The top CPG podcast in the world, highlighting stories from founders, buyer spotlights, highly practical industry insights - all to give you a better chance at success.
Mark Surkin
Foreign. I was just at the Cin7 conference actually a couple of months ago, maybe two months ago, and they were presenting their forecasting tool and they said there's something like over a thousand different algorithms or mathematical models that people have used forecasting inventory. We can't do all of that. We can't put all that into a spreadsheet. But now we have these new software tools that are more and more able to take a thousand different models and put your data through them and start giving you suggestions about what to keep on hand. And that kind of stuff is making us better.
00:43
Daniel Scharff
Welcome to the Startup CPG podcast. On today's episode we tackle the age old question, how much inventory should you actually have? What are the inputs, processes, systems involved? And what are the best practices for emerging brands? We're so lucky to be joined today by Mark Serkin from Soom Foods, sharing all of his learnings. Today's episode is presented by our friends at Cin7. So many brains in our community are using their highly recommended inventory management system for just this purpose and you can take advantage of our special offer with them. It's 50% off the first three months. To get that, visit Cin7.com startupcpg that link is in the show notes. All right, here we go. Mark, welcome to the podcast.
01:25
Daniel Scharff
I'm very excited to have you here to tackle something that comes up in the slack all the time, which is really how much inventory should you actually have? So many companies I think struggle with this, especially as they start scaling into additional SKUs. And so thank you so much for coming on today to talk about it from the brand perspective. Could you kick us off with a quick intro, please?
01:48
Mark Surkin
Yeah, sure. Thank you for having me excited to answer the impossible question. The answer is enough, so just stop there. Podcast over. I guess.
01:55
Daniel Scharff
I'm done.
01:55
Mark Surkin
Anyway. So my name is Mark Serkin. I'm the VP of Ops for Soom Foods. I've been with the company for about four years, maybe a little over that now. And Soom has been around for over 13 years now. Family business started by three sisters. And one of those sisters is our CEO Amy.
02:12
Daniel Scharff
Okay, Mark, and can you give everybody an idea of all of the SKUs that you have? How many, what kinds? Are they separated by channel?
02:19
Mark Surkin
Absolutely. Yeah. So I think right now we've got maybe 15 to 20 total SKUs because it's Tahini and that's our primary SKU. We do that in a lot of different formats, a couple of different sizes for food service that are larger formats and then smaller jar Sizes and organic formats more for retail. We do have a couple of flavors as well to add some diversity to it. Two chocolate SKUs and a couple of flavored in squeeze bottles as well.
02:46
Daniel Scharff
Okay, so about 15 SKUs and I think I read you're in over 8,000 retail doors including Walmart, Target, Whole Foods, Public, Wegmans, a lot of the big guys. Does that sound about right?
02:56
Mark Surkin
You got it. That's exactly right. We're hoping to get to that 10,000 number.
03:00
Daniel Scharff
All right, so there's good meat on the bone here for figuring out inventory numbers. The stakes are high because these are big time retailers where there are penalties and very high expectations about staying in stock and what it means if you have to short somebody. And that math across 15 SKUs, it does start to get complex. So I'm pretty excited to dig into this here. So. So just to get started, I wonder if you could just talk about what your supply chain actually looks like. So what it is like from you actually ordering ingredients, materials all the way through to having sellable product.
03:35
Mark Surkin
Sure, yeah. So I'll give a little bit of context. When I started with the company were all of our product is made at co manufacturers overseas and when I started with the company were using one co manufacturer. We were doing a little less than probably about less than a million pounds a year. This year I think we'll get close to £3 million and we've got three manufacturers. So the supply chain has gotten more complex over the years that I've been here and it is a long supply chain. We're lucky in that we have a two year shelf life. We don't have to do cold chain but when we order it can take anywhere from two to six months to get product landed here in the USA at one of our warehouses where we distribute from. So that certainly makes things complex.
04:18
Mark Surkin
We've got to do a lot of juggling between our different manufacturers that we order from and between the different warehouses that we send product to for fulfillment through all those many retailers that you listed.
04:31
Daniel Scharff
And why is there such a big range? 2 To 6 months. Obviously that's a big difference. Is that depending on the SKU or the size or what's in stock or if they have line time for you?
