The Pressure Lab

What happens to a young athlete's mental health when the label the world gave them stops being true?

In Episode #10 of The Pressure Lab, Keith Wilford sits down with Philadelphia Union midfielder Ben Bender for one of the most honest conversations about athlete identity, injury, and resilience The Pressure Lab has produced.

Ben Bender was the first overall selection in the 2022 MLS SuperDraft. He was 20 years old. The expectations attached to that number, to being chosen first above every other player in the country, are enormous and immediate. He contributed 8 goals and 8 assists in 61 matches for Charlotte FC before a meniscus root tear in September 2023 changed everything. 

Bender underwent surgery to repair the meniscus root tear in October 2023 and spent the next year and a half fighting to feel like himself again. "I didn't start feeling like myself until this off-season," Bender said. "So it basically took almost a year and a half." He struggled to regain his form quickly enough under a new manager at Charlotte, and by April 2025 the club waived its former number one overall pick.
For many players, that is the beginning of the end. For Bender, it was a door reopening. The Philadelphia Union signed him in May 2025, the club that had first introduced him to professional soccer as a teenager, now offering him a chance to revive his career. He posted a career-best 82% pass completion rate across 320 minutes in MLS play that season. He was part of the Union's 2025 Supporters' Shield-winning season and re-signed through June 2027. 

In February 2026, when Bender struck from 18 yards out against Defence Force in the Concacaf Champions Cup, he described the relief of scoring after nearly two years without a goal: "Even though we were up six or seven on aggregate at the time, it was still a relief to get a goal after not having scored in almost two years." 
This is not an episode about soccer. It is an episode about what happens inside a young athlete's mind when the identity built around them, number one pick, rising star, the guy everyone expected, collides with the reality of injury, roster decisions, and starting over.

What does it do to a young athlete's mental health to carry a number one pick label?
Bender was 20 when he was drafted first overall. Before he played a single professional minute the narrative about who he was supposed to be had already been written by others. This episode explores what it means to perform inside a label you didn't choose and what happens to your sense of self when the performance doesn't match the expectation.
How do athletes maintain identity during long-term injury recovery?
Seventeen months is a long time to not feel like yourself. Bender speaks to the specific mental experience of injury recovery that most sports content skips over: not just the physical rehabilitation but the psychological work of staying connected to who you are when the thing that defines you has been taken away.

What does being waived by your club actually feel like?
Being waived is one of the most psychologically brutal moments a professional athlete can experience. It is public, it is final, and it arrives with a clear message: you are not what we need anymore. Bender talks about that moment with a honesty that most professional athletes never allow publicly.

What is the mental experience of starting over at a new club?
Bender described landing in Philadelphia as a "full circle" moment. His parents live just over an hour away. He spent a year in the Union Academy as a teenager. He even suffered his knee injury playing against the Union. The symmetry is remarkable. But beyond the narrative, what does it actually take mentally to walk into a new locker room, prove yourself again, and rebuild confidence from scratch? 

What does resilience actually look like from the inside of a professional athlete's experience?
Bender's story is not a redemption arc told from the finish line. He is still in it, still rebuilding, still earning his place. This episode captures resilience not as a completed chapter but as a daily choice, which is exactly the message young athletes need to hear.

What this episode covers:
  • Athlete identity and mental health when attached to a high-profile label
  • Long-term injury recovery and the psychology of coming back
  • What being waived from a professional club does to a young athlete's confidence
  • How professional athletes rebuild identity after major career setbacks
  • The mental experience of starting over at a new club
  • What resilience actually looks like from the inside, not the highlight reel
  • How personal stability, family, and environment affect athletic performance
  • The difference between surviving a setback and finding genuine forward momentum
  • What the number one draft pick label costs a young athlete mentally
  • Full circle moments: how returning to a familiar environment can restore confidence
Guest: Ben Bender, Philadelphia Union Midfielder, 2022 MLS SuperDraft #1 Overall Pick, Former Charlotte FC

Host: Keith Wilford

Subscribe to The Pressure Lab on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube. New episodes every week.

What is The Pressure Lab ?

