Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
And and this is... You know, for us, we we have, like, a model that is actually seeing three opportunity spaces. And the one you're describing is product and assortment, where everything is actually about data quality and context and, you know, unique data driven consumer and agentic experiences. Right? Let's put it like this.
Speaker 2:Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast where we explore the intersection of retail, ecommerce, and AI agents, which we call Retailgentic. Our mission is simple. We are shining a bright light on the new Agentic AI shopping megatrend which will disrupt the trillion dollar digital retail market. The stakes are high. Google, OpenAI, Microsoft, Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and Anthropic are all fighting to be the Consumer AI Shopping Agent winner.
Speaker 2:There are gonna be some tough decisions for online brands and retailers to make. What happens to checkout? How should payments work? Could you continue to invest in retail media networks? What does the world look like when over half of your traffic is not from humans but from AI agents?
Speaker 2:These existential questions are the tip of the iceberg. On this podcast, we're talking to industry experts, analysts, and influencers to get answers to these questions, identify trends, and best practices. This is Retailgentic, your podcast partner in navigating our AI shopping agent future. And now here's your host, Wingo.
Speaker 3:Welcome to this episode of Retailgentic. One thing that's really fun about being in a Agentic commerce is there's this little community that's kind of formed largely on LinkedIn, kind of a birds of a feather thing going on here where people that are really leaning in for the last year, eighteen months, we generally know each other and share thoughts and best practices and what we're seeing, what we're hearing, the rumor mill, all that good stuff. About a year ago, there was this European fellow, and he was very active posting in LinkedIn comments and also on the Substack. And he had really interesting observations about, well, here's what we're seeing in Europe. And then so, so he's kind of like my European go to person.
Speaker 3:Then he spends a lot of time thinking about loyalty, identity, and how this is going to tie in. And then I have that chart that shows the five levels of Agentic Commerce. Number five is full autonomy. And it's kind of this aspirational Where could we go? So we have a lot of interesting discussions on that topic as well.
Speaker 3:Whenever we have these discussions, I keep saying we've got to get Stephan on the podcast. The person is Stephan Ritter. He is the Director of Ecommerce Transformation at Deloitte. And we've quickly become really good Agentic Commerce friends. And it's been really fun to get to know him.
Speaker 3:It took a while to get him on the pod because he is a busy Deloitte flying around all of Europe. And as the head of Agentic Commerce in Europe, he's quite busy going to shows and meeting with clients. But we were able to finally carve out an hour. There was some news research and some things that came out that he wanted to chat about. So the timing worked out great.
Speaker 3:In this conversation, we'll go through his background, what his role is at Deloitte, and then a lot of, really, a view for what's going on in Europe. So that's a new perspective. I thought there were some really interesting things I learned there. Not only like what are the engines looking like over there, but how is consumer behavior the same and different? And then we go into they spend a lot of time helping retailers and brands.
Speaker 3:He calls brands B2B. It's a little translation thing for you. How you get them to think about this? And how do you get them to start executing and choose a path? So some interesting things there.
Speaker 3:There was a lot of artifacts from the discussion that I'll put in the show notes and then also the sub stacks so you have reference to those. You can look at them after you listen or watch. That's not something you have to have pulled up or by any means. This is a really good discussion. I always learn a lot when I talk to Stephan, especially around that topic of loyalty and identity and where we think that's going to go.
Speaker 3:I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. And here is my conversation with Stephan Ritter from Deloitte, Europe. Welcome back to Retailgentic. I am joined live from Europe by my good LinkedIn friend, and now we've had a couple opportunities to Zoom with each other, and, Stephan Ritter. Stephan is, one of the many folks at Deloitte thinking about Agentic Commerce.
Speaker 3:He is on the European side, and he is the Director of Commerce Transformation at Deloitte. Stephan, long long time listener, a first time caller, so thanks for coming on the pod.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Thanks for having me. It's really an honor being here. It is like I feel the the list of guests is getting longer and longer and more impressive every episode, So I'm really humbled to get an invitation from you.
Speaker 3:Absolutely. Yeah. You always have... You and I chat a lot on LinkedIn, and you're always a very good... You have good insights that you share, so I thought it'd be helpful for the audience to to hear from you.
Speaker 3:We don't do a lot of global stuff, but it comes up with a lot of retailers that I've talked to and brands that are obviously global. And you give us an interesting perspective. So we're looking forward to hear that.
Speaker 1:Yeah, cool. Before we
Speaker 3:go into that, tell us about your background. Are you one of the folks who went straight from school to Deloitte, did you have a little bit of a adventure in the middle there?
