Discover fast-paced, binge-worthy American history through short historical stories of exceptional American heroes. Each episode delivers accurate historical narratives that bring legendary and forgotten heroes to life.
These are real stories and this is my real voice.
Who am I? I am just a regular American dad, who loves our rich history and doesn’t want these stories to be forgotten.
New episodes every other Wednesday.
Follow me on X for daily stories from American History: https://x.com/HistoryWJacob
Episode 8: Hannah Duston: A Frontier Mother's Revenge
Attention Parents who are listening with children:
Please know that this episode contains disturbing violent acts that are shocking to modern listeners from life on the American frontier.
Listener discretion advised.
Thank you. Now on to the story.
INTRO:
She stood over her sleeping captors, gripping a tomahawk in her right hand as they lay quietly in front of a dying fire.
The island wind sent a chill down her spine.
Her hands were sweaty, her heart pounding so loudly she was afraid it would wake them.
She had never killed before.
But her mind raced back to when the Abenaki warrior tore her six-day-old baby from her arms...and smashed the helpless child against a tree.
She tightened her grip on the hatchet, and gave the signal.
This mother would have her revenge.
This is the story of Hannah Duston.
ACT ONE:
1697. Haverhill, Massachusetts.
The American frontier was a dangerous and chaotic place to live. Native American raids were a constant threat. The ignition of King William’s War between France and England only escalated the situation. French-allied war parties came down out of Canada to raid the English settlements strung along the New England rivers.
On March 15th, in the early morning chill, Abenaki warriors poured out of the trees and fell on the settlement of Haverhill. War whoops filled the air. Homes set ablaze. Livestock seized. Twenty-seven of the neighbors were killed. More than a dozen others were seized to be carried north.
Thomas Duston was working on his farm when he saw them coming.
He had to make an impossible choice in a split second. His wife was inside, in bed. She had given birth just six days before. There were eight children scattered across the property, aged 2 to 17.
He could not save everyone.
Thomas managed to gather seven of the children, covering their retreat on horseback with his musket, as they escaped to the garrison. But he left his wife and newborn daughter behind. It was the hardest thing a man could ever do.
His wife was Hannah Duston. Born and raised in Haverhill. Now a forty-year-old with her newborn daughter, Martha, in her arms. A neighbor, Mary Neff who had helped nurse her through the birth was with them.
The raiders took both women and baby Martha..and burned everything else.
Then, the long walk north began.
The march was brutal from the first step. Hannah was half-dressed against the March cold, her body still recovering from giving birth, and only one shoe protecting her feet from the harsh forest floor. The captives who could not keep the pace were either killed along the trail or left to die in the dark, unforgiving woods.
And early on that march came the moment that would define the rest of Hannah Duston's life.
An Abenaki warrior tore Martha from her arms, and flung the baby against a tree. A captured infant was considered a burden to a nomadic tribe.
Hannah had never felt more helpless. She could not fight. She could not run. She could only keep walking. Deeper into the wilderness, replaying the memory in her mind. Her hatred and resolve grew with every step.
Whatever she had been before that morning, she was something else now.
A mother hellbent on revenge.
ACT TWO:
They walked for two weeks.
Over a hundred miles through untamed forest, up frozen rivers, away from everything Hannah had ever known. The raiding party broke apart along the way, splitting into smaller bands and scattering into the wild of New Hampshire.
Hannah and Mary Neff were handed off to a single family group. And with that group was a third captive who would prove pivotal to the grieving mother.
His name was Samuel Lennardson. He was only about fourteen, an English child who had been taken from Worcester more than a year before. He had lived among the Abenaki long enough to learn their language and their ways. Long enough that they no longer watched him as closely.
Samuel told Hannah that when they reached the Native settlement to the north, the prisoners would be stripped, and forced to run between two lines of warriors who would beat them with thorny blackberry branches as they struggled through. A terrifying gauntlet.
Hannah knew her odds of surviving that brutal ritual were not high.
She resolved that no one was coming to rescue her. There would be no ransom in time. Every mile carried her farther from home and closer to the end.
If she was going to live, she would have to save herself.
And she was going to have to do something that no one would expect from a forty-year-old mother, still recovering from childbirth.
She began to watch her captors closely. When they slept. How deeply. How many?
And where did they keep those hatchets?
