Understanding great literature is better than trying to read and understand (yet) another business book, Leadership Lessons From The Great Books leverages insights from the GREAT BOOKS of the Western canon to explain, dissect, and analyze leadership best practices for the post-modern leader.
Hello, my name is Jesan Sorrells, and this
is the Leadership Lessons from the Great Books Podcast,
episode number 207,
with a brief selection from our book today.
And I quote, The order to abandon ship
was given at 5 PM. For most of the men, however, no
order was needed because by then everybody knew that the ship was done and
that it was time to give up trying to save her. There was no show
of fear or even apprehension. They had fought unceasingly for
3 days and they had lost. They accepted their
defeat almost apathetically. They were simply too tired
to care. They worked with a deliberate
urgency, hardly speaking to one another. There was no display of
alarm, however. In fact, apart from the movement of the ice
and the sounds from the ship, the scene was one of relative calm.
The temperature was 8.5 degrees below zero, and a light southerly
wind was blowing. Overhead, the twilight sky
was clear. By 7 PM, all
essential gear had been transferred to the ice, and a camp of sorts had been
established on a solid floe a short distance to starboard. The
lifeboats had been lowered the night before. As they went over the side of
the boat onto the ice, most of the men felt immense relief at being away
from the doomed ship, and few, if any, of them would have
returned to her voluntarily.
However, a few unfortunate souls were ordered back to retrieve various items.
One was Alexander Macklin, a stocky young physician who also
happened to be the driver of a dog team. He had just tethered his dogs
at the camp when he was told to go with Wild to get some lumber
out of the ship's forehold. The 2 men started out and had just
reached the ship when a great shout went up from the campsite. The floe on
which the tents were pitched was itself breaking up. Wild and Macklin
rushed back. The teams were harnessed, and the tents,
stores, sledges, and all the gear were hurriedly moved to another
floe 100 yards farther from the ship.
Later, in the privacy of his diary, Macklin confided,
quote, I do not think I
have ever had such a horrible, sickening sensation of fear
as I had whilst in the hold of that breaking
ship, close quote.
There's a question before us today on the show that is
presented by the book that we are going to be
covering today. Do we build great
things, do great things, or even think great thoughts in America anymore,
or even in the West? This is a question that has haunted
us in the United States since the end of the Cold War in 1989
and the turning on of the commercial internet the same year. We
were promised flying cars and rocket trips to the moon, but instead we got 140
characters, the venture capitalist and recent
Antichrist alarmist Peter Thiel quipped about 15 years ago.
And he wasn't wrong.
Sure, there are great engineering feats being accomplished, but in other
places like China and, well,
China. Here in the West, we amuse ourselves
to death while our heroes are looking for jobs, moving lines of code around, all
the while dodging the menstruations of the harridans of HR, those
low-level busybody enforcers at the tail end of the liberal world order.
What is to be done here at the end of the Fourth Turning
since cynicism, nihilism, and existential doomerism seem to have
run their course now? in the United States.
The Victorian poet Robert Browning in the last century
wrote in his poem Andrea del Sarto, and I quote,
ah, but a man's reach should exceed his grasp, or what's a heaven for?
Close quote. But how can we reach for heaven
if we no longer believe in it as a place to go?
Will we in the West build great things, do great things, or propose great things
again? I think so. As a matter of fact,
I think the rails for a future and for future
greatness are being laid right now in our time. We're
just too blinkered staring at the headlines on our phones
to notice. The book we are exploring
today, the book I just read from, Is a manual. Dare I
say it is even maybe even a map for how to work through the
painful middle between starting the quest to accomplish something
great and the end goal of not always
achieving it. How do we fail with honor?
What do we owe the people we have dragged, harassed,
and even pulled along with us, sometimes against their will?
And how big should our ambitions be before our
lives inevitably end?
Today on the show, we will summarize and extract lessons from a
book by journalist and historian Alfred Lansing,
examining the trials and tribulations of Sir Robert Shackleton
and his ill-fated voyage, the last
ill-fated voyage During the heroic age of Arctic
exploration. Endurance:
Shackleton's Incredible Voyage.
Leaders, it's time to mount up, I believe,
fundamentally, and ride the rails into a new era of
heroic greatness. If, if
indeed we have all of Shackleton's courage to do so.
And back to discuss what we can learn and what we could take
from this book about heroism and the challenges that Shackleton
faced is our co-host, back from episode number 199, where we
discussed The Glory of Henry V,
Zach Stuckey. How you doing today, Zach?
How's it going? It's going well. Going real well.
Very excited to discuss this, um,
because going into this, I didn't know a lot about Shackleton.
And, um, man, this story is
fascinating. If you haven't read the book, I highly recommend picking it up and
just, just learning about this guy, because
man, what he was able to accomplish is
remarkable. And there are lots of lessons.
The— now we usually do at this part, we usually read through sort of a
little bit about the author because I like to lay the foundation for folks
who are joining us, you know, on the show,
who may be joining us for the first time. There's always someone joining us for
the first time who may not know who the author
of our books are. And Alfred Lansing was
not by himself— the author of this book was not by himself a
remarkable man. If you, if you look at
his Wikipedia and you do a little bit of research on him on the internet,
you know, he was born in, in July of 1921. He passed away
in 1975. He was a journalist and a writer.
He served in the US Navy during World War II and he received a Purple
Heart. And then later on, he enrolled in North Park College and later at
Northwestern University where he majored in journalism.
He edited a major weekly newspaper in Illinois until
1949 when he joined the United Press. And in 1952, he
became a freelance writer. He spent time in New
York writing for the book section of Reader's Digest and Time Incorporated,
which most people don't remember Reader's Digest, but that was the
way that most middle-class folks
got engaged with reading and got engaged with novels back in the
day, that the Reader's Digest condensed books that you can, you can find in
any— pardon my, my, my appellation here and pardon my
framing here, but that you could find in any dying boomer's library in
any old, any old house. Because they bought a lot of them. They
really did. Those really brought, you know,
New York Times bestselling books to, to the masses.
And he wrote for them. And he eventually returned to
Chicago and became the editor of Bethel Home News. And then eventually he
wound up in Bethel, Connecticut, and passed away in Bethel, Connecticut.
During the course of time, however,
he— and it says here on the back of the— on the back of— well,
not on the back, but on the intro to the book—
he got a hold of, or he got engaged
with this story at some point
in time during his career.
He got engaged with the story of Shackleton's voyage. And I love this quote here.
At some point soon after their marriage, Barbara, who was his wife,
remembers Lansing, quote, reading something that sparked his
interest in Shackleton and the Endurance. Up
until that point, the only significant book about the expedition had been Shackleton's own book,
South, which was written in 1919, which we also have. And I'll eventually
read that on the show too. A ghostwritten account that harkens back to the
Edwardian era of heroic exploration. We have
pierced the veneer of outside things, Shackleton intones after
describing how he and 2 others survived the unforgettable slide down the
icy side of a near-vertical peak that delivers them to the outskirts of a
whaling station in South Georgia Island. We have
seen God in his splendors. We had heard the text that
nature renders. We had reached the naked soul of man.
Clearly, after 2 world wars and the emergence of Ernest Hemingway,
it was time to free the story of the Endurance Expedition from this sarcophagus
of stilted prose, close quote. And
Lansing sought to do that with, with his story.
Um, tell me what you thought about the writing of it. Tell me what you
thought about what the author, you know, sort of focused on and, and what you
kind of initially sort of took from, from the book. Well, for
starters, people don't write like that anymore.
They don't write like that anymore. And you can tell I
can't remember which author it was, but, but they would—
they wanted to learn to write like other authors. And this would have
been maybe, oh, probably the
turn of the 20th century. So 19th into the 20th
century. And so they, they gave this advice about
if you want to learn to write like great authors, literally
write what they wrote. And so this author would sit there
and he would write exactly word for word A Tale
of Two Cities, then Great Expectations, then, you know,
Oliver Twist and A Christmas Carol, and just literally wrote the
great works by hand and ended up writing some great, great works
himself. And I think that that's very evident with Lansing
here, where he's writing for the book section
in Reader's Digest, and it's very clear that he's
been impacted for the better
by these great books. And it's something that I wish we saw
more of in writing today,
you know. Um, the
nakedness of men's souls— like, people don't
write like that, man. That's a good line. That's a good line.
Well, and you see it in, um, in chapter, uh, chapter 3 of
of, uh, of Endurance when Lansing is documenting
Shackleton's, you know, attempt to gather all these guys
together, right, to go into— and to, to go,
to go explore, right, to, to go down and to see, to see
what's there. Um, and it opened— chapter 3
opens up with, they were on their way at last, really on their way,
and Shackleton was immensely relieved. Uh, the long years of
preparation were over.
