Protrusive Dental Podcast

🦷 Plaque Friday™ is here!

Get 20% off Protrusive Guidance Ultimate for as long as you stay, plus 7 days free to try it. That’s every masterclass, AskJaz, verifiable CPD on hundreds of podcast episodes, and our new live series Caries, Cracks and Contact Points with Dr Ronit Patel. Use code PF26 at checkout. Ends Monday 30 November, 11:59pm UK.
👉 https://protrusive.co.uk/plaquefriday

Rotary or reciprocating files — which should you actually be using?
Is one safer than the other? Does reciprocation really reduce file separation? Are you choosing your system because it suits the canal anatomy, or because it is simply the one you were taught?
Endodontic file systems can feel like a maze of brands, tapers, alloys, motions and marketing claims. But beneath all that noise, the real question is much more practical: what is your file doing inside the canal, and what compromise are you accepting?
In this episode, Dr Samuel Johnson returns to unpack the Endo Showdown: rotary versus reciprocating files. We cover file motion, glide paths, shaping philosophy, NiTi metallurgy, cyclic fatigue, torsional fatigue, and why no system is perfect.
 https://youtu.be/HfWDBbNgjsA 
Watch PDP270 on YouTube
Protrusive Dental Pearl
A palliative root canal can be useful for an unrestorable tooth if disinfecting the canal allows infection to heal and natural bone to recover before extraction and future implant planning.
⚠️ Do not dismiss root canal treatment purely because the tooth is not a long-term functional restoration.
✅ Where appropriate, consider whether endodontic disinfection could improve the future implant site by allowing natural bone healing.
Key Takeaways
  • The purpose of shaping is not simply to scrape canal walls; it is to create space for irrigant flow.
  • Irrigation is the most important part of root canal disinfection.
  • Rotary files move in a continuous 360-degree rotation.
  • Reciprocating files cut in one direction and reverse before excessive stress builds up.
  • Modern reciprocation is designed to cut, release and gradually progress apically.
  • File choice is not just about motion; metallurgy, taper, design and operator experience all matter.
  • NiTi hand files with strong shape memory may be problematic in curved canals because they want to straighten.
  • Martensitic heat-treated files are more flexible and can better follow canal curvature.
  • Unwinding flutes are a warning sign that a file may be close to separation.
  • Inspect files regularly during treatment, especially in curved, calcified or difficult canals.
  • A glide path is essential before introducing larger rotary or reciprocating files.
  • Without a glide path, a shaping file may create its own path, risking ledging, transportation or perforation.
  • “Grabby” files pull themselves into the canal; this can be useful in experienced hands but risky if forced.
  • Reciprocating systems can feel simpler and safer, but they are not foolproof.
  • Cyclic fatigue happens when a file repeatedly bends around a curve until microcracks form.
  • Torsional fatigue happens when part of the file binds while the motor continues to turn.
Highlights of the episode:
  • 00:00 Teaser
  • 00:47 Introduction
  • 02:13 Protrusive Dental Pearl: Palliative Root Canal Treatment
  • 05:30 Main Question: Rotary vs Reciprocating Files
  • 06:31 Hybrid File Motions
  • 08:19 File Choice Is More Than Motion
  • 10:26 Purpose of Shaping in Endodontics
  • 11:10 Chemo-Mechanical Preparation
  • 11:34 Rotary Motion in Root Canal Treatment
  • 11:45 Origins of Reciprocation
  • 12:21 Balanced Force Technique
  • 18:00 NiTi K-Files vs Stainless Steel K-Files
  • 22:37 Practical Advice: Inspect the File
  • 23:40 Rotary Can Also Be a One File System
  • 24:24 Reciprocation and Sense of Safety
  • 24:47 “Grabby” Files
  • 24:53 Midroll
  • 33:54 Choosing Between Rotary and Reciprocating
  • 35:20 Cyclic Fatigue
  • 37:41 Endo Radar Pro Ads
  • 40:20 Torque and RPM in Endodontics
  • 41:41 Why Reciprocation Advances
  • 42:56 Debris Extrusion in RCT
  • 43:34 Benefits of Rotary Systems
  • 44:13 Tactile Feedback in Root Canal Treatment
  • 45:21 Outro
Want more?
Check out previous episode with Dr. Samuel Johnson: Working Lengths and Troubleshooting Apex Locators – PDP216
🦷 Looking for an endomotor?
Upgrade your endodontic workflow with the Woodpecker Endo Radar Pro. Head to protrusive.co.uk/endomotor and use coupon code PROTRUSIVE at checkout to claim an exclusive discount and your choice of complimentary file system.
#PDPMainEpisodes #EndoRestorative
This episode is eligible for 0.5 CE credit via the quiz on Protrusive Guidance.
This episode meets GDC Outcomes C
AGD Subject Code: 070 Endodontics
Aim: To improve dentists’ understanding of rotary and reciprocating endodontic file systems, including file motion, glide path creation, file metallurgy, fatigue mechanisms, irrigation principles, and practical steps to reduce procedural risks.
Dentists will be able to –
  • Understand the clinical differences between rotary and reciprocating file motions and how these may influence endodontic workflow
  • Recognise key risk factors for file separation, including cyclic fatigue, torsional fatigue, file distortion and inappropriate file use
  • Apply practical principles around glide path creation, irrigation, file inspection and system selection in endodontic treatment

What is Protrusive Dental Podcast?

