Retailgentic | Consumer Behavior & Retail Trend

In this episode, Scot sits down with Debra to unpack what might be the most important shift in digital advertising since social media.
This isn’t theoretical. It’s happening right now, and brands that don’t understand it risk getting left out of the new chain of commerce.

Highlights 
  • Why ChatGPT’s ad rollout is just the beginning, not an experiment
  • The tension between trust vs. monetization in AI interfaces
  • How retailers are both excited and terrified of AI shopping agents
  • The emergence of “AI Media” as a new category (like social + retail media before it)
  • Why current ad formats are “boring”… and what comes next
  • How companies should actually prepare (hint: it’s not just media buying)
  • The shift from advertising to agent influence, and what that means for the future
We’re still early, but not that early. The rules of digital advertising are being rewritten in real time, and for the first time in decades, the winners aren’t obvious. The question isn’t whether AI will reshape commerce. It’s whether your products, and your data, are ready to compete when agents decide what gets bought.

Timestamps:
 02:19 – Meet Debra Aho Williamson 
 05:00 – From social media to AI: spotting the next shift 
 09:00 – What “AI Ad Economy” actually means 
 11:00 – Are we at a social media–level inflection point? 
 13:00 – ChatGPT ads: early signals and what matters 
 16:00 – Why current AI ads look like search ads 
 18:00 – Trust vs. monetization: the line platforms can’t cross 
 23:00 – Why retailers are leading AI ad adoption 
 25:00 – Google’s AI ad strategy vs. ChatGPT 
 29:00 – Perplexity, Copilot, and the fragmented landscape 
 33:00 – Where Meta fits (and why it’s surprising) 
 35:00 – New ad formats: sponsored prompts + conversational ads 
 38:00 – Reddit, TikTok, and emerging players 
 40:00 – How brands should prepare for AI media 
 43:00 – Why structured product data is critical 
 45:00 – The future: ads for agents, not humans

👉 Connect with Debra: https://www.linkedin.com/in/debrawilliamson/
👉 Learn more about Sonata Insights: https://www.sonatainsights.com/

🧠 Want to stay ahead in AI commerce? Subscribe and follow along:
📰 Subscribe to the free Substack: retailgentic.ai
📺 Watch episodes on YouTube & Subscribe for updates: https://www.youtube.com/@Retailgentic

Creators and Guests

Host
Scot Wingo
CEO and Co-founder, ReFiBuy.ai

What is Retailgentic | Consumer Behavior & Retail Trend?

Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).

Speaker 1:

I mean, the fact that you just mentioned that Reddit is doing some sort of AI shopping really shows me, like, this is... We we are kind of in the Wild West of where any sort of business model, any sort of thing is going to be something that could potentially be big. So we're going to see lots of companies coming out with AI... Ways to do AI shopping, AI try on. I love this stage where, you know, every day, there's, like, a new big announcement from a company that you have to look at and go, Is this going to be the next big thing?

Speaker 2:

Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast, where we explore the intersection of retail, ecommerce, and AI agents, which we call Retailgentic. Our mission is simple. We are shining a bright light on the new agentic AI shopping megatrend which will disrupt the trillion dollar digital retail market. The stakes are high. Google, OpenAI, Microsoft, Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and Anthropic are all fighting to be the consumer AI shopping agent winner.

Speaker 2:

There are gonna be some tough decisions for online brands and retailers to make. What happens to checkout? How should payments work? Could you continue to invest in retail media networks? What does the world look like when over half of your traffic is not from humans but from AI agents?

Speaker 2:

These existential questions are the tip of the iceberg. On this podcast, we're talking to industry experts, analysts, and influencers to get answers to these questions, identify trends, and best practices. This is Retailgentic, your podcast partner in navigating our AI shopping agent future. And now here's your host, Wingo.

Speaker 3:

Welcome to this episode of Retailgentic, One of our most popular topics at this moment in the growth of agentic commerce is the intersection of advertising and agentic commerce. As we as we recorded this ChatGPT had was about thirty days into their test of their ad program. And because of that and where we are right now, I want I was very excited to welcome today's guest, Debra Aho Williamson, the show. She's the founder and chief analyst at Sonata Insights. Previously, she spent over nineteen years at eMarketer and one was one of the earliest analysts to start tracking social media and its importance on the ad and e commerce industries.

Speaker 3:

She now has a newsletter substack called the AI Ad Economy that I highly recommend subscribing to. In this conversation, we talk about the ChatGPT ad rollout, the competitive AI advertising landscape, what some of the retailers are doing around this intersection, such as in Sparky, Rufus and the Target shopping assistant, how brands and retailers can start preparing today for where she sees this going. And finally, we talk about where Debbie sees Agentic commerce and ads intersecting and going in the near future. Enjoy the commerce... The conversation, and happy Agentic conversing.

Speaker 4:

Welcome to Retailgentic. Today, I am joined by Debra Aho Williamson. She is the founder and chief analyst of Sonata Insights. Debbie, welcome to the show.

Speaker 1:

Thanks, Scot. It's great to be here with you.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. So the history here is I've been trying to consume all the content I can about the intersection of the traditional ad world, retail media, ad networks, and attempted commerce. And as I was searching around, I found your newsletter. And you know when you find one of those newsletters and you kind of go go read the whole back catalog. So I started it something about two weeks ago, I think it was.

Speaker 4:

And then I've been going slowly back to your catalog. And then I was like, I've got to see if I can convince her to come on the podcast, and you graciously agreed to some random person, asking me to to come on their podcast. So so I really appreciate that.