Speaker 1:No. Actually, you know, I approach approach the consulting space more from the... Let's say, the digital and agency business. So spent many years around customer journeys and user experience focused agencies. Always helped retailers and brands rethink how people actually shop, you know, when I think about it, through all these twenty five years.
Speaker 1:It's terrible to think about it. But always spent this time on the intersection of experience, business, commerce, tech, and a lot of the bigger projects were actually global e com rollouts, multi country, multi language, multi currency stuff. American brands that want to be successful in Europe and the other way around. And, yeah, now at Deloitte, I'm like two years at Deloitte, I lead the Agentic Commerce offering in Deloitte's Commerce Transformation Practice in Dusseldorf. And my work sits where...
Speaker 1:Again, commerce strategy and AI enabled customer journeys come together. But what makes it interesting and what made me join is actually that Deloitte is bringing these other dimensions into it, what would be also cybersecurity, identity, a dedicated fraud team, a data strategy team. I think that these four are really the differentiating factors compared to the usual e com shop or communication agency that were usually responsible for e commerce sites.
Speaker 3:So two years ago, you got bought on to do Agentic Commerce? Because that was that was pretty early. Or you got on and do something else, and you you raised... Did you raise your hand for Agentic Commerce, or did you get assigned?
Speaker 1:I raised my hand be... Because I really felt... And I think this is when I started writing about it on on on LinkedIn, because I really think this is the next big thing and had this impression really early because, you know, what makes it special to me is that it is it is experience driven, it is consumer driven. Yes, we have all these new amazing technological capabilities, but I think the adoption rate and how quick the people jumped on it really made the difference and and is responsible for the urgency that all the brands and and retailers feel at the moment. And I think this this makes the difference.
Speaker 1:Right? It's like when you look at the mobile revolution or other things where we needed, like, a decade to explain that mobile is the next big thing or... And and push the people more or less into it. This feels really, like, organic coming from the customers. They they...
Speaker 1:Before the first companies have even thought about it, like, it is... Was a small percentage, but coming up and saying, okay, I have an answering machine that is able to give me good answers, so I will look for products. I will look for product details. I will... Let's see what the LLM can come up with when I ask more complex questions.
Speaker 1:And I think this is what makes it really interesting.
Speaker 3:Let's start with the the question that is the the big source of debate here in The US, which I don't a 100% understand, but but you've probably seen me on LinkedIn getting into some arguments about this. How how do you define Agentic Commerce?
Speaker 1:Yeah. This is always my favorite part of your show. Right? You know, together with the the topic of the naysayers and and who's actually saying it's not a true trend and the numbers are quite very low and it's not worth looking into it. For me, Agentic Commerce is when AI moves from being like a better search engine or answering engine for the shopper to acting on shopper's behalf.
Speaker 1:And the shopper's behalf, and this is for me very important, doesn't mean necessarily checkout. I think this is where we are pretty aligned, because I think discovering, comparing, assembling, and in some cases then maybe moving it to the shopping basket. But in other cases it is just picking up the links that you received in your research. Today, taking it over to a pricing engine and find the cheapest one when the LLM didn't deliver the answer is is even a way out of it. Just doing the just doing the discovery and the product consulting piece with the model and with the AI help, and then go down like the classic route.
Speaker 1:And this is this is what a lot of companies see in their traffic already, that out of the... Out of nothing, people are showing up on their PDP buying a product. No. And... Yeah.
Speaker 1:I think that that is really... Makes it difficult, of course. And... Yeah. I called it...
Speaker 1:Have to find out whether it's more a threat or an opportunity for you. And this is heavily depending on how you look at it.
Speaker 3:Yeah. So how about... So one of the arguments the naysayers would make is the the autonomy question. Like, in their mind, they have this very strict definition of agentic commerce where you basically say, I want shoes, and the agent figures it all out and shoes arrive and the human's not involved at all. Do you see the human playing a role in this or do you think the agent just does everything?
Speaker 1:It depends. For lower involvement products, that might be fine. I think Jason Goldberg brought up toilet paper example. I think it would be absolutely fine getting toilet paper in this way, but for everything else, I still see the human making the decision and, having fun during the discovery phase. And this is...
Speaker 1:In most of the examples, most people forget that still e commerce is fun and used to be fun. Right? It's like comparing stuff. And I think Google, ten years ago, they had this study actually saying that the customer journey that is assuming that everything is linear is totally wrong. And in some cases, you have people, like, after two weeks picking up the idea of buying something up again and putting it back again and starting at a different point.
