Desmond Fleming hosts visionary business leaders who share insights on how they built their companies and how venture capital made it possible.
Desmond Fleming 00:00
If you were to chart your view of equity perps being legal onshore in the US by the end of this year, what's the happy path in your mind?
Rob 00:11
I think there is a very high chance like 80% that happens this year. So what we have to understand is we have to make sure that the regulators, both the SEC and the CFTC agree that these are futures and not swaps.
Desmond Fleming 00:23
Right,
Rob 00:24
Right. And
Desmond Fleming 00:25
all the momentum seems like, yes, we think these are futures.
Rob 00:28
So I think that is where the winds of change are going. I think that's what people want to believe. I think that is where the regulators are trying to push things to. But you have to get the right people involved to agree to that perspective. Right. And so I mean they are already having conversations with, you know, the one of the eight people who want to do Perps in the U.S. there are many people who are trying to do this about, okay, well like how does it work mechanically? Like, you know, what is, how might you think about, you know, what leverage looks like? How might you think about delivery, like, or rolling and like what does this do to the market structure depending on if it's an equity versus if it's a commodity, if it has physical delivery, if it doesn't have physical delivery. And so that conversation is happening. But for the people that are actively pursuing this today, there's real engagement with the markets team already around. You know how this might work. Right. I expect that there is a good chance that this happens in November. So I think we're moving in that direction. I think Chair Selig has been incredibly thoughtful about trying to bring all of this onshore. The work that's being done with the harmonization with the SEC has been really helpful here. And so there's also a lot of interested parties who want this to be that way. So there's all of the startups. There's a lot of
Desmond Fleming 01:44
money on the line. It's
Rob 01:45
a lot of money on the line. Yeah, I mean there's a lot of the startups, but there's also Coinbase and ICE and CME who also care about this topic. I think CME is probably anti, but ICE and Coinbase and Robinhood and all of these guys are pro. And so there's the incumbents and then there's also, you know, the cowshis and Polys and the like the architects and you know, the, even the, the on chain guys, Lighter and hyper liquid are both trying to figure out how they might be able to do something here as well. And then there's a bunch of, you know, I'm sure you've seen it, but there's a long tail of new startups trying to do something similar. And so there's real conversation happening and I think it's going to happen quicker than people think.
Desmond Fleming 02:22
Let's say perps go legal in the U.S. how do you think about where demand will initially form? So like if you think about the end state of this market, there could be a world where demand pools at the Robin Hoods, at the Coinbases, etc. It could pull at the lighters, it could pool in Hyper Liquid being fully available here. It could also pull to or form with a newer exchange or startup opportunity. Obviously that's one of the areas that you know, both being venture investors, we care about, we get excited about. But the path forward for a startup to acquire and maintain the mind share for this kind of consumer opportunity seems tough from my, from my vantage point.
Rob 03:03
So again, like, okay, if we're talking about equity perps specifically and I think this is different than commodity perps, I think this is different than, you know, I do also believe by the way, and this is sort of an aside, but there's also conversation around perps or long dated futures around FX and things like that as well. I think those are almost an easier sell at the moment. And for the equity side you also need to split out the CFTC registered DCOs and DCMs and like a Hyper Liquid and lighter, right? Hyper Liquid and Lighter are in a more murky camp right now where you know, obviously President Trump talked about hyper liquid
Desmond Fleming 03:42
40%.
Rob 03:43
Yeah, I guess last week maybe they
Desmond Fleming 03:46
were holding some,
Rob 03:46
who knows? Well, who can say. But they, and that conversation is real. And I think actually lighter is a little bit further along than Hyper Liquid right now. But they're both actively engaging with the regulators. But there is a real question around, okay, well like how do you fit, you know, maybe a regulated FCM plugging into shared liquidity and if you do that, like how do you fit that into the DCO rules? You can't basically. So you'd have to amend the DCO rules. I don't actually think that will happen. So I think what is more likely to happen is what we've seen with Polymarket which is that you pull out a just two completely separate instances of these things, right, where you have a regulated fully, you know, off chain like you know, DCO and DCM that is maybe hyper liquid branded and or lighter branded. But in those cases you can't arb the liquidity the same way as you could if you did like with some other people have talked about, which is like, you know, whitelisted markets but on like clearing on the hyper liquid or lighter chain.
Rob 04:44
Yeah,
Desmond Fleming 04:45
but that, that is a benefit for anyone who wants to compete in these markets. Because hyper liquid or lighter would have to build their liquidity from scratch,
Rob 04:53
correct? Yeah, that's right. And so then it looks a lot more like a, you know, all the people we just talked about, I think in terms of like who wins. It's tough. I mean we've seen it's really hard for net new exchanges and net new DCOs to like win liquidity and win market share unless it's a new product. So like with prediction markets, obviously with Kalshi and Polymarket, they've built a business that's not brand new. I mean like IBKR was talking about this years ago.
Desmond Fleming 05:18
Yeah,
Rob 05:19
but they built this business because it wasn't yet popular. Right?
Desmond Fleming 05:22
Yeah. And then there was a guy at Founders Fund, right. Who, or maybe he was associated with Founders Fund who had a prediction market.
Rob 05:29
Oh, so yeah, so they're not the first prediction markets to exist. So there were other prediction markets to exist. So Joey Krug, who is, who now runs crypto at Founders Fund and previously was at Pantera, he, before that he started a prediction market business. And there's others like other people have. But that was actually a crypto startup like there was prediction markets have actually been talked about for years. Like non crypto. And then there's like, you know, call it like the architects of the world who are. Okay, well we'll do like net new products or Kalshi trying to do this now too.
Desmond Fleming 05:58
Yeah,
Rob 05:58
we'll do net new products which is like, oh, let us try like FX or Compute or like things like that. And that means that we can like build liquidity earlier in a net new thing that CME and ICE and others don't already have. It's hard. But if you can be earlier to market and you can have better product construction, I think compute is kind of its own thing because it's hard. You might be able to win that liquidity or things where it's like, oh, well now I just want to list like a Tesla perp.
Desmond Fleming 06:21
Yeah,
Rob 06:22
like it's, it's unclear why the, you know, why like current exchanges wouldn't be able to like win that liquidity. And because they already have those market makers on like they can already do like the right type of quoting. But perps is also a, it's a retail product. Like I don't think perps is going to get huge institutional use. So it'll get some, in terms of like basis trades that people do and like, you know, some of the delta neutral stuff but for like hedging, like people aren't going to use a perp. Right. And the fact that in crypto we've like, you know, just kind of basically hard coded in that, you know, the natural funding rate resets every eight hours and it's basically 10.95%. It doesn't really make sense because it's not, doesn't allow the market to change the funding the way it should. But it works for retail. And so what does that mean? Like, well, the retail exchanges should be the ones that are actually like probably the most successful. And so that includes, you know, whatever like the Coinbases. And I mean Robinhood's not an exchange but they're, they're a broker but they'll plug into Kalshi and Poly and like all of these.
Rob 07:24
Yeah, Kraken, like all of those guys that are trying to do it. And Kraken has their Bitnomial DCO so I expect that's who ends up getting the most volume. And then they plug into the retail FCMs and the retail FCMs distribute it and so whoever has the best infrastructure to do that. But I don't know if that's like a CME, you know, product today.