Speaker 1:

Absolutely delighted to be here. And, the the the newsletter's not that old, so, you you didn't have that much to catch up on. But I'm really happy to hear that you went back and read everything.

Speaker 4:

I like the way you come at things. And I thought this is very informed. I thought we would just kind of have a conversation about your... You're kind of exploring the area that I wanna chat more about. So it's perfect perfect time, and some of your latest articles have been spot on for for where I think things are going.

Speaker 1:

I'm really looking forward to chatting with you because, your area is something that I need to get better and learn more about as well. So hopefully, we can learn from each other.

Speaker 4:

We'll have a little learning work work session, and everyone can watch us do it. Before we jump in, tell us a little bit about your background. How do how do you know so much about advertising?

Speaker 1:

I'm an analyst. I'm a researcher. I'm a speaker. Basically I spent my entire career tracking how new new consumer behaviors are turning into new ad economies. I started out as a journalist in the earliest days of the .com and Internet advertising growth at Ad Age.

Speaker 1:

I covered the .com boom at The Industry Standard, which is a news magazine for the Internet economy in the late nineties. I spent nineteen years at eMarketer as an analyst writing research about consumer demographics, and I was one of the earliest analysts to identify social media as being something that marketers should pay attention to. I wrote my first report about it in 2006 when Facebook was two years old. I published 120 reports over seventeen years chronicling the growth of social media. And now at Sonata Insights, I am on to the next big transformation in consumer behavior and marketing and advertising, which is obviously what we're here to talk about today, consumer AI behavior and the impact on marketing and advertising strategies.

Speaker 1:

And what's that... What what is that doing to discovery, to media, to paid strategy? I love playing at this early stage of business and of changing technology and changing marketing because we don't know who the big players are going to be. We don't know which ad models are going to be the ones that are successful. We know that things are changing dramatically, but there's so much possibility ahead.

Speaker 1:

And that is an area that I absolutely, absolutely love participating in and thinking about and writing about and helping my clients strategize about.

Speaker 4:

Have one random question about e... When you're a time at eMarketer. The... I love I love their little charts. Do they, like, do they, like, coach you as one of the analysts?

Speaker 4:

Like, whatever you do, your your report has to generate one of those little charts. Like, is that, like, a thing there?

Speaker 1:

Oh, the red and black charts. I mean, when the founders of eMarketer created those legendary red and black charts, I don't think anybody realized just how ubiquitous they're going to be. But it's really become... Yeah. Absolutely.

Speaker 1:

It became a signature. As soon as you see one of those red, black, and gray charts, you know that it's an e marketer chart. And I love that they created that signature. Hopefully, I'll be able to do that with my own work at Sonata Insights. But yeah, it was something that we all had to learn how to do, was take that data, translate it into red, black, and gray, and a headline on it, put our methodology on it.

Speaker 1:

And lo and behold, these charts appeared everywhere, presentations, websites, other people's reports. They they live on in a lot a lot of places for sure.

Speaker 4:

And startup pitches, I'll be watching some random startup pitch, and they'll be... Yeah. There's an eMarketer chart. You can, like, see it instantly because of the the the the shape. But it's like in an area I didn't know eMarketer...

Speaker 4:

Like, in my world, eMarketer is, like, in ecommerce, and I've seen some ads and, you know, now some of the stuff they do. And, but it'll be like some other thing. I didn't realize eMarketer went into so many verticals. It's interesting.

Speaker 1:

Yeah. Absolutely. And and advertising, e commerce, mobile, you name it. I mean, there... There's a lot that eMarketer covers, and I I love my time there.

Speaker 1:

And I learned a lot there. A big part of my research that I do today is based on the foundation that I built at eMarketer, which is really understanding. You look at a lot of data. There's a lot of research, a lot of surveys that get published. I learned really quickly at eMarketer how to identify what was a good research methodology, what was a good survey, how how do you actually know that these these these results are objective and responsible and not just promotional hype, which we know a lot of research does and is.

Speaker 1:

So I bring that a lot into my business too. So when I'm doing custom research with clients, we're always looking to be as objective as possible.

Speaker 4:

N equals five is not enough. That's all I know about service.

Speaker 1:

That's right.

Speaker 4:

The bigger the bigger n is the better.

Speaker 1:

Yes. That's right. That's right. A minimum 1,000 in a consumer survey if possible. That that was one piece of training I got at eMarketer.

Speaker 4:

Let's talk about your newsletter now. What what inspired you to start a newsletter and, you know, tell everyone how they could subscribe? We want to get you some subscribers here. And then also, who do you kind of view your audience? When I'm writing my letter, I kind of like know who I'm writing towards.

Speaker 4:

Who's your audience you're writing your newsletter for?

Speaker 1:

Yeah, so my newsletter's called The AI Ad Economy. It's on Substack and LinkedIn. And so you can subscribe in your favorite destination, wherever you like to hang out. But it's really about identifying where consumer AI behavior meets advertising and what are the growing advertising strategies to meet those consumers in AI platforms, services, apps, you name it. So we all know ChatGPT right now has advertising.

Speaker 1:

I'm tracing that as well as the growth of advertising in places like Copilot, Rufus, Walmart, Sparky, Perplexity, of course, Google with Gemini, AI overviews, AI mode. These are just the beginning. But this newsletter really is a fun playground for me to track the trends, the insights, the people, the companies that are shaping this new wave of advertising. And you asked who it's for. So it's for a pretty wide audience, people who work in marketing, CMOs, agencies, publishers, digital media companies, investors, anybody who really needs those signals beneath the headlines.

