
The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Modern Caries Management Part 2: Peptides, SDF, Hydroxyapatite and Xerostomia | PDP269
META DESCRIPTION:
Prof Avijit Banerjee on peptides, SDF, hydroxyapatite vs fluoride, grey occlusal lesions, sealants, dry mouth and why stepwise excavation is outdated.
URL SLUG:
modern-caries-management-part-2-peptides-sdf-hydroxyapatite
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Minimally invasive management of caries
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Self-assembling peptides and Curodont Repair
- Silver diamine fluoride for caries arrest
- Hydroxyapatite toothpaste vs fluoride
- Managing grey occlusal lesions
- Therapeutic and preventive fissure sealants
- Caries management in xerostomia and after radiotherapy
- Stepwise excavation vs selective caries removal
- S3 guidelines on deep caries management
A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO MODERN CARIES MANAGEMENT PART 2: PEPTIDES, SDF, HYDROXYAPATITE AND XEROSTOMIA
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP269
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE
EPISODE SUMMARY
In part two of this series on the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati and Prof Avijit Banerjee move from diagnosing caries to managing it with minimal intervention. Prof explains how self-assembling peptides work, why minerals and fluoride work together like bricks and mortar, and why he believes we can't wait for perfect trial evidence before adopting new technologies.
He explains where silver diamine fluoride fits, mainly for arresting cavitated lesions in high-risk children and older adults. He gives his view on hydroxyapatite toothpaste versus fluoride, stressing that fluoride at dental concentrations is safe and effective. He answers community questions on grey occlusal lesions, fissure sealing while restoring, managing severe dry mouth and radiation caries, and whether stepwise excavation is still taught, pointing to new S3 guidelines on deep caries. He closes with the difference between a cook and a chef. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is the free Contemporary Caries Management Implementation Pack.
IN SHORT
This episode explains how to choose between modern minimally invasive caries treatments. Prof Avijit Banerjee's framework is fluoride and prevention for early enamel lesions, resin or peptide infiltration as lesions progress, sealants for early dentine lesions, and SDF to arrest cavitated lesions in high-risk patients, always alongside biofilm and diet control.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Jaz's pearl: download the free Contemporary Caries Management Implementation Pack at protrusive.co.uk/mid.
- Self-assembling peptides infiltrate early enamel lesions and form a scaffold for minerals, but still need a mineral source.
- Prof compares minerals to bricks and fluoride to mortar: you need both for mineral deposition.
- SDF is best for arresting cavitated lesions in high-risk children and older adults, though it stains black and is used off-label for caries in the UK.
- Prof says fluoride at dental concentrations is safe and effective, and he would still advise a fluoride toothpaste over hydroxyapatite alone.
- For an uncertain grey occlusal lesion, consider sealing it, or a tiny exploratory opening if risk is high.
- In dry mouth, use high-fluoride regimes, glass ionomers, and trays or dentures to carry remineralising agents.
- Stepwise excavation is largely outdated; selective caries removal with a good peripheral seal is now preferred.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. What are self-assembling peptides, and how do they work?
2. When should you use silver diamine fluoride?
3. Is hydroxyapatite toothpaste as good as fluoride?
4. How should you manage a grey occlusal lesion with no radiographic signs?
5. Should you fissure seal teeth while restoring?
6. How do you manage caries in patients with severe dry mouth?
7. Is stepwise excavation still the standard of care?
8. Why do principles matter more than protocols in caries management?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: modern caries management, part two
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: the Contemporary Caries Management Implementation Pack
3. What are peptides, and how do they work?
4. Why we can't wait for perfect evidence, and why mineralisation needs bricks and mortar
5. Peptides in practice, and why taking early disease seriously motivates patients
6. Where SDF fits: arresting cavitated lesions in high-risk patients
7. Hydroxyapatite toothpaste vs fluoride
8. Biofilm, diet, behaviour change, and combining fluoride with other minerals
9. The grey occlusal lesion: seal, survey or explore?
10. Should you fissure seal while you're restoring?
11. Managing severe dry mouth and radiation caries
12. Is stepwise excavation still taught? Selective caries removal and the new S3 guidelines
13. The cook and the chef: understanding principles, not recipes
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: MODERN CARIES MANAGEMENT, PART TWO
JAZ:
Welcome back, Protruserati, to part two of our episode on modern caries management: to drill or not to drill. In part one, we focused on communication and diagnostics: triangulating the data, working out which caries diagnosis technologies are worth it, and whether tools like AI caries detection are actually meaningful.
The big revelation of part one was to be proactive. Don't just monitor. We're going to do active surveillance, using things like proximal resin infiltration or peptides. And I left you on a bit of a cliffhanger last time, so we start by working out what peptides are and how they work.
Should we be using them, or is there not enough evidence yet? And what about hydroxyapatite toothpaste? Is it a poor man's fluoride, or a silver bullet for caries? Then we answer all your questions from the community, like whether there's still a place for stepwise excavation.
Or how to manage patients with severe dry mouth who are getting caries left, right and centre. So this part two is more about managing caries, with a focus on minimal intervention.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: THE CONTEMPORARY CARIES MANAGEMENT IMPLEMENTATION PACK
JAZ:
The Protrusive Dental Pearl is going to make implementation easier. It's all very well being a good dentist, listening to the Protrusive podcast and feeling motivated about going into clinic. But then you have a busy day, you forget what you were told, and it can be difficult to implement all the wonderful things you've learned.
If you don't implement it, you might as well not have learned it. That's why, for today's pearl, I'm giving you a nice pack. The team and I have made an implementation pack. It's something you can pretty much laminate, with all the key points from this episode and the last.
It includes the major communication points, for example from part one, when Prof said he asks his patients, "What matters to you?" I love that. It's a great way to find out your patient's goal. Plus everything on caries diagnosis and caries management that we covered last time and today, including the flow charts and evidence Prof referred to. We've made a lovely zipped folder you can download, print out, laminate and enjoy, all for free.