Ellipsis. The begging, the hypocrisy, the finagling, all were
finished. The simple act of sailing had carried him beyond the
world of reversals, frustrations, and inanities.
And in the space of a few short hours, life had been reduced from a
highly complex existence with 1,000 petty problems to one
of the barest simplicity in which only one real task
remained. The achievement of the goal. In
his diary that night, Shackleton summed up his feelings. Quote,
now comes the actual work itself. The fight will
be good. Who
frames history that way anymore?
We just read Empire of the Summer Moon by the author and
journalist S.C. Gwynne on the show. That was a 2-part
episode. You should go back and listen to both parts. And, and I'm
telling you, S.E. Gwynne writing from— I think the book was published in
2010— writing from 2010 is
not writing romantically the way, the way
Lansing is writing about Shackleton. He's writing factually.
He's trying to get across facts. He
does make some statements in Empire of the Summer Moon that
the Comanche Nation found to be objectionable. And he does
frame it in a certain kind of way, but that
framing is definitely postmodern and lacking romance.
Lansing isn't writing about Shackleton like this and about Shackleton's
voyage and the guys that were on his ship and went along with him
on this journey, and we'll talk about the expedition in just a moment, but who
went along with him on this expedition in that kind of way. Yeah. He's writing
about it in a way where he wants people to be romantically
engaged. He wants them to see the adventure.
He wants them to be inspired to great things, even though,
you know, it may not have worked out for Shackleton in the end. Well,
and look at, look at this guy. So, so people often call
Churchill the, the last inheritor of the
Victorian era, right? Sort of the, the last
lion, which is a great series of books, by
the way. But I think
that Lansing could sort of be
looked at as the last inheritor of
the modern romantic sort of
inclination, because this book is published in
1959. This
is right when, you know, postmodernism is starting to take
hold in Mamatra with
Foucault and Derrida and all of these other guys.
So The world hasn't lost its
mysticism. It hasn't lost its, its
ability for beauty. And that, to me,
is one of the reasons why
this book is so enduring, right, is that
it does allow for this tragedy to be
a very beautiful thing, in a way. Yeah.
This is something we talk about on this show. And so one of the distinctions
with the difference that I've sort of brought to our listeners
is a sort of this, this sort of not
idea, but the sort of insight that, you
know, we, we have a lot of tragic
circumstances that cross our social media
feeds and even in the era of television. If
it bleeds, it leads, right? Tragic circumstances
will be delivered to us, right?
They will be delivered to us first in the television
era, which Lansing is writing
as this is beginning, but also in the newspaper era.
We will deliver to you tragic circumstances, but at least in newspapers and with writing,
they did attempt to make it kind of romantic. But then you make that switchover
into TV in the '60s and '70s, and now it becomes more and more
sensationalized. And then of course, we take that sensationalization. And now
we assume it to the algorithm and now AI. And now we're fully into
the sensationalistic nature of tragic
circumstances. Yeah. There's a difference between tragic
circumstances and telling a tragic story.
So a tragic story could be a hero's journey, but tragic circumstances are
merely just one more thing that you experience in your Instagram
scroll in between grandma's recipes and whatever some social
media influencer is saying. Well, and, and you've
got tragic stories like the Arthurian legend, which is
truly a tragic story, right? And then you've got tragic
circumstances, which are, my cat has cancer. You know,
those are, those are 2 fundamentally different things. And I think that
where things started to lose the plot was this sort of
postmodern inclination to, to question
everything and break it down into systems and, and
look at it cynically instead of the more
romantic view of there is mystery and magic in
the world that we can't explain. And isn't that wonderful?
You know, that's— that to me is, is
where we have missed the boat in modernity.
And I think that the best leaders are the ones who are able to sort
of inject that mysticism and magic into what they're doing.
Because yes, you need to look at things rationally, but if
all you have is reason, then, then you have no
room for hope because hope sometimes
is irrational. And this is something that a
friend of mine and I were talking about sort of in a different context, and
he brought this point up to me, um, and he'll be on our show actually
a little bit later on in the year. We're going to talk about, uh, the
book, uh, The Book That Changed Your World. We're gonna talk about that book towards
the end of the year, and he's going to come on for that, Brian Bagley.
But he and I were talking about this, and he said something that has
struck me, and I haven't really been able to do anything with it. So maybe
you'll be able to help me. But he said that
the areas of American society— and he's a former
pastor, so he's going to really focus in on that. But you could broadly— this
is a broad stroke critique— the areas of American
society that should have been most focused on preserving
virtue, which allows us to preserve romance, by the way, and put a story
around tragic circumstances that instead turn them from merely
just one more thing happening to a story.
The institutions that should have preserved that pragmatism, or sorry,
that virtue instead got captured by pragmatism. And
pragmatism is merely, to your point about rationality, it's merely
the rational weighing and measuring
of different circumstances, figuring out what works and what doesn't. And
by the way, this goes along with deconstruction and then sort of moving along.
And the triumph of pragmatism has destroyed— this is the point he was making— the
triumph of pragmatism has destroyed virtue,
particularly in institutions that should have been dedicated to preserving that virtue.
I don't know what to make of that critique. I don't know how to hold
that. I don't know if you have any thoughts about that, but it occurred to
me when you were talking about How Lansing is writing about
Shackleton's
Victorian effort to
cross the Antarctic. And we'll talk a little bit about that in just a second.
But that Victorian effort to cross the Antarctic, the way
in which Lansing wrote about this
was a way that was not, or
that went against, at least in my brain, what you're talking
about, went against pragmatism. Am I thinking about that
correctly, or is there something in my friend's critique that's
off on that? Because I'm a pragmatist myself
by nature, and so I want to do what works. But at the same time,
I do have a romantic, a bit of a romantic soul. Well, I
think that we're conflating pragmatism with cynicism
in this case. Okay. All right. And I think that
virtue Is, is necessary
for romanticism because you have to believe in
heroism as a virtue, right? But if you,
if you look at cynicism and, and to a certain extent
pragmatism, but, but more broadly speaking, cynicism,
cynicism is shades of gray,
right? And if you can boil everything down to shades of
gray, well, then there is no virtue. Right. Because virtue is
just one shade of gray versus another shade of gray. Okay. And
so that's all our society has
become, is obsessed with shades of gray. Because if
we have shades of gray, then we can excuse
any behavior. Any behavior becomes
excusable at that point. And you cannot— I
noticed you're drinking your, your Jocko energy drink here.
Jocko Willink's concept of extreme
ownership cannot take root in a society
that has sort of this, this shades of gray moral
relativism that allows me to excuse any behavior. Right.
Because you, you have no, no
room to say, well, you're bad and I'm good. And this all comes
because we choose to be defined by our circumstances
instead of being defined by something
else. Right. I think it was Bishop J.
Fulton Sheen, Fulton Sheen, something like that, who said we
would not bow to the yoke of Christ. So we are
forced to bow to the yoke of Caesar. And I think that
that sort of encapsulates this idea of if we
do not choose to be defined by something
greater than ourselves, like you talked about earlier, reaching for heaven. Why would we
reach for heaven if there is no heaven? If
we won't be defined by the fact that we are,
you know, followers of Jesus Christ or Buddha
or whatever, and we have an inherent nature that we are trying to
overcome and that we can
by degrees, by consistent mental physical effort,
overcome that, that baser nature that resides
in all of us, if we choose not to be defined by that and instead
choose to be defined by the circumstances in which we find ourselves
at any given moment, then we have to
have a law for every circumstance. We
cannot be trusted to govern ourselves. And that's the,
the problem that we're facing And that's why
Endurance is such a remarkable story, because
given all of these very difficult circumstances, it would be very
easy for a mutiny to have occurred. But my
understanding is
that in such mutiny, they weren't entirely pleased with everything that went
on, but they weren't doing what
Hudson's crew did to him, which is Okay, you and a few other guys are
getting set adrift in Hudson's Bay because we're going home.
Right, right. Well, that gets to— and I want to— I'm glad you brought this
up. That gets to who Shackleton
was as a, as a leader. So you can see this chapter
2 of the book. I love this. I'm going to read a few selections here.
So
Shackleton was introduced to the idea of going to the Atlantic
through his marriage
to the daughter of a wealthy lawyer. And
you can see this, and I'm gonna just quote from the book directly here. The
first introduced him to the Antarctic and his imagination was immediately
captivated. The second increased his desire for wealth.
