A look at what it takes to make an indie film. Each episode shares advice on things like funding, planning, and getting a project across the finish line, without a studio-sized budget.
Brian Ralston (00:00):
Post-production is its own kind of thing. These jobs are not short-term jobs that assemble on a set for 28 days and go away.
Bishop Porter (00:20):
So welcome guys. Glad you could be here. Tell us a bit about yourselves. I'll start with you, Ben.
Ben Urquhart (00:26):
I'm Ben Urquhart. I'm a board member of the California Post Alliance. I have a long career as a post executive working at Focus Features and Universal Pictures.
Bishop Porter (00:36):
Two of our favorites. Okay. And you, Brian?
Brian Ralston (00:39):
I am Brian Ralston. I am one on the founding committee of California Post Alliance. For about 26 years now, I've been a film composer in Los Angeles. And for about the last 15 of those years, I've also been film producing. Coming to that mostly from post-production side. I do a little bit of both.
Bishop Porter (00:55):
Very cool. Yeah. We've got to have the creative and then the business management, I guess, for you as a post supervisor, you said. So Ben, tell us how the Post Alliance came to be.
Ben Urquhart (01:07):
All right. So the California Post Alliance came together because essentially there is not a single group that endeavored to represent all of post. And as we all know, we are at a crisis point, particularly in California and Los Angeles around keeping this work here and keeping an active community going that's financially rewarding and stable and creating great post-production jobs. And the unions have done a lot of work around this. Other groups have tried to get things together and our leadership came together just at the right moment, largely around an open letter that was sent by Peter Roder, who's a music contractor, who was basically up in arms. He's a passionate guy and he was up in arms about what is going on. We've got to do something. And the Post Alliance was this coming together of people across all of post-production to have one group to represent us and go do a fight for getting a standalone incentive.
Bishop Porter (02:08):
Tell us personally, how has your work been, let's say the last five years since COVID? Have you been steadily working? Have you seen a drop off?
Ben Urquhart (02:15):
There's been a tremendous drop off. I was reorganized out of Universal all two and a half years ago. I am competing for a small amount of jobs with brilliant people that I have worked with for decades and that have come in through the streaming wars and services. And there are just not enough hours or jobs here in California right now.
Bishop Porter (02:40):
And do you see a lot of them are in Canada, they're in the UK or they're in New York?
Ben Urquhart (02:44):
When I started at Focus, it was in New York. And I will tell you that because it was even at that time so expensive to work in California that I and my teammates and my bosses there pioneered a lot of these offshoring techniques. Well, it's come back. It's time for us to do the same and get competitive with those jurisdictions.
Bishop Porter (03:05):
What about you, Brian? Tell us how you got involved in the group.
Brian Ralston (03:09):
Gayle Levant, who's a harpist, if you've seen the Oscar ceremony, she's the harp on that ceremony every year. She was one of the founding members early on as well. And I met up with her at a panel discussion that we were on and she thought that I would be a good voice to have in it because I see both sides. On one hand, I can be putting a budget together and hiring musicians or hiring even crew, but on the other hand being a composer, I'm impacted because I'm the one hopefully being hired and allowed to work here in town. So having both sides of that voice to understand would be, she thought, a good asset to the group. And this was pretty early on and when we were forming the group. And at that point, new people were coming to our founding committee from all disciplines.
(03:51):
The goal was clear about a post-production rebate that we were headed towards, but at that early time it's like, how do we do this? Everyone was telling us we couldn't make this happen in the amount of time that we needed to. The Peter Roder letter was huge about the urgency that we have because once a lot of our infrastructure gets repurposed or closed down, it's probably not going to come back. We have scoring stages in town that have closed. Paramount tore theirs down many, many years ago and rebuilt other facilities in its place, physically in its place. And that's one of the unique things about Hollywood is our infrastructure has been here forever. It's unique. It's why we had a monopoly on this for so long, but technology has allowed us to really be mobile with that infrastructure. Georgia knew how to build sound stages and do a thing like other places around the world, other orchestras around the world, the more they do, the better they get.
