and says hey i think you might be doing that wrong cares enough about you to stop what they're doing and grow you the only emotional response you should feel is some kind of gratitude and an advantage to move forward and it's like several of our instructors i've heard them stop and dissect that thing that's an obstacle for five minutes our students now have a lot of
[Bryan Pollock] (52:58 - 53:52)
those obstacles okay um i think it's tricky to how we communicate with that generation i was i was on like the tail end of a generation that was raised in in a uh in a way that you have grit yeah they call it and i have people to thank for that i have grandparents and parents and wrestling coaches and everything else to thank for that but being able to uh enjoy something while it's sucking yeah a lot of people aren't able to enjoy things when they're not even that bad if i'm not happy i shouldn't do this and that's so and it's it interferes with their progress because you're like i know what is your freaking problem so you're bleeding a little who cares get the thing come on man rub some dirt on it yeah so so we feel like maybe there's a little bit less work ethic because there hasn't been manual labor or hardship upon their normal assigned task list
[Bill Laurie] (53:52 - 53:57)
and i think the work ethic is nobody wants to be uncomfortable yeah to achieve a greater goal
[Bryan Pollock] (53:57 - 54:14)
but the work ethic is suffering because of that in their defense they were trained that way they were trained their defense yeah they were trained that way they aren't is a general rule of thumb kids are brought up differently now than they were 30 years ago yeah but i still say that
[Bill Laurie] (54:14 - 55:11)
whatever it is i just say it in a different way now like i have right now we're very busy with scheduling and you'll have students that email you and then four hours later you didn't email you back and i had one last week and i'm like i'm sorry if i created an expectation that made you feel like i was going to be able to email you back in four hours that part's on me with how busy we are there are some times where 48 hours go by and i barely get through the emails that keep this place running right so i will never set an expectation it is very likely that this thing which i have started working on won't be finished for a week so am i still not saying knock it off you're not the only thing going on around here absolutely am i saying it in a way that that person feels heard yeah i'm sorry if i created this expectation but let me tell you what is likely so you know what to expect and you can plan for it and we've agreed upon it maybe you haven't agreed but i'm in a little more position of authority so i've told you that this is the thing right right and it's like that we need to talk about
[Bryan Pollock] (55:11 - 55:28)
this we did talk about this so i mean it's like 30 years ago though the kids that were pushed to the trades we've all had this conversation before it was uh 30 years ago it was an adhd but that's what it was right well it was but how they handled us
[Bill Laurie] (55:28 - 55:47)
you know educationally like when i went to school those are the kids that had the classroom in the boiler room and it wasn't about helping them through and find it helping them find their workarounds it was about don't let them screw up the kids that have a chance put them downstairs and now we're building everything we're fixing all your broken stuff
[Bryan Pollock] (55:47 - 56:04)
yeah my english teacher had a chart of uh of how everybody's grade i was like the black hole no matter where he moved me in the class the black hole would suck all the grades down he put me he'd move me around and just suck all the grades all around because i was like this is bullshit
[Bill Laurie] (56:04 - 56:14)
what has education done for most of the people that have the trades mindset they've been grading a fish on its ability to ride a bicycle for a hundred years on its ability to find a tree is
[Bryan Pollock] (56:14 - 56:37)
what i like to say the root of my question though is we got the kids that were deemed problematic or not college material for 30 years but i i feel anecdotally that that is changing the trades are becoming cool again they are and we're starting to see kids who could go to a four-year college but are choosing not to and they're intentionally choosing trades so it's not just the kids that
[Bill Laurie] (56:37 - 57:47)
are choosing that and this is a discussion i've had with the lack of silos that my school has now like i've got to talk to people advising and hear the conversations of it's taken me years to teach some of my advisors that have masters and bachelors or bachelors of doctorates that most of the students that come here are never going to do a four-year degree what they're going to do is come here for two years get associates and go out there and make society function and be successful and happy doing something they love they are crucial and and you know for a college which for a long time colleges have been only about feeding four-year schools right high schools guidance counselors feed the four-year feed the four-year that's changed and it's changed because it's 250 an hour to get your car fixed and if you don't go to one of you know one percent ten percent of the shops it's probably going to be broken worse when they're done because we have given up on making sure that people that first day i've ever met this guy but you and i should probably hang out more absolutely man but like people that choose to have their hands dirty are what make you who don't choose that be able to accomplish all the things
