Law Matters 1030

Immigration attorney Mo Goldman explains a proposed Department of Labor overhaul of employer-sponsored green-card labor certification, including why it could make hiring nurses and physical therapists slower and more expensive. Sherry and Mo also discuss voting eligibility for green-card holders, naturalization risks, election politics, and the immigration consequences of high-profile criminal cases.
  • The PERM labor-certification process, last significantly overhauled in 2005, currently uses wage determinations and specified recruitment steps to test the labor market.
  • The proposed Department of Labor rule would remove required newspaper ads and expand digital recruitment, including mandatory job-search website postings and potentially social media.
  • The proposal would eliminate Schedule A exemptions for occupations including registered nurses and physical therapists, potentially making sponsorship more expensive and lengthy.
  • Mo warns that added barriers may worsen shortages in healthcare, especially in rural areas, and could extend some green-card processes from roughly one to one-and-a-half years to multiple years.
  • A green card grants permanent residence and work authorization, but not citizenship or the right to vote; naturalization eligibility is generally after three years for qualifying spouses of U.S. citizens and five years for others.
  • Mo recounts a past case in which a noncitizen was mistakenly encouraged to register and vote; he says the person withdrew from voter rolls and disclosed the circumstances in a sworn statement.
  • Mo describes serious potential penalties for noncitizens who vote illegally and for false statements on naturalization applications, and urges careful, truthful disclosure.
  • Sherry and Mo discuss the proposed rule’s comment period, political developments after the election, and the difference between individual immigration cases and blanket enforcement.
  • They assess the immigration consequences facing Russian climbers charged after scaling the Empire State Building, including possible deportation and obstacles to naturalization.
  • Mo argues that immigration cases require individual assessment, noting that some people without status were brought to the United States as children and that lawful pathways can be limited.

What is Law Matters 1030?

Law Matters mission is to carry out non-partisan research, education, and informational activities by opening the lines of communication through public media, and classroom settings between law enforcement, lawmakers, law litigators, and military personnel, whose goal of increasing awareness, serves to avoid illicit drug and criminal activities, preventing deterioration of neighborhoods.

Sherry (00:00)
Our guest today is Mo Goldman, immigration attorney, who keeps us up to date on everything that's going on. Mo, thank you for being here.

Mo (00:09)
Thanks for having me on again, Sherry. I just you know have been reading this morning a proposed rule on basically pretty significant overhaul regarding our legal process for individuals who are being or who would be sponsored by

employers, immigrants being sponsored by employers. And it it's been a long time coming that they were going to possibly make some changes and modernize it, them being the Department of Labor. But this is quite a a pretty drastic change.

Sherry (00:51)
What's going on? What are they doing?

Mo (00:53)
Well, I guess the first thing is I should explain a little bit about what the process has been historically, at least in the last, you know, twenty to thirty years. there's so we we have a labor market test process for most occupations that are being offered to a foreign national.

And the idea behind the system is pretty obvious. They wanna improve they want protections for US workers, but they also want to balance that protection with allowing employers the opportunity to sponsor foreign nationals for jobs that are available and also you know make sure that they're not.

First of all, undercutting US worker salaries, paying less for foreign foreign labor, and also to make sure that occupations that are being offered to foreign nationals are fairly offered to US citizens. Makes sense, right? So

One of the tricky balances that comes into it is that a lot of those employers that are sponsoring a foreign national often have that foreign national already working for them in some sort of capacity. and most of the time you're talking about people who are on legal work visas.

the most common one that people are aware of is the H1B visa for people who are going to be working in a either high skill job, specialized knowledge type of position. Many are utilized by the high-tech industry. And and so

What happens is the employer has to undergo a process known as perm P-E-R-M. Perm labor certification process. The last time there was a significant overhaul of that process was twenty-one years ago in 2005. And and what that process has required.

Over the last 20 plus years is that the employer first of all gets a wage determination from the U.S. Department of Labor based off of where the job is located, so geographical, and also the type of position being offered. And there's a database, a comprehensive database.

That has the wage levels. There's different wage levels depending on the complexity of the occupation, and what the requirements are for the position. And so there are four different lay wage levels, level one, which is more of an entry level, all the way up to level four, which is somebody who might be in a

you know, higher upper management, or a position that has a lot more I guess you'd say autonomy for the person. They don't have to depend on being instructed as much on what they're supposed to do, or they're supervising other individuals. And so there's

Those different wage levels. And so to begin the process, the employer has to submit a request for a prevailing wage determination to the US Department of Labor. Wait on that to come back, and that determination will tell them how much they're required to be paying the foreign national. Okay?

