Scalability School

This episode is a tactical deep dive into two of the biggest measurement questions in DTC right now, capped off with Zach Stuck joining to break down how MarsMen sets ad budgets off forecasted recurring revenue.

The first half is a real client case study on Meta's Incremental Attribution (IA). Brad walks us through an apparel brand, with an AOV just over $100, strong organic and influencer traffic, and $150-200K per month in spend. A conversion lift study at the start of the year showed their one-day click ROAS almost perfectly matched their true incremental number, so 1DC became the account's benchmark. When they tested IA head-to-head against one-day click (each with its own holdout), IA looked terrible in week one, then dramatically better in weeks two and three, and the lift study combined with Triple Whale MTA data validated the win. Then Meta changed its click attribution definition in March (only outbound clicks now count as clicks, with profile clicks and comments moved to "engaged"), and IA performance deviated hard from one-day click, Triple Whale, and product-level MER. IA also stopped responding to bid adjustments. The takeaway: they reverted to one-day click, with a plan to retest IA in three to six months as Meta feeds the model more conversion lift data.

The second segment covers creative cohort spend analysis: breaking down each month's spend by the month the ads were launched. If most of May's spend is running through ads launched last year, your new creative isn't earning spend and something is broken in the pipeline. If nearly all spend is from ads launched in the last 30 days, you are over-reliant on a few recent outliers. Splitting the view by evergreen versus promo ads shows whether new creative is compounding month over month, which is what actually earns the right to scale spend. Zach adds Homestead's layer on top: tracking "breakthrough" ads ($2K spend in 7 days at target) versus scaled ads every month.

The final segment is Zach on how MarsMen scales: if you can forecast next month's recurring revenue, you can spend into that full amount, as long as your blended MER covers OPEX and your new-customer ROAS holds at target. He walks through the cash-flow traps (90-day subscriptions deferring revenue, promos shifting cohort behavior), MarsMen's rebuilt forecast model that applies retention curves at the individual customer level, daily new-customer targets by channel, and a reactivation play: offering discounted one-time purchases to list subscribers who never converted because they didn't want a subscription, which he estimates is worth hundreds of thousands per month.

Key Takeaways
  • Why Meta's Incremental Attribution passed a conversion lift test, only to then fall apart three weeks later.
  • How you can REALLY spend 100% of next month's forecasted MRR on ads this month, and when that math breaks.
  • The one thing that might be the real reason as to to why your account performance suddenly shifted after March 2026.
  • The percentage of this month's ad spend that should come from ads you launched this month, and what it means if the answer is almost none.
  • Is your "dead" email list quietly hiding hundreds of thousands in monthly revenue?
  • Why one-day click beats seven-day click for brands with heavy organic traffic, and how to know which one your account should trust.
  • What a "breakthrough ad" actually is and why your creative team should be measured on them every month.
  • Caution: How adding a 90-day subscription offer can put your cash flow at risk 60 days later.
  • Should subscription brands hold email, SMS, and organic to daily new-customer quotas the same way they do paid?
  • Is the creative volume game dead, or are the people abandoning it just measuring hit rates wrong?
Chapters
  • 02:32 — Should you test Meta's Incremental Attribution in your account?
  • 07:30 — How do you design a fair test of one-day click vs. Incremental Attribution?
  • 11:32 — What did Meta's new click attribution definition change, and why did it break results?
  • 14:02 — When should you turn Incremental Attribution off and go back to one-day click?
  • 26:30 — How do you run a creative cohort analysis to see if your new ads are earning spend?
  • 35:31 — How does a subscription brand use next month's MRR to set this month's ad budget?
  • 46:02 — How do you turn a "dead" email list into six figures of monthly revenue?
This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you! To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn more about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com Learn more about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com Made With AI

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

Because just due to the nature of how one

day click and incremental work, kind of

like we said earlier, one day click is

only giving credit to

people who click within 24 hours.

By default, it is substantially more

conservative than

incremental attribution.

So we don't want to be

misled by one day click.

What should we do?

That third data point that I'm alluding

to is split it down to

evergreen and promo ads.

It still ended up being the case that

evergreen consistently is

stacking up month over month.

And that's what compounds, right?

It's like if you can make more ads every

single month that earns spend in the ad

account, then that's what compounds over

time and allows you to increase spend.

I think a lot of brands

actually kind of forget about that.

They're like, hey, they didn't buy.

We did all these like whatever flows to

get them to maybe get a

bigger discount over time.

But then there was probably one reason

why they didn't buy.

So talk to that customer about that one

reason why they didn't buy and give them

a strong discount to still close.

Because like it's very likely better off

when you still have contribution margin

on that customer to be gained if you just

give them even a slightly bigger discount

to like bring in those dollars versus

them just sitting on

an email and SMS list.

And now let's take a listen to the

Scalability School podcast.

Welcome back to another episode of the

Scalability School podcast.

Andrew is allowing me to have the

absolute honor of introducing the

podcast, opening it up for reasons that

he will describe shortly.

He sounds beautiful, but he's going to

let me open this sucker up.

We have a couple of

topics to jump into today.

We're going to talk about

incremental attribution.

We're going to talk

about creative cohorts.

And if we are blessed and lucky, Zach

Stuck will be joining us

for the back half of this.

We're going to talk

about scaling ads, man.

It's going to be dope.

But look, as you can hear, I'll sing you

a little with my husky voice.

I'm in the mood for love.

That's where I'm at

right now with my bad voice.

I've lost my voice, but

it's not totally gone.

I just sound like I'm struggling to

breathe, which is true.

So and my laughs sound like I've been

smoking for 40 years.

Other than that, doing

great, feeling great.

These are aura points.

You're just stacking

aura points right now.

So much aura.

Yeah, people are going to actually

require me to do podcast appearances with

this voice from now on.

So I'll have to 11 labs

it and figure that out.

I think that, you know, one of the things

we love is tactical episodes.

And that's what we're

trying to get into here, right?

Which is around incremental attribution

and versus one day click.

I'm really excited to talk about it.

So let's go through this.

Like, I mean, we have some data from the

founders community as

well, which we'll talk about.

But Brett, frame it up for us.

Yeah.

So we've been thinking a lot about

incremental attribution

since meta rolled it out.

And I have an N of one kind of sample of

a recent experience that we've had where

we went through kind of the

disappointment, excited, back to

disappointment and trying to figure out

where we go with incremental attribution.

So if it's something that you think, if

it's something that you've been thinking

about testing, maybe you've already

tested and you've had a similar

experience, hopefully you can lean on

this to kind of decide, is it worth

testing in our account?

And should we expect that there's going

to be meaningful performance swings?

Because, you know, everybody's always

looking for, I mean, I'm kind of the guy

that always asks everybody for a hack at

the end of the episode because I like to

hear the tactical nuggets.

