Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
What we're seeing at the moment is
more American consumers especially
saying, "Okay, I, I need to start,
you know, I need a new couch.
I need a new fridge.
I need a new pair of shoes."
And we actually saw a 20% increase in
the rate of US consumers reporting that
they're buying more in the last few
months between the end of August and May.
And we do see that in the data, right?
We saw a lift between flat growth
and a 2% increase, um, in Q3.
So the data kind of nets out, like
very well cor- correlates to what
we're seeing in that sentiment data.
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast,
where we explore the intersection
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call retailgentic.
Our mission is simple.
We are shining a bright light
on the new agentic AI shopping
megatrend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.
The stakes are high.
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.
What happens to checkouts?
How should payments work?
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not
from humans, but from AI agents?
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating
our AI shopping agent future.
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.
Welcome to the Retail Gentic Podcast.
On today's episode, we have Kayla
Schwartz, director of strategy and
consumer insights at Salesforce.
Salesforce has tons of data from their
various platforms, and they use that
data along with frequent customer
surveying for quarterly e-commerce
trends and a awesome holiday forecast.
In this episode, Kayla takes us through
both the holiday forecast, in very
detail, with specific focus on their
agentic commerce predictions, and she
also gives us a sneak peek of some
interesting Q3 data that is dropping soon.
If you love data and consumer behavior
and agentic commerce as much as I
do, you're gonna enjoy this one.
Stay tuned.
Welcome to Retail Gentic.
Today on the podcast, I'm excited
to welcome Kayla Schwartz.
She is director of strategy and
consumer insights at Salesforce.
Hey, Kayla.
Hi, Scott.
Thanks for having me.
Good.
You're a feather- fellow southerner.
I'm, uh, way up north in North
Carolina, and you're down in South
Carolina, my neck of the woods.
Oh, I forgot that you
were in North Carolina.
Look at us representing.
I'm from Aiken.
I'm an Aikenite.
Okay.
You, you, uh…
Everyone listening won't know what that
is, but that's a little town in South
Carolina over by the Augusta area.
Yeah.
And I know, uh, Charleston really well.
It's a beautiful, beautiful
part of the world.
It is.
We're blessed to be able to live here, so
it's, uh, and it's good to be on the pod.
Yeah.
Yep.
Uh, so we've known each other forever,
and, uh, but all the listeners don't.
So fill us in on a little background.
What does the director of
strategic strategy and consumer
insights do at Salesforce?
Yeah.
Well, you know, I've been with
Salesforce now for 11 years.
I come by way of the Demandware
acquisition, actually, back in 2016.
Um, and I have a very cool role here.
I- my job is to study the shopper,
study the retail industry overall by
using all of the amazing data that we
have access to through our commerce,
marketing, and service cloud platforms,
and now our Agentforce products as well.
So, um, it-- essentially using all of
that data, running some consumer sentiment
studies, and forecasting out trends,
building predictions, and studying
the most important time of the year,
which is the holiday shopping season.
Ah.
I thought the most important time
at Salesforce was Dreamforce.
Well, for retail.
Ah.
Okay.
Gotcha.
Uh, did you go to Dreamforce?
It looked like…
Uh, I saw a couple of the streams.
It looked like it was
a really fun, fun show.
Yeah, I did.
I did.
Um, got back late last week.
It was a great show.
You know, it was really exciting
to see how the Agentforce is really
taking shape, and, um, especially
within commerce and retail products,
and there's just so much excitement.
S- you can really feel it.
And, uh, it was, it was exciting
show to be at this year.
Yeah, I don't know if anyone is as
all in on the agent and agentic stuff
as you guys are, so it's neat to see
that, you know, Benioff definitely
is, like, fired up about it.
So seems like he's reinvigorated
and, and really charged up
about it, which is neat to see.
And then I was excited, uh, I, I know
one of your colleagues from his Google
days, Nitin, and it was exciting to
see him, um, kind of in the Salesforce
camp working on Commerce Cloud and,
uh, we're gonna have him on soon.
So, uh, you know, some of the stuff
you guys announced there, but it was
fun to see him on the stage as well.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's exciting to have Nitin on board,
and, uh, he's leading Commerce Cloud now.
So we are now part of the Commerce Cloud
un- umbrella here, um, at Salesforce.
I was originally on Retail
Cloud, and so now we're, we're on
Commerce or AgentForce Commerce.
And, uh, so it, it's good to all be
unified and, uh, working together
to, to bring better commerce and
agent solutions to customers.
Yeah, and the data we're gonna talk about,
so this is a forecast, but then you guys
also put out a quarterly kind of a recap.
Um, and I'm eagerly waiting for Q3,
so we'll, we'll see what that, that…
You know, I'm expecting it
any day now, so we'll see.
And, uh, uh, uh, and then, uh, you
know, you guys have access to all
this transactional data from the, the,
the various platforms you mentioned.
Do you guys do a lot of surveying
as well, or you're less on the,
um, stated preference and more
on the observed kinda side?
We do.
We do, um, several consumer sentiment
studies throughout the year, um,
for various pieces of research.
But for holiday, um, we've
done two so far this year.
One was done in May, and then the other
one we wrapped at the end of August.
So, um, it was about
5,500 global consumers.
And what's really cool about
the c- sentiment studies is
that we can see the behavior.
So when…
T- to analyze the difference
between what consumers say they're
doing and what they're actually
doing, um, is really interesting.
Sometimes it, it, it doesn't go together,
but when it, when you see it actually,
like, really, like, cohe- the cohesive
story, when you see the behavior and
the sentiment and, and you can s- see
how they relate and the connections
between them, um, really powerful story.
And we, we really are seeing
that this year, which is cool.
And you are in luck.
We- I do have some Q3 data to
share, so I'm, I'm happy to.
Okay.
Wow.
