On The Money

Backing seasonal shares that have a strong track record of outperforming in the winter months is an investment strategy that’s tended to deliver the goods more often than not. Lee Wild, head of equity strategy at ii, joins Kyle to explore the reasons behind the trend and name the shares he’s chosen for his two hypothetical winter portfolios.

Kyle Caldwell is Funds and Investment Education Editor at interactive investor.

On The Money is an interactive investor (ii) podcast. For more investment news and ideas, visit www.ii.co.uk/stock-market-news.

Important information:
This podcast is intended for information purposes only and is not a personal recommendation. Past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of your investments may go down as well as up, and you may not get back all the money that you invest. Full performance information can be found on the company or index summary page on the interactive investor website.
The ii Personal Pension (SIPP) is for people who want to make their own decisions when investing for retirement. Usually, you won’t be able to withdraw your money until age 55 (57 from 2028). If you are in any doubt about the suitability of the ii Personal Pension (SIPP), Stocks & Shares ISA, Trading Account, and/or any related tax treatment of these products, you should seek independent financial advice.
Interactive Investor Services Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

What is On The Money?

Every week, Kyle Caldwell and guests take a look at how the biggest stories and emerging trends could affect your investments, with practical tips and ideas to help you navigate your way through. Join the conversation, tell us what you want us to talk about or send us a question to OTM@ii.co.uk. Visit www.ii.co.uk for more investment insight and ideas.

Kyle Caldwell:

Hello, and welcome to On The Money, the weekly podcast that covers investments and pension topics in a practical manner. This episode, we're gonna focus on an investment strategy that has tended to deliver the goods more often than not, which is to target shares that have a strong track record of outperforming in the winter months. To explain all and to also towards the end of the podcast, discuss some other stock market approaches, I'm joined by Lee Wiles, who is head of equity strategy at Interactive Investor. So, Lee, it was twelve years ago when you first put together these two hypothetical winter portfolios. To kick off, could you explain the premise of the strategy and how it's decided which shares make the course?

Lee Wild:

Yeah. Sure. Thanks, Carl. Yeah. I mean, your objective objective is to create two portfolios that best exploit stock market seasonality.

Lee Wild:

So some stocks have to do... Or do do better in the in the winter months, so winter months being from November to April. So the portfolios are data driven, so we don't make any sort of stock specific decisions ourselves, decide what... We run the data, and that gives you the five constituents for each of the two portfolios and the manual intervention. So it's a really simple process, and we only screen stocks from the FTSE three fifty.

Lee Wild:

That's just for a greater level of liquidity. So there are two portfolios. We've got the wild consistent winter portfolio. So that's the five most reliable winter performers over the past ten years. So we run the data over ten years.

Lee Wild:

We see year by year which, you know, stocks have returned or or returned profits and generating positive returns. So for the consistent portfolio, constituent companies must have generated profits in nine of the past 10 winters. So those with the best average return make the cut. So average return between November and April over the past decade, excluding dividends for the... This year's constituents in the consistent portfolio is 13.9%.

Lee Wild:

So if you had owned them for the FTSE three fifty benchmark index, it's 5.1%. So for the aggressive winter portfolio, that's made up of slightly higher risk, higher return stocks. They may still have risen in eight of the past 10 winter periods. So we relax the the entry requirements, gives us a bigger pool of of potential companies to to choose from. So get that in that pool, logically, some would have generated better returns than those stocks in the in the consistent portfolio.

Lee Wild:

So we look at those high return stocks that have still risen in eight of the past 10 winters, and the average return for those... For them in the current portfolio is 20.1%.

Kyle Caldwell:

And over the twelve years you've been running these hypothetical portfolios, they've outperformed the market nine times out of 12. Could you run through the figures and what for you are the key drivers behind performance? Why does the winter portfolio strategy tend to wear? The things get... Were things were brilliant

Lee Wild:

up until COVID. So COVID threw a spanner in the works of a lot of these sort of stock market anomalies. So up to then, the portfolios had risen every year since 2014. And since then, you know, we we had a couple of, you know, few volatile years, but we're back on a sort of winning track last year. Portfolios did well.

Lee Wild:

Think we're gonna talk about them in a minute. But... The data is provided by Steven Eckert. He's a mathematician and cofounder of Herman Herman House. So statistics produced by him show that a £100 invested in the FTSE All Share Index in 1994, if you'd held them for the past thirty two years, you'd have got £352 now excluding dividends, so it's a good return.