ACT THREE:
Fifteen days after her capture, on the night of March 30, the twelve member group camped on a small island, where the Contoocook River empties into the Merrimack, near what is now Penacook New Hampshire.
The Abenaki thought it was safe there. They were deep in their own country, far from any English town, with three helpless captives who had not given them any trouble yet.
That was their first mistake.
Hannah’s plan was almost complete, but it was missing a crucial piece. She took Samuel into her confidence and requested his help.
The young boy was all in.
Samuel, trusted and left to his own devices, went to one of the Native Americans and simply asked him to show the best way to kill a person with a tomahawk, and how to take the scalp afterward.
And the warrior, suspecting nothing from a boy who had lived among them for a year, showed him exactly how. All while Hannah, from a distance, watched his every move.
This was the Abenaki’s second mistake.
In the black hour before dawn, Hannah, Mary, and Samuel rose quietly in the dark. They stole the sleeping camp's own hatchets. And they struck.
With baby Martha’s final cries echoing in her ears, Hannah swung.
With a vision of everything she loved set ablaze, Mary swung.
Remembering his mother’s cries as he was torn away from her, Samuel swung too, killing the same man who had just taught him how to use the axe.
It was fast, and it was ruthless. Ten of their captors lay dead. Men, women and children alike. They, like the killers who took them, showed no mercy.
Two got away. One woman, badly wounded, escaped into the dark. And one young boy fled too, running madly into the trees.
Hannah, Mary and Samuel rushed to the water, piled into a canoe and pushed off into the river.
But Hannah stopped.
She knew that three ragged captives, two of them women, would come home with a story no one would believe. She needed proof of her escape.
So she turned the canoe around and went back to the lifeless bodies on the island. One by one, she scalped all ten of them and carried the scalps with her down the river
She had come north as a prisoner with a newborn baby in her arms.
She was going home as an avenged mother, who could never be the same.
ACT FOUR:
The journey home was its own ordeal.
The three avengers traveled by night and hid by day, slipping down the Merrimack through enemy country on the stolen canoe. Along the way, they found shelter for a night at the home of a settler named John Lovewell, then pushed on, finishing the last stretch on foot.
On April 21, more than a month after she had been dragged from her burning home, Hannah Duston walked back into Haverhill. Alive. And carrying ten scalps.
Hannah embraced her husband for the first time since the raid, shaking with relief and exhaustion. She was finally home.
Thomas took her, along with Mary Neff and young Samuel, on to Boston. The old bounty the colony had paid for enemy scalps had lapsed the year before. But when the leaders of Massachusetts heard the story, and saw the proof she laid before them, the General Court awarded the bounties.
And that story spread through the frontier like wildfire.
The illustrious preacher Cotton Mather told it from the pulpit and in print. He compared Hannah Duston to Jael, the woman from the Book of Judges who drove a stake through the skull of an enemy general while he slumbered.
Mather wrote:
“One of these women took up a Resolution, to Imitate the Action of Jael upon Sisera...to take away the Life of the Murderers, by whom her Child had been butchered.”
Hannah was an instrument of divine justice, delivered from her enemies and avenged upon them.
The grieving mother from a frontier town quickly became a legend throughout Puritan New England.
CLOSER:
Hannah Duston stayed in Haverhill the rest of her life. About a year and a half after the raid, she gave birth to another daughter, Lydia, who got the opportunity at life that was taken from baby Martha. Lydia married at 23 and raised nearly a dozen children of her own, affording Hannah the chance to dote on them as a grandmother.
Hannah breathed her last around 1736, nearly forty years after the fateful night on the island.
But her story did not die with her.
Some 150 years later, in 1874, the town of Boscawen, New Hampshire, raised a statue of Hannah Duston near the island on which her legacy was wrought. She stands with a tomahawk in one hand and the fistful of scalps in the other. It is widely considered the first statue in America honoring a woman.
You can visit the monument today and see the place where she made her escape.
Where a frontier mother became a hatchet-wielding woman who avenged her newborn tenfold.
CTA:
If you liked this story, please subscribe, and leave a 5 star rating and a review. It helps more people hear these forgotten stories. You can find me on X, Facebook, and Instagram at History With Jacob.
Next episode will cover Washington’s Immortals: The Maryland 400. Weeks after the Declaration of Independence, the entire American army was trapped. The Revolution was almost over as soon as it began. But these brave boys from Maryland kept the cause alive.
Don’t miss it, but until then, stay legendary.