The Lion Counseling Podcast helps men escape the cages that hold them back and become the Lions they were created to be. It exists to help men obtain success, purpose, happiness, and peace in their career and personal lives. The podcast is hosted by the founder of Lion Counseling, Mark Odland (Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and Certified EMDR Therapist), and Zack Carter (Counselor and Coach with Lion Counseling). In their podcasts, they address a variety of topics relevant to men, including: mental health, relationships, masculinity, faith, success, business, and self-improvement.
Alright, welcome everyone to the Lion Counseling Podcast. I'm Mark Odland, founder of Lion Counseling and the podcast where we serve Christian men, on a variety of issues talking about masculinity, theology, living out your faith, living out your vocation. And today I'm pleased to have, Michael Clary here, author of Loser Theology. That is quite the provocative title there Michael. I like it.
Mark Odland:It's gonna stir up some discussion. I'm sure it's a good conversation to have. Why don't we start out by you just giving us kind of a brief overview of people who aren't familiar with you or your work about who you are, yeah, we'll go from there.
Michael Clary:I am a pastor and church planter. The church was founded in 2010, so that was seventeen years ago, sixteen years ago. And we founded the church in the inner city of Cincinnati, Ohio and about a year and a half ago, we moved the entire congregation to a new location in just across the river in Northern Kentucky about ten minutes from our previous location.
Mark Odland:Yeah.
Michael Clary:And recovering loser as the book title indicates. And my wife and I have been married for twenty seven years and we have four children, two teenagers and two in their early twenties.
Mark Odland:Wow. Well, that's awesome. Whenever I hear... We've got four kids as well, my wife and I, and so it's always fun to hear about someone else who's got a big family with all the fun that comes with that and sometimes challenges. But so recovering loser, that's interesting.
Mark Odland:I'd love to hear more about that, and maybe that could be a good intro into the book, kind of your overall thesis or kind of the thrust of where you're going with that and what you're... Kind of discussion you're trying to spark, in the lives of the reader and and maybe maybe Christians everywhere.
Michael Clary:Yeah. So the the book has a bit of an autobiographical, thread that goes through it. It's... I mean, it's it's I tell some of my own story at various points in the book, but it's not like an autobiography or anything. Tell my story as I'm trying to teach through the concepts.
Michael Clary:And the thing that's interesting is that think as the book has come out, a lot of people have told me they resonate with this particular part of my story. And that is when I say I'm a recovering loser, what I don't mean is I've always just been kind of a passive guy who didn't really want to do much. And then I found my courage and decided to take action. Rather, it is... I've I've always been, you know, a fairly assertive
Mark Odland:Sure.
Michael Clary:Strong will type of person, but I suppressed those things because I was taught that that is more godly to do. And if you kind of suppress your agency, if you, let people, you know, walk all over you, if you become a doormat and just kinda pushed around, that's humble, and that is more like Christ. And so I absorbed things that even made me act counter to my nature. And I did that for some period of time. And then as a pastor, you're preaching through the Bible every week.
Michael Clary:And so as I preached through books of the Bible, I kept running into teaching that ran contrary to what I'd always had been told. And eventually I just reached a breaking point. I was like, I've been told isn't right. And it's harmful to people to not give them the whole counsel of God. So I just sort of shed that thinking.
Michael Clary:And it took some time to kind of recondition, retrain my mind and ministry instincts. But as I did, I found just a healthier, more joyful, more fruitful ministry and happens to be more true to what the word of God teaches in my view.
Mark Odland:Well, I appreciate you sharing that. It's... Have... Do you feel like... Is it oversimplification to think that the influence of feminism has...
Mark Odland:Is what has kind of pacified Christian men and kind of worked its way into congregations, or do you have another hypothesis for kind of why that's taken hold the way it has?
Michael Clary:Well, feminism is definitely a character in the story. I would... I mean, I I think a case... A strong case could be made that this is a predominant issue, just a feminization of our culture, a feminization of the church, which then conditions people to accept their Christian discipleship from a feminine frame. So, you know, God made men and women different.
Michael Clary:Women are naturally attuned to be more deferential and passive passive and to follow the lead of of of a strong man. And if that is sort of the normative mode of the Christian life, then you're you're kind of pouring men into that mold and expecting them to conform to feminine traits and expectations. And to do that, they have to shed some of their masculinity and some of their masculine energy or to repackage it as well. This is actually real masculinity. Real manhood is more feminine and and that's it it's more womanly and, you know, real men cry at movies.
Michael Clary:You know, real men, you know, they they serve. They don't lead. Real men are more deferential and they, you know, they're not they're not very strong and and bold. You hear this sort of thing all the time. And so I think that's absolutely part of the story.
