Scalability School

Episode 9 speed-runs the biggest retention levers brands can pull to increase revenue growth and improve order volume. They debunk deliverability myths (image–text ratios, why adding real text helps), along with comparing the differences of plain-text vs image-heavy emails. Jacob Sappington also clarifies Klaviyo vs GA vs ad platform attribution and how Klaviyo's new active-profile enforcement curbs old billing "hacks."

Key Takeaways:

  • The single change to a pop-up that can spike opt-ins and orders immediately
  • Why you should change the pop-up and not your flows first
  • Offer vs build vs creative: how should you weight each for mobile pop-ups
  • Why this one thing is likely killing your Landing Page's performance to convert.
  • How your traffic source may be affecting your conversion rate
  • The easy setup mistakes that are likely throttling the performance of your email flows
  • The magic number of how often 7- and 8-figure brands should email and text without burning the list
  • Are third-party identity tools worth the risk and which safer paths exist

To learn more about the Scalability School Podcast or listen to other episodes head to https://scalabilityschool.com

To Connect with Jacob Sappington send him a DM at https://x.com/jsappington

To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com

To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch

To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck

Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

brands just have really bad popups.

You know, the past couple of years,

they're kind of becoming like a cool

thing again, but for so long, I think

they're just ignored and it just

felt like something that was never

cohesive to the site.

And so it just feels like they're

actually being taken seriously.

And there's been a lot

of players into the space.

And so yeah, I'm here for it.

If I'm pulling levers, I get into a

client's email account and like the

first couple of things that I can do is

either send more emails, make

the emails look prettier.

I can fix the pop-up or I can go and

start messing with flows.

Like I'm sure it depends by brand, but

like, do you have any

examples of like simple changes that you

made to the pop-up or any

changes that you made that led to a

pretty big impact for opt-in rights

and probably revenues or results?

Pop-up is like the lowest lift, highest

impact place that we can touch.

It's always a part of our initial plans

for how we help our clients grow.

You know, developing an email takes time,

especially when you're first

meeting a client and getting to know

their voice and everything.

But we can probably nail like 20 words of

coffee on a pop-up pretty quickly.

But like just last week, we had a client

where it was, it was as simple

as just making a pop-up a full screen.

It was a, a white box variant versus a

full screen variant, five and a half

percent to 8.3% same AOV, double orders

and double the conversion rate.

All these inbox providers and primarily

Google, Google's probably

going to make up 60%

of your list, maybe 70%.

Um, they don't tell you what they factor

into for deliverability.

And so you're kind of always making some

assumptions that people always

talk about like an image to text ratio.

I think 60, 40 people recommend, but a

few stuff, text into your emails,

they're likely going to

inbox a little better.

And that's, um, there, I mean, there's

softwares that are set up around

this, uh, are just injecting text into

your emails to help you, uh,

inbox a little bit.

Yeah.

Would you trust like a one

hour view based attribution?

If it's Snapchat, I don't trust anything.

Snapchat says meta click based.

I started to get a little bit more

trustworthy, but, um, there's a lot

of nuance there too.

So anyways, not to be real.

And now let's take a listen to the

scalability school podcast.

All right.

Welcome to episode nine of the

scalability school podcast.

Brad and I are here with Jacob Sappington

email SMS retention legend.

And he's going to talk to us today about

how these tactics or how we can use

tactics on these channels, uh, to

actually make money today, Jacob.

Welcome to the show.

Yeah.

Thanks for having me guys.

It's my first podcast in a while.

So, uh, it's good to be back.

Yeah.

Well, we, uh, we kicked Zach off in

exchange, so we're, we're much

happier for you to be

here than, than him.

Yeah.

Off the Island.

Yeah.

Off the Island.

Yeah.

He had too many Twitter followers.

So where does it now it's called the

losers and the econ

and Brad and I hosted.

Yeah.

Um, the, all right.

So, you know, there's a ton of things

that we can get into today.

I think obviously everybody's here to

like, what can we do in

retention and SMS better?

Um, I think there's a lot of it that you,

there's a lot of hype and

there's a lot of ups and downs.

Brad, there's some like stuff that you

wanted to get into right away in

terms of hot or not, essentially.

You want to, you want

to kick it off with that?

Yeah.

I don't, I don't know if we're going to

exactly go one by one through this, but

I think it'll, uh, if we hit some like

overrated and underrated discussion

points, I think that can push us into, we

can take them and go deeper.

So I'll give you the floor to decide if

you want to expand on any of these things

or not, but I'll just, I'll just kind of

list some things and you let me know how

you're feeling.

Um, all right, let's go.

All right.

Pop up software, um, or I did underrated.

I love Clavier software.

It's including your plan.

So I would say, uh, the right ones are

appropriately rated and there's

a lot that are overrated as well.

Okay.

Cool.

So we don't, you don't have

to mention specific providers.

I know you're a big, you're a big fan of

Clavier for lots of reasons.

That was actually something I wanted to

talk about later is like, I feel like

people are perpetually confused about how

Clavier bills and I feel like I see you

on Twitter, I'm explaining it to

everybody all the

time we could save that.

Okay.

So I guess let's, let's do, let's do is a

sub bullet point of popups in general

that like, what are people missing with,

with popups that makes them not as

effective as they otherwise should be.

