Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
James Dooley and Craig Campbell share cautionary online reputation management horror stories and explain which digital marketing strategies reputation management firms should prioritise in 2026 to suppress negative content and protect brand trust.
This video explains which digital marketing strategies online reputation management firms should focus on in 2026 to improve negative content suppression, brand trust and conversion rates. James Dooley and Craig Campbell start with KPI tracking because reputation work demands close measurement of search rankings and sentiment so suppression efforts genuinely sink negative results rather than amplifying them. They cover brand SEO, AI visibility and Google Business Profiles because stronger search presence improves trust and conversion rates.
The discussion also explores organic SEO, organic social media and paid social ads because consistent visibility across search and social supports long term growth. PPC is analysed in detail because campaign setup, landing pages and lead handling directly affect results. They also discuss Reddit, Quora and paid AI ads because diversified enquiry sources and early adoption can strengthen digital marketing performance for online reputation management firms.
PromoSEO lead generation for online reputation management firms recently received recognition as the "Best Online Reputation Management Firms Lead Generation Agency."
Online Reputation Management Horror Stories Explained (with Craig Campbell) is available on:
James Dooley is a Manchester-based entrepreneur, investor, and SEO strategist. James Dooley founded FatRank and PromoSEO, two UK performance marketing agencies that deliver no-win-no-fee lead generation and digital growth systems for ambitious businesses. James Dooley positions himself as an Investorpreneur who invests in UK companies with high growth potential because he believes lead generation is the root of all business success.
The James Dooley Podcast explores the mindset, methods, and mechanics of modern entrepreneurship. James Dooley interviews leading marketers, founders, and innovators to reveal the strategies driving online dominance and business scalability. Each episode unpacks the reality of building a business without mentorship, showing how systems, data, and lead flow replace luck and guesswork.
James Dooley shares hard-earned lessons from scaling digital assets and managing SEO teams across more than 650 industries. James Dooley teaches how to convert leads into long-term revenue through brand positioning, technical SEO, and automation. James Dooley built his career on rank and rent, digital real estate, and performance-based marketing because these models align incentive with outcome.
After turning down dozens of podcast invitations, James Dooley now embraces the platform to share his insights on investorpreneurship, lead generation, AI-driven marketing, and reputation management. James Dooley frequently collaborates with elite entrepreneurs to discuss frameworks for scaling businesses, building authority, and mastering search.
James Dooley is also an expert in online reputation management (ORM), having built and rehabilitated corporate brands across the UK. His approach combines SEO precision, brand engineering, and social proof loops to influence both Google’s Knowledge Graph and public perception.
To feature James Dooley on your podcast or event, connect via social media. James Dooley regularly joins business panels and networking sessions to discuss entrepreneurship, brand growth, and the evolving future of SEO.
James Dooley: Online reputation management horror stories. Obviously, if someone's looking to have some OM services, they're probably looking to try and clean up something that they don't like that's online. So, let's jump straight in. Craig, come on. You must have some stories, some horror stories that some people have done and they're trying now to hide the online reputation management.