Michael Clary:And
Mark Odland:Sure.
Michael Clary:I would say there there are a number of different factors that coincide, but without a doubt, I would say feminism and the effect... Just a feminization of the church is a major major thread.
Mark Odland:Yeah. That... Yeah. That... I mean, that doesn't surprise me to hear you hear you say that.
Mark Odland:I mean, I do see similar themes in my counseling practice, you know, working with high achieving Christian guys and them feeling like they're conquering the... In my case, it's it's almost like this compartmentalized life because I see these guys who... They're just out there conquering and rocking it in the business world, but then they come home. And when it comes to them being a dad and being a husband, they feel kind of emasculated. They aren't sure how to...
Mark Odland:It's very disorienting to feel like when I'm over here, have all this admiration and respect and feel competent. And over here, I don't feel that.
Michael Clary:Yeah.
Mark Odland:And and and even in couples who claim to be a conservative version of Christianity, which I guess taps into some of the Gospel Coalition stuff that we were talking about off camera, is that, you know, guys like Piper and and Tim Keller who have kind of been held up as, I guess maybe at first glance, kind of conservative evangelical champions. It sounds like you kind of have had some critique of how perhaps from your where you're standing and kind of looking at things differently, that may have infiltrated some of their theology as well in a way that's not always helpful. Is that is that a fair characterization?
Michael Clary:Absolutely. Those, I worked as a waiter whenever I was in college, and the the guy that was the manager of this restaurant, he was a hard driving, very strong, directive kind of guy. You didn't want to cross him. He would you know, if you... He'd write you up, the people get fired.
Michael Clary:And so I I was really intimidated by this guy. And then there was one Friday night after, you know, a lot of people, what they would do is at the end of their shift, they would go up into the bar and hang out and spend all the money they'd made in tips at the bar and they hang up. And the manager's wife had showed up. And somebody was remarking to me and said, watch how different this manager is around his wife. And I noticed that around her, she's the boss.
Michael Clary:He was a hard charging, almost bully every... In every other situation. But whenever his wife walked into the room, he totally transformed into a little puppy dog and and like whatever she said. I think that is a parable for how a lot of modern evangelicalism works, and this is also true in conservative churches that would consider themselves complementarian, where the man is on paper, he leads. But in practice, his leadership is the wife says, here's where we can go, and now you lead us there.
Michael Clary:And so she's the setting the direction, and he's implementing her vision and direction. And so that emasculates men because they they have to suppress and deny their own agency in the process and and outsource it to the wife, and then they are also expected to carry all the responsibility though. So if something goes wrong, he's blamed. But if something goes right, then she is credited. Now you you, there's another situation with a man that I knew at church once where a very successful, very driven, ambitious guy out in the world in his business.
Michael Clary:But when it came to church, he was also very deferential to his wife. His wife fit a seminary degree, and he did not. And so it kind of assumed that she was, you know, she was the brains of the operation when it came to matters of faith in church. And and this guy, when it came to matters of the church, he was sort of the opposite of what he was in the world. Out in the world, he was a businessman who's kinda cutthroat, very aggressive, ambitious.
Michael Clary:In the church, he he trained other people to be more passive and deferential and to kind of put their wife... Hit their wives in the driver's seat. And I was just like, this is not what you do in real life, and that tells me it's like there's... You... You've kind of come to accept different ways of operating in these two different realms.
Michael Clary:In the world, you can be a man. But in the church, you have to be effeminate. You have to kind of, you know, deny your masculinity in order to survive there. And and he would enforce it ruthlessly. I mean, if if you had real men that would assert themselves with boldness and agency and courage, he would he would get annoyed and said, brother, that's not Christ like.
Michael Clary:We cannot act this way in the body of Christ. When really, it's just like somebody's just being outspoken and direct. And he he had really had a problem being direct. You... He never quite said what he meant.
Michael Clary:There was always a kind of a passive aggressive way of speaking. And I'm like, I've seen him operate close deals in the business world. I've been in the room when he's closing deals in the business world, And he's like, this is what I want. This is what it's going to cost you. And it's like he'll leave people hanging out to dry.
Michael Clary:And it's like he was he was a strong dude, totally opposite in the church. And I think that a lot of men enter into the church feeling like I can't be a man here. I I have to operate in a different paradigm in the church. It's frustrating, and that's part of why I wanted to address the issue is it's not a men's book, but I think men will particularly benefit from it because it affirms and values the way God made them.