Sherry (04:52)
All right.

Mo (04:53)
once you get that wage determination, let's say it's an engineering job in Tucson, Arizona, and the Department of Labor comes back and says they the employer has to pay at or above a hundred and ten thousand dollars. the employer then has to say, Okay, we're gonna commit to this. And if so, they then embark on the

the labor market test, which is where they do very specified recruitment steps. And since 2005, the recruitment required two Sunday newspaper advertisements in the in the newspaper of general circulation. So the largest newspaper circulated in the area.

so for in Southern Arizona and Tucson, Pima County, it would be the Arizona Daily Star. And then three additional forms of recruitment. And then also on top of that, they have to do a there's a basically it's an advertisement that is done within the the

state. So there's a a portal that the state has for occupations through what's called the SWA, the State Workforce Authority, and they will post that for 30 days. So there's a pretty stringent process. Now the newspaper ads are kind of ridiculous because who's looking at, you know, classified ads for jobs?

in 2026 in a paper newspaper. and so that's always been mandatory and I've always looked at it thinking, gosh, that must be, you know, what's keeping these newspapers afloat. Because when you request ads, classified ads, and you get quotes from these papers, you're talking about sometimes thousands of dollars for

Sherry (06:37)
Yeah, the doctor.

Mo (07:00)
Two Sunday advertisements. and so that has always been something that's a little curious to me because we've moved to a more digital situation now with digital recruitment. And so, you know, there are changes that are being proposed, one of them being they're going to eliminate newspaper ads.

which will save costs and then replace them with broader digital recruitment. and there are some other changes that are going to update like job search website posting is going to be mandatory and it will you know provide a broader labor market exposure to the employer.

they'll sometimes require social media recruitment. And a lot of these things were optional or have been optional, but they're gonna make it more stringent on the employer to, you know, do these sorts of things. Probably so one of the most significant policy changes that this that this proposed rule would have

is traditionally registered nurses, physical therapists, occupations that have a huge void where we need them are they they've been known as what's called Schedule A occupations, where they have been exempt from labor market testing and can jump straight to filing their green card petition.

Because it's basically what they call pre-certification, where they wouldn't need to do the labor market test because there's such a high demand for them. They're gonna eliminate that altogether, which will make it more difficult to go through a process that's gonna cost more money and take more time for employers. And and that could be a

pretty significant change for RNs and physical therapists and the organizations that that sponsor them. it it's always been a lot more flexible, especially for healthcare systems, to have nurse sponsorships or physical therapy sponsorships.

to be more streamlined. And now it's gonna potentially be more substantially longer and more expensive, which could become a deterrent for these healthcare systems from wanting to move forward with the process for a lot of these folks. So

Sherry (09:50)
You know, that makes no sense. We're we're in need. It it just we're in need of these. Yes.

Mo (09:54)
Yeah. The demand is so high and now we're gonna make it more difficult. it doesn't make a lot of sense. So yeah, I mean the it the pro well, the Department of Labor put the rule together. So it's through the employment and training administration section of the Department of Labor.

Sherry (10:03)
Who authored that change? Was that Kim?

Mo (10:18)
It it's obviously being proposed by, you know, people within the government that wanna make it more restrictive for employers to hire foreign nationals, but you have to be careful what you wish for here. You don't want to end up in a situation where all of a sudden all these nurses and physical therapists

have to leave or jump ship because they they're not able to get permanent status in the US and again you know maybe they're able to fill nursing jobs at you know hospitals in more urban centric areas, but it's the rural areas that are really suffering.

Sherry (11:06)
Whatever they can do to screw it up, right?

Mo (11:06)
So yeah, so I mean the system is always in flux, but you know, one of the issues, especially with nurses, is that we don't even have a temporary work visa for nurses. There used to be a temporary work visa, but that got eliminated like over 20 years ago. And

We need nurses. Like, you know, the there are certain occupations that we're constantly behind on as far as having enough professionals. That would include home health care, nurses, and pretty much anything in the healthcare industry. all the data shows that were were severely lacking.

Sherry (11:46)
Mm-hmm.

Mo (11:59)
In qualified professionals. And in some of these situations, like nurses, this process to get them green cards is the only way to bring them into the United States from abroad. And if the employers are gonna have to go through this whole, you know, song and dance, you're talking about a process that

right now might take a year to a year and a half to now ballooning to multiples of years. And then, you know, all these health systems, universities, research institutions, they're gonna be impacted by the by these changes pretty significantly.

Sherry (12:43)
It's like they're shooting themselves in the foot.