Speaker 1:And especially when it comes to complex products, I think that it's very valid. When you look into more complex scenarios like buying something for your smart home, checking whether, you know, something is compatible with your home assistant, the solar panel works into the converter and stuff like that. You can you can play around hours and and weeks with that. And and so the autonomous part for me is is important that it is actually really helping you comparing and making a good and valid decision. And this is not only like this is the question, this is the answer, but looking into different aspects.
Speaker 1:And there is also like a back and forth usually where the user is sharing much more information with an agent than it would do with Google. And so I really love the story. I can't remember in which show, but I really love the comparison that, you know, in the last ten years, we have brought anything on the PDP down to like five keywords, right? Reducing it to the max, finding the perfect product with five keywords. And now today it is the opposite.
Speaker 1:It is like, you know, I love understanding what the product is about, what is the context of the product, how is it used, what is the emotional scene where the product is used. And then, of course, on the other side, what is the context of the user, Right? Also including at what point in his decision journey is he? And is he sitting in his car and I have to present the results of my research on a mobile screen? Or is he sitting in front of his desktop and open for complex tables where he can put all the technical features on it.
Speaker 1:This is something that really, really interesting. And now, as we have seen last week with Claude coming up with, you know, Claude design and and really modifying on the fly user interfaces, entering the next level.
Speaker 3:Yeah. They call them ephemeral user interfaces. It's pretty wild where you just like, you know, there's no static user interface. You just kind of say, well, I could show the customer this very particular thing they're looking at in this, then build it right as they go, which is pretty, it's amazing. We've taken such a step function up.
Speaker 3:I think a lot of people in the industry are having a hard time getting their head around it.
Speaker 1:I think there's a lot of other examples. We heard new info about... What was it called? Google disco, I think, right? Google disco was another case of on the fly generating a user interface.
Speaker 1:And actually, I think what we have seen from OpenAI, at least coming up with individualized tiles and depending on what product category, coming up with product cards and stuff. One is comparing a technical product, one is showing some fashion, can also do a great job in actually helping the people making a better decision. This is... You know, making this decision alone is a piece of autonomy what the... Where the model decides this is the best way that probably, this is the best way of of the user to experience this this commerce journey.
Speaker 3:Based on all the context on both sides together, the perfect personalized one to one marketing image for what's going on. Let's start at 30,000 feet. You're kind of sitting there. And are you in Berlin or Dusseldorf or Cologne?
Speaker 1:I'm in Dusseldorf, yeah.
Speaker 3:Dusseldorf, yeah. And so you obviously do a good job of consuming all the stuff you see that 's going on here, and then you've got the things going on in Europe. Where are things in Europe? Just give us kind of a state of the union European Agentic Commerce high level. What's going on there?
Speaker 1:So my feeling is Europe is moving fast, but different. Of course, it is absolutely valid that some of the features and this is a pain point for especially, I think, the companies for The US companies that are eager to offer their Agentic Commerce portfolio. But at the moment, most stuff is only available in US. And there is also... I heard that Shopify is differentiating based in US and for US shoppers and stuff like that.
Speaker 1:So really, expect this to go away step by step, opening up, and that all the features, maybe including checkout, again, will be available. But as I said, I think the main thing and the main battleground is the Discovery phase. So I don't think it's too relevant or it's very relevant whether or not you can check out there. It is another step. It is like two clicks instead of one click that you have to do.
Speaker 1:But when you look at the adoption rate in Germany especially, it is already at a, you know, in some cases, higher level than in The US. So, like, I... The the last number I heard is, like, 70 of the young consumers in Germany actively use AI when shopping.
Speaker 3:What are what are some good surveys? And what are... When you're looking at European data, what are your gold standards you're looking at? Like I look at I really like this one called AlphaSense that Morgan Stanley puts out. You see me write about it.
Speaker 3:And then I like the SimilarWeb and Sensor Tower give us so there's like some stated stuff and observed stuff. What what do you look at to to get the European picture?
Speaker 1:Of course. First source of truth is the Deloitte consumer.
Speaker 3:Of course.
Speaker 2:So you guys have a...
Speaker 3:You guys do a consumer panel.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. And this is coming out every quarter. And you can see...
Speaker 1:You know, also, I think the last one is... Came up just today, this morning, and actually covering with all the uncertainty that is happening on the market at the moment, making it very difficult. But still, there is like a positive outlook for the adoption of shopping differently and actually making more... Let's say, more choices in the price, including the overall value, but being more considerate when buying stuff. Right?