Breaking news.
And, uh, uh, I like that.
I like it when the observed starts
to match the, uh, the stated as well.
It's like, as a data nerd, it, like,
feels very satisfying for some reason.
I don't know.
It does.
It does.
Yeah.
And it's, like, very
frustrating when it doesn't.
You're like, "What's
wrong with these people?
You said you were gonna do
this, and you're not doing it."
Yeah, exactly.
I know.
I agree.
Yeah.
Only data nerds would understand that.
Let's talk about agentic, and then
I wanna get a little Q3 update.
So, uh, one of the reasons I wanted
to have you on is as I was looking
through the holiday predict, uh,
you know, forecast, uh, you know,
one of the data points around agents
and, and AI really stuck out to me.
So, um, reveal that to the
audience, and we'll chat about it.
Yeah.
Well, it's a really exciting
year, and in fact, one of our…
Our theme for the holidays
this year is, um, discovery.
So essentially, the way the consumers
are discovering brands, the way
they're discovering products is
changing at a very fundamental level.
And my theory, based on what
we're seeing in the data and the
potential that this can bring, is
that it's going to fundamentally
change commerce, um, in the future.
We're seeing how that's taking
shape right now, but looking in
the years ahead, very exciting.
And so when-- as we know and understand
for this holiday season, the, the
biggest shift, um, at the moment is
the way consumers are using these,
um, third-party agentic search tools.
So ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini,
you know, name your tool.
Um, even TikTok and Instagram, we
kind of put in that bucket because
those are all now powered by, um,
LLM, uh, search features, and we know
our Gen Z audiences, TikTok search is
their most preferred search channel.
And so what that's doing is it's
changing customer expectations,
and we're seeing how that's playing
out right now, and it's absolutely
going to shift holiday behavior.
Um, two ways that we're seeing this
happen right now, w-we're seeing more and
more consumers turn to these tools first
when they start their shopping journey.
So about 9% of US consumers at the end
of August said that they were using
these tools to start their journey.
And if we look at the rate of shoppers
back in May that said they were doing
this, it's about a 34% increase.
But what's really interesting in
our data is that what's happening
with the oldest generations.
It's no surprise that Gen Z
is adopting these tools first.
But back in May, we saw 0% of
baby boomers using, uh, an agentic
search to, to start the journey.
And then fast-forward to end of
August, and about 2% to 3% of baby
boomers are using these tools.
So, um, just really strong
adoption right off the bat.
And over the holidays, we're anticipating
that AI will drive about $263 billion in
global holiday sales, which is about…
We're anticipating 21% of
the total season's revenue.
So big impact, and it's just a, a very
strong acceleration over last year.
Yeah, that, that hits me pretty hard
because the last two weeks I've been in
these random LinkedIn battles where, you
know, I post a lot about, I, I call it
ChatGPT announced agentic commerce because
it's the Agentic Commerce Protocol.
It's their name.
And then I get in these
religious holy wars over…
There's a, the set of people that, that,
y- you know, and they kind of go down
this weird logic path that doesn't make
sense to me, and they're like, "It--
We see this definition of agentic…"
And, and sometimes they'll actually talk
about a Salesforce one that I don't, I
don't know where they're getting it from.
But in their mind, the consumer
can have no part in it at all.
And because in ChatGPT,
you're kind of along…
It's an assistant more than a…
It's like a GPS.
It kind of guides you and doesn't
just go buy stuff for you.
Um, they're like, "That's
not true agentic."
And I'm like, "The, A, it doesn't matter."
But then they, then they kind of
go down this rabbit hole of, you
know, therefore no one's doing it,
and it's not really something that,
that people should worry about.
And I'm like, "Well, you know, I don't,
I don't follow your logic path there."
We're arguing over a definition, and
then suddenly you're saying no one's
using this thing, whatever we call it.
I'm like, "We, we can argue over the
definition, but that doesn't make sense."
So it's, you know.
And then, um, you know, it, it's
definitely, uh, one of the higher
estimates for this year I've seen.
So that's pretty…
Is it because, um, you…
Another thing that I think really
messes with people's heads is I
get in these arguments, they'll
throw some data out there.
They'll say, "Look, no one's using this."
And they'll, they'll have a survey.
It's never a Salesforce survey.
It's some other thing.
And as I dig into it, it came out in
like July of this year, but then the
data was from like November of last year.
And I'm like, that was, that's like
10 years in AI land because the, the
web search functionality was kind of
garbage in November of last year, and
it's just gotten to the point, you
know, it got really good in Q1, and then
people kind of realize it's there by Q2.
So these things are like,
we're packing, you know…
You and I have been at this long enough.
We're packing two or three of
traditional e-commerce years into
each quarter right now in a weird way.
So yeah.
So it's really, there's a set of people
that are really boggled by all this.
Yeah.
It's, it's, there's, decades are
happening, right, in like just a
matter of a year or two in terms of
development and it, and you can't even
compare l- to last holiday or last year
because the tools weren't the same.
Um, and even if you think back on, you
know, if you go back to like old social
media trends, 'cause that's where a lot
of, uh, especially our younger consumers
are learning how to use these tools.
If you go back to old social media trends,
um, and see how the recommendations
have evolved and what, you know, it
went from like how to create funny
pictures and memes to, okay, now you
can actually use these to build, um,
solid recommendations for yourself and
your family and pl- budget and plan and,
you know, there's so many use cases,
but within the context of shopping.
And something that I'm also seeing,
and maybe this is more anecdotal, but
especially within older generations, they
learn how to use it for one use case.
So for example, our neighbors used
it to help translate for them while
they were, um, while they went abroad
for a vacation over the summer.
Um, and they're baby boomers, and
they were so blown away by how
powerful the technology was, and now
all of a sudden they're like, "Wow,
I can use it for this and for that."