Lee Wild:

If they'd only invested in the market between the November 1 and April 30 every year, that £100 will be worth £486. So significantly better. It's for... But to... Just for clarity, if you'd only invested in the summer months over that period, your £100 would have shrunk to £66.

Lee Wild:

So this seasonality, well, you know, not everybody, you know, believes in it, but, you know, the numbers don't lie. So as I say, the pool... Portfolio had risen every year until the the pandemic. Still at nine out of 12 winters. So, yeah, recovery since is...

Lee Wild:

It puts the aggressive portfolio in a very strong position versus the benchmark. And if you'd have bought the the aggressive portfolio in 2014, reinvested profits into the 2015 portfolio and so on, you'd have generated a return of a 115.6% so far. So it's 13 percentage points more than the the FTSE three 50. The consistent portfolio is less. It's a a 67% total return, but still respect able.

Lee Wild:

So you ask why it works. So there isn't really a neat explanation. I mean, research by Steven Eckig has gone back many decades and and sort of rummaging through the history books. You can really trace some of these trends and seasonality back hundreds of years. And it...

Lee Wild:

It's not just The UK where it works. It does work in other markets too. So lots of theories why that is, And and the... These are the three most probable, I think. It's it's the greater flows into the market after the summer break.

Lee Wild:

So a lot of the big decision makers at the financial institutions in the city and on Wall Street and elsewhere, you know, obviously, take the summer breaks. Decisions are parked on... Until, yeah, those decision makers return from the holiday, then that that... Those decisions take time to implement in the market, and that's when you start to get the, you know, the repercussions of those decisions starts to be through through the winter months. So, you know, in the old days, the city would shut down for, you know, Henley and the cricket and all that...

Lee Wild:

All those sorts of sporting events over the summer. People would go away. Nothing would happen in the markets. It's not like that anymore. It's a, you know, twenty four seven global markets.

Lee Wild:

Communication's much quicker and easier these days. So it's it's a liquidity and a sentiment thing, I think, from this this perspective. These... That... That's what these new strategies would do.

Lee Wild:

When the people return from the summer holidays, you get a big boost in in liquidity and sentiment. So that's the that's the first reason. Santa rally is the next one. Again, why that happens is up for discussion as well. So this really refers to his...

Lee Wild:

When equity markets historically have done well in the run up to Christmas. I mean, you could attribute it to seasonal optimism more broadly, but there is also some calendar year end window dressing of portfolios by the funds and investment houses. So where they might sell losers, buy stocks that have done better over the year, might flatter the flatter the the portfolios or the numbers that determine the city bonuses. So that's another theory. And finally, you've got ISA season, which is, you know, a really strong period for for shares when you...

Lee Wild:

It's at the end of our financial winter. So investors really taking advantage of tax efficient products in the run up to tax year end. And so investing in companies, parking them in tax tax wrappers. So, as I say, referred to as icy season and seem to us as probably... We we know that that's a busy period for stock markets.

Lee Wild:

So of... On its own, it's not gonna be a a huge driver, but sort of as part of that, it it it likely will have some influence.

Kyle Caldwell:

As you pointed out, people will believe in the seasonality, others won't. But I I do think it's very fascinating at the very least, and we'll come back to the Santorale towards the end of the podcast. You've just mentioned the long term performance, and you pointed out that last year was a successful pay. Could you run through the shares that stood out last year?

Lee Wild:

Yeah. Of course. Yeah. The I mean, last year... I mean, there...

Lee Wild:

There's always a number of... And it's normally geopolitical events that sort of will will move markets through the through the six months. Last year, we had obviously the Iran war crash and subsequent recovery. So at the end of the strategy last year, the consistent portfolio had returned 6.3% or 6.6% including dividend income. The aggressive portfolio was up 6.7% or 7%...

Lee Wild:

7.7% with dividends. That's FTSE three fifty with 6.27.5%. In terms of the the companies, well, I mean, the the consistent portfolio, we had the IT services firm and and now the FTSE one hundred constituent computer center. There were profit upgrades there. Shares were up 30% over the winter, a great contributor.

Lee Wild:

And safety products conglomerate, Halmer, that did brilliantly too. That was up around 24%. And in the aggressive portfolio, we had real stellar returns from Keller, the engineering contractor, that was up 41%, and the games workshops, fantasy war games, that was up 22%. BAE Systems in the news because of, you know, global conflicts and pressure from the states for European governments to spend more GDP on on on defense. That was great for BAE, a big boost from that extra military spend and and expectation that that spend will continue over many years.