Mark Odland:Yeah. So it sounds like you're you're trying to tap back into the basic premise, right, that men and women are different, And if if how we're wired naturally is suppressed, it's gonna lead to problems. And so part of it is kind of giving... I don't if permission is the right word, but but permission for men. I mean, is it fair to say that permission to be more blunt is part of it for you, or is that a oversimplification?
Michael Clary:Well, it depends on what you mean by blunt. I say... I would say plain spoken. K. Direct is good.
Michael Clary:Blunt has the connotation of perhaps being rude or insensitive. And so I think, you know, a godly man... Well, let's say a man who is just not quite figured out yet how to express his masculinity might be more blunt and just kinda careless. I see this happening a lot with, Christian guys on the right where they're learning to reassert themselves as men in a masculine way, and they think masculinity means you lack tact and you have no regard for how other people feel. I'm like, well, that's not masculine.
Michael Clary:That, you know, it it is not against the masculine spirit to be considerate of other people. That's just good courtesy. However, effeminate is I'm not really going to say what I mean. So, I think a masculine guy that's godly will be direct and and will say, you know, Mark, I've... You may not like what I'm about to say but I I owe you the the courtesy of being honest.
Michael Clary:Let me just say how I think and say it directly. Now if it hurts you, then a masculine guy said, you know, I I know that may sting, but I say this because I care about you and because I want you to... I don't wanna deal with you around the truth. Yeah. A godly righteous guy will do that.
Michael Clary:You might have a guy who's not quite so godly, and he's trying to learn how to be masculine. That might be like, well, if you if you if it hurts your feelings, that's on you, bro. And it just... He's he's totally callous. I'm like, come on.
Michael Clary:It's like, we're dealing with human beings here. Yeah. And so I figured there's there's a bit of a clumsiness as men are learning how to assert themselves in masculine ways.
Mark Odland:I like that. I like that. Obviously, I'm biased doing as a Christian counselor as my day job, primarily doing trauma counseling for men who have been through hard things. I would almost propose a third category, and that's the godly man who hasn't dealt with his stuff. And so the lack of you know, him being kind of oversensitive to certain issues, maybe he's done a good job of pressing forward and staying busy and working harder without doing the deep soul searching around some of the painful experiences in his life.
Mark Odland:He's he's godly in the sense that he's genuinely trying to be faithful, and he's trying to understand the scripture. But then when the rubber meets the road, he has a personal interaction, and the lack of emotional capacity just kind of ends up making him put his foot in his mouth. So it's one of those things where I would never claim even as a licensed therapist that somehow like, well before the invention of modern psychology it was impossible to be a real Christian because you know that's very presumptuous, right? So I see psychology as just one of the many realms of understanding God's creation, right? As people would say in the old days, the two books, there's the book of creation and the book of scripture, they're both revealed by God.
Mark Odland:And so it's an act of worship to try to understand both, right? So I don't know if you feel free to disagree with me if you have a different perspective, but I guess the way that I kind of approach it is I have the same impulse that I think sometimes feminism is kind of... It's like we're all fish swimming in the water and we don't even know we're wet because it's like just reality all around us. And so there's this need for correction in some ways. But then sometimes certain whole categories like for example therapy, right?
Mark Odland:Therapy is dominated by female therapists and a lot of them are overtly feminist in the kind of therapy they provide, And so I'm left as this kind of minority kind of like position as like the guy Christian counselor who's like, it's not all bad. It's like not all bad, but it's kind of like therapy's been like co opted into that's a female thing and therefore guys trying to be masculine run from anything that smells like that stuff, right? So I think it's like it's interesting tension in a way to be like to correct something that's been over corrected one way, you kind of have to swing the other way. But then the question is, is there room for nuance in the middle or does that become a distraction? Like practically, pastorally, do you do you feel like you almost have to deal more with black and white, Or is there room for kind of this middle ground where it's kind of messy and you're like, yeah you don't have to become a female, but yeah you probably should learn how to communicate with your wife.
Mark Odland:Know you're not going to communicate like her girlfriend does and just nod your head and say, oh my gosh that's so hard. And only be that. But, yeah, learn some of those skills too. Like, I guess that's where I'm kinda landing is, like, guys are comforted when I do marriage counseling to be like, I'm not trying to converse you into one of... To be a replica of her female friend that she's having coffee with.
Mark Odland:It's okay for you to be a guy and still, like, learn how to communicate with her. So Yeah. Right. I don't know. I I threw a lot at you there.
Mark Odland:But
Michael Clary:Yeah. So I think from the pulpit, that's a good place to be declarative, and that's my normal mode of operating in the pulpit. This is true black and white. And you're... You don't really have the time to explore the nuances and exceptions.
