What if one bad decision completely changed the course of your career?
In this exclusive, members-only episode, Jaz sits down with a fellow dentist from our community who shares his raw, honest story about a moment of misjudgment — committing fraud — and the painful lessons that followed.
This isn’t about blame. It’s about insight, accountability, and redemption.
From the shock of investigation and court hearings, to the struggle of rebuilding trust and identity, this conversation shines a light on what really happens behind closed doors when things go wrong.
The aim of this podcast was to hopefully deter colleagues from temptation which can affect anyone at any time.
This is a members-only podcast episode due to its sensitive nature.
You can access it by creating a free Community account at: https://www.protrusive.app
Highlights of this episode:
Love this episode? Don’t miss Divorce, Alcohol and Rough Patches – Overcoming Adversities (IC040)
#PDPMainEpisodes #BeyondDentistry
This episode is eligible for 0.5 CE credits via the Quiz on Protrusive Guidance.
This episode meets GDC Outcomes A and D
AGD Subject Code: 555 Ethics in Dentistry
Aim: To reflect on the ethical, professional, and emotional lessons learned from a real-life case of dental fraud, highlighting accountability, insight, and rehabilitation while identifying practical steps to prevent similar incidents.
Dentists will be able to –
The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
I Committed Fraud: Learn from My Mistakes | PDP248
META DESCRIPTION:
An anonymous dentist shares how committing NHS fraud led to court and suspension, and the lessons on honesty, pressure and getting support early.
URL SLUG:
i-committed-fraud-learn-from-my-mistakes
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Professionalism, honesty and the consequences of fraud in dentistry
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- What happens if a dentist commits NHS fraud?
- Consequences of dishonesty for dentists
- GDC fitness to practise and interim suspension
- How performance pressure affects dentists
- The Swiss cheese model in dentistry
- Where can dentists get support during a GDC investigation?
- Coping with the stress of a complaint or investigation
- Practising honesty in dentistry
I COMMITTED FRAUD: LEARN FROM MY MISTAKES
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP248
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR X (ANONYMOUS)
EPISODE SUMMARY
On this members-only episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, recorded for the Protrusive Guidance community, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Dr X, an anonymous dentist who committed fraud as an NHS performer by claiming for bite-raising appliances that patients never received. Dr X takes full responsibility and explains the wider harm: inaccurate patient records, public money lost and damage to the public's trust in dentistry.
He describes being referred by his employer to NHS England and the GDC, pleading guilty in the Crown Court, completing a community order and now facing a Professional Conduct Committee hearing while under interim suspension. Jaz explores the environment that can lead to such decisions, using the Swiss cheese model, and shares a mistake from his own past. They discuss the stress of long investigations, where to find support, separating the behaviour from the person, and Dr X's message to practise honesty even when it costs you.
IN SHORT
Dr X shares how a dishonest decision early in his career led to a criminal conviction and suspension, so other dentists can learn from it. His advice is to think of the impact on your family, seek support early, own up straight away and practise honesty even when it costs you.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Dishonest record keeping can harm patients, waste public money and damage trust in the whole profession.
- In Dr X's case, fraud led to a Crown Court conviction, a community order and an interim suspension.
- Dr X says the greatest hurt has been the embarrassment and stress caused to his family.
- Pressure, isolation, targets and a lack of leadership can line up like the holes in Swiss cheese.
- If you're struggling or tempted to do something wrong, talk to someone and seek mentorship early.
- Your indemnity provider is the first port of call; support from outside dentistry also helps.
- Investigations can take years, so build resilience and lean on family and community.
- Practise honesty at a cost: if being honest costs you, do it anyway.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. What did Dr X do, and why does it matter?
2. What happens when a dentist commits NHS fraud?
3. What advice would Dr X give his younger self?
4. What kind of environment can lead to dishonesty?
5. What is the Swiss cheese model?
6. What happens with the GDC after a criminal conviction?
7. Where can dentists get support when they're in trouble?
8. What does practising honesty at a cost mean?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. A members-only episode: why we're sharing this story
2. Welcome, and why Dr X is anonymous
3. What happened, and why it matters
4. From employer referral to Crown Court
5. Advice to his younger self, and Jaz's own mistakes
6. The environment behind it, and the Swiss cheese model
7. Suspension, remediation and looking deeper at the why
8. An uncertain outcome, and the stress of waiting
9. Where to get support
10. Separating the behaviour from the person
11. Practise honesty at a cost, and outro
CHAPTER 1: A MEMBERS-ONLY EPISODE: WHY WE'RE SHARING THIS STORY
JAZ:
Hello Protruserati. I'm Jaz Gulati. This is to everyone on the Protrusive Guidance app. This is a Secret Podcast. There's a few secret podcasts we have on here, which are not on the public domain, so they're not on Spotify. They're not on YouTube. They're very much in this community, most noticeably. A couple of years ago we did one with a colleague of ours, someone in the community who had a bad patch with like divorce, alcoholism, that kind of stuff.