[Bryan Pollock] (57:47 - 57:51)
i'm not good with fractions but there's a five out of four chances somebody else is going to break your car
[Bill Laurie] (57:53 - 59:28)
whatever it might be but i mean you know it's it's that's why the trades have changed right yeah it used to be at 100 so we'll have him go take some automotive classes because what else can he really do my father who was a printer by the way his father came to him apparently when he was in high school you know you're nothing but an f up i don't know what to do with you i'm going to send you to this printing high school so you can at least do something and my father you know he printed textbooks and later on when newspapers were still a thing he printed the newspaper and i remember looking at there were two printing presses for this paper okay one had a single dot one had two dots at a certain part and sunday morning when the front page was color i could tell from 20 feet away which one my dad what shift my dad worked because he knew exactly how to get that ink to look like a magazine cover closer than a than just a tablet cover or paper cover without wasting ink and he used to have to have meetings you use too much ink and he would grab two copies and throw it in front of his boss which one do you want to buy this drab pos or this thing that actually gets your attention and they leave alone for another six months but like my grandfather knew he wasn't going to amount to anything in the everyday world that he was used to and he didn't realize what he was doing he's like going and building things or artistic or some flare is probably where you're going to be a superstar yeah things that require craftsmanship craftsmanship now is almost dead yeah production has ruined i have a on our whiteboard at the shop
[Bryan Pollock] (59:28 - 59:40)
we're always writing stuff and i think the latest thing i wrote on it was do it nice yes which is like yeah put the little wires back in the little clips whatever thing to look like it did when they built the car you know i don't want the thing
[Bill Laurie] (59:40 - 1:00:37)
laying over when you guys start out and i think this is directly proportional to how quickly somebody gets thrown in the flat rate before they're ready when i was young there was no quick lane tax there was no not being on flat rate right they fed you the bugs man you're going to work on whatever i decide might work out for you and you're going to get paid the book time maybe you'll make it so you were pushed to find shortcuts that were unacceptable and you didn't find out they weren't acceptable so you had comebacks that you had to fix for free and usually technicians that started out rough and then got to that five-year mark where all of a sudden i crank out time no matter what nonsense is going on then you come back to i'm doing 80 hours a week i bet i can make everything i touch perfect and do 72 75 five hours isn't worth being a hack i like when it's like my sense of accomplishment it should look like you were never there yeah i love it unless you made something better if you made
[Bryan Pollock] (1:00:37 - 1:00:43)
something drastically better than fine if it's bolts it's weight savings can i can i ask statistical
[Bill Laurie] (1:00:44 - 1:00:49)
uh questions about the school i don't have all the information in the forefront but i'll do my
[Bryan Pollock] (1:00:49 - 1:00:52)
best roughly how many students are in the automotive program at your school we are
[Bill Laurie] (1:00:52 - 1:01:01)
right around we have 420 seats but it's about 330 or 40 students okay but still filling out and
[Bryan Pollock] (1:01:01 - 1:01:05)
growing rapidly because it was way more than it was five years ago i have waitlists all the time
[Bill Laurie] (1:01:05 - 1:01:20)
okay um when i get more instructors i'm actually allowed to hire five if i get them um by august of 27 i can very easily have 550 students signed up for classes don't know where
[Bryan Pollock] (1:01:20 - 1:01:25)
i'm putting them yet what number of those 330 do you think will complete the program
[Bill Laurie] (1:01:26 - 1:01:50)
we probably lose 10 to 20 that don't complete the program okay how many of them get poached by a dealership say way less now because i throw them out of the building tell uh tell i throw them out so we just they're not they're not coming to job fairs you're not coming to my job fairs you're not invited to the building you're not doing anything you can hire them on your own if you don't care about their success because their success maximizes your success i attended
[Bryan Pollock] (1:01:50 - 1:01:54)
so i attended an advisory board meeting yeah sorry i get very upset about this we quit going
[Bill Laurie] (1:01:54 - 1:01:59)
to job fairs oh yeah what did i say don't make me throw you out of my building yes and that's
[Bryan Pollock] (1:01:59 - 1:02:29)
what i wanted to say oh yeah we're the very beginning of an advisory board meeting there's two independents there's uh there's me and there's and there's one other and then everybody else in the room is dealerships and all the credit in the world to you man and you were talking to us too and i get that but i don't think us i don't think the aftermarket is the problem for that specific issue uh but you said hey and if you pull one of my students out and they quit the program to go work for you full time you're never allowed back in this building yeah and it doesn't
