Hosted by Bill Eddy, LCSW, Esq. and Megan Hunter, MBA, It’s All Your Fault! High Conflict People explores the five types of people who can ruin your life—people with high conflict personalities and how they weave themselves into our lives in romance, at work, next door, at school, places of worship, and just about everywhere, causing chaos, exhaustion, and dread for everyone else.
They are the most difficult of difficult people — some would say they’re toxic. Without them, tv shows, movies, and the news would be boring, but who wants to live that way in your own life!
Have you ever wanted to know what drives them to act this way?
In the It’s All Your Fault podcast, we’ll take you behind the scenes to understand what’s happening in the brain and illuminates why we pick HCPs as life partners, why we hire them, and how we can handle interactions and relationships with them. We break down everything you ever wanted to know about people with the 5 high conflict personality types: narcissistic, borderline, histrionic, antisocial/sociopath, and paranoid.
And we’ll give you tips on how to spot them and how to deal with them.
*This transcript is produced using transcription software and reviewed for quality. Despite our best efforts, some passages may be incomplete or contain errors due to audio quality or software limitations.*
Megan Hunter
Welcome to It's All Your Fault on TruStory FM, the one and only podcast dedicated to helping you with the most challenging human interactions, those involving high conflict situations. I'm Megan Hunter and I'm here with my co-host Bill Eddy.
Bill Eddy
Hi, everybody.
Megan Hunter
And we are joined today by Dr. Patricia Papernow, who will be introduced shortly. So welcome, Patricia.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Glad to be here.
Megan Hunter
Thank you so much. We are the co-founders, Bill and I, of the High Conflict Institute and ConflictInfluencer.com, where we focus on training, consulting, coaching, classes, and educational programs and methods, all to do with high conflict. Today we're talking about blended families, which is why we have Dr. Papernow with us. And we're just thrilled about it because she has a brand-new book.
So welcome, listeners, and thank you for joining us while you get your tire fixed today.
So let me just give a little background on you first, Dr. Papernow. Dr. Patricia Papernow is widely recognized as one of the world's foremost experts on blended families. She is in her fifth decade of working with, learning about, and teaching others about stepfamily relationships. She is the author of dozens of articles and book chapters and the three leading books about stepfamilies. And that's no joke. She's done the work for sure. Dr. Papernow is the recipient of multiple awards and I'm sure I could list them all out here, but you can see them on her website. She's just finished the second edition of Surviving and Thriving in Stepfamily Relationships, which will publish on November 26th.
We want you to go out and purchase this book now because pre-orders are everything. It is available for pre-order. You'll find that link in the show notes. So welcome, Dr. Papernow. Anything to add to that distinguished bio?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I think that'll do just fine.
Megan Hunter
All right. Well, let's just dive in right away. The first edition and the second edition are how many years apart?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
The first edition I finished in 2012, was published 2013. So it was about 15 years of new research that I had to work my way through. [inaudible]
Megan Hunter
Wow.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
It was overwhelming. And you know, I got into this because I married a man in my first marriage who had a 5-year-old and a 9-year-old. And about four years in, I needed a dissertation. And I could see things had changed in my family. My, you know, my stepkids were now 9 and 13. But it wasn't just their ages, something had also changed in our family structure. So I was allowed to do what's called a qualitative dissertation, interviewing people. Good things, because I'm terrible at numbers. And that was, I finished that in 1980. There was nothing to read.
You have to do what's called a literature review for a dissertation. Nothing to read. And now it is completely overwhelming. But it's scattered in research journals and it is not out in the public. So I'm just thrilled to be here.
Megan Hunter
So you're the one getting it out into the public. You're breaking it down. Yeah, that's good. That's good. So what, was there one major finding, or more, maybe more than one, between the 2013 edition and the second edition coming out here in 2026? Did something, like, really big happen that surprised you?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
You know, it's more that we've built and built and built on what we know. That we know this is a fundamentally different family structure. It makes five normal but major challenges that make a lot of differences between parents and stepparents, between adults and kids. And more that we've had layers and layers of detail and clarity. For instance, one of the main findings, way early on, is that parents need to carry the limit setting and disciplinary role, and stepparents need to focus on befriending, getting to know kids. There are lots of reasons why that's difficult that we can talk about, but it's really crucial. And we now have study after study after study after study. We have some about that harsh discipline is worse.
