The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Your Patient's Face Might Be Causing Their Sleep Problem, with Dr Dave Singh | PDP253
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Dave Singh on craniofacial sleep medicine: why the jaw is retruded, sleep apnoea endotypes, UARS, and palatal expansion in adults.
URL SLUG:
patients-face-causing-sleep-problem-craniofacial-sleep-medicine
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Craniofacial sleep medicine for dentists
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- What is craniofacial sleep medicine?
- Obstructive sleep apnoea isn't just in older, overweight men
- Do mandibular advancement devices work for everyone?
- Endotypes of obstructive sleep apnoea
- Upper airway resistance syndrome (UARS)
- Sleep bruxism and tooth wear
- Palatal expansion in adults for sleep apnoea
- Screening dental patients for sleep-disordered breathing
YOUR PATIENT'S FACE MIGHT BE CAUSING THEIR SLEEP PROBLEM
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP253
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR DAVE SINGH
EPISODE SUMMARY
On this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Dr Dave Singh, a UK-trained orthodontist and former professor of sleep medicine at Stanford, about craniofacial sleep medicine. Rather than simply bringing the jaw forward with a mandibular advancement device, Dave describes an aetiology-based approach that asks why the mandible is retruded in the first place, starting with the cranial base and the midface. He discloses that he invented the DNA appliance, founded Vivos and now runs REMA Sleep.
They discuss how development and epigenetic factors, such as breastfeeding and diet, may affect the face; the four endotypes of obstructive sleep apnoea; screening and referral; upper airway resistance syndrome; sleep bruxism; CPAP; and Dave's view that the palate can be expanded in adults without splitting the suture. Dave also outlines his diagnostic protocol. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is that sleep apnoea isn't a "fat old man" disease, so every patient should be asked about their breathing and sleep.
IN SHORT
Dr Dave Singh argues that sleep-disordered breathing often has an anatomical cause, such as an underdeveloped midface or narrow, high palate, so dentists should look beyond mandibular advancement devices and ask why the airway is compromised. He stresses that diagnosis must come from a physician, and that dentists should work closely with sleep and ENT colleagues.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Jaz's pearl: sleep apnoea isn't a "fat old man" disease, so ask every patient about their breathing and sleep.
- Dave says mandibular advancement opens the airway in only about a third to a half of patients.
- His aetiology-based approach asks why the mandible is retruded, starting with the cranial base and midface.
- He describes four endotypes of sleep apnoea: craniofacial, neurological, metabolic and muscular.
- Upper airway resistance syndrome can cause symptoms even when the AHI is normal.
- Sleep disorders must be diagnosed by a physician, so build relationships with sleep and ENT colleagues.
- Dave believes the palate can be expanded in adults by stretching rather than splitting the suture; this is debated.
- His diagnostic protocol uses photos, a sleep study, CBCT and intermolar width measurements.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. What is craniofacial sleep medicine?
2. Do mandibular advancement devices work for everyone?
3. Why might a patient's mandible be retruded?
4. What are the different endotypes of sleep apnoea?
5. What is upper airway resistance syndrome?
6. Is sleep bruxism linked to sleep apnoea?
7. Can the palate be expanded in adults?
8. How should dentists screen patients for sleep problems?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: what is craniofacial sleep medicine?
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: sleep apnoea isn't a "fat old man" disease
3. Meet Professor Dave Singh
4. What do teeth and sleep have in common?
5. Do mandibular advancement devices work for everyone?
6. An aetiology-based approach: why is the mandible retruded?
7. The cranial base sets the pace for the face
8. Evolution, epigenetics and why our teeth got bigger
9. The four endotypes of sleep apnoea
10. Screening, referral and diagnosis
11. Upper airway resistance syndrome
12. Tooth wear, bruxism and CPAP
13. Palatal expansion without splitting the suture
14. A diagnostic protocol, and malocclusion as adaptation
15. Professor Singh's UK course, and outro
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: WHAT IS CRANIOFACIAL SLEEP MEDICINE?
JAZ:
Welcome to the controversial world of airway and orthodontics. We are joined today by Dr Dave Singh. He's someone who's literally just finishing his tenure at Stanford University. He initially qualified in the UK and then moved to the States and worked with some of the biggest names in orthodontics. The title today is craniofacial sleep medicine. This episode is similar to the themes discussed in our episode with Dr Liz and Dr Megan, but it's not so much about the sleep studies like we've discussed before, or mandibular advancement devices, because the craniofacial sleep medicine element looks at anatomy.
So whilst in the dental sleep medicine world, we may help someone's sleep apnoea with either a CPAP machine or a mandibular advancement device to stop their jaw from falling back, allowing the patient to breathe better in their sleep, in this context that could be regarded as putting a plaster. It's treating the symptom, not the root cause, because the root cause could be anatomical. It could be a narrow maxilla, a high arch palate, a scalloped tongue that just does not have enough room.
And so this episode really does take an anatomical and epigenetic approach. You know, after we recorded, I was reading more about the orthodontic societies and what they believe. And actually there's a lot of friction or controversy about the kind of stuff that Dr Dave Singh discusses with us today. There is data and evidence for it, but one of the appliances that Dr Dave Singh invented expands the maxilla on adults.
And what I was taught when I was doing my diploma is that actually, you can't do that after a certain age. You can't expand the maxilla anymore. But Dr Dave Singh says you can. Even in adults, you can have significant structural change, enough to improve their breathing. Isn't that fascinating?
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: SLEEP APNOEA ISN'T A "FAT OLD MAN" DISEASE
JAZ:
Hello, Protruserati. I'm Jaz Gulati, and welcome back to your favourite dental podcast. I really want to dive into this hot topic, so I will just leave you with your Protrusive Dental Pearl. Every PDP episode I give you a pearl. The pearl is very simple and related to the topic in hand, and that is to get rid of this myth that obstructive sleep apnoea is a fat old man disease.
We used to think this, but it's not the case. A lot of the GPs I deal with still think this, but it's not the case. We need to be screening everyone for airway issues. We need to be asking about their breathing. We need to be asking about every patient's sleep. I've been sleep testing my patients for the last couple of years. It's been really fascinating, the conversations you learn about their sleep, and then you look at their anatomy and their sleepiness scale, or the impact that just even simple snoring, you know, simple snoring could be having on their partner.
And of course, many theories between obstructive sleep apnoea and bruxism. And actually Dr Dave Singh touches on that today. So once again, it's not a fat old man disease. Let's be visionary. This entire episode builds on that narrative and will give you so much more insight. So I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: MEET PROFESSOR DAVE SINGH
JAZ:
Professor Dave Singh, welcome to the Protrusive Dental Podcast. It's an absolute honour to host you. I've heard so many great things about you, and the topic we have is absolutely amazing because it's such a topic that confuses a lot of people. And you are very fascinating to me. You qualified in the UK and, from our pre-chat, you were essentially headhunted by the US. You started off as an associate professor.
Now you are a professor in the US. So please, for our listeners, can you introduce yourself and give us a taste of your journey? And especially I want to end with how you niched into sleep medicine before we then talk about craniofacial sleep medicine.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Well, Jaz, thank you for inviting me. It's great for me to be here and address a UK audience. Yeah, so it's a very long and interesting journey, and this was never planned. It just worked out that way. So yes, originally born in England, went to the US for a sabbatical, actually to Canada, and the Canadians sent me down to Michigan. And the long story short is that I visited the US as a visiting professor for about three years.
And eventually they sent me an invitation to relocate to the US as an associate professor. And the reason why I took that opportunity is because it was a centre for craniofacial disorders. It was a multidisciplinary team with the plastic surgeons, the orthodontists, a speech pathologist, all working together. And so it was unique in those days to have a craniofacial centre. And it was a lot of fun.