The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast

SEO METADATA

SEO TITLE:
Rotary vs Reciprocating Files: The Endo Showdown with Samuel Johnson (Part 1) | PDP270

META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Samuel Johnson explains rotary vs reciprocating files: file metallurgy, glide paths, cyclic and torsional fatigue, NiTi hand files and extrusion.

URL SLUG:
rotary-vs-reciprocating-files-endo-showdown-part-1

PRIMARY TOPIC:
Rotary versus reciprocating endodontic files

SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- How reciprocating files work
- The balanced force technique
- NiTi vs stainless steel hand files
- Heat-treated martensitic NiTi files
- Glide paths in root canal treatment
- Cyclic and torsional fatigue in endo files
- Debris extrusion with rotary and reciprocating files
- The palliative root canal before an implant

ROTARY VS RECIPROCATING FILES: THE ENDO SHOWDOWN WITH SAMUEL JOHNSON (PART 1)
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP270
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR SAMUEL JOHNSON

EPISODE SUMMARY

In part one of the Endo Showdown on the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati welcomes back Dr Samuel Johnson, known for his weekly Friday endo case videos, to compare rotary and reciprocating files. Sam explains that the real purpose of shaping is to create space for the irrigant, and that metallurgy, taper and operator experience matter as much as the file's motion.

He traces reciprocation from early 90-degree movements and Dr James Roane's balanced force technique to modern files, and explains why he no longer uses NiTi hand files, preferring stainless steel. He covers heat-treated martensitic files and why unwinding flutes act as a safety backstop, "grabby" files, one-file systems, and the false sense of security they can bring. Sam also explains glide paths, cyclic and torsional fatigue, torque settings, and what the evidence says about breakage, centring and extrusion, before sharing why he personally prefers rotary. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to remember the palliative root canal, because nothing beats the patient's own bone.

IN SHORT

This episode explains how rotary and reciprocating files differ, and why Dr Samuel Johnson believes neither is clearly better. The key messages are that shaping exists to let irrigant work, a glide path is essential, file metallurgy and taper matter as much as motion, and you should choose a system you understand and use it carefully.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

- Jaz's pearl: a palliative root canal on an unrestorable tooth can let the bone heal before extraction and an implant.
- Sam says the main purpose of shaping is to create space for irrigant to flow, not to scrape the canal walls.
- Metallurgy, taper and operator experience matter as much as rotary versus reciprocating motion.
- Sam prefers stainless steel K-files to NiTi hand files, which spring back and struggle in curved canals.
- Heat-treated martensitic files are more flexible, and their flutes visibly unwind before they break.
- One-file reciprocating systems like WaveOne Gold suit newly qualified dentists, but can give a false sense of security.
- Always create a glide path first, like drilling a pilot hole before a larger drill bit.
- Rotary is generally said to extrude less debris, but the evidence on breakage and centring is mixed.

QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE

1. What is the purpose of shaping a root canal?
2. What is the difference between rotary and reciprocating files?
3. What is the balanced force technique?
4. Are NiTi hand files better than stainless steel K-files?
5. What is a "grabby" file?
6. Why is a glide path important?
7. What is the difference between cyclic and torsional fatigue?
8. Is rotary or reciprocating better?

IN THIS EPISODE

1. Introduction: the Endo Showdown, part one
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: the palliative root canal, because nothing beats natural bone
3. Welcome back, Sam, and why his Friday cases show the mistakes
4. Beyond rotary vs reciprocating: hybrid motors, metallurgy, taper and experience
5. The purpose of shaping: it's all about the irrigant
6. Where reciprocation came from: from balanced force to modern files
7. Are NiTi hand files worth it? Shape memory, heat treatment and martensitic files
8. One-file systems, grabby files and a false sense of security
9. Why you need a glide path, and cyclic vs torsional fatigue
10. A word from our partner: the Qudent Endo Radar Pro
11. Torque, reciprocation, and what the evidence says about breakage, centring and extrusion
12. Why Sam prefers rotary: smoothness, cutting efficiency and tactile feedback

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: THE ENDO SHOWDOWN, PART ONE

JAZ:
Welcome, everyone, to part one of the Endo Showdown: rotary versus reciprocating files. Which should we be using? And it's with none other than Protrusive favourite Dr Samuel Johnson, aka I Love the Pulp. If you haven't already checked out the previous episode we did, or his channel, you'll definitely want to after today.

When I announced in the community that Dr Samuel Johnson was returning to the podcast, there was a lot of buzz. Someone even said his was their favourite episode of last year. Obviously an endo geek. There were so many questions from the community, so in part two of this two-part series we'll have a rapid-fire round of them. You'll have to wait until part two for that, because in part one we talk about decision-making when it comes to rotary versus reciprocating, file mechanics, and all the geeky material science we know you love.

Sam also covers the pros and cons of the two systems. And if I'm saying that, you already know there's no such thing as a perfect system. Nothing in dentistry is perfect. But we owe it to our patients to do our own research, pick our battles and choose our compromises wisely.

After this two-part series, you'll come away with more of an idea of how your particular file system is working for you at the moment. Is it benefiting your patients? What are you sacrificing with your specific mechanism of action? We'll definitely gain that perspective from Sam today.

CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: THE PALLIATIVE ROOT CANAL, BECAUSE NOTHING BEATS NATURAL BONE

JAZ:
This is a PDP episode, so you have your Protrusive Dental Pearl. The pearl is to remember that there's nothing better than natural bone. No graft material is better than the patient's own bone. So how does that tie in with root canals? Sometimes you can root canal treat a tooth, but there isn't enough tooth structure left to restore it.

So what do we do? We take the tooth out, clean out the gunge, and graft the area for a future implant, which has its own challenges and disadvantages. But let's not forget, my friends, about the palliative root canal: a root canal you do to heal the infection naturally, just as any root canal does.

Yes, the tooth won't be functioning. You still have some sort of coronal seal, but it's not a functioning tooth. But once the bone has healed naturally, because you've disinfected the root canal system, the implant is so much more predictable when you extract the tooth. And sometimes this approach suits our patients, because it buys them time to save up for an implant, for example.

So don't forget or discount the benefit of a root canal, even for an unrestorable tooth. If you can treat the underlying infection, you'll help the future prognosis. Let's now jump into the main episode, and I'll catch you in the outro.

CHAPTER 3: WELCOME BACK, SAM, AND WHY HIS FRIDAY CASES SHOW THE MISTAKES

JAZ:
Dr Samuel Johnson, welcome back again. You're a fan favourite, Sam. Oh my goodness. I'm going to go straight into it. For those who didn't hear our previous episodes, Sam is a super endo geek, but also one of the nicest people in dentistry. It's so clear from your voice, your smile, your aura, everything.

No wonder everyone loves you. I'm going to read out some comments from the group. Just over 24 hours ago, I said, "Ask your endo file questions," and 20 comments later, we have the likes of Kostas Koleonidis. Sorry, Kostas, for butchering your name.

"I love his channel. If you talk to him, tell him I'm a big fan. Love the detail in the videos. We've adopted many of his techniques." Here's a really cool one, Sam. Shelly Shah said, "I don't even do endo, but I love his channel too."

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Yes.

JAZ:
That's a top one. Christopher said, "Great choice. His episode was one of the best of 2025." Hope this one beats it. No pressure. He's got a real question as well, but we'll save that for later. And the last one, which is one of my favourites, is from Ben Mallard: "Can you let Sam know that his weekly Friday video is the highlight of my morning getting ready for work?" There we have it, mate. I just wanted to shower you with that love.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I find it difficult to take love like that. I don't know why. Maybe it's just a thing with me, but it's really, really difficult. But thank you so, so much. The weekly cases... If I had enough time, I could do a case every single day, but I always choose the best.

Well, actually, I always choose the one with the most learning value. I'd say about 50% of the cases I put out on Fridays are ones you wouldn't necessarily see someone put on Instagram. They're not Instagram-ready. A lot of them are essentially mistakes.

JAZ:
Well, that's why we love them, because they're raw, honest and authentic.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
The most important thing is the problem, and how to solve it. That's essentially how I choose them. I wish I had a team behind me who could edit them and so on. I enjoy doing it, but it's a lot of work.

CHAPTER 4: BEYOND ROTARY VS RECIPROCATING: HYBRID MOTORS, METALLURGY, TAPER AND EXPERIENCE

JAZ:
We need to talk separately, Sam, about helping you get that team. I can help with that. But you mentioned problems. A big problem in the endo world is decision-making, and everything is challenging when you're newly qualified, including deciding between files and file systems and trying to see beyond the marketing hype.

Initially we thought we'd talk about ProTaper versus this brand versus that brand. But actually, although there'll be lots of related questions, like the ones the community has posted, the main thing is to look at the mechanisms.

There's rotary and there's reciprocation, and we're going to do a deep dive into these two. Are there any other broad types of system beyond these two, or are these the main ones we can focus on?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I think these are the main ones. But what I would say is that a lot of the time I use a kind of hybrid system. One of my very first videos for the channel was on an AI endo motor, and its USP.

I don't know if you're aware of it, but it has something called T-Mode. There's a very famous Japanese endodontist known for removing fractured files. His name's Yoshi, and I can't say his surname, sorry. He developed this T-Mode, and the first movement is essentially a watch-winding movement.

I use it quite a lot for getting past aberrant canal anatomy. It replicates the movements you make with a hand file, because with a hand file you get that tactile sensation, don't you? And because these 90-degree movements don't go too far, you're not risking cyclic or torsional fracture.

With this endo motor, once you're past the issue, the ledge or the weird anatomy, you press the button again and it switches to rotary. So I suppose, technically, that's a different type of motion, isn't it? But in a broader sense, it's reciprocation and rotary. When I was first qualified, and when I first did my master's, the question was always, "What do you use? What do you use?"

It's not really a huge issue for me now, because once you get into all this, it's not just about the action, the kinematics. It's a lot of things. It's the type of metal, the metallurgy of the file itself.

Taper is a massive one. And operator experience is another huge factor when you're thinking about which type of file to choose.

JAZ:
I agree. Going back to what you said about being newly qualified: understanding the mechanism is one of the first big things you have to grasp. Then, as you evolve and learn more, you see things you can no longer unsee. I remember in my endo journey, and I don't do much endo now, I started following endodontists, and every time they described a file, they'd say "04" and so on.

And I thought, "Okay, that means something. There are different numbers here, so there's more to it." Then they'd write the name of the metal used. And I thought, wow, there's so much more to files than I knew, and it's always evolving.