(04:50):
We're not locked into Los Angeles anymore, so we have to start compete with other aspects. And that's where these tax rebates all around the world have drawn work away because they all want a piece of this Hollywood pie.
Bishop Porter (05:03):
Absolutely. Yeah. It's good and bad. We've exported this vision of what Hollywood is and globally everyone knows what it is and what it means and they love it and they want to be a part of it. But the bad side is we've lost some of the jobs because of that export. So tell us about the bill that was recently passed, just high level, kind of the broad strokes, what were in this post-production bill. I know that happened, what, the last month or so?
Ben Urquhart (05:28):
That's right. Governor Newsom signed it, I think on the 18th of September. We had a great signing ceremony at the TV Academy. He was wonderfully articulate about post-production, which was cool for all of us in the room.
Bishop Porter (05:44):
He got the good notes on that study up.
Ben Urquhart (05:46):
Yeah, he did get the good notes. The bill is a standalone post-production tax incentive for work in California. It is a 35% credit. There are a couple of uplifts for distant non-standard out of the zone.
Bishop Porter (06:02):
Out of the zone. Out of the
Ben Urquhart (06:03):
Zone.
Bishop Porter (06:03):
Meaning outside LA, proper so many miles or something.
Ben Urquhart (06:07):
That's right. But one of our huge big deals I'll let Brian talk about because it's music specific.
Bishop Porter (06:13):
Okay. Yeah.
Brian Ralston (06:14):
I mean, music's been hit really hard.
Bishop Porter (06:15):
And why is that, Brian? Is it a product of being able to do the job remotely from home on your computer with the tools you need and you don't need to go into a facility?
Brian Ralston (06:27):
I may make some generalizations here and I don't want to offend any of my musician friends, but if you're a producer hiring an orchestra for your score, you don't really care about who the trumpet player is. You don't really care about who the violin player is. Now, if you're hiring an actor, you're hiring Tom Hanks, I always like to say. But as long as the musician is competent and talented and we get it done on time and on budget or whatever, then the performance of that score, they're not casting the orchestra. And so technology has allowed us to be mobile. Not only send those parts in PDFs and record it somewhere else, we can monitor that in real time, better than Zoom. High quality audio can be monitored in real time. You can even record remotely if you had to. And those digital files get sent, recorded, digital files get sent back.
(07:16):
You can even mix here, but record somewhere else. And that's done routinely. Visual effects is no different. Visual effects offshores and sends out a lot to other locations around the world globally. But if that work is done in another location that has a tax rebate and there's enough of it to qualify for that tax rebate, then there's incentive to do it there. While rebates are not going to just universally solve the problem, I've always felt if we don't have something that competes, Ben likes to say, "We're not asking for charity, it's parity." We're not even in the conversation. We still need to have contracts that are competitive. We still need to have an experience of working here that is better than working there. But at the bottom line baseline of the cost, we can start now to produce a lot of these things for a lower cost overseas.
(08:07):
Or I could pick a small number of orchestras around the world where if the music's not that difficult, it's good enough for this film. But London Symphony is not, you're not going to shake a stick at that. That's like London Symphony at Abbey Road is a huge orchestra, and yet the cost of recording there over a long time is still more economical than recording here.
Bishop Porter (08:31):
Because of the incentive.
Brian Ralston (08:32):
Because of the incentives and because of the contract. So we, California Post Alliance, can lobby and get everybody together and try to get an incentive passed to help with that equation. It's not the only part of that equation, but we need it. You're not even in the conversation if you don't have it.
Bishop Porter (08:48):
Without it. Exactly. And I think we're seeing that across the production incentives all over. I mean, I came up in the business in Louisiana when that was the hot state to go to. All the studios, many majors came through there and did a lot of work then. And then Atlanta became the new hotspot and everyone was going there and they built up the infrastructure. When you can make something at a 30% or 35% discount, every producer's going to go there all day long.