I think for the most part,

Branches have really bad popups.

I think, you know, the past couple of

years through amped and through

Alia and through all these other ones,

like they're kind of becoming like a

cool thing again, but for so long, I

think they were just ignored and it just

felt like something that was never

cohesive to the site.

And so it just feels like they're

actually being taken seriously.

And there's been a lot

of players into the space.

And so, yeah, I'm here for it.

I love it.

I want to see, you know,

more people in our space.

Do you think that the software is the

thing that like, is it, is it the

software that drives the impact like a,

like an AMP to Oranalia or is it the

copywriting, is it the offer?

Is it some combination of those things?

I'm sure it's a combination, but like,

how would you wait

maybe each of those things?

We always look for three main tactics.

So we think about the offer.

I think I could have a great offer and a

terrible looking pop-up and I could rip

options.

Um, I think we think about the build, how

you functionally put it together matters

a lot.

And then the third lever

that we think about is creative.

So headlines, um, you know, you know,

assets that you use for it, those are

important, but like on mobile, we prefer

things to be very direct, not a lot of

creative involved in it.

And so it's, it's on there, but it's,

it's third for a reason.

I think the software

can make a difference.

But what I struggle with with different

software vendors is for the most part,

they have the same tech.

What I really struggle with is that, uh,

you know, how someone defines an

impression or who they're defining as an

impression or as a conversion.

None of us just know.

So, um, you know, maybe, you know, back

when AMP first came out, like, uh, I

always had like, we, we still use them

because we would like, uh, fact check,

um, email subscribes in Clavio as a

source of truth to make sure that

everything was, um, uh, as an expected,

like, um, you know, you don't just like

clone a pop-up and

double your opt-in rate.

And so I think that the.

Biggest confusing point that's still

confusing for me for a lot of sources is

just how do you actually define that?

Um, and trying to get like an Apple

samples comparison to, to traffic.

That's the biggest challenge.

So if we're talking about, let's keep

going on the pop-up thing.

Do you fire pop-ups on landing pages

versus just the main site or do you

fire them on listicles and

not just shopable landers?

Like what's your thoughts on that?

Yep.

Um, a lot of brands push the merger with

their traffic to those LPs.

I want to capture traffic there.

It's one of the main ways that we've, uh,

been able to grow this

growth for, um, some of our clients.

The thing is you just have to make sure

that it's relevant to whatever

content you have on the shop or the LP.

Like one of the worst things you could do

is have a BOGO on your shoppable

because you're being really aggressive

with some acquisition offer.

And then your pop-up offers 10% off.

And so you're

immediately adding confusion.

You're immediately adding friction.

Someone thinks can I

combine BOGO on 10% off?

Um, it's just like

really weird messaging there.

So, you know, maybe, maybe listicles are,

uh, something that's even

like less offer incentivized.

Maybe it's, um, something, you know,

like, I get maybe a guide of some

sorts or, you know, some, some sort of

content that resonates with what

they're actually pushing on the listicle,

but we want the popups on there.

We don't, you know, there's always this

expectation of some level of bounce

rate increase from adding a pop-up.

But the, the, the thought process that we

have is that the LTV of an email

subscriber is higher than the LTV of a

non-email subscriber.

And so my ability to say in front of them

and the cheaper method than

meta, um, is really important.

And so, uh, yeah, we still want them on

those places as well.

What do you expect for like good pop-up

rates, like our collection rate?

We see a lot of

brands come to us like 3%.

Um, we've had some brands

that we've been able to rip 20%.

Um, and I think it really just comes down

to the traffic that they're driving.

We've had brands we've

struggled to get to 6% too.

And so a lot of times those are brands

that are like, have like really

heavy organic presences as well.

And so the reason they're coming on site

is not the same reason.

You know, if you're running an ad, um,

and someone's interested in buying

today and you're running an offer driven

pop-up, there's probably a pretty high

likelihood that they're interested.

But if someone's coming to you from SEO,

from organic social, the reason

that they're there is not to shop likely.

Um, and so those are the

times like brands like that.

We've had brands who had like really

heavy organic presences and we've just

had to separate that traffic out or show

them different pop-ups relative

to why they're on the site.

That's really interesting.

There's, I would love to have like some

specific examples of pop-up changes.

So I would say, I'm curious, like if you,

if you broke things down into, we're very

heavily deviated off of this overrated

under-rated and I'm okay with it.

Cause this is really,

this is really interesting.

Like focusing on, um, pop-ups, I think

it'd be interesting to know like where

pop-ups generally speaking, whether it's

the software or not, um, fit into like,

if I'm pulling levers, I get into a

client's email account and like the first

couple of things that I can do is either

send more emails, make the emails look

prettier, I can fix the pop-up or I can

go and start messing with flows.

Like I'm sure it depends by brand, but

like, let's, let's say that it is the,

the pop-up and maybe you disagree with

that, but like, do you have any examples

of like massive changes or like simple

changes that you made to the pop-up or

any changes that you made that led to a

pretty big impact for opt-in rates and

probably revenue as a result.

Yep.

Yep.

Pop-up is like the lowest lift highest

impact place that we can touch.