Mo (12:46)
Constantly. Constantly. Like the all these changes. And mind you, these are not changes being made by the Congress, by the the people, you know, who voted for them. These are being proposed and changed through policy.

Sherry (13:05)
Yeah.

Mo (13:05)
regulatory. And that's, you know, I think people if if this proposed rule makes its way through and becomes a final rule and becomes the regulation, you know, we're I obviously gonna have to see how it plays out, but my prediction is it's going to have a significant negative impact on

all these different industries, and the healthcare industry especially.

Sherry (13:37)
Yeah, the writing's on the wall pretty much. There's so much going on.

Mo (13:40)
So

Yeah. So that's the that's the you know the latest and greatest from this early November, mid-November morning. it just never ceases to change or or not change, never ceases to surprise. I think the worst part about this as an immigration attorney is then I have to

Sherry (13:54)
Yeah.

Mo (14:08)
try to explain to organizations like I represent a pretty large organization that works in physical therapy and they can't find US workers to fill physical therapist jobs. A lot of them are coming from India and are foreign nationals and

It's the only way that they're gonna be able to do physical therapy for a lot of folks. Like if you go into a physical therapy, like pretty some of those larger c companies, you're gonna see a lot of foreign nationals working in there. but then who's gonna fill those jobs if it's gonna, you know, be difficult for them to bring here?

Sherry (14:53)
Yeah. They're making it just very difficult on both sides of the aisle, both sides of the the employee who is deliberately studying a career choice that might bring them to America have this opportunity. And then of course the company was trying to bring talent into the into America and they can't do it because it's so impossible.

Mo (14:57)
Yeah.

Yeah. So we'll see. I mean, the only saving grace is that this is a proposed rule. and there will be significant pushback in the comments, because there's a comment period. and they can then revisit some of these proposed changes. and maybe you know

tweak it or realize that it's not going to be much of a benefit. but you know, that might be wishful thinking.

Sherry (15:46)
So where were you on election night?

Mo (15:49)
I actually went to the election night party that they had for Joanna Mendoza. there's no secret that I'm not and have not been a big fan of Juan Siscomani. I at one point was in the primary running against Joanna Mendoza.

but then became a supporter of hers. and so I went to that event and honestly it was the first time I I I've only gone to about say four different election night parties or events. And this was actually the first time I I felt a little bit of happiness. I I

Sherry (16:34)
Yeah.

Mo (16:36)
You know, I I was just happy to see that the voters came out and and I believe it was a referendum against the corruption that we've been seeing, the protection of this administration, the Epstein class, you know, voting against that everything, immigration,

Sherry (16:54)
The whole Yeah, the whole thing. The the yeah pedophiles in in you know f Congress, pedophiles in the White House, it's just with thieves.

Mo (17:07)
And and I've said repeatedly, I mean, you know, Representative Siscomani, you know,'s probably I've never talked to him directly, but he's probably not a bad person. You know, everything I've heard and read about him says he's a nice person, a good guy, but you gotta step up and stand up against the

Sherry (17:32)
Corruption.

Mo (17:33)
you know, the the the the White House and and who's in there. I'm sorry. It it you know it it's really, you know, at the end of the day, a question of who are you representing? Are you representing your constituency or are you representing the administration? And by his voting record, by his silence

He just has never, you know, met the moment, in my opinion.

Sherry (18:04)
Well, the thing that really bothered me was he came out and told the people in Arizona, I'll never vote for the big beautiful bill. It's not good for Arizona. And by the time they woke up the next morning, he had signed it and walked away with this, you know, gift basket or whatever the hell they gave him to convince him. So I'm like, Okay, your cheap date. Clearly you can be bought. And then watching the voting record throughout, I

Mo (18:12)
Yeah.

Sherry (18:31)
changed my signature line on my emails to say we don't want to make another big mistake. And you know, I I just that was my way of telling people this is not good. You're not voting for it.

Mo (18:41)
Yeah, I mean and and that to me that's that's what was the most disappointing aspect of his legacy the last two terms that are the two terms that Representative Ciscomani was in place. so yeah, I was at the event. It was really nice. I was home and in bed by ten o'clock.

And and you know, we'll see where things go from here. It's gonna be an interesting, you know, two years ahead.

Sherry (19:15)
What do you think Trump's gonna try to get done between now and January?

Mo (19:19)
Well, you know, obviously trying to get as many judges appointed probably. not sure what other things he's going to try to to do. He he seems to be at least he's been IA for the last few days, after the whole debacle with the the FAA and the

the the ground stop across the nation on the airlines. So I don't know. I mean

Sherry (19:49)
Before that it was the spy thing.