Lee Wild:

Shares were up over 9% last winter.

Kyle Caldwell:

So let's now move on to this year's lineup. For people watching the podcast on either YouTube or Spotify, we're gonna show both hypothetical portfolios and show tables of them, of the constituents. But could you give a a brief run through, Lee, of what has made the lineup this year?

Lee Wild:

Yep. We we got three stocks keep their place in the in the consistent portfolio. So Computer Center after last year's rally, which I just mentioned, that was never gonna miss out. It's had a great summer too, though. So news flow has been good.

Lee Wild:

We're gonna find out more. There's a Capital Markets Day on November 24, and there's a full year trading update at the end of January. So we'll find out more about Computer Center. But the fact that you had a great summer, it may or may not be a problem. It just could be a you know, a long period of positive momentum, which is is fine, but it'd be nice if it had tailed off, slowed down over the summer to to take a breather.

Lee Wild:

But Computacente still looks like a great company, so we'll see how that does. Halmer is in again. Shares were down over 20% after a great winter. Shares were down at 20% over the summer, doing really what we would like constituent stocks to do. Do well over the winter, not so well over the the summer.

Lee Wild:

Come back the next winter and do well, that sort of thing. So, yeah, over the summer, most of it was downgrading full year growth forecast, but, yeah, hopefully, a platform for recovery this winter. ADM was in again, risen nine of the past 10 winters, so, fingers crossed for, for another one this year. And Games Workshop, that's one of two new constituents. As I say, it was in the aggressive last year.

Lee Wild:

Now it's in both. Shares were back where they were this time last year after a big tumble over the summer, so we're hopefully, again, a platform for for winter growth. And Standard Chartered, that's the other new face. Not been in either portfolio since since inception, So does have a strong record of of winter returns. So all eyes on on the the banks there.

Lee Wild:

In the aggressive portfolio, we've got Games Workshop, Keller, BAE. They keep their place. Computer Center is like Games Workshop in both portfolios this year, and it's done by Antifa Gas, the sort of big Chilean copper miner. Shares fell 8% over the summer. Disappointing production targets for '27 and and warning about higher diesel prices and and their impact on cost.

Lee Wild:

But, yeah, Antarctica has bounced at the start of this year's portfolio, so it had a couple of great sessions until the until the midterms. But, yeah, one one hopefully to to watch this winter.

Kyle Caldwell:

And what are your thoughts on the prospects for the portfolios this year, I mean, during the winter months? I mean, as ever, there's no shortage of headwinds, but it does seem to be, at the time, it's recording at least, a lot more pessimism at the moment. Lot of volatility among tech related, AI related companies with, you know, increasing question marks over whether the enormous sums of money that's being spent on artificial intelligence, infrastructure, and advancements, whether that's gonna lead to the future earnings growth and profits that the market expects. So what are your thoughts for the portfolios against that backdrop?

Lee Wild:

Yeah. Look. I mean, as as we speak, the past two trading sessions have seen massive losses for for those... The stocks that you're referring to, really, the AI trade. So, yeah, I mean, it's a warning that markets can be can be volatile.

Lee Wild:

So, you know, as you say, they've spent hundreds of billions of of dollars on computer chips and data center infrastructure. Investors are gonna wanna see a return on the... On that money. So, yeah, the midterms, they knock BAE Systems concerns that you defer about defense spending. BAE makes a hell of a lot of money in The States, and any any suggestion that defense spending there may may be curtailed to whatever degree is is is, you know, making investors nervous around those sorts of defense stocks, be it The US exposed stocks.

Lee Wild:

But the things I I go through in my... The articles that I write that give... To to talk about the... Or introduce the winter portfolios, every year, I run through a big list of risks. And most years, it's the same.

Lee Wild:

It's just... We... Last year, we had the AI trade. Last year, I was talking about the budget and and wars, whether it be in Ukraine, you know, conflict or tensions in The Middle East, very similar risks every year, and they've done pretty well up to up to now. So the budget that we've just had, I mean, the launch of this year's winter portfolios was sandwiched by The UK budget and with the midterms.

Lee Wild:

So The UK budget was was kind of neutral for for for the portfolio anyway. And the the midterms... Well, I mean, we'd have expected some volatility anyway. Whether or not there was any sort of direct impact on the AI trade, you'd have expected a little bit of volatility as people analyzed, you know, the the the repercussions and what what the election result meant. But the biggest impact really has been has been The Middle East and the decision in in February to, you know, to attack Iran, and we're feeling the repercussions of that through inflation and higher interest rates.

