IOE Insights

What happens when children help shape what they learn, rather than simply following the curriculum?

Mark Quinn speaks with Professor Dominic Wyse and Dr Yana Manyukhina about children’s agency and why it involves more than listening to their views. Drawing on two years of fieldwork, they share examples of pupils helping design curricula, develop classroom rules and organise their own activities.

They explore how teachers can create meaningful choices within the constraints of assessment, inspection and national policy. They also ask what education might look like if children’s experiences and enjoyment mattered just as much as their results.

Links to research: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/news/2026/nov/what-if-children-had-more-say-school-research-real-world

:

More IOE Insights podcasts: https://uclioe.info/podcast
UCL Institute of Education: https://ucl.ac.uk/ioe

Image: Mat Wright for UCL

Creators and Guests

MQ
Host
Mark Quinn
AL
Producer
Amie Liebowitz
Series Producer, Research for the Real World / Academia et al.
JI
Producer
Jason Ilagan
Executive Producer, IOE insights

What is IOE Insights?

Thoughts and ideas on education, culture, psychology, social science and more from our academics, students, alumni and wider community to create lasting and evolving change. Podcasts brought to you by UCL Institute of Education (IOE), the world's leading centre for education and social science research, courses and teaching, and a faculty of University College London (UCL).

More from us: https://ucl.ac.uk/ioe

[Voiceover 1 Male]
You're listening to IOE Insights, the UCL Institute of Education podcast at University College London.

[Dominic Wyse]
I think there is a bit of a deficit around children's agency, and I think that's a problem. We found one very powerful example of a school navigating in that context and succeeding, we think, in helping children exercise their agency.

[Yana Manyukhina]
One of the children told us that school feels like prison. It feels like being stuck in prison. What we learn from them is that when they have choice, when they have more freedom, when they have a sense that they can make a meaningful difference to how they learn, they're much more engaged.

[Voiceover 1 Female]
This is Research for the Real World. Conversations about education and social science research and its impact on policy, practice, and our everyday lives.

[Mark Quinn]
This is Research for the Real World. Hello, I'm Mark Quinn, and I'm the Deputy Program Director for Early Career Teacher Entitlement Programs in the Center for Educational Leadership at the IOE. In this season, we're highlighting the work of the Helen Hamlyn Centre for Pedagogy, which was founded at the IOE in 2017. The HHCP focuses on children from birth to 11 years, and its aim is to influence change in educational policies in order to nurture a more equitable society for all. So I'm delighted to have Dr. Yana Manuykhina and Professor Dominic Wyse. Yana is a senior researcher who focuses on issues of equity, justice, and fairness for children in education, particularly by leading one of the center's core themes, Children's Agency, which is something we'll be exploring today. She has recently co-authored the book, Children's Agency in the National Curriculum, The Promise of Structured Freedom. Dominic is professor of early childhood and primary education and at the center's founding director. Internationally recognized for his influential work on the teaching of reading and writing, Dominic co-developed the award-winning theory, The Double Helix of Reading and Writing, with Charlotte Hacking. Welcome to the podcast, Yana and welcome, Dom.

[Dominic Wyse]
Thank you.

[Mark Quinn]
We're going to kick off straight away with just asking you to talk a little bit about yourselves. I'll go to you first, Dom. Just remind our guests about your academic journey, how you found your way here.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah, well, if you go back long enough, you'll find me in a classroom in various primary schools, including in London and Bradford and Huddersfield. I then did my first master's degree. I got a job in my first university at Liverpool John Moores University. Later moved on to the University of Cambridge and Churchill College, Cambridge. And now I've been at the IOE for more than 13 years. My main role is leading the Helen Hamlyn Centre for Pedagogy and doing a range of research that, as you've said in your introduction, includes a lot on curriculum and literacy, but also, particularly with Yana, I worked on agency, children's agency, and to some degree teachers' agency as well.

[Mark Quinn]
Cool. Can I just ask you just to cast your memory back, if you can, that far, Tom, to those days teaching in your primary classroom? What was that like? Did you enjoy it? Were you a good teacher?