04:40
Mark Surkin
Yeah, that's a good question. So it depends on SKU and manufacturer. The bigger SKUs are easier to fill. Like if we're doing, we do giant drums at tahini, it's like £500 in a drum. You put four on a pallet, it's Very easy for the factory to fill that, not a lot of extra work to it. They fill a drum, they nail it, bang it closed and put it on a pallet. That same amount in jars, for example, 16 ounce jars, you've got to do 500 jars that all have to go into cartons, get palletized, get wrapped up, get QC checked. It takes longer. So that's one of the factors that go into it. We can get our bulk SKUs faster than we can get our retail SKUs.
05:20
Daniel Scharff
And just because you mentioned both food service channel and retail, obviously the pack sizes are really different. You mentioned those huge drums that you have. Are there any other differences in how you think about your supply chain for those two channels and the kind of production time and route to market, all the stuff you need to just be really prepared for?
05:39
Mark Surkin
There are, I think there's certainly nuances to it. One of the things that we always try to do is keep consistent for customers within the channels as well. So when we're selling to manufacturers, for example, the manufacturer has a very specific formula for their product that can be very easily impacted for any minute changes. Whereas one of the things that we talk about frequently that we track actually is the viscosity of our tahini. That's how thin or thick the product is. It's an agricultural product, it comes from a single ingredient, sesame seeds. Right. And it's going to change over time and we can work with our factories to control that, but there is some variability in that. So we have to be much tighter on details like viscosity.
06:25
Mark Surkin
When we're working with a manufacturer that's got a hummus recipe that they've just got to produce over and over again. Whereas if it's going on a retail shelf, all of us in our kitchens, we're not thinking about viscosity, we're just following a recipe for hummus or cookies or whatever it is, and it's not really going to be as impacted as it would be for a large manufacturer.
06:45
Daniel Scharff
All right, very interesting. Okay, so let's cut right to the chase. The big question today, how much inventory should you be sitting on across all of these SKUs? Just tell me about how you think about it first overall, and then we can dive into some of the specific inputs.
06:59
Mark Surkin
Yeah, sure. So we work with Cin7, that's our IMS system. And actually the way they categorize your products in their forecasting tool is a nice way to think about this. I think they've got winners, chasers and losers. You don't necessarily Want to call any of your products losers, but it is helpful to think about keeping your inventory in stock in terms of those categories because you're never going to be perfect, right? You're always trying to maximize your inventory without stock outs and without having too much money sit on the books.
07:31
Mark Surkin
And when your supply chain is long like ours, it can be much more difficult to manage that because you can find yourself becoming reactive to things that happen in a moment when you can make a decision that can impact you in three months, but you can't really do anything to control what it's like in the moment. So going back to your question, when we think about how much to keep on hand, when we think about our winners, our fast moving products, the SKUs that keep us going, it's a very easy formula, right? We know our lead times, we know pretty much our velocity, we know our expected growth, we know how much we have to keep on hand before our next batch of product comes in. So that's like some people call it safety stock, some people call it a par level.
08:11
Mark Surkin
Whatever you want to call that. It's pretty easy math where I guess the art to this or the magic to it comes into play is what about the chaser products? And what about losers that maybe you don't really want to call losers because they're new product launches or they're products that you're really trying to grow through marketing? How do you figure that out? That's where there's a lot more art to it, right? I was just at the Cin7 conference actually a couple of months ago, maybe two months ago, and they were presenting their forecasting tool and they said there's something like over a thousand different algorithms or mathematical models that people have used forecasting inventory. We can't do all of that. We can't put all that into a spreadsheet.
08:53
Mark Surkin
But now we have these new software tools that are more and more able to take a thousand different models and put your data through them and start giving you suggestions about what to keep on hand. And that kind of stuff is making us better.
09:06
Daniel Scharff
And fundamentally, what do you think theory is then around stock levels you would keep for those categories, you got your winners, you've got your chasers and your losers. Does that mean like, you know, at its base level, the losers, I'm just not going to worry about stocking out as much because it's not as high risk if they go out of stock. But I mean, like you said, that might be a new SKU and you're going to try to grow it. And if you go out of stock on a new SKU that you're trying to grow, you may not get those growth opportunities with a particular retailer. So is there an overall theory about stock levels for those three different archetypes?
09:39
Mark Surkin
Yeah, totally. The overall theory is sales ops meetings. We just work with our team like we have every week, unless people are on vacation or whatever it is. We have a sales ops meeting, inventory forecasting meeting. We go through each sku, we look at our forecast, sales team talks about anything that they've got coming up that we may not know about and we look at our gaps and figure out what to do about each one. So to your point, one of the losers we may not care about, we may just say we're going to let that go out of stock. That probably a good problem. If it goes out of stock because it's selling more than we expect it to and we'll order more when it happens.