He felt obliged to provide for his wife in the manner to which she was
accustomed. Who, by the way, pause, who talks about,
who talks about a wife that way anymore? Anyway,
back to the book. The Antarctic and financial security became more or less
synonymous in Shackleton's thinking. He felt that success there,
some marvelous stroke of daring, a deed which would capture the world's
imagination, would open the door to fame, then riches.
Between expeditions, he also pursued his financial masterstroke. He was perennially
entrenched with new schemes, each of which in turn he was sure would win his
fortune. It would be impossible to list them all, but they included an idea
to manufacture cigarettes, a surefire plan with his endorsement,
a fleet of taxicabs, mining in Bulgaria, a whaling
factory, even digging for buried treasure. Most of his
ideas never got beyond the talking stage, and those that did were usually
unsuccessful. Shackleton's unwillingness
to succumb to the demands of everyday life and his insatiable excitement with
unrealistic ventures left him open to the accusation of being basically
immature and irresponsible. And very possibly he
was, by conventional standards.
And this is the great sentence. But the great leaders of historical record, the Napoleons,
the Nelsons, the Alexanders, have rarely fitted any conventional mold. and
it is perhaps an injustice to evaluate them in ordinary terms.
There can be little doubt that Shackleton, in his way, was
an extraordinary leader of men.
And then I go to this quote, which I love.
Nor did the Antarctic horizon to Shackleton merely the grubby
means to a financial end. In a very real sense, he needed it.
Something so enormous, so demanding, that it provided a touchstone for
his monstrous ego and implacable drive.
In ordinary situations, Shackleton's tremendous capacity for boldness and
daring found almost nothing worthy of its pulling power. He was
a Percheron draft horse harnessed to a child's wagon
cart. But in the Antarctic,
here was a burden which challenged every atom of his strength.
Thus, while Shackleton was undeniably out of place, even inept at a great many everyday
situations, he had a talent, a genius even, that he shared with
only a handful of men throughout history: genuine leadership.
He was, as one of his men put it, quote— this is the
quote— the greatest leader that ever came to
God's earth, bar none. For all his blind
spots and inadequacies, Shackleton merited this tribute.
And, uh, and it is a tribute from— I have the guy who had the
quote, Sir Raymond Priestley, who was commenting on Shackleton one
time. I love this quote, and I quote from Sir
Raymond, uh, Priestley talking about Shackleton:
For scientific leadership, give me Scott. For swift and efficient
travel, Amundsen. But when you are in a hopeless situation
where there seems no way out, Get down on your knees and
pray for Shackleton. Close quote.
This then was the man who developed the idea of crossing the Antarctic
continent on foot.
Dude had a monstrous ego. And, and by the way,
by the way, I'm a big fan of like Ulysses S. Grant. So
when I read about Shackleton as written about
by Alfred Lansing, I'm remembering Ulysses S. Grant, who was a failure.
at literally every normal thing, every normal thing,
except, except for war. He was even a failure
at the presidency. The presidency wasn't enormous enough
for Grant. And Grant knew it, by the way. He knew it.
Well, I think that he was hard on himself. I actually am a fan of
Grant as a president. I think that he was hard on himself because look at
the shoes that he's being called to fill. He's not filling
Andrew Johnson's shoes. He's filling Abraham
Lincoln's shoes. That's true. And, and yes,
Grant recognized that he was a— because Grant is one of my heroes,
like he's on my, my, my wall of fame, you know.
And I think that, that Grant did
exactly what the president is supposed to do according to the
Constitution, which is execute the law.
And yes, he had some, some hucksters that got in there
that did what they were supposed to that they were not supposed to do.
But when it was discovered, he got them out as quickly as possible. And
it, it wasn't perfect, but he had huge shoes to fill.
But I agree, I was thinking exactly the same thing when you brought it
up, that Grant failed at just about
everything that he tried that was not soldiering.
Mm-hmm. The only other thing that he did that succeeded was
adjacent to soldiering, which is telling his story of
soldiering. That's the
only other thing that he did well. And that was largely because
Mark Twain helped him. I don't know that it would
have been as successful, his memoirs would have been as successful without
Mark Twain's intervention. Yeah. But
I love the connection here.
Because I think that it is actually very apropos, right? It
seems to me that— and this is actually— I'm going to sound
a little egotistical here, but I kind of feel sort of a kindred soul
here because sometimes it's very easy for me to get down on
myself and feel like I have this ineptitude for everyday
stuff, for the mundanity of life.
But these men that you reference, were literally— it
was almost like they were tailor-made for these
extraordinary circumstances in which they found themselves.
And it reminds me of a quote from
Shakespeare, and I'm going to butcher it, so please forgive me.
But, you know, some men are born great, some men
achieve greatness, and others have greatness thrust upon them.
And it seems to me that Shackleton is an example of someone
who who had greatness thrust upon him and rose to the
moment just like Grant did. He
also was— and we can't take this part out, and this gets to what I
was saying in my opening— he was a man. And I still
believe, by the way, there are people like this in the United States, and I
still believe the United States is still the best vessel for men like this because
men like this still come. And yes, let me be very clear
to all my ladies who are listening, Women can have the same sort of monstrous
egos, but women channel it differently because they're allowed different
channels. And that's just sort of the way it is, um,
for a whole variety of reasons that we have gotten into on this show in
the past and we will get into in the future, but we can't really get
into right now. Men come from other
countries to here because this is still the best
vessel. The West in general, but the United
States in particular, is still the best nation state with the
best creed and the best structure to be able
to channel those monstrous desires to do something
great into a place where you can
actually do that. And by the way, if you don't believe me,
Elon Musk is South African. He's not an American.
There will be people, and this is where I get back to what I was—
this is now the click-through. There will be people who will be willing
Well, no, not even people. I'll give you a perfect example. Let me pause it.
Let me rewind this back. NASA just opened up its
applications for the Artemis II
expedition, which
is going to establish a base on the moon.
Last time NASA opened up its applications
for astronauts They got over 8,000
applications and picked 10 people. That's amazing.
There are still— I now I go back to,
I go back to, um, I go back to Elijah in the Old Testament. There
is still a remnant, which is what God told Elijah.
There is still a remnant of people in the United States
who are willing, who are drawn, who are called
Deep in their soul to escape the mundanity of normal life
and to go out and do something heroic. And in our era, the most
heroic thing that's coming up on the horizon is both the moon and
Mars. Those are the 2 most heroic things that are coming up on the horizon.
And you can call Musk crazy and you could say those
astronauts are nuts, but I think Lansing would
say, if he were here, if we were interviewing him, Just like
people called Shackleton nuts to walk across
Antarctica on foot. There's no difference.
And so the age of heroism has not left us. It's just been,
as I sort of quipped in my opening, it's just been muted by the HR
harridans of a fading liberal world order. That's all.
It's just been muted by them. Well, and let's be honest, HR's job is
to just make sure that the company doesn't get sued. Like, that is, that is
HR's job. And frankly, they cause
way more problems than they solve, in my opinion. But, but
I, I actually, I think I'm going to push back on this because I think
that for the extraordinary people or people who are put into
extraordinary circumstances, you are absolutely right. That
the Moon and Mars are sort of that next frontier. But
if you look at society's problems and a microcosm. I
think that the next frontier is actually living a life of
virtue, having a family, building a
company, rebuilding American infrastructure. I
think that those are going to be the heroic things as well. I don't know
if you've ever read the book Freedom's Forge by, shoot, Herman
something. Anyways, it's a great book, talks about
the, essentially the rebuilding of
American infrastructure prior to World War II. Because if
you look at our history, we have sort of these, these
periods of great industrialization. The first one is— it
starts in 1793. Next one is after the Civil
War, actually. The third one is kind of
like right around the
1930s. Fourth one is the 1950s.
And potentially we're entering into another great period of
reindustrialization, depending on a bunch of different
factors. But I think that
the, the men that that book talks about, Freedom's Forge, were every
bit as heroic as an
Elon Musk or, you know, an
Ernest Shackleton, just in different ways. For
example, For example, one of the guys whose name escapes me right
now, he was born in
Scandinavia. I think it was Danish. And he came to the United States,
got a job working for Chevy, and literally worked his way up from the
factory floor to being the CEO of the company because he
was able to look at these systems and see, we're not doing this
right. We're being highly inefficient. And he is sort of the
father of all subsequent operations management
theory, even like Toyota Production Systems and everything else. It's
not Deming. It's not Deming.
Deming is actually an acolyte of this guy.
I wish I could remember his name. Anyway, it'll
come to me. I'll look it up. But, and maybe you can do an insert
and be like, readers, it was this guy. But But the
point is, is that he was like the father of all of it.