It's always a part of our initial plans

for how we help our clients grow.

You know, developing an email takes time,

especially when you're first media

client and getting to know their voice

and everything, but we can probably

nail like 20 words of copy

on a pop-up pretty quickly.

And we've had clients who, we've had

clients who came on for paid and not

email, and we've seen the pop-up and

said, that's actually problematic.

You're, you're gonna, um, prevent, you

know, put a roadblock towards paid

social, having an impact as well.

And so we've done free pop-ups for

clients like that before in the past,

just to not, you know, make

it harder for our paid team.

But like just last week, we had a client

where it was, it was as simple as just

making a pop-up a full screen.

It was a, a light box variant versus a

full screen variant, five and a half

percent to 8.3%.

Um, double the orders, double the, um,

let me think, same AOV double orders

and double the conversion rate.

That's pretty, I mean, it's interesting.

You would say, because I feel like a lot

of people come in and looking at flows

as the first place that they're, I mean,

obviously I think that's where a lot of

people go, um, and where a lot of other

email firms go, but you would say pop-up

is an easier one to

win, win with right away.

Pretty interesting.

Brad, feel free to follow if you have

other pop-up questions, but I'm going to

get into like, I'm just going to talk

about flows for a second.

So let's say the average client comes in

there, seven to eight figure brand.

They have some flow set up like, you

know, sort of the

standard win back or whatever

else, right?

Like the things that

everybody tells them to put in there.

Where are you going to look for

optimization in terms of places that

a lot of people aren't looking?

Yeah.

Before I jump into that one thing I also

just want to think about for pop-ups

is, uh, pop-ups touch everything.

Pop-ups touch your flows.

They're, they directly

feed into your flows.

Um, if I optimize that content or I

optimize the framework, um, but I

don't have more people

coming in, my upside is limited.

If I go from a five person,

I'll turn to an eight percent.

I'll turn to eight.

What's that?

Like 40% maybe something like that.

So I try to do math here.

So we don't, yeah, yeah.

Good.

I could call it.

That's a good idea.

That's a good idea.

But anyway, so like I immediately add

more people to the,

to the flow final pains

are a little bit of, um, a lagging

indicator that it's like, it's, it's

like kind of like retirement.

You know, everyone says that if you start

saving for retirement when you're 18, by

the time you're 65, it just like those

last 10 years, just like shoot up your

network, it's the same concept where if I

don't start collecting today and I

don't optimize that for today, then six

months from now, I don't have the same

number of people that I could be talking

to as I, as I could.

So Andrew, the, the last thing you said

there was, um, like how do we triage

like where to put our focus at in flows?

Yeah.

I mean, I guess what I'm saying is like

everybody had, everybody listening

to this has exposure to

some sort of email work, right?

And I think pop we've identified popups

as being a place that's, that's an

unutilized place or utilized place.

I'm thinking about, all right, what else

are you looking at that like, aren't the

normal things that people would be

looking at in terms of

optimization around flows?

So I would say, do they have all the

flows that we would

expect them to have in place?

Are they using either a first party or a

third party identity resolution software

to increase their number of triggered

events for like flows within the flows.

They do have, do they have enough emails?

A while back, a client asked us or a

prospect assets who we end up signing on

with, um, you know, I only have one

email, my I'm going to

check out how much money

is that costing me.

And they wanted us to put

like a dollar figure to it.

And so what I went ahead and did was we

took three of our biggest clients, um,

who were doing probably $10 million a

month, just in this single flow.

And we aggregated the numbers and we

basically found out that 50% of all of

your abandoned checkout revenue comes on

email one and then two through five, or

you know, how many emails you have in

there contributes to remaining 50%.

So it's almost like I can get $2, but I'm

choosing to pick up $1.

And so it's like, do

you have the right flows?

Do you have enough

emails within those flows?

Do you have any like technical issues in

place that are, but we frequently find

people have flow filters set up

incorrectly or additional filter set up

incorrectly, which you immediately maybe

trim the number of emails that you're

going to send to someone

that's a, that's a common one.

And then maybe the content is just bad.

Maybe they're, they're not focusing on

their offers enough.

Like we've had clients or prospects have

came into our, um, into our funnel and

they have an offer on their pop-up and

then they don't send the offer via

email for 30 minutes or the whole entire

first email doesn't contain the offer.

And so they aren't

getting that for a full day.

So I would say like the biggest bucket of

issues are, do you have the right flows?

Do you have enough emails?

Are you layering an SMS in there?

Um, but then there's a lot

of like small technical things

that can break things as well.

So just to be clear, these flows, these

are like abandoned

checkout, welcome flow.

What are the other ones?

Yeah.

What's that?

So like the welcome flow,

the browser abandoned flow.

Um, yeah.

Everyone says add to cart, but I'm anyone

you identify with the add to cart, you're

also going to

identify through the browse.

And so the only difference there is I can

now talk to them a

little bit differently.

Otherwise like welcome

browse, checkout post purchase.

Yeah.

If like, and we like to split post

purchase between pre-delivery and post

delivery, so what are the expectations

that someone has as soon as they order?

Um, and what are the expectations someone

has after they, their product comes in.

So much of LTV is

driven by the product itself.