Speaker 1:And so that is like... You can see that in the new study. I will send it over to you and you can add it to the...
Speaker 2:We'll put it in the show notes. Yeah.
Speaker 3:So that's... Why do you think that is? Like, why are Germans embracing this a little bit faster than we are? Is it because well, you guys have Amazon. You have Google Shopping.
Speaker 3:So you have similar other options. But what do you think there... There's always this view that that Germans are very, you know, kinda like an engineering culture, lots of exactness, and the trains are always on time and clean and that kinda thing. Is is that part of it? Like, Germans are just, very, very detailed.
Speaker 3:They probably do give a lot of context because they know pretty specifically what they want and that kind of thing. Or is it some other just e commerce isn't as it's a bigger leap up from where you were or something like that.
Speaker 1:That's difficult to say. Think on the retailer and brand side, what I find very interesting is that you have and I think this is one of your core topics as well, right? The big themes are product data quality, machine readable pricing and inventory and stuff. And this is where I feel that actually the B2B side is in a much, much better position because maturity is higher. There is not so much technical depth.
Speaker 1:As I said before, in the last ten to fifteen years, everything was actually set up for a well oiled e commerce machine when it comes to attribution, to the product data and the Google algorithm finding the things. And now all of a sudden, there's a totally different vector how how these agents approach your systems via an API or, you know, finding it difficult to read the human centered interface and the text that are on it. So I think all these aspects are in a much better state when it comes to B2B. Yeah, interestingly enough, also the B2B space is now looking into all the potential of loyalty and identity the ability in general to plug into AI ecosystems without losing control of the customer relationship.
Speaker 3:Yeah. And when you say b to b, I think you're meaning wholesale, you know, brands selling wholesale or not not industrial not industrial products.
Speaker 1:Exactly. Not end consumers, but, really, I think, of of course, there is an advantage. Life is easier when you have a login for everyone, and people have to identify anyway to get a price of things, right? That makes it easier in that area. But in general, I think that a lot of brands and retailers are really struggling with their data quality and standing in front of something that is defining whether or not they will survive, right?
Speaker 1:Really speeding up something that should have happened ten years ago. An engineer, an architect in my team, actually, when I came up with a PowerPoint slide that said, These are the seven strategic levers of Agentic Commerce, and he said, Stephan, these are the same levers that we are preaching for more than ten years for omnichannel, right? Having data in place, linking the system, being API first, not having a vendor lock in but reopen to all different systems. This is something that has been around for some time. And now I feel that Agentic Commerce is really speeding this up dramatically and, you know, giving a lot of pressure on these things that could have been solved ten years ago.
Speaker 3:On the consumer side, what are the top engines? Does it look kind of similar to The US? So you've got, like, Chatch BT, and then, you know, they had a lead, and then Gemini caught up. I always hear about, Mistral or Mistral or how you say it, which is the French one. It it had buzz, like, a year and a half ago, and it's kinda...
Speaker 3:I haven't heard a lot about it lately. I think maybe they've fallen back, but, is that something to please?
Speaker 1:It it it feels like they gave up the race and are really focusing on on other niche sectors. I think at the moment, not very relevant, especially when it comes to consumer products and retail. But there might be the chance to actually catch up again. But at the moment, actually, think I see the same leading systems you are seeing in The US. And I think the protocol walls are still on.
Speaker 1:But in general, UCP, MCP, and A2A are for me the most important parts of the technology, and these are very valid here as well. And I see, you know, everyone actually moving into the same direction. For a short period of time, there was this discussion, are we really willing to go into a direction defined by Google that owned the system before? And now we're doing the same thing again. But looking at the open standard and the open protocol, I think people pretty quickly stopped complaining and said, yeah, this is actually what you have to do.
Speaker 1:It is it is simple. It is straightforward. It can be adopted by by by anyone, and it is up to you which parts of the whole solution you're using or not.
Speaker 3:You brought up one of my favorite topics, the protocol wars. What what... I'm I'm sure you've spent a lot of time analyzing these and digging into to the guts of it all. And what do you think? Do you think there's a winner or are we gonna have, like, a a lot of just kind of everyone will do all of them?
Speaker 3:How how do you see this playing out?
Speaker 1:I don't think there will be one single winner. I think they each solve different parts of the problem or have, like, a different vector and and, like, the direction they're coming from. But UCP, of course, is kind of different because it shows how Discovery, Identity, Checkout, Merchant Control, and all this stuff can work together. So lining up the things and making the connections in this open commerce framework is what makes it different. And the rest still has to be defined, right?