Our premium members are already used to this kind of treatment. We have so many premium infographics across our episodes, and the premium notes that accompany every episode are a great way to enhance your learning. But these two episodes were so foundational that we've put together this implementation pack from them.
The Contemporary Caries Management Implementation Pack is yours to download. If you're watching or listening on the Protrusive Guidance app, just scroll down. It's all there below the video and audio. If you're not on the app yet, take the hint. Otherwise, head over to protrusive.co.uk/mid.
MID is minimal intervention dentistry. So /mid, and you'll find the most wonderful collection of everything you need to know: deeper resources if you want to geek out, but also the executive summary and actions you can implement to solidify everything from part one and everything I'll share today in part two.
I'll remind you again in the outro, but for now, enjoy part two. We start with peptides and then move on to your community questions. Catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: WHAT ARE PEPTIDES, AND HOW DO THEY WORK?
JAZ:
So, Prof, we covered so much ground in part one, and then left everyone on a cliffhanger, because I wanted you to educate me about peptides. In that episode, I learned a few new things about what's working. Resin infiltration, for example, got the go-ahead, and there are so many things I'm going to change in my practice, even in how I communicate with patients, verbally and in writing.
There was so much validation in there, which is brilliant. But to be honest, I know very little about peptides. So I'd love to start with what peptides are and how they work. Then I'll ask you to move on to a conundrum that I think a lot of people have, though maybe it's just me. With things like peptides, silver diamine fluoride (SDF) and fluoride varnish, how do you decide which micro-invasive option is most appropriate? Does it come down to funding, and what the patient can afford, or are there other decision-making trees?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Absolutely. To answer that: there are decision-making trees. Caries consensus guidelines have been published for five or six years now, which give you exactly that. They map out a flowchart for how you might use some of these things. As we speak, I'm actually convening an international group of experts to look at initial caries lesion management and all the things we're talking about.
Hopefully, this time next year, we'll have some publications on that too. In the meantime, we've talked about sealants, and about resin infiltration, as you mentioned in part one. There are other technologies, and I repeat, I'm not here to plant my flag in anybody's camp.
I'm stepping back and looking at everything equally. Peptide technologies have been around a long time. They're not brand new. The research was done in the '90s and noughties by very respected materials and biochemical sciences researchers, a lot of them in Leeds. They used self-assembling peptides, and the argument is that these are attracted into the porosities of an early enamel lesion, an E1 or E2 lesion.
In the acidic environment of those porosities, the peptides form a network. They polymerise, if you like, to a degree. Think about how mineral forms in dentine: collagen is the scaffold that allows mineral to be deposited around it.
In a similar way, scientifically, that's what happens within the enamel lesion. You've got the peptide scaffold, and then mineral ions from saliva, toothpaste or whatever product the patient uses can get in, form the lattice and rebuild the lesion.
The theory, scientifically at least, is that the beauty of peptide technology is that the peptides infiltrate the porosities and then pull in the mineral. So in theory, you get a bottom-up infill of the lesion. That's in contrast to fluoride varnish, topical fluorides and topical remineralising agents, which are exactly that.
They're topical. They work on the surface. Most topical remineralising agents work on the top 20 or 30 microns.
JAZ:
Is that SDF as well?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
I'll come back to SDF. Those work topically. The theory, and I'm labouring this point, is that you might get deeper penetration with something like peptide technology.
People are grasping on to this, and vVARDIS's Curodont Repair is the product currently on the market that lets us use this technology. But I've been part of laboratory research at King's and at the University of Nottingham looking at different types of proteins to do the same thing. So there's clearly an interest there-
JAZ:
Very exciting.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
In this technology. So you've got one product at the moment, a bit like we've got one resin infiltration product. The difficulty is always proving that it works in your mouth or my mouth. You can prove it in a laboratory, in standardised experiments.
But we're looking at such subtle changes: moving an E2 lesion back to an E1 lesion. As we discussed in part one, even detecting those lesions is hard enough, let alone detecting changes. And we live in a very sceptical world, where people want absolute, definitive proof before they change their practice. All right?
CHAPTER 4: WHY WE CAN'T WAIT FOR PERFECT EVIDENCE, AND WHY MINERALISATION NEEDS BRICKS AND MORTAR
JAZ:
Which is good. We should be like that, right?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Well, you say that. We didn't have that proof for amalgam. We didn't have it for resin composite, or bonding agents. We didn't have it for anything, but we still use them.
JAZ:
Ah, that's very true.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
We've never had that proof for anything we do in dentistry, but we still use things.
JAZ:
Lithium disilicate as well. When it came out, it was a brilliant find, but it was a bit of a gamble at the time.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
That's the point. Logically, with any new technology, product, material or invention, if we wait for absolute, categorical proof that it does something so much better than what we've got, we'll never get advancement.
We'd still be using amalgam. So even though I'm a researcher, as I've gone greyer I've become more pragmatic. And I repeat: I am not saying that Curodont Repair is amazing, or that DMG's Icon is amazing, or that any particular product is amazing.
That's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that the technology is out there and it has a body of scientific evidence. Whichever camp you're in, you can argue it's a positive or a negative. But it's there. Ultimately, it goes back to what I said earlier about detection technologies.
It's up to the clinician to learn about the product and work out when to use it. Products obviously have criteria for when they should be used. You mentioned fluoride varnish, silver diamine fluoride, and then the micro-invasive options like resin and peptides.
And coming back to peptide technology, don't forget you still need minerals. Peptides on their own won't do anything. They'll infiltrate, but they won't "heal" anything, in inverted commas, without mineral deposition. So you need minerals.
That mineral comes from saliva, toothpaste, mouthwash or whatever extrinsic source. When I teach mineral deposition and fluoride in a very simple way, I say: imagine a builder building a brick wall.
What do they have? Bricks and mortar. They build a wall. First of all, does a builder stack the bricks vertically, or interlace them? They interlace them. Why? Because you get more structural integrity. That's exactly what happens with mineral crystals.
They interlace. And how do the bricks stay together? With mortar. That's your fluoride. So fluoride doesn't cause mineralisation. It assists it. Fluoride can get into mineral crystals and affect the crystals, the bricks themselves. But if you want mineral deposition, you always need a bit of both.