And if I can help you adopt the product

that I'm selling to you, I think my

likelihood of increasing your LTV goes up

pretty considerably.

And this identity resolution thing, what

does that, what does that mean?

Yeah.

So, um, you have all these different

identity resolution partners out there.

You have first and third party ones.

Basically they're saying we help you know

who people are on your

list or on your website.

So the first party ones are ones that

they're already on your list and you

know, cookie expires and

we don't know who they are.

So they're browsing my website.

I see someone browsing, but

I can't say this is Andrew.

If I knew this was Andrew, I could send

Andrew an email saying, Hey, Andrew,

you're checking out this

protein powder or whatever it is.

And so first party helps me identify

people who are already on my list.

And then the third party ones are the

retention.com, the

revenue roles, the open

sends, all these different ones that say,

there's someone on your, on your website.

You don't know who they

are, but I know who they are.

And I can tell you who they are.

At least that's the theory behind them.

And those love the first party ones.

And then we're kind of mixing the third

party ones because they can

just enter in so many, so many risks,

especially have done incorrectly.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean, I think, yeah,

that's, that's what I thought.

And I, there was, I remember reading on,

uh, reading about retention.com,

getting into some legal hot water.

You know, I read it

on the public internet.

Okay.

This isn't just me conjecturing.

Like I know that

there's issues around that.

So I was curious what you meant by that.

But, um, anyways, sorry, Brian, go ahead.

Is that, uh, what's your overrated

underrated take on third party?

I think a lot of them aren't actually

great at what they say they're great at

of actually identifying people and

matching them to people on your list.

And if they aren't great at that, then

they're just like opening up the door

for like so many deliverability issues,

which is like the number one

issue that we see from that.

You see, you know, previously you'd set

up like a welcome series of sorts

for those third party people, which is a

terrible idea actually, because

someone's coming to your website, you

just clone over your welcome series and

you say, Hey, thanks for signing up.

And it's like, they actually

didn't sign up for anything.

No one really

recommends that way anymore.

They kind of bring people into

the CRM in a much lighter way.

But even then I'm, I personally don't

like them, but they

also drive performance.

And so it's kind of a balance of what the

client is interested in.

I can, I can tell them

reasons why we don't like it.

And then we can talk about the risks.

And then if they decide they want to take

that risk, then, um, you know, I'm

more than happy to help them out with

that one that I've been, you said

we don't talk about vendors.

No, you can't know letter it.

That's all right.

Okay.

Well, we'll just go ask him for a

sponsorship after the fact.

There we go.

One that I have been really gung ho to

test out and I'm, we have a, we're

assigned a client who was

already on a test with them.

And so that should be wrapping up your

next week or so as customers AI.

Their whole thing is that they have been

throwing out reports showing how

they are much better at identifying than

other third party ones.

And if, if the identification rate goes

up to a pretty healthy degree, and I

don't carry quite the risk that I do with

other ones, then I become

much more interested in it.

Um, right now it's a, uh, it's very easy

to, to wreck things

if you're not careful.

It's funny that you say that the CI

identification thing, I know

if econ brands are using them because

about 40 seconds after I go on their

website, my wife is the one that's opted

in and she's like, why are you on this?

I was like, I'm just poking around.

You know, like I'm just doing some

research and she's like chronically

the one that's opted in.

I'm sure it's IP address related.

Um, and it's, it's hilarious because I

never get them, which is my preference.

Anyways.

So no, it's, uh, it's,

it's funny that you say that.

Cool.

Okay.

Sweet.

Well, we can, we can kind of get back on

the, uh, the overrated, underrated

chain, cause I think that there's a,

there's some, there's some fun stuff we

can continue to dig into there.

So I think we've talked a fair about,

about popups and there's probably

even more to dig into, like maybe you

have some suggestions on popups and

we've also talked a bit about flows.

And again, I'm sure there's some more

there, but like, let's deviate

to campaigns for a second.

Sending volume isn't really like an

overrated underrated thing, but I guess

maybe the way to rephrase it is like,

when you guys look at the average

account, are they

sending too much or too little?

I would say average is too little.

And I think, uh, you know, previously I,

I would have said most brands are, are

good with eight to 10 emails a month.

And you know that I've been

at home for almost four years.

And since then I've had my eyes open that

you can send far more

emails than I ever realized.

We have some clients who send 30 a month.

So basically daily, we have a couple of

clients who send two a day, every

single day, and I think that's pretty far

beyond what I, uh, think is worth it.

And we're working with them to hopefully

reduce that down to just a single

email a day, doing a

nice without tests there.

So anyways, yeah, I think that most

brands can probably

send three emails a week.

Um, if you have a larger list, if you

have more to talk about, if you have more

segmentation opportunities, you can

probably go, um, you know, beyond that.

But I'm talking like big buckets of

customers, I'm merely

engagement audiences.

You know, if you have like, you know,

local things happening in LA or something

like that, and you're seeing it's like

5,000 people, I wouldn't, I'm talking

about like, like, what am I going to do

with my major sends?

I think three a week is a pretty good

standard for most brands.

And then the bigger

brands can go even higher.

Yeah.

And so like a seven, eight figure brand

probably in the seven figure range.

Three week is probably a good benchmark.

Once you get into the

eight, it's more than that.