Desmond Fleming 07:44
Right, right, right. Makes a ton of sense. It is certainly a category of, let's call it the overlap of crypto and financial services that seems to be getting a ton of oxygen obviously for obvious reasons. How long have you been in the crypto ecosystem?
Rob 08:01
So it's an interesting question because. So I was on the first working group at Goldman looking at digital assets, which was 12 years ago.
Desmond Fleming 08:09
What is that, 2014.
Rob 08:10
Yeah. So I've been in it in some way for that period of time, but I wasn't full time focused on it.
Desmond Fleming 08:18
When did you buy your first bitcoin?
Rob 08:20
Right around then. So yeah, 2013, I bought my first Bitcoin and like everybody else,
Desmond Fleming 08:25
Mount Gox.
Rob 08:26
Yep, about it on Mount Gox before the Mount Gox blew up and you know, used like, you know, used a Tumblr and like did the whole thing and like, you know, I was an analyst at Goldman and I was like, you know, trying to play around with it and figure out what you could do with it. And
Desmond Fleming 08:41
yeah,
Rob 08:41
it was interesting but I was on the first working group there. And like all the conversation then Goldman was like two things. It was like, okay, well now like Fortress cares about this, so should we offered OTC? And it's, you know, Bitcoin's 300 bucks. This is incredible. This came out of thin air. And also tokenization. And so I don't know.
Desmond Fleming 08:59
Oh wow. In 2014.
Rob 09:00
Yeah, so, so you, you probably are a little young to remember this, but in 2014 and 2015 there was a. Do you know Blythe Masters is. I think she was the most senior woman at JP Morgan at the time.
Desmond Fleming 09:13
Okay.
Rob 09:14
Like you know, call it one level down from Jamie. And she left to go run a thing called Digital Asset Holdings, which is now Canton.
Desmond Fleming 09:22
Right.
Rob 09:23
Which has been around forever. And she went on the front of Bloomberg Business Week, I think it was Bloomberg Businessweek. And there was a headline that was like blockchain, not bitcoin. And all the conversation at Goldman and JP Morgan and at all of these places was tokenization is going to change the future. And in fact there's a business called Axoni that we invested in at Goldman that was like a high yield credit tokenization platform that was sort of a bank consortium. But it was all tokenization is the future. The tokens are stupid, they're not going to subsist, but tokenization will happen. And that was like the topic of conversation over 10 years ago. So it's been a little bit interesting to see how the world has evolved, which is that like everybody lost faith in tokenization and the tokens existed,
Desmond Fleming 10:02
tokens won,
Rob 10:04
but then the infrastructure didn't exist and now we're back kind of full circle where the infrastructure exists and now we have real buy in. And so it's been quite interesting but,
Desmond Fleming 10:14
and I do have a question that's very related to that, but I want to pull one of these threads. It sounded like early days at Goldman. Fortress was one of the early institutional buyers of bitcoin and that's why Goldman cared at the time.
Rob 10:28
So I won't, I don't know how good a relationship was between Goldman and Fortress, but Pete Briger and at the time Mike Novogratz, who were at Fortress were some of the earliest bitcoiners on Wall Street. And they were like evangelists everywhere. And so there's a guy, Wences, the founder of I think Xapo was, had gotten Pete Briger into it and they were like buying bitcoin up in like 2011, 2012, 2013. And they were some of the earliest evangelists of it, like in industry. But when people like Pete start to care about bitcoin while the service providers, the banks care.
Desmond Fleming 11:03
Right.
Rob 11:04
And so, you know, and you know, all of a sudden Bitcoin was 300 bucks. There
Desmond Fleming 11:08
we go.
Rob 11:09
And so, so that was the early days. But then I really, I've been full time in this space, you would say, since about 2021. 2020,
Desmond Fleming 11:17
okay.
Rob 11:18
I launched the crypto business for a big fund called Golden Tree Asset Management, which is a hedge fund. About 65 billion of AUM now, was about 50 billion then. And that business, like every hedge fund in early 21 was like, crypto's ripping, like we need to do something.
Desmond Fleming 11:33
Yep.
Rob 11:34
I was doing fintech stuff.
Desmond Fleming 11:35
Yep.
Rob 11:35
And I was like, okay, well you seem to like this because I was doing it on my own on like nights and weekends. And so I launched that business for them with a couple people and built that and met my current fund through a co investment and then they asked me to come on in early 22.
Desmond Fleming 11:49
So the question I have is between now or 2014 to now, very different kind of regimes and narratives that have occurred throughout crypto. And I'm curious to get your perspective on, hey, is this the most excited you've ever been within the ecosystem? Because it feels, as someone who has transitioned to the ecosystem to spend more time, this feels, let's call it the most tangible and the most traditionally commercially focused where it's about saying, how can we create value consistently for the constituents within the ecosystem outside of the kind of, I'll frame it as the consumer, consumer positioning or the alternative kind of dollar financial ecosystem narrative that existed for a long time. From my perspective,
Rob 12:41
it's hard not to say that I was most excited in 21 because everyone was most excited in 21. Right. In terms of just like, you know, the space seemed like it was inevitable. And
Desmond Fleming 12:49
yeah,
Rob 12:49
I mean the amount of capital that went into that was also
Desmond Fleming 12:52
very like NFT, like it was web 3 read, write, own. But
Rob 12:56
it was everything. It was DeFi too. Right. And so I don't know if you were playing around in DeFi during the DeFi summer in 2020, but like DeFi felt extraordinarily novel at the time. Right. And that I think when DeFi started to happen, it became very clear to me that like you could build net new financial like derivatives and businesses and products using essentially just smart contracts. Right. And that was 2020. And so I was really excited then. But I think what's interesting now is the one. There's just the interest in DC from the regulators and from the administration and from Congress in a way that there hasn't been. I mean, obviously getting the Genius Act was incredible. And some of the work we've done around some of the accounting rules and others and then the amount of which this has now permeated all of the banks and all of the asset managers. That said, the conversation was very deep at the banks in 2015 and 2016 too. Bitcoin went in 2016 up to 19k, and when it went up to 19k, there was a team at JP Morgan that was like 70 people deep that was looking at the space. So it was really deep at one point in time as well. But when bitcoin came all the way back down to 3,000, soon after that, people lost interest. Now the nice thing is that bitcoin price matters to the industry, but it no longer is the thing driving tokenization or stablecoin adoption. And that's the difference that we have now. And so that's why it feels like there's an inevitability now that there wasn't before. But there's been other pockets of real excitement.
Desmond Fleming 14:33
Yeah, yeah, yeah. If you add to one of the things that I've loved to observe, especially over the past, call it 12 to 18 months, as we move out of this cycle into a digital asset cycle. It's been really fun for me to observe how different crypto teams are birthing. You know, it's the same thing you see anywhere else in tech or venture where there can be a team that's well funded, very, attracts really great individuals, but the company may not work out and those teams spin out. I'm curious from your perspective, if you almost had to create a player. I don't know if you play like Madden or NFL Live back in the day or NBA Live, whatever it was. If you had to create a player or team, you know, what teams would you pull from that you would get excited about?