We were very successful there, and part of my findings during that time led me onto a sidetrack into sleep apnoea. And that's a long story in itself. But imagine the children with craniofacial anomalies such as Apert syndrome, Crouzon syndrome, and so on and so forth. In those days, we were doing a new technique called distraction osteogenesis, which is well known now. And what we were doing with these children is actually doing either midfacial distraction osteogenesis or mandibular distraction osteogenesis.
And part of my findings was that when you did this procedure, the airway behind the jaws increased in size phenomenally. And I thought that would be a great kind of approach to take to sleep apnoea if I could reproduce that non-surgically. And that's where my journey really started.
JAZ:
It was at a time where, I mean now we are learning more and more about this. This is practised more and more in general practice. I myself, I'm carrying out home sleep tests for my patients reported by a sleep clinician. Even now it's not even mainstream, especially not in the UK. I feel as though our colleagues in the US and Australia, from a UK perspective, I know you mentioned the UK, but we are a worldwide podcast, so a lot of countries that are a little bit behind when it comes to airway and generally sleep medicine.
So there's a lot to unpack and I really want to give everyone a flavour, but your background is like academic, not wet finger dentistry. And then you kind of fell into this niche of sleep medicine.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Yeah, so first of all, all my kind of qualifications were validated in the US. First of all, as a doctor of dental medicine. Second, I have a PhD in craniofacial cleft lip and palate. And that was done at Bristol, and part of that was Frenchay Hospital, Bristol. And then I did a third doctorate in orthodontics, a Doctor of Science in Orthodontics. So that's my basic training there.
I did start on the FDS pathway as well, but I got sidelined by my PhD and that kind of just took off, and I was really enjoying what I'm doing. So I stayed with the game, and that's what eventually brought me into the area of sleep medicine. Because at that time, people were talking about snoring and using a device to reposition the mandible. I'd done a lot of research on Twin Blocks and other devices as well, so I knew in a fair amount of detail how the Twin Block device works.
And so I thought to myself, and I also knew the downside of those techniques as well. And so I thought there has to be a slightly better solution. And that's what got me going in terms of developing these new ideas and approaches.
CHAPTER 4: WHAT DO TEETH AND SLEEP HAVE IN COMMON?
JAZ:
And so this leads nicely onto, there's a whole umbrella of sleep medicine, but then now it's like dental sleep medicine. We're putting the word dental in front of it, so to make it more applicable to us. So, Professor Singh, what do teeth and sleep have in common? Like, tell us about the links and why those dentists who perhaps are not doing screening, are not discussing sleep. What do you think should be our role in general dental care?
DR DAVE SINGH:
I'm a former professor in sleep medicine at Stanford. I actually finished there September of this year to focus on my new company, which is called REMA Sleep. So my disclosures are that I'm a founder of REMA Sleep and also the founder of Vivos. And Vivos was my company because I was the inventor of the DNA appliance, which was the first powerful expander to be FDA cleared for sleep apnoea in both children and adults.
And so when you think about craniofacial sleep medicine, we first of all think about the speciality of sleep medicine itself. And there are about 65 known sleep disorders and a few variants as well. And the one that the dental profession tends to focus on is sleep disordered breathing, and that kind of branches off into what you might call dental sleep medicine. In my experience, dental sleep medicine is mostly surrounded by mandibular advancement therapy.
It's mandibular manipulation, and that's a good tie-in with most general dentists, especially those that have a background in TMJ, TMD therapy. But of course, these mandibular devices are being used to treat both mild, moderate, and even severe sleep apnoea. So the dental sleep medicine is predominantly based on advancement devices. And that's kind of interesting because when you think about the emergency situation where a patient collapses or someone collapses, the idea is to open the airway by pulling the mandible forwards.
That's where the idea actually came from. But I'm not so sure if that's a long-term solution for people who have a diagnosis of sleep apnoea. And it's interesting that dentists—
CHAPTER 5: DO MANDIBULAR ADVANCEMENT DEVICES WORK FOR EVERYONE?
JAZ:
And so I guess one doubt I've had, Prof, is when I have someone and we do a sleep test and they come back as mild to moderate, then it's a bit of a grey area. Because our guidelines suggest that perhaps this patient doesn't need a CPAP and they benefit from a mandibular advancement. So for one of our students, listeners, or new colleagues, an appliance that brings the jaw forward, or a better way that it was explained to me is stop the mandible from dropping back, thus keeping the airway patent, giving the tongue more space.
And please do correct me if I'm saying anything that is not the best way to say it. But these appliances are something that we as dentists can help our patients with. But the problem is a lot of dentists, myself included, we are like, okay, well if it's not CPAP, it's a mandibular advancement. We don't know what other options there are out there to help our patients. And I'd love for you to sort of break down what other ways we can help our patients.
I dunno if that's part of the remit today.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Oh, absolutely. I mean, it's a wonderful question. It's a very big question. So let's look at this from a kind of empirical point of view. So bring the mandible forwards. The idea is that you will bring the tongue forwards and open up the airway. That's a generic idea. And if you look at patient profiles using endoscopy, such as DISE, which is drug-induced sleep endoscopy, and then you look at the behaviour of the airway, when you manipulate the mandible, you can see whether it has an effect or not.
So this goes all the way back to my initial training on the cleft lip and palate children. We put an endoscope down their nose and we were looking to see how well they were able to seal the oropharynx after surgery. So that's where I got the insight to be able to assess airway behaviour. Now again, generally speaking, about one third or about half the patients, if you bring the mandible forwards, the airway will open.
So you will get an immediate effect in about half, maybe a third of patients. But in the other half or the two thirds, sometimes you will not get that effect. So generically, yes, it's a good idea. It may or may not be the most appropriate protocol for that individual patient. Number two is the idea—
JAZ:
Correct me if I'm wrong. When we give this mandibular advancement and we say, go home, try it out, we are relying on subjective measures, which will give us, “my snoring is improved” or “I feel better,” where that's subjective feedback from patients. But what you mentioned about the drug-induced endoscopy, have I got that right?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Yes.
JAZ:
So there's a colleague, I saw Dr Lukasz Lassmann in Poland. He posted wonderful, he's a dentist, he posted a wonderful Instagram video of having someone there doing that. And then he was fitting, I think it was a TAP appliance or something. He was titrating, he was twisting it to advance the mandible forward to now meet objective aims of, he was actually visualising the airway opening. But we don't always have, in primary care, access to that.
I mean, if we took time and money out of the equation, would that be the gold standard way of delivering a mandibular advancement device?
CHAPTER 6: AN AETIOLOGY-BASED APPROACH: WHY IS THE MANDIBLE RETRUDED?
DR DAVE SINGH:
It would not be. And so I have to be a little bit controversial, but be very honest in the sense my approach is different. It's an aetiology-based approach. So my question is, having gone through various kind of experiences, my question is why is that mandible retruded? Why is it falling back? Why is the tongue obstructing the airway when you sleep in certain individuals but not in others?
And so when you think about why is that mandible retruded, the short answer is developmental compensation. So when the body's developing, it essentially follows a cranio-caudal gradient from the top down. So what happens is the cranial base gets there first, undergoes maturation first. The midface, including the nasal complex and the midface, follows suit as second. And any space that's left is then gonna be occupied by the mandible.
It's cranio-caudal. And eventually you'll get some kind of signs also on the hyoid bone as well. So when I see a patient with a retruded mandible, the first question I ask is, why is that mandible retruded? Number two is the therapeutic approach: Well, I'll just bring the mandible forwards. So what you had is developmental compensation. The mandible's back. And then what you do is non-surgical decompensation. You just push the mandible forwards.