Speaker 1:I think we have seen a lot of pilots and prototypes everywhere, and especially the companies that were really early on and saying, Hey, I love MCP, so here's my full product database via MCP server, and all of a sudden you have... It feels like you have half China on your servers scraping all the product data and information that it can get. And the other piece of opening your agents is ending up in problematic cases as well, right, outside players actually keeping your agents busy, and when you wake up the next morning, all your tokens are gone for the next year. You know, that is another problem. And this is where I think the identity complexity, but also what I see as a maturity level signal clearly is when companies start thinking about authentication of agents for the first time.
Speaker 1:This is when you feel, okay, there's something happening. And also, the same is actually valid when the first time people ask, Can you tell me about the loyalty graph? Knowing the term and knowing there's more to loyalty in the Agentic Commerce context, there's already... Something is going on and the right pieces come together. And this makes it really interesting then going into sparring and helping, sorting the rest out.
Speaker 1:But what is at the moment still the case? I don't know what your experience is. Are usually the product people approaching you with, Can you help us with the product data? Or is usually your first point of contact?
Speaker 3:Usually, over time, it's changed. In the early days, it was the SEO team, and they were kind of trying to... They saw their Google traffic going to zero. They were freaked out. They were like, you could tell they're trying to get in front of it.
Speaker 3:And they thought maybe we could help them. We we can help them with other stuff, but we can't help them with Google's traffic going down. That's a Google decision. And, now it's board level, C level kind of things where the transparent reason they want to talk is their products aren't showing up and they're frustrated. They don't understand why.
Speaker 3:Once you get to know them a little bit better, they will tell you almost more important that they don't really talk openly about it is because traffic is declining so fast, they can see a missing they know they're going to they have a hole in their revenue number this year. And they've they've done the the the Sherlock Holmes seem to figure out where did the traffic go, and now they know it's basically on to Agentic Commerce. They can see many of them... I wrote that piece about the dark Agentic Commerce traffic. And, many of them are...
Speaker 3:They're also looking at their analytics and saying, the traffic that's growing is this really weird traffic that's just going right to our PDPs. It's untrackable. So they're starting to really piece that together. And and that's when we... Those two things, that's where we can help a lot.
Speaker 3:So that's where people are, at least in The US. They've kind of pieced it together that that's going to be... This is how they will solve their problem.
Speaker 1:And this is... For us, we have a model that is actually seeing three opportunity spaces. And the one you're describing is product and assortment, where everything is actually about data quality and context and unique data driven consumer and agentic experiences. Let's put it like this. And then the second area is actually price and economics, so everything that is connected to that.
Speaker 1:Also, some call it value, not necessarily price, because a lot of the brands in this opportunity space see the chance to differentiate themselves by not offering the lowest price, but adding value to the equation, saying... You know, answering the question that is coming from the agent, not with this is the product, this is the price, but I understand what you are trying to solve and I would love to offer you a bundle of products or something that is connected to services or something that actually has the knowledge and the know how how to solve things as a bundle. And this is actually working quite well. With a sports shoe company, we had a very interesting test using MCP protocol and asking the same questions several times. And first time, MCP switched off.
Speaker 1:Next time, having MCP switched on. Like zero point two seconds later, the model gave an answer saying, Yeah, and by the way, you can get this shoe right, by logging in into this loyalty program, then you are adding a discount to the equation. This is also... Right? This is not something that has to be rendered and then the search engine needs two days to actually digest it and stuff.
Speaker 1:It is instant. It is instantly available. And the very next, like, zero point two seconds, the machine gives a different answer when you switch on or off certain information. And that is what makes it so interesting because, of course, in the next step, we haven't discussed A2A, but looking into these fully auto numbers where actually agents start negotiating conditions with each other. What is happening, by the way, in some B2B sectors already but this will make it very, very interesting incorporating all the information that are actually in this loyalty graph, so to say, because giving the other agent an idea that you are a very valuable customer because of your shopping history, your customer lifetime score or something like that, right, or the points you have collected and opening up...
Speaker 3:You're not a heavy returner. You're very light on returns.
Speaker 1:And giving the reasoning in the background and giving a reason to actually buy the product instead of just relying on the lowest price is a route and the direction that many brands take. And the the third third opportunity space then is actually experience and service, right? Unique product consulting and hybrid experiences. This is what a lot of companies are also trying out, actually saying, Yeah, we can combine this with on-site service, live service, delivery, whatsoever, and actually making this an additional argument. And going through these three opportunity spaces is then opening, let's say, the eyes of some of the executives saying, Okay, so, you know, we are not doomed.