Rob 15:26
I mean, the Coinbase mafia is everywhere. So you can see that very clearly. There's a, I mean they were, you know, the earliest, most successful of these companies. And I think they, you know, it's a different business now. It's a big public company, but you have, you know, founders of a lot of different protocols, a lot of different businesses that have come out of there. Turnkey. I don't know if you know Bryce, but you know, they're one of the largest
Desmond Fleming 15:51
early on the custody team, right?
Rob 15:53
Yeah, I was early on the custody team. Obviously Balaji came out of there. But honestly, after that, it's really been the HFTs. So the HFTs like Jane, Hudson River, Tower, Jump. A lot of the best DeFi founders have come out of the HFTs because they have some ability to. They already know how to code. They understand financial primitives from sort of like a core aspect. And they were some of the earliest to get really excited about DeFi. And so I actually think that, you know, we obviously, you talked about. We were talking about perps. Right. Like Vlad and Jeff Yan are both, you know, came out of HFTs. Right. So that is where I think we've seen a lot of the most successful DeFi people. And outside of DeFi and outside of call it money movement, there hasn't been a lot that has been super successful. So there was a lot of people doing NFTs like we talked about, and other things, but those are where we've seen, I think, the most interesting primitives come out of.
Desmond Fleming 17:01
Let's talk a little bit about kind of you and your background. I was doing some prep and research, and one thing I didn't know about you is you played soccer growing
Rob 17:01
up.
Desmond Fleming 17:01
I think you were a pretty highly recruited soccer player. You went to George Mason.
Rob 17:07
Yeah, I went to George Mason and played there, although I had a bunch of knee injuries. But yeah,
Desmond Fleming 17:13
walk me through kind of your experience in college athletics to transitioning to working at Goldman and then ultimately getting to where you are today.
Rob 17:22
Yeah. So I grew up in sort of like suburban, suburban, rural Ohio. And I was. I grew up in a situation where, like, sports was, like, life basically. You know, I think, like, a lot of us were like that, especially in, you know, who didn't grow up in cities. And I honestly, like, the first time I had ever been to Washington, D.C. was when I went to George Mason for a recruiting trip. And I was like, this is like, insane. This is such a huge city. And now I think of D.C. as a small city.
Desmond Fleming 17:55
It's like a suburb.
Rob 17:56
It's like a suburb. Yeah, I
Desmond Fleming 17:57
know.
Rob 17:58
And. Well, only the second time ever I had been to New York was my Goldman interview. And so it was sort of interesting coming to play soccer there. I unfortunately had a bunch of knee injuries. I was, like, convinced I was going to, like, I was like, I'm going to play pro soccer.
Desmond Fleming 18:14
Yeah.
Rob 18:14
This is going to be like,
Desmond Fleming 18:15
I'm going to the Premier League.
Rob 18:16
I mean, I was like, I'll go play in the MLS. And, like, you know, and I was like, I was pretty decent. And after I had all the injuries, I, like, I honestly, I didn't know what to do with myself. I think I just kind of, like, I lost a little bit of my way, and I wasn't sure what I was interested in. And I ended up transferring to Washington University in St. Louis, which is where I graduated. And I was like, okay, well, I'll fall back and go to law school. Cause I guess that's like, what people do, you know, or whatever. And I'll figure it out. And then I'd actually put down a deposit to go to law school. And then realized I didn't want to do that either. And so I sort of. I ended up working a job with sort of a. Like, a corporate development job that came through a friend at a healthcare company, like a healthcare rollup. And the founder of. Or not the founder, but the CFO of that business was like, a Goldman guy or whatever. And like, six months in, he was kind of like, you know, hey, would you. Seems like you're very motivated and you want to do something, and you have a knack for this. And honestly, I had, like, no idea what was going on in finance. I was like. I was like, whatever.
Desmond Fleming 19:19
You
Rob 19:19
were
Desmond Fleming 19:20
20,
Rob 19:20
21, 22. And he was like, do you want to. I could refer you to this job. Would you be interested in doing it? And so came in for my interview, got the job, and it was like, honestly, like, I was like, oh, I'm going back to Ohio. Like, this sucks. Like, New York sucks.
Desmond Fleming 19:33
Oh, wow.
Rob 19:34
Like, this is too big of a. For me. Like, this is, like, the talent pool is different, you know, whatever. But, you know, having grown up an athlete, and I still just think this way when we recruit people or when we, you know, invest in companies and founders, like, you just have this, like, drive to, like, get better at things, learn things, et cetera. What happened is, one, a lot of luck along the way, but two, also just an ability to. Or a want to just, like, learn a lot and be very curious. And the willingness to take a lot of pain along the way. Right. Like, I think Travis Kalanick talked about this in the Senra podcast that he just did, where he's like, oh, the life of an entrepreneur is just being able to take more pain than somebody else. I also think that's sort of true. That's definitely true in New York finance as well. And at the time, I was just like, oh, well, there's these successful people doing finance. And so I'll figure out that thing. And I was really good about making the right jump off points into my career. Always trying to do the best work I could, take the biggest stretch roles and then only leaving for a new role if it was something that could, you know, kind of expand on my capabilities and my skill set. And so I,
Desmond Fleming 20:43
and you felt like those jumps were pretty non linear.
Rob 20:47
Pretty non linear. Yeah. So I left Goldman. I was like okay, I'm going to go back to business school because I don't really want to be here anymore and I want to do something else. And while in business school I started working with a couple buddies of mine who are also at Goldman on like basically a startup private equity firm. And I was like okay, we'll do something new. And at the time it was, we were trying to do roll ups of it was basically like QSRs so quick service restaurants. And it was like, you know, this was like a little bit on the back end but not all the way now on like the search fund era
Desmond Fleming 21:22
of
Rob 21:23
business school people. And so we were, it was sort of a search fund thing and we were funding the deals. One off one of the first checks was actually the dean of the Columbia Business School into this thing and we were just like trying to do this thing. And then I was also going to school but then I also was like still doing a bunch of crypto at the time like personally. And I thought I was going to get a crypto job actually because I was doing this and I realized I didn't want to do it anymore. And so I told my partners like, you know, whatever, give me a little bit of the economics I still have and like you guys can run with it. And they're actually still running that thing.
Desmond Fleming 21:56
Yeah,
Rob 21:57
it's like they raised 250 million bucks to do this roll up business and doing a bunch of other stuff. And I really hated QSRs. It was like not my thing.
Desmond Fleming 22:07
I was going to say crypto, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana I don't think was around at that time but and
Rob 22:12
Ethereum had just, the whitepaper had just come out right.
Desmond Fleming 22:14
The ICO. So it's like 2017
Rob 22:16
time
Desmond Fleming 22:17
frame
Rob 22:17
and
Desmond Fleming 22:17
then QSRs. You're buying Wendy's. Totally different world.
Rob 22:20
I was just like, I was like, I was sort of like a kid trying to figure it out. When I was at Goldman I worked on a lot of fintech stuff too. And so I was like, oh, I kind of and I like crypto and so then I was like, okay, I'm gonna do a crypto thing. And then the market crashed.
Desmond Fleming 22:34
And
Rob 22:34
I was like, okay, well, now there's not a crypto thing to do anymore because people don't remember. But Consensys almost went under. And Consensys was like the only hire, like the large scale hire of people other than Coinbase. But Consensys was here in New York, they were in
Desmond Fleming 22:47
Brooklyn.