And he led to Toyota Production System, Six Sigma, Black Belt,
Kaizen, all of that stuff. But the point is, is that
that is no less heroic because look at what it
was able to do. Because of the work that he was able to do,
we won World War II. Like, without this guy, we don't win World War II.
War II, literally. Mm-hmm. It was during the Great Depression,
and FDR is just hammering this guy over and
over and over again in the press and saying, all of your problems are
because of that guy. And then FDR calls
this guy on the phone and says, I need you to come to the White
House. We have to talk. Something's going on in Europe that's
going to change everything. And
His wife and kids are like, Dad, what are you doing? Why on earth
would you go and talk with that man who's done everything to drag your
reputation through the mud? And he says, because
he is my president and I am an American.
Because he is my president and I am an
American. And because of this guy, they
actually started Getting American
industrialization tooled up so that we could be
to the point where we're churning out a Liberty ship, which was a supply
ship, literally every day.
It used to take them a month plus to do it, and they got to
the point where they could do it in less than 24 hours. Like,
that is heroic. So I don't disagree with you that that is
heroic. Actually, I don't disagree with you on that at all. I, and I think
that this is, this is represented in the book by the gentlemen that,
the men that Shackleton pulled along with him. Mm-hmm.
Who joined him on his journey and who did, who
performed impossible feats, um,
when like the ship was breaking apart and
when they had to make the decision about, this is one of the gnarly
parts of the book, but they had to make a decision about what to do
about the dogs. Yes. And, and eating them, right?
Um, and when they had to figure out how
to get through those long Antarctic nights when you couldn't
walk and when the ice floes were breaking up and when it was
really cold to go outside and, you know, empty the container
of, you know, empty the container of urine, like, you know, all the, all
the, all the, all the, the, the monumentally
small things. things, right, that we take for
granted just happen. Also, to your
point, I agree, can be heroic.
However, let me sharpen my point. I think that we
have elevated the banal a little bit too much,
just like we have many other things in our society and culture. We've screwed up
the hierarchy. Partially this is because of deconstructionism, but also it's
because of— It's because when you lose heaven,
when you lose what to aim for, then you become mired in the muck.
And the small things, while heroic in and of themselves in their
proper order in the hierarchy, when they are
misordered in the hierarchy, become something else.
And I think that a reordering is actually occurring.
I think it's occurring, to your point, I think it's occurring in our social media
feeds. I think it's occurring because this is where it's going to happen. I think
it's occurring in our actual lives. I think it's occurring in the kinds of conversations
we're having. We're not the only ones having this conversation. A
cultural reordering is going on, a reshuffling of the hierarchy.
Yeah. And the people who do those small
things will still be honored.
And I think a person like Shackleton will say, as
one of those old men said, um, at the beginning of Band of Brothers, that
great HBO show, um, when he was asked by his grandkids, you know,
were you a hero? And he said, no, but I was in the company
of heroes. That line just kills me every single time.
The men who came along with Shackleton, who did the
small things like what you're talking about,
They thought they were in the— I'm sure, well, they didn't think that probably at
the time, but afterward they understood that they had been in the company of
heroes. And I think that that's what we're missing. Everybody doesn't want to be the
hero, but everyone wants to— I believe fundamentally everybody wants to go along on the
hero's journey. This is why Odysseus—
Odysseus's men followed him to the end of the earth because they want to go
along on the journey. They want to be able to tell the tale, not
necessarily in their social media feeds, but they want to be able to tell the
tale to their kids. Yes. And to their grandkids. Well,
and to your point, there's the great speech from the movie Patton. Now,
I don't know if this is actually something Patton said,
but he talks about, you know, you lucky— and I'm going to
use his language, which he basically says— He was a
salty dog. Yes, he was. He basically says,
you lucky bastards don't know how lucky you are.
Because you don't— when your grandkids ask, what did you do in
the great World War II? You don't have to say, well,
I shoveled shit in Louisiana.
That's right. I love that line. It's a great
line. By the way, Francis Ford Coppola was the writer of Patton.
People forget that. No way. Oh yeah. Oh man.
Oh yeah. Coppola wrote Patton. which people forget about that.
That's phenomenal. It's just, it's such a monstrously—
I mean, he comes out in front of that giant American flag and George C.
Scott just, just, just nails it out to the back row, right?
Um, and when most people think about Patton, they don't think about the historical Patton.
They think about that movie because that's how good— that's how good that
speech was. But, um, to your point, Historically speaking,
yes, Patton did say some variation of some of those kinds of,
of phraseology, um, in
many interactions that he had. Because just like
Shackleton, he was a person of monstrous ego, um,
who walked around with pearl handle pistols and,
and, you know, pearl handle revolvers and wanted—
he wanted to bring people along on the journey. And this is the thing that
we forget about heroics. This is the thing that we forget about.
And I think we have to be reminded about it. So I think of— and
this is sort of the last sort of— I'll make a sports reference here. And
this is the last one I'll make during this episode. But I think of Michael
Jordan in The Last Dance. And I
watched Michael Jordan. I grew up during those years. So I'm very familiar with Michael
Jordan and how Michael Jordan was and how he played.
He was a completely unlikable— and he still is, a
completely unlikable person. He is petty and small
and has a monstrous ego. And I'm sure he's worked on that now that he's
in his 60s, but it's, but it's, but it's still there,
right? And
he got into people when they didn't want
to be gotten into, and he dragged people along. He harassed,
he bullied, he intimidated. He— but he wanted
to be the greatest. And he says this in The Last Dance, I wanted to
be great, and I wanted other people to go along with me on that journey
too. So if I got into people's faces and got them to do things they
didn't want to do, well, I mean, that was the cost. But was I a
tyrant? Well, maybe, but you say that because you've never won anything.
If you don't want to play the game this way, then go play it a
different way. Go do something else. And this, I think, is an
important It is. And this is really important
because you have to dare mighty
things. And this is where the romance— we've lost the romance, but where the
romance comes in, right? Uh, you know, it, it's very
trite, but shoot for the moon. If you miss, you'll reach the stars, right?
Like, but, but the fact of the matter is, like,
he was the greatest to play the game, in my opinion. Yeah. Because he
was so like dedicated with
that. And he wanted to bring other people along.
Yeah. Right. And it's— to me,
it's like, yes, there is
romance and beauty. And I brought up like the having a family
and rebuilding society's institutions because that's what
the average young person is going to be facing.
And for a young man, masculine energy is,
is really a building and an organizing energy. If you look at it,
masculine energy provides structure.
Without that structure, it is chaos.
And what is the opposite of, of masculine energy? It's feminine
energy. And Jordan Peterson calls feminine energy chaos, you know,
like him or hate him. But, but realistically, it's
like feminine is really good at maintaining and relating
to existing structures, but it's not good at building structure. And
I'm sure I'm going to get canceled for that, but it's, it's just, it's what
I believe. And I think that
what you're talking about is the step further.
It's not just taking the
parts that you have and building a house. It's, it's cutting
down the wood. It's stepping into the chaos and
imposing order where there was none. And that's where
I think that, that the men like Michael Jordan and,
and Shackleton and Grant and, you
know, Eisenhower, all of these guys really did that. Now,
Eisenhower is actually a really interesting case to me
because I don't know that he did necessarily step into
the darkness as much as Shackleton or some of these other guys
did. He was the great organizer and
orchestrator, and that impacted the next 80 years.
Yeah, I would say that Eisenhower was a linchpin
or a switch character in history, just the character of
Eisenhower, not the actual man himself, where he was
the link or the bridge between the old way
and the new way, and there always has to be a bridge. Yes. I think
right now we are living in bridge times because we have come out of
the Fourth Turning. We can't see the
next high yet, but the rails are being
laid by people. So I think Musk is a bridge
character in our reality. I think that
For all of his nonsense, I think Donald Trump is a bridge character. For all
of his nonsense, I think he is. This is not a political statement, it's merely
a statement about who he has allowed to be in his orbit to
do things, right? I
think that folks who are— and you
talk about average folks— I think the folks who are social media influencers,
particularly ones that are picking up on the zeitgeist of the time, whether they are
right or left doesn't matter, Politically speaking, I don't care about that.
They are bridge characters. So we are bridging
over to the next high, which, by the way, I always have to say this
on the show, will not look historically like the
last high we were in, which is what everybody remembers. Yeah. And
so we actually don't have a vision for the next thing
beyond heroics, like what Musk talks about with Mars. We
don't have a vision. Instead, we are sometimes captured by—
and this is why I brought up Peter Thiel— we are captured by
the remaining cynicism and nihilism, which is where he's coming from, the
Antichrist perspective, and the fear. And this is it,
the fear that we won't make it, the fear we won't make across that bridge.