And again, empirically, that's a fine, nice principle to follow, but it hasn't addressed the underlying cause to say, why was that mandible retruded in the first place? Add onto that, why is the tongue falling back whilst I sleep? Now long story real short, when I woke up this morning, two things happened. First thing I want to know, where is my tongue in space? And my tongue is sitting on my palate.
And number two is, did I remember my last dream? And the answer is yes, and it was weird. So the point here is that the tongue is supposed to rest on the palate whilst you're asleep. And classically, when you're asleep, you're breathing through your nose, the tongue is on the palate, the lips are gently in contact, and the teeth are slightly apart, the freeway space. So that is the homeostasis.
That's craniofacial homeostasis. That's upper airway homeostasis. That is our gold standard. And now the question is, why is that mandible retruded? Is there something upstream, the midface or the cranial base or something else, which is producing that clinical sign and those symptoms? And we can do a symptom-based management, or we can say let's have an integrative endotype-based approach to say here's the underlying condition. Let's see if I can actually correct that.
CHAPTER 7: THE CRANIAL BASE SETS THE PACE FOR THE FACE
JAZ:
Okay. So are we alluding to the mandible is retruded or underdeveloped because the maxilla was restricted or underdeveloped and it follows suit?
DR DAVE SINGH:
That's close, and we go even further up. So I always start with the cranial base, and I have a kind of little phrase that helps people just remember this. The cranial base sets the pace for the rest of the face. It rhymes. So we look at the cranial base. In modern humans, Homo sapiens, the human genome has been sequenced. But for modern humans, generally speaking, there are two cranial base phenotypes.
You've got the short cranial base phenotype and the long cranial base phenotype. So for the long cranial base, generally it's Caucasian people, Middle Eastern people, people from South Asia. They tend to have a long cranial base phenotype. On the other hand, people from North Asia—
JAZ:
Is that the good one or the bad one?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Say again.
JAZ:
Is that the good one or the bad one?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Oh, they're both the same. They're both the same. It's just a morphological classification based on cranial base morphology. So they're both good. They both work. So the short cranial base is North Asia, East Asia, and Africa. So now when you think about cranial base morphology, the people with a short cranial base have a tendency to have a class three malocclusion, a prognathic mandible. And the people with a long cranial base have a tendency more towards a class two kind of facial profile where the mandible appears to be retruded.
So now here's my question. If you have a patient with a class three malocclusion and they also have a diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnoea, where are you gonna put the mandible? It's already protruded.
JAZ:
Absolutely. But just so we can go back to basics, when we say the cranial base, what bones does that convey? Is it like sphenoid and, like, are we looking at the maxilla? What bones are consisting of that?
DR DAVE SINGH:
So cranial base at the front, you've got the ethmoid bone, and that's going to form the very top part of the nasal cavity. And then behind that, you've got the sphenoid bone. And behind that, you've got the occipital bone. So in a sagittal view, that would be the three bones lying in the cranial base. Now the interesting thing is between the sphenoid and the ethmoid, you have a synchondrosis, the spheno-ethmoidal synchondrosis.
And that is a cartilaginous site of bone formation, which elongates the cranial base. And so as the cranial base elongates, the midface, which is attached to the anterior part of the cranial base, can translate forward in space. Now the human face doesn't grow forwards very well, but it does grow forwards. And so the maxilla is translated forwards, anteriorly in space. Now the maxilla itself grows backwards. So what happens is it's moving forwards, but it's growing backwards.
The first molar, the second molar, and then the third molar are all going to erupt into the space vacated by the anterior translation. And if that's deficient, you'll end up with third molar impaction, for example. Also, if the maxilla doesn't develop very well, you end up with a more severe class three type of facial profile.
CHAPTER 8: EVOLUTION, EPIGENETICS AND WHY OUR TEETH GOT BIGGER
JAZ:
And so what's the number one aetiology of that not developing, the midface and the maxilla not developing to its true extent?
DR DAVE SINGH:
That's a great question. So why wouldn't the midface develop as well as you would like? And my kind of approach to that is epigenetic. Because the human genome hasn't changed for 30,000, 40,000 years in terms of Homo sapiens. And if you go back historically, the third molars usually were fully erupted and in occlusion. And so what is it? What happened? Did the teeth get smaller? What happened to the teeth during that time?
What happened to the bone during that time? So one of the things that early on people used to talk about was the idea that, well, the bones are getting smaller. That doesn't make sense because if you look at the historical or the evolutionary record for mammals, specifically humans, the teeth have been getting bigger as evolution progressed. So you have the trigon, which is a three-cusped tooth. You have the talonid, a four-cusped tooth.
You've got the Dryopithecus pattern, which is a five-cusped tooth, which we are familiar with. And now we even have things like the Carabelli tubercle, which means that modern teeth are huge. They have these six cusps, potentially at least five and maybe six. Not only that, the enamel in modern humans is the thickest enamel that we have had in terms of evolutionary history. So our teeth have been getting bigger over a period of time, and it makes no sense for the bone to get smaller.
So the reason why the maxilla is underdeveloped, there may be some epigenetic influences. And the biggest one that you can think of is there's been a sharp shift away from breastfeeding, away from suckling, away from nursing at birth. So remember, humans are mammals, and the young are going to suckle at birth. And if these babies or children did not suckle or breastfeed 10,000 years ago, that baby would not have survived because there was no formula, there was no bottle feeding available at that time.
So one of the biggest shifts we've done is the child-rearing practices, and that happens very early on in modern societies.
JAZ:
And do you think the orthodontic societies also, do they argue about this? Because I feel as though there is some argument that they say that actually it's mostly genetic and that perhaps the epigenetic part of it is not as well respected. And do you think that whole thing about our diets becoming softer and therefore we're not developing to our full extent is because of that change in diet over the years and now becoming more industrial and farming?
Is that also a factor to play?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Absolutely. Is it controversial? Yes. The reason for that is it just takes time for the evidence to emerge. And if people are not researching these areas sufficiently, then the momentum is lost and people just kind of ignore it, if you will. But the epigenetic factors are strong. We have done studies where we compared babies and children who were breastfed versus those who were bottle fed, for example.
And in this study that we published, there was about, I'm just guessing now, I forgot the exact numbers, but about 50% of the kids who had deficient breastfeeding had increased likelihood of having a malocclusion, crowding, and that kind of stuff. Now, does diet play a role? Absolutely. Because you go back 30,000 years, we had a non-refined hard diet. And this brings us back to big teeth.
JAZ:
Usually I've heard about our jawbone getting smaller, not so much about teeth getting bigger.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Yes. So this is the idea in terms of why would you have bigger teeth in terms of evolution. So during the time when evolution was happening, humans, Homo sapiens, also had another revolution. It's called the Big Bang theory. The Big Bang theory. You know, there's one that refers to the creation of the universe as a separate one. But the Big Bang theory in terms of human evolution is that we developed these massive brains very quickly over a short period of time.
And so this is why we have these large and fragile brains. And the genes associated with that are the HAR region. That's the Human Accelerated Region, about at least six genes that produce specific proteins to enhance brain development in humans. So now you think about this very large and fragile brain, and you have a very hard unrefined diet. So these big teeth, these big molar teeth, are going to dissipate forces away from the brain.
They're going to use the architecture, the craniofacial architecture, to absorb those forces and prevent microtrauma to the brain. And we know that trauma to the brain is not a good thing. It might be something like concussion. It could be an athlete. It could be in a military situation where you have a force that impacts the brain and suddenly you are knocked out. And then you have post-traumatic stress disorder and all those other things that can follow from a severe concussion.
So the idea to have large teeth and large jaws is to actually protect this very large brain of ours, which also needs a large blood supply. So it's very well oxygenated. And so when you think about teeth and sleep, what do they have in common? It's really about the lifespan. They are predictors of lifespan. They are predictors of longevity.