So hopefully you walk away with a kind of

an understanding of what to do with

incremental attribution from here.

But I can walk through, I actually have a

bunch of notes in screen shares and I can

just walk through a timeline of a test

that we ran through with a

client and their experience.

And then Andrew, you can always interrupt

me and we can ask questions

and dig into anything deeper.

Does that sound good?

Yeah, definitely.

I mean, I think I'll just mention the

community stuff out of the gates, which

is people had seen it

underperform thus far utilizing IA.

Right.

So it depends.

Like one member said, he saw that it was

especially on remarketing review through

attribution on past

purchases was inflating numbers.

Sees IA aligned well

with seven day click.

Another member said that incremental ROAS

and ads manager often lands around 90% of

seven day click ROAS

when you break it down.

And Barry Hot legendary said he thinks

it's good 90% of the problems he sees

because it solves those problems, 90% of

the problems he sees,

especially on bigger accounts.

So it's interesting.

It's like, it's interesting.

It's kind of like people said hasn't been

as good, but then like overall we're

like, I can see where it's happening.

And it's going to be better.

So yeah, I'd love to walk through it.

Sweet.

I will flip this over.

You're watching this on youtube.com,

which is a website on the

internet that shows videos.

Brad is sharing a screen, but if you're

not, you know, and you're just having it

in your ears, then, you know, I'm sorry,

but you can go and look at

the visuals on youtube.com.

Somebody the other day

I met at a conference.

This is true.

And said, who is the other guy when he

met me on the, on the podcast.

And he goes, I love

his, I love his voice.

I've listened to every episode twice.

So some people just come for the audio.

Hey, if this helps you fall asleep at

night, that is an acceptable, is an

acceptable listening method.

Kind of an honor really.

Yeah, we're just trying to, you know,

we're just trying to

smash records around here.

So, okay.

I will also try to explain what's on the

screen for everybody

that's, that's listening.

So let me, let me frame this up with a

little bit of context ahead of time.

First off, this brand

is in the apparel space.

Their AOV is over a hundred dollars, not

quite one 50, but it's

kind of in that range.

Depends on the seasonality and what

products are popular.

And they have actually a

fair amount of organic traffic.

They influencer like

posts, things like that.

So if that's helpful for context for, for

brands that are thinking about this.

So the beginning of the year, we went

through a bunch of different things with

this, with this brand.

And we started to test meta conversion

live studies directly in the platform to

try and tease out how incremental is

meta, et cetera, et cetera.

So here's what I can tell you.

So their average one day click row is,

which, which shows up, shows up here as a

3.12 for, for the account or basically

year to date up to this point is very,

very close to the actual conversion live

data results that we got back from meta.

So there's like almost no difference

between their one day click and the

incremental number that we

got back from, from meta.

So that's encouraging because that means

that we can use one day click as a, as

this, I don't know if

barometer is the right word.

We can use it as a temperature check to

say, Hey, if we're going to hold our

performance accountable to something,

this one day click

number is reasonable for them.

And one day click is probably, you know,

like I said, for the organic traffic

reasons that I mentioned, one day click

is probably more applicable to them for

them than the average

account where seven day click.

You know, I think there's this, this,

this stat that's floating around

recently, which is 70 click kind of under

reports by 15 to 20%.

We generally see that

except for this account.

So just, just kind of framing that up.

So we ran a conversion of study to start

the year, came back and basically said,

Hey, your one day click row eyes number

is basically your, your, your, um,

incremental number, which is different

than incremental, uh, attribution.

Those are, those are different things.

So just framing that up.

So what we did is we ran through that

conversional test and we started to get

through the rest of, um, the, the, the Q1

Q Q2 rolls around beginning of Q2 rolls

around end of March.

And we want to say, Hey,

incremental attribution.

We're starting to see some

success in other accounts.

We're hearing about it.

Meta started to

suggest it a little bit more.

We want to actually test if this is going

to be successful or not.

So what we do is we launch, um, we take

our top performing campaign on a one day

click basis and we split out and have an

additional cell for incremental

attribution and throw them both into the

conversion of study.

So that's the test.

It's one day click versus incremental

attribution with a

holdout for each of them.

Um, so that's kind of test design.

Uh, we go through the first week of

performance and incremental attribution

itself looks terrible.

Well, I, I have a, I have

a tweet thread about this.

If you go to my Twitter, you can find it.

And it just looks miserable.

And I'm like, should we turn this off?

Like, I'm really, I'm

really like nervous.

This is not going to pan out.

Um, but no, we decided to commit to this

and set up the test.

So like, let's give it more time week

two, three roll around and the conversion

lift results inside of meta are reporting

much, much better now in favor of

incremental attribution.

So I'm starting to feel good.

Uh, I see, Hey, one day

click on it looks good.

Incremental attribution looks good.

The commercial lift

study results look good.

They use MTA data as well.

So they use, they use triple oil.

Um, uh, but your, your North

beam would be a comparable.

It's like that also looked good.

So everything was checking out that this

was looking really good.

And then, uh, we get to the end of the

test and the results basically say

incremental attribution is substantially

more incremental than one day click.

So there's a thrown around the word

incremental, like a million times.

Um, so if it's worth

digging into that further, I can.

But, um, basically, uh, incremental

attribution was performing way better

than one day click rise.

So we say, okay, we feel

pretty confident in these results.

Um, now it's only one test.

And so maybe it's worth repeating.

It's on one skew and a

subset of hundreds of skews.

Uh, so before we roll this, you know,

maybe before we roll it out aggressively

or just like blanket account wide, we

kind of want to go campaign by campaign.

So we start to roll it out

to several more campaigns.

And what has ensued over the last couple

of weeks is I think what's, what's really

the visuals behind me.

Um, and I can go into that in a second.

Andrew, do you have any, any questions or

like anything I can clarify before I dig

into like what we've

been seeing more recently?

I mean, I think the big thing that you

mentioned is basically like it was the

patience that sort of paid off for you.

Like, and that you're using

incrementality as like a

main measurement guide.

You know what I'm saying?

Like it's so much around

like, is this truly incremental?

And, and you waited, which is really hard

for a lot of people to

do both of those things.

Yeah.

Yes.

Yeah.

Very, very difficult.

Especially after that first week started

to look, look miserable.

And when I say look miserable, it's like

triple whale looked bad.

One day clicked, looked really bad.

Um, and it just seemed to take some time.

And that's the sentiment that I've heard

in the Foxhole group from people is like,

Hey, either, uh, generally speaking at

first, it's not going to look great, but

over time it starts to get better.

Uh, and then the sentiment I've been

hearing lately is that

it starts to fall off.

Uh, and that's where these,

these graphs start to come in.

So I'm going to try to zoom in a little

bit here and I'll kind

of show you the change.