And then he came to talk about it, which I really appreciated to help others. In a similar way, one of our community, one of our members, okay, unfortunately had some misjudgment, right? We all make misjudgments in our career. And this colleague made a bad judgment of committing fraud. Like this could be like insurance fraud or claiming for stuff for monetary gain, right? And look, these things unfortunately happen and he's been through hell from the sounds of it, like from speaking to him, and you're gonna hear his story now, and we just fully anonymised it.
So why are we doing this? Okay. He's not even using this for like his remedial sort of stuff. You know, ask guys not to repeat what he did. And also if you are going through a fitness to practise or a complaint or something, whether you did something bad or you did okay, but it was communication fault, or you just have this malicious patient who's out to get you and like, and now you're worried about it going like legal and medical-legal and stuff.
And I think you really need to hear this episode. Need to hear the story, the themes, where to get help from, how to even think about bouncing back, and how to like cope with this kind of stuff. But more than anything, it's just a nice, I say nice, I say lesson guys. It's a lesson for us all. And I just thank Dr X, we're calling him Dr X, so much for sharing this with us.
Right? I think this will help some people. Just always be honest guys, be professional. We all make misjudgments, but I'm hoping we can learn the lessons from this podcast. But also, if you are stuck in a rut, you know, there are people you can talk to. We are here to help. And if you have any comments, please comment below. A Protruserati, he is watching, he's listening to everything you guys are saying down below in the comments.
So I'm hoping these guys will help you. And just to always stay professional and do the right thing. And maybe you have done the right thing and then there's a malicious patient. Well then, where to get support from, how to cope in those tough times. Okay. I'm hoping I reveal a vulnerability about myself. Some stupid things I did when I was 21 and 22. And I talk about it here because I just felt like, I felt so bad for our guest today.
I was like, okay, well let me make you feel a bit better. I did something stupid and I was happy to share it just so that you can understand that we're all human and hope you gain something from this guys. So those who are premium members, you can get CPDs for this one. And I hope we're all respectful in the comments. But you know, anything that you wanna say, if you want to find out who this is, you can DM me.
I will tell you. Okay, because he's happy to pass on if you wanna have a chat, if you’re in a stuck position or anything, then he's a good soul. He wants to help. Okay. So I hope you learned something from this one. I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 2: WELCOME, AND WHY DR X IS ANONYMOUS
JAZ:
Dr X, thank you so much for joining us. I was just saying before we hit the record button how grateful I am that you're part of the community. Like I'm really sorry that you're in this spot of trouble, but I'm just amazed at you as a human to think, to have this chat with me so we can help someone else. Hey, hopefully not get in trouble because it happens to everyone.
Sometimes there's huge, generally bad luck involved as well for colleagues. They see a patient who woke up on the wrong side of bed and they come with a complaint or sometimes they see blue-on-blue complaints, which are really sad. People with the best intentions can end up in trouble and I've seen cases where they've been going on for years and then three years later it was like nothing to answer, and that dentist went through misery for three years of their life, affecting their mental health and everything, right?
So I'm just grateful that we have this very rare conversation and we need to speak more about these kinds of things. 'Cause for sure you'll help a lot of dentists’ mental health after today. And I just wanna say thank you for this selfless service. Obviously, usually I'd say, hey, and just sell for that kind of stuff. But we’re keeping you completely anonymous, Dr X, because of the main fact that you are doing this, and thankfully we're doing it anonymously because you have been advised by your representatives and the medical legal community not to speak up publicly about this, which is I imagine would always be their advice to anyone undergoing what you're going through.
And therefore, because of this, dentists, we don't get to hear, we don't get to see that side because always been shielded, hey, don't talk about this. What if it affects you? So I'm just amazed and thankful that we can do this in an anonymous way so we can get the right message across to all listeners without compromising your future position. So please, Dr X, tell us how you ended up in some trouble.
CHAPTER 3: WHAT HAPPENED, AND WHY IT MATTERS
DR X:
So, when I was an NHS performer, I committed fraud. The way I committed fraud is I usually did a checkup or treatment on a patient and they were exempt so they didn't have to pay. And then I usually put through a bite raising appliance, so I abused my position of trust. This is the worst thing I've done in my life. So when I did this, it was quite early in my career.