And there's so many other ways that
they can apply this to their life.
And so it just takes one sort of
introduction, one use case, and
then the opportunities are endless.
And so then it translates into, "Oh, I
can use this to budget my shopping list
for the, for the week or for the month."
Yeah.
Very cool.
And then, so you said
the theme is discovery.
Uh, is, is that because you're-- that's
the primary use case you're seeing
for Agentic right now, is just kind
of the surfacing of new products and,
and then, um, you know, down the road
it'll get more into the purchase funnel?
Or like, say a little bit more about that.
Yeah.
Right now what we're seeing, what shoppers
are telling us, is that they like it
for three main reasons, the top three.
Uh, and this was true in May, and it
continues to be true at the end of August.
It's the personalization.
So the way we see them using
it, they're taking pictures of
themselves, of their spaces.
They're giving it a ton of personal data.
But what they're getting back are
highly curated shopping lists that
only are re- are relevant to them.
And the second is it compares
prices, it finds deals.
We know that there-- you can search
for a discount or coupon code
through these services, and it'll
go scour and find them for you.
Um, we're still in a price-sensitive
economic environment, um, and so this
is another tool in the consumer tool
belt to help stretch their dollar.
And then the third is, is
just does a lot of research.
So the actual purchasing part is not
as prevalent or as sought after yet.
And right now it really is about
the data and the information.
But what is interesting is when
we look at the behavioral data, so
actually what's happening on e-commerce
sites, when we look at referrals
from LLMs, they are the most highly
qualified traffic that we see today.
So traffic that comes from a LLM or a,
a ChatGPT or a Perplexity or you name it
referral, it converts 700% better than
social media referrals and 200% better
than any other form of traffic, so direct
or, um, traditional search, um, digital
media advertising, you know, you name it.
And so the traffic that does come to
an e-commerce website from these search
tools is highly motivated, incredibly
valuable, and I'll also add that
they're way more engaged on site too.
So they spend more time on site
than the average site visitor, but
especially the social media visitor.
Um, they spend about 137% more
time on an e-commerce website.
So they crave information.
When they get the right information,
they are much more likely to convert.
And so, um, it is still a small percentage
of overall traffic, but when we think
about the possibilities, um, and the
opportunity, it, it, it's really massive.
Yeah.
I got in an argument over this
too, so I need you to just, like,
be my wing woman on LinkedIn.
So I'll- … I'll, I'll go, I'll go stir
up a fight and then you can go and, like,
hit them with, over the head with data.
It'll, it'll be, it'll be lots of fun.
I got data for days, so.
It gets tiresome.
I, I kind of gave up finally.
I was like, "All right, don't believe it."
Um, the, uh…
So anything in Q3 that, around agents,
or that was more broad e-commerce?
Um, that was more, broad e-commerce,
we're seeing some, some good positive
growth, um, in e-commerce overall.
So we saw e-commerce sales grow
about 5% in Q3, which is up from
the 4% growth we saw in Q2, which is
way up from the flat, flat growth,
basically no growth we saw in Q1.
So we are seeing an acceleration,
um, in sales, which is great.
Um, what I can say in the agent
space in Q3, we are s- continuing to
see those accelerations of traffic.
A lot of the continuation
of the same trends.
Um, a lot more traffic.
In fact, the first half of the year,
traffic from, um, agentic search
sources or AI search grew about 119%
year over year, which, you know,
again, thinking about where we were
last year, not surprising that it's
gonna grow at significant rates.
Um, but again, highly qualified.
Something that we are seeing, which
is interesting- Is that every single,
at this point I wanna say it's every
single week, but we'll look at it.
If we look at it on a monthly basis, the
rate of this traffic that makes it to a
product detail page continues to go up.
So one of the things we observed
the very early days of this, late
last year, beginning of this year,
was that we were seeing traffic,
but it wasn't going anywhere.
It wasn't going to the
right place on the website.
And so what we know about e-commerce
is if you're not getting to the right
page right off the bat, the likelihood
that you're gonna leave is pretty high.
But as we've gone through the year,
and as we know a lot of these platforms
have made a ton of investment in
their commerce strategy, the rate
of that traffic that does land on a
product detail page continues to grow.
And this is also, um, interesting
because social media referrals are
actually the most likely traffic
to land on a product detail page.
So we're starting to inch closer
to what we see with social media,
which is it's getting to the right
place, but it converts a heck of a
lot better, um, than social media.
So, um, we're continuing to see that
grow and evolve in Q3, and I think
as we get to Q4, or I guess we're
now we're in Q4, but as we get to the
holidays, um, we're gonna see more.
We're-- A- a- and holidays is always
a, a, a moment of change, right?
A moment of acceleration in trends.
So w- we anticipate that this will just…
It's gonna, it's gonna be very,
very important this holiday.
Yeah.
That's interesting.
I like how you're comparing
it to social media.
It's kind of a good comp because Google,
Google traffic's its own thing, right?
Um, I wonder, do you have a theory of why
it converts better and is more engaged and
stays on site more than the social media?
Like, what's your-
That's a great question.
You know, social is so interesting
'cause it drives so much traffic and
discovery, but my sense on social media
traffic is that these shoppers are at
the very beginning of their journey.
They're discovering you or your product
for the first time, and so- The, you
know, the idea of, uh, and especially
at certain price points, right?
You're not gonna impulse buy
something that you just discover.
You're curious about it.
You're gonna do some more research.
You're gonna go to the page,
but you're gonna follow up.
You're going to do more research
on that product before you
ultimately end up buying.
And so what I think with social
media is that those spl- the…
It does really well with the types of
products that are low price point, easy
entry, you know, under $20, low risk.
But if you have a higher price point,
you're, as a consumer, just knowing
myself, you're gonna do more research
before you make that purchase.
