Cloud 9fin

High-profile collapses like FTX and Celsius are only the beginning of the story — the real chaos begins in bankruptcy court. Global, anonymous creditors, in addition to issues around token valuation and jurisdiction have made these cases uniquely difficult to untangle.

In this episode of Cloud 9fin, interim distressed debt editor Sasha Padbidri and distressed debt reporter Nicholas Rizzi break down why these bankruptcy cases are so hard to administer, and whether the courts are finally catching up.

Have any feedback for us? Send us a note at podcast@9fin.com.

Creators and Guests

Producer
Evie Rusman-Okonkwo
EMEA Podcast Producer for 9fin Limited

What is Cloud 9fin?

Leveraged finance, distressed debt, and private credit drive today’s markets. Cloud 9fin delivers expert insights on high-yield bonds, syndicated loans, direct lending, and debt restructuring. Join top analysts and investors as we explore credit markets, special situations, and private debt strategies shaping the industry.

From credit risk assessment to institutional credit trends, each episode provides actionable intelligence for fund managers, institutional investors, and financial professionals. Whether you’re tracking high-yield issuances, analyzing corporate debt, or uncovering distressed debt opportunities, we’ve got you covered.

Through its AI-powered data and analytics platform, 9fin provides everything you need to get your head around credit or win a mandate — all in one place. We help subscribers win business, outperform their peers and save time. Stay ahead in leveraged finance market trends—subscribe now for expert discussions on the forces moving global credit.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Hey everyone, I'm Sasha Padbidri, interim distressed debt editor with 9fin, and welcome to this week's episode, where distressed debt reporter Nick Rizzi and me will be diving into the murky, messy world of crypto bankruptcies. Welcome, Nick.

**Nick Rizzi**

Thanks for having me.

**Sasha Padbidri**

We've heard a lot about crypto bankruptcies just given the high-profile nature of people like Sam Bankman-Fried, FTX, Celsius, and libertarians, of course. But there's another story to be told, right, once these companies are in bankruptcy court. I'll leave it to you to unpack that.

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah, because obviously, a lot of the headlines are talked about with some of the fraud cases attached to some of them. But because of the unique nature of what they're doing, they're working on a decentralized anonymous currency that spreads across the globe. A bankruptcy for them is not like a traditional company. A lot of things that are simple or relatively simple. And bankruptcies become really, really complex in these kinds of cases. Things like just compiling a creditor list.

**Sasha Padbidri**

So things we take for granted.

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Okay. All right.

**Nick Rizzi**

Oftentimes the only identification that some of these tokens have on who owns what is just a string of numbers and characters that go up to like 46. And you have, how do you tell them, hey, you have a bankruptcy claim and we want to pay you back when you can't find them? Another thing is that, there's been headlines that the price of Bitcoin jumped in value by like $8,400 in one day in 2024. So when do you set the value of this currency for repayment? If you do it at petition date, people have complained that they're losing about half their value of their token because of the fluctuation of price.

**Sasha Padbidri**

I just want to further unpack some of the hurdles that people that you talked to for your story, like what they encountered during these crypto bankruptcies? Because you said that there was like a lot of — I don't want to say cultural disconnect, but I think that there were some vibe shifts that they were not used to, right?

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah. I mean, these cases tend to have a massive amount of creditors. Like FTX, for example, had more than 1 million creditors.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Oh, that's insane.

**Nick Rizzi**

And a lot of people who are into crypto, obviously there's a lot of institutions and institutional investors into them, but by and large, they're retail investors. Some of them are libertarian, some of them are anarchist. Then, you know, that's a group of people not exactly known for their love of government and systems of power.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Or love of communication.

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah, that too.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Right? Yeah.

**Nick Rizzi**

And so they're used to dealing with people who've been in bankruptcy court before, and now they're sort of faced with a group who don't understand the process. Some of them don't like the process. And so you have instances where the only way you can find some of these creditors are by going into Discord chat rooms and one source told me that they had to take their person that was monitoring the chat room off because they kept getting into arguments with the people in the chat room.

**Sasha Padbidri**

That's crazy. No, you're right. Crypto people on Discord are interesting characters. Out of curiosity, what are some of the text messages that your sources were fielding during the process of contacting creditors?