I was, yeah, a dentist for about five years when I did this. And then there is no rationale for it. I've held my hands up and I've taken full accountability and responsibility for this. So I appreciate you apologising, but it's no one's fault except my own. So that's one thing I've put my hands up at the very first moment of my… so it was—
JAZ:
Yeah, I just wanna say like, it's akin to like, 'cause international, it is akin to, for the US people, claiming something to the insurers that didn't happen, for example. Or, I mean it did happen, but your justification perhaps wasn't there and it was perhaps led by monetary gain rather than clinical needs. That's essentially what's being sort of discussed, right?
DR X:
Yes. So I would like to express the implications to this. So record keeping, one, lying on the patient records. So if you do wrong records, it could affect their treatment for other clinicians. So for example, a bite raising appliance, then the clinician would see, oh, you've had one. But they didn't. But they will go onto more invasive procedures to affect it, to address their bruxism, which they never had anyway.
So there's that implication. There's an implication of the public withdrawal of funds for other diagnostic or therapeutic resources. There's a huge loss of trust. The public are apologising to the profession for these ridiculous actions. So if the public was to stop coming to the dentist because they can't trust us, because we're out for financial gain, then that’s huge repercussions to their health and to our medical profession.
So again, I apologise to the public for that. And this all falls down to trust.
JAZ:
Just to emphasise, for anyone who’s listening and watching to this, this is gonna be like a very closed— not only is it anonymous, but it's also closed so that the 5,000 or so people in the community will be able to have access to this and anyone who wants to. But we're gonna verify that they are a dentist before they're able to watch this, basically. Because I think the lessons are— 'cause the lessons are here really for the dentist to learn.
And again, I'm so appreciative for you to have so much humility and be like, look, put your hand up. And I really, honestly, you have to love anyone who just can put their hand up and say, you know what, I cocked up a bit. And I really, honestly, Dr X, I respect you so, so much. And I'm really sorry for all the sort of side effects of this and, and it's just how it drags out.
And I imagine it's a very painfully slow process, which I'm sure we're gonna get to as well. So all that stuff happened, and I appreciate that you're listing there all the things that it— the ramifications, right? So all the ramifications. Are you still able to practise or is there like a suspension?
CHAPTER 4: FROM EMPLOYER REFERRAL TO CROWN COURT
DR X:
Okay, so let's take it from the beginning. So I was approached by my employer at the time and they sat me down. They talked me through it and again, I was completely open and honest about what's happened. And then they referred me to NHS England and also the GDC. Then NHS England approached Crown Prosecution Services and during this—
JAZ:
Crown prosecutors like something like, they usually do like really serious stuff?
DR X:
Correct. This is—
JAZ:
I get serious, but like there's difference between like someone who commits like bloody GBH or something and—
DR X:
Well, yeah. Well, the thing is, I don't wanna minimise this at all. This is very serious.
JAZ:
I appreciate that. I totally get it. But like, I just feel like— I mean, I totally get where you're coming from and I appreciate again your humility to say that, but it's there. So what I'm trying to say is, in the eyes of the law, that kind of level of fraud is at the same level as someone who commits a grievous bodily harm.
DR X:
Correct. Correct. Yes. So they had to formalise their legalities and I feel that this should be used as an example for other clinicians not to fall and do the mistakes as I did. Saying that, when they went to the CPS, I went to court twice. I went to the magistrates and because of the amount of fraud I did, it brought me up to the Crown Court. Okay.
And pleaded guilty twice. And I got a criminal punishment. Crown punishment. Okay. Then I served that within 12 months. And now, during this—
JAZ:
Are you able to say what that means? Because I don't know. Is that like…?
DR X:
So I got a community order of 12 months where I had to do 200 hours of unpaid work and rehabilitation. But my crime is punishable with prison. I could have gone to jail, I could have got handcuffs, I could have heard the slam of the door behind me. So, yeah.
CHAPTER 5: ADVICE TO HIS YOUNGER SELF, AND JAZ'S OWN MISTAKES
JAZ:
Yeah. I really appreciate you because I know it's so difficult to talk about. Honestly, I'm so grateful because, because I think everyone— you said that if you can go back in time, and then you can be sitting on your shoulder when you were there on the computer and you were thinking— we all have moments when no one's perfect. We all have moments where we do stupid things.