So, um, it's a discovery engine.
It's incredibly valuable and very
important, but it's not a conversion,
um, engine yet for most brands.
And so what's different with these AI
search tools is that you are, I believe,
much further along in the journey.
You're asking more nuanced questions.
You're getting more information.
And likely by the time you've
hit that product detail page,
you've already engaged with that
agent, that ChatGPT or whoever,
whatever your product you're using.
You've already engaged with that
and asked a ton of follow-ups, and
you've gotten a lot more information.
And so by the time you do
hit that product detail page,
you're, you're ready to convert.
Um, and so it again, highly qualified,
which goes back to, you know, thinking
about your SEO strategy, or now I
guess we're calling it AEO strategy,
how important that now is going to
be because y- you're gonna wanna make
sure that your, the information that's
being shared to that end user on these
channels is accurate and is going to
convert them because they're likely
doing all of their research there.
Preaching to the choir.
That's, uh, that's what my company does,
not to insert an ad there, but yeah.
The, uh- So the 21%,
so it's the theme of…
So now I'm going back to holiday.
Sorry, I'm bouncing around.
Uh, I just get curious about these
things and take little side journeys.
Um, anything else in Q3
before we go back to holiday?
Absolutely.
Yeah, we can go back to holiday.
We can, we can, we can bounce around.
I'm cool with bouncing.
So the theme is discovery and the,
and you're kind of saying 21%.
Is there, is that kind
of like touched by AI?
So this is for my definition, people.
So it, it's like influenced
by AI kind of a thing.
Influence.
It's like an attribution model.
Gotcha.
I gotcha.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah.
Okay.
That makes sense.
Absolutely.
Um, and then to your, to your point
about that, that dramatic change, they
didn't start showing the product cards.
We call them product cards,
the little, little…
I'm sure you've seen them.
Um, uh, and, you know, Perplexity's had
them for a while, and then ChatGPT's
just really added them, uh, you know,
kind of like w- mid Q1, and then they
tweaked them with five when it came out.
Um, so you wouldn't really end up getting
too much further down the funnel, 'cause
the experience was really good in the
research part, and then in the find part,
it just kinda like had a couple of blurbs.
It's like, "If I were you, I'd
go check Amazon and Target."
And you're like, "Okay, well, that's…
Yeah, thanks for doing that for me.
Can, can you do that for me?"
Right.
So then now they've actually put a
fair amount of investment into find
in Q3 and, and a little bit of Q2,
and then in Q4, obviously, with the
checkout, they're working on the
bottom piece, which is the buy part.
So it's gonna be interesting to see how
fast this starts showing up in your data.
Oh, yeah.
I'm excited for it.
And, you know, I've been talking to so
many customers recently about this topic.
It's such a huge topic of conversation at
the moment, and, um, everyone is asking,
you know, "How can, how can we do this?
How do we embed in ChatGPT?"
Um, and so, uh, speaking of Dreamforce,
it was really exciting last week to
be able to come to our customers and
say, "Okay, now we have a solution,
and we're gonna have this integration
now with, uh, ChatGPT, um, to, you
know, embed that buy button and sh-
have your product catalog show up at
that point of discovery and research."
Um, and so this is just
going to be really powerful.
So I think s- once we start to see that
become more embedded, as you said, in
that in-chat type of, um, journey versus
just like, "Here, click out to a link,"
or, "Go to the store, figure it out," um,
it's just going to continue to take off.
Um, and so yeah, this…
It's so exciting.
What I think is also really cool,
Scott, and I don't know if you've
seen this at all in your data, but…
And the, and the reason why I say this is
going to be a fundamental transformation
within commerce is that these tools
are not just being used online.
Um, 57% of our, um, survey respondents
said that they're using these
tools while they're in the store.
So 50, 57% of AI users are chatting with
an AI assistant while they're shopping
through a brick-and-mortar store.
And for our Gen Zs and millennials,
they're more likely to engage with
the AI agent than they-- in the store,
than they are with the store associate.
Um, and so when we think about how
the in-store journey is also going
to be impacted by these tools, and
then the downstream impact of that
too, because they're taking pictures
and they're asking follow-ups, and
they're asking for recommendations,
and they're comparing prices.
And so if you think of you're taking
a picture of a product shelf, what
other products are around your product?
How does that impact the results?
Um, and I think the downstream impacts of
this are going to be beyond what we even
know, definitely within the digital space,
but also in the physical space, which
makes this just really mind-blowing to me.
Yeah, I have a fun use case for that.
My dogs love bully sticks, uh, and they
get one bully stick every other day.
Um, and the pet store has a big wall of
them, and it was, like, so confusing.
So I just took a picture and said, you
know, "Help me pick the best bully stick."
And it was like, "Bottom
row, second from the left."
And it had done the math on,
like, you know, the length of the
bully stick, the dollars per in…
It all…
It, it actually, like, do the calculations
out too if I wanted to see them.
But it was pretty neat how it just, like,
s- you know, within seconds told me the
best bully stick, so it was very helpful.
That
is helpful.
I don't know if it tasted the best,
but, um, the dogs seemed to like it, so.
And just think about too, like, you're in
a rush, you're in a store, you don't wanna
flag down a store associate, you know.
Like, it's just so much, so easy.
Get all the information.
And
it was complicated, like these four purple
box ones had a BOGO, but then they looked
like they were maybe twice as much as…
You, you know how it is
in some of these stores.
There's, like, this mental
gymnastics you have to go through.
Totally.
I used it, um, when I was in the
home improvement store, 'cause I was
painting a piece of furniture, and
I had, like, my inspiration picture.
But my problem is I get way too
carried away, and I'm like, "Okay,
I gotta go buy all the supplies."
And I knew the type of wood that I was
painting, but, like, that's the only thing
I had to figure it out at that point.