**Nick Rizzi**

I didn't get into specifics, unfortunately, of what they were saying. But, one of my sources described it, and excuse my language, as a circle jerk of like, negative comments and negative Nancys, that a lot of these people did have legit complaints because they're obviously invested in this token and now they're potentially losing their money. But he said a lot of them were just angry, needed a place to vent, and it just became this sort of circle.

**Sasha Padbidri**

A cesspool.

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah. And so they just found it wasn't very productive to keep going into that. Another thing is when they were putting out the forms to try to get people to sign on and identify themselves as a creditor, Discord is known, and just most internet chat rooms like this are known as being a hotbed of scammers, right? So people are always there trying to get your money. So like, they were distrustful of like, hey, we're a financial firm. We're just trying to get you repaid. Just give us all your information. And so they had to try to figure out ways to be like, listen, we're trustworthy. We're an actual firm. We're not trying to take your money.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Wow. We said earlier, I think there's a lot in corporate bankruptcy where debtors and creditors do take a lot of these things for granted. I didn't realize that there was this whole other story when it comes to crypto bankruptcies. But moving from that, I was just wondering in your story, you also talk about how fraud complicates these cases, right? Can you just unpack that a little more?

**Nick Rizzi**

A lot of these cases had fraud where in the FTX case, Sam Bankman-Fried, he pulled out some of the money that people put into FTX into his own trading account that was controlled by his on-again, off-again girlfriend. Others misled creditors on how safe their asset was and accused of bumping the price up of their coin. And so to do some of that, you have to have a little messy bookkeeping. You know, you have to cook the books a little bit. You have to make these things hard to just look at and find. And so if you're dealing with a crypto fraud, you're not really dealing with the highest quality books, records, and stuff like that. But what I thought was interesting is I assumed that it would be more complex than any other traditional fraud case in bankruptcy. But one source told me that actually Lehman Brothers had more claims and more complications. So they are complicated, but it's not anything extra compared to other fraud cases.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Got it. And I guess my final question to you is this: do you think that admin processes for these crypto bankruptcies will become more streamlined or clearer in the future? I mean, this is still like the quote unquote Wild West. That we're looking at, right?

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah and I think that's the question on everybody's mind. I think certain things they're going to have a way to do them or a way to follow them. And a couple of people said, once you do a couple of them, you kind of figure out the tips of the trade and how to navigate some of the stuff you learn. You get a lot of lessons learned. So there should be things that are streamlined. But like every company, everything's different. And so new things crop up all the time and certain things like when do you set the value compared to dollars on these tokens is not really legal precedent yet. So some of that is still being argued over.

And then if you have a split between people who want to get repaid in tokens and people who want to get repaid in dollars, you know, that hasn't really been said that we're doing it all one way or not. So some of the stuff will become easier. Some of it is still unsure. And then even if you know the best practices to contact these creditors, you still have to find like a million anonymous creditors and let them know that. And —

**Sasha Padbidri**

Not all of them in the US, right?

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah. And that was another thing, these are global companies. Most of them had headquarters and offices spread across the globe. The people investing in them and getting the coins and using their services all across the globe. So they're still trying to figure out how jurisdiction works.

FTX had jurisdiction claims in the Bahamas or in the United States. And so that also hasn't been worked out yet. But on the positive side, a lot of judges have been dealing with these cases before, so they at least know a little bit. They're not sort of unsure and you don't have to explain to them what a decentralized currency is anymore.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Cool. Well, that's good to know. And, you know, hopefully the next time we talk about this or the next crypto bankruptcy we see, hopefully there's a little more clarity. And I do hope for the sake of the mental health of the restructuring advisors involved in the future, they don't have to go on Discord to contact these creditors.

**Nick Rizzi**

Yeah. Some people have tried using NFTs. You can ping a wallet with an NFT, so you don't actually have to go onto these chat rooms, but that has mixed levels of success, but courts have been okay with that. But we'll see with the future. Yeah. But as long as they can stay off Discord, I think that'd probably be better for everybody.

**Sasha Padbidri**

Agreed. Yeah. So on that note, thank you, Nick, for discussing your recent reporting with me and to our subscribers. If you would like a copy of Nick's very awesome navigation of the murky world of crypto bankruptcies, please reach out to us at podcast@9fin.com. Thanks for tuning into this week's episode. Hope to see you again soon.