So that's further for the people that are

listening in that seven and eight range.

If they wanted to go about increasing the

volume of campaigns, I have

two questions related to that.

The first is like, how do they actually

validate that sending more

is actually doing something now?

If they're smaller, sending more revenue

goes up on the website.

It's probably pretty obvious, but I'm

wondering like, okay, how

do you actually validate that?

And two, how did they come up

with ideas for what to send?

Like, are you, do you guys have a list of

here's the campaigns

that we want to talk about?

I'm sure if you have more skews, it's

easier, but I guess those, those

kind of two buckets of

validation and then ideation.

So first off, I would just be a

reasonable benchmark of revenue per email

and see like, as I increase my cadence,

does that maintain to a decent degree?

Another thing is that, um, common trap

that people fall into is they

just evaluate the unsubscribe rate.

And so they will say, Oh, my

unsubscribe rate's still 0.3%.

It's a healthy level.

And it's almost as if like every single

email, you know, for the most part,

you're going to send to the same

audiences pretty consistently.

And if I'm saying to the exact same

person every single day,

then when they unsubscribe,

it's only, you know, I'm only counting

that unsubscribe as one out of the

hundred thousand people in

the email that I sent to.

But if you look at gross unsubscribes,

you see a much different picture where

it's like, Hey, I only had a 0.3%

subscribe rate, but I

lost 2000 subscribers.

And so I would, um,

look at revenue per email.

I'd look at the gross unsubscribe.

So I'm seeing, um, and then I would just

try and make a trade off of like,

understand the trade off is, is an

additional $10,000 in email worth the

2000 people that I lost off my list.

Do I, would I rather, you know, one thing

that brands can use to their advantage

is promotional calendar.

And I think anytime you have a

promotional calendar, you

can be more aggressive on

the number of sins that you have.

And so, um, if you have a really

consistent calendar where you're

messaging people, I think that you can be

more aggressive there without, uh,

some of the, the risk

associated with an increased cadence.

And so, um, those are the primary things

I'd be paying attention to click rate.

Trending down is obviously another one

too, but revenue per email, unsubscribes

are probably too many

KPIs I pay attention.

You mentioned for a client, you're

running a holdout right now.

Like is a holdout necessary?

It sounds like actually isn't maybe even

necessary in most cases, like it might

be overkill or many people don't even

send enough to know in the first place.

Like how you feel about holdouts.

Yeah.

Um, we've not done very many holdouts,

like really at all, because we're only

trying to hold out the campaigns as a

variable and Clavio's own tooling, uh,

is more so focused on the flows.

So it took us a little bit of

brainstorming to figure out

how we can even handle this.

Because a lot of times we're relying on

Clavio's attributed revenue, but if I'm

holding out a group of 20% of people from

an audience, of course, I'm not going to

attribute any revenue to them, even

though they might actually be purchasing.

It's just not the money is

just not being shown to Clavio.

And so what we did was we, uh, took their

main segment that they

send to maybe 650,000

people, he put it through a flow where we

attach some properties, group one, group

two, group three, through five.

And then we assumed that in a 650,000,

uh, sample size that

we would get a fair roll

the dice and we wouldn't have to worry

about trying to, uh, hold LTV consistent

across the groups.

Thanks Dave, re-cook for that suggestion.

And then what we've done now is that we

took 20% of the people we exported the

data Clavio's exports, allow you to see

someone's lifetime value.

And so we're measuring two things.

Does the LTV lift of group one maintain

consistent with groups two through five?

And does the number of subscribers

maintained also stay, like that, do we

see an improvement in

subscribers retained?

So the holdout test

is kind of pain to do.

And I expect that we'll have to run it

for one to two months

at minimum to get any

statistically significant data.

Um, so yeah, if someone's not sending

very much, I would say just send more.

You don't need to over complicate it.

If you feel like you're sending too much,

maybe you could do something like this,

but it is mildly complicated setup.

Yeah.

Um, I'll, I'll shut up and let Andrew

jump in a second here.

I feel like Dave is also, maybe when you

send an invoice to

Dave, I feel like we're

just constantly saying Dave's name.

Maybe he's just really good

at providing value on Twitter.

And that's why he keeps coming up.

I used to work for Dave and he taught me

how you spreadsheets.

I attribute all my

spreadsheets to Dave or Chad GPT.

All right.

Dave, Dave, Dave's going to send you an

invoice instead then.

So awesome.

Um, cool.

Okay.

So then the second piece of that is,

well, actually, okay.

Before we dive into getting more ideas,

what is the sending volume difference in

that specific test that you're running?

I'm just genuinely curious.

103,000 in group one versus whatever.

130,000 times four is

265, 20, 130 versus 520.

Okay.

20%, 20% to 80%.

Gotcha.

And how many, like, what's the difference

in like actual, um, direct, is it volume

of emails?

Like if you're saying you're going from

three to six a week or like, what

does that actually look like?

And it's 14 a week versus seven a week.

Okay.

Okay.

Got it.

Cool.

Okay.

And then my second half of this Andrew,

feel free to stop, but, um,

but just like campaign ideation.

Like if you're going from seven to 14,

like what, what do you talk about?

Yeah.

What are you even going to ask him?

Yeah.