10:16
Mark Surkin
And another one we might say, let's be prepared, we'll accept a risk of an overstock because we think this one might grow. And OPS never has really enough context on that. So we have to be talking to our sales team all the time about what's going on there. And there's no AI algorithm that can fix for that.
10:32
Daniel Scharff
It's great to hear. You're giving me flashbacks of my big CPG days. Also I used to work for Mars Chocolate and then they have this very exhaustive, never ending process called S and O P Sales and Operations plus and it runs on a monthly cycle. And it's like week one, the sales team does this, week two, the ops team does this. And it obviously culminates in that meeting. It is this same cycle you're talking about. It's iterative, getting feedback, always checking. And those big companies, they really very rarely are going to have stock out. They are an OPS machine. So it sounds like you have maybe a closer touch process since it's happening on a weekly basis, probably a more consistent format.
11:12
Daniel Scharff
And so what I'm hearing from you is you have all the inputs that salespeople are entering in a way where they're getting into this system. So whether you're able to use a system like Cin7 that can integrate all of these inputs, or people are entering it into Excel or whatever they're doing. The fundamental part is the sales team is doing some kind of a projection about things that are going to change. Like there maybe is like a baseline understanding of how many doors you're in and the velocity of the product and how those things change over time. And they're going to be also adding information about when there's a promotion happening or a store expansion or a new launch. And all of that is coming into your overall inputs.
11:51
Daniel Scharff
But it doesn't stop there because you still need to actually weekly monitor these things with the team. So checking in, maybe it's partly just looking at the levels with everybody and making sure that everybody really feels good about the forecast that they made. Or maybe seeing if there are any changes that you guys didn't understand or like, since they are all actually putting those inputs ahead of time, what would be the things that would change in a meeting like that? Like something unforeseen or that you really need to talk through?
12:18
Mark Surkin
Yeah, so good question. We actually, we have two types of this meeting. We have our weekly meetings, which is just kind of let's go through the numbers and make sure we don't have any upcoming gaps that we'd have to think about. Or like anything where we've got a big overstock that weren't expecting. And then we do a monthly meeting where we're looking at our actuals from the prior month and we're talking about the forecast. What promotions need to be added or possibly removed because they didn't come through, what velocity dropped unexpectedly. And maybe a sales team, a member of the sales team has to go check with that customer to see what happened. Maybe there's something downstream that we didn't find out about.
12:55
Mark Surkin
So there's that monthly meeting sets the stage for the sales team to be able to keep their forecasts up to date in the system. And the weekly meeting allows us to assess and respond to issues that might come up.
13:08
Daniel Scharff
So one natural tension in this world, this industry of ours, is between ops and salespeople. I think just because it's the nature of our roles and what we're incented on, like salespeople, they do not want to miss an opportunity. They don't want their sales numbers going down because there's a stock out. Ops people do not want to be sitting on lots of extra inventory because they want to be efficient. What do you find that dynamic is actually like in those meetings? Do you feel like it's just truly collaborative or do you feel like the salespeople are getting nervous and they're pushing and you're pushing back on them to try to arrive at the truth? How do you navigate that tension?
13:45
Mark Surkin
Yeah, that's a great point. So you use the word tension. I like to Use the word balance because I like to try to think about it more positively. But there's certainly tension sometimes. And it's funny that you mentioned, like, OPS is trying to minimize overstocks and sales is trying to make sure they have enough inventory. Sometimes our dynamic is the opposite. Like in ops, we are happier with as much inventory as we can get away with because we don't want to have to worry about it. And this is also a factor of us being a small team. Often our sales team is also thinking about the money that's on the books and thinking about the other factors involved inventory that are not just about the sales. And they're saying, you've got to reduce your ordering.
14:27
Mark Surkin
Or they might be saying, like, let's be tighter on this than we expect. We've got a saying that we say way too often, which is basically, let's try this, but it's going to be tight. I don't have the T shirt with me. We have some soon T shirts that say it's going to be tight and it's one of our pallets running across the ocean. But to answer your question about the tension, I think the tension is good because you don't want everybody agreeing on everything all the time. And as were talking about before, there's art and science to this.
14:56
Mark Surkin
And if you just order based on data all the time, without that nuance from the sales team, without the OPS team saying, oh, but let's think about whatever globally is going on in our shipping lanes right now, that may slow things down or may speed things up because some congestion is resolving at ports. All of that nuance is really helpful for everybody to bring to the table. And what can start as stress generally just becomes like collaboration to get to a point of agreement to place some orders.