Mo (19:53)
Yeah, I I mean the Nvidia situation. I I don't know if there's enough will out there for the people to you know to put up with much more of this and maybe he's realizing I don't know. It it it's so frustrating because he's he's obviously, you know, not all there. I mean immediately after the election his

tone on immigration changed from, you know, deport them all to maybe we should, you know, consider a pathway for legalization or change law. And then two days later he appointed Stephen Miller his chief of staff. So yeah and again I I think the just inconsistent

Sherry (20:36)
That tells the whole story.

Mo (20:46)
statements the the the constant pivoting from one you know one policy idea to another is just so unhealthy for the for the country, you know.

Sherry (20:46)
Message. Yeah.

It would be different if you had people who were really in tune and and qualified, but you don't. You have people who have a personal agenda. And the thing that really bothered me about Stephen Miller is he didn't profess his loyalty to the Constitution and the rule of law. He professed his loyalty to Trump. And so did this other attorney, and I I'm probably gonna crucify his name. I don't have it in front of me.

Mo (21:21)
Yeah, a hundred percent.

Sherry (21:29)
his last name is Sharf, I think. He's an attorney. William William Sharf, who is one of his attorneys. And the thing that impressed me too, and I I talked about this before, if you look at both these men, they both had that same blank expression on their face, that soulless, no expression in their eyes.

Mo (21:34)
I don't know that. Yeah, I'm not sure.

yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay.

Yeah, like can't you like smile once in a while and show other emotions? I mean, you kind of see that from Heg Seth a lot too. It's like, you know, they just seem very unhappy. And I I'd like to wake up and see people smile a little bit. Like, you know, especially if you're in a position of leadership. I don't wanna feel like I'm waking up and, you know

Sherry (21:57)
Is it I'm calling it?

You do.

Mo (22:20)
the the people who are making decisions for millions are unhappy and bitter for one reason or another. At least that's the impression they give. And and it's not the impression that that I want to see from anyone in a leadership position.

Sherry (22:40)
Yeah, I understand that Miller was pretty much the author of Project Twenty Twenty Five. And you know, if if that's his goal and that's his agenda, we're in for a world of hurt if he stays in in this position. Because it's not been easy the last couple of years. It's gonna get worse if we don't do something about it.

Mo (22:56)
Yeah.

And at least Susie Wiles was probably, you know b well and also able and and willing to push back against her leader, you know, where Miller will do whatever he's told.

Sherry (23:06)
Somewhat normal.

Unfortunately that's true.

Mo (23:21)
Or it's the other way around. Trump will do whatever Miller tells him. now

Sherry (23:28)
People are wondering who Miller really works for. Does he work for Putin?

Mo (23:31)
Hold on a sec, I got cut off for a minute. I'm back. Sorry about that. someone tried calling me. I realize I shouldn't have my phone on on some sort of block so I can't get calls while I'm on with you.

Sherry (23:34)
Okay.

I put mine on airplane mode.

Mo (23:47)
Yeah, that's probably the move, but whatever. I'll do that next time. But yeah, so election night was was fun. It was pretty, you know, enjoyable.

Sherry (23:51)
Okay.

I found it to be hopeful. I was like, this this is pretty amazing. And I'm I'm hoping with all my heart that these people don't go in there and all these Democrats go in there with an attitude and start just tearing stuff up. I hope they have a system in place and you know, prioritize and be humble because we're kinda tired of the, you know, Trump era of

Mo (24:01)
Yeah.

Mm-hmm.

Sherry (24:27)
politics and

Mo (24:28)
Yeah. Now the good news, I mean, there are the you know, not everything is gloom and doom in my world, although it does sound like it, you know, every time you talk to me. I've had, you know, some pretty good results on green card applications.

for my clients recently. I for example, did a marriage-based green card interview on Friday. Now obviously if it's a good faith marriage, a valid marriage, and they can prove it, most of the time you're gonna get approved on those anyways. But

Sherry (24:51)
What?

Mo (25:11)
You never know, especially these days. It's everything's a little bit uncertain and, you know, can be very nerve wracking. But I went to the interview on Friday with my clients, husband and wife, young couple, in their twenties, and by Saturday it updated on their portal online that that that his green card got approved. So

You know, that was a pretty quick turnaround, less than twenty four hours.

Sherry (25:41)
Explain to the listeners the status of a green card. That doesn't mean you're an American citizen.

Mo (25:45)
Sure. No, and that, you know, we'll we'll get to voting and registering to vote, you know, with regards to that in a second. But first let me explain. so when somebody is applying for what's known more commonly as a green card, the green card also known as permanent resident status.