Brian Ralston (09:12):
And even now we're hearing stories about Atlanta. New Jersey has a competitive rate now in New York and they're pulling away from even Atlanta. What's the difference between Atlanta and us? They had to build that infrastructure, which they are still paying off and it was a huge cost to build it to take advantage of that. We already have it here. We have these stages. The sonic signature of the Sony scoring stage and Warner Brothers Room and all this other stuff, there's a unique sound to that actually. It's not just that it's here. It's not just that I can get any player on any instrument to sight read perfectly in Los Angeles. Even if you're using non-traditional orchestral instruments, you still need someone that can read music, knows how to play with that click track in their ear, knows how to do that. And that's unique.
(09:59):
That's not anywhere in the world. The other thing is cost about you could sight read and get a perfect take in two or three hours here where that same thing in another orchestra might take you six, nine, 12 hours to get something usable. So the costs aren't exactly equivalent to each other. But in general, it's expensive to shoot here. It's expensive to post here. It's expensive. And if these rebates are going to change that math, then that's what we need to do.
Bishop Porter (10:31):
When was this letter written? How long did it take to get the steps in motion to have this get to the bill? Because it seemed fast to me.
Ben Urquhart (10:38):
It was incredibly fast. I think it's really important to highlight that because we were told that there's no way that this was happening. We were told that over and over and over.
Bishop Porter (10:49):
That's kind of what I heard.
Ben Urquhart (10:50):
Yes, that played in part of our story in really interesting ways, but we officially became a 501 in January of this year. We hired our lobbyist on a phone call just before Christmas. He's an incredible lobbyist. He is a very serious guy and a really great guy too. And then he found us an author for the bill, Nick Schultz, Assembly Member Nick Schultz of Burbank, which District 44. Here we are right now. Yay, Nick Schultz, who also just jumped in. We had our first town hall on February the 4th of 2026, and nine months later or eight months later, we have a piece of legislation. It was really hard. It was a really hard and intense grind seven days a week. Our founding members group of 20 of us, we meet every Sunday morning at 8:00 AM. No one's family is happy with them, especially at 8:00 AM on Sunday.
(11:53):
But I mean, we've just buckled down. It was all about the urgency.
Bishop Porter (11:58):
It speaks to the commitment, the camaraderie, the village, everything that had to come together. And also just how dire it feels right now and how the past few years, since the strikes in 23, things just have not picked up to what we need. And you put the fires of last year of 25 on top of that, and it's just been one hit after another.
Brian Ralston (12:18):
Absolutely. Do you remember when Local 700 came on board as a co-sponsor? It was like -
Ben Urquhart (12:24):
That was June, July?
Brian Ralston (12:26):
Yeah. So in June, July -
Bishop Porter (12:27):
Was it the session in June or July?
Ben Urquhart (12:30):
They did not come on as an official co-sponsor because we were working on the bill language and they really wanted to get some labor standard language into the bill, and it took us a while to get there. These coalitions and alliances are really tenuous. I think that's one of the greatest stories here actually, is that once we got around the corner with Local 700 and they came fully on board as a co-sponsor, initially it had just been us with our tiny little ragtag group of members.
Bishop Porter (12:59):
For those who don't know, tell us Local 700 is what?
Ben Urquhart (13:02):
Oh, yes, exactly. The Editor's Guild, the motion picture Editors Guild, which has, I believe, 7,500 members in California at least. Once we came around that corner, I had an insight, which is, holy cow, I've spent my whole career competing with every person here, and they are all competing. Who's going to get the job? Who's going to make the better pitch? Who's got the better deal? And what we needed to do to give ourselves a sliver of hope here in California is unlock from that competitiveness and pour that energy into making something happen.
Bishop Porter (13:37):
And the bill, is it five million a year? 10. Okay. So it starts when? January one or?
Ben Urquhart (13:46):
The fiscal year. It's tied to the fiscal year. And we haven't written any rules and regulations with the CFC, the California Film Commission, because it's an election year. There's going to be turnover there. We know Colleen Bell is going to leave. And so we're in a little bit of a holding pattern around writing rules and regs, but the money's tied to the fiscal year, so that's July one of 27. And we assume that the applications will happen either before or around that. We don't know yet. There's a lot to be.
Bishop Porter (14:19):
Yeah,
Ben Urquhart (14:19):
Sure.
