Too Complicated for Mediation? When to Settle and When to Fight

🎙️ Podcast Episode

🔹 Many clients ask: "Is my case too complex for mediation?"
🔹 Example case: A deadly hotel fire in Las Vegas that resulted in 15 deaths.
🔹 15 lawsuits were filed after the fire.
🔹 20 defendants involved — including the building owner and various companies.
🔹 Despite the complexity, the case is being resolved through mediation.
🔹 Parties have gone through multiple rounds of mediation.
🔹 A resolution is expected in the coming weeks. 

💡 Why Mediation Works — Even for Complex Cases: 

🔹 Going to court with dozens of plaintiffs and defendants could take a decade.
🔹 Legal fees and court delays can drain time and money.
🔹 Plaintiffs or defendants may pass away, disappear, or go out of business during a long trial.
🔹 Mediation can: 

• Be completed in a few years (even for complex cases)
• Be faster and more efficient
• Save money on legal costs
• Provide more control over the process

⚖️ Mediation vs. Court:
🔹 Court: Bound by the court calendar and backlogs.
🔹 Mediation: Can be scheduled in the private sector at a much faster pace.
🔹 Mediation is voluntary — you can reject the outcome and still pursue litigation.
🔹 In court, once a judge rules, you must comply with the decision.

📝 Final Thought:
🔹 Mediation is not just for simple cases like divorce or small claims.
🔹 It can absolutely handle even the most complicated disputes — like a deadly fire involving multiple lawsuits and dozens of parties.

What is The Expert Podcast?

The Expert Podcast brings you firsthand narratives from experts across diverse industries, including private investigators, general contractors and builders, insurance agencies, vehicle specialists, lawyers, and many others.

A lot of clients ask if their case is too complex or complicated for mediation. Here's a good example from Las Vegas, where there was a very serious fire at a hotel. It was a deadly fire that killed, I believe, 15 people. This case has a lot of complications. It's being settled through mediation. According to the news story, there were 15 lawsuits filed after the fire, and there were 20 defendants—the building's owner, the wife, companies that were involved with the fire. So this is a complicated case.

The article says that the lawsuit was close to a resolution. How is it being done? The parties have gone through multiple rounds of mediation in an attempt to reach a settlement. They believe that a resolution is likely in the coming weeks. Right? So think about it—you have 15 lawsuits, you have 20 defendants, dozens of plaintiffs—and if this thing went to court, it might take a decade. We've seen cases where five, six, eight years, ten years go by in all the legal fees, all the court appearances that have to happen in order to get that case done.

And even then, plaintiffs sometimes can disappear, they can die, they can move away. Sometimes defendants go out of business. A resolution through mediation, even though in this case it probably takes a couple years, can be much more efficient, save some money. More importantly, it can speed up the process of getting a resolution.

Look, if you go to court, you're at the mercy of the court calendar or the docket—getting cases on the docket, getting hearings on the docket. And if the court's busy, it might take a long time to get all those things done. But mediation can be done in the private sector at a much faster pace. It's also voluntary. You don't have to agree with what the mediator says. You can reject it and move on to litigation. Once a court says something, you're done. You have to abide by what that court says.

So yes, mediation can handle complicated cases—this is a perfect example. Or it can handle simple cases like small claims, or divorce, or probate cases, which aren't quite as complicated, and resolve those quickly and privately as well.