Is a status that allows the person to live in the US, to work legally in the US, to travel both domestically and internationally without any cause for concern, typically. and once they have a certain number of years as a permanent resident.

They can then be eligible to apply for naturalization, which is US citizenship. there are two different tracks for that. If a person is married to a US citizen, a permanent resident is married to a US citizen, and they've had their green card for at least three years and have lived with that.

spouse for that time period and can document and prove it, then they are eligible to apply for naturalization. Everybody else has to wait five years from when they become a green card holder. and that would include like some of those situations I was talking about earlier.

employment-based sponsored green cards, or other f family-based or sometimes other like asylum people who were granted asylum and got a green card. those are all under the five year track. And so while they're here on green cards, they are not eligible

And or permitted to register to vote or to vote in any election. And they're also not eligible to hold certain political office. Sometimes they may not be eligible for certain positions or jobs that are only for US citizens. and so

What ends up happening is they then if they want to become a US citizen have to file a separate application called an N four hundred that allows them to have an interview. they have to in most cases speak English. th there are some exceptions.

Sometimes based off of a person's disability, or if they've had their green card for a certain amount of time and they're over a certain age, they might have an exception to the rule of English speaking. and they have to pass a civics test, a question and answer process on that. And

Also, when they apply for naturalization, there are a lot of questions on the application related to their eligibility. And a couple of the questions have to do with whether they've ever registered to vote, whether they've ever voted in a local or federal election. And and that can be a problem for some people.

you know, I'll let you note what you had mentioned earlier before we went live.

Sherry (29:35)
A couple of weeks ago I had Gary Rastaño on who is the former Arizona US attorney and we talked about the situation where he was describing we were talking about election law and he was describing that there was a f lawsuit filed by Trump's people indicating that there was a lot of illegal people registered to vote in the state of Arizona. And after the investigation

There was, I think, three. but they didn't vote. And the way they became registered was applying for a driver's license. They were automatically registered by a third person. And I believe that happened because when I went to renew my driver's license, they changed me from an independent to a no labels person.

without my knowledge, I didn't know it until I received a ballot in the mail saying no labels. I'm like, what the hell? And so when he said that I thought, Okay, that makes total sense. And you can't hold somebody responsible for something somebody else did. You know, I can't be held responsible for being a no labels person when I didn't do it. The people at the driver's license place did it for me. So, you know, I understand what

Mo (30:34)
Yeah.

Sherry (30:57)
He was saying and it applied to your clients.

Mo (31:02)
Yeah. And I've had cases where people did not willfully register or you know realize that they weren't eligible to vote. I haven't had it happen that often. I've had it maybe about five to ten times over the last 20 years. but

There are incidents where I've had people, I had one man who was in a parking lot. I've actually had it happen a couple of times. And someone from one of the different political parties came up to him and and said, Hey, are you legal in the US? And he was like, Yeah, I'm here legally. And he goes, Well, have you registered to vote? And he said, No, I've never done that. I

didn't think I could, and the person said, Yes, you can, and then assisted him in registering. And and then in the aftermath of that, he he did he he voted a few times and it wasn't until a few years later that he realized he wasn't eligible to do so. and

Then he came to me and asked if he could apply for naturalization. And I said, well, this could be a problem because you, you know, when we went through the the screening and the questions on the application, we get to that question, have you ever registered to vote or have you voted? he said yes and explained the story.

And so what I had him do was we did a sworn statement explaining how what happened was not a willful act. He didn't intend to commit you know, a potential crime. and we we withdrew his name from the voting rolls. and that was all we could do in that situation.

Sherry (32:57)
Yeah.

Mo (32:57)
And then he had to explain it. we we did we st it was what happened was it was more than five years previous prior to when he applied. and at the time and and what the law says is that if you can show five years of good moral character prior to applying for naturalization, you are

potentially eligible to become a naturalized US citizen. So, you know, it was a time where I don't think it would fly today. In fact, these days I wouldn't tell somebody to apply for naturalization after having, you know, that sort of background. I I definitely wouldn't wouldn't do that. But

At that time, this was about ten, maybe more than ten years ago, I felt a little more comfortable with him applying and explaining everything and showing evidence that he withdrew as soon as he came privy to that through talking with me and and he became a citizen.

Sherry (34:03)
Well yeah, it sounds like a good person.

Mo (34:07)
Yeah, I mean otherwise he had no, you know, no criminal history, did everything else right. He just was misled by somebody who was taking advantage of the situation. and getting him to register. and I gosh, I don't know if it was a Democrat or Republican or whatever, but you know, it was somebody who saw a potential

voter for their political party and wanted him to register.