15:27
Daniel Scharff
So I don't feel like the answer to this overall question of how much inventory you should actually have is a specifics number. It's not like 90 days of inventory or, you know, exactly. It sounds like kind of what you said at the beginning of the podcast is it's really about having enough and having this kind of a system and having all your inputs in there, but also having a feedback loop where you're then just monitoring and looking at the launches and looking at the inventory and trying to manage it in a place where you have enough inventory that you're comfortable as much as you feel like you can have, but also being comfortable in some scenarios where it might be tight and just being okay with that for certain SKUs or situations is that a fair way to sum it up so far?
16:10
Mark Surkin
Yeah, I think that's a fair way to look at it. I think I would just add to that. Like, it's about having enough, and it's about understanding the impact when you don't have enough or when you have too much. Because sometimes the impact isn't that important and you can stomach it, and other times it's really a problem. So, like, really just understanding the priority of the problems that you have with your inventory. Inventory is really important, too.
16:34
Daniel Scharff
So let's talk about that a little bit, because in. When I was in business school, in our ops class, we learned about the cost of overage and the cost of underage and the cost of overage. Meaning, like, okay, you have too much inventory. That one is kind of a more straightforward calculation you can do of the cost of the capital that you have with the inventory that's sitting in your warehouse. And maybe you have to, like, dispose of some of it or get it through an alternative channel, something like that. The cost of underage, that's a little bit more difficult when you actually have a stock out, because it can be qualitative in some ways. Not just the actual lost sale, but also there are things that can happen with a relationship. So how have you navigated some of those situations?
17:13
Daniel Scharff
Because I've definitely been in that situation where, okay, we're out on a skew and I know we're not going to have it in time for this order from a retailer, and we're going to have to do the dance for 45 days, letting them know, like, I think it's on the way. No, it's coming. Yeah, it's definitely coming. What is that underage impact been like for you in some scenarios? How have you navigated it?
17:32
Mark Surkin
Yeah, I like the way you described that. Overstocked, definitely much easier to handle than stock outs because, like, it sucks to have too much money on the books, but you just deal with it. Stock outs, like you said, they compound. Right. So you really want to avoid them as much as possible because you're not just losing that sale. It pushes all of the future sales forward, further into the future. Right. So one thing that we learned this year, that I'll give a shout out to our friend Claude, that in the past, we've often been more reactive than I think we've liked to be. When we've had an overstock or we've had tight cash flow and we've adjusted our ordering patterns as a result of that. And because of. You heard our long supply chain.
18:14
Mark Surkin
Like we don't see the impact of that until two to three months down the road and then it will continue to impact us for another couple of months before we can recover. So a decision that I make today on my volume ordering will still be coming back to me in six months or more in many cases. So I took a lot of data and I plugged it into Claude about our inventory levels and our cash levels and I asked it, just give it some general prompts and said, analyze the data and tell me how much of a correlation and a causation you are seeing between these two data sets. And what was interesting was that there was actually not as much of a causation between our cash levels and our inventory levels as we thought they were.
18:59
Mark Surkin
Because when were not choosing to reduce our orders, it actually wasn't impacting our cash flow as much as we thought it was. And when were choosing to impact to reduce our inventory levels, it was not having like the same negative impact, like it wasn't doing anything to it.
19:15
Daniel Scharff
Why would that be?
19:16
Mark Surkin
What we learned basically was our reactivity to control cash flow by changing our inventory levels was just making our inventory management harder, but it wasn't improving our cash flow. It wasn't doing much of anything.
19:28
Daniel Scharff
Is that because the amount that you would reduce it would just wouldn't be enough to have such an impact on the cash flow versus the operational difficulty that you're putting in place?
19:37
Mark Surkin
I think that, and keep in mind this is Claude data, so the conclusions we have to think about more, but what we think is the impact of that is we're making an inventory decision based on today. But then by the time it is in effect for us in three to six months, whatever was happening today is no longer happening. The skew that reduced volume has improved, the flow of inventory that had slowed down has fixed itself. So then the decision that we made to fix a problem now is no longer a problem. So we just need to trust that the higher level inventory decisions and forecasts that we're making are good.
20:18
Mark Surkin
And if we stick with those and we're patient with them, we're going to have less issues than if we keep making reactive decisions in the moment based on oh no, I'm out of stock today, or oh no, our inventory level is a little too high.