So you can see kind of Q1 and this is the

one day click versus incremental.

The dotted line is incremental.

So they're like very close in line.

Like that's the thing to take away from

this visual is that they are tightly

correlated, not only correlated, but

they're actually pretty close together.

So one day click looks increment, looks

like incremental attribution incremental,

maybe parts a little bit higher, which I

think you'd expect

because one day click is

very conservative, but then we start to

have things trend off

aggressively over time.

So, uh, I'm highlighting on the graph,

March 25th, we start to see this

deviation from one day click and

incremental attribution.

They still follow each other from like a

correlation standpoint.

They're still pretty close, but the gap

between those two lines

starts to grow substantially.

Um, and there's a couple of things that

happened around this time.

And that's where we're like, uh, from,

from then to now is what we're trying to,

trying to dig into and understand.

So the first thing that happened, um,

which was at kind of the beginning of

March meta says, we are changing the way

click attribution works.

Um, we are going to say an outbound click

is click attribution, but engagement, uh,

the kind of engaged version

of, of that is going to change.

Even though a click to a profile, a click

to comment, whatever things that used to

historically you've been counted as, as

click conversions, that's

now moving to an engaged.

Um, so that changed, um, and then, uh, so

that changed and then started to roll out

to other accounts that they announced at

the beginning of March.

I think later, later in

March, it started to roll out.

Um, that was one of the big things.

Uh, we ended our test probably at the

beginning of April, uh, and we started to

roll out the test, uh, then as well.

And that's kind of, since, since those

things have happened, um, the kind of

ensuing results have been, there's this

deviation in one day click and

incremental attribution.

Uh, so that's an insight.

Uh, and our question now becomes, uh,

well, is there, is there a third data

point that we can look at or a couple

more data points that we can look at and

ask the questions like,

well, which one should we trust?

Should we go back to one day click and

use that as our guide?

Or should we lean into

incremental attribution?

Because just due to the nature of how one

day click and incremental work, kind of

like we said earlier, one day click is

only giving credit to people

who clicked within 24 hours.

By default, it is substantially more, uh,

conservative than

incremental attribution.

So we don't want to be

misled by one day click.

What, what should we do?

That third data point that I'm alluding

to is triple whale, um, uh, MTA tool.

Uh, historically triple has like largely

followed, uh, the one day click.

And so we've built up a lot of confidence

in one day click in the platform because,

um, we've spent three

years using one day click.

It's worked extremely

well for those reasons.

Um, and that is now also deviating very

substantially from

incremental attribution.

Um, not to continue this yap, but I'll

pause in a second, but, um, you would

also expect that because triple is using

click based it's, it's click based.

So like it's not completely unexpected.

Um, and at the same time, the deviation

leaves us a little bit concerned.

The final data point that we used, um, to

kind of look at this more recently is,

well, how did the actual new customer

sales for these products look over

particularly the last couple of weeks?

We've had Memorial Day recently, so that,

that certainly throws it off, but we've

definitely noticed a downward trend in

the overall efficiency.

So something that we like to do for

brands that have multiple products or

product categories is take, um, as much

as we can look at product level sales

with product level spend.

It's not perfect, but it allows you to

see trends over time.

Um, so if I were to take new customer

sales of this, of SKU a divided by spend

for SKU a, what is that?

What is that product level MER that has

gotten less efficient over

the last couple of weeks?

So what that's leading me to say is,

okay, well, where do we go

from here with this information?

We are actually going to start deviating

back to one day click in the short term

until we feel more confident in

incremental attribution.

Maybe we need to run a

new conversion of study.

Um, but all of that to basically say, I

don't really feel confident in

incremental attribution for this account

at this point in time, because it just

seems to be heavy, heavily deviating

from, um, the

performance that we did see.

Even though we started to validate it

with an actual conversion

lift test inside of meta.

So, um, that's, that's,

that's my personal anecdote.

One other anecdote on incremental

attribution, another account, same thing.

Like it started off really slow.

It got really strong for two weeks.

Last couple of weeks,

it's been miserable.

So we're just turning it back off, going

straight back to the

seven day click over there.

How much are they spending by the way?

They'll spend 150, 200 K a month.

And what's your hypothesis?

So this is what it is now, but what's

your hypothesis about like how this is

going to change in the next six months?

Yeah, I have this, this brand because of

the organic trend of this brand.

Um, that's why I've thought that one day

click is, and we've, we've kind of

experimented in one day click has been

the more reliable thing to use.

Seven day click for them.

It's a little bit too wild because if

they have an organic moment or something

pops off, meta does not react quickly

enough to bid back down.

They use cost controls as well, pretty

heavy on cost controls, cost cap and min

row as, um, meta doesn't throttle back

down quickly enough

using seven day click.

It still doesn't with one day click

either, but we can manually

make some adjustments there.

And so, um, one day click

for that reason feels better.

The reason we'd like to incremental

because it opened up, it was the theory

was it would open up maybe the delivery a

little bit more and be a little less

conservative on who we're bidding for.

Now, obviously we could change our bids.

We can increase the budget.

We could just force more

spend into one day click.

Um, but the idea, and I

think this is why Barry likes it.

Barry had a great explanation on Twitter.

It's like in theory, it should solve all

of the one day view weird

issues that, that you get.

Um, but I think the only hypothesis that

I can really think of for this brand

right now is that incremental attribution

is not, it's not doing a great job for

this account at teasing out what's

actually incremental.

And it's still conflating that with some

of the view based conversion, some of the

engaged conversions, uh, and

some of that are organic demand.

Uh, and so what it thinks is incremental

is actually purchases that, um, I guess

would have happened

anyways, which are not incremental.

What I think will happen, what I hope

will happen is, I mean, credit to meta.

Um, they, they allow you to do conversion

of studies and don't make you spend

absurd amounts of money.

And they want this product to solve the

problems that people are having.

Like they're, they're, they're the ones

that are saying, um, they're pushing

people to test these things.

And so I think as more conversion, uh,

studies are run, um, and as, uh, more

brands are doing this, I think

incremental, incremental attribution

should only get better.

So I think three months, six months from

now, we should be

retesting it, um, for this brand.

It's going to be a wait though.

It's that with IA, they just don't have

the data now, like, or as

much data as they could have.

It's like, it's still too limiting.

Or is it sort of one of those things that

we see on meta where it's good initially.

And then like, as more people adopted, it

goes down like, or, you know, like, or do

you see that happening in the future?

Um, or like, what is it, do you think

mechanically that was holding it from not

being not performing the same way?

Or is it too generous?

Is it the opposite?

I mean, I, I kind of, I'm reading what

you're saying, but

there's a little bit of both.

It's like some of it's limiting, but some

of it's also just like, seems like it's

kind of taken, putting

it out there too widely.