[Dominic Wyse]
I'll answer the first question first because it's easier. Yes, I did enjoy a lot of it. I think we all know enough about professional jobs to know that it's it's not, you know, laugh a minute stuff. It's challenging, it's exciting, it's sometimes emotionally draining. But yes, I did. And I also had various leadership roles, you know, within different school settings. Was I a good teacher? I hope so. I know that a lot of the time I was good according to the feedback I got from parents and colleagues and head teachers. I'm not going to claim I was perfect.

[Yana Manyukhina]
What about children themselves? Did you ever ask for children?

[Dominic Wyse]
Excellent. And this is what I love about Yana. She's always going to keep me on task. I was a teacher who did appreciate the idea of child-centered education, which we may come back to later. And so, yes, of course, I did things like ask the children what their views were, etc. But this will come out more as we go on.

[Mark Quinn]
I only ask because I'm certain that that experience, that early experience of you being a teacher, will have informed everything that came afterwards, right? Your academic journey since then will have been at least to some extent grounded in that experience. And yeah, I'm sure you look you know things now which you wish you'd known then, I guess.

[Dominic Wyse]
Absolutely. Yeah, yeah. That is one of the kind of ironies, if you like, that knowing what I do now from a research perspective and having studied deeply and thought deeply about things, I would definitely do things differently were I a teacher again. And but that's also just life learning as well as the job learning, isn't it? But I you're right, it has that root, if you like, into research and academia. Inevitably, you know, makes us think somewhat differently. And I'm sure when you hear from Yana you know, she has a different path in. Yeah, you know.

[Mark Quinn]
Yeah, well, let's hear that. Yana how did you get to be where you are now?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Well, I joined my current job, which has only ever been my only job, straight after I finished my PhD. So I joined the HHCP in 2018, shortly after it was founded. One of my, I think the very first project that I worked on together with Dom was to help inform the change in the Ireland's national curriculum, for which we reviewed several national curricula. What came out of that work was that surprisingly to me, I didn't quite find enough of a of an emphasis in most of the curricula that we looked at children's own perspectives and interests, something that we came to call children's agency. So I think that was a very significant project because from there I developed a very strong interest in exploring what it means to actually respect children's agency in formal education. How does that policy translate into practice in the classroom and how children experience those opportunities or lack of them? And that has informed my work since then. So there's been a consistent theme of focusing on children's agency.

[Mark Quinn]
So we should get a straight answer then. Let's talk about children's agency. And there is obviously quite a lot of talk about this. We use this word quite a lot, I think, with teacher agency, children's agency in education, but perhaps we don't always use the word that carefully, or maybe we don't even know what the word means. So, what meaning are we giving to this idea of children's agency? Dom, doing it take this?

[Dominic Wyse]
I'm gonna start off, but I think this would be a perfect way that we can we can both uh address this. I mean, I'm gonna start very simply by saying it's the capacity to act, and that, if you like, is is almost a de dictionary definition. I think if I recall, that is roughly speaking one of the things that the Oxford English Dictionary have the way it defines agency or one way. But Yana and I arrived at, and I remember as doing a lot of back and forth, and both in writing and and just discussing this, the so we came to the socially situated capacity to act, uh, and we have published that now in various ways. The socially situated bit is rather important, and and I think I'm in a moment gonna suggest you pick up the button, Yana, because of course one can have a capacity, and we could be talking about other capacities actually, and the opportunity to exercise that capacity is directly affected by things that are happening around people.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Yeah, well, so I think there are two ways of looking at agency, is one is which would be more of a psychology-informed perspective, which would be that agency can be understood as an inherent trait that resides within children and they either get to exercise or they don't. What we came to appreciate through the research that we've done in the schools is that agency is more of an emergent phenomenon which is relational and contextual, and that brings me back to the socially situated element of the definition, which highlights that agency doesn't exist in a vacuum and children don't learn in a vacuum. The classroom is a context full of different factors that affect how much opportunity children get or don't get to exercise agency, to exercise choice. Those involve larger structures, larger educational structures such as curriculum frameworks, accountability systems, assessment frameworks, but also down to the material aspects of the class, just the layout of the classroom might be conducive or not conducive to children being able to exercise choice. So there is a lot of context that goes into defining what opportunities there are for children.

[Mark Quinn]
So it's a capacity to act, but also requiring conditions, the conducive conditions in which to exercise that agency, I suppose. Yeah?

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah.

[Mark Quinn]
And different from the idea or additional to the idea of children's voice?