Yes. And that's what we're currently in the moment of, is the fear
that we won't make it across that bridge. But I'm here to tell you,
You can get the right team of people together. That masculine energy
can get the right team of people together, and we can cross that bridge.
And this book shows us how to do this. So I want to talk about
the team for just a moment. Yeah. Back to the book.
Um, Shackleton built the crew list around a nucleus of tested
veterans. The top post as second in command went to Frank
Wild, a small but powerfully built man whose thin and mousy hair was
rapidly disappearing altogether. Wilde was a soft-spoken and
easygoing individual on the surface, but he had a kind of inner toughness. He had
been one of Shackleton's 3 companions in the race for the Pole in 1908 and
1909, and Shackleton had developed a tremendous respect and personal liking for
him. The 2 men, in fact, performed— formed a well-matched
team. Wilde's loyalty to Shackleton was beyond question,
and his quiet, somewhat unimaginative disposition was a perfect
balance for Shackleton's often whimsical and occasionally
explosive nature. Pause. Every Michael
Jordan needs a Scottie Pippen. You need a number 2.
Every Kobe Bryant needs a Shaquille O'Neal. I
haven't said this on the show recently. But leaders out there,
if you don't have a good number 2, go find one. And a
good number 2 is like William Riker
and to, you know, to the great, you know,
Jean-Luc Picard. played by the currently traveling
across the galaxy, now deceased Patrick Stewart. Um,
you need a number 2. You need a William Riker. You need a Scotty
Pippen. If you don't have a number 2, even in your family, if you don't
have a number 2, go find one. Um, and Shackleton had one in Wild.
Okay, back to the book. The birth of second officer aboard the Endurance was
given to Thomas Crean, a tall, raw-boned, plain-spoken
Irishman whose long service in the Royal Navy had taught him the ways of
unquestioning discipline Good. Number 3.
Alfred Cheetham, also shipped aboard as a 3rd officer, was Crean's
opposite in appearance. He was a tiny man, even shorter than Wild, with an unassuming,
pleasant disposition. Shackleton spoke of Cheetham as,
quote, the veteran of Antarctica, close quote, since he had already been on 3
expeditions, including one with Shackleton and one with Scott. Then
there was George Marston, the expedition's 32-year-old artist.
Marston, a boyish-faced chubby man, had done outstanding work On Shackleton's
1907-1909 trek. Unlike most of the others, he was a
married man with children. By the way, pause for just a moment,
gentlemen. Just because you're married with kids doesn't mean the time of heroic adventure is
over. And all you have to do
is sell your wife. And if you can't even sell her,
how are you gonna go on the heroic expedition?
All heroic expeditions start at home, gentlemen. Okay. The
nucleus of veterans— back to the book— the nucleus of veterans was completed when Thomas
McLeod was signed on the Endurance team as
a seaman. In the matter of selecting newcomers,
Shackleton's methods would appear to have been almost capricious.
If he liked the look of a man, he was accepted. If he didn't, the
matter was closed. And these decisions were made with lightning speed. There is
no record of any interview that Shackleton conducted with a prospective
expedition member lasting much more than 5
minutes. That's brilliant. Like,
you talk about speed and entrepreneurship, like, the dude knew what he
wanted and he could spot it, and he went on his intuition.
Leonard Hussey, an irrepressible, peppery little individual, was signed on as
meteorologist even though he had practically no qualifications for the
position at the time. Shackleton simply thought Hussey, quote unquote, looked funny.
And the fact that he had recently returned from an expedition as an
anthropologist from the torrid Sudan appealed to
Shackleton's sense of whimsy. Hussey
immediately took an intensive course in meteorology and
later proved to be very proficient.
Let me say something to the young men out there. Just because you don't know
something about something— and by the way, you have
more information than these gentlemen had at your fingertips. You have more
information now than they had in 1908, 1909,
1917, whenever, whenever, 1914. More
information. Go take the
initiative and go find the information. Go
find the plums. Doctor, back to the book. I
want to, I want to add to that really quick. Yeah, go ahead. Very briefly.
Yeah. The era of a, of a
diploma, adding anything to your credentials
is fast coming to a close. Yes. Because we have
so glutted ourselves with high, uh,
graduate college graduates that don't know
what they're talking about, that can't do what they were quote unquote trained
to do, right? That having a
college diploma will be worthless. So will be— so the
homeless guy next to you, like, he'll have a college diploma, right? So it's
meaningless. Oh, yeah. What is meaningful is, can you
do the job, or can you learn to
do the job quickly, just like this meteorologist?
That's where the value comes in, because the
world is changing so rapidly now because
of what AI can do. And make no mistake, what is
commercially available to the average person is merely a fraction
of what AI can actually do and is doing
for the companies that harness it. So I'm reading a
book right now. I'm not going to say the name of it, but I'm going
to have the author on in about a month.
And we are going to talk about the
challenges of AI adoption and the psychology behind AI adoption and
what leaders can do to sort of help other folks navigate this.
The material fact of AI adoption,
I would've said maybe 2 or 3 years ago, could
probably be fought against, but now I don't believe so,
or be resisted, but now I don't believe so. And so now
This is the pragmatic part of me. Now the issue becomes,
how do you become, to your point, how do you become more like the meteorologist?
And I think one of the key ways to becoming more like the meteorologist is
actually, weirdly enough, reading books. I
don't think it's in the AI. I think it's actually here in
the physical books, but that's just me. When you
enter my house, the first room you enter into is a library. Like, so I
might be biased.
Back to the book. The last 2 folks on the expedition, Dr. Alexander
Macklin, one of the 2 surgeons, caught Shackleton's fancy by
replying when Shackleton asked him why he was wearing glasses, quote,
many a wise face will look foolish without spectacles.
And Reginald James was signed on as physicist after
Shackleton inquired about the state of his teeth. Whether he
suffered from varicose veins, and if he was good-tempered, and if he
could sing. At this last question, James looked
puzzled. Oh, I don't mean any Caruso stuff,
Shackleton reassured him, but I suppose you can shout a bit with the boys.
Despite the instantaneous nature of these decisions, Shackleton's intuition for
selecting compatible men rarely failed.
Leaders trust your gut.
That is a way to build a team
without using algorithms, without,
without more data points, without analysis paralysis or
paralysis by analysis, whatever variation we want.
Shackleton believed so much in the
strength of his own vision.
that he was able to draw in, and I do believe it was a spiritual
and psychological drawing in, but we can leave that aside for just a minute. He
was able to draw in the type of
people into his orbit that would be compatible.
I don't know. I can't explain at a, at a tactical
material level how all that works, and I don't think we're supposed to. I think
we're actually supposed to leave that to other entities in other places.
I think we're just supposed to follow along with it. We're
just supposed to follow that thing. And if your gut
tells you this person's good, regardless of what the data
points say,
it's okay to trust your gut. And tragically, we live in an era— but tragically,
we live in an era where we have too much information and we default to
the information. And then when the person we
have picked proves to be incompatible
in person, but they were compatible on paper,
we now feel as leaders compelled to keep on going with them and try to
make them fit. Because our rational
intuition— not our rational intuition— our rationality
may have to say it was wrong and the data was wrong. And we don't,
we don't want to do that. Whereas with Shackleton, the way
that he's picking gentlemen and the way that he's picking people on his team,
if they're wrong, and I'm going to be blunt on this, if they're wrong, they're
dead. It's a very simple metric.
If you're wrong, you're dead. Now, this doesn't, this doesn't eliminate material skills. I mean,
for God's sakes, a physicist, a meteorologist, a, um, a
person, several people who had previous experience. So we did have previous job interview
experience with these guys before the 1914 expedition. across the Antarctic
on foot. I mean, he had seen them live, so he had some
parameters there. I'm not dismissing that. I'm merely saying
that all the data points in the world that you can get from your AI-driven
resume filter thing,
we still have to allow for the space for human intuition to
exist inside of leadership. And I worry a lot that
we crowd all that out in favor of the data points, and then we
become stuck when the data points don't prove out in real life,
or when things get far— I actually— I think you're absolutely
right. I think you're spot on here. One of the things that comes to mind
for me is that you could have had somebody else—
let's say Amundsen tried to do this expedition,
um, arranged the same team— he wouldn't have gotten the same outcome.
I think that Shackleton is sort of this linchpin in the team
that makes it all work because of, of his
nature. Now, I think that
part of that is— You mentioned
earlier sort of this almost supernatural calling
out to these men to come in, and I actually
believe that's true. I had a mentor who who taught me that all
great endeavors follow a 3-step process.
Goes vision, then people, then processes.