And that's what you thought was going to

happen, but it didn't.

Yeah.

It's a, it's a good question.

I, it would be interesting if somebody

from meta, um, unfortunately they just

had a bunch of layoffs.

So hopefully none, uh, no people in the

incremental attribution department,

because, uh, it would be very interesting

to hear from meta how.

It actually works.

So my understanding of how incremental

attribution works is that there's tons of

brands at any given time that are running

conversion of studies on, on, on.

Meta and they meta use those to inform

building this new optimization algorithm.

I don't, I don't know exactly how they

would describe it, but

conversion of studies were used.

Historical conversion of studies were

used to build this model.

And that's how it optimizes.

I think the tricky thing about that is

like, there's,

there's so much difference.

And this is true of one day click and

seven day click as well, but like,

there's so much difference and uniqueness

to each individual brand, depending on

how much organic traffic they have, how

much spend they're

getting from other channels.

Um, the industry, like there's, there's

so much nuance in between those that

maybe for this brand, the, the mean of

what they built conversion, uh,

incremental attribution on

top of just doesn't apply yet.

Um, because the other, here's the other

thing that I didn't, I didn't say like

we've continued particularly over the

last, before we made the

decision to shut off, shut this off.

We've continued to dial back the bids and

tell meta, Hey, we don't,

we're not happy with performance.

Like we're, we should dial this back and

it's continued to

basically spend regardless of that.

It's not, it's not adjusting the way that

one day click or seven day

click does to bid changes.

Um, so my, the only hypothesis that I

really have at this point is that they

built the model on kind of the, the

average of the conversion of studies.

And just, that's not working for this

brand at this point in time.

Um, I know a couple of brands that spend

the majority of their budget through

incremental attribution.

So it's very possible that it works.

You know, I'm curious if people are, uh,

spending on multiple,

uh, uh, attribution types.

Um, and the, this, this needs to be one

of the subsets of them.

Um, and if they're reaching a different

pocket of audience, but, uh, to the

different pocket of audience, like we're

not actually seeing

really different delivery.

There's a lot of overlap between one day

click and incremental attribution.

And the, um, so there's a

lot of overlap and reach.

And then the net new visit rates was

basically the same between them.

It's not like we were reaching a bunch of

new people by using

incremental attribution.

Um, it was about the same, the same rate.

And for this brand, that's like 70, 70%

pretty consistently.

Yeah.

It's interesting.

I mean, I think it's, it's, it's sort of

in this weird, interesting phase where

you hear a lot of

people talking about it.

There's a lot of hope in it.

You know, do you think if you made this

like one day click and you made it seven

day click versus incremental attribution,

what do you think would happen?

That's it?

Yeah, that's a good question.

All right, friends, quick break.

This episode of scalability school is

brought to you by North beam

incrementality, which

honestly is so awesome.

Let me just tell you

a little bit about it.

If you're a marketer, you probably agree.

Incrementality testing is broken.

It's insane.

You got to do all this crazy stuff, but

with North beam, you do

it right in the platform.

It builds tests using your own MTA data,

launches them directly in the ad platform

and automatically monitors them

throughout the test.

And if something threatens validity,

you're alerted to it within North beam

before it ruins the results.

The really nice thing is it solves all

these problems you hear about

incrementality testing all the time, like

labor, spreadsheets,

statistical reference.

Designing tests is

normally so slow, right?

And error prone.

So with North beam incrementality, it's

automated and accurate.

And your team is able

to spend with confidence.

Give it a shot with

North beam incrementality.

Really, the future of

incrementality is here.

And North beam has figured out a way to

make it easy for you.

Do you think if you made this like one

day click and you made it seven day click

versus incremental attribution, what do

you think would happen?

Yeah, that's a good question.

I mean, that's what I'm kind of like

struggling with, generally speaking,

right now is the difference between a one

day and a seven day click obviously

changes the way that meta delivers.

Because we use cost controls, generally

speaking, the question that I would go

back to is, okay, if they're not reach,

if there's, there's overlap between the

different attribution methods and who

you're going to reach, then there's like

not, not a ton of value in that.

Because if I wanted to use seven day

click because it was going to bid more

aggressively than a one day click, well,

the alternative thing I could do instead

of switching from one day click to seven

day click is just open the

bids or spend more forcefully.

Like I could just be more aggressive.

Um, now you can make the argument that,

okay, more data in a seven day click,

maybe makes Facebook optimized a bit

better, meta optimized a bit better and

allows them to be more efficient.

Um, I've just not really seen that to be

the case, especially when you have a

brand that's consistently

getting through learning.

And in this case, it's just been, it's

just been more effective to use one day

click because it doesn't go for those,

uh, especially with the way that they

changed click based attribution to be

actual link click, as opposed to on all

kinds of clicks that are, uh, whatever

you could qualify as a click.

Yeah.

I don't know if that answers your

question, but, um, I have my

hypotheses around all of it.

I mean, what's your, what do you think

about the overall change with like the

definition of clicks and

like link clicks and stuff?

Like, do you think it's been a net

positive or do you think

it's a net positive overall?

What's your thinking?

Cause it seems like it's, I mean, I think

it should be too, but it seems like it's

in the short term, like really screwed up

some results because people were, it was

optimizing on one thing and it's like

almost had to relearn, you know?

Um, I would assume that through like gem

and lattice and all this, like one of the

signals is this

definition and that's changed.

Right.

Um, that's, uh, that's screwed, screwed

things up to a degree.

I don't know.

What do you think?

Yeah, I think that's,

I think that's right.

Um, it's, uh, it's

definitely, uh, it's definitely.

Pausing my, I think more confusion in the

short term and especially for, for brands

that are on cost controls, right?

Like you, you went from bidding on a very

specific type of, of, of

click and that changed.

And if, if the amount of conversions that

were coming through changed by 20%, you

have a completely different bid that you

need to adjust for now.

Um, and so again, I think like short term

volatility, but in the longterm, I think

it's the right thing to do because one,

it adds like way more clarity for an

advertiser setting up a

campaign from scratch.

It's like what they're

actually giving meta credit for.

Uh, and then two, you know, I think

people will, I think generally people

will agree that if you had to go rank

order, what's actually incremental.

It's a click is probably the most

incremental, most commonly, uh, of an

engagement of some kind.

So a click to a social profile.

And so I should redefine that an outbound

click is probably the most incremental.

The next range of the, what they qualify

as engagement, you know, it's,

it's video views of some sort.

It's clicks to profiles,

it's likes, it's whatever.

It's probably the next most incremental.

And the view is the thing

that's least incremental.

Um, but you know, how's that changing

with short form video content?

And apparently, um, zoomers don't click

ads or, you know, that

that's the, that's the story.

So, um, yeah, I mean, in

theory, it all sounds great.