Rob 22:48
And so then I was like, okay, well, what am I gonna do? And so I ended up doing fintech investment banking, which when I was at Goldman, I was in like the strategy group, so it was like more like M and A for the bank. And so I was like, okay, when I'm doing investment banking. And it was, I was good at it and I liked it and it was like a grind. And I liked fintech a lot, and I liked crypto a lot. And so I was continuing to just like go to meetups on the side and spend a bunch of time just like running through like, you know, anybody I could get connected to and like, okay, like, you know, what's going on in the space? And I was staying connected, but I was like, oh, well, there's not like a way to make a living here yet that like my mother would like, you know, and that I could like live in New York. And there was, but I was, I think I was a lot more risk averse then than I am now. And what happened is that we started doing some interesting things at the investment bank I was at, it was a little bit more like merchant banking. And there was some investing side to it. And it was. We were doing a lot of trying to build out those capabilities in frontier technologies. And so around 18, 19 and into 20, we started to hear from our clients that they cared about crypto. And so people like Visa, people like Franklin Templeton, people like MasterCard as a couple, a bunch of the other fintechs, the Squares and PayPals of the world and the place I was at PJT, they realized that I was like the only person who knew anything about crypto there. And so they started trotting me out to like, I gave Jenny Johnson at Franklin Templeton her first teaching on crypto ever. So they started just like trotting me out in front of all these CEOs, and I started to realize that there was more. There was again becoming institutional interest in the space because I
Desmond Fleming 24:41
had been there earlier, but then it had died off. And so it was again happening. And that was when I realized that we were able to do a few interesting things too, where we did fundraisers for crypto companies. So Caitlin Long, who. I don't know if you know her, but she. She actually started the first iteration of Erebor,
Rob 25:01
like
Desmond Fleming 25:01
all the way back in 2020. She was like, trying to become like a digitally native crypto bank at the time. And so we would do these fundraises and they would let me lead them. Cause it kind of didn't matter to the firm. But they were like a way to learn or whatever. And we would take equity back as payment instead of like fees.
Desmond Fleming 25:19
But no, because of your merchant banking comment, you guys wouldn't put your own capital. So
Rob 25:24
we'd put some capital up too. Okay. So we put some capital up and then we would help them raise more capital. And that would be like,
Desmond Fleming 25:27
balance sheet on firm or like.
Rob 25:29
Yeah, it was like a little bit of balance sheet on firm. And so we started doing some interesting stuff like that. And that helped me continuing to like, deepen what was my network in the space and that just like raising my hand and saying, hey, I'll do this thing. Kind of put me into, like, a different category from all of the other senior associates, like junior VPs at this bank where I was like, running a lot of my own stuff. And that it meant that I was like, working. Like, I was kind of like moonlighting doing that while I was also doing like, M and A.
Desmond Fleming 26:00
Yeah.
Rob 26:00
But it ended up being really worth it because I got connected to a guy at this place called Golden Tree, like I mentioned earlier, and he had been. Personally had made some money in crypto, and he was like, hey, do you want to come on and like, you can do some fintech stuff, and then you also can help me build a crypto business if it makes sense. And so ended up doing that, and that kind of the rest is history. We ended up building this business. 2021 happened and like, everything went to, you know, bitcoin went to 60 some K, which now we are depressed when it's at 60 some K. But
Desmond Fleming 26:30
at the time was like, amazing,
Rob 26:32
which is so crazy to me.
Desmond Fleming 26:33
I know. And it kind of built this business there. We hired. We had a team of 11 people and we were doing. It was all. I was all partner capital. We didn't raise LP capital for
Rob 26:45
it.
Desmond Fleming 26:46
But just like taking that risk of being like, okay, like, I'll come and kind of do this thing at a new place. And each step of the way, I'd kind of taken these risks of like, kind of putting myself out there and, you know, I think taking on a little bit more pain each time to the point that when this opportunity came knocking where my partner said, hey, do you want to come run out of our partnership and help us build this business? It was also a bit of a risk because I, at the time Dragonfly was, we had just raised the third fund, so we're on fund four now. We had just raised the third fund, $675 million fund we had raised. It was our first institutional fund. The first two funds before that were kind of like friends and families, family offices, things like that. And we had done well, but we were definitely not the brand that we are today, I don't think. And so I came on and was like, they also definitely weren't known for the stuff that I was doing. So stuff we're talking about now, they were doing, they were great investors in DeFi, great investors in Asia, great investors in a lot of the
Rob 27:45
more crypto native stuff, but not some of the things we're talking about. Not at
Desmond Fleming 27:48
the intersection as much.
Rob 27:49
Yeah, right. And so I came on to kind of build that business. And this was during Luna and right before FTX. And there was a time during FTX where I was like, I don't know if this, like is the, this is all dead. But you know, now four years later, like it's been, it's been a great run. We've raised another fund since then. We've had a couple of great investments. So glad I did it. But it's been like every step of the way. I think I was thoughtful about where I was going, but I'm not sure that I could have said it would have ended me up here where I was. Yeah,
Desmond Fleming 28:20
yeah, that's the non linear, linear, whatever. Linear, non, non linear component of it. How do you think your relationship with risk has changed? Right. So you, you've, you know, over a decade, you've, you've made these jumps, taken on risk. Now you, and at different points you were on the buy side, on the sell side. Now you're fully on the buy side. Now you're taking very, a very specific type of risk. So I'm curious about how your relationship with risk has changed. And then on the other hand, two pronged question, who are your investor influences? Right. And again, you are an early stage venture investor within the crypto ecosystem, which is a very specific type of risk. But I'm sure there are investors that you have either read about or looked up to that have influenced some of your style.
Rob 29:09
It's interesting because of the fact that I've been at so many different types of places. My relationship with risk has changed a lot over time. I think. You know, when I was at the hedge fund, we talked a lot about our margin of safety, which when you're at a venture VC fund, you never talk about your margin of safety. Your margin of safety is zero. And I have brought a lot of that to what I do now, but have also had to realize over time that I had to take more risk. So I think there were times in my career, on my early stage of venture career where I was a little bit too focused on, okay, well what's the downside risk to this? What is the variance of outcomes potentially that could happen? And not enough focus on the upside. And I definitely made some mistakes years ago that were, oh well, this is a good risk adjusted return. But I was pricing a Series A like it was like a pre IPO coded sort of deal, which it has to take a different type of underwriting. But at the same time I think it's allowed me to be. So I invest much more generalist across stages.
Desmond Fleming 30:23
Yeah.
Rob 30:23
So I've done seed through Series D at this point and it's allowed me to be more flexible in those rounds and in those types of opportunities to try to spot ways to make money anywhere across those different stages. My seed investing has gotten better over time and, but if I look at my, actually my own stats, my seed hasn't been great, but my Series A and Series B has been really good. And now we have this ability to, I think, you know, go even further upstream, further upstage. As we've, as we've been, we've been growing and so I think for me it's been about, more about figuring out and isolating the risk depending on the deal and the stage and with a fit for our current fund mandate which has continued to evolve and so it's a little bit of an odd, it's
Desmond Fleming 31:15
amorphous and it's changing, right?