Sherry (34:38)
Yeah. You said that they they do a civics test. Are any of the questions on there about voting and registering to vote?

Mo (34:39)
It it was messed up.

Sherry (34:48)
Do you

Mo (34:48)
there is one question on it that asks what are some of the or name I think it's like name three things that a US citizen has a right to do that that someone with permanent residence or a green card is not eligible to do, which would be like serving on a jury, re voting.

in holding certain l political office

Sherry (35:15)
Okay. Yeah.

Mo (35:16)
be a president. although no, you can't if you naturalize, you have to be a a a natural born citizen.

Sherry (35:25)
So do you know how frequently they update the voting roles, if at all? It seems like I I keep getting mail for this one person who's been dead for I I heard like five years. But I still get mail for him.

Mo (35:41)
Yeah, I know. I I think it it might depend on the state or the jurisdiction. I'm not sure though. but yeah, I mean the the amount of people that are probably still on that are not even alive has gotta be quite significant.

Sherry (36:00)
You know the thing, it's it's like a double standard though, because we've got felons who are now appointed diplomats under this administration, but you know, you've got people who've never even gotten a parking ticket, who aren't citizens, who aren't allowed to vote or have a voice, but and they were brought here as children. You know, they had no choice. And and they're in this this limbo.

Mo (36:20)
Mm-hmm.

Sherry (36:27)
It just seems so unfair.

Mo (36:29)
Yeah. Well and there was and one thing that people have to be leery of is you know that there is a significant crackdown and and if you even if you did register or vote without willfully intending to, you know, commit a crime, you know, you have to be really, you know cognizant of that. There

in September of this year, a couple of individuals from New Jersey were charged with illegally voting in a federal election. And they they made it worse for themselves based off of what I read because they in the aftermath of that they applied for US citizenship naturalization and made false statements. And

They lied. They the form, the N four hundred, asks them if they ever registered to vote or voted in any federal election. And both of them falsely claim that they had not.

w an alien or non citizen can carry a maximum sentence of one year imprisonment and a fine of up to a hundred thousand dollars. And making false statements while applying for US citizenship can carry a maximum sentence of ten years imprisonment and a fine of up to two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. So, you know, the

Sherry (37:42)
my god.

Mo (37:58)
Stakes are really high. People have to be, you know, smart about and and and part of it is, you know, you you you can't if if you think that somebody walking up to you, for example, in a parking lot and you know, telling you that you can register to vote, you know, you may not want to be listening to that person. but like you said.

Sherry (38:21)
They have an agenda for sure.

Mo (38:22)
Sometimes these happen without any intent. like what you were saying about, you know, Gary R Restano and the you know, the the state just automatically registering people through the motor vehicles division.

Sherry (38:39)
Yeah. Yeah, I had no say. I didn't know it happened. And you know, it that's wrong. They need to change that. And I I just I also feel that if if the recorder's office is gonna entertain having no labels party as part of the system, whatever it is, they should send out information to the people, the residents saying, Hey, we've got another option for you.

Mo (38:43)
Yeah.

Yeah. Isn't

Sherry (39:06)
You might wanna read this, see if you wanna join that group, which

Mo (39:11)
And also listing no labels, isn't that counterintuitive since it's a label? I I always thought that was funny, like we're the no labels party, but that's a label. You're labeling yourself.

Sherry (39:16)
Exactly.

Exactly. And you know, I asked him I said that's a horrible name. What's up with this?

Mo (39:27)
The no labels party should have no label. It should just be like, okay, we don't have a label. No, it is kind of a ridiculous name for a political party.

Sherry (39:36)
Well, they tried to register as Arizona independence. And apparently the Republicans had a little heartburn over that. And when they were trying to do open primaries, which I think is a smart thing to do, save us a lot of money and time and aggravation, they they nixed that too. So

Mo (39:55)
Mm-hmm.

Sherry (39:56)
I'm hoping I'm hoping that they try to do that again because I think more and more people are becoming more educated about what open primaries means. And, you know, you can pick and choose who you want on the ballot as opposed to just the Republicans are just, you know, the no labels are just the Democrats. And you know, it I think they're shooting themselves in the foot too, because you've got a lot of independence out there.

Who like, you know, they'll research the person instead of the party. So by them saying no, we don't want you voting in the primary, you're you're not getting the votes that you would have normally had. I had to ask for a Republican ballot because they don't automatically send it to me. And you know, it's it's it's just counterintuitive and crazy. Anyway, I've got to ask you this because this is this is your thing.

Mo (40:30)
Yeah.

Yep, exactly.

Mm-hmm.

Sherry (40:52)
This couple from Russia who climbed which building was it? The Empire State Building?