The visionary comes up with the vision. That
vision then attracts the people, the right people,
and then the people create the processes that make the vision a
reality. Now,
what's-his-face who wrote the garbage book Good to Great, And
yes, those are fighting words.
He says it's actually that you go first
who, then what. And I think that that's absolutely backward.
It is vision, people, processes. And we see that
that's what happens here. Shackleton has the vision.
The vision is big enough and exciting enough and romantic enough
that it speaks to the people. And it is the people who come
in who prove absolutely vital in
creating the processes and systems that they needed to
survive. So let's talk a little bit about
terror and disillusionment and the
silence of the Antarctic. So, um,
they thought they would have no trouble walking across the Antarctic Arctic on
foot. And I know this seems crazy to us now,
but it only seems crazy in retrospect looking back.
At the moment of that expedition moving forward,
Shackleton was on the tail end— Shackleton's expedition was on the tail end of,
as was already mentioned, the Heroic Age of Arctic Exploration.
People were going to the Antarctic on
ships, They were going to the Antarctic on dogsleds. They were
scaling mountains. They were doing big things. Were they
succeeding? Yes. Were they failing? Yes. But the Heroic Age was
an age— the Edwardian Age at the end of the Victorian era was an age
where, yes, quite frankly, British people
were looking to the North Pole and the
South Pole both as places where
that were the last great frontier that had not yet been penetrated by
colonialism. It had not been yet penetrated by British colonialism. And of course,
because the British had been doing colonialism for 400 years, they were like, of course
it's going to be us. Who else is there? There's nobody else. The Americans aren't
going to do it. This is 1914. The Americans are
highly insular. They just finished wrapping up the West
and closing out the West, and they're not quite They're not quite the industrial
behemoth they would later become post-World War II.
The French weren't going to do it. The French hadn't been
relevant on any kind of colonial expedition
since they ground out in— they began to grind out in Africa,
on the continent of Africa, particularly in Algeria, but then also other places.
The French were having problems. The Germans— this is 1914—
the Germans are ramping up for war. I mean, there's getting ready to be a
major war in Europe at the time when Lansing
goes on this expedition.
And the Russians, please, they're not even part of the
conversation. The pre-communist revolution,
pre-Leninist, royal Romanov-run
Russia, not the Soviet Union yet. It was a
mess. It was a mess. It was a mess. Not to put too
fine a point on it, but they couldn't find their hands with 2 behinds and
a flashlight. And yes, I did say it that way. That was
Russia. So this is the analysis that the
Britons, the British public,
and that heroic age is looking
around at. This is the neighborhood they're in, the context
in which they're making the decision to go to the poles, both the North Pole
and the South Pole, and to go on these heroic journeys.
Every heroic journey, however, has terror in it. And
even though they believed they would have no trouble accomplishing this,
they were not unused to the idea that there would be hardship. And this is
a distinction with a difference. Yeah. They knew it was going to be hard,
but they weren't scared.
And by scared, I don't mean They didn't have fear or they
didn't have trepidation. They probably had that, but
they did it, as I tell my 9-year-old, I told my 9-year-old recently, they did
it in spite of the fear, not to
avoid the fear, not because of the fear, but in spite of the fear.
These, these, and that's what being a hero,
that's being a hero really is about because we've sort of elevated this idea
of courage in a In a post-World War II— well, I always say
World War II— a post-Cold War context, we've taken this idea of being
a hero, and again, just like I said, misordering of the hierarchy, we've
brought it down, right? And
when you do that, the fear
of small terrors now becomes the driving force,
which is why we're all on it. Not all of us, but a lot of
us in this country are on SSRIs and anti-anxiety medication. Because the
fear of small terrors now becomes massive,
massive things, right? And
they were existentially— and this is a huge point that I got from the book—
these men that went on this expedition with Shackleton and all of the men that
were involved in the Heroic Age of Arctic and Antarctic
exploration, these men were existentially
unlike us. They would not recognize us
now, just as we do not recognize them. And
so I think we as leaders
need to be looking for, need to be seeking out,
um, well, we need to be seeking out
men who can be bound together through the strong gods of like shared
loves and truths and loyalties. Uh, I would assert a deep
commitment to a Christian worldview. But if you can't get that, shared loyalties,
you know, shared loves and capital-T Truths are usually helpful for
binding people together.
But you also have to recognize that when bad things do
come, the types of people you want are the types of
people who aren't going to run away. They're going to stick. They're
going to stick when the bad thing comes. They're going to stick when the shit
breaks apart. Like we opened up with, with, with today. They're going
to stick when the dogs die. They're going to stick when,
when the— yes, when the— they're
going to stick when the, when the, when the, when the shoes fall apart and
there's no more food. And, and now, well,
we're going to stick by taking a break. So we'll be right back in just
a moment. And we're
back. Okay. So you asked, you asked a
great question about these strong gods of
love, truths, loyalty, a shared Christian
worldview, and whether that kept the men alive.
And I actually think it was absolutely vital to
their survival. So I've been reading this book that
talks about what happened to the Korean— to
American prisoners of war during the Korean
conflict. And the
instances of physical torture were
higher during World War II and Vietnam. In
Korea, it was far more insidious.
So what they would do, these, these North Korean POW
camps, they would gather everyone
together And they would have these essentially
almost like revelation sessions where what they would
force everyone to do is talk about things that were
incredibly shaming. And they
wanted everyone to have sort of this,
this experience to be shamed in front of everybody else
so that you would no longer look at your commanding officer
as a, as a figure of authority. You
would no longer look at your buddy as someone worth respecting.
Uh, they would give people rewards for ratting
on their, on their fellow prisoners, like extra cigarettes and things like
that. Um, but they wouldn't punish the
person that was being ratted on. So
they would, they would sort of create this animosity
between everyone. And what ended up happening is that
there were people who would have what the POWs called
give-up-itis, where they would just go sit on their
cot, put a blanket over their head, and they'd be dead within 2 days because
they got so depressed and gave up, gave up on the will to live.
They wouldn't deliver letters that had good news to the prisoners. They
would only deliver bad news, like over overdue bills,
or the— a wife who's given up waiting for her husband
and is marrying, you know, moving on and going to marry someone else.
All of that stuff. And it strikes me
that the isolation of
endurance is sort of similar to these,
these POWs. But the way that they
handled it was entirely different in that
they were doing things every single day that would build camaraderie.
You're all— this is gonna sound gross, but it's true. You're all
eating the same dog. You're all eating the same seal.
You're all singing the same songs. As there was one
guy, I can't remember who, but the banjo player, they were
all singing the same songs with the banjo player. Yeah. Right? Like,
that built that camaraderie, and then everybody is
turning to the leadership and saying, okay, now what? What do we do
now? And I think that that's sort of where
the difference lies here, is that these, these strong
gods of shared loves, truths, and loyalties
are what kept them going. You know,
whereas in Korea they broke those, you know.
So you don't have love for your, your buddy, your commanding
officer, your, um, your
spouse at home. You don't have any sort of
moral truth because the guy that you thought was Mr. Morally
Upright, he's standing there and telling you about how one
day there was a little kid that saw get bayoneted that he should
have stopped but didn't, you know, so, and, and
so they're completely breaking all of that. And these guys, these POWs,
there are more POW casualties in Korea
than there were in World War
II. That
is— so yeah, no, go ahead. Yeah, no. Well, and so to
me, it's like, that's where things break down.
I also had some thoughts about the fear of small terrors, but I wanna hear
what you have to say and then we can go to that. Yeah, yeah. So
if you go to part 2 of Endurance—
and by the way, I usually kind of give a little— I should probably have
done this at the beginning— a little bit of a setup of sort of how
the book is put together, how the book is actually structured.
But yeah, I mean, you have great maps in the book. Of
the journeys that they went on, how they entered the ice pack,
went around the Weddell Sea, their open boat
journey from Elephant Isle to
South Georgia Island, and then where the Endurance
was crushed, where their ship was crushed, and then the drift of the ship.
Every effort was made to sort of put together— not to sort of, but to
put together an accurate representation of the,
um, of the journey. Um, and the book is divided up
into, into several different parts. And in part 2, it says this.
Part 2, chapter 1 opens up with this: May the Lord help you
to do your duty and guide you through all the dangers by land and sea.
May you see the works of the Lord and all his wonders in the deep.
Then we wind up talking about the breaking up
of the whaler and the breaking up of the Endurance,
and we go into detail about that. And to your
point, this is why I'm bringing this up, says this, and I
quote, McNeish and
McLeod, 2 members of the expedition, began mounting the whaler
and one of the cutters onto sledges. The boats with their sledges would weigh more
than a ton apiece, and nobody had any delusions that it would be easy to
drag over the chaotic surface of the ice with its pressure ridges
occasionally 2 stories high.
