Life in the Tax Lane (Canada)

February's Life in the Tax Lane is here! A new month brings new tax developments! As we move further into 2025, stay ahead with the latest edition of Life in the Tax Lane. This free, fast-paced 10-minute video for Canadian tax professionals delivers insightful discussions on key updates shaping the world of Canadian tax.

This month, the Video Tax News Team discusses the uncertainty surrounding unlegislated tax proposals, including the capital gains inclusion rate increase and CRA’s evolving approach to administering unenacted rules. Stay informed on selected 2024 and 2025 developments affecting trusts, short-term rentals, and CPP contributions and more. The discussion also covers important timing considerations for filing objections, CRA’s potential move toward automatic tax filing for certain taxpayers, the tax treatment of pre-marriage charitable donations by a spouse, and that losses from personal scams are non-deductible in most cases.

Topics: Uncertain and Unlegislated Proposals | Select 2024 and 2025 Developments | Late Objections | Automatic Tax Filing? | Donation by Spouse Prior to Marriage | Losses from Personal Scams

Sources: https://www.videotax.com/web-tips-articles/life-in-the-tax-lane-february-2025-episode-117

Program Recorded: January 28, 2025

NOTE: This episode was recorded prior to the capital gains inclusion rate change deferral. For information on that change, see:
Finance release - https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2025/01/government-of-canada-announces-deferral-in-implementation-of-change-to-capital-gains-inclusion-rate.html
CRA release - https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/news/newsroom/tax-tips/tax-tips-2025/update-cra-administration-proposed-capital-gains-taxation-changes.html

Life in the Tax Lane is for general information purposes only and deals with dynamic, time-sensitive and complex matters that may not apply to particular facts and circumstances. The information provided should not be relied upon as a substitute for specialized professional advice in connection with any particular matter. For more information visit videotax.com/disclaimer. ©Video Tax News Inc. 2025, All Rights Reserved.


What is Life in the Tax Lane (Canada)?

These 10-minute podcasts are a rapid-fire discussion of select recent developments in the wonderful world of Canadian tax presented by the Video Tax News Team. For more information go to www.videotax.com.

The following presentation has been prepared

by the Video Tax News team for Canadian tax

and financial professionals. Program recorded

January 28th, 2025.

Enjoy.

Welcome to the February edition of Life in the Tax Lane.

We got Joe back. Joe and Hugh are matching again.

So all things are right in the world.

Hey, I feel like an oddball. We got to

Say February 2025.

We got binge watchers out there.

Oh, thank you. That is very true.

And it's not just our parents.

Well, I got to say February.

We've got the snow possibly melting in some places.

So I'm getting excited about sort of like getting out of

that deep freeze, but I'm a little uncertain to as

to when it will actually happen.

Caitlin, speaking of uncertainty.

Yes, let's talk about all of these tax proposals

that have been introduced

but have not yet received Royal Ascent.

So the big concept, the big question we're getting is

how do we file our tax returns based on these proposals,

especially as Parliament is prorogued until March 24th.

so first off, as we've alluded to previously,

the proposed increase to the capital gains inclusion rate

to two thirds.

Well, CRA has said that they are going

to administer the proposals

as if they have been enacted, meaning

that they're going to be updating their forms

to reflect a two thirds inclusion rate.

So what does that mean for filers, you or I

or our corporations that are filing these tax returns?

Well, we have an option. This is a self-assessing system.

So we can choose

to file our tax returns based upon the proposals,

the two third inclusion rate consistent

with CRA's administrative position,

or we can choose to file our tax returns based on the

existing legislation at that 50% inclusion rate.

Now, those options aren't risk free.

I mean, for example, if you're filing on the 50% inclusion

rate, paying taxes associated with

that 50% inclusion rate, if the proposals eventually pass

and your tax liability increases when they pass, boom,

you're going to have non-deductible.

There's that risk of non-deductible interest

that you're going to have to pay on that tax liability.

I mean, if you file on the two thirds inclusion rate in

accordance with CRA's admin policy

and the rules don't, the proposals don't pass,

well then congratulations.

If you paid the associated tax liability on time,

you would've just advanced our the federal government

an interest free loan, which you're going to have to ask

for them to return to you.

so a few factors we need

to be keeping in mind when determining

what filing position we want to take.

That's right now, go ahead. Yeah, yeah.

Now I was going to say the other set of proposals

that we have out there, these are proposals

that haven't made it into notice of ways and means motion

and CRA's historical practice would be

that if it didn't hit a notice of ways

and means motion it isn't enacted.

We are not going to administer the act on those proposals.

However, recently we have heard

and seen announcements coming from the CRA

that they would administer provisions that have not

yet been included in a notice of ways a means motion.

So for example, as it's going to hit our personal tax returns,

that proposal to extend the charitable donations deadline

to February 28th,

whereby you could still claim those donations on your

2024 tax returns.

CRA says, yep, go right on ahead.

We will administer those rules as proposed.

So what we're seeing is what may appear to be

a kind of a newer position by the CRA as to them kind

of picking and choosing which proposals they would

administer. Joe or Hugh.

Any thoughts there? It's a dynamic area. Yeah,

I think, I think we got to be clear that just

because they're doing it for, for that one,

they're not necessarily doing it for all the other ones.

In fact, we can assume that they're not,

unless they actually specifically make a comment saying

that so we got to be careful

that we don't get too comfortable with them.

Hugh, any thoughts from you,

Joe? I think that's dead

on.