Speaker 1:The machines are not necessarily taking over and ruining the last, the last percent of my margin. There is a way out and there is more opportunity than threat.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Think it's great for what you're calling B2B because they get to tell the story, right? They spend all this time, like to use your running shoe example, or, you know, you spend all this time innovating a new shoe, and then in the old world, all you could do is say running shoe.
Speaker 1:Exactly. Exactly.
Speaker 3:And you talk to the people designing these shoes, and it's built for a very specific customer. Like, all right, we know there's this customer. They've been doing 5Ks, and now they're going up to half marathons or something. And they'll get very specific about that customer.
Speaker 1:And this is where the customers also are changing, right? It is like, I think conversations are evolving on the customers. It's not the machine only getting better, but the more people are educated that the more context they give, the better the answer is. It is like they start... You know, they start with, yeah, I wanna I wanna run the New York marathon.
Speaker 1:Right? It is like, the weather will probably be... And so on and so on and so on. And I'm an experienced driver. My weight is...
Speaker 1:And and I'm, you you know, I I have problems with my with my left foot or something like that. And then the machine comes up with a very good answer. And this is what was usually only possible in in in human interaction, a very experienced sales salesperson who has a lot of experience with a running shoe. And now all this experience can actually be... You know, is available at your fingertips, and that is new.
Speaker 3:Pivoting a little bit, I saw on LinkedIn you recently attended something called Talent One's Incentivized Conference. That sounds like... I don't even know what that is. And I've been to several shows in Europe. They used to have an Internet retail show that's gone now.
Speaker 3:And I know Shop Talk has a big European show. What was Talent One incentivized? Was Agentic Commerce part of the conversation? And let's say I wanted to go over next year or this fall and go to a show or two, what would you recommend?
Speaker 1:Okay. That is a complex question. So first of all, Telen One is is a is a loyalty vendor, let's say, and and they are moving more and more into the direction of becoming an operating system for loyalty instead of being a monolithic platform for discounts. Some use and look at them like it is a great discount engine. And some, like, for one of the bigger shoe companies, they're doing exactly this, right?
Speaker 1:Responsible for the pricing and playing discounts. But looking at them as like an open ecosystem, an open operating system for everything that has to do with incentivization, and that is including emotional incentivization, right? Really, always when you need an engine... Let me put it like this. When you need an engine that is helping you nudging the AI or the user or whoever to do the next step and what could actually help making the next step, it is a great solution.
Speaker 1:They are absolutely API first, and we are working with them for several clients. Also international, we won a big fashion company The US just recently, And, yeah, don't want to make too much advertisement here. But...
Speaker 3:I have to get them on the podcast. Listen. I love talking about loyalty, so it seems like they'd be a good guest. You'll have to offline send me someone that I could chat with. Yeah.
Speaker 3:Absolutely. Other what other show... Other than the awesome Talent One show, what what should we get?
Speaker 1:So... And they moved they moved step by step into the direction, just to finish that, in actually thinking about Agentic Commerce and how Agentic Commerce can be very essential for how they look at loyalty. And this is where we are compatible. And I think it's worth looking at their point of view. They added an open...
Speaker 1:A universal incentivization protocol on top of the Google protocol. So rest of the explanation. I think in general, one of the best shows for retail specific and commerce is K5 in Berlin. That is happening in June. And then, of course, Shop Talk Barcelona is is very similar to Vegas.
Speaker 1:Despite that, Barcelona is much prettier then.
Speaker 3:You know, one of the reasons, timing wise, that we had you come on is there's... You guys have put out some... You're really leaning in, on the European side into writing about Agentic Commerce. And, one paper I'll include in the show notes, you had a paper called... I'll pull it up just so if you're watching, you can kinda see the visual here.
Speaker 3:It's from Monitor Deloitte, and it's called Digital Agents AI Takes Command. Who will influence tomorrow's purchasing decisions? Walk us through a little bit of the... What... What's the What's the big takeaway from the paper here?
Speaker 3:I think we know who's going to influence the... Obviously, Agentic Commerce is going to play a role, but what are some of the more tactical things? Like what should a retailer be doing and some of those types of things from your paper?
Speaker 1:I think we looked into most of the aspects already before, but the big thesis is that Discovery is the Battleground. This phase is where the consideration set is formed. Instead of thinking too much about the checkout and the final state of what Agentic Commerce could be, really focusing on how you can actually enable the machine to do this and optimize this discovery for the customer who's asking. I think that is the most important point here. If you are not readable, trustworthy, and context rich for the agent, you will not end up on the shortlist.