Mark Odland:Sure.
Michael Clary:In a counseling office, then you have more room to explore those variations in that environment. Whenever I'd... Even the word therapy itself, I don't know the etymology of the word, but I know at least the connotation of how it's used and what people assume. Don't use the word. Even the words like counseling or pastoral care, those words have a certain expectation that people bring to them.
Michael Clary:Interesting. So if you say therapy and counseling, that sounds like, okay, I want to go and pour out my feelings and the person I'm talking to is going to show empathy and compassion and they might give me a word of hope and encouragement along the way. And so whenever people come up, just tell em like, that's that that's not what I'm here to do with you. I'm happy to help you in any way I can and so I might share things that you don't want to hear and I want to push back and there may be a time when I'll say, okay, now, you've talked a lot. I need to preach a sermon to you.
Michael Clary:So give me five minutes to explain what I have to say. Yeah. And that... I don't know if that's good technique. Well,
Mark Odland:but you know what? You're also you're also kinda trying to stay in your lane according to where you feel like you're... Like what your calling is and what your role is. And it sounds like you're not blindsiding them because you're trying to kind of frame the expectations up front of like this is what this kind of what this conversation is gonna look like. And whether you're saying it out loud or not if you expect this to be just me nodding my head and saying, oh yeah that's really hard, that's probably not what you're going to get from me.
Mark Odland:You know, so yeah I could see that.
Michael Clary:I knew, it seemed like when women go to a counselor, what they're looking for is some form of affirmation and a counselor, there is a financial incentive to provide what the customer is looking for. And so if a counselor is going to say, You're in sin and you need to repent, well, you might've just lost a customer. And that's a hard thing for a counselor to do because a counselor is not like a pastor. A pastor, you have not total job security, but there's some expectation of rebuking and it's not elective. Everybody's required to be part of a church.
Michael Clary:You're not required to see a counselor. And so as a counselor, it's like that. I think there's an incentive built in to the industry where the the counselor have to overcome the temptation to pander and to flatter the counsel in order to maintain their source of income. And, of course, I'm not saying that anybody does that or or anybody in particular, but that that... I'm just speaking to the incentives.
Michael Clary:Yeah. And so whenever women go to counselors and they're going to a woman counselor, you have two females, which women are naturally attuned to relate and connect and to affirm one another. And then you have the financial incentive of the counselor where, you know, to be able to stay in business, she feels the temptation at least to tell the other person what they want to hear. And so women go to and basically end up reinforcing from us an outside party, sometimes their own delusions. And the counselor may not say, it's like, you know, you're you're actually...
Michael Clary:You're way wrong there. You're out of touch with reality. They would say, that's right, girl. Like, he he doesn't deserve you. You're better than him.
Michael Clary:It's like they may say the same thing just from a a a licensed opinion that would otherwise be the same as just one of her girlfriends. And so that... I find that very dangerous. Now with men, it it it's a bit different, but I think a similar dynamic can play out. Whereas the word therapy, counseling, soul care, they all have this...
Michael Clary:There is an emotional layer that is is built in. So, even just the word care. It's like, I want to go and seek pastoral care. If you use the word care to talk about what you're going to get from a pastor and he rebukes you, then, he violated your expectation. You weren't supposed to rebuke me.
Michael Clary:You're supposed to care for me. And so that, and so I just... I I think that that is... There's a place for that, and there's a need for pastors to show compassion. But if if the expectation is set on the front end that this is going to be basically your pastor doing what a therapist would do, then that's gonna be wrong expectations and it may end up, you know, going astray because you're not really the expectations are set that you're gonna give them a certain type of interaction that they're not gonna actually get.
Mark Odland:Yeah. Yeah. I think that theme of expectations is is important for how as... You know, those in ministry, those in professions, see our own role, see our own competency, see our purpose, and also what other people are expecting too. Right?
Mark Odland:So, I mean, I think I... Because I work primarily with Christian guys in in what I do, it's it's not an accident that words on my website that may not be on, other therapist websites are words like emotional surgery, tactical targeting of traumatic memories, to be reprogrammed, reprocessed efficiently in 10 to 12 sessions for the purpose of resetting your nervous system in a way that's in tune with the way God designed your body to heal. Right? That that's diff... That's different than you're gonna be in this open ended process for months or years.
Mark Odland:Yeah. And I think I think you're on to something as far as the value as a therapist, my personal belief is you can't just hold the value of making the person feel good. It can't just be to validate everything they say. There's like you said, there's discernment about times when people need encouragement and need empathy for sure, but that always has to be held in tension with truth. Yes.