You need minerals and you need fluoride. That's the best combination. For example, my understanding, and I'm happy to be corrected, is that the Curodont product in the US actually has fluoride mixed in with the peptides. And there are studies taking the Curodont peptide product and adding minerals to it, and you start to see changes.
But I repeat: showing those subtle changes definitively, to a statistically significant level, in real life, is borderline impossible. That doesn't mean the technology doesn't work. Those are two separate things.
CHAPTER 5: PEPTIDES IN PRACTICE, AND WHY TAKING EARLY DISEASE SERIOUSLY MOTIVATES PATIENTS
JAZ:
Is it just like a varnish you apply?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Essentially, yes. There are two different varnishes, with little protocol steps. But the beauty of Curodont, for example, is that a dentist doesn't have to apply it. A dental hygienist, a dental therapist or an extended-duties dental nurse can do it. So it changes the equity of access, because, in theory, more people could get it more easily.
There are obviously business aspects to this as well. And one of my big things is moving away from "watch and wait" to "detect and manage", which you touched on in part one. It comes back to communication with the patient, and the patient's motivation.
If patients see the profession taking their early disease seriously and starting to do something about it, the hope is that, psychologically, they also start to realise it's actually really quite important. The dentist isn't just fobbing them off with a toothbrush and toothpaste, which they use every day anyway, and which makes diddly squat difference.
They're doing something different. They're using technology and these materials, and the team is rallying round and making a big deal of this. "Maybe I should be making a big deal of it too." People sometimes forget that behavioural psychology aspect when they look at a product, protocol or treatment in isolation. Always look at the bigger picture.
CHAPTER 6: WHERE SDF FITS: ARRESTING CAVITATED LESIONS IN HIGH-RISK PATIENTS
JAZ:
So I now understand peptides and how they work. My favourite part was how we took a leap of faith when we moved from amalgam to composite. It really sets the stance and future direction for these novel treatments.
That was pragmatic of you. I was half expecting you to say, as a typical professor, "No, we need evidence before we start using it." Instead, you were very pragmatic, and linked it back to other materials and what we've learned from them. The next thing I want to understand is SDF. It's been around for a long time as well.
I see a lot more colleagues using it, though I haven't yet. You said flow charts already exist, and I'll make them available to everyone. But for a given patient, how do you decide? Let's touch on how SDF works. We already know fluoride, and you've explained peptides beautifully.
But then there are all these micro-invasive methods, and you also throw in resin infiltration. How does one decide what's most appropriate for the patient?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
You're absolutely right, SDF was the next thing we were going to talk about. Silver diamine fluoride has been around for a long, long time. First of all, it isn't indicated for early white spot lesions, so it actually becomes easier.
If you really want to break this down: for very early enamel lesions, E1 and possibly into E2, the patient uses topical remineralising agents, fluoride, oral hygiene, biofilm control and diet control.
That's your standard care, your primary prevention. If the lesion is spreading further into the enamel, deep E1 into E2, and you're concerned it's progressing, then resin infiltration and peptide infiltration technologies can come in very elegantly.
If it's starting to spread into early dentine, D1, perhaps with some microcavitation, then you're really looking at therapeutic sealants and possibly sealant restorations. SDF is actually better for something else. First of all, in the UK it's licensed for dentine sensitivity, not caries management.
So we're using SDF off-label to manage caries, though people often do. A lot of the studies were done in the Far East, on children with multiple cavitated carious lesions, where SDF was used for stabilisation and arrest. So you've got multiple cavitated lesions,
in a complex patient with a complex care pathway, maybe medical needs and other problems going on, and you've got to manage that patient with a staged care plan. Part of the first stage will be stabilisation, but at that stage you don't necessarily want to be picking up drills and cutting lots of holes.
That might be appropriate for some patients, but for others you think, "Do you know what? We've got to get in there and try to stop this chemically, and give ourselves a bit of breathing space."
JAZ:
And sometimes patients are medically compromised or in care homes, access is difficult, and you need to do something.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Absolutely. Children, older adults, that type of patient. There's going to be more research on SDF in older adults. There's a body of evidence in children with multiple lesions who are high-risk, highly susceptible patients, showing that painting SDF onto those lesions can and does arrest them very effectively.
It's not a cure. You still need diet control, brushing, the right toothpaste and everything else, but it gives you breathing space, and it can at least arrest the process. As you and your listeners will know, the downside of conventional SDF is that it causes very dark, black staining.
On front teeth, that could clearly demotivate patients. On posterior teeth, perhaps less so, because you don't see it as much. There are now techniques, especially in children, where you apply SDF first, and then, once the lesion has arrested, overlay the cavity with glass ionomer.
So you get a sort of layered restoration. Obviously, be aware that some of the dark stain may show through the GIC or around the margins. You've got to be careful. Note things down very carefully, and take intraoral photos as part of your notes.
I think that's important now too. There's more and more evidence, more case series and so on, showing this can work very, very effectively. If you want me to quote a full randomised controlled trial, you won't get one.
They're not feasible to run anymore. So it goes back to what I said earlier about wanting evidence, guidelines and protocols. I've said this many times in public: I think we're reaching a critical point in all of healthcare where we actually have a lot of evidence.
Whether we choose to use it is another matter. But we have evidence, and nobody is going to fund clinical trials to prove one product over another. They literally cost millions of pounds, take an inordinate amount of time, and the benefit of running the trial would be limited at best.
So we have evidence, and we need to start building these products into our practices. And actually, the best evidence comes from primary care practitioners: people doing the day job at the coalface, writing down what they use and what they see, and doing active surveillance at six, 12 and 18 months and so on. That's the most powerful data.
JAZ:
So it sounds like a thumbs up for SDF in the cohort of patients where it's applicable. But it comes in at a later stage, as you've clarified. Fluoride varnish is the earlier stage, and resin infiltration and peptides sit somewhere in the middle.
That's all very clear now, and thank you very much for that.