Speaker 1:

And we all know there's so many headlines in AI these days. I try to bring my journalistic background to bear here, and I try to help people understand what's really happening, without the hype, without the layers of breathless, you know, enthusiasm of what AI can be.

Speaker 4:

In your bio, you mentioned in o six, you you started really leaning in on social. Do do you think this is another one of those moments? Are we at, like, this big kind of, you know, Cambrian explosion of things happening here, or is it too early to call?

Speaker 1:

No, absolutely. I mean, even before I launched the newsletter so the newsletter launched only in December of last year. But even before that, when I started Sonata Insights, I knew that a transformation was coming. This was going to be a tectonic shift, again, in consumer behavior and in marketing. I could see the signs based on everything I'd done with social media research over the years and before that, the growth of the internet, the .com boom, and even before that, the rise of internet advertising.

Speaker 1:

You see these things happen. You see consumer behavior starting to shift, and you see the marketers going, oh, wow. I need to be there. I need to really understand where my consumer is because suddenly they're not using search. They're going to this other thing, ChatGPT or whatever, and they're finding information.

Speaker 1:

Ah, I need to be there. And there's a lot of similarity to where marketers were with social media. Obviously, AI is very different than social media, but there's a lot of similarity that I can use there where I can say, okay, we see consumer behavior changing. We can see the opportunities for marketers and retailers and commerce providers to play in this environment. They're not entirely formed yet, but I fully believe, yes, this is, one of the biggest tectonic shifts in advertising media and marketing that is going to happen.

Speaker 1:

And we're just at the very beginning. We're, like, in, you know, year one of this transformation. And think about social media. I mean, social media... 2004, it was when Facebook started.

Speaker 1:

That's when I date social media. What... Twenty two years later, social media has grown from maybe a billion dollar in ad spending at the beginning to billions and billions just for one company, Meta. We are at that earliest stage right now with AI and and the impact of AI on marketing and advertising. So I'm super excited to see what's going to happen in the next five, ten, twenty years.

Speaker 4:

Let's kinda take it, chronologically and start with kinda where you see us today. And you did a very good job of rattling off all the companies there. So I find people love to, there's a bit of a weird obsession with ChatGPT, so let's start with that one. And they kind of famously announced kind of on a Friday afternoon, we're doing an ad test and there was like a big uproar and then we had the Super Bowl commercials and all that thing. And then you just recently wrote a really good article about, again, you're very good at like not getting pulled into the drama on that, which I appreciate, although the drama is kind of fun.

Speaker 4:

Sure. Yeah. I don't know if you saw And they were at the event in India. They wouldn't touch each other. Did you see that?

Speaker 4:

That whole... There's, like, a whole another drama today.

Speaker 1:

Yes. Yes.

Speaker 4:

And Sam and Dario are going at it. And... But, you know, what are you seeing and hearing about the ChatGPT rollout of these tests that they're doing?

Speaker 1:

Well, it's it's very early. And ChatGPT is very, very careful to describe it as a test. Do I think they're going to do this test and then say, oh, no. I guess we're not gonna do advertising. Didn't work.

Speaker 1:

No. This is a test that's leading towards something much bigger. ChatGPT is hiring for ad engineers, product managers, developers, people to lead the ad business. So this is not something that they're going into lightly or as an experiment to just kinda see if maybe advertising fits. This is definitely the start of where advertising might be going within ChatGPT.

Speaker 1:

It is early. Right? And I think that there's a lot of things that are are going to change over the next couple of months as we start to see some results from these early tests. One thing that I know that ChatGPT and OpenAI have been leaning really heavily into is the idea of trust. And that means the ads are separate.

Speaker 1:

The ads are clearly identified as ads. The ads don't impact what people see in the responses that they get. I mean, ChatGPT has been very, very careful in all of its framing around this launch to make that very clear. It's important. Right?

Speaker 1:

I mean, you think about it. I mean, you don't want... I mean, you've built this sort of new economy, this new environment where people are going to get information. I mean, heck, today, I I was just looking for restaurants to go and try out because I'm currently in San Diego for a little while. And I wanted to see, like, what are some cool restaurants?

Speaker 1:

I I didn't necessarily want to be influenced by an ad at that point. And so this kind of behavior, this kind of, you know, interaction between advertising and marketing and where does the line draw between this organic information and the paid information is something that ChatGPT is definitely still figuring out. And I think the test will show a lot about where those lines are and and also, honestly, what people are comfortable with, because we don't really know. This is all new. I think another thing that is really interesting and will definitely change is that the ad formats right now on ChatGPT are kinda boring.

Speaker 1:

I mean, they're pretty basic, right? I mean, you look at them. I mean, you've probably seen some examples and things floating around out there, but they're just search ads. They're like textual search ads with the picture and search copy. And people have told me who are involved in the test that there's a reason for that.

Speaker 1:

It's because they are search ads. Right? They are not uniquely designed at this point for ChatGPT. That made it easier for advertisers to launch into the program. That made it easier for advertisers to probably compare performance because they have an identical ad unit that they can compare on ChatGPT versus maybe where it appears somewhere else in search.

Speaker 1:

And that made it easy then, I think, for maybe consumers to be like, oh, okay. I recognize that. I've seen an ad that looks like that. Do I think that this is the exact ad format that's going to continue on ChatGPT? No.

Speaker 1:

These are just the very earliest days. So that's what we're seeing right now is just the bare minimum of what an ad might currently look like, but not necessarily what it's going to look like in the future.