It's just a TBD, how it all

continues to, uh, to play out.

Oh, Zach's here.

Hey, what's up, dude?

Hi guys.

So let's talk about the creative cohort

spend analysis, uh, that you pulled,

like, what's the context of this, Brad?

Um, I'm, I'm interested to hear about it.

So creative hit rates, creative volume.

That's been like a topic of discussion.

Motion put out an awesome, I don't know

if exactly, I don't remember what they

called it, but it was like the creative.

I don't know.

They put out this 2026 creative PDF.

It was like 80 pages long.

And it was awesome because it showed

like, here's what the biggest brands are

doing from a creative volume

perspective and by industry.

And then also it said like, here, here

are the types of ads

that brands are running.

Cause they have this AI tagging.

That's awesome.

Um, and so we've been

thinking about that a lot.

We've been looking at a lot and kind of

using that as a benchmark for, okay, how

much are our brands launching

on creative on a monthly basis?

And, um, what does that mean?

But I think there's been, I think we

talked about this in a recent episode.

I feel like there's like this sentiment

building in the Twitter sphere for DTC

where it's like, people are kind of

getting frustrated with

the volume game a little bit.

And they're, they're leaning back towards

hit rates, making better ads, spending

more time, being more thoughtful.

And I think that's a fair exercise.

I'm still definitely in like the creative

volume is important camp

because you have to take swings.

Um, and at the same time you want those

swings to be calculated, but I don't

think anybody would say

it shouldn't be calculated.

Uh, but that's, that's a,

that's a separate topic.

In any case, the, the thing that we've

been thinking about and trying to map

back to is this idea of viewing our

creative through a cohort lens.

And I think I'm not sure if this is in,

um, there might be like a creative kind

of report in, uh, what

you and Kurt built, Andrew.

Um, but it might be more

of a CPMR related thing.

It's like the creative cohorts in their

CPMR, which is sick.

Um, it's a really cool view.

Um, but what we basically want to know,

the question we're trying to answer is

like, where did our

spend come from this month?

So in May, was it ads that we launched in

May or is it everything that we've had in

the ad accounts historically?

And then I can go back and I can look and

I could say, okay, if our entire ad

account is made up from spend,

ads that were launched last year, all the

new shit I'm making is going to waste.

Like I, we are not doing a good job at

making new ads that are resonating.

And then you can start to

dig into the reasons why.

So this is kind of a, this is a bit of a

surface view of like, okay, um, are we

making the right things?

Are we actually progressing?

And I have an example

of what this looks like.

So I can, I'm sorry for the non

YouTubers, but I'll flip my screen over

again and we can look at this.

Um, I realized that I didn't update the

previous document properly.

So I have a different looking one here.

Sorry, you blame, blame,

Claude, Claude for the visual.

The data is accurate though.

Um, so I'll try to describe what's here.

Can you guys, guys see this?

Okay.

Yeah.

So what you'll see is

we've got spend by month.

So January 300 grand, February 400, some

grand, March three, 300

grand, April 289, May 258.

So far we've got some

time left in the month.

Um, so this cohort view is what we've

been finding really valuable.

So if we look at January, we can see how

much spend in January was made up from

ads that were launched last year in this

case and ads launched in January.

And in this case, about

10% was from ads in January.

And I guess what you're looking for when

you're looking at this is that the month

that you're currently in and previous

months are making up like a reasonable

percentage because there's, there's two

things that would be an issue.

If January here, which is 90%

pre-January, like if we're looking at May

and it was all ads launched last year, be

like, fuck, what have we been doing?

What have we been doing

this entire year so far?

We haven't made any ads that are working.

Um, and then that's, that's the trigger

to go look into that.

It's, it's, uh, it's using this.

You shouldn't just look at this and not

do something with it, but you're trying

to find insights to actually go and do

something with this.

But the other way, the other thing to

consider is, well, if all of your spend

is from ads that you launched in this

month or in the previous month, I mean,

there's some caveats to this, but you

might also be concerned that like, okay,

you're really over, over, over indexed on

stuff you've launched recently.

Uh, and you might want to continue to get

new things in the pipeline because you

don't want to become overly reliant on

just a couple of, uh, outlier ads.

I mean, all our ads are good, but at the

same time, you don't want to become

overly reliant on this.

Uh, and so this is just a view that we've

been looking at to make sure, okay.

Um, are we, are we

launching new ads successfully?

Um, are there any pockets

that we can look into, right?

Like may, this is the biggest, this looks

like one of the biggest months, um,

where, uh, in the same month that those

ads are getting to spend almost 20% and

it's not even over yet.

So like, did we do something recently

that's hitting really well that we should

be leaning more into?

Um, so just kind of sparks that.

And if you wanted to run this, like

motions, not sponsoring this, but I can

give you the prompt to go.

You can just drop this in motion and, uh,

in their little runneth chat and it'll

produce this for you.

Um, HTML graph and everything.

Um, just kind of a cool way of, um,

looking at this and breaking it down.

So basically what you're saying is

instead of doing cohort or creative sort

of like by batches or

like, Hey, this was this batch.

You're doing it by a monthly cohort.

And that's how you're looking at them and

categorizing them in order to make sense

of the performance by each

of those cohorts by month.

Like it's, it's a more linear package.

Makes it easier to understand what we

did, what we shipped in

February is still good.

And what did we, and then you were able

to dig in and look at February and say,

these are the things that gripped that

are helped to scale.

How do we go back and

replicate some of the unlocks we had?

Is that, that's essentially what you're

getting at with this.

Yeah, exactly.

And there's, there's, this is, this is a

view in a certain way

that you can look at it.

Uh, if you're a motion user, you can go

to their new launches report and that'll

give you a weekly version of it.

It doesn't look exactly like this, but

it'll give you a weekly version where you

can expand and contract.

Uh, and what you want to do, I mean,

we've talked about, um, I feel like, I

feel like scalability school needs to

take a lot of credit for like spend

velocity as a, as something to lean into.

I know Zach, that was something that you

mentioned a ton last year, like spend

velocity and things picking up quickly.

But like, if you launched ads in the last

week that became the top spender, that's

the signal to lean into is like, okay,

um, did we hit on a

seasonal moment that's relevant?

Or is there something lasting in here

that we can go recreate, um, and lean

into and do more of.

And this is just another

way of, of looking at that.

So there's the weekly view of it.

Um, but it's, it's basically just like

forcing you to, to reconcile.

If you're, if you're a brand owner and

you are hiring create, like you, let's

say you have your brand owner and you

have a creative agency, uh, and you hired

them in March and you pull this report

and all of the spend is going through

shit you've created.

Like that's, you know, there's obviously

different ways of looking at it, but

like, that's the, that's the question to

go ask and say, it's like, Hey, is

anything you're making actually, um,

producing like net new net new spend in

the, in the, um, this one has seasonal,

um, seasonal swings.