Look, you know what, Dr X, I'm gonna make myself vulnerable for you as well. Right, 'cause I know even though anonymous, I've had issues in my life, nothing clinical, but before I became a dentist, I had a sports betting issue. Put it that way. I'm happy— I'm gonna say it for all listeners out there. I've been through my own troubles in life, and it is one of those things where it's money, and I look back and I think, and I'm like blushing now, I'm like, oh my God, I can't believe I did that.
Sometimes this rush happens and this ill judgment happens, right? And it's not good. And I just wanted to make myself vulnerable as well because I'm so appreciative of what you're doing. Right? And so I've had my demons and you've had yours, and no one's perfect. You know, at any one point we can all have our demons. Like someone could be unfaithful to someone else, that's a bad thing that they've done, right?
And you just— stupid thing that any human could do. And so it's like, what advice would you— if you could sit on your shoulder while doing it, right? What advice would you give to yourself or anyone else who's maybe like two ways and thinking about considering, you know, how they can boost their income or whatever it could be. Like for me, if I can go back in time, be like, look, just focus on your studies.
Focus on the good things in life. You know, go out and chill. Why are you getting involved in all this sports stuff? Do you see me? I'd say like that. What advice would you give to your former self?
DR X:
I would say look at the stress and trouble you are providing to your family who are there to support you. That's the main thing, the huge embarrassment I've caused my family. You know, if your family is well known within society and whatever, then for them walking down the street and knowing that one of their family members has committed a crime, especially when they're meant to be a professional and they're meant to be well known and respected in society, is hugely embarrassing for them.
And that's what's the most painful here. You do suffer yourself, but yes, you can go around and forget about it, but other people who you affect, who you love, your loved ones, and the people there who support you through these hard times— it's hard for them as well because they're just guessing and thinking, oh, how can my so-and-so do this? And I haven't even done it myself, but yet I'm affected by it as well.
So, yeah, that's the worst thing. I would say I would go back and tell my younger self to stop, listen, and get support early on. Like, if you have a thought in your head of doing something that you know is wrong, you should seek support at the earliest opportunity. And if you do it once or twice by mistake, you should own up to it and put measures in place to stop you from doing it again.
And that's what I should have done earlier, but when I was young and immature, I didn't have that support network. And it's only until after you—
CHAPTER 6: THE ENVIRONMENT BEHIND IT, AND THE SWISS CHEESE MODEL
JAZ:
I can imagine you felt like in an isolated space though. I felt like you were like just like alone in the surgery and then you didn't have anyone to talk to. I'm just making it up— like you tell me whether you felt that or not, but that’s kind of stuff that you might do when you lack good mentorship, lack good leadership. I don't wanna say your leaders are bad or anything like that, but like, when you are in like a hamster wheel setting, burnout, you tell me what kind of environment you were in.
DR X:
Yeah. So I actually appreciate you said that because one of the rationales for fraud is lack of leadership, lack of someone putting a spotlight on you. But again, I don't wanna point fingers here because at the end of the day, it's all about my actions. So when I was in a corporate setting, with the pressures of performance is there. And a lot of my other colleagues were away at the time and I was there to provide dentistry to the community.
Corporate breathing down my neck about performance, performances, and then something called clawback. So if you don't perform your target, you'll get something taken away from your salary. So again, I don't want this as a reason or rationale for what I did, but it's provided—
JAZ:
It's important to deconstruct it. Right? It’s a bit like when airplanes crash, you look at the black box and we learn so much.
DR X:
Yeah, exactly. I really, at the moment, yeah.
JAZ:
It's great aviation. They have this open thing. Okay, well this happened. Instead of pointing fingers, let's look at it. Because I appreciate, Dr X, that you're saying that you're free to blame and I respect that so much. But we have to take you out the equation and think, okay, when someone commits fraud, okay, and does things like that, what is typically surrounding them? And the benefit we have as a community to analyse this and look at this from a step back is we can then identify if we can see a colleague or ourselves— whether what we call the holes are lining up, you know, the Swiss cheese model, right?
You know the Swiss cheese model? So Swiss cheese, you know Swiss cheese, that cheese has got loads of holes in it, right? Yeah. The chances, right, of a hole going from one side of the cheese all the way to the other side of the cheese is very low, but sometimes if all the holes line up, it's like all the things— airplanes crash, right? The pilot was tired that day, plus the engineer who was supposed to check the left tyre was away and his backup didn't get the message.