You know what? Dental schools probably have some sort of contract with what we'll call Big Endo, who give their files to the dental school cheaply or for free, so that students use those files and keep using Big Endo's files when they go out into the big, bad world.

Big Endo could be any big company, and their files are good. They work. But we come out of dental school knowing only that one thing. At my dental school in Sheffield, we only used rotary. So, pausing there, for the students listening: what is a rotary action, and what is a reciprocating action?

CHAPTER 5: THE PURPOSE OF SHAPING: IT'S ALL ABOUT THE IRRIGANT

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
We need to bring it back slightly, because you need to think about the whole point of shaping. Believe it or not, the point of shaping isn't to scrape the walls of the canal. I can't tell you how many comments I get on the YouTube channel about this. There have been a few cases with huge centrals, probably about ISO 200.

They're very, very wide, and I've used no shaping files at all. I've gone straight to irrigation. And the keyboard warriors give me lots of criticism for not using files. But the whole point of a file is to create space for the irrigant to flow.

That's the most important thing. Irrigation is the most important thing in root canals. If you get that into your head as your philosophy, you're going to have a lot of-

JAZ:
Hence why it's chemo-mechanical, right? That term exists for a reason.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Rotary was the more traditional action: a 360-degree motion of what I call cleaning instruments. I think of it like a cleaning brush. Essentially, you're trying to bore out a wide enough diameter for the irrigant to flow. There's a massive bone of contention over how much you should open up the canal to let the irrigant flow.

I think there's a paper somewhere suggesting a size 35 is the best opening for irrigant flow. I probably disagree with that. I think it's a combination of shaping, irrigant and activation. I use an ultrasonic activator, which creates ultrasonic bubbles that let the irrigant get into all the little nooks and crannies.

So that's where rotary comes from: opening up the canal space, which of course you then need to obturate.

CHAPTER 6: WHERE RECIPROCATION CAME FROM: FROM BALANCED FORCE TO MODERN FILES

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Reciprocation, from my understanding, was first developed in the 1950s. I think it was Micro-Mega, a French company, that suggested a 90-degree movement.

That's nothing like the reciprocation we have today. It was developed then and completely lost in time. Then an eminent dentist, Dr James Roane, developed the balanced force technique. How aware are you of the balanced force technique, Jaz?

JAZ:
You've sent me back to my endo workshops in DF1. I feel like you put your finger on it and maintain the finger position or something. That's as far as I can tell you. It's in the last dying neurons of my brain.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Balanced force is one of those phrases you hear all the time, and you think, "Oh yeah, the balanced force thing," but you're not quite sure what it actually is.

Initially it applied to hand instrumentation, and it was about keeping the hand instrument centred within the canal. Of course, they were using stainless steel hand files then, whereas we're using NiTi. Essentially, from what I remember of the balanced-

JAZ:
I'll just pause you there, Sam, 'cause I need some clarification. You just said we're using NiTi hand files. Do you mean K-files, or are you still talking about the actual systems, like rotary?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Dr Roane was using stainless steel hand files. At that point NiTi wasn't widely used. I'm almost certain it wasn't used in 1985. NiTi was developed in the 1960s by the US Navy. I find this interesting, but I don't want to bore the listeners. Again, it's one of those things developed ages ago and then lost in time.

The balanced force technique was essentially about keeping these hand files centred. Those stainless steel hand files were quite thick, so they didn't bend easily, and they tended to straighten up in the canal.

People were seeing a lot of ledging, perforations and things like that, so balanced force was a safer way of negotiating a file down the canal. Then there was an eminent paper by, and I'm really worried about pronouncing his name wrong,

a Canadian dentist, I think, in the early 2000s. He thought that any endodontic file, rotary or otherwise, can only twist so far before it breaks.

There was a paper that worked out how much you could twist a rotary file before it breaks. His genius idea was: what if we only cut up to the point where it's just about to break, and then release? And that is essentially the basis of reciprocation.

You make a cutting stroke of a certain turn, but before it breaks, or is due to break, you release it.

JAZ:
So it spins one way and then back to zero, or beyond? I know this may be too geeky, but it goes one way and then back the other way, whereas rotary just keeps going the same way, right?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I know that in that first paper, his reciprocating action wasn't the same as, say, WaveOne Gold or Reciproc. And it wasn't a dedicated file he used.

I think he used a ProTaper, maybe ProTaper Next, or actually I think ProTaper Universal. I could be wrong on that. Once he released the paper, there was a flurry of research, and lots of dentists were brought in to develop a file with this safer movement.

Of course, another supposed huge benefit of reciprocating files is their centring ability. So it's a bit of an evolution, isn't it, from Dr Roane developing balanced force to creating something more mechanical.

CHAPTER 7: ARE NITI HAND FILES WORTH IT? SHAPE MEMORY, HEAT TREATMENT AND MARTENSITIC FILES

JAZ:
Before we continue with which one you use when, and what the current trends are, I can already tell you my perception: a lot of practices and GDPs like to use reciprocating because it's, "I'll use the one file, and it'll get me most of the way there."

I don't want to say novice, but there's a difference between someone with less experience, who does endo occasionally, and someone who does endo all day long. You may not appreciate the nuances, and sometimes you use a system because it's what you know and are comfortable with.

It's like, "If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail", the endo version. The hammer is the same file you use because it works for 97% of cases. But there will be three cases where it may actually do more harm.