CHAPTER 7: HYDROXYAPATITE TOOTHPASTE VS FLUORIDE
JAZ:
I've realised that when I first invited you on, I was very ambitious, 'cause I wanted to talk about early caries and deep caries. Sometimes it's worth going one inch wide and one mile deep.
So let's really focus on micro-invasiveness, 'cause I think there's so much value here, and we'll invite you back one day to talk about deep caries. One of the next things I'd really like to ask you about is the rise of hydroxyapatite toothpastes.
From what I've seen and read, I believe it's more than marketing hype. There seem to be very beneficial qualities, and robust evidence on its action and how it could be therapeutic for high-caries-risk groups.
But how does hydroxyapatite compare with fluoride, both for the general public and for patients who, rightly or wrongly, are anti-fluoride? For them, it's, "Okay, please use hydroxyapatite. I feel confident that you're using a toothpaste with something in it, rather than a natural toothpaste with nothing in it."
At least it's got hydroxyapatite, which gives me some confidence. But is that false confidence, or is it justified? I'd love to hear your view.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Again, the problem with this debate is that I'll offend somebody whatever I say, because there are camps. So I'll try to be as objective-
JAZ:
Go for it. We don't mind. Offend who you want.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
No, I don't want to, of course, but-
JAZ:
I know you don't, but we need to get to the science.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Absolutely. The honest truth is, and I don't just think it, I know, we know in the profession and in healthcare, that fluoride, the way it's used in oral and dental care, at the amounts and concentrations it's used at, is not toxic.
It's not a neurotoxin. It is perfectly safe, and it works perfectly well. We've got 50 years of evidence from studies done from the 1970s onwards. Those studies showing the efficacy of fluoride, in places like the Pacific islands where they fed people sugar and so on, would never get ethical approval today.
They were done in a different era, but they were done, and they're pretty unequivocal. Boom, it works. Without trying to get too political, and being careful about who's listening, we now have a culture where people don't read evidence.
They look at the headline, interpret the headline, and don't actually read the data. There's a big push in the United States to take fluoride out of drinking water. I stand to be corrected, but I think 10 states have now actively taken fluoride out of the water.
You may or may not be aware that the EU is looking at a body of evidence submitted by some scientists claiming fluoride is a neurotoxin. That has been hugely refuted by lots of reputable associations and scientists. But if the EU Parliament believes it, you might find that in the next year or two fluoride is taken out of toothpaste and water, or at best carries a government health warning label.
And I greatly fear that happening, because the benefit of fluoride is clear. Absolutely clear. What has happened more recently is that one or two clinical trials presented over the last two or three years have suggested that the benefit of fluoride is tapering off.
It's not an exponential, ever-increasing improvement in health. We've reached a point where it's plateauing. That doesn't mean fluoride doesn't work. It just means it's reached saturation in what it can do, and that's a big, big difference.
It doesn't mean, "Oh well, it doesn't work, so let's stop using it," because then disease would come back terribly. However, there are people who are anti-fluoride, and, without making any judgement or casting any aspersions, that's the situation. And there will always be competitors producing products.
One is hydroxyapatite-containing toothpastes. Others are NovaMin-containing toothpastes, bioactive glasses and so on. These alternatives have been around a long time, and I'd agree with you that hydroxyapatite toothpastes will be better for your teeth than charcoal and all the other fad toothpastes that influencers talk about on social media.
There is some science and chemistry behind them. But as I hinted earlier with mineralisation as building a wall, and I know that's a very simplistic way of looking at it, but keep it simple is my mantra:
To build a brick wall, you need bricks and mortar. The bricks are your mineral ions, your hydroxyapatite and so on. The mortar is the fluoride. If you only have the bricks... unless you're an Inca building cities 7,000 feet up a mountain, fitting together stones weighing several tons so accurately you couldn't get a piece of paper between them, so you didn't need mortar.
That's not quite how teeth and mineralisation work. So, in my personal opinion, and I know it's not everybody's, I'd still be loath to drop fluoride. You'd want to use a toothpaste containing fluoride at a certain concentration. Having an extra mineral source is a good thing.
That's not a bad thing. But since you're pinning me down on this one, I'd still advocate using fluoride in some form. We've just been doing some work with mouthwash companies on the advice given to patients and the profession about using fluoride-containing mouthwashes, and antimicrobial mouthwashes to manage perio.
CHAPTER 8: BIOFILM, DIET, BEHAVIOUR CHANGE, AND COMBINING FLUORIDE WITH OTHER MINERALS
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Because the other big thing to think about is this. We've been talking about caries today, quite rightly, 'cause you've got me on, but caries is a biofilm-mediated disease, as is periodontal disease. And in early-stage management, ultimately, it's the biofilm we're trying to manage.
Yes, there may be early lesions, and we want to infiltrate them, repair them and get mineral deposition, 100%. But the key take-home message is biofilm disruption and modulation. If a patient, you, me, anybody, can disrupt or modulate the biofilm in their mouth, they don't have to worry.
JAZ:
That ties in with what James Goolnik says in Kick Sugar: technically, we don't need any of these varnishes. We don't need fluoride, in the same way we don't need restorations, if you have a well-controlled diet and literally kick sugar out, and you're very meticulous with your biofilm. All these diseases are preventable.
We sometimes forget that diet is the big problem we need to be tackling, rather than just managing the consequences.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Absolutely, I couldn't agree more. But we live in a pragmatic world where human beings have a naughty gene. That's what I've coined it: a naughty gene. People will keep having sugar and doing these things. I'm not disagreeing with the sentiment, but practically, there are 8.2 billion people on the planet.
JAZ:
And policymakers bear this in mind. I was taught by Prof Robinson that we think giving someone knowledge will change their behaviour and lead to better health outcomes. But knowledge doesn't change behaviour. We all know we shouldn't smoke and that we should exercise more, but we still don't, right?
So it has to happen at policy level, which is why there's fluoride in toothpaste and in water. So you've said that if one pathway was a hydroxyapatite toothpaste and the other a fluoride toothpaste, you'd choose the fluoride one.