JAZ:
Fascinating. So there we are. Protect our brain. Goes back to the origins and the evolution.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Absolutely. And again, the studies coming out from there are far and few between. But the studies that we have done, we were able to reduce the risk of concussion in high school footballers by having a mouthguard. So the mouthguard is to prevent dental trauma. We understand that. But in addition, it actually protects the brain. And so when you think about boxers who wear a mouthguard, it's essentially to prevent the concussion.
Because if you take a blow to the chin, you can classify them into a small blow onto the chin, which can be absorbed by the bone and doesn't produce a concussion. Number two is the other extreme where the blow to the chin is so large that you get a fracture of the mandible, typically a condylar fracture. And by fracturing, the brain itself has been protected and the bone has been sacrificed.
But the one that's in between, the intermediate force that is applied to the mandible, the condyles are rammed up into the temporal fossa, and you get an atypical temporal lobe activation. And that is what causes the concussion. And that's a long story real short. And that's the one that we are trying to protect in athletes specifically.
CHAPTER 9: THE FOUR ENDOTYPES OF SLEEP APNOEA
JAZ:
Okay. Wow. I didn't know that. And it just gives another reason to help protect our athletes in primary care, to make sure that they are at reduced risk of concussion. I think the way you described it makes absolute sense. Now when it comes to, again, the whole topic of dental sleep medicine, but we're talking about craniofacial sleep medicine, what would you pose as the key difference there?
So tell us more about this difference, from dental sleep medicine as we know it, as we've discussed, and as the sort of little boom in dentistry of discussing these topics, whereas craniofacial sleep medicine, like you said, is aetiology-based. You said, well, we're looking at the root cause. Tell us more about that.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Yeah, so if you think about the diagnosis, it's obstructive sleep apnoea. But behind that, there's at least four different endotypes. And so the classical one is the craniofacial one. For example, you said that the mandible is retruded. There's an obvious anatomical variation there. So number one is a craniofacial type. Number two is it may be neurologic. So the reason why this person has sleep apnoea is because of some kind of issue with the neurology.
And we can think about different examples of that, such as arousal threshold. And so this patient or this individual, when they're asleep, they have a low arousal threshold and they are woken during sleep. And so there's a neurological component. Another group of individuals have high loop gain. And high loop gain, again, is really the control of ventilation, their control of breathing. And if they are hypersensitive, they have high loop gain, they tend to overcompensate and they can end up producing a worse situation and actually depressing breathing.
So there are some neurological endotypes of sleep apnoea. And then number three would be the hormonal or metabolic one, which is really obesity. So these are people who have a high BMI. They're overweight. And so what happens when they lie down is they increase the work of breathing. There's an increase in ventilatory load because you've reduced the lung volume. It's physically harder to breathe. And so there are different endotypes of sleep apnoea.
It could be metabolic, it could be neurologic, it could be craniofacial. And then the fourth group is myopathic. Because once you get past the oropharynx, now you're into the pharyngeal region. That airway is predominantly muscular. And if there is a lack of muscle tone, there's an increased risk of upper airway collapse. It will reach a critical collapse pressure, and once it gets there, it will collapse. So that's an idea to say, well, why is that muscle tone so deficient?
And so that's another example of saying, hey, I need to address the muscle tone in this case, as opposed to, for example, a craniofacial condition in a different case, or there may be an overlap.
CHAPTER 10: SCREENING, REFERRAL AND DIAGNOSIS
JAZ:
Would you say that in the current state of affairs around the world, because you are in the best position to answer this, do you think that the current state is they may or may not have a sleep test, and that may give them an AHI, Apnoea-Hypopnea Index, that may suggest that okay, they will benefit from a mandibular advancement device? But it's just given without thought to their, like you said, the myotonic, is it hormonal, is it this?
It is just a one-size-fits-all to try and see if this suffices the patient's needs. Do you think this is where we're currently at?
DR DAVE SINGH:
I think you summarised it pretty well, Jaz. It's almost like a trial and error. But part of it is because it's licence-based. If you have a dental licence, you practise in a certain way. If you've got a medical licence, you practise in a certain way. And my ideas are saying we have to look at the condition overall and what is the most appropriate treatment for that individual.
And the way that these people turn up for treatment can be either direct or indirect. They may have a diagnosis of diabetes. They may have hypertension or other cardiovascular diseases. They may have dementia. They may have obesity, and so on and so forth. And underlying these conditions, there may be an undiagnosed diagnosis of sleep apnoea. And so when your patient comes to the dental office and you're going to do maybe a surgical procedure, you can take a blood pressure measurement or you can ask the patient, are you taking meds for hypertension, and so on and so forth.
So if there is a history of hypertension, then there's a chance that this patient may actually have undiagnosed sleep apnoea in addition to that. And so what we're going to do is maybe do a pre-screening. In other words, we're going to look at this patient's craniofacial features, saying is there any features here that make me suspect that you may have undiagnosed sleep apnoea? For example, the mandible is retruded.
And then number two, you can also do screening, which is a questionnaire to say answer these questions. For example, Epworth Sleepiness Scale or other scales as well. And then if the questionnaire comes out with an increased risk of sleep apnoea, then you may go to either a home sleep test or a PSG. And it is becoming easier to do these tests. You can get now a home PSG or a home sleep apnoea test.
And based on the outcome of that test, which will be read and interpreted by a physician, the physician will say, hey, this patient has mild sleep apnoea based on the apnoea-hypopnea index, the AHI, and therefore we can look at different forms of treatment options.
JAZ:
I'm just gonna clarify that. So if the diagnosis comes back as mild, I just feel that the current default is, okay, they're mild, therefore mandibular advancement. How can we equip dentists in having the right knowledge and referral? Or do you think that this is something that dentists can manage, just knowing when to use the mandibular advancement device and when to refer for something else or when to carry out something else?
How can we unbox this for dentists to make it tangible? Because right now, yes, many dentists are just used to, okay, the patient's snoring, they have an AHI of 10, they're a little bit overweight, or they have a retrusive mandible. The partner complains of snoring, therefore mandibular advancement device. But rather, what's the root cause? And let me find a purpose-built therapy for this cause.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Sure. And remember this is really referred to as oral appliance therapy as far as a dentist and orthodontist are concerned. And so now we say, okay, beyond mandibular advancement devices, are there any other devices out there that would be placed intraorally and have a beneficial effect? And the answer is yes. And this is where education, information, and training come in. And there's the whole purpose of holding these types of teaching events and seminars and so forth, is to be able to share a broader base of knowledge.
And so the more information you have, the better decision you can make based on the information.
JAZ:
It's all about diagnosis, isn't it, Prof? Because diagnosis is not just OSA. It should be OSA due to this factor or that factor or that factor. It's a bit like when we diagnose periodontal disease. It's periodontal disease due to smoking or due to poor hygiene or due to having an aggressive form that's genetically linked, and then treating that accordingly. Am I talking sense here?
CHAPTER 11: UPPER AIRWAY RESISTANCE SYNDROME
DR DAVE SINGH:
Absolutely. That makes complete sense. And again, thinking about the diagnosis of mild sleep apnoea, for example, let's go a little bit upstream and make it even less severe, and now we're talking upper airway resistance syndrome. In other words, this patient had a sleep study and the apnoea-hypopnea index was less than five. Okay, they did not have sleep apnoea. However, they report sleepiness. Maybe they have fatigue. Maybe they have chronic pain.
Maybe they have headaches. And generally not sleeping very well. So I actually met, I was at the conference last weekend, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine. I was presenting some findings there and I just happened to meet someone at the conference. And when I shook her hand, her fingertips were really cold. And she said to me, oh, I have sleep apnoea. And my kind of idea was, it was a discussion just based on this.