So I'm keen to learn about that from you. But because you touched on K-files, let me load up one of the community questions, which you might as well answer now, from Theon. Theon asks, "Is there any use for NiTi K-files? It seems like stainless steel K-files can do pretty much everything."

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I've got something to say about this. Let me take it even further back. At university, at Manchester in 2009, we weren't shown rotary or reciprocating files. We all used hand files and cold lateral compaction.

JAZ:
Not even ProTaper hand files? 'Cause we had ProTaper hand files.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
No, I think they were just normal stainless steel K-files, and we were shaping up to a 25. To do a molar endo like that, you'd need hours. But in a way I could understand where they were coming from, because cold lateral compaction is still seen as a kind of gold standard. It's the basics, isn't it?

You get it, and I suppose that's what university is for. When I got to my VT practice, I couldn't have everything I wanted, but the nurse asked what I wanted. I thought stainless steel hand files, but then I thought, "Let's get the NiTi ones, 'cause they're more expensive." In my mind, that's why I wanted them.

JAZ:
They're premium.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
The pack came in nicer packaging. And when you bend them, they flip back to the way they were. My famous adage is that you don't know what you don't know. I realised very, very quickly that if you have a file that wants to spring back to its original shape, then with anything other than a straight canal, you're really in trouble and you'll really struggle.

When we talk about the history of rotary and reciprocation, the very first ProTaper files, ProTaper Universal essentially, had that kind of shape memory. And I don't think either of the practices I work in now has any NiTi hand files at all.

I think they're a detriment to your practice. I can never pronounce these: martensitic and austenitic. The austenitic phase is the one that wants to keep its shape.

I think a lot of NiTi hand files are in this austenitic phase. And I wonder whether they make NiTi hand files that are more martensitic.

Where if you bend the file, it keeps the bend. I use HyFlex a lot of the time at the moment, for a lot of my cases, though of course I do mix it up a bit.

JAZ:
Educate us. Is that a rotary or a hand file? What is it?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It's a rotary file, and it's been heat treated. It's also made by electrical discharge machining, which I don't fully understand. But when NiTi rotary or reciprocating files are heat treated, they change from the superelastic austenitic phase into the more martensitic phase.

That's important because the martensitic phase is more flexible. When you're in a canal, the worst thing you can have is a file that wants to straighten up, because you want it to bend with the canal. Another odd property of martensitic files, before I forget, is that they're ever so slightly weaker than austenitic ones.

You'd think that was a bad thing. But one of the main problems with early NiTi rotary files was that there was no safety backstop. These files would just fracture, like that. Whereas with these softer rotary or reciprocating files, every time I pull them out of the canal, I look at the flutes.

If the flutes are starting to unwind, the file is about to break, so you can change it straight away. You might hear that martensitic files are softer and their torsional limit is lower.

But the ability to unwind slightly acts as a bit of a safety backstop, if that makes sense.

JAZ:
That's golden advice: check your files periodically under your loupes for any unwinding. I learned that the hard way, and I'm sure you have as well, mate.

That's a great point. Theon, thanks so much for asking that question, 'cause I didn't know. It sounds like Sam agrees you can do pretty much everything with stainless steel. And not only can you do everything with them, and they're cheaper, but they're probably safer, because they don't have that shape memory, which you don't want unless you're dealing with a really straight canal.

CHAPTER 8: ONE-FILE SYSTEMS, GRABBY FILES AND A FALSE SENSE OF SECURITY

JAZ:
I think that one's been answered, which means we can get back on topic: rotary versus reciprocating. I've already given you my perception that, in the real world, many clinics choose for efficiency reasons, and probably cost as well. Is it cheaper for a clinic, on average, per case?

There are so many nuances here, and you know too much, so you've got to simplify it. On the whole, do you think practices favour reciprocating because of the simplicity and cost of using one file, versus the four different files you might have to use in another system?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I'd say HyFlex is arguably a one-file system as well. I was an NHS dentist for a long while.

JAZ:
That's rotary, yeah? Not reciprocating.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It's a rotary file. Sorry, I'll be clearer about which is which. I used that for a very long time on the NHS, and I thought it was quite a cost-effective file. I don't really use WaveOne Gold, but I'll tell people now: if you're newly qualified and looking for a one-file system, WaveOne Gold is a really, really good option.

There's a really good study on this, looking at whether it's well received and well used by newly qualified dentists. A lot of the students and newly qualified dentists who used WaveOne Gold, or any reciprocating file, had a sense of safety.

The problem is that we're only talking about rotary versus reciprocation. I'd say WaveOne Gold isn't very grabby, but Reciproc, which is another reciprocating file, is very, very grabby.

JAZ:
"Grabby" is a wonderful term, 'cause it already makes sense, but make it super tangible. What's a grabby file?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You put a rotary or reciprocating file into a canal, and if it wants to drag itself into the canal, that's grabby. When I was first qualified, I didn't like that, even on the hands-on days during my master's degree.

Now I like grabby. I like a rotary file that wants to go into the canal, mainly because I don't like pushing a rotary or reciprocating file in, as I've had my fingers burnt many, many times by fracturing them. But I've been doing it for so long now that I know the limits of the files I'm using.

Initially, when I went to my VT practice and demanded those NiTi hand files, we also eventually got WaveOne Gold, and it just felt nice. It felt safe. But it's really important not to get complacent. That safety isn't foolproof, and I fractured WaveOne Gold files early on.