You know, some of what we call authoritative discipline, leading with warmth and following up with firm, calm structure, can work when you have a solid relationship with a kid, but even that too early blows up. And another thing that we've learned is that there are very positive, robust links between positive stepparent-stepchild relationships and children's wellbeing, and links between negative and children's wellbeing, physical and emotional, more chronic illness. And so stepparent-stepchild relationships are really important to kids' wellbeing, and we have more and more layers about how they're important and how to do them well.
Megan Hunter
Well, it makes sense, right, Bill?
Bill Eddy
Absolutely.
Megan Hunter
I think of my own experience, right? And I think of all the people we talk to and hear from who, you know, kind of go in, probably in our generation, go in with that more authoritative, like, parents must obey their, or children must obey their parents, and parents included, stepparents, because the adults must be respected. And what you're saying, Patricia, is, pff, that blows up.
Bill Eddy
Let me ask if you could say a little bit more, Patricia, on the role of the stepparent in terms of discipline, because that's such a common tricky issue. In dealing with high conflict families, as a lot of what I do is, we get the stepparent who actually may be much better at friendly discipline or authoritative discipline, as you put it, than the real, I don't know if I should use the word, the real parents, the original parents.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
The parent.
Bill Eddy
The parents, okay. The parents, and so a stepparent may actually be better, and then of course a stepparent may be high conflict, and let's say one of the parents is reasonable and the high conflict parent wants to just come in and take over. It's like, "Joe, this is how you're supposed to do it." So how do you manage that? What do you suggest?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Well, I think the first thing to know is that, let's back up and say that kids' behavior is often more irritating to stepparents than it is to parents, for whole lots of reasons. So I have taught all over the world, and all over the world, stepparents want more limits and boundaries with their stepkids, and all over the world parents want more love and acceptance for their kids. Now, there's some good reasons for that. Parents have held their children as babies. They have been adored and feel adoring. They have slowly over time developed agreements, many of which don't have any language even for what's rude, what's a mess. Is this sugar cereal a breakfast? Is wheat cereal a cardboard?
You know, those kinds of agreements grow slowly over time. And that difference between parents and stepparents is often one of the first things you see in a high conflict stepfamily. And the dilemma is that kids' behavior is more irritating to stepparents, partly because they don't have that connection. And even struggling kids are still reaching for their parents. Connection makes a hormone. It's called oxytocin, which buffers stress. So you add connection plus shared understandings of what, what's a mess and what's rude, and the kids' behavior is more irritating to stepparents. And it's also true that parents, single parents, do sometimes get more permissive. So stepparents feel pulled.
Now you add, "I'm the grown-up here." And now you add, for women, stepmoms are often carrying a huge invisible load of parenting. "I'm doing X and Y and Z and A and B and C, and why shouldn't I run this household?" So the pull is really strong. And the research is so clear, study after study after study. This is a brand-new relationship you're building. You know, the wish is, "I've come in, I want you to love my kids the way I love 'em. I want to care about these kids." But A, they don't care about me. Kids come into a stepfamily through divorce, through way more change than they asked for.
Plus they have another parent, alive or dead, wonderful or horrid, in another household, and if I care about my stepparent, am I disloyal? So kids are often not real open to stepparents. What stepparents need to do is build a new relationship. Now, how do you build a new relationship? You don't walk in and say, "You will do this or else." You walk in and say, "Tell me what interests you. How was school today? What good thing happened at school? Oh, you do social media? I don't know nothin' about social media. Teach me what you do. You like to shoot baskets? Okay. I can shoot baskets." How do you get to know somebody? You cook favorite foods together. One of the ways, you asked about how has the research changed, and lots and lots of research about specific behaviors. They call it affinity-building behaviors. Behaviors that build connection.