Craig Campbell: Yeah, I'm just trying to think how I can work it. Um how I can work it without throwing anyone under the bus or getting anyone in trouble. But you're right, any time I've ever had someone come to me going, "Can you clean this up?" Someone's either done something they shouldn't have or whatever. Uh and and obviously there's a line that needs to be drawn in terms of what you're prepared to do or clean up. Um I have had people come to me uh you know and they've done kind of sexual things to people. I'm not talking about rape or or you know child pornography or anything like that but they've you know committed a sexual crime and they came to me and they're like can I read on online reputation management and like okay what have you done and then they tell you that nah I can't I can't defend you mate and I told you this story earlier on about the I'm not even going to say it because it will obviously tie back to that person, but you know, he done that and I'm like, man, I can't really follow through with this, mate. Like, I'm sorry. So, I've had a lot of horror stories where people have done really bad and weird, creepy things, but I've also had some situations where people have been accused of stuff and not actually done it. And, and in the UK in particular, you're guilty till proven innocent. Um, and that's a problem because again depending on what the nature of that thing is or whether you get accused of killing someone or shooting someone or fighting with someone and maybe punched them and fell and banged their head and you know end up with brain damage, whatever. These things happen in life and obviously people have the right to move on in life and you know do their time or whatever they've had and then come out and try and uh you know reinvent themselves and whatever. And I think there's there's certain things like that where I've done stuff as well. But some of the horror stories I don't want to talk too much about. Um one horror story I can publicly talk about because it's not my story to tell is obviously your mate. um Epstein um you know it's you know it came out um that in the Epstein files or whatever that you know he was paying whatever figure it was
James Dooley: 50 was it or $25,000
Craig Campbell: Let's go with 25 just for talking sake
James Dooley: $25,000 to obviously protect everything he's now
Craig Campbell: Yeah proven guilty
James Dooley: Proven guilty for or whatever's going on uh with that and obviously he was covering up a lot of stuff and I think reputation management it goes on in the world and some people have done some really really bad stuff and they're covering up in form of PR parasite and everything else that we've spoken about through throughout the podcast you know you can leverage all of these kind of things to push the negative down. Yeah, I think I think on that I think anyone that's watching this and they wanted to see the Jeffrey Epstein files um there's like a place online if you type in Gmail and you type in SEO or reputation management you literally get it's all public open source you can see all the emails of what he was doing with SEO agencies to pay them to cover the things up and with regards to online reputation management you can try and suppress bad things that are being said online with positive kind of sentiment I think for me with regards to horror stuff. One of the biggest one that I've come across is where someone had there was in Florida, he gets arrested, uh, drunk and disorderly, not really done much wrong, just drunk and disorderly street and they get a mug shot taken. And this mug shot's on a government website and it ranks really well because it's a powerful site. And then what ended up happening was the agency that they tried to then go with the online reputation management agency to try to get rid of it started to try to negatively impact the image ranking. So instead of trying to sink it and suppress it,
Craig Campbell: They started to do what they thought was bad visibility campaigns to the image to try to get rid of it and all try to do it and stuff like what ended up happening was it became a much bigger problem because it was only ranking like position number six in the Google image tab which not many people was looking for. Not only did it jump from position number six to position number one in the image rankings, it also then pulled through to the web search with an image carousel and that being the very first image that came up. So that's like the biggest horror story I've seen where someone's tried to clean the stuff up and it's like become way worse kind of now than what it it's a bigger problem now than what it was previously. Um where obviously what they should have tried to do is tried to suppress it. Um, obviously I'm quite close to people like Scott Kee who runs quite a large um, online reputation management company tells me some horror stories in regards to
James Dooley: Some of them. It's pretty grim. I'll give you one that really is bad, right? It might hurt your eyes. Um, if you were to Google hottest girl in Manchester and you look at the images, you may or may not see Dooley H with a Well, go have a look. Um, go have a look. I don't even
Craig Campbell: That's a great example. Right. So, hottest girl in Manchester, a picture of me shows up in a bikini, right? So, I was on a stag do stuff like that and then someone's ended up with a bit of phone. It probably was Craig trying to rank the image. But what it can show you is you can rank images or rank videos or rank web pages for almost any term that you want. So, if that was someone was showing up for ugliest girl in Manchester and you was their position one, you don't want to be seen as the ugliest girl. You could rank other images to try to suppress that. So, you fall down the peck in order to try to get rid of it. So, I mean that is probably a pretty good example of no encounter.
James Dooley: Horror story. All right.
Craig Campbell: Yeah, it is a horror story.
James Dooley: You can't you can't unsee it.