Nevertheless, there was a remarkable absence— this is to your
point— of discouragement. All the men were in the same state of
dazed fatigue, and nobody paused to reflect on the terrible consequences of losing their
ship, nor were they upset by the fact that they were now camped on a
piece of ice perhaps 6 feet thick. It was a haven compared with the nightmare
of labor and uncertainty of the last few days on the endurance. It was quite
enough to be alive. And they were merely doing what they had to do to
stay that way. There was even a case of mild
exhilaration in their attitude. At least they had a clear-cut
task ahead of them. In the 9 months of indecision, of
speculation about what might happen, of aimless drifting with the pack were over.
Now they simply had to get themselves out, however appallingly difficult
that might be. Then they
They packed the sleds into the next afternoon, into the next day.
They made pilgrimages back to the derelict ship, the Broken
Endurance, which was a torn and twisted framework of wood.
And then Shackleton did something interesting. Shackleton called all his hands together in the center
of a circle of tents. His face was gray. He explained it was
imperative that all weight be reduced to the barest minimum. Each man, he said,
should be allowed the clothes on his back, plus 2 pairs of mittens, 6 pairs
of socks, 2 pairs of boots, a sleeping bag, a pound of
tobacco, and 2 pounds of personal gear. Speaking with the
utmost conviction, Shackleton pointed out that no article was of any
value when weighed against their ultimate survival,
and he exhorted them to be ruthless in ridding themselves of every
unnecessary ounce, regardless of its value.
After he had spoken, he reached under his parka and took
out a gold cigarette case and several gold sovereigns and threw them
into the snow at his feet. Then he opened the
Bible Queen Alexandra had given them and ripped out the flyleaf and
the page containing the 23rd Psalm. He also tore out a
page from the Book of Job with this verse on it.
Out of whose womb came the ice and the hoary frost of heaven? Who
hath gendered it? The waters are hid as with a stone,
and the face of the deep is frozen.
Then he laid the Bible in the snow and walked
away.
Hold the Bible in your hearts, kids, because we're going to lay down everything that
you don't need. Yes. And,
and he practiced what he preached. He was
the first one to do it. If he hadn't done
that, they all would have said, okay, yeah, but
you didn't do it. So, so they'd all be carrying their own
stupid little things, right? And
it would have impacted their ability to travel, and they may not have
survived. And the failure of—
and you know what, I, I can't— I'm hesitant to judge people
in traumatic situations like war or prisoner of war situation.
I'm very hesitant to judge them because I'm not quite sure I would do any
better or perform any better than they did. I think it's massive hubris
to, to look back historically and to say, well, I would have done different. Or
I would have done better, or I would have done this, or I would have
done that. No idea what you would have done.
And let me say this: perhaps the
revelation sessions would not have been so effective
if some leader, an officer, or whoever
had just not gone along and just gotten
killed right there, and then the next one. And the next one,
and the next one, because they're going to kill you all anyway, or you're
going to die there. So you have nothing to lose but your lives.
But that level of commitment, that level
of principle, right, is
heroic in and of itself. And I also think that that is
one of the things that in the last 25 years of America.
what has frustrated Americans is, and you see this in this, in the current
election cycle, which I'm not going to get into, but you see this in the
current election cycle and in the last election cycle and in the one
before that and in the one before that and in the one before that and
in the one before that, going back 25 years.
I would even, yes, going back 25 years, this is when this started.
What we are looking for The small h heroes
is we are looking for big H heroes with principle,
principled enough to put down
the privileges and the trappings of power and to rapidly, not even rapidly,
but to abandon them the way that Shackleton did the gold sovereigns in the snow
and to go first. And we don't see that.
We don't see that anywhere. Had a conversation with around a book
called The Builder's Stone a few episodes ago. You should
go listen to that episode with a good friend of mine, Richard Messing.
And I agree with all the points made in The Builder's
Stone by Melanie Phillips.
However, her 10-point or 20-point plan for
restoring the West based on a shared Judeo-Christian
heritage, while I agree with it in
principle, The leadership
required to execute such a plan in fact
does not exist because the leadership in principle
can't even do the basic things that would require it to even take the
first step on the 10-point or 20-point plan that she has in the back of
her book. And this is where I will build into the recent
election, even though you won't. I think that this is where Republicans
failed.
Because they were elected in 2024 to do very specific things.
Get sexual predators out of government and prosecute them. Lower the
cost of living and get us out of these
entangling foreign wars. Basically be the populist
party. But the problem was, is that
they were claiming populism without actually doing anything that
the populace wanted. And that's
because they are men and women
without principle or virtue. Now,
everybody says, well, you know, everyone in Congress is bad
except for my congressperson. And
I don't care. I think that what has
happened is they have
forgotten their whole
purpose for the job that they are doing and become so enamored with
themselves. And it's a disease that spreads to everyone who goes there.
But on a larger scale,
they are exactly what you talked about. They are people who are
without this virtue or principle, so they are unwilling
to do the things that they have to do. And it's because they
lack context. And here's what I mean by this.
And this goes back to the— you called it the fear of small
terrors. And I just, I love that, the fear of small terrors, because
we live in a world that is surrounded by the fear of small terrors.
Now, why did Fight Club resonate with so many
people? Why did Chuck
Palahniuk, however you say his last name— Palahniuk. Yeah.
Yeah. Why did Fight Club resonate with so many people?
People say, oh, well, it was the, it was the, the book and movie that
defined Gen X. I actually disagree. I think that Fight
Club resonated with people because when you're in a situation
where you're going to get punched in the face or you punch first, you
get things put into context very quickly.
And we have lived in a society that has it so well for
so long, we are missing that context.
And because of that lack of context, the tyranny of
small terrors is able to take over our every
waking moment. But these men didn't have
the luxury— and yes, it is a luxury— of small terrors.
So this is where I— now this is the jiu-jitsu insert. Here we go.
So, you know, I mean, I've been doing jiu-jitsu for a while now, and,
you know, every time I talk about it on the show, you know, because
this is the venue I have to talk about it, and so I'm going to
use that. But you're right, like, there's
nothing more— even Joe Rogan has said this— there's nothing that will turn
you more politically conservative in a
heartbeat than any kind of martial arts, any type of
combat sports in general. And I use combat
sports very loosely, combat arts.
And yes, there is sport jiu-jitsu and there are sport martial arts, just like there
are combat jiu-jitsu and combat arts. Okay. Yes, I got it.
There's nothing that will turn you,
to your point, in a more principled direction quicker
than the consistent
execution in jiu-jitsu, in grappling.
Yes, wrestling will get you there. Boxing for sure.
Muay Thai. Shout out to all my Muay Thai people
who are listening because there are several of them. I know some of them
personally, but there is
nothing that will get you there closer. I was actually having a conversation with a
friend of mine, as I'm recalling this now, a conversation with a friend of mine
probably about a month and a half ago. And
he's a weightlifter and a big guy,
you know, weightlifter, fitness guy, fitness freak.
And he said, you know, the first time he did jiu-jitsu, he thought he was
gonna like, you know, just ragdoll this like
140-pound
kid. And he's like, I'm 225. I'm 6'2 and 225. Like, I've
been lifting weights for 10,000 years. It's fine. Like, I'll go get him.
And jiu-jitsu was, again, paraphrasing Joe Rogan,
jiu-jitsu is the one martial art that
delivers exactly as promised. And the promise of jiu-jitsu,
particularly Brazilian jiu-jitsu, is that the smaller person who is
trained will beat the bigger person who is untrained.
Yes, they will have muscle. Yes, they will have strength. And yes, that's a factor.
But you don't know what I know. And on a 3 to 5 minute
timeline, sorry, you're done.
And there is nothing more humbling. A friend of mine said this. There's nothing more
humbling than getting ragdolled by a 140-pound person that you thought
you were just going to take. And all of a sudden,
principle— now this ties into what you're saying, Zach— all of a sudden, principle gets
real, real clear,
real quick. Yeah. And that was what these men had. These men had
clarity because of circumstances about what was
real, what was not. They were also—
and this is something else, this is, this is the other, the other thing that
occurred to me while you were talking. These were men that
were not, as C.S. Lewis would frame them, men without chests.
Yes, we live in an era of men without chests from his
great essay, Abolition of Man. Great essay. Oh my
gosh, we covered it on the show. I believe it's like back in episode number
80-something. It's in the 80s somewhere. Go, go look it up.