Bill Eddy
So let me quick follow-up. So can a stepparent and child, can the stepparent have oxytocin towards the child?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I think it partly depends on the kid. And the thing is that in the same family, one kid will be much more available than others. Age and gender make a difference. Very young children are much more available. Teens have a harder time. Girls seem to have a harder time than boys, and teen girls, the age my daughter was when I met my second husband, have the hardest time. And I'm also finding that young adult daughters of recoupling dads often have a hard time. So if you've got a kid who's really young and whose parent in the other house is not badmouthing, those kids are awesome, often more available. You have kids who are struggling with a badmouthing parent or just with all the change.
As the rate of change goes up, kids' wellbeing goes down, tons of studies. That kid may be a little slower, and you're gonna have to go a step at a time. Those relationships do get really warm sometimes, you know. And sometimes even when you've met kids as grownups, if you're able to stay in that friendly, get to know you place, those relationships can be incredibly important.
Bill Eddy
Mm-hmm. I've seen that.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Have you?
Bill Eddy
Definitely. I think of some high conflict divorces where the stepmom, in particular, was kind of the post-divorce glue for the child and actually for the whole family. I remember doing mediation with a father and mother, and they had to change child support and spousal support 'cause the single first mother got a new job. And the dad wanted to have his new wife in the mediation. The first wife asked me if I could give her some tips for coping because she thought it'd be a good idea. And it was. And I've had that, where the stepparent facilitated exchanges and all these things in ways that the parents still don't get along, but the stepparent gets along with both of them.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And it can be a real gift. The other thing that happens sometimes is, usually the polarity, I call it the polarization polka, around parenting is that the stepparent wants more limits and the parents wants more boundaries. A parent wants more acceptance and love. Sometimes it's reversed. The stepparent comes in warm and empathic, and the parent's been rather rigid. And so the stepparent is saying, "Hello, loosen up." And that's a really wonderful entryway for stepparents to build relationships with their stepkids.
Megan Hunter
Would you recommend that, before a couple decides to blend a family and they have the marriage or they move in together, is it a good idea, let's say, for the intended stepparent and the other parent, let's say dad's getting remarried, should the fiance meet with the mom of his children and maybe together or just the three of them to talk about parenting? Let's talk about it in two scenarios. One where that other parent maybe has some high conflict traits and is badmouthing, and then a scenario where it's just kind of normal. Like, everything's rational-ish.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
One of the things that I suggest to all step couples is to reassure the children's other parent. It can be pretty anxiety-provoking, even for a low conflict, fairly sane and stable parent, that your children's other parent is bringing in a new person that I have no choice over, and that I cannot supervise, who's going to have an intimate relationship with my parents, and there's always the fear that I'm going to be replaced. One of the things that I suggest is that both the parent and the stepparents, separately, that the parents say, "You know, Janie's gonna be part of this family. She's gonna be moving in, and I want you to know we are as clear as can be. You're the mom. I hope she brings good things to our kids, and you're the mom, and that's what we're telling the kids." That's very helpful. Very helpful if stepparent can reach out.
Now, I suggest start with a handwritten note. You know how powerful that is these days. A handwritten note. "I'm gonna be spending more time with your kids. You are the mom. I want you to know I hope I bring good things to your kids. We'll get to know each other slowly. But you are the mom. I will never, ever replace you."
And that is what we believe, and that is what we're saying to the kids. And I suggest if you can get up your gumption and you can get kind of grounded, take her out for coffee. Take her for a walk. I just want to repeat what I said. Now, I don't often get these folks until they're like year three or four. And things have messed up. And so then I'm saying to the stepmom or stepdad, "You know, I wish I'd said this earlier. I just want you to know." And I can't imagine, this is another thing I coached, "I can't imagine what it must be like for you to share your kids."
Megan Hunter
A little empathy.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Yeah.