[Bill Laurie] (1:02:29 - 1:02:37)
mean you can't i respect the hell out of that but you're not going to be invited to job fairs you're last on the list and don't negatively impact the education they signed up for
[Bryan Pollock] (1:02:37 - 1:02:42)
for your short-term gain my school goes out of their way to lube bay and not let them ever do
[Bill Laurie] (1:02:42 - 1:03:36)
we do so much and spend so much time making sure we understand the needs of our industry partners and we want the industry to be as successful as possible you know who's always gonna be first awake tech the students and that's it end of discussion and the conversation that student and that student success is first and if they come to me halfway through and say they hate this i'm gonna sit down and i'm gonna grab people and find out what do you like to do because we probably teach that too and it's not about success in my program it's not about me and my numbers i don't care it's about that student going taking classes and the thing that they want to do that they love and 10 years later they're doing it and they get home at the end of the day and they were glad that they went to work that day not miserable because they hate what they do that's what student success looks like right empowering the person is it stressful time no i have to fidget with something
[Bryan Pollock] (1:03:36 - 1:03:40)
because to make the most success but i was clicking my pen and he doesn't like that sound
[Bill Laurie] (1:03:40 - 1:04:35)
on the audio so yeah and it's like that's like those a lot of people know like that's me that's been me my whole existence this is what we're doing this is about the student this is about who i'm here to serve and anything that you're interested in doing and interfering with that the answer is no yeah i am here and we are bending over backwards to get you what you need which is more bodies that go to a point where they finish what they started so when you get them they finish what they started for you too and i am not going to let you interfere with my students by the way interfering with your own success inadvertently because you just want a body i just want a warm body i just want a warm body i got a firearm in six months because they don't know anything or they don't finish what they're doing i didn't teach them anything right no i will not let you mess up the industry for yourself for the industry itself or for these students i love and if you're not about maximizing their success you're gone so if we have
[Bryan Pollock] (1:04:35 - 1:05:05)
uh if we have a shop owner or a shop manager listener who uh wants to be a good representative of the independent after market uh at their local automotive program uh school how can they best get plugged in and best be a good representative and and help because right now if you walk into these schools it looks like it's a billboard for the dealerships because the dealerships are the they have the money we got a bunch of money out there to make the rick hendrick automotive
[Bill Laurie] (1:05:05 - 1:06:02)
training center or whatever i think it depends on the team right so we have an interesting mix i was a dealership guy i was a corporate jaguar guy i had my own shops i i am not propelled to give anybody an advantage in different areas um i have somehow managed to beat down most of the monsters that relate to ego and pride within myself so i'm not now have this title and i know more than shop owners about what's going on in the industry that i've been somewhat divorced from for eight years if your program in your area is run by people that understand that they really do need your input to know what's going on in your building that they're never in to give the students everything they need for success it's easy it's an email or phone call away hey i'd like to sit down with you and talk about what students might need to know
[Bryan Pollock] (1:06:02 - 1:06:07)
when they come out what's changed or the attrition rate of all these kids that you just send up to
[Bill Laurie] (1:06:07 - 1:07:37)
the dealership um i'd like to just let you know what happens when i get them from your school any place that you call that's not like well i just might not be a fun conversation for me but yeah i would love to know how they're doing out there if that's not the answer i don't want to say anything bad about any other schools but they might want to address their hiring practices for their leadership teams and their educational departments anyone who's in who's done something and is now teaching it and then running that area has to know i'm not doing this every day and if the amount of time that i was doing this every day i experienced ridiculous and quick changes all over the place from every angle not just in what i was working on the whole experience i went from everybody's a mainline tech to gs's that do oil changes in the bay next to you to a quick lane that's separated from your building from everything scribbled down in some kind of gibberish on the back of a repair order to having a terminal at your desk that you shared with three other guys to logging in on your phone and putting in your repair work that much evolution has drastically changed what someone needs who's learning to enter this industry and if you stepped away to teach i don't care if you i don't care if you are an immortal and spend a thousand years and you started off shooing horses and went all through this industry you walked away it kept changing you have no idea what's different you have to be ready to talk to these shops the shop owners never mind if your area is going through something different than the rest of