The Pressure Lab is a first-of-its-kind mental fitness podcast built specifically for competitive and youth soccer players navigating the real emotional demands of the game.

This weekly podcast from HEADFIRST, a Philadelphia Union Foundation initiative, is hosted by Keith Wilford who gets into the realities of being a young athlete today. Featuring conversations with pro athletes, coaches, mental health professionals, and youth development experts, each episode is an honest conversations about pressure, identity, confidence, failure, burnout, belonging, and the emotional weight competition can put on you.

No highlight reels. No empty hype. Just real stories, real insight, and practical tools for players and the people around them.
If you’ve ever felt the game get bigger than the field, The Pressure Lab was made for you.

About HeadFirst: HEADFIRST is a mental fitness initiative of the Philadelphia Union Foundation designed to equip young athletes with the tools, language, and mindset to perform under pressure and grow through everything sport puts them through. HEADFIRST is proudly sponsored by Independence Blue Cross and Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine. More information at www.myHEADFIRST.org

About the Philadelphia Union Foundation The Philadelphia Union Foundation is a 501(c)3 nonprofit, dedicated to creating opportunity, building community, and developing the next generation of athletes and leaders through soccer and education-based programming in Chester, Pennsylvania and the surrounding region. More information at www.philadelphiaunionfoundation.org

About Our Host: Keith Wilford is a Mental Health and Wellness Educator at YSC Academy and founder of The Wilford Movement. A Widener University All-American and MA in Counseling Education, Keith has spent his career at the intersection of sport, education, and youth development. He is a national leader in student development and has coached and counseled student athletes at some of the most competitive academic and athletic programs in the country.

Tag In here: https://forms.gle/VLBmyLFjVmbtZxBb6. In a few honest words, tag in with the heart of why you’re here: why you play, why you coach, why you care, why you support someone you love in sport. Share your moment and add your voice to a space that puts every player’s whole self first.

(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) Going through my injury allowed me to rebuild

my gratefulness, I think, and to step in

to each day, to each session, with so

much gratitude that I get to do this,

that it's a privilege to be able to

be in the position that I am.

Step into the Pressure Lab, brought to you

by Headfirst, the Philadelphia Union Foundation's Mental Health

Initiative.

Here, we believe mental fitness is as important

as physical fitness.

You train your body every day.

This is where you train your mind.

The pressure, the doubt, the setbacks, they're all

part of the game.

But what you do with it, that's the

skill.

Welcome back to the Pressure Lab.

Today's guest is Ben Bender, the number one

overall pick in the 2022 MLS Superdraft.

Ben has experienced almost every side of what

it means to chase a dream as an

athlete from a young age.

He spent time in the Philadelphia Union Academy,

started at the University of Maryland, and then

heard his name called first in the overall

draft by Charlotte FC in 2022.

From the outside, his path looked set, but

after a major knee injury, the start of

his professional career did not go the way

any athlete would plan.

What followed were setbacks, recovery, the challenge of

rebuilding not only physically but mentally, too.

Now with the Philadelphia Union, Ben joins us

to talk about resilience, confidence, identity, and what

it takes to keep moving forward when life

doesn't go according to plan.

Ben, I want to thank you to the

Pressure Lab podcast, brother.

Thanks for having me, Keith.

It's good to be here.

Before every episode, we sort of have this

process called tagging in, and so tagging in

is this way where we're going to show

up fully for each other in this conversation

to feel some things, feel some emotions, take

us back to some of the things that

you have experienced, some things that we can

probably connect and relate on.

So as I sit here with you, I

think my tag in is that it's really

eye-opening and to hear your story and

sort of what you have experienced at such

a young age.

Having played lacrosse, I've had success, but I

never had the success that you had at

such a young age to be considered a

pro at this point in time.

And so I'm humbled, but also have a

tremendous amount of gratitude to hear your words.

And I know that our audience is looking

forward to it as well.

I'm looking forward to sharing my story with

you as well.

Like you said, there's a lot of setbacks.

And yeah, going through adversity really helps you

become, you know, a stronger person.