[Dominic Wyse]
Yes, we that I'm glad you've raised that because there are a number of terms that are close that we wouldn't, you know, we don't need to get too picky about, sometimes we don't need to get too picky about precise definitions. I mean, it clearly to me, anyway, is important that children do have a voice in their education, for example. But that voice can be quite, in some respects, quite minor. So, you know, let's take something very minor, like does a child get a chance to choose whether they use a pen or a pencil? Let's say. Turns out, of course, these things are not minor in primary education at all. And yeah, and actually there are yeah, well, that's a good example. A license, can imagine that a license to use a pen. It is done with with some good intents as well, isn't it? So, and so there's voice. There's also another related term we've really discussed at length, including with Kay Tisdall at Edinburgh, around children's rights. So we we do not see children's agency as synonymous with rights, but clearly it they're important and they're related.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Yeah, I think the most important element that distinguishes agency from all those concepts is that there is an emphasis on actual change. Whereas with voice, you can create an opportunity for children to voice what they want, but you don't necessarily act on those expressed preferences. Whereas with agency, we don't call just an expression of a preference agency unless it's been taken into account and unless children are able to see what change it leads to.

[Mark Quinn]
Okay, okay, that helps, that is helpful. So voice is, I guess, one of the rights which they might have. They have the right to express a view on something that might be, and it is very commonly, isn't it, in school? There's a kind of structure around children's voice or or pupil voice. You're talking about something else, you're talking about some activity, some action, some change that takes place as a result of this voice, which we're now going to call their agency.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah.

[Mark Quinn]
And it's distinct also from being child-centered, is it? Or is it is that is that also an inadequate term for what we're talking about?

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, I think there's a whole there's a whole history of thinking, a long history of thinking about what some people now call child-centered education, closely linked to progressive education. And in my view, agency, and now I'm I'm now talking about you know intellectual work on agency, research on agency, is coming out of a very different tradition. And so definitely I do not, in fact, we make the point, aren't we, in our book, that we think that what we've contributed takes us, accounts for things like child-centered education, but is different and goes beyond and is new.

[Mark Quinn]
And in particular ways, it's new?

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, I think child centered education, I'm going to give another example. So one of the classic kind of tropes of child centered education is you have a primary classroom that's organized around topics, for example. That is a classic trope. It doesn't sum up the whole thing. Now, in an agentic classroom, very different things happen. I mean, we've we've got a precise example from our research that we did, and we will get into this more as we go go along. But this was a kind of complicated, complicated in some respects, not necessarily from the point of view of the children, by the way. I think it was a kind of professionally complicated context, a very powerful one, where in almost every structure that we could detect, and almost every process that we could detect, and we can't, we couldn't detect everything, we genuinely thought children's agency's been respected, supported, sustained, developed, and the outcomes in general seem to us to be remarkable.

[Mark Quinn]
So we can talk about some of those examples if you want now. So if we're talking about how children shape their learning or have an active participation in the way learning takes place, can you share some of those examples you've written about in the book, perhaps?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Uh yeah, we do mention a few examples. I think one of the most prominent ones that we tend to give when people ask us is about the curriculum design in one of the schools that we worked with, where children were involved in the process of designing the curriculum from the start by being asked to bring objects of their choice to a discussion with teachers. So a child would bring a plastic bottle, a toy, or maybe a drawing of something that they like, and they would be asked to explain what specifically about this object they found interesting and fascinating, and how would they like to see that reflected in the curriculum? So, what would they like to learn about that specific object in the context of the curriculum? Then the conversation will take. This is, of course, very raw and might seem like how does that amount to a well-designed curriculum framework? But this was the starting points for conversations between children and teachers, which would go on for several days, uh, where the role of the teacher would be to guide the children to express what exactly they are interested in, because that's also might be a tricky bit to find out. And then in the process of negotiation, in the process of conversations between teachers and children, the teacher's job would be to try and assemble all those expressed preferences into a coherent framework that would represent the curriculum for the next year. So the curriculum was very flexible, was very fluid, very much arising out of those conversations between teachers and children. And when we spoke to children about what this meant to them, they consistently highlighted that, oh, I know that I'm gonna learn something I'm genuinely interested in. Maybe not this term, the curriculum was divided into four uh sections. So some of children's objects would feed into one section, not the other. But children were very much aware, and this is where the importance of children recognizing the their potential and their influence on their learning becomes very uh significant. They knew that at some point in the year they will learn something that they're really keen to learn. And when we would ask, Well, about the rest of the year, they would tell us, Oh, but then we're learning something that my friend wants to learn about, and that also meant something to them.