Mark Odland:Because if you lose sight of truth, whether it's from where you're standing, right? Truth about what God's word is saying, truth about how relationships or your own body works, truth about how emotions tend to function, almost like that the truth of the how things actually, you know, how God created things to work basically, right? So yeah, I think that... Yeah, that's a... It's an interesting critique.
Mark Odland:You know, it made me curious, I'm not sure what sparked this in my mind, but maybe it was the review, the Gospel Coalition review, was quite in-depth actually. Was interesting, it highlighted a lot of things that like it kind of like resonated with, it pushed back on a couple points. One thing that I was curious about for you is I forget the terminology from the book but it was highlighted in this review about kind of a kind of like when you think about Tim Keller's church plant in New York, like almost like an aloofness or intellectual pandering, something like that. And so I guess my thought would be if someone were to push back and say, well that's his ministry, you know that's kind of like his when you planted a church yourself, which is interesting. But I think the expectation like say you were a missionary in Tanzania or China, there'd be some tension in your mind between, okay, this is the truth of the gospel, you just throw out the seeds and some will grow and some won't, and it might seem like foolishness to some.
Mark Odland:And yet, like Paul on Mars Hill also like speaking philosophy to the philosophers, using the unknown god as a bridge to kind of get into that opportunity to to have more conversations. Would someone like Keller be wrong for saying, have a bunch of intellectual, atheistic, agnostic type people here, so I'm kind of going to incarnationally learn to speak that language or to reach this specific group of people. Is there merit to that? Is is is... Are you critiquing that or not critiquing that?
Mark Odland:I'd love to hear your, like, your thoughts on that.
Michael Clary:I do critique that, but I I would also allow for legitimate uses of it. And so, in the miss... Missiology, missions, evangelism, church planting, and that whole field of study, the the label they use is contextualization. Right. Which is I come from a context, you come from a context, and the gospel of Jesus Christ is the eternal truth.
Michael Clary:So how can I communicate something to that person where they are without distorting the message Right? Knowing that there's gonna be points of perhaps alignment and points of disagreement, and I have to take that into account. When I I I first came to trust and follow Tim Keller because he would speak this language, and I assumed he was acting in good faith, and I'm not saying that he wasn't, but I do think there's some reason to question, what the legitimacy of the way he was applying it. And so let's say there's a legitimate... You know, you you go to some tribal village and you know that, okay, these people, they worship multiple gods, and all of the concepts that we take for granted are gonna take a very difficult work of inculcating them with a worldview that can even comprehend the gospel.
Michael Clary:So it's gonna take some time. And so I wanna pick my moments. I wanna push these buttons. I wanna hold off on those, I and wanna walk my way through it, knowing that the whole time what I'm aiming at is the whole counsel of God and and and them to a place where they are fully formed disciples. That's the goal.
Michael Clary:If that's somebody's goal, then I have all the patients in the world if they make strategic decisions. I wanna talk about this, but not that. And eventually, we'll get there. And the presumption is always, we'll get there eventually. Now what I've seen happen in, and I think Tim Keller, there are there are examples of this to where in moments whenever he was asked directly, what are your thoughts about homosexuality?
Michael Clary:He he punted. He would say it's like, well, I would say it's less than god's best. It's not ideal. Or here's another example. He said, I know homosexuality won't send you to hell.
Michael Clary:How do I know that? Because heterosexuality won't send you to heaven. I'm like, that's very clever. It's a rhetorical slide of hand, and it's deceptive in my opinion because he's not he's not addressing the issue directly. That's not a contextual thing.
Michael Clary:It's not I'm dealing with an individual who is who is homosexual, and I'm trying to get them to understand the gospel without getting hung up on their particular sin. I am trying to communicate something broader. Keller would... So here's an example. There's a woman.
Michael Clary:She's a journalist. I wanna say her name is Kirsten Powers, but I'm I'm... I may have the name wrong. She's a well known journalist and she went to Redeemer Church and she made a profession of faith and said she became a Christian there. Well, then, sometime later, she left the church because she found out through some other source that Keller and Redeemer Church is not pro choice.
Michael Clary:So they are... They would be technically against abortion.
Mark Odland:Okay.
Michael Clary:And that frustrated her because she was like, I have been here for years. I've been in their home. I was discipled by his wife, and never once did I hear this particular issue addressed, and it was an issue that she agrees with the world. So she is pro choice. She's...
Michael Clary:She disagreed with the pro life position. And so that tells me, okay, they they obscured a necessary issue of discipleship, the sanctity of life in order to reach her for Christ, which she made a profession of faith. But at no point subsequent to that profession of faith did she ever hear after years of sitting under his preaching, did she ever hear any indication that there were anything other than pro choice. And so I'm like, okay. That's a tell.