And so I think it'd be cool to

talk about some of my experiences, and I'm

sure we can relate.

No doubt, though, when did you start playing,

like sort of, you know, start playing and

realize that this is sort of what you

wanted to do?

Yeah, when I was four years old, that's,

those are the earliest memories I have.

Playing soccer with my two older brothers.

I have two older brothers that are five

and six years older than me.

For as long as I can remember, I

was chasing them around in the backyard.

I remember watching Premier League games with my

dad on weekends, watching Wayne Rooney, Christiana Ronaldo,

and yeah, just wanting to become a professional.

And yeah, those were my first experiences as

a kid.

Did you have other influence or inspirations that

were not necessarily soccer related that made you

want to like sort of pursue this pathway

or this journey that you decided to set

on?

Like, when did you realize that, you know,

I'm pretty good at this?

Yeah, I think when I was probably getting

into my teens, I would say it got

to be a little bit more serious.

There were a couple tournaments that I played

in that allowed me to take different opportunities.

There was a tournament in the States that

was called the Tottenham Hotspur America Cup, and

there were scouts there and they were picking

some of the best players in that tournament

to go over and train with Tottenham Hotspur,

who is a Premier League team.

And yeah, I think it was kind of

at that moment where, you know, I saw,

you know, this whole world of soccer unfolding

in my eyes and I'm like, wow, like

these guys over here in Europe are just

playing on a different level, and this is

what it's going to take to, you know,

play at this level.

Like, these guys are faster, like they're quicker

than me, they're smarter than me.

But I had some talent as well, and

I knew I could, you know, keep up

with them at the same time.

And so my pathway was different than some

people's.

But yeah, I think going into my teens

was really how, you know, I realized that,

you know, this could actually be a possibility

one day.

Yeah, this idea of hardship, highlight and hero.

And, you know, when you think about that

support system and the heroes of your life,

like who has inspired you along the way?

Definitely my dad from a young age.

He's he definitely instilled the passion of the

game for me.

It's pretty funny.

He up until 14, he was really, really

hard on me.

And then a flip of the switch kind

of happened, and it was kind of like

he he he took hands off and he

was like, OK, if you're going to pursue

this, you know, go for it now.

And he's still critical of my game sometimes,

but I think he did it in a

really, you know, special way to where, like,

if now that I'm 14, I'm getting a

little bit older, you know, I'm on my

own a little bit more, like, if I'm

going to pursue this, then, you know, I'm

I'm the one that's going to have to

put in the work and everything.

And it didn't feel at all forced, you

know, after I was, you know, 14 and

go into the academy and I was on

my own a little bit.

So I think he was one of my

heroes for sure.

Growing up, you know, he instilled all that

passion in me.

And then I would say my two older

brothers, just the fact that I got to

play so much with them growing up in

the backyard, you know, battling one V ones,

getting beat up by them, learning how to

be stronger, training individually with them.

So many hours on, you know, a local

field by our house that we would go

out and shoot and just be there for,

you know, so long.

And, you know, I I look back and

wish I could do that again with them.

It was such a special time training with

them.

And I think those are the moments that

really prepare you and set you apart from

from other players is those those times with

your family, because a lot of unique people

out there in different styles.

So pretty cool.

Have you ever had maybe have you gone

back into the backyard and have you done

that at times yet as a pro?

Earlier on, about two years ago, I went

back.

I mean, I visit my parents not frequently,

but as much as I can get down

there to Baltimore, Maryland.

But yeah, I've been back there with my

brothers and we've we've kicked the ball around

around, you know, the yard.

And we played croquet the other day.

And we're just reminiscing of the times that

we we used to spend with one another.

So it's pretty special.

Absolutely.

You know, people talk about like, you know,

the being the guy, you know, sort of

in the sport that you play and and

obviously that was you being a first round

draft pick and coming out of Maryland and

expectations.

And so when you got drafted.

Was there pressure that you felt on yourself

instantly?

Did you sort of know going into it?

Like, what was the I mean, I don't

know how many people have the opportunity to

be a first round draft pick.

Yeah.

You know what I mean?