This thing that had to be oiled wasn't oiled and all those things lined up. Okay? It's led to the airplane crash. And so it's not just you, it's the environment you were in. It's the phase of life you’re in. It's the system you’re in. Okay? And everything just had to line up for something like this to happen. I think we can learn a lot from that. And so I think the message here, if any colleague is— if you are stuck in a rut and you're really in a stuck place and you're thinking that, oh, I'm not meeting my targets, because if you are like easily meeting your targets, right?
This thought wouldn't come to your mind. Potentially, right? You're more than likely. But if you are struggling, you're like, okay— it's like you're seeing so many patients a day. It's like really constant. You're burning out. That's when these things are more likely to happen. And so if you are feeling stuck, I think the lesson here is talk to someone, get some good leadership, get some mentorship.
CHAPTER 7: SUSPENSION, REMEDIATION AND LOOKING DEEPER AT THE WHY
DR X:
Correct. So going back to your question about practising. I'm actually in interim suspension at the moment. It’s part of the GDC's IOC. So their body that has the public interest at heart, they're not related to the GDC at all. So now my case has gone up to the PCC, Professional Conduct Committee. My tribunal is soon regarding my final outcome of my registration. And the GDC tests the impairment of my registration.
So again, it's an uphill struggle. The main thing is abuse of trust and also the public perception of the profession. So yeah, it's an uphill struggle, but again, I've done everything I could in my hands. For example, charity work. I've given back to the community. After I've done my 200 hours of community service, I've gone back to that charity shop. I work, I give my time to Cancer Research, and I raised money for Asthma UK, and I'm gonna do a white collar boxing match where they raise money for charities as well.
So I'm trying to give back to the community. If the listeners can hear— it's all about trust now. So if we go back to trust, I've listened to one of your podcasts about communication, how trust is gained in small chunks and then lost in big buckets. So if anyone can help me in showing that my trust can be regained, then yeah, I would love to hear the views.
Because this is dishonesty. It's a major character flaw, and that's hard to remediate and to show that I've remediated from. I’ve been to psychologists and, well, counselling really, not psychologists or psychology, but counselling to seek therapy and to find— look deeper into the why. So the why can stem from a whole number of things. Could be, when I look deep into myself, it could be a family trait.
Like I've got older brothers and sisters that are really successful and I just wanted to be held in good esteem at their level. There is again— when people commit fraud, there's always greed that looks into it. So yes, it's greedy and yes, I was greedy and it’s financial gain at the end of the day, which I paid back now, I paid back.
JAZ:
And I just wanna say, greed happened to me as well, right? When I was doing the sports betting stuff, it happened to me as well. It can happen to anyone at any point, right? And I feel as though there are certain environments— again, appreciate the humility, but you're human. You're absolutely human.
DR X:
Yeah. And then another thing is ego. So not being able to feel that going to work and helping people was enough, that I felt that I needed to be more financially rewarded for what I was doing. So I fell underneath the standards by thinking, well, if I'm here, I'm the only one here treating everybody. I mean, I should be rewarded for this. And I did what I did was wrong.
It's not the way to go about it within the profession. Now, it's only after this has happened where I've found the support groups like your Protrusive Community and I've stayed in the field of dentistry by becoming a sales rep. So I'm in sales now and I support clinicians with the technical aspects of what we do. We support and we support clinicians teaching the dentist, and then we go to the clinic and we teach them about the technical aspects and the sequences to provide that surgery.
For example, sinus lifts, ridge expansions, full arch surgery. So, yeah, I'm really blessed to stay within the profession and show that this is my passion, and I really wanna stay in the profession because of this. And no treatment is different and you can always reflect and improve on treatments going forward. And that's the reason why I really wanna stay in the profession, because of that scope of improvement and providing the best to the patient.
So, I was a geek in dentistry, and I did an endodontic qualification and an implant qualification. I had to exit the implant one because of my suspension. So I really, I really liked dentistry in terms of the equipment you use to provide the best services. Something simple as an apex locator, you know the way it works with capacitors or resistance, it's just amazing how technology's there to improve our services.
And yeah. And I miss that. I miss that.
CHAPTER 8: AN UNCERTAIN OUTCOME, AND THE STRESS OF WAITING
JAZ:
Well, as I say, there is doom and gloom everywhere, right, Dr X, but there's never been a better time to be a dentist. And now with the technology now, AI and all that kind of stuff, there's so much helping us. Thank you for sharing your story. You've shared some lessons. We deconstructed what environment could lead to someone to do this. What do you think your chances are to practise again?
Is this something that's up in the air? We don't know?