Bishop Porter (14:20):
The important thing is it's done and it's been earmarked and got to go. Yeah.
Ben Urquhart (14:24):
And we know that 10 million is not a lot of money.
Bishop Porter (14:27):
Speak to that a little bit because when the grand scheme of things, when you chip away at how much it costs to do these projects, and we all know how expensive movies are and in California, yeah.
Ben Urquhart (14:37):
A little back of the notebook matchbook math. To me,
Bishop Porter (14:40):
That
Ben Urquhart (14:41):
Comes out to about 20 million, 21 million in wages that wouldn't have been here. So look, that is some good news. It's not enough for all of us here. Nick Schultz said this is a down payment. Governor Newsom said, "We know this is a starting point." And we're starting to see a little bit of analysis come out. This is going to be an oversubscribed program. There is no economic data right now that's tracking post-production lines in our wonderful 4.0, $750 million tax incentive, post-production is a lump. And so this gives us the opportunity to start to unfurl real information about who is post-production, what is post-production, how many mortgages are they carrying, how many sandwich shops depend on editors, many.
Bishop Porter (15:35):
Yeah. And then you'll have the metrics to back it up when you get the supporting industries that all rely on this.
Brian Ralston (15:42):
And if we remember the production rebate, the other one that exists, that's currently $750 million, did not start at $750 million. So that's on version 4.0 now. So there's been four iterations of that. They're working on another one. And so the hurdle of getting it into law was our biggest hurdle. And the best problem we can have is that it runs out of money because everyone used it and it's like, look, this is obviously popular. It's working. We need to add another zero to this. And so it just gives us something on our agenda to talk about this year.
Bishop Porter (16:23):
Get it in the door and then you build, that's the first step and then hopefully build on it. So what's the reception been like amongst the community? I saw the signing and all of that. It's gotten some good reports in the trades and things. I'm sure people are thrilled.
Brian Ralston (16:36):
I think people are very thrilled. I think there's a little skepticism in how much is 10 million going to help us. But again, once we start collecting this data, once there are some use cases that we can point to and say that this actually helped generate this and this for this project and that project, I think that's a good place to start.
Bishop Porter (16:55):
Exactly. Yeah. It's always good to have these positive things because everyone's been hurting. So when you have something feels like, okay, we're moving in the right direction. Even when they bumped up the overall incentive to 750, we didn't think that would happen, right?
Brian Ralston (17:07):
In contrast to that, remember this post-production standalone bill doesn't require you shoot in California. That's the whole point. So we want that James Bond film that creatively needs to go all around the world and shoot to come back to California for post. That's probably the biggest single difference in how it's structured is post-production is its own kind of thing. These jobs are not short-term jobs that assemble on a set for 28 days and go away. These are career jobs of people in post houses that have families here and have lived here for decades. And those are the jobs that we're actually supporting with a post only bill. It's a different kind of career we're supporting, as opposed to these crews that crew up for a shoot and then all dissolve and go away. So these are post houses and entities and composers and musicians that live here, have careers here.
(18:04):
It's a different infrastructure. And if we lose that, if the musicians start moving to Nashville or London or whatever because that's where the work is going, then we lose access to all this talent.
Bishop Porter (18:14):
Yeah. And the community that LA was built on is such a huge part. Yeah. So that being said, how long do you typically work on a project as a composer?
Brian Ralston (18:25):
If someone asks me, how long does it take you to do the score? I'll say, well, how much time do you have?
Bishop Porter (18:28):
Oh, really?
Brian Ralston (18:30):
That's how much time it takes. So not my best window of time I can remember, but I've done a score in about five days.
Bishop Porter (18:38):
Really? Do you remember which project that was?
Brian Ralston (18:40):
Yeah, it was a film called Don't Fade Away with Ryan Quan and Misha Barton and Bo Bridges. Never been shown in North America. It was released in Australia. So I would love to have six weeks.
Bishop Porter (18:50):
And what's your instrument of choice or do you play many?
Brian Ralston (18:53):
I play trumpet piano, but I mostly write for others to play now. I don't really get to play like I used to in college. But yeah, and that's the fun of it is every film is different. This one might be electronic, this one might be rock and roll, this one might be orchestral. And I think that's fun to figure out my own way to use these different ensembles.