Yeah, it was it happened so fast, honestly,

it was, you know, things were going well

during the season, but I wasn't really expecting

to be super high on the draft list.

I was surprised to go number one overall

with how everything unfolded.

The timing of Charlotte being a new team

in 2022.

And, yeah, just the fact that they placed

their trust in me.

A guy that's a sophomore and a local

guy from Maryland.

But I mean, with the season that I

had looking back like.

I think maybe I should have had more

confidence that like, OK, yeah, like they should

pick me.

Yeah.

So now, you know, you're drafted first.

You're so grounded.

Did you feel anything changing yourself being a

first round draft pick?

Not really, I.

Honestly, I feel like the first five months

after being drafted was like a dream like.

It I didn't feel much pressure.

I think I was just playing off of

instinct the whole time.

Like things were going.

So easily for me, like I couldn't I

really wasn't expecting it because, you know, when

I got there, like I'm a younger guy,

like I'm thinking I'm going to have to

really fight for a spot like and, you

know, things aren't going to come easy for

me.

And then, yeah, I'm a I'm a sub

the first game and with 70,000 fans

and I hit the post and then the

next game, our next home game, I get

a goal and an assist in front of

30 or 40,000.

And I had just been playing, you know,

high school and college with under, you know,

with 5000 max fans.

And then it's like everyone's coming to these

games to watch us play.

And, yeah, honestly, I wasn't really thinking about

it.

And, yeah, things were going really, really smoothly.

So smoothly, we say smoothly and then all

of a sudden.

Yeah, tell us.

So you've been so honest about your whole

journey so far.

And, you know, most.

Myself, like most athletes don't know how to

handle or process that first injury.

And that was something that you started off

with.

So I'm curious if you can give, you

know, the visual and sort of tell us

what took place, as you I would imagine

suffered your first real significant injury.

Yeah, for sure.

Yeah.

So the first five months were really easy,

like I said.

And then it was about a we had

a coaching change and then I was in

and out of the lineup and then it

was 2023 and things were going really, really

well at that time.

I started five games in a row.

You know, I was feeling really fit, really

energized, was getting a couple of goals.

And then, yeah, all of a sudden it

really hit me like I got that injury.

I had a couple of opportunities at the

time, like a pre-Olympic camp with U23

national team.

And looking back at that time, I think

I was taking these opportunities for granted and

really, you know, when I look back, I

wish I was more grateful for the good

times that I had on the field.

And if I could go back, you know,

I would have been more grateful before the

games.

You know, the fact that I'm starting like

every single person that's at, you know, every

kid that's at this game wants your spot

like so many people would give so much

to be in your position.

And so, yeah, going through that injury, I

think it was a it was a meniscus

root injury, which was a little bit of

a strange injury for a soccer player.

And that put me out about seven to

eight months.

And the road to recovery was more difficult

than I expected and more difficult than the

trainers had expected.

And so, yeah, I think going through that

that period, I reflected a lot.

And yeah, like I said, I'll go back

to the gratitude part.

Like now, I think I play with so

much thankfulness in my heart every time I

go out there.

When it when it happened, what was sort

of the first sort of your first reaction

to it?

It starts to hit you during the two

to three to four months where you are

still in the gym and, you know, preseason

has started for the guys and you don't

get to be with them.

And yeah, over time, it kind of eats

you up because you see yourself as the

player that you were before the injury.

And then when you don't get to that

level again and you have your, you know,

identity wrapped up in that player before the

injury, it really eats you up inside.

And so those are the things that you're

battling each and every day.

And as competitive athletes as we are, you

know, every pro athlete wants to be at

the top.

And when you're not there and when you

have, you know, had success before, you know,

it eats your mind away.

And so those are the things that you

battle and adversity you go through and you

have to to find a way to get

through that and to overcome it.

And I think a lot of young athletes

are afraid to talk about the idea of

sport and identity.

And because it's almost like if if if

I'm not this, then what am I?

And what knowing what your relationship has been

with soccer and with sport and success.

How did this injury challenge your identity?

Yeah, when when you play, you know, from

four years old and then you achieve your

dream of being a pro and then you

set even higher standards for yourself.