But we have created men without chests. and then we
expect them to act with principle. We have created
politicians without chests and we expect them to act with
principle. And I do believe that over the next 25 years,
men with chests are coming back. I believe the era of men without
chests is over, or at least it's buried for the time being
because we're done with it. I agree. And
this makes me think of Nietzsche, who talked about, you
know, God is dead, but be very, very careful. Right. And I think that,
that what we did in creating a world of men without chests was
actually we followed through on the
snake's promise to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden, right?
You won't die, but you'll be like God, knowing good from evil.
And so the, the, you know, the, the promise that the
snake is making is you're going to be just like God. Right?
Which is not true. Um, but
we bought in, in modernity, we bought into that lie that we can be
our own god. And so we can't
have, uh, you know, bringing this back to the question of the strong,
uh, the strong gods, we can't have those things because we've set
every single man up. This is what postmodernism fundamentally does.
is creates an insular society where every single person is their
own sort of authority. And
who are you to tell me that the truth that I believe is any less
valuable or virtuous than the truth that you believe,
right? So we have no shared love, we have no
shared truth, we have no shared loyalty, because who are you to
be loyal to a country that da da da da da?
So we can't have those things. This is why we can't have nice things,
Hasan. But this
is why. Yes, but, but
it— the people that were
alive, that were on this expedition, they literally
did love king and country, right? When they sing God
Save the King, they're not just singing God Save the King, they're
praying, God save the king. The king.
That's right. That's right. This book is
incredible. I have it marked up, as you can see on the video. If you're
listening to it on the audio, you won't see that. But I have this book
marked up. I have it labeled. This is probably one of the most incredible
leadership books, right along with About Face by Colonel
David Hackworth and Once an Eagle.
which we're going to cover in the next couple of years on this
show as well, that really is a primer for how to
behave in tough situations, how do we
gauge when, to bring that quote back, all hope is lost,
what kind of people you need to take along on that expedition,
and what kind of expedition to mount.
It even explores the idea, because Shackleton, Let's be real. I want to be very
real here. Shackleton was not a person
necessarily that you would want to have over to your house for a
barbecue. You know, he wasn't a likable guy. And
by the way, I think that we have elevated
likability above all other virtues. Hmm.
And in particular, heroic people
are going to have to irritate somebody somewhere. Either by
accident or on purpose, and that is going to make them
unlikable. I don't mean a knucklehead. I don't mean,
pardon my use of the term, an asshole. But I mean, but it can go
there. But that monstrous ego that Shackleton had also
separated him from the men, and that is talked about in the book.
There was a clear separation, a clear hierarchy, and yes, partially it was a Victorian
hierarchy. It was our already enforced. These men already knew what the deal was,
and it was a hierarchy of class. But even in our own time,
we want everybody from the
CEO of Google to the Pope in Rome
to be likable. And I think we have to
abandon, or at least put that on the back burner, in order for
heroic actions to be done. And by the way, we see this in families.
And this is sort of what I'll say before we turn the corner and talk
about the last piece here, because I know you, you got to go, we got
to wrap up. But I think in families,
the pursuit of parents, or parents' pursuit of being likable
and being liked by their children rather than being an authority over their
children— and yes, I did say over— an authority over their children
under the authority of, of a transcendent being.
Has again created all kinds of problems in the
hierarchy. And it's hard to be heroic. It's hard to make
a heroic decision. Like,
here's a heroic decision. I'm gonna make this very real. The decision
whether or not to give your 5-year-old a cell phone.
You have to be willing, and
may I even say be excited about Being
unlikable to that five-year-old and to that
five-year-old's friends, and more importantly even,
being unlikable to the other parents of the other five-year-olds that
are in your peer group. And if you can
accomplish that in your own family on a small
decision like that, it becomes easier and easier to be
heroic as the decisions become more and more consequential.
As they get older and older.
I, I love that. I love that because I think that,
to quote the villain Syndrome from The Incredibles,
and, and honestly, you know, people ask which villains have a point—
Syndrome every time. Um, but
if everyone's super her. No one is.
Everybody says that their dad is their hero. For what?
For getting up and going to do mundane tasks every day? Like,
that's not heroism. That's just you trying to, to
be like everybody else who says, my dad is my hero, right?
And like, frankly, I think that this sort of
embracing of the mundanity is the effects
of, of postmodern feminism in
particular in our society. Because
it used to be, you know, the
guys working on the factory floor would hate the guts of their boss.
But if their boss told them to do something, they'd do it. Why? Oh, yeah.
Because, because he's my boss and I have to do it. Right.
Right. And, and now it's like, we don't have
that. And don't get me wrong, like, there are benefits of,
of balancing masculine and feminine energy. And, and
oftentimes feminine leadership styles are
more productive in an office workspace. Mm-hmm.
But I do think that the point is
often missed that we think that everyone has to be
like bought into everything, or that mundanity has to be
heroic to a certain extent. And I
think that— and I am even guilty of this,
right? Talking about having a family. But, but like, all of that
is countercultural that I mentioned earlier. Having a job,
building a business, having a family, that's all countercultural now.
I think that there is
a great reckoning that is going to be coming where the,
the masculine virtues are going to have to be re-embraced
in order to reinvigorate the structures that society
needs for the first turning to actually work.
And I think that that's— we're starting to see that now, just the,
the, the rumblings of all of that.
I, I, as we turn the corner, I want to give you a couple of
data points that will maybe support that thinking.
Um, everybody can't figure out why Donald Trump keeps banging on and on
about Greenland. Okay. Um,
people can't really understand or contextualize why one of
his first acts upon coming into office was to, um,
wrest control of the Panama Canal away from the Chinese?
It maybe makes sense at a geopolitical or even a military level, but
there's also a cultural angle to this.
Why is Donald Trump consistently antagonizing Canada? They're
our friends after all, right? You don't antagonize your quote unquote friends.
And so these kinds of things, to your point, are the rumblings, right?
Elon Musk bangs on. We've already brought him up several times on the show, but
Elon Musk bangs on about going to Mars. The
Artemis expeditions are going to be happening in the next
2 to 3 years, and NASA is already opening up applications.
So if you have a STEM degree and you're physically fit,
you might want to look into that because maybe there
might be an opportunity to go to the moon. Again and
establish a moon base before the Chinese do it or the
Indians. I don't know what you're talking about. We never went to the moon.
All right, I'm just kidding. For those of you listening, I'm just kidding. All of
these things, all these things are
the rails. They are the rumblings. He calls it— Zach
calls them the rumblings. I call them the rails. I think the rails are being
laid. The ground is being tilled up for that return
to masculine virtue. By the way, if you think I'm crazy,
it is estimated— SpaceX has estimated, they put out this
number— that it will take 1,000 flights a day, every day for
20 years to put a million people on Mars.
Yeah. That's a level of
exploratory
That only Americans, quite
frankly, have. I, I don't think it exists— I said this
before on the show already— I don't think it exists in as deep a
pot as it does here because of the unique nature of
what America is and who we are and who has
come here. And this is part of the restoration
project of the next term. This is part of opening up a new
frontier, gradually cracking it open again,
because it never opens up. It's never
opened up just because we want it to be opened up. You have to force
it sometimes. And I think we're, I think
we're, we're building the rails to force it. And I think
America is going to be the ones that does it.
Final thoughts, Zach, on the book in What should leaders take from this
book? Why should leaders pick it up? Why should they bother having this
on their shelf the way that I do, all marked up and labeled?
You know, I had a CEO of a startup once tell
me that he thought Dauntless Courage was the guidebook for any
startup. And, you know, I read
Dauntless Courage, which is about— it's by Stephen Ambrose. It's about Lewis and Clark.
And frankly, I don't think that it holds a candle to
this book and the Shackleton expedition in general.
Right? Like Lewis and Clark, they're out there, they're making negotiations and
everything else with local native treaty, native tribes
and trying to survive. Yes.
But I think that Shackleton
is actually more relevant today than Dauntless
Courage was, because
a lot of our popular zeitgeist is telling us that
leaders have to be liked. You know, leaders have to do all those things.
Leaders have to be this, this, um,
perfect person. And Shackleton most certainly
is not. But what he does do
is he eats last. Sometimes it talks about how he was
willing to give up rations for himself so that his men could
eat. He was a great example of saying
and doing, of integrity, right? My actions
correspond with my statements, and my statements correspond with my underlying
beliefs. And I think
that
That is what leaders need today
more than any sort of technical skill.
What they need is the ability to keep people
motivated and engaged, to adapt to any
situation that comes their way— good, bad,
ugly, right? That's what Shackleton's
expedition highlights in spades, and there
are a million different lessons that anyone could learn
from reading this book that are incredibly valuable.
I can't add any more to it than that.
I want to thank Zach for coming on the podcast today. Always a
pleasure. And with that, well,
we're out.