I mean, a lot of the ones that are

sending that frequently offers all the

time for offer, offer new product

release, new product

feature, primarily the

content there for the

client that sends a 14 a week.

Luckily we're not in charge

of content ideation for them.

Very likely.

But, uh, yeah.

Uh, I mean, anytime your business has

something to talk about, talk about that,

uh, product features, testimonial

features, story features.

We had a client that's been scaling

really aggressively in the past year.

They're not a client of this anymore,

but, um, they were scaling really

aggressively and they

did frequent promotions.

And at one point we checked their data

and six other top 10 performing

campaigns were non-promotional

story-based messaging

that was just talking

about someone's experience with their

product and how it's helped them

with problem solution type thing.

And so I think the first thing I jumped

to it would probably be offers as a way

to drive it, but I also know that not

everyone wants to be so offer heavy.

So, you know, leaning into problem

solution, if you have it leading into

testimonials, reviews, product features,

half the battle is

just being in the inbox.

If you're in the inbox and your mind's

one day exists, you know, maybe, maybe

they don't need the product you're trying

to sell them today, but you reminded

them that they do need something else

that you can provide them.

So half the battle is

show up in front of them.

And the other half is like, what, what

can my content help push you to?

So somebody goes, how many, you know,

what's the ratio between, um, sending

SMS versus email?

I mean, I feel like you spend send SMS a

lot less, but curious on that.

Yeah, we're much more

conservative with SMS.

I would say two a week is a pretty good

number for nearly every brand.

I have less hard opinions on this, but I

think one a week would have, would work

for most brands.

And again, like, you know, we talked

about like the cost

of email being so much

cheaper than meta, obviously like SMS is

cheaper than meta, but SMS is still

really expensive in the cost scale.

Especially if you're not segmenting your

list, we see a lot of unsegmented SMS

lists that are just full list sends.

So, um, you know, if you're a decent rate

for our clients, it'd

be like half a penny.

We've seen some clients go down to a

third of a penny, but most people are

probably sitting at like

eight, eight tens of a penny.

And those sound like small differences.

But when you're sending it to an audience

of a hundred, 200, 500,000 people,

and you're sending it multiple times a

week, we're talking, you know, we had a

client that we helped save, I think I

want to say $30,000 every single month

by segmenting the list.

And we saw next to no

drop off in revenue.

Yeah.

It's just, they're

just blasting everybody.

Yep.

So another thing I've always been curious

about is a lot of these emails that you

get from brands through Klaviyo or

wherever are heavily

designed one big graphic.

Right.

And then, and then I always feel like the

plain text stuff looks better and

actually is what I respond to more.

So two part question.

One is, is like, what, what in terms of

design is innovative and revenue

driving in email on, and then the second

one is like, is there an ability to send

more plain text emails or is there like,

you know, take that wherever you want to.

I think plain text stands out because

everyone sends design.

I think if every single person sent plain

text and plain text

wouldn't work as well.

Generally speaking, we see, um, you know,

image driven emails have a lower click

rate, but they have a better conversion

rate of people who do click and the

plain text ones tend to have a much

higher click rate and a

much lower conversion rate.

And so they ended up being like a kind of

like a wash in the end.

Uh, I think, you know, back to that

problem solution brand, they weren't

doing this problem solutions through

plain text, but I think anything that you

can attach a story to

plain text will do really well.

And so like, we don't have hard and fast,

like for plain text a month, but they're

great whenever you

need a really quick email.

They're great whenever you need to kind

of explain something.

They're great when you want like a

personal touch to it.

And so yeah, they're fantastic.

We love using them.

And again, like I think supplement brands

can really, really lean into this

because they're, those are always, you

know, primarily problem solution brands.

And so, uh, that's a great example of it.

And then from like, like design

perspective, don't overcomplicate it.

Um, you know, we have brands who have, we

see brands who want to throw a

million blocks in there or, you know,

you're just, you're just giving people

a million different

things to pay attention to.

And so, you know, I've heard many people

say like the rule of one, like have

one concept for your email.

I think you can go beyond one, but after

a couple of modules, a couple of things

you're trying to get someone to pay

attention to, uh, you're just

deleting the message.

And so I just recommend to keep it pretty

simple conversion focused

as CTAs and heroes, maybe, maybe you have

like some, some product feeds where

you're helping someone discover different

products from you guys.

And you're maybe using like

the dynamic data that shows.

Best sellers across your whole entire

plot mix or one of the

personalize to this person.

So there's a lot of, there's a lot that

you can do, but I would just

say, just don't overdo it.

Does this is a, this is a, I'm gonna

expose myself here is, uh, does plain

text read differently by like an inbox

provider, like his Gmail, looking at

that and actually saying this is

different than the designed email, like

something with HTML I'm assuming.

Um, yeah, I'm just curious.

Yeah.

So if you, um, if you're using image

slices, which is what 95% of DZ brands

do and what we do as well, I have an

assumption that Google is not reading

the image behind that, you know, things

like AI vision now it's, if it

isn't happening already,

it's going to be, um, very soon.

And so before when you used images, the

inbox providers had to

kind of fall back to alt text.