Bishop Porter (19:12):
Okay. What about you, Ben? Typically, how long are you on in a post-production cycle?
Ben Urquhart (19:17):
Well, when a script lands on my desk, it's typically getting 26 weeks of post.
Bishop Porter (19:24):
So half a year?
Ben Urquhart (19:25):
Yeah. And that's what's really interesting about these jobs is that they really are these long jobs where you are collecting real payroll information and you understand what's going on here. And as a studio, accumulating this data is essential to making further business plans, which is how we kind of land on the, it's going to be 26 weeks. And then of course, everyone wants that to go lower and fewer people and so on and so forth. And that's the joy of making films. It's all a negotiation. Indeed. Yeah.
Bishop Porter (19:58):
And you hire a team in your role.
Ben Urquhart (20:00):
That's right.
Bishop Porter (20:01):
About how many people do you typically bring on?
Ben Urquhart (20:03):
It depends on the film, but five to 12 and sometimes going way up if you start to include visual effects people or your sound.
Bishop Porter (20:12):
Can you share a project you've worked on recently that we would have seen in the theater?
Ben Urquhart (20:16):
The last film that I worked on at Universal, which is the movie Strays, it is an R-rated talking animal film with Will Ferrell and Jamie Fox. It's directed by Josh Greenbaum. It is a technical marvel that no one knows about. Getting the dogs to talk correctly is really tricky and making their mouths work. But the way that we ended up shooting it was we used, I believe it was 6K cameras and we used the full frame and every single shot was a repo to get the dog, basically to make our animal actors more believable. It was such an incredible amount of work. It was essentially a live action animation. Every shot is a visual effect, removing handlers and people and adding the mouth things, and it is drop dead funny. It is one of the funniest and raunchiest - I
Bishop Porter (21:09):
Believe
Ben Urquhart (21:09):
It.
Bishop Porter (21:10):
Will Ferrell and Jamie Fox.
Ben Urquhart (21:11):
That's right. Yes. And we were doing that in the middle of COVID. So in fact, when we did our first pass of line readings, we were at Evergreen, which is a music recording studio, in the big room, and our actors were 50 feet away from each other, but just so they could see each other because it was COVID and we had to keep that social distancing and it was really tricky. But the movie, it's so ridiculously funny. It's what I love about the making of movies is that so much raw material goes into the engine and post-production is a place where it gets refined into jewels. It's been an honor to be a part of this California Post Alliance to really speak to those jewel makers out there and represent them here.
Bishop Porter (22:00):
Well, we got it. We'll fix it in post.
Ben Urquhart (22:02):
That's right.
Bishop Porter (22:03):
That's a tall order, but everyone says it probably on every project.
Brian Ralston (22:07):
I don't know if Benny, if you experienced this in post or not with COVID, but I found that first year of COVID actually didn't impact me like everyone else because we get everything at the end. So I was still actually getting... There were two films I did during that year of COVID for music that were shot pre - COVID, and they were kind of in editing, COVID thing, everything shut down. They finished their editing a little one person in an edit bay and whatever. And then when it got to me, yeah, we had to do some recording things differently, but there was still product coming to post that was already shot. The COVID hole of work for me was delayed by a couple years to then all of a sudden we get into 23, let's say, and production is ramping up. We figured out how to do this.
(22:55):
We have COVID safety officers on set, all this stuff. And now I'm sitting around waiting for -
Bishop Porter (23:02):
Without much work.
Brian Ralston (23:03):
Without much work, because I got to wait for that stuff to go through the pipeline. So music, I think, was almost a delayed reaction from COVID.
Bishop Porter (23:11):
That makes sense. Yeah. And was it the same with the strikes for 23? So that was resolved in October, and then you think, okay, the writers' rooms are back open, things are going to start moving. But the post teams, y'all saw work in March maybe? I don't know.