Michael Clary:And, of course, being familiar with the ministry of Tim Keller and and Redeemer Church, that... That's a tell that you're unwilling to say the hard thing, which means, okay, your contextualization is not on the road to, I'm leading you patiently, truth by truth, until I get to your particular idol and address that. Rather, I'm using contextualization as a fig leaf to excuse my unwillingness to say the hard thing. And to me, that that's the tell that says, okay, this this methodology itself is flawed and it is being used to give people excuses to not say the hard thing and I had been trained in that methodology and I had seen in my own ministry a willingness to kind of hold back and think, well, we'll get there eventually and I don't want to say the hard things. Somebody might get offended.
Michael Clary:I don't want to ruffle feathers and then I realized, I was I was using it as an excuse as well. I was convicted by by that And so I said, I have to abandon this. This is not good. I'm being dishonest. And I felt my conscience was very troubled that I had deprived people of the the the teaching of scripture that I was obligated to give them.
Michael Clary:And once I made the change and I started to break from that pattern, what I noticed happening was people started to get upset. Lots of them. And and I was like, okay. Like, tells me, I... Now that I'm saying the things that I'd been hesitant to say before and now they're getting upset.
Michael Clary:This tells me that I'm... I am... The fact that they're upset is not necessarily an indicator of its rightness or wrongness. However, when I say the thing that I believe is true and I say it in a way that is not bombastic or fire breathing or anything, I'm just... I'm giving the plain truth and saying it directly but in a in a charitable way, then people get angry, then I know, okay.
Michael Clary:Like, now I'm doing faithful ministry and these... And I'm challenging the idols of the day. I'm challenging people in their sin, and their reaction to it is telling me I am over the target.
Mark Odland:Interesting. Yeah. So it sounds like you were actually pretty steeped in kind of Pastor Keller's teaching and his kind of model of ministry until you weren't. I mean, are you do you believe that the way that he... In those examples you gave...
Mark Odland:I mean I know we're not gods so it's hard to know for sure, but with the examples you gave, do you... Is your is your problem with it that it was just a flawed strategy, or is it that you feel like the passive nature within us as as leaders at times, we just kind of, like, drift with the current, and that becomes the strategy to accommodate the passivity. Is that your concern versus, like, hey. He really... They've discerned this was the strategy, and it just was not effective or not correct.
Michael Clary:I I would say both. If it were just a failed strategy that didn't work, then I would not be upset about that. But, you know, we're all we're all trying things. We're all trying to to learn how to best minister the gospel in these crazy times. It was when it became clear to me that this was not merely a failed strategy, but this was a way to smuggle in, either smuggle in progressive ideology or at least to not confront progressive ideology, but to do so under the guise of a concern for mission.
Michael Clary:And so it's like, hey. You do very conservative bible believing Christian. You should not talk about this list of prohibited things because that offends progressive sensibilities. Now, if you do that saying, I'm gonna save that until later, but I'm committed to get to them in time. That's a strategy.
Michael Clary:That's contextualization. If you say, but if you deceive yourself into saying, it's always this thing that I'll get to eventually and you never get to it, that means that you're using a strategy to avoid a duty, and that is unfaithful. And so I I think there are good Christians who adopted the strategy and ended up being unfaithful without realizing it, and they did so thinking that this is the way you do ministry. This is what it takes. And I am being a good Christian evangelist by not talking about difficult things.
Michael Clary:That was what troubled me, and I think a lot of people followed it. And once it clicked for me, I was like, this is not good, and I need to I need to reject it for myself, and I need to warn other people that may be doing the same thing. And that these experiences kind of prompted the the reflection on and ultimately the writing of the book that where I tell the story of how these things played out.
Mark Odland:Yeah. I mean, that's that's that's thought provoking to kind of pair pair those two strategies that way, and it sounds like you definitely ruffled some feathers when you shifted the strategy. But as the dust settled, my guess is you're you're feeling okay about how it turned out, at least in your congregation.
Michael Clary:Yes. Well, I I can give you a brief testimony if you'd like. Sure. I started to make changes in the mid-2010s. So I planted the church in 2010, and those early two, three, four years I was steeped in this Tim Keller way of thinking and others.
Michael Clary:Not not even knowing that he he was... I always thought he was a staunch conservative. I didn't realize some of his progressive tendencies at that time. But then in the middle of mid two thousand tens, when I made a change, there was there was some frustration that I started to feel intention within my own church. I'll fast forward about seven years or so.