DR X:
Correct. It's up in the air. We don't know. I'm looking down the barrel of erasure. I'm not saying I'm not— if I was to go in there and think I'm not being erased, then that shows lack of insight. So I'm actually going there expecting the worst. But the main thing is I've done everything I can to show insight. To give a remorseful apology and to make sure that my risk of repetition is extremely low and that I can be trusted again.
So if they see that, then, yes, it'd be great. But yeah, I don't know. I'm not asking for anything like a reprimand or conditions, but because it's been three years now since I've been doing a suspension, I think that's given me— I'm grateful for that time to actually reflect on what I've done and to move forward and just to ask for a second chance with the utmost humility.
And you know, being read your rights in the court dock by the NHS counter fraud people and then be pleading guilty is not a position that anyone wants to be in, and it was the worst thing. Leading me to that was— it's just very hurtful. So yeah, I mean, I'm grateful for the family support as well and the community support, and thank you for allowing me to talk about it because this is therapy in itself.
JAZ:
It needs to be heard. And I'm, again, I really appreciate your attitude that you have, the healing that you've had done. And just on that last bit, Dr X, if you don't mind, right? Yours are one of some reasons that someone could end up in trouble. Now, sometimes it could be as like— you may take out the wrong tooth, it could happen, you're human, right? And then that could land you in a lot of trouble.
You may perforate, but maybe you didn't warn about perforation. You may miss a few BPEs and then maybe the communication, the diagnosis of perio wasn't good for that one particular case which ended up being picked up by someone else, right? We are human. And we want our standards to be as high as possible, but we're not perfect. And so someone may end up— and quite often it’s miscommunication, right?
You did some aesthetic treatment, for example, and the patient comes back saying, you know what? I'm not happy with the shade. And you're like, well, I kind of did it. And then the patient goes straight to the GDC. Anything that happened. And so it's now the clinician versus the patient kind of thing. I know yours are different, yours with the other bodies and stuff. But there could be a whole, very messy thing and it can drag on for years, you know?
Three years. And that’s reminded me to make sure we touch on the super important point, Dr X, which is— it can take a while. And that's a lot of sleepless nights. That's a lot of what's gonna happen? That's a lot of— I dunno if you've experienced this, but dates being like— there's a date set in Feb but then it gets moved to May, then it gets moved.
DR X:
It's a very different kind of stress because there's stress that you're not in control of. It's a looming stress. It's a cloud over your head because you don't know the outcome, but you are still fighting it, you know? And I haven't quit in any of this process, because I've seen a lot of tribunal people don’t turn up, and I'm there participating. I've acknowledged my mistake and I'm cooperating with the authorities to try and help them understand why I did this and be an example to other clinicians as to not to repeat these actions.
And yeah, so it's very hard stress. Yeah.
CHAPTER 9: WHERE TO GET SUPPORT
JAZ:
I appreciate that. I'm glad you mentioned family and that you’ve got a supportive family. And I think if anyone's out there and they may be in the middle of an FTP or— I live every day with the thought, Dr X, that when a complaint lands on my table, not if, I just live with this. Okay. It hasn't happened yet. It might happen tomorrow. And it's gonna really challenge me and it'll challenge anyone.
And I just hope that myself and anyone who's affected by a complaint and then such a process, which if it leads to it, has the resilience and the support family and the love to be able to get through this very sickening period of life. So where can we get support from? Where do you advise someone who is in trouble now to get help from?
DR X:
So I would like to also thank my indemnity, and they're the first port of call. The indemnity.
JAZ:
If you've been happy with them, I'm happy for you to shout out who it was. But I dunno if you should actually— okay, this is why I'm confused because it's good to— like, we always moan about indemnity and stuff, right? But when indemnity has tried their best and done a good job, maybe it's a good thing. I dunno, what should we do here?
DR X:
Look, for me, it was touch and go. Sometimes they were on my side, sometimes they weren't.
JAZ:
Okay, appreciate that.
DR X:
But after time has gone by and they really got to know me, especially the latest meeting I had with the barrister that they've formulated, I took my wife along and they saw the personal aspects of how it affected me, my family, how we actually— we're all sorry as a family and we were remorseful. We wanna move on from this and now they're willing to help. Their tone has changed now, so they don't want me to be punished twice.
One from the Crown Court, and again for the GDC. They're suddenly now on my side. But before, at the very beginning, they knew where it was going. They thought, yeah, this is erasure, this is a dead case.
JAZ:
A dead end.
