10 minutes of expert insights every weekday. Your morning ritual for staying ahead in retail media.
Pressure Test Nift
===
[00:00:00] Kiri: The honeymoon is over, so everyone in retail media says. The easy money is gone. What they mean is that on-site sponsored product ads, the first lever that most retailers pull, is running out of juice. A [00:00:15] lot of these platforms are at a saturation point. So the leaders who are tasked with growing this lucrative media business are looking for the next thing, the next pot of gold.
[00:00:28] Is that off-site [00:00:30] audience extension? Is that putting screens in stores? Well, all of those options are viable, but there are trade-offs. They're low margin, or they are expensive and slow to deploy, or they need a dedicated, [00:00:45] expensive sales team to bring in advertiser demand, or all three.
[00:00:50] But there is a new idea out there that is potentially a win for the advertiser, a win for the commerce media network, and a win for the [00:01:00] customer. It's called Nyft, and the biggest barrier to retailers adopting it, according to its CEO and founder, Ellery Pfeffer, In his words, "The biggest objection is that it is too good to be true."
[00:01:14] So [00:01:15] is it? Let's dig in. As a quick disclaimer, this video was commissioned by Nyft to give an independent assessment of its commerce media offering. They brought me in knowing that I'd include my usual spicy take, [00:01:30] and that I'd be asking people in retail media for anonymous feedback. That's why I'm calling this video a pressure test.
[00:01:38] Now, this isn't the first time that I've had nice things to say about Nyft. A year ago, I wrote about [00:01:45] the company in a column for The Drum on the ways that retailers could rely less on on-site search ads.
[00:01:53] We need models for the future that are not going to be disrupted by AI agents who are pulling the [00:02:00] customer journey forward a few steps. Nift style placements sit in moments that AI shopping agents are unlikely to disrupt,
[00:02:10] and gifts that are tied to reviews and genuine [00:02:15] experience create the kind of customer content that AI models look for when they recommend products. So that's what I wrote about a year ago now. And one more piece of context, Nift works across commerce media well beyond [00:02:30] retail.
[00:02:31] They work with payment apps, fitness brands, travel, much more. But this is the Retail Media Breakfast Club, so I'm asking the question I was brought in to answer: where, when, and how does this make sense for a retail media [00:02:45] network? And where doesn't it?
[00:02:46] So what is Nyft? It's a marketplace. On one side, we have brands. They want net new customers, and they're prepared to pay for them by offering a gift to get people to try them out.
[00:02:59] On the [00:03:00] other side, we have partners, retailers, and other businesses with customers. They want ad revenue, but not if it messes with their existing ad partners, their sales conversions, their loyalty program, or the customer experience.
[00:03:14] [00:03:15] Nift lets brands offer gifts as a surprise and delight moment in the customer journey.
[00:03:21] Saket Mehta, CRO @ Nift: Rating an experience, uh, checking into a gym, um, your anniversary with that, with that s- you know, [00:03:30] specific, uh, brand, when you get an item delivered and rating it, right? Making a repayment that's coming in.
[00:03:36] Kiri: As founder Ellery told me, " You're never gonna give your customer a happy birthday ad, but you would give a gift." so the brand [00:03:45] wins, they get a new customer, and the customer wins 'cause they just got a gift, and the retailer, well, they never paid for the gift that made their customer happy, and they get a split of what the brand paid to be there.
[00:03:58] Saket Mehta, who [00:04:00] is Nift's chief revenue officer, used to sit on the other side of the table running advertising partnerships and revenue at Block
[00:04:08] Saket Mehta, CRO @ Nift: what I've always wanted, being on the other side and owning, you know, revenue, um, [00:04:15] goals at a, at a commerce media company is, how do I make the ad not feel like an ad,
[00:04:20] Kiri: Now, one retailer I spoke with raised a fair concern. Could this be a negative experience for their customers?
[00:04:27] After looking into it, I don't think so. [00:04:30] End customers, by and large, seem to really love Nift. Most consumers say that they hate ads, and sure, there's a good argument that they only really dislike disruptive, irrelevant ads, and that the relevant ones [00:04:45] can actually be quite good. Just ask my bathroom cabinet, which is bursting with late-night Instagram purchases.
[00:04:51] But a gift is different, especially when it arrives as a surprise rather than a reward. Lauren Didone, Nift's [00:05:00] director of client success and growth, told me that a gift occupies a different part of your brain.