Michael Clary:These tensions continue to percolate and they would spike at different times depending on what was happening. 2020 happened. George Floyd happened. Cove... COVID happened with the vaccine mandates and all of these things.
Michael Clary:And eventually, it led to a breaking point where I had a significant number of people in my church. They just left all at once. I had four elders that resigned. Oh, wow. And about half of my church left, and they went and started another church.
Michael Clary:So it was a split that happened. During that time, I did a lot of soul searching as this was playing out because I wanted to be sure that I could stand before god someday and give account for the way I conducted myself. And so I was... I could say with a clear conscience that there was no... I mean, there's always sin in the mix anytime we do anything, but there was there was there was no sin issue that I could identify that on my part that was driving it.
Michael Clary:It was it was driven by a sincere and genuine desire to honor Christ and to not to not cave to the spirit of the age. Sure. That was the worst thing that ever happened to my ministry. I mean, it was brutal. Yeah.
Michael Clary:Emotionally in very other ways. So that was twenty twenty two and it's been about four years since then, almost exactly to the day was October 2022. It's been four years. So now in the last four years, we have more than replaced the half for the people that left our churches since doubled in size to where we're bigger than we were before that split. We have purchased a property to move, relocate across the river to Kentucky.
Michael Clary:So we're in a larger facility, larger church, and there is more health and unity in my church than ever before. And I've and I've got seventeen years worth of data to compare to. And I'm like, the last four years has been the healthiest and most unified, joyful, vibrant, evangelistically fruitful years of my ministry. And not only that, in terms of just the types of people, the diversity of people, before before the split, we was always just like, hey, we're in a diverse neighborhood. We wanna reach the people that are here.
Michael Clary:So we always strive to do that. Since we've just... We we don't talk about that at all. We just, let's just talk Bible, talk Jesus, sin, and repentance, and good old fashioned gospel, you know, kind of ministry and we have so many people of different ethnicities and nationalities that live around here. It's like it's just like a very much much more reflective of the the kingdom of God and the local area where we live than ever before.
Michael Clary:And so I'm just like, the contrast is pretty vivid. I've always loved what I do. I've always loved my church, but it is much better now than it was before. Wow.
Mark Odland:Well, that's quite a story. I... I'm sure there's a whole another podcast in there about what it was like emotionally to go through that ringer.
Michael Clary:You know?
Mark Odland:Even even if you feel like you're doing the faithful thing, there are real real relationships involved, and, that... That's not easy. You know, the the only kind of question I would have... I'd love to get your idea... You know, your thoughts on this is when you're doing ministry where you're like, I'm just gonna speak the truth, I'm not gonna like strategically withhold any hot button issues from scripture, it makes sense to me that you would get unity because the people who are in are really in.
Mark Odland:I mean they're they're really like, okay, I'm I'm getting this... I've taken this whole package. But in this politically charged environment that we're in, where about half the country leans left, if they just kind of stumbled, hey that... Hey there's a there's a church over here, let's check that out. And then despite temperament or the upbringing for whatever reason they kind of lean to the left, is the amount of landmines that would potentially be in the service because of moral issues gonna immediately like trigger them and they run out the door and never come back?
Mark Odland:And if so, is it just like I'm accepting that? Or is it like... Because that would seem to contrast like again the Keller model of like let's get them to know Jesus, let's kind of start there and strategically remove those land mines ahead of time so that at least they get their foot in the door, and then we can kind of work on them.
Michael Clary:Yeah. Wait.
Mark Odland:Yeah. What what are you thinking?
Michael Clary:Oh, man. That's such a good question, and I'll try to
Mark Odland:keep my response. I know we're almost out of time. We'll keep it to five minutes here, but
Michael Clary:I'll I'll I'll try to keep my response brief. I have a presupposition now that I've learned that if the left and right of let's say our parents or grandparents generation, they might have been, okay, we disagree on tax policy. We disagree on, you know, foreign policy, something like that. But we agree on what do we what do we want out of life? What are the fundamental building blocks of society?
Michael Clary:We left and right fifty years ago, everybody wants to get married. Everybody wants to have children. Everybody wants to educate them and have a brighter future. Everybody wanted that. The left today doesn't want that.
Michael Clary:The left today is adamantly opposed to it and attacking it at every turn. And so if one way to look at it is like, well, we wanna welcome these people in so that they can hear the gospel and grow. Another way to look at it is like that's leaven that you're allowing into the loaf. And if... So I want somebody that comes in to know what they're getting and to not be sold a false bill of goods.