Rob 31:16
That's
Desmond Fleming 31:17
right. And then the entry points of risk taking that you feel comfortable with in this particular seat are also changing too.
Rob 31:25
I think that's right. And I think, I mean, I'm interested like you guys are mostly seed through B
Desmond Fleming 31:29
C. We are, I think for us it's a function of where the market is at right now. If you had asked me three, four years ago, I'd say we're exclusively seed in Series A.
Rob 31:39
Yeah.
Desmond Fleming 31:40
Today I think a Series A can look a lot like a historical Series B in terms of check size, valuation, you know, entry point, et cetera.
Rob 31:49
Yeah.
Desmond Fleming 31:50
So I think it. We still are very focused on seed in Series A for sure, but I think the. At the end of the day, everyone's trying to just be involved in the best companies, however you can figure that out.
Rob 32:01
Yeah. And I think that's right. And so. And I think that's what's happened to us too. Right. And so we've continued to be more willing to go later stage and later stage or to, you know, call it underwrite. In the past, we hadn't really done Series Bs. For first check we would do it, but now, I mean, you know, Polymarket we did. That was the first check we did. There was sort of an extension of in between the A and the B, but then we did the B and in the C and the in the D. And that was a thing where we started to get more comfortable kind of adding on to those investments over time as well. Rain, same thing. You know, we're co investors with you guys and that was one where we actually actively tried to get really involved in the A, but they kind of took a. They pushed us off and took inside money only. But then we kind of chased it into the B and into the C and we've started to see. I think that's where a lot of our sweet spot is and that's where we kind of get the right ability, where we feel comfortable about taking risk. I don't think for me as an investor, I think my partners are better than this. For me as an investor, when it's in the ideation stage, but like, not. There's not something I can like, feel. And the
Desmond Fleming 33:09
primordial ooze
Rob 33:10
phase. Yeah, that is not a place where I feel like I've got an edge. So I don't know. But to your question around who do I.
Desmond Fleming 33:18
Yeah, investor influences.
Rob 33:19
You
Desmond Fleming 33:20
mentioned margin of safety, which is obviously a Seth Klarman reference. I don't know if that's what you meant by it or not.
Rob 33:26
Well, it's funny, it's Seth Klarman, but it was like the mantra at Golden Tree. So this guy Steve Tannenbaum, who's been one of the most successful bond investors ever. And so I think it's something a lot of people talk about. I've always really looked up to Vinod Khosla. I think he has a lot of conviction and is willing to be very different from the rest of the bay. I mean, Peter Thiel, sort of the same thing, but that's sort of a cop out. But like what we try a lot to do or not to do, and I really try hard not to do is not chase whatever themes are not care about, you know, what are the hottest companies and what will, you know, get the most other venture capitalists talking about us, but more about what we think are durable, long term sustainable businesses. I think a lot of the venture industry is just grouping, just punching. Right. And most people take signal from like eight firms and they bunch into these other things and they say, okay, well this must be great because Sequoia did it. And if Sequoia did it, somebody else will, you know, price up in the future and you know, etc.
Desmond Fleming 34:29
And if this
Rob 34:29
market is big enough, there can maybe be two players or three players. I'm comfortable with being in number two, not number one. And maybe it's still so early that people don't really know the difference between 1, 2, 3 or 4.
Rob 34:44
Yeah, I think that's. I think that's completely right. And we try really hard not to think about those things. There's a guy and I'm going to butcher, I'm blanking on the name, but Jeremy, I think it's Gifford or Giffen, who.
Desmond Fleming 34:56
He does his own thing, right?
Rob 34:57
Yeah, he's been on. I think he runs a different fund, but I'm blanking on the name of the fund now. But he's been on Invest Like the Best a couple of times. And one of the things that he talks about a lot, which is also something that Buffett says a lot, which is a big part of investing, is just being able to sit still for a long period of
Desmond Fleming 35:13
time.
Rob 35:14
And that resonates with me a lot because I have a tendency to be action oriented. And so I want to do a lot of deals. And so one of the things that I'm very focused on and has been a big part of the way we do business has been that we are always default no. Right. And you have to figure out like, is this somebody that I want to, you know, pick up the phone and talk to on a Saturday night and would I talk to them, you know, at any given time of the year? And if that's not true and if I'm not excited about to do this deal at any price, then I shouldn't be doing the deal
Desmond Fleming 35:49
default. No. Could be tough if the org absorbs too much of that because then you don't do anything.
Rob 35:56
That's true.
Desmond Fleming 35:56
And that's at odds with what you get paid to do, which is deploy money. So how do you navigate that tension of running the firm too, or helping run the firm,
Rob 36:04
I think. I mean, this is an interesting point for you, but there's a lot of incentive misalignment in venture capital,
Desmond Fleming 36:13
right?
Rob 36:14
Because if you're a GP managing partner, like, your sole incentive is probably to just make money. If you're an associate or analyst or principal, like, you're
Desmond Fleming 36:26
trying to do deals.
Rob 36:27
You're trying to do deals. Right. And that natural tension leads to a lot of bad behavior.
Desmond Fleming 36:33
Right.
Rob 36:34
And so you have to. My job is to make sure that we're taking the right risk. Right. Which means that I have to take people that work for me and that work for the firm and slow them down and have them and really try to train them to be like, this is what makes a great investment. But then also to encourage them that they can have a good career by not doing a bunch of deals, but also by doing good deals and building a great brand for themselves. And it's a little bit easier for us, I think, in so much as that we don't really follow on. We mostly only lead or co lead. And because we only lead or co lead, the incentive to like, oh, I'm just going to do every deal that like Sequoia does
Desmond Fleming 37:16
kind
Rob 37:16
of goes away a little bit because we're just not going to do that. And the team knows that. And it also means that they know that they have to be willing to, like, you know, spend a bunch of time on a board and do a bunch of extra work on it. And so that helps a little bit. But it also means that, like, I don't think me saying that we're in default. No. Actually changes that behavior because of the incentives the way they are,
Desmond Fleming 37:38
the behavior is going to be there.
Rob 37:39
Correct?
Desmond Fleming 37:39
Yeah. Yeah. Let's jump back into talking a little bit about current state of the market. What are some of the ideas that you're excited. Most excited about right now. So when I think about, let's call it this, we think a lot about, hey, we're navigating this transition from stablecoins to digital assets. We obviously think stablecoins can 10x from where they are today. But if we think about digital assets, there's a lot of focus on on chain credit. There's a lot of focus on perps. There's still obviously attention within prediction markets and then kind of outside, at least from my perspective, outside of the digital asset ecosystem, people are trying to think through how will AI and capital markets or how will AI and financial systems overlap? So that's kind of my view of the world, of what's interesting at the intersection of fintech and crypto today. But what are you most excited about?
Rob 38:32
I think it's a lot of that. But one of the things that's happened is the space has matured a lot. Right. And in any maturing space it also means that you start to figure out what works and what doesn't. And some of the really net new novel, dreamy stuff that starts to come down a little bit because the marginal Stanford dropout is now working in a different industry. So in 21, every Stanford kid wanted to work in crypto. Today, every Stanford kid wants to work in AI. Like
Desmond Fleming 39:01
we're coming back to perps or like, you know, OTC prediction market, like structuring.