Lee Wild:

So, yeah, we've we've been confident in previous years. We've had we've had worse in previous years. We had the the the pandemic and bounced back from that. One So would imagine we can bounce back from from some of these other other rooms of high profile geopolitical events.

Kyle Caldwell:

As you've outlined, there's always risks and headwinds. I think if there weren't many risks that people are thinking about, then that'd be a risk in itself. That'd be a sign that maybe the markets become way too overconfident and valuations are potentially racing ahead of reality. Now while our customers cannot buy the portfolios in their entirety, the constituents within them can provide plenty of food for falls. Although, there should be lots of other things that investors should be thinking about when researching stocks, think about a lot of fundamental factors, and, of course, investors should be trying to ensure that they have a resilience and a a well rounded portfolio.

Lee Wild:

Yeah. I mean, the portfolio is... They're they're never intended to to form the nucleus of any investment strategy. It is an anomaly. It's got a good history of success, but the portfolios are very concentrated.

Lee Wild:

There's only five in each one. So you would never never sort of pin all of your hopes on on on winter portfolios. They should really make up just a... Probably a small part of any investors who brought the portfolio.

Kyle Caldwell:

And while the historical data does indeed show the stock markets do perform better over the winter months versus the summer months, That doesn't mean that you should, you know, sell in May and go away like the old sort of maximum, well, goes. Yeah. For me, that's an analogy that is old hat. I think you you referred earlier to the reasons why because, you know, the the analogy used to be because, you know, investors will go away for the summer, come back on Saint Legend's Day. They didn't have mobile phones.

Kyle Caldwell:

Well, as you mentioned, you know, it's trade twenty four seven in in in some instances, and everyone's got a mobile phone, and they can, you know, use apps to buy and sell stocks very easily.

Lee Wild:

Yeah. Yeah. Well, look, I mean, the the Winx portfolios and selling, mate, they are related strategies. But you're right. I mean, the idea that you should sell sort of all of your portfolio, you know, ahead of the holiday period and then come back and buy it all back, obviously, it doesn't make any sense.

Lee Wild:

The concept is dated. But as I've mentioned, the summer can be a tricky period. I mean, with with fewer fewer people trading, volumes down, you know, that can... It affects liquidity and can cause greater volatility. So there are sort of...

Lee Wild:

There are reasons to to just be a a little cautious over the summer, but, yeah, selling mate doesn't really work anymore.

Kyle Caldwell:

I'm gonna end by just very briefly going through a couple of other strategies. One that comes to mind for me is the dogs of the footy strategy. So under the strategy, you build a portfolio of the 10 highest yielding 4,100 stocks, and you hold them for a year, and then you then look for the next 10 highest yields and stocks. You typically do it at the start of a year. Now the rationale is the...

Kyle Caldwell:

Some of these companies are potential value opportunities. They've been out of favor because the... Either the share price has fallen, the yield has therefore risen. However, I think with any high dividend yields, you should really treat it with a healthy dose of skepticism as... Because because of our share prices and yields have that inverse relationship.

Kyle Caldwell:

The high yield can mean stocks out of favor, and the market is potentially expecting a dividend cut down the line. So it's really important to look into the bonus, check whether you think that dividend is sustainable going forward. Look at things like dividend cover, its track record for growing dividends, the debt levels, and whether the management has made any sort of recent comments committing to the dividends. Although there have been occasions over the years when management has promised to maintain or increase the dividends, and then they then cut. So I would I would also be a little bit skeptical about as well.

Kyle Caldwell:

For me, if I was looking at the 10 highest yields and stocks in the 41 hundreds, I'd consider them on an individual basis rather than buying all 10.

Lee Wild:

Yeah. No. You... You're right. I mean, high yields or super high yields have often been a a...

Lee Wild:

Or should be a red flag, but, I mean, I don't think you should discount those high yields completely. It's were always worth, as you say, really, worth doing your, you know, some investigation. I mean, you'd probably only want a little bit of exposure to them anyway. I mean, you wouldn't sort of, you know, bet the farm on on sort of a a 10% yield. I mean, it might come good, but it's less likely, and there are...

Lee Wild:

It comes with with added risks. But, I mean, you and I... You sort of create these portfolios at the beginning of the year, these portfolios to generate £10,000 of annual income. So within that, I will look at... Yeah.

Lee Wild:

You need an element of safety. You can't be gung ho when you're looking to generate that level of income, but you will... You you you do have some room to add a little bit of spice. You know, things haven't always gone well. I I typically choose maybe one company from the from the 100 that...