Megan Hunter
Listen, anyone listening to this, listeners out there, if you're in this place in your life, right at this time where you're about to blend a family, I think this is the most crucial, critical piece of advice from my perspective. Do that handwritten note. Just start off that way. You need to alleviate the fear in that other parent. And just something as simple as a note that could take five minutes to write. And then kind of follow up with maybe a coffee date if necessary or something, I think is extraordinarily powerful and will save you and your children, all of everyone involved, will save so much time and will reduce stress significantly. And you can focus on the relationships, right? That instead of focusing on the conflict and nastiness.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I also think it's helpful to say to kids, it's helpful for the parent to say to the kids, "Janie or Joe is gonna be spending more time with us. I hope they bring good things to you. You have a mom," or "You have a dad." They're never going to replace them. Your mom or your dad has a permanent place in your heart, like the sun, like the mountains. And I use that, you know, little kid language with teens and older kids too, because there's the little kid in them that needs to hear this. And it's very helpful to kids when stepparents say this. "I'm gonna be your stepdad, you've got a dad. I'm gonna be your stepmom, you've got a mom.
"And you know, we're gonna figure out our relationship together. We'll get to know each other over time. And I hope I bring good things to you. I will never, ever replace your mom."
Megan Hunter
Direct communication.
Bill Eddy
Yeah.
Megan Hunter
I mean, it's common sense, but why, you know, so many don't know.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Common once you hear it.
Megan Hunter
Yeah, yeah, it is, you're right. Otherwise it can seem a little trepidatious, and do I really need to do that? And then, you know, people have their feelings involved, and, you know, what they're seeing maybe in movies and TV about blended families, and that it's contentious. Really, we have to be dedicated and thoughtful about these things in advance. And just provide common sense, direct communication and think about the fears of each person that's involved, right? The fear of that other parent that's thinking, "Is this new person that I don't even know who's gonna be around my kids now a whole heck of a lot, and having a lot of influence, is this person going to turn them against me, going to replace me, going to badmouth me?" I mean, these are the most primal relationships, right? So to have those simple little direct communications, just a huge predictive tell, right, of how things can go.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I think these things often need to be repeated over time.
Bill Eddy
Oh, yes.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
As kids get older, they often need to be repeated. And I just want to add something. I use that language of blended family. I always put quotes around it. Because I want to express or tell people, I just want to remind us all, it captures the longing and the wish. That's not the reality. Becoming a stepfamily is a lot less like you put blueberries and strawberries together and now you have this great smoothie.
It's a lot more like you bringing together a group of Japanese and a group of Italians and saying, "Let's make a family."
Megan Hunter
Yeah.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And we're not going to make a family by everybody's eating pasta with chopsticks. That's going to make misery.
Megan Hunter
I love that.
Bill Eddy
Interesting.
Megan Hunter
So, Bill, I know you were interested in some research around the idea that divorce rates for second marriages is around 70% compared to 40 to 50% for divorce in first marriages. Does that sort of hold true through your research?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
That number, I think, is what we call a woozle. It was invented by Larry Genong in Maryland.
Bill Eddy
It's out there.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Yeah, it's out there and it gets repeated and then it gets the truth. So the divorce rate is a little higher. I don't believe that it has ever been that high. It is a little, it's higher in cohabiting families. And by the way, all of this relates to cohabiting families.
Bill Eddy
Yeah.
Megan Hunter
Define that a little bit, if you would, for our listeners.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
So you're living together, but you're not married. And the rate of cohabitation has gone way up all over the world, in Europe more than here, but it's increasing here. That people don't want to get married again, or for whatever reason, many, many couples are cohabiting. And the rate goes way up over 50. The divorce rate in the United States is actually at a 50-year low. Now, that's partly because we have so many cohabiting couples. The place where it's rising is between 2010 and 2019, it doubled over 50. Those couples particularly are more likely to cohabit. And they're also more likely to do something called living apart together.
We live in two separate households and we have a committed relationship. That is also very useful if you've got high-needs kids. You've got a kid on the spectrum. You've got a kid with a serious ADHD. You've got a kid who's very, very depressed. You've got a kid with really big medical needs. Those families sometimes work better living apart together. We're in a committed relationship. This is a little harder for the couple and they miss each other, but it's a heck of a lot easier with the kids and makes a healthier family for everybody.
