The Clinical Excellence Podcast

How can writing and theater enrich the lives of doctors and the communities they serve? Dr. Adam Cifu welcomes Dr. Doriane Miller, a University of Chicago professor of medicine, playwright, and co-founder of the Wellness Resilience Arts Program (WRAP) for youth. Drawing on her work with patients and her experience writing plays, Dr. Miller explores the power of stories to make people feel heard and understood. Their conversation considers what feeds a physician’s soul, how patient relationships help doctors weather demanding work, and why seeing our lives reflected onstage can open a path toward healing.
https://urbangateways.org/the-joy-in-resiliency-wrap/

What is The Clinical Excellence Podcast?

The Clinical Excellent Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum Institute for Clinical Excellence is a biweekly podcast hosted by Drs. Adam Cifu and Matthew Sorrentino. The podcast has three formats: discussions between doctors and patients, discussions with authors of research pertinent to improving clinical care and the doctor-patient relationship and discussions with physicians about challenges in the doctor-patient relationship or in the life of a physician.

[00:00:00] Dr. Cifu: On today's episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast, I'm joined by Doriane Miller talking about the humanities in medicine.

[00:00:13] Dr. Miller: I actually think that it may lead to other things as physicians. It may be one of the reasons why some of our colleagues have gone into concierge medicine. And the reason why is because oftentimes if you don't have things that will feed your soul, it will lead to burnout.

[00:00:41] Dr. Cifu: Welcome to season five of The Clinical Excellence Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence. On this podcast, we speak to patients and doctors about all aspects of clinical medicine. I'm Adam Cifu, and today I'm joined by Dr. Doriane Miller. Dr. Miller is a professor of medicine at the University of Chicago. She received her medical degree from the University of Chicago and completed a primary care internal medicine residency and general medicine clinical epidemiology fellowship at the University of California, San Francisco. She is the inaugural director of the Center for Community Health and Vitality at the University of Chicago. The center's mission is to improve population health outcomes for residents on the South Side of Chicago through community-engaged research, demonstration, and service models. Dr. Miller joined the University in January of 2009. Prior to joining U of C, she served as national director of New Health Partnerships, a demonstration project funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the California Healthcare Foundation, focused on collaborative self-management support.

In the past, Dr. Miller's work in improving asthma outcomes through school and community interventions was noted by the American Academy of Asthma, Allergy, and Immunology with a 2006 Special Recognition Award. Apropos of today's conversation, Dr. Miller is the author of two plays: It Should Have Been Me, addressing the issue of adolescent depression in the face of community violence, and Wish You Were Here, which addresses the recognition of intimate partner violence.

Doriane is a treasured colleague of mine and a sympathetic ear for when the burdens of the job get to me. I think I waste a lot of her time in clinic.

Doriane, thank you so much for joining me today.

This season, we're talking to people who have incorporated the humanities, really broadly defined, into their work in medicine. You've certainly done that with your writing in multiple genres. So, really, thanks for taking the time to chat with me.

[00:02:45] Dr. Miller: Oh, it's a pleasure being here with you today.

[00:02:48] Dr. Cifu: So I'm going to start, like, really broadly, and just sort of ask you why you write. I, you know, did not know about your playwriting and was, like, thrilled to get to actually watch one of them on YouTube. You've shared some of your sort of personal reflective writings with me in the past. We actually led a little writers' group in the past, and just sort of wanted to know, like, why do you do that? Is it therapeutic for you? Is it an extension of your work as a physician? Sort of where does that come from?

[00:03:19] Dr. Miller: My interest in writing comes from, I think, the opportunity to reflect upon the stories that people have shared with me as a physician. I've been a primary care doctor at this point for more than thirty years, and I've heard lots and lots of stories over that time. And although most people think when they become a physician that it's going to be about the science, and the investigation, and figuring out the cure and being whatever, whether it be from the 1960s and Ben Casey, [unintelligible], House, which was a really different kind of a physician in terms of his particular story, that in many ways it really is about the stories that people tell us in their day-to-day lives. Some of us, and I thought about this when I decided to go into medicine and when I was much, much younger, and thought about this from the perspective of science and that, you know, microscopes are really neat and you can see all of these incredible things when you look at things on a slide, and the science behind it, but I think that the real beauty of what we do as physicians is to think about how the stories that people tell us translate into ways in which we can hopefully find ways to help them. And you may say, "Well, okay, that's what primary care docs do," or, "That's what psychiatrists do," but actually, it applies to other professions within medicine as well.