And when you meet some of those standards,

but you don't achieve the bigger goals because

of a setback, then you feel like the

world has ended.

And because you play every day and this

is this is what you do.

This is what your job is.

Your identity is taken away.

I think looking back, a success could be

from from my injury is that there's the

fact that I gave my everything, you know,

trying to get back on the field as

soon as possible.

Sleeping right, eating right, doing, you know, controlling

the things that you can control, even though

you're not on the field.

And so, yeah, your identity can be shaken

for sure.

But it's the mentality and the grit, the

desire to get back to where you were

and to prove that, you know, each and

every day I'm going to wake up and

overcome this, you know, these negative thoughts, even

though it's hard, even though you can't be

out there on the field with your teammates,

even though you can't be out there getting

better in certain ways, you can get better

in in the little ways, you know, in

the gym and doing other little details.

This podcast is powered by Headfirst, a program

of the Philadelphia Union Foundation has built a

free toolkit at myheadfirst.org with worksheets, guides,

videos and resources designed for athletes, parents and

coaches navigating the mental side of the sport.

And if you want something tangible, something your

athlete can carry with them to every practice

and every game, request a Headfirst bag tag.

It's a free luggage style tag that attaches

to any soccer bag and links directly to

myheadfirst.org through a QR code.

It's a symbol, a reminder and a connector

all in one.

Request yours at myheadfirst.org.

Coaches and clubs reach out to us directly

and we'll send a full package for your

entire team.

You know, when you have success, you're you're

being affirmed constantly.

For sure.

You know, it's a first round draft pick

and so many things have gone your way.

And I'm wondering if if you felt any

of that.

Like, did you have really challenging days where

you're like, I don't know if I'm going

to come out of this?

Yeah, for sure.

I think every day you wake up, those

thoughts come into your mind.

You have to surround yourself with the right

people that can, yeah, speak life into you.

And I think that's what I tried to

do to to help me get through those

tough times.

I like that speak life into you.

You know, I think it speaks vibes when

you say that, I think.

When you say speak life into you.

Can you elaborate a little bit further about

when you say that, what that means?

You know, whether it's your friends or your

family.

Spending quality time with you.

Talking about things outside of the game that

you enjoy doing.

Talking about who you are as a person,

your character.

And, yeah, I think I think my family

was able to to come around me and

do that at that time.

They were able to to encourage positive reinforcement,

for sure.

And encourage me, you know, for for who

I am as a person.

And that's hard because I want them to

encourage me for who I am on the

field.

But I think that builds character that when

you go through those trials, it builds perseverance

and it builds even stronger faith.

And when you get tested and when you

when you go through those things, that perseverance

becomes like a fire inside of you.

And so I think those are the ways

my family and my wife and friends came

around me during those those tough times.

What helped you inspired like, how are you

able?

How are you able to see something without

knowing?

With the level of uncertainty without knowing what

the outcome was going to be like?

What are you going to tell that 14

year old who just has this growth plate

issue that keeps manifesting as some continuous injury

that they just are like, I don't know

if I can even do this anymore.

Yeah, that's a tough one.

Because it really this this past week has

hit me different in terms of, you know,

playing a bigger role on the field and

scoring a goal for my team.

Because I've actually had those thoughts up until

this week, because it's been it's been about

three years since my major injury.

And I was expecting to bounce back in

eight months and be that same guy who

I knew myself, you know, on the field

before my injury.

And so what drives me during those tough

times is I have a goal in mind.

I want to provide for my family in

the future.

Like, that's something that, you know, I really

want to do.

And I think when when you say someone

who has growth plate injuries or someone has

a reoccurring injury, I still feel pain from

my surgery, you know, in some way.

And there's little exercises that I've learned to

to make sure that I do before I

go out.

Simple things, simple exercises like Nordics, like you're

definitely familiar with.

And that's something that I had to implement

in my training.

And so there's things that you learn that,

you know, you're not just stuck in the

water and, you know, you can't get out

of this.

You can you can figure out certain ways

to, you know, battle against the pain that

you have.