Bill Eddy
Interesting. I have another question. I don't know if you're about to ask it, Megan, but it's one of the ones I gave you, which is my biggest question, for practical reasons, because I do a lot of consultation with people going through divorces, high conflict divorces. And it's not unusual that they have a new partner who gets on the screen to the consultation with me, "And this is my new partner, Mary or Fred or whoever. We're kind of a team here in this custody battle from my, the first," let's call him the first father. It's more common it's the father that brings his new partner, maybe not married yet, but during the process gets married, would say, okay, we're dealing with the really upset, angry ex-first wife, and we're kind of a team. Here's some tips.
I give a lot of tips. And they go through the custody battle, which may last years. And then I hear, "Me and my new partner, we got married last year, and this year we're going to get divorced because the first marriage custody battle has destroyed the chance for us to have a happy stepfamily." Do you see that? Does your research talk about that? Do you have any tips for that?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Two things. Let me see if I can hold on to them both. The first is we do need to include that step person somehow. And stepparents have no legal standing in our court system. So they are often completely left out of all post-divorce processes. Parent coordination, mediation, family therapy. And that doesn't work because stepparents, in a committed family, in a committed relationship, are major players. How to include them is something we all need to be thinking about. Whether to include them has to... We have to include them.
How to include them? 'Cause you include a stepmom and you've got a really upset mom, that's gonna be messy, except for a really clinical term. So what do you do? I mean, one of the things I'm telling parent coordinators is, okay, you're meeting with a couple, say it's a dad and a mom. Mom does not want to be in the room with stepmom. But stepmom's a major player. So anytime you guys make an agreement, I'm gonna give you 24 hours or 48 hours, and you each need to go away and think about it. And that means dad's gonna go and consult with stepmom. She needs input. She's a major player.
She may not have final say, but she needs input. He comes back and says, "Well, I'd rather do this than that." Mom says, "That's because she said it." And what I teach...
Bill Eddy
It's all her fault.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And what I teach parent coordinators to say is, "You so wish you didn't have to deal with her. I understand. And she is a major player in your kids' lives. Now, I know you want the best for your kids, right?" I'm gonna wait till she says yes. "Here's the research.
"Wanna hear? You're not gonna like it. Still wanna hear?"
Bill Eddy
Oh, okay. They say.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
One of the most important things you can do for your kid is to support their relationship. You're gonna hate this. Support their relationship with the other parent and stepparent. You know why? Here's the research. Children who do poorly. Well, let's start with the good news. Sometimes I ask, "Do you want to hear the good news first or the bad news?" Here's the good news. Children who do best in divorce have positive relationships with all of the grownups in their lives, and I'm saying this low and slow, one beat at a time, 'cause she's gotta chew each piece of this.
Mom and dad, mom and stepmom, dad and stepdad. You know the children who do worst? They do worse when they have a distant relationship with any of them or a conflicted relationship. And they do the very worst. The very worst for kids. Wanna hear?
Bill Eddy
Mm-hmm.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
You're not gonna like it. You still wanna hear?
Megan Hunter
Do we want to hear it?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
The very worst for kids is not divorce. It's not single parenting. It's not stepfamily. It's conflict. Even moderate tension, you guys know this. Moderate tension. And this is research, the moderate tension research is non-clinical, non-divorced families. Moderate tension impacts kids' attention, it impacts their academics, and it impacts their immune systems. Moderate parental tension, and the intervening variable turns out to be sleep. You muck up kids' sleep.
So mom, we got a hard job for you. This is gonna be hard. 0 to 10, 10 really hard, 0 easy? Seven. All right, it's not a 10. Let's figure out how to help you do this.
Bill Eddy
Well, this leads into another question then. And that is, well, let me just mention, I want to say, so I do a lot of consultations. And I'm happy to include whoever my client wants to include. And they may include other family members too. And that works well. But what's interesting, as a mediator, I did a lot of divorce mediations, and I told the two parties, I said, "Anybody you want to bring, if you both agree, then we can have anybody else in the room." And the discussion of, "Well, I want to bring my girlfriend," or "I want to bring my new wife," or whatever, I say, "I encourage that if it's okay with both of you, but let me tell you, it makes your life easier to have their input here in this room rather than afterwards undoing what may happen in here." And so many times the new partner was an asset to the family.