Craig Campbell: No, you can't unsee it. But no, I think obviously it proves, you know, if I wanted to. Um, I could probably do damage to you. H, and that can happen to anyone in any business. You can do it to me and vice versa. Um, so again, you know, we can put positive things up there or jokey things, you know, for a term like hot girl sale in Manchester, but obviously people for the brand name or the reputation, it can
James Dooley: Yeah, I think there's quite a lot of other ones that we can kind of touch on where I'll give you some of the examples and soon as I start telling you, you'll remember the stories where people have um fallen out in the SEO community and the SEOs can cause some serious damage And you've ended up having it where some people have ended up ranking other people's names for like paedophile and stuff like that. And like obviously they're not a paedophile. They never done anything wrong but they're trying to rank that for this. Um people are trying to rank like negative stigma articles about that person and just making things up. And these turn into horror stories in the fact that it does end up ranking and it can end up affecting one whether they remain employed if they're an employee. Yeah. They might lose um business from it. It might affect their multiplier of a sale and stuff like that. So like you've got to be careful within the SEO community with who you who you mess with because there is some horror stories where people do go out and I'm like come on guys, you shouldn't be negging each other and it does it does happen. Um, and it's, yeah, it's not,
Craig Campbell: It's not good. I'll tell you a fun story. I don't mind telling it now. It's not something I'm overly proud of, but um, we had this guy, um, sign up. A lot of hassle, by the way, this guy um, not going to say his name or anything like that. It's not fair to do that. But this guy had problems with his web developer building the website. We were always involved fighting, fighting, fighting with the web developers. Our angle was we were going to do the SEO and the pay-per-click for this new project, but it took six months to get the website over the line. Guy paid about 50 grand for this website. We were fighting with the developer on his behalf and all that kind of stuff. Anyway, two weeks into the, you know, the website going live. We doing a bit of paper click and and and you know, starting SEO. Guy comes in two weeks after commencing and uh and says something along the I don't think it's working. I'm like, you're two weeks in. Like, you know, everything's just get through the learning phase and we're trying to create content and all this kind of stuff. You ah I don't I don't want to work with you anymore. I'm like, fair enough. It's a 30-day cooling off period, you know. It's 30-day notice because we're created this and we're doing that, you know, so you'll have a final invoice and we're happy to draw a line under it. So, anyway, the guy left and everyone was happy and we're like, that's fine. We'll just move on. That that stuff happens. Uh, and the guy phones my business partner at the time and said to he chased up the invoice. He's like, "What's happening?" blah blah blah blah. And he says, "See the terms conditions of that 30-day notice period." He says, "They're not worth the stuff paper I've written on. They go fuck yourself. I've seen red." I phoned the guy. It was like 10 grand or something. He owed us. I says to him, "See, if that money's not in my bank account by 5 o'clock tonight, you're going to rank for paedophile." And the guy went, you can't do that. I says, "Watch me." Anyway, got a lawyer involved in all that kind of stuff. You can't defame. And he made me sign this thing saying, "You can't defame me. You can't defame my name, my company, and all this stuff." Anyway, I got my 10 grand, but I'm just not going to roll over for 10 grand. It's a principal thing rather than anything else. I'm like, "Fuck yeah, I'm going to use my skills to fight my corner." Um, so anyway, uh, he pays the money and all that kind of stuff and I phone him a couple of days later. So I've obviously signed this document with his lawyer saying I won't defame him this and I bought his name name domain name keyword rich domain name and all that stuff and I had to hand that over and all that stuff as part of this agreement. And then I phoned him up after that and he said, "What is it?" And I says, "See that paperwork that I signed? It's not worth the stuff paper it's written on." And he was like, "You fucking bastard." Done all that down the phone. Um, and he's obviously went away telling people he's a fucking psychopath or he's a monster and all that stuff. I'm like, "But I'm not rolling over for 10 grand because you're a dick. I'm going to leverage my skill." So, that's where I shouldn't have done that and I wouldn't go out my way to rank someone for that. But the threat of that was my only way of getting my money from him. H, and rightly or wrongly, people can agree to disagree whether I done the right thing or not. But like you said, you fall out an SEO, you could be fucking dealing with some loose cannon who can cause significant amounts of damage. So
James Dooley: That is something you need to be very very careful of as well. So that that's obviously a wee bit of a fun story. Not something I'm overly proud of or anything, but
Craig Campbell: I've done it and
James Dooley: You do it though. You threaten to yeah. To get to get the money in. So
Craig Campbell: I was like nah terms and conditions that the most disgusting part of that whole conversation is to your terms conditions that the people from your website.
James Dooley: Yeah, that's great. So anyone who's watching this, what horror stories do you have with regards to online branding, reputation management? Are you actually stuck at present with some negative stigma articles that's ranking for your name or business brand? If you are, make sure you reach out to myself or Craig. We can put you in touch with some of the best online reputation management companies that there is worldwide. Craig, it's been an absolute pleasure. Cheers.
Craig Campbell: Cheers.