DR X:
Yeah, dead end. No point of pursuing this. But as soon as, you know, I got a community order, then they didn't think it would come this far. So yeah, they thought— because if I had a suspended sentence or imprisonment then yeah, this wouldn't go this far. So, yeah, now I appreciate their support. So, indemnity. Approach your indemnity. Approach people outside dentistry. Approach your GP. Approach a civil servant who's a lot older and wiser, who's been through life.
And sometimes if you go out of dentistry and formulate a network, or if you want to stay into dentistry then yeah, talk to them about it as well. But there's so many things you could do. Like it's just a lifestyle change as well. This month is the time I quit drinking too, for two years now. I've been more in touch with my religion. So yeah. Going against Hinduism is— Hinduism teaches you about trust and honesty and helping people.
And I didn't do that, so I let down my religion as well. So I looked at the broader things and yeah, it's hard to feel that you've done the terrible mistake, but it's hard to get back. But I'm not a dishonest person. Even though I did a dishonest action, I wouldn't go up to people and lie to them.
CHAPTER 10: SEPARATING THE BEHAVIOUR FROM THE PERSON
JAZ:
Let me tell you something about that. You just said a very good thing. Okay. You're not a dishonest person, but you did a dishonest thing. And this is one thing I'm really into— how I can be the best parent. Like, I really, like, I read a lot about that. I read more in that than dental textbooks nowadays, right? And so one thing— and also just trying to improve the relationship with my wife and always trying to make sure that I serve my family the best way possible.
And so one advice I keep reading is to separate the behaviour from the individual. So when I'm now speaking to Ishaan, like instead of saying, hey, Ishaan, you're being lazy. Why watch TV? Do your homework. Okay. That’s just calling him lazy. Like we need to separate the behaviour, which is laziness, from him. And so yeah, your behaviour was crappy. So was mine when I was 22 and I did that thing.
Okay. It was crappy behaviour. But generally I'm not like that kind of person who does that thing. Generally, you are not a dishonest person, right? And so it's separating the behaviour. Dr X, you've been very honest, remorseful. I felt very emotional with this podcast, and I can only imagine the hell you've been through, right? And like, you've been very— like, you stuck your hands up and said, yeah, I did the stupid thing.
Just like I can reflect back when I was 22 and I did that stupid thing. We all do stupid things. We all have skeletons in our closet, right? And that's reality. No one's perfect. Okay. And I'm just so sorry for the rough time, 'cause obviously you love dentistry very much. That's super clear. I just, the only thing I wanna say to you— like, look, please see this in a nice way, and free advice is worth every penny as they say, right?
But just, just as someone who's got your best interest at heart, all I wanna say to you is— in life, have you read this book by David Goggins? Can't Hurt Me. Have you? Have you? Have you?
DR X:
Yeah, I've heard of it, yes. Yes, you've mentioned before.
JAZ:
Please pick up that book. You need to, please. If there's one book that you read— because I really need you to hear the messages that are inside that book. Because basically the point is, people become bankrupt. People go through years of drug abuse issues. People are sometimes at the wrong side of a crime. And sometimes people are like victims of something really nasty, right? And if you let that define you the rest of your life, right— so please don't be defined by a misjudgment that you made.
Please don't let that happen. 'Cause that's a misjudgment. Honestly, it can happen to anyone. And in the right— in the wrong environment— it can happen to anyone. So whatever happens, okay, whether you get back on the register or not, I just wanna say, we as a community wish you all the best and thanks for the lessons that you shared with us today. And we want to see you succeed in any way, whether it's through dental business or whatever.
Use your dentistry knowledge in any way you can for the greater good.
CHAPTER 11: PRACTISE HONESTY AT A COST, AND OUTRO
DR X:
I have one final point. If I may, I would like to just tell everyone, just practise honesty at a cost. What I mean by that— if it costs you to be honest, then do it. For example, if your kid is three and you know who was under a hundred centimetres or whatever gets a free entry to the zoo for example, and you have to pay for a ticket.
Just pay for it. Honesty at cost is the paramount thing that you should practise going forward in any aspect of life. And you can take that across your career as well. So yeah, thank you.
JAZ:
That's a great reflection there. And whatever happens, I just hope, Dr X, that you know, you don't let this define you and that whatever pathways you take, whether it's clinical, nonclinical, you put this behind you and are able to appreciate the beauty and the variety of life and not just be like, okay, everything stopped in that time period when this happened. Because what's the point of— what are you gonna do in this one life that we have, right?