JAZ:
It's almost a false sense of security. Just because it isn't grabbing doesn't mean it isn't removing a lot, perhaps in the wrong part of the canal.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I think the very first file I fractured was a Reciproc file. I remember it well, 'cause I was working on a Saturday, of all things. I can't believe I booked a Saturday. I was using it the wrong way, at too tight an angle, and sweeping it around. Maybe I had that false sense of security that reciprocating files are foolproof.

Another reason it might be better for less experienced dentists is something you touched on: it's just a simplified sequence, isn't it? You get the glide path, use a one-file system, and you're done.

And 90% of the cases you take on as a newly qualified dentist won't have tight bends, or canals that split and join deep down. Another thing I'd say, though, is that I'm almost certain Reciproc was specifically designed to be used without a glide path.

CHAPTER 9: WHY YOU NEED A GLIDE PATH, AND CYCLIC VS TORSIONAL FATIGUE

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
What I mean by a glide path is this. A lot of the canals you come across will be open, but a lot of the time they'll be blocked or calcified, or there'll be aberrant pulpal anatomy you can't see, because it's deep in the canal.

Have you ever drilled a hole in a wall to hang a picture? You don't start with the drill bit you'll use for the final hole, because it's really hard to put quite a large drill into a wall without moving all over the place.

You start with a pilot hole, using a very small drill bit.

JAZ:
Same with implants.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
And then you use that to... Yeah. Do you know what? I have absolutely nothing to do with implants, and I had no idea that's what they do. That just shows my ignorance. I thought they just drilled it in and left it.

JAZ:
It's more universal. We get it.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
With a glide path, you just want to make sure the canal is patent, meaning open. Because if a big, fat rotary or reciprocating file doesn't have that path to follow, it'll just follow its own path, won't it? It'll cause a perforation, transportation, a ledge or whatever.

JAZ:
So the glide path is mandatory. But when it comes to decision-making, in every episode we make premium notes, and we try to pull in more from around the web to compile a good summary of the episode.

Imagine a table with rotary on one side and reciprocating on the other. Can you suggest any indications? For example, a reason to use a reciprocating file might be that you want a simplified, more cost-effective system and you're new to endo, or you might disagree with that, because maybe you need more experience before using reciprocating.

But give us things like, "For curved canals, use that." And let me break it down a little more, because one thing the nurses and dental assistants who work with me find very annoying is when I'm about to do a Class II, an MOD, an MO or a DO, and they ask, "Hey, which matrix are you going to use?"

And I say, "I don't know. I won't know until I've removed the caries and looked at the distance between the margin and the adjacent tooth's convexity, and the height of where the contact needs to be," and all these little nuances.

So I say, "I'll let you know once I've done my cavity prep." And nurses always look at me funny, because every other dentist they've worked with says, "This is the matrix I use. Just get it ready for me." Whereas I say, "I'll know when I know." So I'm really fascinated: is it the same with you endo bods?

When you open the access cavity, you know a bit from the radiograph, and you've got an idea of what you'll use, but you'll only really know once you're in there? Or do you have a system where you know from the beginning, "I'm using this file system, so nurse, please get it ready"? I'd love to know that before we make the table.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I'm probably going to give you a wishy-washy answer, but I don't think it matters whether you use rotary or reciprocating. Maybe I'm ruining today's title, but the evidence certainly doesn't favour one or the other.

I think it's basically down to personal preference. Reciprocation does have obvious benefits, which we've already talked about: the apparently lower risk of cyclic and torsional fatigue. By cyclic fatigue, I mean that when the file spins in the canal and goes round a curve, one side of the file is repeatedly compressed and stretched, compressed and stretched, and that tension-compression cycle happens over and over again until micro-cracks form in the metal.

And then it breaks. We like the paperclip analogy. If you bend a paperclip back and forth enough times, it breaks. So remember: with cyclic fatigue, the file is free to move within the canal space, but it breaks from that repeated back-and-forth bending, which is more likely in a very bendy canal.

JAZ:
It's more likely in a bendy canal, but am I right in saying that, especially in a lot of the countries you work in, we don't use a file on more than one patient? So one could argue that cyclic fatigue is rare, because the file doesn't go through enough cycles.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Yeah. But people are human beings, aren't they? Obviously there are newly qualified dentists, but even yesterday I did a case with four proper canals, each with its own portal of exit. Sometimes I've been using a rotary file, a HyFlex file, for a long time.

Especially if I've struggled to get down calcified, difficult canals, I'll look at the flutes, see they're perfectly fine, but replace the file anyway, because I'm concerned about cyclic fatigue.

Again, I'm going from memory here, but I remember from my master's degree that there's a limit to how many times a rotary file can turn, and it's very low compared with what you'd think. You'd think it could turn all day, but it can't.

So that's something to be concerned about. When I was newly qualified, I was using reciprocation and sometimes a bit of rotary. Now I do two-hour appointments, but back then I used to split appointments into two one-hour slots, and keep the file for the same patient, not different patients.

The file would be autoclaved and sit in decon, and when the patient came back, we'd use the same file. I stopped doing that, mainly because I was concerned about fatigue in the file. The other type of fatigue, of course, is torsional fatigue, where the stress on the file exceeds the elastic limit of the metal.