Speaker 4:

And it's probably too early to call, but do you agree that this trust thing is the the line they can't trust, they can't cross? And kind of embedded in there is, and a lot of people feel like Amazon has kind of jumped the shark on ads. Like you can't, you know, I look for these veggie dip things for my dogs, and it's like a thousand ads. And then my thing I'm looking for, it's almost like, you know, hide the cheese kind of a game that Amazon plays now in the search experience. And and then a lot of people feel the same way about Google.

Speaker 4:

So, you know, in some ways you could argue that that's why people like the experiences because it doesn't have ads, yet they're adding ads. How... Do you think they'll be they'll be able to navigate that? Do you think that's the right that's the right thing to try to navigate?

Speaker 1:

I do wanna touch on that. But first, sorry. I have to ask you. What is a veggie dip for dogs? I have to know

Speaker 4:

about It's veggie dipped. D e n t. And it's a so you know the little what are they called? The ones that look like a little bone. There's milk bones and then greenies.

Speaker 4:

So greenies were good for dogs because they clean their teeth. This is like next level. It, like, actually has some... Something on their teeth that keeps their teeth sparkling.

Speaker 1:

Oh my gosh. And and so... Yeah. I mean, so that just tells you... Mean, that's up to your point of Amazon and advertising.

Speaker 1:

If you're seeing that many ads and sponsored links for products that are like this or similar to this or advertisers who have something that they want to sell to people who are interested in Veggie Den for their dogs, I mean, that tell... I mean, that proves your point right there. Like, this this is a a product where... You know, this is a a place where lots of companies have figured out they can make some money and they can get some attention for themselves. And Amazon has been more than welcome to...

Speaker 1:

More than willing to welcome them welcome them. So I totally see your point. I think there's some really interesting parallels here, though, to what Amazon did. And I'm sure you know this almost better than I do. But Amazon existed as an online retailer well before it had advertising.

Speaker 1:

I mean, how many years? Do the... I don't know if I remember how long Amazon was an online retailer before they actually introduced advertising.

Speaker 4:

Probably '97 is when they started. And then no ads... Marketplace was a six. And then ads, I guess, are ten years, so fifteen. So eighteen years.

Speaker 4:

I guess eighteen years.

Speaker 1:

Alright. So Amazon existed for a really long time before advertising. And now Amazon is one of the largest sellers of digital advertising in the world. Right? I mean, you've got Google.

Speaker 1:

You've got Meta, of course, ahead of that. But if you look at Amazon, I mean, it's right up there. So it's been able to successfully build an advertising business, and people are still using Amazon. People are not, like, going, oh, ads. Too many ads.

Speaker 1:

Maybe maybe they're running away a little bit, but they're still using Amazon. ChatGPT obviously started incorporating advertising way sooner. Right? But to me, I mean, everything about AI is moving faster than it ever moved for Amazon back in the day. I mean, it made sense why Amazon took a long time to incorporate advertising because it was building a business in a different era than we are now.

Speaker 1:

And so the fact that OpenAI already has advertising, I think, just tells you about the speed at which this transformation is taking place and how people are discovering, finding, researching, and eventually buying things. And I don't think OpenAI could afford to wait a year, two years, five years. They needed to move fast because they knew what they had built in terms of something that would be valuable to people. And then I think they realized that this was also going to be a really valuable audience and environment for advertisers. So to get back to your question about trust, I know you you asked me though about trust, and I don't wanna...

Speaker 4:

They have an interesting problem in that they've got this iceberg of free users. Right? So something like 98% of the users of ChatGPT are in the free tier. And I think they thought maybe more of them would pay up to get the faster better, but I think people are hunky dory with the free version. So then they're like, well that freemium model may not be working as fast as they want it to, could be part of, which is another, which is kind of Ads, you know, ads do help us have, you know, a lower cost Netflix broadcast TV.

Speaker 4:

They they do serve a role for that that freemium kind of a tier.

Speaker 1:

Absolutely. Absolutely. And and and we've seen in past scenarios companies rolling out ads after saying, oh, we're never going to have ads. You know, you mentioned Netflix. That's a great example of a company that for years said, no ads on Netflix.

Speaker 1:

No ads on Netflix. No ads on Netflix Netflix. And then suddenly, oh, there's ads on Netflix. And I think that they've been able to build a decent business and and ad support. Some people will watch ads to get a lower price for Netflix.

Speaker 1:

So, OpenAI, we all know OpenAI is losing their... You know, has invested billions and billions of dollars in infrastructure and, you know, whatever... Everything that it needs to run its business. So, of course, OpenAI needs ways to generate revenue. Subscriptions, obviously, and enterprise, two really important places for OpenAI to generate revenue.

Speaker 1:

But advertising, obviously, another one. And, you know, who's the head of applications at OpenAI came from Meta, came from Facebook. She knows about businesses that were built on the foundation of advertising. So I think definitely, you know, is going to be a part of of OpenAI. It's going to start to to to pay...

Speaker 1:

Help pay the bills. And I think it's going to ramp up pretty quickly once they start to really put their minds and their AI into developing interesting new ad formats that we probably haven't even seen or thought of yet.

Speaker 4:

What did you think of the mix of people that were in there? I remember... So I've seen Target, Williamsonoma. There was another one I can't remember. Do you have a list of like the people that have admitted they're doing it yet?

Speaker 4:

And what do you think about that mix?

Speaker 1:

Yeah. I mean, I've seen various lists floating around. Yep. Target, Williams Sonoma definitely being on there, Albertsons. Retailers are very heavy into this.