[00:04:54] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:04:55] Dr. Miller: Even in pathology, the pathologist needs to start with a clinical story in order to make sure that they're making the appropriate interpretation of what they're seeing on the slide. Radiologists, the same thing. Surgeons, the same thing.

And so I think that the crux of the matter is how do we think about the story, the interpretation of that story, and how does that filter into what we do as physicians on a day-to-day basis?

[00:05:21] Dr. Cifu: Let me, um, two questions kind of come to mind. I'm going to ask the one that's maybe more, you know, on subject of what we're talking about, and then one which is a little bit off, you know, off the thread. Thinking about the stories and thinking about what's important about, you know, tackling them in writing or other sort of health humanities work, I have certainly found in my own work that I think about these things, I talk about them with friends, colleagues, families, obviously, in a HIPAA-compliant way, but it is often sitting down and, you know, trying to write something and trying to edit something that actually really gets me to understand it. Is that true for you? And if so, why do you think that is?

[00:06:12] Dr. Miller: It's true to some extent in that it takes a while sometimes to process some of the depth of the stories and what this means within the context of my patients' life, but also, being able to take those stories and to reflect upon them in terms of what's happening in the broader society.

[00:06:31] Dr. Cifu: Sure.

[00:06:31] Dr. Miller: And so that's actually been a part of what I've been able to do in thinking about this over my career, in that we have such a privilege to do the work that we do, but the individual story is applicable to thousands, to ten thousands, to millions of people who are out there, and oftentimes, they don't have a voice or a vehicle to share their stories with one another.

[00:06:58] Dr. Cifu: Right.

[00:06:58] Dr. Miller: And so I think that the humanities, whether it be through... Some people express this through visual arts, some people express this through writing, gives the opportunity to share this, to say, "I am here, and you are here, and we share things in common." And the ability to process those things through an artistic framework, I think, for me, speaks to the humanity of how we are in this world.

[00:07:25] Dr. Cifu: That's so well said. Okay, this is a totally off-topic one, so have patience with me. You know, you talked about how important stories are to medicine, which I completely agree, and I also agree that it's not just the kind of generalist primary care people; it's really everybody. We are lucky to practice in a time where we have a lot of, you know, healthcare professional colleagues who are not doctors, right? Nurses, physical therapy, chaplains, you know, whatever. And I feel like although that is a terrific thing for patient care, I think it has given the opportunity for physicians to outsource that, right? Very often on the inpatient service, there's a temptation to say, "Oh, that's for the social worker," or, "That's for the case manager to take care of."

[00:08:20] Dr. Miller: Mm-hmm.

[00:08:20] Dr. Cifu: And I'm torn that maybe that's improved care, but it's also maybe made our professions have the potential to be a little bit less rich, um, and maybe to make us a little worse at our jobs. Do you think that's true? Is there any truth to that?

[00:08:36] Dr. Miller: I actually think that it may lead to other things as physicians, and may be one of the reasons why some of our colleagues have gone into concierge medicine.

[00:08:44] Dr. Cifu: Interesting.

[00:08:45] Dr. Miller: And the reason why is because oftentimes if you don't have things that will feed your soul, it will lead to burnout.

[00:08:52] Dr. Cifu: Right.

[00:08:53] Dr. Miller: And it's more than about the logistical paperwork things. Sometimes having the richness of those stories and those interactions helps you to bear the burden of some of the things that are a little bit less pleasant in terms of what we do on a day-to-day basis.

[00:09:08] Dr. Cifu: That's interesting. You know, I've thought about that evolution in terms of, you know, are we selecting the wrong people to medicine? Are we, you know, are we taking people who are too smart, too well-rounded, have too many interests, who are not satisfied just doing medicine?

I actually like the way you talk about it 'cause it strikes me as a little bit more optimistic, that what's happened is that we've narrowed what we consider medicine, and therefore people are less satisfied with it because it's not sort of, you know, pushing all those buttons that need to be pushed for an individual.