[Mark Quinn]
Okay, so they understood that their time, their time would come where they understood the they understood the the curriculum overall and who had inputted at various points to the curriculum across the year.

[Yana Manyukhina]
The reason this was important is because we also, when we talk about agency, we also talk about sense of agency, which is something that is internal to children, how they understand their capacity to influence their learning journey. And unless you nurture that sense of agency in children, it's very hard to raise them as agentic people in the future.

[Mark Quinn]
And is this individual agency? Is this a collective agency?

[Yana Manyukhina]
It's an excellent question. Uh, we only uh talked about individual agency, but we also recognize that it's impossible to not to mention the uh collective agency aspect of it because children they learn together. Uh, friendships and peer groups are very important. One thing that we learned as well are very important to children in terms of how they learn and what the learning process, how they experience the learning process. Uh, this is something that perhaps we might want to explore further in in our future research.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah, I mean it's it's something we've reflected on. It's not the first time someone has raised the issue of collective agency. One of the things I would say is the the way that we looked at agency generally, so taking full account, as full account as we could of structures and individual capacities. Now, structures are things created by people, multiple people, groups of people. And indeed, your reflections, Yana, of various points on peers, for example, the children's peers and their influences. Well, there is a form of collective agency going on there. We might have identified it as something different, but it's not, yeah, it's not that we don't accept. But I think for me, thinking off the top of my head, it's more, it seems to me it's bundled in with concepts of the various influences on whether a child or a teacher actually acts and actually is able to act.

[Mark Quinn]
Right. So this isn't an episode about teacher agency, but it does certainly the example you gave about the teacher who was able to open up the curriculum design to their class sounds to me like the kind of teacher who feels that they've got agency over the curriculum that they're able to teach, right? Is it was this an unusual setting that you were found to find yourself in?

[Dominic Wyse]
What was I think from everything I know about primary schools, it was to some degree to some in some ways unusual. We would, for example, have to mention, and we do, that it was part of a trust, for example, where the legal rules on curriculum are different.

[Mark Quinn]
Right.

[Dominic Wyse]
You know, we've had we do acknowledge all of this in in the case studies we present and you know about each school. And you'll be familiar with this, you know, it had an executive head, I'm not sure if that was a specific term, and a head of the school, even while we were doing the research, interestingly, there became two primary schools and then a secondary, as I recall, and the primary school that joined the first primary school in the trust, there was a very different dynamic that had to be navigated, as you can imagine. And the other thing that struck me, and it's this is a much broader thing, was there was an incredible appetite for learning from the teachers that and including doing master's degrees. I can't remember if anyone was doing a doctorate, but but you know, so at least one one of the senior staff, for example, was doing her dissertation for her masters in something akin, I think, to agency, you know. So, and all of these, these are just a few factors that are important. And I, if I make, while you were talking earlier, Yana, it reminded me also of, I just wanted to say a quick thing about the actual research methods we used.

[Mark Quinn]
And yeah.

[Dominic Wyse]
We deliberately chose a design that was, you know, had, you know, in-depth, two years of in-depth field work that Yana spent a lot of time mainly. I mean, I went as well sometimes, but you know, talking directly to the children and recording in various ways what they said over a two-year period. So she she worked with those children, for example, across the transition from one year group to the next. This is unusual. This doesn't happen in research more generally all that often. And so we're gonna we have to say, you know, on another day, you'd get me talking about randomized control trials and systematic reviews and meta-analyses. But this was the design we chose. And I think we can have some of these conversations because of the design we chose. There's some conversations we can't have, we can't overgeneralize.

[Mark Quinn]
Yeah, but you were able to observe and you were able to, I guess, see some of the actions which arose from the agency or the voice, I suppose, that the children did have and that their teacher had.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yes.

[Mark Quinn]
Um would you theorize then that pupil agency it depends upon their teacher having some agency as well?