Speaker 1:I think that is a pretty short... It feels at the center of everything.
Speaker 3:There's less shots on goal now too, right? Because increasingly Chat2bt is just tweaking the user interface. I don't know if this is going to stick. They used to have the nine product tiles. Now there's only like three or four embedding, and they're making almost like a recommendation.
Speaker 3:Like it's the user interface is changing very dramatically right now as they tweak the Discovery Engine. So it used to only have like nine opportunities, and now you're probably down to three or four to get your message in there. So it's going to be really interesting to see how this plays out. It's going to be feast or feast. Either really good at this or really bad, and it's going to be pretty painful.
Speaker 1:I think one very important area, and you had several conversations I know, is is still the retail media space. Right? It is like, what what is coming what is coming after the advertisement? How how will the AI engines be able to monetize what they're heavily investing in? Right?
Speaker 1:This is still an area that is interesting now that everyone obviously is trying to stay away from the recommendation as such, not preferring products, not giving like a star recommendation or stuff like that. And I think the experiment placing ads next to the answer didn't work out well either. So what is what is your view there? What what do we have to what do we have to agree?
Speaker 3:I think there... Sam Sam has been very clear that there's a way to make ads work. Right? We've seen it at other places, and I I think I think they'll just... They'll get there.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Because, the lady in Fiji built all this for Instacart, and it's pretty good. So I think I think it'll get there. I think they're very aware. Everyone thinks they're gonna be stupid, which I don't think is pretty fair.
Speaker 3:They've they've built a trillion dollar company. So I guess I tend to give them a little more benefit of the doubt that, you know, sure they'll make mistake. When people aren't super entrepreneurial and they don't realize a lot of this is trial and error, like, you know, every one of my companies, we fail more than we succeed. But all it takes is like one in five, and you're good. So a lot of people see the rapid trial and error as failure.
Speaker 3:And I think they're reading it wrong. I see it as being smart and doing lots of experimenting. And, you know, they're clearly iterating and getting to different outcomes. So I'll give them the benefit of the doubt. I think they'll get there.
Speaker 3:It probably won't be this year. It'll be next year.
Speaker 1:I think this is a very important point, right? It is like, I think it doesn't matter from from what angle you're approaching the topic. Your organization, your team, your system, everything, everyone involved is learning from experimenting with what is here today. I think the idea of waiting until, I don't know, 2028 or something like that, saying, Yeah, they will figure it out and then I'll just jump on it, is not working. Because usually what makes every AI pilot successful is the learnings that you make on the way and the iterations and finding your way of looking at it, because there is not the one size fits it all solution for it.
Speaker 1:And, you know, it is bizarre that actually a lot of brands and retailers are arguing, you know, I'm so special and now I lost my opportunity to play out how special I am and how special my relationship is because I cannot put this information on the HTML page anymore. This is crazy. All these companies should be able to explain why they are special and what they can add to what the consumer is looking for for the whole experience to actually play this as a strength instead of looking at how difficult it will be to communicate that and integrate that into an agent's answer.
Speaker 3:Yeah. We had... I know you know Casey Lobaugh from Deloitte. We had him back on the show pretty early in our journey, like September of 'twenty five, and a lot's changed since then. But you guys have taken a lot of his big picture frameworks, you have a really interesting framework for how help retailers think through this.
Speaker 3:Walk us through kind of high level, we'll include maybe some links to this as well in the show notes for people interested. So do you... So a retailer comes to you and they say, Stephan, where do I start? Like, how do you answer that?
Speaker 1:I think, first of all, I mentioned the three opportunity spaces already that we see. And one thing that I think Casey came up with is actually saying, You have to make a decision in what area you feel your brand, your company, you as a retailer, whatsoever. Where do you want to protect? Where you want to participate? And where do you want to lead?
Speaker 1:So where do you see the chance to really make a difference? And then going through the opportunity spaces and make this decision in Product and Assaultment, Price and Economics, and Experience and Services gives you a first idea, right? Saying, Okay, this is where I really think that we as a DIY retailer, we as a shoe brand or whatsoever can make a difference. And then you have to check your, we call it enablers, in the background. That is actually everything that is connected to it and that we have to at least talk about to make sure that you get the full complexity.
Speaker 1:So these enablers are like ecosystems and partnerships. There's a tech and agent integration area. We have government risk and measurement, that is one area. And the last one is identity and loyalty. I talked a lot about this already.