Speaker 1:

And I saw a really interesting chart from Sensor Tower that looked at the early players, a pie chart, and looked at the early advertisers that it was able to find ChatGPT. And I don't have the numbers in front of me, unfortunately, but I want to say it was something like almost a quarter of the advertisers were in the retail category. And that makes a lot of sense because retailers, I think, sense both an opportunity and, quite frankly, a risk in a company like ChatGPT or a place like ChatGPT and what people are doing there. The opportunity, obviously, is to integrate and become a place that ChatGPT refers people to so that they can purchase on that retailer site. The risk, of course, is that ChatGPT doesn't refer to the retailer, and the retailer gets left out of the equation.

Speaker 1:

And so I think it's very smart and very wise for retailers to be among the first advertisers on this platform because they want to demonstrate. They want to learn. They want to participate. It's that old kind of frenemy conversation. Like, you know, you wanna get in bed with a new company, a new tech company, because you're afraid of them, but you also wanna learn from them.

Speaker 1:

And I think that's where retailers are in this equation.

Speaker 4:

So that's ChatGPT. And then you mentioned Gemini. What are you seeing? And when they announced at NRF, they announced UCP. They introduced one new ad format, which is kind of like where you've narrowed it down to a merchant and you can inject a special offer.

Speaker 4:

It's like a direct offers, the name of it. And then in a LinkedIn post, lady running both commerce and ads announced another ad unit, which is kind of like in my world, we would call it product listing ads. They didn't really name it, so I don't know what we'll call it. You know, maybe it's AI listing ads or something like that. And I have a lot of questions about that one because it looked like you're actually buying your way to the top, which is kind of like,

Speaker 3:

you know,

Speaker 4:

that that definitely feels very much like the ads are influencing that editorial, if you will. But but I haven't seen it live in the wild, and it's a screenshot, so it's hard to tell exactly what's going on there. Have you have you seen any other interesting things out of Gemini?

Speaker 1:

Yeah. Well, so, first of all, there are no ads in Gemini itself, there... But there are ads adjacent to AI overviews and in Google's AI mode. And Google's actually made it very... I think they've actually come out and said, at least for now, no ads in Gemini.

Speaker 1:

They're keeping that an ad free zone. I don't know if that was in competition with what ChatGPT was doing or if they really do intend to keep Gemini as sort of this, you know, paid or or environment or or some some place where it it it really is just you and and and the chatbot talking without the in... Intrusion of advertising. I don't know if that's going to happen. But, anyway, I digress.

Speaker 1:

The... Yeah. I I think that Google has got a very interesting and very powerful position to build out new ad formats that make complete sense across its portfolio. I mean, obviously, is a massive player in search. Its search ad business is doing just fine right now regardless of what all we're talking about about ChatGPT and about consumer behavior.

Speaker 1:

Yeah, there are shifts happening. But overall, Google's ad business is still doing really well, and much of that is on the foundation of search. And, you know, obviously, there's other parts of business as well, but search is the traditional search is a big component to that. So we're still seeing search being important. And so what Google's able to do, which I find really interesting, is to then layer on these other ad formats that are part of its AI offerings, but look kinda similar to what we might see in search.

Speaker 1:

So they're comfortable for advertisers, they're... Quite frankly, they're gonna be comfortable for users as well. So you've really got a nice intermingling of traditional formats, which advertisers and consumers are comfortable with, emerging into AI environments, which are kinda new and different and experimental. And over time, I think, yes, the ad formats that will be more dedicated and more unique and more, you know, more specific to a... The AI environment.

Speaker 1:

But for now, it's just really nice to see how Google is interplaying all of the pieces of its business and still managing, you know, to keep a very successful ad business even as it's layering on additional new ways to reach people in... When they're using the AI parts of Google, that make a nice complement to Google, but also make a nice competitive threat to whatever OpenAI and ChatGPT are doing. So I I find it really interesting, and nobody should write off Google, absolutely, in this conversation.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. I found it shocking they can turn off so much search traffic with AI mode and stuff and not take a bigger hit in their ad revenue. That's pretty amazing. It's a testament to the model. Yeah.

Speaker 4:

I think the remaining clicks just become that much more valuable. And it's kinda like there... There's a scarcity in clicks now that's making CPCs go up to counteract the drop in traffic that they're sending.

Speaker 1:

Yeah. Yeah. I I fully believe that for sure.

Speaker 4:

And then I saw Perplexity kind of announce they're not gonna do ads. So they're kind of in the anthropic camp, it seems. But, you know, they're all over the place. They could change their mind at any point.

Speaker 1:

Well, you know, Perplexity actually did have ads. So last year, they they did do a test of advertising. It was kind of unusual. It was cost... Like, cost per thousand based.

Speaker 1:

It kept people within the Perplexity environment. You know, you didn't click out to any external destination. Is a little bit akin to what ChatGPT is doing now, where the conversation that you were having with Perplexity triggered an ad to show. And they signed a few partners to do it, but I don't think Perplexity ever really put the muscle into it. Or because it's so much smaller, I really have the resources to put the muscle into developing an advertising business the way that it should have.

Speaker 1:

I love that Perplexity was first or among the first. I love that it got the attention and demonstrated what advertising could look like on an AI environment. But I feel like not not enough consumers use or even know what Perplexity is to make it something that advertisers actually wanted to put, you know, on their experimental, you know, media dollars, put add some... You know, put some put some experimental media dollars toward. And I think then Perplexity also realized, look.

Speaker 1:

We're... You know, we we have... This is just too much. We have to focus. And so it, I think, pivoted and is now focusing more on commerce.

Speaker 1:

I don't I I don't doubt that Perplexity will eventually restart some sort of ad business, but, you know, you're right that right now, it's... It doesn't have one.