It's got more history and more data. But here's a curveball. Hydroxyapatite has lots of fans. Is there any suggestion that combining them helps? For example, toothpaste A contains 1,500 parts per million fluoride, and toothpaste B has some ratio of hydroxyapatite and fluoride.
It's going to be much more expensive. But could it potentially help with that plateau and nudge patients towards staying caries-free? I don't know if we have that kind of data.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
We haven't, and we never will. That goes back to what I said: to do that sort of trial... I like the way you're thinking, because that's how we in the profession should think: understand the science and then start to see. We have combinations. The difficulty is that we then want the hardcore evidence to prove exactly what you've just said, and that's not feasible.
JAZ:
You can never control all the variables: diet, saliva, chewing time, everything.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
And you'd need tens of thousands of patients, over several years, to show any difference. So does that mean mixing hydroxyapatite with fluoride is a terrible thing? No.
It means you pick the right patients. We may not have a toothpaste containing both fluoride and hydroxyapatite that's financially viable for the patient. But you might use a fluoride toothpaste alongside a hydroxyapatite paste, or another mineralising paste, in combination.
Those products exist. There are the GC products with casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate, which can be combined with fluoride as well, at lower levels. Not toothpaste levels, but lower levels, in combination.
People have done some basic clinical trials, and in this area they're usually non-inferiority trials. That means you compare product A with product B. Product A might be the gold standard, the positive control, what we've always done.
Product B is the new innovation, and they try to show that product B is no worse than product A. That's potentially doable in a smaller trial. But a full randomised controlled trial proving product B is better than product A just isn't going to happen nowadays.
And I don't blame companies, 'cause it would bankrupt them.
JAZ:
So hydroxyapatite is better than charcoal and all the other fads for patients who are averse to fluoride, whatever their beliefs. But what about a dentist listening who's okay with fluoride, and is wondering, "Should we switch, at home, for my children or myself?" There's no good reason to change a winning formula.
CHAPTER 9: THE GREY OCCLUSAL LESION: SEAL, SURVEY OR EXPLORE?
JAZ:
The next two questions are clinical scenarios. The first is from Yazan in the group. It's a common scenario: a grey occlusal lesion. Think of an upper right first molar that just looks grey. You can't see anything on the radiograph, and there's often a wide area of greyish-black tint shining through.
You can't really see anything radiographically, or feel anything tactile like microcavitation. How do you tell whether it's active or arrested? And how might that guide you towards a micro-invasive approach rather than just watching and monitoring?
Is it right to actively survey it, or should we seal it at that point, or use a different modality?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
These clinical scenarios are always interesting. What you'd need to do is look at the patient's caries risk and susceptibility, absolutely, and examine the rest of the mouth.
If the patient's susceptibility at that point was stable or low, moderate to low, and you're not sure there's a lesion, and you've taken a radiograph and can't see an obvious radiolucency, then you'd consider fissure sealing it, so that any microcavitation within the fissure pattern that you can't detect is sealed.
Then do your primary prevention properly, all the things we've discussed, and sort out the patient's review and recall pattern. Maybe get them back in three or four months to reassess, check signs and symptoms, and do your active surveillance, as you suggested.
If, on the other hand, the caries risk assessment is high, you obviously start doing things to bring it down through behaviour change. And if there are multiple lesions like that in the mouth, not just one, it gets more interesting, because then you're thinking, "What do I do here?
"I don't really know." That's when you might consider taking the pit on that upper premolar and, with air abrasion or a tiny bur dropped into the pit, just open it up. Not cut a big cavity. Literally just open up the pit to give yourself an idea, like a test hole.
JAZ:
Like an exploration, an investigation.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Yeah, but really, really small. Really small. If you go in, get down to the DEJ and find it's all as clean as a whistle, fine. Obviously you stop, seal it up with a bit of flowable composite, and fissure seal the rest. So essentially you've done a sealant restoration, to use the old-fashioned term.
JAZ:
Or a PRR.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
You took the words out of my mouth. But that's old school. We don't use that term anymore. It's a sealant restoration. Now let's twist the scenario slightly: you've got multiple lesions in the mouth. You can see early proximal lesions on radiographs, but this one's just a shadow.
Clinically, you're thinking, "Do you know what? This might be the most extensive one in this mouth." Always go into what you clinically feel is the most extensive lesion. It goes back to triangulation: triangulate the signs and symptoms with your clinical investigation and examination, and think, "Actually, I think this premolar is the worst lesion."
That's the one where I'd do a tiny exploration in one pit. If you find a great big hole and lots of soft caries, boom, you get on with your restoration. But that also tells you the other lesions may have progressed further than they appear radiographically.
If you go in and there's nothing there, you know the others can probably be managed non-operatively or micro-invasively, and you don't need to drop a bur in. I get asked about scenarios all the time, and they're very, very specific.
With patients, there will always be other clues, and the skill is looking for them. And if you can't find other clues, then at the end of the day, if you're in doubt, just do a tiny exploration. If you have an air abrasion unit, you can literally cut the smallest hole in the pit.
Or take a micro bur, or a really small bur, and just drop it in. Yes, I know it's invasive, and here's me not wanting to be invasive, but you're trying to look after the patient. Dare I say it, it's a bit like a surgeon doing a biopsy. Think of it that way.
JAZ:
That makes total sense.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
And if you want to "sell" it, which I don't like as a phrase, or rather explain it to your patient, say, "We're going to do a tiny little biopsy. If we find something, we'll open it up and treat it. If we don't, we'll just seal it up. Job done."
CHAPTER 10: SHOULD YOU FISSURE SEAL WHILE YOU'RE RESTORING?
JAZ:
Great. This reminds me of one of our members, Mohammed. Over the last three years, we've been very geeky in our community about our restorations and protocols, and there's one interesting thing about his protocol that I really like. Maybe you teach or advocate it, maybe you don't, feel free to say.
Whenever he does a restoration, say an MO on a first molar, a distal on a second molar, or any restoration on premolars and molars, while he's got everything isolated, he fissure seals all the remaining fissures as standard.