Michael Clary:And so you say there are lots of landmines. I would say, yes, there are landmines and the the landmines are everywhere if you're if you're if you believe two plus two equals four, that's a landmine. And so reality itself is offensive to the left. And the the whole idea of just a normie leftist is a shrinking population. Almost all leftists nowadays, they are radically unhinged and they believe things that are just they they believe in fictions.
Michael Clary:So, I I mean, I I do believe it's like a it's a mental disorder. Leftism. I do know good, godly, normal Democrats, but they're very, very few. Most of them, like, if they're a Democrat, then they, by default, by definition, what is required of them to be a Democrat is to be an unhinged leftist for the most part. So if they're...
Michael Clary:If they come to the church, I think they're they're going to be offended, but not by, Republican talking points or not by, you know, political talking. They're gonna be offended by the plain spoken gospel. And so in any given service... So here's one example. There's Sure.
Michael Clary:Somebody that's been visiting our church. Husband and wife know the husband. He's pretty... He's very conservative. But his wife is kind of on the fence, and she's not crazy about the church.
Michael Clary:And she told her husband, and he told it to me. He said, my wife said, like, you know, one of the things she doesn't like about the church, she's like, you know what? They just mentioned sin so much. And that was one of her objections to the church. And, of course, he's he's a very direct guy, and he's like Yeah.
Michael Clary:That's kind of the problem with the whole world, and that's what the gospel is about fixing is our sin. And should we not talk about the very thing that Jesus died to save us from. So in our church, you're going to hear about sin. You're to hear about repentance. You're going to hear about the holiness of god, the law of god, and you're going to hear about the forgiveness that is offered in Jesus Christ, the sacrificial atonement, his love for us, God's compassion, our mission to the world, healthy marriages, healthy families, healthy communities, loving one another, forgiving one another, walking in obedience.
Michael Clary:You're gonna hear the whole range of it, and that to me is just Christianity one zero one. There's nothing particularly uniquely conservative about that other than it's just basic Christianity. But if a leftist comes in, that they will notice that. They will feel that. And in my opinion, it is the same as Paul in Acts 17 whenever he's at the Areopagus and you you alluded to this a moment ago.
Michael Clary:He starts off with just saying, Yeah, see you're very religious, and let me tell you about this unknown God. But he gets to the end of his speech and he says, Therefore God commends all men everywhere to repent, for He has fixed a day in which He will judge the world. To me, that every service, you're going to hear some version of that where there's going to be an approachability, but you will be called to hear what God's word says, and we need to repent of our sin and accept the gracious offer of forgiveness in Christ. And if that offends a leftist, so be it. But that's that's the message, and it has been a unifying message for our church and very healthy, very, very beautiful.
Mark Odland:Well, you know, I'm used to interviewing people, and they give watered down answers. But, I mean, you're living up to your book here. I mean, you're you're not giving passive answers, Michael. Like, you're you're you're being bold with, how you see it, and I think people will have a be... It'll be a thought provoking conversation for people to listen to.
Mark Odland:And even for those who maybe have always thought of themselves as a certain type of Christian or a traditional Christian or a conservative Christian, starting to kind of like, wait a second, like what do I think about this? How do I approach mission? How do I balance evangelism with discipleship? How separate or connected do they have to be? Boldness versus nuance.
Mark Odland:Where's the place? Where's the time? There's a lot there's a lot we chewed on today, and it'd be easy to talk for a lot longer, but I know we're at that time. And tell us where people can find you, where they can pick up the book if they're interested.
Michael Clary:Yeah. Sure. The book is a biblical, biblically grounded, articulated from the scripture argument. And so I think it's it it's it's not just a it's not a let's bash leftist or Democrats or something. It's it's that's the reason from the scriptures.
Michael Clary:But the book is available at Canon Press and Amazon. Amazon link, you can just search Loser Theology or you can go to losertheology.com and that takes you directly to the publisher's website. It can be ordered there. It's also available audio, Kindle, So there's that. For...
Michael Clary:To find me, my website is dasindaniel,dmichaelclary.com. And that's also my Twitter handle at d Michael Clary. You can find me there too.
Mark Odland:Alright. Well, Michael Clary, thank you for, being a guest on the Lion Counseling Podcast. I, it was a thought thought provoking conversation. I appreciate you making the time.
Michael Clary:Thank you very much. I appreciate you having me on today.
Mark Odland:Yeah. And for all you listeners out there, I know we cover a lot of topics, a lot of different kinds of guests. If you're ever interested in having counseling from a Christian perspective with me or someone on the team at Lion Counseling, check it out at escapethecagenow.com. And, until next time. Take care everybody.