Rob 39:06
Yeah. The Castle guys. Yeah. Who are, who I have. I think they're great, they're really smart kids. But you know, there's definitely some of that of course. But I think it has kind of coalesced around what we like to refer to internally as like the future of money and the future of finance. Right. And like that's where the space is like really showing that it works. Right. So it starts with stablecoins, tokenized assets, net new novel financial products, prediction markets. I do think those things are heavily colliding with AI today. Very quickly, the idea of doing, whether it's agentic payments or autonomous finance, those things are coming together really quickly. We have this term, we wouldn't actually do it start this term. But Eric, the founder of Venice, who was previously the founder of Shapeshift, has this thing that
Desmond Fleming 40:00
Bitcoin OG
Rob 40:01
Bitcoin OG. He's been in space forever. He has this term that he says freedom enhancing technologies. And we started to use that term a little bit because I think that includes in many ways I think Nous Research is a freedom enhancing technology. Yeah,
Desmond Fleming 40:16
there's an open source agent harness.
Rob 40:18
Yeah, sort of open source agent harness and things like his current business Venice, which is sort of a cross between like a VPN for inference, but also just like it's like privacy preserving inference and routing for different models.
Rob 40:35
A lot of what we're seeing like even like OpenRouter, I think in many ways is that today that's not how they started. They started as like a
Desmond Fleming 40:41
corporate expense management thing. And so I think there's, we're in this world today where AI is becoming more political than ever and it's going to be probably more political than just about any new technology has been in a long, long time.
Desmond Fleming 40:57
Yeah, well, there's rightfully so given the amount of capital at work, at stake, but also the potential power, concentration of power of this technology.
Rob 41:09
But I think people are also rightfully scared about what happens with the concentration of power.
Desmond Fleming 41:14
Right.
Rob 41:15
And so I expect that there's going to be a lot of work and technology and interest done to make sure that people still have the ability, they still just have their own basic human rights. Right. We're also in a period of time, by the way, people have the right to intelligence, they have the right to use open source models, they have the right to use open source code. We are in a period of time where globally that has been infringed upon in a way that it hasn't been and ever. I mean, not ever. That's hyperbole, but it hasn't been in a long, long time.
Desmond Fleming 41:49
Yeah. Could you say, could you say more about that? I think I come at the venture ecosystem world from a, you know, relatively narrow US scope. So what's going on? The States.
Rob 41:59
So not just, but it is also the States, right. So we know now that like facial recognition is being used in the States the way it was used to suppress Hong Kong dissidents when China during COVID. Right. Like facial recognition in the US is now being used in the same exact way to try to find dissidents or people who are protesting and, you know, potentially, you know, arrest them or, you know, etc. And that level of use of technology, whether it's AI, whether it's ML, whether it's, you know, kind of anything else that's going in that people are working on. Autonomous technologies is going to continue to be used by those in power, no matter who it is, no matter what political affiliation to try to get the outcomes they want. Right. Like that is just the nature of humanity. And because technology, because AI is becoming more powerful than ever and because it is allowing us to do far more than we've ever been able to do with far fewer people, it. The likelihood that that technology gets abused is high. Right. I mean, we're seeing this in the conversation about the AI race about, okay, well, you know, is the US behind China and is this a national security issue? But the reality is it is a national security, but it's also a human rights issue for everybody everywhere. Right. And so I think it is important that we push forward and we fund technologies that have privacy or freedom, enhancing sort of foundational,
Desmond Fleming 43:40
you said freedom preserving or freedom enhancing technology?
Rob 43:43
Freedom preserving or freedom enhancing? We've used both before. But
Desmond Fleming 43:47
so where, if you had to think about your whatever market map, market structure framework in your head, what are the buckets of freedom enhancing technologies? I understand the, you know, element of Venice, right. Where it's meant to be. I'm in control of my inference and no, it's uncensored. Yeah. How else do you think about that?
Rob 44:08
Yeah, well, I think it's broadly so. A lot of it is about the ability to, you know, use open source software and the way. And not be. And be able to have the right to freedom of speech in the way you, open source software. Right. And so we saw the first bill passed this year in, I believe it was Colorado, to outlaw VPNs, right?
Desmond Fleming 44:29
VPN?
Rob 44:30
That's crazy. I did not.
Desmond Fleming 44:32
VPNs. $70 billion industry,
Rob 44:34
right?
Desmond Fleming 44:35
And VPN
Rob 44:36
Express Nord or whatever it is.
Desmond Fleming 44:39
But like, you know, VPNs, the people who want to outlaw these things will tell you, well this is just used by criminals, like, why would you need a VPN otherwise, right?
Rob 44:46
But VPNs are also used by many, many people, journalists, many people in a lot of different industries to do very legitimate work. Right? And the same is true in AI. The same is true in being able to access open source models. The same is true and being able to use, you know, different types of software that exist in different places. And so I'm being a little bit vague because I also think this is like politically sensitive. But there is a push to consolidate power both at company levels, but also at political levels and at government levels to make sure that there's more surveillance than ever. Right. And on a day to day basis, people do not care about surveillance. Right? Like the actual consumer does not care. And so what you need to do is you need to build products that allow people to have the same experience it could have elsewhere, but also, you know, preserve their privacy. And so there's also, for another example of this, there was a guy recently, and this is obviously a bad case, but there was a guy recently who was, he was like chatting with Claude or ChatGPT or whatever around.
Rob 46:07
I think it was about a legal case that he was, that he was part of. And I think this was actually a, it wasn't a criminal legal case, but it was a civil one. And he ended up, they ended up having his chat subpoenaed and he was like, well like listen, this is the same as talking to a lawyer or I have privilege and they said no because of the third party doctrine. You don't have any privilege on what you, on what you put on in your chat. Previously if you were to do something on your computer that then was going to. They had to then get a warrant or a subpoena against you personally. Right. But now they can essentially go and pressure OpenAI to give you those chats. That type of
Desmond Fleming 46:49
which in a way is saying that data is not yours, it's
Rob 46:51
not your data anymore.
Desmond Fleming 46:52
And consumers presumably that's also in their terms of service. T's and C's, whatever.
Rob 46:57
Yeah, it's on all the terms.
Desmond Fleming 46:58
But like consumers are like I don't care because I want to use this AI.
Rob 47:01
Yeah, I mean we've seen it I mean recently with the new AI assistant that everybody's using
Desmond Fleming 47:06
Instinct baby
Rob 47:06
instincts. Right. Like so like it's all anyone's talking about and you're basically giving up like all of your data to them. Right?
Desmond Fleming 47:11
Yeah.
Rob 47:12
And so I think that, I mean Apple for instance has always had this perspective that they have for many, many years anyways I think that's changing now. But for many, many years did not allow for backdoor into iPhones unless there was a warrant.
Desmond Fleming 47:29
Right.
Rob 47:29
And I think there's ways to break that now that there weren't before. But they always push back against kind of warrantless surveillance of iPhones. And I think we need to do the same for AI and the future of AI and for the future of software that will mostly be written by AI.
Desmond Fleming 47:47
Very interesting. Fascinating. So that is I would say the one of the companies I did want to talk about that I think you recently invested in. Correct me if I'm wrong if you didn't lead this deal. But related to this theme is Sapien.