That's when you're using a rotary or reciprocating file, and the tip binds in the canal but the motor keeps turning. That happens if the motor's torque isn't set correctly. People ask about RPM and torque. RPM is how fast the file spins, and torque is the point at which the motor stops pushing and goes backwards.

CHAPTER 10: A WORD FROM OUR PARTNER: THE QUDENT ENDO RADAR PRO

JAZ:
On Protrusive, we get asked geeky endo questions all the time, but one of the top questions is, "Which endo motor should I get?" A good endo motor is so valuable. Whether you're at a busy practice or an associate moving between practices, if you do a lot of endo, you'll value a good endo motor.

We've teamed up with Qudent to bring you a special promotion on the Endo Radar Pro. I had a product demo a couple of months ago, and the cool thing is that the head itself has free-form rotation.

That makes it far less awkward to read your apex locator measurement, 'cause it's not only a motor, it's also an apex locator. With a fixed head, it's sometimes difficult to read the screen. Free-form rotation really helps you access all the canals, however far back and awkward they are.

With other motors, you have to detach and reattach the head, but this one rotates freely. The other trend this satisfies is that dentists buying endo motors nowadays no longer want the screen on the handpiece itself. That's getting too cumbersome and fiddly, going up and down trying to get the right settings on the handpiece.

So we've gone back to favouring a large screen, and that's what this one offers. Dentists want to put the endo motor on the bracket table right next to them and see the screen and the visuals. It makes it so much easier to toggle file systems, speeds and torque.

The motor connects to the handpiece via Bluetooth, so there are no wires, which is great: you still get the feel of a wireless handpiece, but all the settings are conveniently changed on the motor, not the handpiece. Not to mention, it's more ergonomic. The Endo Radar Pro comes with an autoclavable head, which is where you insert your file. If you're limited to endo, or you're a specialist, you'll probably want to buy a couple of additional heads.

The promotional price in total is less than £650. I say less than, because I always like to quote including VAT. Once you check out and enter the code, it'll be well under £650, and there's another perk as well: you get to choose some free files. You can pick Solo files, which are similar to WaveOne, or M-Taper, which is similar to ProTaper rotary.

When I was learning about these files, I found out they've been sold for seven years with 80% customer retention. So you get a new endo motor and get to try a new file system, either reciprocating, the Solo, similar to WaveOne, or rotary, the M-Taper, similar to ProTaper.

The discount and the files are all applied at checkout. The website to claim this is protrusive.co.uk/endomotor. That's /endomotor. And as always, your coupon code is PROTRUSIVE. This offer is time-sensitive: the best pricing is in the first 30 days, or until it sells out. So check it out at /endomotor. Let's rejoin the episode.

CHAPTER 11: TORQUE, RECIPROCATION, AND WHAT THE EVIDENCE SAYS ABOUT BREAKAGE, CENTRING AND EXTRUSION

JAZ:
So that torque setting applies to both rotary and reciprocating, right? Because you do-

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
No, you're correct there.

JAZ:
You put in a torque setting for ProTaper, even rotary, like ProTaper Universal. Is ProTaper Next rotary or reciprocating? ProTaper Next is rotary. I remember when I was learning about ProTaper Next, they said, "It's swaggering." But actually it's rotary.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You've just taken the words out of my mouth. I was about to mention the swaggering.

JAZ:
If I'd asked you whether it's rotary or reciprocating, you'd have said swaggering, 'cause that's what's on my mind. They brought swagger to dentistry. But jokes aside, it's rotary, and even with these files you still have to set the torque.

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You don't set the torque for reciprocation, because that's the whole point, isn't it? The file only goes one way, and before it reaches the elastic limit of the metal, it comes back. Originally, what they wanted was for the cutting rotation to be longer than the release rotation, so you'd get some movement towards the apex.

We were talking about reciprocation being used in the '90s. That type of reciprocation was just back and forth equally, and they found it was ineffective, because it was just juddering in the canal. It wasn't advancing. It makes sense: you need a bit more in one direction.

JAZ:
That makes sense. So I understand the torque now. But what you said right at the beginning was that reciprocating has the advantage of fewer breakages because of this feature. Is that right?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Some would say so. The problem with studies in endo, or really in anything, is that it's almost impossible to get a consensus. That's why I said right at the start that I'd give you a wishy-washy answer, because it's about how you feel.

You might feel safer using reciprocation because you like the idea that this movement is less likely to cause torsional fracture, and you think it'll give better centring ability as well. We talked about the balanced force technique, and obviously reciprocating motion borrows something from that technique.

But the evidence on centring ability is all over the place. Some say reciprocation is great, some say rotary is great. You obviously get that feeling of safety, and it's better for less experienced dentists.

JAZ:
Okay. I was going to ask: doesn't reciprocating produce more debris?

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
This is where we move on to the benefits of rotary. They say a rotary action is less likely to extrude material, whether that's debris from the canal, bacteria, or material in a retreatment.

The evidence broadly supports this, but again, it comes down to a lot of factors: the file design, the taper, the technique. In fact, one study suggested that Reciproc produced the least extrusion of material.

CHAPTER 12: WHY SAM PREFERS ROTARY: SMOOTHNESS, CUTTING EFFICIENCY AND TACTILE FEEDBACK

DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Another benefit of rotary, I think, is that it feels smoother. That's something you decide for yourself, whether it's good or bad. But one thing I noticed with reciprocation is that juddery effect, isn't it? You may or may not like that.