And I feel like that's why this is

changing so much, especially recently.

I love it.

I don't have any questions on this.

Zach, do you have questions on this?

No, it makes a ton of sense.

Um, we do this kind of like end of month

report every month that, um, our like

creative ops manager and our VP of

performance creative put together.

It's similar to this and then just goes a

bit deeper where we see the difference

between what we call like breakthrough

ads versus scaled ads.

Um, which breakthrough is like, does it

hit $2,000 in spend within a seven day

period at the North beam

when they click target goal.

And so we kind of look at month over

month over month where we're saying like,

okay, how, how are we performing?

How many ads are actually breaking

through or scaling this

month versus previous months?

And it's, it's somewhat, it's almost like

a, maybe one step

deeper, maybe one step above.

I don't really know like the best way to

describe that, but yeah, I

mean, this is super important.

It's like, what do we miss?

And like, what is the longevity?

It'd be really interesting to

look at it, um, over time too.

So you're like, this is what it looks

like now, but then what does

it look like going forward?

I don't know.

I don't know if I'm like explaining that

right either, but the progressive like

swing, like does the, does each month end

up turning into 10% of a spend?

Or does it actually eat up

like, ideally, is it a quarter?

Is it 25% of spend for the first month

and then kind of degradates down to like

10 and then holds at 10?

That'd also be interesting too, to see.

Yeah, that's a great point.

I mean, the reason that like the, the

thing that inspired me to do this in the

first place is we had a brand who was

like, they were like generally bought

into the idea of

creative volume is important.

Um, but they wanted to like, see the

proof that it was working.

Um, and so they started, they, they

probably quadrupled their, their output,

um, through a bunch of like very

thoughtful adjustments on the way that

their internal team operated.

So they took inspiration from kind of

like ideas that we were sharing with them

and then they converted

it into actual output.

And it was just important for them to

make sure like, Hey, did what we, we, we

produced, uh, a hundred ads this month.

And you know, that's up from the 20 we

were previously locked into.

Did those do anything?

And so it allows us to look

back and say, yes, they worked.

But here's another way to split it.

It's like 50 of the ads that you gave us

for, were for a promo

that lasted three days.

And so like, that's, that's useful, but

like, and it makes sense because promo,

promo spends harder, uh, and over a

shorter period of time, but you want to

make sure that those evergreen ads that

are still live in the ad account continue

to actually produce.

Because then, you know, you've actually

hit something and it's not just like a

one hit wonder promo ad that

you can actually repurpose.

And so it was just like validation for

them that what they

were making was working.

And when you split it down to evergreen

and promo ads, it still ended up being

the case that evergreen consistently is

stacking up month over month.

And that's what compounds, right?

It's like, if you can, if you can make

more ads every single month that earns

spend in the ad account, then that's what

compounds over time.

And allows you to increase spend, uh,

over the, over the year.

Talk about, there's this guy, Zach Stuck,

who has this brand called Marsman.

Um, and it says, we're going to go into

now how Marsman scales on

next month's repeat revenue.

Uh, which is kind of a hot topic.

I feel like everybody wants to know.

I mean, headline, I mean,

Zach, I want to go into this.

Sure.

Sure.

I mean, Brad, do you want

to like tee this up anymore?

Do you, is that, is

that enough for me to.

Yeah.

I mean, the, the, the frame, the, I

remember we were having

a conversation one time.

And one of the things that you mentioned

is like, one of the things that we think

about for pushing spend aggressively.

Now you guys are, you guys have hit an

insane, um, growth rate

and, and, um, uh, MRR.

And so, and you're pushing

growth, growth aggressively.

And I look in brands that have solid

repeat rate all the time.

And maybe they have different

profitability goals.

They have different

growth goals, whatever.

Like often it's uncommon that the brand

is not being

aggressive enough in scaling.

Cause they haven't done the financial,

uh, homework that you guys have done to

understand, like, how

much can we spend into this?

Um, and one of the things that you

mentioned that you use is like a guide

for this is like, well, okay, if we know,

and I might not be framing this perfectly

exactly the way you phrased it, but, um,

you said, Hey, if we have this, an idea

that our EP customer revenue next month

is going to be, I'm just

going to pick a number.

It's going to be 500 grand.

I'm probably selling

that very short for Mars.

Like it's gonna be 500 grand.

It's like, well, we know we're

gonna have 500 grand in cash.

We can spend into that, like at least

that much next month.

Um, because we want to

be, want to be aggressive.

Um, so I'm sure there's a lot more

context and things that go into making

the decision, but it's, it's, it's, it's.

It's at least, uh, maybe safe.

Cause you have the cash to be able to

spend into, uh, into that.

So that's the framing.

Yeah.

So at the end of the day, like this is

where these MRR businesses or

subscription businesses scale so quickly.

It just comes down to this simple model,

which is if I can forecast for this

example, 500 K in reoccurring revenue.

And I know that my OPEX is going to be a

hundred thousand for the month.

Um, I know that I need to maybe run at

like a 1.8 or two, two, let's just call

it a two, uh, MER, uh, or two blended

rows, whatever term you want to use.

Um, to still maintain

profitability with a hundred K OPEX.

I then know I can spend

that full MRR into it.

And as long as I know if I'm trying to

achieve a two MER, I have to

be at a one new customer ROAS.

And so if I can stay at a one new

customer ROAS, I can still hit my target

and I can keep going.

The nice thing about this is like with

time and with more scale

that MER can actually go down.

Um, as long as your OPEX doesn't offset

it too much, meaning that like, let's

just like ratched up those numbers a ton.

So let's say, um, we're, our MRR is 5

million a month now, for example, and we

know what our OPEX is.

Maybe our OPEX is a million a month now.

I don't know, for example.

And so with that, because we have such

good margin and we know we're going to do

5 million in returning, we might be able

to say, Hey, we can run

a 1.5 MER now in total.

So I can still spend that full 5 million

in revenue and do only 2.5 million in

revenue to average

out to a 1.5 total MER.

So again, like this is where with more

scale plus the returning customer

revenue, when you can forecast, um, that

returning it like just, that's where

things really start to compound.

I think the thing that's been really

interesting for us is, is candidly like,

there's so many things that you do in

these subscription businesses that will

have like a, uh, fundamental changes on

like forecasting that returning customer

revenue that could have big impacts on

like how you think about the business.

So let's say you run a sale at the end of

a month, one month, and your cat goes

down and you scale into it.

The next month you could assume,

depending on how many percentage of those

customers are 30 day customers versus 90

day customers, you might see

a big spike at the end of it.

But let's say like you run an offer where

your 90 day subscription versus 30 day

subscription is a bigger discount.