Speaker 4:

And then you mentioned Copilot. What... What's, going on at Copilot?

Speaker 1:

Copilot's another interesting one because, obviously, Copilot's really tied into Bing, really tied into Microsoft advertising, and everything that Microsoft is doing through its ad business. So Copilot kind of runs under the radar. Not that many people really think about or or have explored the fact that Copilot has had advertising for many months, probably a year, almost a year or even more. There's been ads in Copilot. They're they're very basic.

Speaker 1:

They look like search ads, just like what ChatGPT is doing. But I find it really it's really fascinating that there's... I would say Microsoft probably has gotten a lot of learnings about what works and what doesn't work. They haven't really shared too many of those. I'd love to interview them.

Speaker 1:

Microsoft, if you're out there, I'd like to talk to you through my newsletter.

Speaker 4:

We do have a lot of, folks, Microsoft folks that that follow. So

Speaker 1:

Alright. Good. Maybe heard. Yeah. Come find me.

Speaker 1:

I want to interview you. I want to learn more about what works and what doesn't work in Copilot advertising directly from you and talk about it on my newsletter. So quick promo aside, I do think it's interesting. Copilot's a very different environment. It doesn't get as much buzz.

Speaker 1:

It's much more kind of work focused and business focused. I think a lot of people are using Copilot just maybe in passing as they're using Word or Excel or making PowerPoint presentations. But, I, you know, I... I'm very appreciative that, Microsoft has taken the step to... Early step to incorporate advertising.

Speaker 4:

Then... So Anthropica announced they're gonna do ecommerce or agentic commerce. So we know they want two ads because it's like they've kind of threw the gauntlet down on that.

Speaker 1:

I I think they made that loud and clear on the Super Bowl, didn't they? Yeah.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. And then did you... Were you surprised to see Meta announce on the earnings call? You may not you may not have seen this, but you probably did. The...

Speaker 4:

You know, Mark Zuckerberg said they're working on some agented commerce tools. Now I read that as consumer based. Some other people argue it's more for merchants, but we'll see where it comes out. Do you think that they'll... They see this as a big threat and they need to...

Speaker 4:

Obviously they're spending a lot on AI, but I thought it was interesting they were kind of leaning into commerce because they kind of abandoned commerce in my world for a while and partnered with Shopify instead.

Speaker 1:

It is really interesting. So Meta is the second largest digital ad seller in the world behind Google. And so Meta knows how to put ads into its surfaces, its consumer experiences. I... If you had asked me a year ago which companies would be successful or maybe even first or second out of the gate when it comes to advertising on...

Speaker 1:

In AI, I would have put Meta there. I would have said, okay. Meta is a company that has a... First of all, it has a huge ad business. It knows how to sell advertising.

Speaker 1:

It knows how to create successful ad products. It's creating a bunch of consumer AI facing... Consumer facing AI platforms. Why isn't there advertising there? And the answer, I think, is really simple, which is that Meta has decided, at least for now, that advertising, that AI is going to be better suited to help its existing advertising perform better.

Speaker 1:

So they're just using AI, as part of the infrastructure to make... You know, they add... To help improve the ad targeting, to allow advertisers to create multiple creative variations, you know, thousands even of create... Creative variations. To...

Speaker 1:

And then on the consumer side too, they're using AI to figure out which content people want to see and show them more of that content. So that keeps them on the platform longer, which turns into more app advertising opportunities. So Bet has been really smart about using AI in those ways and I think has been probably one of the most successful digital companies in incorporating AI on the back end of its advertising business. But I'm super surprised that they aren't selling or trying to come out with advertising in the consumer facing AI. When you open up Meta like Instagram and you search, I mean, you get an opportunity to search on Meta AI right there.

Speaker 1:

Like, there could be advertising there, but they just haven't done that yet.

Speaker 4:

And I don't know who invented this, but it's definitely pretty prevalent in Rufus. And then I think Sparky has it as well. And it's a sponsored prompt. You seen the sponsored prompt? I kind of liked that ad format because it feels more like AI native to me.

Speaker 4:

And it... You know? And it's it's kinda mixed in. So you... You're choosing as the user to kinda see it.

Speaker 4:

You're not, like, having to see it. So I kinda like that one, but I may be in the minority there.

Speaker 1:

Yeah. I mean, I I think that's interesting. And that kinda brings us back to what we talked about with ChatGPT, which is where is that line between you're having a conversation with the AI and you're getting information and it's sharing information with you. When is it appropriate for an advertiser to sort of slide into that conversation? And if any company would find a way to do that successfully, I feel like Amazon and Walmart are really well positioned because they know how to drive people from searching and looking around and find...

Speaker 1:

Trying to find things to actually buying something. I mean, they're actually really, really good at that. So I'm not surprised that these are the kind of ad formats that a company like Amazon would be leaning into with Rufus. I haven't seen much about the performance. Amazon doesn't...

Speaker 1:

I don't know if you've seen much, but Amazon doesn't talk very much about Rufus advertising. It talks more about the impact of Rufus on consumer behavior and how how much people use Rufus. And I've seen third party data as well about how embedded Rufus is into... Already into the process of using Amazon. So I feel like it's let...

Speaker 1:

Laying the foundation for a bigger advertising business there. But what they're doing right now, it seems to me like it makes complete sense.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. So I know very, very large companies are asking Amazon for all kinds of Rufus thing, and there seems to be like a fortress around Rufus. Like, they won't share any information about what's going on inside of there other than what they they put out publicly on their earnings.