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah. I I'll let you come in. It's just because I I wanted to say just, yeah, that thing about teacher agency. They're they're obviously related, it's true. I mean, the children are going to find it because of the power dynamic alone, very difficult to exercise agency. And Yana, you'll have things to say about this, I'm sure. If the teachers don't at least they need to be disposed to at least encourage agency however much they feel able. So they're definitely connected. But I think also if you took, if we're talking about the field of research and professional practice, teacher agency is the dominant voice in our discipline, in the discipline of education. And we would slightly push back on that because we're pro children, if we can put it like that. That's not to say that teacher agency isn't important, it's massively important. You know, the other work that our center does, for example, is around teacher agency in terms of should they be enabled to choose which pedagogies to use? Should they be able to choose what assessments to do? And we know this is an international issue, isn't it? And that different jurisdictions allow different amounts of teacher agency. So very important. But I think we need to genuinely, and particularly in England, which our study focused on mainly, I mean it's international and it's outlook, but I think there is a bit of a deficit around children's agency, and I think that's a problem.

[Yana Manyukhina]
I think it's a very important point to make that how much freedom children get in the classroom very much depends on how much freedom teachers have and perceive to have in the classroom in terms of what they do with children. And on many occasions, when we spoke to teachers in the research, we've heard that specific objection that we are constrained by the structure, we are constrained by the national curriculum prescriptions, by Ofsted inspections. So, regardless of how much I'm willing to give this freedom of choice to children, I'm not able to because they're all these boxes to tick that I have to, as a teacher, for my school to also perform well on an inspection. That is all that all of that is true and needs to be acknowledged. At the same time, we did find a lot of examples in every school that we went to, from minor examples to more significant examples, like with this, the curriculum example was quite an unusual thing that we found. But our sample was small, we have to acknowledge that. Still, this was something that going back to your earlier question, this was something that we were quite surprised by. We did find in every school that there are ways to give children agency in various forms to various extent, but it's not impossible. Even within existing structures, there are opportunities to present children with a meaningful choice. That's not to say, though, that's not to detract from the point that structural and systemic change is needed, specifically within international curriculum where children's agency doesn't feature explicitly at all, even in the new version. Um, and I think we think that that needs to change.

[Mark Quinn]
So amongst the different schools you went to, and some were maybe more extraordinary than others, or some maybe had more some, you know, the schools or the teachers in those schools had greater or lesser license to adapt the curriculum. Even some smaller examples, Yana, of this sort of structured freedom that you saw in action. Can you uh let us know some of those?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Sure. Well, in one of the schools, for example, where change was a little bit less perceived as less possible within the uh so-called main subjects like English or math, where the emphasis would be on preparing the children for the test, like we observe in a lot of schools. There was a lot of freedom given to children outside the formal learning with uh after school clubs. Is that what they're called? After school clubs where children were uh would come to the teacher with ideas about what kind of an after school club they would like. One of the examples I think we give is about dumbling Rubik's Cube. So children initiated this after school club, they ran it themselves. They were given full support by the school to organize this activity. So there are ways, even where prescription formal prescriptions get in the way, there are ways to instill in children that sense of agency that we mentioned previously, which is also important for children to develop into agency learners.

[Mark Quinn]
Should we talk a bit about the national curriculum then? As one of the big structures that teachers have to deal with. And you mentioned earlier, uh, Dom, you mentioned chant, which I think is children's

[Dominic Wyse]
children's agency in the national curriculum. It's an unusual acronym.

[Yana Manyukhina]
We've got to love it a lot.

[Dominic Wyse]
We quite like the idea of children singing, of course. You know.

[Mark Quinn]
So do you see the national curriculum as a limiting factor on children's agency, as an enabling factor, or is it somewhere in between?