20:32
Daniel Scharff
Sounds a lot like my fantasy football team. When I set the lineup and then I go in and tinker right before the start, I'm like, no, I had a good strategy. Just stick to it, you know, don't second guess it.
20:42
Mark Surkin
Right.
20:43
Daniel Scharff
So it's pretty interesting to think about. I mean, I guess also that probably speaks to the quality of your team and also the supply chain that you've built where a lot of these problems do end up not working themselves out because it's you guys working on them. But you do sort out a lot of these issues and you have a good, solid, growing business that then can smooth out maybe a lot of the blips that you would have if you were making only short term decisions. So I think that's pretty interesting to think about. I also want to just come back to that point about how you forecast, especially for launches. So Soom has been around for longer than a lot of brands who are listening to this podcast.
21:20
Daniel Scharff
You have an enormous number of doors and SKUs and channels and there's just like more, I would say, predictability in a forecast at that point because there's more history and more data points. And honestly, you probably actually have more experienced salespeople than some of the earlier stage companies, just because, you know, later stage companies will have that. People who are much closer to the accounts and have more experience planning promotions and understanding what launch velocities are like. Do you feel like it's pretty smooth just to trust that process? Like, hey, I know we're launching these new SKUs in these doors and we're just going to take the sales team's word for what that's going to mean.
21:58
Daniel Scharff
Like the likely launch velocity when these promo plans are going to happen and we're just going to order what they say or is there something that you're double checking in these new SKU or new door launches?
22:09
Mark Surkin
Yeah, so that's an interesting question. Weight posed it. So if it's a new SKU that we're launching in a retailer, whether it's a new retailer or not, that's where it gets more difficult. If it's an existing sku, we're already moving it through. Like we're probably going through a distributor like Unfi or Kahu or whoever it is, and the retailer is with one of those and we're just basically adding more product there. It's just growth with an existing channel that we're already with. It's pretty simple, it's straightforward, we know what the volume's going to be. There's always a couple of months lead time before those pressed orders come in, which give us enough time to get everything set up.
22:46
Mark Surkin
And that's, I think, a function of our sales team knowing what the lead times are and working with the retailers or the brokers and the distributors and whoever it is, just to make the timelines work, where it gets more complicated and where I think sometimes we do have some operational pushback is new SKUs that we're launching because operationally we're doing work with the co manufacturer who's producing it to understand not just lead times but the moqs. And generally if it's a new product launch, we're trying to be as low as possible because we don't want to overstock, we don't know how fast it's going to move. We've probably got comparable data from other similar products in those stores, but we don't actually know what it's going to do.
23:27
Mark Surkin
So sales team knows what they want and ops team works with the factory team to understand how little we can produce and still have the product on time, in the margins we want and all of that.
23:41
Daniel Scharff
And one thing I wanted to ask more about is I feel like we're talking a lot about finished product inventory, forecasting, that kind of stuff. But also, I mean, most brands will also need to have this forecast translating into when they need to order specific ingredients and packaging materials and outer packing trays, whatever it is that's coming in. Can you talk about that a little bit? I don't know with your comans if it's like, you know, really the kind of scenario where you just order product from them and they take care of everything else or if that is actually your responsibility to be forecasting way upstream as well.
24:14
Mark Surkin
Yeah. So most of our products, we're lucky to be able to have them turnkey. But that doesn't mean we can ignore the raw materials side of it and the packaging side of it because the factory's got to do it like it's part of the process. So for us, every year we actually do a general overall forecast for the entire next year because the sesame harvest happens once a year. It's actually happening right about now in Ethiopia, and that's the yield for the next year. Now if there's inventory issues or whatever with the sesame yield, there's certainly other sources to get it from and things like that, but factories have to plan a year in advance for their raw materials purchasing.
24:55
Mark Surkin
And generally when they're buying packaging, like they're not buying it a month at a time, they're getting it at volume so it can be as cheap as possible. So they're probably going to order six months of packaging or more and just store it in the warehouse. So we've got to have a pretty good idea of what we think our growth will look like for the next year, both on an overall level and a per SKU level. And we've got to communicate that to our partners who are making our product for us. And we've got to work with them on that a little bit. Like that's also an opportunity for us to negotiate on pricing and terms and see if there's anything we want to improve along the supply chain.
25:30
Mark Surkin
The more you know, whether you're making the product yourself, whether you're turnkey or if you're doing the sourcing and somebody else is making it, like the more you know about the whole supply chain, everything that goes in your product, the better you can make decisions.