[Bryan Pollock] (1:07:37 - 1:08:47)
the industry is so contact your community college or your automotive program nearby get on an advisory board go to the career fair days anything you can participate in go to career fair days go to advisory board send an email hey go to hey so it's going to be hard to compete with the hr director and the full-time recruiter that the local dealer group has at career fairs because they go to all of them but if you have the bandwidth to go take take a table take a box full of mechanics wear gloves or uh nice safety glasses whatever it's going to be yeah giveaways but don't just give them away put giant connect four on your table and they got to beat you at giant connect four anything like that and they're going to line up to try to beat you and win something but you get that three or four minutes to talk to that young man or woman and get a feel for them and give them information about you and your company and your business and then you know which ones you really want to go after right and and what and and you can establish those relationships a little bit more effectively than they just walk by and say hey and grab a pair of sunglasses or whatever it might be
[Bill Laurie] (1:08:47 - 1:09:31)
and if you're just hiring you know most of the schools can't send you their best guy i get emails all the time can you send me your three best students no i can't because i have a whole ton of places that ask me the same thing and i can't decide who's the best or who's not who's not as good it's not okay anymore it's not a conversation we're supposed to have but you can send me a flyer for your job and i can hang it on the jobs board and let students see that you can do so all you guys in these shops if there's a school close to you make a flyer for need new technicians this is what my shop is about put a picture of a cool car in the back of it email it to these directors and ask if they'll hang it up in a common area you're not really getting preferential treatment by your thing being hung up but most of you are asking can you send me your best students
[Bryan Pollock] (1:09:31 - 1:09:41)
i i can't no would you do me a favor and send me your three best students absolutely thanks i appreciate that all right but you hang up that flyer on their bombshell for you
[Bill Laurie] (1:09:42 - 1:10:03)
yes um we can't like and it's it's it's part of how people especially students need to be talked to it wouldn't be appropriate for them to feel comfortable in an educational environment if i'm gonna go say you three are the best and the rest of you aren't the best so how much do they're not ready to hear that yet they have to work through the educational piece
[Bryan Pollock] (1:10:03 - 1:10:18)
what's the going rate to bribe administrators or programs to get a hundred alignment rack is usually what the dealer groups in our area do usually alignment equipment is what they do oh previously you know i can cut that out previously people are gonna get in their
[Bill Laurie] (1:10:18 - 1:10:52)
feels over there's an interesting thing you guys are all met you're you're you're really screwed now in my area i have an interesting feeling about integrity your existence can strip you of anything but that you have to surrender it and it's impossible to get back so at my school with me in charge good luck you're not bribing me my integrity is worth more than anything you could possibly offer man i wouldn't tell anybody that i bribed you it would be a secret just between you and me they wouldn't know that requires me to do things a different way than the rest of the world in many cases so there's just no bribing me thank you for coming
[Bryan Pollock] (1:10:52 - 1:10:55)
to hang out and talk with us man this has been fun thank you i feel like we could go for another hour
[Bill Laurie] (1:10:55 - 1:11:07)
but yeah i mean well you know it's interesting we physically live maybe 15 minutes apart from each other and we do this how many miles away from home yeah we had to come two thousand miles
[Bryan Pollock] (1:11:07 - 1:11:17)
to sit down and record so we could do this all the time oh my confessions of an automotive educator yeah oh god yeah
[Bill Laurie] (1:11:19 - 1:11:34)
the tism doesn't go away we just learn to manage it so you know all the same things that make me forget where i put my screwdriver still happen on the educational in the educational area i just have a ton more workarounds with all the times i've had to find things right do this do that
[Bryan Pollock] (1:11:34 - 1:12:16)
so yeah cool totally me thanks bill thank you thanks for listening to confessions of a shop owner where we lay it all out the good the bad and sometimes the super messed up i'm your host mike allen here to remind you that even the pros screw it up sometimes so why not laugh a little bit learn a little bit maybe have another drink you got a confession of your own or a topic you'd like me to cover or do you just want to let me know what an idiot i am email mike at confessions of a shop owner.com or call and leave a message the number 704 confess that's 704-266-3377 if you enjoyed this episode be sure to like subscribe or follow join us on this crazy journey that is shop ownership i'll see you on the next episode