Mo (40:59)
yeah, yeah. I I they it was was that the yeah, it was the Empire State. They went up the spire or something like that too.

Sherry (41:00)
Okay. They've got a court case coming.

Yeah. They didn't ask permission, no permits or anything. They just weasel their way up there. Now they want to become citizens. They want citizenship. What are what is your thought?

Mo (41:19)
man. Well

That's cr they get charged with they had to have been charged with like trespass or some sort of crime, right?

Sherry (41:26)
they they got charged with so many there's like twelve different things that they did. And this is this I wanna hear what you have to say and then I'll tell you what I'm thinking.

Mo (41:35)
Sure. well from I I did see they they were facing deportation. I I know that. I don't know if they're I mean they they're a hundred percent not going to become US citizens. they are, you know, in a world of hurt here because they committed

Sherry (41:44)
They had a true hearing that.

Mo (42:00)
you know, pretty significant you know, criminal acts, by, you know, not only potentially endangering themselves but other people. you don't know if somebody gets you know, a big gust of wind and blown off the building or s or falls.

And also they're in an area that is, you know, not open to the public. I my assumption is that they've they I I don't know what their status is if they have green cards. I I'm assuming they do, because then they would not be facing deportation proceedings.

But

I think they got a plea deal that might make it so when you're charged with crimes, you can you can try to mitigate your immigration or deportability liability by pleading crime.

that may not make you deportable, but I'm not sure what the status is of that case. I know that they're probably going to, you know, be in deportation proceedings at, you know, some point, if not already. And you know, they probably are not going to

win the case unless they are able to get a good plea deal. but again, every immigration case has its little like nuances. So, you know, it it depends on their background. It depends on you know, whether they have I mean, I don't know if they have green cards. If they're sit if they're citizens, then that's not an issue.

But there's no way at this point, if they were going to apply for naturalization, that they would get naturalization because they have to show good moral character for five years preceding the apply application of the N four hundred naturalization application and the fact that they're facing felony charges.

and I'm reading those charges right now. First degree reckless endangerment, second degree criminal mischief, and third degree burglary, as well as a misdemeanor charge of unlawful climbing. There's just absolutely no way that they're going to be able to become citizens for at least five years, if not longer, and they're probably gonna be in deportation proceedings.

Sherry (44:45)
Yeah, I I had a little heartburn when I saw that happen. I'm my father in law, former father in law, was one of the architects for Sears Tower. And because I knew so much about the building, I was hired as one of their safety security people. And I can't help but wonder if they had some kind of an inside paid symbol to get up there and begin

Mo (45:07)
They had to have an insider. Yeah. I mean, how do they get up there? That was my question too. I th there's no way that they could just get into that part. I I don't think it's possible.

Sherry (45:21)
And not just that, you know, to just totally no not ask permission. It's a private property, endangering not just their lives, but the lives of others. I mean, there's just a litany of things that went through my mind when I saw this happen. And they had a hearing, the somebody's trying to get them a plea deal. And I'm like, you come here and you don't respect our laws or our private property, and you're pulling a stunt like this.

And you're now you're asking for citizenship. I think they're gonna go to jail and as soon as they're done with their prison sentence, be deported back to Russia.

Mo (45:59)
I would have to agree on that. And and on the other hand, if you haven't seen, there's a really good

It's probably still on Netflix. the the guy Alex Honnold. he did a climbing of Taipei one one in Taiwan, with no absolutely no ropes, no harness or anything. Fr he free soloed it.

It it's amazing if you have a chance to watch it, if you can watch it without getting heartburn. But he, you know, and and he did it with permission of the I'm assuming the you know, the government and you know, the building. It was it was made for T V, it was made for Netflix and I mean th to it it was

Sherry (46:31)
That's the mistric then.

Mo (46:50)
It was hard to watch. as somebody who's not a big fan of of of heights myself, I don't mind flying, but I don't think I could make it up, you know, anywhere, you know, near the probably first floor of climbing the building. And this guy climbed with no no ropes, one thousand six hundred and sixty-seven foot.

Sherry (47:08)
Yeah.

Mo (47:15)
skyscraper and the spire on top of it. So yeah, I mean, I I think they're they're toast.

Sherry (47:24)
Yeah, they their attitude too really bothered me because they it was like they were entitled. They've done each these fronts in other places and they felt like they're entitled to do it. And I was like, no, no. This is not, you know, you're endangering people. So I just wondered what your take on that was gonna be. I think we're on the same page.