And so I said, "Okay, this is the type
of wood, and this is the picture, what
I want it to look like, and this is
the brand of paint I'm going to buy.
Tell me what shade o- of this
paint, what supplies do I need?"
And, um, it was really cool.
It gave me a bunch of options and,
like, different, like, mixtures I
could make and, like, if I wanted it
to look, have, like, a little bit more
of an this undertone or that undertone.
It was, it was really cool, so.
Yeah.
Always forget glossy and flat.
Yeah.
I know, I think walls are flat and
furniture's glossy, but I don't know.
Yes.
Yes.
Personal preference, I guess.
Okay.
Um, so let's look at the, the big…
So that, that's, that's good to
kind of, you know, zoom in on that.
Let's zoom out, and what's the
overall holiday forecast looking like?
Yeah.
It's, it's gonna be w- we're anticipating,
based on our models, um, about a 4%
growth worldwide in digital sales, um,
which is equaling out to about $1.25
trillion in spend between
November 1st and December 31st.
And then in the US,
we're anticipating 2.1%
growth, or about 288 billion.
Um, what I'm really thinking, though, is
with the interest rate cuts in September
here in the US, we could potentially
see a little bit higher numbers.
We- we'll see how that nets out,
but, um, what we are seeing out of
Europe right now is really impressive.
Europe is growing very rapidly- And
it started in Q2, and Europe as a
region as a whole had several interest,
interest rate cuts in the spring.
And since then, we've seen the region
overall grew by 8% in Q2 and 10% in Q3.
And Europe had been
struggling for a long time.
And so what's happening out of Europe,
knowing that they had those cuts
and the potential it could have here
in the US knowing that we had one,
we're supposed to get two more before
the end of the year, we could see
a lot of buying power come back for
just in time for the holiday season.
Yeah.
Good.
Hopefully the…
I think most of the tariff stuff's
kind of quieted down, but the Chinese
one I think is, like, a big one.
Obviously, we get a lot of, a
lot of these types of things from
there, so we'll see how that goes.
I'm not a tariff expert.
So let's, let's kind of take that
two perc- two percent-ish for the US.
How does that compare to last year?
Is it kind of a slowdown from
last year, kind of about the same?
Kind of about the same.
Um, I believe last year we saw … Last
year, I believe we also projected 2%.
I think we ended up seeing
3%, if I remember correctly.
So it was within the ballpark,
but, um, very similar.
We are seeing an acceleration
in US sales at the moment.
So if we look at Q1, sales were
down about 2% year over year.
Q2, it went flat, and then Q3 we're up 2%.
So, um, July and August
were really great months.
September was a little bit more flat,
but, um, the summer was really strong.
We are seeing in our sentiment
data that the US consumer has a
ton of pent-up demand The consumer
has really been holding back on
spend for the last 18 to 24 months.
And just because they're not buying
doesn't mean they don't want or need
the items that they aren't buying.
They're just waiting for
the right opportunity.
And what we're seeing at the moment
is more American consumers especially
saying, "Okay, I, I need to start,
you know, I need a new couch.
I need a new fridge.
I, I need a new pair of shoes."
And we actually saw a 20% increase in
the rate of US consumers reporting that
they're buying more in the last few
months between the end of August and May.
And we do see that in the data, right?
We saw a lift between flat growth
and a 2% increase, um, in Q3.
So the data kind of nets out, like
very well cor- correlates to what
we're seeing in that sentiment data.
Um, we also know that American consumers
and global consumers say they're
back to prioritizing physical goods.
So we ask shoppers to rank where their
disposable income is going, and last
year, savings was at the top of the list.
In fact, we asked, asked it three
times, and each time it was savings.
But this year, it has switched
back to physical goods.
So savings is still number
two, but I think what we're
seeing is that pent-up demand.
Shoppers are saying, "Okay,
I, you know, I can't hold off
on these purchases anymore."
When you say physical goods, is
that implying like, like hard,
hard lines kind of thing, or
soft lines are included in that?
Like, like apparel counts
as a physical good- Yep
kind of just like- Exactly … okay.
Just like- Yeah … not digital goods.
Okay.
E- exactly, not digital.
Or experiences.
Um-
Ah, yeah
… so
like
vacations- Tickets,
travel … restaurants.
Yeah.
Cool.
So it'll be interesting to see kind of
if we start to pace faster than that.
How…
Remind me, when you guys get into
holiday mode, I know you typically do
a drop kind of like after, um, Black
Friday and Thanksgiving, and then kind
of another one after Cyber Monday.
Is that kind of, am I remembering
that right, or is, is that
kind of the plan this year?
Yeah.
So we will start publishing data actually
the, the, either the Tuesday or Wednesday.
Have to speak to the web team about
this, but on the official date.
But the week of Cyber Week we'll
start publishing data, um, and
it'll go back through October.
So the week of Cyber Week, we'll
publish all of our October and early
November data, and then, um, that
week we'll do daily data drops.
So, um, starting on Tuesday, Wednesday,
Thursday, all through Cyber Monday.
Um, and then we'll also be publishing, you
know, our findings and what we're seeing.
So that will also come too.
So we'll have a little bit
more color to the story.
But we publish dashboards actually
on our, on salesforce.com,
our holiday insights dashboard.
So if you just wanna get the data,
the pure data, it, it's all there.
Um, and it, you can filter it by country,
by vertical, um, and we're gonna have,
we're gonna have a lot of AI data.
So we're gonna have a section just
for AI and what we're seeing with
agents, um, what we're seeing on
discovery, purchase, customer service.
Um, and then we're also going
to have like BOPIS and returns,
so we'll have all of that there.
Very cool.
I, uh, we did a fair amount of that
at ChannelAdvisor back in the day,
and, uh, I learned don't do that
again because I don't envy you.