Speaker 1:

Right.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. Yeah. So I I don't think there's any way to know what's going on inside of that.

Speaker 1:

Well, I mean, the other thing to say too is obviously, you know, Walmart and Amazon are two of the largest players in retail media. They're not going to let this region... They they have important businesses to protect in retail media. So finding a way to integrate those advertisers and what they're doing in their other... In their larger retail media organization into the AI offerings that they have makes complete sense.

Speaker 1:

Right? They want to present a full package to advertisers.

Speaker 4:

Any other wildcards you can think of? Like right before we hopped on, saw Reddit is doing something. They announced a new AI shopping search engine that kind of is gonna... It it kinda aggregates up all their reviews, and it's like a little scrolly bar of different products. Thought it was, you know, it's like a very weird time everyone's doing different things.

Speaker 4:

Pinterest is another one that, know, they've got to do something because they're kind of in trouble, I think. And then I bet you've probably really dialed in on TikTok. I always wonder, like, is TikTok gonna get in this, or is what... Is TikTok shops just perfect and they're not really gonna jump into the AI world at all?

Speaker 1:

Yeah. Well, I mean, yeah, we haven't talked too much about AI driven commerce, or because we talk mostly about the advertising side of the business. But, you know, you're right. I mean, I mean, the fact that you just mentioned that Reddit is doing some sort of AI shopping really shows me, like, this is... We we are kind of in the Wild West of where any sort of business model, any sort of thing, it's going to be something that could potentially be big.

Speaker 1:

So we're going to see lots of companies coming out with ways to do AI shopping, AI try on, you know, look at... See what something looks like, you know, in in your house with AI. And, by the way, here's the advertiser that can sell it to you. This... I love this stage where, you know, every day there's like a new big announcement from a company that you have to look at and go, Is this going to be the next big thing?

Speaker 1:

Looking back over my years of researching social media and all the news that happened then and the things that I covered, you know, we know that like, what, maybe 20% of what actually gets announced ends up being something interesting and consequential to the development of the business. But it's really fun to see all these players recognize that, how AI is being incorporated, just behind the scenes in your company, but more and more as a front end to the consumer experience is really important. It's been the foundation of my business looking at consumer behavior. So every time I see something like what you're talking about, it just makes my eyes go, okay. Wow.

Speaker 1:

You know, we are just really in an exciting area... Era for, how consumer behavior is going to change.

Speaker 4:

Let's kind of flip it and look at... You know, imagine your clients are... And we don't need to know any names, of course, but imagine they're more on the media buyer side. Right? So they're kind of trying to navigate all these new things.

Speaker 4:

What are some of the topics top of mind with them and what do you think are some best practices you're seeing kind of, I know it's early, develop. You mentioned, did you call them test budgets or exploratory budgets or something like that? So it seems like they must have a, you know, I don't know anything about the media buyer. It seems like they seem to have some dollars set aside for trying things. That's interesting to know too.

Speaker 1:

For sure. For sure. And, yeah, and I've written about this in my Substack. I wrote a whole piece about how organizations can prepare for AI media and how to know if your organization is ready to participate in AI media. And by the way, AI media is a term that I'm trying to popularize.

Speaker 1:

I think about social media and retail media. AI media is exactly what we've been talking about today, which is the advertising business that's developing on platforms like ChatGPT. So, yeah, I mean, I feel like businesses preparation is definitely rooted in your organization. It's not just a tactical thing. It's not just, oh, hey.

Speaker 1:

You know, this looks interesting. This is like a shiny new toy. Let's put some ad dollars toward it. I feel like it's really important that at that the business, whether it's the agency or it's at the the the client or the marketer side, someone really needs to own the idea of what AI media is internally. Otherwise, I think these...

Speaker 1:

Any any sort of experiment you do is going to stall. I think setting aside a bit of test budget completely makes sense. Where you get that money could be a variety of places. It could come from... Some companies have experimental money set aside for experimental type of things in media.

Speaker 1:

I think search is a place where companies will pull dollars from and will start to see... To take take money from and to to try to impact what they're doing on a company... On a place like ChatGPT. That's partially why the ads look like search ads because it makes it easier for you to go, oh, okay. Well, I could just take a little bit from over here and move it over there and make a nice comparison.

Speaker 1:

So I think search advertising budgets are another place that companies should look to pull from when they're starting to invest in AI media. I think measurement, I mean, measurement is always a topic where brands want more than is available. Mean, in social media, people still want more than what's available. And creators, people still want more than what's available. So right now, there's not a lot of measurement in what you can do on these AI platforms.

Speaker 1:

And so taking what you can get, even if it's what you call... We call, like, vanity metrics or just, like, the basic impressions or things like that, I mean, that's valuable learning. The measurement will get better. Attribution, that's something that I think you could hopefully look toward in the future. You might be able to attribute a little bit right now, but that might be something that is a future kind of metric that companies can prepare for.

Speaker 1:

On the retailer side, though, I mean, I feel like there's a lot that retailers can do. So optimizing your product feeds, having structured data so that the ChatGPT or the AI engines can easily pull information when someone's searching organically. That prepares you so that not only can an AI assistant accurately represent you, but then you also have an asset you can point to when you start to place advertising on these platforms.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. If only someone would start a company that did that.

Speaker 1:

Oh, is there an opportunity here, Scot?

Speaker 4:

Yes. Yes. So, that's what RefiBuy does. So... Yeah.

Speaker 1:

Awesome. Uh-huh. Okay. So... Yeah.

Speaker 1:

That... I mean, you... So you agree then how important it is to have this structured information available. Right?