Ben Urquhart (23:25):
Even later than that. Really? Because Brian's describing this horrible double dip where the COVID stopped us, but we still had material coming through. We kind of got ourselves up and running, figured out how to work. It is hard to sound mix. We're used to being together on a stage. That's part of how you get the movie away from a director is you all gather and you have a slow intervention called the final mix. But yet then when the strikes came, we just dropped even further and well, here we are.
Brian Ralston (23:58):
That's also when the overseas things can even further take hold because yeah, we're on a strike here, but there's still content being produced in the world and they're figuring out, okay, we already bought the script. We don't need to have a writer do whatever. Where can we now go that we're not impacted by this? And the SAG stuff makes that hard, let's say, from an actor perspective. But from a post perspective, if there's other ways or other places to shoot, they go there for work. I know the orchestras during COVID overseas just came back up and were recording in a room altogether way differently than we were here. And everybody's like, "Well, I'm not unsure about this, how we're putting everyone so far away in this car. If I go to Vienna, it's like normal orchestra. They're back to normal working." So we almost trained the policy of how that all changed how we work, trained other places to step up.
(24:54):
And it wasn't just a rebate thing, it was just the fact that they were working again. So there's a perfect storm of events here that's helped producers and production companies, especially Indy, that aren't signatories already, let's say. Where can we go elsewhere to get this done? And the more work they do elsewhere, the better they get.
Bishop Porter (25:12):
And that's all facets, all departments across the board. Just to kind of wrap up, what do you guys see the next thing that needs to happen in the community just to keep things strong, to keep the impetus going, building on what we started?
Ben Urquhart (25:25):
I mean, we need to aggressively pursue expanding this credit and making it bigger. And I think that really is about more of the same, but at more scale. We are a membership-driven organization. We need members, we need corporate members, we need people to be out there and to take some time to unlock themselves from competing. I mean, it's how we have the best talent in the world, but we need everybody to unlock a little bit from competing and pour a little energy onto building this bigger and stronger because it will be oversubscribed and we are really at a crisis point. I mean, I'm glad we were able to deliver some good news. All of this federal credit movement feels really good, I have to say. I just saw on the news today that New York posted a film production quarter of 1.6 billion versus hours of 1.7 billion.
(26:25):
And of course, the social media world is on fire with we're giving up our crown and we should not do that. And we have the opportunity to pull that back and knock these people off the throne and show them how it's done.
Bishop Porter (26:41):
And New York has a better credit when you compare apples to apples.
Ben Urquhart (26:46):
The New York Post Alliance or the Post New York Alliance is a sister organization of ours. It was Jennifer Freed is one of our core members. Yes.
Bishop Porter (26:58):
The legend, Jennifer Freed.
Ben Urquhart (27:00):
Jennifer is a part of both. And look, they got their credit in 16 years ago and look what it's done for them. So look, that's good news. Let's follow suit and maybe go a little faster.
Bishop Porter (27:13):
Look at their metrics, get what their numbers say. Yeah.
Brian Ralston (27:16):
My message that I say to all my friends and union friends and production friends, don't now get complacent to sit back and think that we got this rebate, even though I know we need to push for the funding and add a zero to that, but we got this rebate, now we can just sit back and work. You still need to compete globally for this work in every aspect of what you offer. So the contracts need to be competitive. The experience of working here needs to be a second to none. The people have to want to come here because we can't just rely on a rebate. Again, it's giving us some parity, but it's not the only part of the math equation that a producer is looking at. And I'm glad we have it. We absolutely need it. But there may be other things that say, "Yeah, but I still enjoy recording this score in London, or I still want to do this for this reason or that reason." We need to compete all across the board and not get complacent with just now sitting back and going, "Oh, we fixed it." We still need to address our contracts.
(28:21):
We still need to have a better experience. We still need to pump out the best work that Hollywood knows how to do.
Bishop Porter (28:26):
Yep. With all the talent that we have in the city.
Brian Ralston (28:28):
Absolutely.
Bishop Porter (28:29):
Yeah, in this part. Well, that's great. Appreciate y'all both coming. We look forward to what's next with the program.
Brian Ralston (28:35):
Thank
Ben Urquhart (28:35):
You.
Brian Ralston (28:35):
Thanks for having us.