To me, that makes a lot of sense, because while you're there and it's isolated, the whole reason this patient needed a restoration is that their caries risk was high enough for them to need one. Is that something you teach or advocate?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
So you're talking about sealants on the other teeth, not the same tooth?
JAZ:
On the same tooth. But the next level up is: while you have the quadrant isolated to treat the first molar, should you also fissure seal the second and third molars while you're there?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Okay. Now, that's an interesting one.
JAZ:
Not that he does this. I'm just taking it a level up.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Understood. That's one to be a tiny bit wary of. On an individual basis, if you feel it's appropriate, maybe you can. I'm picking my words carefully here. I'm not advocating it as routine.
You don't just whack fissure sealants on every occlusal surface of every tooth because the patient is slightly higher risk. You need indications. The classic situation is a youngster with first molars erupting into a mouth that's a bit more cariogenic, where brushing isn't so good and the tooth is partly submerged as it erupts, so it isn't at the occlusal level.
You might consider sealing there, taking into account the patient's other issues and whether they, or their parents or caregivers, can clean their teeth. Sometimes there's an indication for preventive sealants, i.e. putting a fissure sealant on a healthy tooth that's erupting into a cariogenic mouth.
That's a preventive sealant. Everything else we've been talking about is a therapeutic sealant, which means there's some early disease. So it's a fine line, and you have to be a bit careful. From a population perspective, slapping fissure sealants everywhere clearly isn't the way to go.
On an individual level, if you felt there was genuinely uncontrolled caries susceptibility, if they were very clearly red on a red-amber-green traffic light system, very high risk, then that's a different situation, and you might. I have a very sore bottom, because I sit on the fence so much.
People get frustrated with me, because I don't always give the answer they want to hear.
JAZ:
But you've been clear, because every mouth is different, and you've given us guidelines to work with. And sealing the tooth you're restoring makes sense to me.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
No, that's different. Absolutely. If you're placing a restoration, the fissure pattern is deep, and the patient has already struggled to manage the biofilm, which is why they had the lesion in the first place, that seems logical. I wouldn't have a major issue with that.
JAZ:
But on sealing the other teeth preventively, you've answered that: it depends on the patient, and it's not routine practice to seal fissures preventively unless you've got the specific scenario you described.
So I think you've been very clear there and given good guidelines, which is brilliant.
CHAPTER 11: MANAGING SEVERE DRY MOUTH AND RADIATION CARIES
JAZ:
The next question is another tricky scenario, but rather than a specific tooth, it's about a whole mouth: the elderly patient with severe xerostomia, perhaps from radiotherapy.
You've seen them in good health, and then you watch it deteriorate, and it's tragic. That mouth can deteriorate so quickly, and cervical root caries can be so difficult to restore, and we want to do everything we can. Personally, I'll sometimes make them whitening-style trays and give them Tooth Mousse to use, and all these things.
But I don't know what the best agent is. Can you paint a picture of this particularly high-risk individual? What's the most we can do? What's the standard of care for someone at such high risk?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
I give lots of lectures on caring for older adults and patients with these sorts of problems, and I've had the privilege of looking after many of these patients over the years at Guy's Hospital.
Xerostomia patients, older patients, patients who've had radiotherapy: they're all very, very challenging, because, as you rightly say, you can literally watch the teeth deteriorate. What you can do before any treatment like radiotherapy, in the build-up to it, is get them onto high-fluoride regimes.
Use high-fluoride toothpastes, mouthwashes and so on. Try to get their oral hygiene as good as possible, and get patients tuned in to their risks and where they come from. That's stating the obvious, but it's your primary prevention.
You have to really reinforce it. Nevertheless, lesions can still come, and it's a problem. Honestly, once the lesions are there, they're very difficult to restore. Some modern glass ionomers, the glass hybrid cements, can be quite effective.
Resin composites and bonding can be too, but it gets harder and harder. You're shaking your head, and I agree with you. I think modern glass ionomers are probably the way to go. But what you hinted at, making little trays, a bit like bleaching trays with reservoirs, is good.
The other thing I've done in the past: a lot of older patients still have their partial dentures. Depending on where the major connectors are, I get them to put the mineralising agent, whichever one it is, or toothpaste, onto the fit surface of the denture when they put it back in.
That way, you're bathing the at-risk areas, the cervical margins, in good ions, mineral, fluoride and so on, rather than that bit of sugar and acid, because they no longer have the protection of saliva. So you use the denture as a carrier, or make a little tray.
I think that's very, very sensible. But the bottom line is, I wish there were an answer. Sadly, there isn't. As always, it's case by case.
JAZ:
But these are the patients we'll invite back every three months, with oral health education and fluoride varnish.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Correct.
JAZ:
With the trays, I've historically just used Tooth Mousse. But I don't know whether the money would be better spent on regular toothpaste. I don't know about its efficacy in that scenario.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
It comes back to the same argument: we don't know. We don't have trials to prove or disprove it. The logic is that products like Tooth Mousse, with CPP-ACP, the Recaldent formulas, should in theory bind better to the tooth surface and keep the ions a bit more concentrated there. But a lot of it is about what the patient can tolerate.
Patients with dry mouth often find different toothpastes very astringent. You want to take the sodium lauryl sulphate out for those patients. Something like Tooth Mousse can actually be quite palatable, and they quite like it.
They can rub it on with a finger, put it in a tray or under a denture, and that can sometimes give some patients relief. So it's something to work on with your team, trying a few products until you find one that not only works but that the patient can tolerate and will use.
We might have the best thing since sliced bread, but if the patient finds it astringent, painful or difficult to use, they won't use it. So it's always a balance.
JAZ:
Okay. Artificial saliva: it's obviously not as good as the real thing. But can it help? Does using artificial saliva reduce their caries risk, or doesn't it, because it's not real saliva?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Funnily enough, I work in a hospital looking after some of these patients, and in the good old days, many years ago, we had a product called Biotène, a form of artificial saliva that came as a spray or a liquid.