[00:05:06] Here's what she told me. She said that if you get ten percent off at a restaurant, that's an obligation to spend, but a thirty dollar [00:05:15] credit to try a new restaurant is a gift. And Planet Fitness, who is a current Nift partner, is very deliberate about this
[00:05:23] Justin Unger, Director of Partnerships @ Planet Fitness: we are, um, committed to our members and our member experience. Um, and what we have [00:05:30] found is that Nift is a great way to bring-- uh, extend value and bring additional satisfaction beyond the four walls of our club. we don't wanna be directing them or giving kind of our stamp of approval on a [00:05:45] partner experience that is less than ideal. And so we're very mindful of are our members still actually redeeming the gifts when they do enter that experience?
[00:05:55] And the answer is yes.
[00:05:56] Kiri: The retailer Foot Locker sees the same thing [00:06:00] after a purchase. Speaking at a Nyft session at Cannes this year, Laura Loesch, Foot Locker's head of media, said that ninety percent of customers that get a Nyft gift say that they love the experience, and they want to come back to Foot Locker [00:06:15] again. In Nyft's spring twenty-twenty-six survey of more than three thousand one hundred consumers, eighty-two percent said that this way of discovering new brands is better than ads, search, or social, and the [00:06:30] experience rates four point eight on Trustpilot.
[00:06:34] Saket Mehta, CRO @ Nift: it's fully opt-in. If the customer doesn't want to engage, they wanna look at it later, they have the opportunity to do that, and they can ignore it, or they can en-engage at that moment of [00:06:45] time.
[00:06:45] Kiri: Now, the reviews do have one recurring complaint, and that is gifts with a minimum spend. That makes a gift feel a bit more like a coupon sometimes. And brands often push back on giving big discounts, but Nyft [00:07:00] holds the line at a minimum of fifty percent off. Its matching algorithm also gives more exposure to the gifts that people actually choose and use, and the partners who are hosting these gifts get to approve which brands [00:07:15] and offers actually appear.
[00:07:16] For a partner, the experience is only as good as the gifts on offer. A high bar protects it, but it could also mean fewer offers and less revenue, and that's a trade-off that each partner will have to [00:07:30] weigh. Now, here's what I think is one of the biggest advantages for the partner side.
[00:07:34] Nyft brings its own demand, net new non-endemic advertisers. Retailers don't need to go out and sell this to their existing [00:07:45] advertisers. Nyft already has the demand coming in, and my read is that there's more demand from advertisers than supply from platforms, which might be a problem for Nyft, but it's kind of great for retailers.
[00:07:57] And Justin says the team behind it [00:08:00] has been great to work with
[00:08:01] Justin Unger, Director of Partnerships @ Planet Fitness: they kind of bring true white glove service, uh, very kind of, uh, approachable and, and, and available and always responsive.
[00:08:08] Kiri: One department store retailer that I spoke with couldn't quite picture what Nyft could [00:08:15] possibly offer that wouldn't compete with its own extensive product range. Partners get to choose which categories and brands appear from more than fourteen and a half thousand brands, and they can block any competitors or existing [00:08:30] assortment that they might have a double up of coverage.
[00:08:33] Nyft says about fifty-six percent of its October US advertiser spend came from physical products. For a specialty retailer, that still leaves plenty to choose from. For one that sells [00:08:45] almost everything, the block list does a lot of work. Now, if this sounds familiar, it's because Nyft looks a little bit like several things that RMNs already know: a loyalty program, an affiliate program, [00:09:00] post-purchase ads, product sampling, and this is Nyft's blessing and its curse.
[00:09:06] It is a new category of media offering with some relationship to all of these, so there's a lot of education to do [00:09:15] to clear up exactly what it is and isn't Planet Fitness runs its own affiliate network too
[00:09:22] Justin Unger, Director of Partnerships @ Planet Fitness: we haven't seen any overlap yet. Um, I think it's complementary right now.
[00:09:26] Kiri: So back to that question, why are RMNs [00:09:30] sleeping on Nift? It sounds too good to be true is the answer that Ellery gave me, which sounds like a pat answer.
[00:09:37] Though knowing how furtive a lot of retailers are, it could very well be true. So here's what I see as the real issues, [00:09:45] including what a few retailers told me on background Number one is control. This is the flip side of the done for you plug and play we'll bring the demand side of the coin. The partner doesn't get to control the [00:10:00] sales motion or some parts of the experience, and plug and play only allows so much customization.
[00:10:07] To be fair, the partners do get to decide which brands and categories appear. They can exclude competitors. They can [00:10:15] choose exactly where the experience shows up. What they don't control is which brands Nyft signs and what offers those brands make. That also means relying on Nyft to run a thriving marketplace.