And I said, you probably most likely have upper airway resistance syndrome. And she said, what is that? I said, well, one of the reasons why we sleep is actually to conserve energy. And by doing that, we actually elongate the lifespan. So we spend about a third of our lifetime sleeping. And sleep is a microform of hibernation. So when you think about hibernation, what happens is that you're in a cosy den.
It's dark. It's cold outside. You get peripheral vasodilation. Your breathing slows. Your heartbeat slows. Your blood pressure comes down. And you conserve energy. And the bears and other mammals that hibernate do that for about two or three months a year, and it elongates their lifespan. Humans do something similar every night. And so now when you are conserving this energy, your core body temperature goes down. Now let's say this individual with upper airway resistance syndrome, they are about to have an episode of apnoea, but they wake up momentarily and they fall back to sleep again.
And so what happens is they have sleep fragmentation throughout the night. In other words, when they wake up in the morning, they're not fully rested. They're not kind of, you know, in a severe condition, but they're not optimal. And one of the ways their body's going to conserve energy during the day is peripheral vasoconstriction. And so when you talk to some of these people, they have cold fingers and cold toes.
And they may have a history of TMJ problems, chronic pain. And typically, if you said to me, pick out an individual like that, it'll be a non-obese, younger female. That would be a classic way of saying you may have upper airway resistance syndrome as opposed to frank sleep apnoea.
JAZ:
And now that must be very difficult for us to diagnose as dentists. So for example, I'm so happy you're talking about this, because I literally have a patient I'm seeing right now who, and tell me again, because I'm learning from you here, the validity of my thought process. His history was that when he had the Oura Ring where he is measuring his sleep every night, there was not a single night where his sleep metric came back as restful.
His sleep was always restless. And he had all the other signs of just feeling tired. And he looked just generally a bit pale and tired. And I worried for him. And I'm gonna be doing some major restorative work because he's got some major wear. And before I do this, okay, I need you, I'm a little bit concerned. I think you may have some sort of sleep disordered breathing.
So I've got his results back. I'm gonna get them reported now. But AHI of one, right? And so how do I, I'm convinced he has, and he's got very small maxilla, small midface. And one of the reasons why I think he's got wear is because his mandible is outgrowing his maxilla, is what I'm seeing. And so how can I help to confirm this diagnosis of upper airway resistance syndrome if I'm right?
If you think I'm barking up the correct tree here. And also what are the treatment modalities available once we get that diagnosis to dentists? Or is this out of the dentist's hands then?
CHAPTER 12: TOOTH WEAR, BRUXISM AND CPAP
DR DAVE SINGH:
Well, because sleep disorders are medical conditions, they have to be diagnosed by a medical physician. It can be a sleep specialist, ENT, a general practitioner, whoever. But the actual sleep study has to be, the diagnosis has to be made by a physician. Once you have the diagnosis, you can then say this patient will be a great candidate for, fill in the blank, some kind of oral appliance.
Now you mentioned tooth wear. And remember I mentioned that humans have the thick enamel. Modern humans have the thick enamel that we've had historically. So if that enamel is worn away, the question is why? And again, you've talked about restorative. And we have done some of these cases, we actually published to say even though the patient walked in with severe wear, that was not our primary concern.
Our primary concern was to ensure that patient has a healthy profile systemically. And then we go into the restorative after that. So let's think about sleep bruxism for a second, since that shows tooth wear. The idea was to say that people who have some kind of issue when they're sleeping, they're going to brux and grind during sleep. And the idea was some kind of protective reflex to open the airway and keep them oxygenated while they're asleep.
That hypothesis has not been borne out. Now does bruxism occur? Yes. Do you get flattening and wear of the teeth? Yes. But what's the underlying reason? Why would you brux to try to open the airway? And so long story real short, this goes back to the trigeminal cardiac reflex. And again, I'm showing you these scenarios for us to get an idea in terms of how we'd explain that.
And we'll talk about the restorative stuff in a second. But let's just go way back in history and say here's a young child, the daughter of a caveman, and she's walking and suddenly she slips and falls into this icy lake and she's gonna drown. Well, what's the body's reflex? That very cold shock is picked up, especially to the face and the trigeminal area. What it does essentially is it slows down the heartbeat and you get dilation of the blood supply to the brain.
So basically what you did, you said, okay, if there's one organ I have to protect to stay alive, it's going to be my brain. And what we find is when you grind and clench, you actually increase the blood supply to the brain. So possibly that's the reason why you brux. It's a primitive reflex that is kind of playing out inappropriately in modern humans. And again, that's the hypothesis.
JAZ:
What would trigger it in the sleep though? So I understand that when there's a traumatic event like falling in that cold lake, that's the trigger. So why is it that some people are bruxing in that manner that you described? What's the trigger? Is it the fact that they're not able to breathe?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Yes. So if you fall into the lake, obviously you hold your breath and you become hypoxic. And when you have OSA, when you have apnoea, you have hypoxia. Okay, you have oxygen desaturation of the blood. And that's a signal to say, I need to survive. I need to do something. And one of the primitive reflexes is maybe to say, okay, I need my brain to be healthy and divert the blood supply to the brain.
It's a bit like the fight-or-flight reaction where you redistribute vasodilation to the muscles and so forth in that kind of situation. So again, it's a hypothesis.
JAZ:
Can I just clarify that what you are saying is, and it's a little nuance here, and I'd love for you to just confirm this is where, and this is what, and I'm just summarising what I think you believe, and I'd love to share this for the audience to highlight. Where we think that the reason we brux could be to open the airway. So some people have said protective function or parafunction or the bruxing is a protective behaviour to open the airway perhaps.
What you are suggesting is actually the bruxism is to divert the blood to the brain in response to the hypoxia. Have I got that right?
DR DAVE SINGH:
So my original hypothesis, it was actually a little note in the British Dental Journal in 2007, called the Spatial Matrix Hypothesis. Since that time, it's been improved. But the idea is that bruxing and clenching does not actually open the airway. That was the idea. So some of the early studies by people like Simmons and other people, they said that when you are in a state of bruxism, what happens is that when you clench, you start getting increased masseteric activity.
The masseters are gonna clench. And they said that when the masseter clenches, it protrudes the mandible and opens the airway. That was their idea. Of course, that doesn't happen because the masseter is a jaw elevator. It does not protrude the mandible.
JAZ:
It would be the lateral pterygoids you'd want to go, which is where the left and right synchronous grinding happens.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Correct. So I think bruxism or rhythmic masseteric muscle activity is some kind of primitive reflex which does not open the airway per se. Now again, when we think about airway behaviour, this is what we're coming to now. So for example, when the airway, when you expire, the upper airway starts to get smaller. If it reaches a critical collapse pressure, it will collapse in on itself, and we want to prevent that from happening.
And so what happens in CPAP people? So CPAP is continuous positive airway pressure. It's the treatment of choice for physicians throughout the world. Now it's a good option, but in my opinion, not the best option. Does it work? Yes, it does. Should you use it? Absolutely. But again, did you address the underlying aetiology to say, why is that airway collapsing during sleep? And so what the CPAP does, as you probably know, is you wear a little mask over your nose and mouth maybe, and it's blowing air into your airway to make sure it doesn't collapse.
Just like blowing up a balloon, to give an analogy. And then the idea is to say, okay, now I have to kind of exhale and keep repeating that. Some people don't like that because it's overriding their own breathing physiology. It kind of, the machine is breathing for you. And to make a bad situation a little bit worse, most of these people with sleep apnoea have healthy lungs.