You know, your, your, the, the turkey's
coming out of the oven and like suddenly
a big data drop comes and you gotta run
to your computer and do an analysis and,
you know, put some thoughts together.
It's, it's very hard to process
all that going on at the same time.
Kinda, kind of takes a little bit of
the gloss off of, of Thanksgiving.
It's a hustle, that's for sure.
One year, actually, my oven broke
the night before Thanksgiving-
Yeah … and I do this, I've been
doing this now for so many years, eight
or nine years, and, you know, we're
up at 3:00 or 4:00 in the morning.
We're so tired.
And my oven broke, and I was
cooking my turkey in a slow
cooker, like in my Crockpot.
Thankfully, I have a very large Crockpot.
But, um, never again.
After that, I was like, "Okay,
that was way too stressful."
We just, we, we cater.
We get, we get, you know, the
local, you know, barbecue place.
S- seems like a good reason for
your husband to try to do that,
uh, that deep fry one, you know.
Every- everyone I know that
does that, they start a giant
fire in the neighborhood.
I'm like, I'm-
That's just how
we do- That's, I'm the
guy that'll happen to me.
Fire.
Yeah, yeah.
House is on fire and I'm just
trying to get the data out.
I just gotta publish the data
firemen are trying to drag you out.
So your, your predecessor, Rob, I, I
got to see him at Retail Club and I
got a Garfie, so that was exciting.
Um, so he kinda introduced me to this
concept of what he called discount
chicken, where, where the consumer and
the retailer kinda wait each other out
and, and then, you know, uh, ultimately
the retailer has to cave because the,
you know, the, the goods become, you
know, a- as you get into those past the,
the Cyber Week, uh, you know, you, you
kinda need to liquidate them and get
them out of the stores and everything.
Um, any, any things you guys are
predicting on the biggest discount day
or what, you know, the whole f- you
know, is this gonna be more discounts
than last year or kinda similar?
Yeah.
We, we are gonna have more discounts.
So we're projecting about a one full
percentage point increase in the
average discount rate for every region.
Um, it, it, it, both across the season
and then especially for Cyber Week.
Um, so w- what we learned, um,
last Cyber Week was that…
Or maybe what I should say, what
the industry learned is that
shoppers were wanting deals.
And this is probably the clearest example
of discount chicken we've ever seen.
And so I was a little bummed that Rob
wasn't there to, to experience that
with me because it was incredible.
Um, for the first time ever, we saw
the average discount rate The highest
average discount rate to not be in Cyber
Week, at least in the digital world.
Um, any guesses on when that day was?
Uh, last day for free shipping?
Was that, like, the 19th or 20th?
N- nope.
It was the Tuesday after Cyber Monday.
If you waited until the Tuesday
after Cyber Monday, you got a better
deal than you would've gotten if you
purchased on either of those two days,
which is something we've never seen.
What we have seen is
discounts have stuck around.
So let's say Cyber Monday's average
discount was 30%, the Tuesday after
might be 26 or 25, which is still
much higher than the average for
the season, which is about 22%.
But we've never seen it be higher
than any other day during Cyber Week.
What I do know about last year was that,
and I, I alluded to this before, highly
price-sensitive shoppers told us that
they were waiting for Cyber Week to make a
lot of their purchases that they had been
holding out for for a lot of the year.
And in fact, Cyber Week
was a year, was a…
Last year, we saw the fastest
growing channels were for products
like, um, appliances, furniture,
um, items that people really needed
but wanted to get a deal on, and
so they waited until Cyber Week.
And so what we saw was that a lot of
retailers didn't come out with their
best foot forward during the week, and
so shoppers held onto their wallets.
And what ended up happening?
Discount chicken.
They waited, they sat, and
ultimately it led to another day
of even better discounting, um,
after Cyber Week had already ended.
And so, um, if there's any lesson
in there for this year, I would say
come out with your best foot forward.
Um, you know, the sho- the shoppers are
most attentive during Cyber Week, and so
you're going to get the most eyeballs,
the most attention in that period, and you
don't wanna have to be playing catch up
to recoup those sales that didn't happen.
And so, you know, come out
with your best and final.
Um, and, and w- we're still in that
price sensitive environment as 2024.
Even though we're seeing some economic
tailwinds that are good, good signs, a lot
of those behaviors are sticking around.
And so if we see similar patterns to
last year, which I don't anticipate we're
seeing based on what we're modeling right
now, but if we do, um, it could mean that
some people feel like they missed out
on, on demand because they were, they
didn't come out with their best and final.
Interesting.
I wonder if it'll…
If the consumer will continue to
play the game and push it back
to, like, Wednesday or something.
You could see that happening.
'Cause sometimes it's in the re- and
you could argue it's in the retailer's
best interest to start high and
then kind of walk it down and, like,
you know, there, there used to be a
thing called Filene's Basement, and
that was their liquidation strategy.
It's pretty clever because it, it's
kind of like the game of chicken because
ultimately the consumer starts to worry
that it's gonna get gone, as we would say.
It will, you know, they will sell out.
And, uh, so yeah.
So it'll be interesting to see
how that plays out this year.
Well, the als- the other thing you
have to keep in mind too is that
shoppers will return and buy again.
So if you try to play too many games
over Cyber Week with your discount
strategy, they'll just buy it again and
then they'll return the other purchase.
And so that is gonna
cost your balance sheets.
So just don't play games, and be
really strategic about your strategy,
um, really clear, and hon- and, and
communicate about your promotional
strategy with your customers.
I think what we've…
If there's anything that I saw last
year, there was a lot of frustration
from consumers because, um, they just
didn't understand what the strategy was.
Um, anecdotally, there was one brand I was
seeing that was doing a lot of advertising
on, on Facebook, and they were coming
out with different deals, but no one knew
on the day what the deal was going to
be, and there was no real clear upfront
like, "Are you going to be offering a
site-wide discount or is it only going to
be like a different product every day?"