Lee Wild:

Or or the three fifty perhaps. It's it's maybe got a slightly higher, you know, more generous yield that comes with extra risk. And I might put a little bit less into that than I might... What I do with some of the other constituents. So it just adds that, you know, you can supercharge returns in some years.

Lee Wild:

Other other years, it doesn't work, but then you haven't committed quite so much to that stock. So, yeah, high yields, they are a red flag, but do your research and don't discount them all.

Kyle Caldwell:

Another seasonal strategy which we've spoken about is the Santa rally. So this is based on the fact that December was typically one of the best months of the year for the stock market. However, my understanding is from when I'm doing a bit of research for the podcast, there isn't really a a generally accepted explanation for the reason why December is so strong?

Lee Wild:

No. I mentioned there a couple of possibilities. I mean, you've got the, I say, broader seasonal optimism. So everyone's in a better mood. Maybe.

Lee Wild:

You've got the year end wind addressing of portfolios by by sort of investment houses, that sort of thing. So the one eye on city bonuses in, you know, in a few months time, that sort of stuff. You know, is it the more positive vibe that Christmas generates typically? Possibly. People at Christmas parties and sort of a generally happier time of year for for for a lot of people.

Lee Wild:

But, equally, it doesn't really guarantee... You know, the Santo rally, everybody talks about it this time of year. Everybody looks for it. I mean, we've done some analysis over the years about this. The the Santo Rally won't start on the December 1 and end sort of...

Lee Wild:

Over the Christmas period at some point, you know, Christmas day or eve or whenever that might be. And it... It's very... It depends where you start that Christmas period from depending on what returns you're gonna see. Yeah.

Lee Wild:

You you you... You're there and more often than not, you get a a a... An uplift at some point during the Christmas period, but it's not always as clear cut. So... And

Kyle Caldwell:

to end, wanted to focus on a longer term trend that tends to be a friend for investors, which is the so called smaller companies effect. So there's been academic research on this. There's a often cited report from the London Business School, which shows from 1955 that there is a a notable difference between the performance of smaller companies versus larger companies. There's, of course, plenty of logic behind this. You know, due to their size, smaller companies have greater room to grow versus a larger company.

Kyle Caldwell:

And as the late Jim Slater says, elephants don't gallop, which, of I really like. And this part of the market, it is less intensively researched by... For managers and other investors, and then that gives stock pickers a great opportunity to gain an edge. However, this historical long term performance has certainly not been playing out over the past five years or so. It's been a tough time to be a smaller company's investor.

Kyle Caldwell:

And one of the main reasons why is the the macro backdrop, the higher interest rates environment we're in, which has been a headwind for small company stocks.

Lee Wild:

Yeah. I mean I mean, you're right to say that it's it's easier for investors to research smaller companies these days. I mean, the the the... You know, data going back to the to the nineteen fifties. You know, back then, it was very difficult for you to get a a real handle on some of these smaller companies.

Lee Wild:

Certainly, it would have been the same in The States and and and The UK. Now it's far far easier. Have a have a little look on the Internet, and there's lots lots of publicly available research. But that doesn't make it... You know, it makes it easier to find information on the company, but it doesn't make it easier necessarily to find those sort of 10 baggers or those those real big winners that people look for among the smaller companies, and you also write with higher interest rates.

Lee Wild:

Yeah. These growth companies, smaller growth companies rely on on borrowed money to fund growth. And if that money becomes more expensive to borrow, then that's gonna impact the the business. So... And the the the growth trajectory as well.

Lee Wild:

So it's, yeah, great looking for smaller companies, but... And and they've had a... There was a a, you know, a good period where yeah, you could... With access to cheap money following the great financial crisis or global financial crisis, you had to, yeah, access to cheap money for for a number of years. It's not quite that straightforward these days.

Kyle Caldwell:

Well, Lee, that's all we got time for for today, but you will be regularly updating the two hypothetical winter portfolios in the coming months. Listeners to podcast can keep track of them on ii.co.uk.

Lee Wild:

Thanks, Scott.

Kyle Caldwell:

And that's it for our latest episodes of On The Money. As ever, we love to hear from listeners. If you've got an idea of a topic you would like us to cover in a future episode, then please do get in touch by emailing otm@ii.co.uk. As ever, you can find plenty of investment inspiration on the Interactive Investor website, ii.co.uk, and I'll hopefully see it again next Thursday.