25:44
Daniel Scharff
It sounds like a nice setup to where you can do that kind of annual forecasting. And I hear that kind of annual thing also when I talk to people in the olive oil business talking about the importance of that annual forecast also. Although there are ways to make adjustments. So that's interesting. But I guess I would consider you guys fortunate if you have that kind of a turnkey setup, meaning you can basically order finished product and you don't have to manage so many different, let's call them SKUs in your system, which would be all of the. Yeah, that. Primary packaging, secondary packaging, labels, all that kind of stuff, ingredients especially. That can be a huge benefit of working with a turnkey co manufacturer who will then take a lot of that work off your hands.
26:21
Daniel Scharff
But there are a lot of businesses that will need to actually manage all of that themselves if they're not working with turnkey comands. And you have way more experience than this than I do. But generally what I understand is like you can have turnkey comands or you can have comands that are not turnkey, where you're really managing all of that stuff for them. The benefits can be like, you might want to be closer. Like you really want to be close to the ingredients that you're ordering. Or maybe you just don't have the scale even to work with a coman at that level. That can just take all of that on for you. And do you see any other pros and cons of that? Turnkey versus non turnkey?
26:56
Mark Surkin
Yeah. Another way that we think about it, sometimes we kind of do a hybrid approach if we want control over something if it's going to make your product better or solve a problem in the business. And we've had a couple of scenarios like that where it's Just easier for us to source a certain type of packaging. And the CO main will source all the raw ingredients, but we're doing the packaging. For example, there's a couple of SKUs that we have made here in the US at Co packers from our bulk tahini. So of course we're sourcing the tahini. We might be sourcing one type of packaging and they're sourcing the rest of the ingredients.
27:29
Mark Surkin
Just like working with your sales team, you work with your co manufacturers, you treat them like partners and figure out what best and generally they're going to work with you to make it work. So there's no one size fits all, it's just whatever makes the most sense.
27:44
Daniel Scharff
Yeah, super interesting to think through. And okay, so let's just talk a little bit more about the system and what this actually feels like in the meeting. So if you have a system like Cin7, there are other inventory management systems out there as well, or you're using Excel just in some way, ideally you can input all of the variables and have a way to capture the impact all of them. Like, okay, here's how much we're going to need by week, which is based off assumptions around my store count my SKUs, my velocity, any promos and stuff that I'm doing, any new expansion opportunities that are coming, and then adjust a lot of that for the shipping time because if you're going through a distributor, they're going to pull it in pretty far in advance in terms of when it would actually hit stores.
28:29
Daniel Scharff
So allowing for that and then obviously also assumption around the lead time then that you need to order everything for it to be ready in time for that. So knowing all of that, basically you're like in Cin7 in this instance is giving you what kind of a dashboard are you looking at then in that actual meeting with a sales team, are you just like looking at it? Is it just a stock level that it's spitting out for you, that's the main thing that you need to see? Or weeks of inventory? Or are you just like kind of looking at what the projected weekly inventory is going to look like by sku, given all these things? Like what's that actual dashboard you're looking at in that meeting?
29:02
Mark Surkin
Yeah, so we're actually not looking at Cin7 in the meeting. And so we started onboarding with the Cin7 tool Foresight AI about, I think two months ago. And inventory forecasting is the core of our business. Right. If we get it wrong or if we change process without understanding what's going on we're going to have a lot of problems. So right now the way we're doing is we're using actually our prior dashboard that is Google Sheets, very like massively built out Google Sheet that takes all the data points in and we enter the data from Cin7 into that. And that's what our sales team is used to seeing. And then operationally, Jake, who's our logistics and purchasing guy, he and I spend time in the Cin7 dashboard afterwards and we're comparing the data sets so that we can understand how the two systems differentiate.
29:48
Mark Surkin
And over the next, probably by the end of this year we're going to. Our goal is to move completely out of the old spreadsheet model and to be working completely in Cin7. So right now what the sales team sees is the spreadsheet that we've been using for years. They've each got a tab. Like we've got a tab for retail, we've got a tab in it for food service, a tab for Amazon. Whoever's responsible for that channel goes in, they enter their forecast in their columns for we do it a month at a time per sku and then there's a roll up tab in the sheet that pulls it all together. And that's where we all look at it together and find the gaps that I mentioned before and talk about promos and things like that may be coming up.