[00:10:29] If [00:10:30] Nyft doesn't do a great job of selling to brands, that ad revenue dries up So you don't spend time or money drumming up demand, but you can't control or influence it either. Number two is the size of the prize. By my [00:10:45] rough math, a retailer with five million purchase confirmations a month could expect something like two to three million dollars a year from a single placement.
[00:10:54] Nyft calls that a fair conservative estimate, and that's real money at close to [00:11:00] full margin. But next to growing on-site sponsored products, activating marketplace sellers or inking big off-site partnership deals, it's an incremental line more than a foundation
[00:11:12] Nift agrees that for the biggest networks, [00:11:15] on-site search will always be the core engine. But partners get higher CPMs than they would with ads.
[00:11:22] Saket Mehta, CRO @ Nift: we also see really premium CPMs and RPMs that our publishers are able to generate,
[00:11:27] Kiri: and the number grows as partners [00:11:30] add moments.
[00:11:31] Nift says that one health and fitness app grew its Nift revenue five times over in a year by adding an in-app milestone by building Nift into the app itself and messaging lapsed [00:11:45] users.
[00:11:45] And channel matters too. In Nyft's top-performing placements, SMS and in-app earned roughly twice the revenue per thousand compared to email. Number three is that it's new and different, and [00:12:00] sadly, this is where we're at in retail media right now. There's a lot of playbook following. So something that looks new and different is harder to get over the line.
[00:12:10] One retail media leader told me that Nyft didn't give them an immediate hook. [00:12:15] They compared it with a product sampling solution, which they jumped on right away because they could both see the value and the margin story that they'd need to sell it internally
[00:12:26] Nyft's answer is that margin is actually where it's [00:12:30] strongest, and I think the economics back that up. When I asked how an RMN leader would actually build the business case, Nyft gave me the exact formula. It is eligible customer moments times by the share [00:12:45] of customers who activate times by the share who pick a gift times by the price the brand pays times your revenue share.
[00:12:53] And that is a sound formula, but it is a different kind of business case from the ones that most RMN leaders are [00:13:00] used to taking upstairs. So where does Nyft fit for a retail media network, and where doesn't it yet? Well, I think it depends as much on how your organization is set up as on the product itself.
[00:13:13] Nyft makes [00:13:15] sense if your media and loyalty teams already work closely or you run both of them together. One retailer's first reaction to Nyft was, "Well, I'd need to get my loyalty team to review and approve this." Well, if loyalty is already at the table, that [00:13:30] hurdle disappears. Nyft says that one global tech retailer runs the program inside its thanks for joining email It also makes sense if you have customer moments that earn nothing today.
[00:13:44] Delivery [00:13:45] updates, birthdays, loyalty sign-ups. In Nyft's own survey, consumers said that they're most open to discovery around their birthday and anniversary. It also makes sense if you can reach customers by SMS [00:14:00] or in-app, where Nyft says its top placements earn roughly what email does. And it makes sense if you want high margin, non-endemic revenue without building a sales team, or if you don't have a media network at all yet.
[00:14:14] Nyft [00:14:15] says businesses without media networks are actually a really important part of its business today. Now, where is this not the right fit? Well, if you need an initiative that carries this year's growth target, a single placement here is a [00:14:30] seven-figure line, not a nine-figure line If nobody can own something that sits between media, CRM, and loyalty. As one retail media leader put it, "Who owns this?" Well, Nyft's advice is to start with one moment [00:14:45] and one owner. If nobody will take that, it's gonna stall. And finally, if you need to own the advertiser relationship and the sales motion.
[00:14:55] With Nyft, you won't, and that's kind of the point, honestly. Finally, if [00:15:00] you sell almost everything, The more categories you have to block, the thinner the gift pool gets.
[00:15:06] Will adding Nift change the trajectory of an established retail media network next year? No. Should many of them do it [00:15:15] anyway? Yes. The product isn't really the hard part. Getting your own teams to agree on who owns it probably is. Ellery summed up the bigger picture when I spoke with him. Most retail media today [00:15:30] captures demand that already exists, and that demand is finite.
[00:15:35] As more networks reach the same shopper across more surfaces, efficiency goes down, and eventually operators have to get [00:15:45] creative about how they monetize the customer relationship. Novel approaches like this may offer commerce media networks a way out of what I've called the doom loop. That's the vicious cycle where networks launch with [00:16:00] sky-high profit expectations, grab some quick wins by repackaging trade dollars as retail media, and then stall out when that easy money runs dry.
[00:16:10] The honeymoon may be over for retail media, but it turns out that a [00:16:15] gift is still a pretty good way to start a new relationship If you want to read the full written pressure test, we'll link up to it below.
[00:16:24] Thanks for listening, and I'll catch you next time [00:16:30]