Speaker 1:Having the check marks on this and saying, Okay, then now let's look at these use cases that we see for your specific customers. And when we identify the complexity and actually the return on value for each one of these, you can say, Okay, actually I want to start with this one. Maybe it's a low hanging fruit, a not so complex one that is giving some value. Maybe it is a very advanced one where you want to lead. And then building a roadmap that is actually making sure that all enablers are in line when you're starting with this.
Speaker 1:That is the way to go from our point of view.
Speaker 2:Okay, cool. So you got to
Speaker 3:pick a lane, lean into it, decide if you're going to protect that lane, participate or lead, and then execute. And I think that's good. It helps, it helps boil it down. Everyone's like, oh my God, it's overwhelming. I don't, I've got, you know, 200,000 SKUs and I'm gonna have to do all this stuff.
Speaker 3:And I, yeah, so it's good to help, help give people a little roadmap.
Speaker 1:And also, right, talking about tryouts and not only small pilots that cannot reuse or learn from it, it is very interesting that... For example, for MCP, there was part of this test. It is very interesting that as soon as... For one group of products you activate... It might be only 20 products, but you activate the MCP server and give information via API to the machine, it is already beneficial when it comes to visibility because agent understands, Okay, there's data for me.
Speaker 1:And even if it's not able to find the data in this, it is beneficial for you visibility because it can understand parts of the whole thing. And yeah, I think that shows actually the direction, right? Taking a small start, but yeah, try to already make this happen in your live environment in a secured way, not risking too much and so on and so on, and then iterate from there. It is part of it.
Speaker 3:I know we're running up against time, and you're in the the faint... The fancy Deloitte podcast room. I don't want to get you in trouble by by overstaying your welcome. Last question. Let's look into the future a little bit with your crystal ball.
Speaker 3:Where where do you think things are going? And, you know, I usually ask 2030. Some people freak out that that's too far away, which is funny because we used to be able to see five years in e commerce, and now we can't see six months. But whatever you're comfortable with, are some interesting future directions you think we're going be going in?
Speaker 1:So actually, the 2030 question is really interesting because I think being in 2030 and looking back to these first steps, of course, there will be things that we won't believe that we really did that. Actually, all the mistakes that have been made and of course, being on another level of maturity in the future, they're looking at it. It is comparable to, Yeah, why not measure the size of kids' feeds by X-raying their feed? Right? It's still one of my favorite examples.
Speaker 1:Unbelievable that you did this in the sixties and seventies. But people did this, right? And from today's standards, that is incredible. And I think by 2030, some of the examples you see out today will sound incredible and insane mistakes. But also in that direction, I think Agentic Commerce will be a normal part of the shopping stack.
Speaker 1:You know, not every category, as we discussed in the beginning, will be fully autonomous. But AI will almost everywhere influence Discovery, basket formation, pricing, of course loyalty, and how you are able to discover the services. This will be in a much more systematic way than today. That is the one and only thing. Other than that, I have to say, I think the two of us discussed several times how difficult it is to write a white paper, not to talk about a book about the topic, because everything is changing every two weeks.
Speaker 1:And yeah, I think there are again announcements to expect from events happening this week, when I'm not wrong. And yeah, it really is one of the most thrilling topics that I've seen for a long time.
Speaker 3:Yep. We call that job security in the biz. Yeah. The more crazy and chaotic it is, the more people need, need you and I. Awesome.
Speaker 3:Stephan, it's really good. I'm glad we were able to make this work and you could get the fancy room and everything. So, we we appreciate you giving us that view. We'll... Maybe maybe we'll have you back kinda like around holiday time or post holiday, and you can kinda give us a little recap of what what went down in Europe and what are some of the other big changes.
Speaker 3:But we really appreciate you being our eyes and ears across the pond. And folks want to follow you online, I assume LinkedIn is probably the best place.
Speaker 1:Yeah. LinkedIn or... I'm kind of moving everything to Substack now, being the new source of truth after X not being it anymore. Everyone meets, is good to really... Some some good folks I I lost sight on are now on Substack, and so so I really love being this, like, a new source of of of information and and updates.
Speaker 3:I'll put a link, but just on LinkedIn, you're Stephan Ritter, and I imagine that's the same on LinkedIn as well. I mean, Substack. Absolutely. Thanks, Stephan. Have a good day, and we appreciate you coming on.
Speaker 1:Thank you. Thanks for having me. Bye bye.
Speaker 2:Follow, rate, and share to stay up to date with Retailgentic, your guide to
Speaker 3:the future of AI
Speaker 2:shopping agents.