30:27
Daniel Scharff
I wonder, because you have such an interesting background, I think like going very deep on technology and obviously go super deep on ops as well. Do you feel like you have any best practices or tips that you would give to earlier stage brands probably than where you guys are just to try to have this process go really smoothly, whether it's around data integrity or just coming back to like the actual structure of this meeting that you have or the frequency of it, or how to have really transparent conversations with people or whether it's like the right kind of leadership alignment to have in these meetings. Any just overall tips for people who want to establish this process, want to get it going in the best way possible?
31:07
Mark Surkin
Yeah, don't buy software until you really know what your process is going to look like. Because there's a million software companies out there that do this kind of stuff and they all work a little differently, they've got different feature sets and if you go into a decision too soon, you'll spend money that you don't want to spend yet and it won't work right for you because you don't know what you want. So even though it sounds clunky like you could write it down on paper first. Before I started, the team had post it notes that they put up on a wall to do this kind of stuff and Jake could show photos of that and they did a really good job like that. Like when were smaller business, we didn't have as much complexity. Post it notes were fine.
31:45
Mark Surkin
And then when I started there was a spreadsheet that just. You could scroll to the right on this spreadsheet probably for a couple of years and you'd still not get to the end of it. And it was just like a new column for each week or month that was being forecast and it was really hard to track anything. But it worked for a while. So like do the most basic thing that works. You don't have to put a lot of money into it until you have enough complexity that the model that you can cobble together is no longer working.
32:12
Daniel Scharff
Yeah, that makes sense to me. You know, we always encourage brands to be scrappy at the early stage. And if you don't have a lot of SKUs or a lot of complexity, you may be able to do this in a simple way. When I talk to ops people who are very seasoned, that's the thing that they're really highlighting first. Like it doesn't solve your problem just to buy some fancy software if you don't have the right process in place. Because if you don't have the right process and the right inputs, the data is not actually going to be meaningful to you. And so yeah, some people advocate like just get that process down even if it's kind of messy and manual and be running it.
32:42
Daniel Scharff
And that is the point where then software can come in and take a lot off your hands through there. So do you feel like there is a natural point for earlier stage brands where like, okay, if you have now a repeatable process and you understand the inputs, this is the point where now a software system can start giving you a ton of lift.
33:04
Mark Surkin
Yeah, I think it's. There's always a point when you're growing out of what you've been doing before and sometimes you're good enough that you can see it happening before problems start happening because of it. Usually it's because problems are happening. So we knew it was time probably towards the beginning of this year, maybe at the end of last year that for us to look for software to replace our giant forecasting spreadsheet because were having more and more overstocks and stock outs and we would go back to the data as it looked at the Time that we made the decision, and we'd say, well, the data looked right, but we know that we also had this other set of information that the model just couldn't account for.
33:46
Mark Surkin
And the best example I can give you for that is that right now our model shows our forecast into the future week by week, and it just averages the data out over time to give us that week by week look. And we're now some distributor customer. Like, we go through Dot Foods as one of our food service distributors, and we send them a truckload at a time, but the sheet is spreading that out over four weeks. Meanwhile, we've got a truckload that leaves one certain day and that's causing dips inventory. And then when you see that without realizing the nuance to it, you're being reactive and thinking, well, this really isn't working at all. My forecast is a mess.
34:24
Mark Surkin
It's a difference in how were distributing when we built the model out versus the volume and velocity of our individual orders now that we've grown to a certain level.
34:34
Daniel Scharff
So interesting to hear. Okay, Mark. As we kind of wrap up here, just even outside of software, whatever. Just because. Mark, honestly, it strikes me that it seems like you guys have ops in a much better place than a lot of brands that I talk to typically. Like, it seems like you guys have your hands around this pretty good, and you have. The way you've engineered the business makes it easier for you guys, I think, to stay on track operationally. A lot of times I talk to businesses on the ops team, and it feels just like there is a lot of panic happening. Do you feel like there are any lessons you would overall just operationally give to brands?
35:08
Daniel Scharff
Or, like, if you were scaling up a lot of the zoom operations, again, like, anything that you would say, like, these are a couple just great tips to get right as you're establishing the supply chain, as you're finding your partners, as you're even, like, maybe it's predating that to, like, even when you're figuring out what skus you're going to launch and the sizes and the packaging stuff that will just really help you scale in a much smoother way operationally.