I use a rotary file, HyFlex, essentially because I started using it seven or eight years ago, and I know it really well. But I feel there's better cutting efficiency with rotary. HyFlex is rotary. I like its smoothness, and I feel I get more tactile feedback as well.

What I mean is that I can feel the canal, because root canal treatment is essentially all done by feel, isn't it? You'll never get feedback as good as with a hand file, because it's right there in your hand.

But if I'm getting towards the apex and can't quite get to the end, or can't get zero on my apex locator, a lot of the time I'll put a little bend at the end and feel around for the apex. Sometimes you can feel a ledge, so you can feel something.

I feel I get better tactile feedback from the canal with rotary. But of course, I could have used WaveOne Gold for eight years and feel I got the same tactile feedback. So it's basically subjective, isn't it? Another great thing about rotary, I feel, is that it gives you a much wider variety of ways to customise how you treat teeth. I get asked a lot about my protocol, and it's pretty boring.

JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening to me and Sam all the way to the end of part one. We've left you on a cliffhanger: he's just about to explain his painfully boring but ever so important protocol.

How does he do his endos? Don't forget to tune in to part two to learn his protocol. And don't forget the offer on this endo motor. There'll be a recurring offer, but for the first 30 days from when this episode is published, you'll get the stated offer, the highest discount. The website is protrusive.co.uk/endomotor.

That's protrusive.co.uk/endomotor. If you've been looking and waiting for the right, reliable motor, this is a great opportunity to speak to your practice or your principal and consider buying it. Having said that, I know many associates buy their own motors. Extremely sad, I know, but I love you for it.

This episode is, of course, eligible for CPD. We are a PACE-approved education provider. If you're watching on the premium version of the app, scroll down and don't forget to answer the quiz, and our CPD queen, Mari, will send you a certificate. If you're not on the app yet, what are you waiting for? This could be easy CPD you rack up every week just by listening, and of course you unlock a whole bunch of courses and extra premium clinical videos as well.

Head over to protrusive.app to start your learning journey. You'll come for the courses, but you'll stay for the community. And last but not least, don't forget to tune in next week for part two. I'll catch you same time, same place, ladies and gents. Bye for now.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

QUESTION:
What is the purpose of shaping a root canal?
ANSWER:
Sam says the main purpose of shaping isn't to scrape the canal walls, but to create enough space for the irrigant to flow, because irrigation is the most important part of root canal treatment. In very wide canals, he has sometimes relied on irrigation alone. He also uses ultrasonic activation to help the irrigant reach the nooks and crannies.

QUESTION:
What is the difference between rotary and reciprocating files?
ANSWER:
A rotary file turns continuously through 360 degrees in one direction. A reciprocating file turns one way to cut, then reverses before it reaches the point where it would break, with the cutting rotation longer than the reverse so it advances towards the apex. Sam explains that the idea grew out of research into how far a file could twist before fracturing.

QUESTION:
What is the balanced force technique?
ANSWER:
Sam explains that Dr James Roane developed the balanced force technique for stainless steel hand files, which were stiff and tended to straighten in the canal, causing ledges and perforations. The technique kept the file centred and made negotiating the canal safer. He sees modern reciprocation as an evolution of that idea into a mechanical movement.

QUESTION:
Are NiTi hand files better than stainless steel K-files?
ANSWER:
Sam doesn't think so, and no longer has NiTi hand files in either of his practices. Many NiTi hand files are in the austenitic phase, so they spring back to straight when bent, which makes curved canals difficult. Stainless steel K-files can hold a bend, are cheaper, and in his view can do pretty much everything you need.

QUESTION:
What is a "grabby" file?
ANSWER:
Sam describes a grabby file as one that wants to drag itself into the canal. He didn't like this when he was newly qualified, but now prefers it, because he dislikes pushing files and knows his files' limits. He finds Reciproc very grabby and WaveOne Gold less so, but warns that a file feeling safe doesn't mean it can't fracture.

QUESTION:
Why is a glide path important?
ANSWER:
Sam compares a glide path to drilling a small pilot hole before using a larger drill bit to hang a picture. It makes sure the canal is patent before a larger rotary or reciprocating file goes in. Without one, the file may follow its own path and cause a ledge, transportation or perforation, especially in calcified canals or those with unusual anatomy.

QUESTION:
What is the difference between cyclic and torsional fatigue?
ANSWER:
Sam explains that cyclic fatigue happens when a file spins around a curve and is repeatedly compressed and stretched, like bending a paperclip back and forth until it snaps. Torsional fatigue happens when the tip binds in the canal but the motor keeps turning, exceeding the metal's elastic limit. Correct torque settings and replacing files help reduce the risk.

QUESTION:
Is rotary or reciprocating better?
ANSWER:
Sam believes neither is clearly better and the evidence doesn't favour one. Reciprocation may feel safer and suit less experienced dentists, while rotary is generally thought to extrude less debris, though studies vary. He personally uses HyFlex rotary files because he finds them smoother, more efficient and better for tactile feedback, but says it's largely personal preference.

ABOUT THE GUEST

Dr Samuel Johnson is a dentist with a special interest in endodontics, known online as I Love the Pulp. He trained at Manchester University, has a master's degree, worked for many years as an NHS dentist, and now works in two large practices. He posts a clinical endo case on his YouTube channel every Friday, often choosing cases that show problems and how to solve them.