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, if we're talking, we're talking about England's national curriculum, and I think it's really rather important that we make this clear because for all sorts of reasons, sometimes the countries of the UK get lumped together, for example, in terms of perceptions of education policies. So, I mean, Jana's, if we've got time, we can say a bit more about the Republic of Ireland later. Yeah, okay. Um, Yana just mentioned our early project there. England is this rather curious mix, it seems to me, of without question, very tight central control of curriculum and assessment and increasingly of pedagogy, actually. You know, so for example, in the in the teaching of reading, we and writing actually, so we have a reading framework and we have a writing framework, both of which are prescriptive, very strong statements about how reading and writing should be taught from the central government, basically from the DFE. Now, that does not happen quite to that degree in every country. When you then link in what Yana mentioned earlier about, and we have data about about offstead inspections, kind of also adding to the pressure to conform in particular ways, then you definitely have a prescriptive system. Now, the the interesting bit is, of course, we found one very powerful example of a school navigating in that context and succeeding in, we think, in helping children exercise their agency. So I don't want to kind of overplay this. I think professional autonomy exists to some degree, professional agency, but I come back to what we've both said, it could be so much better. So I think there, you know, there really are problems in England in terms of power and control. I mean, straightforwardly as that.

[Mark Quinn]
And it's it's the national curriculum, but not just the national curriculum.

[Dominic Wyse]
Exactly.

[Mark Quinn]
It's the accountability structures, it's the leadership structures, perhaps.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah, yeah. Well, we haven't really mentioned statutory assessment. And I should mention that in the context of how much autonomy teachers have. We know this from other work we've done in the center. We did the independent commission on primary assessment, you know, where a group of 10 or so commissioners, all very experienced in education in different ways, felt that there was a really pretty desperate need for change. Now, unfortunately, we've just reviewed England has just reviewed its national curriculum. And although there are some very welcome new aspects, that it's not fundamental enough. It really hasn't addressed some of these kind of issues we're talking about, which you it really should do. The evidence is there.

[Mark Quinn]
Because the evidence exists in other countries or it doesn't have to be this way. Yeah. So yeah. So, Janny, you want to talk about Ireland as a comparison? Yeah, I don't talk about it.

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, you were talking about Ireland where we began our theme of agency, and then of course it continued in the Champ project. But also going along at the same time, is I've been working as one of four academic advisors to Ireland's Curriculum Council. And they have developed their programming national curriculum. They do it first, the first big difference is they only do it about every 25 years. I mean, they really, and then they really take their time over it. I'd have to concede, of course, the population of the Republic of Ireland is very small compared to England, but that's a different kind of question. They have decided their uh ministers and their well, they have a curriculum authority, and that's an important difference. England used to have a curriculum authority, it doesn't have one there. What they've arrived at is, in my view, one of the most progressive in a non-sort of historic way, perhaps a more simple way, a progressive national curriculum for primary schools, where children's agency and teachers' agency is explicit and lived, or it will, the intention is it will be lived throughout every subject area in that curriculum. And it's not, this is not lip service, it's an absolute commitment. And as far as I know, it's probably the first worldwide that has really looked anything like that.

[Mark Quinn]
And what does it look like? I mean, can you give us an example, even and a subject example, of of how agency is absolutely built in or baked into the curriculum?

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, it begins. There's and forgive me, I'm my head hasn't been directly into the to that the recently published document. In fact, what they've even more recently published is the kind of programs of study for subject areas, and they're getting rolled out. But the framework document has principles that include the fact that children and teachers should have agency. And then within the subject areas, what that requires is that teachers find ways through the delivery of subject knowledge to ensure that pupils have a thing, they have a voice, are able to exercise agency, are able to make choices. Now, of course, like any uh policy text, it needs to become reality. And there will be, inevitably, there'll be teachers who are concerned about this because it's new. There'll be some teachers in schools who are thinking, excellent, this is what we've been wanting to have the backing to do and have done. You know what I mean? So that's the kind of and it's new. It's it's begin, it's just rolling out. So, in a way, quite rightly, I can't answer directly some of your question because we want to see what they do with it.

[Mark Quinn]
It strikes me that we've been talking for about 30 minutes, and I haven't asked you why any of this matters. And and Jan, I know that you're particularly interested in children's agency because of how it connects to their sense of engagement with their learning, with their well-being in more general terms. Simple question: why does all of this matter?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Very often when people ask why agency is important, they tend to think about the learning outcomes. And there is a point to be made there, even though that's not what our research was about. So we didn't track children's learning outcomes, we focused more on the experience that children have when they have agency compared to when they don't. And I'm much less tethered to the outcomes uh point because I through I uh unlike Dom, I don't have a direct teaching experience. I've never been a teacher. So I got to see the classroom reality through this two-year project mostly. But what I got to see made me very, very acutely aware of how much the experience of children matters while they are in school. From talking to children over two years, listening to what they shared about how school feels to them. And some of the statements were quite drastic. One of the child, can I say that? One of the children told us. I'm frequently censored on this. This is why I'm asking. Wat bij je One of the children told us that school feels like prison. It feels like being stuck in prison. And that I find that heartbreaking. I think that when we send children to school uh for so many years to spend so many hours of their daily life, when they're uh at the most of their neuro neuroplasticity, when they're most curious and they're most willing to learn, and make them feel like they suffer and it's a a drudgery and it feels like prison. I think that's actually that's that's almost Can