Speaker 4:

Yeah. I'm prompted you you honor... You... You're a genius.

Speaker 1:

We didn't plan this. We didn't plan this. No. I 100% agree. I mean, the the the structured information is is essential.

Speaker 1:

And the more that retailers can do that, the more... And the more quickly, the better it's going to be for them, both on the organic side of AI as well as forming the foundation for paid media.

Speaker 4:

I wanna be cognizant of your time. I could we... I have to have you back because we could go on for a whole another hour here.

Speaker 1:

It's been Yeah.

Speaker 4:

I've been learning a ton. And the... Kinda looking forward, do you do you... Where do you think this goes? And like, you know, in in my world, because I'm kinda dialed in on the the the retail part of it, I think there's a thing that's kind of like retail media where there's ads built on these new protocols like instant checkout and things where it'll be easier to track kind of like retail media because there'll be a transaction that'll be hosted at ChatGPT or AI mode or wherever.

Speaker 4:

But at least you don't have the endless attribution kind of argument. You're just kind of like, boom, we sold something. Do you think it looks a lot like that or do you think it's going to be a wide spectrum? What's what's in Debbie's crystal ball for where this stuff goes? And I usually ask people look five years up, but it's so early in a...

Speaker 4:

In ads, maybe just like one... You know, twelve or eighteen months. Let's just, like, look a little bit into the future.

Speaker 1:

Yeah, that's so much easier. Honestly, thing that so I think I mentioned it at the top of the podcast. I researched social media for seventeen years. And every year was a new year. It still is.

Speaker 1:

Every year, something new happens. A new platform comes out. A new controversy happens. A new ad format comes out. Something happens in social media every single year to make it a new year and new new and exciting.

Speaker 1:

AI, I feel like every week... Month is a new year when it comes to this. If you if you if you understand my analogy, like, basically, every month, we're like, wait. A month ago, we hadn't even heard of this, and now it's everywhere. And then two months later, it's something else.

Speaker 1:

And three months later, it's something else. And so I feel like even looking one year out is a challenge, but I'm gonna try. I'm gonna try. So let's talk about ad formats. So we talked about how the ads are kind of boring.

Speaker 1:

They look like search ads. They're not too exciting. That's just barely scratching the surface. I think that ChatGPT is not always going to be just like a basic little search box in the middle of the page. There's going to be different ways that you interact and engage with ChatGPT depending on what you're doing, whether it's shopping, whether it's looking for entertainment, whether you're planning travel.

Speaker 1:

There are going to be different interfaces, and that will open up the opportunity to have different types of ad formats more akin to the spectrum of ads that advertisers are used to. Video ads, I know ads look like social media ads in environments that are a little bit more social. You know, ad ads that lead to, you know, per... Direct purchase opportunities. So I feel like, you know, we're really just at the beginning stages of what advertising is going to look like.

Speaker 1:

I don't... I expect there will be brand new formats that we have never heard of before, that advertisers are going to have to get used to. We saw that with social media, we... Where where face... Companies like Facebook came out with ads that looked just like content in the feed, and you had to you had to figure out, well, how do I, as an advertiser, show up, you know, among all of those feed posts that I that that that are in someone's social media feed.

Speaker 1:

They did figure that out, and it became hugely successful. So I feel like in AI, we're going to see formats that we've never even comprehended before. And then, you know, honestly, we talk... There's so much talk about agents and agentic commerce, and I think that is a shift we're going to see more and more development in over the next few months and into 2027. Buying, the ability to have an agent go out and buy for you, to make a transaction for you is going to start to become more of a reality.

Speaker 1:

And, you know, not to get too too futuristic, but it's going to lead to an environment where the advertising is not aimed at the human eyeballs or the human sensibilities at all, but is aimed at the agent and is designed to get the agent to perform an action. So it's not even going to look like advertising. We might start to see glimmers of that in the next year.

Speaker 4:

Well, I like that. Let's let's save more conversation on that for next time because that Yeah.

Speaker 1:

Let's do it.

Speaker 4:

That's... It will stay fascinating to me. And maybe there'll be even ones for the open clause that everyone's like, there's there's a set of my friends that have, like, gone way off the deep end on that. I don't know if you know any of those people, but there's open claw and maximus now that are just, like, way, way deep into that. And they have been doing all kinds of these types of things.

Speaker 4:

Yeah.

Speaker 1:

I mean, so we're talking about open claw right now. I mean, I would love to come back in, like, three months and and and and talk about whether we are still talking about Open Claw or we're going, oh gosh. That was so three months ago. Like, because we moved on to something else.

Speaker 4:

Debbie, really appreciate it. I wanna be cognizant of your time. Appreciate you coming on. Your, your newsletter is AI ad economy, and it's on Substack, and we'll link to that in the show notes. And then it's also on LinkedIn.

Speaker 4:

And the way I found it is I went to Debra Aho Williamson, and then you link to it right there on your LinkedIn. And you could probably find it just by searching AI Ad Economy. Anywhere, anything else, any other places people can find you? Are those the two main spots?

Speaker 1:

I'm really active on LinkedIn, so definitely follow me there. I write about this and and talk about all the trends in what's happening in AI and advertising there. And, yeah, it's been really great to talk to you and and to learn a little bit more about your business as well.

Speaker 4:

Thanks for getting us up to speed on the AI Ad Economy. We'll have to have you back soon.

Speaker 1:

Awesome. Thank you so much.

Speaker 2:

Follow, rate, and share to stay up to date with Retailgentic, your guide to the future of AI shopping agents.