[00:09:44] Dr. Miller: Yeah.

[00:09:46] Dr. Cifu: So the answer to this may be obvious, but I still need to answer it. You know, there are people who have hobbies in medicine that they will say, "Besides keeping me a happy functional person, it doesn't really affect how I do my job." When you think about your work in sort of healthcare humanities, does that feed back and affect how you practice medicine? Do you think that changes the way you practice? Do you think about your works when you're teaching or caring for people?

[00:10:19] Dr. Miller: When I'm giving lectures to medical students, even to early-stage investigators that are doing research, I include patient-related stories in those particular talks because I think that for me, it helps to center the reason why people are doing this work in the first place.

And so, in talking with medical students who, you know, they think of themselves as pluripotent stem cells for many — not necessarily all, but for many — and they're figuring out, "Okay, what's it going to be in terms of my future specialty?" Well, there are opportunities to think about what that specialty might be within the context of why you decided to come here in the first place.

[00:11:01] Dr. Cifu: Definitely. So it was sort of a perfect transition to what I was going to ask you next. You know, we all spend a lot of time with students, trainees, young doctors, and I wonder, for people who find working in the humanities an important part of their career, do you think that it's sort of important that we expose everybody to it? You know, the people who are growing into their field? We certainly can't demand, like, "You need to be a poet, you need to be a writer, you need to be an artist," but is it important for people to see that as an option or should we, you know, almost suggest that people find something related to medicine that they work in? Or is this a very personal, kind of idiosyncratic interest that some people will have and some people won't have?

[00:11:54] Dr. Miller: I think that people need to remember what they bring into the profession from their personal perspectives. And for some people, that may be all about the science, but there may be people who have had found pleasure in doing other things, whether it be playing the violin, whether it be going to the theater, whether it be participating in the humanities in one way or another, in that we don't just bring our left-brain science into the profession.

But I think that the beauty of it is that we are able to think about this from the interactions that we have with people and bringing that piece in. And so oftentimes, it's a question of not only feeding the soul but also healing the soul, if you think about it in that regard. Some of the people that have done this in the extreme, I think about... I think his name, if I remember correctly, the poet William Carlos Wilson.

[00:12:54] Dr. Cifu: Sure. Williams.

[00:12:54] Dr. Miller: Williams, thank you. As a poet, I also think about David Feldshuh, who wrote Miss Evers' Boys, the play around the Tuskegee syphilis experiments, and how he's been able to blend both work in the theater and to bring in the medical lens into his work. So the question of how we think about the role of healer, whether it be role of healer as a shaman, the role of healer as a cleric, but the people who we encounter want to make sure that their stories are heard, how that information is interpreted, and how we relate to one another on a person-to-person basis.

The other thing for me, and you may be getting to this in a little while, is that taking, for me, taking that interest and then applying it to other areas of how people can see themselves and to actually think about how they can heal. Theater is a very ancient profession. It goes all the way back to the ancient Greeks. And oftentimes when people would go to the theater and the forum and listen to the chorus and then see various things acted out that perhaps reflected their day-to-day lives, but it was done at an arm's length, that they were more accepting of taking in those messages in that format rather than seeing what they're seeing up close and personal.

[00:14:22] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:14:23] Dr. Miller: So that's one of the things that led me not only to write both of the plays that you mentioned in the introduction but also to co-found an organization for youth who are struggling with issues around violence in the community. And it's not an organization; it's actually a summer program called WRAP, or the Wellness Resilience Arts Program.

[00:14:46] Dr. Cifu: I like the way you talk about the sort of, it's almost, you know, a balance in your life of these other things which you do strikes me as, as you know, an anti-burnout medicine. It's also nice because I always get sort of my hackles up when people talk about life-work balance, 'cause I tend to think, like, you know, it's all one thing, and it's figuring out how you can make everything work for you.

And boy, you know, the way you describe it is perfect for that because yes, you have things outside your work but help your work. You have things within your work which support other parts of your life; it's kind of wonderful. Getting completely away from medicine, I like the way you talk about the long history of theater.