[Dominic Wyse]
I come in on the censorship point?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Yeah, please.

[Dominic Wyse]
Because uh I know I remember when that came up and it was actually to do with how should we communicate the the results of the research. And somebody quite reasonably said, well, it was only one child who said it was like prison of the children that we worked with. But I mean, the point was that the other children to us to varying degrees in less dramatic ways pretty much are all.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Sensometry.

[Dominic Wyse]
Yeah. And in fact, it is important if even only one child says, I feel like I'm in prison. Society should be at least thinking, okay, it's only one child, but we're a bit worried about that, you know.

[Yana Manyukhina]
About that child at the child.

[Dominic Wyse]
And they could then ask, Oh, is that the experience of more children?

[Mark Quinn]
And do we know? I mean, how do we know that children's agency is a key to unlock that prison?

[Yana Manyukhina]
When I when we spoke to children, what we learned from them is that when they have choice, when they have more freedom, when they have a sense that they can make a meaningful difference to how they learn, they're much more engaged. So in the school that stood out in the sample, uh, where more agency or in more meaningful ways was given to children, children loved learning. On so many occasions, from different children, we heard that I love school, I love going to school. And when I asked, what exactly does it make your experience so enjoyable? They they would tell us, oh, because we choose what to learn. Every day they would get an opportunity to choose what to do. Maybe not all of it. Again, like we say, we're not arguing against the importance of a structure with the importance of some discipline and behavioral. But even when it comes to behavioral rules, children were involved in designing uh behavioral rules, which would be conducive to a pleasant learning process. And getting that ownership also allowed them to think about I want to be an effective learner. So what rules do we need to take to be in place? It's not like children want chaos when they're genuinely interested in learning. So motivation, engagement, the more sustained engagement we observed in the learning process when children get to choose more of the aspects of learning and also love of learning. And recently there was an inquiry, a parliamentary inquiry, into the declining rates of learning among children in the UK. Well, there you go. So, how do you make children more love learning more? You let them choose more of it. That's that's the answer that we are on.

[Mark Quinn]
Just an absence from school.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Exactly, yeah. So those all of those are concerns on the agenda of policy education policymakers. And this is what it speaks to.

[Mark Quinn]
And were teachers in those schools that you were observing, do they have the same observations? They also say that their children are behaving better, learning better.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Absolutely, yes, but also they are happier teachers as well.

[Mark Quinn]
So, did you collect data?

[Yana Manyukhina]
Always thank you for mentioning the research design and the in the tools that we used. Because one of the things that we did, we spoke extensively to teachers as well, even though teacher agency was not the primary focus of the research, but we spend lots of time talking to teachers about what they observe, children's experiences are with versus with no agency.

[Dominic Wyse]
I think also one of the other schools in the sample was what you might call, I don't know, maybe if there is such a thing as a traditional inner city school set in a deprived area. There's a kind of set of assumptions, I think, in amongst educators around, for example, that you need more structure. Now, I think there's really interesting debates around all of that. And I don't think there isn't one way, but I I think sometimes in areas like that, people, not just schools, can sort of make the assumption that children are not able. We can't be giving them their agency because because their language is way behind, allegedly, or you know, or even their thinking, you know, view. And yet I think we would argue, as Yanni was saying, structured freedom is exactly that. So the structures that the school creates obviously have to be keep order, and we know that in order to learn well, it needs to be a calm and ordered environment and so on. But you still got to give freedom, we think. We think you get better outcomes if you know you determine the nature of the freedom as well as you can, and you genuinely offer it, and you then, of course, evaluate what the impacts are on the pupils from their perspectives, of course, is the other thing. Now, I I would concede, and this is me really talking more about my experience in a career, not directly about some of the data, that I would concede to achieve these things in an area that is rife with poverty is really hard. Because human beings are complicated always, but life is much more complicated if you're living in, for example, pretty extreme poverty, which we know, by the way. In fact, of course, the change to the two-child limit, only just come in will have a massive impact on poverty overnight. Massive. I mean, it's an enormous, and it's it's something the amount of money, I think it's about £350 per child extra. Now, those factors we haven't really, you know, talked about. We could we acknowledge that they are the backdrop. And in in the Helen Langen Sensory pedagogy, that is, of course, another one of our themes, our social justice theme, where we do dig around in the weeds of these things.