Mo (47:31)
Course. Yeah.

my take is that they're insane. Yeah, they're they they they they're definitely not not normal. I'm very impressed. and wasn't she was like in a cat suit or something. Like like bat like Batman and Catwoman or something. I don't know. yeah, it whatever. Like, you know, they they can do that.

Sherry (47:47)
They're in deep duty.

Yeah, they you know, they at man.

Mo (48:10)
in other places, but I I just

Sherry (48:12)
Well they said if he ends up back in Russia he's gonna end up fighting in the Ukraine war. They're gonna just say, Okay, here's your

Mo (48:17)
Well, that's gonna be potentially his defense from being deported. he might try to argue that that, you know, but mandatory service is not not a basis typically for asylum.

Sherry (48:34)
No, if you're a citizen of that country, and remember we I think you and I were the ones that talked about it. Trump's grandfather left Germany because he didn't want to be drafted in the military, went to Canada, started a a whorehouse, made all this money, tried to move back to Germany, and they said, No, we don't want you. And that's how he ended up in America. So, you know, if he's from Russia, that's called, you know, service to the country. So

Mo (48:45)
Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah, I know. But anyways, yeah, I mean I I would my biggest concern would be the public safety aspect that, you know, they're endangering people's lives potentially. And also just the complete disregard for rules, which we have to adhere to. I mean, if I went up to the top of a building that I don't have permission to be in or on,

Sherry (49:04)
Right on.

Mo (49:30)
I face the consequences as well.

Sherry (49:33)
It's the same thing. And when I had Border Patrol on, I asked him, Okay, I'm going to Mexico. What if I decide to come back, just crawl over the wall? What's gonna happen? They said, You're gonna get arrested. I said, Okay.

Mo (49:43)
Yeah. And and people, you know, people will make that argument on immigration as well. I get that. But you know, what you have to look at with immigration is the you know the the overarching situ I I think with immigration, you know, there's always that argument that people need to follow the law, do it the right way. They shouldn't be just, you know,

climbing over the wall, crossing in, whatever. You know, I I I understand your argument there. I think one of the, you know, counter arguments that I would typically make is that we have right now, at least right now in this time, a system that doesn't offer people a reasonable pathway.

to legally process. And just from the beginning of our conversation, I talked about how they're constantly changing and and and making the goalposts further and further away, making it more difficult. again, it doesn't excuse somebody coming into the US without authorization, but does provide some, you know, reason or explanation

and then there's people who came here that didn't even choose to come here that, you know, were brought here by parents or an aunt or an uncle. And there are a lot of people like that, you know, and and so it's not as black and white as you're here without legal status, so we should just, you know.

Sherry (51:16)
The little kids.

Every story is different.

Mo (51:34)
deport new immediately. Yeah. Every case should have a separate assessment and look at the the backstory, the equities that the person might have to make a determination about their deportability versus just the whole deport them all with no consideration for, you know.

whether that person was brought here when they were a year old.

Sherry (52:01)
Have you ever been down to Agua Pierta to their immigration holding place?

Mo (52:08)
I have not, no.

Sherry (52:09)
Okay, I I was down there and it's a beautiful facility. The young lady came from someplace in South America, I don't even remember where, but she only had a third grade education and the government down there said, Okay, here's your computer, here's the programs, you need to qualify, you need to get a high school education, and you've got thirty days to do it.

So she's down there in this place that looks more like a hotel. It's it's very secure, but it looks more like a hotel. She's down there with her two kids who walked from wherever they came from. But they gave her the ability to to learn, to move forward with her life. And I asked her when I was down there, I said, was your goal to move to Mexico or were you trying to get to America? She said, No, I want to live in Mexico. I want to be here. My family's here.

I said, okay, I get it, you know. And it was just the way they she was treated in the facilities were so different. Next time I go down there I'll have to see if you have time to go with.

Mo (53:15)
Yeah, I'll have to check that out sometime. I just haven't made it made it there.

Sherry (53:17)
Yeah, because yeah it's it's an interesting system that they have. Maybe we could learn from that. So

Mo (53:23)
Yep. So yeah, that's the latest you know, from my end. I've got a couple of I've got a busy week ahead here. So I've got two green card interviews today, bunch of court cases, bunch of stuff I need to get filed.

Sherry (53:42)
Never a dull moment. Well, I appreciate you coming on and keeping us updated on what's going on.

Mo (53:44)
No.

No problem. Yeah. Thanks for having me. I'd be happy to come back maybe after the Thanksgiving holiday at some point.

Sherry (53:56)
Yeah, that'd be good. Okay, we'll try

Mo (53:59)
Well, thank you so much again, Sherry.

Sherry (54:01)
Okay. Hang on, let me see if I can get this to turn off. There you go.