They had different skills, different abilities, and different schedule. Exchanges are so much easier if you have a positive third person can go to the school when the child's sick or whatever. So I just wanted to say that.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Well, before you go on, I just want to say that's really helpful for me to hear.
Bill Eddy
But here's... Yeah. Oh.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
That's helpful for me to hear, because I mostly see the mom who can't stand to be in the same room. So I think it's great that it can be a resource. And I'm gonna take that from here.
Bill Eddy
Yes. And I think mediation, because so much divorce mediation is post-divorce, when there are one or two new partners, I've done mediations to modify support and health insurance and schedules with both parties bringing their new partners. And it's been fascinating. And what I find is that one of them in the mix is high conflict. It's better to have them in the room where I can educate them than to have them outside attacking whatever came out of that room. "What did you say to her? Did you give in?" Things like that. But here's the question I want to get to.
We have this method, New Ways for Families. It's a counseling method. It's also an online class, coaching method. It teaches parents skills for co-parenting, flexible thinking, managed emotions, moderate behavior, and checking yourself rather than pointing fingers. Up to now we haven't really included stepparents in that. And we asked the courts to order, and there's a lot of court orders for this. They just order both parents, so neither parent's the good guy or the bad guy, you both need these skills. And yet we haven't been including stepparents. And what you're saying is making me think, yes, we should, we should encourage it, but then the question is, do we have them go through this?
Because there's a counseling structure with a workbook. Do we have the new stepparent, let's say it's dad and stepmom, go through it together? Or do we have, say, dad go through the counseling and stepmom go through it separately? Any thoughts? And maybe that's too much to throw at you.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
It's a really good question. Just starting with the first is, if there's a committed stepparent in there, that needs to be included, and part of what you need to be teaching about is, here's what a positive stepparent-stepchild relationship looks like. That information is not out there. You know how you get in Facebook rabbit holes? There is a rabbit hole of pained stepmothers because it's such a hard role, but also because they're set up to do something impossible. "I'm supposed to love these kids. I need control in my house. And I'm carrying that huge invisible load of the female in the house."
So the basic information about both parent-child and stepparent-stepchild relationships are critically important for kids' wellbeing, and stepparent-stepchild relationships begin from a different place. You're gonna be starting a new relationship. This is how you start a new relationship. And parent, in this case dad, you're gonna need to be the person who sets the limits and you're gonna need to step up to giving your kid warmth, connection, spending one-to-one time, and being the limit setter. Now, stepmom, you will probably always want more limits.
Megan Hunter
True.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
That's a conversation between you and your partner. But before I toddle off into that, just back to, I really think that basic information needs to be part of divorce education.
We have good divorce education in this country, and my hunch is that yours is one of the best. It needs to be part of it.
Bill Eddy
Well, I always learn something, and we definitely, we're at a time where we're actually updating our workbook, and so this is real helpful.
Megan Hunter
And I saw Bill taking notes.
Bill Eddy
We'll get some of your information into it.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And I don't know whether workbooks should be separate or together. I'd be glad to look at it and think about it with you. Because this is stuff we all need to be thinking about, you know. I increasingly am speaking to AFCC folks who are post-divorce, folks dedicated to protecting kids and families from conflict. Don't talk about or think about stepfamilies.
Bill Eddy
Mm, right, right.
Megan Hunter
Yeah. And it's so big. It's so big. It's as big as...
Dr. Patricia Papernow
It's not only big, it's different in critical ways. And if you go in with a first-time family map, my metaphor is you're driving around Indianapolis with a map of the Los Angeles freeway.
Megan Hunter
Yeah.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
You're gonna go much too fast. You're gonna have a lot of accidents. Everybody's gonna be upset with everybody. The right roadmap makes a huge difference. It's not an easy roadmap. Some of the things might be hard to do, but at least knowing what you're reaching for will make a huge difference.