For some reason, I have always found that some of our arts, visual arts, writing, storytelling, music, as I completely understand as, like, a human thing, that I understand why, you know, the first humans, whatever, 50,000 years ago would be doing this. Theater has always sort of confused me in a way because it is, you know, a more complex thing.

We're going to think about parts of our life, and then we're going to, you know, react them out, right? And theater, I think, for the most part, is you're doing it for somebody else, right? You have conversations with friends, which could be theater, but it's only really theater if other people are watching you.

[00:16:26] Dr. Miller: Mm-hmm.

[00:16:27] Dr. Cifu: And the way you describe it does give me some insight into why this is maybe more of, you know, of an innate human art than I have always thought it. You described it as almost, you know, feeding back experiences to people so maybe they can, I don't know, process them in a different way than they process them in their real life. Is that-

[00:16:50] Dr. Miller: That's a part of it.

[00:16:51] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:16:51] Dr. Miller: I think that's a big part of it. Although I mentioned the two plays that I've written around health-related topics here in the intro, I actually caught a bit of a bug, and so I've written another play that's based on...

[00:17:07] Dr. Cifu: You're totally a masochist, right?

[00:17:08] Dr. Miller: Oh, totally. Totally. And someone asked me, "When do you sleep?" And I said, "I sleep. I sleep quite well, but I portion out, you know, parts of my day in life, and week in order to be able to pursue some of these things." It's about the stories around the Great Migration and generational stories around healing, and loss, and trauma associated with the Great Migration. Had the opportunity to have a staged reading of that play a couple years ago at a local university. And it was very interesting. It was presented in front of a drama class. And as the people in the audience watched it and then we did a talk-back afterwards, which was supposed to be a critique of the play, some of them sat there and said, "Oh my gosh! That's my so-and-so!"

[00:18:03] Dr. Cifu: Right, right, right.

[00:18:04] Dr. Miller: And they were able to see parts of their family history in pieces of the characters that were presented. And so it was fascinating to see that reflection of someone actually being to say, "Somebody knows my story."

[00:18:23] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:18:24] Dr. Miller: And the story was worth telling.

[00:18:26] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:18:26] Dr. Miller: Yeah.

[00:18:27] Dr. Cifu: That's a great way to say it, 'cause I have had that experience where, boy, I identify with what I'm seeing, not personally, but from sort of family history, family lore, but in a way that's much different about, you know, a grandparent telling you of it, who, you know, is not a professional storyteller, may not as be, you know, may not be articulate as much as a playwright, and where, you know, you have to sort of put your own feeling into their story. And often when that story is presented to you by strangers, written by a stranger, you know, it can actually be even more powerful than hearing it from relatives. That's a neat way of thinking about it.

[00:19:13] Dr. Miller: The issue of empathy, and empathy from the perspective of putting yourself in someone else's shoes is part of that craft.

[00:19:22] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.

[00:19:23] Dr. Miller: And being able to tell that through the story, at least in my experience of having written, at this point, it's actually more than three plays. It's four plays, and then I'm working on another one, which is also more of a personal story, that it is the filtering and interpretation of what you're seeing. Thinking about yourself in someone else's shoes helps you to develop characters that are authentic and relatable.

If I could just add a little bit about the program that's called WRAP. It's a program that's done in partnership with the Logan Center for the Arts at the University of Chicago. It's a four-week program where we have youth between the ages of 13 and 18 to come in and to work with trauma-informed teaching artists and social workers in a variety of artistic expressions: visual arts, African dance and drumming, poetry and spoken word, and also filmmaking with a capstone. So, that's part of the gift.

[00:20:24] Dr. Cifu: So Doriane, thank you so much. You kicked off the season of the humanities in medicine, and I think this was a wonderful, very broad look at it all. So thank you for your time.

[00:20:35] Dr. Miller: Thank you so much.

[00:20:37] Dr. Cifu: Thanks for joining us for this episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast.

We're sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence at the University of Chicago. Please feel free to reach out to us with your thoughts and ideas via the institute webpage, bucksbauminstitute.uchicago.edu.

The music for The Clinical Excellence Podcast is courtesy of Dr. Maylyn Martinez.