So out of nowhere, that becomes a larger

percentage of your

customers at the end of that month.

You now are deferring all that revenue

for 90 days on the back of the month

where then you're like, Oh shit, I better

plan my spend

accordingly around those pockets.

Also, like if you're testing different

bundles, you're testing all sorts of

stuff, like this can all

have huge impacts on it.

So I think like as much as reoccurring

revenue is like a blessing, it can be a

curse too, because there's so many

different variables.

If you are really doing a bunch of

testing, like we have been with Mars,

where we're trying like different offers,

different price points, you know, 30 day,

90 day, you know, 180 day subscriptions

to kind of see like,

what is the sweet spot?

All of those changes will then have an

impact down 30, 60, 90, 180 days from now

that you really have to

like, be careful with.

And there's a lot of like assumptions

that go into the model

until you have like longevity.

So, I mean, the smartest thing you can

really do is like, just be like, cool,

we're going to sell a

30 day subscription.

That's all we're going to sell.

We're going to scale into that because

then there's no other

crazy nuance that happens.

The second you had a discount, additional

discount or whatever, like that could

actually impact your cohorts, which then

resets your, all of your learnings on

what's expected for

returning customer revenue.

But the simple math on it is when you

know what your MRR is going to be and you

have a good, good model built around it,

like you can usually

spend into that fully.

And most of these brands that are, that

are scaling the greens of the world, uh,

IM8s, whatever, like they're looking at

the returning customer revenue and

saying, Hey, if we're going to do 5

million this month in MRR, we're

definitely going to spend

at least 5 million in ads.

Yeah.

And the, in the issue, the point that you

made that's, you have to be careful with

is when you, you add the 90 day as you've

maybe, maybe you rip a bunch of 90 day.

And all of a sudden you went from a

hundred percent is 30 days, a hundred

percent of your subscriptions are 30 days

to 50% of them dramatically are 90 days.

Well, if you're, if you don't change your

cohort math and your four year cashflow

forecast to account for that, you're

going to spend into all of that, but

you're not, you're actually not going to

realize that cash for

another 60 days beyond that.

And that's where you put yourself into a

funky cash position.

So that's what you're saying about

keeping it simple to avoid.

The cash positions, plus then like

running different discounts throughout

different times of the month too.

So like maybe you run a discount, like

4th of July is in the front half of July.

Father's day is on like the back half of

the month or like mother's

days in the back of the month.

So like, depending on when you're running

those, those sales, it's also going to

have fluctuations on the returning, which

then ideally you're looking at, okay, I

did, you know, 500 K of MRR.

I can spend 500 K.

You have to really be cautious of when

you're spending into that 500 K around

all of those moments that

you've made historically.

Otherwise you can overspend in the front

half of the month and then you don't have

enough budget on the back half when CAC

is actually really good.

Can we talk about the forecasting and how

many times you're, how

often you're reforecasting?

Like, is it built on subscription base,

repeat purchase cohort curve?

Yeah.

Like, is it a simple percentage?

Like what is it?

Yeah.

So we just rebuilt our entire model this

week because we had some issues candidly

for May of us like missing, but all

learning opportunities for us.

But we, we just rebuilt it where it

actually goes down to the individual

customer level and then is now starting

to pull in all sorts of moments around

that individual customer.

So we basically look at who that customer

is, what they paid that first day, if

there was a discount or not.

We factor that into the retention curve

of that individual based on us knowing,

Hey, sometimes when they use a discount,

they're much more of like a, you know,

they're not as the longevity of that

customer is less because they're more of

a discount shopper and

they're more likely to cancel.

So we're like, we're applying retention

curves based on the decisions they made

and the sales price point or whatever

they did on the front end.

Plus then we're starting

to pull in other things.

Like we're pulling in, we're going to

start planning things from like gorgeous

or a CX team to say like, did this

customer reach out

through our portal to cancel?

But then they stayed on because we gave

them an additional discount.

What does that mean for the

longevity of that customer?

So now we're getting down to the per

customer basis where candidly, like prior

to that, we were looking

at it more holistically.

We were saying, okay, how many customers

bought on this day, 30 days ago, look at

that monthly core, look at the churn for

that cohort and just kind

of make a lot of assumptions.

But at the scale that we're getting to

now, like we had to look at it as

granular as we possibly could.

The thing that's really interesting now

is we're taking this forecast.

We're basically saying, okay, again,

simplified numbers, 5

million in MR this month.

We want to do 10 million in revenue.

We can run in a two blended ROAS, which

would mean that we'd have to run.

We'd have to, you know, run at a certain

degree where we would still maintain

profitability, officer

OPEX, all that stuff.

We're then saying, looking at our

forecast, we're then saying, okay, new

customer target is 5 million in revenue.

How do we go hit 5 million in revenue?

We're breaking down our targets by

channel and estimated orders

by channel every single day.

So now we're looking at like not just

orders or NCROAS or CPA

from Facebook or one day click.

Like we're literally looking at did

today, did email SMS drive the correct

amount of customers?

Did organic drive the right amount of

customers like by channel?

Because again, like at the scale that

we're getting to, if like one of those

channels misses, but everything else is

hitting, we could miss our target by, you

know, six figures,

potentially even seven figures a month.

So it's been really, it's been really

cool to actually like be able to start to

diagnose it that way and actually look at

it on a per day per channel basis.

Because I don't think many brands get to

the point where they're doing enough

volume where then it actually validates

like did email actually

drive 300 customers today?

Yes or no?

Because it's just like too granular, too

segmented based on size.

But now that the numbers have gotten big

enough that we can actually like keep an

eye on the trends,

like it's really helpful.

Also, then we can plan, hey, if we're

going to run a promotion, email can be

flat for the first half of the month.

But then during that sale period, we

expect it to actually pop up.

We also, you know, have the indication

that like, you know, new customer cac is

going to drop on these channels, but

maybe it doesn't move on podcasts because

that's linear throughout

the month, things like that.

So, yeah, I mean, forecasting is

important for all businesses, but

especially for subscription, like you

have to really dive into it.

Otherwise, like you will either not grow

as quickly as what you possibly can or

you'll actually inverse, which is like

you're not thinking enough of how many

net new subscribers you need to add and

what performance needs to be on every

single channel for you to actually add

net new subscribers.

Because for the most part, most of these

subscription brands are only growing

because they're adding net new because

likely most of them are churning the same

amount as they're adding in.

So everything above and beyond that is

like the real growth path.

And the podcast point is interesting

because it's like,

those are the things you do.

And like, I think a lot of people, it's

like maybe they put together a monthly

view, but the day to day can shift so

much to your point for a promo.

Even like week or day to day trends, like

maybe your weekends are more aggressive,

maybe they're slower, depending on the

category that you're in.

I have two follow questions on that.