They do not need ventilatory support per se. Unlike people with COPD, for example, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, or interstitial lung disease, for example. Those kind of people do need ventilation. However, most people with sleep apnoea probably don't need ventilation per se. I'm not saying you shouldn't use a CPAP. I'm just looking at the underlying idea behind it. So now we have a variant of CPAP coming out.
And instead of having continuous pressure, it actually provides intermittent pressure. In other words, the air being blown down your airway is only applied when you exhale. So when you exhale, the airway starts to get smaller. And that is the point at which it may collapse, increased risk of collapse during exhalation. That's the lowest pressure. And so at that point, they apply the pressure, the air pressure from the intermittent PAP.
And that prevents the sleep apnoea. Again, they haven't really looked at why the airway is collapsing, but it just shows you that we need to understand upper airway behaviour a little bit more before we decide which is the most optimal therapy in a particular case.
CHAPTER 13: PALATAL EXPANSION WITHOUT SPLITTING THE SUTURE
JAZ:
Then going back to my patient then with the potential upper airway resistance syndrome, because obviously he's gonna get reported by the sleep clinician. And is the upper airway resistance syndrome something that's managed with CPAP? Or what are the ways that we can, obviously the sleep physician will confirm the diagnosis, but what's the culture, what's the trend like in diagnosing this? Because the symptoms and signs and everything's pointing, and also the sleep metrics they shared with me, everything is pointing to having a sleep issue.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Right.
JAZ:
And the wear and everything's pointing towards it, but his AHI is not matching up. Therefore, it points us towards this upper airway resistance syndrome. But are sleep physicians happy to make such a diagnosis? Do they use a different screening or different test for this?
DR DAVE SINGH:
There's not a different screening. There's not a different test. But again, it's about patient management. What are you going to do? So let's take a large population that has an increased risk of upper airway resistance syndrome, and those are children. So kids tend to have, if they're gonna have some kind of airway issue, it's probably gonna start as UARS. It might present as mild, moderate, even severe sleep apnoea.
And so now we just look at these children to say, where is the resistance coming from? Classically, open the mouth, you look down their throat and look at the size of the tonsils. If it's not in the tonsils, then you can look at the nose to see do they have allergies, nasal obstruction. And the same rules apply for adults as well. So we're gonna find out where is the resistance coming from.
And classically, it's craniofacial in the nose. And now what we know is the floor of the nose is the roof of the mouth, also known as the palate. And so especially in children, but actually also in adults, you can do palatal expansion in these cases. Now palatal expansion, in my opinion, is a historical misnomer because orthodontists, a great group in the profession, looked at the palatal width and tried to expand it widely kind of medially-laterally.
But the palate itself and the maxilla, it's a three-dimensional object. And so you have to really say, I need to maximise or optimise that structure, its morphology in 3D, and not simply make it broader. And so when you talk about the 3D aspect, if you think about children, even adults, who have upper airway resistance syndrome, one of the things you might be looking for is do they have a high arched, narrow palate?
So the idea is not just to widen the palate, but I want to flatten the palate. And when you flatten the palate, you actually increase the nasal volume, you decrease the nasal resistance, you increase nasal airflow. And there are studies coming out showing that dentists can do that using various different types of devices and approaches.
JAZ:
So I was always taught that in children, yes, you can expand certain ages, rapid maxillary expansion, but in an adult it is miniscrew-assisted expansion, MARPE. Are there, I mean, if you try and expand using clear aligners or fixed appliances, that's not true expansion, you're tipping the molars. So in some of the previous episodes, we've talked about MARPE. Is that what you are suggesting, or is there something else that we're missing?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Well again, this comes back to my disclosure. I'm the inventor of the DNA appliance, which became the first palatal expander to be FDA cleared for treatment of mild, moderate, severe sleep apnoea in adults and in children. And so as kind of my research, what it showed is what is going on with palatal expansion? Why is it that we have to, quote, split the suture? Now when you split the suture, it's really a bone fracture.
And so we didn't understand historically the structure or behaviour of the craniofacial sutures, which includes things like the midpalatal suture. So if you look at how these sutures behave, like any other system of the body, they are subject to suture homeostasis. They have to be in a state of balance. If you look at the suture width, and measuring, and we've actually done studies on this and published, then if you look at the actual suture width, it's approximately 250 microns.
It varies between 100 microns to about 400 microns. And 250 microns, as you know, is 0.25 millimetres. So now we know historically by trial and error, the orthodontist discovered that if you turn the screw of a powerful expander by a quarter of a millimetre, it seems to have a beneficial effect over a period of time. So what's happening is that when you stretch the suture beyond 250 microns, you get these stretch-sensitive genes.
And what happens is that you get signal transduction. And so the stem cells, which are found in the sutures, they undergo differentiation and they start producing bone-forming osteoblasts, osteoclasts, and therefore you get suture remodelling. So recent research shows that the sutures provide a niche for the mesenchymal stem cells. They're found in the sutures. And so if you split the suture, you've overridden the biological boundaries.
I'm not saying you can't do that. I'm not saying you shouldn't do that. I'm just saying that this is kind of going beyond what the biology would represent. But if you harness the body's own mechanism, you can stretch the suture without splitting it, and you will get those changes. The upside is that these sutures, craniofacial sutures, the circummaxillary sutures, they're in a state of balance. They're going to check and balance each other out.
And therefore, not only do you get changes inside the palate, but you actually get extraoral changes also in the face, for example the zygoma. And therefore when you do this, quote, powerful expansion, if you look at the patient's face and measure, the volume of the midface increases to a small extent. And so inside the midface there, you've got the maxillary air sinuses, which also increase in volume if you measure them.
And then behind that, you can measure the upper airway and see what effect, quote, powerful expansion has on that as well. So I think powerful expansion is not fully understood or appreciated. I'm not saying you shouldn't use MARPE or SARPE or any of those techniques, but there may be a non-invasive, non-surgical option, which is sometimes less expensive and more comfortable for the patient. So again, a lot of research has been done.
JAZ:
Can you describe what this looks like for those watching? Can you show us what such an appliance or such a treatment looks like, and those who are listening, we'll describe it for you as well. Is that okay?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Say again, Jaz.
JAZ:
Have you got any images of what a DNA appliance looks like that we can describe to our audio listeners and show to our visual watchers? And is this something that you think someone who has upper airway resistance syndrome may benefit from?
DR DAVE SINGH:
It's certainly possible. Again, I don't do a device-based diagnosis. My diagnosis is aetiology-based. I need to understand where did this UARS come from. Let's say it came from nasal resistance. So now I have a choice here.
CHAPTER 14: A DIAGNOSTIC PROTOCOL, AND MALOCCLUSION AS ADAPTATION
JAZ:
Here's my question about making it tangible, Prof, right? Help me out. Because as the dentist, yes, we rely on the sleep study, which is reported, and then yes, you're getting the official diagnosis from the sleep physician. But as a, like for example, our sleep physician that we use in the local hospital, they may not be familiar with this. They may not be able to recommend this or have the knowledge about this.
So how can we, as dentists, arm ourselves with enough of a screening system to figure out, okay, how can I best find out where is the obstruction? Where is the problem? To help then filter out which is the best management technique for my patient.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Well, the first thing any dentist should do is to establish a strong collaborative working relationship with a sleep physician or an ENT or other doctor that has a similar interest and line of thinking. This is an integrative approach. And so we want to have the oral myofunctional therapist, the orthodontist, the dentist, the sleep physician, the ENT working as an integrated group. And therefore you're gonna get the best possible outcomes.
Now whether that model is generalisable and deliverable in the UK, I don't know. But certainly that's been my experience in the US, that you can work across these disciplines and get a really good outcome. So I would say do a lunch and learn. There's plenty of literature and studies out there. The devices that we have been using in the past and the future have gone through the FDA approval process.