And so shoppers ended up waiting
to see if the product they wanted
would go on sale or not, and a lot
of people were frustrated 'cause
they were like, "I don't know.
I just feel like I can't plan."
Um, and so, you know, that sort of
frustration puts, turns people off and it
makes, it, it just adds to the frustration
of the week and they'll just go elsewhere.
Um, and so just being, I think, really
clear with your, with your audience about
what your strategy is can go a long way.
Yeah.
I feel like as a shopper, I
feel like they don't know.
They're just kinda like, "Oh
boy, we didn't sell enough.
We're gonna lower it again."
It's kinda like they're throwing
a dartboard on the other side.
So yeah.
Which is funny because then I'm, in the
industry I know they have all these, like,
analytical software things that are doing-
Yeah … yeah, I don't know what they're
doing, but they're not, they're not
communicating across, across the aisle.
Exactly.
Exactly.
And shoppers wanna be able to
plan, they wanna be able to know,
and they, they, they're waiting.
They're still holding onto those
same trends of last year, which
is, "I'm waiting for Cyber Week."
And also something to keep in mind
too is that Cyber Week is not just
a moment for gift buying anymore.
It's a moment where shoppers are
buying the things that they need
too, that they just were able to
hold out on because for those deals.
Yeah.
And so, you know, thinking about how
you're catering to those specific
shoppers as well is also really important.
It's not just a gift buying moment.
It's a good time to buy a vacuum
cleaner, but not as a Christmas gift.
I've learned that the hard way.
Just kidding.
Yeah.
Thankfully I know not to do that.
I know we only have you for
about five more minutes.
Anything, you know, a- any-
anything around loyalty?
I know you write a good
bit about loyalty programs.
Anything interesting going on
there, um, kind of tied into
holiday or just in general?
We're seeing a lot of
consolidation in the market.
Um, consumers are staying more loyal
to their favorite brands and retailers.
Um- And we're seeing the rate
of repeat buyers continue to
increase every single quarter.
So there's a lot of consolidation
happening across the market.
A lot of that is being driven by
what's happening with loyalty programs.
Um, so again, price-sensitive
environment, loyalty programs are
another way for the consumer to extract
value out of their transactions.
And in fact, in our data, we found
in regions like the UK … Or sorry,
not the UK, Australia and Canada.
Australia and Canada are unique because
those consumers are feeling a lot
more economic pain than the US, than
most of Europe, uh, Latin America.
And so what we're seeing in those
consumers is they're leaning heavily
into loyalty programs as a way to
unlock more discounts or more benefit.
Um, and so a lot of that
is driving consolidation.
I'm gonna do more of my purchases at
the same location so that I can unlock
those discounts or tiers or whatever.
Um, and so that is absolutely playing…
I mean, it's happening right now.
We're even seeing loyalty
improve over the holiday period.
So if we were to look at the rate
We track loyalty by the
rate of repeat buyers.
And if you were to look at that rate
on a quarterly basis throughout the
year, Q4, we see the lowest amount
of repeat buyers because, you know,
you're gift buying, you're buying from
brands you wouldn't normally buy from.
But even over holidays, we're
seeing that number go up.
So we are seeing consolidation
over the holiday period.
What we are anticipating this holiday
is that loyalty in particular, so where
a consumer chooses to buy, loyalty
programs definitely, free shipping is
another top, um, factor, lower prices,
and then, um, better product quality.
Um, so going back to the comment about
tariffs, um, the de minimis exemption
ending and, and there being a lot of
unknowns around if I import a product
from abroad, will I pay an import fee?
Will I be responsible for that?
Well, I don't want to.
Um, so I'm not gonna do that.
I'm not gonna import cheap goods,
kind of like what we saw with last
year with the rise of Temu and Shein.
Um, so they're saying,
"Hey, I'm gonna buy it.
If I'm gonna pay more for it,
I want it to be good quality."
So we're seeing a re-emphasis on quality.
But our prediction is that loyal
shoppers will spend about 20% more than
the average, average shopper or new
first time buyer, um, with a specific
brand this, this holiday season.
So they're becoming our most
lucrative audience, um, and most
important, uh, customer segment.
Last question.
Any interesting demographic things that
are popping out at you in the data?
You mentioned some baby boomers starting
to think about using the, the AIs.
Uh, how about the other side?
What are the little Gen Z-ers up to?
Well, the baby boomers are adopting
Gen Z behavior, and the Gen Zs
are adopting baby boomer behavior.
Oh, no.
They're wearing the big sunglasses
and putting on the, the bucket hats.
They're definitely putting
on the bucket hats.
Um, we're seeing Gen Z really show
preference for, uh, brick-and-mortar
retail, and which is interesting, right?
'Cause it's, like, the antithesis
of everything we've been
told about this generation.
And I don't know about you, but I feel
like we tend to typecast generations
into these molds, and then we get
surprised when they shift and change.
Like, I see…
I have three gen alphas, and, like, I
see, have, like, already the theories
about what this generation is going
to be, and I'm like, "But there's…
Mine are all so different," and,
like, I just don't see this.
Um, but anyway.
So with Gen Z, they're
going back to the store.
We've…
And you could argue that maybe it's a
fluke in our data, but we've been seeing
this consistently, this shift, I wanna
say maybe the past 24 to 36 months.
But every single time we poll about
the store, Gen Z is showing more
and more interest, and I'm curious
what you're seeing in your area.
I was in Atlanta a few weeks ago, and I
was in Buckhead, and I went to the sto-
the mall on a Tuesday, and it was packed.
Tuesday evening, it was packed.
High school kids everywhere,
and it was like, this was weird.
But I don't know, maybe that was just
a use, like a s- use case of one.