Megan Hunter
Yeah, I think that is very clarifying and I think reassuring to hear, probably for many, many who have been in blended families.
Bill Eddy
Mm.
Megan Hunter
Either in the past or currently in them now, there hasn't been a roadmap. And people have been doing the best they can, I think, in most circumstances. So to have something like this is so helpful. So I know that Bill and I will be talking about this for sure when it comes to New Ways for Families and a lot of the work we do. So we're very grateful for that.
I know this is probably a little bit different rabbit hole here, but I know it's very important. Was there anything new in the research about what to call the stepparent?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Great question. And it was on my mind a little while. Well, how to name the stepparent?
Megan Hunter
Yeah, and this came from Bill, so I have to give him credit.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And it's a question that comes over and over and over again, and so often stepparents want to be called Mom or Dad. But kids already have another mom or dad. You want your best shot at making a happy, positive relationship with your stepkid. You insist, "You call me Mom or Dad," you have now put this child in what we call a loyalty bind. If I accept and care about my stepmom, am I disloyal to my mom? If I care about my stepdad, I am disloyal to my dad. So insisting that kids call stepparents Mom or Dad may be the adult's wish. It's probably gonna backfire.
It's not gonna be useful. So my general guideline is, you know, as I said earlier, that as the rate of change goes up, kids' wellbeing goes down. Huge change to become part of a stepfamily. The adults are in love. The kids are not in love. You foisted this new adult on this kid. So generally, if you can let kids decide what to call stepmom or stepdad, it's gonna be a lot easier. Now, the glitch comes when the adult stepparent says, "But I expect in my culture that adults are respected."
So often what kids want to call stepmom or stepdad is by their first name. And if that's a problem for you, then get creative with your stepkid. Sometimes it's Mr. Dan. That works. A little harder with women. Ms. Rose, then. You know, what works. As kids get closer, they may find another name. I don't know if you saw in the Democratic Convention when Kamala Harris's stepdaughter stepped up and said, "She always listened to me. She was there and she listened to me."
Now, there was a stepmom who got it. Got it. They called her Mamala.
Bill Eddy
All right, I remember hearing that.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Mamala. So they found, the kids found a way to name her. She's very close to them. A way to name her that did not compete with mom.
Megan Hunter
Yep. Yep. You know, as most of our listeners know, I'm a stepmom of five. And three of my own. And one of my stepsons, over time, we started just kind of joking about him calling me Step. And here 20 years later, that's what we, we love it. It works for us. It's not a diss. It's not any, it just works for us. And we love, we love it.
You know, we have an easy relationship.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
That's sweet.
Megan Hunter
Yeah, so I think to the point that if you can reach agreements and have that direct, you know, instead of me being directive about what to be called, me as the stepmom role. Either let it develop naturally or just, you know, have that conversation with the child or the children yourself, if there's a comfort level, I think, between the two. And for a parent, for that adult to give the child that open space just to think about it and know that they have some agency and some, you know, their own thoughts around this, and what they're comfortable with. So I think it's a good one. It all goes to where we started this conversation, which is about relationship.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And you know, you just used a really important word, which is agency. There is much, much more research now on adolescent stepparent-stepchild relationships, which are some of the toughest. And it's partly a wonderful young guy named Todd Jensen, who I think was an adolescent stepkid, and tons and tons of research about what makes a positive stepparent-stepchild relationship for kids. And I will send you a link to his website. It is full of, he keeps posting very concrete, fully research-based tip sheets for how do you become a stepparent, how do you be a parent in a stepfamily, how do you be a kid in a stepfamily. And one of his studies was of, they were young adults who had been adolescents when their stepfamily formed.
Asking adolescents to give advice to their stepparents. And I'll tell you, every single one of them hit the research, but it was in the kids' voices. But one of the most important things was, can you give this child a say? Give them a say in what you're gonna be called. Give them a say in what color their room is gonna be. If you're gonna do something together, give them a say in what it is. If you're worried about money, say, you know, "Within twenty bucks, what would you like to do today?" Respect the child's pace.