And so don't let that define you. Yes. Thank you. It's a misjudgment and anyone can do that. Now, sometimes you get punished, sometimes you don't. You are getting punished. I'm really sorry for that. But you've been very remorseful and you put your hand up. But please don't let it define you. We wish you all the best as a fellow human, fellow brother, fellow professional. So whatever way your life goes from here, please know that you have people that love you and care for you and from speaking to you.
I just wish you all the best in whichever way you go.
DR X:
Thank you so much.
JAZ:
Thank you buddy. Alright. All.
There we have it. Guys, thank you so much for listening all the way to the end or watching or wherever you're doing for this specific different episode. Again, it's not on YouTube. Not on Spotify. It's just for you guys and community. There's another one, like I said, we had from a few years ago, which I'll link, which is another anonymous one where we get to cover these themes, which are otherwise like got stigmas and stuff associated with it.
But I'm hoping this will really help us and let's thank Dr X for just sticking his hands up and saying, look, I made a boo boo. I did a bad thing. And just the remorse he's shown and I really appreciate that Dr X. Thank you. This episode is eligible for CPD. There was a lot of legal themes in there, professionalism themes in there. And so these CPD points that are more difficult to collect.
And so you can claim them. If you're not already a premium member, please do consider upgrading your subscription to be access to CPD and all the masterclasses that we have. But even if you don't, we still love you. It's great to have you here and hope this was helpful. If this was, then please let me know, because sometimes these rare opportunities come to record content like this.
I only hope that it helps, like for these ones, the reach is not important. Forget Spotify, forget YouTube. It's genuinely serving. Might really help five people, but it might help 'em in a life changing way. Okay, so if you find this helpful, please consider telling someone else about the community so they can join. We can verify that they're a dentist. And they can catch this episode which has some very important themes, I think.
Alright, thank you so much guys. I'll catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
What did Dr X do, and why does it matter?
ANSWER:
Dr X explains that, as an NHS performer, he claimed for bite-raising appliances for exempt patients that were never provided. He takes full responsibility and describes the wider harm: false records that could mislead future clinicians into more invasive treatment, public funds diverted from patient care, and a loss of trust that could stop people seeing a dentist.
QUESTION:
What happens when a dentist commits NHS fraud?
ANSWER:
Dr X describes being approached by his employer and referred to NHS England and the GDC. NHS England passed the case to the Crown Prosecution Service. He went to the magistrates' court and then the Crown Court, pleaded guilty and received a 12-month community order with 200 hours of unpaid work. He stresses that his offence could have meant prison.
QUESTION:
What advice would Dr X give his younger self?
ANSWER:
Dr X says he would tell his younger self to think about the stress and embarrassment he would cause his family, which he describes as the most painful part. He would also say stop, listen and get support early: if you're tempted to do something you know is wrong, talk to someone, and if you've made a mistake, own up straight away.
QUESTION:
What kind of environment can lead to dishonesty?
ANSWER:
Dr X is clear that the responsibility is his alone, but he describes working in a corporate setting under performance pressure, with targets, the threat of clawback and colleagues away. Jaz adds that isolation, burnout and a lack of mentorship or leadership can all contribute. Dr X also reflects on greed, ego and wanting to be held in high esteem.
QUESTION:
What is the Swiss cheese model?
ANSWER:
Jaz explains that Swiss cheese has many holes, but it's rare for them to line up all the way through. In aviation, a crash usually happens when several small failures line up at once. In the same way, a person's environment, stage of life and the systems around them can line up, which is why it helps to look at the whole picture.
QUESTION:
What happens with the GDC after a criminal conviction?
ANSWER:
Dr X explains that he is under interim suspension and his case has gone to the GDC's Professional Conduct Committee, which will decide on his registration. He is preparing for the worst, including erasure. He has paid the money back, done charity work and counselling, and hopes to show insight, remorse and a low risk of repeating his actions.
QUESTION:
Where can dentists get support when they're in trouble?
ANSWER:
Dr X says your indemnity provider should be the first port of call, and found his became more supportive as they got to know him and his family. He also recommends talking to your GP and people outside dentistry who are older and wiser, building a support network, and making lifestyle changes. Jaz encourages anyone struggling to reach out.
QUESTION:
What does practising honesty at a cost mean?
ANSWER:
Dr X's final message is that if being honest costs you something, you should still be honest. His example is a parent who could get their child into a zoo for free by saying they're younger, but pays for the ticket anyway. He says honesty at a cost should guide every part of life, including your career.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Dr X is a dentist and member of the Protrusive Guidance community who has chosen to remain anonymous, on the advice of his representatives, so that others can learn from his experience.