And the other challenge we're going to have is

as a tax preparer, I got to use e-filing.

How will the system handle this?

They would have to accept me filing using current law.

That doesn't mean they have to make it easy

and for a lot of individuals, they're going to end up

with exactly the same tax liability either way.

So why not take the path of least resistance?

Yeah, that's right. Now let's move on

to the second topic here.

And that is 2024 and 2025 development.

CRA just released an item, which has a good summary

of the things that we're going

to be seeing in the near future.

And just to mention a couple of the things on there.

First of all, they mentioned trust returns in respect

of bare trusts. You don't need to file those for the 2024 year.

Also, the CPP enhancement

we've got the final year of the phase in of this.

So we're seeing a bit of a jump for 2025, but then

after that, we're only going to see indexation,

type enhancements.

So this is kind of the last big year there.

Also, don't forget short term rental income

having a disallowance of the deductions

if you are not on side from a regulatory perspective,

you don't have your business license

or whatever else in place by the end of December of

2024 disallowance of those expenses.

So a number of good reminders in there.

I'd definitely check out the link

and take a look at that release.

As a firm, are we prepared for all of these big changes?

Well, Joe, I find every year

as the personal tax season grinds to an end,

I've got someone who didn't get assessed like they were

supposed to get assessed, and we have until April 30th, 2025

to object to 2023 personal tax returns.

Normally the default is we get 90 days from an assessment.

If we don't file that objection, we can go

and pretty please ask CRA to give us an extension up

to one year after that due date to file an objection.

And we had the Federal Court

of appeal comment on something

that I think we've noticed when we look at cases in the

recent past that the tax court is hearing literally hundreds

of cases every year from people who missed that deadline

because they were still dealing informally

with CRA providing more information.

It's all going to get fixed and it didn't get fixed.

And the Federal Court of Appeal notes

that their hands are tied, these deadlines are fixed

and firm and those appeal rights have been lost.

So I know I've said for years, if you're pushing up

to the objection deadline, file the objection

so you're not reliant on CRA generosity

to get your return fixed up properly.

Mm-hmm. Some great important tips there.

Another item we wanted to mention,

it was buried deep in the fall economic statement

and didn't get a whole lot of press,

but I could see this one hitting the books regardless

of whichever party is leading the government,

you know, in the coming years.

And it's the whole concept that CRA would be able,

you'd have to get draft legislation

but the proposal that CRA would be able

to automatically file personal tax returns

for lower income Canadians.

And the concept here is a lot of lower income Canadians

are entitled to benefits, but

unless they file their tax return, they're not going

to get those benefits.

So they got to get the tax return in.

So let's get CRA to automatically file these tax returns

where the individual can review those returns,

maybe modify or opt out from this system.

So interesting development here.

Lots of countries automatically file

tax returns for the individual.

So it's not a new concept,

but it's a new kind of idea here

that we're talking about in the fall economic statement.

The fall economic statement also proposed the idea

of exploring options for CRA to potentially file returns

for more middle income taxpayers as well.

So less certainty there,

but it's an interesting trend that we're seeing

and we'll see if it comes to fruition.

Thanks, Caitlin. Now the next topic I wanted

to mention is a donation by a spouse.

So you've got a spouse

and they've made a donation sometime

within the last five years.

It hasn't been claimed yet. Guess what?

You can actually claim that amount.

But what happens if your spouse's donation was made

before they became your spouse?

You got into that spousal relationship.

Can you still make the claim?

The short answer from CRA is yes,

you do have a possibility there. Hugh, what do you have?

Well, Joe, unfortunate short answer from CRA

to a recent question was, oops,

I clicked the wrong link on my email,

or I got sucked into someone claiming

to be a relative in dire need of financial assistance

and now I'm out of pocket from one of these personal scams.

Is there any tax relief for that?

And CRA had to give the right answer.

Nothing in the act lets you deduct losses due to fraud

unless they are somehow linked

to an income earning source like business or investments.

And unfortunately, none of these would be the loss

of your personal cash generates no tax relief.

So a good reason

or even more reason to be wary of responding

to those really high pressure emails or even phone calls.

Well, that's about all the time we have today.

just wanted to, if you have a chance

and you'd like to attend our personal tax update seminars,

we definitely have them going on.

They are so much fun,

just like the fun you're having today. Thanks again.

The Video Tax News team has been

provided Canadian accounting professionals

with practical tax information for over 40 years.

Subscribe to one of our tax newsletters

or join us as we present live

and pre-recorded seminars relating

to both personal and corporate tax.

For more information, go to videotax.com.

The proceeding information is

for general information purposes only

and deals with dynamic, time sensitive,

and complex matters that may not apply

to particular facts or circumstances.

Information provided should not be relied upon

as a substitute for specialized professional advice in

connection with any particular matter.

For more information, go to videotax.com/disclaimer.

Copyright Video Tax News, Inc 2025 All Rights reserved.

Some of our videos offer closed captioning and/or transcription solely for the convenience of our viewers. A third party automatically generates the closed captioning and/or transcription. Video Tax News does not review the accuracy of any information that appears in a closed caption or transcript. Video Tax News makes no representations or warranties and expressly disclaims any responsibility or liability with respect to, any errors or omissions in, or the accuracy, reliability, timeliness or completeness of, any information that appears in a closed caption or transcript. We encourage viewers to verify any information provided through the closed captioning/transcripts with other sources.