To be brutally honest, I'm not sure those products are even made anymore, or they're not very easy to get hold of. And now that people carry bottled water everywhere, it's about having that moisture in the mouth. It depends on why the patient has a dry mouth.
Sometimes pilocarpine or other medications can be given to try to stimulate salivary flow, if the salivary glands are functional, and of course there's chewing gum and so on. But you have to think about why the mouth is dry. If the salivary glands have been destroyed or damaged, no amount of stimulation is going to create saliva.
As for substituting it, it's not my absolute area of expertise, I'll put my hand up, but I'm not aware of particularly effective products that replace saliva in the classic sense.
JAZ:
I didn't think so.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
I'm happy to be corrected on that.
CHAPTER 12: IS STEPWISE EXCAVATION STILL TAUGHT? SELECTIVE CARIES REMOVAL AND THE NEW S3 GUIDELINES
JAZ:
The last question will hopefully be a segue into when we invite you back to talk about deeper caries. I was taught stepwise excavation at dental school. I don't really use it anymore, because I manage caries by removing as much as I can but leaving some soft caries, and we'll get into that whole debate next time.
But I no longer do the thing where you place some GIC and then cut it back some months later to place your composite on top. Is stepwise caries excavation still the standard of care, and is it still taught?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
I had the privilege of writing the last two editions of Pickard's, while it was still called Pickard's. The next edition, the 11th, isn't called Pickard's anymore, 'cause we changed publisher.
I've been writing that book for 15 to 20 years, and stepwise excavation used to be in there. I still have a paragraph on it, because some countries and some schools internationally still teach stepwise excavation.
If you're not totally sure what we're talking about: you have a large carious lesion, you go in and scoop out the soft stuff, you place a provisional restoration for a few months, then you go back and take that restoration out. You drill out the remaining caries, which has now arrested, and then place a filling.
That's classic stepwise excavation. The bottom line, and this is a teaser for next time, is that we now have such clever materials that seal so well that the idea of going back in to remove the provisional and re-prepare the cavity is basically defunct. We don't need to do it.
We have tons of evidence that selective caries removal works. You remove the soft, wet, infected tissue, leave the slightly more leathery affected tissue, make sure the peripheral seal is good, and then you can use your resin composites, glass ionomers and all the other variants of those materials.
I do still have a paragraph on it, as I said, even in the latest book, partly because people should be aware of how what we do has evolved, so there's a historical element to it. The information is widely available, and there are countries and situations where people might still consider it.
The S3 guidelines on deep caries management came out literally last week, and stepwise excavation is mentioned there too, because globally it's not totally dead in the water. But I don't teach it. It's now all about selective caries removal, and that's it.
JAZ:
Amazing. That's a great teaser for re-inviting you to talk about deeper caries. Talking of the guidelines, are they freely available? Can I attach them to this episode, or would I be infringing anything?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
No, you absolutely can. They're open access. I can send you the reference. Anybody can read them, and we'll be talking more and more about them over the next few months. They're very high level, and to me very obvious. But, like what we've talked about in parts one and two, they're statements that give clinicians a structure, a skeleton to hang their care on, and validation if they're already doing it.
And if anyone had doubts, they can see that this is the right thing to do. There's tons of evidence, and we had medico-legal experts look at the whole thing as well, so it's now very, very clear.
CHAPTER 13: THE COOK AND THE CHEF: UNDERSTANDING PRINCIPLES, NOT RECIPES
JAZ:
Excellent. Before I say goodbye and point everyone to where they can learn more from you: you lecture so much, and you sit through other people's lectures, and sometimes you might hear something and think, "Ooh, I don't quite agree with that." The more experience you get, the more often things don't reflect your practice.
Without naming anyone, is there a concept being taught, on social media or in person, that you think is really outdated when it comes to caries management, or just wrong?
Something you've seen in the last couple of years where you think, "You know what? It's worth telling all our members: we need to move away from this way of thinking"?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Honestly, if you'd asked me at the start, I'd probably have said what we've talked about in parts one and two: early detection and management. I listen to lots of people talk, and I've not really heard anybody say anything too outrageous in the last decade. People talk a lot about dental materials, and maybe we can touch on that next time.
Obviously, with the amalgam phase-out, that ship has sailed, and we don't really have to discuss it anymore, which I'm quite pleased about. But people sometimes hang all their hopes on certain materials.
What's interesting, when you do all these clinical trials, the background work, the guideline papers and consensus papers, reading a lot and talking to a lot of people, is that you learn very quickly that in caries management, if you look at the equation very simply, you've got the clinician at one end, the procedure and material in the middle, and the patient at the other end.
Without doubt, the two most important factors are the clinician and the patient. The patient needs to understand their job: biofilm control, diet control, using a toothbrush and so on. The clinician's job, as we've been discussing for the last couple of hours, is to understand what they're trying to achieve, and then how to achieve it.
And if they use things properly, follow the protocols properly, don't take shortcuts, and understand... So here's a thing to leave your listeners with, something I've said to all my students, and I may well have said it to you too: it's the difference between a cook and a chef.
My wife is a brilliant baker. She can give me a recipe, and I can go to the supermarket, buy the ingredients, and follow her instructions: "Right, step one, do this. Step two, do that. Step three, do that." I can follow instructions. But if I followed the recipe 10 times and made 10 batches of cakes, maybe one batch would be edible.
Because I don't understand why I'm mixing things when I'm mixing them, or why I'm adding things. That's the difference. The chef does understand, so they can change and modify the recipe. As a clinician, it's all about that understanding. My students often say to me now, "Oh, just show me how to do a composite.
"Show me how to do a glass ionomer. Show me how to do this." And I say, "Well, you could be taught like that. We could teach and lecture dentistry like that. But then we'd have to teach you 500 recipes," because every tooth, every mouth and every patient is different.
So what you do is learn the principles. Once you know why you're using these materials and how to use them, you put it together. And the irony is that if the clinician does that, it matters very little which procedure or material they use, as long as they execute it properly. That's a very intriguing point.