[Mark Quinn]
So I I've no more questions, but I was just wondering, were there other questions you would like me to have asked or comments you would like to have made in this area? You just started talking about social justice, Tom. Um, so if I were giving you a free three minutes of airspace, what what would you fill it with?

[Dominic Wyse]
Silence. You go first, Diana.

[Yana Manyukhina]
You did ask this question. Um, I think partially I responded, but I I would definitely spend three minutes talking about how much difference it makes to children's experience in school to have more agency, and also how much happier as children they get to be. And I think that is uh something that is overlooked because when we talk about education, we tend to focus primarily on the learning outcomes and what grades kids get and what kind of um doors the certificate can open. But uh but just being a child and being a happy child in school, I think is so important. And I think that's what we'll that's all what we also need to be concerned about as a society, as education policymakers and researchers. How do we make our children enjoy school more? Make them happy learners. I think that's really important.

[Dominic Wyse]
I I agree, and I think what that rather nicely highlights as well is many parents will say it's a kind of classic thing, isn't it? As long as my child's happy, as long as in school, as long as my child's happy. So that's both a commonplace and important expression in its own right, but it's also quite profound, isn't it? And by the way, it's no easy task, is it, under the circumstances we've been talking about for teachers, for all the staff in a school, including the heads, every member of staff, not just the, you know, the including the people who make food and the people, the caretakers and everyone and the governors have got to be united in, yeah, that that aim is that the minute should be a minimum entitlement. Are the children in our school happy? And do we ask them uh in not necessarily directly, but do we genuinely are we interested in this uh in our schools?

[Yana Manyukhina]
No, we ask them directly.

[Dominic Wyse]
Well, yes, we would. We would.

[Mark Quinn]
Yeah, and and I guess that might be a good place to to end this particular conversation. But I I'd thank you both, Tom and Yana, for coming in and talking to me. It's been really, really fascinating. It seems to me that this is perhaps an under-researched area of your for your final comments, really, about how we need to know more about what actually every parent does one, which is a happy child in a school where the where the teacher enjoys teaching them, where the teacher can see the difference that they're that's being made for each child, where the child maybe does have some agency in some capacity to choose what they're doing and how they do it. And uh it does seem to me that that's uh something we need to be studying a bit more and not just focusing on the exam results at the end of it all. I think that would be a great place to move on to. Thank you again.

[Yana Manyukhina]
Excellent.

[Mark Quinn]
Thank you.

[Dominic Wyse]
Thank you for your questions and your uh observations. Yeah.

[Mark Quinn]
You've just heard from Dr. Yana Manuykina and Professor Dominic Wyse. Some of what we've covered today is also available in the episode notes. If you've enjoyed this episode, why not listen to another? Search IOE Insights to find episodes of Research for the Real World, as well as more podcasts from the IOE. And a quick favor before you go. If you're listening on Apple or Spotify, we'd really appreciate it. If you could give the IOE Insights podcast a rating, five stars would be nice if you're enjoying the show. And that will help us to reach more people who are interested in hearing about such important work. And that includes the other podcast that I present with my wonderful colleague, Elaine Long. It's called The Staff Room, and we speak to educational professionals at all levels, from ECTs through to academics and executive leaders across the system. I'd be Mark Quinn. Thank you for listening.

[Voiceover 1 Female]
Research for the Real World is brought to you by IOE, research development and IOE marketing and communications at University College London. The series producer is Amie Liebowitz. The executive producer of the IOE Insights podcast is Jason Ilagan

[Voiceover 1 Male]
Thanks for listening. Search IOE Insights for more podcasts from the IOE.