When you get when you see that channel

level performance, like

maybe you can use two examples.

You could use a meta example

or the email example or both.

It's like if those are off, are you

reallocating in the platform?

Is it kind of like that's

where the deep dive starts?

Like, OK, meta is off.

OK, well, is there somewhere

in meta that we can reallocate?

And if it's like, nah, probably not.

This is all shit.

We got to go to somewhere else.

It's like, are you

making that daily decisions?

Are you zooming out over

a longer period of time?

And the mini follow to that is like, what

are you using as the, I

guess, like source of truth?

Are you using just like MTA

data or using platform data?

Just kind of normalized.

Yeah.

So for the CAC by channel, we're using

last click to dictate that.

And then we kind of back into a last

click and then an MTA to kind of like

figure out for our paid channels, like

what is the happy medium there?

So that's kind of like the blend.

At the end of the day, it's like, you

know, we've had, so for example, like

email and SMS has been falling short

based on our daily targets.

And we're sort of, we're trying to figure

out, OK, like what's happening on email

and SMS that's not allowing us to

continue to like perform at the levels

and the growth that we need to see month

over month from those channels.

And so for us, it was like, oh, well, we

run a subscription offer, like a discount

50% off your first purchase and like for

life on that subscription.

Um, but we don't really have that many

like unique offers to add into email and

SMS to get those extra pops or get the

people that weren't willing to purchase.

So there's, there's one like tactic that

we're about to start testing where

basically if a customer is sitting in our

ecosystem, in our own channel list, and

they haven't converted over the course of

like a 60 day period, we're actually

going to start discounting single

one-time purchase offerings.

So normally we're not a one-time purchase

brand. We're not trying to get any

one-time purchases, but we have, we have

such big lists now that like there's all

these people that just, just don't buy

simply for the fact that they don't want

to subscribe or they haven't gone on

Amazon yet to buy on one-time purchase.

So that's just like a way for us to be

like, Hey, we have this like dead list

essentially of just people that have come

into the funnel, but haven't bought for

some reason that I think a lot of brands

actually like kind of forget about that.

They're like, Hey, they didn't buy. We

did all these like whatever, uh, flows to

like get them to maybe get

a bigger discount over time.

But then there was probably one reason

why they didn't buy. So like talk to that

customer about that one reason why they

didn't buy and give them a strong

discount to still close.

Cause like it's very likely better off

and you still have contribution margin on

that customer to be gained.

If you just give them even a slightly

bigger discount to like bring in those

dollars versus them just sitting on an

email and SMS list and then just like

dying off because you, you pull them from

the list because they

don't, don't interact.

So yeah, there's like little things like

that, that we found by digging into, Hey,

email and SMS is off for that day.

What, what can we do to actually get

those extra pops throughout the month?

Um, and yeah, same

thing kind of with paid.

I mean, paid is more of

the typical analyzing.

It's like Apple ovens off this week.

Okay.

What are we, what are we doing?

Have we not, you know, have we tested a

quiz funnel to Apple oven or are we just

running listicles or whatever?

Right.

So it's like landing page creative, the

whole gambit of normal

funnel optimization stuff.

Have you, so the thing you just said

about like the retention, you guys

running the same playbook then for people

who have like lapsed as customers.

Like they, they tried it for two months

and they, they unsubscribed and now you

have to do this whole win

back to get them back on board.

Are you guys good?

Same thing.

One time purchase or push them to Amazon.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Same thing.

Same thing.

Yeah.

I think the biggest thing this week was

just like, Hey, we're not talking to

these people that just don't want to buy

it because it's just a subscription.

So it's like, let's just

go clean that up first.

Cause that's probably hundreds of

thousands of revenue,

like every single month.

If we just give them a proper discount to

come in one time purchase at like not

quite our subscription offering, but like

in, in between our one time purchase and

our subscription price.

So yeah.

And then next would

obviously be like lapsed customers.

The interesting thing about, about

supplements and lapsed customers is like

very, very low chance of their, we've

tried things before in the past, like

free gifts and shit.

It just like doesn't move the needle.

So, um, yeah, we've, we've, we've, we've

attempted it, but I would say like,

there's probably still

more, more room to fix there.

I mean, absolute banger.

I tried not to talk very much cause I

sound terrible, but Brad appreciate you

asking good questions.

Zach, thank you for sharing.

Is there anything else

you guys want to go into?

No.

Yeah.

Okay.

All set.

Poskey Foxwell signing off.

Thank you for listening and

we'll talk to you guys soon.

This episode is brought to you by the

Foxwell founders membership that Andrew

and his wife, Gracie run.

It has been absolutely pivotal for not

just the Homestead team, but

the easy street brands team.

We've had, I don't even know how many

members are currently in there that are a

part of our ecosystem.

But when it comes to anything from

learning ads to understanding what's

going on to building an agency to knowing

retention, it's been

absolutely useful for our team.

When they get stuck or they need help to

just go there and

resource all the other experts.

So definitely would recommend it for

anybody that's looking to, you know, take

it a step deeper, try to get a little bit

more knowledge on growth marketing and

all the world D2C is.

Yeah.

I think one of the most incredible things

about it is you can just like open up the

Slack group every single day.

You can pin your favorite channels for

the topics that you care most about.

And like every day there's going to be

somebody who just like, because they want

to contribute something valuable to the

group, you can go learn

something every single day.

And it's going to be extremely useful.

There's some ballers in there that you

just get like the

benefit of learning from that.

But like for the for the costs, like you

couldn't pay them that for their time.

But through the membership, like you get

access to some incredible

people and tons of resources.

Yeah.

I mean, I think the biggest resource to

me, too, is like the events that, you

know, Foxville Founders does.

They've been able to do some even in

Wisconsin, even in the boring state of

Wisconsin, which is pretty awesome.

Getting people together in person and

able to have really just like honest

conversations of what's going on, what's

working for them now, you know, where

they're at in their business.

Knowing that there's going to be, like

Brad said, some real killers in the space

in this in this membership that can that

can help and are willing

to take the time and help.

So that's been a huge part of why a lot

of our team have

really enjoyed it as well.

And the applications are now open if

you're looking to join.

So Foxville Founders.

Yeah.

Foxvillefounders.com.

Go check it out.

Go apply.

The only way that we grow this podcast is

by you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like reviews kind of don't

really mean anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful, but they don't

do a lot for the growth of the podcast.

And so sharing YouTube links, sharing

Spotify links, sharing Apple, whatever we

call it under the podcast app now.

Anything you can share,

the better we're going to be.

Guys, anything else

you want to say on this?

Yeah.

Please go check us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe.

Make sure to

subscribe on YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly refresh the YouTube

comments because it dictates

my mental health for the day.

So please say

something nice about all of us.

Thank you, everyone.

Thanks for listening.

Honestly.