So yes, image emails have far less

readability than a plain text would

both for the inboxes as well as for, um,

people who are, um, vision impaired

or have like accessibility concerns, uh,

you know, all these inbox providers

and primarily Google, Google is probably

gonna make up 60% of

your list, maybe 70%.

Um, they don't tell you what they factor

into for deliverability.

And so you're kind of always making some

assumptions that people always talk

about like an image to text ratio.

I think it's like 60, 40 people

recommend, but if you

stuff text into your emails,

they're likely going to

inbox a little better.

And that's, um, there, I mean, there are

softwares that are set up around this

that are just injecting texts into your

emails to help you, uh, and box a little

bit.

Yeah, that makes sense.

So you mentioned segmentation in there

and saving people a bunch of money.

Um, we can come to the money thing in a

little bit, but, um,

what's like the 80 20

of segmentation, like what, what, what, I

guess, like, well, how are you

thinking about segmentation?

Like, is it we're trying to increase

relevance, which is going to lead to

improved open rates and click rates in

general across both that segment and

then the broader list as a result or

like, um, I'm just curious, like mindset.

And then like, what is like tactical

piece of advice for like how to actually

implement segmentation knowing the vast

majority of your revenue is going to

come from the hyper

recently engaged people.

There's a reason why a lot of agencies

and people default to like engage 60

engaged 90 day audiences.

We want to take it beyond that,

especially if the

product kind of demands that

thing of like jeans, I own some modern

boat jeans and I haven't bought

new pairs for four years, but

I plan to buy some more soon.

If you looked at me from a, from a

customer perspective, you said I haven't

bought in four years.

I'm a laps customer.

No, it's just, it's just because you made

a great product and I don't need to buy

anymore for awhile.

And so if your product lends to a longer

time usage, then you have to give someone

a reason to purchase, whether that's

offers, new products, they might like,

that's, that's like the primary things,

but, um, uh, it's largely dependent on

your own product.

I think people just try to make it a

cookie cutter approach for everything.

So yeah, most of your revenue is going to

come from a small bucket of customers who

are very, very recent, and you should

think about email as a dependent channel.

Email is just pulling people from meta,

from organic social, from SEO, and it's

just a cheaper medium to get them there.

If you had the best flows in place, but

you didn't have the other channels

funneling the mental email in SMS, you

would, they just want to have any impact

whatsoever.

So I just want to apologize.

I'm going to ask about attribution, which

is if I start to fight on Twitter,

yeah, which is like, what, what's

something that everybody misses between

Clavio paid and GA, what is, what's the

piece there that you

feel like most brands

are missing out on cause I feel like it's

always a battle to get, to get a full

understanding of that.

I think GA is the most conservative look.

And I think Clavio is

the rosiest outlook.

You know, if you're looking at like

Clavio default, the

amazing thing is that Clavio

now has comparative models.

So I can, we've done this for Zach for

all of, for multiple brands.

And they've recently

adjusted their attribution model.

But, um, if I wanted to know, are my, you

know, open rates are really open rate is

really so much like a view based

attribution for you guys.

And if you, if you had a one hour view

based attribution and the row is was

solved, which would you trust like a one

hour view based attribution?

I don't trust

attribution, generally speaking.

Okay.

So I don't know.

I don't know.

You know, it's like, it depends on if

it's Snapchat, I don't trust anything.

Snapchat says meta click based.

I started to get a little bit more

trustworthy, but, um, there's a lot of

nuance there too.

So anyways, not to derail.

So my point of view is that, uh, open

rates are open based attribution is

really similar to view based, but if I

take it down from a five day down to one

hour, that's much more trustworthy to me.

If I like to click based only, that's

much more trustworthy to me.

And then I think literally this week, I

think Clavio is rolling

out multi-channel attribution.

Um, I think it just came out like Monday

and they're multi-touch.

Um, and so you can like

weight things differently.

I like to maintain the default part of

what's, what's impactful about being

an agency is that we have so many brands

that we can look at.

And if you change the context for how you

attribute revenue for

every single client,

um, you kind of lose some of that, uh,

that network effect.

And so the nice thing is

like, I can compare it though.

I don't have to change the attribution.

I can go and I can say, okay, our default

is this, but if I go

in and say, um, a one

day click or a one hour click or seven

day click, whatever I want to do, I can

see what that would actually be.

Um, but while maintaining my baseline

attribution as the default.

Yeah.

That makes sense.

I there's, I want to go back to just like

saving money or maybe not even

necessarily saving money, but like just

the money piece of it in general.

Cause I, you know, I think we kind of

started with this, but I've seen several

times where like on Twitter, a couple of

times you suggested like, Hey, do these

couple of things and that's going to save

you money on your bill.

Or you're on the opposite side where it's

like, no, you're completely

misunderstanding how your bill works.

So I think it would be really

helpful to leave people with.

And you know, obviously we can dig into

any couple of things or any, anything

else we want to, but like what, when you

first start working with people, like

what is the most obvious thing that you

generally do that helps them save their

bill and like, and then this follow up to

that is why are so many people

confused about their billing?

Because most people use Clavio and Clavio

did not make it easy

to understand that first.

Um, I think it's, uh, the opportunity for

immediate cost savings is a little bit

lower now since they've went to active

profile enforcement.