Rob 48:02
It's probably Sapien is not related to this theme specifically. Yeah, it's adjacent to that. Venice is probably the one that's the most kind of. Has the most open. Yeah, right,
Desmond Fleming 48:10
right in that fairway. But I do want to talk about Sapien nonetheless. Bring us inside kind of your thinking into that company. Why are you excited? I can understand some of the high level themes outside in.
Rob 48:24
Yeah. So for Sapien. So yeah we led the Series A, $35 million Series A. a16z had led the seed. The founder, he had led engineering for Shopify Pay which I think is like one of the best payment products that has ever existed. To be honest. He's trying to do a couple of things. He really has three products today but one product is, which has now become a very hot topic but was not when he started this, which is smart routing for inference essentially. Right. And so right now you know we had OpenRouter and OpenRouter of course made it impossible to route to any model. But what he's trying to do is say okay, well based on whatever you want your agent to do or ever workflow that you need, I have enough data from all of my customers to say whatever the trade offs you want to make between efficiency, cost and accuracy, I can route it to the right model.
Rob 49:26
Coinbase was one of the first that came out and said okay, well we are actually building our own routing because we're spending too much on tokens. And there was the whole token maxing era which lasted for like three months.
Desmond Fleming 49:37
Yeah, I think people are still token maxing to be honest.
Rob 49:41
I think most of the people I mentioned about your portfolio, most of our portfolio is now very actively trying to get ahead of token maxing and be like how do we actually figure out how to make sure that we are getting ROI of tokens? And so that's part of his product. Right. And so it's okay, what workflow do you want and how do we do that for you? Right. And he combines that with essentially a control plane for agents which is okay, well you know, a single API to plug into Twilio, plug into anybody you would use for text or for email, whatever you want your agent to be able to access, inclusive of also, you know, single use, virtual cards, stablecoin payments, stablecoin wallets, also accounting and maybe permissioning and things like that. So it's really this control plane. And the idea is that like a lot of companies that started very agentic came and they said well we just have to build all this infrastructure. We have to plug into every API, we have to build all of our own accounting infrastructure, all of our own data infrastructure. Well like there's going to in the future there's going to be a lot of companies that are going to want to build agentic first that aren't going to have to build all of that because like they need to focus on their customers, they need to not focus on like the core infrastructure.
Desmond Fleming 50:54
Right. 100%.
Rob 50:55
And so those are the kind of the two main products. And then he also has the ability for now for you to come as someone who's maybe not in technical to say okay well I want to build a, call it an agent to do for a drop shipping business that is going to help me do XYZ for my drop shipping business. Right. And he has the data to. Because other people have built these types of agents of what has worked best and what has not. And you can build an agent with him in or with Sapien in natural language and they'll give it to you for free for I think right now it's 15 days to see if it actually works.
Rob 51:33
Right. And then they'll start charging you for it.
Desmond Fleming 51:35
Yeah. And then I guess they monetize on the inference through the agent.
Rob 51:38
Yeah, they monetize the inference. So they mark it up the inference. And they also. And they're doing the same thing which a lot of these guys are doing which is they're now starting to build out their own compute as well. But so they'll mark that up and then they also for like any payment that you goes through x402 or cards they you know, they charge a fee on top of that. Which essentially ends up looking like interchange.
Desmond Fleming 51:59
Yep, yep, yep. Fascinating. Maybe we'll talk about compute and then kind of start to wrap things up.
Desmond Fleming 52:07
Any thoughts on that market is certainly. I'm sure you've met a leading question. You probably do have. You do have thoughts on that market. People have tossed around different comparisons to compute as being similar to oil or similar to power and electricity.
Desmond Fleming 52:24
Obviously the capex guides are what they are. What have you kind of seen in that ecosystem? And also putting a venture brain and hat on. Where do you get excited about as an insertion point?
Rob 52:32
We've struggled with the compute space a little bit. So this is one of those areas I talked earlier about trying not to chase the
Desmond Fleming 52:44
hot.
Rob 52:44
The hot thing. Right. And I'm sure you've seen but like all of the brand name VCs have done something in the space. We did one thing very early stage like a pre seed 15 mil post type thing to kind of learn something. But we've looked at all these deals whether it's the index providers, OTC providers, compute desk or in all of these guys silicon data. There's also. There's like Architect on the exchange side. I think my general perspective has been that two things. One, it's nothing like oil. And this idea that compute's like oil makes absolutely no sense. Oil is a commodity you pulled up from one place or another. You know it ends up. It can be slightly different but like after it goes through refinery and after it comes upstream like it ends up powering your car the same way.
Desmond Fleming 53:29
Right? Yep.
Rob 53:30
It's. It is more like electricity. Right. And you know, if you ask some people, they'll tell you, well, like why, like electricity futures have never worked. Like there were Enron futures on the CME, you know, 20 plus years ago and they came out to a bunch of fanfare and there was like no volume in them whatsoever. And it's because a lot of the same things that you see in compute, which is that, you know, whatever, the chips are not the same. The software that the chips run are not always the same. The power quality is not always the same. The ability to cool them is not only the same. The data center they're in can have different sort of ways of which they make things more power efficient. Right. And so they don't drain and they don't have the same kind of half life that they would otherwise. And because of that, having a standard compute future becomes, I think, a lot harder to be usable for a broad range of people.
Rob 54:32
And there's a lot of really interesting arguments to why that may or may not be true. But I think the other thing that adds to this problem is that it's not the biggest users of compute today. Right. So like the hyperscalers they have, they don't want to be anything other than long, right?
Desmond Fleming 54:52
Yeah.
Rob 54:53
And like all who are the biggest users other than hyperscalers? Well, it's like the HFTs,
Desmond Fleming 54:58
like
Rob 54:59
Jane Street might be one of the biggest users of compute in the world right now. They had a super interesting video about how they do have their own compute auction within Jane Street.
Desmond Fleming 55:07
Oh, I
Rob 55:08
did
Desmond Fleming 55:08
not see that.
Rob 55:08
Yeah, so it was like
Desmond Fleming 55:09
internally.
Rob 55:10
Internally for
Desmond Fleming 55:10
teams to bid on compute.
Rob 55:12
Yeah, their own teams have to bid on compute at Jane Street. Oh,
Desmond Fleming 55:14
wow.
Rob 55:15
And so they may be one of the biggest users of compute in the world. They also, I was talking to one of the guys there, it's not clear to me they want to be anything structurally other than long. And for the people who are hedging, maybe like, you know, called the lineal clouds or something, what are they doing? They're just entering into long term contracts. Right. And those long term contracts in and of themselves hedging. And so it's sort of unclear. You already have this like market structure issue that maybe can be solved, maybe can't be. But then you also have, it's unclear who the buyers are of if you figure that piece out.
Desmond Fleming 55:49
Right,
Rob 55:49
right. And so I think you take those two uncertainties together and then these deals are getting done for companies that are doing like a million dollars of revenue, like in very small volumes at like 300 million posts, you're sort of like,
Desmond Fleming 56:01
yeah,
Rob 56:02
it's like, it's hard for me to make sense of it.
Desmond Fleming 56:04
The asymmetry gets baked out. Yeah, which is why you do a deal at 15 posts.