Do your best to stay warm and connected. Respect the child's pace. And for adolescents, when they feel they have a voice, their resistance goes down.
Bill Eddy
Excellent.
Megan Hunter
Makes sense. It makes sense. There's so many questions that have popped into my head about so many things, like setting limits and how to do those things. But I think we'll leave that for another day, and I would encourage everyone to go get this book. Order it now. And what's the title of it?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
Surviving and Thriving in Stepfamily Relationships: What Works and What Doesn't.
Megan Hunter
Pretty plain and simple. It says it all right there. So we'll put that link in the show notes. It's available on Amazon and really anywhere books are sold. So you'll get lots of information there. And we'll get that link that you just mentioned, and we'll put that in the show notes as well, because I think people are going to find that extraordinarily helpful also. Any last thoughts before we sign off?
Dr. Patricia Papernow
You know, I think I'm gonna leave one more. That is, you do not have to be silent if you're upset with your stepkid. You do have to communicate in a way that builds trust and caring. So I have something I call the sentence stem, and it is, "I'd love it if..." "I'd love it if, when we come into the same room, we just say hello to each other. I know it's hard that I'm here, but I'd love it if, when we're in the same room, you look at me once. I'd love it if, when I put my pocketbook down, you don't spill your coffee on it." So it's important to know you don't have to be silent. But you do need to be much, much more skillful.
Megan Hunter
Oh, and I'd love it if you put that on a T-shirt.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I love it.
Bill Eddy
Yeah.
Megan Hunter
Just wear it around the house, have a poster, have a whiteboard. If you're in a blended family, just put, "I'd love it if..."
Dr. Patricia Papernow
That's a great idea.
Megan Hunter
At that time.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
I mean, I have people put it on an index card and put it on the refrigerator, but I like a T-shirt even better.
Megan Hunter
Right.
Bill Eddy
Mm-hmm.
Megan Hunter
Exactly.
Bill Eddy
Mm-hmm. And I already love it.
Megan Hunter
Well, yeah, we love it.
Bill Eddy
I'd love it if people would get your book too, because I think you had so much good information, not just research, but what to do, how it fits together.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
And lots of stories. Stories of people who are doing this well, stories of people struggling. And there is another book. It's called The Stepfamily Handbook: From Dating to Getting Serious to Forming a Blended Family, with quotes around blended family. That one's really good if you're just starting out.
Megan Hunter
Great. We've got that link in the show notes as well. Listeners, you can find that there too. So thank you so much, Dr. Papernow, for joining us today. Thank you for doing the research on this really important topic that impacts so many people. And we like to think about impact. Bill and I have been in the impact business for a long time and I know you have as well. So thank you for all the work you've done in this area and the impact it has on people.
Dr. Patricia Papernow
My total pleasure to be here.
Megan Hunter
So we got all those links. We've got a, you know, a little surprise. We'll have Dr. Papernow back at some point to talk about what I inadvertently called golden divorces, but they're actually called, I think, gray divorces. So it's those, research around 40% of people who are in a stepfamily and deal with issues associated in the latter parts of life, like elder care, end-of-life decisions, inheritance. Ooh, right? That's the crunchy one. So we'll have you back and I know everyone will be tuning in for that.
So be sure to subscribe, share this episode with someone who might benefit. There's probably lots out there. And join us next time for more practical ways to manage the challenging people and situations in your life. Until next time, if you're looking for training or consultation about high conflict in your organization, visit us at HighConflictInstitute.com. If it's for your personal life, visit us at ConflictInfluencer.com. Keep learning and practicing skills. Be kind to yourself and to others while we all try to keep the conflict small and find the missing peace.
It's All Your Fault is a production of TruStory FM. Engineering by Andy Nelson. Music by Wolf Samuels, John Coggins, and Ziv Moran. Find the show, show notes, and transcripts at trustory.fm or HighConflictInstitute.com/podcast. If your podcast app allows ratings and reviews, please consider doing that for our show.