So previously they would say, Hey, we're

going to bill you off active profiles,

but it's really only based off the number

of people that I send to an

a single campaign.

So if I had a hundred thousand list, now

I'm paying for a hundred thousand lists,

but I have 200,000 people, if I split

those 200,000 people into two different

segments, I can send to

both those, no problem.

And so that was kind of like the, the

gaming, the manipulation

that, um, people would do now anymore.

It's, it's, it's a little more dangerous

to do this at the forefront of a

partnership because you don't understand

their CRM yet, but if I drop in a segment

of people who are just absolutely dead

profiles, you know, they've received 15

emails in the last six months and they

haven't done anything, haven't been on

site, they haven't done any of these

things, you know, like those are probably

people that are pretty safe to clean out.

What I'm really hopeful here's a feature

request for Clavio or for other

ESPs is that they

have all the data points.

They have machine learning teams help me

understand who I should be sending to

and who I shouldn't be sending to, which

that kind of creates a disincentive for

them because it's going to trim some of

their costs, but

that's what I want to see.

What do you think about, um, the way

email agencies price, I feel like some,

you know, it's like email agencies

sometimes are charging for a number of

emails there that you're

sending, they're charging too much.

When does that get out of hand for you?

Like, what do you think is the most

efficient way to charge and when,

what should people look out for?

We've went through our own

iterations of like how we charge.

And so I think I have a

good perspective on this.

I, we previously used to have a set price

and then you would get a number of emails

and I basically tried to relay it to

people that they were basically playing

X dollars per email.

And then I think that that kind of

diminishes the expectation around

the strategy work that gets done.

And so we moved away from that and we

say, Hey, the bulk of what you're

paying us for strategy and the creative

gets tacked onto that.

And if you want to add additional emails

on top of your plan, you can do it for

$250 in email, whatever it is.

And so, you know, for a lot of brands,

they're going to send an email and make

10 grand with their very, you know, nice

attribution, but you know, $250 is

usually no brainer for most brands to

say, Hey, I have something I want

to talk about next week.

Let's do it.

I have seen agencies charge as much as a

thousand dollars in email,

which I think is crazy.

I think at that point, I think one of the

hardest things about hiring an agency or

hiring a, an email marketer is if you

don't have the skillset, you don't know

how to evaluate for it.

And so maybe you bring in someone who

helps you find the right fit.

You have someone audit you and tell you

how they would run the account.

But if you're paying a thousand dollars

in email, you should probably just

hire in house.

So yeah, I, on the low end, I've seen

like people charge really low rates.

Just, you know, as they're freelancing,

getting their foot in the door,

whatever it is.

And I feel like I have since we, since we

haven't, I haven't been in that world

for four years when I put freelance.

And so I have less of a perspective on

that, but on the high end, I've seen

agencies charge like a thousand dollars

in email, which is just crazy.

So we'll just finish off with a section

that we like to call beefs with Z, which

is anything, anybody, anything or anyone

you want to get into that it really

bugs you about the work that you're doing

in terms of industry wise, in terms

of tactics that you see that really bug

you things that you would want to get out

in the air.

But if you need a second to think, I'll

start out with Zach.

Well, okay.

Well, I want to say

my, my beef is with Zach.

That's why he's not here.

We're just, we're

just, we're really beefy.

The D the text right now are just insane.

They're just, yeah, it's crazy.

So anyways, drives me crazy.

When people force, you know, we're back

on popups for a second.

When people force you to go to your

inbox, to get a

coupon code, some agencies

will do this on accident.

Others will do it maliciously and say,

Oh, we're driving up a tribute revenue.

Cause you're forcing an email open, which

I think is really dumb.

You're immediately making them compete

against 50 other brands in their inbox.

If you're sending them a text, you're

making them compete against their spouse,

their friends, their

hobbies, whatever it is.

And so I'm okay accepting a lower

attribute revenue, keeping them on site,

putting the coupon on a pop-up and just

like being like, we've had clients who

I've, who we've said your attribute

revenue is going to drop.

The only thing that we're changing is the

word the code is listed.

This is better for you.

So I've got beef with everyone

that does that intentionally.

Yeah.

It's usually, it's like our biggest one,

I would say Brad or degrees, like in the

paid social worlds, people

hold stuff hostage, right?

Like they, they build it in their own ad

account and they're in their own

business manager and then the client like

leaves and still there.

It's a mess to unwind all that.

People don't want you to hold it.

So anyway, Jacob,

thank you for being here.

If people have questions,

I can funnel them to you.

You can always reach out to

us, Andrew at foxwelldigital.com.

Thanks for being on the podcast.

Yeah.

Thanks for having me guys.

Thanks.

The only way that we grow this podcast is

by you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like reviews kind of don't

really mean anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful, but they don't

do a lot for the growth of the podcast.

Um, and so sharing YouTube links, sharing

Spotify links, sharing Apple,

whatever we call it under the podcast app

now, anything you can share the

better we're going to be guys, anything

else you want to say on this?

Yeah.

Please go check us out on YouTube, rack

up those views for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe.

Make sure to

subscribe on YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly refresh

the YouTube comments because it

dictates my mental health for the day.

So please say

something nice about all of us.

Thank you everyone.

Thanks everybody for listening.

Honestly.