JAZ:
Excellent. I'm glad you ended on that one, and yes, I've heard it before. Thank you so much for a brilliant two-part series. I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned so much. There was so much validation, but also so many things I probably should have looked into more, and I'm glad you were here to help with the learning curve. I'm sure everyone's in the same boat.
Everyone's on a different journey, and you've definitely helped mine, so thank you so much. Is there anything you'd like us to check out, apart from the S3 guidelines? Any books? Anything we can help support you with?
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
I suppose it's the Elsevier textbook that came out in 2024, Clinical Guide to Advanced Minimum Intervention Restorative Dentistry. It's a mouthful, but it's essentially Pickard's 11th edition. It's what undergraduates and postgraduates are using, it follows the European cariology curriculum, and it's there for primary care practitioners.
So it's not just for dentists, but for dental nurses, hygienists and therapists too. It has all the information I've talked about, evidenced with clinical pictures and protocols, and everything lined up.
JAZ:
Amazing. I'll definitely link that. Thank you so much again, Prof. We'll bring you back to talk about deeper caries. This has been brilliant, and I'm really happy with the direction we went in. I appreciate it, so thank you so much.
PROF AVIJIT BANERJEE:
Cheers. Thanks, Jaz. Take care.
JAZ:
All right, I'll hit stop. Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening to part two all the way to the end. You must, must, must download the implementation pack. Remember, it's protrusive.co.uk/mid. And if you're already watching or listening on the app, just scroll down. It's all there for you to download. If you're a premium member, answer the quiz while you're there. It'll literally take you a minute, and our CPD queen will send you the certificate.
I hope you enjoyed that CE. What I love about delivering education through a podcast is that, for all us busy dentists, whether you're commuting, exercising, chopping onions or gardening, which are the four most common things you do while listening, it's a great way to rack up your education and get 1% better with each episode.
So I just wanted to take a moment to say thank you. Thank you for always coming back to us, and for sharing our podcast with your colleagues and helping us grow. We've now got a small but mighty community of the nicest and geekiest dentists in the world. Head over to protrusive.app, 'cause you're missing out if you're not on there.
If you identify as nice and geeky, we want to see you there. I want to thank Team Protrusive for setting up this two-part special. It's been a lot of work behind the scenes to get it across the line. And another hat tip to DMG for the offer on Icon Proximal for proximal caries.
You can get your first kit at a massive discount. It's one kit per dental professional, don't forget, and it's available at protrusive.co.uk/dmg. That wraps up this month, which was all about clinical clarity and decision-making. Next month is all about relationships that support your career.
That's your dental assistants, the wider dental team, and of course mentors. Don't miss another episode. Hit that subscribe button, whether you're watching on YouTube or listening on Spotify or Apple, or hopefully on the app, because you're a true Protruserati. I'll catch you all same time, same place next week. Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
What are self-assembling peptides, and how do they work?
ANSWER:
Prof explains that self-assembling peptides are drawn into the porosities of early enamel lesions, where they form a network, similar to the collagen scaffold in dentine. Minerals from saliva, toothpaste or other sources can then deposit on this scaffold, in theory rebuilding the lesion from the bottom up. He stresses that peptides still need a mineral source to work.
QUESTION:
When should you use silver diamine fluoride?
ANSWER:
Prof says SDF isn't for early white spot lesions. It's best for arresting cavitated lesions in high-risk patients, such as children with multiple lesions or older adults, as part of stabilisation in a staged care plan. In the UK it's licensed for dentine sensitivity, so caries use is off-label. It stains lesions black, but glass ionomer can be placed over arrested lesions.
QUESTION:
Is hydroxyapatite toothpaste as good as fluoride?
ANSWER:
Prof says fluoride at the concentrations used in dentistry is safe, effective and backed by decades of evidence. He believes hydroxyapatite toothpastes are better than fad options like charcoal, and an extra mineral source is helpful. But in his view, minerals need fluoride to work best, so he would still advise using a fluoride toothpaste.
QUESTION:
How should you manage a grey occlusal lesion with no radiographic signs?
ANSWER:
Prof says to assess the patient's caries risk. If it's low to moderate, consider fissure sealing the tooth, strengthen prevention, and review in three to four months. If risk is high or there are several similar lesions, consider a tiny exploratory opening of the pit with air abrasion or a small bur, then either restore or seal, like a biopsy.
QUESTION:
Should you fissure seal teeth while restoring?
ANSWER:
Prof thinks it's logical to seal the remaining deep fissures on the tooth you're restoring, as the patient has already shown they struggle with biofilm control. But he doesn't advocate routinely sealing other healthy teeth, except in specific cases, such as erupting first molars in a cariogenic mouth or patients at very high, uncontrolled risk.
QUESTION:
How do you manage caries in patients with severe dry mouth?
ANSWER:
Prof recommends starting high-fluoride toothpastes and mouthwashes early, ideally before radiotherapy, and optimising oral hygiene. Once lesions appear, they're hard to restore, and he finds modern glass ionomers most practical. He suggests trays, or the fit surface of a denture, to hold remineralising agents against at-risk areas, choosing products the patient finds tolerable.
QUESTION:
Is stepwise excavation still the standard of care?
ANSWER:
Prof says stepwise excavation is now largely outdated, though it's still taught in some countries. Modern materials seal well enough that there's no need to re-enter the cavity. Instead, selective caries removal is supported by strong evidence: remove the soft, infected tissue, leave the leathery affected tissue, ensure a good peripheral seal, and restore.
QUESTION:
Why do principles matter more than protocols in caries management?
ANSWER:
Prof compares following a protocol without understanding it to a cook following a recipe, versus a chef who understands why each step is done and can adapt. He believes the clinician and patient matter most in caries management. If clinicians understand the principles and execute them properly, the specific product or material matters relatively little.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Prof Avijit Banerjee is a researcher and educator in cariology and minimum intervention dentistry, who has carried out laboratory research at King's and the University of Nottingham and has looked after medically complex patients at Guy's Hospital. He co-wrote the last two editions of Pickard's, now published as the Clinical Guide to Advanced Minimum Intervention Restorative Dentistry, and is convening an international expert group on initial caries lesion management.