So we know that they are reliable and they're safe. And number two is that they are covered in the US by medical insurance, for example. And again, I don't know how that would translate into Europe and into the UK. But the devices that we have been using have all been through the approval process to make sure they're both safe and effective. So get the conversation going with your medical colleagues.
And that's the best way. And this is the reason that, going way back to the first question, why would I want to leave the UK? It's because I had a chance to be a part of a craniofacial team in the US, and that is really where my understanding actually came from.
JAZ:
Okay. So to actually go further in the field, I understand you had to be where the action was. You were in the arena, able to develop and grow in that area. So again, I'm sorry to go back to my patient, but I genuinely want to help my patient here. So once we get the official diagnosis, do you think dentists should be using imaging?
And what type of imaging to actually see, to measure the volume of the airway? And is that linked to upper airway resistance syndrome if the AHI is coming as low?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Again, wonderful question, Jaz. So it's not specifically about the size of the airway. It's the behaviour we want to capture. But you're right. Generally speaking, a larger airway diameter is less likely to collapse. So let's see now, in terms of what's my diagnostic protocol, what would I do classically in the ideal world? First thing I do is I take photographs of the patient, just like an orthodontist would.
You take the photos from the face, lateral profile, so on and so forth, intraoral photographs as well. And from those photographs, you can get some easy eyeball assessments. And also you can make measurements. And so we can kind of think about in terms of what kind of cranial base phenotype this is and get information from the photographs. And this is the kind of thing that I do in my training sessions.
I go through in a good amount of detail. This is not rocket science. Every general dentist that I have met can do this. And you can train the staff to do it as well. Not a big deal. So number one is we collect standardised photographs. Number two, even before that or in conjunction with, we need to have a sleep study. We need to know whether this patient has mild, moderate, severe apnoea.
Maybe they don't have apnoea. Maybe it's suspected, a differential diagnosis of UARS, for example. So now we have a sleep report saying we suspect this patient may have UARS because a sleep study is negative, and yet they've got daytime symptoms, excessive daytime sleepiness, feeling fatigued, feeling chronic pain.
JAZ:
What about sleep trackers? Would that be one whereby, like, I wear my watch and I get some very restful sleep according to my watch when I do sleep? And then would someone who has, I don't know if you looked into sleep metrics and sleep measuring. Nowadays the Apple Watches and stuff, they're fascinating. I once made my prosthodontist colleague a, what was it called, a mandibular advancement device, right?
And then the next day his iPhone came up saying your blood oxygen was 4% higher than ever recorded before while you slept. And that was a fascinating piece of data, objective collected. So how accurate and reliable are these? For example, the whole lack of restfulness for my patient. Is that something that we need to take with a pinch of salt, or does it carry diagnostic value?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Well, if you look at this, the wearable technology has really moved really fast. And so the tracking devices that patients now have, like a smartwatch or a ring or so on and so forth, they are extremely useful. Some of those devices in the US have been FDA cleared for sleep tracking or even sleep diagnosis. So there's a blurry line between do I need a full-blown home sleep test, or can I use my smartwatch and get the same amount of data in a very easy kind of way?
At the end of the day, that data has to be interpreted by a sleep physician. So you can use your sleep watch. You can use whatever you want, your Fitbit, whatever it is, to say I can monitor my sleep. That's part of it. So now we have the facial photographs being taken. I have a sleep study saying here's my metrics to show I have good, bad, or indifferent sleep.
And then what I like to do classically is take a 3D CBCT scan, a 3D cone beam scan. And classically, the scan that I do goes from the cranial base down to the hyoid bone. And I want to capture all the information to say, okay, what kind of phenotype am I working with from a craniofacial perspective? And we do very specific measurements there to come back with here's what we are finding.
And the final bit is study models or intraoral scans. We take certain measurements, and the classic measurement that I took, this is going way back when I wrote my first book on this topic, is the minimum intermolar width. So at the cervical margin of the teeth, it's the mesial palatal cusp of the first permanent molar, and you're measuring the minimum width at the gingival level there to find out how wide is this maxilla.
If you go back to the studies, the first person to measure that, well not the first person, but the person who published it was Jim McNamara. He's professor of orthodontics at University of Michigan. And he invited me to the US so many times, and in fact, he sponsored me to come to the US. And I wrote about at least 20 papers with Jim as my second author on those papers.
So intermolar width classically, if you said give me a number, I'm gonna take a guess. I would say 38 millimetres for a typical Caucasian individual. If you look at someone from African or Asian origin, I would say maybe 42 millimetres. Now again, these are just numbers I'm picking out to say generally speaking, based on our experience. Of course, it's an individual-based thing, but an easy thing to do.
Look at the study model, measure it, and say is it wide or is it narrow? And therefore you have at least a starting point in terms of treatment planning. So we have a diagnosis. We have our treatment objectives. We make a treatment plan. And then we estimate how long it's going to take. And that's a classical kind of protocol that I follow to help people, help dentists to help their patients with these types of conditions.
JAZ:
So tell me about the palatal expansion. How long does it take, what does the device look like?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Again, what it looks like is irrelevant because you never see the device. It's how it feels. Now what we have inside the mouth, and actually all of the body, is proprioception. And so when the device goes into the patient's mouth, the patient should immediately feel improvement. So let's go to the clothing store here and I put on a jacket and it feels too tight. I'm not gonna buy that jacket.
It looks great, but it's too tight. It's not comfortable. When that device goes into that patient's mouth, there will be, wow, that feels nice, or there will be a sense of, oh, this is okay. The body does not lie. So I'll give you a real example. We were doing a teaching seminar for paediatrics, actually, and we had seven children who volunteered. The parents had the children volunteer to be a part of the training part.
And the first six children that we had, we put the device in the patient's mouth and they all walked out of the office and they were totally fine. Patient number seven, I put the device in his mouth and within 30 seconds he kind of spat it out. So that case, that device, that design did not meet that patient's requirements. The body doesn't lie. And so when it comes to placing a device into a patient's mouth, we're gonna get biofeedback immediately.
Of course, when you're planning ahead of time to say I'm gonna get very close to where I wanna be, possibly without any adjustments when I actually deliver the device. And so what is it that we're trying to capture here? Well, this is what you might call, quote, the bite. Okay? So we're talking about the bite. And this is so important in terms of tying in the teeth with the rest of the body.
So again, let's think about teeth and the bite, because this is going to determine where the device is gonna go. So now we say, well, this patient has a malocclusion. And there are many different definitions of malocclusions. Pick your favourite one, your favourite orthodontic textbook, and you've got a definition for malocclusion. Now let's kind of turn the coin over and say, what is your definition of occlusion?
And you can pick out any of your favourite definitions saying this is what I mean by occlusion. And then you can turn around to me and say, what is your definition of malocclusion and occlusion? So for me, malocclusion is a solution for a complex adaptive system to remain in homeostasis. That is what malocclusion is. It's the best I can give you to give you at least reasonable function.
It's a state of compensation. So a malocclusion is a solution for a complex adaptive system. Craniofacial, oral tissues. You have four sets of tissues. You have hard tissues, bone, soft tissues, muscle. You've got the functional spaces, which include the airway. And you have the dental tissues, which is teeth. That's a complex system, and the system itself is adaptive. You can move the jaw, you can move the teeth, you can move the tongue.
It will adapt until it settles into homeostasis. This is the best I can give you given the conditions I'm working in. That is a malocclusion in my understanding. Now we're gonna turn the coin over again and say, okay, now what is your definition of occlusion? Occlusion is the endpoint of the body with respect to the plantar surfaces of the feet.
And between those two boundaries, all functional spaces for physiological function have to be accommodated. So what we've done here is tied in the bite with the rest of the body. So what the device looks like is not important. What is important is what is the spatial signalling the body gets from this device. And the great thing is we can adapt and change and modify and adjust that device to get the best possible outcome.