And so I've learned I've learned, yeah, like

doing Nordics, doing different stretches, like you just

have to you have to up your your

rehab.

You have to up your prehab.

And and, yeah, I think, you know, you

can get through it.

You know, youth sports and it's it's it's

so massive now.

So whether or not across all sports where

people are moving 100 miles per hour.

Not many people are still and obviously going

through an injury for, you know, seven, eight

months of going through rehab.

There's a lot of moments where you're sort

of by yourself and you're quiet and you're

still, you know, what were some of the

things that you needed to hear from your

coaches or from people around you that kept

you inspired?

Like, what are some of the things and

even even when you're not injured, like what

are some of the things that you need

to hear right now to keep you putting

one foot in front of the other?

I think it's important not to look too

far into the future.

I think that's something that I did when

I was injured.

And when you look into the future and

you worry about something that hasn't happened and

you you envision, you know, something like, for

example, I envision myself not being able to

get back and and sprint like I used

to be able to because of having too

much pain or, you know, just worrying about

what's what's going to happen.

And I think I needed to hear that

from my family, especially that, look, you need

to stop worrying about eight months from now.

Right now, you need to focus on being

able to walk, being able to jog, so

to control the things that you can control.

So they were really helpful in just telling

me to stop looking so far into the

future.

You can't control that and take it day

by day.

Take take small steps, control what you can

control and believe in your abilities to get

back and and see where it goes from

there.

Did anything ever deter you?

Did anybody ever say anything that sort of

sort of kept you off track where you

sort of felt like I didn't need to

hear that?

That's an interesting one.

I like that question.

One of the the captains actually at Charlotte

where I was playing after I had gotten

the injury and I told him I can't

remember if it was before my surgery or

after my surgery and he looked at me

and saw how bad shape my leg was

in after the surgery.

And he made a comment and he said

it's going to be tough to get back

to where you were.

And then he made a comment after that

and said even the best ones have a

tough time, meaning the players in the Premier

League, the players in La Liga, the players

at the top, that you would think being

out that long and they have that pedigree

that they would step right back into their

spot.

And so the comment was kind of like,

I took it as, okay, I'm not a

big player.

And so my career is going to be

in the dumps because I'm not one of

those big players that he was referring to.

So it was like I felt like I

was being written off a little bit.

And so at that time, it was even

more frustrating to hear that because I couldn't

control the injury.

And so I had to battle little things

like that as well.

Is there anything that you would offer up

for someone that may be experiencing that where

they have their own self-doubt already and

maybe somebody else is affirming their self-doubt?

Maybe a couple of things out there that

maybe there are some helpful tools or things

that you believe that maybe you'd help to

sort of get through those moments.

Yeah, another thing that I can think about

is when I was talking with my dad

through the injury and how he would always

say, make sure you don't re-injure it

and make sure you don't come back too

fast.

And so that was always in the back

of my mind as well during the recovery

processes.

Make sure you're pushing the boundaries and how

fast you go, but at the same time,

don't do something that's going to re-injure

you and set you back.

And so I guess my encouragement to someone

who's struggling with these doubts and someone who's

affirming these doubts is believe in your recovery

process.

Believe that you can get back to where

you were.

It may not look like there's light at

the end of the tunnel, but I can

say from experience there is.

It's not an easy road.

There's a lot of adversity along the way,

but you can do it.

You can get through it and you can

get stronger through it as well.

You can become a stronger athlete because of

it.

You can build stronger character because of it.

And yeah, so I think there are definitely

positives to take away from injuries for sure.

It builds character.

Ben, I have taken a lot from your

words.

And I know a bunch of young men

that I teach and there was their last

day at school today before playoffs and the

World Cup kick off.

And my hope is that they have the

opportunity to sort of listen to what you

have said in this conversation.

At the end of every conversation, they're different

than at the 40th minute.

And I'm tagging you in for my spot

and there's a tag out.

So I'm sort of decompressing with you.

And I just want to throw something at

you as sort of a final reflection as

you sort of tag out.

As you hear the phrase, you know, rebuilding

your identity after something that is challenging.