But they really wanna be
back in physical retail.
I think, uh, I have a 18-year-old, and
they, the, the COVID kids kinda crave
in-person interaction and going somewhere
with their friends, and they do the online
thing, and they're very, you know, she'll
order a lip gloss thingy on TikTok in five
seconds, and, you know, constant random
packages showing up with that stuff.
But yeah, she loves to, like, go out
with some of her friends to, uh, you
know, there's always a, a routine of,
you know, hitting a, a couple of the
clothes stores, and then gotta hit
Sephora or Ulta, uh, more beauty products.
So yeah.
But, you know, they'll just go there for,
like, an hour and a half and just try on
everything and talk about stuff, and yeah.
So there's a, there's largely…
It's kinda like what we did
as kids in my generation.
It's like the malls are kind of
like a social kind of a thing.
Yeah.
You know, so, so it's interesting to
see that kinda coming back a little bit.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's, um, it's exciting.
I think, though, what is different
is, again, the social aspect.
It's going to be a little bit
more, more experience-driven.
This is a very experience-
inclined generation.
They like, you know, when we look at
loyalty programs, you know, what baby
boomers like is, in a loyalty program is
stacking points and getting discounts.
What Gen Z likes in a loyalty program
are experiences and unlocking like
different like in-store or, you know,
whatever type of experience they offer.
They lean more towards that.
And so it's going to be interesting
to see how the mall evolves with this
generation, but also how the mall
will change because we know that the
way they shop in-store is different.
Like they're on their
social media feeds in-store.
They're chatting with an
AI assistant in-store.
So how does that traditional model
shift as these digital natives
gravitate to traditional models, but
use them in a much more nuanced way
and engage with them differently.
So there's a lot of oppor- a lot of
exciting change, I think, happening
in this space, and time will only tell
to see how it nets out, but that's, uh
They like, they like to go to the mall.
I think this now gives you a
built-in excuse to go to the
mall and count teenagers and, you
know, go buy some beauty products
and expense it to Salesforce.
Get, get, uh, get Mr.
Benioff to pay for it.
Well, you know, I don't have a mall here.
There's no mall.
I know.
We have, like, an out- an
outdoor outlet mall, but- There's
one, Mount Pleasant.
Uh, isn't there, like, a mall in…
Is it Mount Pleasant?
Uh, Mount Pleasant Mall is actually
a ven- it's an antique store.
Ah, okay.
Yeah.
I've actually been there.
Which
I love.
That's a great store.
Um, um, I, yeah, that's a lot of fun,
but- King Street.
King Street counts.
King Street, yeah.
That's true.
King Street is a, is a fun…
And there's a ton of new stores coming
to King Street, so that's been fun.
But-
There's a little candle store
on one of the corners where you
can, like, make your own candles.
It's like a swarm of Gen Z-ers.
It's like, 'cause it's so experiential
and they just love to take Insta
shots of it, the, the whole, while
the candle's being made and stuff.
Yeah.
It's a, this, yeah.
There's a shop on King Street where
you can also make your own perfume.
Mm-hmm.
Yep, seen
that one.
Yeah.
You can, like, make your…
Yeah, yeah.
Speaking of experiential retail,
there's a ton of that on King Street.
All the ice creams and things either
have to catch on fire or have some
gimmick where they roll or they're
frozen with a nitrous oxide or something.
It's like…
Does everything have to be experiential?
It's crazy.
It's funny how smart retailers
are about this stuff.
It is.
It's, it's true.
Even, even, like, um, like the jewelry
stores now, like, I mean, I guess
Claire's was always doing this, but
the new jewelry stores, I've noticed,
at least on King Street, are more
centered around the experience of,
like, getting a new piercing, and
then, like, the jewelry's secondary.
You buy the jewelry on the side,
but the experience is, like, getting
a new ear piercing or whatever.
Um, and so there's so
much more of that now.
And there's permanent bracelets
that are sized just perfect for you.
They last, like, a week, but
they're permanent, so you have to
go through this whole sizing thing.
Yeah.
But when you think about it- W- it's
experiential, but it's also w- when
we think on the retailer side, how
important now their data's gonna be-
going to become, because they're gonna
have to continue to deliver on that
online experience but in the store.
So how do you make it personalized?
How do you make it, um, how do you
make that Gen Zer feel unique when
they shop in the store as they
do when they're shopping online?
And so the, the idea of having a unified
commerce strategy and a unified data
strategy is even more important now,
especially because this generation is
going to potentially be the largest
consumer generation on the planet.
And so h- how retailers rethink their
overall strategies, connecting that
online and offline journey, um, is going
to become more, more of a larger part
of their strategy in the years ahead.
Gotta feed the Gen Z-ers.
Well, I'll be working for them someday.
Or they'll be taking care of us.
Well, thanks for all the insights, Kayla.
This was amazing.
I learned a ton.
Um, if…
I, I know you're super busy during the
holiday, but if, if you see any cool
agentic things and you wanna pop in,
just even if it's for five minutes, and
chat with us about it, we'd love to chat
with you then, but I know you're busy.
And hopefully you get time to, to make
the, the turkey the proper way this year.
So I hope, I hope all that lines up
for you and all your data is good,
and your, your drops are such that
you can have a bit of a Thanksgiving.
So I know it's hard being on,
on your side of the fence there.
I appreciate that, Scott.
Well, um, I would absolutely
love to come back and share
the agentic data that we have.
We are pl- literally planning that as
we speak, so we're, we're figuring out
what we're gonna have and, um, working
through all those data sources right now.
So we're gonna have some good stories
to tell and love to, to share.
Awesome.
Sounds good.
Well, until we see you around during
the Cyber Week, um, have a great time
and thanks for coming on the pod.
Thanks, Scott.
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with RetailGenic, your guide
to the future of AI shopping agents.