35:31
Mark Surkin
Well, first, thank you. It feels good to hear, and it's a testament to our team for doing a lot of awesome work. We're a small team, so the ops department is just three of us, but everybody in the company contributes to that. So I think the first tip that I'll give on the heels of that is be collaborative with your team. Like make sure you've got the right people in each role, people who want to do the work and who either can learn the skill set they need or have it already, and collaborative people who like to work together. And that's just a fun environment to work in. And it's hard to achieve. It takes time. But you put time into that. It is very rewarding. Second to your question, just tips operationally, things to set up.
36:11
Mark Surkin
I think overall, when I think about the work that I do and that my department does for Soom, it's really comes down to the 8020 rule. And if you can accept that you are always going to have 20% of your business, that's not really going to work that great or as well as you want it to. And it's always going to be a moving target. And in that 20%, you're taking time to prioritize which things you think you need to fix in order to drive your growth and your business goals. Work on those things. Shift what you can out of the 20% into your 80% and accept that there's going to be a new thing that's going to come in. The 20% is never going to reduce, and that's a good thing. Like, you want to keep your job security.
36:53
Mark Surkin
You'll always have new stuff to work on. Enjoy the challenge of it and work with your team to understand what the goals are for growth and business so that you can prioritize what to make better.
37:03
Daniel Scharff
Yeah, spoken like a true pro. Mark, actually, that was so interesting to me, the way that you started talking about the collaborative part of it. I have to tell you, I worked at a company. I forgot about this. This was so crazy to me. Where the ops team, I would say, was really the opposite of that. Such like, they used to have their own room and you weren't allowed to go in there if you needed to talk to them.
37:26
Mark Surkin
Oh, wow.
37:26
Daniel Scharff
They would really isolate themselves that way. Then they didn't have their own room and you just weren't allowed to go over their desks and ask them a question, talk to them. If you did, they'd be like, you need to set up a meeting with me and I can do it next Tuesday if you would like to talk to me. Like, this is crazy. It's like as if you're like a buyer and I'm trying to get an appointment with you. And it was so unhealthy, especially because in a growing business, it's so dynamic and it's just going to be that way. You have to Be as collaborative as possible. And you want your sales and ops team close to each other, the kind of way you're talking about so you have that balance.
38:01
Daniel Scharff
Maybe that's why I use the word tension and use the word balance is because you guys do it better. You have the better collaborative culture for it.
38:07
Mark Surkin
Yeah, I hear you. That's a tough environment to work in when nobody wants to talk to each other. I mean, a lot of companies like us, we're a remote team, so you can't just knock on the door. But we still, we meet up when we can. You know, there's kind of an open door, Slack slash phone policy. It doesn't matter how much technology is out there. You need your people.
38:25
Daniel Scharff
I love it. That's a great place to end. Mark, I want to thank you really sincerely for sharing all of these learnings. I love when we have real operators here on the podcast who can share all of these learnings with all the brands because that's what it's. It's all about is the actual practice of how you do this stuff in the market. As you're growing, you guys are at a stage that many brands dream of getting to. So it's so helpful to have these learnings. I also want to thank again our sponsor for this episode, which is Cin7 and Cin7, which is being used by the Soom team. We have a cool discount for Startup CPG members so you can get 50% off the first three months of Cin7 core.
39:02
Daniel Scharff
If you want to check out the link, it's in the show notes Cin7.com startupcpg that gets you access to that discount. And you will love chatting with their team. They'll be very happy to talk to. And remember, you have to have a good process before you start putting the system in place, as we've learned here from Mark. And definitely check out Soom. You can find Soom's number one bestselling Tahini in over 8,000 retail doors including Walmart, Target, Whole Foods, Publix, Wegmans, H E B. So many more. More places online on Amazon Thrive Market Misfits Markets. Check out their website which is Soomfoods.com and there is an Amazon 15% off discount code you can use to check it out. The Discount code is STARTUP15. It expires 1231 26, so check them out. You will love it. I love it. Mark, thank you again.
39:48
Daniel Scharff
We really appreciate you.
39:49
Mark Surkin
Thank you, Daniel. This was fun.
39:52
Daniel Scharff
Well, my friends, we've now arrived together at the end of another episode of the Startup CPG Podcast, the top globally ranked podcast in cpg. As you may know, we're not just a podcast. We're a community of brands and experts and you should join. You can sign up @startupcpg.com you'll then get an invite to our online Slack community. You're going to hear about amazing events near you, all of our special opportunities to get you in front of buyers, investors, brands and more. It's a free community. So what are you waiting for? I will see you there or on our next episode. Bye Bye.