So that's a principle that I work from. This is not rocket science. You can call it a palatal expander. You can call it a mandibular advancement device, and so on and so forth. And there are other devices as well. And one of the things I want to do is show people to start with a very simple device that requires minimal or no adjustment. It doesn't involve palatal expansion.
It doesn't involve mandibular advancement. And yet it has been FDA cleared for the treatment of mild, moderate, and severe sleep apnoea. So really, the device is an airway device. It's going to optimise the airway in these cases. And that could be UARS, or it could be something a bit more severe than that.
CHAPTER 15: PROFESSOR SINGH'S UK COURSE, AND OUTRO
JAZ:
I mean, that sounds amazing. I think it's beyond the scope of this podcast, but it definitely piques my interest. I'm gonna be researching more about the DNA device you mentioned. But I know you're coming to the UK to do some teaching. I'm more than happy for you to share the details of that so those who are interested in this space can learn more. Please tell us more about when you are visiting.
Because what I took away from today is think beyond the mandibular advancement device. Look more at the aetiological cause, which definitely has opened my eyes. But again, I need to probably bring you back for a part two or something. But in terms of those who wish to learn more, how can you tell us more?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Sure. So I have written some books on this topic and several papers, and hopefully we'll be able to access those from the website. But next year, in May, we're going to hold our first introduction to craniofacial sleep medicine for dentists. And that's gonna be held in London, May 1st and 2nd. And so there's some early bird discounts for people who want to register ahead of time. And so yes, my idea is to be able to share this information literally worldwide.
I've done teaching in North America, Australia, Asia, Europe, and actually never done an event in the UK. So I'm looking forward to coming back to London, May 2026. General dentists, orthodontists, implant dentists who are interested in this aspect, we'll do a nice kind of two-day introduction to craniofacial sleep medicine. And my idea is to give you at least one technique which you can then implement in your office as a starting point on this new journey.
JAZ:
Amazing. Well, I'll put the link to that in the show notes. And I wanna thank you, Prof, for giving up your time, your busy schedule, to talk about such an important thing. You've definitely opened my eyes. And I'm gonna hit the papers, hit the books again. You mentioned McNamara. When I was doing my orthodontic diploma, his name was everywhere. He wrote so many books on it. And so amazing that you were headhunted by him, if you like, and invited.
That's so cool. And I'm wishing you all the best with your new direction that you're going in now, obviously. So you are no longer at Stanford?
DR DAVE SINGH:
Correct. I finished there in September. I have a new startup company called REMA. And we're looking at devices which are extraoral, could be used by a dentist, could be used by a physician. Again, I want to make a very flat field in that what is the best option for your patient? It might not be surgery. It might not be CPAP. It might not be an oral device.
Are there any other options? And there may be other options, including pharmaceuticals. And so the idea is to have a broad range of information to make the best decision in terms of patient management.
JAZ:
Thanks so much. I'm gonna put all the links to reach out to you in the show notes, and of course the link to the event in early May 2026. Thanks so much for your time.
DR DAVE SINGH:
Thanks, Jaz. Thanks for having me. It's been a pleasure.
JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening all the way to the end, as always. And of course, there's a quiz attached to this. Recently we ran a poll. We asked you, where do you consume these episodes? And 41% of you said you listen or watch on the app. That is amazing. So if you're not already on the app, get on there. It's Protrusive Guidance.
It's on Android. It's on iOS. And what we've got planned for 2026 in terms of really making a difference in your career is amazing. And of course, by the time this episode launches, Protrusive AI, aka AskJaz, has already been launched. And I'm hoping you guys are loving it and blown away. So we have so many great things on the app. Interestingly, just 17% of you watch on YouTube and everyone else listens on Apple and Spotify.
But remember that you can listen on Spotify and Apple, but then you can answer the quiz on episodes, is eligible for CE credits, and we are a PACE-approved education provider. I want to thank our guest, Dr Dave Singh. Now he's coming to London, I think the dates are May 1st and 2nd, 2026. He's teaching a two-day course with Dr Kalina Borska as the introduction to craniofacial sleep medicine.
There is an early bird rate, and the early bird code is EARLYBIRD20. And so I'll put all the links and everything in the show notes. If you like what Dr Dave Singh had to discuss today and you're interested in learning more about an aetiology-based approach, I think this will be a very interesting course. All the links and everything will be in the show notes, so please do check it out.
And thanks again for listening all the way to the end, and catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
What is craniofacial sleep medicine?
ANSWER:
Dr Dave Singh describes craniofacial sleep medicine as an aetiology-based approach to sleep-disordered breathing. Rather than only treating symptoms, for example by bringing the jaw forward with an appliance, it asks why the airway is compromised, looking at the development of the cranial base, midface, maxilla and mandible to find and address the underlying cause.
QUESTION:
Do mandibular advancement devices work for everyone?
ANSWER:
Dave explains that bringing the mandible forward opens the airway immediately in roughly a third to a half of patients, but not in others. He describes them as a generic, symptom-based approach that doesn't address why the jaw is retruded, and notes that patients with a Class III jaw relationship, whose mandible is already forward, may not suit them.
QUESTION:
Why might a patient's mandible be retruded?
ANSWER:
Dave describes facial development as working from the top down: the cranial base matures first, then the midface, and the mandible fills the space that remains. In his view, a retruded mandible is often a developmental compensation for an underdeveloped midface. He suggests epigenetic factors, such as less breastfeeding and softer diets, may play a part, though this is debated.
QUESTION:
What are the different endotypes of sleep apnoea?
ANSWER:
Dave describes four: craniofacial, where the anatomy narrows the airway; neurological, such as a low arousal threshold or unstable breathing control, known as high loop gain; metabolic, mainly obesity, which increases the work of breathing; and muscular, where poor muscle tone lets the airway collapse. Patients may have more than one.
QUESTION:
What is upper airway resistance syndrome?
ANSWER:
Dave explains that upper airway resistance syndrome describes patients whose sleep study doesn't show sleep apnoea, with an AHI under five, but who still have fragmented sleep and symptoms such as daytime sleepiness, fatigue, headaches or chronic pain. He says it's often seen in younger, non-obese women, and may be linked with cold hands and feet.
QUESTION:
Is sleep bruxism linked to sleep apnoea?
ANSWER:
Dave says the idea that bruxism opens the airway hasn't been proven, because the masseter closes the jaw rather than bringing it forward. His hypothesis is that bruxism may be a primitive reflex, triggered by low oxygen, that increases blood supply to the brain. He stresses that this remains a hypothesis.
QUESTION:
Can the palate be expanded in adults?
ANSWER:
Dave, who invented the DNA appliance, believes the palate can be expanded in adults by gently stretching the sutures rather than splitting them, encouraging bone remodelling and three-dimensional changes to the midface and airway. Jaz notes that this view is controversial, as many dentists are taught adult expansion needs miniscrew-assisted or surgical approaches.
QUESTION:
How should dentists screen patients for sleep problems?
ANSWER:
Dave suggests looking at facial and craniofacial features, using questionnaires such as the Epworth Sleepiness Scale, and noting related conditions such as high blood pressure. Patients at risk can have a home sleep test or polysomnography, but the diagnosis must be made by a physician. He recommends building strong working relationships with sleep and ENT colleagues.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Dr Dave Singh is a UK-trained dentist and orthodontist with a PhD from Bristol in craniofacial cleft lip and palate, and a Doctor of Science in Orthodontics. He moved to the US to join a craniofacial team, was until recently a professor of sleep medicine at Stanford, and invented the DNA appliance. He is the founder of Vivos and of his new company, REMA Sleep.