Rob 56:09
You do the deal at 15 posts and you kind of try to learn something. And maybe the issue is that they're not, you know, whatever the team that has the interest of like the hottest VCs in the world. But I think at that stage, like, you kind of never know. Right. The data kind of proves that out. Yeah,
Desmond Fleming 56:22
yeah. You figure it out over time. So maybe we'll improvise on the fly here. We'll maybe do a little bit rapid fire. We'll see what happens. But first question is, what is your most contrarian crypto take right now?
Rob 56:36
I think the concern that I have maybe more than a contrarian take is that there's a lot of things that are happening in crypto right now, and this has always been true, that are propped up to be very exciting because a lot of people want it to be exciting and because there's a lot of economic incentive for that to be true. But that like, don't really make sense in terms of like trying to bring, you know, this intersection together. Right. So actually. And then this is, this is leading to what is actually a contrarian take, which is that I think like spot tokenized equities is. It will work, but it will work within the normal ecosystem. Which means that, you know, BTC.
Rob 57:22
Correct. And they will, and they will launch their thing in October and like there's going to be, you know, traditional fund admins and clearinghouses and you know, all of these people and transfer agents around the table. Although I think like a Superstate or a Securitize will. Will take some of that share. But they're the, you know, the Stock X's or xStocks of the world and the Andos of the world and like, you know, all these people trying to do kind of their own tokenized, you know, spot equity business. Like, they just, they're structured in a way that is not able to serve like, you know, any mass market whatsoever. And it's also not clear to me that like there's that much demand for these things. And so if we think about this for a second, the biggest markets in the world that are, that, you know, people say, okay, well these are rich markets, but they're, you know, international, so they don't necessarily have access to US equities. That's basically not true. Like all the rich people in Korea can get US equities. All the rich people in Japan can get US equities. Like there's very, very few countries where they can't. The who are actually buyers of these things cannot get access to US equities. And so it's just, it's so, it's so unclear to me, like what problem is being solved. And I expect that like a lot of what is happening here is like a lot of people are holding inventory and then they're like putting out these charts that are like, oh, it's up and to the right. It's still very de minimis. But like most of that inventory is sitting at the market makers and at the exchanges and not actually sitting in the hands of like net new demand, real demand. I think the derivatives piece, like perps like we talked about, that'll get very big, but I think for, I think spot, I just don't think it's like that interesting.
Desmond Fleming 58:58
Yeah, it's a little bit of the question of who's the incremental buyer within the broad crypto or digital asset ecosystem today. Okay, next question. What is your, I'm going to use the word greatest. You define greatest in your own opinion. Greatest investment success today. And what do you think you got right?
Rob 59:16
Oh gosh. Yeah. So if I define it from a multiple perspective today, it's Polymarket. It wasn't actually that long ago, it was three years ago. Ish.
Desmond Fleming 59:28
How'd you meet Shane? Did you prior relationship or outbound?
Rob 59:33
So outbound. So interestingly for my career, I have found that I have been. We talk a lot and I'm sure you guys do too about like, oh, make sure that you have good deal flow. My best investments have all been like spotting some data and then just like, you know, cold emailing people. And so same thing happened with the Rain guys when Sam Altman got fired. And so that was, was, you know, summer of 23.
Desmond Fleming 59:59
Yeah,
Rob 59:59
yeah. And he got fired on a Friday.
Desmond Fleming 60:02
What a way. The timelines diverge.
Rob 60:05
He got fired on a Friday and he got rehired on a Monday.
Desmond Fleming 60:09
Yeah.
Rob 60:09
And in every single chat that I was in, people were being like, oh, check the Polymarket. And
Desmond Fleming 60:16
I'd obviously I had heard of Polymarket before. I had grown a lot during the election in 2020 and they had raised that round by General Catalyst at the time. But then after FTX and Luna, everything kind of died off. And after the election, prediction markets had pretty much there was zero volume in them after that election.
Rob 60:41
But when that started happening, when people were like, check the Polymarket, even as small volume as it was at the time, I think it kind of clicked in my head that, okay, one, now there's interest outside of politics, but two, oh, this is actually going to be really social. And it's not just a trading platform, it is a social platform. And it hadn't clicked in my head before that. I'm sure smarter people than me had figured that out before and we started to see the data kind of pick up a little bit. I think around the same time or soon after, Trump tweeted about a Polymarket. Like he was going to.
Rob 61:11
Because
Desmond Fleming 61:11
everything was on chain.
Rob 61:11
Yeah, it was. Everything was on the chain. So you could, you could see it. And so I pinged Shane. He had met some of my other partners years ago, but he had. We didn't really have a relationship with him and he hadn't met me personally. I said, hey, like, you know, love what you're doing, like, you know, can we chat? And we went for like a three hour walk on a Friday night, like through downtown SoHo.
Desmond Fleming 61:29
Yeah.
Rob 61:30
And he, if you've ever met him, he's like just an incredibly charming guy in person. And he has this unwavering vision of building markets for everything. And at the time, he told me the same thing that he'll tell me today, which he's doing, is that he's building markets for everything. The Polymarket is a truth machine and that these things are net positive for humanity. And I know he strongly believes that. And so it's been kind of a wild ride in the last three years. You don't typically have things change that quickly, but it's been, you know, it's been a pleasure to be a part of it. So
Desmond Fleming 62:03
amazing. Love it. And then my last question, and we can wrap after this, is I love asking people in tech and venture, you know, given what you know so far in your career, if you had to rewind the clock or. The thing that I love is that the tech ecosystem for sure is very willing to like, give back, mentor, blah, blah, blah, blah. So given what you know, if you were to think back to the version of you that was 22, 23, 24, someone who's listening to this podcast is like, man, Rob is the man. I want to be like that guy. What's the advice that you would give to someone just starting out their career in VC?
Rob 62:41
What I would tell people is one, understand the incentive misalignment that we talked about before and just always do the hard thing. Be willing to work the hours, be willing to grind, to meet anybody, to go and travel anywhere. Like, just understand that the more work you put in now, the more pain you're willing to take now. It will compound over time. And it was very clear to me that, like, being willing to make some sacrifices earlier in your career will pay far more in when you're 35, when you're 40, than any work that you'll do between 30 and 35 or 35 and 40. What people don't realize as well is that just the network effect of just knowing many people, being highly thought of, being someone who is known to keep your word. It starts to compound in a way that now. I had breakfast with the head of the US Soccer Federation this morning, and we talked a lot about how I can help in US soccer because I'm a big soccer guy, like we talked about earlier, and that was sort of a random chance meeting. And that meeting will probably end up in more random chance meetings and just being willing to do all of these things and work these things because of the fact that, you know, we had built this network earlier, and people knew that, hey, this was an interest of theirs, and they're maybe potentially able to help out. And so I think those are just really important lessons to learn, because I think it's easy to say, oh, I want to take. I don't want to work hard. I don't want to work on a Friday. Like, I want to take the easy way out and just. You forget and you don't realize how much damage it can do to the future.
Desmond Fleming 64:20
Yeah, 100%. I love it. That's part of the inspiration for the pod because we called it the Longest View. So we'll end on there. Rob, thank you so much for coming on. This was a lot of fun.
Rob 64:29
Thanks for having me.